Go back

Can small farms feed the world?

from The Food Chain

31m 59s

Can small farms feed the world?

The BBC podcast "Food Chain" explores the complex relationship between farm size, sustainability, and food security. It highlights how small, organic family farms—like those in England and Argentina—produce diverse, environmentally friendly food using natural methods, with strong community ties and improved animal health. However, these farms struggle economically due to low margins and limited market access, making sustainable farming difficult to scale. In contrast, large farms use efficiency and technology to produce year-round crops, but at higher environmental and financial costs, including reliance on pesticides and fertilizers. The podcast argues that while full conversion to organic farming may be challenging due to production constraints, it is feasible with systemic support. Experts emphasize that a shift toward more plant-based, local, and diverse diets—alongside investment in small farms—is crucial to feeding a growing population without harming the planet. Agricultural sustainability depends not on farm size alone, but on equitable support, better policies, and a reevaluation of consumer habits. The evidence shows that small farms, especially in developing regions, are vital to global food security and biodiversity, and that their success requires targeted investment in infrastructure, education, and fair market access. Ultimately, a balanced, inclusive farming system—combining efficiency with ecological responsibility—offers the best path forward for both people and the planet.

Transcription

4576 Words, 26010 Characters

English
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. At Whole Foods Market, chef inspired flavors meet industry leading quality standards, especially for Thanksgiving. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever. So their fresh turkeys and spiral cut hams bring rich satisfying flavors. You can taste in each bite, no compromises, just quality and peace of mind. You can share with every guest at your table, celebrate the season with a holiday spread from Whole Foods Market. Welcome to the Haunted Library. Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, a story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human. Listen to the Haunted Library, wherever you get your podcasts, or find us on YouTube. At normal transactions, some kind of cyber attack on a bank of millions of dollars. Something I don't think anybody has seen before. The cyber criminal group from the BBC World Service. The Lazarus Ice is back for season two. It was really like in the movies. Find out more at the end of this podcast. Hello, and welcome to the Food Chain from the BBC World Service. I'm Grace Limstone, and I've been visiting small farms. This is Pat, Pat, and Big Farms. So it's picking up about chin-tunnel sugar meat in the basket hopper at any one time. And asking, "What's the greenest way to produce affordable food?" Small organic farms might be good for the environment, but could they ever produce enough food for a growing population? A Big Farms more efficient. Should we try to scale up organic farming? Or is small farms better for nature and rural communities? You invest more of yourself, I think, into farming than lots of other professions. You don't shut the door and drive home from the office at five o'clock on a Friday. I've spoken to farmers across England, and also to smallholders in Argentina. I want to know if small farms could feed the world without costing the earth. Rob Walton is feeding his pigs in a muddy field on his farm in Somerset in the south-west of England. This is a couple of saddleback sows. Saddleback sows? Are they the parents then? They're the mums, yeah, and then there's a land-raised poor. Oh, is the paella colour that one, is it pale brown? As well as pigs, Rob keeps cattle, chickens and sheep. Shall I shut the gate? The farm has been in his family for generations. But 20 years ago, he decided to switch to organic farming, which doesn't use artificial fertilizers or pesticides. I was getting incredibly frustrated about having to keep lots and lots of animals on the farm just to make an income that was putting too much pressure on the land and on the animals and on ourselves. And organic farming seemed to me to be working more in partnership with nature, partnership with creation and the environment than conventional farming was. So switching to organic does that mean that you have fewer animals per area of land? Yes, but we found in doing so, in reducing the number of animals. There was less disease, the animals were healthier and did better off the ground than they had before. But can you make a living having fewer animals? Well, the answer for us was to sell those animals direct, so that's why we direct to the public. Direct to the public, so that's why we started the farm shop. So this is more like a disease. Hello, hello, hello, hello, hello, hello, hello, hello, hello, hello. Rob's wife Lizzy runs the farm shop where they sell meat and all sorts of vegetables, which they also grow on the farm. Oh, and you know, there's baskets of what we got. Garlic. Yeah, and then all the tails that you saw grow. Cale. Leafy green kale. Oh, yeah. Are you a customer? I am a customer. Do you come and shop here often? Yes. And why do you come here? Because I like to know where my food comes from. And it's all good. Having this shop and a cafe has enabled the farm to survive. We're here. We directly have relationships with our customers, which is brilliant. If we were still selling to a supermarket through a abattoir or something, it would be a nightmare. We just couldn't do it. The price would be so low, we couldn't produce the food for that price. Each year Rob moves the chickens, pigs and other animals to fresh fields. The animals manure fertilises the ground for crops, rotating crops in animals, as well as growing a variety of nutrient-rich plants, means that Rob no longer needs artificial nitrogen fertilizer, which when used to excess can acidify soil, pollute rivers and contribute to greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. The aim of organic farming is to help the environment. But does Rob think having a smaller sized farm is better for nature too? Probably. I think these smaller family farms would generally have more smaller fields that would be great biodiversity on these farms. So ultimately, I think if we're looking at the whole picture, they're more invested in their environment, I think. But small farms are facing very tough times. Since 2005 in England, more than 25,000 small and medium-sized farms, those covering less than one square kilometre, have gone out of business. These smaller sized farms now account for just one quarter of all agricultural land in England. It just looks so idyllic. We're standing in the Somerset countryside, these small fields, these rolling hills, the pink sunset in the distance. But do you think we could really produce enough food with small organic farms like this? Yes, we could. It's down to the fact that we'd have to pay a little bit more for it. We can't produce food as cheaply in this way. But the overall benefits to the environment, to the climate, to local communities are that much higher. So it's taking everything into consideration. It shouldn't be just down to the minimum cost of food. We shouldn't just bring it down to that all the time. But in England, fewer than 3% of farms are organic, and across the world, the proportion is even lower, just 1.5%. So what's preventing more farmers from switching to organic? Next stop is a small dairy farm in Derbyshire, in the English Midlands. I'm Tracy Langton and I was born on this farm, so I've been here since 1971, and I'm a third generation farmer here. Obviously Jesse's the fourth generation taking it over. We are predominantly dairy. Oh, we've got a little bit of beef. We've got about a hundred head of cattle in total. What do you do with the milk? The milk sold to first milk, and that goes to make cheese. Oh, and what's first milk? Milk processor. A milk processor, yeah. And you're doing lots of things for the environment on this farm, but you're not an organic farm. What's the difference and what's stopped you becoming an organic farm? I think it's how we can access the market really. I think if we could sell direct to the public, it'd probably be better to go organic, but because of where we're located, it doesn't really lend itself to that. So we're still putting on nitrogen at the minute, but that's something we're going to do less and less off because we're planting more clover, more herbal lays that don't need it, and we're going to use more slurry. Last year, encouraged by a British government scheme, Tracey and Jess planted two herbal lays. These are fields sewn with a mixture of grasses, herbs and legumes that nourish the soil, a more drought-resistant and attract insects. Herbal lays can be used to graze cows or to make hay. Couldn't the whole farm be planted with herbs for them to eat? Yeah, yeah, absolutely, in court I say we're just, it's a completely sort of new thing because we're supposed to be being more sustainable, and that's sort of why we're doing it, but we're just very steadily dipping our toe in. It grows at a less rapid rate because you're not putting the fertiliser on it, therefore we just want to be careful that we're not going to not get the volume to feed the cows. But I mean, you were saying that the margins for a small farmer are really tight, so I suppose that's why you need to be quite careful about completely switching your methods in case. Exactly, yeah, you don't want to put all your eggs in one basket, and when you've only got 75 hectares to play with, you know, you're not like one of the farms that have got thousands of hectares, so we've just got to be very, very careful how we do it because we don't want to make a mistake and then run out of food. Should I shut this gate? Tracey's daughter Jess shows me round the farm. It's almost bending on the herbal, it looks like a normal grassy field, really doesn't it? Yeah, there's just different species, but you can sort of see the different like long grasses. They're just starting to come through like bits of chickery, you still got your sort of rye grasses in there, but your flavours and stuff will really come through in the spring. How will you test whether it's been successful? Well, we're just going to see if it performs as well as our rye grass mixes, see how the cows milk if they milk as well off of it. We go to see the cows gathered around metal feeders in their barnyard. Now these are the milking cows, you've got Charlie and Evie there. Jess has a degree in animal science and is helping the family introduce new techniques like genomic testing to select the best cows to breed, but despite innovations like this, margins are still very tight. I ask her if the price of milk covers the cost of producing it. No, sadly not at the moment, the margins in milk are very very small. We do everything we can to meet every standard blown atlas just to provide the British consumers with the highest welfare, highest quality milk and dairy products we can do, and it would be nice to see that reflected in the costs on the supermarket shelves that consumers are paying. Under tremendous pressure to keep costs down, a small farmer thinking of going organic has to weigh up where their farm is located, how any change would affect their yields. So to supply the tons of food we eat, do we need big intensive farms? If you look through there, there's a carrot just starting to grow. Andrew Blenkeron is the manager of the Houston Estate, which sprawls over 40 square kilometres of the Suffolk countryside in the east of England. The main farm on the estate is an enormous 20 square kilometres. As we stand in a field with rows of plastic sheets glinting in the wintery sun, cars drive past on the busy country road behind us. There's holes in the plastic to allow the moisture to get in and these are protected from the worst of the frost and it'll get them to reach the market a month to six weeks ahead of anything else. So what it'll do is give continuity of supply of UK produced carrots all year round. And do the carrots do you have to put a bit of fertiliser and herbicide on or? Not so much when they're under place, it has had a herbicide put on already otherwise there'd be a mass of weeds that would have grown underneath that in that incredibly warm environment, there'd be a mass of weed. So you couldn't grow carrots all year round without using herbicides? You can grow carrots all year round without using herbicides but you have to hand weed them and we struggle to get people to hand weed them and the moment you put a person in the area, it's £10 an hour. So you'd probably what you would do is get a gang of 10 people, you'd probably have them in two days, so what's that? It's probably about 200 hours, you know, so that adds significantly to the cost of production. The Euston Estate Farm grows 8,000 tons of carrots, 25,000 tons of potatoes, 20,000 tons of onions, as well as tons of sugar beet, barley and wheat for bread. If all this was grown organically, we'd see a big jumping prices on the supermarket shelf. So what's this? It looked like, um, this had this had sort of façille, there was façille, there was a bit of quinoa, but this big farm does several things to help the environment. It rotates the crops and grows green manures, plants which nourish the soil naturally. It started to make its own organic fertiliser from maize, and in the corner of fields, it sows critiquely and quinoa for birds to eat. It's also planted lots more hedgerows and trees. There's a load of haze or coppice, a nice big oak in the middle of this. But farmers have to balance the benefits of giving more space to wildlife with the impact on production. So basically, if you have a bigger field, it's much easier to use machinery like tractors and combine harvesters. Yeah, yeah. Much more efficient, a lot less downtime. So downtime is when the machine is not operating, when you turn it around, ready to go back the other way down the field, and that has significant impact in you, you work rate and what you can achieve in one any one day. Looking at this farm with its fields dotted with patches of woodland, I've learned that big farms don't have to be vast bleak monocultures. But our large farms more efficient. A study by the British government found that among the best performing farms in England, big and small farms actually had very similar productivity rates. This shows that small farms can be very efficient and potentially could supply more of Britain's food. However, the study also showed that many small farms are not making a profit and are struggling to survive. So what about scaling up organic methods? Back in the used in the state office, I asked Andrew if he thinks we could produce enough food if all farms were organic. Personally, I think it's unrealistic. The output per unit of area is unrealistic based around our present levels of consumption. Using organic as an example, it's potentially a niche market that's been satisfied. The amount of food that you produce is considerably less than in a conventional, arable system. There are some really good examples of people adopting what we call integrated farm management. So that's about working with nature, so reducing our dependence on artificial inputs. It's about trying to find that right balance. Artificial nitrogen fertilizer has enabled the world to vastly increase food production over the past 70 years. And Britain's National Farmers Union told me that in the post-war decades, European governments, including Britain, encouraged farmers to remove hedgerows, believing that bigger fields would increase food output. But Andrew says that many farmers in Britain are now replanting hedges and understand the environmental risks of using too much man-made fertilizer. Again, I think the appreciation that artificial resources have been over-utilised. And we have to remember that farmers have only done what's been asked of them and been rewarded. So I think utilising science, utilising some of historic techniques, there's a massive move towards building soil fertility, building soil organic matters because the realisation that we've potentially had gone too far. But Andrew says farmers still need artificial pesticides and fertilisers. We don't just use fertilisers just for the funerary. We use it because it enables us to stay competitive in the marketplace. We can continue to produce food at the price point at which consumers want to pay. There's lots of work that says between 80 and 90% of the people in this country buy on price. It would be absolutely fantastic if we could say to the consumer, "I'm afraid you need to pay more for this product because we use less artificial fertilising." And it's not just about maximising production, it's about ensuring that the quality of the crop is right because that's another one of the key issues is that we've probably waste 40% of the food that we're producing in this country because one of the things is it's not just quite up to the speck of the retailers. So you start talking about the wonky veg and that's sort of thing. And I've seen it myself, people go to the supermarket shelves and they buy the what looks the most pristine example of that particular product on the shelf. A potato with a minor blemish in it, most people leave to the side. I've travelled across England and farmers all think we should buy local, eat seasonally and waste less food. Above all they say they're under tremendous pressure to keep costs down and that food prices barely cover the cost of production. Joe Lewis is a policy director of the Soil Association, a charity campaigning for nature-friendly farming. I asked her whether it was really feasible to feed the country using organic methods. Well the most robust modelling to date has shown that you absolutely could transform all of the UK and Europe's farms to organic farming and still feed a growing population a healthy diet, a ants bear land for nature and for trees. But what you can't do is to continue to support unhealthy diets that are heavily reliant on industrial livestock farming. The challenge we have is that half of our crop land is producing grain for intensive poultry, pig farming, dairy farming and more again of our land is diverted into producing biofuels. So what we're calling for is a level of ambition for growing organic in line with Europe's commitment to 25% of farmland being organic and then alongside that that wider mainstream transition, harving nitrogen use and pesticide use. You said we need to change our diets in what way? The mantra really is less and better meat and more and better plants and we also have to wean ourselves as a nation of our addiction to ultra processed food which makes up well over half of our diet in the UK that's far higher than any other country in Europe and we're We're getting our heads around. i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w i'w o'n ffordd y ffordd y ffordd y ffordd y ffordd y ffordd y i'n gweithio'r cyfle i'n gweithio'r cyfle i'n gweithio'r cyfle i'n gweithio'r cyfle i'n gweithio'r cyfle i'n gweithio'r cyfle. But would food be much more expensive? How could people on low incomes afford organic meat or vegetables? How would organic or what they call agroecological farming without significantly increasing food prices in general except in meat and dairy where we would, as I said, need to eat less to make it affordable to eat better and phase out unsustainable industrial livestock. I would say, though, when it comes to families that are struggling with poverty, we've got to stop pretending that cheap ultra processed food is some kind of answer. I think what we've learnt is we need to tackle poverty head on and we need to have targeted measures that make nutritious food available and affordable like extending free school meals, for instance, fruit and veg vouchers. But we can't hold down or use poverty as an excuse to hold down food standards when that pushes so many costs onto our health system, onto our water quality and onto the climate. Switching to organic farming sounds like a huge shift in our diets and shopping habits is the idea that people buy from local farmers. How would that work in cities, for example? It is about rebalancing rather than going 100% local, of course, but there is actually a huge opportunity for a new wave of what we like to call market garden cities can take local food supply chains much more seriously and use the green belts to feed our urban populations. Government can really lead the way with looking for more local sourcing for public settings like schools and hospitals. Joe Lewis raised the question of meat production. So here are the figures. Two-thirds of the world's farmland is devoted to grazing livestock and of the remaining third, 33% of this is used to grow animal feed according to the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization. If we look at the global picture, family farms produce a whopping 80% of the world's food according to the United Nations. The very smallest farms, those of less than two hectares, produce about a third of the world's food, but only take up 12% of the world's farmland. Meanwhile, just 1% of the world's largest farms control 70% of agricultural land. Latin America has the most unequal distribution of land in the world and small farmers can find it hard to compete with big land owners or large companies. I spoke to Marys Lukin, who has a small holding in the province of Corientes in Argentina. She belongs to an association of women farmers called Bucharest de la Tierra, Women of the Land. I have 26 hectares, which I cultivate with my children. I have four sons and two work with me on the land. We cultivate maize, pumpkin, potatoes, cassava, and peanuts. We have chickens, turkeys, docks, sheep, and pigs, and also cattle for our own consumption, and sometimes we supply local shops. My typical day starts at 6 a.m., with feeding the animals on the farm. We give the animals water and food as early as possible in the morning, because here in Corientes it is very, very hot. It's difficult to survive because our output is small compared to the big producers. They have enormous extensions of land and produce large quantities. They don't have our difficulties. We produce small quantities, but with a lot of variety. We use organic fertilizers made from leaves or manure from our own animals. Principally, what's needed in this region is money for the small farmers to survive. We need grants to obtain tools and inputs, because without inputs, like irrigation, and help to drill wells, a farmer can't produce. Luis Beduski is a senior policy officer for the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization in Latin America. He says family farms are crucial for global food security. These farms play a fundamental role in combating hunger above all. They provide food and they help to stimulate the economy of rural areas. They have a great potential for sustainably managing resources and making traditional knowledge available to society. Very often rural communities and indigenous peoples know certain plants and forms of cultivation and can help us find new varieties, new plants. Family agriculture shows more diversity in its crops. These farmers combine species, varieties, and this increases its resilience. Luis Beduski says family farms are not defined by their size, but how they're organized. They produce food for their own consumption, as well as for sale. They can be very small, one or two hectares in the dry corridor of Central America, or considerably larger in the southern comb. In general, they are much smaller than, for example, the big soya or sugar plantations. I ask Luis Beduski if smaller or bigger farms are better for the environment. In any living system, if there is more diversity, there is more capacity for adaptation and resilience. If I see a landscape that has miles and miles of the same crop, fields and fields of soya, fields and fields of maize, fields and fields of sugar cane, clearly this diminishes the biodiversity. But small farms are not automatically better for nature. They have a great capacity to adopt practices that are more compatible with caring for the environment. But only if there is support for that. There are also big farms transitioning to organic or agaricological models, so there is great potential, but one size is not better than the other. They are going to work out their own transitions towards more sustainable, inclusive, resilient and efficient models. Luis Beduski says family farms could easily supply more of our food. Of all the agricultural land in Latin America, family farms make up about 75% of all farms, but have access to just 20% of this land area. With very little, they produce a lot. Imagine if they had more funds, services and other productive resources. With a bit of help, he says family farms could rapidly increase their output. I'm thinking about the small producers in the dry corridor of Central America. With investment in micro irrigation, farmers can do marvelous things. Imagine if you give a family assistant that captures rainwater. It's very cheap, but capturing this water means the women, and it's usually women and children, don't have to walk an hour and a half to collect water. So small investments, a bit of innovation, small pieces of equipment, means a saving of time and an increase in the productivity of their work, land and water. I think this should be part of the political debate, because in the end that's what it's about. As a government, where do I place my scarce resources? We can be sure that investing in family farms is a good investment. It has a payoff, it pays well for society, and there is evidence internationally that allows us to say this with confidence. Luis Bedewski in Chile, my thanks to him, to Madis Lucas in Argentina, and to Rob and Lizzie Waldron, Tracy and Jess Langton, Andrew Blenkeron and Joe Lewis in England. It's possible for farms of all sizes to produce food in a nature-friendly way, but supporting smaller family farms might just be an answer to feeding the world without costing the earth. You've been listening to the Food Chain from the BBC World Service. It was produced and presented by me Grace Livingstone. Where does North Korea get the cash to fund its nuclear weapons programme? North Korea is nothing if it is not creative, clever, agile. Well, according to US investigators, cybercrime. A cyber tech was on no one's radar. The attacker had very good knowledge of banking systems. Although the regime denies any involvement, evidence suggests that North Korea's hackers are getting better and better at doing it. What they did was also quite sophisticated, not something anybody has seen before. The Lazarus Highs, season two, from the BBC World Service. There was put in handcuffs, both my feet bound and my hands, taken to an interrogation centre. We were genuinely very frightened. Search for the Lazarus Highs, wherever you get your BBC podcasts. Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human. Listen to the Haunted Library, wherever you get your podcasts, or find us on YouTube.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Organic farming, as practiced by small family farms, prioritizes environmental health, animal welfare, and soil fertility over mass production.
  2. Small farms like Rob’s in Somerset and Tracy’s in Derbyshire show that organic methods can improve biodiversity and reduce reliance on artificial fertilizers and pesticides.
  3. Despite environmental benefits, small farms face financial pressure, with narrow margins and difficulty competing with large-scale, low-cost conventional farming.
  4. Large farms in England, such as the Houston Estate, use advanced techniques to ensure year-round crop production, but at higher costs due to herbicide and labor use.
  5. A global shift toward organic and agroecological farming is feasible in theory, but requires systemic changes in diets, consumer behavior, and food pricing.
  6. Small family farms, especially in regions like Argentina, produce a significant share of the world’s food with high crop diversity and resilience, yet lack access to capital and infrastructure.
  7. Sustainable farming depends not just on farm size, but on support systems—such as grants, irrigation, and local markets—that enable small farmers to thrive.
  8. The future of food security lies in a balanced system that integrates small and large farms, promotes local sourcing, and reimagines diets to reduce meat consumption and processed foods.

Summary:

The BBC podcast "Food Chain" explores the complex relationship between farm size, sustainability, and food security. It highlights how small, organic family farms—like those in England and Argentina—produce diverse, environmentally friendly food using natural methods, with strong community ties and improved animal health. However, these farms struggle economically due to low margins and limited market access, making sustainable farming difficult to scale.

In contrast, large farms use efficiency and technology to produce year-round crops, but at higher environmental and financial costs, including reliance on pesticides and fertilizers. The podcast argues that while full conversion to organic farming may be challenging due to production constraints, it is feasible with systemic support. Experts emphasize that a shift toward more plant-based, local, and diverse diets—alongside investment in small farms—is crucial to feeding a growing population without harming the planet.

Agricultural sustainability depends not on farm size alone, but on equitable support, better policies, and a reevaluation of consumer habits. The evidence shows that small farms, especially in developing regions, are vital to global food security and biodiversity, and that their success requires targeted investment in infrastructure, education, and fair market access. Ultimately, a balanced, inclusive farming system—combining efficiency with ecological responsibility—offers the best path forward for both people and the planet.

FAQs

Yes, small organic farms can feed the world, especially when combined with sustainable practices. Models show that transforming UK and European farms to organic methods could still meet dietary needs while protecting the environment.

Farmers switch to organic farming because it works in harmony with nature, improves animal health, reduces pollution, and supports long-term environmental and community sustainability.

Big farms are more efficient in terms of machinery use and output per unit area, but a government study shows that top-performing small farms have similar productivity levels to large ones.

Organic farms reduce reliance on artificial fertilizers and pesticides, promote biodiversity, improve soil health, and help combat climate change through sustainable land use.

Organic food could be more expensive, but experts suggest that reducing meat consumption and shifting to more plant-based diets could make it more affordable and sustainable for everyone.

Yes, small family farms, especially in regions like Latin America, produce a significant portion of the world's food using diverse, traditional methods and are vital for food security and rural economies.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.