Go back

Bold request from Alex Murdaugh's defense. Husband accused in sports park murder. Plus, self-defense tips.

29m 37s

Bold request from Alex Murdaugh's defense. Husband accused in sports park murder. Plus, self-defense tips.

Dateline True Crime Weekly covers multiple high-profile cases involving murder, legal controversies, and retrials. In South Carolina, Alec Murdoch’s 2023 murder conviction is overturned due to claims of juror misconduct, with his defense alleging investigator David Owen misrepresented evidence to the grand jury. A new trial is set, though the prosecution maintains the blood spatter evidence remains valid. In Douglas, Georgia, John Worrell, husband of Doris Worrell, is accused of hiring a gunman to kill his wife so he could begin a new life with their live-in nanny, Paula. The defense seeks a change of venue, claiming community knowledge and gossip prevent a fair trial. In Massachusetts, Lindsay Clancy’s retrial is confirmed on first-degree murder charges, with the case set for March 29, 2027. Mario Fernandez-Saldana, convicted of murdering Jared Bridegan, receives a life sentence plus 30 years, while Nima Momeni, convicted of stabbing Bob Lee, is sentenced to 16 years to life. A self-defense expert advises on situational awareness, emphasizing voice use, avoiding headphones, and being proactive in recognizing danger. The episode concludes with a preview of the upcoming investigation into Courtney Clenney’s alleged murder of her boyfriend.

Transcription

5057 Words, 28380 Characters

English
Hey, good morning. It's the start of another workday for the Dateline team. They never found his body at all. Our producers are catching up on breaking crime news. Well, he got 16 years, and he's probably served a bunch. What provoked that statement from the current DA? Police are saying that entire story was made up and staged. Welcome to Dateline True Crime Weekly. I'm Andrea Canning. It's November 19th, and here's what's on our docket. In Coffey County, Georgia, a man who allegedly masterminded the murder of his wife so he could start life over with their live-in nanny is heading to trial. The gossip and the rumors started to sort of bubble up about a possibly inappropriate relationship. In Dateline Roundup, a big decision in the Lindsay Clancy case, and we've got a double sentencing for you. We'll take you inside the courtroom for the sentencing of the man convicted of fatally stabbing Cash App founder Bob Lee, and the sentencing of the man convicted of plotting to murder Microsoft designer Jared Breidegen. If Jared was a gentle giant, Mario was a yappy little dog who had to pay someone else to bite. Plus, a self-defense expert has some tips for us on how to stay safe without even getting physical. Self-defense really starts before you are ever in a physical altercation. But before all that, we're heading to a South Carolina courthouse where allegations of investigator misconduct took center stage at a recent pretrial hearing. For disgraced attorney and alleged murderer, Alec Murdoch. Alec Murdoch is one of the most infamous murder defendants in the country. In 2023, his blockbuster trial for the double murder of his wife Maggie and their son Paul attracted true crime tourists and media from around the world. After six weeks of testimony, Murdoch was convicted and sentenced to life behind bars. But earlier this year, in a stunning reversal, the South Carolina Supreme Court ruled that Murdoch was convicted of murder. The South Carolina Supreme Court overturned his convictions, ruling that the court clerk had improperly influenced jurors. Now, prosecutors are gearing up to try Murdoch again. But at the latest hearing, his defense team asked a judge to throw out the indictments altogether, accusing the lead investigator of misleading the grand jury. What we're asking, Your Honor, is a reboot. Go back to square one. Dateline producer Carol Gable was in the courtroom and is here to tell us what happened. Carol, welcome back. Welcome back to the podcast. Thank you. Carol, before we get into the details of this hearing, set the scene for us. You've been covering this case for years now, and we have some new faces, a new judge. The newest face and the most consequential one is Deborah McCaslin. She is really a no-nonsense judge who has really wrangled, I think, lawyers who are used to doing a bit of showboating in a courtroom. And she has basically not fallen for it. She sets deadlines. If they miss them, they miss them. And every time we have a hearing, she reminds them that this trial will start on time. Carol, how did Murdoch seem to you? We know he's at ease in a courtroom. He comes from this long line of attorneys. He was an attorney. He's been behind bars for a while now. How's he doing? Well, frankly, he looks really good. And if you didn't know differently, when he's sitting with his defense, his defense team, he just looks like one of the lawyers. And he was actually, he was in a suit, right? His lawyers had asked several hearings ago that he be able to wear civilian clothes, not the orange jumpsuit. So he shows up in a coat and tie, and he looks like everyone else. Okay, Carol, let's get into what's being argued. A lot of the discussion was about forensics related to the crime scene. Give us a recap about how Paul and Matt, Maggie, were found after they were killed. Murdoch called 911 and said he'd come home from visiting his mom to find Maggie and Paul shot to death in the kennels on their property. The investigators took the clothes Murdoch had been wearing for testing. And of course, they were looking for things like gunshot residue and blood. That was in June, 2021. The grand jury met a year later, July, 2022. What did the lead investigator tell the grand jury? About the testing? Well, the investigator told that grand jury that an expert had found evidence of high-velocity blood spatter on Murdoch's T-shirt. That suggested that Murdoch must have been close to the victims when they were shot. This investigator also testified that Paul's DNA was also found on the shirt in the same area as the blood spatter. So what is the defense saying that the investigator got wrong? The defense told the judge, that they had unearthed a state lab report done early on in the investigation that concluded there was no human blood detected on Alec Murdoch's T-shirt. And if there was no blood on the T-shirt, how could there have been blood spatter? In order to have blood spatter, you got to have blood. It's pretty simple. The defense said that this early report that there was no blood on that T-shirt was not conveyed. It was not conveyed to the grand jury. Who was the investigator the defense is accusing of misleading the grand jury? And has this investigator said anything about the allegations being brought against him? His name is David Owen, and he was the SLED agent on duty, South Carolina Law Enforcement, or SLED. And when he testified at Murdoch's criminal trial, he was asked about this very topic, about the early report, showing there was no blood on the shirt. And he said he was not aware of that state lab report until after he had testified in front of the grand jury. That's what the prosecutor told the judge at last week's hearing, too, that the agent did not know about the lab report and did not intentionally mislead the jury. There is no error when this is the best understanding the agent had at the time. The prosecutor went on to say that their expert still believes there was blood spatter, spatter on Murdoch's T-shirt. The evidence of the shirt is not even false. The expert still stands by it. Carol, if the judge agrees with the defense and throws out these indictments, it doesn't mean this is over for Murdoch. Well, it doesn't. And I think the prevailing wisdom is he would be re-indicted. So why is the defense pushing so hard for this if the prosecution can just go back to the grand jury? I think all of these motions and the motion hearings have been, have been an opportunity for the defense to get out their point of view and their allegations to a wide audience of potential jurors. Don't forget, all of these hearings are televised live. And when we were at this latest motions hearing, the public was just packed on their side of the courtroom. The judge has not made any rulings yet. She said this to the attorneys in court. Let me ask if I, if you had, if you had to go back to the grand jury, could you have it done and all ready to go April 5th? I think she was just trying to get them on the record that she could still, even if you make a pit stop at a grand jury, which we'll meet in December, that if re-indicted, they'd still make their April 5th trial date. Okay. Forever complicated, Carol, and ongoing. Thank you for breaking this all down for us. Thank you, Andrea. Coming up, nearly 20 years after a mother of three, Doris Worrell, was shot dead at an indoor arcade, her husband stands accused of orchestrating her murder. For our next story, we're heading to Douglas, Georgia for the latest in a murder case that has hung over the small town for decades. Years ago, parents in Douglas used to take their children to John's Sports Park. It was a place where kids could play miniature golf and race go-karts. But on the morning of September 20th, 2006, it became a crime scene after one of the owners, 39-year-old Doris Worrell, was found shot to death in the indoor arcade. Investigators tried to track down her killer, but the case went nowhere. Then, in May of 2025, investigators announced they'd made an arrest. Sometimes slow, steady effort is really important. We're rewarded with justice that arrives like a thunderbolt. It was none other than Doris' husband, John Worrell. Prosecutors accused him of recruiting a gunman to murder Doris so he could start life over with their live-in nanny, Paula. John Worrell has pleaded not guilty, and at a recent pretrial hearing, his defense team argued he cannot get a fair trial in the community where his wife was killed. Here to catch us up on the case is Dateline producer Dorothy Newell. Hey, Dorothy. Hey, Andrea. Dorothy, let's start with John and Doris Worrell. What was their life in Georgia like? Sounds like it was kind of fun with that amusement park. Well, yeah, to begin with, that amusement park was the center of a lot of social life for the kids. It was John's thing. John was the owner. Doris was a stay-at-home mom. She had been a teacher and an interior designer, but they had three kids, all under the age of 11. They were really active members of the local Baptist church. And what I noticed when I got there, I've been there a few times, is that everybody really does know everybody in this town. They knew Doris and liked Doris and John, so it was was a very tight community. It still is. Dorothy, take us back to the day of the murder in 2006. What did officers find when they arrived at the scene? So John had been on errands, and he came back to the amusement park, and that's where he found Doris's body. He called it in, and at some moment, somebody shot a picture of him pretty much kind of collapsing on the ground with the police there, and he seemed to be truly distraught. First, the police thought this was a robbery gone wrong, and then there's a theory that it was a retaliation hit from gang members who were angry that they'd been thrown off the property by John recently. Eventually, investigators, after looking at these theories, ruled them out. Dorothy, investigators started hearing whispers about a possible relationship between John and the live-in nanny, Paula. She was 18. At the time of the murder, but the family, they met her years earlier. Yeah, that's right. She was undocumented, just barely 15, 14 to 15 years old when she appeared in Douglas. She had been abandoned. The Dorals met her through a church member who brought her in and said, this is Paula, and she needs a home, and she needs some help. And Doris and John said, we'll take her in. And she really became part of the family. She helped take care of the kids. She helped to work at the amusement park. She was going to the amusement park, and she was going to high school there. And what I gathered from talking to people in town is that as she got older, the gossip and the rumors started to sort of bubble up about a possibly inappropriate relationship between John and Paula. Whatever it was, the police got wind of it after they started looking into this killing. Since investigators learned about John's alleged relationship with Paula pretty quickly, Dorothy, did they question him right after the murder? Dorothy, did they question him right after the murder? We know the police talked to John right after the killing. It's pretty clear to me that investigators heard from John and from Paula that they did not have an inappropriate relationship. And John actually moved out of Georgia? Yes. In August of 2007, John moved with the kids to Florida and eventually moved to Costa Rica. In February of 2008, Paula was deported to Venezuela. Paula eventually moved up to Costa Rica, where they lived together. And she was deported to Venezuela. And she was there as man and wife. They ran an ice delivery business and raised the kids. We know that John was arrested in 2025. What led investigators back to him all these years later? So they were keeping their ear to the ground pretty well, and they learned that this relationship broke up. Paula moved on. John moved to Missouri. But a new group of investigators came in, one in particular, who thought he could do something with this case. So he got together with the sheriffs, and they went to go find him. And they went to go find him. And they went to Costa Rica to interview Paula. And eventually, she agreed to cooperate. She's the one who ends up providing the key information that leads to John's arrest. And he was arrested in Missouri, brought back to Georgia. We should remind people, prosecutors are not saying John was the gunman himself. So they're saying he may have hired one or maybe two people. Yes. You recently attended a hearing in Coffey County. There were some pretrial motions. Doris's family members were there. They were in the courtroom, including her children with John. Yeah. Doris's family and friends were on one side, and on the other side appeared to be John's family, including those three kids, who are all grown now. They were clearly supporting their father. One of them waved at one point to John. Do we know why Doris and John's kids are continuing to support their dad? The only insight I have is that they lived with their dad from the moment their mother was killed all the way up through the time they went to college. They have nothing else. This is their only parent, and this is who they've spent most of their time with. And they clearly love him. Yeah, that's really hard for them. Before their dad's arrest, they hadn't spoken to Doris's side of the family in years. And Doris's sister actually spoke out about that in her first press conference, and it was pretty emotional. She spoke directly to the children. If any of you are watching today, I would like to thank you for being here. I would like to thank you for being here. I would like to say, please come home. You have a home with us. We will welcome you with open arms. We love you. We've always loved you. So, Dorothy, what was the focus of the hearing you were just at? They had various motions, but the most important one was a request for a change of venue. The defense is convinced that John cannot get a fair trial in Coffey County because too many people know too much about this case. And they've been steeped in information about this case since the murder. And, Dorothy, this is a little unusual, but surprising to read the lengths that the defense went to to show that they need this change of venue. Oh, yeah. They had hired investigators who did this deep dive into what was reported and how it's been reported and what people have said day after day on this case, especially since the arrest. What I find really interesting is that the defense looked into online discussions, you know, those threads that people have because people can be so opinionated about these cases. I mean, at one point, the judge suggested to the defense that just because there's this widespread interest doesn't mean that people believe it. And the prosecutor has questioned repeatedly of all these people that you've heard them talking about. How do you know that they're from Coffey County? How do you know that they're not just these true crime enthusiasts who are offering their opinion? And they live in Alaska. You know, and the other question is, given the nature of the case, how do you know that they're from Coffey County? How do you know that they're social media? Where do you go to get away from opinion? True. It's hard. Is the judge weighing all the arguments and will come back with a decision on the change of venue? He made it clear at the hearing that he would take this all under advisement. Whatever he decides, he wants this trial to start March 1st, 2027. It'll be here before we know it. Dorothy, we'll keep an eye out for any developments. Thank you for the updates. My pleasure. Up next, it's time for Dateline Roundup. Emotions run high at the sentencings of two convicted killers. The man who stabbed to death Cash App founder Bob Lee and the man who conspired to murder his wife's ex-husband, Microsoft designer Jared Bride again. Plus, a self-defense expert has some advice about staying vigilant and staying safe. Welcome back. Joining us today is our This week's Roundup is Dateline field producer Justin Ratchford. Justin, welcome back to the podcast. Thanks for having me. So, Justin, first, we've got some news out of Massachusetts. There was a brief but tense hearing earlier this week for Lindsay Clancy, the former labor and delivery nurse accused of killing her three young children. She pleaded not guilty at trial on the grounds that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis. That trial, of course, ended in a mistrial. And we've been talking a lot these past few weeks about her defense attorney, unsuccessful attempts to get the charges against her dismissed. We have also been waiting to hear if there will be a retrial. On Monday, Justin, we finally got word. That's right. On Monday, the prosecutor's confirmed there's going to be another trial. Okay. Do we know, Justin, if they're going to try her again on first-degree murder charges? Well, that was the interesting part. The prosecutor seemed to skirt around exactly what charges the district attorney planned to bring against Clancy. It requires a jury trial, so we'd be ready to take a jury trial date. Lindsay Clancy's attorney, Kevin Reddington, seemed to think that asking for a jury trial meant one thing. He had this to say in court. As they say, alia e acta est. The die has been cast. I think you can read between the lines that they intend to proceed on first-degree murder indictments. So ominous, Justin. Absolutely. The die is cast essentially means there's no going back now. Historians attribute this Latin idiom to Julius Caesar, who famously said this before the Roman Civil War. Lindsay Clancy's retrial will proceed. Any idea on a date? Well, the attorneys went back and forth trying to pick a date. And at one point, the judge jokingly made his own reference to Julius Caesar, mentioning the day the Roman leader was assassinated. We can do this, keeping with historical quotes, we can do this on March 15th. Yeah, it's a March. Yeah, it's a March. And then if that other case has to be continued, we can continue that. I could do that. Sorry, I don't have. I'm not, you know, I'm not saying any jokes. All right. I'm just trying to talk to both counsel about getting a date. Sounds tense. What did they ultimately settle on? As of now, March 29th, 2027. Okay, we know there'll be back in court. Before then, lots to sort out. Definitely. The next hearing is scheduled for December 30th. Next, we have an update from a courthouse in Jacksonville, Florida, in a case I've been covering for years. The murder of 33-year-old Microsoft designer Jared Bridegan back in 2022. Prosecutors charged three people with murder, his ex-wife, Shanna Gardner, her husband, Mario Fernandez-Saldana, and Henry Tennon, who was accused of being the hitman who shot Jared. Mario Fernandez-Saldana was the first and only defendant so far to go to trial. He was convicted back in August on charges including murder and solicitation. He was sentenced last week. But Justin, before the sentencing could even get started, Mario's defense team had something to say. They did. they filed a motion for a new trial. They said that there was new firearm evidence that would have changed the verdict. The judge spent five minutes considering the motion and ultimately denied it. Didn't waste any time. After her ruling, the judge immediately went right into sentencing. Yeah, she didn't skip a beat. She called for victim impact statements. Jared's sister was the first to go, and you can really hear the hurt and pain in her voice. My world crumbled, and my faith briefly left me, and I went numb. Every year, I have to buy a birthday cake for Jared. I sink to an empty chair, and I close my eyes, and I envision that he's there with me. Justin, Jared's wife, Kirsten, who we've spoken to on the podcast before, gave a statement as well. She didn't hold back. Yeah, she told the court how Jared was a fiercely loving and dedicated victim. Someone whose life had immense value until Mario took it all away. And then Kirsten drew a scathing comparison between him and Jared. Mario has always been a small man in comparison to Jared. Small in stature, lacking in integrity, deficient in courage, and devoid of honor. Mario knew had the fight been fair, the outcome would have been completely different. Mario did not address the what was his sentence. Ultimately, the judge sentenced him to life in prison plus additional 30 years for solicitation to commit a capital felony. And those 30 years will be served concurrently. Okay, Shanna Gardner and the man prosecutors say was the hitman are scheduled to go on trial next year. They have both pleaded not guilty. It'll be interesting to see if Mario testifies against either of them, so we'll keep an eye on that. Finally, we have another sentencing to fill you in on. Two years ago, the judge sentenced him to life in prison, plus additional 30 years after a jury found Nima Momeni guilty of murdering Bob Lee, the founder of the payment service Cash App. He stood before a judge to learn his fate. Justin, prosecutors said Momeni drove Bob Lee to an isolated spot under the Bay Bridge and stabbed him. Momeni's defense was that he stabbed Lee in self-defense after Lee attacked him. The jury ultimately convicted Momeni of second-degree murder. Cameras were not allowed inside at the sentencing, but there were several powerful victim impact statements from Lee and Momeni. Momeni's defense was that he stabbed Lee in self-defense and stabbed Momeni. Momeni's family, including his daughter Scout, who spoke directly to Momeni. According to court reporters, she said to him, you did not just end a life, you ended an entire future built around a man. Momeni had a chance to speak as well? He did, and he steadfastly maintains his innocence. He told the court that both families have suffered, but unfortunately, we have completely different understandings of what transpired. The judge sentenced Momeni to 16 years to life in prison, minus time served. Since he has been locked up for almost four years, we could see him released as early as 2038, Justin. Bob's brother, Oliver Lee, spoke to reporters about being pleased that the trial is over, but wanting more from Momeni. He needs to admit to himself that he perpetrated this crime and that he is a murderer and he will forever be a murderer of Bob Lee. Momeni's defense says that they plan to appeal the case, so we'll see what happens with that. And I should mention, if you want to know more about Momeni, you can go to our website, which is under the Bay Bridge. Justin, thank you for all these updates. This month, Texas fitness influencer and model Peyton Knight made headlines when she revealed she carries a handgun when she's jogging by herself. That may sound a little extreme, but it did make us curious about what steps people can take to stay safe when they're out and about. Today, we're joined by Katie Ring, host of the podcast America's Most Infamous Crimes. Some crimes are so shocking, they don't just make headlines, they change a nation. She's also a self-defense expert and martial arts instructor, and she's here to give us some tips on how to stay safe and stay aware. Katie, thanks so much for being here. Thanks for having me on. I'm excited. Great. So first, just tell us about yourself. You, as we said, you're a self-defense expert turned podcast host. I always say I can't believe I get paid to do this. Yeah. What I love is that I get to blend my self-defense knowledge with true crime. I swear most people are I watch it to know what I do in case I'm in this situation. So I'm really happy I get to teach people at the end of the episodes lessons from different cases. I love that. I love how you mix those two things together. And one of the biggest themes you talk about is situational awareness. It's something I think about all the time. Tell us what it means and how you can be better about paying attention to the things around you. Yeah. So I always say, you know, a lot of people think self-defense is physical, but self-defense really starts before you are ever in a physical altercation. And my goal is to never be in a physical altercation. So situational awareness is just being very aware of your surroundings. And you don't have to be hypervigilant all the time. It's just being aware of people's behaviors, not being distracted, especially going in and out of cars, in and out of your house, you know, entries and exits, not looking down at your phone. One thing I do suggest, especially when you have certain routes you take every day, is having places on a route where you know you can escape, where you know other people will be, because if someone's following you, you don't want to lead them to where you live. So ideally, you know, along your route, be like, okay, the liquor store is there, the grocery store is there. Somewhere where people are. And then I also think using your voice is so important as well. I was asleep the other night, and I heard this woman screaming, get off of me. I don't know you. And I am such a heavy sleeper. And I heard that, and I was up immediately. Like, I raised up, like, from the dead. What did you do? I called 911. Luckily, they had already had a couple of calls. And, where I live, our police response was pulling up before I was even out the front door. But, you know, using your voice, screaming. Screaming is good. And something else, the headphones. I try to walk as often as I can. And people wear their headphones. You know, they listen to music or podcasts, which is great. But at the same time, I mean, these noise-canceling headphones now, like, you can't hear anymore if someone's coming up behind you. Yeah. So when I'm walking around, I'll, have one in, and I have it pretty low. Whenever I walk, I don't let anyone come up behind me when I don't know who they are. So, like, if I hear or see someone behind me, some people feel so uncomfortable doing this because they don't want to seem rude. But I will look at whoever's coming behind me. And I have brought up time and time again about the rude angle. Don't be afraid to seem rude. You know, it's something that is, like, ingrained in a lot of us that we don't want to offend anyone, which it's okay to not want to be rude. But if you're in a situation where your instinct is kicking in that something's not right, be rude. Your safety is more important than anyone else's feelings. And if they're offended by that, then that's, that's their problem. Don't be afraid to walk across the street or even scooting over a little bit off the sidewalk and let them pass you. Absolutely. I think it's just, you know, drill it into your head on a daily basis that these are things that, that you need to do. And just simple ways to change your way of living. Yeah. If you're prepared, you don't have to be scared. Katie, thank you for coming on. Thank you so much for having me on. That's it for this episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly. But if you like what you're hearing, check out Dateline Premium. Subscribers get early access to our latest original podcast series, ad-free, and there's bonus content, too. And coming up this Friday, it's a case that made a lot of headlines back in 2022. You may remember Courtney Clenney, the OnlyFans model accused of killing her boyfriend, Christian Obamsele, in their Miami apartment. This Friday, I'm bringing you the full story, including my interviews with both families. What does she say happened? Christian was injured. And I said, hang up, call 911. Courtney is not arrested. How does that sit with your family? It does bring up emotions. It was insane. Watch Tick, Tick, Boom! this Friday at 10, 9 central on Dateline on NBC. Thanks for listening. Dateline True Crime Weekly is produced by Carson Cummins, Caroline Casey, and Kiani Reid. Our associate producers are Ellery Gladstone-Groth and Aria Young. Production and fact-checking help by Carol Chen. Our senior producer is Liz Brown-Kurloff. Veronica Mazzica is our digital producer. Rick Kwan is our sound designer. Original music by Jesse McGinty. Paul Ryan is executive producer. And Liz Cole is senior executive producer of Dateline. Thank you. Have a good one.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Alec Murdoch, convicted in 2023 for the murder of his wife and son, has his convictions overturned by South Carolina’s Supreme Court due to alleged juror bias, prompting a new trial.
  2. Murdoch’s defense claims lead investigator David Owen misled the grand jury by omitting an early lab report showing no blood on his T-shirt, undermining the blood spatter evidence.
  3. The prosecution maintains the blood spatter evidence remains valid and that Owen did not intentionally mislead, asserting the expert testimony still stands.
  4. In a separate case, John Worrell, husband of Doris Worrell, is accused of hiring gunmen to murder his wife so he could start a new life with their live-in nanny, Paula.
  5. The defense in the Worrell case argues for a change of venue in Coffey County, claiming widespread community knowledge and gossip undermine a fair trial.
  6. A retrial is set for Lindsay Clancy, who previously was acquitted of first-degree murder charges after a mistrial; prosecutors have confirmed the case will proceed with first-degree murder charges.
  7. Mario Fernandez-Saldana, convicted of murdering Microsoft designer Jared Bridegan, is sentenced to life in prison plus 30 years, with defense claims of new evidence rejected.
  8. Nima Momeni, convicted of stabbing Cash App founder Bob Lee, receives a 16-year-to-life sentence, with his defense asserting self-defense and plans to appeal.

Summary:

Dateline True Crime Weekly covers multiple high-profile cases involving murder, legal controversies, and retrials. In South Carolina, Alec Murdoch’s 2023 murder conviction is overturned due to claims of juror misconduct, with his defense alleging investigator David Owen misrepresented evidence to the grand jury. A new trial is set, though the prosecution maintains the blood spatter evidence remains valid.

In Douglas, Georgia, John Worrell, husband of Doris Worrell, is accused of hiring a gunman to kill his wife so he could begin a new life with their live-in nanny, Paula. The defense seeks a change of venue, claiming community knowledge and gossip prevent a fair trial. In Massachusetts, Lindsay Clancy’s retrial is confirmed on first-degree murder charges, with the case set for March 29, 2027.

Mario Fernandez-Saldana, convicted of murdering Jared Bridegan, receives a life sentence plus 30 years, while Nima Momeni, convicted of stabbing Bob Lee, is sentenced to 16 years to life. A self-defense expert advises on situational awareness, emphasizing voice use, avoiding headphones, and being proactive in recognizing danger. The episode concludes with a preview of the upcoming investigation into Courtney Clenney’s alleged murder of her boyfriend.

FAQs

The South Carolina Supreme Court overturned Murdoch's murder convictions due to alleged juror misconduct. Prosecutors are now preparing to retry him, and a recent hearing saw his defense request to throw out the indictments, accusing the lead investigator of misleading the grand jury.

The investigator testified that high-velocity blood spatter and Paul's DNA were found on Murdoch's T-shirt, suggesting he was close to the victims when they were shot.

The defense claimed an early state lab report found no human blood on the shirt, which contradicts the blood spatter evidence. They argue this information was not disclosed to the grand jury and thus constitutes a misleading omission.

David Owen, a South Carolina Law Enforcement (SLED) agent, is accused of misleading the grand jury by not disclosing the early lab report showing no blood on Murdoch's shirt.

The defense is seeking a change of venue, arguing that John cannot get a fair trial in Coffey County due to widespread community knowledge and ongoing public discussion of the case.

A new investigative team, led by local sheriffs, traveled to Costa Rica to interview Paula, the live-in nanny, who eventually cooperated and provided key information leading to John's arrest.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.