The BBC podcast *Chasing Mr Sunshine* investigates a major financial scandal in Thurik council, where local officials—including finance director Sean Clark and entrepreneur Liam Kavanaugh—misused public funds through risky investments. Liam secretly siphoned millions from his solar energy company, Rock Fire, into personal accounts and made lavish, conspicuous purchases, such as luxury cars and a Bugatti, which drew attention to his financial misconduct. Sean Clark made high-risk, unrated, and illiquid investments without proper oversight, bypassing council rules on diversification and due diligence. Financial advisers at Arling Close flagged these risks and issued warnings, but Sean ignored them. A deeper institutional failure emerged: the council lacked basic governance, with no written records of key decisions, no accountability, and a culture of silence and blind trust. Chief executive Lynn Carpenter, while not legally responsible, failed to supervise or challenge Clark’s actions, contributing to a chaotic environment. Executives grew concerned about the company’s financial health and potential legal exposure, prompting Liam to use personal charm and promises to secure their loyalty. The case illustrates how personal ambition, poor oversight, and a breakdown in governance can lead to catastrophic financial outcomes in public institutions. It serves as a powerful warning about the dangers of unchecked power and the need for transparent, accountable decision-making in local government.
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
Everyone's talking about AI, but to understand where it's going, you need to
understand where it came from. What can the Luddites teachers about technology replacing human work?
Can humanity learn from the nuclear age before creating something else it can't control?
The future of AI didn't begin with chat GPT. It began centuries ago.
This is the global backstory superintelligence. Five special episodes exploring the history
behind the biggest story of our future. Listen to the global story wherever you get your BBC
podcast.
It was much more glam than I was expecting. Even red carpet and those fake flames outside.
Friday the 23rd of February 2018, the Civic Hall in Grey's Essex.
This is a night when Thorek tries to forget its problems a little and puts on a bit of a show.
Inside the hall at the candle that dining tables, people in black tie and nice dresses are
catching up, laughing, enjoying a bit of Prosecco. It was really glamorous, you know, it was quite
a quite an event. Just a very glitcy evening. The Thorek Civic Awards are build as a way to
pay tribute to those who've worked to make their home a better place, charity workers, volunteers,
activists. Local campaigner Sam Bern is here. She's nominated a friend for the Young Achiever
Prize and because she had been shortlisted, we went together. Good evening and welcome to the
Lights Go Down and the winners come up to take their trophies and thank their friends.
They announced the nominations and then they announced the winner for each section. And
many people in this room were in tears with some of the speeches that were given.
The Spotlight picks out a huge poster next to the stage. A billboard covered in corporate logos.
This evening's sponsors. It shows the stylized outline of three mounting peaks over the words.
Rock Fire Capital, who I'd never heard of, very big and at the top with a very small
Amazon underneath. Rock Fire Capital, top billing. Founded, owned and run by Liam Kavanaugh,
aka Mr Sunshine. Liam is sitting at a table near Sam. He's in the front row just a few meters
from stage. Quite tall, slightly balding, well-covered, pale gentleman in a thing we'll see.
And sitting next to him smiling and clapping as Thorik's local heroes collect their awards,
is Sean Clark, Thorik's head of finance. Two of the most powerful men in Thorik,
enjoying a night out together. At this moment, Thorik's investments have turned Liam's company
Rock Fire into a major player, but Liam also has a secret. Ever since Thorik first invested in
Rock Fire, he's been transferring millions out of the company into his own bank account.
If the people in this room find out, it could destroy everything.
For Sean, the stakes are high too. He's invested hundreds of millions into solar bonds
from Liam's company. Everything will be fine if the interest payments keep coming.
But if this goes wrong, the trouble will spread far beyond Thorik.
There were amazing stories of how people had given themselves to better the lives of others,
and this is the table that's right in the centre of it all. With Mr Kavanaugh and Mr Clark,
the best of Thorik, and truly the absolute worst of Thorik.
For BBC Radio 4 and Intrigue, this is Chasing Mr Sunshine, presented by Catherine Nye and
Myron Jones. The story of two men at the centre of a billion-pound mystery,
and one of the biggest financial scandals in the history of local government.
It's probably the place that a few years people are going to be saying,
Thorik is a borough that we are all aspiring to be like.
It would be a bit like the bank lending you a mortgage, but not securing it against your home.
I didn't anybody not notice he suddenly got a ludicrous multi-million pound car collection.
It's almost as if he was asking to be caught, I think.
Episode three, this doesn't tell up.
Mike, check one, two, three, four. Are we rolling?
Have you done any interviews about this before?
I felt like enough water had gone under the bridge now that we were able to speak a little more freely.
Mark Pickering is the CEO of a company called Arling Close.
They act as a financial adviser to councils, helping them decide what to invest in,
and what not to invest in. One of their clients was Thurak.
Around the time of that award ceremony, Arling Close was doing a routine check
on all their clients' investments, and they spotted something extremely weird in Thurak,
something that shouldn't have been there.
We became aware that they'd made increasing amounts of investments in areas which we had no
knowledge that they'd been doing that, and that prompted deeper and further questions.
Enormous, unprecedented investments in rock fires, solar farms, even though Thurak were
paying Arling Close to advise them, Sean Clark, Director of Finance had never mentioned these,
and worse, Sean had also been telling the council that Arling Close had okayed the investments.
I reported onto a council body claiming that Arling Close had been consulted when that was in fact
untrue. And in fact, you were actually saying the opposite, you were saying that these investments
are not supported by you. That's correct. So why, in your view, would Sean Clark be saying the
exact opposite? It's a bit of a bit difficult to answer that one, isn't it? Getting inside his head
as to why he might have done it, I don't know. I mean, that is a big part of this investigation,
to be honest, is he a complete idiot or a complete liar? Well, I have to leave that for your audience,
oh yes. Arling Close arranged a meeting with Sean to clear the air. It doesn't go well.
So they send a letter. They want their objections made very clear and in writing.
Mark's got it with him. The council's current treasury management strategy makes a number of
references to Arling Close in relation to risk management issues. It also states in section 5.1
that the council has consulted with Arling Close on its content. We are not comfortable with
these references because in terms of consultation, the opposite is true. The majority of the council's
recent investment activity and by implication, their funding have been undertaken expressly
without any involvement from Arling Close. Our advice has either been ignored or we simply have
not been consulted. And Mark says, if they had been consulted, Arling Close would have given
a simple response. We do not recommend investing in Liam Cavern as solar bonds.
And when Arling Close dug into the details, they found red flags everywhere.
For one thing, most of the rock fire bonds Thurick bought were unrated. In other words,
none of the big ratings agencies had assessed whether they were worth anything at all. More
than a third of a billion pounds of Thurick's investments fell into that unrated category.
Another problem. Arling Close found that Liam Cavern as bonds were what's known as illiquid.
An illiquid bond is one that doesn't trade very often, so it's hard to establish the
market price. And it's also likely that in difficult times in financial markets,
you might find it hard to sell or even impossible to sell at any price.
In other words, if Thurick needs to get any of its hundreds of millions of pounds back quickly,
there might be no one they could sell the rock fire solar bonds to. They'd be stuck.
And there's more. Arling Close were even more worried by how Liam Cavern had set up the bonds.
So Thurick were not getting security ultimately over the solar asset. They were getting
an income stream from a special purpose vehicle which itself had security over the asset.
Can you break that down for me like what that means in the simplest form?
It would be a bit like the bank lending you a mortgage but not securing it against your home.
It means that if the asset themselves underperform or there's a default
that you have no recourse to any asset to recover your losses.
In this instance, if the asset had defaulted then Thurick would have been left high and dry.
Arling Close's formal letter to Sean lays all of these problems out.
It's investor-speak for this is very dangerous and you should stop it right now.
And Arling Close even gives Sean a possible out, offering a new contract with them
on condition that Thurick's investment strategy returns to normal.
This is Sean's double or quits moment. It wouldn't be easy but at this stage he could still
you'll listen to the experts.
Nah, screw that, think Sean,
and ignores Arling Close's ultimatum.
So Arling Close cut ties with Thurak.
Why for you did you feel like you had to end the relationship?
The investment activities that they were undertaking
were pretty extreme.
We felt that the likelihood of them blowing up
was quite high, think, but try several times
to help a friend and then eventually you have to leave
them to their own devices, don't you?
Sean Clark has a slightly different version
of the end of that relationship,
which he described to our old friend,
Gareth Davis, from the Bureau of Investigative Journalism
back in 2019.
So you're obviously saying that now that Arling Close
is no longer your treasury advisors,
when did that stop?
March 31st this year.
Obviously.
What was there a reason for that one?
I think we just weren't using each other
as we maybe they thought we should be.
We have some differences of opinions.
Did they feel like you weren't keeping them in the loop enough?
Gareth, I really don't want to go into that one.
This was a conversation that we were having with them,
that's two of the reason why we. They're not talking specifics, that's fine,
but it wasn't connected in any way.
Well, let's say that Arling Close
had views on certain investments
that they're closer to and views are like, was that they're not?
Do you have a treasury advisor at the moment or are you
between. No, we're between.
We're looking at what best to do.
This is astonishing.
Sean from Accounts has decided that he's a financial genius.
He doesn't need any investment advice
from professionals anymore.
He's investing hundreds of millions on a hunch.
We talked to a number of other retired
and serving chief finance officers
about the decisions that were made in Thoroughck.
Dan Bates has performed similar roles to Sean Clark
in a number of councils across Devon, Lancashire and Leicestershire
at all places in between.
We're not experts in everything.
We can't possibly be.
So we should have that judgment say,
actually, I don't feel like I could do this.
I need to get somebody who's specialised in and make sure
that we've got, you know, every. I dotted an every tea cross.
And correct me if I'm wrong,
but surely, if you're going to invest a billion,
and it matters that you don't lose it,
you don't put most of it in one company, right?
You don't even put it in just one sector.
You're absolutely right.
You know, if you put 80% in one company,
and that company goes south, then such is your 80%.
So that's really important.
But also, if that's an unrated bond,
you just want to put it in the first place.
You go through a process of saying,
this company looks like it's not rated.
There's no way we can get that assurance that that would be saved.
So, I know where I've worked, we've just said we won't touch it.
While Sean was dealing with Arlene Close,
Liam was dealing with his own secrets.
Remember, ever since he first did business with Thurick,
he's been quietly moving millions
out of the company into his own personal bank account.
And then, he starts going further.
He begins making huge, luxury purchases
directly from the company account,
not even bothering to move the money into his bank first.
So, we're sitting at a desk.
And in front of us, it's quite a,
a kind of boring looking spreadsheet, to be honest.
Why are we looking at this, Marion?
This is the entire bleak bank account details
Liam's company, Rock Fire.
I really love it when Marion turns up
with leaked bank account details.
So, here we have a two million pound be gassy,
a Land Rover Discovery, a souped up Bentley,
top of the range, range Rover, another Bentley.
Okay, so this is significant
because this is not what you'd expect company accounts
for a solar farm to be buying.
No, you'd expect a solar power company
to be either buying solar assets
or buying equipment that you needed to run solar farms.
And, well, Lamborghini's
and it's not really what you're expecting.
Liam's lawyers say he was entitled
to use rock fires money in the way he did
and that there was no wrongdoing.
Even with his most expensive purchases,
Liam finds ways to improve what he's bought.
He has his Lamborghini eventador,
price 350 grand,
pimped up at a rack merchant.
A workshop that adds fun new colors
and decals to the outside of a car.
We got someone who does know a bit about cars
to look over Liam's collection.
I'm James May, I'm a former presenter of BBC Top Gear
and the Grand Tour.
What's your first feeling about what is tasting cars is like?
Well, it's pretty flashy,
which seems to be a bit of a trend
with people who either commit crimes or win lotteries
or by some other means suddenly come into large sums
of money they rather give themselves away
by buying very conspicuous cars.
Do you like the idea that the Lamborghini eventador
has been pimped up and sent to a rack merchant?
No, I wouldn't do that.
I'm very much a fan of keeping things standard
because I subscribe to the rather unfashionable belief
that car designers know what they're doing.
It's very much, I think what the old people would call a flex.
Meaning what exactly?
Well, it's to say I have a load of money.
This is what I mean about people buying flashy cars
when they become suddenly wealthy.
It's not subtle stuff, like a pimped eventador
is a very conspicuous display of wealth through car ownership.
That is almost sort of on the bingo card
for a lottery winner, that sort of thing.
If I turn in, get the drift going then.
I could've chatted to James May about cars for hours,
but he was also fascinated by our story,
especially because the ground to a test track
was right next door to Liam Cabinus, Swindon, Solar Farm.
Had it anybody not noticed?
A, that all this money was disappearing,
but also that he very obviously had it
because he suddenly got a ludicrous,
multi-million-pound car collection.
There are so many questions for Thurick Council, too.
I'm struggling to understand how Sean Clarks
able to get away with making so many huge payments
to companies owned by just one entrepreneur.
High-risk, un-rated bonds.
Why isn't someone at Thurick checking what he's up to?
It's a question, journalist Gareth Davis had, too.
There was no question there was a lack of due diligence.
A lack of scrutiny.
There was a culture of blind trust, basically.
That culture of blind trust in Sean's judgment
explains some of it, but he had another thing going for him.
Success.
At this point, Sean's big gamble seems to be paying off.
The solar investments are paying interest,
bringing in new money for the council.
At the time, the chief executive, the leader of the council,
other elected members thought he could do no wrong.
He was on to a winner.
He was keeping the council safe from the swinging cuts
that other local authorities were having
to endure at the time as a result of austerity.
Were they all fully aware of the details?
No, I don't think they were, but I don't think they were asking.
Officially, Thurick Council did have rules
which were supposed to police any investments
that Sean Clark chose to make.
Rules aimed at stopping overly risky investments.
They cover very, very basic ideas.
The importance of diversifying investment,
not putting all your eggs in one basket, appropriate due diligence,
doing proper research before handing money over.
And finally, accountability and governance to the executive,
telling senior people what is going on.
All very sensible and quite obvious,
but Sean has ignored all of them again and again.
And if anyone's senior noticed, they haven't done anything about it.
The new chief executive, Thurick Council, welcome, welcome.
What do you think attracted you to the job of being chief executive here?
This is from your Thurick, a local news site.
When a new chief executive to the council
called Lynn Carpenter was appointed in 2015, they interviewed her.
I believe that Thurick is probably the place
that a few years people are going to be saying
Thurick is a borough that we are all aspiring to be like.
Lynn, isn't your average council chief?
- Ladies and gentlemen, who are the most important 98, the 60th Pongwell Fires.
- She played netball for England for years.
33 international caps and a bronze medal at the 1998 Commonwealth Games.
But in Thurick, she was in charge of keeping the council running.
- Look, people here in Thurick pay our salaries.
We are ultimately and rightly accountable to them.
And we're here to make their lives the best they possibly can be.
- Ling Carpenter is the chief executive, the most senior council official, non-elected official.
She has overall responsibility for the running of the council.
Ultimately, the buck stops with her because anything that happens on her watch,
especially of something of this size, would ultimately be her responsibility.
- Ling wasn't organising the individual investment Sean was making.
But during her time in office, Sean was repeatedly given more delegated authority,
the right to make financial decisions with huge amounts of public money on his own initiative,
excusing him from normal supervision.
By the spring of 2018, Sean's licence to invest had gone up from £200m to half a billion
pounds. All that financial power in the hands of a finance director of a small local authority.
- It was Ling's job to oversee Sean and to be aware of the huge risks he was taking on behalf of Thurick.
- Few of the chief executive and your council direct finance director is investing hundreds of millions of pounds of public money.
It doesn't really cut it.
Whatever explanation you have isn't going to cut it, you ultimately have to take responsibility for what happened.
- Is she either guilty of being involved in terrible investments or not knowing about them, which is also terrible?
- Basically something up here.
Apparently Ling could be supportive if staff had personal problems,
but their leadership style is described as being autocratic.
Her colleagues said they were scared of having honest conversations with her about work
for fear of being publicly shamed.
There were so many problems that Thurick council under her leadership.
It had an office culture where the basic rules and procedures of local government had completely collapsed.
An official government report into Thurick's management talks about this,
and the authors don't sugarcoat just how extreme the situation became.
They describe as astonishing, the lack of supervision that Sean's investments received,
and they say it amounted to a deep institutional failure.
The internal checks and balances that one would expect to see were either weak or wholly absent.
But perhaps the most extraordinary findings are about how most basic decisions were taken and recorded in Thurick while in carpenter was in office.
We've found that significant decisions are not formulated and minited in such a way as to make the decision clear,
or in a way that reflects what actually happened at the meeting.
There is often no recorded single truth of important decisions, no record of why decisions were taken,
nor even if there was any decision taken at all.
A council spending hundreds of millions of pounds of public money,
where no one even writes down major decisions, or even knows if they happened,
where truth itself is a mysterious concept.
When the reports authors tried to interview Ling carpenter, things took a strange turn.
Part way through the interview, the chief executive advised us that she was unable to continue that day.
Despite attempts to do so, we were unable to secure an appointment for the interview to continue,
and the interview could not be concluded.
Sean Clark, the Director of Finance, went about arranging these deals.
There wasn't even evidence at the time that these transactions were made,
that any of this had ever taken place.
I mean, it's mind-boggling.
Incredible. Nothing in writing.
The stereotype of local government is red tape and bureaucracy.
Every decision signed off by three different committees.
That's what Eric Pickles, remember him, said he was trying to do away with.
He was going to give councils what they wanted to do for decades.
Freedom, power, and responsibility.
But in Thuruk, maybe there wasn't quite enough red tape.
No paperwork at all. A culture of chaos.
Ling carpenter's lawyers say that she was neither structurally nor legally responsible
for the acts of Mr. Clark. On that interview with the government inspectors that she cut short,
they say that she later provided written answers to their inquiries.
Ling has now left local government and returned to her first love.
She is now a regional director, brackets Europe, for world netball.
Amidst and partially because of this chaos,
Liam Kavanaugh has become a major player in the solar energy world.
He owns more than 50 solar farms across the UK,
from Swindon to Belfast, Norfolk to Ernest Morn.
In fact, that solar farm is just 10 minutes from L'Anwar-Purguingir-Goguerre-Ghwindrobor-Landicilio-Gogor-Gogor.
Liam knows that his skills line salesmanship,
knowing how to read someone, their strengths and weaknesses,
and using that to close the deal.
So to manage the business, he's been recruiting.
An array of solar executives and industry experts now work for him,
running the operations.
But soon, some of those senior execs begin to worry about what they've signed up for.
It's become clear that rock fire is not a normal energy company.
Normal energy companies don't have a CEO who dips into the company bank account
to buy himself Bentley's and a Bugatti.
We have this email exchange between two of Liam's executives.
I'm not working with someone that just treats us like a cash point for his own equity.
His colleague responds, "I agree. Something is fundamentally wrong."
One of Liam's execs, even threatened to resign,
will call that rock fire exec Ben, not his real name.
I spoke to him on the condition of Alan Imiti.
What did he say?
Ben told me that he was worried that if Liam kept taking so much money out of the company,
they would never be able to pay back Thorek.
And Ben was also worried that he might become implicated in the misuse of company funds.
When Ben raises his concerns, Liam has a choice.
He could listen to the feedback and take it on board.
Begin running rock fire more like a normal energy company with a normal CEO.
But then backing down is not his style.
Instead, Liam decides to switch on the charm.
He drives over to Ben's house in a brand new blue Porsche
and takes him for lunch at a very fancy restaurant in Brighton.
A 15-course lunch, in fact.
Teriyaki glazed Celeria.
Flint, Al, sourdough, malt butter, crispy onions.
Over the fusion banquet, Liam explains.
It's all a big misunderstanding.
Beef tartar, miso cured egg yolk, beef fat crouton.
And then, more significantly,
he promises to take the fall if things go really wrong.
Duckham, duck egg, duck fat potatoes, sambal ketchup.
He promises to insulate Ben from the Thorek side of the business.
Barbecue pork belly, chars wee monkfish, mustard, helder beans.
Ben will just run the solar farms.
That way, says Liam.
If this blows up, 99% will be on me.
Jerk marinated guinea fowl, truffle pasta, fennel, runny yolk, hard cheese.
It works.
And by the time they order the coffees, Ben withdraws his resignation.
Liam is safe, again, for now.
Citrus jelly, chocolate and miso pudding.
But the next challenge will be less easily managed.
Next time, on chasing Mr. Sunshine.
They have made some really shit decisions for money.
Money isn't theirs. Money isn't ours.
And he's also got his gun collection.
You know, there's automatic assault rifles.
If you were to put a pig in a palace, that's him.
He thinks he's the wolf of Wall Street and he's off to play with your money.
Who can stop him?
Their tactics may be evolving.
There's nobody who's safe from a sophisticated attack.
But the fight back against the scammers is on.
I know exactly what you're up to,
and how much money you've stolen from my mom.
I'm Shari Val, and together with the scam secrets team,
we shine light on the techniques criminals are using to steal your money.
So we can put the power back into your hands.
He's wary. He spotted the red flags himself.
That's really safe from a whole lot of fighter to the station.
The brand new series of scam secrets.
Listen first on BBC Sounds.
AI, but to understand where it's going, you need to understand where it came from.
The future of AI didn't begin with chat GPT, it began centuries ago.
This is the global backstory superintelligence, five special episodes exploring the history
behind the biggest story of our future.
Listen to the global story wherever you get your BBC podcast.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The story of Liam Kavanaugh and Sean Clark reveals a major financial scandal in Thurik council, where public funds were misused through risky, unregulated investments.
Liam Kavanaugh secretly diverted millions from Rock Fire Capital into his personal accounts and made extravagant luxury purchases, raising red flags about corporate accountability.
Sean Clark, Thurik’s finance director, ignored council investment rules, including diversification and due diligence, and made high-risk, unrated, illiquid bonds without proper oversight.
Arling Close, a financial advisory firm, detected serious flaws in the investments and issued a formal warning, but Sean ignored their advice and continued the risky strategy.
A culture of blind trust and lack of transparency existed, with no documented decisions, accountability, or oversight, leading to institutional failure in local governance.
The council’s leadership, especially under chief executive Lynn Carpenter, failed to supervise financial decisions, creating an environment where misconduct could thrive.
Liam used charm and personal manipulation to silence concerns from executives, promising to absorb blame and ensuring their loyalty through emotional and financial incentives.
The case exposes how unchecked power, poor governance, and personal ambition can lead to financial disaster, offering a cautionary tale about trust and oversight in public institutions.
Summary:
The BBC podcast *Chasing Mr Sunshine* investigates a major financial scandal in Thurik council, where local officials—including finance director Sean Clark and entrepreneur Liam Kavanaugh—misused public funds through risky investments. Liam secretly siphoned millions from his solar energy company, Rock Fire, into personal accounts and made lavish, conspicuous purchases, such as luxury cars and a Bugatti, which drew attention to his financial misconduct. Sean Clark made high-risk, unrated, and illiquid investments without proper oversight, bypassing council rules on diversification and due diligence.
Financial advisers at Arling Close flagged these risks and issued warnings, but Sean ignored them. A deeper institutional failure emerged: the council lacked basic governance, with no written records of key decisions, no accountability, and a culture of silence and blind trust. Chief executive Lynn Carpenter, while not legally responsible, failed to supervise or challenge Clark’s actions, contributing to a chaotic environment.
Executives grew concerned about the company’s financial health and potential legal exposure, prompting Liam to use personal charm and promises to secure their loyalty. The case illustrates how personal ambition, poor oversight, and a breakdown in governance can lead to catastrophic financial outcomes in public institutions. It serves as a powerful warning about the dangers of unchecked power and the need for transparent, accountable decision-making in local government.
FAQs
The podcast investigates a financial scandal involving two powerful men in a local council: Liam Kavanaugh, who secretly siphons money from his solar company, Rock Fire, and Sean Clark, the finance director who makes risky investments without proper oversight.
The bonds were unrated, illiquid, and lacked security over the solar assets. This meant there was no assurance of value, and if the assets underperformed, the council could lose all its investment with no recourse.
He claimed the investments were profitable and that the council was safe from austerity, leading the leadership to trust his judgment without proper scrutiny or oversight.
Lynn Carpenter, as chief executive, failed to enforce proper governance, allowing Sean Clark unchecked financial power and creating a culture of chaos where major decisions were never recorded or reviewed.
He made luxury purchases like Bentleys and Lamborghinis directly from the company account, and his lawyers claimed this was legal, but the spending was inconsistent with a normal energy company's operations.
He offered them lavish lunches and promised to take full blame if things went wrong, effectively using personal charm and financial incentives to silence dissent and maintain control.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.