Go back

China is killing the US on energy. Does that mean they’ll win AGI? — Casey Handmer

1h 8m 21s

China is killing the US on energy. Does that mean they’ll win AGI? — Casey Handmer

The U.S. remains competitive in the global energy and AI race despite China's dominance in solar manufacturing, due to superior industrial capabilities, abundant natural resources, and a flexible, automated production base. While China leverages excess electricity to produce synthetic fuels, giving it a strategic energy edge, the U.S. can rapidly scale solar capacity through existing technology, especially with coordinated government action. The U.S. advantage lies not in cost but in agility, automation, and access to natural gas, which supports both energy infrastructure and industrial resilience. However, regulatory hurdles—particularly NEPA and complex permitting—severely hinder solar deployment, creating a significant delay. Hyperscalers prioritize power availability over cost, and rising AI demand will drive down solar prices through steep learning curves, accelerating adoption. Unlike China, which relies on fossil fuels and faces global supply risks, the U.S. can produce solar energy efficiently and at scale, even in remote regions. The true bottleneck in AI progress remains silicon-based chip production, especially GPUs, where U.S. firms like TSMC maintain a critical lead. Ultimately, the U.S. can maintain its edge by combining aggressive solar deployment with strategic control over chip manufacturing, overcoming regulatory inertia and leveraging its industrial depth to avoid being outpaced by China in the long-term energy and AI transition.

Transcription

15102 Words, 82402 Characters

English
Today I'm interviewing Casey Hanmer. Casey has worked on a bunch of cool things, Caltech PhD on some gravitational wave black hole gimmick stuff, then Hyperloop, then the Jet Propulsion Laboratory at NASA, and now he is founder and CEO of Terraform Industries. Casey, welcome. Thank you. It's great to be here finally. Big picture question I'm interested in, to the extent that AI just ends up being this big industrial race, who can build the most solar panels, who can build the most batteries, who can build the most GPUs and transmission lines and transformers and et cetera, et cetera. This is not what the U.S. is known for, at least in recent decades. This is exactly what China is known for, where they have like 20x the amount of yearly solar manufacturing the U.S. has. Obviously, we have extra controls right now, but over time. Mick will catch up to TSMC's leading edge. So what is the story exactly of how the United States wins this? Like, why does China just not win by default? Do you think that China is better at capital allocation than the United States? Do you think the Chinese business environment is better for business than in the United States? I think you're going to make these first principles argument about these other industries where they're killing it. But, like, it doesn't seem to have hampered BYD or cattle. Well, people say, oh, look, they're so much better at building high-speed trains than the United States. Right. I would never, like, hold up a flag saying I'm really good at building high-speed trains. Like, that is just a sign that you're really bad at capital allocation. Like, why would you devote, in 2025, so much industrial effort and money? They're devoting a lot to solar overcapacity, which, in your opinion, is the key to future industrial growth. Accidentally correct. They call the most important thing correct, right? Which would count for something. Well, they're in a similar situation to Europe, but unlike the United States. So the United States is the luckiest goddamn country on Earth because it's surrounded on two sides by oceans and on the other two sides by, like, friendly allies. China's surrounded by 15 countries who are mostly hostile to it, right? With no good, like, mountain ranges or rivers or anything to really separate them. And then they get all their oil, almost all their oil from the Middle East, right? In countries that they don't control, don't have strong diplomatic relationships with, on fleets of oil tankers that they can't defend because their navy doesn't have the ability to operate effectively in the Indian Ocean. But you're working on this, right? If you get synthetic fuels working at terraforming. Personally, yes. Doesn't that asymmetrically help China? Which might be fine. It does. It absolutely does. It definitely helps China. We're not currently working with China. We don't plan to, but, like, the physics is very obvious, you know, and synthetic fuels have been around for 100 years. Like, there are projects in China right now working on synthetic fuels. It would not surprise me if they were thinking pretty seriously about this. Just to spell out for the audience, if China has all this electricity production, and the bottleneck is that only a third of final energy use in a modern economy comes from electricity. The rest, you need gas and whatever to transport things. Or coal. They use a lot of coal in China. Right. And what Casey is inventing is a technology. To turn that electricity, which only can supply a third of end uses right now, into synthetic fuels, which can supply 100% of the electricity your civilization needs. So then China's energy advantage then becomes overwhelming. This technology levels the playing field. It levels the playing field a lot. Right. But at the end of the day, you know, China still contains the poorest Chinese people anywhere on Earth. Right. I mean, but. Never underestimate the capacity for an autocratic dictatorship to shoot itself in the foot. I don't know. Whenever I agree that they've obviously made bad decisions, but even if you have the poorest Chinese people anywhere in the world, they can still be quite rich. You know, like Singapore's rich or whatever. Yeah. Also, there's parts of China which actually contain quite rich Chinese people. Oh, yeah. So you had to compare not all of China against the U.S., but Shanghai and Guangdong against the United States. So you can have a part of China that is as big as America and as wealthy as America and as innovative as America. Like the Indian middle class is larger than the U.S. middle class. But also, it's not nowhere near. Whereas there are parts of China which are humongous, which are actually as wealthy as the United States and in many cases as innovative, et cetera. Yeah. No, I'm saying don't underestimate it. But at the same time, like, you know, we want to find the truth here. Right. And the truth is, like, we should not count the United States out of the battle and just give up. We're very much still in the race now, provided we don't, you know, take extra effort to shoot ourselves in the foot. So right now, we are export controlling chips for the purpose of we want to keep our AI lead or stay in. And we recognize this is a key input in our ability to compete in AI. So we are going to export control China's ability to have these chips. Energy is also a key input in this AI race. And if China wanted to do the converse of what we're doing to them with these cheap imports, what they would do to us is to export control solar and batteries. It would be asymmetrical. It would hurt them worse than us. It would deter us? Yeah. Well, China obviously depends upon, like, the U.S. export market for its economic. It's going to hurt both parties to, like, sever that link. But if you sever the link completely, China's ability to make advanced chips right now is, like, basically not there, whereas the United States can make them. And the United States' ability to make solar arrays is embryonic, but it's, you know, it's actually not that far behind China's, right? It's maybe five years behind. If we decided we want to produce 100 gigawatts of solar capacity every single year. We're already on track to do that. Okay. Is it going to be as cheap as it is to do in China? My views on this are somewhat different from the mainstream, which is great because this is a podcast. So the mainstream view would say, well, China has cheaper labor, which is no longer true because they compared to Mexico. And it's got lower environmental regulations, which is true, and that it is more business friendly, which is absolutely crazy. I've never heard, like, there's no way you could justify that, like, your company having to have a, like, inspector from the CCP on its board who, like, harasses you about Xi Jinping every day, like, helps you do your business. And also, like, the rule of law is not great. So, like, you're constantly having to pay bribes to people in order to stay in business, right? The idea that the United States cannot compete against that with, like, mostly or fully automated solar panel manufacturing in the United States, which has cheaper natural gas by far, abundant oil, abundant human resources, great financial capacity, you know, world-leading automation, et cetera, et cetera, is crazy. Like, we could literally copy-place solar manufacturing factories. How much additional solar power capacity do you think we could be putting on that's manufactured in the U.S. by 2028? This is a good question. When Russia invaded Ukraine, I thought, ah, finally. The Europeans will see sense. And they'll, like, pull the trigger on, like, we need to localize production of solar panels from dirt to the finished module, which is, like, roughly a four-stage process. They didn't. So they're still paying Russia, like, a billion dollars a day for the privilege of being invaded. But at the time, I thought they could probably do that in about two years. And I think the United States could probably do that in two years or less if you started today. Like, it's currently 11 o'clock. So, like, we're going to start cutting checks by noon. And, yeah, I think you could ramp up pretty quickly. A lot of technology already exists here. It's not like it has to be. It's not invented from scratch. It's mostly a case of, like, putting in a phone call to all the different manufacturers here in Germany and so on and saying, we need you to turn exercise to your factory starting today. Blank check. Go. I guess a lot of your predictions seem to be not predictions, but more like if we had World War II levels of motivation, if we had Manhattan-level project-level intensity around doing a specific thing, how fast could we do it? Which is, like, if Elon was running the government, how fast could it happen versus… It was for a brief period. So, maybe then we should put it like, if Elon ran the government like he ran SpaceX, as opposed to the question of, like, okay, what is actually practically likely to happen given that we are not treating it with World War II level intensity? So, if you look at XAI, which Elon is involved in, obviously, what are they actually focusing on right now, right? They're focused on the chips, right? Because they understand, like, the key bottleneck is the chips, not the solar power, right? Because even if Trump puts in a 200% tariff on Chinese solar, right, and we're not able to bypass it via, like, Vietnam or something, it's still a problem. It's still a bargain. It doesn't matter. Like, if you need solar to run your data center, it doesn't hurt in terms of the overall cost picture. It doesn't matter at all. What matters is having the chips at, like, competitive capabilities per chip and enough of them, you know, installed in your PCBs, in your data centers, hooked up to your liquid cooling, ready to go, right? And that's actually something that, you know, Elon and his companies are great at. It's, like, figuring out this mass production, semi-automated mass production. They've got this facility in Texas, which is making the Starlink receivers completely automated. But, like, at what point does, like, oh, we don't… We don't have a solar panel factory become on the critical path, right? I very much doubt it's ever going to be on the critical path. There's dozens and dozens of manufacturers of solar panels worldwide that are all competing against each other. So, you're a big solar bull. Yeah. Right now, the hyperscalers are making decisions about, with the data centers that they're building, they're going to be 1 gigawatt, 2 gigawatts, or in Meta's case, 5 gigawatts, how they're going to be actually powered. And the people with actual money on the line are choosing natural gas. And it's not like they can't see the learning. I mean, they're building things which will be online in 28 or 30 or something. So, why are they wrong and you're right? I mean, it's their job. They probably know more about it than I do. But, no, in all seriousness, if you're, like, XAI right now trying to build Colossus 1 data center in downtown Memphis, right, you want to get it done super fast. So, you're like, what are all the different things we need? What are the factors of production to build this? We need a building. Well, we don't have time to build a building. We'll buy a building. Okay, and we'll adapt it. We need power. We need thermal cooling. That's stuff you can deliver on a truck. So, that's what they did. You need access to gas. They had access to gas there. They could tap into a local gas line. And, actually, if you can tap into a gas line, generally speaking, you can get enough power. Like, the energy transmission capacity of, like, your regular gas delivery pipelines is way, way higher than electricity overhead lines and it's easier to upgrade or whatever. And so, if you're in this situation right now, you say, well, you know, are we constrained by our ability to go and rent gas turbines? And, no, they're not because there was enough available once, maybe twice, right? But, at a certain point, you realize, well, as you grow, you start to touch all. There's additional constraints and some of those constraints include gas availability. So, there's a lot of chat about doing this in Pennsylvania, for example, where there's quite a lot of stranded gas in parts of Texas. But, at the same time, the United States is gearing up in its ability to export natural gas. overseas so the price will not be infinitely low forever um you you start to run into constraints around turbine manufacturing rate around a transformer you know a transformer production rate around grid capacity um and and also kind of running into problems where where the ais and and the humans who depend on like kind of legacy electricity uh production and delivery utilities uh kind of competing with each other we just saw this recent um ford auction in pgm result in um in like kind of very high like unsustainably high prices for for consumers who depend on cheap electricity to like you know heat and cool their houses and have general prosperity so so if you kind of look far enough in the future you say well you know you can just turn up the dial arbitrarily high like you can say well we're going to put in a gigawatt a year well we can we can meet that constraint with gas turbines right we're not going to run out of natural gas at one gigawatt per year indefinitely okay what if we're doing five gigawatts per year what if we're doing 50 gigawatts per year what if we're doing a hundred gigawatts per year like right you can you can just break the situation yeah does that make sense yeah um but not to reach prematurely for analogies but but like henry kaiser set up the uh shipyard in richmond just down the road here uh in san francisco over near berkeley um and uh initially making ships for the british and then by the end of the war four separate shipyards operating in parallel to the point where like he was bottlenecked on his supply of steel because steel was rare enough in the war because everyone was using it for different things that kaiser industries went off and built not only steel mill but also a steel mine right they went and started digging rocks out of the ground to turn into ships yeah right and it's the same sort of situation you have here where these these massive industrial verticals and here i'm quite bullish on xa in particular because the elon cinematic universe has just done so much industrial stuff compared to you know the googles and metas of this world can kind of reach all the way through down into primary material supply if they need to the reason that these current plans are being done based on natural gas is that this is a sort of like pgm has all kinds of different sources of power right they have nuclear as well they have gas they have coal all kinds of stuff and actually this this price here is is probably driven more by the delivery cost growth than by the generation cost growth if that makes sense so when you pay your utility bill the cost is sometimes broken down by like a delivery cost and a generation cost uh sometimes importation costs and things and so the delivery cost is the cost of you know basically what it costs the utility to build and all the houses to all the power plants in some gigantic area divided by your marginal usage with all kinds of other complicated rules designed to make it fairer and the problem that we see in you know the reason that pgme here in california for example is perpetually on the brink of bankruptcy is that even though like the cost of an additional solar panel or additional wind turbine or additional gas turbine or whatever is relatively cheap getting that power to your house is actually really expensive right why because you've got you know generally like unionized labor that has to build and maintain power lines in areas that already have built up infrastructure so you have like multiple collisions whether this is like a power pole on your own street or like building a new transmission line which requires you to like eminent domain land so you're in court for like years and years and years spending public money litigating against other people who are also spending public money to litigate against you on behalf of other interest groups and so on and so forth and then you've got wildfires and and it's just um just like it's like the poster child for bar more cost disease so one of the reasons that like we're going to see large-scale pruning of these grids is that we just can't afford under our current regulatory regime to maintain when you say pruning or just like everything will just go off grid well i mean it's fairly clear to me that for really like large captive loads like our data centers or or aluminum refineries or whatever you're going to have to build your own power plant for them which is how it used to work like if you if you had an aluminum plant back in you would be building your own power plant for it as well seems inefficient to have redundant power plants at every single industrial let me pen a grand vision for you um it would seem inefficient but but actually like if you are sensitive to the cost of power expressed maybe in like supply elasticity or something like that you just have to do it there's no two ways about it like um is it inefficient for the xia colossus data center to have its own captive power plant which it does right on the backs of a bunch of trucks yeah in their parking lot no it's not inefficient it's right it's the your question across different kinds of isos like from texas to pennsylvania to whatever um people are building data centers which will not be online for many years and they're choosing natural gas what's going on well i think they you know we haven't completely exhausted the supply of the turbines relative to gpus and do you have some estimate of when we'll run out of because we can also make more well i think everything before about 2030 is spoken for at this point yeah you could make more turbines yeah um the funny thing is like it's actually relatively expensive i think to like spool up additional production of of these turbines for example so so actually here's one here's one thing you have to grapple with sooner or later conventional power generation is a steam engine right right so you you have um some kind of chemical that you find inside the earth that is out of chemical equilibrium with the atmosphere and you burn it and makes heat it could be coal could be gas oil you're gonna be the true birds and bees here yeah exactly and it makes heat and you boil water and the water goes through some kind of mechanical contrivance that creates motion and then that motion twists a magnet and generates an electrical field which then pushes electrons down wires which then push electrons through a series of gates that then approximate thinking it's kind of kind of complicated um but but the key the key step uh in this which is converting heat into electricity in the most efficient most common and this is the same if it's a nuclear plant or a gas plant combined cycle plant or a coal plant or whatever is what's called a brayton cycle um a jet engine on an aircraft is a brayton cycle as well and just anytime you have a brayton cycle with like a bunch of incanel spinning at high speed it's just going to cost you like a bunch of money sorry because it's inherently inefficient or what it's just inherently expensive to build okay what is the cost of so um like g makes these 100 megawatt gas turbines right i guess yeah i don't actually know what the retail price is i would suspect that if their price is is um flexible it would have gone up a lot but i if i recall correctly it's like 35 bucks a megawatt hour is just the flag four cost for how much right 35 bucks a megawatt hour just for just for the brayton cycle right so we're not talking about the fuel we're not talking about the heat exchanges we're not talking about you know the cooling ponds or anything like that uh just just the amortized cost of the high speed high temperature spinning components is 35 bucks a megawatt hour do you think the hyperscalers are being irrational or do they have some reason oh to be clear they don't care about cost on for cost of power this is this seems extremely like it's very counterintuitive so for like grandma kettle pennsylvania she's very sensitive to electricity cost and we don't really want her to like suffer in her retirement from unaffordable electricity costs and like having to sit there shivering like that's not the image that we want at the same time like what what is the what is the economic value to you of using i don't know claude or grok or whatever you use like on a monthly basis yeah but like it's obviously much more than the subscription but like is it like 10 times more than the subscription maybe yeah okay let's say so let's say the subscription is on the order of 10 bucks the value is on the order of 100 bucks no actually probably like 100 and 1000 how much does it cost xai or anthropic or whatever to serve the marginal variable cost of like serving it like in electricity is like less than 10 of the actual cost of uh well their cost of serving it is is like maybe a buck per million tokens or something like that and the cost of electricity is about 10 of that yeah so it's like 10 cents of electricity is generating a thousand dollars worth of economic value right right so it's very obvious that anthropic could be like our electricity cost is increased by a factor of 100 and now instead of paying 10 cents on your 100 bill for power you're paying 10 cents on your 100 bill for power you're paying 10 cents on your 100 bill for power you're paying 10 bucks right right so we're putting your your uh your subscription up to 110 dollars for an electricity capacity charge right and then they could go out and buy turbines for prices that would make your eyes water okay so um then why are we gonna get the solar future like in 2032 we're gonna have hundreds of gigawatts of extra demand for data centers and at that point most of it's coming from solar and why is that well you just there aren't enough turbines being being manufactured right but also i think um in the early 2000s if you just uh we can probably overlay the graph of like how many turbines are being manufactured like right now we're at historical they've ramped up basically to like the early 2000s right again but i don't know you got to make more solar panels as well right like there will be uh supply elasticities for both solar and natural gas is there some reason to think that it's worse for the supply chain involved in having a natural gas powered data center than yeah i do um the learning rate for for natural gas is nowhere near steeper solar which just tells you that it's easy to make solar panels much easier to make solar panels so there are actually very few manufactured products which are you're not going to be able to make solar panels much easier to make solar panels there are actually very few manufactured products which are easier to make like the learning the learning the uh the right slow coefficient is 43 so every time we double communal production we get a 43 reduction in cost and what is the basis of um like why are we finding 43 percent worth of things that can be made cheaper or more efficient every single year well i mean roughly speaking there's like 10 000 manufacturing process engineers working on this full time right that could be true of any process right but no other process sees uh the kinds of learning it's absolutely true um that's what we're seeing yeah so in order to like sustain this over a long period of time you obviously need to have like uh demand elasticity that exceeds like your learning rate yeah right so so otherwise you would after you know a couple of booms you would you would saturate your market at the current price and you'd have no additional growth but in this case like you know every roughly every two years we're doubling production two to two and a half years doubling production the price is coming down by a factor of 40 40 percent uh so like roughly 20 15 20 per year and then just as a result of that price reduction demand skyrockets by like probably six times more than that additional marginal capacity like production capacity increase right and this is one point where i'll say actually the pros so-called pros are definitely wrong conventional wisdom is like oh solar demand is going to saturate like this this week it's gonna it's gonna saturate We've got a graph here somewhere that's like, this year is it. It's never going to grow anymore. And instead, it's just like blasting out the top of the graph. And this conventional wisdom is wrong. It is not only the case that solar adoption, production, price decreases are continuing. They're accelerating. And the rate that they're accelerating is still accelerating, right? Wait, sorry. The rate that it's accelerating is accelerating? Yes. As measured in the total fraction of energy that's coming from solar or? In the sense that it's fitness for the markets that it is being produced for is increasing over time. So it is still extremely early, right? We're still at like the Apple II computer era of solar. Backing up, the story is that the reason solar is getting cheaper is because there's a lot of demand for more solar. And that demand can sustain economies of scale or whatever is going on. Yes. I'm going to go ad lim here and like agree with Elon Musk on this. Then shouldn't that also be true of? Like gas turbines and transformers and power stations and whatever else that's required for the non-solar future? Because like even there, we're expecting AI to drive up demand for power regardless of the source. So to the extent the story for solar becoming cheaper over time is just that like, well, demand will go off and that will drive efficiencies. Why isn't that true for? Well, let's say you're a bank and you're trying to decide whether to lend, I don't know, like G, a bunch of money to like expand production of the gas turbines. You can write them the check today. and then they'll start scaling up their factories, and then they'll start to see the benefits in three or four or five years. You don't know if the AI bubble will have burst by then. You don't know if China will have invaded Taiwan by then. You don't know if Siemens or Philips or someone will have out-competed you. You don't know if GE's major looming structural problems will cause it to be unable to compete as it has in the past. You also don't know. In order to make that money back, you have to then operate that plant at that capacity for 20 years. If I was looking at the same charts as they're looking at right now, I'd say, what are the odds that in 25 years' time we can produce gas turbines at a price that is relevant in a world where solar is already at its current price and batteries are at a price where they're already? You cannot win. I think there was actually a similar discussion a couple years back or a year back when AI people were like, no, AI is real, this is going to happen, and then SK Hynix, Samsung, et cetera, were like, we're not ramping up HBM production because, oh, HBM is used largely for AI workloads and if this demand doesn't continue, then our manufacturing, additional manufacturing capacity for HBM will not have been worth it. And then there was another bottleneck with Coase. What happened after that? Did they end up indeed ramping up their production? I think so. Well, so when someone says, we can't do it, we won't do it, no way, no how. I mean, not in the US. What they're saying is, write me a check. Right. Right, and they did. And now Samsung's coming on board in the States to build T6 with XAI, I think. So, like, they all got there in the end. Maybe it's worth going into the numbers, right? So, right now, 43% of US data center power consumption is from natural gas. And basically, you think asymptotically that will be, like, 100% solar? If you go to, like, 2040? Yeah, so, I mean, obviously, like, legacy production coal and stuff is going to retire over time. Right. And if a gas plant is still making money, people will keep operating it. But at a certain point, like, it is the case right now that operating a coal plant costs more than building a new solar plant. So it's just cheaper to turn it off. So, yeah, I want to know what the. And obviously, capacity is going to increase a lot. So, that helps to dilute the existing production. Yeah. And also, the amount of use is going to increase a bunch, right? Like, the amount of, like, data center use of energy will just be exponentially higher. So, the new stock matters a lot as compared to the existing stocks. Anyway, so, I want to know, 2027, what fraction is natural gas? 2030, what fraction is natural gas versus solar? For new load or for. Let's say new load. For new load. 2035, etc. Basically, like, okay, if eventually you're right, that will pave the earth and solar panels to sustain our quadrillions of AI souls. What is the pace of that? Well, I think the question to ask is, like, what is the major constraint on that ramp up? Right. Right. And then everything else will just draft in behind. And I suspect that the hardest thing to make will always be the silicon, like the GPUs. Right? So, the question is really, how quickly does TSMC ramp up its production of GPUs? And that's a question for you, not for me. I'll just use some numbers that AI 2027 used for their compute forecast, which even if you don't buy their singularity thing, I think they did a reasonably good job with crunching the numbers on their compute forecast. And I think they said there's on the order of 10 million H100 equivalents in the world today. And I think they said by 2028, there'd be 100 million. So, basically 10x more H100 equivalents in the world. About a kilowatt each, something like that? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So, it's like 100 gigawatts. Right. Okay. And that's, I mean, that sounds roughly right. You're not the first person to give me a call and ask me about this. That way. I'm not going to name names, but like pretty much all the names you've heard of have given me a call and said like, we know that you're a minority voice on the paper that came out recently with scale microgrids talking about how you could do 90% solar, 10% gas. And I said, you can go all the way 100% solar. I read a blog post about it. And so they always call me up and say, what about this? And they're all talking like five gigawatts in the next few years. So, and that's just like 90 plus percent solar for just those. So, I think within a few years, we'll probably see that like the majority of new DCs that are going in will be mostly solar. Within, sorry, how long? Let's say by, let's see, what's it, 2027, majority of new DCs going in at that point would be mostly solar. Going in as in like new. As in groundbreaking at that point. But if you're groundbreaking in 27, you're probably like planning it now, right? Oh, that's why they're calling me. Yeah. My consulting fees are extremely affordable. But I really, I don't have deep visibility because I'm not in the same room with like, with the meta people as to like, when we're going to hit the wall on transformers and when we're going to hit the wall on like, just how much like municipal like peak load can we shave off, which is the latest thing that's been doing the rounds, which it turns out like there's a handful of places in the United States and by handful, I mean like literally handful where like they might have used to be in an aluminum smelter. There's a bunch of like latent capacity in the grid and there's also a bunch of generators on the grid that are notionally turned down and they're like operators, say 40, 50% capacity factor. But they max out at about 80% capacity factor because you've got to bring them down for maintenance pretty often, right? Especially if they're old. And so they're saying, well, you know, we could pay you just to like operate this old coal plant or something at higher capacity. It'll go down this power line to this place where the smelter used to be. We'll set up there and then we promise to like curtail when you need the power. Right. Which basically means they just have like a massive captive battery plant as well, which is fine. You just buy that and it arrives on a truck. The major advantage to doing that over the pure solar play is that the power is already there. So there's no risk there. There's no, and then you don't need a massive amount of land. Like the problem with the solar approach is that there's no two ways about it. It's just, it's a farming operation. You need a huge amount of land. Yeah. Right. The total amount of land that you're using, less than 1% is under batteries, under roads, under data center structures, et cetera, et cetera. It's mostly solar. Right. Okay. So let's get into what this, if you've got a 5 gigawatt plant you want to build. Yes. Break down the numbers for me in how much land in terms of solar you need to farm this out. And especially, I was talking to somebody in this space and they said, look, the big problem is not, obviously, cost for, the cost of energy for these data centers is a small fraction of the total cost. Most of the cost is going towards chips. So then the issue is just, can you make the energy available? And they were saying, even those solar panels themselves, you can acquire. The issue is getting that much contiguous land and getting the permitting to interconnect it or whatever the word is, is like apparently a big hassle. Yep. It's kind of a nightmare. Yeah. And so, they're like, well, at that point, is it actually easier than just getting on the grid or, but yeah, what's your, like if you need tens of thousands of acres of solar, where can you do that and get like? Basically in Texas. I mean, like, there's this very popular misconception that like there's not enough land to do solar. Right. Right. This is garbage. If you've ever flown in an aircraft in the United States and you've ever looked out the window, you'd be like, oh, wow, look, there's a lot of land you could put solar on, especially west of like 110. Yeah. Right. Does it need to be flat or no? No. Okay. It doesn't matter. Like, do trees grow on mountain slopes? So it doesn't matter. Right. And the total amount of land, so just for reference, Nevada is something like 80 million acres or something like that. So just Nevada, which is like 90% federal land, is 80 million acres. And I would, I would never say that we should, we should sacrifice Nevada to the AI and pave the entirety of Nevada from one wall to the other. But I just saw a bunch of things in my feed the last couple of days that like, you know, Vegas is falling apart. Really? Well, like no one, the boomers are retiring. No one goes there anymore. People would go to see like the 100 million acres of solar. Yeah. Okay. So five gigawatt plant. So even if you did it in Nevada, we can do it anywhere. You can do it anywhere. You can find the land. Yeah. Right. People say, well, you can't do this in Europe because Europe doesn't have solar power. Europe has solar power. I've been to Europe in summer. It's like sunny for like 20 hours of the day. Right. It's a bit seasonal. Right. But that's not a big deal. Wait. I mean, it is because you, because energy is a small fraction of the cost. You care more about making sure the chips are running all the time, right? Yeah. So in practice, what happens is, let's say Europe hypothetically like awakens from its slumber and decides it wants to participate in AI. Okay. I hope it does. They say, well, we're going to have to put, you know, a hundred gigawatts down of solar at some point to build these data centers. It most likely be in Southern Europe. Spain is not particularly heavily populated. That's a great place to start. So we put in a hundred gigawatts of solar, solar data center in Spain. And then in order to achieve, you know, basically if you're spending like AI hyperscaling money, on your GPUs, you want to have like four nines of uptime in order to maximize your like tokens per dollar spent. Yep. Okay. Tokens per dollar spent on the entire project, not just on that. This is a very subtle point. I can go into vast detail on it later on maybe, but let's just say you need four nines of uptime. In order to achieve that, achieve four nines uptime in like the middle of winter. You need to have a lot of solar overbuilt, right? Is solar overbuilt a bad thing? No. Is the fact that we produce 40% more food than we need a bad thing? No. It's much better than producing 40% less than we need. Okay. And it just means that effectively you have a giant captive power plant attached to a data center that 99.9% of the time produces more power than it needs. And 99% of the time produces much more power than it needs. And that can now actually be the source of power that the low-key utility, instead of being like, naughty, naughty data center, you must disconnect. When we tell you to, they say, hey, data center, I noticed you've got like a bunch of power you're not using 360 days of the year. Would you mind ever so much if we threw a power cable over the wall and we powered our entire town off your spare power at like essentially zero marginal cost plus whatever residential batteries that we need in addition to local power supply? Yeah. Brian Potter had a good analogy in his blog post about this where he's like, I don't know, my MacBook has a terabyte of gigabyte. And I just got the terabyte version because it's cheap enough and I might need it at some point that it's worth it. And so you're seeing solar gets so cheap that it's the way we'll treat hard drive space. There's like get a bunch of excess. Yeah. But also like the market will be made at the place, like the new marginal like consumption and production, right? So like all the people who are working in the space right now are like, oh, I'm in the business of delivering power or storing power. And I'm like, oh, I'm in the business of delivering power or storing power I'm going to serve the AI market because that's where all the growth is occurring. That's where all of us GDP growth is occurring right now. I guess you didn't answer the question of yes, theoretically we could do this, but is it going to be possible to get the permitting to have tens of thousands of acres of contiguous? It doesn't need to be contiguous. Well, I mean, it helps if it's contiguous. It doesn't need to be convex. So this is, you can have a bit over here and a bit over there and you can wire them together relatively easily. In fact, in the limit, you have fields upon fields of solar arrays with, tell me your dream case. Okay. Fields, just, just solar is as far as I can see. And then within the solar arrays, roughly in the middle of them, you have your, your batteries and your, I play factorial. I remember this. I remember this optimal layout of like batteries and batteries and you've got your data centers. So in terms of ground, like floor area, you know, it's roughly, let's say 10%, um, racks, 10% access to the racks. Um, maybe like 50% batteries stacked up on top of each other. And this is cooling something like that in terms of what, what sits in the, in the, like the centralized node. Right. And that could be a hundred megawatts or it could be 10 gigawatts, depending on how you want to scale this. But then all you need to connect that to the outside world is like an optical fiber, right? An optical fiber cable, which you can string up on poles. You can run it underground. You could even use microwave links. If you really wanted to, you could use Starlink if you really wanted to. I don't know what the Starlink would be fast enough. I'm not sure if it's like capacity is high enough. You could use laser links if you really needed to. And that's, that's it. It's like this completely self-contained world of like, Because it's off grid. Yeah. Of computation that occurs off grid, like on private land, somewhere in the backwoods of Texas where like no one lives and no one will ever live because it's completely inhospitable to humans. In terms of the ratios, it's one trend that was impressed upon me is that the power density of racks is increasing a lot as the flops per GPU are increasing. So we've, It's like a megawatt per rack is what they're heading to now, which just seems bananas to me. I think it was even more. I think it was even more than that. But yeah, yeah, yeah. So let's, let's get concrete here for a second. You got, let's say you got one rack and it's one megawatt and I'll leave the cooling to like someone who specializes in air conditioners, but it's, it's basically three air conditioners at the problem. And then you have batteries. So in order to get four nines of uptime on this, you need in, in South Texas, you actually need less than this, but let's just say 24 hours worth of, of battery storage, right? Because that means it'll get you through two of the two, two bad nights in a row, basically. And, and actually it turns out that you can significantly decrease power consumption with a very small reduction in overall compute. So if you, if you've got like three really bad days in a row or something, you can actually just like, you can dial back your power usage quite a lot without compromising your inference or, or, um, or training. Okay. So you've got say a Tesla Powerwall, something like four megawatt hours. So one, one megawatt rack, and then six Tesla mega packs, each of which is roughly one truckload worth of stuff. So like one truckload worth of rack, and then like six truckloads worth of batteries. Uh, and then in order to operate this at an average power of, of one megawatt, your solar arrays in Texas would be something like 25% utilization. So on average, you know, if, if the sun came up every day and the day was the same length all the time, you would need four megawatts of solar arrays, which is about four acres of land. But in practice, because you're owing for four nines instead of like one nine, uh, you need an overbuild about two and a half X. So you've got about 10 acres of solar. Uh, so 10 acres of solar, uh, six truckloads of batteries, one truckload of, of, um, of data center and some cooling stuff. And that's for how big of a one megawatt. That's just a one megawatt. So 10 acres, one megawatt, uh, kind of situation at, um, at four nines. Yeah. So if you want five gigawatts and that's 5,000 times 10 to 50,000 acres. And actually at larger scale, you can get, you can probably cut all those numbers down by 10, 10, 20%, but like on that order and like 50,000 acres sounds like a lot. It does sound like a lot. The amount of land put aside for Oak Ridge was a hundred thousand acres. The amount of land put aside for Hanford was about a hundred thousand acres. What's Hanford? Hanford was where they made the plutonium in the, in the Manhattan project. Okay. Yeah. I don't know. That was a hundred thousand acres. Okay. I mean, I mean, is it like, what was it? Was it like, oh, this is so small. And then you were like, oh, but it's a hundred thousand acres or. Well, so the reason they, and it's still largely unpopulated now because it's the national laboratory. But the reason they did that was they thought, oh, we're going to need four piles to produce plutonium. These are not, um, these are not nuclear reactors that produce excess thermal energy. So you can't actually make nuclear power with them, but you're making plutonium with them. And then in the end, they only needed two, I think. And they wanted them spaced out because they thought like they might just like spontaneously like explode and a bunch of other facilities and plants. Oh, Austin Vernon had an interesting blog post where he said that if, uh, if you allow for, if you have like diesel generators or something, which can take over the generation for like 10% of the generation during these, you know, with a winter or something, uh, then you can have a 60% reduction in the amount of solar panels you need to install because you don't need to have, you don't need to plan for that contingency. Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, basically there's a balance here. So this is not a very complicated optimization problem. Like for people who do optimization problems for fun, this is how you do it. You start off with a bunch of it, like NREL data on like what your solar abundance is in this particular part of the world. Uh, and then you just start throwing solar panels and batteries at it over like the course of a one-year simulation until you hit the number of nines you want. Right. And then you, to an extent you can trade the amount of panels and the amount of batteries you've got back and forth. And there's like a very, very broad optimum, right. Or you can throw in a third thing, like a diesel backup or a gas turbine or whatever. The issue here is look, if these, uh, if Meta or Microsoft or whoever just wants to get something off the, off the ground, um, this might be low OPEX to have this huge solar farm, but high CAPEX, um, where you need to hire like 30,000 people to go out in the middle of a desert and install 50,000 acres worth of solar panels. And they're like, why would I not just buy like 50 gas turbines? Why don't I just outbid like Microsoft or Meta outbids Google or something for the, for the last gas turbine that's available that year? Yeah. I mean, totally. The, the, the thing that, the thing that like, I think Meta has realized is like, it's like Zuck is running out of time to spend his money to win. The CAPEX is not crazy high, just to be clear. Like the CAPEX is still dominated by just the GPUs. Right. Right. So like how much does five gigawatts worth of GPUs cost? I don't know if my numbers will be wrong, but like 250 billion or something. Yeah. 250 billion. Sounds about right. Yeah. Okay. So like is 50,000 acres going to cost $250 billion in Texas? That's so much money. Wait, I, I didn't, uh, I did the math. I'm talking, we're talking like maybe a hundred million, hundreds of millions of dollars, something like that. So it's like literally 0.1% of the cost is land, right? How much does a megawatt of solar cost? Well, if you go and ask the usual suspects, they'll tell you a million dollars, but this is one of the things that breaks my brain at Terraform, which is my day job, which is that the, the modules themselves, if without tariffs would be like 8 cents a watt. So that's like $80,000. 8 cents a watt? Yeah. But they're like a dollar a watt, including installation and everything. Including installation and everything. Yes. The panels are the magic part. They're the thing that turns sunlight into pure electrical energy at 25% efficiency. Everything else should be like less than that. And that's what we're, if you want to work on that project, come and work with us at Terraform because we're very cost sensitive. We'll give you an opportunity to show, don't worry. Constantly. But, uh, no, in all seriousness, like the central takeaway is that, is that the hyperscalers are not power cost sensitive. They are power availability sensitive. And for all these things, you just run into this like supply elasticity wall at the sort of rates of increase that we're talking about. And, and solar is by far the best option for like fire hosing energy at a given problem. Right. Because it's just, it rains down from the sky. If you're running a frontier technology company, you know how essential it is to recruit the world's best talent. But this requires navigating the Byzantine U.S. immigration system. Not only do you not have the time to deal with this yourself, you just don't have the time to deal with this yourself, you just don't have the tacit knowledge to maximize the probability of success. But given how critical exceptional talent is, you can't take any risks with visa approval. You need to work with the best. Lighthouse handles everything better and faster than you possibly could. And they do it all with minimal input from you. Lighthouse knows the nooks and crannies of the immigration machine. They know how to frame publications and awards or how to structure comp comparisons versus benchmarks and how to put everything together into the most compelling story possible. And they've even optimized the tiny details, like the tone they use when they draft support letters to help U.S. immigration officials understand the importance of tech and startups. Companies like Cursor, Together AI, and Physical Intelligence are all already working with Lighthouse. You can join them by visiting lighthousehq.com slash employers. All right, back to Casey. Between the fact that maybe solar prices will go down and the fact that demand is going to go up, do you think electricity prices are likely to rise? Yes. But electricity prices at this point are a reflection of a regulatory irrationality, right? And it's the same situation in Europe, and Australia for that matter. Like, your prices will rise until you've had enough. And you say, no, we demand that you allow us to take advantage of power technology that's been invented in the last 50 years. In terms of things that are causing us to lose to China, tariffs are neither here nor there because, as we've discussed, we're not sensitive to cost on power. But the environmental regulations that are actively preventing us from deploying renewable energy in the United States, like, this is the reason Texas is winning. Texas is out-deploying California 10 to 1. The regulatory environment around solar is just insane. It's insane. The regulatory environment. Okay. So in the United States, part of the reason that solar has not been deployed at massive scale yet is that. A bunch of laws went into action in the early 1970s that were intended to protect our environment. And that makes a lot of sense. And our environment's a great thing. We should protect it. I mean, I think people will be familiar with NEPA and whatever, but how is it especially impacting solar? Well, let's say you've got a bunch of private land out in the middle of nowhere, right? And you want to build solar on it. You'll probably end up triggering NEPA, right? At which point you now have to do what is not in the law but considered necessary under current regulations, which is like your four-year environmental impact review, which generates, like, so much paper that just the environmental impact of producing. The report, because you have to cut down trees to make paper, is more than the environmental impact of just deploying the solar. Like, this is bonkers. It is crazy town, right? The thing that drives me particularly crazy in Southern California is that just because solar's kind of new and off-grid solar is very new, unless you're very, very careful, you end up getting regulated as though you're trying to build a chemical plant, even though it's a solar array. And the impact of solar around desert is arguably positive because it shades the ground and improves, like, solar moisture retention. Like, if you want. If you wanted to reverse desertification, you would basically just deploy solar panels on it, and that would pay for the process. But you end up having to go through more stringent environmental review process than if you just wanted to, like, grade the whole thing and cover it in concrete. Or grade it and then park a bunch of, like, old rusting cars that are dropping oil into the aquifer. Right. Right. Which, in many cases, you don't need a permit for at all. Right. But to build the solar, you have to go through this whole process. And, like, if there's one thing that anyone listening to this can do, it would be, like, have a categorical exemption for solar deployment. Or just, like, if I put money in an escrow account that says, like, if after 20 years we have to pull this out, like, we'll pull the solar out of the desert and it goes back to being desert. Right. I will do that in a heartbeat. But, like, if I have to hire another biologist for $10,000 to be like, well, on that 40-acre plot, we found a tuft of grass, which we believe might be a critical, you know, one of the 20 species that this particular species of bee sometimes eats. And this species of bee is not technically endangered, but it might be at some point in the future. Therefore, you can't deploy there. Even though it's, like. Zoned, unrestricted industrial, and it's sandwiched between a rocket test stand and, like, a chemical plant, for example, in an industrial part of the desert. I will, like, I'm going to become the joker. It is insane. It is, like, I just think we need to be a bit balanced about this. It's, like, I don't want it to, like, drive species into extinction. But, like, the meta problem here is if we don't move our industrial stack off fossil fuels in 10 or 20 years, first of all, we'll get poor the same way UK did, right? Because they ran out of coal, basically. And the second thing is. We'll get poor because we'll flood our coastal cities in Florida underneath climate change. We need solar synthetics for that part. We also need to do sulfur injection and a couple other things. People will point out that transmission line growth has been stuck in a rut for decades. And we have all these bottlenecks in terms of substations and transformers, et cetera, et cetera. Why will this not hamper this abundant solar future? That's a really great question. So, actually, you and I had a conversation along these lines almost two years ago when we first met. And it caused me to go and write a blog post. So, this is a good way of thinking about it. I think there's another blog post you wrote, though, which was also to our conversation we had, which was how to feed the AIs. That's much more recent, yeah. That was after dinner, I think. Yeah. And to be fair, like, I usually am fairly clear in my blog posts if I'm posting or if I'm serious. But this one, actually, I'm dead serious on. It's actually the one where I'm. It's, like, the most out-of-the-money bet as well. Like, everyone else that I consider to be, like, a respectable forecaster in this area disagrees with me on it. So, that's one side. Well, so, the grid, we know why the grid is expensive. It's a lot of wires strung up in, like, hard-to-reach places that are hard to maintain, especially as, you know, the workforce ages and regulations and all the rest and eminent domain and so on and so forth. Okay. So, grid's not going to get cheaper anytime soon or easier to build. And if you look at the projections of, like, how much grid, you know, DOE would have us needing to build in the next 10 years versus how much is actually being built, it's, like, it's not even in the same order of magnitude. So, you say, well, are we totally screwed? The answer is no, we're not totally screwed because batteries actually do the same job that the grid does. But this is kind of weird, so hear me out. The grid transports power from one place to another. It transports almost instantaneously at the speed of light. So, it's actually performing a spatial arbitrage. Right. Right. So, the idea being that right outside the local nuclear power plant, power is really cheap because they make a lot of it. And in your house, power is really expensive because you don't have a power plant in your house. And you pay the intermediator. A small fee, and they allow this trade to take place. And that's basically how the grid works. And until quite recently, the only way we had of meaningfully storing energy, like, storing electricity on the grid was pumped hydro. And that only works in a handful of places in limited capacity. And it doesn't work all that well either. The efficiency is not great. Now, we have batteries. Batteries store power at one time of day, and they release it at another time of day. So, batteries are performing a temporal arbitrage. An arbitrage over time. But they can be local, or they can be more remote. I think we'll end up seeing batteries next to the solar arrays, and batteries in the middle of the grid at substations, and batteries on the sites of existing power plants that get turned off, and batteries in your house, and batteries everywhere in between. One way of thinking of this is, what is your per capita allocation of batteries in kilograms per head? And, like, when you and I were much younger, you know, the lithium-ion battery was in a cell phone, say. So, you got, like, I don't know, 10 grams per person or something. And nowadays, half the people. And there's town drive Teslas. So, your per capita allocation of lithium-ion battery is 100 kilograms or something like that. So, we're talking, like, four or five ohms of increase of total battery per person. That trend is only going to continue. And then you say, well, okay, we've got batteries that are performing this temporal arbitrage, and the sun comes up every day, right? So, like, the power swing from, like, midday, you're otherwise curtailing the solar array, to dusk when everyone's watching TV and cooking dinner or running the air conditioners to cool off in the evening is very predictable. Right? Whereas, like, oh, we had, like, really bad weather, so we had to use the power line that runs to the extra power plants over by Hoover Dam or something. It doesn't get used nearly as much. Or, like, its peak utilization happens almost never. Which means that the utilization of the batteries is, on average, like, let's say 300 days a year. And the utilization of your most expensive grid, highest voltage grid assets is much, much lower. And that includes, like, the substations and transformers and stuff that serve that. So, it's a really bad position to be in if you're a grid operator. Right? Because you've got this. This aging, existing thing that the batteries are cannibalizing. The batteries are being installed behind the meter. You don't have a say in whether they're being installed, how they're being used. All you know is that your utilization of your asset where you get to charge top dollar for it is just dropping year after year after year after year. At the same time as your operating costs are increasing year after year after year. So, it's just very clear that, like, the average distance the electron is going to travel between generation and consumption is going to decrease in the future. Pretty radically. Yeah, I guess. It's already decreasing. It's going to continue to decrease. The difference is that, I mean, it's especially helpful for solar, but, like, solar is the one that's most intermittent. You can predict the amount of solar power you're going to get in three days pretty accurately because of weather prediction. But you can't, like, buy more batteries. You can't, like, change the amount of batteries you have. Well, actually, in the limit, you can because you can put them on trucks and drive them around. Right? So, there could be a capacity market for batteries where you drive them around to people who need them in a pinch. In practice, it's going to be cheaper just to double the size of your battery because batteries. It can get cheaper and cheaper and cheaper and cheaper. But what it does mean is you can say, well, I know that I'm going to have, you know, three low days. So, I will start curtailing now by 5% so I don't have to curtail by 50% in three days. And then, overall, for the whole year, I'll only curtail, you know, five hours. So, I'm still at four nines instead of having to curtail 24 hours because I can't predict the weather. Okay. So, let's assume you're right. And then, I mean, I think at some point you will be right. Like, maybe we disagree about – sorry, I'm not qualified to disagree. Maybe you – Some other person might disagree about what year it happens. But I think it's hard to deny that in the asymptote – Oh, yeah. Our civilization is headed towards lots of energy use for AI and a lot of that coming from solar. In that asymptote, I've just, like – I want to get, like, the crazy nerd sci-fi, like, what does our civilization look like? What is happening in this, you know – Kodeshev level one. Yeah. Let's wait till we get to turning the entire earth into an AI factory. But more like, I don't know, the 2030s. Mm-hmm. Where you've gotten multiple people who are building on the order of 5 gigawatt or 10 gigawatt sites. The value of the hardware – is dependent on its complement, which is the software, right? Like right now, AI models are fine. And so the hardware they're running on, the economic value they can generate is sort of bottlenecked by how good the software is. But if you actually had AGI, if you had like a human level intelligence or maybe even better. Ideally better, yeah. Yeah, running on an H100, that H100 is worth a lot, right? Like we're paying a lot for humans to do work. Right now, I don't think AI is that valuable. Like the models themselves aren't super, super valuable in terms of just pure economic value, right? Open AI is generating on the order of 10 billion ARR or 20 billion ARR. That sucks, it's terrible. How can they sleep at night? I know. But for context, McDonald's and Kohl's generate more yearly revenue than that. But I think the promise of AGI is to automate human labor. Human labor generates on the order of $60 trillion of economic value. Or like that's how much is paid out in wages to labor around the world, right? So that's what AGI can do. And even if you just curtail it to just white collar work, that's still tens of trillions of dollars of value. So once we have models which are actually human level, they will be worth at least that pending the fact that you can build them or you can run them. Well, I don't think we should constrain ourselves to being like, oh, well, maybe there'll be some fraction of current payroll, right? Because like that's kind of a very contingent on like humans being humans thing. Yeah, I think it's a lower bound to be clear. Oh, yeah, lower bound for sure. But like if you think about, like someone trying to like estimate the upper bound for the market value, the market cap of like Caterpillar, right? Based on like, well, it takes, you know, this many men and like burrows and wheelbarrows to like dig a trench. And so, you know, it couldn't be more than that, right? But actually, you know, one way to think about the industrial revolutions is every time you figure out industrial revolution, what you're doing is you're finding some way of like bypassing a constraint or bypassing a bottleneck. And the bottleneck prior to what we call the industrial revolution was metabolism, right? It's just like how much like oats can a human or a horse physically digest and then convert into useful mechanical output for, you know, their, their, their peasant overlord or whatever. And, and nowadays we would giggle to think that like, oh, the amount of food we produce is meaningful in the context of like the economic power of a particular country, because 99% of the energy that we consume routes around our guts, you know, through the gas tanks of our cars and through our aircraft and, you know, grids and stuff like that. Interesting. And so right now, the AI revolution is about routing around cognitive constraints that in some ways writing, you know, like writing, printing, press computers, the internet have already allowed us to do to some extent. A credit card is a good example of something that routes around a cognitive constraint of like building up network of trust, right? It's decentralized trust. Yeah. That's interesting. It's also really interesting, something that came up, and I want to credit James Bradbury and Gwern with making this interesting point when I was talking with them a couple of days ago is if you measured by GDP, AI's outputs might be underwhelming, right? One of the complaints that economists have about the internet is that it's hard to measure the consumer surplus that's created by the internet because a lot of the goods and services that are made available, you pay zero for them. And so they don't show up in GDP. Well, it's the same with oil. Yeah. In that sense that it's only 1% of energy is like 1% of GDP. Oil is like $8 trillion a year or something, right? Yeah. But if you said, well, one day we're going to consume 100 times more energy in the form of oil than in the form of food, the dual cost of food is whatever it is, the cost of a Big Mac, then oil should be like $800 trillion a year, right? It's 100 times-- like per unit energy, oil, like gasoline, is 100 times cheaper than the cheapest food that humans can digest. So does that mean that we've shot ourselves in the foot by using oil to run our economy? Right. Because it's so cheap? Like, no. Right, right. And also, its fraction of GDP also doesn't correspond to how important it is. For example-- oil is like 1% of GDP or something. But if you don't have oil, then you have these oil shocks, which cause double-digit decreases in GDP. So the elasticity of demand often matters more than its, like, raw fraction contribution to GDP. But anyways, on the original point about AI, so you're going to have this huge deflation of-- so Gordon put it this way. He's like, if you imagine Dario's data center of geniuses, how is that showing up in GDP? Yes. It's going to be the inputs, which are the chips, the energy, et cetera, and the outputs, which are just the tokens. And neither of those is going to be that astronomical in comparison to the value that data center of geniuses is producing. So in terms of GDP numbers, if that data center of geniuses automates a bunch of-- or at least complements a bunch of human work, et cetera, it might actually cause a nominal decrease in GDP while at the same time contributing massively to what we might think of as the valuable stuff you may think humanity or human civilization can produce. And so in the long run, it might make more sense to think of the size of our economy or the size of our civilization as the raw energy use that we do rather than GDP. Because again, GDP will see this huge deflation because the variable cost of running AI will just be pretty cheap as compared to, like, paying humans wages, et cetera. MARK MANDEL: I think we're at the point where, like, you've got a mixed economy with, like, an AI doing my job and also a human doing my job. MARK BLYTH: I love how this is the new way we use the phrase "mixed economy." MARK BLYTH: Yeah. Then obviously, like, I still have some pricing power relative to humans, and the AI thus has pricing power, right? MARK MANDEL: Yeah. MARK BLYTH: But if it was the case that, like, a new kind of job emerges that AI is really well adapted to, like, because it's not competing against humans for most of those roles, it would be competing against the other labs, right? And so you'd actually see, like, the cost pushed down to, you know, a small multiple of whatever the marginal production cost of those tokens is. That would be my guess. So I think it might be a mistake to assume that, like, well, if we're going to pay, you know, a top AI researcher $200,000-- $200,000 a year, lol. Let's say the sort of AI researcher that I could be, $200,000 a year, that if an AI comes along that's as good as me at that, even taking into account the fact that, realistically speaking, I only get, you know, maybe 10 hours of really top cognitive work done a week, that it would also be worth $200,000, right? MARK BLYTH: Yeah. MARK BLYTH: It would be worth much more than that in the sense of, like, you can copy-paste its output and much less than that in the sense that, you know, whatever the marginal additional cost of spooling up H100s is. And so if some kind of role comes along that, like, the AIs are really well-specialized at and out-compete the humans quickly, then we'd also expect to see both the cost of providing that service to drop drastically at the same time as the overall value generated in the economy by that service would increase a lot. MARK BLYTH: Yeah, exactly. If we think that the value of cognition is going to be unbounded-- and the way to derive cognition, you can just-- to the extent you think solar will eventually win, you can just-- you can derive it from how much land it takes to power an H100 using solar panels. That is a very interesting derivation, that, like, OK, well, this is-- at a minimum, we're going to just fill up all the land. I mean, at some point, you might have, like, declining marginal value of cognition or something, but-- MARK BLYTH: We kind of discussed this earlier, but if you have, like, a megawatt of-- there's 10 acres-- 10 acres of land feeding one megawatt H100 or something that's generating-- like, let's say a megawatt is 1,000 humans. So one acre is 1,000 humans worth of cognition. The implicit land value there is a lot higher than it is as, like, undeveloped desert, right? It's also a lot higher than it is as, like, the most productive farmland that humanity has ever had, right? MARK BLYTH: At current hardware efficiencies-- I don't know if it's worth spelling out-- basically, H100 has the same amount of flops as a human brain, but also uses way more energy than a human brain. MARK BLYTH: Yes. MARK BLYTH: It uses, like, 50x more energy. MARK BLYTH: Is that right? MARK BLYTH: So 20 watts versus 1,000 watts? MARK BLYTH: Human brain-- oh, 20 watts, yeah, could be. MARK BLYTH: We know hardware can be at least as efficient as the human brain. And the human brain can generate this many flops on 20 watts. So if you do that calculation, then that's 50x 1,000. So 50,000 AI souls off of one acre. MARK BLYTH: And it could easily be much more than that, because neurons are much slower than transistors, obviously. So probably 10 years ago, one of my friends reminded me, you know, like, the way your phone saves power is it goes to sleep between you, like, tapping out Hello. MARK BLYTH: Right. MARK BLYTH: Like, it takes a nap for, like, 10,000 cycles. You know, it's kind of nuts. MARK BLYTH: Right. MARK BLYTH: So just that, like, humans-- I think Elon's talked about this in the context of self-driving cars as well, which is, like, anything humans do is, like, glacially slow from the perspective of a computer. MARK BLYTH: Let's actually go back to the original point of, like, I was explaining why I think it's plausible that there could be more than hundreds of gigawatts of extra demand from AI in the 2030s. I want to understand what that looks like in the real world. Like, at that point, it's become basically this industrial problem of can you generate enough solar panels and solar modules and batteries and not to mention the chips themselves. MARK BLYTH: So that's the industrial point, and then there's a cultural point as well, which is like-- MARK BLYTH: Well, let's start with the industrial point. MARK BLYTH: OK. MARK BLYTH: I want to know what the year 2035 looks like-- MARK BLYTH: Yeah, yeah, yeah. MARK BLYTH: --if we've got AGI and we're just bottlenecked by the ability to deploy it. MARK BLYTH: Yeah, so you can ask a question like, what do you need in order to run-- like, what is the minimum-- MARK BLYTH: Yeah. MARK BLYTH: --minimum amount of matter that you need in order to perform these calculations? So right now, we're talking about, like, AI racking and grid and transmission and a bunch of, like, ISOs and all that rest. You don't need any of that stuff, right? And, like, obviously, XAI is on top of this, because the first thing that Elon will always ask is, like, delete anything you don't absolutely need. So what you actually need is a big slab of relatively cheap silicon to make the power and then a small slab of relatively expensive silicon to do the thinking. And if it's in space, that's all you need, right? Because it's in the sun. the time. So you don't need a battery, right? But if you're on the earth, you need a battery as well. So you need some interconnect. and you don't need a transformer right you don't even need a dcdc converter you can actually make do with buck converter or with relays or whatever to basically match the the current output of your solar array with the charge state of your batteries and the power consumption of the um of your you know gpu or something but like a solar array about the size of this desk for example will generate about 500 watts in in full sun so you can actually imagine like aliens who have different silicon technology stack building their systems as like an integrated solar array with you know a bit of uh a bit of you know computranium in the middle for example uh on the same wafer uh but that's that's basically all you need and then on the same wafer that's because it's all silicon it's all silicon yeah it's all silicon all the way down what's silicon made of well it's an element it's chemically in the crust uh there's no shortage of it this is a great prompt for a sci-fi exercise because if especially in space you don't need batteries so you just like the the prompt is uh the the future tsmc just manufactured integrated solar uh and they can fly around right they're solar cells yeah and they don't they're they're relatively dense so they don't fly crazy fast they don't need to because they're immortal is this what the dice is you're moving it up casey is it just is this going to be computranium at the center of uh they can fly closer to the sun to get more power right right up to the thermal limit and they can fly further from the sun to go and explore or like fly to other planets or something and they can they can adjust the orientation of the solar sail with lcd panels that it could be integrated into the into the wafer itself so i mean that's that's actually if you say what what's the what's the post-human state that's it you know like that's we will we will eventually sail with a silicon die in the middle for compute one human's worth of computation one human brain you know can be simulated and roughly a square meter of silicon floating in space what how much are you one square meter of silicon like it's like the signature sheet of paper floating in space yeah that's it that's a future human form that's that's my final form that's the attractive state yeah that's assuming that's assuming a little bit of software improvement but like i don't think that's all that's assuming is software improvement um the dyson sphere that's all it needs a little bit of software a little bit of tweaking i mean if the soft like the the area of the panel you know is kind of the the variable there right um so you can ask well what do you need in order to make the silicon uh making uh solar arrays making chips it's kind of multi-stage process but but basically you start off with uh silica silicates which are rocks ideally in a relatively pure form you uh chemically reduce them um it's a couple of different processes that can do that and then purify them into like ideally like six nines of purity for solar array maybe nine nines for like really nice computers um and then you can do that and then you can do that and silicon purity and uh you grow crystals cut wafers etc etc so then the constraint is like well how quickly can you convert the crust into enough silicon to support you know silicon thought yeah um what does the silicon ecosystem look like any thoughts well it's pretty quick right like if you like how many if you're like one kilowatt per square meter and then you use that just to like rip oxygens off the underlying dirt you know it doesn't take all that long to you need about 20 microns of silicon to make a solar pv array so it's like from dirt as you mean like actual dirt has plenty of silicon in it so for example setting up a brand new silicon refinery takes about 18 months right right um but that's just with the current technology right there's i actually think we may find ways so one of the nice things is if you have infinite infinite free solar power approximately free solar power you can revisit a bunch of legacy industrial processes that are have been optimized for efficiency and say well what if we just like use twice as much power and we just want to do them faster and cheaper right like less capex less lead time more power right and then you can do that and then you can do that and then you can do that and then you can well you can start solving problems it turns out that um that if you want to chemically reduce silicon you can do it electrolytically like with less efficiency and a bunch like under a hydrogen rich atmosphere or something and then so one of the ways that silicon can be refined is by turning into silane which is a silicon tetrahydride i'm not really a chemist but i think that's right so sih4 which is a gas it's like um it's actually like methane but one down on the periodic table and don't breathe it though and um yeah and then and then once it's a gas you can filter it from um to contaminants which don't form gases or can be separated uh by density um much like how uh uranium is sometimes enriched but much much less difficult uh and then uh heat it up to separate it back into pure silicon where you can then you know precipitate out a i mean the reason i think is interesting is because um whenever people who are talking about the ai singularity often their expertise is not in energy or physics or whatever so they focus only on the cognitive elements of the singularity yeah which is like how much faster is it going to go faster how fast is it going to go faster can we make ai smarter etc i think this is really interesting because if we have unbounded cognition which sets up both the ability to supply and to demand more energy i'm very curious like what does the energy singularity look like um where you know we're just trying to saturate as much energy that the earth receives and turn it into cognition i hadn't thought about that before but like there's this idea that like evolution resulted in this like continual like ramification and complexification of the thermodynamic energy and so i think it's really interesting to see that there's a sort of gradient right so you start with like very simple like iron-based organisms and they get this like industrial economy but it may be the case and i don't have a strong reason to suspect one way or the other that like what we're seeing is like the beginning stages of a collapse back towards the simplest possible thermodynamic thermodynamic to cognition stack which is we have fusion in stars and the inky blackness of space and that provides our our temperature gradient and then the most efficient way to convert that into usable cognition is literally electrons being pushed across the fermi gap in a solar array and then taking the return path through some like set of gates right uh making decisions about things and then like beaming lasers to their friends saying hey i just made up a new meme that is an interesting concept that for four billion years we've been increasing the sort of like variance and complexity of creatures and then you might see like this big collapse um should i give you the opportunity to plug why uh why people should work for terraform yeah so actually just to give you introduction i'm going to give you the opportunity to plug why uh why people should work for terraform terraform is my day job it's a company i founded almost four years ago we are making synthetic natural gas from sunlight and air we are also working on other core primary materials stuff we also have a methanol process methanol and methane together uh precursors to every hydrocarbon you could possibly want uh another chemical with ammonia process steel uh desalination and we can also make cement and a few other things so basically everything that the primary uh primary industry does except for glass and paper we are hiring uh our jobs are available on terraform yes the website's meant to look like that because we're very cool um we are some very special people you know i know a lot of smart people and i'm privileged to work with some of the smartest people i know we have mostly mechanical engineers i will never hire anyone who can't do math i will never have the problem with astronomer because we don't have a head of hr i'm sure and also the ceo is not having an affair yeah i mean like step one um i think that was a more crucial issue casey but like heads of hr can get into trouble i'm just saying everyone does math um terraform it's very important to me that terraform is the place that ambitious hardware people go to become the best they can be right that is really important i'm not it's not here to like check in and get your paycheck and like optimize some shiny widget it's still a small team it's still like one project per person kind of situation um and i will level you up like maybe not quite like jensen taught you into greatness kind of situation but like at times it's going to feel that way and you get to work with the the best people that there are at least on the west coast of the united states on on this sort of thing and it's also a unique company i thought years ago like by now i'll have competition we don't no one else is doing this except for a small smart startup in the uk um and uh and so you know you get on the ground floor and it's going to be super cool technology and uh we you know eventually we get to go and build it all on mars as well and like help our robot overlords make more of themselves out of dirt it's pretty cool nice come come work for us casey thank you so much for coming on the podcast oh thank you it's fun yeah i hope you enjoyed this episode if you did the most helpful thing you can do is just share it with other people who you think might enjoy it send it to your friends your group chats twitter wherever else just let the word go forth other than that super helpful if you can subscribe on youtube and leave a five-star review on apple podcasts and spotify check out the sponsors in the description below if you want to sponsor a future episode go to dwarkesh.com slash advertise thank you for tuning in i'll see you in the next one

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The U.S. can compete with China in solar and energy infrastructure despite current disadvantages due to superior automation, natural resources, and industrial flexibility.
  2. China’s energy advantage is amplified by its ability to convert excess electricity into synthetic fuels, which can supply 100% of energy needs and level the playing field in industrial production.
  3. U.S. solar manufacturing is not disadvantaged by labor or regulations; it has abundant natural gas, human capital, and world-leading automation, enabling rapid scaling of solar panel production.
  4. The regulatory environment in the U.S., especially NEPA and land-use laws, creates massive bottlenecks for solar deployment, making permitting a major cost and time sink.
  5. Hyperscalers prioritize power availability over cost, and demand growth from AI will drive down solar prices through learning curves and economies of scale.
  6. The U.S. could deploy massive solar capacity in two years with existing technology and coordinated industrial action, similar to WWII-level mobilization.
  7. Natural gas infrastructure is a bottleneck for AI data centers, but supply and turbine production are not fully exhausted, with solar offering a more scalable and cost-efficient long-term path.
  8. The critical bottleneck in AI development is not energy, but chip production—especially GPU manufacturing by TSMC—and the U.S. has a strategic edge in maintaining control over that supply chain.

Summary:

S. remains competitive in the global energy and AI race despite China's dominance in solar manufacturing, due to superior industrial capabilities, abundant natural resources, and a flexible, automated production base. S.

can rapidly scale solar capacity through existing technology, especially with coordinated government action. S. advantage lies not in cost but in agility, automation, and access to natural gas, which supports both energy infrastructure and industrial resilience.

However, regulatory hurdles—particularly NEPA and complex permitting—severely hinder solar deployment, creating a significant delay. Hyperscalers prioritize power availability over cost, and rising AI demand will drive down solar prices through steep learning curves, accelerating adoption. S.

can produce solar energy efficiently and at scale, even in remote regions. S. firms like TSMC maintain a critical lead.

S. can maintain its edge by combining aggressive solar deployment with strategic control over chip manufacturing, overcoming regulatory inertia and leveraging its industrial depth to avoid being outpaced by China in the long-term energy and AI transition.

FAQs

No, the U.S. does not need lower labor costs or weaker environmental regulations to compete. With abundant natural gas, world-leading automation, and existing manufacturing infrastructure, the U.S. can replicate solar production at scale. The real advantage lies in faster deployment and lower long-term costs driven by automation and supply chain efficiency.

China’s solar advantage is limited by its inability to fully replace fossil fuels in the energy system. Only about a third of modern energy use comes from electricity. The U.S. can leverage cheaper natural gas and advanced manufacturing to compete, especially when solar demand grows and production scales rapidly due to AI-driven energy needs.

Synthetic fuels convert surplus electricity into liquid fuels, which can power 100% of end-energy use. This allows China to use its abundant solar energy more effectively. However, the U.S. can offset this by using synthetic fuels in combination with domestic energy resources and advanced industrial capabilities, maintaining parity in overall energy strategy.

Hyperscalers prioritize power availability and reliability over cost. Natural gas provides immediate, on-demand power with proven infrastructure. While solar is becoming cheaper, the infrastructure to deliver solar power—especially in remote areas—remains complex, and gas turbines offer faster deployment and greater flexibility.

By 2030, solar is expected to supply the majority of new data center power. Rapid learning rates in solar production, coupled with rising demand from AI, ensure a significant price drop. This makes solar the most cost-effective and scalable energy source for future AI infrastructure, especially in regions with high solar irradiance.

A 5 gigawatt data center would require approximately 50,000 acres of solar land, assuming 2.5x overbuild for 99.9% uptime. However, land use is not the main cost driver—panels and batteries are far cheaper than land acquisition. In practice, solar integration is efficient and scalable, especially in sun-rich regions like Texas or Nevada.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.