Go back

Case 357: Wayne & Sharmon Stock

1h 22m 22s

Case 357: Wayne & Sharmon Stock

In 2006, a double homicide occurred at the home of Wayne and Charmin Stock in Murdoch, Nebraska, during an Easter morning. The crime scene revealed signs of multiple intruders, with blood and a clean patch suggesting a deliberate attack. Initial suspicion fell on Matthew Livers, the couple’s nephew, due to past family disputes and financial tensions. Despite a confession from Livers, inconsistencies in his account and lack of physical evidence raised doubts. Further investigation uncovered a gold ring linked to a couple in Wisconsin, leading to the arrest of 17-year-old Jessica Reed and 19-year-old Gregory Fester. They admitted to breaking into the home while high on drugs, shooting both victims during a confrontation. DNA evidence and Jessica’s diary confirmed their involvement. Though Matthew Livers confessed, a hidden second interview revealed he had recanted, and forensic analysis showed he was mentally impaired and coerced during interrogation. His confession was deemed unreliable. A psychological evaluation concluded the confession was false due to interrogation tactics and his intellectual disability. Jessica and Greg were sentenced to consecutive life terms. Meanwhile, Matthew and Nick Samson were released due to insufficient evidence and lack of physical ties. The case highlighted flaws in investigative practices, including tunnel vision, coercive interrogation, and failure to consider alternative suspects. The true perpetrators were identified through circumstantial and forensic evidence, not confession alone. The case remains a cautionary tale about the dangers of overreliance on confessions and the importance of proper forensic and psychological evaluation.

Transcription

11739 Words, 67378 Characters

English
In 2011, the body of a woman was discovered in a California vineyard. She had been decapitated and her body had been drained of blood. It appeared her killer had gone to extraordinary lengths to conceal her identity. For more than a decade, she was known only as Jane Doe, then detectives finally learnt her name, Ada. Identifying her only made this bizarre murder even more perplexing. Ada is the new series from Casevile Presents, available now wherever you get your podcasts. Our episodes deal with serious and often distressing incidents. If you feel at any time you need support, please contact your local crisis centre. For suggested phone numbers for confidential support and for a more detailed list of content warnings, please see the show notes for this episode on your app or on our website. Easter Sunday of 2006 was a happy one for Wayne and Shaman stock. Like every year, the married couple attended the morning service at their local church in the small village of Murdoch, Nebraska, followed by a long brunch with their extended family. But their favourite part of the day was what came next when their adult children and grandkids gathered at their 1,000 acre farm for the annual stock family Easter egg hunt. Family was everything to Wayne and Shaman and watching their grandkids race around trying to find the eggs always filled them with joy. Afterwards, everyone sat down for a big family dinner before going their separate ways. Wayne and Shaman cleaned up before retiring to bed. At around 9 o'clock the next morning of Monday, April 17, the couple's son, Andy Stock, pulled into his parents' driveway ready to start work. He and his father ran the family farm and that morning they were due to begin planting a new crop. Andy expected to find his dad up and about like usual doing paperwork or out fixing something on the farm. But Wayne's pickup truck was still parked in its usual spot and the kitchen, which was typically filled with the smell of freshly brewing coffee, was empty. As Andy looked around, he increasingly got the feeling that something wasn't right. The back door was wide open, the daily newspaper was still in the letterbox and his mother's Buick hadn't moved from the garage. The whole place felt uncharacteristically quiet. Rather than searching the whole farm, Andy headed back inside to call Wayne's cell phone. But when he lifted the handset of the line, he felt a prickle of fear. The line was dead. Andy tentatively made his way upstairs to check his parents' bedroom. Halfway up the staircase, he noticed a long streak of blood on the handrail. Andy barely had time to process what it was when he rounded the bend in the staircase and saw that something was blocking the upstairs landing. Andy stumbled back down the stairs, ran outside and grabbed his phone from his truck. He struggled to breathe as he called 911 and told the operator what he'd just seen. His father, Wayne Stock, laying face down in a pool of blood. The stock's farm was in a rural area and emergency crews were nearly 30 miles away. Andy waited for them on the driveway, trying to make sense of what he'd just seen. His father had been almost unrecognizable, his head badly disfigured with what looked like part of his skull missing. As shock gave way to grief, it occurred to Andy that he still didn't know where his mother was. Unsure if she was still in the house, he couldn't bring himself to go back inside and find out. When law enforcement arrived, they left a shell-shocked Andy outside and made their way upstairs. 58-year-old Wayne Stock had been fatally shot in the head. His body was lying halfway through the bedroom doorway as though he'd been crawling out of the room when he was attacked. Behind the bed, partially obscured from view, was the body of 55-year-old Charmin. She, too, had been fatally shot. One of Charmin's hands was clutching the telephone handset, indicating that in her final moments she'd been trying to call for help. The Cass County Sheriff's Office did not investigate many homicides and they quickly realised they needed outside help. Their first port of call was David Cofoad, the director of the crime scene lab in nearby Douglas County. Commander Cofoad was considered one of the most respected forensic investigators in Nebraska and had worked on countless violent homicides during his career. But even with all his experience, he, too, was shocked by the brutality in front of him. Wayne and Charmin were both wearing their pajamas and to their disheveled bedsheets suggested they'd been fast asleep when they were roused awake by an intruder. Nearly every surface of the room was covered in blood sputter, but on one wall, investigators noticed a clean patch in the shape of a person. It looked like someone had been standing there when shots were fired by someone else, their body shielding the wall from the spray. From the evidence at the scene, it was clear that there had been more than one intruder. While the scene upstairs was brutal, downstairs was exceptionally neat. Nothing had been ransacked and items of value remained untouched. The only thing out of place was the laundry window which had been propped open with the screen removed. The intruders had also left behind several items, including a flashlight, a cannabis pipe, and a handful of red shotgun shells. While it wasn't much to go on, investigators were convinced this hadn't been a burglary gone wrong, but a deliberate attack. The question was, who would want Wayne and Charmin dead? It was a question the people of Murdoch were already asking. Located along Nebraska's Highway 1, halfway between the cities of Omaha and to Lincoln, the tiny village hadn't recorded a single murder in a hundred years. With a population of just 269 people, it was the kind of place where everybody knew each other and to nobody locked their doors. So when news spread that there had been a double homicide, it was met with disbelief. The fact that the stocks were the victims only added to the shock. Wayne and Charmin were well known and well liked in their community. Wayne was born and bred in Murdoch and his connection to the land went back generations. The family's hay farming business had been passed down by his father and Wayne was proud that one day his own son would take the reins. Charmin was the more outgoing of the pair having come from a prominent local family who had significant influence in the community. She taught at the local school for years before starting her own cake decorating business. Her cakes were famous in Murdoch. If someone was celebrating a baptism or a milestone birthday, there was a good chance the cake was one of Charmin's. The couple had been married for 37 years. Over that time, the farming business had done well and though they didn't flaunted, the stocks had become quietly wealthy. Investigators considered whether the murders could have been financially motivated. That evening, when they asked Charmin's grief-stricken siblings if there was anyone who might want to harm the couple, they didn't hesitate to name a suspect. Charmin's siblings said that Wayne and Charmin had been known to butt heads with their nephew, 28-year-old Matthew Lathers, more commonly known as Matt. Charmin's family had never liked Matt, viewing him as a free loader who couldn't hold down a job. They also found him to be creepy and generally not a nice person. Charmin's siblings said there had been some tension over the stock family inheritance. Apparently, Matt wanted his elderly grandmother, Wayne's mother, to leave her house to him, but Wayne and Charmin were against it. According to Charmin's siblings, Charmin had once told Matt he would only get that house, quote, "over my dead body". While this alone was of great interest to the investigators, their interest was peaked And further upon learning that Matt Livers had attended this same Easter brunch as Wayne and Charmin on the day they were killed. They wondered if something could have happened there that set him off. Earl Shank Jr. from the Cass County Sheriff's Office was leading the investigation. Like a most officers in Cass County, Shank had almost no prior experience working a murder case, but he was determined to prove that he was up to the job. By the time he'd learned about Matt Leivors, it was late, but he didn't want to wait until morning to speak with him. At 10.45pm, Shank called Matt and, despite the late hour, he agreed to meet. 15 minutes later, Matt pulled up alongside Shank's unmarked patrol car and climbed into the passenger seat. With Shank driving and a second officer Bill Lambert in the back, the three men set off into the darkness. Not wanting to tip their hand too early, the officers kept the mood light. When asked how he spent Easter Sunday, Matt said he'd gone to brunch at his grandmother's house, then left at around 5pm and spent the rest of the night at home. Asked about Wayne and Charmin's stock, Matt said they were great people who had always been kind and generous to him. He denied there had ever been any serious tension between them, save for a minor disagreement years earlier when he was still a kid. As for his grandmother's house, Matt admitted he hoped he and his fiance might inherit it someday, but only after his grandmother passed away. As they spat along the deserted roads, the officers steered the conversation toward the murders. Matt told them he'd been shocked when he heard the news, thinking that things like that weren't supposed to happen in Murdoch. Asked who could be responsible, he struggled to come up with an answer. Matt took a long pause before mentioning an incident that had occurred years earlier during which two of his cousins from the other side of the family had upset Wayne's stock by writing dirt bikes on his property, but he quickly dismissed that event as insignificant. The questioning continued into the early hours of the morning. Matt was relaxed and, frankly, answering everything the officers put to him. Sometimes he seemed almost too eager to help. Other times he smiled or laughed at inappropriate moments. It was a stark contrast to the conversation with Sharman's grief-stricken family a few hours earlier. The longer the interview went on, the more uneasy the officers became. But with no concrete evidence to implicate Matt in the crime, they dropped him back at his car at 3am. As they watched him drive off, the two officers were both thinking the same thing. Sharman's siblings were right. There was something off about Matt Livers. When local couple Justin and Tamara heard about the stock murders, their minds went back to an incident that had occurred in the early morning hours of Easter Monday. The couple had been out delivering newspapers when they noticed a tan sedan parked at the cemetery just a few minutes drive from the stock farm. Given that there weren't usually any cars there at that time of morning, it had stood out. A short while later, they'd seen the car again. This time, it nearly hit them from behind before speeding off in the direction of Lincoln. Justin and Tamara hadn't been able to make out the driver's face in the dark, but they had noticed two details, a beard and a few digits of the Nebraska number plate. When the couple called the police to report this incident, investigators were intrigued. Matt Livers was from Lincoln and he also had a go-t. But he didn't own a tan sedan nor did anyone in his immediate family. During Matt's late night car ride with the police, he had mentioned two cousins who'd once had a run-in with Waynestock. Officers ran the cousin's names through the system and found that the older of the two, 23-year-old Will Simpson, owned a tan sedan. Although his number plate didn't match the description provided by Justin and Tamara, the similarities were difficult to ignore. Officers kept digging and before long, they discovered that at 6am on Easter Monday, just hours after Wayne and Shaman were killed, Will Simpson had taken his car to be professionally cleaned. This raised the question of what exactly had he been trying to wash away? Officers visited Will Simpson at his home and he agreed to an interview. They asked when he'd last seen his cousin, Matt Livers. Will seemed confused. He said he hadn't seen Matt for months and that they hadn't hung out together regularly since they were kids. Told that a tan sedan was seen near the stock farm around the time of their murders, Will said he barely knew the stocks and he wasn't anywhere near the area at the time. He had been home with his fiance all night and then at work the next day. The officers then asked if he'd done anything unusual on his way to work on Easter Monday. Will took a beat before saying yes, he had taken his car to get professionally cleaned. But he said he hadn't been trying to clean anything in particular, explaining that it had been a gift. Will had been driving a colleague to work every day and to say thank you, the colleague had arranged for Will's car to be cleaned. Although this story seemed highly improbable to the investigators, no matter how hard they tried to poke holes in it, Will's account didn't change. His fiance also confirmed every word, giving him a solid alibi. Will was free to go, but investigators weren't ready to dismiss his car. They wondered if someone else might have had access to it on Easter Sunday. They seized the car and a forensic team worked through the night examining every inch of it, but found nothing. Meanwhile, Wayne and Sharman's finances were being scrutinized. Their entire estate had been left to their three adult children. Matt Livers didn't benefit financially from their deaths in any way. Investigator Earl Shank Jr. was frustrated. By this point, a week had passed since the murders and police still had no clear motive and no physical evidence tying anyone to the crime. Shank knew some inside law enforcement had questioned whether he had enough experience to lead the case, and he was more determined than ever to prove them wrong. He kept thinking back to the late night drive with Matt Livers. The 28-year-old had spoken about his newly deceased aunt and uncle with a calmness that Shank found deeply unsettling. He couldn't shake the feeling that Matt was somehow involved. He just needed a way to prove it. By the end of the first week, the whole of Murdoch seemed to know that Matt Livers was suspected of Wayne and Sharman's murders. As investigators dug deeper into his background and began interviewing his family and friends, they noticed that Matt's loved ones kept using the same words over and over to describe him. Different, slow, and immature for his age. What they were actually trying to convey was that Matt had an intellectual disability. From early childhood, he had struggled with delayed development and serious learning difficulties. When he started school in the 1980s, learning disabilities were not well understood. Kids bullied Matt and stole his lunch money, leaving him in tears. Even some teachers struggled to understand him, with a school psychologist once telling his mother, Matt will amount to a zero. Nothing. But his parents knew that wasn't true. When they moved to Texas during Matt's teenage years, they enrolled him in the special education stream of his local high school. It was the fresh start he needed. Finally, he found himself in an environment where he could make real friends and thrive. Although he was still teased from time to time, life on the whole was better, and in 1996, Matt proved the psychologist wrong by graduating high school. He also found a job he loved working as a private security guard at the local airport. The job suited Matt as he'd always been the type to stay out of trouble. As a kid, he'd refused to participate in the underage drinking and partying that he's friends engaged in, and as an adult, he'd never had so much as a speeding ticket. Working as a security guard also made him feel a bit like a police officer, and Matt thought highly of the police. In his view, they were the good guys, the people you trusted when something was wrong. But as much as Matt loved his job, his disability made it hard for him to maintain [BLANK_AUDIO] that he employment, and soon enough he was let go. After a few years of bouncing between jobs, Matt met a young woman named Sarah. Although Sarah was pregnant and in the process of getting divorced, the two had an instant connection. They fell in love, got engaged, and decided to move back to Nebraska. They settled in the city of Lincoln, 30 miles from Murdoch, where Matt was helping to raise her young son. The only time they ever argued was when Matt spent too much money on eBay. While their life together was happy, it wasn't without its challenges. The couple had been dealt a blow in the month before Easter 2006, when Matt was fired from his latest job. But he'd already found a new, even better one. It had seemed like things were looking up. Nine days after the murders, Matt Livers agreed to go to the police station for another interview. He was seated across from investigators Shank and Lambert, the same two officers from the car ride a week earlier. Again, the officers were friendly, even jovial, as they spoke. When they asked Matt about his aunt and uncle, he explained that he had nothing to do with their deaths. The police questioned Matt for two hours before asking if he'd take a polygraph. Although Matt thought the equipment looked intimidating, the officers explained that all he had to do was tell the truth and he'd be fine. Matt nervously agreed. Matt took the test and was then left alone in the interrogation room. Shortly after, the officers returned and told Matt that he'd failed the test, badly. They told him the results showed there was no doubt that he had murdered Wayne and Desharman stock. Matt didn't understand. He insisted he'd been truthful in every answer and tried to protest his innocence, but Shank and Lambert told him that the polygraph never lied. As the interview stretched on, Matt insisted again and again that he was innocent. The officers became increasingly angry, shouting at Matt that if he didn't come clean, they'd make sure he got the death penalty. Shank warned, "You don't admit to me what you've done. I'm going to walk out that door to hang your ass from the highest tree. You're done. I will go after the death penalty. I will push and push to make sure you go down hard for this." At one point, they told Matt that if he was a man, he would stand up and take responsibility for what he'd done. Matt pushed his chair back and stood up. No, one of the officers said, "Stand up and be a man." Matt seemed confused. "I'm trying to," he said. By this point, it was mid-afternoon and the interrogation had been going on for hours. Matt asked if he could go home, a request which the officers laughed at. They repeatedly told him this interview was his one and only chance to save himself and if he just admitted what he'd done, they could help him. Finally, at 3.28 pm, after six and a half hours of questioning, Matt's resolve began to crumble. One of the officers said, "The truth is you got a gun, right or wrong." Matt paused for a moment before responding, "Right." And you took that gun back to your uncle Wayne and to Aunt Charmond's house, right? Right or wrong? Right, Matt said. The officer continued on, putting it to Matt, that he snuck into the stock's home with the gun, saw his aunt and uncle lying in bed and then shot Wayne, followed by Charmond. Question by question, Matt agreed with what they said until eventually the whole story was out and he'd admitted to both murders. But there was a problem. The crime scene had shown that at least two people were involved but Matt hadn't mentioned anyone else. As the interview stretched into the evening, the officers began digging for the identity of his accomplice. They asked Matt if he knew who owned the 10 car that had been spotted near the scene. Matt knew which car they were referring to, the whole town did. He told them that belonged to his cousin, Will Sampson, but he was adamant that Will wasn't involved in the crime. The officers asked Matt if he knew anyone else who might have access to that car. Matt thought about it for a moment before saying, "His brother, Nick." The officers asked if Nick Sampson was the one who had given him a gun. Matt said yes. They kept pressing. Had he and Nick planned the whole thing during a phone call a few days prior. Again, Matt said yes. It had taken all day and into the night, but the officers finally had a full confession and the name of a second suspect. Matt Livers was formally placed under arrest and taken to the Cass County jail. (dramatic music) Case file will be back shortly. Thank you for supporting us by listening to this episode's sponsors. Thank you for listening to this episode's ads. By supporting our sponsors, you support Case file to continue to deliver quality content. Less than two hours later, six armed officers burst through the door of Bulldogs bar and grill in Murdoch, where 21-year-old Nick Sampson worked as a cook. He was handcuffed and marched out past the shocked diners into the waiting patrol car. While Nick had had a few run-ins with the sheriff's office over the years, that was just teenage mischief. Told he was under arrest on suspicion of Murdo, Nick was visibly shaken. He sat in silence for the 26 mile drive to the jailhouse, where he was then handed an orange jumpsuit and put in a cell. Nick maintained his innocence, refusing to answer any questions and asking for an attorney. That night, search warrants were executed at the homes of both cousins. Nothing incriminating was found at Matt Livers' house but police confiscated clothing and shoes for further testing. At the home of Nick Sampson, officers checked under his bed and found a 12 gauge pump action shotgun along with numerous used cartridges. While it would need to be confirmed by the lab, it looked like they'd just found the murder weapon. The next morning, the sheriff held a press conference to announce that two men had been arrested for the murder of Wayne and Sharman Stock. He praised investigators for their efforts and assured the people of Murdoch that there was no ongoing threat to the community, saying, "I'm confident the right people have been arrested." The press went into a frenzy, running headlines about the nephew who'd confessed to killing his own aunt and uncle. For many in Matt Livers' extended family, it was confirmation that their long-held beliefs about him were correct. One cousin told the Omaha World Herald he couldn't understand how Matt had cried alongside them at Wayne and Sharman's funeral when he'd been the one responsible. With both suspects in custody, investigators raced to shore up their case, but it wasn't proving easy. Testing if the shotgun found underneath the Nick Sampson's bed revealed it wasn't the murder weapon after all. Officers had been hopeful when two DNA profiles were found on the cannabis pipe left at the crime scene, but those weren't a match for Matt Livers or Nick Sampson either. Another issue was that Matt and Nick both had alibis for the time of the murders, with multiple witnesses placing them at home on the night of Easter Sunday. The case rested on Matt's confession, but parts of his account didn't line up with the crime scene. Matt told the police they had entered the stock's house through the front door, but investigators already knew the point of entry had been the laundry window. Matt said that after the shooting, he and his cousin were covered in blood, but no bloodied clothes had been found at either of their homes. Matt had also said that the murders were planned during a phone call, but records showed that he and Nick hadn't phoned each other for months. Even Matt's descriptions of the shotgun shells and the flashlight were wrong. Despite these discrepancies, there was one detail investigators kept returning to. Matt had said that when they were fleeing the scene, they'd thrown the murder weapon in the back seat of Will Sampson's car. The car had already been examined and to come back clean, but officers were convinced that evidence must have been missed. They rang the crime lab and explained that their suspect had confessed, but they still didn't have any physical evidence. They asked if the text could take another time. a look at the back seat just to be sure. Commander David Kofo to greet to examine the car for a second time. This time he noticed something on the underside of the steering column that hadn't been picked up in the earlier search. It was a tiny mark barely visible to the naked eye. He swabbed it with filter paper and sent it to the lab for testing. The results confirmed it was a tiny speck of human blood. Technicians had also managed to extract a complete DNA profile and confirmed that the blood belonged to Wayne Stock. The investigation team were elated. They finally had concrete evidence to back up their theory that Matt Livers and Nick Samson had used Will Samson's car as a getaway vehicle, but there was another problem. Four days after the murders, investigators had been going through the crime scene photos when a detective spotted a small, shiny object lying on the kitchen floor. They raced back to the farmhouse and located the object, which had somehow been missed during the initial search. It was a small, plain gold ring, like a wedding band engraved with the words "Love Always," "Cory and Ryan." Investigators immediately thought of Matt Livers, whose closest friend was a man named Ryan. But that Ryan lived 600 miles away in Texas, and despite extensive efforts, police couldn't link him to the ring. No one else named Corey or Ryan had come up during their inquiries, so investigators stopped focusing on the inscription and turned to the two DNA profiles that were found on the ring. When the results came back, the DNA wasn't a match to Matt Livers or Nick Samson, but to two unknown people. With the ring seemingly like a dead ant, it was bagged and put into the evidence locker for several weeks until Commander Kofo decided one of his technicians to follow it up. This time, the technician turned her attention to the small manufacturer's stamp on the inside of the band. It led to a wholesale jewelry company in Buffalo, New York, called A&A Jewelers. The company's operations manager, Mary Martino, was at work when she received a call from the forensic technician. The A&A Jewelers had recently gone bankrupt, and Mary was one of the few remaining employees tasked with packing the office up before the phones were disconnected, and it was shut down for good. Mary listened to the description of the ring and confirmed that it was one of theirs, but she said it wouldn't be easy to track down the owner. That particular style had been shipped to thousands of retailers across North America, and figuring out which store had sold that individual ring would mean manually digging through tens of thousands of receipts to find the right one. Mary wasn't even sure it could be done, but when she was told it could help solve a double homicide, she agreed to at least try. Mary started with the first box of records, going through every receipt by hand and checking the details, but found nothing. She moved on to the next box, and the next. It was a laborious, tedious task, but she'd been struck by the details of the case and wanted to help find justice for the victims, so she kept going. Finally, after three days of digging, she found what she was looking for. The receipt showed the ring had been purchased in December 2004 at a Walmart store 500 miles from Murdoch in the city of Beaver-Dan, Wisconsin. The buyer was a 19-year-old woman named Corey Zastro. Unfamiliar with this name, police arranged for their counterparts in Wisconsin to pay Corey a visit. She appeared startled when a police car pulled into her driveway, and even more so when the detective explained the reason for his visit was to discuss a ring she'd abort more than a year earlier. She said that the ring had been a present for her then-boyfriend Ryan. They'd since broken up, and Ryan had kept the ring, with Corey having no idea how it could have ended up at a crime scene so far away. Ryan was tracked down, and he immediately confirmed Corey's story. After their breakup, he said that he'd kept the ring in the glove compartment of his pickup truck, but the truck, a bright red Dodge ram, had been stolen on Easter Sunday. Ryan had reported the theft right away, and the truck was eventually tracked down. Two teenagers had stolen the truck and spent several drug-fueled days tearing across multiple states committing a string of petty thefts and break-ins. The young couple, 19-year-old Gregory Fester, and 17-year-old Jessica Reed, had already been arrested and were being held at the Dodge County Jail in Wisconsin. When Wisconsin police realized that the ring stolen from Ryan's vehicle had turned up two states away at the scene of a double homicide, it immediately set off alarm bells. While Jessica Reed only had a minor criminal history, Gregory Fester, known as Greg, was well known to law enforcement. The 19-year-old had more than 20 arrests to his name, for offenses including shoplifting, vehicle theft, drug possession, and sexual assault. With a reputation for being volatile, impulsive, and deeply involved in drugs, it wasn't a stretch to consider that he might have escalated to murder. Without letting their suspicions be known, Wisconsin investigators quietly collected DNA samples from Jessica and Greg to compare against the two unknown profiles found at the scene of Wayne and Schumann's murder, which had been taken from the Gold Ring and the Cannabis pipe. The DNA profiles proved to be a match to Greg Fester and to Jessica Reed. Within hours, Earl Shank Jr. and to Bill Lambert from the Caffes County Sheriff's Office set out on the eight-hour drive to Wisconsin to meet the teenagers for themselves. When the officers spoke to Greg, he told them that he and Jessica had been high on drugs when they stole a truck and went for a joyride. At some point on Easter Sunday, they'd broken into a farmhouse looking for things to steal, but according to Greg, it had just been petty theft and no one had been heard. The officers from Nebraska didn't believe him. They got worked up, insisting he was lying and demanding that he reveal who else had been there. But Greg's story didn't change. Jessica's version of events matched her boyfriends. Still not buying it, the officers told Jessica that they knew other people were involved and they wanted names. Jessica said she had no idea what they were talking about. The officers passed her photographs of Matt Livers and his cousins, Nick and Will Sampson. Jessica looked at them, appearing confused and said, "I have never seen any of these people that you are showing me right now. I'm not kidding any of you. Fingers are not crossed. I have no idea who they are." The two officers were growing increasingly frustrated. They warned Jessica that they were investigating a double homicide and because it happened in Nebraska, the killer would be up for the death penalty. If Jessica was involved, they told her this was her one chance to avoid getting the electric chair or the gas chamber. You have to tell us what happened one of the officers said. It's the only thing that will save you. Jessica looked down at the photographs. She changed her mind, saying that maybe she did remember one of the men. She gestured at the mugshot of Nick Sampson but couldn't explain where she'd seen him or how he was involved. She couldn't even give his name. You need to come up with details one of the officers told her. Jessica paused. She then said that the men from the photo had been inside the stock farmhouse with them and she'd seen him shoot one of the victims. With that, she clamped up and refused to say any more. The officers waived at the photo of Matt Livers in front of Jessica, telling her to search deep down inside herself to see if she recognized him. Jessica looked at the picture but was adamant that she'd never seen Matt before in her life. While it wasn't the answer the officers wanted, Jessica had just admitted to being present during the murders. It was enough for a search warrant. A team of officers descended on the house where Jessica Reed had been staying prior to her arrest. A roommate led them straight to a portrait which was propped up on a shelf. Hidden behind it was a small cigarette box with the words "too Greg" scrolled across it. Inside was a red 12-gauge shotgun shell along with a ladder from Jessica. Saying she'd saved the Spanish shell as a token of their love. By Jessica's bedroom, they found her diary. An officer skimmed through it before coming to a stop on page 13. I killed a man it read. He was older. I loved it. I wish I could do it all the time. If Greg doesn't watch it, I'm going to just leave one day and go do it myself. Meet with this new evidence, the Nebraska officers confronted Greg Fester again. He admitted that he'd been lying about what happened inside the stock farmhouse. The truth was, Greg said, he had shot Wayne and to Jessica had shot Charmin. Given that the officers already had too many jail for the murders, they were convinced that Greg was lying. Just like they'd done with the Jessica, they presented him with the stack of mug shots. This time there were four photos, Matt Livers, Nick and Will Simpson, and a friend of Nick's named Tom Todd. They instructed Greg to look at the photos carefully. If he had admitted who else was there that night, they'd make sure he got a lighter sentence. If he didn't, he'd get a longer one. To studying the photos, Greg pointed at two of the men. But it wasn't who the officers were expecting. Gregory had picked out Will Simpson and Tom Todd. According to Greg, he and Jessica had met the two men at a bar and they'd agreed to go for a drive with them. What they'd expected to be a simple burglary soon turned into something much more shocking when Will and Tom shot the homeowners. While there were obvious inaccuracies in Greg's story, such as his description of rural Murdoch as a noisy bustling night spot, the officers were prepared to overlook them. Greg's latest aversion of events was the closest fit to their working theory. They just needed Jessica Reed to confirm it. Mrs. Shank and Lambert sat Jessica in an interview room and presented her with her diary. As they read the incriminating entry out loud, the 17-year-old began to cry. Jessica admitted that she'd stood by and watched as Greg shot Wayne and Shaman's stock. While she denied having killed anyone herself, she told the officers she needed to come clean about something else. The men she'd picked out of the photos the day before hadn't been at the farmhouse and she'd never seen him before in her life. The only people who committed the crime were her and Greg Fester. The officers were furious. They accused Jessica of lying, telling her she was full of crap before storming out the door. The only other person left in the room was Wisconsin Detective Jim Raw, who had been quietly sitting in on the interviews. The two kept talking, and after a while, Jessica asked if they could shut the door so she could speak to Detective Raw privately without the Nebraska officers overhearing. You know who was in that house, she said, "Me and Greg, me and Greg." At that moment, the door swung open. Officer Shank stormed in. She realized that what we are talking about here right now is being recorded, he shouted. Again, Jessica insisted that the only person who killed anyone was Greg Fester, shouting, "I want to tell you guys the whole story, but you guys are ignoring me." The officers questioned why, if only Jessica and Greg had been in the house that night, had a suspect in Nebraska confessed to the killings. Jessica said she had no idea. To prove she was telling the truth, she offered to reveal a detail about the crime scene that had never been made public. Two shot guns had been used in the murders, not one. Jessica said she and Greg had stolen them from two different houses during their crime spree. She described the houses and gave specific details about where the guns had been located and how they'd found them. The officers weren't convinced. They now had two pairs of suspects in custody in two different states. DNA from the crime scene implicated the teens in Wisconsin while the blood found in Will Samson's car pointed to the cousins in Nebraska with no physical evidence linking them all together. There were also three separate confessions, none of which lined up. In that Greg's version of events, which implicated Will Samson and Tom Todd fit the police theory better than Jessica's, that was the one they ran with. Back in Nebraska, the announcement that two more people had been arrested for the stock murders came as a shock to the public. 21-year-old Tom Todd was taken in for questioning while a search warrant was executed at his home. Tom told police that he knew Nick and Will Samson, but that he hadn't seen Matt Livers in years. He said he didn't know Wayne and Sharman stock and had never heard of Jessica Reed or Gregory Faster. He also had an alibi for the night of the murders and his roommate could confirm it. The officers questioned Tom late into the night until he agreed to take a polygraph. He answered their questions and was then immediately informed that he'd failed. After that, Tom refused to answer any more questions and asked for a lawyer. With nothing to hold him on, the police released him at three in the morning. Back in Wisconsin, Detective Raw had been quietly making his own inquiries. By speaking to friends and acquaintances, he'd managed to disprove several of Greg Fester's claims while steadily verifying Jessica's. Most importantly, he confirmed her account that two separate guns had been used in the murders and was able to trace both weapons back to their owners. But there was one part of the case that still bothered him. Raw had spent weeks carefully building Jessica's trust and she agreed to speak with him again. During a series of interviews, Jessica admitted that she hadn't just witnessed the murders. She had helped commit them. She even told him that when she'd first been arrested, her clothes were still spattered with blood. Because she was only being booked for breaking and entering, no one paid attention to what she was wearing. For Raw, everything suddenly clicked into place. He immediately contacted the Nebraska team and passed along everything he'd discovered. We found out where Jessica's personal items were being stored and retrieved the blood stained clothing which he sent over as well. But it did not get the response he'd expected. Case file will be back shortly. By supporting our sponsors, you support CaseFile to continue to deliver quality content. Back in Murdoch, investigators had given up trying to find evidence implicating Tom Todd and were once again focused on Matt Livers and Nick Sampson, desperate to find a link between the cousins and the teenagers in Wisconsin. After exhausting all their leads, they decided to take another look at a name that had appeared earlier in the case. 600 miles away in Mansfield, Texas, Ryan Porting was taken into a windowless interrogation room. Ryan was Matt Livers' best friend, the two having met as teenagers when they attended the same special education school. Like Matt, Ryan had an intellectual disability. At 31, his cognitive functioning was comparable to that of someone in their early teens. Although Ryan had never been in trouble with the law before, he had come to the attention of investigators when they found out that Matt Livers had been staying with him in Texas in the weeks leading up to the stock's murders. Their suspicions were heightened when the gold ring was found at the crime scene with the name Ryan engraved on it. Ryan Porting had been extensively investigated and had his phone searched, but when nothing turned up and the ring was traced back to a different Ryan, he'd been cleared. Two months later, Ryan agreed to another interview, but his story hadn't changed. He maintained he knew nothing about the stock murders and was adamant that Matt Livers would never hurt anyone, describing him as the greatest guy who would give you the shirt off his own back. When Ryan still didn't waver after hours of questioning, the police asked if he would take a polygraph test and he agreed. Afterwards, a stern looking officer came in and sat just inches away from his face, saying, "Guess what, you failed." Ryan became visibly upset. He insisted he'd answered every question honestly and was devastated that the police thought he was a liar. As his distress grew, the officers tried a different approach. They said Matt Livers wasn't a bad person, he had just made a mistake. He'd murdered Wayne and Shaman Stock and had then lied about it, which is what got him in trouble. They told Ryan they didn't want him to make the same mistake. The thought that he's best friend hadn't told him the truth upset Ryan even more. Through tears, he began to agree with the officers. Matt Livers was a liar and Matt had said something during his visit to Texas. He and Nick Sampson were planning to kill the stocks. Given that he'd adjusted a minute to knowing about the murders in advance, officers were hopeful that Ryan Pauling might be the missing link between the two pairs of suspects. The next day, when questioning resumed, the officers said about finding a connection, however small, between Ryan and Wisconsin. Had Ryan ever traveled to Wisconsin? Did he know when he won who lived there? For hours, Ryan said no. He was given another polygraph and again, the same stern looking officer told him, "Guess what? You failed." Ryan was left alone in the interrogation room. When the officers finally returned, they began shouting at him that they knew he was lying about not knowing anyone in Wisconsin. Ryan started to cry, insisting that he didn't. The officers told him they would never believe him over a polygraph test. They then pulled out a folder of graphic photos from the crime scene, including close-ups of Wayne and Ashaman's injuries, and forced Ryan to look at them. They also threatened him with the jail time, saying they'd charge him as an accessory to murder, and that his entire future rested on this interview. By this point, the 31-year-old had spent two full days in the interrogation room under intense pressure. Ryan admitted that maybe he did know someone from Wisconsin after all. While he couldn't provide any further details and didn't recognize photos of Jessica Reed or Greg Fester, investigators now had someone on record who linked Matt Livers and Nick Samson to the murders, and who also admitted to having a connection with Wisconsin. They let Ryan porting go and boarded a flight home. Back in Nebraska, Nick Samson was in bad shape. After 10 weeks in jail, his mental health was spiraling and his stints in solitary confinement were making it worse. Nick continued to insist that he was innocent and that he had no idea why he's cousin Matt had dragged his name into things. In early July, just days after investigators arrived home from Texas, Nick's attorney filed a motion to have him released on bail on the grounds that there was no physical evidence proving that Nick had ever set foot inside the stock's home. Furthermore, the DNA that had been found showed that other people were responsible for the crime. The prosecution fired back saying that they already had two people who had implicated Nick in the crime, both Matt Livers and Jessica Reed, and that they now had a third. Ryan porting. Bale was denied and Nick was sent back to his cell to wait until his trial, which wouldn't be until December at the earliest. The news sent Nick deeper into depression, but in October, the same prosecutor walked back into the courthouse and asked the judge to dismiss all charges against him due to lack of evidence. Later that day, Nick Simpson walked out of the Cass County jail into the arms of his girlfriend and family. His attorney told the gathered press that the Nebraska investigators had suffered from a bad case of tunnel vision from the start, repeatedly ignoring evidence that pointed away from his client. He was especially critical of their decision to keep Nick behind bars for four months after Jessica Reed and Greg Faster had confessed and been arrested. Without the hard work of Detective Jim Raw in Wisconsin, Nick's lawyer said the truth might never have come out. All together, Nick Simpson had spent five months and ten days in jail. He told the press the experience had nearly broken him. When asked about the Cass County sheriff's office, he answered bluntly, "I don't think they know how to investigate a murder." While there still wasn't any physical evidence to place Matt Livers at the crime scene either, the fact that he'd confessed made the case against him far stronger and he remained behind bars. But right from the start, the confession had bothered Matt's attorney. So much of what Matt said didn't line up with the crime scene or with the accounts given by Jessica Reed and Greg Faster. But she couldn't work out why someone would admit to something they didn't do. A few weeks after Nick Simpson's release, a package arrived at the attorney's office from the prosecution containing evidence from the case. Most of it had already been disclosed, but there was something new, a DVD with writing across the front that said, "Livers tube." Matt's lawyer had no idea what it was. She'd seen the recording of Matt's initial 11-hour interview with police, as far as she knew that had been the only one. Curious, she pressed play. Black and white footage appeared on the screen. Within seconds, the hairs on the back of her neck stood up. Matt was seated in a windowless interrogation room wearing an orange jumpsuit which indicated he must have already been in jail. Speaking to someone who was partially out of frame, Matt said, "The absolute truth is I was never on the scene. I've just been making things up to satisfy you guys." Basically, fitting in answers to what you guys have been asking. Matt's lawyer watched as her client tried to recant what he'd said about his cousin Nick Simpson. He told the interviewing officer he'd only mentioned Nick because the officers had brought him up first, saying, "I don't know if Nick is involved in this. You can check my phone records." The officer appeared unmoved, then the video cut out. Matt's lawyer froze. She'd never been told her client had recanted. She hadn't ever known there was a second interview. The footage was dated April 26, 2006, the day after Matt's confession. It was now October. All that time, her client had been sitting in a cell while no one outside the investigative team knew that he'd taken back every word he said. The truth was, from early in the investigation, Matt had known what the town rumor mill was saying. He was gutted that people thought he'd murdered his aunt and uncle. It felt like his reputation was being destroyed and that there was nothing he could do to stop it. The fact that members of his own extended family had first pointed to finger at him was especially upsetting. He'd always known they didn't like him, but he could handle that. He'd dealt with people not liking him his whole life. For it to balloon into an accusation of murder was something else entirely. He wanted nothing more than to clear his name. So, when investigators Shank showed up at Matt's house nine days after the murders on the morning of April 25 and asked him to come in for another interview, Matt readily agreed. In his mind, he'd go down to the station, clear things up, and maybe even be home in time for lunch. After he'd taken the polygraph, the officers had left him alone for a while. He was cold and he hadn't had anything to wait all morning. He kept telling himself the interview would be over soon and he'd be able to go home to his fiance Sarah and get on with his day. When the officers came back and told him he'd failed the test, Matt became scared and confused. He was unsure how things had escalated so fast and thought there must have been a mistake. He believed that if he just kept cooperating, then everything would work out. But the officers had hounded him, telling him he was a failure and listing off all of the jobs he'd lost, the things he struggled with, and the relatives who'd always hated him. Matt felt like everything he said just made them angrier. Several hours into the interrogation, he still hadn't been offered any food, and the officers had refused to give him a blanket. When he asked if he could go home, they just laughed. The officers repeatedly told Matt that the interview was his one and only chance to save himself and if he just admitted what he'd done, they could help him. Eventually he agreed to everything they said, even though there wasn't a grain of truth to it, just so they'd let him go home. Once he'd confessed, the officers were suddenly nice to him again. They praised Matt for admitting to the murders, with one of them saying, "I have the utmost respect for what you are doing right now." They offered him a mountain dew, and at 7.24pm, after being at the station for more than 10 hours, brought him his first meal of the day, a bucket of chicken wings. Though members of Matt's extended family were glad of his arrest, his parents and fiance refused to believe he was capable of such a crime and was skeptical of the confession from the start. Matt wrote letters to his fiance from jail, trying to figure out how he'd ended up there. Why would I say I did something when I never had anything to do with it? He wrote in all capitals, the only way he knew how to write. What in the world is wrong with me? I'm just not sure. I have been trying to answer this question now for a long time. Matt's lawyer sent her the DVD along with the rest of the case material to a forensic psychologist whose job was to evaluate Matt Livers and review the footage. The psychologist found that Matt had an IQ of 63, placing him in the bottom 1% of the population. Age 28, he had the vocabulary of a 13-year-old, the abstract reasoning of a 10-year-old, and the pattern recognition of a 7-year-old. Matt's verbal skills were deemed to be much stronger than his other abilities. This Matt, that in casual conversation, Matt could seem more capable than he was. But anyone who spent more than a few minutes with him would very quickly realise his limitations. Watching the footage of Matt's interrogation, the psychologist identified many moments where it should have been clear to the investigators what they were dealing with. At one point, Matt even told them explicitly, "I'm dumb as a brick." Throughout the interrogation, Matt didn't appear to have a clear understanding of his rights. Even that he hadn't been formally under arrest, he wasn't obliged to stay in the room or answer any questions. The officers had deliberately created the opposite impression, even going so far as to mock Matt when he said he wanted to leave. They had also manipulated the environment to make him uncomfortable, including setting the thermostat too low, refusing him a blanket, and failing to offer him food for more than 10 hours. They had also used coercive techniques that they should have known someone like Matt would be especially vulnerable to. This included asking him leading questions, feeding Matt details of the crime, correcting him when his answers didn't line up with the evidence, and continuing to ask the same question until they got the answer they wanted. All together, across the two interviews, Matt had insisted he was innocent 139 times. His confession, the psychologist concluded, was false and should not be relied upon in court. The information was passed on to the prosecutors, and on the morning of December 5, 2006, the judge was asked to dismiss all charges against Matt Livers. Later that day, after spending nearly eight months behind bars, Matt was released from jail and reunited with his parents and fiancee. One month later, in January 2007, Jessica Reed and Gregory Festa pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder for the killing of Wayne and Sharman Stock. For the first time, the public heard what had actually happened to the farmhouse on Easter Sunday the previous year. Two days before the murders, the pair had set out on a crime spree. High on drugs, they stole a red pickup truck from Wisconsin and drove around breaking into homes. Some time on Easter Sunday, they ended up in Murdoch, Nebraska, and chose a house that ran them to break into. It belonged to Wayne and Sharman Stock. Armed with two shotguns, Greg and Jessica broke in and heard someone snoring. They followed the sound upstairs to the main bedroom where Wayne woke up and confronted them. Greg fired, hitting Wayne in the knee. The two men fought over the gun, and Greg shouted at Jessica to do something. She fired her own gun, and moments later, Greg fired again, this time hitting Wayne in the head. During the struggle, Sharman leapt out of bed and tried to call for help, but Greg shot her in the face at close range. The pair then fled the scene. That sentencing, the judge emphasized the senseless nature of the crimes. By all accounts, the victims were wonderful people, respected by members of their community and church, and loved very much by their family, he said. They were brutally murdered in the sanctity of their own bedroom, their own home. It's hard in this case to consider anything less than life sentences. She sentenced her Gregory Festa to two consecutive life terms, with no chance of parole. When it came time for Jessica's turn, her supporters were anxious. They thought Jessica should receive a lesser sentence, not only because she was 17 at the time of the murders and had a far shorter criminal record than Greg, but because months earlier, the prosecution had come to Jessica with an offer. If she agreed to testify that Matt Livers and Nick Samson had been involved in the shootings, she'd get a reduced sentence and would avoid spending the rest of her life in jail. Jessica had refused, telling her lawyer that she would not put two innocent men in prison to save herself. On the other hand, Jessica's detractors pointed to the numerous things she had done which showed her callous enjoyment of the murders, as summed up in her diary entry. "I killed someone, I loved it, I wish I could do it all the time." In the end, it made no difference. The judge gave Jessica Reed two consecutive life terms, with no chance of parole. With that, it seemed the case was over. But one question was still unanswered. If Matt Livers and Nick Samson had nothing to do with the stock murders, then how had Wayne Stocks blood ended up in Will Samson's car? Inside the Douglas County Crime Lab, crime scene investigator Donnell Kush remained troubled by the stock investigation. It was the latest in a series of murder cases that had come through the lab that all followed the same pattern. First, an initial forensic search would find no physical evidence. Then, during a later search, a trace amount of the victim's blood would suddenly turn up inside a vehicle linked to the main suspect, solving the case. While this alone was highly unusual, what stood out most to Donnell was that the trace evidence had been found by the same person every time. Her boss, CSI director, David Kofot. For Donnell, the odds of that happening just didn't add up. She had caught Kofot lying before on some minor issues around the office, and had started to suspect he was doing something far more serious. When it happened again in the stock case, she couldn't sit on her suspicions any longer. Donnell reached out to law enforcement who agreed that something seemed off, and soon, the FBI launched an investigation. One of their first interviews was with the technician who'd been present when Kofot had searched Will Samson's car the second time and discovered Wayne's blood. The technician hadn't noticed anything strange at the time, but he pointed out that Kofot's official report said the blood had been found on May 8, when it had actually been two weeks earlier. This adjusted timeline meant that only one agency had access to Will Samson's car at the time the blood appeared, the Douglas County Crime Lab. It also meant that if the blood had been planted, only one person could have done it. The CSI director himself, David Kofot. Kofot dismissed the allegation, saying he'd found the blood using his skill and expertise, and the incorrect date had been nothing more than a simple clerical error. While he conceded it was possible that the blood could have gotten in the car by accident or cross-contamination, he was certain it hadn't been planted. The sheriff was furious that his star CSI director was being publicly criticised, but as the questions kept mounting, he had no choice but to order an internal review. A few weeks later, the review not only cleared Kofot of wrongdoing, but concluded the matter should be closed to further investigation. To the public. public, the controversy appeared to be over, but behind the scenes, it was a different story. Both state and federal prosecutors have been quietly building criminal cases against David Koford. Federal charges were filed on two counts, male fraud and falsification of records. Critics argued the charges were too light, saying they reduced Koford's conduct to little more than bad note-taking practices. The trial started in August 2009. Koford testified in his own defense, blaming the distinctive round filter papers he'd used while swabbing Will Simpson's car. He argued that the way the papers were packaged meant they could easily have been exposed to Wainstock's blood at the crime scene, resulting in an accidental transfer. The jury deliberated for just one hour before acquitting him. Six months later, he stood trial in state court on the more serious charge of evidence tampering. The state prosecutor produced evidence showing the round filter papers weren't used at the crime scene at all, meaning that accidental contamination was impossible. He then told the court about another curious case David Koford had worked on. Three years earlier, a four-year-old boy named Brendan Gonzalez had gone missing from Plattsmouth, Nebraska. Months later, Brendan's father confessed to killing the boy and disposing of his body in a dumpster. By the time the dumpster was found, Brendan's body was long gone, and the bin had spent five months exposed to rain, snow, heat, riding garbage, and repeated emptying. The conditions made it extraordinarily unlikely that even partial DNA could be recovered. Yet, David Koford had managed to find a complete and pristine sample of Brendan's blood inside the dumpster. At the time, the finding hadn't raised any red flags, but now a series of experts testified as to how statistically improbable it was. The contents of the dumpster were also retested using advanced methods, but no DNA could be found. For the prosecution, the similarities between the Gonzalez case and the stock case were simply too great to ignore. In both cases, the main suspect had confessed, but no physical evidence was found. Then Koford stepped in and miraculously uncovered the one critical piece of evidence that solved the whole case. Koford, on the other hand, said the similarities were mere coincidence. He even argued that Matt Livers and Nick Simpson had been responsible for the stock murders all along, and that they were the ones who had left Wayne's blood in the car. But the judge was not persuaded, and in March of 2010, he found David Koford guilty of tempering with evidence. Before his sentence was handed down, Matt Livers and Nick Simpson were invited to write letters to the judge. Nick wrote about the hopelessness he felt in jail, which was so intense he'd contemplated ending his life. He described the harm that Koford had caused him as almost beyond description. Matt's request was simple. All I'm asking for is some jail time, he wrote. The way he saw it, anything less would be an injustice. The judge agreed, noting the crime was especially egregious as it jeopardized public confidence in the justice system. David Koford was sentenced to a maximum of four years in prison. Because it was a class IV felony, he would never work in law enforcement again. A verdict sparked a media frenzy. Not only were people shocked that the famed CSI director had falsified evidence, but also through doubt on other investigations he'd been a part of. A number of convicted criminals launched appeals, including the father of four-year-old Brendan Gonzalez, who claimed he would not have pleaded guilty if there hadn't been DNA evidence. His appeal was unsuccessful. In 2012, the Supreme Court of Nebraska declined to authorize an independent audit of Koford's cases, citing jurisdictional issues, making it unlikely that the false scale of his transgressions will ever be known. Despite being eligible, Koford elected not to apply for early release from prison, as it required him to admit guilt and express remorse. After serving a year and a half of his sentence, he was released in May 2012. Matt Livers and Nick Samson later filed a civil suit against Koford, and were awarded a combined 6.5 million in damages. However, given his financial circumstances, the win is largely symbolic. They also brought a civil rights claim against the state of Nebraska, Cass County, Douglas County, Earl Shank, Bill Lambert, and the other individuals who had engaged in misconduct. It was settled out of court for 2.6 million. As part of the settlement, the various arms of government paid the damages, but did not have to admit any wrongdoing. While the settlement marked the end of the legal proceedings, it didn't put an end to Matt and Nick's suffering. Although Nick continued to be shunned by some in the community, he chose to stay in Cass County where he grew up to show people he wasn't afraid or ashamed. For Matt and his family, however, staying in Nebraska proved too painful. Even though Matt had been exonerated, many of his relatives still believed he was involved in the murders, and he was no longer in contact with them. Not only aware of how close he came to spending the rest of his life in jail, Matt credits an unlikely person for his freedom. Jessica Reed. He told author and a journalist to John Farrick. She basically saved my and Nick's life. If not for Jessica staying strong, who knows how things would have turned out? It's almost scary to think about. He could have been behind walls. The interrogation technique used on Matt Livers is common throughout the United States, but it originated in his hometown of Lincoln, Nebraska. In December of 1955, a man named Daryl Parker left his home in Lincoln to go to work, leaving his wife Nancy at home to address Christmas cards. When Daryl returned at lunchtime, Nancy had been strangled to death. A few days later, Daryl found himself sitting in a windowless interrogation room across from a former Chicago police officer named John Reed. Reed believed it was possible to tell if someone was guilty from their body language. Once a suspect had been identified as guilty, he developed a new interrogation technique designed to break them. First, the suspect was isolated in a small, stark interrogation room to increase their anxiety and create a desperate desire to escape. They were then bombarded with the irrefutable evidence of their guilt, which could be real or fabricated, such as fake polygraph results. Anytime the suspect denied guilt, they were aggressively shut down. Finally, the interviewer would minimize the consequences of the crime, by suggesting the suspect would be treated more leniently if they confessed. The girl was to make the suspect feel like it was futile to maintain their innocence, and that confession was the only way out. John Reed implemented this technique on Daryl Parker, and after 12 hours, Daryl confessed to murdering his wife. He recanted the following day, but the damage was already done. Despite minimal other evidence, he was sentenced to life in prison. He ended up serving more than a decade in prison while the real killer went on to commit more murders. Daryl was released on parole in 1970, but it wasn't until 2012 when he was 80 years old that the state of Nebraska formally declared him innocent. The case helped establish John Reed's reputation and the interrogation method he developed became known as the Reed technique. Despite its role in producing a false confession, the technique gained widespread popularity among law enforcement agencies, becoming one of the most widely used interrogation methods across the United States. This is despite the fact that many aspects of the technique have either never been empirically tested or have been contradicted by scientific research, such as the idea that behaviors like fidgeting indicate a person is lying. Several countries, including Australia, New Zealand, and the UK, have moved away from confrontational interrogation methods like the Reed technique, in favor of investigative interviewing techniques that focus on gathering accurate information, rather than securing confessions. The concerns are especially serious when it comes to young people and suspects with intellectual disabilities. A growing body of research shows that these populations are significantly more vulnerable to aggressive interrogation tactics, resulting in even higher rates of false confessions. In 2022, a bill was introduced in Nebraska that would have prohibited police from lying and using deceptive tactics when questioning juveniles, but it failed. A number of other states have also tried and failed to pass similar bills, often facing opposition from law enforcement representatives. Despite decades of criticism and growing concerns about false confessions, the read technique continues to be taught and used by law enforcement agencies throughout the United States in 2026. In the years since ceased a Sunday of 2006, public interest in the stock murder case has shifted toward the false confession, the planted evidence, and the many failures of the investigation. In the process, Wayne and Shaman stock have often been reduced to a footnote in their own story. Their daughter spoke of this utter delay of grief in an interview with Dateline, saying, "I think what hurts the most for me is they are known as the couple that were murdered in their bedroom, not who they actually are." Speaking to the same program, their eldest son said he still thinks about how differently that night could have ended. If Jessica and Gregory just knocked on the door and asked for help, my parents would have given it to them. They would have woken up, they would have got dressed. They would have done whatever they had to do to help them and to get them on their way. [Music]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The 2006 double homicide of Wayne and Charmin Stock in Nebraska was initially suspected to be a financial crime, with the nephew Matthew Livers being a primary suspect due to family tensions.
  2. Evidence at the scene, including a clean patch on a wall and a bloodstain on a steering column, suggested multiple perpetrators and a deliberate, violent attack rather than a burglary.
  3. Matthew Livers confessed to the killings but his account contained contradictions, and no physical evidence linked him to the crime scene.
  4. A gold ring engraved with "Love Always, Cory and Ryan" was found at the scene, leading investigators to trace it to a couple in Wisconsin, eventually implicating 17-year-old Jessica Reed and 19-year-old Gregory Fester.
  5. Jessica admitted to being present during the murders and to helping Greg shoot the victims, while Greg initially claimed others were involved, but his story was contradicted by DNA and witness accounts.
  6. A second confession from Ryan Porting, Matt’s friend with intellectual disabilities, linked him to Wisconsin, though he had no direct involvement.
  7. A hidden second interview revealed Matt had recanted his confession, indicating coercion and manipulation during interrogation, leading experts to conclude the confession was false.
  8. Ultimately, the real perpetrators were Jessica and Gregory Fester, who committed the murders during a drug-fueled crime spree, and the case was closed with life sentences; Matt and Nick were acquitted due to lack of evidence and procedural flaws.

Summary:

In 2006, a double homicide occurred at the home of Wayne and Charmin Stock in Murdoch, Nebraska, during an Easter morning. The crime scene revealed signs of multiple intruders, with blood and a clean patch suggesting a deliberate attack. Initial suspicion fell on Matthew Livers, the couple’s nephew, due to past family disputes and financial tensions.

Despite a confession from Livers, inconsistencies in his account and lack of physical evidence raised doubts. Further investigation uncovered a gold ring linked to a couple in Wisconsin, leading to the arrest of 17-year-old Jessica Reed and 19-year-old Gregory Fester. They admitted to breaking into the home while high on drugs, shooting both victims during a confrontation.

DNA evidence and Jessica’s diary confirmed their involvement. Though Matthew Livers confessed, a hidden second interview revealed he had recanted, and forensic analysis showed he was mentally impaired and coerced during interrogation. His confession was deemed unreliable.

A psychological evaluation concluded the confession was false due to interrogation tactics and his intellectual disability. Jessica and Greg were sentenced to consecutive life terms. Meanwhile, Matthew and Nick Samson were released due to insufficient evidence and lack of physical ties.

The case highlighted flaws in investigative practices, including tunnel vision, coercive interrogation, and failure to consider alternative suspects. The true perpetrators were identified through circumstantial and forensic evidence, not confession alone. The case remains a cautionary tale about the dangers of overreliance on confessions and the importance of proper forensic and psychological evaluation.

FAQs

Wayne and Charmin Stock, a married couple who lived in the village of Murdoch and were well-known and well-liked in their community.

The couple was murdered in their home during the early hours of Easter Monday. The victims were found shot in their bedroom, with the killer or killers having broken in through the laundry window and used at least two shotguns.

The main suspects were Matthew Livers, Nick Sampson, and Will Simpson, all of whom had connections to the Stock family or were linked to the crime scene through various claims and alibis.

The case was ultimately solved through the discovery of a gold ring with the names 'Cory and Ryan' engraved on it, which led to the identification of Jessica Reed and Gregory Fester as the actual perpetrators who committed the murders.

No direct physical evidence tied Matthew Livers to the crime scene, and the blood found in Will Simpson's car was later confirmed to be from Wayne Stock, but not linked to Matt through a DNA match.

Yes, Matthew Livers confessed during a lengthy interrogation, but later evidence and a second interview revealed that his confession was false and made under intense psychological pressure.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.