Go back

Burnham’s Neets crisis: How Labour taxed a million young Brits out of work

32m 57s

Burnham’s Neets crisis: How Labour taxed a million young Brits out of work

The podcast episode of The Daily Tea, hosted by Tim Stanley and Camilla Tominey, centres on Alan Milburn's long-awaited review into youth unemployment, which addresses the crisis of one million young people not in employment, education, or training. The review sets out a ten-year plan to reduce the NEET rate from 13% to 5%, proposing 450,000 more young people in work, 300,000 school-age work experience placements, and increased apprenticeships. However, the hosts criticise the plan for kicking the problem down the road, noting that it would save only £200 million over a decade against a £120 billion welfare bill, and that its success cannot be judged within a single parliament. They argue the review fails to tackle the root cause: Labour's tax rises, including increased National Insurance contributions and minimum wage hikes, have raised the cost of employing a young person by £12,000. The review rejected more radical measures like scrapping employer National Insurance for under-24s, offering instead a £3,000 subsidy that does not cover the shortfall. The hosts also discuss Northern European models, the need for resilience, concerns about over-diagnosis of mental health conditions, and the looming impact of AI on the job market, concluding that businesses must be incentivised rather than penalised.

Transcription

5954 Words, 32697 Characters

English
Speaker 1With a million young people not in work or training, the
Speaker 2blame lies squarely at Labour's door, battering employers with jobs-killing taxes.
Speaker 1Alan Milburn's got a licence to upskill. His long-awaited report into youth unemployment is finally out, but the review itself continues to kick the problem down the road, setting out yet another ten-year plan.
Speaker 2Welcome to The Tea, The Daily Tea, with me, Tim Stanley.
Speaker 1And me, Camilla Tominey. Tim, you look neither shaken nor stirred. You look hot. You're in a bowtie and a tux jacket. I am. Do you also like my homage to Bond?
Speaker 2There is a touch of Bond femme fatale about you.
Speaker 1Well, I just thought I'd dress in black and look sparkly. Yes. It's half Bond, half Milk Trey. Are we happy with the appointment of Robert Pattinson?
Speaker 2Well, I got a call from my agent to say, I'm sorry, but they went with the vampire.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's right. Because you were there. You were up there.
Speaker 2I did audition. I answered an advert in the stage. It was me, Henry Cavill, Callum Turner, and to my surprise, Piers Brosnan. Yes. He was having another go.
Speaker 1Well, he has done Mobland, and I think, you know.
Speaker 2Well, I said Piers, you know, he was struggling to get up and down the stairs at the hotel. But nonetheless, he had a go. So I did the audition, and it went really well. Did it? I aced the drinking, the smoking, the snogging, and wearing a safari jacket. Did you? But I discovered I was allergic to Blofeld's cat.
Speaker 1Oh, that's right. There was a really funny thing on social media saying, imagine an evil villain had a really difficult cat. They're trying to stroke this thing. It's like, so, Mr. Bond, I want you to die. The whole documentary.
Speaker 2The whole dark plan is undermined by having to deal with a cat with fleas or something. Is he scratching? Just look at him. Is he scratching? Is that ringworm?
Speaker 1Can I just say I wanted Jack Loudon because I love slow horses. Right. And I'll be honest, Tim, I fancy him. Okay. And I do like to have Bonds I fancy. Did you know I was at the unveiling of Daniel Craig, who I didn't fancy at the time, back in 2005. We were at St. Catherine's Dock on the Thames. He arrived in an unimpressive suit, wearing a life jacket on a speedboat. Got off the boat, looked a bit queasy, frankly. I thought, this bloke from our friends in the north, this is going to be terrible.
Speaker 2Anyone would be a better Bond than Daniel Craig.
Speaker 1No, I'm sorry, I disagree with that. Christopher Biggins could be a better Bond. No, I'm sorry. Much as I love Biggins. He was terrible. No, he wasn't terrible.
Speaker 2He was. He was just a thug. No, he was great. He looked like a bouncer.
Speaker 1No, but it's the original Fleming sort of cold-eyed, cold-hearted Bond.
Speaker 2But people always do this. He's an assassin. They always say, he should be light in the books. No, it's a film series. Oh, hang on a minute. It's a film fun series. Oh, my God.
Speaker 1Luray Roger Moore was the best Bond person.
Speaker 2But of course.
Speaker 1Oh, this is absolutely unbelievable.
Speaker 2But of course. There was this, Bond died in one of those Craig films where they tried to establish a backstory, again, hate that, and they have him drinking his first martini. Yeah. And he's at a bar and the barman says, what would you like to drink? I don't know. You tell me. Well, can I recommend a vodka martini, shaken, not stirred? Do you know where that bar was? Where? It was a Virgin Atlantic business class bar.
Speaker 1Oh, so you don't like the product placement. How tawdry is that? But I'm sorry.
Speaker 2Because it's the wrong products.
Speaker 1I'm sorry, but the trunk. He had no class. No, turquoise trunks and that shower scene where he gets into the shower in his tux with Vespa. Oh. Oh, I love it.
Speaker 2It's sensual. Whereas, you see, Rog would fold everything up carefully on a chair.
Speaker 1Well, we don't want that.
Speaker 2If you watch those old films, Ian Fleming, a friend told me this, I'm not a big fan of the books. I've never read any of the books. But a friend told me. Ian Fleming wrote in the early 50s, in the aftermath of rationing, and he wanted to remind people of a time when Britain ran the world and was dripping in luxuries. And it's true. If you watch the films, like I watched Man with a Golden Gun the other day, every few minutes he's ordering something or eating something. There's so much food talk. Rog will sit down and apropos of nothing say, I think I'll have a bottle of Mouton Rothschild to go with these delicious mushrooms. Oysters, yes. And you're like, why are you talking about your food? And of course, it's for a time when people were. They're emerging from austerity and they want to see beautiful places, lovely ladies. Well, are you worried about Pattinson?
Speaker 1It's going to be a bit kind of Gen Z, millennial Bond. You've said emo Bond.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's my image. Because of the Twilight series. That's because I thought of the vampire. But actually, he's a very good actor. He's got a charismatic face. Tenet was very obviously an audition. He's fantastically athletic in that. And so long as he does something new with it, I think that's what it needs.
Speaker 1Is he too villainous, though, him and the audition? I don't think he's too villainous. He was slightly parodied for his performance there. And also, is it a woke appointment, woke Bond, pronouns, ho, stroke, hum?
Speaker 2Who knows? Anyway, I didn't get it this time. And I guess if he does a few of the films, I'm going to have to wait another 10 years, by which time I'll be in my early 50s. And Roger pulled that off. I don't think it's ever quite over. And we're all living much longer now. I reckon I could still be turning up for the auditions into my 60s.
Speaker 1That's right. It also gives us hope because he's 40 getting that job. And we're here to speak about young people who aren't in employment, training or education. And so good for Pattinson for extending his career, I think.
Speaker 2Can you imagine if Gen Z went into espionage? I'm sorry, I'm not killing anyone today. I just feel too depressed.
Speaker 1Possibly, yes. It could be a bit like that. But we shouldn't be castigating.
Speaker 2Let's not be patronising because this is a very serious subject. Can we not castigate a generation?
Speaker 1And to be fair, we've just listened to Alan Milburn, former health secretary, deliver his review.
Speaker 2He was introduced by two utterly atypical young people. Yes. Articulate, hardworking.
Speaker 1Yes. Clearly enthusiastic. But again, I'm sorry.
Speaker 2I just think it's so funny when they do that.
Speaker 1We are sullying a generation. We have this one million neat figure, don't we? We do, yeah. That is haunting the government. And many people looking for explanations as to why that's happened. Some of the raw stats are startling. Yeah. The idea that the number of young people claiming some kind of disability having almost doubled since the pandemic. The idea that, you know, claims for mental health conditions have also skyrocketed. The general idea, actually, that the welfare bill over the course of the next parliament is going to be into hundreds of billions, regardless of any of these changes. 120 billion, yeah. Is extraordinary, right? So something needs to be done.
Speaker 2And at the root of it is a societal imbalance in power and wealth. One thing that stood out for me was when he said that spending on older group people and younger people, the gap between those figures has more than doubled. Yes. So it does feel like when it comes to investment and benefits, it's older people who are doing better than younger people. Right now, 13% of young people are NEETs. That is predicted to rise to 16%. And he wants to get it down to 5%.
Speaker 1Which is ambitious because it's never been below 10%. Well, at least not in the last 20 years. Right. So if you got it down to that level, it would be extraordinary. There are a couple of problems with these proposals. Let's just deal with the ideas, first of all. So the report aims to get 450,000, more young people into some kind of gainful employment. That would also involve upping the number of apprenticeships that are offered to young people. It would also mean creating 300,000 school-age work experience placements. And by the way, all of this is quite difficult. Only this week I was trying to see if I could sort a work experience placement for somebody under the age of 16. You have to jump through lots of red tape. It's a difficulty when it comes to employers' insurance. The whole thing's a nightmare. And at The Telegraph, we wrote a very successful piece at the weekend, talking about the end of the Saturday job. Just from a red tape perspective, forget any of the financials. It's increasingly hard to get at least people from 16 to 18 into work experience or work. So just part that in the mind. So the ambition is clear, but there are a couple of kind of red flag moments in this review. The first is that when you actually crunch the numbers, over the course of the next decade, the net saving to taxpayers is 200,000. 100 million pounds. That's not very much money at all when you just mentioned a 120 billion pound price tag on the benefits bill.
Speaker 2Can I just say this is all projected over 10 years, which means that achievement can't be judged within one or even two parliaments. No. So in other words, how do we judge its success? And at what point can we reward or punish a government? And it's possible that this lot won't even be in power when the plan is supposed to be coming to fruition.
Speaker 1The second problem is it doesn't actually tackle the root of this problem, which is the comparative lack of affordability of employing a young person now compared to pre-pandemic or before, right? So if you actually make it.
Speaker 2He did have a section on that. He did talk about that.
Speaker 1He did know, but it has a section on it where it talks about what it could do to make up for this. So I think I mentioned it before. I was on a panel with James Reid, who has run Reid, which is the UK's largest family-run recruitment firm. Since 1997, he was talking about the cost of employing a young person having gone up by £12,000 since Labour took power. OK, so that is as a result of three Labour budgets. Meanwhile, the minimum wage, which I think was around £3 in 1999 and is now around £12, has gone up by over 250%. Employers are saying that that isn't affordable. The combination of the increase in national income insurance contributions and the increase to the minimum wage, although both are very well-meaning, has had the catastrophic effect of putting businesses off employing young people. And what's come with that is a stigmatisation of businesses. This attitude from Labour that actually business is bad, employees are always good. They haven't acknowledged the role that businesses have played historically in employing young people. They want to employ young people. They want to bring people on. That is the whole point of them. But they can't afford to do so because of the fiscal decisions that this government has taken. And secondly, they can't afford to do so because of the legislative decisions this government has taken. We've got extra red tape, as I mentioned, around work experience and other placements. And we've got the Employment Rights Bill, which has put employers off employing young people because they're afforded more rights, even though they're completely untried and untested. So that's another disincentive. There is nothing in this review that to have to do with this. The review considered increasing the threshold for national insurance contributions by employers from five to ten grand. It rejected it. It considered, which was a suggestion I made the other day, scrapping national insurance contributions by employers for under 24s altogether. And it rejected it because it said it was too expensive. So instead, it's going to say to businesses, if you employ a young person, we'll give you three grand. If you employ somebody as an employee, we'll give you three pounds. It's still not enough money to make up for that 12 grand shortfall. So as is ever the case with this government, I'm writing a column right now. It'll be on the Telegraph website later. Is there an irony here that the government itself appears to be suffering from some of the conditions it's trying to solve? It strikes me that the government is crippled with anxiety. It can't do anything that might put off the Labour backbenchers. It can't do anything that threatens a rebellion. So they're crippled by anxiety like young people. And they've got this kind of, they're displaying symptoms of ADHD. They're inattentive. They can't take a decision. It's all manana, manana. Let's see how this looks in 10 years time. There's no great sense of urgency. It's all slightly, you know, I'll clean up my bedroom tomorrow, mum. But at the moment, I don't want to do anything that might, you know, put me at risk of unpopularity. And therefore, yes, we completely appreciate the sentiments behind the report. But I don't think they're grasping the nettle enough. And therefore, none of these issues are going to be solved. And as with the budget, and as with Dame Louise Casey's National Care Service review, and as with defence spending, let's just kick it into the long grass. It's literally an adolescent approach to this problem, which I find ironic.
Speaker 2Okay. In Alan Milburn's defence, he's not responsible for the government policy of the last two years. And he did say in this speech that the cost of employing people has gone up. And he said, memorable moment, that we tend to focus on the supply side when it comes to youth employment, i.e. making young people more employable, without talking about the demand. And he noted that at the same time as employment overall has risen, curiously, employment of young people has gone the other way. So I think he recognises much of what you say.
Speaker 1Yeah, he was good enough on the Today programme to admit that Labour putting up national insurance contributions for employers was a mistake. And it's not a mistake, I agree with you, that he can undo. That's for Burnham and Healey.
Speaker 2Yes. But inevitably, he's writing a report which is about getting young people into work. So its focus is upon carrots and not sticks. So the Tories in response to this have said, you're not making the savings dramatic and soon enough. And the implication there is that what we really need to do is make employment cheaper. And as this is their actual policy, to redefine whole groups of people as not in need of benefits, so they'll just go out and get a job. I mean, I noticed a couple of days ago, I googled how many jobs are there in the social care sector right now. Can you guess how many vacancies there are in social care? No. 90,000. Yes. That's a lot. And that would take a big chunk. Out of those needs. And you don't need to be super qualified to do social care. And instead, what we're doing is offering visas to people from abroad to go do it, rather than employing people here in this country. So I take the Tory argument. But look, Alan Milburn is a former new Labour minister. This is a Labour government. And this is a Labour approach to the problem. And actually, there's lots about it that I really like. What they've done is they've looked at Northern Europe, which spends more on young
Speaker 1people. Yes, like countries like Denmark. I think Pat McFadden, the pension secretary, was there last
Speaker 2week. Yeah, the Netherlands was mentioned a lot. And there are countries where they don't just spend more on people, but they also devolve the provision of services, which means that your local area is responsible directly for making sure you are able to leave school and find work. And they also have closer collaboration between employers and schools. In some of those countries, schools are almost sponsored by the local biggest employer, which means that there's a natural channel between the leaver and the factory or the corporation that's big in that region. So they're modelling themselves on that. And some of the things he said, first of all, schools have to change so that we don't just give people a GCSE in maths or English, which is very important. But we also give them the skills, which means that they are ready for work. Secondly, he wants to see more vocational education so that people, again, are not just training for arts, degrees. And with the advent of AI, it's going to be old fashioned manual jobs that people are going to want to have. And he talked about more focus upon getting disabled people into work, early intervention in mental health. But he did culminate in saying, but this all counts for nothing if we're not actually making sure that work is cheap and that people can get the jobs.
Speaker 1The jobs have to be there, right, Tim? Businesses have to be incentivised to provide the vacancies and vacancies are 200,000 down.
Speaker 2But final thought, we tend to have on the right a free market approach. We believe in strong nation states and free markets and strong individuals. You give the individuals the best start in life. They then go out into a thriving free market and they find the job that's best for them. And in an ideal world where that can work, that's great. The labour approach is slightly different and it says you need to be more hands on. And one thing I like about this was the notion of a hub. I hate the word, but the idea, like with the old new labour sure start scheme, that there is a physical place within the community that young people who are unemployed can go to and will be helped. I hate the word, but the idea, like with the old new labour sure start scheme, that there is a physical space within the community that young people who are unemployed can go to and will be helped.
Speaker 1So one of the problems with the benefit system has been this post-pandemic shift to online assessments. The loss of face-to-face checks. But also people being put on benefits and not checked on in a year, 18 months, in some cases, three years. I also like the Danish model, which was this policy called flex work. This is where you say to somebody, say, for instance, suffering from MS, that they're not going to lose their overall benefits entitlement if they turn around and say, do you know what? I think I could manage to work on a Monday and Tuesday. But in order to recover for the Friday, I'm going to need the Wednesday and Thursday off. Obviously, there is an inherent fear that if you are somebody who is on benefits, you're going to lose all of your entitlement if you offer to work part time. And I think that is completely ridiculous. We should be constantly directing the system to helping people into work and off benefits, even if it's just for a couple of days a week, because that is progress. And I don't just mean financial progress. I mean psychological and physical progress for the disabled person who wants to get back into the workplace, who wants to make their contribution, who wants to socialize with colleagues and all the rest of it. Work is beneficial overall. It really is. And many, many studies have proven that. I'm merely saying that the nettle that needs to be grasped here as well is that in certain circumstances, somebody on benefits can be earning £33,000 a year, which is higher than the minimum wage. And then the state turns around and is surprised that they don't want to get a job. There is nothing in this review about that overall problem of a life on benefits being more lucrative than a life in employment. And again, that isn't something that the average Labour backbencher wants to tackle. We'll think back to July 2025 when there was a row over a welfare cut that Newsflash didn't actually exist, Tim. They were rowing over a cut that was never going to happen because overall the benefits bill was going up every year. It's still going up every year. And at the end of the day, If this isn't a battle as it was in the kind of 80s and 90s between workers and shirkers, because that's unhelpful language, but it is a battle between those who pay taxes and those who don't. The taxpayer has got a right to say to the government, how much is this saving overall? And I think it is rather underwhelming to say the very least, to have the government come back and say, it's going to save you 200 million in a decade. Is it radical enough? Just to be specific about that number crunching, that's the kind of spreadsheet borne out of the actual Milburn proposals. Obviously, there could be wider savings to be had. If you've got more people, young people, particularly in work and not, for instance, using NHS services, then that's going to have an overall saving. But it's difficult to quantify right now.
Speaker 2Yeah, I agree. There are two other things that I think have to be addressed. One is the danger of falling back into the trap of subsidized work, tax credits, right? A situation in which government is. is paying employers effectively to hire people.
Speaker 1But wouldn't we rather subsidize work than subsidize non-work?
Speaker 2No, of course I would do. But we fell into a trap with tax credits here, that it became impossible. George Osborne wanted to take them away and it became impossible not to do it. And ultimately, you have to ask, why are employers not just paying people? Why shouldn't they bear the costs of employment?
Speaker 1They should bear the cost of employment, but they shouldn't bear the cost of unaffordable employment. Yeah, fair enough. It's such a socialist thing to say. To say, at the end of the day, we think workers should be paid more. And everyone on the left nods and goes, that's quite right. Workers good, employers bad. But it's not an overall net benefit to increase the minimum wage and then have it result in a pub saying, well, we were employing six young people, but the minimum wage has gone up. So unfortunately, we can now only employ three. Isn't it better for six people to be earning slightly less than three young people? Three people to be earning more, but three be sitting at home without work. I agree with that. It doesn't make any sense.
Speaker 2Of course, I agree with that. I just mean, it would be nice to be in a situation in which companies are thriving and they are paying the full costs of employing someone and raising their wage rather than falling into the trap as we did with tax credits if we end up subsidising low pay.
Speaker 1Taxes on individuals and businesses since Labour took power have gone up by over £70 billion. Right. This is where I am again talking about the macro. Economics versus this yet another example of tinkering at the edges, £2 bus fares. Let's allow people to park for longer. Let's not have too much music on public transport. No, Andy Burnham, the quick fixes aren't going to repair broken Britain. If you're going to clobber businesses with taxes, don't be surprised when they turn around and say, we can't afford to employ as many people. Certainly not young people. That's the catastrophic consequence of Labour taking power. The Labour government refuses to acknowledge businesses can see it. Young people can see it. So you can come out with all of this rhetoric. But what changes? The businesses have got to be incentivised. Businesses aren't bad. And do you know what is the most depressing element of all this, which I did agree with on Milburn? And I've done quite a lot of stuff in this space, you know, speaking to young people. We did it at the Daily Tea at all of the conferences. It is wrong to suggest that there is a kind of feckless, lazy generation that doesn't want to get ahead in life. The vast majority of young people, regardless of their class, creed, colour or whatever, they want to be in gainful employment, they want to get ahead, they want to settle down, they want to be on the property market, they want to have a car to drive, they want to have a good life, they want to prosper. And do you know what? This is the other thing that the left don't acknowledge enough. There are so many businesses, big, small and medium in this country that want to help young people to do that. That want to invest in them, that want to bring them on. They want to thrive. There's this impression that all businesses are evil and they must be clobbered with taxes because they're greedy, greedy, greedy. It's total nonsense. If it wasn't for the private sector in this country, this country would be nothing. So, you know, if the government is talking about jobs creation, help the people creating the jobs for heaven's sake. Stop penalising them.
Speaker 2I don't disagree with that. The other thing I was going to raise is the question of resilience in young people. A word I don't think I caught, the emphasis is always upon mental health. Now, that is a form of resilience because if you have a genuine condition, then teaching people the techniques of how to get by on a day-to-day basis with that condition is life transforming. That is a form of resilience. But there's also the resilience of saying, life is hard, none of us are perfect, for a large part of it, you're going to be doing things you don't want to do for not very much money, and it may well be tedious. Yes. But that's just life. You've got to start somewhere. And you have to start somewhere.
Speaker 1Yeah, I agree.
Speaker 2And I doubt this is a government which has got the once-in-a-generation courage to say to the entire population, because it is by no means a young person exclusive thing, you might not be mentally ill.
Speaker 1Yeah, toughen up, get on with it.
Speaker 2You might just be going through a bad patch. Yeah. Or it's possible you're lazy, or you're expecting too much of other people and of yourself.
Speaker 1Yeah. And by the way, it's possible that we may have enabled that because we gave loads of money to people who weren't working during the furlough period of the pandemic. Yes. And we've kind of got you hooked on this. Oh, and by the way, in the Labour Party movement, we did have Magic Grandpa and his magic money tree promising that, you know, we could. We could be spending ever greater amounts of taxpayers' money and have no consequences at all. And that might be why our debt's at three trillion.
Speaker 2And whenever one says something like this, you worry that Mumsnet is going to hire an assassin to take you out. Yeah. But I keep coming back to either we have gained a better understanding of mental health, which is why we're diagnosing it more. And the truth is actually nine-tenths of us are mentally ill. That's not impossible. The alternative is that we're somewhat over-diagnosing it. Because how do you account. I just can't understand how one accounts for this massive explosion in diagnosis. What has genetically happened to our people in the last 10 or 20 years that we are sadder and less capable of living independently? I just can't believe. Is there something in the water?
Speaker 1Put it this way. We didn't have a system before where we had. We had people allowing us to kind of self-diagnose on the internet. And then we didn't have a system before where you could just basically go along to a clinic, do a few tests and be diagnosed with things that you can then claim benefits on the back of, I guess.
Speaker 2Well, Milburn has said that private ADHD clinics should be stripped of any public NHS funding over concerns that they're giving a diagnosis in exchange for cash.
Speaker 1Although the response to that will quite rightly be, well, I think my child has got ADHD. And I'm sick of it. Ignore the signs. I'm sick of waiting. I'm on the CAMHS and other waiting list. I've been on it for three years. And actually, their GCSEs are fast approaching. I want the school to be convinced to put in some measures that might help them to achieve their potential. Therefore, I'm going to go to Professor X of Y and get him to diagnose because only with that certification can I persuade the school to help.
Speaker 2Yes, but the trap we get into here with the left, and a Tory government did this too, is if you insist that certain things are a human right, you can't then deny people those things. So if you say these conditions are, well, let's put it this way. If you say that everyone who presents as having this condition must be believed. Yeah. Then you can't say no to them.
Speaker 1But also, by the way, just to reflect on your resilient point, how can you convince young people to be resilient when we've had successive governments that weren't resilient at all? We've had successive governments that didn't honour the pledges. They made in their own manifestos. We had Keir Starmer running scared of his own majority. We've got Burnham doing exactly the same. It isn't standing up strong and saying, do you know what? We may fail in this endeavour, but it's worth doing because we're doing it for the right reasons and we're doing it for the greater good. And it is going to be no pain, no gain. We're playing a long game. They're saying it's a marathon, not a sprint, but there's no sprinting at all. They're planning to. They're planning to undertake this race, taking pigeon steps in case they get injured. Right? That's not good enough. Yes. So this is the other thing that I think the young don't always appreciate. You have to fail a lot in life to succeed. Yes. My God, if I could show you. Look at Liz Truss, still trying. No, but Tim, if I could show you some of the letters that were written to the editor of my local newspaper, the Hamel Hempstead Gazette, about the glaring errors in my copy, it would literally. You would go, who is this girl and how the hell has she succeeded? And many might still question how on earth has she succeeded in this industry. And that's your opinion.
Speaker 2Yeah. But at least there was an industry. And this is one thing we have to acknowledge. Because I agree with you. I'm always saying this. I work damn hard. I rang up the news desk every day. I talked my way into this job and all that sort of thing. And my father, when he left school at 15 or 16, whenever as early as it was possible, rolled straight from that into an engineering apprenticeship. The nature of work has changed, and the issue now with journalism is there are no jobs to get.
Speaker 1Well, there are some jobs.
Speaker 2There are some jobs, but the industry is undeniably contracting. And this is the other thing. I mean, AI was mentioned in passing, but really I'm always amazed with everything the government does that it's not at the centre of everything they discuss. It's akin to being in the 19th century and not mentioning the spinning Jenny. That's right. Right?
Speaker 1We need to do a whole episode, by the way, on AI. First of all, is it killing us all? And second of all, how do we insulate against it career-wise? Yes. Let's do that in the next week or so.
Speaker 2But I'm just thinking we have people now in university or who did it a few years ago are entering a labour market that's about to contract violently in their face. And all this spending on training, I just don't know how you combat that. How, again, like with mental health, how do you confront an entire generation and say to them, your expectations of what life is like and what you want to do are about to radically change. And we could be entering like a revolution or a revived era of the 19th century in which you have to do manual work because there ain't nothing else. It can be highly skilled manual work. Okay. But I'd like to end on a more positive note than that.
Speaker 1I'd like to end on a more positive note than that because actually there is a positive advantage to this kind of generation or two that are in touch with their feelings and their emotions and are more understanding of others. Actually, EQ is going to be hugely important for the jobs market of the future. Emotional intelligence as well as IQ. Right. And I say that because a lot of the jobs that are going to be stripped out are those that are sort of, you know, kind of quite obviously could be replaced instantly with automation, not involving much human interaction. Actually, we have people who unlike the kind of drones of yesteryear do have a thorough understanding of the trials and tribulations of life, are tuned into what other people are feeling, do want to have human connections. I think it's those people who are going to thrive. Women. You know, that's right. It's going to be women.
Speaker 2Yeah. This is not a good economy for young men. Women and touchy-feely men. Yeah, women. Yeah, I know. It's not a good economy for young men. It could be that in a few years' time the only safeguarded jobs are nurses and train drivers. And Bond. For two very different reasons. And James Bond. But the return to the caring and the manual could actually be what the economy of the future looks like. In which case I come back to, why isn't there a bigger drive to get people to work in social care? Yeah. Well, the daily tea will return tomorrow for Prime Minister's Questions on His Majesty's Secret Tea Service.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The UK faces a crisis of one million young people not in employment, education, or training (NEET), with the NEET rate at 13% and projected to rise to 16%.
  2. Alan Milburn's long-awaited review on youth unemployment proposes a ten-year plan to reduce the NEET rate to 5% and get 450,000 more young people into work.
  3. The review's proposals include creating 300,000 school-age work experience placements and increasing apprenticeships, but critics argue it only saves £200 million over a decade against a £120 billion welfare bill.
  4. Labour's tax rises, including increased National Insurance contributions and minimum wage hikes, have raised the cost of employing a young person by £12,000 since taking power.
  5. The review rejected more radical measures such as scrapping employer National Insurance for under-24s, opting instead for a £3,000 subsidy per young hire that does not cover the cost gap.
  6. The report draws on Northern European models like Denmark and the Netherlands, emphasising devolved services, closer school-employer collaboration, and "flex work" arrangements for disabled people.
  7. Critics argue the plan kicks the problem into the long grass, lacks urgency, and fails to address the root cause of unaffordable employment or the issue of benefits being more lucrative than work.
  8. The discussion highlights the need for resilience in young people, concerns about over-diagnosis of mental health conditions, and the looming impact of AI on the future job market.

Summary:

The podcast episode of The Daily Tea, hosted by Tim Stanley and Camilla Tominey, centres on Alan Milburn's long-awaited review into youth unemployment, which addresses the crisis of one million young people not in employment, education, or training. The review sets out a ten-year plan to reduce the NEET rate from 13% to 5%, proposing 450,000 more young people in work, 300,000 school-age work experience placements, and increased apprenticeships. However, the hosts criticise the plan for kicking the problem down the road, noting that it would save only £200 million over a decade against a £120 billion welfare bill, and that its success cannot be judged within a single parliament.

They argue the review fails to tackle the root cause: Labour's tax rises, including increased National Insurance contributions and minimum wage hikes, have raised the cost of employing a young person by £12,000. The review rejected more radical measures like scrapping employer National Insurance for under-24s, offering instead a £3,000 subsidy that does not cover the shortfall. The hosts also discuss Northern European models, the need for resilience, concerns about over-diagnosis of mental health conditions, and the looming impact of AI on the job market, concluding that businesses must be incentivised rather than penalised.

FAQs

About one million young people are not in work or training, with 13% classified as NEETs and this predicted to rise to 16%. Alan Milburn's report aims to reduce this to 5% over ten years.

The report aims to get 450,000 more young people into employment, increase apprenticeships, and create 300,000 school-age work experience placements. It also proposes local hubs and a Danish-style 'flex work' model for disabled people.

The net saving to taxpayers is only £200 million over a decade, which is tiny compared to the £120 billion benefits bill. Critics argue this makes success hard to judge and the plan lacks urgency.

Employers say the cost has risen by £12,000 since Labour took power due to higher minimum wage and national insurance contributions. The review rejected scrapping NICs for under-24s and offers only a £3,000 incentive, which doesn't cover the shortfall.

Employers face difficulties with insurance and bureaucracy when offering placements, especially for under-16s. This contributes to the decline of the traditional Saturday job.

It is a Danish policy where people on benefits, such as those with MS, can work part-time without losing their overall benefits entitlement. It is seen as a way to help disabled people gradually return to work.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.