Go back

BTC Liquidity Cycle, On-Chain Intelligence, Wall Street & Bitcoin | BMTV Oct. 19, 2026

2h 5m 34s

BTC Liquidity Cycle, On-Chain Intelligence, Wall Street & Bitcoin | BMTV Oct. 19, 2026

The broadcast opened with markets rebounding on Black Monday's 39th anniversary after a sharp tech sell-off the prior week, with Bitcoin trading above $82K and equity futures pointing higher. Grace Remington and Sean Hagan covered global headlines including euro weakness from French political tensions and energy prices, Indonesian stocks plunging amid a possible MSCI downgrade, and JPMorgan's $5 billion investment in national security industries. Discussion centered on the AI trade's sustainability. South Korea's KOSPI fell 8% Thursday, triggering a trading halt, as investors questioned whether the AI boom is too crowded or facing fundamental deterioration. The hosts noted a dramatic shift from roughly $15 billion in AI debt financing in 2024 to over $200 billion in 2026, with Anthropic receiving junk credit status ahead of a potential $2 trillion IPO. Michael Saylor's $100 trillion Bitcoin credit vision was unpacked, including his "alloy" analogy blending Bitcoin with dollar reserves and Strategy's move to daily dividend payments on its preferred stock. Sam Callahan discussed Brazil's currency debasement driving Bitcoin adoption and argued central banks will be last to adopt Bitcoin. Michael Howell warned that strong real economic growth is crowding out financial markets, predicting continued debt monetization that favors gold and Bitcoin as inflation hedges.

Transcription

22371 Words, 123358 Characters

English
Speaker 1Good morning. Happy Monday and welcome into BMTV. I'm Grace Remington with Sean Hagan. Well, it is the 39th anniversary of Black Monday and in a rare coincidence, a lot of people thought we'd see a lot of the same thing happening today with the tech sell-off that we saw heading into the weekend, but early signs in the futures markets pointing to a rebound and so far today, that's what we're seeing as well.
Speaker 2Absolutely. I had to bring out the black coat today for the infamous Black Monday. A lot of the doomers online were calling for the demise of the markets today on this glorious infamous anniversary, but you know, few people point out the positive spin on it, which is the markets actually closed that year up 2% on the year. So, you know, it gets this big scary name, but you know, it was kind of a dip for ants, especially if you're a Bitcoiner.
Speaker 1All right. Yeah. A lot to get into today. We're going to be diving way more into that tech sell-off, but here's who's joining us on today's show. Sam Callahan, director of Bitcoin strategy at Orange BTC, Michael Howell, MD at GL Indexes and Cross Border Capital, and our very own Isaiah Austin, BTC Inc. social markets correspondent. But let's begin with today's headlines. The euro was down in pre-market trading as high energy prices and weekend rioting in France added to concerns about the country's political stability. European natural gas prices hit a four-year high, while analysts warn that French political tensions could put more pressure on the euro if they hurt confidence across the region. Indonesian stocks fell more than 5% today after plunging nearly 12% Friday, as MSCI considers downgrading the country from emerging market to standalone status. The rapaya hovered near a record low and government bonds also sold off with Jakarta officials set to with MSCI later today. JP Morgan says it has invested $5 billion in equity in industries critical to U.S. economic and national security, including domestic manufacturing, energy infrastructure, and supply chain resilience. The bank also reports about $230 billion in financing under its Security and Resiliency Initiative, part of a 10-year, $1.5 trillion commitment. Russian President Vladimir Putin has said that he is looking forward to meeting with President Trump and Chinese leader Xi Jinping next month to discuss ending the war in Ukraine, according to The Wall Street Journal. The proposed summit would exclude Ukrainian President Zelenskyy, and a U.S. senior official says Trump has not agreed to attend. German savings banks are beginning to offer Bitcoin trading through their existing banking app, with the first customers getting access today. The German Savings Bank Association told DPA that the rollout will start at participating banks with another 30 to 40 expected to join each month. And Strategy says it has acquired another 267 Bitcoin, bringing its holdings to $848,517, while also repurchasing $193 million of Stretch Preferred stock. Strive bought 1,223 Bitcoin at an average cost just over eight, or I'm sorry, just under $82,000 each, increasing its worth total holdings to 36,818 Bitcoin. And with that, let's go to the markets and take a live look. Bitcoin trading just over $82K today, up eight-tenths of a percentage point on the day on Wall Street. The SPY and QQQ are pointing higher in trading. The SPY up half a percentage point. Triple Q up almost one and a half. And that's after the S&P and NASDAQ suffered their worst weekly losses since late June as concerns over the cost of AI infrastructure weighed on the market. Over in the bond market, treasury yields are moving lower. The 10-year yield now down to 5.08%. The 30-year at 5.42. We're also watching the short end of that curve, the three-month at 4.17 and the five-year at 4.8%. Gold also edging higher after the weekend, trading around $4,170 an ounce. And finally, oil moving higher. Brent above $108 a barrel today, and WTI crude also above $100 a barrel. Sean, anything standing out to you this morning?
Speaker 2Yeah, you know, it's good to see the markets are getting a bounce here. It's good to see Bitcoin showing some strength. You know, we got awfully close to that 80K level over the weekend. But as futures opened up yesterday, we started to see some strength pile back in. And so wanting to see a continuation this week with Bitcoin, we've been kind of chopping sideways for quite some time now. And, you know, it looks like we're building kind of this nice base for a solid move. And I'd like to see the direction of that move to be up.
Speaker 1Well, you mentioned the bounce. So let's go a little bit deeper into the equities markets now and take a look at the markets. So let's take a look at the equities markets now. So let's take a look at how these are trading individually to start the week if we can. So Alphabet, even companies delivering strong revenue growth aren't immune to the sell-off. It was down 3.3% last week. This morning, it is up 0.7% of a percentage point. Amazon finished down almost 5% last week. Today, it starts up 2.5%. Apple, the one showing relative strength while more AI-related names struggle. It's up 26% year-to-date, the best of the MAG7. But it's actually in the red today to start your trading week, down about 0.1% of a percentage point. Meta, that's one. It's reporting earnings October 21st. So investors are going to be watching that one. It had a particularly rough Friday when shares lost 3.7%. Today, it's still in the red, down 0.2% of a percentage point. Microsoft, totally not better than several other members of this group, was down about 1.5% at close on Friday, up 0.3% of a percentage point. Today, NVIDIA, obviously, the center of this AI boom. It is up 0.7% of a percentage point to start your Monday and also reporting earnings this week. It is up 0.8% of a percentage point this morning after being one of the weakest MAG7 stocks last week and year-to-date.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think a lot of that was just caused by, you know, there's been this repricing in their bond market, in the debt market, private credit, a lot of these various instruments that these orgs use, whether they're public or private. So there's been some restructuring and re-rating. Going on there. Concerns about expenses to refinance and continuing this build out. And that's kind of in the backdrop. And then we saw the KOSPI kind of fall off a cliff, right? And we saw sort of this weakening in confidence coming off of that unwind there with that market. A lot of people tie it to the chip narrative coming out of China with potentially superior chips being able to be produced now out of areas not. Not just Taiwan. So it's going to be interesting to continue to monitor that situation. But we've at least gotten a bounce here. It seems like a lot of the woes have cooled. But we'll see if we get a continuation here. And this is just a brief kind of relief rally. Or if we truly kind of have the dust settle, then we can have a nice continuation through the rest
Speaker 1of Q4. A lot of the concern here is not just sentiment and how does all this financing work, but there are concerns of a global chip supply shortage hitting in 2029. That's weighing down sentiment a bit. But last week, two CEOs from Broadcom and Intel actually talked about this at a conference. They said access to capital and the cost of capital is the reason the AI boom slows. It's not a shortage of chips, semiconductors, or electricity. The Intel CEO just kind of set it out right. He was like, people want to see the ROI. And right now, that's obviously a huge question if companies heavily invested in AI will eventually generate enough returns to make this all worth it. But what do you think? I mean, looking back now, we've had a few days to digest. Is it more the financing or do you think it's a supply shortage that's kind of prompting?
Speaker 2Well, it's all of it. And I think the biggest thing is going to be these earnings calls. I think the market doesn't like uncertainty, or I know the market doesn't like uncertainty, and so getting these earning calls is going to really help us understand profitability, forward expectations, and guidance as well. To your point, there seems to definitely be a slowing in certain bottlenecks. I'm more interested on the data center side of things. There's a lot of these projects being planned. They're raising a lot of capital for them, but we don't see a lot of dirt being moved. If you talk to civil contractors on the ground, there's a lot of They've been accepting bids to build these, but they're caught up kind of at the, the city approval level. So not a lot of dirt actually being moved. And it's going to be interesting to see if we can kind of get back on a pace to accelerate there, or if that's going to continue to be a bottleneck along with other things on the supply side, like chips.
Speaker 1I liked something Dan Ives said. He's a tech analyst at Yorkville. Ives has a really good blog, I guess you could call it, every so often he posts there. But he says this pullback represents a buying opportunity. And what would change his view is a demand signal, not a rate signal. And right now, the demand is there. He says the warning signs he would watch are potential cuts in hyperscaler spending budgets, canceled contracts, or falling GPU rental prices. But do you agree with him? Do you see this as a buying opportunity?
Speaker 2Not as broadly as I would need to read his analysis. But just on the headline alone, I would say no. It's probably overly broad. I think the question is, how do we do this? And I think it's a good question. I think it's a good question. And this trade continues to kind of crowd. It seems to me that the players who are largely debt finance, they're going to have more expensive cost of capital. And then even those that are cash financed, you have to look at the flow of capital of who's financing who. Similar to these flywheels of financial engineering, we're going to have to look at the flow of capital of who's financing who. We see that can be used in a virtuous way. Sometimes they can go sour as well. So I would be cautious of that, especially in this space where there's only a select number of companies doing business with each other. So contagion could spread rather quickly or maybe more sensitively. So, you know, I don't think it's the end of the world, but I would be very careful about kind of like broad sweeping statements. I think there's going to be a narrowing, a little bit of free market Darwinism, so to speak, and the fittest will survive long term and continue to expand on this technology. But it's going to be hard to do so in the macro environment, especially given the nature of what this technology is and and and its promise by virtue of its own characteristics to compress and open source and become easier and more freely and widely available for the public's use. And so it presents challenges to revenue models and and it's becoming more expensive to produce something that cuts the business model of revenue. So so I would say, you know, let's let's try to pick the winners here and watch for some market signal instead of just saying, you know, kind of broadly everyone's going to be all right.
Speaker 1Well, you mentioned the Kospi, so I want to go back there and talk about the global equity sell off that we were tracking last week. South Korea has been particularly hard hit. Remember, it is extremely top heavy with Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix accounting for roughly forty seven percent of the index's market value. And the concern isn't just whether the AI boom can sustain its momentum, but whether these companies can maintain their competitive advantage. Now, last week, remember, it plummeted eight percent Thursday, falling to a six month low. It raced all gains since April and actually triggered a 20 minute trading halt on the floor today. Looking at it now, it looks like it closed in the green up one point seven percent. But Sean, do you think this is still a broader global flight from risk or are investors becoming more selective about their exposure to AI?
Speaker 2I like the way you phrased that question. I do think there probably is a global flight from risk if you just kind of take a traditional risk curve approach, really, you know, equities or, you know, AI tech are on one side of the risk curve traditionally conceived and then, you know, government bonds on the other side with with the re-rating we're seeing in bonds. You know, you can get a relatively risk free return on that on that capital via vis-a-vis the yield there as compared to maybe the uncertainty of a global technology build out. Now, people are obviously going to categorize that differently. But I do think there is an element of that of that to this. I do think that these, you know, macro or treasury markets behavior are acting as a headwind to capital in this AI space. But, you know, I do also think that to your point, it's people maybe trying to be more be more narrow or more intentional with where they're placing bid on this build out. I don't think that, you know, this is the end of the Korean market or anything like that. I think plenty of capital will continue to flow in there. But, you know, what the market is telling us is that investors are certainly being more selective and a little bit more critical with with how they allocate and where they allocate their capital at this moment.
Speaker 1Yeah, but it wasn't just South Korea taking the punches last week. Japan's stock market also was down 5 percent after that initial sell off on Thursday. Looks like it closed down six tenths of a percentage point today. Same with Taiwan, also down six tenths of a percentage point. The euro 600 was watching as well. It did end up closing Friday in the green, but looks like it's down nine tenths of a percent this week. So, you know, it's going to be a little bit of an interesting trade to see. So, with that being said, do you think this is a case? I mean, because this is a global sell off now. Is this a case of the A.I. trade becoming too crowded or is it a fundamental
Speaker 2problem or are the fundamentals starting to deteriorate? A little bit of both, but I think it's maybe more it's probably more by virtue of look in 2024, this was largely equity financed. You fast forward now, I think in 2024 was something like 14 to 17 billion dollars. of debt financing. And now this year it's 200 billion plus of debt financing. Right. So you have you have this massive scale up over two years of the amount of debt financing going into this machine. And now you have the global debt markets kind of rebalancing and repricing. This is going to be sensitive to that, as well as by virtue of the rapid expansion. So, you know, you have a lot of capital trying to chase a few winners. And, you know, the rates are readjusting according to the to the global markets, but also according to just kind of sort of maybe a rebalancing of of this sector specifically as well. So there's a lot of moving parts. I don't think it's out of the normal to kind of see this this moment where the market might be taking pause and re-rating a little bit before it moves forward. I don't think that's anything too out of the ordinary. And I think it's by virtue of a lot of factors. But I don't think we can just sweep under the rug the fact that it went from 14 or, you know, under 20 billion of debt financing in 2024 to over 200 billion in 2026.
Speaker 1I think the key to watch moving forward, obviously, is market breadth as technology weakens, because, I mean, it's this it's 10 companies essentially holding up the entire S&P. I mean, that's a dangerous situation. So obviously, you know, looking at a healthy market, we want the one where other sectors. Are gaining gaining leadership, right, rather than it just being dominated by a select few. But also want to ask you about oil, because we are seeing these these prices skyrocket in the last couple of days. And it used to be just a Middle East problem. Now we're seeing Ukraine really impact these prices as well. How does that impact the tech sell off?
Speaker 2Yeah, look, I I don't think enough attention is on on the Ukraine situation as well. Obviously, we want that war to end. We don't want it to be resolved, but that war continues on. And the problem is so so you have you have two major, you know, factors weighing on global oil and global, you know, refined product prices. You know, the the U.S. struck a deal with with Russia trying to to get energy out and into the world before the war. Russia was responsible for 10 percent of diesel coming onto the global market. That's a lot of supply. You know, we need diesel, especially as we head. Into the winter here. And so that's that's important that that, you know, we we can kind of alleviate energy prices, get energy into the hands of people before a cold, a cold winter, especially Europe is is going to be sensitive to that in the U.S. In terms of price at the pump is sensitive, especially heading into midterms. A lot of incentives to bring those prices down for consumers. But Ukraine's response was to blow up Russia's export facilities. So that's not great. That's that's generally not what you want to see happening. We want to be building refineries, not blowing them up. So, you know, you don't you know. And so I think that that caused some some concern in the market. And and, you know, people started to get a bit uneasy in the market over the weekend after that happened roughly Friday, Saturday, somewhere around that timeline. And then a ship in the Strait of Hormuz hit a water based mine and blew up and that accelerated the concerns. Over the weekend, because people realized, OK, this this Iran thing is still going on. There's mines all over the Strait. Even if we got a peace deal, Iran says they lost the mines. They don't know where they are. And at the same time, you see the U.S. and Israel escalating some some military personnel or bunkers and things like that around the region. So very interesting to watch. It seems like an escalation could be around the corner, maybe after midterms on the Iran front. And at the same time, we have Ukraine. train blowing up, diesel exports, on the russian front so it's been a really really horrible weekend for the energy market at large
Speaker 1yeah and uh i forgot midterms playing a a huge role in this too so um we're i mean lots of headlines to be watching the next couple weeks but as we watch this selling pressure spread across global markets there's another question investors are starting to ask about the ai boom not just whether demand will hold up but whether these companies can afford to keep building the infrastructure needed to meet it and that brings us to anthropic the financial times reporting the claw developer received a double b plus credit rating from kroll back in june that's just one notch below investment grade and technically considered junk status the rating came ahead of a 35 billion dollar chip financing deal with some of the riskier debt carrying an eight and a half percent yield compared to just five and three quarters percent on more securities secure debt backed by broadcom but here's the interesting part anthropic had no traditional debt on its own balance sheet at the time and its financial performance has actually been improving third quarter revenue reached 16.8 billion dollars up nearly 50 percent from the previous quarter with two consecutive quarters of adjusted profitability and now wall street banks are working on another 60 billion dollar financing package as anthropic prepares for a potential ipo that could value it at more than two trillion dollars so sean anthropic technically receiving a junk bond status here how do we reconcile these valuations with the risks lenders are seeing with
Speaker 2them um i'm not sure and i think a lot of people are asking that same question look i mean it it really is um you know do you believe in the the optimism of this technology and is it going to drive down production costs and you know devalue the the sas market you know it's it's um you know certainly i think the answer is yes but but but then the question becomes okay well does that democratize and become open source or does that get constrained you know i've i've historically said you know hey this is kind of self-defeating by nature um it seems almost like it's necessarily going to compress you know we talked about the uh we showed the token maxing chart that one time um from from uh michael burry's newsletter and it shows you know their their largest buyer uh of of tokens at these frontier models is incentivized to just ultimately make you know you have their own in-house models and and their their primary revenue drivers go away um and you know we we've still yet to see anthropic uh turn a profit obviously they have large revenues but but not you know a profit but they're not going to be able to make a lot of money and they're not going to make a lot of money and they're not going to make a lot of money and they're not going to make a lot of um you know their revenue was up about 46 50 percent from q3 uh from q2 to q3 um so they're turning the right direction in terms of revenue uh but they still need to answer that question about driving a profit especially as as things open source but at the same time we we see um the the industry leaders fighting back on this push for open source um you know amazon for example blocking grok bot um a lot of online uh tech giant social media uh shopping e-commerce all these places um are kind of combating uh ai traffic to their sites and and bot usage um it might be kind of like a netflix moment where we thought we were going to get this kind of one streaming service that was going to disrupt everybody and now you know we have every traditional cable news service uh has their own you know streaming service now you have hbo you have tnt you have espn all just are streaming services and they're not going to be so it might be something where they're able to kind of monopolize a bit use their power as these large corporate authorities and now everyone has to use their agents and their ai it might be something like that and in that world ai you know a lot of these valuations might turn out to be great uh and they might turn out to be right um but but i think it's more akin to something like bitcoin ultimately and i think that there's going to be some some serious questions to answer here uh especially as they gear up uh to to go public and offer their shares uh to the public market
Speaker 1okay so we're seeing investors take a harder look at risk which leads us to an interesting comparison from grayscale which challenges one of the biggest assumptions about bitcoin according to this research from grayscale 57 percent of companies in the s&p 500 are now more volatile than bitcoin and bitcoin's own volatility has fallen dramatically over the past five years so sean we have spent years talking about bitcoin as a risky asset one of the most risky assets out there do you feel like that reputation is
Speaker 2starting to change i do um uh for for a select group right it's interesting i i was talking to some uh a couple a couple um uh colleagues who work in in the wealth advisory investment advisory industry over the weekend and and you know you still get split opinions right um uh you know a lot of a lot of their clients view bitcoin actually right now is sort of a a hedge against the macro turmoil a lot of distrust about what's going to happen uh to the dollar for example um and so that's really interesting to hear um it's it's currently still very much viewed as sort of this this alternative um with or without its volatility um not so much a safe bet on the future more of a hedge so that's interesting and then you know there's some of the wealth advisors or people more like the tradfi space that truly understand bitcoin that understand the properties of it how it impacts the sharp ratio of a portfolio so um i do think the sophisticated investors that are reading reports like this reading um reports like the one that bitwise put out two weeks ago i think they're on the ball i think that they're starting to get sharp um but you know there's still that curve right i think that when it comes to institutions or larger retail maybe like a family office there's still kind of this gap you have the front runners kind of that early majority and that's who we're seeing a lot of these headlines come from but the the vast majority still view it at best as maybe some sort of currency
Speaker 1hedge well and if bitcoin is becoming a more mature asset that could have important implications for how investors think about their retirement savings we spoke with amy oldenburg of morgan stanley about this topic last week uh what does it take to bring more bitcoin exposure into retirement accounts let's take a listen now when it comes to explaining the role of bitcoin in portfolios for your clients can you walk us through how you help them think about position sizing and specifically for your investors who are closer to you than you are to your clients who are closer to retirement age how should they be thinking about bitcoin
Speaker 3yeah it's a it's a good question and and um sean earlier you were talking about some of the movement the price movement we've seen the last day or so on bitcoin you know it's still trading with those risk assets i think we've made a very strong argument that this should be trading more like digital gold we saw the volatility actually be pretty you know pretty low this year as we saw some higher volatility in the tech names uh and and you know i think i i'd like to see it perform a little bit more in line with digital gold it's um you know to see this movement with some of the risk assets um you know that we need this to um really you know play the role uh in portfolios that i i think that um the rationale that we've really talked about a fair bit on this digital gold position especially when you see the gold price uh actually going up and you see that bitcoin price uh retreating over the last day or so um so that's something we just need to be a little bit conscious of here because we do think that digital gold uh rationale is going to be going to be going to be going to be going to be a pretty strong rationale for bitcoin within that asset allocation
Speaker 1so given what we just heard from amy oldenburg this could be a pretty significant development for bitcoin's long-term investor base because if retirement accounts start allocating to bitcoin on a regular basis i mean what does that mean for the traditional four-year cycle
Speaker 2well it definitely continues to dampen our volatility right these are long-dated uh actors right it's very thesis driven very directional um a lot of tolerance um to kind of give it its time um you know not they're not they're not traders right they're they're investors with a bit of a longer time horizon so that's not to say that that if bitcoin starts to underperform over over an extended period of time they won't kind of cut it and move on um but they're going to have a bit more patience it's going to be more thesis driven and so you're going to be you're going to have less uh market participants willing to sell bitcoin which is going to drive uh less volatility on these downturns right and i think you're starting to see um the the beginnings of that right this this was our shallowest drawdown of any cycle so far um and you know it's no coincidence that this is the first bear market post the etfs launching
Speaker 1that's a fair point um so do you think if bitcoin starts trading more like a mature portfolio asset are those big boom and bust cycles a thing or the of the past or is that always going to be part of bitcoin's dna um
Speaker 2it's the potential is always going to be there right i wouldn't say it's it's gone especially to the upside right we're we're digital gold to to amy oldenburg's point um but we're less than 10 of gold's market cap okay so so uh at what point do we get there at what point do we get to 50 that's a huge move right that's that's a 5x um and how quickly do we get there and it's 50 of gold really all that much for um gold 2.0 with better properties better scarcity less reflexivity in a world that's increasingly agentic and on chain and tokenized probably not and so how fast do we get there uh and that would considered sharp volatility, uh, certainly. And we would have that quick boom cycle, maybe less of a bust given that people have this thesis driven, um, you know, uh, appetite to just hold and kind of wait, you know, uh, wait out, draw down. So I would say the volatility is disappearing to the downside more so than the upside and that the upside still very much exists. And I think as Bitcoiners, sometimes, um, we feel like we're not being mature or institutional enough to, and we kind of shy away from talking about that upside. Um, but, but you know, that's ultimately just going to have people be disinterested and go to these, the alt coin casino, because they think that they missed Bitcoin. They haven't missed Bitcoin. Bitcoin's only 10% of gold. We're going to surpass the market cap of gold. It's just a matter of when, not if 50% is just a five X around the corner. So that volatility absolutely still exists on the boom cycle part. But now that we have these institutional, uh, uh, investors coming in, it's, and it's, you know, kind of changing the world. So I think that's, I think that's a good thing. I think that's a good thing. That cost basis and having a more stable floor. I don't think we see as much of a bus cycle.
Speaker 1Really exciting to see how this Bitcoin cycle is now developing, especially when you remember that Bitcoin was introduced as peer-to-peer electronic cash, but for most people, it's still more familiar as something to hold than something to use. Cash app is an easy way to send money to family and friends. Buying Bitcoin there is the simple next step from there. You can easily send Bitcoin pay over lightning at square terminals and move Bitcoin into cold storage all in one place. Bitcoin at block is building the full loop. Cash app lets you buy, send, spend, and earn Bitcoin with tools like auto invest roundups paid in Bitcoin and lightning eligible square sellers can accept Bitcoin over lightning, settle in seconds and pay 0% processing fees through 2026. BitKey gives you self custody without a seed phrase or single point of failure with built-in recovery and inheritance tools and a screen on the second generation device. Buy, spend, save all with peace of mind for the future. The point is to make Bitcoin useful from the moment you get it to the moment you secure it yourself. To learn more about Bitcoin at block and access the latest offers for cash app square and BitKey, check out the links and promo codes in the episode description. Terms apply. This episode is sponsored by Bitcoin at block, including cash app square and BitKey. Well, coming up next, Michael Saylor has a $100 trillion vision for Bitcoin, but why does the future he's building still depend so heavily on the dollar? We're unpacking his latest comments coming up next on BMTV.
Speaker 4Bitcoin can help diversify how you spend, save, and invest in your business, especially when every swipe of a credit card eats away at your bottom line. Let's say you run a local grocery chain. Most purchases are small, like a bag of produce or a gallon of milk. So credit card fees start to add up fast. With Square, you can now accept Bitcoin with zero payment processing fees, no chargebacks, and your instant access to funds. Then you choose how money settles into your account, whether in USD or Bitcoin, instantly and right from your Square dashboard. Whether you're aiming for short-term goals or planning for the long haul, you can automatically convert a percentage of your daily card sales into Bitcoin. No extra steps, no added complexity. It's a smart, seamless way to build savings in the background, all while keeping your day-to-day cash flow predictable. And when tax time comes, you'll get the paperwork you need right where you find it. So, let's get started. Bitcoin is just another way for you to take control of how your business makes and spends money. Enable Bitcoin payments and conversions in your Square dashboard. Head to squareup.com slash Bitcoin to learn more.
Speaker 5You believe in Bitcoin, so why would you ever sell it? Life happens, an emergency expense, a new home purchase, or a great business opportunity. With Salt, you can access the power of your Bitcoin and your business. Now, with rates starting at 7.5%. The original Bitcoin-backed lender. No collateral losses, no rehypothecation since 2016. Get your exclusive offer at saltlending.com forward slash BMTV. Real estate has stored wealth for generations.
Speaker 6But what happens when absolutely scarce digital money challenges that role? In Digital Real Estate, Leon Wankum explores how Bitcoin is reshaping property, capital allocation, and the future of investing. Digital Real Estate.
Speaker 7Available now. And ready when the conversation starts. Then, Plod's AI turns your conversation into a transcript showing who said what in a summary of key points and action items.
Speaker 1Michael Saylor is laying out his blueprint for the future of finance, and it goes well beyond simply buying Bitcoin. Speaking at Parify Investor Day with investor Jeff Park, the strategy executive chairman explained how Bitcoin could become the foundation for an entire new credit system. One he believes could eventually reach $100 trillion. Here's how he sees it working out.
Speaker 8We sell the credit. We buy the Bitcoin. We drive up the price of the Bitcoin. We drive up the premium in the common stock. We can issue the common stock. We can buy the Bitcoin, drive up the price of the Bitcoin. As the Bitcoin goes up, the reserves go up. The risk on the credit goes down. The credit spreads compress. We sell more credit. We buy more Bitcoin. Right. And why does it work? Because Bitcoin is a commodity. And because it's capped at $21 million. And we, by ourselves, can buy all the Bitcoin produced in the world forever. Just our company. Strive, in the last two weeks, has bought all the Bitcoin produced in the world. One other company. You get 10 companies doing the same thing. Then, you know, if we bought 10x as much gold as was mined each year, you'd think the price of gold would go up. It's like, it's not complicated, right? It's, it's a, it's a financial ratchet. We're just building the system. Right now, it's about a $1.5 to $2 trillion system. You can scale this up to be a $10 trillion, $20 trillion, $50 trillion, $100 trillion system. And when it gets going, it gets going very fast.
Speaker 2Yeah. And he's explaining his flywheel, right? A lot of people think that, you know, this financial ratchet is a sign that there's something nefarious as a foot or there's stress. Well, well, no, it's, it's intentionally designed to replicate what, what central banks used to do. For example, you know, Saylor uses the bank of England example all the time and how they used gold as capital and built these credit instruments around it and monetized it. And, and it's the same thing, but with a 21st century technology with a much less reflexive supply driven instrument, right? Where, where Bitcoin actually has a having and an auto investment. And so it's going to have a lot more explosive sensitivity to the perpetual bid being put on it. And why would you not monetize gold 2.0 that is, you know, internet native in the 21st century in this agentic on chain economy. So it makes a lot of sense. It is engineered, but it's engineered intentionally. And it's simply replicating what happened to gold at the turn of centuries past.
Speaker 1And there's an interesting catch to Saylor's vision. While Bitcoin may be the foundation of this new system, investors still want the security of dollars. Saylor explained that when strategies preferred stock stretch came under pressure, holding more Bitcoin wasn't necessarily what reassured investors and said they wanted confidence that strategy could keep making its dividend payments. Take a listen.
Speaker 8and then we put in place a buyback program and we bought back about one and a half billion dollars of it to drive it back to par. We learned along the way that the marketplace really values US dollars duration more than Bitcoin. Like it would rather see us have three years of dollars than 30 years of Bitcoin. And so there are diminishing returns. The difference between 10 years of Bitcoin and 100 years of Bitcoin is diminishing. Maybe it's not even relevant. It may not be material. The difference between having 10 months or five months of cash versus three years of cash is huge. Digital credit is an alloy of capital and cash or capital and currency. You know, and, you know, if you created it as 98 percent Bitcoin and two percent cash, it tends to buckle. Yeah, look, it's certainly interesting.
Speaker 2I think it's a good thing that Saylor and the strategy team are listening to the market. Giving them what they want, especially in the infancy of these newer prep credit like products. And I really think it's fun the way that he he calls it an alloy, right? Saylor is performing alchemy, financial alchemy. And so alloy is an appropriate word to use. One thing of note is that he said that their stated blend of material for this kind of backing product for these prefs is about 70% Bitcoin, 30% fiat cash, US dollar cash. And so it'll be interesting as Bitcoin starts to really take off and perform over this next bull market, it'll be interesting to see what kind of rebalancing might occur or if they're okay allowing the makeup of this alloy or the fundamental nature of this alloy to change in terms of its percentage relative to each component of the alloy. But it's a fun analogy. He's the alchemist of the 21st century financial markets. And it'll be interesting to see if the market continues to prefer the duration of dollars, even as these instruments start to add track record. Again, like we've talked about with some people, some guests, for example, like Lauren from UTXO management, typically to invest in a product like this, allocators will need to see about three years of track record to feel comfortable. And so it'll be interesting to see as this track record builds, if that desire for a fiat weighted alloy, at least to that 30% mark will evolve over
Speaker 1time. Yeah, it is interesting because, you know, Saylor is one of the biggest advocates for Bitcoin over fiat currency, but even he knows investors still value cash when it comes to receiving their payments. So I do really love the alloy. Comparison there. For more on treasury companies from someone helping to run the playbook in Brazil, we go to our next guest, Sam Callahan, director of strategy and research at Orange BTC. Good morning, Sam. Welcome in. Good morning.
Speaker 9Thanks for having me.
Speaker 1Yeah, thanks for joining us. So let's talk about your work at Orange BTC. How much of a concern are local currencies right now in the way they're driving Bitcoin adoption in Latin America? Just what are you seeing from average people? Business investors trying to protect what they've earned?
Speaker 9Yeah, well, that was one of the reasons why we thought it was compelling to start a Bitcoin treasury company in Brazil was their history of currency debasement. You know, they're very well aware of what can happen when fiat currencies are mismanaged. And so they understand that they need to protect themselves against the mismanagement of their currencies, against capital controls, against currency debasement. And so that helps when we talk about the education of why Bitcoin matters. It's very easy to explain to a Brazilian, why it's helpful to have a money that nobody can print, right? Especially when you look at fiat currencies, not just in Brazil, but the United States, pretty much everywhere around the world, they're getting debased at an increasingly alarming rate. And so certainly that's a part of the story of why we launched a Bitcoin treasury company in Brazil. And there's really just not that much competition in terms of getting exposure to the Bitcoin ecosystem through some kind of publicly listed vehicle. There's not many options available to Brazilians today. And there's also restrictions on certain pools of capital where they can't access spot Bitcoin, either through their investment mandates or through the regulatory restrictions. But they can buy, say, an equity that represents exposure to Bitcoin ecosystem, like orange BTCs. And so that was certainly part of the thesis for why we started the company. And it's why Brazil, according to Chainalysis' recent global adoption index, Brazil's number one in terms of digital asset adoption. You know, they're very progressive and they understand why this technology matters.
Speaker 2And, you know, in the Brazil market specifically, I'd be curious to know the reaction or the impact, whether material or mechanical, of the MSCI news, right? Obviously a lot of attention on U.S.-based treasuries, but kind of given that outlook of how indices are going to be treated or are going to be treating treasury companies like yours, is there any conceptual or perceptual impact for orange BTC?
Speaker 9Yeah, I mean, I think it affects every company building on Bitcoin, right? Has Bitcoin as their primary treasury reserve asset? It's unfortunate. You know, these index providers are supposed to be neutral. They're supposed to reflect the market and the evolving equity markets. And we're seeing that this committee now is incorporating politics into their decision making. But, you know, we just keep building. This is just one index provider. And in Bitcoin for a long time now, we've seen discriminatory actions against digital assets at different levels of the traditional financial system. And now we're seeing it by one single index provider. And what we see is that the index providers that embrace Bitcoin will benefit and their indices will more accurately reflect the evolving market. And those that create these arbitrary rules and discriminate against companies building Bitcoin on Bitcoin will eventually their indices will not reflect it. And the other thing I'll say is that MSCI's index methodologies are written by committees. You know, they're subject to revisions. They're not permanent, but Bitcoin is permanent. And I would argue that currency debasement is also a permanent feature of these financial system today. And so more and more companies will eventually turn to Bitcoin and different reserve assets to protect themselves against debasement. And eventually MSCI, I'm betting, will change these methodologies as the market will evolve and more and more companies will be building Bitcoin operating businesses. And so I see this as just one roadblock, but eventually, you know, other index providers will embrace Bitcoin and eventually MSCI will have to capitulate just like any other organization that goes against this revolutionary technology.
Speaker 1Developing countries are facing higher debt payments and inflation. I mean, just last week at the Bangkok meetings, the G24 chair said developing countries pay more, pay about $500 billion more than developed countries on their debt. So how can Bitcoin help them depend less on outside lenders?
Speaker 9I mean, this is the problem. This is like I focus on fiscal policy, you know, maybe more than anything outside of Bitcoin, because it is why, you know, Bitcoin exists in the first place. You know, for every $3 in circulation to have been created since Bitcoin's genesis block. And so, you know, we really have to look at the fiscal pictures and the unsustainable fiscal pictures of not just developed countries, but also emerging markets. It's global. You know, this debt binge is global. You know, the IMF recently put out that over $350 trillion in debt, we're at historic levels. And really what that means is that there's only so many things the governments can do. And one of the most politically palatable options for them is to turn to financial repression, is to turn to currency debasement. And so that's why education needs to occur with investors about how do you protect yourself against that? Well, you seek alternatives, you seek monetary alternatives that are difficult to debase, like Bitcoin, like gold. And you're seeing, you know, some of these actions right now. I mean, over the last year in the US, for instance, you know, we're spending more than we did last year. And the entitlement programs are only continuing to grow. And over the last five years, we've seen two things. We've seen financial repression, where inflation is being allowed to run hot. And the US bond market, so the US aggregate bond market is in its steepest and longest drawdown in history. And so it's happening right now. And then at the same time, core PCE was at 3.7% on average over that timeframe. Now that's really, it's difficult for people to contextualize that. It's kind of a vague way to explain this. But really what that means is that the US dollar has lost 20% of its purchasing power over the last five years. That's an obscene level of currency debasement. And that's the reserve, the global reserve asset. And so we need as people, we need to be frustrated with the fact that these central bankers aren't doing their job. Their mandate is price stability. And they're not maintaining the purchasing power of the currency. And ultimately, everybody, every wage earner, every saver, every bond investor, they suffer in this period of financial repression, financial repression and currency debasement. And so people need to be aware that this is happening so they protect themselves.
Speaker 2So I take it you do not believe that the Greenspan 2.0 run it hot game plan is working effectively.
Speaker 9No, I think it's working great. It's just not working for the people. It's working for the government. This is the way that they're trying to solve the problem. They won't outright say this, but the data is the data. This is what's occurring. And I know I'm a little bit sick and tired of saying what theoretically can happen to the dollar. We can theoretically go through financial repression like, no, this is what's happening over the last five years. It'll likely continue because they won't actually do what needs to be done, which is reduce the spending, which is to get the fiscal house in order. You know, that's what actually would help the situation, but they're not willing to go through the pain. And that's why you see actions taken by the Federal Reserve as well as the Treasury Department and the Treasury Department. And so they're trying to kind of cap that long end because they want to have their cake and eat it, too. They want to continue to run massive deficits, but they don't want to suffer the consequence of long term higher borrowing costs. And so they're trying to kind of cap that long end. And the way they do that is through the financial repression and currency debasement. And ultimately, the sufferers are wage earners and savers.
Speaker 2And what do you make of the Bank of International Settlement recently put out a paper describing gold as this monetary protest? And they also said in the same paper that Bitcoin shares that impulse. Um, but you know, how do you view that argument when central banks themselves are buying gold? Um, uh, and so the perpetrators are, are buying the gold, um, and they have this kind of allergic reaction to Bitcoin. So a couple of different points there that, that I would love to hear your kind of reactions to.
Speaker 9Yeah, I would say watch what they do and not what they say, right? That's, um, you know, the central banks know more than anybody, uh, what the sustainability of the fiscal policies are and and they they are doing they're protecting themselves you know they're accumulating gold at a rapid rate you know what they call a monetary protest well why are they protesting i think it's pretty ironic um and then financial institutions themselves they've been embracing bitcoin at a rapid rate over the last three years it's been one of the biggest trends driving bitcoin i would say repricing it higher um and so basically the institutions that are in charge of underpinning the traditional financial system are embracing these alternatives and you have to ask yourself why and the bank of international settlements you know i've been reading their research for going on 10 years tracking their comments on bitcoin on stable coins and one of the most interesting things is they always talk about trust they always talk about how you trust they talk about the soul of money of fiat and how it depends on trust and that the central banks provide that trust and it's so much gaslighting because if you look at any kind of survey of the credibility of the financial uh the federal uh the central banks or the traditional financial system confidence is in the gutter it's at a historic low their credibility is at a low because they're not maintaining the the purchasing power of the currency the main job that they have and it's not really surprising that their credibility is low i mean kevin warsh just last week was saying that um the money printer is a powerful tool but our biggest tool is our credibility and i'm like well you don't have any credibility um just like even jerome paul a couple years ago we now know how much we don't know about inflation i'm like thank you like that's your entire job uh you're not doing a great job and so this is what i mean why people should be frustrated because you know another thing the biz always says is you know our job is to maintain uh the purchasing power of the currency to maintain money as a store of value as a unit of account and a medium of exchange but they totally overlook the fact that nobody wants to hold the fiat currencies because they failed at making it a store of value it's like the number one thing um and so you know i just i've been following the biz and it seems like they're concerned about stable coins uh for the future and they're concerned about stable coins uh for the future and the most part and they should be it's it's a private sector innovation um and and they're concerned about that but also they're not concerned yet as much about bitcoin because they still think of it as this like uh unstable long-term store of value and there's nothing backing it but then they contradict themselves because in 2023 actually in a speech in brazil the former chairman of the biz augustin karstens he was talking about how fiat is an asset with no intrinsic value and that the value comes from trust and that's why the issuer of the money is so powerful and if we ruin that trust we risk uh our fiat currencies getting rejected by society that is almost a direct quote from the former chairman and i would say we're in that right now and that's why we're seeing a large monetary protest from people all over the world including the institutions that are meant to underpin
Speaker 2it and you know as these central banks are are protesting their own policy and buying gold when does bitcoin become a tool for them to use or are they just going to cope and and you know stay at arm's length away from bitcoin until it's it's too late in the private market has has basically kind of periferated this technology on its own yeah i think
Speaker 9we're uh you know we've seen a little bit of of adoption at that level for bitcoin i mean we saw like kazakhstan come out you know on the margin uh we saw the uh czech republic central bank run a study but they found that it was too volatile but they did say that it provided diversification which i thought was interesting but the volatility part is important and understanding what central banks use fx reserves for versus say like a corporation is also an important nuance to understand because central banks have fx reserves and they use those fx reserves during periods of market stress where they have to you know sell their fx reserves to prop up their currency or you know you know sell their fx reserves to prop up their currency or to support the economy during some kind of external shock and if bitcoin is still behaving like a risk asset where during those volatile times it's falling with other risk assets it doesn't really uh it's not very useful for a central bank to have that as an fx reserves today it's not really thinking about uh you know generational wealth or long-term uh total returns like say like a corporation it's thinking about how do we use this during periods of market stress and today i think the market still doesn't fully view bitcoin as a safe haven asset so it is is more volatile and can during those periods of stress but obviously i think that's changing over time as people learn more and more about this uh new new asset but that's why i think like most of the the central banks will be the last to fully adopt bitcoin so
Speaker 1you mentioned the dollar has lost 20 percent of its purchasing power over the last five years and the dollar has lost 20 percent if central banks are turning to gold as government debt grows what does that mean for the dollar and its role in global reserves yeah i
Speaker 9think look at the dollar you talk about network effects a lot with bitcoin right the dollar is a very strong network effect and so i don't think uh you know treasuries is the reserve asset that we're talking about but i do think there's going to be a shift to apolitical neutral reserve assets if treasuries continue to be weaponized um other foreign central banks will continuously look to diversify from that risk as well as countries and investors continue to get concerned about the deficit spending about the debt i mean you know you want to diversify your risks and and eventually you're going to turn to assets that can't be printed um you know and i want to go back because i use 20 percent and i'm using the core pce because that's the fed's you know favorite inflation gauge but i would argue they love it because it understands that it's not going to be printed and it's going to be printed and it's going to be printed and it's going to be printed and it's going to be printed and it's going to be printed more than any other one so i think the dollar has actually lost more of its purchasing power than 20 over the last five years but i think it's just absurd that the most conservative inflation metric that's how much it's been inflated um but yeah so like i think the dollar will continue to be uh very prominent i think we're we're entering this hyper dollarized and and and uh and gold and bitcoin the world like it'll be these apolitical neutral monetary alternatives and increasingly the dollar as stable coins improve access to the dollar around the world and the dollar still relative to other fiat currencies looks quite stable um but but compare the dollar to bitcoin to gold over long periods of time you know you start to reveal the the erosion of purchasing power but i do think we're going to enter this like this period where you know those are the three pillars that people turn to when we think reserves when we think about long-term savings and sam
Speaker 2we're almost out of time but but one more question for you well we got you we got a big fed meeting coming up oil's climbing again inflation remains a problem um and you know over time bitcoin historically hasn't really tended to care too much about the fed funding rate but that correlation has increased as bitcoin becomes more of this global asset do you do you think that bitcoin uh you know needs uh lower rates to do well and outperform like you might see some some analysts theorizing or do you think that this sort of uh monetary debasement and mismanagement um of of kind of global regimes is going to continue to drive a bid towards an alternative like bitcoin regardless of if the fed stays tight yeah
Speaker 9i am look i think the focus on interest rates shows that most people don't understand what's actually driving inflation and economic activity today and that's deficits you know that's the fiscal side this is fiscal dominance and actually you know in a weird way raising interest rates given the deficits are so large and the debt is so large can actually increase inflation and why is that well the interest expense blows out the deficits blow out and that that is interest paid to bondholders and who hold bonds well a lot of older people a lot of uh corporations a lot of banks you know produces interest income and that finds its way into the economy and so it actually can drive more economic activity inflation when the debt gets this large unless it's a really large hike if we're talking about 25 bips of hikes like i don't really care because there's a giant two trillion dollar you know uh uh elephant in the room that's driving things actually and so i don't think bitcoin needs that at all um in fact you know it could actually drive inflationary pressures which could turn to people into more monetary alternatives and so i think people need to understand that we are in a unique period where the interest rate lever is less and less important unless it's drastic moves higher or drastic moves lower that the fed does um and so i i really you know even if even if they hike massively if they hike massively this is where it gets interesting because if it causes pressure with risk assets uh if stocks fall maybe bitcoin falls with stocks um then we have a decline in tax revenues because of how financialized the u.s economy has become and tax receipts are closely tied to capital gains realized capital gains and so if stock market falls and then and then the government's bringing in less revenues because there's less capital gains being realized then we see the deficit explode the other way and so that's why they're in a really tricky situation because you could just see the deficit blow out from a lack of revenues or you could see it blow out from interest expense at the same time so this is why kind of all roads lead to currency debasement to financial repression and this is why it's important to seek alternatives to diversify from this from these risks and that's why bitcoin and gold and other hard assets you know investors should really start to think about this especially when you think about portfolio construction and how bonds and stocks typically move together in these periods historically sam callahan
Speaker 1director of bitcoin strategy at orange btc great hearing your insights thanks so much for joining us thank you
Speaker 2well certainly a lot to evaluate and when you're evaluating your core storage setup you shouldn't be looking for a company to tell you their product is bulletproof you want to be able to see how it works know that other people could inspect it and understand how they handle issues when they come up that transparency is why we're big fans of bitkey bitkey is open source which means independent researchers can inspect and test its software bitkey also maintains a public securities updates page when a confirmed bug has been fixed and is safe to disclose bitkey explains what happened the potential customer impact the fix and whether customers need to take action that kind of transparency matters when you're choosing how to protect your bitcoin security isn't a promise that nothing will ever happen it's the work a company does before during and after an issue is found download bitkey today and use our promo code bitkey to get 10 off the second generation bitkey this episode is sponsored by bitkey
Speaker 1all right let's go back to what michael saylor has been working on obviously he is building bitcoin backed credit but not only that he wants to change how investors are getting paid strategy is now looking to move stretch from a twice monthly dividends to daily payments an idea that could make the security more attractive to investors trading around the clock strategy shareholders are scheduled to be able to invest in bitcoin at a higher rate by the end of the year to vote on the proposed structure on october 28th so that is just around the corner uh but sean who do you think this is about uh in terms of who he's trying to attract is it retail investors is it opening the door to more uh bigger institutional players
Speaker 2it's to normalize the ex-dividend dates right so with strc or any perpetual preferred the name of the game is reducing volatility you reduction in vol increases uh customer confidence right and so there's a lot of different ways to do that one of the ways that strive did so brilliantly was that they uh rebranded themselves as the daily dividend company right and so what happens now that now the dividends are paid daily every time the market is open there's no need to sell and try to gamify that dividend date um the ex-dividend date so uh it normalizes that vol you have less people um gamifying um the dividend distributions and being in there when the snapshot's taken for who qualifies and so now you have perpetual daily pressure um on the actual uh value of the underlying uh which is really going to help smooth the volatility which strc has has been suffering from as have have all the prefs and we've seen a success story proven in the market with what uh sata uh accomplished for strive and so now strc and strategy are hoping to replicate that um well
Speaker 1that's what i was going to ask you next why would getting paid every day and set of twice monthly makes such a difference to investors my initial thought was oh the liquidity and flexibility of it um because daily dividends doesn't necessarily mean higher returns or less investment risk but you're saying there is a little bit less risk there is less volatility
Speaker 2yeah it just normalizes it right you have less people trying to gamify it and sell around that ex-dividend date um and so it's going to keep its par more naturally also there is upside potential right if you're compounding those daily dividends it juices by a couple uh bips maybe even a percentage point or two depending on what the rate is so um definitely good to see the um you know ability to compound technically if you want to to reinvest that it drives up that that kind of annual percentage the annualized percentage for sure but the real innovation here is that it's going to normalize that selling pressure to keep uh its steady near par around those ex-dividend dates because now the ex-dividend date is every single day so it makes no sense and it's just kind of a game theoretical way to to normalize and reduce in some way that it's going to normalize and reduce in some way that it's going to normalize and reduce in some way in some way that it's going to normalize and reduce in some way that it's going to normalize and reduce in some way that it's going to normalize
Speaker 1okay and strategy not the only company building new financial structures around bitcoin shareholders shareholders of nasdaq listed super league enterprises have approved a major transaction involving japanese bitcoin treasury company metaplanet under the proposed deal metaplanet would contribute 2 100 bitcoin along with two and a half million dollars in cash in exchange for a controlling stake of approximately 96 percent once the deal closes super league is expected to rebrand as super planet trading on the nasdaq under the ticker supa the transaction expected to close in the fourth quarter subject to remaining conditions what's your reaction to this
Speaker 2incredibly bullish look the the metaplanet team has certainly um been put through the ringer um but they continue to innovate they continue to find new ways um you know they're buying these these uh financial products in japan launching bonds you can do metaplanet bonds in japan they've had a really hard time bringing um a pref to market it seems um but they're getting creative they're launching in the u.s they have experience they have their trading desk in the u.s they've already set up they know how to interact and engage with this market and they're going to use supa to launch a pref uh here in the u.s so uh very bullish uh right now the market is pricing in those 2100 bitcoins it's trading around par for supa give or take on the day there's a little bit of fluctuation but more or less it's trading at par um but again once a pref launches it's going to be a little bit of fluctuation but more or less it's trading at par um but again once a pref launches it's going to be a little bit of fluctuation but more or less it's trading at par um but again once a pref launches um but again once a pref launches they're going to be raising additional capital to buy bitcoin for supa um so the market has yet to price in a successful pref launch and i'm very bullish on what the metaplanet team has been able to pull off and i'm optimistic for the success of yet another pref coming to the market which we've heard from the other pref participants that the more prefs the better um and and you want investors to be able to diversify to invest in a well diversified blend of these of these income instruments here in the u.s markets and by the
Speaker 1way super league purchased a pref in the u.s and they're going to be able to purchase a pref in the u.s and they're going to be able to purchase a pref in the u.s and they're going to be able to purchase bitcoin on october 10th just a few days ago for approximately 83 041 that's ahead of the larger metaplanet transaction well lately on the show we have covered debt dynamics both in public and private markets as we watch a repricing of sovereign and hyperscaler credit risk joining us now is someone who has been watching these things very closely cross-border capital founder and managing director of mggl indexes michael howell welcome in michael
Speaker 10well hi gary it's great to be here thank you so much for having me i'm michael howell and i'm michael howell and i'm
Speaker 1here yeah we appreciate you joining us um so when you look out at the global financial markets right now what are the biggest pressures building that you see and what is your read on the debt financing outlook for sovereigns in the ai complex well i
Speaker 10think the first thing to say is that financial markets are really experiencing what is a gangbuster economy both in the u.s and worldwide we're looking at a pace of economic growth that is probably last seen in nominal terms back in the what late 90s mid-1980s early 1990s so you've got to go back a long way to see growth of this caliber it may not be high quality growth and otherwise inflation is a key element in that but nonetheless that is absorbing funds from financial markets so what you're seeing right now and what the uh what the bond markets are pretty much telling us uh is there's a competition for funds and all money that is anywhere has got to be somewhere so if it's in the in the real economy fueling growth it's not going to be in financial markets and that's what a flattening yield curve and rising bond yields are going to be and that's what a flattening yield curve and rising bond yields uh pretty much telling us yeah
Speaker 2and and you know that that seems to be pretty uh patently observed and and you know we we did recently get a bounce on on the u.s treasuries for example but just how much do you think these uh these ai whether it's the public bonds whether it's the private credit facilities um on the debt side and then also the crowding on the equity side of the trade how much do you think it's it's pulling kind of liquidity and investable capital away from you know the broader equities market and the equity market and the equity market and the equity market and the equity market we've seen this massive decoupling um from the top and the bottom of indices uh as well as some stress on on even sovereign debt like u.s bonds yeah
Speaker 10it is i mean you've got to think of this as a sequence um the fact is that certain errors in the market have been solved um you know look at uh your your fund managers performances uh through this year i i doubt that many are up a lot of fund managers are suffering this year and just look at the russell 2000 i mean that looks like it's an event that's going to be a big one and i think that's going to be a big one i think that's going to be a big one and i think that's going to be a big one and i think that's going to be a big one and i think that's going to be a big one and i think that's going to be a big one and i think that's going to be a big one and i think that's going to be a big one um so you're um so you're starting to see liquidity being pulled away increasingly from markets and it's the less liquid areas that kind of get hit first so you know junk spreads are starting to widen already um in all these things are sort of adding up to a picture, which is saying that liquidity is beginning to be crimped. Now, let's be clear, this is not because of central bank tightening, or certainly not any aggressive tightening. There are moves clearly to push Fed funds up. But this looks to me relatively passive at the moment. The main reason is that money is being dragged into the real economy, and a strong real economy is crowding out financial markets. That's clear. And I think we want to be also 100% clear, this is not about fiscal digest, or it's not about problems with US debt. It's not about concerns over Trump. It's not about the fact that Besant's doing a good or a bad job. This is all about the economy. And the media have kind of jumped on the wrong bandwagon here and said this is all about frailty in public finances. It certainly isn't. In Europe, it may be. If you look at the French market and the rights you're getting in France right now, that has got a lot to do with fiscal frailty. But that's not. the case in the US at the moment.
Speaker 1And you mentioned the flattening treasury curve. What does that tell you about where we are in the liquidity cycle? And are government bonds attractive here, despite the debt worries?
Speaker 10It's telling us, Grace, that we're late. I mean, that's what a flattening yield curve tells you. What's more, it's a bearish flattening, which is the phase that normally precedes what is a period of strong bond markets. That strength normally comes when you start to see economic weakness. And the fact is, we live in a cyclical world. So although I keep saying that economic growth is very strong now, you've got to look at the consequences and the feedbacks of that. So you've got higher energy prices, you've got rising yields themselves, and you've got a strong US dollar. That's not good for future economic growth. That tends to eat into it. So the fact is that, you know, spring turns to summer and turns to autumn, and we've got to start thinking about how that and how that climatic change is going to affect investing. I think bonds look pretty good. If you can pick up 3% real on the US TIPS government index link bond, that looks to me pretty good. It's very, very rare you get those sort of gifts in the market. And if you look at longer dated treasuries, they're really at a level now where, you know, they're probably reasonable to start looking at again.
Speaker 2And, you know, whether it's the US, you know, treasury market or this AI complex, you know, we need a lot of either refinancing or new financing over the next couple of years. But if you can pick up 3% real on the US, you know, that's going to be very, very rare. Yeah, I think that's a great point.
Speaker 10I mean, the fact is that there's something called the debt maturity wall out there, which basically represents the amount of debt that was termed out in the wake of COVID. The fact that policymakers recklessly slashed interest rates near zero encouraged a lot of borrowers to turn out their borrowings later in this decade. And that echo effect is now coming back to haunt us. It's increasingly going to be a strain on markets. And I think that's going to be a strain on markets in the next few years. And therefore, you've got to step back and say, well, okay, what's the policy reaction that's going to be? And I think almost certainly, like every other policy reaction, what it means is they're going to have to print money again, and they're going to have to print money big time. And this is excellent news for monetary inflation hedges like gold and Bitcoin. This is the future.
Speaker 2And, you know, the US is already monetizing its debt through bank financing treasury bills, even without Fed, you know, the Fed launching another round of QE seemingly. Is that right? And how does that change where the money goes? And if that is the case, which assets do you think stand to benefit from that?
Speaker 10I think what we've seen in the last, you know, maybe in the last year or 18 months is a very clear switch from what is called Fed QE to what I label Treasury QE. And you're absolutely right to say that what's going on is a surreptitious monetization of debt, because effectively, by issuing lots of short term bills, the Treasury is encouraging banks to own those. And if banks pick up that debt, that is pure monetization. Milton Friedman, the architect of monetarism would be turning in his grave looking at what the government's doing. But it works. Besson can kick the can down the road for quite a long time yet. And clearly, he intends to do so. And I think what you're likely to see in the next, you know, maybe in the in the near term, before this administration, ends, you're likely to see Treasury bill issuance, kidding something like 30% of total debt outstanding. That's not an unprecedented figure, but it's clearly a trend. And there's a trend towards more monetization. Where does that money go? A lot of it is going into the real economy to fuel procurement spending, etc. Strategic stakes, I mean, you know, but as well, that's going to spill over and it's spilling over into financial markets. So the fact is that we live in a world of cycles, the liquidity cycle is turning down. But I would venture that the downside is not going to be as great as the last one. In 2021 22, when Powell aggressively tightened, this one looks a little bit more benign to me, but it's nonetheless still going down in the short term. So the recipe or the argument is, if you can pick up monetary inflation hedges, like gold and Bitcoin on weakness, do that. Don't don't don't dump the trade. Just buy more.
Speaker 1So Michael, something we've been covering on the show is China's bond market and the prospects and headwinds for China's GDP growth. What's your read on that market and what are some things investors should be watching there?
Speaker 10Well, I think that's a great point. I mean, the thing is that a lot of people have spilled ink unnecessarily trying to argue that if you look at the spread between U.S. government bonds, which are circa, let's say, five and a quarter percent and Chinese government bonds that may be near a one and a half percent, that virtual 400 basis spread, is telling us a lot about the relative risks of two markets. And the Chinese as well sort of, you know, pump this up by saying, I'll big this up by saying, look, this is all due with deteriorating America. The fact is that nobody trusts the U.S. anymore, whatever. Complete rubbish. I mean, the fact is that what the bond markets are telling us that this spread is telling us is that the U.S. economy is besting China hands down. If you think the nominal, nominal bond yields reflect nominal GDP growth, which is pretty much true over the longer term. It's telling us the U.S. economy is growing at a fast clip, as I keep arguing. But it's also saying that China is in a desperately bad situation. They're already suffering debt deflation right now. And there's only one way out ultimately for them, which is to print money. So what you've got is that they've got to go down exactly the same route. The timing is uncertain. They may be sort of dragged into the same mile that Japan was dragged in for two decades and refusing to act. But ultimately, as we know, when push came to shove, Japan had to act. And Japan's move of monetizing its debt and weakening the yen is really what we're seeing now in the revival of the Japanese economy and the Japanese markets. But China has to do exactly the same thing because there is no alternative.
Speaker 2And is there any particular catalyst that would push Beijing to be less hesitant to create more money, maybe more aggressively? And if they do go down this path, which it seems is inevitable at this point, do they have much risk? Do they have much room before they start to put the yuan under pressure?
Speaker 10Well, I think the great question, I think the first thing is to say that China may be a little bit like France sees a lot of its politics on the streets. And if you start to see disquiet, that is what's going to prompt the Communist Party to actually move. And at the end of the day, the game or the deal they've got with the populace is they make Chinese people rich. There's a wealth effect that they basically have to endorse. And if you get sluggish economies or even higher inflation, the Chinese population don't like that and they make their disquiet known. And that is likely to be something to watch pretty closely. So I think that would be the trigger. I think the second thing to point to bring up is your question about what about weakening the yuan? Well, I think everything that China is doing is designing, if you like, two circulation systems, a dual circulation system. And they've doubled down on capital controls. They've made it illegal for anyone to trade crypto. There's a hint in that particular process. So you can't get money offshore very easily. And what's more, they've got large forex reserve, strict capital controls, compliant state banks. And so they can really keep the internal value of the yuan separate for some time from the external value. So in other words, the external value, which is basically all to do with geopolitics and cosmetics, will probably stay around where it is against the US dollar. But the internal value of the yuan will deteriorate, which means you're going to get rising prices and wages within China. And the hedge against that for Chinese is gold, which is why the gold price has gone up a lot in the last few years. It's Chinese buying, not Western buying.
Speaker 1And if China expands liquidity, how much of that money actually reaches global markets? You mentioned gold. Would you expect gold to benefit first? Or could that also drive a significant move in Bitcoin?
Speaker 10It's actually a great point. The fact is that you would think, theoretically, that it basically has its big impact in gold. And that's really what the evidence shows by far. If you look at the period really since the Chinese started to print money or expand the monetary base from early '22, that has been a major, major driver of a higher gold price. You would think that there would be no effect, given these capital controls and constraints, on Bitcoin. But actually, if you look at the data, there is. So it seems as if somehow the Chinese are getting their money out, whether that's via Hong Kong or whatever it may be. And there is an influence. So when the Chinese ease, Bitcoin has historically historically benefited, not as much as it maybe could, but there is still some positive effect
Speaker 2there. And it seems like a lot of these problems are shared globally at this point, right? I mean, broadly speaking, we have inverted population pyramids, pressure on tax revenues and the costs of competing with each other. How much room do governments really have to cut spending? And is that kind of a fantasy at this phase of kind of the global environment?
Speaker 10Well, my view is zero. I mean, no one's talking about it right now. It's certainly not an issue. Whenever there's any discussion about cutting state spending, the populists are in uproar, even though they realize, or they don't realize perhaps, that they've got to pay for it at the end of the day. So what you've got is absolutely no inclination to cut policies and to enact austerity policies at all. What's more, we're taxed. So, you know, barring some increase in wealth taxes, which is probably inevitable, what you're going to get is monetization. And that is the name of the game. Now, let's not be too melodramatic about that. What does it really mean? All it means is a continuation of the world we've been in for the last probably 150 years. That is going to kick the can down the road, devalue paper money. And what you need is monetary inflation hedges. The fact is that monetary inflation hedges historically haven't been that easy to get hold of, or they've been get hold of, or have been disrupted by things like the Gold Act in the US, when Roosevelt dissolved. So, you know, we've got to get rid of that. And we've got to get rid of that. basically nationalized gold. But now it's much easier to get to invest in those things outside of the remit of governments. So Bitcoin clearly is one of those vehicles, but gold ETFs could well be another one, or gold in Switzerland could be another one. So I think that there are ways to hedge against governments, a profit against governments. But let's be clear, we're not talking about hyperinflation here. We're talking about a humming sound of a faster printing press. And that probably means, what, 1% to 2% per annum higher inflation for everybody worldwide.
Speaker 1When you're looking at gold versus Bitcoin as protection against debasement, which one wins? And is Bitcoin the stronger long-term asset, but maybe the harder one to hold through a squeeze?
Speaker 10Well, if I knew the answer to that, I'd be a very wealthy person. But I think the fact is that, you know, what we know is that from experience recently, liquidity sensitive asset on the planet by far. It easily bests gold and silver and other precious metals. But you've got a much, much longer track record with gold and precious metals. I mean, you've got millennia of history telling us that these are fantastic monetary inflation hedges. Bitcoin clearly is more recent. We're talking about maybe 15 years. But nonetheless, performance has been awesome. So I think you've got to basically have a basket. And maybe the idea, the ideal is to weight that basket by relative volatility. So the faster that Bitcoin becomes institutional and the volatility of Bitcoin goes down, the bigger the weighting in that basket. So at some stage, it may become sort of 50-50.
Speaker 2And I really want to go into, you mentioned this debt monetization backdrop, where debt's being monetized. In that environment, where is Bitcoin relative to equities?
Speaker 10So I didn't. To get to that question, where, for what, for equities? What happens to it?
Speaker 2Yeah. Obviously, we have this debt financing largely driving the equities that are overperforming the top half of these indices. So whether it's from a risk perspective, where people might want to be rotating capital out, or if it's an acceleration of this continued build out and the benefit of these equities that are largely being driven by whether it's private credit or public bonds, what does that mean for Bitcoin in that given environment?
Speaker 10Well, I think the fact is that what you've got is that if you've got a steady monetary inflation, okay, and as I keep saying, that may only mean Main Street inflation is a couple of percentage points higher in reality, okay? But I mean, after all, we've been in this world for some time. I mean, how many years since the Federal Reserve hit its 2% targets? Over five years. So, you know, they're just going to kick the can down the road. This is the world we're in. Equities do okay in that environment, providing that the inflation doesn't pick up aggressively. If you've got a lot of inflation, then equities will clearly underperform big time relative to Bitcoin and gold. But I would have equities in a portfolio as a monetary inflation hedge longer term. But I think you've got to start thinking about which kind of equities do I want? I think that in an environment such as the one we described, small cap are not likely to be great performers. Value stocks are unlikely to be great performers. I think you've got to go for where the growth is and which companies have pricing power. And if you've got a big pick up and inflation, then equities will likely to be great performers. But I think you've got to go for where the growth is and which sectors are likely to be rapid growth areas. So technology, I mean, Parche, you know, the fact we've got high valuations on some of these things already, and they look bubblish. The fact is over the medium term, technology has got to be a winner because, you know, that's where the growth is coming from. I think resources, given the fact we're in a capital war against China, and you've got to scramble for access to resources, resource companies look pretty good too. So I think you can actually, you know, draw a narrative to say there are certain areas of the market we're likely to do well. But I think equities are okay in this environment. What looks bad in the medium term, and I stress the medium term, ironically, not so much in the short term, in the medium term is fixed income markets. And you've just got to see that. Look at the recent history or the period, when I say recent history, going back to the 70s, after the US came off the gold standard, when Nixon closed the gold window, we have basically a free floating dollar. What you've had is gold has gone up by about 8.5% per annum on average, pretty much exactly matching the increase in federal debt of about 8.5% per annum. Liquidity has gone up at the same pace. Equities have done a tad better at nearer 9.5%, 10%. But bonds have languished. So 10-year governments have yielded, or given your return rather, about 6.5%. And five-year are nearer 4.5%, 5%. So basically, the bond market's really lagging in that environment. And that's the thing to worry about medium term.
Speaker 2So in this environment now, and I want to be respectful of your time. I realize we're up against the clock here. But if we could just get one more in for you. Equities are largely up against their all-time highs. Bitcoin has made a recovery off its bottom, relatively speaking. We went all the way down to 58K from our high of 126. And there seems to be a good case that a reversal is well underway here. You know, what would need to change, or what might be a potential catalyst for a, you know, sustained move higher in Bitcoin to begin? And does that necessarily require a rotation of capital out of these equities that are still near their all-time high? We started off this segment talking about how much liquidity and kind of monetary energy has been drawn out of the room by this trade on the equity and the debt side. So, you know, is there a reversal necessary, you know, for Bitcoin to have a continuation here?
Speaker 10I think the first thing to say is technically Bitcoin's got to hold above 70,000. That's a key factor, a key support level. I think if you look at, you know, what could drive the price higher, I would say look pretty closely and listen to what Kevin Walsh is saying at the Fed. It looks to me, and this is early days because we're not far into his tenure, that the regime or the policy regime has changed at the Fed. And it strikes me that what they're paying a lot, lot more attention to is money market liquidity and the integrity of collateral in the system. This is what they should be doing. This is the lesson that we've had from 2008. It's the lesson we have from COVID. It looks like the Federal Reserve has learned that lesson, maybe from hard experience, but they've learned it. And if you believe this narrative, then it's quite likely that liquidity is not going to slump as much, maybe as we have been believing. Or maybe others have been suggesting in coming months. And if liquidity holds up, Bitcoin is the most liquidity sensitive area of the market. And that would be a pretty good bellwether, I think, of what's going on. But I'd look pretty very, very closely at money market liquidity. Look at things like sofa spreads and look at what level of bank reserves are being held at. And it strikes me this is being targeted by the Fed. They do not want an air pocket in money markets. Michael
Speaker 1Howell, it was great having you. Thanks so much for joining us.
Speaker 10Great pleasure. Thank you.
Speaker 2A very valuable interview. And Bitcoin is valuable because of the ownership, control and liquidity it gives you. The challenge has always been finding ways to make Bitcoin more useful without giving up the properties that made you want to own it in the first place. That's what's attractive about VerifiedX, the Bitcoin custody sponsor of BMTV. VerifiedX is designed to let you use Bitcoin across things like payments, borrowing, lending, trading, treasury management and settlement without requiring you to wrap it into a synthetic asset or hand control over to a third party. And importantly for Bitcoiners, VerifiedX is built around self-custody. You maintain control of your own signing while still being able to access native Bitcoin liquidity across programmable financial applications and integrated venues like exchanges. The idea is to expand what you can do with Bitcoin without compromising what makes Bitcoin valuable in the first place. Keep Bitcoin as Bitcoin and activate it. Explore VerifiedX and see how Bitcoin can move, settle and work across programmable financial networks at verifiedx.com. io. Digital assets involve risk. Learn more before participating.
Speaker 1All right, still ahead on BMTV. As we move deeper into Q4, we are taking a look at the trend in Bitcoin's annual returns and looking for signal to see if the bear market is truly behind us. Chart of the day coming up on BMTV.
Speaker 6Digital Real Estate. Available now. Well, Bitcoin has recovered
Speaker 1well from its 58K low, but we have been in a crab market, largely ranging sideways for several months now. As we take our time recovering to the 2025 highs, let's take a look at chart of the day. And Sean, what are you watching today?
Speaker 2Today, we're looking at Bitcoin's year over year drawdowns. This data is courtesy from look into Bitcoin at look into Bitcoin on X. Thank you for the. Data shows both the Bitcoin price and negative year over year streaks. Every red day is a buyer who held for exactly one year being under water. You'll see at the bottom and then obviously just the Bitcoin price chart fractals up at the top. So, you know, the significance of this is, you know, we've talked a lot about things like the 50 week moving average and, you know, relative moves off the bottom. But the real fun obviously starts when we reclaim all time highs and a medium step in between. Is when we can reclaim our relative strength compared to a prior year's price performance, right? You want to be in a place where people who bought and held for a year are in profit. And typically that's when the market will start to accelerate. So how long is that going to take us to get there? And what should we expect? You know, I think it's important to also note that the bear markets don't just wear out with where users or investors out with price based capitulation, but also time based. Bear markets are boring and they cause people to rage quit for lack of better terms. And, you know, we've had four major negative streaks all coinciding with these major drawdowns or bear markets in 20, the 2014, 15 cycle are our, our time to recover the previous year's price to break even on one year holding was 352 days in 2018 and 19 that took 204 days, 2022 and 2023. That took 490 days, which is as of now, the all-time highest price that's going to break even on one year holding was 352 days in 2018 and 19 that took 204 days, 2022 and 2023 that took 490 days, which is as of now, the all-time highest price that's going to break even on one year holding was 352 days, which is as of now, the all-time highest price that's going to break even on one year holding was 352 days, which is as of now, the all-time record. And now in the 2025, 2026 drawdown, it's taken 330 days and counting. So, you know, it's already the third longest, you know, 20 and some change to tie the 20, uh, 14 record for second. Um, and you know, the prior streaks came with drawdowns of roughly 85%, 84%, 77%, which is a great example of that price based capitulation accompanied by, uh, you know, various degrees of time-based capitulation. This cycle, we saw way less, uh, aggressive price-based capitulation. We only drew down about 54% from our 126 K top to about, you know, 58 K low, uh, June, July in that area. So, you know, it's the shallowest bear market, um, on this chart yet we're heading for the second longest, perhaps, uh, um, time capitulation window here. And, you know, there's definitely a case to be made that there may be compensation, um, that we're making up for our lack of depth with some time. Um, you know, even though we bought them, we're not going to be able to get them back. Um, and so, you know, we're going to be able to get them back. Um, and so, you know, we're not going to be able to get them back. Um, early, according to the four-year cycle theorists.
Speaker 1So Bitcoin's bear markets have historically been defined as just these massive crashes. Now we're seeing that the shallow, the shallowest bear market we've ever had a long drawn out recovery. Is there a structural structural reason for this
Speaker 2change? Yeah, I think that there absolutely is. Um, and that's a great question. You know, the, the holder base has changed, right? This was our first cycle with, we had ETFs really driving the market. And that's been a huge story as we've come on off the bottom here as well. We have treasury companies, we have advisors with multi-year allocations, you know, all, all of this, um, kind of, uh, institutional adoption has driven this multi-year thesis driven allocation. And so, you know, the capital is, is unlevered. It rebalances on a schedule and it's thesis driven by nature, but, uh, you know, the, the nature of these participants also does cut both ways. You know, the, the, in this, the same behavior, lessening volatility can give us slower recoveries back to all time highs. You know, the market's been, you know, working out, um, of this bear market. Uh, it's just taking some time to work its way out, to get back to last year's prices, which is a huge psychological level for us to unlock. And typically where the market will then start accelerating with more pace to the upside as we make our push towards that all time high recovery. But that's not to say that things can't heat up just because it has been slow, just because we have a more methodical institutional market participant kind of driving at the margins here. It doesn't mean that there isn't a case that we could speed up, you know, and to stay out of second place, Bitcoin only needs to close above $101,000 before November 6th. That's a 24% rally over three weeks, which Bitcoin has done many times. And maybe we'll see October do its thing, right? We can't forget we're in the magical October right now. Um, but you know, just, just like how the 50 week moving average is easier to defend, uh, for a certain amount of time as time goes by, because it averages lower, uh, to compensate and include, um, our, our, the depths of our bear market. The same thing is true with the year over year price. You know, uh, November 6th, we have to reclaim one Oh one K, but by November 22nd, we only need to be at 84.6 K. So Bitcoin can stay relatively flat and we're kind of out of the woods at that point. Um, by late November. So, you know, the streak should end on the math. Uh, you know, last year's sell is going to kind of roll, um, off the books here, any close above 78.6 K on January 31st to end the year. We'll end it then just based on the math. But, um, I'd like to see it not just kind of be this cheaters way of winning where we just kind of wait it out. I'd like to see us attack it with some force here and, and try to make that, um, reclaim, uh, by the end of, of mid Q4 here.
Speaker 1So you said institutional investors are the reason, um, for kind of this drawn out recovery, the, the bear markets are less volatile, but what did that mean? The upside is less explosive as well.
Speaker 2Yeah, that, that, that would follow. Um, you know, and that's what the majority of people are, are sort of pricing in, or, or at least theorizing, you know, you hear a lot of analysts saying that the fall is dampening. This is going to be a more, uh, mature institutional driven cycle where it's just going to kind of slowly grind upward. Um, like, like traditional assets do right. The, the S and P averages, you know, X percent a year. Um, and it's pretty boring, just this kind of slow and steady up into the right. And that's good, right? Everyone just kind of, we all agree. We just buy in and we just let it go up. Um, but again, I don't think that has to be the case, you know, yes, it's a more institutional, more, you know, quote unquote, mature, less likely to FOMO, um, allocation as these institutional players get in. Um, but, um, you know, this is becoming a less supply shock driven cycle and more of a macro driven cycle. And we see, the, the, the crisis brewing around the world, uh, the, the, the monetary policy, um, has been poor. Um, and, you know, like the, the bank of international settlement is saying, uh, Bitcoin can serve similar to gold as a protest against this. And so, you know, as, as those situations continue to amplify, you might actually see an increased in bid, uh, on Bitcoin. Again, you know, you have all these institutional actors, uh, saying that it's, it's, it's a gold like instrument, but I'll say it, like I said, at the beginning of the show, we're less than 10% of the market cap of gold, right? We're not even 50% of the way there. That's a five X that's quite explosive to the upside, certainly more explosive than the downside we've seen. Um, and also, you know, there's a lot of retail, uh, still in the market yet to be involved. We've talked about what it would mean for the market cap of Bitcoin. If just 1% of wealth managed by wealth advisors, um, gets directed towards Bitcoin and the multiplier effect that has on the market cap, it's not just apples to apples. So there's a lot of catalysts that could really drive some serious volatility to the upside. But that institutional behavior and thesis-driven nature of the allocation might still yet dampen the downside, even while taking advantage of that upside. So I don't think we can just totally write it off. But I would say the base case now is that slow and steady grind. But as we have the potential to unlock these catalysts, there is very much that real upside
Speaker 1in play. Do you think this is a good thing, the less volatility? Is that something investors should welcome, even if it means being more patient about the returns?
Speaker 2Yeah, look, I think that as Bitcoin becomes what it was destined to become, it will become less volatile. But we have a lot of the way to get there still. This is still the early innings, you see UTXO management has about a 20%, give or take, CAGR expectation for Bitcoin's year-over-year performance. Strive Asset Management has about a 50% in a bull market, 30% baseline. So those aren't crazy numbers to be putting out. Volatility could be driven up to the upside. Volatility is good. Volatility is vitality, and you can create these instruments around it. And I don't think that that's going to stop anytime soon, given how early we are in the S-curve of adoption, on the adoption curve of Bitcoin. It goes to stand that as we start to catch up with the market cap of something like Bitcoin, we're going to have a lot of volatility. And I think that's going to stop anytime soon, given how early we are in the S-curve of adoption, on the adoption curve of Bitcoin. It goes to stand that as we start to catch up with the market cap of something like Gold, you should expect volatility, especially as the network effect compounds and adoption expands. It has the potential to be quite explosive as these new entrants are thesis-driven. They're more sticky. They're not wanting to sell. Think about the treasury companies, for example. Think about people who are just kind of adding it as a small percentage of their portfolio or funds that have a thesis-driven directive to have exposure to Bitcoin. Yeah, there might be some rebalancing. That's not going to happen on the treasury front. And that rebalancing is probably going to be outpaced by the expansion of adoption, right? So it's a perfectly fixed supply instrument. You can't print more just because it gets more popular. You can't go mine more like you can with Gold just because it gets more popular. And as you expand demand for it, because more people are participating in this trade and wanting spot exposure, they're increasingly not selling as there's an increasing bid on a perfectly scarce asset. So there's only one way for the price to go, and that's drastically up.
Speaker 1I typically am not a patient person, but I think it's worth it in this case. Coming up next, we are taking a look at Fed rate hike expectations and how the market is projecting if strategy, the so-called central bank of Bitcoin, will see its stretch preferred stock returned apart this year. Our very own Isaiah Austin, BTC social markets correspondent, is joining us right after this break. We'll be right back.
Speaker 11Every year, this community comes together to celebrate, to debate, to build what comes next. And every year, the stage gets bigger. Sound money, center stage. So where do you go to celebrate the next chapter in Bitcoin history? You come home. Nashville, July 2027. How's my rent up 30%? My washer ain't 30% fixed, but my landlord wants 30% more money. Bro, you know investment firms are buying up all the houses? They got like half a million houses. How come every time them Wall Street boys crash the economy, they always get to keep the money? That makes some no sense. That makes no sense. That makes no sense.
Speaker 5You believe in Bitcoin. So why would you ever sell it? Life happens. An emergency expense, a new home purchase, or a great business opportunity. With Salt, you can access the power of your Bitcoin without selling. Now with rates starting at 7.5%. The original Bitcoin balance sheet. Timeback lender. No collateral losses. No rehypothecation since 2016.
Speaker 4Bitcoin can help diversify how you spend, save, and invest in your business. Especially when every swipe of a credit card eats away at your bottom line. With Square, you can now accept Bitcoin. With zero payment processing fees, no chargebacks, and near instant access to funds. And you choose how money settles into your account. Whether in USD or Bitcoin. Instantly and right from your Square dashboard. No extra steps. No added complexity. It's a smart, seamless way to build savings in the business. No background. All while keeping your day-to-day cash flow predictable. And when tax time comes, you'll get the paperwork you need right where you find your reports and bank statement. Head to squareup.com/bitcoin to learn more.
Speaker 7Think about the last conversation you had. Somebody said something you wanted to remember or follow up on. Plod No Pin S provides a hands-free way to capture conversations the moment they happen. No fumbling with your phone. No scrambling to write things down. one press and it's recording pin it strap it hang it it's on you and ready when the conversation starts then plods ai turns your conversation into a transcript showing who said what and a summary of key points and action items what is a restaurant service fee i know what a tip is
Speaker 6i know what tax is isn't the server the service yeah that makes no sense own isaiah austin social markets correspondent right
Speaker 1here at btc inc and our first time four time guest how does it feel feels great uh excited to be
Speaker 12back on it's been a couple of weeks but there really hasn't been a lot of movement in the polymarket odds with the fed so makes sense
Speaker 1Yeah. So let's start there because the odds of a Fed rate hike at this upcoming October 28th meeting sitting at 86% today, that's up from 50% a week ago. Why do you think we're seeing such a massive swing?
Speaker 12Yeah, it seems strange because we haven't had a whole lot of market information and data come out over the past week or two. But I really believe that it started on October 16th when Kevin Warsh spoke in Bangkok. And it wasn't that he said anything. It's that he didn't say anything. Several Fed officials had signaled over the past few weeks that they were comfortable with the idea of pausing their rates. Kevin Warsh did not comment on that, which I think markets found bullish for the odds of them holding the rate. I know a lot of times people watch the Fed and take it very literally. How should I trade it? Should I sell? Should I buy? A lot of times what Kevin Warsh and other past Fed chairmen have done is they will say certain words so that sophisticated investors will know how to trade or counter trade what they're going to do. And sometimes those sophisticated words is saying nothing at all. And that's what Kevin Warsh did in Bangkok.
Speaker 2And let's talk STRC as well. On that front, there's a lot of interesting movement. Strategy's been trying for a while to get this thing back at par. They're moving towards daily dividends. They've been doing massive rebuys, increasing their dollar reserve. Prediction markets are only pricing it at a 77% chance that it returns to par this year, given that we're hovering so close now to a repag and there's only so much time to the year end. What do you think is causing this lack of confidence reaching these levels?
Speaker 12Yeah, exactly. So I believe it was in July, we had a 27% chance of this thing returning to par in 2026, which is insane. I mean, considering how far we've come that the odds in the markets were so bearish on strategies, for lack of a better term, strategy in getting stretched back to par. Last week on Thursday, it peaked up to 95%, pretty much a sure thing that this was going to repeg and now sitting, like you said, 75, 77 range with some pessimism. I believe it was the MSCI news last week, which we all knew would was probably going to be the case that they were going to be delisted from the MSCI. But I think, you know, the crypto market, Bitcoin in general, can be very reactive to news as it happens and not so pricing things in advance. When MSCI came out and said, nope, this thing is not an operating company. We are going to delist it from our indexes, which JP Morgan says is going to take out roughly $2.8 billion in forced selling from the MSTR stock. That put a lot of pressure on Stretch, but not just Stretch, strategy as a whole. When Stretch goes down, how does strategy raise money? Well, a lot of times they tap the MSTR shareholders to get that cash buffer to strengthen their future. dividend payments and their cash reserves. The MSCI news just puts pressure on strategy, which in turn makes people have a little bit less trust in longevity of stretch. But I think it's
Speaker 2fun. So do you think the betting markets are getting anything wrong here?
Speaker 12Yes, I do. So, you know, obviously, we've seen over the past few months, strategy went from a 100% of their balance sheet being in Bitcoin to being sort of a blended approach. I think Saylor called it last week stainless steel, the idea of having a Bitcoin and cash balance sheet, something like 7030 in the future. It really can't be overstated how much strategy has been able to, you know, strengthen their balance sheet over the past few months, five point three billion dollars in cash reserve on hand, not even mentioning the stretch buybacks, which totals up to about 40 months of dividend coverage, which is really what has caused them to be able to return to par. I don't think the the. Prediction markets really understood how much strategy was willing to put in to make sure this thing returned to par.
Speaker 1I just want to make sure I heard you right. So the odds for stretch hitting par in July were 27%. That's right. Now they're 77%. Yes. OK, wow. So we missed out on a good buy there. Well, what do you think happens next to stretch actually hit par?
Speaker 12Yes, I do think it climbs back to par, whether it's this year or next year. You know, I think a big initiative is those daily dividends. They're they just got conditional approval for November if the shareholders. Vote on it. I do think that that will be very, very impactful on driving interest for this thing and getting it back to par. Whether or not those daily dividends become a confirmed thing by the end of the year will yet to be seen. But I do think it's a very pivotal moment right now for for strategy. You know, I'm a big analogy guy. Sorry if this one doesn't land, but it works for me. 1777, the Continental Army, right? They are in the brink of the war being over. They're retreating into the cold winter. They don't have supplies. They don't have medicine. The entire world thinks that they've lost this war. But Mr. George Washington, who we all know and love, he he had belief and conviction. They went in and they won the war and shocked the world. Now, why do I bring that up? That was the pivotal moment where America kind of cemented itself on the global scale as as the the force to be reckoned with and to be respected and understood globally. I think strategy is the key. I think strategy could potentially be having the same moment where, you know, people have lost confidence in strategy and what Michael Saylor is doing by stretch, depegging from par and going way down. But the reality is if they can get this thing back up to par, it shows the market that they are resilient and can survive the stretch winter.
Speaker 2Yeah. Even with MSCI news, you know, the loss of that passive bid, if they're able, you know, you talk about how they use that to tapping the common to raise cash to support STRC and how the prediction markets have viewed that as bearish for STRC to repag. If against all perceived odds, they're able to repag. I think that's a great analogy, Isaiah. And and and if they are able to have this this moment in time where they cement themselves up, you know, against what the markets are pricing in, what does that mean for for the broader Bitcoin ecosystem? Right. If they're able to kind of pick up that crown and come back victorious against all the FUD, what is the impact on Bitcoin itself? And if I market?
Speaker 12Yeah, absolutely. I think it's being so understated and people are having such, you know, recency bias to this thing and forget how much of a incredible, crazy machine it was at the half one of this year. They bought one hundred thousand Bitcoin with the proceeds after hitting par to to put that into context. There were eighty one thousand new Bitcoin mined during that period. So in half one of this year, they bought one hundred thousand Bitcoin with the proceeds. So in half one of this year, strategy bought more Bitcoin with stretch than came into circulation through mining. Think about if that can happen at a prolonged scale. Right. The market is definitely not pricing that in right now. But if it goes back to par again, the whole, you know, they win the Revolutionary War and people begin to respect strategy, even at like a macro scale. You were talking about it earlier. How long can this engine hum? And, you know, the block rewards are getting halved every four years. How much and how long can this engine hum? And, you know, can strategy keep up with buying more new more than the entire supply of new Bitcoin entering circulation? It's incredibly bullish. And now you add in things like strive. And we were talking about some of the things that were happening with MetaPlanet. There is a space race for these instruments to be able to go and buy Bitcoin at a rate that's faster than the new supply. What does that do to an asset? You know, I think, you know, long term, that's extremely bullish. But in the short term, I really think that could potentially if they're able to repeg and get the machine humming and investor confidence returns to stretch, we could be seeing new all time highs by half one of next year.
Speaker 2And, you know, back back to the the social markets, the prediction markets, what should we be watching to try to get real signal here? Are these markets that you think we can actually get some alpha from or do you think that they're going to be mispriced until the bitter end?
Speaker 12I think they're priced very similarly. You know, you could probably think about these prediction markets the same way you think about stretch and MSTR. Right. It's they're pricing out an extreme amount of risk in tentativeness. I would say, you know, not financial advice, but this is one I'm not trading right now. It's very, very close to 100 percent. We saw it go up all the way to 95 percent. I'm staying away. I think it would be much more impactful to buy MSTR stock rather than try to trade these things that I mean, it's all vibes. People are trading, you know, news is coming out like MSCI that don't directly impact this situation. So going to be yet to be seen if there was a market for mid-year 2027, I would be all over that. But, you know, there's just a lot of things that are happening right now in the space that could potentially you saw stretch went down to around ninety seven dollars right after the MSCI news. And it wasn't really significant news. So I'm staying away personally. But if you are a sucker for pain, jump in and have fun. And with the Fed
Speaker 2news as well. I mean, so so I was looking at the markets this morning and, you know, obviously prediction markets have called elections when the polls got it wrong. I know you follow kind of the efficacy of these markets to a high degree. Some of some of the more niche markets like like STRC repegging are lower, you know, liquidity or volume trading compared to something like the Fed decision. How does the lack of liquidity kind of impact the confidence that you assign to kind of their accuracy?
Speaker 12Yeah. So I think the you know, the technology of prediction markets is being able to aggregate public opinion and thought in a way that's very similar to polling. But the difference is when people are being polled, they're not willing to put their money where their mouth is. You get some something the most valuable thing to people in this world is their money and they're willing to allocate money behind an opinion. It it naturally sort of winds its way to a equilibrium that would really factor in, you know, the actual odds of something happening. I think another angle to that as well is that, you know, in these markets where they're super low liquidity, you don't see a lot of whale volume. Higher higher liquidity markets have smaller premiums where whales can get in. And and those whales are usually operating with superior information. I will say, though, this stretch market has more than a million dollars of liquidity in it. So I do think that it is a a valuable litmus test. I'm more so saying I wouldn't touch it because I do believe it will And, you know, there's only like 20 cents to make on the dollar for it right now. But I do think it's an accurate market. And I am watching that very closely. Maybe it wasn't. I don't have the data, but maybe it wasn't when it was at 27 percent. Maybe that was all retail freaking out about what was happening.
Speaker 1Well, I'm looking at the market vol now. It's one point four million, but they have it split across three different markets. It's does it hit par by October 31st, November 30th or December 31st? It's one point four mil across three of those markets. So I don't it's that's kind of interesting that they would combine it all into into one. Yeah,
Speaker 12definitely. But you
Speaker 1look at the Fed, too. This one's almost 50 million volume.
Speaker 12So, yeah, very popular market. I do think, you know. Maybe this isn't interesting to anyone else, but I think it's interesting to me that stretch stretch, it fell to seventy two dollars, obviously, a few months ago. Right now we're sitting at a roughly a 75 percent chance of it returning to par. So if you miss the opportunity to put a call option on stretch when it fell to seventy two dollars, now you have an opportunity to buy this market if you think it's going to go back and get a similar return.
Speaker 1That's a good point.
Speaker 2That is interesting.
Speaker 12And you're buying it. You're buying it for ninety eight dollars at the same premium.
Speaker 1I don't think we asked you. Yeah. What does stretch returning to par mean for MSTR holders looking at the price now? So it actually just fell to one hundred thirty nine dollars per share today, although it is up over two percent on the day, down 11 percent weekly.
Speaker 12Yeah, I think it's huge, mainly because, you know, this is the engine that Michael Saylor is really specified is going to be their Bitcoin accumulation engine. I think that matters for stretch, but I think it matters even more so for MSTR holders and MSTR strategy stock as a whole. Because, you know, when the bull market launches back off, we may be at it now, we may not. But once we start seeing all time highs of Bitcoin continuing to grow, though, I think it's a very likely outcome that we're going to see these Bitcoin treasury company stocks begin to trade at a premium again. And it's really going to matter what is the rate at which you can accumulate Bitcoin? How quickly are you accumulating Bitcoin and how much is that? the NAB, the net asset value of the balance sheet currently worth, this is huge for MSTR. In fact, I think there's nothing that this is more impactful for than MSTR. So it's going to be really interesting to see.
Speaker 2And earlier on the show, we were talking about, you know, obviously the ability to amplify, the ability to issue additional PREF relative to your book value of, you know, the common shares and the assets on your balance sheet depends on various factors. Some have kind of arbitrary governance that the board assigns, but at a minimum, it's determined by investor confidence that you can actually back that dividend sufficiently. And earlier on the show, we discussed the alloy approach that MSTR has taken with the dollars and the Bitcoin blend of 70-30. You know, do you, do you, do you, do you anticipate the market kind of taking their foot off the gas a little bit in terms of requiring 30% of that capitalization of the alloy to be dollars as vibes change into a bull market? Or do you think that that'll be something MSTR will have to continuously keep balanced in that alloy
Speaker 12formation? Yeah, it's a really good question. And I wish I had the answer to that, but I don't even think Saylor himself has the question to that. We were talking about, he was speaking last week, talking about, you know, the stainless steel approach, the cash and the Bitcoin. Um, I, I don't think if you would have asked him that question six months ago, he would have had that answer. And I think it's been by offering these products to investors where these kinds of answers have come out. Um, I do think though, you know, at least as we all believe, which is why we're sitting here right now, that Bitcoin one day will be seen as a, like a pristine collateral asset, something that, you know, is a, almost like a gold or, or a monetary network that is to be respected. And, and, and predicted to go up or stabilize in terms of like true value. Um, I do think that they may be able to decrease the amount of cash reserves, but I also think, you know, because Bitcoin, you know, is recognized the way that it is now, it's a $2 trillion asset. It's very, it's only 18 years old, right? I do think for the foreseeable future, you'll need to see that blend. Uh, but 20, 30, 40, 50 years down the road, I do expect that to, or at least the percentage allocation that we're going to see. So I think it's a, it's a, it's a, it's a, it's a to each, to blend more towards Bitcoin, uh, rather than cash.
Speaker 2And I know you don't have a crystal ball, but, but as someone that looks at these social markets, you know, um, obviously they're not pricing in a repeg, right? They're a little bit skeptical that that would happen. Does, does that sentiment tell us anything about, um, you know, you mentioned earlier, it's, it's very vibes based. How flippant might they be once we do enter a bull market? Do you think they'll continue to be hesitant, uh, to, to anticipate bullishness on, on this business model? Or do you think that those vibes will totally shift if we enter a bull market?
Speaker 12Yeah. And you're talking about stretch specifically. Yeah. So, you know, I think it's nuanced with retail. You're definitely seeing a lot of this, you know, FUD maybe is the right word, but, uh, maybe disinterest or lethargy might be a better word. People are disinterested in what's happening right now, uh, which in the Bitcoin space, we know that's usually the time you should be entering. But, but, you know, um, I think it matters more what these fund managers and these, uh, financial advisors are doing. They're seeing stretch right now as an opportunity to put one to 2% of this sort of basket, uh, into stretch as a upsized opportunity for increased, uh, dividend, uh, rate, where if it did DPEG from, uh, par and go to zero and the whole thing blew up, it wouldn't necessarily affect the portfolio. Like with a, with a traditional, uh, interest rate, uh, on, on, on, you know, the market that it's addressing, it still wouldn't pull the, the annual below 0% for the individual, if you're only allocating like two to 3%. So I, I do think that the FUD doesn't matter as much. And I think stretches is going to keep on stretching whether or not retail even knows that it's a part of their portfolio or, or, um, you know, are seeking out this sort of Bitcoin vehicle.
Speaker 1So Michael Saylor is George Washington and strategies. Young America is at the big takeaway.
Speaker 12Yes. Yes. And probably, probably a 10th, you know, a more like encapsulated view, but, uh, that's how I like to think as a, uh, as a supporter and strategy, I'd like to think that that's the direction we're
Speaker 1headed. Last time you came on and said clarity was trying to make the 53 man roster. So I was expecting like a football analogy and I was like, where's he going with this? I don't even know if there's like a football team left to compare them to. Cause you know, there's no juggernauts. Oh, gosh. I don't know. I don't think so. I don't, I don't want to compare yesterday. Okay. Well, congrats to them. Probably the only win for a while. Okay. Uh, that's going to do it for today's episode of BMTV. Here's who we got coming up on tomorrow's show. Giacomo Zucco, president of plan B network, Eleanor Tarrant, host of crypto in America, Samson Mao, CEO of Jan three lane Castleman co-CEO and president of blockchain.com and Jeff Walton, chief risk officer of strive. Hey, he played football. Maybe he can give me a football analogy for all these
Speaker 2companies. I hope he just doesn't punt on all of our questions.
Speaker 1He would never punters are people too. Okay. Um, that'll do it for us. We'll see you at nine 30 Eastern tomorrow morning for Sean Hagan, Isaiah Austin. I'm Grace Remington, and this is BMTV.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Markets rebounded on the 39th anniversary of Black Monday despite weekend tech sell-off fears, with Bitcoin trading above $82K and U.S. equity futures pointing higher.
  2. European markets faced pressure from high energy prices and French political instability, while Indonesian stocks plunged over 5% amid a possible MSCI downgrade from emerging to standalone status.
  3. Global AI-related equities sold off sharply last week, with South Korea's KOSPI falling 8% Thursday and triggering a trading halt, as investors grew more selective about AI exposure.
  4. Concerns are mounting over the AI boom's debt financing, with Anthropic receiving a BB+ junk credit rating ahead of a $35 billion chip financing deal and a potential $2 trillion IPO.
  5. Michael Saylor outlined a $100 trillion vision for Bitcoin-backed credit, describing a "financial ratchet" flywheel while acknowledging investors still value dollar duration over Bitcoin duration.
  6. Grayscale research shows 57% of S&P 500 companies are now more volatile than Bitcoin, signaling Bitcoin's evolving role as a maturing portfolio asset and potential inflation hedge.
  7. Sam Callahan of Orange BTC discussed Brazil's Bitcoin treasury strategy, arguing global currency debasement and fiscal dominance make Bitcoin and gold essential hedges.
  8. Michael Howell of Cross Border Capital warned that strong real economic growth is crowding out financial markets, and predicted continued debt monetization favoring gold and Bitcoin.

Summary:

The broadcast opened with markets rebounding on Black Monday's 39th anniversary after a sharp tech sell-off the prior week, with Bitcoin trading above $82K and equity futures pointing higher. Grace Remington and Sean Hagan covered global headlines including euro weakness from French political tensions and energy prices, Indonesian stocks plunging amid a possible MSCI downgrade, and JPMorgan's $5 billion investment in national security industries.

Discussion centered on the AI trade's sustainability. South Korea's KOSPI fell 8% Thursday, triggering a trading halt, as investors questioned whether the AI boom is too crowded or facing fundamental deterioration. The hosts noted a dramatic shift from roughly $15 billion in AI debt financing in 2024 to over $200 billion in 2026, with Anthropic receiving junk credit status ahead of a potential $2 trillion IPO.

Michael Saylor's $100 trillion Bitcoin credit vision was unpacked, including his "alloy" analogy blending Bitcoin with dollar reserves and Strategy's move to daily dividend payments on its preferred stock. Sam Callahan discussed Brazil's currency debasement driving Bitcoin adoption and argued central banks will be last to adopt Bitcoin. Michael Howell warned that strong real economic growth is crowding out financial markets, predicting continued debt monetization that favors gold and Bitcoin as inflation hedges.

FAQs

Black Monday is the anniversary of the 1987 market crash. Despite its infamous name, the markets actually closed that year up about 2%, so it turned out to be a relatively minor dip.

Concerns over the cost of AI infrastructure, rising debt financing for AI buildouts, and a repricing of credit and bond markets weighed on tech stocks. The S&P and Nasdaq suffered their worst weekly losses since late June.

Bitcoin is trading around $82K and showing relative strength. Grayscale research notes that 57% of S&P 500 companies are now more volatile than Bitcoin, and Bitcoin's own volatility has fallen sharply over five years.

Saylor describes a flywheel where Strategy sells credit, buys Bitcoin, drives up Bitcoin's price and reserves, compresses credit spreads, and repeats. He believes this system could scale to $100 trillion.

Daily dividends normalize ex-dividend dates, reducing volatility and preventing investors from gaming dividend snapshots. This helps the security trade closer to par and may slightly boost compounding returns.

Brazil has a history of currency debasement and capital controls, making Bitcoin's fixed supply appealing. It ranks number one in Chainalysis' global adoption index, and few public vehicles offer Bitcoin exposure.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.