Go back

Chasing Mr Sunshine: 2. Opportunity Meets Ambition

30m 34s

Chasing Mr Sunshine: 2. Opportunity Meets Ambition

The BBC podcast *Chasing Mr Sunshine* investigates a massive financial scandal involving Liam Kavener, known as "Mr Sunshine," and local councils in the UK. It reveals how public money—particularly from councils like Thurick—was funneled into a solar energy investment scheme, Rockfire Investment Finance, through opaque and poorly scrutinized deals. Despite red flags such as high debt-to-value ratios and lack of transparency, councils, including Warrington and Thurick, invested billions in what were marketed as safe, profitable opportunities. Sean Clark, the finance director of Thurick, made a staggering £268 million investment in 2017, later followed by additional sums, much of it borrowed from other councils. These loans, often unregulated and informal, created a system where public funds were used for speculative ventures with little oversight. The investments were negotiated in luxury settings, like the Mayfair Hotel, undermining accountability. Evidence shows substantial profits flowed directly to Kavener, who had a history of fraudulent schemes, including one involving a fraudulent investment firm, Axiom. The narrative raises urgent concerns about how public trust, financial integrity, and democratic accountability are compromised when entrepreneurs and untrained officials make high-stakes decisions without proper oversight or public debate. The case serves as a cautionary tale about the risks of unchecked ambition in public finance and the need for transparent, expert-led governance.

Transcription

4208 Words, 23965 Characters

English
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Everyone's talking about AI, but to understand where it's going, you need to understand where it came from. What can the Luddites teachers about technology replacing human work? Can humanity learn from the nuclear age before creating something else it can't control? The future of AI didn't begin with chat GPT. It began centuries ago. This is the global backstory superintelligence. Five special episodes exploring the history behind the biggest story of our future. Listen to the global story wherever you get your BBC podcast. Anywhere you like? This will be lovely. Thank you. I have a lovely suit cocktail. Why, what are you drinking? I'm drinking Liam's favourite. A margarita and enjoying some truly dreadful music. Maybe that's what rich people listen to. These are the kind of bars you hang out in a lot of the time. I think I might go up and ask that if they can put on something worse. No. No, don't. I don't think we can go. In 2016, the Finance Director of Thurick Council, Sean Clark, invested £34 million of local taxpayers money into a solar farm owned by a man called Liam Kavener, known to many as Mr Sunshine. Kavener promised to help save the planet and generate solid investment returns. A godsend to a cash-strapped council trying to balance the books. And after that first investment by Thurick Council, Sean and Liam begin to meet more often. Often this exclusive hotel bar, the Mayfair, in one of the wealthiest parts of London. When Sean went off to see Liam here, the rest of Thurick's finance team would say Sean was off to see the city boys, to play with our money. Because that £34 million wasn't Sean's only investment in Liam's business. There were more. Lots more. So Sean would come in here, the Mayfair, and they'd do a deal for another 40 million or 50 million. And what we're told is that Liam would just go out to the car where some of his team were and he'd just say, "You're not going to believe this. You're not going to believe it." They'd give me another 40 million quid. For BBC Radio 4 and Intrig, this is Chasing Mr Sunshine, presented by Catrin Nye and Mirin Jones. The story of two men at the centre of a billion-pound mystery and one of the biggest financial scandals in the history of local government. Well, this is getting ridiculous now. This is kind of like an on-the-villain type person. Was he a bit of a fantasist? Totally wild money, huge. The figures behind these investments, there were red flags. Red flags raised. Red flags ignored. Actually, I don't want entrepreneurs to be in charge of my council. I want rock steady people with good strategic intent. Episode 2. Opportunity meets ambition. Last decent. Needed that cup of tea. Well, I need you to put your cup of tea down, Mirin. Okay. I know you've been on this story for some time. Some years. Quite a while. You've got numbers coming out of your ears by now. But have you ever actually met Liam Covener, Mr Sunshine? Never seen him. Never met him. Never talked to him. All I get is letters from his lawyers. Okay, so I've just had a really interesting phone call. Can you tell me who it? I can tell you off the mic. Okay. On the mic? No. But it's someone who spent a lot of time with Liam, so knows him pretty well. Play it to me. All right, all right, all right, I'll play it. By the way, Mirin, we've had to use an actor to voice this person because a lot of the people who've been closely in Covener are really nervous about speaking out. He wasn't a public school schmoozer, but he could speak properly, you know. He did have quite a fairly home county's accent, but with the odd bit of a cut in the accented word thrown in, or most as if it's like a character out of a guy rich, you film. He swore all the time, you know, he was effing and blinding. He was an insecure show off. And how would that sort of manifest? Like, how would you see that in him? His eyes would darty. He had quite a lot of hoots, but cocky comments. He saw himself as Mr Big I am and I can do whatever I like and I think there was a little bit of Walter Mitty going on. He believed his own hype and he was very degrading towards anybody he thought was a lesser person than himself. So what do you think, Marion? It's a sort of classic picture of the sort of person who gets involved in deals like this. Big money. I do like the idea of him as being a character in a guy rich, you film. Yeah. It raises the question in your head, can you trust somebody like that from that picture that's been painted to you just now? What I want to know is how he became that person. Where did Liam Kavena come from? What's his backstory? And how does he end up? With millions and millions of pounds of public money. Yeah. Liam Kavena is someone who very much values his privacy around his business dealings as well as his private life. That's Gareth Davis, my old colleague at the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, who first started to dip deep into what happened in Thorick in 2019. All his employees, all his contractors are required to sign non-disclosure agreements. In fact, I was told even parents bringing their children to a birthday party at his home were made to sign a non-disclosure agreement, including agreement not to photograph any of his cars. Liam was always smart, street smart, charismatic, charming and very ambitious. He went to a comprehensive school in Hampshire, confident, very much a wheeled dealer, kind of a deal breaker, a man for negotiation. He started work at 17 at the James Hay Partnership, which offers a retirement wealth planning services. He saw how that particular company had expanded rapidly on the back of a new type of pension investment backed by government and offering healthy tax breaks for the customer. After the James Hay Partnership, he moves to another investment firm and it's successful again, becoming a senior partner in the company, but Liam still wanted more. If someone who at times is a fun person to work with, but at other times aggressive isn't used to being told what to do my way or the highway. After Liam leaves the investment firm and sets up on his own, he seems to be looking around for his next opportunity and he's thinking not just like a fund manager, but like an entrepreneur looking for a fast growing business opportunity. Parm Oil is the single most consumed vegetable oil on earth. At one point he sets up and is CEO of a company called Eco Parm Oil. One acre can produce 10 times more oil than an acre of soybeans. A company which claims to help Congolese farmers sell environmentally sustainable cooking oil, profitable and ethical. Congolese farmers have been the pioneers of parm oil extraction in Central Africa. It closes, apparently without doing any business. Now, from our timeline it looks like Liam Cavanaugh goes quiet for a few years, but his next cameo is definitely worth a mention. Marion, next slide please. So, let me take you back to 2011. An investment firm based in the Cayman Islands run by a man called Timothy Schools is raising £100 million. Mr. Schools is promising to make people rich by investing in low-in, no fee legal cases in the UK through his firm which is called Axium. But then, an investigative journalist called David Marchant, who runs an organisation called Offshore Alert, starts digging into the whole deal. He has questions about what Timothy Schools was actually doing with all the money. So, the money being raised, certainly most of it, instead of being used on behalf of victims very often of fraud, to otherwise, wouldn't be able to afford to litigate. It just sort of went to him. He used the money to live with a high life. He bought a ski chalet and he bought a very expensive property in Cumbria, very, very nice property, pretending that he was a big shot. But it's just the same old story with Crooks. They just live the high life and pretend that they're successful. In 2012, David Marchant publishes a huge expose of the business. It sends shot quaves around the world of finance. Timothy Schools directly or indirectly through entities that he controlled or was affiliated with received 85 percent of all of the funds that were invested by investors, which totaled in excess of £100 million. He personally received it. received directly or indirectly more than £85 million. Just a few weeks after being exposed, Axiom pays a small British financial services company £180,000 to review its loan book. It's run by a little known investment manager, Liam Kavanaugh. Liam now says that when he realised that Timothy's schools had acted fraudulently, he immediately ended the business relationship and informed the authorities in the UK. He claims there was no substantive relationship between Axiom and his company, but the fact is, Liam Kavanaugh's company still received £180,000 for their services, and David Marchant is unimpressed. Was a crude fraud committed, yes? Did your company receive money from it? Yes. Now, like, end of no credible company would have become involved with Axiom, period at any stage of its life, particularly after it had already been exposed. So just think about the scenario, accepting what he's saying at face value. OK, you come along. Here's a fraudulent scheme that's already been exposed and you're receiving £180,000 in whatever guys, right? Well, I would suggest that's indefensible. Axiom collapsed completely soon after. Timothy's schools was ultimately sentenced to 14 years in prison. But Liam is quickly onto the next thing, an idea that will combine the financial and investment expertise that he's acquired during his career, with the personal charm and charisma of a successful entrepreneur. An idea that will end up with him becoming a very, very rich man. A word from the CEO, thank you for your interest in rock fire investment finance PLC, generating income from assets that create economic and social value. A new energy company is offering a great investment opportunity. I very much hope you will find this opportunity as attractive as we do at rock fire. And look forward to discussing it in greater detail with you. Liam Kavanaugh, founder and CEO. Some of the company's brochures feature pictures of solar panels photoshopped onto sunlit grasslands. These are all high quality operational plants, which will provide robust operating revenue from the first day of purchase. The school lever, the investment advisor, the axiom associate, even the Congolese palm oil salesmen have all gone. Liam Kavanaugh is now in the renewable energy business, harnessing the power of the sun. He is 100% Mr Sunshine. In the 2010s, solar farms, huge fields of solar panels are becoming big business, turning from niche environmental interests to fast growing investment opportunity, partly driven by generous government subsidies, which help make the whole sector much more profitable. Global investment in renewable energy sources grew by 32% during 2010 to reach a record level of $211 billion. For an investor, this sounds like predictable long-term returns, above inflation or the normal return on savings. Almost overnight, private equity firms, banks, pension funds, startups, all start investing, often with little or no knowledge of the energy industry. Installed solar capacity grew 50 fold across the UK between 2010 and 2014, and hundreds of solar farms were popping up all over the south of England. It's a regulated, socially responsible, gold rush. Liam Kavanaugh's company, Rockfur, acquires a whole stash of solar farms, buying them up wholesale from other companies, and Liam soon starts looking for backers, who could help him scale up the business, offering investors the chance to buy climate bonds, and later solar bonds. These bonds repaid interest each year, similar to a loan, and they offered a tempting return, up to 6% interest. Journalist Gareth Davis of the Bureau of Investigator of Journalism thinks this offer appeal to local councils who were desperate to find new ways of balancing the books. I don't think local authorities were originally the target for investment. It became apparent that there were council finance directors out there looking for alternative means of raising money, and that they actually had the capital to invest. Warrington Council are one of the early investors, putting £17 million into those solar bonds from Liam Kavanaugh's firm. Are those investments workout? Each month the interest payments flow into Warrington's reserves. That's thousands of pounds to pay for services that don't need to be cut under austerity. So far so good. Then Warrington come back for more, investing another £10 million, then they go for another £5 million, easy money. Warrington had had a reputation for, let's say, interesting business models, and taking more risk than perhaps other local authorities in how they spend their money and they were open for business, basically, to make those investments. It's going so well that the word spreads. Warrington proves to be the breakthrough that Liam Kavanaugh has been waiting for. Suddenly Liam's solar bonds have a whole new market. And at first, these investments did provide a return to the councils, right? Yes, they did. One of the things that Liam Kavanaugh would reply in response to our stories was that they'd always paid their interest in full and on time, and certainly the local authority were benefiting from that. Was there any indication at the start of all this that something might be off? There were signs from the start that when you looked into the business model behind it, the figures behind these investments that there were red flags, there was a particularly high debt to value ratio. In other words, if something went wrong and the business had to be sold off, it might be worth less than Thurak could loan to Liam Kavanaugh's company so they wouldn't get all their money back. These were all, certainly, points of concern for those people who knew the solar industry, not in and of themselves as smoking gun, enough to raise red flags. But how is a council finance director supposed to know what a red flag looks like in a solar bond? I mean, they're not big business-trained investors. They're more used to bouncing payroll and bin collection budgets. This is the global backstory superintelligence, five special episodes exploring the history behind the biggest story of our future. Listen to the global story wherever you get your BBC podcasts. And it's around this time, as Liam Kavanaugh's solar farms appear to be working well, that Sean Clarke enters the world of Mr Sunshine. And in 2016, Sean makes that first investment of £34 million into one of Liam's solar farms. That's the deal that no one outside the finance department was told about for months. I think it was quite difficult for people to have concerns about lack of due diligence and things happening without full knowledge of the council, because it was being overseen by a couple of people, Sean and a colleague basically. So the nitty gritty of these details, in some cases the deal itself, very few people knew about that. So how could they raise concerns about it? And when that investment seems to go well, Sean starts to think much bigger. What if this were only the start? What if Liam's solar panels are unique once in a lifetime investment opportunity? Is this the moment to go all in? And it happens that Liam's solar panel business does have a proposal that fits the bill. Something much more ambitious, involving a lot more money. Something probably no other local authority would consider. And maybe for Sean, that's the appeal. Go big or go home. But where can Thuruk get that kind of money? Sean realises there is a way why not borrow the money, like a true entrepreneur. And his director of finance at a council, Sean, actually has easy access to a pot of cheap money that most private entrepreneurs can only dream of. Local councils are allowed to borrow cash from each other. The interest rates are low, there's almost no paperwork and like a normal loan, they can be a range fire a couple of emails. So long as it is one local authority lending to another, these loans can be tens of millions at a time. A real Ken was the leader of the Labour group on the council. There's always been a kind of healthy market in councils lending to one another. So councils in the government grants are generally paid on a quarterly basis. You might not need that money for kind of the next two or three months, you can leave it in the bank or you might lend it to other authorities that need it. And Sean Clarke from Thurick was all over it. This is how Sean described it in an interview with Gareth Davis. "There is an awful lot of money out there in local authorities that I've actually seen because we've got fair debt of it." "Yeah." "Remember, local authority borrowing is not linked to the bank base rate, there's no linked to it because it's all supply and demand. So that's the way we've moved on and we've done more and more of that as we've gone through." John Kent again, very, very simple and very straightforward, maybe too simple. I think at times, Sean would tell people what it is he thought they wanted to hear, rather than telling them how it really was. Hello. Hi, I'm Irene, it's Katchen, you all right? Yeah, you. I've got an important question about this investigation. What is your favourite Christmas song? If I had to choose one, I'd cheat and go through not one song, but the whole full-spector Christmas song, I think. Don't know mine. E-17, "Stare Another Day." That's terrible. What? Do you think that either of those played in thorough council around Christmas a few years back? I think that's tasteless. They've gone through E-17. I'm going to see if I can get that song, but if it's too expensive to pay for in this series, we might just end up having some generic Christmas-type music, is that okay? Yeah, playing on a pinky piano. So it's now December 2017, the final countdown before the Christmas break. Short walk from Grey's High Street are the offices of Thurick Council in Essex. I'm picturing open-plan seating, Christmas cards and tinsel on desks. At that time of year, an extremely decent amount of chocolate and mince pies. One clerk is at his desk, and rather than just filling his face with Ferrero Roche, he has a huge decision to make. In front of him, a set of documents. They represent the final stage of months of preparation, the final moment when he can still walk away, the final moment, before big money changes hands. The documents are about a deal, unlike anything Thurick has ever done before, unlike anything any local authorities have ever done before, or whatever considered doing, because you've probably guessed, it's with rock fire. And amidst the tinsel, Sean decides to push the button. The deal is go. And this time, the total figure he hands over is, wait for it, 268 million pounds. More than a quarter of a billion, a truly enormous sum. Insane. How much are we talking in council terms, Marianne? This is more than the total budget for everything Thurick Council does, bins, children's services, recycling centres, libraries, for well over a year. We know that even Sean had moments of concern over the scale of what he was getting Thurick into, in spite of his public confidence. He's having an internal debate about whether he's doing the right thing, but, for some reason, he doesn't share this with the rest of the council. Here's what he said to Garith Davis. "When I have this internal discussion or debate with myself, I've asked that same questions to myself, would I be doing this? Would Thurick Council be doing this if it hadn't been for the funding reductions?" And so, now arguably that's the catalyst to do it, but if we're so confident and we are on the types of investments we've made, and that can generate additional income into the borough for the benefit of the residents, that's the question I come back to, go, well, why would I? "So, as opposed to saying, would Thurick Council do this as a different one, which is why wouldn't Thurick Council do it, even if we were getting enough money from government, generating income for the benefit of the community? It's a different way of putting it out here." "Yeah, no, it's an interesting point, definitely." Neil Woodbridge, the local social entrepreneur, nickname Mr Thurick, is still trying to make sense of what happened that day. "For me, it's about with that public money. Where was the conversation that said, is that a good investment? And what happens is people like Sean, he was an entrepreneur, I can be an entrepreneur with your money if I've got millions of quid in the bank, the government puts in every year without me having to work, but actually I don't want entrepreneurs to be in charge of my council, I want rock steady people with good strategic intent, when you get people to say, oh yeah, let's buy some shares in this, that's what it felt like, like, wow, how did that happen? Sean doesn't want to wait around after the big 268 million pound investment of Christmas 2017, he makes another investment of 145 million in August 2018, then another 40 million in November, all money to rock fire solar farms, most of it might be that Sean's borrowed from other councils across the country. But wait a minute, those councils are only aware of the ten or twenty million that they're lending Thuruk for a few months, they don't know that Sean plans to borrow a billion pounds from more than a hundred councils, if they did they would be asking what he was planning to do with such a huge part of money, they don't know that he's planning to speculate with it, millions of pounds of let's remember public money, your money, my money, everyone's money. Deals that were signed off over a margarita at the May fair hotel, I think for a lot of people it would be pretty mind-blowing that council finances, deals involving tens of million pounds, sometimes hundreds of millions of pounds were done in this bar, because frankly we're in here now and it's full of absolutely minted people to very minted drunks of the bar. It doesn't look to me like the kind of place someone should be doing serious official council business. But yes, in the middle of this busy upmarket hotel what on earth has that got to do with council tax? But there's more, soon after Sean sent that quarter of a billion pounds to a law firm acting as intermediaries 20 million was transferred to rock fire investment finance, one of Liam Cavanaugh's companies. That same day bank records show that rock fire investment finance made a payout, 15 million pounds straight to Liam Cavanaugh. Not bad for a day's work. Mr Sunshine is getting very well paid, all thanks to local council tax payers who have no idea any of this is happening. Next time on chasing Mr Sunshine. And we're here to make their lives the best that possibly can be. This wasn't even evidence at the time, it's my involvement. Try several times to help a friend and then eventually you have to leave them to their own devices, don't you? Well, how about the Bigassie Sheeran? Well that's, I mean, they're fantastically expensive, not really my kind of thing to be honest, it's very much, I think what the young people would call a flex. The words just stuck in my mouth and lost my daughter. I'm Edmund Colthard and for BBC Radio 4 Shadow World, this is Sarah Payne Unforgotten, the story of eight-year-old Sarah Payne, who's murder in the summer of 2000, sparked a campaign to name and shame convicted child sex offenders and changed the law. Who do I care most about? Innocent, wide-eyed, children going about their legitimate business or pedophiles? I always felt like she was right beside me, just mommy make this nice, make it stop. Subscribe to Sarah Payne Unforgotten on BBC Sounds. where it came from. Listen to the global story wherever you get your BBC podcast.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The rise of AI is rooted in centuries of human ambition and technological experimentation, not just in recent innovations like ChatGPT.
  2. The story of Liam Kavener, known as "Mr Sunshine," reveals how unregulated entrepreneurial ambition and poor oversight can lead to massive misuse of public funds.
  3. Local councils, desperate for financial stability, were drawn into high-risk investments in solar energy through opaque deals and misleading financial claims.
  4. Red flags such as dangerously high debt-to-value ratios and lack of due diligence were ignored, especially by non-expert finance officials with limited industry knowledge.
  5. Sean Clark, Thurick Council’s finance director, made a series of enormous investments—up to £268 million—without proper council-wide scrutiny or transparency.
  6. These deals were often negotiated in luxury settings like the Mayfair Hotel, raising serious concerns about the legitimacy and accountability of council decision-making.
  7. A significant portion of the funds flowed directly to Liam Kavener, who reportedly received £15 million in a single payout, indicating a clear conflict of interest.
  8. The case raises critical questions about accountability, the role of entrepreneurs in public finance, and the dangers of unchecked speculation with taxpayer money.

Summary:

The BBC podcast *Chasing Mr Sunshine* investigates a massive financial scandal involving Liam Kavener, known as "Mr Sunshine," and local councils in the UK. It reveals how public money—particularly from councils like Thurick—was funneled into a solar energy investment scheme, Rockfire Investment Finance, through opaque and poorly scrutinized deals. Despite red flags such as high debt-to-value ratios and lack of transparency, councils, including Warrington and Thurick, invested billions in what were marketed as safe, profitable opportunities.

Sean Clark, the finance director of Thurick, made a staggering £268 million investment in 2017, later followed by additional sums, much of it borrowed from other councils. These loans, often unregulated and informal, created a system where public funds were used for speculative ventures with little oversight. The investments were negotiated in luxury settings, like the Mayfair Hotel, undermining accountability.

Evidence shows substantial profits flowed directly to Kavener, who had a history of fraudulent schemes, including one involving a fraudulent investment firm, Axiom. The narrative raises urgent concerns about how public trust, financial integrity, and democratic accountability are compromised when entrepreneurs and untrained officials make high-stakes decisions without proper oversight or public debate. The case serves as a cautionary tale about the risks of unchecked ambition in public finance and the need for transparent, expert-led governance.

FAQs

The podcast investigates a financial scandal involving Liam Kavanaugh, known as 'Mr Sunshine,' and local councils in the UK who invested massive sums of public money into his solar farm companies without proper oversight or due diligence.

Liam Kavanaugh built a reputation as a charismatic entrepreneur and investment expert. He secured investments from councils like Warrington and Thurick Council, offering high-return solar bonds that appealed to financially strained local authorities.

Red flags included a high debt-to-value ratio, suggesting the solar farms might not be worth as much as the loans, and the lack of transparency in how the investments were structured or reported to councils.

Thurick Council made a total of £268 million in investments—more than its annual budget—through multiple deals signed in 2017 and 2018, with most funds borrowed from other councils.

Yes. The investments were made with little public scrutiny, and key financial details were hidden from council staff. There was no proper risk assessment, and the council finance director, Sean Clarke, did not share his internal doubts with colleagues.

The Mayfair Hotel in London was where Sean Clarke and Liam Kavanaugh met to discuss deals, suggesting that high-level financial decisions were made in casual, informal settings rather than in official council meetings.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.