Change Plans That Actually Get Change Done with Ani Ziyalyan (Vice President of Transformation and Organizational Change Management, First American)
21m 54s
Change is constant and inevitable in business, yet most organizations struggle to implement effective transformation due to a lack of human-centered, actionable planning. Rather than relying on theoretical frameworks or lengthy approvals, successful change leaders focus on real behaviors, clear accountability, and practical execution. The process begins by defining business outcomes and identifying how people will change their behaviors to achieve them. A key differentiator is the emphasis on ownership—every activity has a responsible person, a timeline, and measurable results—making plans actionable and not just presentations. Executives are more engaged when change plans mirror real operations, using their own performance metrics and decision points. Progress is driven through progressive alignment, where early pilots generate evidence-based buy-in, reducing resistance and avoiding endless meetings. Resistance is normal and must be addressed with data, not opinion. Ultimately, the most effective plans are not just documented—they are lived, with leaders stepping into ownership, asking what will change on Monday morning and who is responsible. This shift from compliance to commitment transforms change from a passive exercise into a dynamic, operational priority.
The change keeps changing, transformation is hard.
The leaders really need to change first.
Change management is not done by consultants.
Often businesses bury their head in the sand because it's too difficult.
Here is the biggest culprit.
Everything is changing and evolving.
Change, change, change, change, change, change, change, change, change, change, change, change.
Change is the only constant in business today.
I'm Nali Wartov, founder and CEO of Change Activation Platform Tiger Hulk, and chair of the
Executive Council for leading change.
I've made it my mission to find practical approaches to change that actually work.
This podcast is a chance for me to sit down with some of the change in transformation
leaders making a real impact in their organizations, and then share those learnings with all of
you.
In each episode, we'll uncover strategies and insights that you can apply right away in
your own transformation journey.
Welcome to the only constant.
Imagine your organization hands you the keys to a brand new car, and you've never driven
before.
Would a training video get you safely and confidently from point A to point B?
Likely not, you'd more likely want an instructor sitting right next to you.
And yet, in transformation initiatives, we don't always consider what people need to step
into the unknown and succeed.
This week, I'm joined by Anis D'Aleon, vice president of transformation and organizational
change management at First American.
Anis process starts with a question that too many teams skip.
What exactly do people need to start, stop or continue doing, and how do we actually get
them there, with a sticky, actionable change plan?
Later on, Ani will also share the one non-negotiable marker of a plan that will move the business
forward, and the telltale signs that a plan is just the error.
If you've ever sat through a meeting about a change plan that never fully materialized,
this is the conversation for you.
So Ani, you've started to get into a flow state when you're building change plans.
What does that actually look like?
Nelly, it's so interesting.
When people hear change plan, they often imagine a lot of spreadsheets, timelines, and
communication plans, and that's still very much part of my plan.
But for me, developing the plan is a very different experience.
It really feels like I'm stepping into another world.
It's like another dimension that I step into.
If I can sit down to work on a change initiative, and suddenly I realize three or four hours
have passed without me even noticing, I feel completely immersed in solving what I think
is the most interesting part of change management, which is understanding human behavior.
It's a passion of mine, just focusing on the people side of change.
What fascinates me again is the people.
It's not the project, it's not the tool or the technology.
Of course, those are all important, but I really want to understand why some groups embrace
change quickly while others resist it, what influence is trust, what creates momentum,
what causes people to disengage.
So those are the things that are very fascinating for me, and I've always been passionate about.
So when I'm in that flow state, my mind is constantly connecting dots.
I'm thinking about psychology, leadership behaviors, communication strategies, the organizational
dynamics, culture, and how all of those elements interact with one another.
Dependencies are also very important for me and Ellie to understand without one you can't
have the other.
So one event triggers the other, right?
It's important that we keep that in mind, and it's almost like building a mental model
of the organization and then stress testing it in a way.
So if we do this, what will happen if leaders communicate this way, how will people respond?
If we remove this barrier, does it accelerate adoption or does it hinder it or do we have
resistance?
So all those things are part of this world that I step into.
It's like this dynamic world that experience itself is both analytical and it's creative.
At the same time, I'm solving challenges in my head, but I'm also imagining possibilities
at outcomes and people's responses.
When I finally step back, what gives me the biggest sense of accomplishment is seeing
how all those moving pieces connect into a strategy that can actually help people navigate
that change successfully.
So it ends up on a piece of paper or an output that I develop, and all those parts are connected.
Putting a puzzle together, it's million little pieces that I'm able to connect, and then
I step back and see a beautiful picture at the end.
That's so fascinating.
I think the puzzle description is right, and it's also a puzzle that you can never solve
right, because it is about humans and human behavior, and you can never really, really figure
it out.
So I can totally see that fascinating.
I agree with everything you've said about change.
So walk us through the process step by step without the ad-car style fluff.
What do you start with?
What do you ignore, and where do you think most people might over-complicate things in
this process?
You know, ad-car is a good model, and I actually like all of the major change management
methodologies.
People often ask me, which one is your favorite?
They're all my favorites.
I think they all provide useful frameworks to help ensure you're thinking about the right
things.
It's also a good way to help explain to someone what change management is, but when it comes
to building a real plan, my process is pretty straightforward.
First I get a clear understanding of the business outcome.
What is the challenge you are trying to solve?
What does success look like?
What specifically needs to be different when we're done?
Second I identify the stakeholder groups that will be impacted and assess their level of
impact.
So understanding who's impacted.
How are they impacted?
When are they impacted?
And what's their current state and future state?
How are we going to get there?
And really realizing that not everyone experiences change the same way.
So understanding who is affected and how it's critical is very important.
The third thing I typically do is identify the behaviors that need to change.
This is where I think a lot of people skip ahead too quickly.
Before creating communications or training plans, I really want to know exactly what people
need to start, stop or continue doing something.
I often give the example of receiving a car, right, if you've gotten a brand new car and
that's part of the change that your organization is expecting to go through, you have to determine
what will drive the behavior for you to go from not being able to drive a car, to learning
how to drive a car, right?
That should dictate that an online recording of training is not the right approach, right?
So you need an instructor sitting next to you teaching you how to drive this vehicle.
So really understanding what is the change and what do you need to implement to help
people go through that change effectively.
The fourth thing is I identify the leaders, the influencers and the support teams who will
help drive those behaviors.
Change doesn't happen through communications alone, although communications is an important
part of change, but that's not the only thing that drives change forward.
It happens through a lot of trusted relationships and reinforcement.
This is why we launched champions programs and there's peer-to-peer influence.
So there's a lot of different strategies that should be on a plan or should be considered
to be added to a plan to help drive change forward.
And once I have all those pieces, I then start developing the executable change management
plan.
So there's a difference between the strategy and an executable plan.
And on that executable plan is where I have specific communications, training, leadership
engagement, reinforcement activities, metrics and timelines all outlined.
Where people tend to over complicate things is by producing too much documentation and
not enough action.
I've seen a lot of organizations spend weeks debating a lot of different frameworks, templates,
assessments, when they still haven't answered the most important question, which is what
do we actually want people to do differently in this new desired state?
And if you stay focused on outcomes and behaviors and accountability, the planning process
becomes much simpler and much more effective.
That makes a lot of sense.
I know that you've built the reputation around those actions and making it very execution-ready
as well rather than academic.
What do you think is the biggest difference between your plans that are more action and execution
focused and the plans that never leave the slide deck and just end up as that artifact?
What are the specific decisions or structure that make yours so actionable?
Yeah, thanks.
That's a tough one.
I think a lot of people struggle a little bit with this one to be able to present a change
management plan in a way that actually moves forward and doesn't just stay on a presentation.
So the biggest difference is that my plans are designed for execution and not just for
a PowerPoint presentation or not just for a meeting.
I think a lot of change plans do a great job of describing what should happen in theory.
My focus is on exactly how it's going to happen in practice.
So it's more of a practical plan, not a theoretical plan.
So if anyone has ever worked with me or sees the type of change management plans I developed,
they'll immediately notice that every activity has an owner.
Every milestone has a timeline.
Every dependency is clearly identified.
And if one activity needs to happen before another can succeed, that's also documented.
So there's no ambiguity around who is wrong.
responsible for what and when. I build plans the same way operators build
execution plans. It's very task driven, it's time driven, and it's designed to be
acted upon immediately. So I also think about the plan from a leader's
perspective. If I am then presented to a leader, I want them to be able to quickly
understand what's expected of them specifically. So can they track progress? If the
answer is yes, then the plan has much higher chance of creating real movement. I
need our leaders who are part of that change process to really understand where
their role is, where they need to step in, what they need to deliver, and when,
and how they're going to move the organization forward. So ultimately a good
change plan shouldn't sit in a slide deck. It should function as a roadmap that
leaders and teams use every day to move the transformation forward. Do you think
that means that your plans are more detailed oriented, more tactical, like
are they longer than the average plan? I wouldn't necessarily say that. I do have
high-level change visual, so people can see exactly which phase of the change
they're in, and what actions need to be taken for each stakeholder group. I do have
then very detailed plans that I track behind the scenes, which go into that
traditional line-by-line tracking method and approach. So it's easy to digest
when you first look at a change strategy that I developed that highlights the
high-level items and milestones that we need to get the organization to go
through, and where each stakeholder group will be involved in those activities.
Then the detailed change management plan, the one that's more executable, has
those key milestones, which then outline on this date we will have an all-hands
meeting within which this individual is going to lead the conversation around
this topic. So it becomes very specific, and that approach to
implementing change and influencing the organization can be
clearly seen. So sometimes it does get very long and very complicated,
depending on the complexity of the transformation.
However, I do try to keep it as simple as possible to digest the information
that's on the plan, so our executive leaders can immediately look at it and
understand exactly what they need to do to move the organization forward.
Got it. And the super tactical question, what does it look like? Is it an Excel
sheet? Is it an PowerPoint? Great question. So I'm going to say that it is in a
PowerPoint. I did use to use Visio in the past. I transition that to PowerPoint
presentations, but with all these AI tools at our fingertips I am experimenting
with various tools that we have at our fingertips. Cursor is one that I recently
started to experiment with and has yielded beautiful outputs. I'm not
advocating for one or the other. I'm just experimenting at this point in time,
but it has been PowerPoint as my go-to solution in the past few years.
Got it. Awesome. And you know, many change frameworks are
very beautifully designed, but then like, unusable array. Like, what's one
element of traditional change methodology that you might think
slows down a transformation? Anything that you avoid or don't do that you think
just makes it move slower? Yeah, I've seen this happen a lot. One thing that
can slow transformations down is I would say an over-reliance on
upfront stakeholder alignment and getting sign-offs from everyone.
I think the intent is really good. It should reduce risk. It does get
more buy-in up front. It makes sure everyone's voice is heard,
but in large organizations, especially if it's a bureaucratic organization,
that can quickly turn into lengthy review cycles,
multiple approval layers, and just an endless attempt to achieve consensus
before taking action, which slows things down quite often.
What happens is that the momentum gets lost and the most
risk-averse voices end up carrying this proportionate influence in that scenario.
I found that a better approach is progressive alignment. So,
get alignment on the initial phase of what needs to get done and then progressively
move forward to continue to build that buy-in. So start with the clear direction
and a committed group of sponsors move into action quickly, run pilots,
gather feedback, generate results, and then use those outcomes to bring
others along. I think it's easier to align people around evidence
than just a really big PowerPoint presentation with a really complex plan on it.
Yeah, I think you're so right. We have another episode on
the only constant with Jotu Pandi from Eli Lilly that is talking about exactly
this issue where it's like you'd get stuck in endless alignment loops and it's
just alignment meetings after alignment meetings you never get anywhere.
Yeah, you're spot on it. It's making that transition from opinions to data,
because once you start executing you actually have data to bring to the table and then you tend to
silent the subjective opinions on everyone in the room which tends to take too much space otherwise.
To your point, the ones who are not believers get sometimes too much space.
Yes, and then you spend a lot of time trying to convince them to become believers and time passes
and the transformation that optimal moment to help the organization go through that
transformation passes. Yeah, exactly. I've seen many organizations where those
non-believers, they take so much time and space and effort and then they end up leaving before
the transformation even starts one reason or another and then you've wasted months and quarters
and years sometimes just on aligning people that are no longer there. Yes, absolutely.
And sometimes the resistance also comes from a different place too. I mean, there's often resistance
that we need to address and deal with and resistance doesn't scare us or surprise us. It's just a
normal part of change and sometimes it's driven from a different agenda or a different place and
it impacts the transformation that you're really trying to successfully lead. Yeah, absolutely.
I know when we prepared for this podcast, you said change plans should get changed done,
which I think is a really great way of putting it. What would you say is the non-negotiable marker
of a plan that will move the business forward and what might be some tell-tale signs that
a plan is just theater and will end up in that SharePoint limbo? Oh, for me, the non-negotiable marker
is accountability. A plan that drives results has specific actions, clear owners, realistic timelines
and measurable outcomes. So when I see names attached to deliverables, I know we're moving beyond
intention and into commitment. I also focus heavily on commitment rather than compliance.
That's an important distinction. Compliance gets people to participate because they have to
and commitment gets people to actively help drive the change forward and I want commitment not
compliance. So the tell-tale signs of a plan that's destined for SharePoint limbo is that it's
full of activities but lacks ownership. There are plenty of recommendations, plenty of meetings,
plenty of communications with no clear accountability for outcomes. If nobody owns it, nobody drives it.
And Nelly, there have been instances in my career where, you know, once I've shared the change
management plan with names assigned to activities, programs have shifted their timelines or some of
them have canceled entirely because when I've added names of very senior leaders who needed to be
accountable for leading a change and being the deliverer of the message, that really has stopped
some people and had them reevaluate what the transformation is about and it's moved timelines
for projects because it's helped them realize that maybe not all the answers are as clear as they
need to be so they're not necessarily ready to communicate something. So it's been extremely helpful
to focus on accountability and make sure that when we put a plan together, we hold people accountable
and it's clearly articulated who's going to deliver what. That makes sense. And how do you then work
around those timelines of things changed? Do you spend a lot of time on shifting timelines later on?
We don't spend too much time on shifting our plans actually. We focus on the initial few
activities that we had aligned on our change management approach and plan. What I do look at
Nelly is if we shift timelines, if it impacts the overall strategy, sometimes depending on when
you're implementing a transformation and whatever else is happening in that organization,
the approach could change, given if it's a busy season, let's say, and we need to focus more on
the external customer than the internal employee. So we might revise our change management plans
eventually, but the first thing I look at is what does this strategy overall look like? And
if the program timelines shift can we still meet those business outcomes? That makes sense.
And I know that your plans resonate really well with executives as well and leaders who are not
in change management, which is what I know many people in change management want to achieve is
how do I communicate this better to executives, right? So if you dropped your entire change plan
on the desk of a skeptical senior executive perhaps, what's the first thing that they would
notice that feels different about that kind of plan compared to the norm? Oh, the first thing
that notices that it looks like an operating plan. It's built around business outcomes, execution,
milestones, a lot of decision points and accountability as I mentioned. So not just communication
schedule and training activities. The language is operational. The metrics are very much business
centric. I actually work very closely with the business leaders to identify the business
outcomes that they desire and those are the success metrics that we drive towards.
The work is embedded in how leaders already run the business. So it doesn't feel like an extra layer
of work but it's how do you currently run the business and how can we add interventions and activities
that influence the organization to meet the business outcomes. So I think that's why it resonates
with operators and our executives. I think most business leaders don't wake up thinking about a
adoption models or change frameworks. They're focused on performance results and execution.
And my approach treats change management as a business performance challenge, not just an
adoption exercise. So it answers the question every operator once answered, which is what changes
on Monday morning and who's responsible for making that happen. When leaders completely see that
connection, they stop feeling like recipients of a change plan and start acting as owners of the
transformation. Most senior executives don't care about change frameworks. They care about performance
and outcomes. And that's not a problem for change leaders, that's an opportunity. On these plans
resonate because they look like operating plants, business outcomes, decision points, milestones,
owners, the metrics come from the business leaders themselves and the activities fit into how the
business already runs. So it never really feels like an extra layer of work. And her guiding question
is one you should also consider. What will actually change on Monday morning and who's responsible
for making that happen? When leaders across the business can see that connection, they stop being
recipients of a change plan and start acting as owners of the transformation. And that's the shift
that makes everything else so much easier.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
True change success starts with understanding human behavior and the specific behaviors people need to start, stop, or continue doing.
Effective change plans are action-oriented, with clear owners, timelines, dependencies, and measurable outcomes—designed for execution, not just presentation.
The most critical non-negotiable is accountability
Over-reliance on upfront stakeholder approval slows progress; a better approach is progressive alignment using pilots and data-driven results.
Change plans that resonate with executives are built around business outcomes and operational language, not theoretical frameworks.
Leaders are more likely to commit to change when they see direct responsibility for outcomes, not just compliance.
The process begins with defining business outcomes, identifying stakeholders, mapping behaviors, and assigning influencers—before any templates or timelines.
When plans are grounded in real-world execution and tied to daily operations, they create momentum and enable leaders to act as owners of transformation.
Summary:
Change is constant and inevitable in business, yet most organizations struggle to implement effective transformation due to a lack of human-centered, actionable planning. Rather than relying on theoretical frameworks or lengthy approvals, successful change leaders focus on real behaviors, clear accountability, and practical execution. The process begins by defining business outcomes and identifying how people will change their behaviors to achieve them.
A key differentiator is the emphasis on ownership—every activity has a responsible person, a timeline, and measurable results—making plans actionable and not just presentations. Executives are more engaged when change plans mirror real operations, using their own performance metrics and decision points. Progress is driven through progressive alignment, where early pilots generate evidence-based buy-in, reducing resistance and avoiding endless meetings.
Resistance is normal and must be addressed with data, not opinion. Ultimately, the most effective plans are not just documented—they are lived, with leaders stepping into ownership, asking what will change on Monday morning and who is responsible. This shift from compliance to commitment transforms change from a passive exercise into a dynamic, operational priority.
FAQs
An effective plan has clear accountability, specific owners, realistic timelines, and measurable outcomes. An ineffective plan lacks ownership, is full of vague activities, and ends up in SharePoint limbo without real action.
Accountability drives active participation and ownership, while compliance only ensures people participate out of obligation. Commitment leads to sustained effort, whereas compliance leads to passive execution.
By aligning with business outcomes and operational language, the plan looks like an everyday operating plan, showing clear decision points, milestones, and responsibilities—making it feel familiar and actionable.
Understanding human behavior—such as resistance, trust, and motivation—is central to change success. People’s reactions to change depend on trust, leadership, and how well the change connects to their daily experience.
Excessive approval processes slow momentum, create bureaucratic delays, and allow risk-averse voices to dominate. This can waste time and cause the transformation to stall before meaningful action starts.
It includes specific actions, clear owners, timelines, dependencies, and metrics. It’s designed to be actionable, not theoretical, and is structured like an operating plan with daily relevance to business operations.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.