A shocking and deeply disturbing murder took place in Madison, South Dakota, on January 31, 2012, when 73-year-old Norm Johnson, a beloved local teacher, coach, and community pillar, was fatally shot twice in the face by an unknown man at his doorstep. The victim, known for his kindness, integrity, and decades of service to the town, had a close-knit network of friends, students, and neighbors. The suspect, described as a white man aged 50–60, was later linked to Carl Erickson, a retired insurance officer with a history of depression, anxiety, and a strained relationship with his younger brother Dick Erickson. Carl had previously expressed hostility toward Dick, calling Norm Johnson a “son of a bitch” and claiming he would have killed his brother had the opportunity. Though Carl initially denied any involvement, he was found with matching flashlights, tire tracks, and a .45 handgun consistent with the crime scene. The shooting sparked a widespread panic in the town, which had not seen a murder in over a century—leading to a full lockdown at South Dakota State University, social media-driven rumors, and a wave of fear among retirees. Despite extensive investigation, no definitive evidence tied Carl to the crime, and the case remains unsolved. The tragedy not only revealed deep personal tensions within families but also highlighted the fragility of small-town safety in the face of fear and misinformation. The case stands as a stark reminder of how personal grievances can spiral into violence, and how communities respond to crises with both fear and solidarity.
Hello, everybody, and welcome back to Small Town Murder Express.
Yay and choo-choo!
Yay indeed, Jimmy. Yay indeed.
My name is James Petrigallo. I'm here with my co-host.
I'm Jimmy Wissman.
Thank you, folks, so much for joining us today on another wild, crazy,
one of the weirdest episodes we've ever talked about today.
Just a strange, at the end you're going to go,
what the hell did I just hear?
It's crazy stuff. Can't wait to get to that.
Before we do, though, go ahead and head over to ShutUpAndGiveMeMurder.com.
Get all your merchandise there, everything like that.
Also, tickets to live shows.
Only right now there are no live shows to buy at the moment.
Nothing available.
This week is, or this year's tour is over.
We are announcing our dates, I think, probably very soon here.
Within the next week or two, we'll be announcing our dates for 2027,
and those are going to go on sale in early December, so you can get those.
They make a lovely holiday gift, I've got to tell you.
So go ahead and grab those tickets.
Tell them more, James. Tell them exactly this.
Do not go anywhere other than ShutUpAndGiveMeMurder.com to get tickets.
We say it twice a show.
Don't go to StubHub.
Don't go to any of these places.
We've had people go.
People go, and I paid $180 for my ticket, and you're like,
we would never charge $180 for a ticket, ever,
unless we got like a full band and an orchestra,
and we were doing like a Broadway show.
We would never charge $180 for a ticket.
Unless Bruce Springsteen is our guest to do the show.
And he wants all the ticket money.
$180 tickets.
Otherwise, we're not doing that.
We don't think that highly of ourselves, ever, to charge that much.
Never.
Never.
If you would pay it, even though we don't think you would,
even if you would, we'd go, we can't charge people that much.
What are you, crazy?
You have no fucking mind?
So please go to ShutUpAndGiveMeMurder.com.
Maybe on our last tour when we need the money to quit.
This is it.
Yeah, this is our going away tour.
It's our too expensive for more expensive than it should be tour.
Get yourself Patreon, though.
That is a good thing.
And again, that is also not $180.
Anybody, $5 a month or above, that's all you have to be.
Patreon.com slash crime.
And in sports, just like the name of our other podcast there.
So anybody $5 a month or above, you get everything we put out.
As soon as you subscribe, you're going to get tons of back bonus episodes.
Almost 400 of them, as a matter of fact.
All that you can binge on right away.
And then new ones every other week.
One crime in sports, one small town murder.
And you get them all, everybody.
So it's a great time.
This week, what you're going to get for crime in sports,
we are going to talk about the Mike Vrabel scandal.
The Patriots head coach having an affair with a reporter.
And her whole thing.
It's going to be juicy and fun and current and topical.
And it's going to be a good time.
And then for small town murder,
we're going to talk about the clown panic from like 10 years ago.
There's a documentary about it now.
And there was a period of time when people were dressed up as what they consider,
quote, scary clowns and would jump out and try to scare people
and act like they were going to murder them and stuff.
And somehow, none of these clowns were savagely killed in the streets.
And I don't know how.
What they are is bait for people that are looking for a fight.
Oh.
Oh.
I was so praying to get a clown jumped out.
I go, finally.
License.
I almost got arrested the last time I beat up a clown.
So this is good.
So get in there.
I felt threatened.
My life felt threatened.
Hey.
You know, that's what he was trying to do.
Scare me.
It worked.
There you go.
So patreon.com slash crime in sports is where you get all of that and more.
And in addition, you also get all the shows we put out.
Crime in sports, your stupid opinion, small town murder,
all ad free with your Patreon.
Ad free.
Freak.
Ad free.
And you get a shout out at the end of the regular show.
So that said, I think it's time, everybody, to sit back.
What do you say here?
Clear the lungs.
There we go.
Arms to the sky.
Let's all shout.
Shut up and give me murder.
Let's do this, everybody.
OK.
Let's go on a trip, shall we?
Let's do it.
By the way, everybody this week, the past weekend in Boston and Tarrytown,
amazing.
Thank you so much.
Tarrytown.
Saw old friends, new friends.
People came from Australia and got married in Central Park and showed up in their wedding outfits.
Took a train from their wedding.
It was incredible.
And then Boston, that crowd was just, you guys were intense and amazing and laughed at everything.
Oh, my God.
It was so great.
Fran came over from Australia for like the third time.
Yeah, we had people flying in.
My brother came to one.
Your brother came to one.
My brother, old friends I haven't seen in forever.
And all of my family and AJ, everybody.
Like that, too, our buddies.
So, there you go.
Good times.
That said, let's go on a trip, shall we?
Yeah.
I think it's time.
We're going to South Dakota this week.
Yeah.
We're going to Madison, South Dakota.
Oh, they got one, too.
They all have a Madison.
They all do.
Yep.
It is in eastern South Dakota.
About 55 minutes to Sioux Falls, South Dakota.
That's the closest town anybody might have heard of here.
About two hours and 25 minutes to Highmoor, South Dakota.
Our last South Dakota episode.
episode 708, The Scariest Staircase, which I remember very well because that was a creepy one.
Yeah, anytime it's the scariest anything, we've had Murder at Scary Bridge. Believe me,
it's nasty stuff when we put that in there. Staircases are used in murders about as much
as screwdrivers. They are, though, because people, that's one of those that's like,
people get away with that one a lot because it's like, I mean, he could have fell. Who the hell
hasn't fallen down some stairs? You know what I mean? So it's like the staircase guy, the Peterson
guy in North Carolina. That's why everybody's kind of like, it's tough. It's all of our fears.
When you're a kid, they always tell you, be careful on the stairs. You'll fall and break
your neck. And how many times when you're a kid, you fall down the stairs? I fell on the stairs
20 times when I was a kid. Did you? Well, I grew up in houses that were two stories on the East
Coast. We would slide down them. Raised ranches, it's not a lot of stairs to worry about in Arizona.
Maybe one step down.
Living room or something.
So when I was in Colorado with my grandparents' house, we would just go stiff as a board and
slide down it as fast as we could.
Oh, that's fun. You could do that. Yeah. This is in Lake County, area code 605,
population 6,388. So pretty small town. And there's not anything around it. It's not like
a suburb where there's a bunch of other stuff. This is in the middle of nowhere.
It's a town sitting there. Median household income here, a little less than the national average.
It's $58,564.
Usually around $70,000 in the rest of the country. And the median home cost also well below the
national average at $225,500 as well. So it's just everything's kind of lower here. The motto here is
discover the unexpected. Discover it, goddammit.
Well, I didn't expect a soul to be here. So if I see three people, I'll be pretty surprised
that it's unexpected. It's unexpected.
Yeah. History of this town. A little bit of history. I guess this town, it started when the
arrival of William. It was the first town in the United States. William Lee and Charles Walker. They showed up in 1870. And that led to the establishment of the
town of Madison in the southwest side of Lake Madison. That's why they do that here. Both the
lake and the town were named after James Madison. Madison, Wisconsin, which I think was named after
James Madison. But after Wisconsin, because they were from a place near Madison, Wisconsin,
these guys. It wasn't named after Dolly and her amazing cakes?
It's incredible, isn't it? No, it wasn't. So in 1880, the railroad was extended west
into this area and that made everything, you know, bigger. The problem is it was moved near
a guy named C.B. Kennedy's homestead, which was five miles north of Madison. So this guy,
Kennedy, invited all the Madison residents to move to his homestead. You guys can just set up
your town here because it's closer to the railroad. Obviously, that's too far. So they made it the
move. They made it to Madison. And they moved to Madison. And they
the move and started the New Madison, which is where it is now. New Madison. They rock ridged it,
dude. They moved the whole town. It's crazy. Notable people, Mary Hart is from here. The
lady who used to host Entertainment Tonight and whose voice gave that guy seizures. Remember that?
That was a big deal. Do I remember that? In the 90s, there was this guy who the sound of Mary
Hart's voice gave him seizures. It was on Seinfeld. They did a parody of it where Kramer
would hear Mary Hart and have a seizure. That was the whole thing. Yeah. That's very funny.
That's very funny. Reviews of this town. Okay, here we go. Five stars here because I've never
been to Madison. On Saturday, July 12th, 4.30 p.m. This is very, very specific. I entered into
Washington Street from Highway 34. My vehicle started smoking and I heard a loud pop. That's
not good. Before I knew it, I guess police is what they're going for. A policy officer came,
but I think he means police. He not only tried to reach my husband,
but pushed my vehicle to a side street. What an example he set for others to follow. So grateful.
What an example to do your job, the basic tenets of your fucking job. That's a real example to set.
All he did was push the car with his car? Whatever he did. Yeah. However he did it,
that's his goddamn job. First of all, to clear a car off the road. Second of all, I don't know,
help a citizen once in a while. Next time you're at a school or anywhere and you see a guy pushing
his car, make sure to be blown away by the fact that he's doing his job. Just make sure because
it's the same thing.
The policy is not even close.
No, there's no Y near the E.
So, five stars.
The community is very pet-slash-family friendly.
We just moved into this community and were immediately welcomed.
There's nobody else there.
Why not?
Yeah.
Here's three stars.
Madison is a very small and friendly town based around South Dakota State University.
That's the other thing that's nearby here.
It's a great town for students and residents alike, considering the distance between local grocery stores and restaurants.
The nearest cities are within 40 to 50 miles, which is not very close, by the way, with very minimal traffic between commutes.
Who's there?
There's nobody there.
There's nobody out there.
Is a buffalo going to wander in the road?
What are we talking about?
40 to 50 miles.
I'd like to see more growth in businesses within Madison.
Overall, it's a nice town.
And then finally, one star.
The only one star review.
Worst town I ever tried to live in.
Try.
They didn't even let him in.
They were like, nope, sorry.
The utilities they charge is an outrage, and I feel they have it set up to tax you whenever they want.
Yeah.
That's pretty much how it works.
I feel like I'm in a Stephen King novel or an Alfred Hitchcock episode.
There's no competition in town, and you pay 25 to 40 percent more on a lot of items with not much selection.
South Dakota is nice, but not here.
Yeah, that small town tax.
He just described living in a very small area.
Yeah.
Anywhere that's a distance from a civilization.
Yeah.
They brought the stuff there.
That cost them money.
That's the other thing.
And you save money on your property because it's all coming out of your pocket with the distance gas and shipping.
Totally.
Things to do.
The Prairie Village Steam Threshing Jamboree.
Threshing Jamboree.
I was like, okay.
This is the 62nd annual, so apparently they know something about it here.
It's four days of fun.
Excellent.
There's steam and horse threshing.
I don't know what that means.
Parades, machinery demonstrations, tractor pulls, musical entertainment, and train rides.
It's $15 for adults.
And a four-day pass.
It's $50 for adults.
So $15 a day or save $10 on the fourth day with $50 total.
That's it.
Now, the musical acts here.
We have, oh, this isn't a musical act.
This is Steam Power on the Prairie, a program by David Mench.
That sounds exciting.
David Mench.
7.30, Surf and Safari's playing.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Beach Boys Tribute Band or Jan and Dean, whatever the fuck that is.
Surf and Safari.
The next day, we have the. 5th Annual Prairie Village Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony.
Gotta have that.
The best combine driver?
I think so.
Oh, man.
He took down so much, so many ears.
One year, boy, he set a record.
4.30 p.m., the Fiddlers of South Dakota will be there.
Oh, yeah.
Just fiddling with their junk.
That's all.
Yeah.
Bunch of guys dicking with their dicks.
7.30, the Honky Tonk Stardust Cowboys will be there.
What the fuck is that?
I don't know.
Country music?
Country music mixed with fucking David Bowie mixed with. I don't know what that is.
Stardust Cowboys.
That makes no sense.
And then Sunday night, closing it all out, the Happy Memories Gospel Band.
Oh, boy.
Oh, boy.
Okay.
That said, let's talk. That's it.
That's it.
Four days of that.
$50.
Oh, my God.
That said, let's talk about a murder here.
Let's do it.
Yeah.
This is some strange, strange, strange shit here.
Happenings.
I mean. Jody last week.
Jody Herring, which was a crazy case of someone losing their mind and settling all their grudges.
Yeah.
This is beyond that.
That, you'd go, wow.
Who holds that heart of a grudge where you're going to go after all these people?
This is even crazier.
Okay.
Tuesday, January 31st, 2012.
So, recently.
This is very recently.
Just after 7.30 p.m.
On Northwest 5th Street here.
Okay.
Now, this is across from the Memorial Creek.
And it's a nice house.
It's a brown, clabbered house.
Nice.
You know, nice.
What is that?
It's hard to explain.
It's a style of house.
Okay.
You'd know it if you saw it.
Yeah, yeah.
I don't know how to explain it.
But, anyway, there's a car parks outside the house of where we are here, out of this brown house.
It's a Ford Taurus.
Uh-huh.
And a man walks to the door.
He rings the doorbell.
And the owner of the home answers.
Sure.
It's a man, older man, in his early 70s here.
And the man coming up to the door seems to be an older man, too, from the description we'll get.
Not sure how old yet.
But this man comes up to the door and says, are you Norm Johnson?
Now, Norm doesn't answer very quickly for some reason, the guy there.
But it is Norm Johnson answering the door.
So, the guy asks again, are you Norm Johnson?
Very quickly.
That's a long pause.
If he can say the question again.
Yeah, he cut him off of whatever he was trying to do.
So, then Norm says, yeah, yeah, I'm Norm Johnson.
I think it's also just it's, I don't know, 730 at night.
You're not expecting a stranger to knock on the door.
Yeah, this is my house.
This is weird that you would come to my house and ask me that question.
Normally, someone that you don't know comes to your house to ask you if you're this person.
It's a process server.
So, you're like, hmm.
Yeah, it's something legal.
And I don't want anything to do with this.
Yeah.
So, Norm finally says, yes, I'm Norm Johnson.
And as quickly as the words, yes.
Yes, I'm Norm Johnson, come out of his mouth.
A gun comes out and the man knocking at the door fires two shots directly into Norm's face from a very close range.
In his face?
Right in the face from a very close range.
Wow.
Sending Norm back into his living room, down basically right in his entryway.
And he dies almost immediately.
I mean, it was two.
Holy shit.
Very close shots.
And I believe we're going to find out it's a.45 caliber, too.
So, two shots to the face.
Of a.45, that close.
You're in deep shit.
You're not good.
There's very little room for error.
Absolutely.
So, this man who just died, who's apparently Norm Johnson, his wife, Barbara, comes out, heard the commotion, comes out, and sees her husband lying on the floor bleeding and looks outside because the door's open.
She's like, what the fuck just happened?
She looks outside and sees a man walking toward a dark sedan, a Ford Taurus, parked by the curb.
He's not running.
He's not running.
He's just walking.
Just casual.
Straight walking.
Now, Norm's, this is so sad.
Norm's dog comes over and won't leave his side, which is fucking sad.
That's what they do, man.
That's what they do.
Yeah.
My dog, I hit my head once and was like unconscious for a second and fell on the ground.
And she wouldn't even let Sarah come over to me to help me.
I was like, get off of me, fucking dog.
She's more useful than you are.
Trust me.
She's a human being.
She has thumbs.
She can help me do things.
Yeah, she can get gauze and shit.
You can do nothing for me, but stand over me and go.
And if there is an issue, she knows the phone number.
Yeah.
What are you going to do?
Lick my head?
That's not helping any.
So nine times, nine times, one time.
Are you okay?
Can you do that?
Nine times, one time.
Wait.
Shit.
So let's find out about the dead man.
Who is this guy?
Who could have wanted him dead?
Because normally to find the killer, you find you have to dig into.
To find out who's related to him.
What waters they were wading into.
Who they might have encountered that might have been shady.
Some relationships that they might have.
What were they involved in?
You never know.
So this is Norm Johnson.
Norman Johnson.
Everyone calls him Norm.
Yeah.
Norm's a good.
He also has a nickname Storm and Norman as well.
Oh, what's that about?
We'll find out here.
All right.
June 25th, 1939 is when he's born.
So the poor man.
He's 72 years old, this guy.
He's an old man.
He's an old man coming to the door.
He grew up, was born in Madison, South Dakota.
He's from here.
His dad was Norman.
And just like him, his mom was Charlene.
He has three sisters.
One of them died a few years back from this.
He went to Madison High School and graduated there.
And he was a very popular young man.
Is that right?
Real popular.
Everybody knew Norm.
He was the star running back on the football.
He was the star running back on the football team
and the star of the track team.
That'll do it.
That's how he's Storm and Norman.
In a small town, too.
Like, you are going to be a hero.
I mean, this is a big deal.
He started every single football game in high school.
He's a starter always.
He dated a very pretty cheerleader named Barbara Halseth.
So, I mean, he is.
50s.
Yeah, think about that.
He is.
I mean, he's got cigarettes rolled up in his sleeve
and the duck bill going.
You know what I'm saying?
And getting in those old 50s.
50s cars with his hot cheerleader girlfriend
coming from the game with his Letterman jacket on.
Like, this is very, like, archy what's going on right here.
100%.
Super archy.
They had helmets, right?
Wasn't leather time?
Was it leather helmets?
No.
In the 50s?
Not in the 50s.
In the 50s, they transferred from leather to the. They had, like, plastic.
Because the 40s is when plastic became a thing.
All right.
So, it was plastic before that.
So.
Anyway, here, he dates her.
One of his linemen on his football team, Bum.
Buzz Rumrill.
Oh, Buzz.
Buzz is a lineman on the football team.
He says, Norm was a spark plug of a kid, but real athletic.
He wasn't cocky, but he was popular.
He was the best, and he didn't even know it.
He was just a good kid.
He graduates in 1958 from Madison High.
On September 19, 1958, he is married, which is right before college, when he goes to college.
He marries Barbara Halstead, the high school cheerleader that he's been dating.
They get married at the Trinity Lutheran Church.
Oh, man.
I mean, you know, that's what the teenage wedding song was fucking written for these people.
The old folks wished him well, and there they go.
They all stay married.
They are still married.
She's the one who found him at the door in 2012, and they're married in 1958.
Fifty years of marriage.
Yep.
Over 50 years, they have two daughters, Terry and Beth.
And we'll talk about plenty.
He went to college at Augustana College in Sioux Falls, where he played football.
He went and played football there, but then got his degree, his Bachelor of Arts degree in education, from General Beatles State Teachers College.
No, no.
It's very specific for teaching degrees, apparently, here.
Then he went to San Diego State University outside of Madison.
To receive his—no, I say San Diego.
SDSU, I get it.
South Dakota State.
I looked right at it and said, South Dakota State University.
You know, in Madison, South Dakota, San Diego State University.
San Diego State up there.
God, I'm a dummy.
So he got his master's degree from there, and then he moved back to Madison, where he will coach and teach for 30 years.
Fuck!
He goes back to his hometown and goes back to his old high school, and he's a coach and a teacher.
He teaches English.
He teaches English and language arts.
He coaches track, football, and tennis.
Basking in the glory of 58 for 30 years.
For 30 years.
Well, he loves it.
He wanted to give, I guess, the kids the same experience.
Sure.
That's where he got the nickname Storm and Norman.
Oh, as the coach?
Was a coach, because students remembered him as strict but fair.
Oh, yeah.
You don't fuck with Storm and Norman as far as that.
You're not going to cut up in his class.
You're not going to dick off on the field.
But if you give him effort.
And you do what he asks of you, he'll be very fair, and he treats people.
He treats everybody the same, too, is what they said, too.
He doesn't play favorites and shit like that.
You may got a C on this paper, but if you come to the pep rally and I see your enthusiasm, I'll make it a B.
If you come after class and ask me for a little extra help, I'll hook you up.
That kind of guy.
Yeah.
So one of his students here, who later became a senior advisor to a U.S. senator, he said that he remembered diagramming
sentences in Johnson's class.
He said it was miserable, the work, but he gave Johnson credit for making it more interesting than it had any right to be, he said.
Love it.
He said that, you know, he taught the, quote, the biggies.
He said he taught Mark Twain and Herman Melville, classical authors type shit.
Is Twain big?
Is that a hard one?
Not hard, but it's taught a lot anyway, especially in high school.
It's very, yeah.
That's what I meant.
It's, yeah, I think there's interesting stories.
Then it's decent writing, but it's also funny, too, so I think it helps.
Right.
I think I did, I mean, I'm a terrible reader.
I think I got through Huck Finn.
I think I did.
Yeah.
Well, they probably forced you to in the fifth grade, I would imagine.
What was the fifth grade?
Something like that, sixth grade, seventh grade.
I was thinking I read it in high school.
Maybe it was.
I think I remember it in seventh grade for some reason.
Reading comprehension.
They had me in and told me to read it.
It was definitely seventh grade because it was in New York because there was, like,
there was a lot of black kids in the class, and they were very interested in the language
that was going on in there.
And if I was in Arizona, that certainly wouldn't have been.
It was uncomfortable reading that.
Well, yeah, especially out loud.
Because that's what you have to do is read it out loud.
Very uncomfortable.
So this guy said he was a great guy in the class.
He taught English and language arts, and just everybody respected him at least
if they didn't love him, which most of them did.
But if they didn't, they.
They at least respected him.
He's about six foot tall.
He keeps himself.
He's very well-dressed and groomed and comes to school in a tie or sweaters
and very put together.
None of them doesn't come in in Crocs and sweatpants.
He thinks a teacher should set an example is what he said, which he's very, very.
This is the guy you want to send your kid to school to learn from generally.
Our English class my senior year had a student teacher that came in dressed like us.
He was in draw strength.
baggy pants. I hate that shit.
And then did a poem called
Hibato
and it's like
he's a black guy so it's fine but
the words that he was saying
was saying I guess. Stop trying
to relate to us. Yeah.
You can't. It's in our music
we don't need this word. Teach us that's
all yeah. Very uncomfortable.
So he did other things too
during the summer he would
manage the swimming pool and was
on a painting crew as well to keep him
so he just liked to be busy he said. Wow.
Liked to be busy. He was
a member of the Trinity Lutheran Church
where he served on a
bunch of their boards. He was an usher
and he sang in the choir as well so
whatever he does he's very
immersed in and involved in.
He served on the board
of the Madison Community
Hospital and the Lake County
Red Cross board as well.
So he's a respect those board
members that those are respected people from
the community that you put to
give it an air of respectability.
And there's differences between the trash
collection board and the fucking Red
Cross. Totally. Absolutely.
So he
likes sports. He liked the Green Bay
Packers were his football team and the
Minnesota Twins were his baseball team.
He would take the grandkids
to Twins games. That was a thing that he liked
to do in the summer. And of course he
liked fishing and he liked to play the piano.
So this is the things he does.
A guy named Tim
Osterberg taught and coached with him
for more than 20 years
and he said that he remembered very
clearly about Norm is the teachers
would get up before
the sunrise drive out to Lake
Madison and go fishing before the school
day began. What?
They go fishing before a day of work.
Wow. Is that 4 a.m.
fishing? You gotta yeah you gotta get up
at 4 a.m. and then deal with teenagers
all day. That's a lot.
Smelling like fish. Smelling like fish.
Well luck hopefully you smell like fish if you've
had any luck.
So he said they would
sit in the quiet and as the sun
came up that's when they would stop fishing
when the sun was up. That was it.
And he said the one thing that's one thing
Norm liked was fishing. He
was a great guy. And
they said also Barbara said they
both grew up fishing and both it was
a big family activity. She
said this is Lake County. There was always
lakes near and
she said he was described
Norm as a quiet man who would
definitely spout off when he had something.
to say. That's how she described
him. He's not shy but he's quiet
when he when he needs to be. All right.
Not a big mouth type of guy.
Speaks when he means it. Yep. And he
said he lived in a house with three women his two
daughters and his wife. Yeah. And he
said to live with she said to live with three
women he had to have a sense of humor.
He's got a good laugh.
Yeah. He retired kind of
he retires from teaching
but instead he just
hangs up his chalk
and picks up a fucking pair of cover
alls and becomes the school's custodian
instead. Oh
trade in my chalk for this
broom. And that's what he wanted to do
in retirement sweep instead of
teach. Yep. He
also taught elementary physical
education. So he taught gym classes
too but he retired from his everyday teaching.
He was also the
playground supervisor
after that. He also
was a proofreader
for the Madison Daily Leader which
was the newspaper in town.
Wow. So this guy
loves to do things. He needs to be
stimulated. He needs to be doing activities.
No.
So he also got a job
at Jones Ace Hardware in
downtown Madison.
He doesn't need these jobs by the way.
He has you know retirement
and everything like that. But he liked it. He
worked there from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.
Monday through Friday for about five years.
Four shift. Four hour shift.
That's wild. His
store manager said that almost
every customer who came in knew
his name. Everybody knew Norm. Hey Norm
how you doing? You know he got like the cheers treatment
but reverse. They'd come in and yell
it to him. He would stand
in the aisles and a lot of the people
he had taught at school and things like that
so they'd be catching up with customers
all the time and people would
call him you know Mr. Johnson always
and he'd say no just call me Norm
you don't have to call me Mr. Johnson. All right.
You know I don't want to be stiff like that.
When the economy got bad
in 2007-2008
he
gave up his hours
during that time period so
that younger employees
could have them because they needed the money
more than him. He said well there's people
with families here. I don't know you know I can
do without this job and you should
give them my shifts because they need the money.
That's wow. Yeah.
Actually gives a shit about people.
Weird. So
he said yeah they need it more than I do
and he said he told his manager
I'm just here because I like to get out of the house.
He's like my dad, basically.
- Yeah.
the same thing he has a job like two days a week because he just is bored yeah he tells his manager
as soon as it gets one drop of stress i'm just leaving he goes i won't even say anything i'm
just going home because i don't need anything i'm just here for fun so i asked him this weekend uh
you're still doing that job he goes yep two days a week he just so proud of it he was doing more
and he goes i told him two days is all i got and i'm not staying i'm not staying till five either
i leave at three now he says to deal with the traffic take the the kubota or a bobcat on a
couple of rips he goes i don't even do that anymore sharpen a couple of sharpen a couple
of chainsaws and i go home all right he's having a ball um but he would still come by because
people that was where he hung out kind of and so he would talk to everybody and uh and uh he would
walk up to the register and he'd say this is he would talk to them because they would ask him hey
do you know where this is and shit even when he's not there and he'd say i don't know where this is
he wasn't on the clock so he would do everything and then he'd walk him up to the register and go
this is the only place i can't help you i'm not on the clock so you got to go to the register but
i can show you where shit is um there's another story that the uh his boss his manager at the
ace hardware tells about a local family that lost their home in a fire so norm called them and asked
them to stop by the store when they came in he slipped them a fucking envelope full of money from
his own pocket just heard they had a fire and yeah just said here you go you might need that
like a like a mob boss who's taking care of somebody but he expects nothing from you that's
mob boss at somebody's wedding just a yeah just a benevolent mob boss yeah this is a nice guy so
he's just a good guy and he played the piano he didn't start playing the piano until
later in life he took it up as a hobby because he's bored because he likes to do things um
yeah he's a nice guy another guy a carpenter from around here said that norm checked in on him for
months after norm learned that he had a drinking problem he would check in how you doing are you
okay do you need any you know anybody to talk to things like that he's just a kind man who thinks
of other people and is a a real like example of some people are like they get in people's business
because it's they like to like be in the mix and shit that's not this guy he's just a make sure
everybody's doing okay he likes to do the right thing
it's one of those things where he does the right thing when no one's looking type of deal
even if no one's looking that's a man does it yep so it's very interesting so you he reached out to
troubled people so who the fuck would kill him is a very strange yeah who's feeding him a couple of
45s for no reason makes no sense the pastor at the church described him as a powerful presence
who never needed to be flashy about anything he liked to do things and not seek credit for it he
said he was quiet in nature but he always looked out for the ones in need that's norm so this does
not seem like a guy who needs to be shot twice in the face and in his early 70s in his own doorway
that's a really fucked up thing to do it's fucking disturbing so yeah by january of 2012 norman mar
norman barb had been married for 53 years they have their two daughters who are both married and
moved out and they have four granddaughters and they have four granddaughters and they have four
grandchildren they have their dog you know none of this makes sense and also before this because
this shooting happened uh this is the saturday before the shooting his boss from ace hardware
stopped by for a visit said everything was normal yeah nothing seemed there's nobody you know
stalking him or anything nothing seemed off um now back to the crime scene because we left off
with barbara finding norm here we had to find out who norm was um they call 9-1-1 and obviously and
that's where the police arrive and most of the officers there had been his students they know
these are all madison locals so they're like what the fuck mr johnson what the hell like they're all
they don't understand it at all um now they don't have by the way south dakota doesn't have like an
investigative like a specific agency that handles this uh they have a they don't have a tbi they
have a dci that handles forensics and all that kind of thing for small departments but they're
because yeah south dakota is a lot of small towns that are not set up to process homicides really
sure they're just not um so they have uh you know they everybody gets involved here now the body
of norm he's been shot twice from a very close range which is what they know not good barbara
only heard the shots she didn't see the killing take place and that's probably positive so yeah
they they talked to her all they got was that he was shot and he was shot and he was shot and he was
from her is i looked out i saw a man walking toward a dark sedan parked at the sidewalk and
he didn't look like he was in a hurry right which would be disconcerting if someone just shot
somebody just shot your husband in the face and he you expect at least run away show some respect
for the situation dangerous human being yeah to just walk away is crazy she saw him get in his car
and drive away yeah and she said it was horrible i hope i come out of it this this has been terrible
that's what barbara told the newspaper the next day um now police automatically because this makes
no fucking sense whatsoever right they go canvas the neighborhood they go door to door knocking on
doors did you see anything did you hear anything typical standard stuff and this is pre-ring
doorbell too so you can't really get anybody's footage or anything like that this is just
descriptions they find another neighbor who by the way used to be a madison high school teacher
and coach
oh named orlin larson now shortly after the shooting a man matching barbara's description
of the suspect was seen by somebody else trying to get into orlin larson's home trying to break
into it um and then they when investigators looked around the house to see if they'd broken
any windows or anything like that they found two flashlights outside the house that this
oh shit intruder apparently had left behind um now
larson wasn't there because he had been at the basketball game okay um yeah he'd been at the
basketball game now the description of the assailant is uh a white man between 50 and 60
years old between five foot eight and six foot tall possibly wearing glasses and a ball cap
and believed to be driving a maroon four-door sedan yeah so it sounds like larry david on early
enthusiasm like 2007
2006 larry david i feel like is who's who's the perpetrator here i mean a maroon prius driving
except with the prius yeah yeah so investigators the only real things they have to go on is they
have these tire tracks or they have these flashlights then they find some tire tracks
okay okay they find those they photograph the tire impressions and they find shoe impressions
as well they're going to photograph it's positive so they have that now about a sec about a quarter
mile away from
these two houses that we've found uh there was another sighting of this assailant um at the home
of dick erickson oh what's his name dick erickson is a madison attorney and a city councilman
and a resident reported seeing a man fitting that description with that car by his house too
okay and there was tire tracks there that also match the tire tracks yeah at both other scenes
okay so they have this person now at three different people's houses a teacher a lawyer
and another teacher which is interesting um so the investigators are they don't get it they so
they all they know is a retired teacher's dead another retired teacher's house was approached
and a lawyer's house was watched so and and by the way the uh the other teacher also had been a
madison high school teacher and a lawyer's house was watched so and and by the way the uh the other teacher also had been a madison high
student back in the day and all that and it was about norm's age so they're like they're looking
for all these guys are older the other guy too uh dick erickson the lawyer in his late 60s so these
are all older men from this area that are that have been had this person show up at their house
that's the only pattern they can see of it but at the same time most of the people in this town
went to madison high school or something of that nature so
who knows basically um they're looking and this is by the way the first murder in madison
the ap reports it's the first murder in madison since 1906 wow it's been 106 years since someone's
killed someone in this fucking town on purpose oh my god um and the last murder conviction in
this town came in 1917 so it's been a long time um so there is a neighbor named alan surfling
he'd been out of town in brookings until 9 p.m and he came home to a street full of police which is
very unexpected in this area obviously hasn't happened in 100 years when they they pulled it
last time if you would have pulled up it would have been shit loads of horses out there just
police horses everywhere but so he wasn't even there wasn't even alive no um the officers told
him go in your house and lock your door okay basically load your gun and yeah stay
there and he told the reporters that were there that nothing ever happens on this street this is
crazy yeah it's like the burbs nothing ever happens here
So about 9.30 p.m. at South Dakota State University, there's a basketball game going on there where that was the one teacher was there.
There's an announcement that warns the crowd of a gunman in the Madison area.
Goes out over in the middle of the basketball game.
I'd say you can tell this is not a huge university's basketball program because if this was a Duke game, they wouldn't be announcing shit like that in the middle of the game, I don't think.
Yeah.
But the campus goes into lockdown.
Students in residence halls are told to stay inside and lock their doors.
It's like the whole town goes batshit.
The whole area goes crazy.
Took it serious.
Oh, yeah.
10.43 p.m., the Dakota State sends an emergency email alert to students and staff throughout the alert system.
And it's more than three hours after the shooting.
And the students complained about how slowly the information reached them.
Three hours is pretty terrible.
Yeah.
A student senate held a meeting the next day.
And one of the people, kids, said, definitely looking at how we can improve the students' sense of security.
Then, late night comes around that night.
And the whole town, now this is 2012, so rather than the whole town having to wait until the next morning to go down to the coffee shop and discuss it, they all get on Facebook and go fucking crazy.
It's so fun.
Pile on.
Oh, my God.
Oh, my God.
They're talking.
And it goes from what it was to something way bigger with people, what I heard and this one said.
And then that's a fact.
And these people repeat it.
By the end of this, of the night, there's multiple shooters.
Several people have been shot.
Someone is targeting retired teachers.
Retirees around town start getting phone calls from people going, they're killing all the retirees.
Be careful.
This is what social media has done.
Yeah.
People are loading their guns.
Porch lights are on all night.
Nobody's fucking around anymore.
There's a retired Madison teacher and coach told the newspaper, everybody you ever talked to, everybody was tense.
There were so darn many rumors flying around.
Everybody I talked to had their guns loaded.
It was just bizarre.
He said, Facebook's a good tool.
But in a case like this, there were some pretty wild rumors and accusations out there.
I believe it.
Yeah.
So shortly after midnight, the university president is informed that the shooting was a targeted event, not random and not a campus threat.
This is not going to go to the campus and start indiscriminately firing upon the basketball crowd.
So the next morning at 7.32 a.m., the president of the university tells everybody there's no imminent threat.
Classes will proceed.
At the high school, though, tons of kids stay home.
The high school is half empty.
Nobody goes to school.
They hold their classes under lockdown, too, the whole Madison Central School District, keeping students in the building until the end of the day.
So they do that.
And a 14-year-old who lives about a block from Norm Johnson said people are scared to go to school.
Everybody is.
They're putting them down in the hallways.
Yeah, it's wild.
You should have read Facebook.
It's everywhere.
So the boss at the hardware store said she just saw Norm three days earlier, and she said, I still can't believe it.
It is just unbelievable that this happened in Madison, South Dakota.
Something like this.
That's why we do this show.
Never happens here.
Never happens here.
So the town freaked out for a while, and then when they realized it was a targeted thing, they all tried to help Barbara.
People were coming over without being asked to fucking cut her lawn, shit like that.
Yeah.
Everyone just starts help bringing her food, all of that kind of thing here.
The hardware lady said, the lady who manages the hardware store, said Norm was a mentor to so many people here.
And he said, you know, if he had known about, if this shooter had problems and he knew about them, he would have tried to help him.
He would have tried to fix it for him.
That's the kind of man he was.
That's what makes it so sad.
And the publisher of the Madison Daily Leader.
Who was another former student of Norm's.
Yeah.
Said, this is really a Norman Rockwell town.
You half expect to see kids walking down the street with fishing poles on their shoulders.
Huh.
Very Opie.
So.
Yeah.
But he said, they also said that this night had kind of ruined the town's naivete and, you know.
Kind of ruins Mayberry.
Sheen.
Yeah.
When old Andy's shot in the face.
If when they were walking down to the fishing pole while the whistling was going on in the beginning of that, somebody would have, you know, shot.
The fishing pole at Opie's hand.
It probably would have ruined a lot of things.
Andy be walking down hand on his gun from now on in the opening.
It'd be much different opening.
So that's how it goes.
And they said nervousness stayed around the town for a minute here, too.
Yeah.
So the suspect description goes out that next morning publicly.
The white male, 50 to 60, between five, eight and six feet tall glasses and ball cap, possibly believed to be driving a Maroon.
Four-door sedan officers go door to door on February 1st, asking if anyone saw anything and, you know, nobody really did, except for what we found out the first night that afternoon, the person, the head of the department here, police department tells the press what we have no leads at all.
The town is, you know, on edge and this is not good.
Then later that day, a tip comes in.
A tip comes in.
And we don't know where the tip came from, but I have a pretty good idea where the tip came from.
Tell me later.
I will.
I'll tell you later where I think it came from.
You never know.
A tip comes in and they give a name of a person they think the police should talk to.
And they think they should talk to Carl Erickson.
What's Carl?
Oh, wait.
Carl.
Erickson?
Yeah.
Erickson.
We've had a lot of Erickson's up in this region.
Half the people are named Erickson.
Well, somebody named Erickson.
Erickson was assaulted, weren't they, a minute ago?
No, no, no.
The other guy, Dick Erickson, was the attorney who they said went by his house.
Yeah.
This is Carl Erickson now.
Okay.
He lives in Watertown, which is about an hour away.
Oh.
Okay.
Now, he is born 1938.
He's a year older than Norm.
Carl V. Erickson.
He drove a brown Ford Taurus in the dark.
Okay.
Brown and maroon are pretty close.
He has a beard and gray hair.
But he's 73 years old, not 50 to 60.
So, there's some things there.
A little discrepancy.
But they go to his house.
They knock on the door.
They say, you mind if we look around and talk to you for a minute?
He says, come on in.
No problem.
Sure.
When they do, they see two flashlights that are identical to the ones they seized outside
of that other retired teacher's house.
Like he had a four-pack?
Orlin Larson.
Yeah.
Like he likes a particular type of flashlight.
And they find a Glock.
A Glock handgun.
A.45.
Oh, well, that's not good.
But, I mean, it's South Dakota.
Everybody has guns here.
Literally.
Yeah, but a.45.
Not a lot of people carry that.
Specific.
So, with Carl's permission, they look at his Ford Taurus.
The tire treads appear consistent with the tracks at the two homes that they got.
There are three homes they got tire treads from.
But a Ford Taurus at that time, one of the most common cars there is.
And they all have the same fucking tires on them pretty much.
Yeah.
Who's putting after my car?
They're the market tires for speed or whatever on a Taurus.
I'm going to put some low profiles on this Taurus.
I'm going to go out and get some Yoko Speed tires for my Camry.
Yeah.
And so, but, I mean, that's all they have is he's got a similar car.
He's got a gun like everybody else on earth does.
And he's an older guy.
Who is this guy?
Does he have this some snarling, drooling, you know, bloodthirsty background?
He's a retired federal government insurance officer.
What do they do?
Boring shit.
Sit at a desk and do paperwork that would make me blow my brains out in 15 minutes.
That's what he does.
Under budget is what they do.
And he does it for decades.
Oh, geez.
He came from a very respectable family.
His father is a very successful lawyer in Madison.
And his mother's a librarian.
So, troubled home, obviously.
I found in 1952 he got three Boy Scout awards.
Or three get awards.
I'm sorry.
Carl Erickson received awards here.
Yeah.
He received the Merit Badges in First Aid, Personal Health, Horsemanship, Home Repair, and Marksmanship.
Oh, he's a shooter.
Which come in handy.
So, there's that.
So, we know about that.
Now, his younger brother, Dick Erickson.
Hey, I know that guy.
We know him.
Dick Erickson, who I'm 99% sure is the guy who called the tip in.
Just, you know, opinions only, allegedly.
Sure.
He ends up becoming a lawyer.
He follows his dad.
Yeah.
And becomes a lawyer.
And I found out also, Dick Erickson was a hell of an athlete.
His brother, Dick.
I found an article from 1967 saying that he's an all-state basketball player.
Oh, shit.
And a runner-up for the East South Dakota scoring title.
He signed a letter of intent to go to the University of South Dakota.
Hopes to follow in the footsteps of his father, Leroy, who was there.
who was a three-year regular under that.
dad played basketball too his dad's a lawyer that played basketball and that's what dick follows in
perfectly um apparently they say that dick erickson would like to equal or surpass the record of his
father who played on two consecutive north central conference championship basketball teams uh so
now carl it comes from his dad's a prominent lawyer his mother's a librarian it's a good
family sure what's the deal um remember buzz the lineman from the football team well buzz carl also
went to madison high school at the same time as norton johnson and all these people now buzz said
quote it's just hard to remember carl oh he was a uh wallflower he said he wasn't popular but he
wasn't shunned either i think he really wanted to be an athlete but he wasn't he was the team
manager he was a gopher oh
he was a gopher
he's that guy he's the rodney dangerfield son and back to school and they throw towels at him
yeah that's him um and slingshot their jock in his face so yeah he's not an athlete he is
hauling gear getting water doing things like that um student sports manager water boy whatever so
after graduation carl went to north dakota state university so he wasn't his brother's a big time
athlete going to college to play basketball
his dad's a big time athlete both of them are lawyers and carl is not carl gets a degree from
north dakota state university he moved to wyoming and married a woman named deanna who he's still
married to this very day that they're talking to him um he spent over 25 years as an insurance
officer for the federal government um problem is lately the last 10 years or so he's he's been
cycling through some antidepressants mood stabilizers sleep
medications trying to find what happened i don't know he's kind of sad trying to find the right
things and some people just get depressed as they get older yeah your body it hurts do you think
you know there's a lot of reasons to be the people everyone you know is dead things yeah and sometimes
there's a stretch of two months where you have fucking eight ten people that die that you know
them yeah and you just start thinking of your own mortality it isn't easy to get fuck yeah
oh absolutely man so after retirement they moved to watertown south dakota which is a
which is an hour north of madison they lived in a little one-story house uh carl had a german
shepherd named shep very creative who he loved he also had two horses that he kept in a nearby stable
that he loved um they were his everybody said he was the best not so great with people but
amazing with animals really good horses are everything yep um neighbors describe him as an
odd bird uh yeah he's the old man neighbor who you never know what you're getting out of him
they said sometimes he'd come over and just without asking or without being asked snow blow
your driveway for you yeah but then sometimes he'd give you the finger for no fucking reason
just like you never knew what you were getting out of carl nice yeah he uh he would complain
about the kids the neighborhood kids making too much noise all the time oh no they're kids you
made noise too carl um but then the next day even after he yelled at your kids and told you to keep
an eye on him he would yell at your kids and tell you to keep an eye on them he would yell at your
kids he would show up to jump start your dead car battery or to fucking help you change a tire or
whatever like he's just a weird guy no one can quite get a beat on him here um one thing we
know is he holds grudges oh a neighbor of his said that carl sometimes got overly friendly
enough to creep out this neighbor's wife yeah but the neighbor told his wife not to worry about
her he says he's a harmless old man don't you don't worry about what's he gonna do you know
what i mean then the guy heard another story about carl and said well maybe he is
somebody to a little more less harmless than i thought he said he was talking to him and this
is what this neighbor said when his crows died or his crows when his horses died the the guy
were saying this his last name is crow that's why i said when the crows died when his courses died
he blamed the vets he said quote i ought to take my gun out and go shoot those sons of bitches
both of his horses horses are dead and he blames the doctor yep
and this guy said he was great with animals he just wasn't that good with people
he also has a severe history of anxiety he's got severe recurrent depression
that every medicine he's got doesn't seem to really help it or take to him he has
problems tolerating medicine uh he drinks more than he should as well as he gets older his
brothers told his brother dick told investigators that he suffered from depression and alcoholism
he did not get along with his father and he did not like dick either much like i don't really care
for it myself but he doesn't like his brother dick he doesn't like his brother dick he doesn't
like his brother um big fan to be honest not even my not even mine he said his brother would it was
basically slowly falling apart for the last few decades he's just been coming apart yeah so now
when the police here um he lies to police because they said what about this pistol
is this the did you use this to shoot johnson and he said no no no i did i was in madison
but i didn't stop by and shoot that guy yeah he said that he just went to cabela's
that's all he was doing there's a cabela's in mitchell if you drive through madison so that's
what i was doing going to cabela's and i had my gun with me but i didn't shoot anybody with it
so they say let's go down to the station why don't we you were in a car with your gun with you so
let's check yeah it's it's you you admitted you were in the city this happened in with your gun
with you on the day it matches the description yeah um they say norm johnson and he says i don't
know don't know him he said you didn't go to his house he said not at all and then he said this he
goes i didn't shoot that guy he says quote if i was going to shoot anybody it'd be my brother
oh i'd have shot dick if i was going to shoot somebody i'm not going to shoot some stranger i
don't even know that guy um then he told the cops during the same thing that he might shoot into the
garage housing his brother's sports car to quote leave him something to remember him by
he's going to shoot up his brother's fancy sports car and he's going to shoot up his brother's
sports car that'll learn him think about me wow uh now dick is the only possible link between
carl and norm johnson dick erickson dick is the bridge here um he's carl's youngest our younger
brother and he's like i said a lawyer and a popular attorney and an athlete and all that
he served on the city council and sat on the madison community hospital board same as norm
johnson does yeah so they were colleagues and you know that type of
deal um everybody knew him everybody knew them everybody knew each other there um now in recent
years dick tells the police that his older brother carl has been threatening to kill him
on a semi-regular basis oh so he says it wouldn't surprise me for carl to kill somebody since he's
been shooting he's been he hates me me yeah says he's gonna do it he said the last time we talked
was about six months ago and he said that dick said he brought up norm johnson's name in conversation
well before the murder six months before the murder and carl said this this is from the
affidavit quote dick said that he brought up the name norm johnson sometime back and carl
was still upset with him and called norm johnson a son of a bitch oh so carl does know norm johnson
he's very well aware and we know he knows him because he was the fucking team manager on all
the teams carl norm johnson was the star right okay now uh in the interrogation room
his wife deanna comes in to see him carl's wife he told his wife that the police department uh
wanted to force the police to kill him and that or no he want i'm sorry he wanted to force the
police to kill him it's like i'm gonna force suicide by cop he said and if i can't get them
to do it i'll hang myself in jail so either way i'm not long for this world so okay that's what's
going to happen all right so now we're going to go to the interrogation room and we're going to
talk about what's going to happen in the interrogation room we're going to talk about
what's going to happen in the interrogation room we're going to talk about what's going to happen
in the interrogation room we're going to talk about what's going to happen in the interrogation room
uberti firearm and several 45 caliber shell casings they have loaded weapons already in
the house and they have a guy with a lot of guns at this point so they arrest him for first degree
murder um that's what they do uh while he's being booked there's a group at the church
coming together to do like a little memorial for norm not a funeral but uh
yeah just to talk about it because everybody's in shock so they just gather up and they're
to be around each other essentially here um the pastor says that norm was so committed to the
church and community that many children would have gone hungry without him sure so february 2nd this
all becomes public now it's a big deal now it's a big deal and people are like what the fuck and
they're trying to put together the dots why did he do this why did he do this um and they piece
together what happened carl got into his brown ford taurus and watertown on tuesday january 31st
he brought his glock he had three full magazines with him we find out 54 rounds in all my man is not
playing um he brings at least two that's how many bullets he had with him he brings yeah 18 h mag
yep he brings at least two flashlights and drives south to madison okay um now the high school
basketball team has a home game so half the town is watching that and the streets are basically
empty it's a tuesday night in january
in January in a small town in South Dakota.
Among the people at the game, Orlin Larson, the retired teacher and neighbor, and Dick Erickson is also there.
Oh, he's there too?
The brother, yeah.
Now, before the shootings, residents would report, or the shooting, the residents would report a man moving around Madison neighborhoods with a flashlight peering into homes, knocking on doors.
He did this to multiple houses.
Wow.
He has like a list of people he's going down.
Fuck.
Problem is, Dick isn't home, his brother's one of them, the other teacher isn't home, so he went and knocked on their doors.
They're not home.
The only guy who answered his door is fucking Norm.
Oh, Norm.
Because everybody else is at the fucking basketball game.
Norm's just working all of his shifts today.
That's it.
So, like we said, similar treads with the Ford Taurus there.
Yeah.
And just after 7.30, he went up to the door, asked for Norm Johnson, shoots him in the face, walks back to the car.
Yeah.
And fucking drives away.
Now, at his bond hearing, he says nothing.
His attorney asked that the bond be set at $100,000.
He describes his client as a family man.
He's been married for 45 years.
He just retired from an insurance job with the federal government.
This is not a guy who's going to run to Mexico and, you know, live the life of fucking Sammy Hagar.
Like, he's, you know what I'm saying?
Like, that's not what's going on here at all.
The judge says, no, he's a potential fraud.
He's a potential flight risk and a potential suicide risk.
We're holding him without bond.
Okay.
Now, February 2012 is the funeral, and it's 600 people come to the funeral.
And it's a big deal.
Oh, that's amazing.
It's a huge turnout, man.
Every pew is full.
I mean, they have a whole thing here.
And his coworkers are all there.
Even the teenagers come from the teenage employees at Ace Hardware come wearing their red work aprons.
Oh.
And to show solidarity, they gave his family Norm's apron with his name tag still on it that he left at work.
Oh, fuck.
They present it to him like a flag to a veteran family or something.
It's all folded into a triangle.
Yeah, they folded up nice Norm on top there.
Ace in a diagonal.
There was still a tape measure in one pocket and his hand cream in the other.
So it was hanging on his hook.
They just gave it right to the family there.
Don't give me that.
I don't want his fucking hand cream.
That's going to make me cry forever.
Oh, well, yeah.
I guess you're ready at the funeral.
So let's load it all up at once.
Yeah.
They're already crying.
Dick is also there.
Dick is there as well.
And so is, well, apparently after the death here, what ends up happening is that the Johnson family invites Dick Erickson to dinner.
Oh.
They invite him to dinner, the brother.
And they said they wanted to.
They want him to know that they're not holding this against him.
They're still friends with him, which is these people are incredible people.
What a beautiful family they are.
Also, we want to remind you that we're aware that you were almost a victim, too.
That, too.
Norm's daughter.
Yeah, exactly.
He was after him, too.
Norm and Barbara's daughter, Beth, said Dick is going through a terrible time.
My mother was there.
We wanted him to know that we never had any hard feelings.
We didn't hold a grudge.
He needed to see that we were still friends.
So they talked about everything but murder.
But Norm being murdered.
Um, he ends up pleading not guilty.
Okay?
Is that right?
Um, yeah.
The possible death sentence if they choose to pursue it, which I think would be pretty
pointless for a 70-something-year-old guy.
By the time you even got around to it, I think Mother Nature would do the trick for you.
So.
Likely.
Then at pretrial motions, they announce a plea agreement.
He will plead guilty but mentally ill to second-degree murder.
Oh, boy.
Now, the big question that is one of the things that is, they, he has to say.
In order for this deal to be a thing is, why the fuck did you do this?
Why?
What's your deal, man?
What's the point?
And then we get here, maybe the pettiest, shittiest, most stupid fucking thing in the world here.
Okay.
He's held a grudge.
He says that back at Madison High School.
Oh, my God.
In the fucking 1950s.
While he was the team's student manager, somebody put a jockstrap on his head in the locker room.
He literally, okay.
You said, shot a jockstrap at you.
I was like, oop, ignore that.
He literally, they did that.
And he's like, I'll get you for this.
In 60 years, I'll come to your house and shoot you.
What the fuck?
This is fucking insane, dude.
This is insane.
That's, who the, do you remember, do you give a shit?
I don't care.
No, no.
Who cares?
Who gives a shit?
Wow, that's pathetic.
What did the other two do?
One is, I think, was also an athlete.
And this is why this story doesn't really hold water, because there's also no witnesses.
Nobody else remembers this.
This is just his saying.
And I think the daughters of Norm's daughters, I think, have a better idea of what the motive was here.
All right.
And this is the state's attorney said, he said that a jockstrap was put on his head.
It's the only thing he ever mentioned in talking to law enforcement of why.
That's the only thing he would say.
They put a jockstrap on my head.
And one of the, the same guy said, I know of no one that remembers it or acknowledges it other than Carl.
So.
Norm's daughter bets is bullshit.
And she said, first of all, if he ended up with a jockstrap on his head, which I'm not even saying he was, it was probably just goofing off in the locker room.
It's the 1950s for Christ's sake.
Who cares?
Oh, my God.
It's dicking off.
It's just, that's what kids did.
That was going on in the 90s.
So think about what could have possibly been happening in the 80s.
And I mean, you had gotten, yeah, you'd gotten raped and they'd think it was funny.
Me and my friends have done a hundred thousand times more horrible shit than this to each other and hung out and loved each other right afterwards.
So gas masking him is not that big of a deal.
No.
She said that Carl has been jealous of her father.
That's why he did this.
And that's why he wanted to kill his brother.
And that's why he wanted to kill another teacher.
His brother is an attorney and was a star athlete.
And he was.
And he wasn't.
So he's settling scores.
That's what this is.
He's 70 and regretful of what his life has become.
Even jealous that he dated a cheerleader and married her.
The hot chick.
Yep, the hot chick.
So the daughter said, yeah, this is total bullshit.
Absolute bullshit.
It's horse shit.
And the guy didn't even have a terrible life.
He had a decent life and he had his own marriage and career.
Yeah, it was fine.
A little boring.
Whatever.
He's not that great of a guy.
That's it.
He's just not talented.
He's not.
Some people get more gifts.
He's from whatever.
Nature, God, whatever the fuck you want to call it.
Some people get more natural gifts than others.
That's it.
Maybe he's a little bit upset that Norm also not is just talented and great at everything.
Everybody likes him because he's a nice guy, too.
Exactly.
He would probably be an arrogant fucking prick if he had the talent that Norm has.
That's the problem.
He doesn't have the same personality as Norm.
And the media, by the way, Beth is really pissed off the daughter because she said there's a national news cycle that turned her dead father now into a high school bully.
Because that's all the headlines are man kills high school bully.
So you read that and you almost think, well, yeah, you picked on him for that long.
But it's not even that.
It's some in, you know, no one can put a finger on where or when this even happened or if it even happened.
And if so, gives a shit.
It's so stupid.
The thing is, too, there's there's many more nerds and bullied than there are bullies.
So when when when there's a story of a bully who gets everybody so happy, there was a goddamn fucked up.
There was a TV show.
Where they get professional fighters to beat up a 16 year old, which I'm like, that proves a lot.
That just makes me want to fucking stab the fighter.
Well, now I'll fuck you up.
How about that?
You're you're beating him up for picking on him.
Now I want to pick on you.
That's what I want to do.
Everybody just wants fucking revenge on the bully.
It's like, I don't know, live a better life than them.
That's great revenge.
That's which he didn't.
I think is that's the problem.
He's in his 70s and his time is running out.
Beth said people are putting so much.
Guidance into the words of a mentally ill man.
And so my father has become a bully in the eyes of the nation.
It's hurtful.
It angers me and conveniently, dad isn't here to defend himself.
Another a writer from Madison, who's one of Norm Johnson's former English students, Corey Allen Heidelberger.
He publishes a column in South Dakota magazine about prison crowding.
And he notes that Erickson and Johnson had lived more than twice, lived more than twice as much life since high school as they lived before.
And he said, after all that time to let an adolescent grudge drive you to murder.
Well, you'd have to be nuts and basically says that, you know, he's probably crazy.
Is this the guy you want in prison?
Basically, now, the prosecutor called it beyond senseless.
The defense attorney says he's crazy.
He has a psychiatrist that said he has severe and recurrent depression that for the most part is treatment resistance.
And he says his thinking was irrational and his judgment was impaired.
So he pleads.
Sounds like a very fucking dangerous person.
Sounds like it.
So he pleads not guilty, but mentally ill, which basically means he'll go to prison, but they'll give him someone to talk to mental hospital.
Yeah, that's it.
So during sentencing here, this is when it's revealed of about the jockstrap thing.
That's when it's revealed here.
And Norm's daughters come up and give victim impact statements and said one said, you know, Father's Day coming up.
And my dad would have been.
I'm looking forward to fried chicken, potato salad and rhubarb pie.
But now he's gone.
And.
She said, I'm speaking to you, Carl.
We miss my dad very much.
She was like, look at me.
Look at me, Carl.
Look at me, Carl.
So then Beth comes in, the younger daughter, and she's a substitute teacher at this point in time, by the way.
And she said the locker room story was just goofing off.
And she said that more than 600 people came to my father's funeral, including members of your own family.
And she said, you know, that's how good he was.
What do you have to say for yourself?
Look how many people are here to support you.
And she said, that night you shot him, his dog did not want to leave his side.
Your life has been filled with anger, jealousy, and the need for revenge.
I truly pity your wife and family because you've been such a coward, but I can't blame you for being jealous of dad.
In high school, he was popular.
He was athletic.
He dated mom.
They had 52 wonderful years together and two daughters that adored him, four grandchildren that worshipped their grandfather.
He was just jealous of dad's whole life.
Carl speaks.
And he said, I shot him, your honor.
I guess it was from something that happened over 50 years ago.
It was apparently in my subconscious.
I just wish I could turn the calendar back.
I didn't plan it.
That's crazy.
Well, the judge says, you, sir, may fuck off life without the possibility of parole, which.
Yeah, because you're so dangerous.
Either way, you're not getting out here.
Yeah.
Even if they said, maybe in 20 we let you out.
What, when you're 93?
So great.
When you've got even more shit to sell.
Yep.
And he ordered restitution of $6,320.10 to the family, which sounds like funeral costs.
Funeral costs.
There as well.
And he'll receive future psychiatric examination and could be treated in prison, whatever.
So it's a lot here.
And they keep going on.
And Beth is very upset that the narrative turned into her father's a bully who finally got his and all this.
It's pretty fucking interesting.
A lot of people here.
There's a lot of comments from local people on his like obituaries and stuff and people saying they loved him.
One person said, I was less than enthused to see my English teacher was Storm and Norman.
He remembered me all too well from swimming pool.
So he knew that I'd be I knew that there'd be no slacking in his class, although it was hard for me to realize that at the time over the years, his strictness is exactly what I needed.
At that time in my life and goes on to say that he helped make him a better man and all this.
Right.
Some people are just idiots.
Someone said, someone said, I guess we wouldn't be reading about a guy who went to someone's house to put underwear on the homeowner's head.
Did he even really go to school with the guy?
And someone says, it's easily verifiable that they both went to the same school.
You friggin moron.
And they start arguing.
It's hilarious.
And then one person just has the worst wording of all time for an old teacher.
Um, Mr.
John, Mr.
Johnson touched so many of us as her opening.
Oh, my God.
Not what you want to put in there.
I hope not.
Then she goes on to say, you know, everything from school.
I love him.
He's a wonderful person.
But don't say he touched so many of us.
Touched our lives would be fine.
But don't say it like that, please.
He touched so many.
That's so bad.
Carl is in South Dakota State Penitentiary at the moment and will remain there until he dies, which hopefully will be soon.
SDSP.
He's in his 80s.
Yep.
So there you go, everybody.
That is South Dakota.
Hope you enjoyed that shit.
How crazy is that?
Well, you can't.
I mean, I get, like I said, Jody Herring, you called and got my kids taken away.
I'm going to come over and kill you.
That's right.
Do you snap that?
This is 55 fucking years later.
This is insanity.
I don't think it's that.
I think he was just incredibly jealous of so many people.
Yeah, I think he was going to kill whoever he was ready to exact revenge on everybody.
If there was no basketball.
Game that night.
I figured there'd be three, four people dead.
That's what I probably.
So anyway, there you go.
If you like that story or any other story, get on whatever app you're listening to.
Give us five stars.
It helps so much.
Double thumbs up on Netflix would be incredibly helpful if you could do that.
Thank you.
Head over to shut up and give me murder dot com right now.
New tour dates coming out extremely soon.
Very soon.
And then they'll go on sale in early December.
This year's tour is over.
Thank you, everybody.
So much for coming.
Definitely follow on social.
Media at crime or not crime and sports at small town murder on Instagram.
Small town pot on Facebook.
Get yourself.
Patreon.
That's where it comes from.
Patreon dot com slash crime in sports is where you get all the bonus material.
Oh, there's so much of it.
Anybody.
Five dollars a month or above.
You get everything we put out all the time.
You get almost 400 back bonus episodes as soon as you subscribe.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Get those new ones every other week.
One crime in sports.
One small town murder this week.
Crime in sports.
The whole Mike Vrabel and Diana Rossini.
That's her name.
That whole scandal of a coach.
It's a wild.
It's crazy, too.
There's so many great coincidences.
Oh, my God.
Then for small town murder, we're going to talk about the clown panic of the mid 2010s.
They're tremendous.
Clowns were jumping out.
There's a documentary on it now.
And you'll hear my full hatred of clowns.
It'll be a lot of fun.
So unbridled hatred of clowns.
So check that out.
Patreon dot com slash crime.
In sports.
P.A.T.
R.E.O.N.
By the way, dot com slash crime in sports.
Just like the name of the other show there.
Right.
And in addition to that, you also get all the shows we put out ad free.
And on top of that, you get a shout out at the end of the regular show.
So keep coming back and seeing us.
Listen to the other shows.
Tell your friends.
Do all that shit and keep coming and seeing us.
And until next week, everybody.
It's been our pleasure.
Forget high school.
Bye.
Bye.
Bye.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
A shocking murder occurred in Madison, South Dakota, in 2012, when 73-year-old Norm Johnson was shot twice in the face by a stranger at his doorstep.
Norm was a beloved, respected community figure—former teacher, coach, and mentor—known for his kindness, integrity, and deep ties to local institutions.
The suspect description matches a retired man, Carl Erickson, a neighbor with a history of depression, anxiety, and grudges, who had a prior history of conflicts with his brother Dick Erickson.
A tip from Dick Erickson led investigators to Carl, who was found with matching flashlights, a .45 handgun, and tire tracks consistent with the crime scene.
Carl admitted he knew Norm and expressed a desire to harm his brother Dick, but claimed to have no intent to kill Norm, though he stated he might have shot into his brother’s garage as a “memory” of him.
The shooting triggered a full town panic, with residents locking down, sharing rumors online, and fearing a wave of targeted violence against retirees.
The case remains unresolved, with no clear motive or direct evidence linking Carl to the murder, though psychological and familial tensions suggest a possible motive.
The incident exposed the vulnerability of small towns to fear and misinformation, especially in the age of social media, and shattered the town’s long-held sense of safety.
Summary:
A shocking and deeply disturbing murder took place in Madison, South Dakota, on January 31, 2012, when 73-year-old Norm Johnson, a beloved local teacher, coach, and community pillar, was fatally shot twice in the face by an unknown man at his doorstep. The victim, known for his kindness, integrity, and decades of service to the town, had a close-knit network of friends, students, and neighbors. The suspect, described as a white man aged 50–60, was later linked to Carl Erickson, a retired insurance officer with a history of depression, anxiety, and a strained relationship with his younger brother Dick Erickson.
Carl had previously expressed hostility toward Dick, calling Norm Johnson a “son of a bitch” and claiming he would have killed his brother had the opportunity. 45 handgun consistent with the crime scene. The shooting sparked a widespread panic in the town, which had not seen a murder in over a century—leading to a full lockdown at South Dakota State University, social media-driven rumors, and a wave of fear among retirees.
Despite extensive investigation, no definitive evidence tied Carl to the crime, and the case remains unsolved. The tragedy not only revealed deep personal tensions within families but also highlighted the fragility of small-town safety in the face of fear and misinformation. The case stands as a stark reminder of how personal grievances can spiral into violence, and how communities respond to crises with both fear and solidarity.
FAQs
The case involves the 2012 murder of Norm Johnson, a retired teacher and coach, who was shot twice in the face at his home on Northwest 5th Street by a stranger in a dark sedan.
Norm Johnson was a retired teacher and coach from Madison, South Dakota, known for being a popular high school athlete and a respected community figure. He was married to Barbara for 53 years and had two daughters and four granddaughters.
The shooting occurred just after 7:30 p.m. on January 31, 2012, when a man approached Johnson’s home, asked if he was Norm Johnson, and then fired two shots from a close range into his face with a .45 caliber handgun.
Carl Erickson, a retired federal insurance officer and neighbor, is the prime suspect. He had a similar car, matching tire tracks, and flashlights found at two other locations. He also had a .45 handgun and a history of depression, anxiety, and grudges against his brother Dick.
The town was shocked and panicked, with residents reporting increased fear, social media spreading rumors, and many locking doors and loading guns. The incident is noted as the first murder in Madison since 1906.
Social media amplified the panic, with residents sharing rumors and accusations about a targeted attack on retirees. This led to widespread fear, with people staying home from school and taking precautions for days.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.