The episode of *The Class of 1989* examines how the landmark films of 1989—such as *Do the Right Thing*, *Glory*, and *Driving Miss Daisy*—sparked a transformative era in Black cinema but fell short in representing Black women with depth, agency, or authenticity. While celebrated for their cultural significance, these films often reduced Black women to stereotypical or passive roles, reflecting deep-seated patriarchal and misogynistic biases in filmmaking. The discussion highlights the experiences of Black women in these productions, such as Rosie Perez’s emotional distress during a scene in *Do the Right Thing*, which underscores the power dynamics and lack of consent in creative processes. It also celebrates the emergence of Black women directors like Zane Palsy and Julie Dash, who broke barriers by creating films centered on Black women’s lives—Palsy with *A Dry White Season* and Dash with *Daughters of the Dust*. Despite the progress, the episode argues that Black women were systematically excluded from the mainstream narrative in 1989, leading to the development of independent, woman-centered filmmaking in the 1990s. The takeaway is that while the year marked a turning point for Black film, true inclusion and representation required not just recognition but structural change—ensuring that Black women had equal access, voice, and creative control in cinema.
Hi, it's Ray. We're still a little ways away from the next season of Going Wild, which I can't wait to share with you. But today, I wanted to introduce an episode of a great new podcast called The Class of 1989, produced by our friends at the podglomerate and hosted by Black Film Scholars, Len Webb, and Vincent Williams. Each episode, Len and Vincent take us through the Black Film Renaissance of 1989, a year of contradiction, controversy, and ultimate triumph for Black Cinema, as they analyze six films that left an indelible mark on the world. It's a smart, funny, and surprising series for anyone interested in Black Cinema and Culture. And I'm particularly excited to share this episode where Len and Vincent talk about the representation of Black women in the films of 1989, and how Black women directors would help transform the film world throughout the 1990s and into the present. If you like what you hear, make sure to follow the Class of 1989, wherever you find podcasts. Would that said, let's get this episode started. I'm Vincent Williams, I'm Len Webb, and we are your host of the Michelle Mission, two men, one podcast every Black film ever made. This is our podcast documentary, The Class of 1989. 1989 was an important year in film when Hollywood would change forever thanks to six films about race. Some are obvious, like Do the Right Thing, Harlem Nights, and Glory. A few might surprise you, like a dry white season, lean on me, and driving Miss Daisy. Join us as we explore what happened, and what changed because of the Class of 1989. Ladies and gentlemen, it is high privilege and honor to officially introduce for the first time graduating class. There's only one boss in this place, and that's me. The H.N.I.C., much a matter of what happened. I'm a blow you think you're too many. I would never start with the individual artist. It's definitely symptomatic of our culture. You know, we live in a patriarchal, misogynistic society. Mejorie Holmes is founder of the Black Star Film Festival. Women are overlooked and under, you know, resourced always, definitely 30 years ago. And so, artists, unless they work really hard, are going to make work that is reflective of the culture in which they exist. She is generous about how these six films represent Black women. I am not shocked even looking backwards to, you know, see that this is the case. And I think, you know, unless they were pressed, it occurred to me because our dear Bill Hooks passed that her work kind of first came to prominence as I was graduating high school. The late Bill Hooks was an author, a scholar, and social activist best known for her writings on race, feminism, and class. She examined the intersectionality of race, capitalism, gender, and what she described as their ability to produce and perpetuate systems of oppression and class domination. In the first of her many works, An Eye of Woman, Black Women and Feminism from 1981, Hooks wrote, "Racism has always been a divisive force, separating Black men and white men, and sexism has been a force that unites the two groups." That means all the filmmakers you've just named, they didn't read Bill Hooks. They didn't have an opportunity to, like, interrogate their gaze and think about how they were making work. And I imagine that many of them, I know Spike has definitely tried to change the way that they make work. And so, the project of Blackness in America has often come down to is, you know, sexism more important than racism, more important than classes. You know what I mean? It's like we have to think about all these things. It's never that simple. But I imagine those artists made those films at that time. They were things that they wanted to explore. They are not great in their inclusion or representation of women. But I would say the problem is not that their films aren't great about representing women. The problem is that more women didn't have the same opportunities that those men had to make more inclusive stories. But I would also love for there to be a wider field. Inclusive. That's what it all comes down to, isn't it? It's really challenging because, you know, I love Harlem Nights. I love Do The Right Thing. I don't like to think about films that have white directors, but glory was a great film. I also really enjoyed driving Miss Daisy. I just want to make more space for more voices because say there is a filmmaker that is more sensitive than if they also have the opportunity to make work. Then maybe we can support them instead of the one who's sexist. Like, I think policing people's practices is problematic because then you're asking people to be inauthentic and you're asking people to speak to something that they maybe aren't thinking about. That doesn't mean they can't be called out. It doesn't mean that we shouldn't wish that they had a broader palette. But I'm not really interested in like looking back at this work and saying, like, why wasn't mother-sister a bigger character? That's not what I want to do. You could call that generous or some people might also call it a political on my part. I don't think so, but you know. I mean sure we want people to be authentic, but sometimes authentic can go left and be abrasive. Let's hear from Elizabeth Wellington who covers the arts and culture beat for the Philadelphia Enquirer and who minces no words about one of our more celebrated directors. I'm not the Spike Lee fan. Like, I like Spike Lee, but there's always something in a Spike Lee movie that makes me cringe. And usually it's his relationship and his depiction of women. Like, I'm like, Spike, get over it. I always leave a Spike Lee movie feeling like, let down. Like, really, this is what you think of a Spike? Really? Well, what's specifically about due to right thing where you cringing over? When you're gonna come on, you see Rosie Perez dancing, right? Like, that's a big dance scene. And you're just like, what is she doing? Like, is this new? It felt like in living color. Like, it was just that from that time and that era where she does the dancing. And I think she's so stereotypical. They make her like a stereotypical Puerto Rican. And I don't even see the point. Like, I think we're all in Spike Lee's jacked up imagination. And I don't want to be there. Spike Lee's women never have agency. They're always at the mercy of Spike Lee's massacistic male characters or go through their all stuff and can never see what they're doing to their women until it's too late. Or they have no choice. That's just me looking through my 2021 lenses. And I like Rosie Perez, but I was so irritated by her because her act that was too obvious how she didn't need it to be. So what he's saying about race relations is right, but it's coming from such a filtered. The filter is so doesn't agree with me. Yeah, we'd like to give Spike the benefit of the doubt. He was a very young man when he made do the right thing. And it's a powerful, important film. But as a more mature man, his lens in 1989 was questionable. Here's a 2022 interview with Rosie Perez done by Terry Gross of PBS's fresh air that underlines how intention and practice might not job. I mean, in fairness to Spike, I did agree to the nudity he had to ask permission. My father couldn't make it to New York and I was like, thank God, because I didn't want to tell him. But my brother-in-law, my sister's then-husband, said, I'll talk to him and I'm going, oh my gosh, and my brother-in-law covers this old, very scary guy. And he sat down and Spike had to ask him and we negotiated the nudity. There was supposed to be more nudity. And we negotiated down to what you saw on screen. But at the time when it was done in the middle of it, I was fine with all the other body parts. And when it came to my breast, I just felt exploited. And I had thoughts of my father swirling around in my head and I just started crying. And Ernest Dickerson's yelled cut and Spike was very angry. Ernest Dickerson was a cinematographer when do the right thing. A long time collaborator of Lee's. This was their third film together after she's got to have it in school days. Dickerson was arguably Lee's most trusted colleague. And Ernest Dickerson was like, God bless him because he was- he said, he goes, stop, this is enough Spike. We got it, this isn't right. And I got up and Ruth Carter put a rope around me and she gave me the biggest hug. And Spike was so confused, he goes, but you knew what I was doing. You agreed to it. And I said, yeah, but it was just too much.
It was just too much, I remember saying that to him, and it was upsetting, and the thing is, is that we didn't have a big fight over it. We had a conversation, I'd give him that credit, and he said, "I'm sorry, I didn't realize and I said, 'It's okay,' and we finished the day." While Wood made it to film, definitely resonated with a lot of people. It scarred Perezabit. The violation she felt over the scene was a violation of herself by herself. In a June 2000 feature in the New York Times, read by Marisol Rios, she explains herself loathing at the time, and how it was swept away by her very next project. It wasn't really about taking off my clothes, but I also didn't feel good about it because the atmosphere wasn't correct, and when Spike Lee poods ice cubes on my nipples, the reason you don't see my head is that I'm crying. I was like, "Don't want to do this," and the reason why I cried was not so much because I felt violated, as because I was angry at myself, because I wanted to say, "Say something, get up!" So that's how I felt violated. I felt like I violated myself. But then I went and took my clothes off again for white men can't jump. But that was because it was totally my decision. I felt totally comfortable, and the director was so cool, and Woody Harrelson was like, "Well, whatever you want is cool with me, so there I feel empowered by it." But we do the right thing, it was like, "Now I'm the object. Here's the shot." In many ways, Rosie Perez's character is the object, the shot. There's no more agency to Tina than to mother sister, the ever-present sage who lives on her windowsill played by Ruby D, graceful as ever, but essentially the watcher, observe, do not interfere. Nevertheless, Perez is still beholden to Lee for the career that his film gave to her. Again, from fresh air. I am forever grateful, and Spike and I, people always think like, "Why are you disrespecting Spike? I'm not disrespecting Spike Lee. I'm telling you the truth of what had happened, and things can happen, and you don't need to cancel him. He and I worked it out, and he apologized. We hugged it out, and we're still friends to this day." Bobby Booker of WRTI Temple Radio believes that, "Do the right thing, does the right thing overall?" I was even recently in a coffee shop down like 16th in Jackson, still very, very, very Italian, and this place makes great coffee, and I'm looking around, and they've got like a wall of fame. It's nothing but white men. I tell you, man, Primarilyn, and I said, "Not even for no black folk, I'm like, "Well, what about women? Let's just at least get in there, a little bit on a gender equity tip." And that was this year, okay? So for "Do the right thing," though, all of that felt real because it was the experience that I was living. And there's some other things that I've really dug about then, that movie too, and we talk about gender parity. I've really, I dug Rosie, she was a formidable presence, and I'd taken no BS from Mookie, whose pigeon-toed, I love these, pigeon-toed walk adapters, I loved it. Things were people in my neighborhood too, you know, the fire hydra, everything, everything about that, but also just enjoyed that these were real people having real lives. Folks have a lot to say about "Do the right thing" from this year. What's that saying? Great art evokes a response. But what about the other films? Well, some of the other films literally make women all but vanish from the story. You're talking about glory. And the case of the missing brothers. Which I investigate along with co-producer Mo Poplar. We are here with Carla Brothers, an actor, a working actor, which is always our favorite type of actor. So Carla, what was your experience like even though the footage unfortunately may have been kind, but what was your experience working on the set of glory? Oh, my God, it was amazing. I love period pieces, you know, and that was exceptional. Can you tell us more about the role of Charlotte Fourteen as scripted? In real life, she was an acquaintance, but the lead actor, I mean the lead character there who was played Robert Gould Shaw, who was played by Matthew Broderick. She was an educator, an abolitionist, and you know, for people that don't know what abolition is to a wallish slavery, you know. So she had a pretty amazing life, she was from a black woman, right? Of course. Well, that's right. Because when we say abolitionist, we could be talking about people who theoretically think slavery is, you know, probably an immoral thing, and then we could be talking about people who have skin in the game. Right, right. Well, yeah, she was. She was a little darker than me. And yeah, she was a black woman and, you know, was very her family. And she were very much against slavery and did everything they could to fight for the end of slavery and also to, you know, be educators and personally take a part in doing something about people that were disenfranchised. Now, in terms of the felt, she was still an educator. The scenes that I did were a couple scenes they were having, if there was a love, sort of the love they met at a ball. And there was, the sparks were flying and, you know, they had a lovely conversation and there was this beautiful scene that was shot at, like, I shot it, like a four in the morning, the sunrise and, oh, my God, it was so romantic and stuff. You know, it's really about, it's a courtship. And I think, you know, as I said, when the script was very much, when she, he talks about why I'm sure things must be difficult for you, where even he who's very empathetic as a white man at that time, really doesn't understand, you know, she has to kind of catch him, you know, in a very nice, big and put him in his place, like, there was so much certain things because, you know, you have a limited understanding. My part was, I kind of, all the scenes were all together and it was like, you know, he took like a weekend off and we spent every day together doing stuff, you know, like, you know, he married her, he was, she was a small-term girlfriend or something like that. But, and I think he was probably in there, her character was in there to show even though he is a white man, really, you know, he was the, the, the, the, the Colonel, so to speak of this all, like, you know, they put them in front of everybody else, you know, but they were these heroes, these unsung heroes that, you know, fought for the callers and died. I mean, they literally went, they knew they were marching towards their death and he went right along with them. So he was obvious in a pretty exceptional white man at that time, but even her character showing them that you're making assumptions about, don't assume, you know, my life. Because that didn't happen historically, right? No, it didn't. They were never involved romantically, it also, I chalked it up at that time to the fact that a love interest is much more interesting, you know, because it's, people want to see love and with all this fighting and killing, but they just want to have some tenderness and all of that. That's why I'm thinking the part was in there. Charlotte Porton was not by Rachel, so to speak, but she was like, I'm collected with a curly, you know, hair, et cetera, et cetera. So obviously she was mixed with something, and, you know, I don't, you know, I don't even think that thinking would that far, I think they thought it was a good thing, you know, like we are perspective now. Over 30 years later is where much more savvy about all that, but at that time, it was like, you know, I think it was like, oh, wow, this is, this is pretty amazing because it just was a lot of, you know, even though it was a black cast, it's, you know, think of it as being a black movie, do you? In Lena Me, they literally make a fictional woman the main antagonist for Joe Clark, because systemic racism wasn't enough. You need a black woman to put her finger on the scales. What happened this morning is an outrage, my boy is no criminal. He and those children belong in school, not back out on the street. Our kids don't deserve this, some of those children are smart, they're just discouraged about what chances they got out there. They're kind of jobs, they got waiting for them. Now what kind of chance do they have? He insulted the black football coach. Problem nights can't really call its depiction of black women progressive. The female leads Delarice and Jasmine Guy, where they're anger in different ways, but it's still the summation of their characters. So that's what this is about, he's supposed to kill me.
"I'm sorry, right now, it's the only business." "This is part of it." That role actually to me was kind of non-jazz my guy, because I think that might be the only time I've ever seen her not be like be a bad guy. Like I just felt like it was a Robin Givens role. Not a jasmine guy role, but then again they wanted her to be Crayole. I didn't think her performance was bad. I, or good, I just thought it was. It wasn't a performance that she would have normally done, and I haven't seen her do anything like that since then. What do you think about the roles of the women in general in the film? Well, it did unnerve me when any more clunched Ella Reese in the face, because there's something about men fighting women, like they would fight a man that I find disturbing in any period. No matter how bad she is, she's still like an older lady. And then he pulled out a gun and then he shot her toe off. I didn't really love that. It would have been interesting if they had like a beautiful woman gangster. Not like Ella Reese was in charge of the holes, you know, that 'cause that's her term. I was in charge of the holes, and I don't feel and stuff like that. I think the movie was teaming with male showin'ism, but how much of that was true to the era? And how much of that was what was going on in the '80s, '80s and early '90s anyway? That was when you say true to the era that you mean the era in which the film is set, the '20s, or were you speaking specifically of the late '80s and '90s? I think it was true to both. I think the machismo in the '20s had a different feel from the machismo of the '80s and '90s, just because I think the machismo in the '80s was stiffed in pop culture and loose lick. I don't know if they would have loosely used the word, the B word, as much in the '20s, if they would have in the '90s. My '90s ear was used to that kind of discussion, but I don't know how accurate that was in the '20s, but I think there were definitely women gangsters in the '20s who weren't necessarily running the whole house. Women who were running numbers in Harlem, the women back then were bootlegging, and they weren't necessarily being harassed like Delarice all the time. So, I think the machismo was definitely '90s kind of focus, but a throwback. So you know, we're dancing around the elephant in the room. You've got something to say about the feminist icon that won Jessica Tandy and Academy Award for Best Actress, the sign of womanhood, Miss Daisy. We'll speak more about that in another episode. There's another elephant in here. Well, we've talked about women as drawn by male directors, Black and White, but we have a Black Woman director in Yuzane Palsy, who released her first studio film in 1989, A Dry White Season. This film doesn't have a lot to say about women, Black or White. The film critic Tim Cockshell puts it into context. A Dry White Season is an interesting film in that Zane Palsy is the director. And she's doing a whole bunch of firsts here too. She drug Marlon Brando out of retirement for this movie. She's the first Black Woman director to direct an actor, Marlon, to an Academy Award nomination, and to make a film mostly actually set in South Africa. She was engaged in a whole lot of firsts, and that has to be wrecked, not. You know, and we see what happens to these African people, these Black South Africans. So, particularly at the beginning of the movie. When they're all attacked at that school, when they go to the little demonstration, they're shot in the back and everything. And we see them suffer all these brutalities. And we see them in the docket and court. And there are a few interesting characters. Essentially, we're watching what we're watching is the transformation and the plight of some white folks who are coming to understand where they live and how they're living and what's happening to these Black folks. And to that extent, a Dry White Season is a film to talk about. Who's in policy, very important, but it's still a film about how white people feel. And it doesn't just focus its lens on white people. As Meori Holmes notes, it's primarily white men. I have friends who have been in these rooms, right, where they're trying to get a script made, and they're told by a network executive. You need to add white people to the script, right? So that may have happened to her for all we know. She might have gone in there wanting to tell a story in Mandela or somebody else. And they may have said, we can't do that. But if you make it about this Africana, then we can get your story told, right? I mean, the same is Glory. You're talking about the regiment and it's focused on the white boy, right? But that's the way the story gets made. And it's interesting when you say the word market, because we very much assume that that's what the market wants. But we know it's not what the market wants. It's what the executives are comfortable with. And then that becomes what the market has access to. And those are two very different things. - And I understand completely that as a first, first, first, first, first black woman, first this, first that, first you would the student, all of that, she was in a box like no other box. You know, they had her jammed up. You know, let you make this movie system. But we're going to let you make this movie system. You know, so don't get, you know, that ends still. A movie full of good intentions, but still a movie about, you know, Donald Sutherland and Susan Streow, all of it is still a movie about that. So, you know, appreciate it. But no, it does not live alongside do the right thing and Harlem nights for me. So, we can clearly see that 1989 was a watershed moment for a black film, but maybe not for black women in film. I don't know. We're clear that two years later, Melvin Van Peeble's son, Mario Van Peebles, will come out with New Jack City, a decidedly black film with a decidedly black perspective. But let's not forget that in the same year, Julie Dash brings us Daughters of the Dust, a much greater work of art, coming right out of the LA Rebellion film movement. Yuzane Palsy is the first black woman to direct a studio film. Julie Dash is the first black woman director to have her film receive a wide theatrical release, or the film made for less than a million dollars, all about black women. We also get just another girl on the IRT in 1992, criminally underrated, waiting to exhale in 1995. The Watermelon Woman in 1996, Eves Bayou in 1997. And Wuppie Goldberg submits her place as a movie star for the ages in Ghosts and Sister Act 1 and 2. And we see a lot more of the amazing Alfred Woodard in films such as Crooklyn and Down in the Delta. So maybe black women saw lean on me, do the right thing, and Harlem Knights, the same way as black people in general, saw driving Miss Daisy and glory. They saw something missing. In 1989, they weren't invited to the party. So they started their own. That's it for this episode of the class of 1989. Tune in next week for Spike and Eddie, Brooklyn, B Brooklyn. The class of 1989 is produced by Lin Webb, Vincent Williams and Mo Poplar, written by Lin Webb, Vincent Williams, and Maurice Poplar, editing by Lin Webb, mixing mastering by Chris Pinello, production help from Jordan Aaron, marketing by Joni Deutsch, Matt Keeley, and Anna Belapina, music by Alexa Gold, art by Tom Grillo, special thanks to Dan Christel, executive produced by Jeff Umbro and the Pod Glomerate. All right, ladies and gentlemen, until next time, he's Vince, I'm Lin, and in parting, we say, we'll see you when it's time to meet again. Thanks.
again to our friends at the Podglomerate for sharing this episode with us. If you liked what you heard here today, make sure to subscribe to the Class of 1989 wherever you get your podcasts. And tell 'em I sent you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The year 1989 marked a pivotal moment in Black cinema with six influential films that challenged racial dynamics, yet largely missed opportunities to represent Black women authentically.
Films like *Do the Right Thing*, *Glory*, and *Driving Miss Daisy* were celebrated but often portrayed women in stereotypical, passive, or objectified roles, reflecting patriarchal and misogynistic biases.
Black women filmmakers like Zane Palsy and Julie Dash emerged in 1989, with Palsy directing the first studio film by a Black woman and Dash making a groundbreaking, woman-centered film with *Daughters of the Dust*.
Critics and artists point out that the lack of Black female representation in these films stems not from poor artistry, but from systemic exclusion and the dominance of male directors and narratives.
Rosie Perez’s experience on *Do the Right Thing* highlights the emotional and psychological violation she felt, revealing how power imbalances and lack of agency in film production can deeply impact performers.
The absence of Black women in key roles—like in *Glory*’s romantic subplot or *Lean on Me*’s narrative—demonstrates a broader pattern of erasure and underrepresentation in mainstream Black cinema.
The episode emphasizes that while 1989 was a turning point for Black film, Black women were excluded from the narrative and creative process, leading to the rise of independent, self-directed movements in the 1990s.
The conversation calls for more inclusive storytelling, not just criticism, advocating for opportunities and agency for Black women in film to ensure authentic and empowering representation.
Summary:
The episode of *The Class of 1989* examines how the landmark films of 1989—such as *Do the Right Thing*, *Glory*, and *Driving Miss Daisy*—sparked a transformative era in Black cinema but fell short in representing Black women with depth, agency, or authenticity. While celebrated for their cultural significance, these films often reduced Black women to stereotypical or passive roles, reflecting deep-seated patriarchal and misogynistic biases in filmmaking. The discussion highlights the experiences of Black women in these productions, such as Rosie Perez’s emotional distress during a scene in *Do the Right Thing*, which underscores the power dynamics and lack of consent in creative processes.
It also celebrates the emergence of Black women directors like Zane Palsy and Julie Dash, who broke barriers by creating films centered on Black women’s lives—Palsy with *A Dry White Season* and Dash with *Daughters of the Dust*. Despite the progress, the episode argues that Black women were systematically excluded from the mainstream narrative in 1989, leading to the development of independent, woman-centered filmmaking in the 1990s. The takeaway is that while the year marked a turning point for Black film, true inclusion and representation required not just recognition but structural change—ensuring that Black women had equal access, voice, and creative control in cinema.
FAQs
The Class of 1989 explores the Black Film Renaissance of 1989, analyzing six films that shaped Black cinema. It examines how race, gender, and power intersected in filmmaking during that pivotal year.
1989 marked a turning point when several influential films about race were released, challenging Hollywood narratives and sparking important conversations about representation, especially for Black women.
Many films of the era portrayed Black women in stereotypical or passive roles, reflecting patriarchal and misogynistic biases. Critics note that these depictions often overlooked women's agency and experiences, especially in male-dominated filmmaking.
Critics, including Rosie Perez, pointed to excessive and exploitative scenes, such as the dance and nudity involving Perez, which they felt violated her autonomy and agency, highlighting problematic power dynamics in the film.
Black women directors like Julie Dash, Zane Pally, and others created groundbreaking films—such as Daughters of the Dust—that centered Black women’s lives and experiences, offering counter-narratives to mainstream representations.
These films often centered white male protagonists or minimized Black women’s roles, reflecting a broader industry trend of sidelining women and focusing on male-led narratives, even when addressing race.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.