In Murphy’s, California, a tragic fire in 1990 kills Christina Carlson, the mother of three children, while her husband Carl Carlson survives. The fire begins when Carl douses a Christmas tree with kerosene and lights it as a demonstration to teach his children about fire dangers. The flames spread rapidly, engulfing the home, and the family is only saved when Carl evacuates the children through a bedroom window and drives them to safety. However, Christina is trapped inside, ultimately dying from smoke inhalation. Firefighters arrive too late to enter the home due to blocked pathways, including a plywood-covered bathroom window and debris, which prevented them from rescuing her. Despite the chaos, no physical evidence links Carl to a deliberate act. His history of abuse—frequent violence, controlling behavior, and emotional manipulation—is noted by family members, including his sister Collette and daughter Aaron. Carl’s financial decisions, such as purchasing a $700,000 life insurance policy, suggest possible motive, but the fire appears accidental. The case remains unresolved, with questions about whether the incident was a tragic accident or a premeditated act. While Carl’s character is deeply troubling, the lack of direct evidence—such as fingerprints, injuries, or a clear timeline—prevents a conviction. The story highlights the dangers of unchecked control, emotional abuse, and the fragile line between accident and intent in domestic tragedies.
This week in Murphy's, California, a man is either the unluckiest person alive or a cold-blooded murderer after two family members are killed in incredibly suspicious and incredible ways, but isn't there any proof to actually convict him? Welcome to Small Town Murder! Hello everybody and welcome back to Small Town Murder! Yay! Yay indeed, my name is James Petrigalo, I'm here with my co-host. I'm Jimmy Wittsman. Thank you folks so much for joining us today on another really crazy twisted wild story as you can imagine from the opening, but this is a real weird story with a real strange guy, we'll talk all about it, can't wait to get to that. Before we do get to that though, once you go ahead and head over to Shut Up and give me murder.com, get all your merchandise, everything like that, no live shows left for the year. All over with all done, thank you guys for coming, we had an amazing, amazing touring year this year. It was so much fun we had and we hope you guys had as much fun, new dates coming for the 2027 tour in very soon here, within a week or two, they'll go on sale in early December, so there you go, those are coming, shut up and give me murder.com is a place to go to buy the tickets to find out when they come out and do all that stuff, so get over there and do that. Also, definitely check out our other two shows, which are crime in sports, which we think you like, you don't even have to like sports, we promise. And your stupid opinions, which is just fun, it's just fun, we make fun of people, we make fun of people's reviews, we make fun of people making fun of things, which is the best thing ever, it's great. So check that out, definitely get yourself Patreon though, that is a mustpatrion.com/crimein sports, that is where you get all the bonus material, and there's a lot of it too, so much, so much, all you have to be is $5 a month or above and you're going to get everything we put out. As soon as you subscribe, you're going to get almost 400 back bonus episodes you've ever heard before, new ones every other week, and one crime in sports, one small town murder, then you get them all, everybody, that's how we do it. This week, which you're going to get, oh, I can't wait for this one for a small town murder. We are going to talk about the clown incidents of about 10 years ago. There's a documentary called Clown Panic Out right now. There was this thing that was going on in like 2015, 2017, somewhere in there where people were dressing up as like scary clowns and jumping out and trying to scare people in random places, in random places. It was a thing and I was praying that this would happen because then it's legal to kill a clown, which I think that's my dream since a young child is to be able to actually holding a weapon. Oh, it's on. I can't wait. They would be very surprised when I'd be like, finally, I think go, oh, God, what happened. So we're going to talk all about that and how crazy that was and a lot more than that. So patreon.com/crimeinsports is where you get all of that. Now, in addition to that, you're also going to get, and that would be enough, but we say not enough, damn it. Well, you're also you're going to get, you are going to get everything we put out all the shows, all ad free as well. Sure. Yeah. And you get a shout out at the end of the show here. So can't beat that. What else to get yourself patreon disclaimer time. It's a comedy show, everybody says, we're comedians. Now, that doesn't mean that the murder isn't horrible and real because it is. It's all 100% real. We don't make anything up for comedic effect or anything crazy like that. We just try to do the best possible research on all these cases and hopefully you will love it. So yeah, this is a comedy show. You might go, well, how does that work comedy and murder? Really easy. We figured it out. All you have to do is we never make fun of the victims or the victims families. Why is that? Because we're assholes, but but we're not scumbags. See, that works super simple. It's how it works. There's plenty to make fun of. We make fun of a small town because who cares? Apparently people in Baldnab, Arkansas, because they've got real upset about that. Hey, everybody, Arkansas can't take a joke. So that's pretty fun. Shocking. Imagine, imagine living in a place, named Baldnab. Very clearly named after a dick and not thinking that was funny. That's wild. Zero sense of humor about it. That's pretty funny. So yeah, we make fun of that sort of thing. We make fun of some bumbling police force that lets a murderer go free. We make fun of murderers because why not? What else can we do with them? We can't go and take the ramen noodles away. So this is all the best recourse we have. But yeah, either way, that's what's happening. If you think that true crime and comedy should never go together, I mean, it's a weird choice to click on this show, but you might like it. Let's just put it that way. You might not. Either way, no complaining later. That's it. That's it. That's it. That's it. I think it's time everybody to sit back. What do you say here? Clear the lungs, arms to the sky and let's all shout. Shut up. Give me murder. Let's do this, everybody. Let's go on a trip. Shall we? Well, yeah, we got to. Let's do it. What choice do we? We're going to California, everybody. Oh, that's not so bad. Not the California you're thinking about. No, San Diego, the beach is San Francisco. No, no, no, we're going to Murphy's, California. And that is no apostrophe. By the way, it's Murphy like with a pH, no apostrophe, just Murphy's. So that's how it works. It's a north central California, that central valley. Oh, yeah. Not great. Not great country up there. It's, it's what some pretty stuff. You should have to live in to earn any other city to earn the beach. Yeah, it's about an hour 40 to Sacramento. If you want to go someplace, a slight improvement, I suppose, about three hours to Reno, the other direction, and about, yeah, about two hours and 10 minutes to Lafayette, California, which was our last California episode, episode seven, 12, the murder in the neighborhood. So this is in Calaveras County. As we all know, from Mark Twain there, with their famous fucking jumping frogs there. And area code 209, and the nickname is Queen of the Sierra. How dare you? Well, I think there was an Australian movie by that name where we're craziness going on. Not positive, but Queen of the Sierra. There's nothing royalty about the art, our agriculture area of California. It is, this is a, this is broken down gold mining territory. This is like, there's so hot. It's hot. Yeah, it's so hot. This area around here was originally occupied by the Miwok tribe. Then a couple guys came in, John, Mary, and Murphy, Daniel Martin Murphy. They founded the town. They're part of the Murphy's family and Murphy family. Yeah. And they were part of these Stevens towns and Murphy party, which was the first immigrant party to bring wagons across the Sierra Nevada to Sutter's Fort, which we talked a lot about in the Donner party bonus episode. That was in 1844. So they were on the cutting edge here. They earned a living as merchants, but then they arrived just in time for the gold rush to start. Yeah. And they began prospecting, but they ended up like everybody in any kind of gold rush town. The merchants make way more money selling people shit to mine than the miners actually make. It's the way it works. It's like a casino. Yeah. You're literally out there gambling. Imagine if the casino could set an addition to that. They could then sell you things you needed to play. Like you need to have this pan and the shovel if you want to play blackjack. It's the only way you have to buy it. It's the handle for that slot machine. Yeah. That's that's it. It's an extra 12 bucks. So that's what's going on there. Now they first started in Vasolito or Valacito, which was then known as Murphy's old diggings before moving to another location, which became Murphy's new diggings. Right. And then Murphy's camp and then eventually by 1935, it was just shortened to Murphy's and they lost the apostrophe. So that's it. Now they're these very small mines here. The miners were limited to claims of eight square feet in the streams, but several people became very wealthy still doing that, which is pretty incredible. Eight square feet. The eight square feet. One of the brothers here, the Murphy brothers, John was so successful that he left town at the end of 1849 and amassed a personal fortune of two million dollars back then, which was insane. That's, you know, a hundred million dollars now. Imagine being the two assholes sitting next to him. So like a lot of mining towns, it burned down several times. 1859, 1874, 1893. Not every 20 years or so. It's growing during winter. Yep. After the second fire, there was hardly any gold left to mine. So the town was just never rebuilt to the condition that it was before that. They just kind of let it be what it was. Reviews from modern times, five stars, best small town to live in. Best. Perfect place to grow up and raise a family. The community is so close, knit and loving. Everyone is willing to help each other in times of need, no matter what. All right. They're all struggling still. Yeah, they need help. That's a problem. Here's three stars. This is a great place for tourists to explore, but could use a bit more flair for the locals. The food is mediocre and a lot of the food is not utilizing all the local farms available. There are a lot of events that happen in town.
and music shows, which is a big plus. It's small enough to walk through the entire town without having to change parking spots. You can just park in the middle and walk. - Oh, and then just, okay, so it's like Jerome. - Kind of, it's what sounds like. A local Uber would be great for all the wine tasters not wanting to drive. So one guy with an Uber app would crush it in this town. - You do. - Own it. Then finally, two stars, which is the lowest one I could find. Too much tourism, bad driving by tourists. - No drugs. - Wine fucking drunk. - Yeah, what do you want? - No drugstore, expensive groceries. Not much law enforcement. Insufficient laws pertaining to resident and then in all caps, tourist dogs. - So a dog. - They don't have enough laws pertaining to dogs there. - This guy's had enough with the fucking dogs. - Fucking hate other people's dogs. OPD, I don't like it. So people in this town, 1928. So it's not a big place at all. Very small, under 2000. There is more men than women, about 51.3% women here, which is well out of whack of the national average, but I don't know if that's still for mining times or what, I'm not sure why that is. - That's because I caught up, yeah. - Median age here, wow, 63.3. Older. - Older. - Olderly live here. - Older, that's the thing. People live here that are older. Many of the young people get the hell out of here because there is not much. It's a town of 2,000 people in the central fucking valley. I mean, it's nothing going on. 49.4% married, that's about average. About 19% are single with children. That's a little above the average. Race in this town, 94.6% white, very white, 0.0% black, 0.0% Asian, 0.6% Native American, 4.8% Hispanic. 0.0% Asian in Northern California is odd to me. - Interesting. - Strange. And then the religion here, 68.3% are religious. That's like-- - What? - That's like suburban Boston or Mississippi, usually. Have those rates. - Or Utah. - Yeah, or Utah, exactly, Idaho. And the highest one is Catholic. - Apparently. - Apparently. - Apparently, it was an Irish thing. A lot of the Irish people came here, and that's why it's 54.6% Catholic, which is crazy. - Awesome. - And really low in everything else. Unemployment here is about average. Nothing too crazy. Median household income here, well below average. 45,282 dollars a year. - Yeah. - That's median. Now a lot of that might be a lot of retired people here living on fixed incomes. But the cost of living here, overall, 100 is average. Here it is 120. High. - Oh. - And the housing is the highest thing of all. - Really? - Median home cost here. - Median, $499,700. - Three hours outside of Reno. - Three hours. - Half a million dollars. - Hour and a half outside of Sacramento. It's, which is not desirable as it is. - And the median income is $45,000. So how the hell are you supposed to afford that? That's crazy. - The math doesn't work. - Nope, well, if we've convinced you, dammit, that you can make that math work. We have for you the Murphy's, California real estate report. (upbeat music) All right, your average two-bedroom rental here, this seems like the way to go, $1,410, which I don't know how many rentals there are here, that was the problem. It's a rent, it seems. - It's a revenue mortgage. It just doesn't seem like any other way is affordable. - No, here's a two-bedroom two-bath, so technically, T-Bull for each and every B-Hull, but you're gonna have to cram those B-Holes in there 'cause it's 672 square feet. - Sweet Jesus. - And it is old, and dingy on the inside, and it is not a great place. It's on.27 acres, so not even a huge land. Built in 1936 and looks like it hasn't been touched since. It's got like a metal roof, but not like the nice green metal roof. It looks like people just laid slabs of tin on the roof. It looks terrible. $245,000 for that. - For a shack. - For a shack, and that's the cheapest thing available. They just had a price cut at $35,000 on that one. - Here's a three-bedroom two-bath 1910 square feet on.31 acres. It's nice. It looks nice from the outside. Good family home, nice landscape. It's a nice place. Just had a $20,000 price cut. $399,000 for that, though. - God damn. - So that's gonna be kind of your average. And then finally, you've sold all the wine and panned all the gold, and you're doing well here. For a bedroom six-bath, T-Bull for each and every B-Hull, 5,050 square feet. - God damn. - For 42.3 acres. - Yeah. - It's like a compound and it's Spanish style with the very much Spanish style with different levels. And it's a very cool looking house, actually. Nice courtyard with a fountain there. Like, it's really cool. $2,500,000. - Three hours from Reno. - Yeah, things to do here. Well, they have Murphy's Irish Day. See what I mean? - Oh, the Irish Day. - They got a whole day. They said it can be a beautiful 65 degree day or snowing, but the party always goes on. - It's gonna happen if they're right. - If there's Irish and booze, it doesn't matter. The weather is not the important thing here. They're gonna, they're showing up. It's free unless you wanna spend your pennies on green beer and Irish fare. That is, singing and dancing to live Irish music in the middle of Main Street is not only encouraged but expected. - It's the law. - Sure ass out there. It's the law. You're gonna do a dumb dance while you're drunk. Where else can you drink green wine? I don't wanna drink green wine. - What? - Fuck would you? - I don't wanna drug wine that looks like Ectocooler. I don't want that. 'Cause ice cubes in it too, I'm sure. - Oh, God. It will be flowing until it runs out at Irish vineyards and you can win a trip for two to Ireland. Tickets will be available at local businesses so ask around. They said throughout the day, there is continuous entertainment. Continuous, that sounds like a punishment. Like it's just keeps coming. - It will be continuous. - No matter what, no breaks people, so get ready. Featuring singers, dancers, musicians and jugglers. In case you're not. - And jugglers. - More than enough by dancers and everything else. Are there mimes too? Can we really make, kick it up a bit here? There are pony rides for the young ones and Renaissance actors encamped in the park. - Oh, what do they live in the park? Sounds like they live there and they're once a year, they go, "Now, pretend you're from another time." And you can stay. - And camp means there's a tent of some sort, right? - Right, yeah. - Some sort of apparatus. - The sour smell amongst it. - Oh yeah. And some lucky raffle ticket buyer will win an exciting trip for two to Ireland. So if you like big festive street parties, green beer, Irish music, wine and everything else that comes along with a perfect Irish celebration, then don't miss Murphy's Irish Day this year. I will make sure to miss that. Yeah, like I said, back to the sopranos. It's our health tone. It's an Irish bar or it's St. Patrick's Day every day. Every day. - Every day. - Every day. There's also meet me at Murphy's Music Fest, which has a few people, two I've never heard of and one I have. Summer Moon, S-O-M-E-R, I don't know who that is. Ryan Woodard beats me and the Whalers will be there. Who have I actually seen? - Oh, think about Marley's kids. - Shit. - Well, the Whalers are Bob Marley's band. - Oh, it's Bob Marley's band. - There was, but they have, now there's, all the guys look like they were like 28 years old. So there's, when I saw them in the 90s, it was a bunch of old dudes before we were, you know. - Ah Ziggy was running around with them. He was. - He was. - He was for a while. - He goes with them, yeah. - Yeah, 'cause they're them. - Makes sense. - Property crime here, or crime rate, well we're interested in here. Property crime, just about average. So, you wouldn't think that for a town of 2,000 people. Maybe the tourists make it a little more, but either way. - You have an Irish day, you're gonna tick your crime stats out. - I was gonna say, that might have helped the violent crime here. Violent crime, murder, rape, robbery, and of course assault. The Mount Rushmore of crime is just slightly below the average. So, but slightly, I mean it's pretty much right there. That said, why don't we go ahead and talk about some murder? - Yeah. - 'Cause, whoa, do we have the story for you? All right, let's start out talking about a man here. Let's talk about Carl Carlson, double K. - Perfect. - Luckily his nickname is not Kennedy or something. His nickname, or his middle name isn't Kennedy or something. His middle name is Holger, which. - Jesus is the most German Carl Holger Carlson with a K, is the most German name you can get here. - That is all throat to say that. - Yeah. - I knew a kid in school when I was real little named Holger. I got in my first fist fight with a kid named Holger. Hogi, everybody called him. - That kid can throw, huh? - Hogi, I beat the shit out of him. We were five. - I couldn't throw. - He pushed my friend down. Who was this little blonde kid? I just started pummeling him. And he cried, and then he got in trouble 'cause he was always doing bad shit and pushing people around. And I wasn't, so they didn't get me in trouble at all. But, and then he was-- - What sounds like he has dense fists. - He was big, he was bigger than me. He was a big fucking kid. His parents did, his mom was like six foot three and his dad was like six foot six. They were these giant German people. And after that though, he was the nicest kid ever. He went from being the bully and a dick to,
sort of takes the nicest kid ever. I remember going with birthday party before he moved and he was a sweet kid and everybody loved him. Anyway, Hogi there. So Carl Carlson born about 1960. He grew up in upstate New York. Really? I mean, upstate upstate New York, fingerlights over there. Western New York, Seneca County, he grew up here. Varick is the town that his family is from VAR ICK. And Carl's got a big family from the Varick region here. He, I guess, there used to be an army depot up there, which is why a lot of people ended up there. His father and grandfather had been town highway superintendents. Well, that's a something of highway superintendents in the fucking middle of upstate New York. Yeah, way up there in that time. Yeah. Carl's brother Kurt was a town counselor and Kurt's wife Dono's a town clerk. So I mean, everybody in the local government, everyone in his family is involved. He's one of seven kids, five boys, two girls. And it's a big, loud, rough housing family from what I've understood here. And there's lots of cousins around and a lot of people from the family around. So there's a whole lot of like interaction with the family. His brother Mike described a childhood of mischief and constant family gatherings. How about it? Which sounds familiar. That's about right. Carl left the farm to join the Air Force. Oh, grew up on a farm here. And he, where did he go? Decide to well, he stationed in North Dakota. He'll tell everybody for years and years. And we have no way of knowing if this is true. Based on him, I'm going to say it's probably not. But he tells everybody that his job involved transporting nuclear weapons. Okay. Which he might have transferred like a component that was a switch on something in like a little box. And he's like, you can't have a nuke without this. You can't imagine we keep. I mean, I guess that would be smart in a way to hide them if we, if we all think that it would be useless to put them in North Dakota. No, no, I'm sure there's weapons up there. Yeah. I'm sure we had all of them, right? No, no, we haven't spread all out. There's nuclear weapons everywhere. But he, I don't know if they'd let this jerk off transport him as my that's the only contention I have about it. He is from the generation. And I only say that because my dad evidently was in the service based on the fact that he got a fucking military burial. I don't think they're just better than that for people. But he's really good at being full of shit. One of the stories that he told that was like none of those things are time exists. There's no way to do all of that in the amount of time that you've been alive. It's just impossible. That's this guy and this guy is an embellisher. He loves a get rich quick scheme. He's all about that. He's that guy. He's all right. He's that guy. You know, he's telling big on stories. Yeah. You know, big on what's going to happen or what did happen and then might not ever happen or maybe didn't happen. My dad would have embraced being a dad. It would have been so much fun to know these bullshit stories. The ones that he told me, it's just I cast him off and kick him out of my memory because it's like that didn't happen. Why am I going to, why am I going to store that? Why are we lying here? What's going on? Yeah. So early 1980. Yeah. All right. He meets a young lady up there in North Dakota. A young lady named Christina and Alexander. Christina and Alexander, she's born June 19th, 1960. Her family is from Murphy's, California. Oh, how about it? Her home place here. Her father, art ran a sheet metal business. Her mother, Arlene, was also, you know, around and she's got a sister named Collette that we'll talk about a lot. Now she married her high school sweetheart in the town of Murphy's, which at the time, about 1500 people. Two young kids find each other. They get married. He joins the Air Force. And they move to Grand Forks Air Base in North Dakota where her husband is stationed. Yeah. Now while there, Christina meets Carl. Yeah. And Carl takes her away from her husband. Treats are a little better as a friend that she's like, maybe I'd like to do a relationship with this man. Or she's from a town of 1500 people where she fucking married. Other people exist. Married somebody who she met when she was, you know, seven years old and fucking yeah, and decided that, oh, there's other people in the world. Wow, this is crazy, which is why you don't get married when you're 18 right there. Give yourself some chance. Yeah. Especially if you haven't done anything or been anywhere. If you've grown up in a one place that your whole life don't marry. You think it's a coincidence that just the person who's meant for you just happens to live right down the street. That's a coincidence that happened in this world. Probably not. What are the odds? Your person meant, your, your, your, your soulmate is in your same 12 person graduating class. Yeah. It's like, it's like why magically when you're a kid, your best friend in the world happens to live across the street. Isn't that weird? How the person who you connect with the most happens to be live the closest to you? Anybody. It's just proximity. Once you get a car, your whole life changes and your whole life expands and everything's different. Travel a little bit. Your life is an entirely different thing. Fucking no shit. So she leaves her husband for Carl. Wow. That's that. And Carl later said, I was 23. I mean, she, she was beautiful. I mean, I mean, she really was. And person wise, you just, you don't find she was just, she really saw the best in people. I bet he means it. That's quite the quote. And person wise, you just don't, you don't find she really saw the best in people. Person wise. Yeah. He starts a lot of sentences and then abandons them halfway through and starts over somewhere else. Yeah. That's, that's not what I wanted to say. I'm going to say something else. No, not at all. Now Carl's brother Mike said she was an amazing young lady. Great kid. Great kid. Great kid. He's the older brother Mike. Oh, great kid. Yeah. And she was 18 at the time too. So, I mean, you'd say, yeah, if you're 25, you go, yeah, nice. That's great kid. There. That's good shit. So she's a, she's got an artistic streak. She knows how to do seamstress stuff. She sows things, makes things, shit like that. Everybody likes her though. She's really nice. And that's the last we hear of her first husband. So I don't know what this poor bastard ended up doing, but not staying married. A beer in North Dakota. Yeah. Just having a lot of master baiting in the planes, I guess. I'm not sure. So Christina meets him and they're married in Grand Forks in 1983. So I mean, it's pretty quick here. They move back to the to Varic. That's where he takes her back to the town far upstate New York. Yep. I mean, up there, which I mean, it's it's pretty up there. If you don't mind being bored, it's just boring. It's a different life from a California. Yeah. Well, not really Murphy's California though. That's a, I mean, 10 wise. It's going to be big time. Yeah, a lot colder. It's fucking cold up there, dude. That's goddamn. Sorry. Yeah. Now they have three kids like right away. Boom, boom, boom, pump them out one year next year, next year. They have Aaron in 1984. They have Levi, a son, Aaron's a girl, and then Levi's a son, February 3rd, 1985. And then right after that, pretty much as soon as you can get pregnant and have another kid, they have another daughter named Katie. Wow. So they pound them all out quick and then they're done making kids here. That's it. So in a two year span, they're done. They're done. Aaron Levi, Katie. That's how that goes. They're going to end up moving around quite a bit. Carl is not a guy who's real stable guy who puts down roots. Yeah. And he's kind of full of shit. And he gets jobs, but then he's also trying to do get rich quick bullshit. So we have to go here because that's where the big score is now. There's some, you know, thing that doesn't work out. And then he's going to get another shit job. That all sorts of different shit here. Back in sales. No, no, no, no. Worst dumber shit than anything door to door. At least that's an honest living. Now this is like a, he's all full of shit. We'll talk of one of his big ideas is ducks. We'll put it that way. Yeah. Like have a lot of proper. Yeah. We'll talk about it. Yeah. We'll get to it. Don't worry. Yeah. So they move around. They move out west, backed up state in New York. Carl drifts through shitty jobs. They never have enough money because Carl never works enough, or never has enough jobs. And so that's kind of what they're doing here. Then in 1986, a car that car loans bursts into flames in the driver. So it's interesting here. So now a witness later said that Carl cleaned his belongings out of the car about an hour before it burst into flames. Yeah. Yeah. That's not, that's not. And the investigators found that interesting, but it wasn't enough to, to put a flag up. So they just paid it out. The payout was reportedly around $10,000, which in '86, good money. Pretty good chunk of change. Yeah. Small fire, not a huge check, just a car burning. So now there's also everybody says he's a super big fucking bully car. That's one of the main two to his family. He's a big bully. Very much like drill sergeant to the kids as far as the voice he has. A very like kids were doing like just I'm gonna scare my kids into doing shit, which you're much bigger than them. You don't need to do that. It's not that hard. It's not that hard.
Everybody said to me, "Always thinks he's the smartest person in any room, no matter what room that is or who else is in it, he's the smartest guy." How annoying is that person? Oh, God. Which how many times have we come across that in these stories? That is a certain personality type that is kind of disturbing. I love being told I'm wrong, and it's wrong. You're wrong, I'm like, fuck, yeah, fuck that up. The arrogance and confidence when people are super duper wrong. Yeah, everybody knows that they're wrong and they really believe they're right. It's so obnoxious. And then when they realize that they're wrong because everybody has now convinced them they're wrong, then they're like, "Oh yeah, that's right, that's right." Of course it's right. We all know that we're talking about. He's got a real air of just arrogance about him. Yeah. He kind of says here. He's got really, really shitty behavior around the house. Kristina sister Collette says that he controlled Kristina by calling her names, mainly calling her, "fatty and chubby" after she had the kids. And she would do this, he would do this in front of her sister. So this isn't just behind closed doors. This woman watched him call her a chubby, come here, like fuck is wrong with you. Not even like a playful or funny one. Try to make that playful and funny with your wives, everybody out there. Any man listening, go to your wife and try your best to playfully say, "Hey chubby, and see how she takes it." Start a TikTok trend, man. Do I look fat in this? No way, chubs. You look great. That's not gonna work. Yes, that's so change. Yeah, fatty, I think you do. So no good, that's not gonna work. And obviously not good for her either, for her psyche to be here and this from the person who's supposed to be nice to her. She, at one point, watched him kick a hole in the door when he was angry. The whole household was tense, basically. She says also one time Carl hit Christina so hard she flew across the room, which the hardness isn't really the issue here. It's the matter that he's hitting her, which is crazy. Later on, when we'll talk about it in detail, his children said basically he would beat them in private and be careful not to leave marks. You know, a real crazy, think about it. He's not, I lost my temper, I'm at a control and then feel bad later, which is still terrible, but at least this is. It's also in the 80s when that was like, yeah, it's socially acceptable to punch a kid, well the hit a kid. Yeah, the 80s is where it switched. The 80s, we got like after school specials, my name is Luca and I live on the second floor. It started his child abuse really picked up in the 80s of like we should watch. The 88th when it like started to really take off, but 81 to 87, perfectly. I got hit in the grocery store right in the fucking face. Nobody back. I don't care. No, didn't like punky Brewster have an abused friend or something in one of those shows. Arnold and Willis had one of those. Yeah, no, especially if I grew up in New York, I mean, Italian lady punching her kid is going to be completely normal and you go good for you. Normal. So anyway, people also described him as emotionless at moments when most people would be very emotional, very stoic and emotionless. Now, Christina stays here and her oldest daughter remembers, you know, Aaron, she remembers how her mom would try to make everything a little bit better. It would take the kids in like the woods to collect leaves and acorns and shit and try to have them not be so tense and she said her mother wanted the kids to grow up with both parents in the same house, which is why she never left. Basically, she thought it would be better for the kids even if he's hitting them all, which that sucks. So late 1980s, they're struggling. They're moving around not having a great time. Art, who is Christina's dad, he owns a sheet metal business. He offered Carl a job in the sheet metal business if they move out to Murphy's, California. So they moved to Murphy's because they really have no other choice at this point from upstate New York from all the way from there. They don't buy a house. They rent a house when they first get there very for a short period of time. Then they rent a small home and I'm talking a thousand square feet small home, three kids thousand square feet. That's small. When they first arrived, they rented a small home from a from the Lucero family here, Joan Lucero recalled that, you know, Carl was kind of just an off-putting guy basically. It's an old house basically that they rent an exchange for fixing stuff up to odd jobs is rent. Kind of yeah, like they pay a little rent or maybe if they fix something they take the rent off that month or whatever the fuck is how. So yeah, it's an old house. It's cold in there. It's heated in part with kerosene. Kerosene. I get I don't even know how that heater works. I get fuel oil northeast. We used oil a lot, but I never heard of kerosene to heat a house that seems dangerous. I only heard of it. I just don't know how that works to heat the entire house. I imagine it's just same as propane or natural gas. I suppose. It's getting a furnace somewhere, right? I guess. Yeah. Just kerosene seems like a pretty volatile substance to be doing that with. It feels like that makes your house smell too, right? It's kerosene. You're burning kerosene. It has to be, but it's an oil-based fuel. Man, it's described as a thousand square foot house covered with imitation brick shingles had been built as a shack for miners. That's where this house came from. That's how old it is. It's not a real house. It's a fucking miner shack that they eventually put like solid walls up in. That's it. It's a 16 acre property. It used to be an active gold mine. Yeah. There's no gold left now. It sits at about 2600 feet of elevation. There you go. Christina dives in and tries to make this a home basically. An old miner shack heated by kerosene. She's like, I make this comfortable for my three kids. She's nesting here. Carl Miserable here hates it. Fucking hates everything about it here. Collette, Christina sister said Carl wanted Christina. Collette said Carl wanted to move back to New York. And Christina said, sure, if you get a job that has benefits there, but for right now, you have a good job here with my dad and you have benefits. And I'm not going to move all the way back there for nothing. Yeah. So if you get a good job with benefits, then sure. But otherwise we live in Murphy's California. That's it. So he works in her father's shop and all that, which does sound miserable. I wouldn't want to work for. You know, that sounds that's shitty. Collette said Carl was not happy in Murphy's. He wanted to go back to New York and my sister told him we're not going back to New York unless you have a job with benefits. So Carl was stuck in Murphy's, whether he wanted to be there or not. That's it. That's what Collette said. So he works there. He's working. It's a, you know, like I said, a sheet metal shop and everything like that. And basically makes him kind of a business partner. The father does like I cut. I mean, he's he's trying to help his daughter, essentially, and Carl makes. The only way to be interested in sheet metal is if you're financially benefiting from this in a way that is better than hourly. Otherwise, this is I'm going to leave. So other sheet metal is sheet metal. That's a tough job. It's a tough life. Just doing sheet metal. You get cut burns. It's these last savings in your skin. It's not easy. Oh, yeah. All over the place in your lungs for Christ sake early December. Yeah. Early December 1990. Okay. Here we go. A few weeks before Christmas. Carl goes shopping. Not for Christmas presents, mind you. Like normal people do. No, he goes shopping for life insurance. Like we all do. That's a good gift. It's a real good guy. I got you life insurance that I'm the beneficiary of. Merry Christmas. Enjoy the birth of the newborn cancer. Yeah, exactly. I've a Maria my ass. So he went to state farm. And he asked about $100,000 policy on Christina and a $50,000 policy on each of the kids. Okay. That's what he asked for. But he ends up buying a $200,000 policy on himself. A $200,000 policy on Christina. Yeah. And a $100,000 on each child. Each fucking child. Do you also get a time share and Bermuda? What the fuck? 700 grand worth of insurance. He got this agent is good. Yeah. He came in. I'd like about 250 grand worth of insurance. How about 700,000? What do you say? How much do you spend on hotels? Yeah, exactly. If you come and sit down and get a free 19 inch color TV, come on and sit down and talk to him around the golf in South Carolina. Oh God. So basically the premiums for all these insurance policies are a large share of their household income. Like this is crazy. It's ridiculous. [BLANK_AUDIO]
So, he initiates the purchases, he increased the amounts and he is the beneficiary on Christina's policy, she is the beneficiary and his policy. Now the children have a different structure, I guess Christina was the beneficiary of the children. Okay. So, now, sometime in late 1990, December, November, we're not sure, sometime around the life insurance thing, the window in the hallway bathroom breaks, we don't know how, there's three kids, anything's possible. So, Karl covers it up with plywood. The hallway bathroom, as if there's two? The hallway bathroom, yeah, in the hallway bathroom, it broke. So that's what we know, he put up some plywood, covered up the window, all class. He should maybe if he didn't have so many fucking insurance policies, you could afford a glass. That would help. Of course, somebody to glaze in a new friend. God damn it. So, Christmas 1990, it's a big thing here because they're back there with the family and all that, so there's a lot going on for Christmas. I guess Collette, Christina's sister, would arrive in Murphy a few days before Christmas and bring a longer husband and their two boys, one of which is named Rockio, Rockio? R-O-C-K-I-O? What? Yeah. Who's never heard of that name? I don't know, that's according to this book, that's, that's, that's, I'll give you the title of the book and all that later on too. So they're close an age to the girl cousins, so, you know, all the kids play together and all that. It's a three and a half hour drive for Collette from Red Bluff to Murphy's and, but she did it every year so the families could spend time together and the kids could have some cousin time and all that shit. Now, Collette is the younger sister, but she's kind of more of a motherly role with Christina. Their parents get divorced and Carl thought it was strange that Collette was overprotective of Chris. Why are you overprotective of your older sister? He said there was no reason for that and he said he told people he resented Collette's mother superior attitude. Oh, mother superior over here, I could hear him saying it. He didn't come out and say it though, he, he really hated Collette because she comes over and, you know, competes with him for Chris's attention and also just, you know, he feels like he's outnumbered then, like they're teaming up on him and all that kind of shit. But their parents are divorced, so Chris is probably the semblance of normalcy for her and she doesn't see her all the time. So that's probably, she's grasping at a, at a protector. Absolutely. And at the same time, this is just a way, if someone else is around, he has less control over Christine. That's it. It's a control thing in my mind anyway. Yeah. So New Year's Eve, I believe this is. Now, Carl, he's at work at art's sheet metal shop here. He picks up the phone and Chris is telling her him that there's supposed to snow and there's snow falling already. It doesn't snow here very often. So they're like, this time of year, it's usually later, if it snows, it'll be January, February. So she said, listen, there's already snow coming down in the house here. And I need you to get milk and eggs and some basic grocery items, because I'm not going to take the kids out in this shit basically. Right. Now he's rolling his eyes because he's from the Finger Lakes region where it snows like four feet of time. It's just the, they just, the fucking storm just bounces back and forth from the little finger like to finger lake and covers these places. So he's like, oh, come on, this isn't that bad. But he said, fine, I'll fucking stop and, you know, I got a few things I got to do first, I got jobs, I got to do. They said, well, can you get a, Christina said, can you get a couple movies to pick up some movies? Because this is 1990. So he said, tell me which ones you want. You want stuff for the kids, what am I getting here? And she said, yeah, just get something animated, see if they have the little mermaid. Because it's 1990 and it's fresh, that's the, that's the fresh one, not even a laden yet. So Carl said, all right, fine, Jesus Christ. So he does it. It was snowing where he was. So he didn't want Chris to take any chances and go driving around because they don't, they live kind of outside of town and it'd be driving through some hilly shit and yeah, he's rather he do it. So he finishes a heating job and at that point when he's done, he sees, he sees, it's snowing pretty hard and it's sticking to the ground. It's real snow. It's real snow. And if you know you go from a place with snow, it either sticks or it doesn't. If it doesn't stick, it's not a big deal. If it sticks, that means it's going to accumulate and you're in deep shit. So he was like, oh shit, he decided to cut his work day short going, I guess Chris was right up to be paranoid about the snow. So he stops off at a market to pick up the food she wanted and then grab some videos and makes the drive home and by then it's turned kind of icy too. Yeah. So I see some slippery conditions and I guess you have to drive through Penn Gulch road, which is narrow and hard to navigate even when it's nice out. Yeah. Now it's icy and snowy, but Carl makes it home okay. They dinner, dishes are done. They all sit in front of the TV and watch the land before time. They got the land before time, that's storm is coming, all the little mermaids were sold out. So that's the best he could do at blockbuster was the land before time. That's not so bad though. No, it's fine. That's good. I just, I mean, the kids might have wanted to see the little mermaid because it was newer, but they'll be all right with this. They'll live. If they made it today, they'd try to make those dinosaurs look realistic. Yeah. Yeah. They'd give them like tattoos and shit. Yeah. The supplements and stuff would be weird. They'd be strange. They'd have cell phones and shit. Yeah. And I'll be like the fucking Insta sucks today and the boring. So anyway, this snow storm, it's kind of a freak snowstorm because it hangs around and goes all through the night into the next day. Wow. Snow is all night long, like from afternoon to morning, which is in the middle of California, but the middle of the foothills of the 26-hundred square feet. Yeah. So they're kind of right where it usually is under the snow. Yeah. But this is a cool thing for the kids. For the kids, it was the first time since they've been here that it's like covered in snow. So if you know anything about kids and snow, they just want to go out in it. They love it. Even kids now put fucking iPads down and want to go out in the snow. It's awesome. It's the only thing they can distract them. I took my desert children, my dusty ass dehydrated desert children after the mountains and were driving to the snow. They're like, we want to stop and get out and I got out and let them get out. My daughter, my daughter fell down and it suddenly started crying and went, "Oh, my God." She's like, "It's so cold. I'm like, it's fucking high, man." Get off. Stupid. It's not you're laying in it. That's a good idea. You're crying your eyes. Get in the car, we'll go back home. That's hilarious. My nephew's, it's snow is there like till dark. You can't get them inside. It's all I want to do is fucking get in the snow. So for them, it's like a magical day. You know what I mean? I think that was maybe the day, December 30th going into New Year's Eve or whatever. So by 1990, by New Year's Day, 1991 now, the next two days later, your January 1st, 1990, 91, holidays over, the trees got to go. I don't believe in it. Leaving it up a certain amount of time that goes on fucking New Year. So Kar and Christina hates this because there's going to be needles everywhere and it's a big mess. Karl drags it out into the gravel driveway and this is with all the kids around him. He douses the tree with kerosene and tells them to stand back. There is one thing on this planet that you need to know. Zero is a dry Christmas tree. A Christmas tree is accelerant enough. We were in the woods once and I was a teenager and we found an old Christmas tree in the woods who must have been there for a year or two and we said, well, fuck it. Let's burn it. So we stood it up and let it on fire and these fucking flames were 50 feet in the air due from a dental tree. It was crazy. They burned. Oh my god. So hot. We knocked it over so it wouldn't set the whole woods on fire. It was crazy. That is those needles are crazy. Right now and the hottest thing you've ever felt. It's unbelievable. And this is still covered in tinsel too. So there's like non-natural things and that's going to be an accelerant also. So he did it. He fucking sparked it up. The tree went up quick and it's scared Katie, the youngest daughter. She got re-scared and also the other kids too. But Carl calm them down, pulled the kids away from it because they're like close to it and it went poof and they were like, oh shit. So he pulls them back. It is a poof. It's a crazy noise. It is. It's like when you light somebody's wool sweater and wear it and it goes poof and that goes out in half a second. This is. This kid's gone. Ronan. So he said, told him to calm down and said, nothing bad is going to happen. Now Aaron asked, why did you light it on fire? And he said, I wanted to show you how fast a fire can start. So he's saying, he's using this as a learning tool for the kids saying, look at this. They said, because if this tree was still inside the house and the lights got hot enough, it could have easily.
started a fire. So, this is just trying to show you how carefully you have to be with that. And Aaron said, "I already knew that." I learned from Smokey the Bear. He came to my class at school. I don't know what the hell you're telling me this for. They tell us. Smokey for paid to teach us things. Yeah. He said, "Well, you can't really know about fires until you see one for yourself. That's the only way to know." And he was real. This wasn't like a fun thing. This was real like, "You need it. This is serious, right?" So, he said, "Because the house can go up in an instant. It can blow up." Oh, wow. And he snapped his fingers and said, "Just like that. Boom." Sleep well, kids, and we tuck them in. You know, I poured on that tree. That's what's warming you right now. Well, imagine telling a six-year-old, not a five-year-old, and a four-year-old, "Hey, kids, anytime in the night, the house could burst into flames and blow up without us even having any warning." So the flames began to go out, and the Christmas tree was kind of just smoking at that point. And Levi said, "Is it going to burn anymore?" And he said, "No, it's only going to give off smoke now." And they said, "Are you going to light it up again?" And he said, "No, you'll let it fizzle out now." And they were like, "All right. I'm going back inside. Let's get into that." So, yeah. And she remembers Aaron said she remembered him trying to make it a lesson- like a learning thing. He was real serious about it. Okay. That's the morning of January 1st. 2.26 p.m. A 9-1-1 call comes in. Okay. Fire crews are dispatched to their home. Carl apparently had driven to a neighbor's house to call it in. Okay. And the people, the two neighbors, two older women who he ran across said he was frantically asking them to call 9-1-1 and get emergency people here. Okay. So the fire crew had a hard time finding- apparently Carl had a hard time finding people to help him call 9-1-1 because it's a sparsely populated area. And then the fire crews, they have their trucks on an icy steep winding road trying to get there. So they had a really hard time getting there. Yeah. It's not meant for that. So by the time they arrived, the Carl and Christina's house is completely engulfed in flames. It is a fucking Roman candle essentially. So the three small children are outside and in Carl's pickup truck. So he's got all three kids there. Carl is standing outside not burned or injured or anything like that. Okay. So who's missing? Mom. Where's mom? So Carl tells the first responders, my wife's still inside. Oh shit. Yeah. He said that he rescued the kids through the bedroom windows, but he said I couldn't get- I couldn't get to Christina. I can't get to Christina. She's in there. He said she's in the bathroom. So the firefighters go to the back door, but they can't get in. They can't get down. They get in the back door, but the hallway is completely cluttered with shit they can't get in. They can't even get past it. Oh god. Yeah. It's they called it obstructions. And I have a quote from the firefighter here. He said different people have different housekeeping standards. And there how there have been times when I would run into stuff, but I was never totally blocked. I don't know what kind of obstacles I was encountering that day, but it was enough that we couldn't go any further. So they just left shit in this back hallway. So they said they used all their might fucking- I mean, they had multiple firemen with adrenaline pump and trying to shove shit out of the way and they couldn't get beyond three feet into the back door. Damn it. Okay. So they backed out. They couldn't do anything else. So they surround the- Yeah. Surround the structure and put water on it until they get the fire out. That's it. That's the only way they can get it out to even try to find Christina. Oh god. Now the bathroom they saw from the outside, the bathroom had one window covered from frame to frame with a sheet of plywood that's still intact or still there and burned, but then there. Later on, Christina's father would count 17 nails in that nailing it to the- which is a lot of nails. It's firm. Yeah. That's firm, especially for something that's not permanent. You put four nails in if it's not permanent. Yeah. Well, yeah. That's now your window. You've made that. It's not going anywhere. No. So the only other way out of the bathroom was in the hallway. It's out that window or in the hallway and we'll talk about that. So the firemen, they get inside the house. Okay. This is, you know, they get the fire out and they break away pieces of Levi's room and pull because that's connected to the bathroom. That's the only way to get in. So they're pulling charred pieces of wall apart to get into the next room. They create an opening. They step through and they said they found what looked like the white rim of a bathroom sink. That's all charred and burned. Okay. In bad shape. So there, and I'll read from this book and I'll give you the title and author and everything later. They said it was there in a soot-filled cradle that Mills encountered a nude female body. The body was, she's cradled. Oh, it caught. Okay. Yeah. The, basically, the room is a cradle of soot. That's how they're trying to say the victim was slumped partially out of the bathtub, the head facing the ground. The skin was charcoal black. It was a, it was something he couldn't take his eyes off of the invest of the fireman. There was a distinct mark on the victims back, a bit of pink flesh peeking through the back char in the distant, in the distinct shape of a cross. He said it looked like it had been stenciled there. Oh, she was wearing her back. I think so. I think that's what happened. Now, Christina is not burned. Mind you. Oh, as we'll find out here. No, she's not burned. She died of smoke inhalation. Oh, damn it. She also has a washcloth over her face when they find her. She's trying to survive. She put a wet washcloth over her mouth. And yeah, it's, it's fucking brutal. So she's blackened by soot and char, though. And like we know the pink shape of a cross on her back. So yeah, we don't know what happened, but it looked like she, we find out later she was dead before the flames reached her. She was trying to get out of that window or something. We don't know what she was trying to do, but we know she was trying to cover her mouth up with a washcloth and not breathe in the smoke. So now the kids, they have an account of what happened to because everybody was in different places. Aaron, the oldest, said she woke up from her nap to her mother screaming and saw fire. So she woke up to fire and screaming. A dresser had been pushed in front of the girl's bedroom window that wasn't normally there. Okay. Now Carl broke the glass from the outside, shoved the dresser aside and pulled the girls out through the window from the outside. All right. Okay. He then put them in his pickup truck and then went for Levi. Yeah. And I'll give you more details in this in a minute here. So then according to Aaron, once he got Levi out of the house, he just stopped. She said that her father kicked the outside wall below the bathroom window, but he didn't try to pull the board off. Why would? Didn't do any of that. They said he watched the house burn. She said for a few moments. He watched the house burn. And she said, I didn't understand that my mother was behind that wall dying. He just stood there. And he just, he kicked the wall like he's making. Kick it like trying to kick. I don't know what it is. So, and that's from like a six-year-old too. So who knows what, you know, your mind perceives at that age. So Christina's dad arrives here because he had been small town. He had been told there's a fire at your daughter's house. So he came over. And when he showed up, there was a breathing tube wrapped around Carl and Carl said he felt dizzy and nauseated. So he was, you know, they were working on him. The back doors to the ambulance were not like, they weren't closed yet when Christina's dad pulled up. So he fully expect, he expected to see fire trucks, but he didn't want to see the ambulance freak them out because he didn't know anybody was hurt or anything. He said, I had two people come to my door that had scanners and they told me we think there's a fire at your kids house. And when I got went out there to the front yard, I could see the smoke. When I got there, I looked in the ambulance and Carl was there and the three kids too. And I looked around and said, well, where is Chris? And one of them said, one of the kids said, quote, she's gone to be with the angels. Oh lord. Holy fuck, that's dark. That is, my god, that's dark and grim. Holy shit. That means Carl told them that. We'll get to exactly what Carl told them. Absolutely. Well, we're going to dissect this whole thing here. So they obviously asked Carl what the hell happened? He's the only adult here. So he said, well, the children went down for a nap. And Christina got in the bath. I was watching the Rose Bowl and fell asleep. That's what he said. He said, but something woke him up from his snooze. He doesn't remember what. But he decided that there was some time she was getting in the bath. Kids were asleep that he could deal. He could fix something that was messed up in the house, basically. I'm going to go repair something. Chris had been been complaining that the heat
is not strong enough in the bedroom. It doesn't come out in the bedroom very well. The rest of the house is warm. The bedroom's cold. Karl likes it cold when he sleeps, so he hasn't been real. - There's no problem with that. - He's not in a real hurry to fix it, basically, but she has complained enough and out of where he says, "All right, fine." He's experienced with this. He does sheet metal work and shit like that. So he knows what he's doing. He's done a lot of heating jobs and stuff with arts company. So he said he figured that it was something wrong with either the insulation or the duct work, which seems like the first place you'd start. Is there power to it? Okay, now we'll check insulation and duct work. - Is it working then getting the air to the destination is the problem? - Yeah, so Karl goes out to the garage and brings in a heavy ladder, big ol' heavy ladder into the living room, 'cause he thought he'd need to crawl his way up into the attic, basically. But he gets all this, it's a big pain in the ass to unhook the ladder from the wall of all the shit in his garage and bring it in and squeeze it into the fucking house, 'cause it's a big bulky ladder. And you know, he's knocking shit off the coffee table on the dogs barking and you're like, - I got it. - Fucking damn it. - Oh God, I, yes. - They put my air filters in the tippy top corner of this fucking house. You have to put a 10-foot ladder up to reach the goddamn thing. - You remember my old house before I moved to New York? Do you remember the house, there was the one in the hallway that was like, it was 18 feet in the fucking air. - Doesn't make any sense why that's way up there. - Nothing anywhere near it. It's 18 feet, we had to get this giant ladder and oh, it was so terrifying. Every goddamn time we had to-- - And it's not on the bottom of a surface, like a lot of 'em are underneath like, you know what I mean, on a ceiling. - No, this is on the face of a wall at the highest fucking point of my house. - That's what I had to do. I was like, this is terrible, man. - I have a 12-foot ladder and I gotta carry that motherfucker through my house to get this thing done every three months and earlier sometimes, especially in the summer. - Yeah, in Arizona. - So goddamn dusty. - Fucking constant. Well, you gotta do it once a month in the summer. So Carl and didn't even end up using the ladder. So he wasted all this energy getting the fucking ladder in there. So he stands up on a chair to pull the attic hatch open. When she'd think he would know how high the attic hatch is and what he would need to get up there. But anyway, he said he could see the problem right away that the insulation on one of the wires was damaged. Okay, he said it was an easy fix. All he needed was a stretch of insulated copper wire. So he went out hunting in the garage, looking at his tools and cubby holes looking for piece of copper wire that he could do this with. Okay. He said he was out there for no more than five minutes. When he heard Chris yell, "Carl, get the kids." No, what he does is, what a lot of guys do, is he's like, "I'm in the garage." So she doesn't know I can hear her. I'm going to ignore her. - I'm not saying anything. - I won't say anything, he said. So he stops. Doesn't pay any attention. And he's looking for the wire. But he said at that point, he heard her yell something else. He heard her yell, "Carl, Holger, Holger, Carlson. Go get the goddamn kids." And he's like, "Uh-oh." Uh-oh, she got middle names involved, this is bad. So he said, "Fuck, I better do that." So he said that she's in the bath. He's searching around for parts and he doesn't know what's going on here. He set an electric light on the China cabinet near the bathroom as he left the house to go out to the garage, he said. 'Cause he had a light from going into the crawl space and he set that down. He said he noted that the hook on the top of the light was broken, that one of those that you hang, yeah. It's the hot ones. Yeah, oh yeah, that was a real hot. After about five minutes in the garage, that's when he heard his wife. He ignored her, then he heard his middle name and he was like, "Oh shit." He ran out of the garage and saw smoke pouring from the attic vents inside door. "Oh shit." So he's like, "Uh-oh, this is bad." Then he heard her yell, "Get the children." So he said, "Oh, fuck." And that's when he started running around, busted out the window, pushed a dresser aside, pushed a dresser aside, pulled his. - Micah-side? - Push that micah-side, pulled his daughters out, went and got Levi out and the same thing. And then he said, he threw them in the truck, drove down the rural road and, quote, "until he found two older ladies and asked them to call 911 and said that his wife was trapped." Okay, now, this is what he's taught. This is a detailed account of Carl going into the house and the fire and why he got the kids and how he got the kids and how Christina still tracked in there. He said, when he saw the smoke coming out from the roof vents, he's hard as pounding and he just. He said, he launched himself onto the front porch and was under Levi's window. The window was double locked and had a screen on it. So he said, he ripped out the screen off somehow, even though it was hot. And then he smashed the window with his elbow. - Okay. - Which at that point, he had sleeves on so you probably wouldn't cut yourself. The room was already filled with smoke and Carl could see a fire blazing in the hallway. Levi was covered by just a big smoke fucking cloud in front of him. He said all at once a patch of smoke cleared and he saw the faint outline of his son's figure. I don't know how smoke would clear in a house that's on fire currently. Just in a blanket just cleared, Matt. There's no breezes. It would only get worse, I would imagine. So Levi was curled up in a fetal position on the edge of his bed clutching his teddy bear that his mom had just made him. - Shit. - 'Cause he's a child. He's fine. Carl said with a swoop, he grabbed him, pulled him out but that the swoosh caused the smoke to ignite. I don't know, smoke doesn't ignite because, you know, embers to ignite smoke. - He fed the fire some oxygen. - That's it, yeah. So he said suddenly the fire was coming straight at them. He described it like it was like a dragon shooting flames at him. - Yeah. - Oh yeah. He said quote, "It was like we were in the movie back draft." - Oh yeah, that just came out. - Oh yeah, he said, "All I can remember is a grab Levi by the hair, I pulled, brought the hair, I pulled him out." - Got my child by the hair and like bull yelled at me, "Run, damn you, run, I don't know that movie at all." - You didn't see it? - I saw it once back. I hate those fat movies like that. I'm so bored by that. - Kurt Russell yelled at the bald one boys. - And I love Kurt Russell and I still couldn't tolerate it. It's a bunch of guys sitting around. - Well, they made a bald one brother, the hero. - Who cares? - Yeah, I got it, just never got into that kind of shit though. - It's fun movie 'cause it's just about robbing the pension, James, that's all the movie. - Yeah, yeah, I remember that. I just remember being bored by it, I don't know, it just wasn't until. - I liked it. - I was too young too for like the hero stuff, that it was just, it's just making firemen sexy, like they need any fucking help. - I haven't seen it since the mid 90s, but I don't think we need any to prop firemen up any more than they already are. - And the handsome bald one brothers get laid on top of the fire truck, it's crazy. - These are guys who spend most of their time watching pornography and eating and fucking cooking each other's shit and working out. We've made them the heroes of all heroes. They also do have to go in a building every once in a while going to kid out, which is the big hero thing. But, you know, so they are, they're fine. I'm not against firemen, but it's all right. Enough firemen propaganda, we got it. They're great people, and they're lovely. - They still won't go into a burning building until a lineman comes to the hospital power. - The other thing, yeah. I didn't want to say that 'cause I'm glad you did. - I'm glad you did. - 'Cause that's, a lot of signs of just go, yeah, we can't go in there. - We can't go in there, fucks the point then. Why are we here? But I know they have rules and regulations. Anyway, I pulled him out, and then the fucking, the ball of fire came toward us, and we were both blown back off the porch. - Oh dang! - Oof! - Yeah, like a dragon. Levi had some minor scrapes, a bloody nose, and things like that. Carl said he rushed the boy to his truck and yelled at him like an angry drill sergeant to fucking get, stay down in the wheel, not in the wheel well in the floor. - In the cab on the floor board. - Don't move. - Yeah. - So then he said, okay, went up for the girls, and with one push, he knocked the dresser over and found himself leaning halfway into their room with his legs dangling out the windowsill. - Good shove, yeah. - The girls' closet was near the hallway, and he could see them hiding in there with a blanket over them, these poor kids. So the smoke in their room wasn't as thick as their smoke and Levi's room, so he said he was able to motion to them. They could see him, so he was saying scream and for them, get over here, get over here. Grab your sister, he told the older one, and get over here, I need both of you to come over here and climb up here. So their dresser, they climb up on the dresser, Aaron helps Katie climb up there, and the two of them grab the father around the neck. He fell backwards off the window ledge and landed on the ground, but shielded his daughters from the fall, because they were like on top of him, and he fell on his back out there. Katie really didn't know what the hell was going on, 'cause she's four years old, so she's shrieking, and all upset, I believe, because she. If I'm not mistaken, because she only had one shoe on, that's right. - Oh, yeah. - This is scary. - Yeah, so now Levi, by the way, earlier, when Levi, this is what he told Levi, before he went to get the girls,
He said, "I want you to get on the floorboard and keep your ass there. You understand? If you get out of the truck, if you pick your head up, you're dead. You hear me? Don't move. Stay where you are." What? Yeah. He said though, later he only did that because he said the last thing I wanted was for Levi to see his mother running out of there with her skin all burned up as part of her on fire. He said, "I said a whole lot of things I shouldn't, but I needed to put the fear of God in him." That's what he said. When he got to the room that Aaron was saying, "Don't worry, Daddy's here, Daddy's here," and that made him feel good. He said, "The dresser slowed me down a little bit. I jumped up and kept trying to push the top over. I mean, it was really blocking me, but it didn't matter. I knew I was going to go through it." That's the dresser that had just been put there. The youngest is crying because she has one shoe on. He's saying, "Don't worry. We'll get you more shoes. It's fucking fine. Don't worry about it." The other one must smell like bacon for a while. It's going to. Carl's eyebrows are burned off, so he's looking like the fucking Mona Lisa at this point. But the girls are not hurt at all and really near it neither is Carl. He then threw the girls in the back seat and ordered them to stay put. He said, "You get down there with your brother. You keep your heads down. You don't look up." That's what he said. "Just stay down." So before he could slam the door, their Dalmatian puppy showed up at his side. So they walked out of the house and he just picked it up and threw it in the car with the kids and was like, "There. Fucking stay in there. Everybody in the car." That's where we're storing everything valuable right now right here. He said the last thing he needed was a dog running around while this is all going on. Carl then ran back to the house hoping he would find something on the ground that could help him break Chris out. He said, "Chris, can you hear me? Standing." He said he was screaming under the bedroom window and there's no answer. Now the bathroom window had the piece of plywood over it, which is why he was hoping to find a tool laying around the yard. The window got. I'm sorry. Yeah. So I guess the window had gotten stuck and Chris had broken the window trying to get it unstuck. That's how it happened. Which shattered the glass because he tried to pry it open with a plunger. Oh. Which doesn't work. I don't know the tool at all. No. So the bathroom window was higher up off the ground than the other windows in the house. A lot of those are the higher one because they got to kind of be above where you shit. So. Yeah. It's also because that's where the steam goes and the window you open it up and say you've bent the steam from the inside. Yeah. And also you don't want people to see your ass or your shit. See your shits. Yeah. Usually it's just your head sticks out there. So he scrambled around the yard. He said he couldn't reach it without the ladder. So he picked up a piece of broken fence post which he used to rip the screen off but the fence post wasn't strong enough to knock the plywood out because it has 17 nails in it by the way. He nailed the shit out of this. He said he needed some kind of axe for that. So he ran around to the back door thinking he could break his way into the laundry room but black smoke was pouring out through the cracks. He attempted to kick it down but the heat was too intense and he decided my best chance of saving Chris is going through the bathroom window. It's all I got. So he said by the time I got back around to the bathroom the whole front of the house had become a wall of flames. The house was caving in on itself and there was nothing I could do. Oh boy. So that's it. There was no way for him to reach Chris. So that's when he kicked the concrete foundation like his daughter said that because he was so frustrated after discussed after a minute or two he drove to the pickup and decided to drive away. He said the kids had been traumatized enough and he said quote put yourself in my spot. Would you let your kids watch the house fall in on their mother? No you wouldn't. You put the truck in gear and you drive away from that. I don't know about that. I don't know. It's a weird. It's almost logical. It's one of those where you're like I mean I guess. He's trying to put the kids first but in doing that they're out of harm's way in doing that. I'm going to try to save them emotional drama because I can't save that woman now and I know it. Yeah. Yeah. That's fuck man. So he drove to the neighbor's house to call 911 found the older ladies. They called 911 when he came back the house is engulfed and he said and all this while it's like I'm not hearing the wife. So I'm not Christina the wife the wife. So I figure okay she must have went out a different way. There's a back door. There was no help me untrapped. There was no screaming and pain or anything. So I figured she must have got out went somewhere. Now by the way he is going to the next day and we'll finish up this day but the next day the newspaper comes out and the Amador County ledger dispatch and he is a hero. Man who saved his fucking children from burning house. He's all hero. The fire district chief commended the father for the quick rescue of the children. He's a local. Yeah. A tragic figure and a heroic figure at this point. Yeah. It's heartbreaking. Everyone's picturing just running out of a flaming house with two little girls dangling off of him and I mean it's a puppy. Two little girls, a little boy and a Dalmatian puppy all in in his arms. It's a fucking Disney movie. It's ridiculous. The sun holding his neck like a cage while the dog runs next to him. He's got children and either are dog under one arm while the girls dangle from his shoulders. That's what it is. You know, ridiculous. I see the dog running alongside him with his tongue flopping out. That'll happen. That's true too. Yeah. I want somebody to draw that for us. Somebody who does like animation or some draw that for us. I'd love to see that. Just this heroic figure with the house. Everybody's smiling. Oh, there's no. Yeah. No, it's good. It's a Disney. No, it's Disney. New Disney. Yeah, but it's still Disney because mom's dead. Well, yeah, mom's got to die. That's why it's Bambi. Didn't Bambi die in a fucking forest fire, but Bambi's mom. Oh, no. She was shot by a hunter. Oh, she was shot by a hunter. Who died in a forest fire. There was some, there was some Disney movie. I mean, every movie somebody's parents. That's how he does every one of that explains why their parents aren't terrible parents just letting them wander the jungle or the woods or rather the fuck their home habitat is. No, his mom wasn't by something. Yeah. Frozen girls that parents died in a shipwreck. Yeah, yeah. It's only something you know. It's always fucked up. No one just, you know, had like vascular problems and didn't work out like that. Nobody had a poor diet. Your mom had a block deorta. That's what happened to her. Yeah. Just fucking tragic. Bambi's mom's in the crosshairs. No. Bambi's mom. Aneurysm. She just dropped, man. It was sad. Looking at her reflection in a brook. Deer text or something. Looking at her reflection in a brook, just licking it and fucking boom. Aneurysm. Got that. Got that. So the, by the way, people who knew Carl said he carried the clipping around with him in his wallet and showed it to everybody he met or talked to. Look at me. I'm a hero. Look at that. What's your name? Well, read about me. Yeah. Investigators noticed. He doesn't have any burns on him. His eyebrows are a little cinched, but that's easy. There's not like he's not covered in like bunch of burns like eyebrows are like wool sweaters. They will disappear in a second. Yeah. You have a little cigarette wrong and lost an eyebrow. No. No. No problem is once they go, they might not come back. That's the issue with eyebrows. That is scary. Because I know a girl who plucked them all and then they never came back. And so she had to draw them on forever and she's very sick. There's a series between tweezing and burns though because if, if, if a little fire hits it, at least the root still there, like, when you're still there, when you're yanking them out of your fucking face, you're telling your body, no, when your body eventually listens. Her pencil fell on the heater and she said, Oh, no, my eyebrows. And we all died laughing. We all laughed. So the pencil fell. It's a constant. She said, Oh, no, my eyebrows is what she said. We just all died fucking laugh. And this isn't like second period, too. So she had all day to go and fucking her eyebrows up. Did she mean they're not done yet? Or did she mean that? No, that's her eyebrows. That's my eyebrows. My eyebrows fell on the heater. Oh, no, my eyebrows. I'll never forget that. So that's so fucking funny. She's a cool checker. That's a fun exclamation. Oh, no, my eyebrows. And we looked and looked at her and just, just died laughing. So he has no burns. Now Christina's sister Collette comes over the next day and she walks around the ruins and finds something lying near the scene. She'll never, she'll never quite let go. She said, Quote, I went out to the house the next day and I'm looking around and there was an axe there outside the house. Remember Carl said if only an axe you could blast through a wooden window with an axe. Yep. So if Carl had really wanted to do something to get my sister out, he had a tool that he could have knocked the boards out with. So that's what she says and she wants answers too. She asked to see her sister's body. Let me see my sister and he said, well, this is a quote from her, quote, he told me she's a crispy critter. He said what he called his wife, dead wife, a crispy critter, critter. a crispy crust.
Critter to his wife's sister. Yeah. Krispy Critter. She said, and that was how he explained the death of my sister to me. I think that's the real Carl. I think very few people see that. Oh, she's a Krispy Critter. Why would you say that? So you don't want to see her because she's a Krispy Critter. Why would you say she's, you know, her body was damaged and I don't think it might be. I don't think you want to look at that. It's a terrible thing to look at. There's a lot of different ways. There's a million gentle ways to put that. Well, she's a Krispy Critter. She's been beer battered. You son of a bitch. Krispy Critter. Yeah. She's not a piece of calamari. Where are we talking about here? Yes. So you don't want to see her. Now Collette rather than start a fucking war with Carl, she shut herself up and said, well, I'll let the fire people investigate it. And I don't want to say anything because I don't want to be shut out of the children's lives, basically. So I'll do that. Collette ends up by the way telling different stories to different people, which is strange. He tells different people different stories. He tells them different stories of how the fire started, different reasons why Christina couldn't escape and different reasons why he couldn't save her to multiple people. In the police report here, they have Carl statement and he never details in the police report or at least it's not in the police report any efforts to rescue his wife from the bathroom. He outlined though a, this is, this is the information he gives and a lot of times you can tell where a person's coming from with the information they give, rather than what you ask them. What they dig out of them. Yeah. So he outlined mainly a string of coincidences that he thought led to the fire. So he's trying to explain the fire rather than giving. We'll investigate the fire. He said that you know, Christina broke the bathroom window with the plunger. So he boarded it up to keep the cold out. He said the water pipes had frozen. So he had hauled five gallon jugs of water inside. Now for the pipes to freeze, by the way, it's going to get cold, right? Like I know here where I live, like if you're, for your pipes to freeze, it has to be like less than 50 degrees in your house for a good amount of time for your pipes to, it's like it takes a while. Like you can't, if you keep it even 55 degrees in your house, do you fucking pipes aren't going to freeze? So I don't know how that happened, but 55. He said the night before the fire, Christina mistook a kerosene container on the porch for a water jug and brought it into the hallway. She brought five gallons of kerosene in the house. Who the fuck confuses a kerosene container with water? First of all, I don't know. You put kerosene in your sparklets jug? That's what I mean. I don't think so. So anyway, this is brought it into the hallway where they have a rambunctious puppy and a rambunctious cat who knocked it over. That's what he tells the cops and spilled two gallons of kerosene on the carpet. Two gallons. Wow. So minutes before the fire, he said he'd been fixing an attic fan and had laid a defective electric light on the china cupboard near the kerosene spill, which just happened to be right outside the bathroom where Christina was taking the bath. So yeah, now, okay. The kerosene, by the way, is one of the things they find. They do an investigation. They find the burned utility light that Carl would also blame later on. They found a smoke detector that appeared to be disconnected, which isn't good. They also found items that smell of kerosene. So Carl, a week after the fire, there's an investigator who tests the carpet in the hallway. He found out that he found that the carpet was well saturated with kerosene. Oh, boy. Really saturated. Now, days before the fire, obviously, he said that it had been spilled and whatever he said. Christina soaked it up with clothing and boxes, which is that how you clean? How do you clean kerosene up off a carpet with clothing and boxes? Cut it out and lay new carpet as I do it. There's no way to get that out. You start with paper towels, just to get the chunky stuff or whatever, and then you cut the carpet out, right? So he later said that the clothes dryer had been giving off fumes. Oh, from the clothes that she soaked it up with? I guess. Yeah. He said, "We did have a spill of kerosene. We had a kerosene heater that was broke. We cleaned it up days before the spill. I mean, yes, you smelled a little kerosene, but we saturated it with so much water. It wouldn't burn in a million years." That's what he said. Which is not how that works. No, it's the fuel. When it turns into a gas, that's when it's flammable. It's bad. I don't give a fuck how much water you pour on gasoline, it's still flammable. It's still in there. That's why. Yeah. So the fire officials determined the origin of the fire was directly outside the bathroom, probably in the kerosene. So that makes sense. Now this fire investigator, a week after the fire, tested the hallway carpets and found it well saturated with kerosene. Also noted that the bulb in the utility light had was elongated from the heat. Like it had melted from the heat. Those fucking lights, man. Which means, though, that didn't start the fire because it's not broken. It's melted down. Oh, it was upside down, too. And if it was elongated, it was stretch. Yeah, it was stretch. It means it melted and the glass got too heated and stretched. So or the plastic, whatever's on the outside, I assume, glass. So a lieutenant with the sheriff's office who he said that on its face, it looks like it could be an accident, but when someone dies, the default is to consider it suspicious until you know better, which makes sense. The investigators, he said, quote, the investigators weren't going to just accept that this was an accidental fire just based on his story they had to do more. So an investigator, who's interviewed later on a program, we'll talk about here, he described the finding. He said it wasn't a puddle. It was a poor is what they found in the pattern, okay? He said the most important evidence on this fire, there's an immediate poor of kerosene outside the girl's bedroom door and outside the bathroom door that it was ignited on purpose. I was positive that the spill pattern was deliberate. Yeah. Cause, okay. So yeah, a poor, a spell means it tips over and there's a puddle. A poor means there's like movement of the, of the two of the liquid. Yeah. You can make a trail and then light on fire and it's like an action movie, exactly. So he said also, if you aren't talking about, or if you are talking about an accidental spill of kerosene, what you should see is just a center like puddle of kerosene, but that's not what we have. So yeah, outside the bedroom door of the girls outside the bathroom door, but not near Levi's room. Huh. Interesting. So, and now that is the state farm investigator. The police fire investigators did not see that poor pattern at all at the time. The only one who saw it was Ken Busky, a state farm investigator, you know, cause for them it's money. He said he saw a horse shoe shaped burn pattern that include that, and that's what he concluded the fire was set. And he sent his report to state farm, but not the cops. So the cops think they've, they've just, they don't know that that's happened. So Carl told investigators, by the way, the board that the window was on, he told them that the window pain broke and he couldn't afford to fix it. So he boarded it up to keep out the cold. And you know, now different outlets reported different ways. ABC News reported that Carl saying he boarded it from the inside, but other people said that it was definitely outside and had 17 nails in it. And there are witnesses that said it didn't happen the week before. It happened either the morning of the fire or the day before. Oh, like really recently boarded this up right there. Carl said it was like a week, maybe less. And the thing was is that it's really easily, it's easily to come off. I mean, you've got adrenaline. Your kids are there. So he's like, she should have been able to knock it right out. Shouldn't have been the proper, yeah, not me, her, but she, she was being lazy in there and dying of smoke and elation all lazy. So Mike Carlson, Carl's brother comes out to try to help the family a little bit here. What he does is crazy, Carl, the funeral is on the 5th of January. He does not stay for the funeral. He does not go to his wife's funeral, didn't buy the headstone, nothing. He did nothing for her. Nothing, the service was held at a local elementary school. Her body wasn't there though. It was going for an autopsy. So they had to, you know, not bury a casket here with no, with nobody. Yep. So that night investigators heard that Carl Carlson, because they were like, where the fuck is he? Because the investigators go to the funeral. They were like, where the hell's the husband? They learned that he was planning to take his children
and leave the state for good the next morning, we're moving. So they rush from the funeral over there and show up at his house at 10 p.m. where he's staying to interview him again because they're like, if he fucking leaves and we can't talk to him. So yeah, and they said that Carlson's account of the events of the fire were the same as the prior interview. So that's all they got out of them. They also talked to six year old Aaron and this is like way past her bedtime and everything else here. Aaron gave an aversion of the events that sounded the same as what he did from what she knew. Aaron opened the bedroom door saw the flames in the hallway slammed the door pulled a blanket over her and her little sister and her father pulled them through a bedroom window and she said that she said that her father told them to lay on the floor after her father came back to the truck. She said that he told them that mommy wasn't heaven quote unquote yikes. Already told her that in the car on the way to call 911. He said mommy's in heaven before yeah, he didn't even know she slipped out and is in the backyard right now. You're going to get her help right now. Yeah. Now so the next day January that was the fourth is the funeral January 50 takes the three kids leaves New York and goes back to goes to New York from California. Christina's family literally went to had to go to the airport to meet them to say goodbye to the grandchildren. They didn't know they were leaving. They only heard it from the cops. So the one investigator said this is the sheriff's office guy. He didn't stay for any funeral services or purchased a headstone. He just packs up and leaves. That's right. Unbelievable. Now Carl's explanation was he said he couldn't bear to stay with his father in law because that's where he was sleeping. Oh yeah, I don't want art to yeah. And look at him every day knowing that he couldn't save his daughter's life. He said every day I would have to look at him and think he lost his daughter and I didn't save her. How do you do that? You just take the kids and leave forever. So so now his daughter's dead and her son-in-law is taking his grandchildren and going across the country leaving him to deal with this sheet metal business all on his own. All on his own. And a week ago everything was fine. Yeah. Yeah, dude. It's just a few days. There's literally. Yeah. The Christmas was great. So on the sheriff's report completed six days after the fire. Next to the entry that reads evidence of foul play, the deputy checked no. And next to further action, he checked no. In other words, case closed on R&D basically. Now they can't follow up. They said, quote, once he got to New York, it was virtually impossible at that point for us to follow up with him. We certainly would have liked to. Yeah, it was impossible. He said the sequence of events that he gave were just incredible for lack of a better term. You break a window in the bathroom so you board the window up. The solvent was there. The ignition source was there. There were so many accidents that just occurred to create this fatality and it just raised flags. Yeah. For a guy that like just gave his kids the lesson of how this house can go up so fast. That's more. He took zero precautions for this house to not go up and you know, let me put this hot light by the caracene spill and I'll be back in a minute. It's a crazy thing to say. Yeah. Here's a lesson to go into garage. In fire safety, while I'm just fire marshal bill just being reckless at every turn. It's put all these flammable rags in a pile over here. Yeah. Here. No, no, put the light next to the next to the soaked rags, but not right in the poor pattern. If we could just put it next to just we'll make a triangulation between the light and the poor pattern. Those drop lights are the ones that have the cage around the ball cage around. It's that metal around the bulb is fire. Hang on from the inside of your hood and your car and you're working on it. It's got a little hook on the tip of it. And he said that was broken so he's just setting it on shit. That thing's so hot. It's so hot. That's why it dangles from a hook. So it's got a plastic handle at the bottom. You don't touch the bulb. And those bulbs aren't just like house bulbs. They're like, I don't know how many watts of those. Yeah. They're hot though. They're crazy. So the other people who are suspicious are the owners of the home they live in, the Luceros. Uh-huh. They're longtime friends of Christina's father. They rented the house to Carl and all of that. And uh, yeah. So they're like, huh, interesting. They're suspicious. Joan Luceros said she was always suspicious of Carl's story. She said, quote, there was just too many holes. Yeah. One would be why didn't he try to pull his wife from the fire instead of driving away to call 911? That's the obvious one. Yeah. How could he afford a $200,000 life insurance policy on Christina when sometimes he couldn't pay the $300 a month in rent? Oh my God. And why did Carl's? Why did Carl abruptly move back to New York less than a week later? So, um, the investigators here, they're looking at some stuff and they start looking into, because the fire is deemed fine by the fire investigators. But now the detectives are looking into other shit. They start looking into the insurance stuff. Yeah. The policy on Christina was issued 19 days before she died. Everything's right. Yeah. Carl's explanation was, quote, we'd been in talks with the insurance company for probably four or five, five months. I had no debts. That's what he said. So it's like, it wasn't just a, I didn't, I didn't have debts that I needed insurance money to pay off. It's not like I owed them off the money or something. And he said, this was, I tried to get it in October and they just took this long. So it's just a coincidence. All right. But insurance is generally for, for, to protect the debts that you have because this person died, you can't pay the debts any long. If you have no debts, what do you need that much insurance for? That's a good point. And that's what they're suspicious of. But his point was, I didn't do it to get money to pay something off because I didn't have debts. Yeah. Because they're saying, you can't say I needed the money because I didn't need, I didn't know anybody shit. That's what he was saying. But he's defending himself. That's a defensible yeah answer rather than an answer. Yeah. So that's why they're suspicious. So a month later, Carl's Carl calls the Cal fire investigator Carl Kent. So we got Carl Carlson calling Carl Kent. He calls from New York and says, listen, I have a theory for you. He said, I'm pretty sure it was the utility light that started that fire because that's what I think that you guys aren't getting there. I need you to understand how off they are. I told you, I put a utility light next to the oily rags in the pile of kerosene, you know, in the fucking kerosene coped coated carpet. I thought everybody knew how hot drop lights get on accidental kerosene spills. Yeah. He said that so they said that Carl Kent, the investigator said the bulb had stretched and elongated, which happens when a bulb is near a fire, not when it starts one. Oh, it's still covered that. Yeah. It's not charter broken. Therefore, it was close by, but not in the fire in the fight didn't start at that. That makes sense. He said, yeah, then he told other people, it was the pets that knocked over the kerosene can. Then he told somebody else that the dryer might have started a fire, which is not even near there. And then in another telling, he said, he tried to reach her, but the flames were too high. So he was like, at the room, he said, he couldn't get in there. And then another person, he said, he had burns from trying to save her, which he definitely didn't have. So March 3rd, 1991, Christina's death is officially ruled an accident accidental autopsy found soot in her lungs and no sign that she'd been hurt or incapacitated before the fire. So he didn't like beat the shit out of her throwing her room into the house on fire. But it didn't say in the death ruling how the fire started because those are separate issues. Now, this Carl Kent wants to interview Carl Carlson, but he's 3000 miles away. And basically this small department doesn't have the money to send an investigator to upstate New York. They just can't afford it for, for the Carl party and we can't afford it. We can't afford it. So, and Carl said, Carl Kent said the DA's office said it was a good circumstantial case, but there wasn't enough to prosecute at that time. And they didn't think that sending a guy out there was going to get him to like make a confession. So they're like, what's the point? You're going to go out there waste your time and fly home stupid. So state farm didn't want to pay. The agent who sold the policies recommended denying the claims citing the suspicious circumstances of the purchase 19 days before the death. And the investigator that state farm hired concluded the fire was set deliberately based on the horseshoosh of shape burn pattern. But since no one has ever charged with anything, state farm has no choice but to pay out, they have to. And one of the investigators said, I've worked with insurance investigators and if an arrest is not made, insurance companies are not going to deny the claim. They can't. So the check is reportedly for $200,000. That's what he gets. Okay. This is like a year later January 31st 1992. He gets this. Okay. Now, after this, by the way, down the road, about seven years, state farm, state farm, because they do it every seven years, destroys the file and throws
out the carpet samples with the kerosene on them. And Cal fire destroyed most of the file about the same time as well. But Clark, Clark, Carl Kent kept a portion of it for himself just for his own records. Okay. June 1991, the landlord's file a lawsuit, the Luceros file a lawsuit against Carl. For what? Well, it's for a negligence lawsuit. It's basically just to force him to return to California for a deposition. And he does return and is deposed. So now everything's official now. It's on the fucking record. And yeah, and the Calvarras County office of the of the Luceros attorney said, quote, it happened at his office, he said I was hoping when he came back into California, they would reopen the investigation, but that never occurred. Now the Luceros were awarded $7,500 for the damage to their house. It's gone. It's fucking gone. Your house was worth $7,500 bucks. Wow. The front and center of the three bedroom house were gutted. And the fire officials estimated the damage at $80,000. Oh, no. And Joan said the house was not insured. So they got $7,500 and that's it. They got fucked. Yeah. Wow. That's crazy. So I'm sorry. And they didn't even get that, by the way, that is what the judge awarded them. But does Carl have $7,500? If not, they're not getting it. Yeah, they might pay him who knows? So back in New York here in Varick, New York, Carl bought a section of the family farm from his parents with his insurance money. He bought a piece of the farm. The property sits on Yale Farm Road in the town of Varick, which is between a couple of lakes there. As a hobby, he raised Belgian draft horses on his farm. No idea. I don't know why. But it sounds exotic. And it sounds they sound like a Clydes d'Alie. Like they have a very happy horses. Yep. I think that's what the, but I don't know. They sound big and stocky though. Belgian draft horses. Yeah. They sound expensive. Yeah. He said, and he said, what's wrong with this? He said, I collected the insurance money. What did I buy with it? A house for my kids. I didn't go get some 18-year-old girlfriend. I bought a fucking house for my kids. What am I supposed to do? I live in the street with them. His brothers are wild. They're all weird. Krispy Critter is one of his answers. What a weird guy. Yeah. He says his brother. Now Mike, his brother, Carl's brother, said Carl came from California and was a different guy than he used to be. He was stoic, emotionless, and controlling, crazy controlling, especially with his kids. He said he kept his kids away from their cousins, wouldn't let them hang out, which was real weird. So the brothers ended up drifting apart here. Even though they were so close, his brother came out there and helped him move back. Now, 1993, two years after the fire. He meets another woman. Woman named Cindy Best. This is the meets him up in Seneca County. Apparently, I think it was a bar they met at or something to do with dancing a bar. Carl told her the story, everything about it. She said, first time I met Carl, he pretty much told me his story of how his first wife died in a fire. Now, he had three children and he was raising them by himself. I just felt real sorry for him. Of course she did. That's why he told you. That's his sympathy for his wife. Oh, this is his line. So they get married that year by 1993, but the end of the year, they're married. They end up having a son named Alex as well. Now, the girls really take to Cindy. They like Cindy and they want her to fill in. Levi, not good. Levi missed his mother. Well, not interested in Cindy. No interest. Cindy said that was kind of hard trying to get Levi to be close to her. She noticed pretty early on that Carl lied sometimes, bit of a liar. She caught him in lies about bank loans and overdraw on accounts. They fought about money all the time. She said he spent first and worried about bills later. Yeah. An investigator later said, if you gave him $20, he'd spend 40 somehow. So that's the guy he is. That's him. He always also had a get rich quick scheme in the book still and something in the works always, always trying to figure out a way to scan the system here. So now Levi is the most effective of everybody. The two girls seem to move on better than Levi does. Levi has a hard time. Cindy said he was kind of a mama's boy and he missed his mother terribly and she could understand. Yeah, girls look to mom for to dad for protection and boys look to mom for comfort. That's what's very usually works. Mother's very important to a boy. So she said he was definitely the hardest of the kids to win over. People close to Levi said he had nightmares for years about the fire and about his mother screaming. So he said he heard his mother fucking screaming whereas Carl was like, I don't know. She's quiet in there. Yeah. I figured she got out. That's that's a difference. Now after the move to New York to the kid said the beatings started. This is when the beatings came. Oh, he's aggressive. Big time. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Aaron later said that called a multitude of instances of especially Carl physically abusing Levi. She said he used this is disturbing, man, especially for a poor, a little kid who lost his mom and was in a traumatic event like that. He used cattle prods, pipes, shovels and pitchforks. Really rigid, hard instruments that like if you set like if there was a Frankenstein was in town and you said, get them and everybody that's these are the implements you'd grabbed and then get torches and chase him through the streets. Frankenstein's monster was with the cattle brought or is he? Yes. Electrifying them with the cattle brought either way. Bad. That's not sure. So I mean, I think there's other things you could hit him with. If you have something that's got electricity and that's what you're using that. Yeah. He said most of it happened in the barn and Aaron said Carl would send the kids to their rooms before a beating so there was no witnesses. He would send the girls you go to your room and then take Levi out in the barn and abuse him. Oh my god. She said he threatened them about calling for help. If you tell anybody about this, you're in your next. Wow. She said that he told them they would be dead by the time the police got there. That's what she said. He said, I'll kill you both. Aaron said, Levi would get beat with anything that my father had within reach. Wow. This is horrifying. This poor kids. So guess what? Anything at all. Anything. Whatever. Yeah. He grew into, guess what? A real rebellious kid. Is that right? Weird. You get a kid. Have them have the most traumatic thing happened to him. Lose his mother in a fire that he's a part of. Then you don't take him to any therapy. Then you beat the shit out of him. Wonder what's going to happen. It's rageful. Get out. Weird. Yeah. He loves. He's the picture I saw of him. He's got a slayer t-shirt on. He's into metal. He's fighting with his dad constantly. He's always spending time outside the house. Yeah. That's who he is. He's like one of the kids. One of Christina Applegate's brothers friends and don't tell mom the babysitter's dead. That's who he turns into. I figured if he wanted her boyfriends unmarried with children. Either way. That too. Same. Same guys. Yeah. So he fought constantly. Levi told his father that he believed and he didn't. Wasn't shy. He told his father, you killed my fucking mother. I think you did it. And Aaron said that she and Levi both told him to his face that they thought he killed their mother. Levi said. Wow. He's got nothing. We're going to do. Beat me again. That's what it comes to. You turn into you turn in the fucking Judd Nelson from breakfast club. You know what I'm saying? You know what I got for Christmas? A carton of smokes. Carton of cigarettes. I'm sorry. He said, "Here smoke up, Johnny." There you go. That's what's going on. Yeah. Sure. I love it. Show them the burn. Yeah. So I got you for the rest of your natural born life. So yeah. So anyway, that's what they said. Aaron remembered everything and she said that it just nothing added up. She said, "Yeah. Levi and I told our father we knew that he murdered our mother." Carl's reaction was not being mad or even being, your feelings would be hurt if you didn't do that. Wouldn't you be hurt? Christ, I'm hurting too. I lost my wife and I've been raising you fucking kids and now you think he killed her. Yeah. God, day. I think it was easy being a single father. But anyway, his biggest concern was what would the community think? What is everyone around that knows me going to think if my own kids are accusing me of this? Shut up. Keep your mouth shut. I don't want anybody accusing me. At one point Levi and Carl got in a pretty violent fight over Levi's accusations and Levi leaves the house at 16.
Yeah, gone. So he's out now fall of 2002 there is a barn That on the property on his farm that burns down in the middle of the night. Oh, his barn burns down That's three fires so far. So a lot of fires around him three of Carl's Belgian draft horses died in the fire Oh shit those expensive ones very common. Yeah, so many more horses die in fires than any other mammal on earth because they're in shard And that happens a lot See, the sopranos with Ralphie. Yeah, I mean, that's what that very stinky fire. It's bad. So Carl had woken Cindy and said he could hear the fire crackling from their bedroom window And that's how he was alerted to it. He ran out to fight it while she called 911 Now Cindy'd been awake too and she said I didn't hear any fucking crackling. Well, he's talking about um She said that you she knew that to see the barn from their window you had to turn and look back You couldn't just glance out you had to know to look it. It was a specific way you had to look out And now one of the horses here Um was his prized mayor ginger and Cindy said she knew that Carl did this on purpose And she spent years wondering why would he kill an animal? He loved he didn't understand it She just didn't get it why he would do that She said it took her a long time to understand what Carl was all about and she didn't get it yet. Um Now He gets a payout The barn is uh There's different accounts ranging from 80,000 to 115,000 dollars. Yeah Now Carl later on says he only got 60,000 dollars and lost 365,000 dollars worth of stuff. So that's proof that I didn't do this The barn was only insured for 90,000 and I had 365 365,000 worth of shit. So why would I burn it? Oh, I'll be does The 365 you can't get back out of it unless you burn it. There you go. So Christine's family they shut the fuck up again Uh-huh Collette the sister said we made it very clear that um To Cindy they warned Cindy they called Cindy and said we made it very clear that she should probably be careful Um, Cindy doesn't listen though. Obviously Um, why would you listen to your husband's old wife sister? You don't know this fucking lady So Levi in 2003 gets married at 18 years old wow to get away from all this shit um He marries Cassie hone h-o h-n and uh, they're gonna have two daughters over the next few years. Oh Aaron and Katie also grow up and move away from varic as well from the town Levi stays in the area But doesn't live with them um Carl worked basically at this point to make sure the daughters didn't like their stepmother for some reason I don't know why they she would do that But he seems to like to stir it up a little bit here. Keep people separated Control. It's a easier way to control So the other thing too there's a all this craziness is going on But there's also a sense of like normalcy here because they they get a kid from New York City From the fresh air kids foundation where they send city kids out to farms for a couple weeks to yeah Or they used to do that in the seventies and shit all the time. Well, I don't know. It's shit about this You never heard about that. No. It's a big program. They had it everywhere all over the country where they take city kids And they put them go take them out to a farm for a couple weeks So they could see what it's like to not live in the middle of it so they could see grass and trees and shit If you live in the south Bronx, you haven't seen any is it like just to see it or is it like a word there? Where you go there and and stay for I don't really farm, but you go stay it's like an exchange But you just go stay with some family for a couple weeks and maybe if they go out and farm you do some farming or you just hang out on the On the farm and eat decent food and you know play in a yard and do all that kind of shit. I think So that's all they do here Now the Carl Sins, they're not paid to do this. This is just a volunteer program So it's very nice that people do this so they get a boy that comes out it was Cindy's idea And this kid stayed with the family in the summer of 2003 and then came back in the summer of 2004 Fuck he loved it He loved it. So Carl treated this guy nice and While this kid was there everything was normal enough for this kid to want to come back again Or maybe things are worse where he is. I'm not sure I could be worse You maybe his mom's a crack head. We have no idea. So this is just cattle prods up here Maybe I look a pitchfork once in a while So I guess this kid was terrified of the animals when he first got to the farm But then he got into it and he loved horses after that. So now One of Carl's business plans Ducks Yeah You're you're looking at me like well how the fuck is that a business plan? How do you make money on that? Okay, that's exactly what I thought too. Yeah, I'm glad you looked at me like that How do you sell this? Yeah, obviously ducks You don't want that on your property because the duck shit is everywhere Well, it's a farm though. So I mean, they should ever learn anyway. Okay, you got a farm He wants he wants to raise gourmet ducks Not ducks that are real discerning about what they eat but ducks to be served in gourmet environments Um, only served ducks that eat as cargo Yeah, that's what I like there Raised on the farm and sold to restaurants Away from the farm at Hudson Valley and New York City basically Um, and he said this is it. I'm gonna be a millionaire I am the best ducks They're all gonna come to me for ducks basically. Yeah Um, now this is how it ended Carl had thousands of ducks and nobody wanted to buy them Ha Nobody wanted his ducks No When he hasn't realized is all of these restaurants have suppliers right these things yeah And places that serve duck too, that's a high-end item. Yeah, they have very specific suppliers of certain Things I know in New York City. There's like a few that they would go to for something like that So it's not a high-demand meat Way in the ones that are it's very much they needed to be They go to a company that guarantees it's a certain way and if not you can get your money back or they'll send you more ducks Whereas this is just some guy in a farm going you should come to my farm. I got a shitload of ducks up there You can fucking eat them. It's great finger-like duck man. Yeah So he has no buyers. So what he does is he kills all the ducks himself and leaves their carcasses to rot on the farm Just butchers a thousand fucking ducks and leave them there. Just massacres ducks Massacres ducks and leaves in Iraq That's what he does That's a He could have given them human being that's capable of that he could have given them Kill a fucking shitload of ducks. That would be horrible I would have a thousand Whatever it was. Yeah thousand ducks or some shit a lot of ducks. So Hundreds of ducks. We don't know. Yeah now He's tried other get rich crack schemes including at the the duck farm He's had some truck scheme some tractor thing. He was trying to pull off all right Cindy has no idea she says I she thinks this is where all the money goes to his get rich quick scheme. She doesn't know He spends coke about money like a co-cat. That's a problem like he just Throws it out. You give him 20 health fat 40 Wow So he one of the investigators said he blew through Most of this money to this get rich quick scheme here So That's that Now by 2008 what does Levi up to? Well, at this point, he's a single dad. He's working blue collar jobs. Yeah, not a lot of money 23-year-olds with two kids He turns to his father and they were they started to make up with each other Which I don't know how if you if you're positive this guy killed your mom I don't know how you can ever make up with him but Whatever um Carl help Levi get a job at the local glass factory Which at least is a solid and decent paying jobs Levi would do odd jobs around the farm just to help his dad out You know the sister Katie said his life was on the on an upswing at this point. Right. Um because as a matter of fact In 2008 and over the summer, I believe he fell in love with another young woman named Jennifer And the two of them were planning to be together Right in the future. So everything's great now November 3rd 2008 Carl takes Levi to the Seneca Falls savings bank to meet an insurance agent Okay, they wanted term life insurance $400,000 in base coverage plus a $300,000 accidental death rider Okay, so there's an accident because he works at a glass shop sure Which I had a friend that worked at a glass shop and came this close to dying when his entire lower path of his body was Burned with denatured alcohol which burns clear. Yeah, you don't see flame So he didn't know he was on fire for a long time and he had to get he was in the hospital for months He had to get skin grafts cover. It was a wow. It was a miracle. He didn't fucking die I mean, it was crazy that he didn't die and then he turned into a Jesus freak and a fucking tried to get us in a multi-level marketing scheme Yeah, anyway. That's what happens when you get burned So that's that's glass is dangerous work. I can lead to Jesus later. You never know So if he died of natural causes it's 400 grand an accidental death 700 grand Car is the beneficiary
Sure. Yeah. Dad needs. Oh yeah. Carle himself pays the first premium in cash. Now the whole deal was that Carle would manage the money for Levi's daughters if anything happened because Levi didn't trust his ex-wife to handle it. So he let his dad distribute the money to his kids. There was only one more thing. Levi is scheduled to undergo a physical exam on November 21st as part of it. Now Cindy didn't know any of this was going on and she just said, quote, I just trusted my husband and this insurance agent that they were setting it up best for Levi's daughters. She doesn't really know the details. November 20th, 2008 at the family farm in the morning. Carle and Levi went back to the bank this time to notarize a one-page handwritten will from Levi. This makes Carl the executor gives him power of attorney and leaves all of Levi's assets to Carl. Yeah. I don't know either. To then distribute to the kids. Now, later on that afternoon, Carl had a truck based a farm truck, I guess. And it would break down all the time and it was up on a jack under the jacks under the front bumper. The front wheels are off and Levi's underneath that he's working on the brakes and the transmission lines and all that kind of shit. Now, I guess this truck doesn't get used very often but it needs to be fixed up. Carl's out there also but he's not helping work on the truck because he is in a suit and tie dressed for a funeral because Cindy's aunt had died and they're about to leave to go to the service. So Carl walked out of the garage and went to the funeral with his wife. Yeah. There they go. They leave. He's working. Now, Levi is texting quite a bit that day. Jennifer, his girlfriend, said that on the morning of the 20th at 11.30, she received a text from Levi asking if he could quote, "Have me forever." So long-term shit here. I keep you forever, the little cast per phrase. Yeah. She texted back, yes, which is quite the rich reply. That's better than no, but it's not exactly what you need something there. Sure. Sure. What the hell? And then they said, "I love you back and forth." Then Jennifer stated that she sent a bunch of follow-up texts and Levi didn't respond. So now she was pissed off because she thought he was playing fucking head games. You don't even have you forever. I love you. Now you don't answer my fucking text. So then about 4 p.m. a 911 call comes in to the barrack office there. Carl and Cindy came home. Cindy saw Levi's truck still in the driveway and just went inside. Carl went into the garage. Two seconds later, he's banging on the kitchen window yelling for Cindy to call 911. Uh-huh. And the 911 is what your emergency. Cindy said, "I think I need an ambulance." She doesn't know what the hell's going on. She just got yelled at. They said, "Okay, what's going on?" She said, "A truck fell on my stepson." Oh, no. The dispatcher said, "A truck fell on your stepson?" And she said, "Yes." And we just got home and I don't think he's alive. He's pinned underneath the truck. My husband's lifting up the truck. Honestly, I don't think he's alive. And they said, "Is he breathing?" Which is the dumbest fucking question after I don't think he's alive. Probably not. Yeah, he's breathing fine, but I think he's dead. This would be the dumbest answer ever. But you never know how stupid people are. True casual ass breaths. I think he's dead. Yeah. Cindy said, "No, he's not breathing." And they said, "Okay, start CPR." And they're trying to, but he's trapped under a truck. There's no way to even do that. Now inside the garage, um, the truck was, had was raised up on a single jack under the front bumper. The jack had come out and the truck had tipped off. And remember, it has no front wheels on it. So it just slams down on the roaders. Yep. So Levi was underneath the goddamn truck, obviously. Carl and a neighbor got the truck off of Levi. His chest was completely crushed. Cindy said it was concaved. Oh, fuck. The horrifying. Everything's broken in there. Everything. He's liquefied to the side. Yeah, take a bag of bones and just smash it against something and see what you got. The moisture that's happening. Trucks are so heavy and you can't pinch. You pinch off a body. It's just gonna give way everywhere. This is like an old steel farm truck, too. This is a big corner. Some shit. Yep. So Cindy said that, you know, that and then responder said you could see he would have been dead for a couple hours. Like he wasn't didn't just die. He's dead. When the paramedics arrived, according to them, Carl was banging his head against the garage wall. And he later said, quote, it killed me. I cried like a baby out in that barn. Anybody would tell you, I like to beat my son in the barn, not watch him get killed by a pickup truck. Anybody would tell his sentences are sincerely just so bizarre. And they're very confident in terms of I said this, you should believe me. Yeah. Anybody you'll tell you or this or that, he likes to put it on qualifiers that are like, you're put it on you for not believing him because it's crazy to not believe him. Now Cindy, she said that, you know, they were coming back from the funeral. We pulled in the driveway. I saw it was in the same spot. Went into the house right after that. Carl came, was banging on the kitchen window and crying and hysterically telling me to call 911. That's all she saw. So Carl appears distraught. He told the sheriff deputies the same story. He found the truck and toppled off a jack and trapped his son. He told the medical personnel that when he left, Levi was alive and working on the truck. And that's that. So the deputies have no reason to doubt any of this. Yeah. One of the guy from California says the officers at the scene didn't see anything out of the ordinary. They saw what appeared to be two grieving parents and what appeared to be a horrible accident. Yeah. Makes sense. The family doctor signs off on the death as accidental. No autopsies even performed. Wow. He's found under a truck. It's pretty obvious what happened. You can't really weigh anything in there. It's all just a mess. It's all mush. Now Katie, the youngest daughter, she said she sums it up and just says her whole childhood was a parade of bullshit and disasters. She said this was our life. It was just one bad thing happening to us after another. Terrible. Poor kid or poor lady at that point. Now Christina's parents, they hear about this in California that the grandson's been killed, obviously. And Christina's mom said I felt really bad, but I didn't think it was an accident. I thought it's happened again. And the sister said, quote, this is Collette, I knew Carl did it. I don't know how I didn't know what he had to gain, but I knew he did it. And then Aaron said the daughter, the oldest daughter, I knew as soon as I heard that Levi was gone that my father had done it. I knew with every fiber of my being. Holy. He is fooling nobody, except the only people that count here, which is the people who could put him in jail. Yeah. Yeah. If his ex sister-in-law thinks he did it, that means nothing legally. And it's because the police are exposed or investigated or exposed to him in little blinks where he's got it all cord and rough. That's how you start a family is just by having little blinks and you can, you can get somebody to love you for a second. Yeah. Well, plus he keeps everything separate. Like he takes the kids, puts them in a room, takes Levi out to beat him. It's the same thing. He keeps everything quarantined from everything else because that way he can control things. He's like how Elizabeth Holmes ran Theronos. Yeah. Like just keep everyone separate and that way I can control everything they know, think and do. Right. So the second they get around each other, there's a prop. It's over. But the only people that matter here are the cops, basically. So December 2008, about a month after Levi died, Carl appears in surrogate's court to handle his son's estate. He told court officials, Levi did not have a will accept, yeah, accept the will that he had personally driven to the bank and had noterized the morning by tide. We said doesn't have one. Now, after Levi's funeral, Carl came home from town with an envelope. Cindy remembers him saying that Levi had an insurance policy and she thought it was strange for a 23 year old to have life insurance already. Then in early 2009, the check arrives seven hundred seven thousand two hundred and ten dollars. That's an enormous check because he got the extra three hundred. Right. The qualifier of accident. Yeah, the accident. So now the kids didn't know that. The kids knew he had told the kids they had a small policy, but it was barely enough to cover the funeral. That's what he told the Katie and Aaron Levi sisters. Cindy said the statement started coming in and the numbers didn't look right. She realized that he was not giving the money to Levi's daughters. He was just, he had set up annuities and he's just draining them. He even did a thing where he spent like $60,000 in penalties to get money early. Oh my god. Yeah, because it's all found money to him. Cindy said as time went on, you know, some of the statements would come through when the numbers didn't look right. Then Cindy found out about the other policies that Carl had taken out on Levi's two little girls. He took out policies on his granddaughters through
$350,000 each. - Oh my God, those girls are so dead. - With Carl as the sole beneficiary. - Oh my God. - Yeah, one account said the premiums were funded with about $60,000 of Levi's payout. - Oh my God, this is just how he's gonna live life? - This is gonna kill people. He's gonna be like Geraldine Parrish in the homicide book. We all do a bonus about that, but she had a whole thing. We're like 50 people, she had insurance policies on it. But this is family, he's just killing his family. - He's gonna get all the way down to a four-year-old and a six-year-old girl. Because that's what Levi has. - He's a prized man. - Levi's ex-wife said, "Who the hell puts that kind of life insurance "on a four-year-old and a six-year-old?" - Right. - What do they worth? They're not worth anything. Like they're really, they're worth the most. Like you could sell one for the most or they are the most emotionally of one of them dies and hurt you the most. But in terms of hard money, five-year-old ain't worth shit. They have no earning power, no potential. - Yeah, monetarily. They're contributing fucking zero to this house. - They're a drain at this point. - Yeah. So 2010 comes around two years later, a year and a half. And Cindy's starting to be pretty suspicious of Levi's death here. - Okay. - She starts to suspect Carl. She thought about the barn and the window that you had to turn around to Seattle and say that he knew that fire and the barn was going on ahead of time. - You should've thought about it. - You should've thought of a fire. We'll get your attention. But was it during the day or during the night? The no. - No, and she didn't notice it and she was right next to him. So that's why she's like, there was nothing to notice. You had to turn around and look and the whole deal. So then she thought about the truck that Levi was working on because it wasn't important. Nobody used the truck. It was just sat there. Didn't need transmission and break workers who gave a shit basically. Then she hired a private investigator because she thought about Levi and all the things he went through and boarded up window and she talked about the three different stories. She heard him tell about it over the years. She said I'd better hire a private investigator and she found out that Carl had an insurance policy on her as well. - She didn't even know. - For $1.2 million. She's the dentist of everybody. - Oh, dead holy shit. She said I'd be worth $1.2 million to Carl if I was dead. - So they end up finding an investigator finds every penny of the $707,210 was spent. - He blew it. - He blew it in a couple of years. Unfucking believable. - Buying new policies that he was gonna get rich on. - That's right, it's Crack Carl. They withdrew the money. The investigator said everything is gone. It was a little bit at first. Then it got to the point where it was a feeding frenzy and he talked about the early withdrawals and 60 grand in penalties for that. So Cindy said now she's in fear for her life. She's still sleeping with Carl, but she keeps scissors and pepper spray under the mattress where she can get to it and a knife under there too. So she's got scissors and knife and pepper spray all lined up under the mattress that she can reach to. Which if you wake up on fire, that's not gonna help you. - No. - Nobody that he doesn't confront anybody or strangle them or anything like that. It's gonna be a way that you never thought it was. That's what it's gonna be. You're gonna be in the basement and the door won't open and then the whole house will burn down around you or some shit. - And all of a sudden. - You never know. - Rames are licking at you. - Yeah. She had panic attacks. She told a friend everything and said, "Tell me, please tell me I'm crazy." And the friend was like, "No, that sounds perfectly same." - You're crazy at all. - Damn it. She said I was living with fear, looking over my shoulder and I had to sleep in the same bed with him, which was horrible. I kept scissors and pepper spray under the mattress, in case something happened in the night. 2011, and they have a kid too. They have a young child, remember. So 2011, Cindy can't take it anymore and she leaves and takes her son, Alex, and takes off. - Yeah. - Out of there. Aaron and Katie, by the way, she said, had turned against her by then, encouraged by Karl. - Okay. - So she can't control the girls. - He was about to kill her. - That's what it looks like. - She wanted to go to police, but she doesn't have any evidence of anything. Well, she, my husband has a life insurance policy on me as an evidence of anything. So, then February 2012, Jackie Heimel, as the name, H-Y-M-E-L, Jackie. It's a relative of, it's identified as Levi's cousin, but then someone else identifies ABC News. Oxygen identifies this person as Levi's cousin, but ABC News describes this person as Cindy's cousin. So somebody's cousin calls. - Is that the fam? - Yeah, they get, she calls the sheriff's office, the Seneca County Sheriff's Office in New York and said there's a good chance that Levi, Carlson, was murdered by his father. So they said she talks about the fact that Carl had made money off Christine's death and that Christine's children never saw any of that money. Which I mean, they saw it, they lived in a house, so they did. Now the cops look into it. They take it seriously. They take the call, they look into it, but there's a couple of problems. Number one, Levi's death was four years ago and it's already been closed as an accident. There wasn't even an autopsy. Nothing, the truck has long been moved. There's no more crime scene there. There's nothing like that. And the second problem is Carl. He has no criminal record whatsoever. None, he was a farmer with draft horses and a sad story about his wife dying and his kids being sad and all this type of shit. And they said that from the outside, it looks like this poor bastard who lost both the wife and his son and keeps trying to move on and persist with his life here. Then though, he said the family members, the dollar figures and the suspicion, he said I couldn't stop looking at it this investigator. Then they also figured out too, nobody investigated the Levi case because he looks in the file and he's looking into it and the responding officers just saw two parents crying in a truck and a family doctor saying looks like an accident. So no one even photographed the jack placement for the file. Nobody photographed anything. They didn't treat it like any kind of crime scene. They just treated it like it's like an old lady at a heart attack and bed or something. That's how they treated it. Where the jack slipped any of that? Like if you found a 90-year-old lady peacefully died in her sleep, that's how they treated it, like, well, that's sad. Oh, well, nobody asked who had raised the truck up? Why would you leave your son under a vehicle balanced on one jack with no stands and no blocks? No jacks dance at all. As a guy who grows up with a dad like mine who has always working on something, you don't get under a car with one fucking jacked up from the front, that's not how it works. There's a whole stands you put it on. There's a whole thing to that. If you're so broke that you can't afford stands, you slide a tire under the truck, anything. Because that jack is hydraulic and it will fail. Or fall, because it's just a small jack. It's a bottle jack? It was a small jack, wasn't a big jack even. So yeah, they look at it again. There's no scene to examine, just paper. A policy receipts, that's it. The insurance policy, the payouts, things like that, but there's no crime scene proof. They pulled the insurance file on Levi. They found that he died November 20th. And the November 3rd is when the application for the life insurance went in. That's 17 days. With Cindy, it was not, not Cindy with Christine. It was 19 days with the funeral with that. So they found that Carl paid the first premium. They found the medical exam was scheduled for the next day, the 21st day after Levi died. Then they found the will, notarized the morning Levi died, leaving everything in the carl. Then they found the surrogate's court record where Carl said there was no will. They were like, why is he lying in court? They said it was extremely unlikely that someone would have that many tragic events in a few weeks after they obtain exorbitantly high life insurance policies. It's so bizarre. It's like, these are like his last ditch desperation efforts to keep whatever afloat, but it's not keep anything afloat because it just blows it all. He's either got the worst luck in the world or the best luck in the world. One of them too is going to look at it. And a yearning to shop. Yeah. Yeah, he needs to buy. I've never seen a consumer. Traitor's is in ducks. Yeah. He doesn't buy anything fancy watches or anything like that. He's just a consumer. April 9th, 2012, investigators Carl Cindy, who is now estranged from Carl. And she said, shortly after I left, is when law enforcement called me. First thing I said was, thank God you called. They said they had a gotten a tip from a family member that maybe there was something more to Levi's death. That's when we started working together with law enforcement. She's interviewed many times over the next few months and a profile of Carl kind of comes out of her. She told them about the policy. She didn't even know about till after he died. Levi died. She told them about the policy on herself that she had to find through a private investigator. Policies on the granddaughters told them about the barn, the window that he couldn't see out of all the shit that she's been thinking. She unloads on them. And they said, Cindy didn't find out about it until after Levi was dead. And Carl had pretty much blown most of the money on a get rich quick scheme. So yeah, she said that she also told them Carl and Levi had been at our--
for years and that Carl was the one who convinced Levi to buy the policy, saying what are you irresponsible? What if something happens to you at work? You're going to leave your little girls with nothing? What's wrong? They grow up. Grow up. And he was like, oh, okay. I said, I'll pay the first premium. All right. Sure. So the insurance totals here. Okay. This is what he's a total in his life here. 86 car fire, $10,000. December 1990, he gets policies on the whole family, $200,000 on him, $200,000 on Christina, $100,000 on each child. January 1st, 91, Christina dies, $215,000 paid to Carl by state farm, 2002, pay out somewhere between $60,000 and $115,000 for the barn fire where the Belgian draft horses are killed. November 3rd, 2008, policy on Levi, $400,000 plus $300,000 accidental death. He's the beneficiary, Levi dies, $700,000 paid to Carl. Then after 2008, he put the policies on the two daughters and also on Cindy. So they lay this out and they go, there's going to be an ending to this where more people are dead. And that's absolutely. There's more coming. Then summer and spring it or summer in there, 2012, investigators decide they needed to get someone close to Carl. So, a Seneca County investigator describes the plan and said, the plan is that we set up is we simply have one of our undercover narcotics enforcement investigators plant a flat tire, a disabled car out in front of Carl's house. Look at Carl broke down, hook him out and look at it. Carl looking for a friend and somebody to talk to engages with the other cover investigator. They do days and days of traveling around farms, looking at different areas and just kind of build a friendship, I guess, a fake friendship with each other. So they just have to accidentally meets this guy who happens to have a flat tire and they get along great. Okay. And also Cindy's private investigator, unbeknownst to Carl also pretends to be Carl's friend. Oh, that's fun. Carl doesn't know he's Cindy's in private investigator or anybody's private investigators to another guy. So between the two of them, he spends the summer of 2012 hanging out with his two new best friends who are they don't know about each other either. I don't think and they're trying to fucking which is great. So funny. 2012. Okay. Cindy said, I'm going to get you guys a recording. So she wires herself up. She said, she saw an old episode of Dateline and decided to do this. Thanks, Keith Morrison. Yeah. She bought a voice recorder and just tucked it under her tit and her bra. That's all she was like, I'm getting it on now. She's like an open mic comic. Stick it on a table near the stage. Hope, hope it gets something amazing. He's going to muffle it in it. Well, that's the problem. Cindy said she describes what Carl said on her own early recordings. And she said, one thing he told me is that he had realized he forgot to put the blocks under the truck. And if he had done that, the truck wouldn't have fallen on Levi. So basically, he's like, it's my fault it happened and I feel horrible. I feel so guilty. Okay. Which is an appropriate reaction. That's one thing. Oh, maybe you're human after all. But these recordings weren't very audible because they come from inside of a bra equipment not made to be put there. So every time she moves, it's different. But the police can hear enough to where they take the next step here. Okay. They're like, okay, we like it. November 14, 2012. Cindy meets Carl at a restaurant. Now according to everything here, she was recording as here as well. And Carl, during this meeting admitted to her that he killed Levi. What do you say? She asked him directly if he pushed the truck. And then he said, yes, and even demonstrated with his hands how he did it. Oh, yeah. So she drove right to the police after this meeting and put the recording down. Again, it's muffled though because she's not because she's got upstate New York. Has it heavy bosom? Heavy, heavy bosom bras. And she's not exactly Donnie Brasco over here. She's not getting the job done. You couldn't make out the words. She got the broad part of Brasco. So they asked her, well, could you do it again? Think you can get him to admit to murder again if we give you like real equipment. Like, well, why are you up for real? And she said, all right. So Cindy meets Carl at another restaurant. She wore a police wire this time and playing close investigators sat nearby, which is because they'll record from like video record from where they are, too. Like the if you'll see the Charlie Adelson case, they got that's how they got him finally was his talk with that with McBanoi, the Katie McBanoi at the restaurant audio. You I mean, it's so easy now that people can impersonate people like you can make a lot of celebrities say some bad shit if you can impersonate Christopher Watkins been a victim of it for you for years and years. Think about it. All the guys back then. Right. But so you if you got somebody Arnold Schwarzenegger, some horrible things. My God. If you got somebody close by with a camera, you can prove that this is not an impersonator. It's actually watching him speak the words. Yeah. So they meet. So yeah, one of the I think this is the golden buck is the restaurant. Carl suspicious. Yeah. Well, you want to have dinner with me again. What's going on? He's suspicious. And Cindy says, do you want to search my purse in my bra? Do you want to search my purse? And he says he looks at and goes, "Nah, it's all right." Cindy's not wearing a wire. So then they have the wire. And Cindy said, "I asked you if you pushed the truck." And you said, "Yes." Carl said, "No, I didn't push the truck." I said, "No. I said I had nothing to do with it, but I said I took advantage of the situation once it happened." Oh, she said, "Carol, you told me that you didn't set it up that way, but when you were in there, you saw an opportunity." And he said, "No, after it happened, then I saw an opportunity." That's exactly what I said. And he described the setup. He said, "The truck's front tires off the single jack." And he said, "It was so wobbly. It was never, it was never meant to be." And he said, "Nobody would get under a truck if it's not meant to be." No, it was never planned from day one to ever go that way. And then Cindy said, "I led him to believe our marriage had a chance if he came clean and I told him I could, he could trust me." Okay. So late November 2012, she sets up another meal with Carl. This time when he arrives instead of her being there, it's two detectives approaching him saying, "Can we talk?" He said, "All right. He's not handcuffed. It's just voluntarily goes down to the police station to talk. He's told he's not under arrest. And he will be in there being interrogated for nine and a half hours." Oh, shit. Nine and a half. That is a long day. He denied killing his son 75 times in nine and a half hours. Wow. He also gave several different versions of what happened, which is just as questions every hour, every every every eight minutes you're being asked, did you kill your kid? Yep. Um, no shit. Early in the session, he thought, "Maybe I need a lawyer." He said, "I want a lawyer or something, I guess." And they said, "Would you say?" And he said, he said, "Did you say you want a lawyer?" And he said, "Nah, not at this moment. No, but I'm thinking about it for later." He complained. He felt sick. He said he needed his pain medication. He said he had panic attacks. He said he's been taking pain pills for so long as memories hazy. So I don't know what I can tell you. He said, "In some ways, the whole thing's a blank," as we said. So investigators tried multiple approaches. They played to his ego as the hours went by. They figured maybe this is what it is. Because they had the undercover they sent to make friends with them, kind of taught them who Carl was. He likes to talk and he likes to feel like the smartest man in the room. And if you let him and act like you believe him, he'll talk for hours and say crazy shit. He said, what the cop said? What we gained from that, again, was just more knowledge about Carl, who he is, what he says, what he talks about, his character. And I think it was all important when we get to that interview process to know Carl as well as we can. Right. Absolutely. You have to know how to approach him. So Carl, during this, they play him a clip of Cindy's recorded conversation where Carl says you're trying you're trying to give her a little ammunition to see where she's going with this because I have no clue. Then at one point in the interrogation, he says he found Levi earlier and didn't call anyone. He cracks. He said, I found him dead. I fucking panicked. I don't know. I don't know. This is what he said to the cop. That's illegal. They said, what does panic mean? And he says, I just left him illegal. Okay. I would think so. Then went to a funeral. Yes. Then just left. Then in the second version, he tells them he was there when it fell. Okay. Okay. He said, I opened the truck door because I had to get inside to move the linkage for the fucking truck. And when I did, it tipped and it just woosh. Fucking fell off.
over. It was an accident. And it's, I blame myself every day, just like you said. They said, look, you know, we, we know you feel bad about it, but they gave him that whole thing. We know it's probably, I said, all right, fine. I did it by accident. I opened the door and that toppled it. Oh, I put myself in and, yeah. And then left. And then left. That's the thing. They said, why didn't you call for help? And he said, he just, he, he didn't register. He compared himself to a kid who breaks a window and runs so he doesn't get caught. Sir, you are 50 years old. You're a father. That doesn't work. Well, grandfather, for Christ's sake, a detective said, you caused the truck to fall on him, and you left him dying on the floor. And he said, yeah. Later on, he said, I let him down. I walked away. And I lived with that for four years. They said, did the insurance policy had on him? Have anything to do with that? And he said, no, not at all. He said, he never, never even thought of insurance. I didn't, I didn't even realize what I did 19 days, 17 days ago. And that morning, when I took his fucking motorized will to a bank, didn't cross my mind. So if, if a fortnight had passed, and I forgotten all about it, this morning's event sure didn't refresh my memory. No, I just said, fuck it. I'm going to go fix the truck. The transmission line on the truck is really the most important thing. So the cop said, he did admit that he left his son on the floor dying, but he never admitted that it was a plan deliberate act. At the Andy Han wrote and signed a statement, admitting the truck fell on Levi when he got into the front seat. And he wrote that the truck fell off the jack. He panicked and left. Now, obviously there's some inconsistencies. Number one, he told the medical personnel in 2008, Levi was alive and working on the truck when Carl left for the funeral. Then he told the deputies, he came home and found the truck toppled off the jack, told the court he had no will. Then he did have a will. He told Cindy, he forgot to put the blocks under the truck. And that's his fault. Then he told Cindy, he pushed the truck because he saw an opportunity. Then on the wire, he said he didn't push the truck. He took advantage of the situation once it happened. Then he told the detectives. He found Levi and panicked. Then he told them that he opened the truck door, tipped it and walked away. And it's the same thing he said in his handwritten statement as well. He said he knew the truck was unstable. He jumped in the cab. He knew Levi was alive and he left knowing Levi would likely die. Yep. Okay. So anyway, that's that's how it goes. The one lieutenant investigator guy said, I don't believe it for a second that he accidentally dropped the truck on his side. But for legal purposes, it really doesn't matter. Under New York state law, that's depraved in difference. That's murder in the second degree. Okay. So irrelevant, whether he meant to or not. So he's arrested and charged with second degree murder and insurance fraud. He's held without bail. A grand jury indicts him on two counts of second degree murder, one intentional, one depraved in difference and one count of second degree insurance fraud. Okay. He goes to court. He's all hobbled and using a walker now. These guys fucking pussy. These guys get around so well until they get in the court. And then it's just very, they need wheelchairs and walkers and they're just very fragile once they're in jail. It's very nothing worse than a spineless fucking pussy that commits really heinous crimes and then wheels his bitch ass into court a week later. Fuck you. He goes into court without an attorney to represent him and tells the judge that he applied to be represented by a public defender saying that he does own property. So he's not broke, but all of his assets are tied up in a divorce proceeding. So he needs, he actually is indigent and needs fucking public defender. Now his daughter, Aaron, goes to visit him in jail. She grew up believing he killed her mother and now her brother. She visited his and jail just to tell him so. Just to say, I think you're an asshole. I think she said, quote, I looked at him and I was like, I know that you killed my brother and I know that you killed my mother. And he smiled like a cheshire cat. And he said, it's been 22 years. They haven't caught me yet and they're not going to. What? That's recorded, right? I don't not in a visit probably. Wow. It's not over the phone. It's face to face. I don't know who the fuck's recording is. So Christina's dad, because I don't think it's like, it's a jail. It's not like a big plexiglass. It's an upstate New York jail. They're probably meeting in like a the breakroom or something. Yeah. Probably sit in one of those circle tables that's bolted to the floor. Yeah. So Christina's dad also said that he suspected Carl all along, but he didn't want to lose access to his grandchildren. He said, I'm the one who counted the nails. There were 17 nails in that board. 16 and the four in each, in each side. That's a lot too much. Too much. Yeah. So December 8, 2012. He's in jail in New York. California reopens their investigation. Oh, shit. 22 years. My ass. So Carl Kent, who was the fire, the investigator there. Now he's retired, but he still has his partial file. He's the only guy who has anything, any of the partial file he kept it. So he gets a phone call from a new investigator. And they look at everything and they kept returning to the geometry of the bathroom. They said, it's a small room off the hallway, tub door window. The door opened into the hallway where the carousine was. The window was behind plywood. She's trapped in there. She's stuck. Yeah. From both ends. Christina was in the bath. He's called to get the kids. That means she was awake, aware of the fire and thinking clearly enough to give an instruction because the kids heard that too that she yelled for him. She had time to speak. She had time to soak a washcloth and put it over her face. She just couldn't get out the door. It was probably engulfed in flames inside the door and couldn't get the board off the window. Later on in an interview, Carl is asked, she only needed seconds to get to the window or seconds to get to the door. Why did she do neither? And Carl said, we don't know because it went up so fast and so hot. Yep. Also, the rescue of the kids that made him such a big hero that he carries around newspaper clippings, he said he broke the bedroom windows from the outside to reach the children. That means he was outside the house moving around as it's exterior, breaking glass and pulling children from broken windows. He did this at least twice, but didn't suffer any cut serious enough to be noted or any burns or anything. Right. He just came out perfectly fine. Doesn't get any cuts from glass that's left be nothing. He went past the bathroom window to do it. The bathroom windows, the one with the plywood, he said the fire was too gone to get her. His daughter said he kicked the wall beneath it, but nobody's ever said that he tried to pry off the board. No one ever even him. He had removed a dresser from in front of the girl's window. They said, but why was the dresser pushed in front of the child's bedroom window in the first place when it wasn't there the day before? Right. What's that about? So what's the fucking story here? So they said, take these two scenes side by side. They have nothing in common, a house fire in California, a truck falling in a garage in New York. Totally different. An investigator said that's what made it more suspicious. They said he doesn't kill them with his bare hands. He doesn't stab them. He doesn't shoot them. He creates a hazardous situation. Then sits back and lets his let's his situation kill them. He's like a bond villain. He put you on a fucking conveyor belt going toward a giant saw blade coming at your tape. And he's like, well, I'll just go walk away then. And I got other stuff to do. I got a dinner plans. I'll let you get it. He's jigsaw. He's the saw villain. Just letting him think. He would let him kill them while he watches or he's a part of it. It's crazy. So that's what it is. Both victims were alone when he died. When they died, both had been placed in a position they couldn't escape. And in both cases, Carl's the last one to see them alive and the one who benefits financially a ton. And within the last month, that became a viable thing for him. So also, they look at Levi as a possible witness. One investigator said, I only suspected that Levi knew something about the day of the fire that he just didn't want to talk about. Was my father not knowing to save my sisters? That's the question that's going through this kid's mind. I think that Levi got himself out of the fire. And I think only because Levi got out, it forced Carl to get the girls out. Oh, he was going to let everybody die because he had him on the kids too. Yeah. So once Levi got out, he was like, oh, shit, I got to get the kids out. That's what the investigators said. I think his intent was to stand out there, watch the whole house burn up and not just his wife. I think his intent was to see the kids go to and collect not just one life insurance policy. I think he intended on collecting four. So the kerosene poor pattern supports part of that theory. Investigators describe the pores outside the bedroom door in a arc shape to the bathroom door. Yeah. $100,000 policies on the kids. Levi always thought he killed their mother on purpose. In 2008, Levi had a good job, a good thing going on and a girlfriend and all that. And then there's the $700,000 policy. The investigators said he started to think, what if Levi knows why let a witness be there living? As Levi got older, he started to worry. Carl wanted to remove the one person that really had had the key to what had happened. And he was gonna get paid.
so much more about it. Oh yeah. So that's the investigation keeps going more than that in a second. About a month after he's arrested in New York, he does an interview with the Syracuse post-standard newspaper, fucking idiot. Great idea. Wow. They describe him walking into the jail interview room leaning on a walker. He said he said he's had surgeries on his back and shoulders and he once been kicked by a draft horse. Pissed me off so bad. I burned the whole thing to I mean shit. He he said I'm like a 70. I bet he did. That's I mean. I would not be surprised if that's the reason he looked all shit up. It's possible. He said I'm like a physically a 75 year old man physically. He said for years before and after Levi's death, he took up to 35 pain pills a day. Now he says he had nothing to do with either death. They call it a rambling three hour interview in jail. He told the post-standard that the death of his first wife in 91 in a fire. The death of his Belgian horses and 2002 barn fire and the 2008 Jack, you know, Levi fallen with the Jack there. All coincidences. Yeah. He said that they said well didn't you collect large insurance policies and he said, well, yeah. Of course. Yeah. He said there's no way. He said there is no way you kill somebody for money. You just don't. It's just not a thing you do. Well, it's what half the people kill for. Go back inside. All those people did that. To be accused of killing your son for money is beyond and his voice trailed off. And then he said, if anybody's had shit luck, I've got it. No. It's all luck. That's all my bad luck. Yep. He said he just my son came to repair the power steering lines. We went to a funeral. He said, the last I saw him, I stopped in the garage before leaving to slip Levi 50 bucks for working on the truck. You know, and then when they returned about four hours later, he said, it seemed weird that he hadn't left yet. You know, when you have that feeling that something's not right. And he said he opened up the garage and there he was. And he said he was so cold. He was blue. My wife came out. She knelt down. We were both crying. I took that 50 bucks back. Said let me get that 50 back. You don't need that. You don't need it where he's going. Carl said he didn't cause Levi's death and vowed to fight it in court. Really? Bullshit. He said, I will never I will never plead guilty to this. Not hell or high water will make me plead guilty to this fight it later. He said he didn't want his children to have to be witnesses at his trial, though. Also, he said to see them on the stand. I don't think I could take it. I would rather sit in jail for 25 years of my life knowing my kids would not have to get ripped open. Okay. It's going to hurt when they say that I was going to hurt that's what I hear when they say that I did bad things. Yeah. Yeah. Um, and then he said the only took out the insurance policy on Levi at Levi's request. Yeah. He said it's not not like I took out an insurance policy on him. He took a policy out. I just happened to set it up and pay for it. I just happened to do it and be the beneficiary. He said and I was the beneficiary because he didn't want his young ex-wife to have anything to do with it. He also boasted about his daughters. One was a park police officer for the state at one point and the other was a translator for the military. He talked about his days on him as a missile specialist at Grand Forks Air Force Base where he met his first wife and all that. He talked about the duck farm. He and Cindy ran for a couple of years. He even noted that it was featured last year on a popular cooking television show in Canada. Where? Show me that, Karl. Show me your duck farm. He sold no ducks. Yeah. For he slaughtered them all. Yep. He said he had to give it up due to his health. That's what he said. Not because nobody wanted his ducks. He blamed the reason why he's even sitting in jail on Cindy. He said you lived with me for three and a half years after Levi's death and now all of a sudden we got a divorce coming and this happens. What a coincidence, don't you think? She just is bitter. He also said he had arranged to meet Cindy for dinner the day after Thanksgiving at the Golden Buck Restaurant, but he was met instead by two police officers who took him in and he said he was questioned for 10 hours. The cops say eight hours. The recording of it says about nine and a half. So it's a good amount. Karls. Yep. Karlsson said he gave a statement to the investigators and signed it, but he couldn't remember what he even said. He's got it. He said we was in so much pain during the interview with the police that he didn't have his medication. You know how it goes just too much, which is wild. Now several people in the police station said he appeared to be in a lucid state, not in pain. So they asked what about the fire death and he's like, oh, that's a totally different thing here. He goes, you know, for 22 years her family has been suspecting me and all that kind of thing and he confirmed he did get life insurance from her. But he said I pulled my, I had life insurance policies on the three kids. I pulled from the burning house. I could have let them burn too. He said if I was, if I was in it for the money, I could have just walked away and let my kids die. Wow. That's a wild statement. What about the barn fire? That is telling his fuck about what he just did to leave. Think about that statement. Yeah, he just said it just says what he did to leave us. He was in it for the money. That's unthinkable, though, to a normal human. That's crazy. Yeah. He says that about the barn fire, he goes, look, I've had a lifetime of bad luck. That's what it is. He goes, I understand why people might not believe him. He said, quote, I understand that part with coincidences this and that. I have no logical answer for answer for you. I wish none of this happened. Now, weird part, as I'll read from the newspaper, the investigation in charge is against Carlson or a strange twist to a tale that advisor today magazine prays two years ago as an example of how life insurance can protect families. Real. Yeah. The full page story about the Carlson's in the October 2010 issue, quotes an investigator on how Levi's insurance policy helped care for two young girls in the wake of their father's tragic death while he blows seven hundred. Yeah. The same guy who talked about that said ultimately, they will have the advantage of having a foundation for security established through the selflessness of their father and through the caring and prudent oversight of their grandfather. Unbelievable. Yep. So that's interesting. Now, that investigator said that oversight turned into an emptying of accounts. Yeah. And he said, I'm seeing people, two people fighting over the death proceeds of a young man where the money was supposed to go to his kids. Yeah. He said, this investigator said the way it was structured. He said, everything Carl told me at the time seemed plausible and logical and Levi didn't offer any objections to keep it away from the ex-wife, keep it in the family. You can trust your dad. He said, yeah. He said, most people, they said, he said a lot of people would say 700,000's too much. It's unreasonable for a young guy. But he said, most people don't realize how much money it takes to raise a child from birth to college. If you take that into account, $700,000 really isn't that much money. And you multiply it by two because there's two children and the earning potential of this kid over his lifetime is probably about 700, 800 grand. Who knows? So I would hope more than that Jesus Christ for some of you doing on jobs in upstate New York. Oh, you mean Levi? Yeah. I thought you meant his kids. I was like, Jesus, that's brutal. You're really pigeonholing these kids quick. So April 2013, plea offer from New York State. They offer him a deal. Plead guilty to a single count of second-degree murder. The district attorney said the plea would have satisfied potential charges, including the possible murder indictment in California. This will cover everything he won't do it. He said, no, I will never do it. I will never plead guilty. May 14, 2013, a new grand jury indictment is unsealed for more counts. Unlawfully concealing a will, perjury, making a false written statement and offering a false instrument for filing. Now will you plead? I'll believe I will shit. And the defense attorney says, I just got the material. We don't know if anything substantially changed because of this or that or if this enhances their allegations, I have to look into it. Now October 24, 2013, Aaron, the daughter goes on 2020. And she said it was never a question for me. It was a matter of fact of whether he killed his mother, her mother. She said when she heard Levi was dead, she tried to push her suspicions away and said she was relieved when police were investigating. So pretrial shit here. They try to get the, the, the wire shit thrown out and the entire interrogation thrown it. He's really not going to plead. They said he had shoulder pain, no medication, nine and a half hours of questioning. That makes it pretty much involuntary, whatever he said. And also his, he said his statements to Cindy were protected by spousal privilege. The court rejected all of his grounds and said, no, no, we're going to court here. Absolutely here. So the trial date is set for October.
October 21st, 2013, then it's pushed into late November, 2013. Then November 7th, 2013, jury selection is finished. They're just about to do opening statements, and a plea deal is made. Yeah, half. I will never plead guilty to this. He's so fucked. He doesn't know idea. He pleaded guilty to one count of depraved indifference murder in exchange for 15 years to life, and the DA's agreement to not pursue civil forfeiture of all of his shit, basically, because his farms paid off and all that. The insurance fraud charge goes away during the trip, the plea though, the subject of California came up, and Carl's lawyer in court said California was recognizing this plea and was not likely to proceed with any charges out there. The judge asked if anyone had promised anything about California, and they said, no, he said the DA still hadn't even talked to California, we don't know shit, but that's what it seems like. Carl didn't say anything, while this is going on, an observer said, Carl showed about his much emotion as someone talking about the weather. They also said, we were getting ready to go to trial. We were confident we were going to get a conviction, and the guy said, he was a little of the prosecutor said, I was a little disappointed that he took the plea. That was right. He kicked his ass. Now, so they said he knew the truck was unstable. He given the way it had been jacked up. They go through the whole thing. He knew Levi was still alive and he walked away. They said the judge went over the elements of the crime with Carl, and I'll have to tell you, it's pretty creepy listening to him because he showed about his much emotion as someone talking about the weather. That's about that. Carl's brother Mike spoke to reporters after the plea, and he said the only thing that shocked him was that his brother actually confessed. He said, you have to understand Carl a little to know what he's like. He's always been very boastful and egocentric, whatever you want to call it. I think he felt like it was, take me to trial and I'll beat you there. He's betrayed his family a number of times. It's hard for me to put my head around leaving your son to die. That takes a pretty evil sick person and he needs it to be put away. Awful person. No, brother, sentencing the judge says, you belong in prison and I suggest you belong there until you die. You, sir, may fuck off 15 years to life. So we're just going to bring you up for parole all the time and tell you to go fuck yourself. Eligible for parole in 2027. Then he gets sent to Clinton, which is Dan Amora, which is a horrible fucking prison. So good for you, Dickface. Enjoy. Enjoy fucking Clinton. Then October or August 29, 2014, Calaveras County files first degree murder charges for Christine his death with special circumstances for financial gain. Right. He's eligible for the death penalty at that point. Twelve days later, he files a motion to withdraw his New York guilty plea. He said he had lied when he admitted to killing Levi. Now he's now he doesn't admit it anymore. Now we want to court. He said he did it. The motion is denied as untimely because you're supposed to file it before sentencing, not after another state charges you with a crime. So he appeals all sorts of shit in the New York case. We don't have time to get into that. But none of it works basically January, 2020, he's brought back to California for trial. During the trial, he calls Cindy and she describes all the calls and all this kind of shit. She said, quote, he was calling me from jail during the trial. Yeah. Carl was. He was telling me, did you see that jurors, that juror, they look so scraggly? What about the one with the big ass? What do they wear close from Walmart? It's so bizarre. He called to fucking snap on the Jerry to roast the Jerry had been, yeah. After he got arrested, he, you know, was still writing to me. He wanted me to help him, you know, convince people he was innocent. Why does he think I would help him? I'm the one that got him arrested. How dumb is this fucking guy? So the defense moves to dismiss the case for pre-charged delay because 29 years had passed. The house was long gone, state-farm destroyed its file and the carpet samples, cal fire destroyed most of everything witnesses had died or forgotten. The defense said the fire scene with all its contest tents were completely destroyed. The defense also argued that two neighbors, the only witnesses who saw Carl's emotion during this, would testify that he frantically asked them to call 911. The trial court denies the motion, finds prosecutors had not delayed the case to hurt the defense. The delay was explained by Levi, quote, nobody had a reason to reopen Christina's file until Carl's son ended up under a truck. They sure? Yeah. Carl runs about two weeks, Aaron testifies about her father burning the Christmas tree, beatings with Levi with cattle prods, pipes, shovels and pitchforks, threatening to kill the daughters if they told anybody, oh yeah, Katie testifies and says sitting, she was sitting on the stand. She said it was obvious he did it and that caused her to second guess her entire life. Christina sister got up there and said he called her fatty and chubby and said that he called her a crispy critter, gross, that he had all that life insurance money with his other wife there. They brought in everybody here. They bring in Carl's sister-in-law, another person saying that Carl saw, they saw Carl hit young Levi on the head with shit, Carl of the fire investigator saying the hallway carpet was well saturated with caracene about a caracene about a week before the fire. The utility bulb, all the shit we talked about, the state farm agent who sold them the policies right before the fucking fire, they show everything, they even show his New York police interview. They show everything. They talk about the 86 car fire, the 2002 barn fire, everything is emitted. The defense was the evidence is too little and too late. There's no house, there's no carpet, nobody knows what you're talking about. Sorry. Also that the jury should also be instructed on second degree or involuntary manslaughter as well. This is bullshit. This is clearly bullshit. Now, the verdict comes in on Levi's 35th birthday, by the way, the jury deliberates for a few hours and then comes out and finds him guilty of first degree murder. He found the murder was committed during an arson or with premeditation and express malice. It found true the special circumstance that it was committed for financial gain and that he had a prior murder. He's been so much shown up. He's fucked. Yeah. So it's a lot. Then there's for sentencing, they have, oh, reactions to that. Christina's daughter here said, I think it was Aaron said, I'm just happy, yeah. And Christina's sister said it's a long battle. It should have taken effect in 1991. Carl's own brother said, I'm just glad it's over. It's done finally. And I hope justice is served. Mike. Yeah. He gave up on his brother. Fuck him. Letters come in during sentencing, victim impact statements from Levi's daughters. Oh boy. This is bad stuff. One said quote, Carl, you are the worst grandfather. Call them Carl, like when Corey Richards kids called it Corey in court, that's Carl. Carl you're the worst grandfather. I bet you don't know what love, kind or kindness means. PS, I hope you pay the price. Ooh. And Levi's youngest daughter said, dear, judge, I don't want Carl to get out of jail because I don't want him ruining my life like he did to daddy. Oh, geez. Oh. Judge says you, sir, may fuck off life without the possibility of parole. Yeah. Consecutive to his New York sentence. We'll do it after. So when he finally does get out there, he's going to court immediately go into fucking California, also ordered $200,000 in direct victim restitution to Christina's heirs, the original insurance money plus 10% interest from the day he cashed the check, which is 30 years ago. 10% on hundreds of thousands of dollars 30 years ago October 16, 2023 goes for an appeal. That doesn't work at all. He said that they should have been instructed of involuntary manslaughter. So there's a book that comes out, Aphrodite Jones publishes Levi's eyes, a son's deadly secret and a father's cruel betrayal spent years on that interviewed Carl and president and everything. I wish we had more time to go into more of the book because I gave you some stuff from there, but this would be 12 hours long if I went into all the details of this. So then Carl goes on pears Morgan, who is a douchebag, but when he hates someone, it's pretty funny. You're going to interview someone who he hates is going, but I, you're a twice convicted murderer and you're going to go talk to pears Morgan and look for sympathy. Have a chat. You're going to have an English guy grill you up. So, and again, not a fan of pears Morgan here, but in his interview, he says that he blames everything. He blad luck, bad lawyers, the trial wasn't fair. He said to prove that number one, I'm innocent, number two that I do.
didn't get a fair trial. That's why he's there. He said, he was asked, why are you so damn unlucky? And he said, I don't know. He said, I only pled because my attorney told me to. He said his lawyer told him on day one, it was a heater case, so high profile that he'd lose no matter what. He said it took 15 years because he could do, or he took 15 years because he could do 15. He said he wished he had never taken his lawyers and wife advice. He said, they said, well, what are your biggest regrets? He said, trusting people, trusting an ex-wife. And he thought that he was going to do 15 and get paroled. Yeah, that's what he thought. Yeah, when asked, didn't he realize the fire could have killed your children, too? He said, if I was in it for money, wouldn't I have done that? Wouldn't I have killed my kids then, too? And Carl's version, as the fire was too gone, once he got to Christina, and they said, he said breaking into the bathroom might have been the worst thing he could do. And he said, why? 'Cause what would happen if I died in the fire, too? Oh. Now the kids would have no parents. What if I died? That'd be terrible. Didn't just see back draft. Come on, the burn fire, he said, I got 60,000 for a loss, the 365,000. Who burns something down for a loss? Okay. And then, here's Morgan responded, I think you'd burn anything down. Which is a pretty funny fucking response. On the letters at sentencing from his family, he said, I don't remember even hearing that. That was the victim statement. Believe me, everything's such a blur when you're in the court, you know? You've got to get tough skin. You can't think of words, this guy. Also, an investigator talking about the board over the window said, there's no way she could have pulled it off. There's no reason. No reason he couldn't have gone to that bathroom. No reason. Then he pointed out Morgan. Pears Morgan pointed out that he and he insured the children as well, Carl agreed. And at the end, Pears Morgan offered him one last chance to apologize. He didn't. And then Pears said, then I just look him in the eye and went, I don't believe a word you're saying. And from then, from that, it obviously became a very different interview. It becomes more contentious, he's much more defensive. And by then, or by the end, he was just angry and stomped off. Then Pears Morgan, after the interview said, Carl Carlson is the world's biggest bullshitter and he just thought he could, he could something it's bleep. I don't know, something me into oblivion and I would just believe him. Fuck me. I don't know. I guess yeah. Aaron said, I saw the monster more than the man. She's a cybersecurity analyst and lives in Georgia. I don't know. Christina and Levi are buried together at the Calaver at the Wayne Avista Cemetery in Calaveras County. They buried Levi in California, huh? Yeah, with his mom, with his mom. So that's nice. Anyway, there is Murphy's California and a goddamn twisted story of a very bad guy. Anybody that's paying $60,000 penalties to withdraw money early? Look at them very carefully. Very carefully. That's a dangerous person. There you go. Hope you enjoyed that. If you did, easy way to tell the world, get on whatever app you're listening to and give us five stars. It helps a ton. Also Netflix, two thumbs up helps a lot. So thank you for doing that. We appreciate the hell out of that. Also follow on social media at small town murder on Instagram at small town pod on Facebook. Shut up and give me murder.com. No more live shows left this year. They are gone until 2027, but good news. The new dates are coming very soon in the next week or two and they'll be up in December to buy. Thank you to everyone who came out this year too. We had a great time and just some great shows. - Good shows. - Thank you guys for doing that. Really, really fun stuff this year. So come out and see us there. Get yourself Patreon, everybody. Come on Patreon.com/CrimeInSports. That's where you get all the bonus material. $5 a month or above gets you every damn thing we put out immediately. I'm talking all the stuff. You get, as soon as you subscribe, you get almost 400 back bonus episodes. Absolutely right, then new ones every other week. One crime in sports, one small town murder. You get them all this week. What we're gonna do for small town murder. We're gonna talk about that time about 10 years ago when clowns are popping up everywhere and scaring people. There's a documentary called Clown Panic Out right now about that time and I hate clowns more than anything. So I can't wait to talk about that. And hopefully someone murdered a clown while they did that. That's all fingers crossed possible. It's possible. So check that out, Patreon.com/CrimeInSports. And in addition to all of that, you also get everything we put out. So much. All crime in sports, your stupid opinions, both small town murders, all add free with your Patreon. Add free. And on top of that, you get a shout out, which is right Goddamn now. Jimmy, hit me with the names of the people who would never ever take out insurance policies on us to begin with. Hit me with them, right Goddamn now. This week's executive producers are happy hour in Ogolawa in Nebraska, where the fuck that is. I don't know, good luck with everybody, thank you. Thomas Woodward, Travis Sandall, and Brandon Henderson. Thank you guys so much. Thank you guys. You fucking well, we appreciate it. We appreciate it. Other producers this week, Elizabeth Rockefeller, Peyton Meadows, Janice Hill, Rebecca Forbes, Kate McClendton, McClendton, Sue Bean, Elizabeth Masulo, Shannon would know last night. Tina Jo, McAllister Lynch, Mary Lauer, Forensic Atelier, AC. What's an AC? Amber Albertson, Adrian Wilson, not that one. Gene Lovonian Skarns, Zach Summers, Kaelin P, Matt with no last name, Debbie Watts, Nala S. Christo with no last name, Ashley Melencone, Arno Hanton, D.S. Eli, Eli, perhaps. Erica with no last name, Marie Eve, parody, say, paratis. Jay would know last name, Danny with no last name, Roland, no last name, Jeff Witt, Ertha McClelland, Chastity LeBef, Charlie with no last name, Ladybug, Jason Clark, Christine H Kelly, with no last name, Jen Hatfield, Heather Tisseling, Julia Chilcoat, Stephen Reed, Jeanette with no last name, Megan Meyers, Jen Toe, Jessica Sonia, Cody Pinkstock, Anna Taylor, Eli Norsworthy, B.M. Forever. That's, that's me, man. Have you ever been, never gonna stop. No, snuck with no last name, Steve Martin, probably not, but. - Oh, we hope. - I'd love it, Matt. What is the spot, Spartansky, Spartansky? Elaine with no last name, Matthew Souter, Jen Lothner, Janet Bennett, Tim Gruss, Trenton France, Jacob Garfinkle, will aren't, aren't net. Not real, will or net, that's what, I think that's what they mean. Sarah Palmer, Carol Hagen, Levi Wiley, Captain Hammered, John Wilkins, Michelle Del, Dow, Dow, Dow Ponte, Brian with no last name, Mary CL66 Shannon Perzel, Candy Kane, 1735. There are 1734 of them. Wow. - Wow. Dustin Dugan, William Weir. Yep, William Weir, Nick Smilly. That's not Smiley, that's too else. Bryce Grinstead, Sam Richardson, Nanya with no last name, Chesley McDermott, Bambi Bogey, Bambi Bogey, I don't know. Bambi Bogey. - I don't know. Brandon Henderson, Jean Simon, Jill with no last name, Becky's Gold, Chris with no last name, Jared Cedarland. What is it? We got money from Orr, somebody's Gold. Yeah, Becky's Gold. She found some and sent it over and over. Leslie with no last name, Melanie Helton, Carrie with no last name, Patty Bennett, Debbie and Joe Johnson, or their grandkids, Column Nanon Pomp, so we can call them that. Scott with no last name, Walter McCoy, VP and Morgan McAllister. Thank you all for what you're doing. Thank you so much, everybody. From the bottom of our cold dead hearts, we appreciate the shit out of all that you do for us. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Keep coming back and seeing us week after week. We are just so appreciative of it. And you want to follow us or do anything with us on social media or anywhere else in the world. Shut up and give me murder.com is kind of the home base of that. So do that, keep coming back and seeing us week after week. And until next week, everybody, it's been our pleasure. Bye. (upbeat music)
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
In Murphy's, California, a family tragedy occurs when Christina Carlson and her three children are killed in a house fire, with the mother dying from smoke inhalation and the children surviving due to being evacuated.
The fire started after Carl Carlson, the husband, doused a Christmas tree with kerosene and lit it to demonstrate fire risks to his children, a decision that escalated into a deadly blaze.
Firefighters were unable to enter the home due to blocked entryways, including a plywood-covered bathroom window and debris, making it difficult to locate or rescue Christina.
Witnesses report Carl’s abusive behavior, including physical violence, emotional manipulation, and controlling actions, especially toward Christina and his children.
A suspicious pattern emerges in Carl’s life, including excessive life insurance policies (totaling $700,000) and a history of financial instability and erratic behavior.
The fire occurred during a snowstorm, with snow accumulating and icy conditions, adding to the danger of the situation.
The only evidence of the fire's origin is the kerosene-lit tree and the blocked entry points, with no clear proof linking Carl to the cause or intent of the fire.
The case raises questions about whether the fire was accidental or a deliberate act, given Carl’s history of abuse, control, and financial recklessness, but no conclusive evidence of murder is presented.
Summary:
In Murphy’s, California, a tragic fire in 1990 kills Christina Carlson, the mother of three children, while her husband Carl Carlson survives. The fire begins when Carl douses a Christmas tree with kerosene and lights it as a demonstration to teach his children about fire dangers. The flames spread rapidly, engulfing the home, and the family is only saved when Carl evacuates the children through a bedroom window and drives them to safety.
However, Christina is trapped inside, ultimately dying from smoke inhalation. Firefighters arrive too late to enter the home due to blocked pathways, including a plywood-covered bathroom window and debris, which prevented them from rescuing her. Despite the chaos, no physical evidence links Carl to a deliberate act.
His history of abuse—frequent violence, controlling behavior, and emotional manipulation—is noted by family members, including his sister Collette and daughter Aaron. Carl’s financial decisions, such as purchasing a $700,000 life insurance policy, suggest possible motive, but the fire appears accidental. The case remains unresolved, with questions about whether the incident was a tragic accident or a premeditated act.
While Carl’s character is deeply troubling, the lack of direct evidence—such as fingerprints, injuries, or a clear timeline—prevents a conviction. The story highlights the dangers of unchecked control, emotional abuse, and the fragile line between accident and intent in domestic tragedies.
FAQs
Christina Carlson and her children were tragically affected when their home was completely engulfed in flames on January 1, 1991. Christina died from smoke inhalation and was found in her bathroom, with a washcloth over her face and a distinct pink cross-shaped mark on her back. The children were rescued by Carl, who pulled them through bedroom windows. The house was blocked by debris, preventing firefighters from entering the bathroom, and the fire destroyed the home.
The fire started when Carl lit a Christmas tree filled with tinsel and needles, which he doused with kerosene. He claimed it was a demonstration to teach the children about fire risks. The tree ignited quickly and the flames spread rapidly, eventually engulfing the entire house.
No, Carl was not injured. He was standing outside the house and reported that he rescued the children through bedroom windows and could not reach Christina. He remained unharmed throughout the incident.
The firefighters were blocked from entering the house due to a heavy accumulation of debris and clutter in the hallway and back door area. The obstruction was so severe that they could only get about three feet into the house before being forced to abandon further entry.
Christina was found with a wet washcloth covering her face, indicating she was attempting to protect herself from smoke inhalation. Her body was heavily soot-covered and charred, and she was found in a position slumped in the bathtub with a pink cross-shaped mark on her back, suggesting she may have been trying to escape the fire.
Before the fire, Carl covered the bathroom window with plywood to prevent snow from entering, and he had previously covered a broken window in the hallway with plywood. These actions were later noted as part of the home’s condition and may have contributed to the difficulty in rescue efforts.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.