Go back

Busting 50 Legal Myths People Still Believe

16m 55s

Busting 50 Legal Myths People Still Believe

This transcript debunks common legal myths surrounding police interactions, school policies, and personal freedoms. It clarifies that police can lie during interrogations, and requesting a lawyer does not imply guilt—people remain free to leave an interrogation room. Traffic tickets are not admissions of guilt and can be dismissed if errors exist, such as wrong data or unattended court appearances. Drivers must show ID when stopped while driving, but not when walking without suspicion. In some states, turning around at a DUI checkpoint or flashing headlights to warn others is legal, especially under First Amendment protections. Rescuing animals in emergencies, like breaking a car window to save a dog, is permitted under good Samaritan laws. Schools cannot randomly search students or block exits without cause, and online posting can lead to school discipline if it causes disruption. Additionally, burial in one’s backyard or squatting are legally possible under strict conditions. The video emphasizes that many widely believed rules—like needing a warrant for searches or being legally required to report crimes—are inaccurate. It also highlights that citizens can only make arrests under specific, limited circumstances and that actions like dumpster diving or finding money are not automatically legal, with responsibilities to return lost items or report them. The core message is that legal knowledge empowers individuals to act confidently and safely in everyday situations.

Transcription

3332 Words, 18786 Characters

English
Today, I'm busting the craziest legal myth. Right, smashing a car window to save a dog, escaping prison and not being charged for it, and legally burying someone in your own backyard. But before we get to the weirdest laws of all, we're starting with the most common myths right here at the police station. Just tell us it was you. We found your fingerprints are just seen. One of the most common legal myths people believe is that police can't lie, but they can and they do. Everybody in the other room already copped. Police are trained to lie during interrogations to get you talking. They'll say your friend confess, they have your fingerprints, or things will go easier if you just talk. Myth number two, asking for a lawyer makes you a guilty. It doesn't. Talking with that one? That's what actually gets people in trouble. Unless I'm under arrest, I'd like to leave, or I want to lawyer. All right. Say what you want. Nobody in the room. Even if the police leave the room, always remember, the recording never stops. They're also not required to tell you you're being recorded. Myth six, if you're in an interrogation room, you have to stay. Unless you're arrested or detained, you're free to leave. Just ask. Am I free to go? If they say yes, get up and walk out. But there are way more legal myths I have to show you, like whether you can legally turn around at a DUI checkpoint. If you're allowed to smash a car window to save a dog and whether flipping off a cop can get you arrested. A lot of people believe that if you're given a speeding ticket, you have to pay it no matter what. But if the police officer makes a serious mistake on it, like the wrong date, plate number, or location, or the officer doesn't show up in court, you can sometimes get the ticket dismissed. Next is where people really mess up. They believe that signing a ticket is an admission of guilt. But really, it just means you agree to show up in court. In some states, refusing to sign a ticket could get you arrested. Can I see your license registration? This is another big myth. A lot of people believe that when a police officer asks for your ID, you don't have to show it. But that's only true in certain situations. Give me your ID. Come on. If you're walking, and the officer doesn't have reasonable suspicion, you've committed a crime, then you usually do not have to show ID. But if you're driving your car and get pulled over, every state requires you to show your license. What's in the trunk? Yes, it's your car. Police generally can't search your car without your permission, a warrant, or probable cost, like smelling alcohol. I don't consent to a search of my car. All right, he got me. Here you go. Have a nice day. Oh, there's a DUI checkpoint up ahead. It's a place where police officers check to see if drivers are under the influence. I've seen people argue that police have the posting. The exact location of DUI checkpoints online. That's not always true. In states like California, they're supposed to give advanced notice about checkpoints, but it's not required. And in states like Iowa, DUI checkpoints are banned entirely. What most people don't realize? You can legally turn around before a checkpoint, as long as you follow traffic laws. One of the most common myths that I see online is that it's illegal to flash our headlights to warn other drivers about the police. But it's often legal. Courts treat it as protected speech under the First Amendment. But certain states have restrictions on when and how you can flash your headlights. So check your local laws. But one of the wildest things people don't realize is that in a real emergency, a police officer can legally take your car. OK. It's rare, but if they're chasing a possible suspect or an emergency, there's no law stopping them. Next, most people know you legally have to stop at a stop sign. But what about if the stop sign is on private property? Well, unlike public stop signs, there usually isn't a law that forces you to stop. Though not stopping could lead to a crash, which means you could be sued. Another myth, that flipping off a cop will get you arrested. It's actually protected under the First Amendment. But just because it's legal doesn't mean it's a good idea. And it can lead to a lot more trouble. If you're rescuing a dog trapped in a hot car, in some states you can break the window. It's called a Good Samaritan or a hot car rescue law. But you should always check your state laws, confirm the doors are locked, call emergency services, and make sure the animals in real danger. He's in real danger. We save them. Nice job. But now I'm going to show you what your school can and can legally do. Hey, you. Right now, give me that bag. Wait, no, don't you need a warrant for that? Hold on. Huh? Most teachers think they can just search your bag, but the truth is they can't. Teachers need reasonable suspicion you're breaking a law or school rule. I'm going through your bag. No, no. They can't just demand to look through your stuff. Well, I'm fine, but you're staying after class. Mike, is that even legal? Teachers can't physically block students from leaving except in rare emergency situations. That could be false imprisonment. Fine. But you should know if you do leave, you could get worse punishments, like suspension. All right, thanks, Mike. I tried. A lot of people don't realize that schools can punish you for stuff you post online, even if it's posted outside of school. But only if it causes a big disruption at school or targets a student or teacher. That's why you should always think twice before posting online. Oh, and while schools can't randomly drug test the entire student body, they can randomly drug test you if you participate in school-sponsored extracurricular activities, like chess club debate or sports. And while we're on the topic of schools, most people assume spanking is outlawed. But some states still allow it. I know it's weird. This next set of laws, they control what you can do in and around your own home. Whoa, this house has booby traps. Building traps that could hurt someone is illegal. Even if the intention is to prevent break-ins, the law doesn't allow traps that could hurt someone just to defend property. What's even crazier is that if someone trespasses on private property and gets injured, like falling into an uncovered hold that the owner knew about, the trespasser can sue the owner. Most people think they're informed, but what they're really seeing is outrage, fear, and whatever gets clicks, which brings me here to the sidewalk. Most people assume the sidewalk in front of their house belongs to them, but in most places, it's actually public property and owned by the city. However, even though you don't own the sidewalk, local laws may still make you responsible for keeping it safe, like shoveling snow and clearing ice. Next, some areas require a permit for garage sales, because doing too many can make it look like you're running an unlicensed business. In some places, kids need a permit to sell things, like lemonade, cookies, or crafts. Some cities have become more relaxed about this, but in others, those stands can still get shut down. Oh, man. But don't worry, I already got you a permit. Yay! Now let's go inside. A lot of people think they're landlords always need permission to enter their home, but in an emergency, like a fire or a flood, the landlord can legally come in, even without asking. Next is one of my favorites. Police can legally enter your home without a warrant if they're chasing a suspect. It's called hot pursuit. And if they see anything illegal while they're inside, they can arrest you for it, even though you had nothing to do with the chase. I've been seeing a lot of YouTubers building secret gaming rooms or hideouts in their homes. And underneath those videos, there are always comments saying it's illegal or you need a permit. But in most states, there's no law against making a secret room. As long as you're not making big structural changes, if you're just turning an existing space into a hidden room and putting a bookshelf over the door, that's usually legal. Now let's go to the backyard. One of the weirdest legal myths is that you can't bury a loved one in your own backyard. But in some states, it's allowed. As long as you follow zoning laws, file the right paperwork and meet local health codes. It's hard work. Just don't do it without telling your neighbors unless you want rumors starting. And while we're in the backyard, another legal myth that you can burn your trash whenever you want. Not true. Most cities ban open burning unless you have a permit. But there's one more housing law I have to talk about. And it's one of the most viral myths out there. It's called squatting. It's when someone enters and stays in a home without permission. A lot of people think the law protects squatters immediately, but it doesn't. To actually take over a property, squatters need to qualify under something called adverse possession. Can you keep it down? And to do that, they usually have to meet a strict list of legal requirements. Now I'm going to show you the 14 weirdest legal myths of all. First up, the citizens arrest. A lot of people think they can say, I'm arresting you anytime someone does something wrong. But most states have strict rules. You usually have to witness a serious crime and use reasonable force. If you mess it up, you could get charged with assault, false imprisonment, or both. Did you know escaping prison isn't illegal in some countries? Places like Germany and Mexico see the urge for freedom as part of human nature. So the act of escaping prison isn't a crime. But if you assault a guard or steal a car on the way out, that's very illegal. And those acts can get you extra charges. One of the craziest myths is that people believe you only get one phone call when you get arrested. Most states allow a reasonable number of calls, which means multiple. Some jails will even let you use your own phone. One of the weirdest myths that keeps getting reposted is that you have to be in a car to use a fast food drive-through. But that's not actually a lot. You can walk through. What most people don't realize is that businesses have the right to refuse service. So if you try, they can still turn you away. What's even weirder is that in over 20 US states, you can legally take home and eat roadkill. Some even let you claim it through an app. Montana, Alaska, and West Virginia are especially chill about it, as long as you don't cause the accident yourself. Myth 42, you can't legally own a tank. Well, if it's demilitarized, it's legal. If the cannon works, you need to get an ATF permit. Owning a tank is expensive, but not illegal. Oh, and you don't legally have to report a crime just because you saw it. There's no general legal duty to call the police just because you witnessed a crime. A few states require it, but only for serious felonies. And even then, it's rarely enforced. But if you hide its aspect, destroy evidence, or help someone escape, that's it. accessory after the fact, which is a crime. Many think surgeons must sleep a certain amount of hours before they operate. Surprisingly, this is false. There's actually no law that forces them to rest. Hospitals might have rules or shift limits, but legally, a surgeon can operate with zero sleep. If they mess up, it's usually a lawsuit, not a crime. You'll be surprised to learn that dumpster diving is technically legal. Once trash hits the curb, it's considered abandoned. No privacy rights. But if you step on the private property to get it or your city bands it outright, you could still get fined or arrested. Myth number 47, it's illegal to marry your step sibling. Actually, it's totally legal. Since there's no biological connection, incest laws don't apply. Might raise eyebrows, but doesn't raise a legal issue. Number 48, opening up someone else's mail is always illegal. If you open it up intentionally, yeah, that's a crime. But accidentally opening it isn't. Think you can sit anywhere on a public sidewalk, not always. Dozens of cities have sit-ly ordinances that ban, sitting, lying down, or even placing your stuff on sidewalks during certain hours? They're controversial, but still enforced. And finally, number 50. If you find money on the ground, whether it's $100 or a million, most people believe it's Finder's Keepers. But Finder's Keepers isn't a real legal rule. If you find something valuable and don't try to return it, you could be charged with theft. Most states require turning it into police or making a real effort to find the owner. And Mike, I think he dropped this. What? Oh, my God. In videos to be made about you without your consent, should you really tell your lawyer everything? All these questions and more on our first episode of What the Law, where we answer your real legal question. Did someone say we? Hello, everyone. I'm Muppet Mike, a completely original and non-trade market-fringing puppet paralegal. Let's get into the first question. Terry V from Instagram asks, "How does a citizen's arrest work?" The funny thing about that is they actually are designed not to work. That's not funny. I don't get it. What I mean is, in order to encourage that the law stay up to law enforcement, less protections are offered to private citizens who make arrests compared to police officers. It's not getting money or the more you explain it. Can I do a citizen's arrest on you for that joke? Most states authorize private citizens to make arrests if they personally observe the crime. The person arrested has actually committed a felony, even if you didn't see it. Or a felony was, in fact, committed, and you have probable cause to believe that the arrested person committed it. So if you've got a citizen's arrest somebody, you better be right. Right. Exactly. Like I said, as long as they act on probable cause, police officers are usually not suddenly liable for mistakenly arresting an innocent person. But private citizens are-- Oh, oh, oh. Could I do a citizen's arrest on somebody if they wronged police citizens arrest me? No. But you can sue them. [SCREAMING] Next question. Mary I from Facebook asked, do lawyers charge for emails? Lawyers that charge by the hour, Mike, you should clarify that with them before you hire them and find out everything they will charge you for it. It can help in your decision. However, we are definitely charging you for that question. Instagram user IHeartHolima asked, how do I get over a boy? Oh, Mike, let me do this one. Go ahead, mop it, Mike. Self-love. Surround yourself with people who care about you. And listen to the New Taylor Swift album. I'm actually surprised. That was such sound advice. Brandon W. from Instagram asked, can someone make a YouTube video about you without your consent? The short answer is yes. What's the long answer? Anybody can post whatever they want. But there are certain things they can't do or else. [SCREAMING] You can sue. That's right. Yay. What can't they do? They can't defame you, meaning they can't give false statements about you that harm your reputation. They can't invade your privacy. And they can't use your likeness to promote a product without your consent. Oh, so I shouldn't have made this deep fake. Hi, I'm law by Mike. And you should buy mop it, Mike. Brand anti-diorium medication. Yeah, that's a lawsuit. Oh, then I have some phone calls to make. Is constructive criticism a commentary, OK? Of course, as long as it falls under fair use, and YouTube has always been great when it comes to fair use claims. Yeah, just asking you to incline. Next question. What if you did something very bad? Should you tell your lawyer everything? How much does lawyer client privilege actually protect? I bet the guy that asked that doesn't want people to know. Yes, that. Yes, you should tell your lawyer everything. Everything? Everything. Even. Yes, we need to know everything in order to give you the best legal advice. And we can't repeat anything. You tell us in private related to your case, but there's some major exceptions. Lawyers love exceptions. You can tell your lawyer about crimes you've already committed, but you can't plan ongoing or future crimes with your lawyer. You only get post-crime advice, not pre-crime advice. But shouldn't you give your lawyer a heads up if you plan on committing a crime? Not if you wanted to say a secret. It's not protected by attorney-clined privilege. Your attorney also can't be held to attorney-clined privilege if they believe that keeping your confidence would result in death or significant physical harm to someone. But you can tell me if you plan on hurting someone. I love gossip. The other day, I was telling my lawyer-- No, that privilege also goes both ways. Don't talk to anyone else about what you talk about with your lawyer or it breaks the privilege. Oh. I'm sorry, Mike. Let's just move on to the next question. Well, I have no proof my neighbor is messing with my vehicle. What kind of punishment would he get for causing an accident by loosening my lug nuts? They must be referring to this very safe TikTok challenge. It's called the lug nut challenge, and it evolves loosening or removing lugs from car tires and hopes of gaining lights online. I love TikTok. I do whatever the algorithm tells me. People on TikTok were loosening people's lug nuts, hoping to catch the moment where they almost kill their friend on camera. Boys being boys. If you have proof of this, it's a very serious offense. Attemptive murder serious. At the very least, a perpetrator would likely be charged with destruction of property. And if anyone is hurt, they could be looking at assault and battery charges. Or funeral expenses. Question. Do police have to read your Miranda rights before taking you into custody because I sat in jail 18 hours till it was read to me, then made bond? Ah, so this is a very common misconception. Your case actually isn't automatically dismissed if you aren't read your Miranda rights. What? You mean one order SVU was wrong? Why, most guagatay? Why? Not completely wrong. It wouldn't get your case dismissed, but the anything you say can and will be used against you gets a little trickier. Basically, any answer you give the police have asked when arrested or even formally interrogated usually can't be used as evidence in court. Oh, but if there's plenty of other evidence that you committed a crime, they wouldn't necessarily need to use that to find you guilty. Exactly, mob at Mike. Wow, I think you actually learned something today. I did, and I think you did too. What did I learn? Not to drive home without your lug mugs. Oh, mob at Mike. Ha-ha.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Police can lie during interrogations to encourage confessions, and asking for a lawyer does not imply guilt.
  2. Individuals are free to leave an interrogation room unless detained, and recordings continue even if not disclosed.
  3. Signing a traffic ticket does not admit guilt; it only confirms court appearance, and tickets can be dismissed if errors are found.
  4. Drivers must show ID when stopped while driving, but not when walking without reasonable suspicion.
  5. In some states, you can legally turn around at a DUI checkpoint and flashing headlights may be protected under the First Amendment.
  6. Emergency rescues, like breaking a car window to save a dog, are legally allowed under specific "good Samaritan" laws.
  7. Schools cannot randomly search students’ belongings or block exits without reasonable suspicion or emergency justification.
  8. Burying a loved one in one’s backyard is legal in some states if zoning and health codes are followed, and squatters must meet strict adverse possession requirements.

Summary:

This transcript debunks common legal myths surrounding police interactions, school policies, and personal freedoms. It clarifies that police can lie during interrogations, and requesting a lawyer does not imply guilt—people remain free to leave an interrogation room. Traffic tickets are not admissions of guilt and can be dismissed if errors exist, such as wrong data or unattended court appearances.

Drivers must show ID when stopped while driving, but not when walking without suspicion. In some states, turning around at a DUI checkpoint or flashing headlights to warn others is legal, especially under First Amendment protections. Rescuing animals in emergencies, like breaking a car window to save a dog, is permitted under good Samaritan laws.

Schools cannot randomly search students or block exits without cause, and online posting can lead to school discipline if it causes disruption. Additionally, burial in one’s backyard or squatting are legally possible under strict conditions. The video emphasizes that many widely believed rules—like needing a warrant for searches or being legally required to report crimes—are inaccurate.

It also highlights that citizens can only make arrests under specific, limited circumstances and that actions like dumpster diving or finding money are not automatically legal, with responsibilities to return lost items or report them. The core message is that legal knowledge empowers individuals to act confidently and safely in everyday situations.

FAQs

Yes, police are trained to lie during interrogations to get a suspect to talk. They might say things like 'your friend confessed' or 'you have fingerprints' to pressure a person into confessing.

No, asking for a lawyer does not make you guilty. You have the right to consult with one at any time, even before being arrested.

No, you are free to leave unless you are formally arrested. You can simply ask, 'Am I free to go?' and leave if the answer is yes.

Yes, you can legally turn around at a DUI checkpoint as long as you follow traffic laws and do not obstruct the flow of traffic.

In most cases, yes. Flashing headlights to warn of police is protected under the First Amendment, though some states have restrictions.

In some states, yes. Certain 'good Samaritan' or 'hot car rescue' laws allow breaking a window in emergency situations to save a dog or person.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.