Go back

61. Chocolate

from The Sweaty Penguin

45m 21s

61. Chocolate

This episode of The Sweaty Penguin explores the complex, often exploitative supply chain of chocolate, focusing on its environmental and social costs. Cocoa farming in West Africa—especially Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana—drives significant deforestation and child labor due to low farmer wages and a powerful oligopoly among global traders. These traders control pricing, leaving farmers with minimal profits despite decades of labor-intensive work. The supply chain is long and opaque, meaning farmers never see the final product; many live in poverty, earning less than $1.25 a day. Climate change exacerbates the crisis, threatening cocoa production through heat stress, drought, and disease. While initiatives like the Living Income Differential and the Cocoa Protocol aim to improve sustainability and farmer livelihoods, they face limitations such as unintended increases in deforestation and lack of enforcement. The root issue is not just environmental but economic: a lack of fair market competition and pricing. Sustainable solutions include agroforestry, better certification systems, and increased investment in farmer education and technology. The episode concludes with a hopeful message: with systemic change—especially fair pricing and market reform—chocolate can be produced in a way that supports both farmers and the environment. Eating chocolate isn't the problem; how it's produced is. Consumers are encouraged to check labels and support ethically sourced products, recognizing that chocolate can be part of a sustainable future if the industry transforms. The discussion ends with a nod to Disney’s new film, “Coco,” highlighting how a simple word can represent both a cultural staple and a complex global issue.

Transcription

6646 Words, 38872 Characters

English
This episode of The Sweaty Penguin is brought to you by Squids. Do you wish octopuses were boring? Try Squids today! Welcome to episode 61 of The Sweaty Penguin and Dirk Dickas Hottest podcast. The first episode of season 4. I'm your host Ethan Brown. It is Friday, October 15th. You can subscribe to The Sweaty Penguin on Apple, Spotify, Google, Podcast, Addict, wherever you get your podcasts. Be sure to leave a 5 star rating in a review and you will get a shout out at the end of the show. The other way to get a shout out, join our Patreon. For as little as 5 bucks a month, you'll also get access to some Sweaty Penguin swag, exclusive bonus content, and more. You can do that by heading over to patreon.com/the Sweaty Penguin. The Sweaty Penguin is presented by Peral and Promise, a public media initiative from the WNET Group in New York reporting on the issues and solutions around climate change. You can learn more at pbs.org/peral and promise. You know we always pick an interesting topic to kick off the new season and today we are talking about Coco, a word that simultaneously describes the beans that are used to produce chocolate, Conan O'Brien's digital content, and the most recent film Disney's made that actually has an original story. Come on Disney, think of something new. Like a Reese's factory, we've got a lot to cover with chocolate today. And no, I'm not going to ruin chocolate. But chocolate actually does have a lot of serious problems. Just listen to CNN reporter Richard Quest. Find out that this group of cocoa farmers in the West African country of Cote Duvoir had never tasted chocolate. These farmers have been growing beans for decades. They're about to get their first taste of chocolate. You have never tried chocolate. It turned out not one person in this group had tasted chocolate. Can someone tell Richard to calm down? Not everyone is coco for cocoa puffs. If he gets any more agitated over someone having never tried chocolate, he could be looking at a brand deal. But this news piece raises an important question. Why haven't cocoa farmers tasted chocolate? As it turns out, it's because chocolate takes a lot of steps to make. It first grows as a yellow orange football-sized pod on the cacao tree, with each pod containing 30 to 50 seeds that we know as cocoa beans, covered in a white pulp called Baba. The beans are then removed, cleaned, fermented, dried, graded, packed into sacks, checked for quality, and shipped off to manufacturers, a time and labor-consuming process with some of these steps taking over a week of hard work. Once manufacturers receive the beans, they'll clean them again, roast them at low temperatures to develop flavor, and then remove the shells to get to the nibs, which are finally ground into cocoa liquor. The cocoa liquor can then be placed under extremely high pressure and broken down into cocoa powder and cocoa butter, or it can be refined through another complicated process into what we know as chocolate. So as you can see, that's a lot of steps. That's like building an IKEA dresser or cancelling cable. Since the process to make chocolate has so many steps requiring the beans to travel across continents, it makes sense that these cocoa farmers would never get to see the final product. Well, it makes sense to everyone except Richard. But what is concerning is that this chocolate supply chain is filled with problems. Thankfully, cocoa pods don't fart methane, they're pretty polite at the dinner table, but there's issues of deforestation, issues of human rights, and issues that climate change presents to the cocoa pods themselves. And knowing that farmers don't even get to taste the chocolate after all their hard work, it's even more disappointing to see that farmers are the ones facing the brunt of a lot of these issues. So today, we'll discuss what problems face the chocolate industry, how climate change could make things a lot worse, and where we should focus our attention to fix this very long and complicated supply chain. And let's start with some chocolate economics. Coat Devoire and Ghana - two bordering countries in West Africa - produce nearly two thirds of the global supply of chocolate. In fact, in Coat Devoire, chocolate represents 22% of the value added to GDP, 40% of exports, and employees 70% of the population. If you listen to our vanilla episode from last year, this setup might sound a little too familiar. Almost all the vanilla comes from Madagascar, and Madagascar is massively reliant on vanilla. In between the four times I played I like to move it move it for Madagascar in that episode, we discussed how this heavy reliance on one or a few exports creates problems. According to the UN's Commodity Dependence Report, countries that are heavily dependent on exporting a small number of commodities regularly see higher rates of poverty, mortality, income inequality, and corruption, and inferior education and human development. If there aren't options when it comes to jobs, then it becomes really difficult for people in communities to find ways to improve their livelihoods. In Coat Devoire, this dilemma is very clear, where overall poverty rates are decreasing, but rural poverty rates where the farmers would be are increasing. So cocoa farmers find themselves in a difficult spot. Many cocoa farmers and workers in the global south have to get by on less than $1.25 in US dollars per day, below the threshold of absolute poverty. Knowing that A, making chocolate takes so much manual labor, and B, unless you're cookie monster, chocolate is really a luxury item that's frustrating in its own right. But let's talk about how that affects the supply chain. Under these circumstances, cocoa farmers can't buy trucks to transport their cocoa or obtain the resources necessary to trade on the global market. So they sell their cocoa to middlemen called Peasters at a price set by the government. In Coat Devoire, cocoa is about $1.45 per kilogram right now. Many argue that's too low, but we'll get into that more as we go. The Peasters have trucks and transport the cocoa to warehouses, which are owned by what are called co-operatives. These aren't the co-ops we're familiar with where farmers share resources or your college makes you take a semester off to do an unpaid internship and write a diary about it. These are companies that buy the cocoa from Peasters and sell it. It's worth noting that Peasters end up carrying large sums of cash from the cooperative to the farmers, and there are very often cases where a Peaster gets robbed and they don't end up paying the farmer, putting the farmers in an even tougher situation. The co-operatives then sell the cocoa to one of the big chocolate traders. This is a very small group of companies dominated by Barry Kellabout, Cargill, and Ola. These companies buy cocoa from the warehouses on futures contracts, process it into chocolate, and sell it to the manufacturers we're familiar with, like Nestle, Mars, Hershey, etc. Who then sell it to us to eat by the fistful until our poop turns black? No? Just me? Now, that's a really complicated supply chain, but to me, there's one key problem that jumps out and ruins everything else. Smack dab in the middle of it all is an Ola Gopoli. If you're not familiar, an Ola Gopoli is an industry dominated by just a few companies. Just like cellular networks with AT&T Verizon's print and T-Mobile, or Baseball with the major leagues, minor leagues, and watching your idiot kid get three strikes when the ball is sitting on the tee. In this case, it's the traders, Barry Kellabout, Cargill, and Ola. In a free market with lots and lots of cocoa traders, they'd be competed, so the co-operatives could charge higher and higher prices for the cocoa and see who's willing to pay it. In the Ola Gopoli, since there's just a few traders, they basically choose what they're collectively willing to pay for the cocoa. If the co-operatives won't sell it for that, they won't sell it at all. And that trickles down. The co-operatives will then only be willing to pay so much, which means the peace stores will only be willing to pay so much, which means the only way the farmers sell their cocoa is to sell it at a ridiculously low price. Combine that with the fact that there's not many other options to make a living in rural Cote d'Ivoire and Ghana, and the farmers are essentially stuck. So what do they do? They go to really desperate measures to grow and sell more cocoa. One way is creating more land to grow on, and in the heavily forested countries of Cote d'Ivoire and Ghana, that means deforestation. Globally, forest loss due to cocoa production from 1988 to 2008 has been estimated at between 2 and 3 million hectares, equivalent to about 1% of total global forest loss over that time. And according to the forest carbon partnership facility, cocoa production is estimated to have been responsible for about 1/4 of historical deforestation and Cote d'Ivoire and nearly 15% in the high forest zone of Ghana. In fact, a United Nations Red Program blog post said that cocoa is the main direct cause of deforestation in Cote d'Ivoire and Cote d'Ivoire has the fastest deforestation rate of all the countries in Africa. In other words, out of the entire continent of Africa, Cote d'Ivoire is being deforested the fastest and the primary reason is chocolate. And to think, some of that chocolate becomes Russell Stover. Is dollar store chocolate worth deforestation to you? And Cote d'Ivoire is taking notice. Their government recently formed the special surveillance and intervention brigade, nicknamed the Green Army. Because apparently the chocolate army just sounds like a bunch of angry Easter bunnies. The Green Army has 650 armed soldiers, and these soldiers patrol Cote d'Ivoire's protected forests in search of illegal loggers. Listen to this France 24 Correspondent Shadow, one of these teams. With water up to the waist, the commander and his teams follow the sound of the chainsaws as discreetly as possible. But it's not enough. The loggers spot us and manage to escape. They leave behind a chainsaw, petrol, and a section of forest sentries old raised to the ground. First off, by the loggers spotted us. Do you mean they spotted the soldiers? Or they spotted you and your camera crew? I don't want to speculate here, but I feel like carrying a tripod and boom mic through a rainforest would create a little ruckus. But more importantly, the fact that the loggers are portrayed as the villains here is absolutely absurd. I don't know specifically what these loggers were doing, but given that Cote is the main direct cause of deforestation in Cote d'Ivoire, I have to imagine this Green Army encounters Cote farmers more than anyone else, and none of them are chopping down forests because they have a beef with trees. In fact, the reason is pretty obvious. They desperately need money, and clearing forests to grow more Cote is their only option. And while enforcing your laws about protected land is important, until Cote farmers can survive without cutting down these forests, this Green Army feels pretty useless. They're not going after bad guys. They're going after people in a really challenging situation. But this deforestation does lead to a number of problems. A study in Tropical Conservation Science that surveyed 23 protected forest areas threatened by Cote d'Ivoire found five had lost half their primate species, and 13 had lost their entire primate population. And elephants, who the Ivory Coast is named after, are in rapid decline as well and at risk of disappearance. I mean seriously, you've got to try pretty hard to make all the elephants disappear. David Copperfield probably couldn't even make one elephant disappear. Yeah David, you can't just blare music and move the stage like you did to vanish the statue of Liberty. Deforestation can also cause soil erosion, flooding, desertification, and climate issues, both locally and that there's less shade and trees actually have a cooling effect on the surrounding air, and globally, in that trees both reflect sunlight back into the atmosphere, and most importantly, they absorb carbon dioxide. And when you cut down a tree and release that carbon back into the atmosphere, you're contributing to climate change. And again, this isn't cocoa farmers choosing to cut down forests, but due to the structure of the industry, they really don't have another choice. Another all-too-common consequence of cocoa farmers desperately needing to grow and sell more cocoa is child labor. Meet Yaku, a child working on a cocoa farming Cote d'Ivoire, as he shares his story with a reporter. My mother brought me when my father died, he tells me. Yaku insists he's 16, but he looks much younger. His legs bear machete scars from hours clearing the bush. The emotional scars seem much deeper. I wish I could just go to school, he says, to learn to read and write. But Yaku says he's never spent a day in school. Yaku's story is devastating. And sadly, he's not alone. According to a 2015 report from two-lane university, there are over 2 million children working on cocoa plantations in Cote d'Ivoire and Ghana alone, and more than 500,000 of them work under abusive conditions. These children often have to carry very heavy loads, be exposed to pesticides, and use dangerous tools like machetes. In fact, the title of the video uses the term Child Slaves, which honestly is an accurate description. Children are trafficked into cocoa farms forced to work against their will as Yaku expresses, given no pay and put in very dangerous conditions. And again, as tempting as it is to abhor the cocoa farmers, they're desperate. With the way the cocoa industry is set up, this is the only way they can find to produce cocoa at such low prices. That's how quickly a powerful oligopoly in the middle of a long supply chain can devolve into the exact opposite of a free and fair market. That's certainly not to say the cocoa traders want children in the supply chain, unless they're at the end enjoying the singing cows at Hershey world, but they have created the conditions for it. And if all of this isn't difficult enough for farmers to navigate, there's another looming threat, climate change. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's Fifth Assessment Report, in tropical West Africa, unprecedented temperature increases are projected to occur one to two decades earlier than the rest of the world. As such, vast areas of Cote d'Ivoire and Ghana will become less suitable for cocoa production by 2050, according to a study in climatic change. In fact, in early 2018, there was even a story floating around the internet that chocolate was going extinct. A warning for chocolate lovers, you might want to start stocking up now because the sweet treat might be extinct by 2050. This warning comes from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, or NOAA. They say changing temperatures around the world will make growing cocoa plants nearly impossible within the next 30 years. That's terrifying. Luckily, it's also wrong. That's right, how does Gacha Journalism feel now? A writer for Gismoto traced this story back to a business insider article in December 2017, which highlighted research into chocolate that is genetically modified to be more climate resistant. That used the headline, "Chocolate is on track to go extinct in 40 years." That piece referenced a 2016 report from the NOAA, which highlighted some of the challenges facing chocolate in a warming climate, but never made the claim that chocolate might go extinct. It doesn't even contain the word extinct. So yeah, chocolate might go extinct because of climate change. Just like New Yorkers might go extinct because of climate change. If left to their own devices, it's a distant possibility, but it's a very fixable problem. So as much as I've had fun scaring you today about chocolate, we can at least catch a break on this one. No, chocolate is not going to be extinct in 2050. You may have immigrated to Mars, but rest assured there will probably still be Mars bars. But what is the cause for concern exactly? If it's largely incote devouring Ghana, obviously Coco doesn't mind hot weather. And it's true. Temperature rise alone isn't going to have a profound effect. Coco also grows in hotter temperatures in Malaysia and Indonesia, no problem. But the higher temperatures will not be accompanied by higher rainfall in this region. And that creates a problem. Because when plants are hotter, their leaves release more water vapor through a process called transpiration. The ground would also be releasing more water through evaporation, so the plant roots wouldn't have as much to suck up from the ground. One pound of chocolate requires 3,170 gallons of water to produce, which is actually nearly twice that of beef, over 29 times that of corn, over 176 times that of an Apple. and over a thousand times that of an ice bucket challenge, so as you can imagine, every drop of water counts. The Coco Bean is also prone to a litany of diseases and viruses, including ones with some excellent names like frosty pod and swollen chute, which shockingly are not STDs. But seriously, imagine if human diseases had silly names like this? Sorry, I can't come to work because I caught stinky teeth on the subway. Plus, my cousin has a bad case of oily foot and my cat is crawling with porcupine whiskers, so it's kind of a whole situation here. Anyway, climate change threatens to worsen these issues as well. Obviously, that's bad because it can kill off a plant in just a few years, but it can also lead to farmers needing to use more pesticides. That caused farmers even more money and creates hazards where pesticide residues leak into the water and cause algal blooms, killing off nearby aquatic organisms. But whether chocolate is going extinct or just getting tougher to grow, think about how that affects not just us consumers, but the farmers trying desperately to make a living. When they're struggling so much as is and don't really have other options, imagine the disaster that could play out when climate change makes regions of Cote Tivoir and Ghana unsuitable for cocoa growth using today's methods. This is why, as depressing an issue this may be and as guilty as you might suddenly feel about eating chocolate, cutting chocolate from our diets isn't actually the answer. It can't be. It tastes too good, but it would also mean turning our backs on these farmers. For a problem this complicated, the fact that somehow getting more money back to these farmers would fix the majority of it makes it a little less overwhelming. That's tough, sure, but it's way easier to wrap our heads around. So how do we do that? First off, let's look up the supply chain to the big companies, the traders and the Hershey's and Mars and Nestle's that we're familiar with. Do you really think it helps their bottom line to have child labor and deforestation on their supply chain? Maybe in the short term, but when you consider the cost of the PR disaster that would come from this podcast episode going viral, the extra money many people are willing to spend to support ethical companies. And the fact that according to research from the University of Minnesota, people's demand for chocolate doesn't really change that much when the price changes. It seems like in the long term, even these big companies should want to see these problems resolved. I mean how else could they get on TV and say there's no wrong way to eat a Reese's? Come on, this is definitely the wrong way. According to Kevin Bales, author of the Slave Nexador, these companies do want to improve their supply chains. Here's a clip of him from 2009, discussing an agreement they made called the Coco Protocol to fix these issues. How can we work together to make sure we solve this problem? And the answer was, what's called the Coco Protocol, it's the first time in history that an entire industry has decided to take complete moral responsibility and financial for their product chain. But we've never achieved it until the present moment, and we're just hitting the point where I feel like I can say, cautiously, it's a success. Now, I am enthused by the fact that these companies have taken an interest in creating a more ethical and sustainable industry. I just wish they would have put a little more effort into the name. I mean, seriously, sweetie treaty, confection convention, smores accord, chocolate concordate, truffle de scuffle. Although the companies have created many initiatives in pursuit of improving the supply chain, to say they've attained any level of success as Kevin did, it's really bizarre to me. Because not only do we still have child labor and deforestation, but these companies still remain unwilling to pay a fair price for their cocoa. In July 2019, to help lift farmers out of poverty, the governments of Cotevoire and Ghana attempted to negotiate a new minimum price for cocoa beans with the world's largest cocoa processors of $2,600 per ton. The cocoa industry did not agree to pay. So no, if this oligopoly continues squeezing the price down to something unreasonable, they just aren't going to find success. If you can't get actual competition from other companies to create a free market, at least pay a price that resembles what the free market would call for. That can be out of righteousness, but it doesn't have to be. Eliminating child labor and deforestation would probably help the company's long-term profits too. But these price minimums are just one option and actually have quite a lot of downsides. If you've taken an economics class, you may have learned that a government-imposed price minimum can make it impossible to balance the supply of the product with the demand for it. Less people would want to buy the product at the higher the natural price, and more people would want to produce and sell the product at the higher the natural price to make more money. As a result, you get a ton of unsolved product. Since chocolate is not currently a free market, a lot of that logic doesn't apply here. Who knows what these companies would pay without a price minimum? But it's important to keep an eye out for some of the consequences. Child labor and deforestation wouldn't be necessary if farmers were paid more, but if higher paychecks resulted in more people deciding to grow chocolate and cutting down forests to do it. That would be a problem in its own right. That's not to say these price minimums are bad, but it's hard to see them as anything besides a bandaid. Or should I say a Reese's adhesive? A crate tape. No? Okay fine, I'll stop. Another interesting solution that Cote d'Ivoire and Ghana are trying is something called the Living Income Differential Program, in which the two governments would pay farmers premiums when they sell chocolate in order to get them a living wage. As big of a government intervention as that is, it would theoretically ensure farmers can support themselves and maybe start to chip away at these issues. But critics point out that it creates the exact same supply demand problem. More farmers will want to get into chocolate if they can get these premiums so you'll have more supply than demand so the global price would crash. And during the pandemic when everyone was baking and there were those sourdough shortages, chocolate supply outpaced chocolate demand. How all we were doing was eating chocolate. So again, this is a really interesting program, but we definitely need to keep an eye on it to see how it plays out. Another option we talk a lot about on the podcast is certifications. We have a whole episode on those addressing the pros and cons so I won't get into all that here, but ultimately the goal is to get farmers premiums for adopting environmentally and socially responsible practices. If a smart certification program could be set up for chocolate farmers that actually helps the farmers, that wouldn't cause the supply demand issues that these other solutions do. Whatever way these farmers can get some money, there are a lot of ways they can fend off climate change and otherwise improve their operations. There could be technical solutions like drought-resistant crops or machinery to perform some of the manual labor. I mean, you'd think by 2050 there would just be an app for picking cocoa pods, right? I don't know. Pokemon Coco, Three Amangas Catears, Super Mars Barrier Run. Wow, I really have a problem. Oh, brother, this guy stinks! There's also water-saving solutions to help during droughts. And there's also a whole bunch of cool options using a system called agroforestry. Like growing trees to provide shade for the plants and keep the soil healthy or planting other crops to avoid some of the pest issues and simultaneously give farmers other sources of income. All of these solutions require education and most importantly money. So after we figure out the money situation, we'd want to start this conversation to be sure chocolate does not end up going extinct. If you look, I know you were probably expecting a fun episode on chocolate and this might have bummed you out a bit. It certainly bummed me out a bit writing it. But the reason I'm staying positive and the reason I hope you do too is that the root of the problem is really simple. I don't get to say that often on this podcast, but in this case, it is. There's an oligopoly leading cocoa farmers to get underpaid. Knowing that, I think it's reasonable to be optimistic that we can find a solution. A Twix fix, an almond joy ploy, a fudge nudge. Oh, what's that? This podcast is being cancelled. Apple podcast is adding an addendum about too many puns to their community guidelines. Yeah, that sounds about right. And if we can find a solution, we'll have given farmers better livelihoods, reduce or hopefully eliminate child labor and deforestation, and ensure that as climate change worsens, we can still keep making cocoa in the future. Except for you, Disney, don't do a remake. Do you wish onion rings were smaller and took 20 minutes to chew? If so, squids are for you. Climate change doesn't affect squids too much, but it does affect squid predators, meaning we can see even more squids in the future. How will we entertain them you ask? Well, I don't know. Maybe a squid game, perhaps? The only animal that actively hates SpongeBob. Wait, Squidward's an Octopus. The Sweaty Penguin is presented by Parallel and Promise, a public media initiative from the WNET Group in New York, reporting on the issues and solutions around climate change. You can learn more at pbs.org/parallelandpromise. Welcome back to the Sweaty Penguin. With me today is Dr. Sophia Cara De Nuto, Assistant Professor of Geography at the University of Victoria. Dr. Cara De Nuto, welcome to the show. Thanks Ethan, so great to meet you. I usually start by asking about a specific projector paper or book that's in the works, but you're working on several really interesting projects right now, examining issues ranging from deforestation to poverty to private governance as they pertain to cocoa farming. So I'll leave this a little more open ended than usual. Tell us what you do. Tell us how you got into this research. Oh, thank you. Well, I first got interested in this research when I did an internship in Cameroon, now about a decade ago, cocoa was actually one of the main drivers of deforestation. The context of Cameroon is not as big of a driver of deforestation as it is in West African countries, especially Coati-War and Ghana, where by far the number one driver of deforestation, but in Cameroon, it's less so. And I'd say the reason I became also more and more interested in cocoa is because it's quite an exciting crop that from a climate perspective can also do a lot to restore degraded ecosystems or to create landscapes that are both productive and also ecologically intact. So in the sense that you produce cocoa through agroforestry, agroforestry is actually the most sustainable way to produce cocoa in the long term. Something that really surprised me is that a majority of the cocoa in the world is grown in just two neighboring countries, Coati-War and Ghana. Why did cocoa farming end up so concentrated in this one part of the world? Yeah, that's a really great question. And it goes back quite far in history with Ghana and Coati-War both being previously colonized by European powers and the case of Coati-War was the French and Ghana, it was the British. And it was a colonist actually that introduced these types of export-oriented crops that were monocultures, even at the time. I think in both cases, the country's really focused on cocoa as a major economic revenue of the major government state-based revenue, of major development strategy for both countries, especially Coati-War has really focused on that post-independence. So cocoa really is the main driver behind Coati-War's economic growth. As climate shift, looking to these new countries like a Cameroon that might be getting into the chocolate game a little more, what can these countries learn from Coati-War and Ghana? What opportunities do they have to grow cocoa without the level of deforestation it's typically come with? Oh, definitely. I really believe that there are these opportunities. I think in the case of Cameroon, for example, Cameroon has a huge opportunity to brand itself and the cocoa that it produces as being more sustainable. Of course, there would have to be a system to set up, you know, verify that that's actually the case for the specific lots of cocoa that are being exported. But, you know, in the past, Cameroon has had a relatively bad reputation on the international cocoa market. That's a quality coming from Cameroon was not very high compared to Ghana, for example. And this is largely due to the drying process where Cameroon uses a lot of wood stove or you know, stove drying, so the cocoa can tend to be a little bit more smoky and flavor, which is not very desirable. So, you know, if those issues are managed and Cameroon starts to market itself as a country that, you know, has an experience as massive deforestation and is implementing Agroforestry as a major method for production, I think that there's a big opportunity there. At the same time, in Cotevoire, Ghana, I'm sure climate change presents a huge concern for the farmers who are already facing such difficult conditions and now their land might just become unsuitable for cocoa in the not-too-distant future. I know Cotevoire and Ghana recently started this living income differential program giving premiums to cocoa farmers, which certainly has its pros and cons. What are your thoughts on this program? Is it robust enough to succeed in a change in climate? Mm-hmm. Yeah, that's a great question. We're actually looking into that right now. I have a post-doc who's going to be going to Ghana in September to try to gain a better understanding from the various stakeholders involved in the living income differential and where this policy might have success and where this policy might have unintended consequences. It's especially related to even more deforestation. So, we're really excited about that research. It should be coming out, hopefully, within the next year. And yeah, we find it really interesting that the living income differential has been promoted as part of the effort to produce cocoa more sustainably. So, everybody understands that poverty is a root cause of deforestation. And so, addressing poverty, ideally, would also result in less deforestation. But that seems like a very simplistic understanding of the local context. And there's this paradox called Devon's paradox where actually the more resources a resource user is given access to, the more likely they are to use that resource. So, there is actually from an unintended consequences perspective, the real risk that the living income differential will increase deforestation if the proper mitigation tools are not put into place. So, that's something that we want to look at in the near future in the case of Ghana. And of course, all of this comes back to the fact that the cocoa traders are in oligopoly and that eliminates free market competition. I know there are some instances, though, wherein oligopoly makes more sense than lots and lots of small companies. I've seen the argument made for cable and electricity providers, for example. Is chocolate a natural oligopoly? And if not, does it make more sense to dismantle the oligopoly or work with it as best we can? Mm-hmm. And we have a research project on that, it's called Traders in Sustainability, a website just launched so you can check it out. But we're working with these commodity traders, not only cocoa, but also coffee and palm oil. And we're trying to understand what is their role when it comes to operationalizing sustainability to Bitcoin? Because on the one hand, yes, there's a lot of drawbacks, especially from a socio-economic perspective and power-balanced perspective between these massive corporations that are buying and trading cocoa and the millions of smallholder farmers who are eating out of living. But on the other hand, there may be opportunities there because you only need to change the mindset or change the operations of a handful of companies. And if they really put that to task, make meaningful change in their supply chains, we think that there might be a massive opportunity to really upscale the chains that is needed to have truly deforestation-free cocoa production and upscale agroforestry type methods for production. Yeah, the Traders in Sustainability project seemed really interesting. And I was particularly interested in the private governance piece of it because one common tool we see is certifications. We've discussed the pros and cons of certifications before, but with chocolate, it seems like it would be difficult when the farmers wouldn't have a lot of resources and certainly not the money to apply to be certified or something. How would certifications work for chocolate? Have we found a good way to do it? Yeah, that's an excellent question. So far, we haven't found the silver bullet. I would say I don't think progress is being made fast enough and there's obviously still deforestation happening. I think what's really promising is the Cocoa Enforced Initiative, which is the zero-deforestation commitment in Ghana and Co-C4, is a public-private partnership, which of course many academics would argue that doesn't necessarily make it a positive thing. But in the case of Cocoa, the government of the sector is very difficult for all the reasons I mentioned before. The millions of smaller farmers operating in remote areas, it's difficult to control. There needs to be a partnership. There needs to be collaboration between the public and the private actors involved. And especially this idea of what we call indirect supply chains. So Cocoa corporations or the companies that are buying, Cocoa will often have sustainability programs where they will be working with a number of smallholder farmers in the given geographic location. That will be their direct supply chain sustainability programs. But we found that they're also sourcing from areas of the country that are not within these sustainability programs. So that's called the indirect supply chain. And there there's a big question mark with regards to who's going to be governing those indirect suppliers. And very many people would argue, oh, it's, you know, the public sector, that's to be the government that manages that. But, you know, the government also has limited resources to actually regulate all of that. So there has to be some type of a collaboration. Last question, I know this can be a really depressing topic, seeing poverty and child labor and rapid deforestation. So I want to ask, should we feel guilty about eating chocolate? Or is any of this reason to stop eating chocolate? No, I think that's what's so exciting about Cocoa production that there are ways to not only reduce environmental harm, but actually enhance environmental benefit. And that's what's so beautiful about this agroforestry approach. Depending on how you do it, you know, cocoa farming can be a way to enhance biodiversity, enhance carbon mitigation or carbon sequestration compared to the status quo. So I do think that if your listeners out there are worried about their chocolate consumption, I would say maybe spend a little bit more time looking at the origin. And, you know, because there's a lot of chocolate products where you have no idea where it came from and, you know, there's no indication, no label, it's very likely that that came from Ghana and Cozyvar and that, you know, there might not be the most ethical practices involved behind that. But, of the other hand, there's a lot of opportunity to make positive change by establishing cocoa farms in integrated areas. I try to make that exact point every time we do a food episode, there's so much opportunity to fix these issues, it's never hopeless. So I completely agree with you there. Dr. Kurdenuto, thank you so much for joining us. Yeah, thank you Ethan with wonderful talk with you. This wraps up episode 61 of the sweaty penguin. Remember, you can get a shout out at the end of the show by leaving a five star rating in a review on Apple or podcast addict that helps boost us in their algorithms. You can also get a shout out by joining our Patreon, just like our latest patron, Laura Cremens. Thank you so much for joining our Patreon, Laura. We really appreciate it. Keep an eye out in the mail for your stickers and the Patreon website for all of our exclusive content. And if any of you want to join our Patreon family, unlock all that cool stuff and help grow the show, head to patreon.com/the sweaty penguin. It takes just a couple minutes, you can do it for just five bucks a month, and it really, really goes a long way. Once again, the sweaty penguin is presented by Parallel and Promise, a public media initiative from the WNET Group in New York, reporting on the issues and solutions around climate change. Thank you all for listening, and I'll see you next week. Today's episode was written by Olivia Amite, Ethan Brown, Shannon Demiano, and Maddie Schmitt, fact-checked by Megan Cremens, and edited by Frank Hernandez. Our producers are Olivia Amite, Ethan Brown, Megan Cremens, Shannon Demiano, Frank Hernandez, Dane Kim, and Caroline Cale. Our ads were voiced by Frank Hernandez, and our music was composed by Brett Saka, special thanks to our Emperor Penguin patrons Lawrence Harris and Brownie Central. Clips today came from CNN, France24English, CBSDFW, and fora.tv. [BLANK_AUDIO]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Chocolate production involves a complex, multi-step supply chain that spans from cocoa farms in West Africa to global manufacturers, leaving farmers disconnected from the final product.
  2. Cocoa farming in Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana, which account for nearly two-thirds of global cocoa, is deeply tied to poverty, with many farmers earning less than $1.25 per day and facing poor working conditions.
  3. A dominant oligopoly among cocoa traders—Barry Callebaut, Cargill, and Olam—controls pricing, suppressing farmer incomes and enabling exploitative practices like deforestation and child labor.
  4. Deforestation linked to cocoa expansion is a major environmental issue, with studies showing cocoa responsible for up to 25% of historical deforestation in Côte d'Ivoire and significant loss of primate and elephant populations.
  5. Climate change threatens cocoa farming through rising temperatures, reduced rainfall, and increased disease, making regions less suitable for growth by 2050.
  6. Initiatives like the Living Income Differential and Cocoa Protocol aim to improve farmer livelihoods and sustainability, but face challenges including unintended consequences like increased deforestation.
  7. Agroforestry and sustainable certification programs offer viable long-term solutions, though access and affordability are major barriers for smallholder farmers.
  8. Addressing the root cause—market oligopoly and lack of fair pricing—is essential to reducing environmental harm, poverty, and child labor in the cocoa industry.

Summary:

This episode of The Sweaty Penguin explores the complex, often exploitative supply chain of chocolate, focusing on its environmental and social costs. Cocoa farming in West Africa—especially Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana—drives significant deforestation and child labor due to low farmer wages and a powerful oligopoly among global traders. These traders control pricing, leaving farmers with minimal profits despite decades of labor-intensive work.

25 a day. Climate change exacerbates the crisis, threatening cocoa production through heat stress, drought, and disease. While initiatives like the Living Income Differential and the Cocoa Protocol aim to improve sustainability and farmer livelihoods, they face limitations such as unintended increases in deforestation and lack of enforcement.

The root issue is not just environmental but economic: a lack of fair market competition and pricing. Sustainable solutions include agroforestry, better certification systems, and increased investment in farmer education and technology. The episode concludes with a hopeful message: with systemic change—especially fair pricing and market reform—chocolate can be produced in a way that supports both farmers and the environment.

Eating chocolate isn't the problem; how it's produced is. Consumers are encouraged to check labels and support ethically sourced products, recognizing that chocolate can be part of a sustainable future if the industry transforms. The discussion ends with a nod to Disney’s new film, “Coco,” highlighting how a simple word can represent both a cultural staple and a complex global issue.

FAQs

Chocolate production involves many complex steps—such as fermentation, drying, roasting, and grinding—that take weeks and require the beans to travel across continents. Farmers never see the final product due to this lengthy supply chain.

Cocoa farming leads to deforestation, especially in Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana, which contributes to climate change. Deforestation also causes soil erosion, flooding, loss of biodiversity, and threatens species like elephants and primates.

Rising temperatures and reduced rainfall make cocoa farming harder, as cocoa plants are sensitive to drought. These changes could make large parts of West Africa unsuitable for cocoa production by 2050.

A small number of large trading companies—like Barry Callebaut, Cargill, and Olam—control the market (an 'oligopoly'), setting low prices. Farmers are often paid just enough to survive, with little room for fair wages.

No, chocolate is not going extinct. A false claim from 2018 was based on misinterpreted research. While climate change threatens cocoa production, it is a solvable problem with sustainable farming and adaptive solutions.

The Cocoa Protocol is an industry agreement where major chocolate companies commit to ethical and sustainable practices. It aims to reduce child labor, deforestation, and improve farmer livelihoods, though full success remains challenging.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.