The transcript examines a growing national security crisis centered on the illegal transfer of advanced U.S. chips to China, driven by a conspiracy among top figures including Donald Trump, Howard Lutnick, and Jensen Huang. Rather than being a mere sex scandal, the core issue is a willful, self-serving disregard for national security in exchange for personal profit and political advantage. The Trump administration downplayed intelligence warnings, and its actions—including promoting ties with China and Putin—raise serious concerns about its commitment to U.S. values and democracy. The upcoming trilateral summit with Trump, Xi, and Putin is portrayed as a dangerous display of alliance with authoritarian regimes, particularly given their support for Iran and targeting of U.S. military forces. Meanwhile, Congress is urged to act decisively, reclaiming its constitutional powers to oversee, regulate, and enforce accountability, especially in areas like immigration and foreign policy. The narrative also highlights troubling human rights abuses, such as a seven-year-old child’s message to Trump from a detention camp, and critiques the political hypocrisy of figures like Marco Rubio who dismiss international law. Ultimately, the piece calls for a resolute, principled Democratic response—one rooted in accountability, transparency, and the defense of American democracy against authoritarianism. The underlying message is that national security and democratic integrity are at stake, and institutional oversight must be strengthened to prevent further damage.
Twas the night before Toyotathon and all through the land, not a creature was stirring, not even Jan, that's me.
Winter plans were made, skiing, skating, hiking, and more, and they came to fruition with Tundras, Camrys, BZs, and RAV4s.
In bed, dreaming of the places they'd gone, everyone knew Toyotathon is on.
Dealer inventory may vary. Current offers on these vehicles end November 30th.
Offers are subject to change throughout Toyotathon, which ends on January 4th.
See your participating Toyota dealer for details.
Toyota, let's go places.
Hello and welcome to the Bulwark Daily. I'm your host, Tim Miller.
It is Monday, so of course we are back with editor-at-large Bill Kristol. Hey, Bill.
Hey, Tim. How are you?
I'm doing well. I've been running all around the country.
I was in Denver for What's Next last week. It was a great conference.
Lauren Egan wrote about it in our newsletter. I was home for my friend's 40th.
I'm in Nashville now. I'm going to do a little Tennessee work.
I saw Orville Peck last night. People who are listening on the audio might hear him as one of our outro songs.
It's been a whirlwind.
I'm not paying attention to football, so don't tell me what happened in football because I don't know.
That's just fake. That's just fake. You're not paying attention after that Texas LSU game Saturday night?
You were paying attention.
Texas played LSU Saturday night? I don't remember that.
Okay, let's move on. You have been cooking.
We're going to talk about the China chip conspiracy.
There's so many angles to what's been happening with Jensen Wong and NVIDIA.
I think that maybe some people are following every little bit.
For some people, it might be kind of hard to untangle what is the central part of the controversy and the conspiracy that's relevant to politics,
not just relevant to his sexual lifestyle choices.
Bill, why don't you just kind of take it from the broadest area, and then I want to talk about a couple.
Yeah, okay. I mean, I have been slightly obsessed with this, because I do think I had the instinct from the beginning this would be a very big story,
which I think it is, and a genuinely important one, and that it wasn't just a sex story.
It's not even mostly a sex story. That's kind of the MacGuffin, to use that Hitchcock term.
It's what got us into the thing, but it's not the actual—it got the action going, so to speak, but it's not the actual heart of the story.
It's not even a counterintelligence story.
That was the next shoot or drop, right, that Rubio had sent Trump a memo, and Trump had ignored it, which is pretty shocking.
Yeah.
It's the willfulness, the purposefulness that's really key.
Jensen Huang and Donald Trump and Howard Lutnick and Elon Musk, for that matter, they are all on board for the same agenda,
which is making money for themselves, being totally reckless and careless about U.S. national security and U.S. national interests,
as opposed to their personal interests, and in fact, being perfectly willing to help China, basically, when you get right down to it.
And I think that's the core of the scandal and the degree to which they have pursued this pretty relentlessly for a couple of years.
And pretty shamelessly and unapologetically, Trump is bringing Howard Lutnick on his trip to China this week and is defending Jensen Huang.
You know, it's—that's the real scandal, right?
It's not—the honeypot thing is a little misleading.
Jensen Huang doesn't—I don't think was, you know, seduced or blackmailed into doing something he didn't want to do.
Did you ever watch The Americans, Bill?
You know, I never did.
Oh, you have to watch The Americans.
Well, it's a Russian couple that are embedded in America, and they do honeypot.
And are, you know, even though they're married and have children and seem like a normal family, like, they are okay with each other getting involved in that.
And I—that was the one part of the story I was hoping it was true.
I was hoping it was the Chinese-Americans, because Alice Wong's husband had introduced them.
And so I was—I was like, maybe this is—maybe this is just like The Americans, where he's sending her in and he wants her to sleep with him.
I think it's true in the sense that that may well have happened.
Well, certainly something happened, and that maybe the husband had something to do with that.
That part of it closely, really.
But the core of it is the willingness of them all to do this, that they weren't—I mean, in a way, the honeypot thesis depends on someone being seduced against his own, you know, interests or sort of almost against his will or being blackmailed then to do something or whatever.
And in this case, they were all happy to be doing what they're doing.
And that, for me, is—that's why it is truly a scandal more—a conspiracy more than just a scandal, if you want to think of it that way.
Yeah, and it was kind of a happy ending for them, so to speak.
But, you know, the point that you're making, I think the core point is what relates to kind of China and the national security element of this, right?
They are selling these chips that we had controls on for a reason, because they're highly advanced.
There's a lot of risks.
We could talk about that.
Well, A, they all talk about how we're trying to compete with China and beat China in the AI race.
And then, simultaneously, they're using loopholes and carve-outs and subterfuge to, like, get our most advanced chips to China.
Obviously, this is—
That's what Jensen wanted, because it's good for his company.
It's good for his mission.
Trump, I think, as you said, wants it, because he likes chairmanship.
He doesn't care about China.
That's all—that's all fake.
What he does care about is the U.S. economy.
He thinks it's good for, you know, that NVIDIA is juicing it.
There's stuff in this for him and his family as well.
Lutnick and his kids, same deal, right?
And so—and part of it is personal and flattery.
Like, Trump—like, Jensen flatters Trump, and he likes him personally.
That is the conspiracy, right, that is at the center of all this.
And you had Julia Curley on YouTube yesterday.
What was kind of her view on this from that, from the national security vantage point?
No, very much that.
Julia served in the CIA and at the NSC as an intelligence person, really understands this stuff.
She walked very interestingly through the kind of counterintelligence side of it.
But her core view is this wasn't a counterintelligence failure.
The intelligence community wrote a report.
Rubio actually—Rubio's staff assembled it, and they sent it around.
Explaining what was happening.
And Howard Lutnick watered what was happening to be happening.
And it turns out Trump watered what was happening to be happening.
And Jensen Huang watered what was happening to be happening.
So I don't think it's too strong to say it this way.
Selling out U.S. national interests, U.S. national security interests for both personal gain
and maybe because they kind of like Xi and they didn't think there's any problem there.
A couple of other subplots I just want to mention.
Trump personally sold NVIDIA stock before this crash.
And obviously—
For people who haven't been paying attention, the NVIDIA stock price has been tanking
after Jensen gets pushed out of the company.
But the stock sell-off started to happen before the news came out.
And there could be a lot of reasons for that.
It's just something to look at.
And I think it's certainly interesting that Donald Trump sold a million dollars worth of NVIDIA stock
while he's publicly out there pumping the company when they all knew that this was coming privately.
And then maybe there's some other—
There's some other people that are also involved in that kind of sell-off as well
because it's certainly raising some eyebrows when you're seeing this all happen.
When, as the reports show, the Rubio and the counterintelligence memo was going around, what, in May?
So plenty of people knew this was coming for months.
And so there might be another corruption angle, I think, to this as well.
And also a distortion of the U.S. economy angle.
As you say, they were interested in keeping the stock market up.
But, God, this is—
This is beyond my expertise, to say the least.
But it seems like one reason the stock started to go down is people started to look more closely at the books
and think it's kind of a—it's, you know, artificially inflated worth of all these companies.
They're selling to each other, financing each other.
There's a little bit of a circular kind of thing going on here.
And there could be—I mean, AI is real.
And obviously what these companies produce in some respects is real.
But we could be looking at something—yeah, a bit of a stock market manipulation, a narrow sense.
Trump and the Latinx buying and selling, but also a broader kind of bubble that's been created in AI world
and in the export of these chips, in the world of the export of these chips.
So it's a national security problem.
It could also end up having real effects on the U.S. market and ultimately on the U.S. economy.
The administration is now discussing closing this loophole that they created through the Commerce Department.
So that will be kind of interesting to monitor what they actually do versus, you know, what the statements from—
officials on background to reporters say that they're going to do.
This is relevant as we look ahead to this week where Trump, Xi, and Putin are set to meet in Shenzhen.
This was an AIPAC meeting that was also happening.
And now the three leaders are going to have a side meeting.
It will be the first ever trilateral summit of the three countries' leaders.
In the preview of these stories, I got a few laughs about things that won't be discussed.
The AP says that—the Trump administration says—
they have no plans to discuss Ukraine.
So Trump said he's going to end the Ukraine war in one day.
And now, two years later, he has a summit with Putin.
The war is still going on, and he's not even going to bring it up to him.
Like, say, hey, buddy, maybe knock it off.
No, that's not going to come up.
Semaphore reports that they also have no plans to discuss NVIDIA.
Senior U.S. official told reporters NVIDIA should not have any bearing on the trip.
These are national security matters that we developed in the administration interagency process,
and we don't expect it to figure at all.
In any of our conversations with the Chinese while we're there.
So, not going to bring up that the Chinese were illegally buying these chips.
So, anyway, take all of that anywhere you wish.
A lot to unpack.
Yeah, why discuss national security when you're meeting with Xi and Putin, you know?
I mean, they've got so many more important things to discuss.
Possible hotel deals in Moscow.
Possible kickbacks to the Trump family from Chinese-associated companies.
The Board of Peace.
The Board of Peace has a lot of stuff that they're working on.
They've used the UAE.
I mean, one thing you mentioned the
The loopholes are so massive in this.
It's like beyond, obviously, Jensen Huang and NVIDIA, the UAE stuff that you've talked a lot, we've spoken a lot about it.
You've been very much on top of going back, what, a year and a half.
All the ways in which the Trump administration has undercut our national security and pretending to be tough on China is soft on China.
They don't even pretend to be tough on Putin.
They're just pro-Putin, basically.
I mean, it's really appalling.
We're going to see a summit with two dictators, one of them ruthless internally, not particularly aggressive so far externally, but certainly our chief adversary.
Everyone says that.
And the other brutal dictator who's invaded his neighbor.
And Trump, cozying up to the two of them, sucking up to the two of them, being buddy-buddy.
Wishing he could be a dictator, but getting schlong to the midterms.
And wishing that he, unfortunately, lives in a country where we still have real elections, thank God, and are able to enforce them despite the wishes of Trump.
And he got clobbered a couple of weeks ago.
Yeah.
You know, a couple of weeks ago.
It's unbelievable that was just two weeks ago.
Someone said to me, that was a good show last week.
I enjoyed this.
Some of my friends said I enjoyed the show last week where Tim gave you credit for guessing right about the elections.
And I said, well, that must have been several weeks ago.
You know, I can't even believe that it's less than two weeks since the election.
Look at everything that's happened.
What are the next two years going to be like?
But anyway, the Trump meeting is kind of stomach-churning.
Hopefully, no great damage is done.
But even so, what is the world?
What do our actual Democratic allies think when they see this?
I mean, this is what Trump cares the most about, being buddy-buddy with Xi Jinping and Putin.
It's stomach-churning and appalling.
It's also humiliating.
And I think that it's important to really focus on this.
In addition to the things that we have been talking about, China and Russia have been helping Iran in the war that we started.
And they've been helping Iran with targeting.
The impact of their help probably has led to. Obviously, it's led to the damage of our military installations in the Middle East.
And the idea that Trump would go. This isn't to say, oh, you can never have a summit with somebody that you're an adversary with.
But the idea that we're going and the top of the agenda isn't America cannot accept working with a country that is actively targeting our troops.
Yeah.
And the Middle East.
It's crazy.
It's hard to imagine the flip version of this where it would be a Democratic president and how Fox would be handling this.
The idea that Trump will go try to cozy up to these two guys.
Forget all the atrocities they're doing internally in their countries and in Ukraine in the case of Russia.
But the fact that they're targeting our men and women in uniform.
And Trump's not going to bring it up.
It doesn't seem like it.
Maybe we'll see on Thursday.
But if there was a polymarket account on this, I'd put heavy.
On the side that Trump doesn't bring up the fact that Russia and China are helping Iran and targeting our troops.
And it's like, whatever.
Trump's just going to go there and be like, let's. He's like, we're going to discuss a nuclear.
He wants some nonsense deal that makes it seem like he did something historic.
And then you hear the Russians are talking about this.
The Russians are fucking giddy.
If you look at the statements coming out from the Russian side, they're acting like this is Yalta.
What's happening this week, right?
This is a huge elevation of their standing in the world.
Why should a petro state with a collapsing economy even be considered for a trilateral agreement like this?
Might as well be China and us and India.
So this is a huge elevation of Russia.
And yeah, I mean, they know that Trump isn't going to push them around on Ukraine and are happy to get the standing in the world and make it seem like they're big players and dealmakers.
Yeah, and let's not forget, I mean, Putin was ostracized around the world correctly after this brutal invasion of Ukraine.
And who's brought him back onto the stage?
Trump over a year ago, right?
When he rolled out the red carpet, literally, for him in Alaska.
And all of our allies were appalled.
And now he's got. He's perfectly happy to have Putin elevated, as you just said, to this tripartite meeting where they're sort of pretending to do Yalta and divide up the world again.
Like, it didn't work out so great.
I mean, maybe it was. Maybe there was. Not much choice at the time.
But anyway, totally a choice here not to do this, right?
I mean, this is totally. I mean, Trump's the one who seems to be the main mover.
I guess Putin must be the main mover.
But Trump is certainly the fellow mover of this.
Xi is like, well, I'm the host.
I guess I can't say no to the meeting.
I don't think that he particularly likes elevating Putin either.
You know, he's got. Of course, though, they have helped Putin in some ways in Ukraine.
And it's terrible.
I mean, Joe Biden, if I can bring him up.
Probably shouldn't since he's. I could do without his book that he's putting out now.
But anyway. Oh, my God.
I know.
Let's not even get into that.
But anyway, he. I will say one sentence of. Joe Biden went out of his way as a kind of old guy to go to Ukraine, right?
When I came, it was at the end of one of his Europe trips,
a kind of secret trip to Ukraine, right?
And because he wanted to show solidarity with the people of Ukraine.
And to his credit.
And he didn't do everything he should have done for Zelensky,
but he did a heck of a lot, you know?
And here's. And Trump is going out of his way to show solidarity with Putin.
We just shouldn't lose sight of this basic moral difference
between Biden and Trump and between. People who care about freedom and democracy
and people being slaughtered
and people who instinctively side with the dictators
who have brutally invaded a neighboring country.
Totally agree.
That was a great move by Joe Biden.
I think not reading his book is also a great move for you.
It sounds that way.
Have you looked at it?
I can't.
I just can't.
Okay, I want to move on.
You all have been hearing about the travails of the felines in my house.
For the past couple of years now.
You know, we have Slinky now that I'm feeding.
We had Neighborhood Cat, Aretha.
I've been using those to fight off requests for a dog,
for a canine in my home.
You know, just not my cup of tea.
That's not for everybody, right?
But many of you guys have dogs.
Many of you are dog people.
I hear from you.
And our sponsor, Unconditional,
I know is something that you're going to want to turn to.
And I know that and I can vouch for it.
Because for this ad's endorsement,
we've turned to producer Ansley and her dog, Bodo,
who has a very sensitive tummy.
Bodo's got a sensitive tummy.
And he needs food that is healthy, that is good for him.
It makes the fur shine.
You know, whatever you're looking for in your dog food.
Unconditional makes premium air-dried dog food priced for everyday feeding.
They use real meat, dried slowly at low heat so the nutrients stay in.
Unconditional owns its own factory.
So every bag is made in Fresno, California.
Shout out Fresno.
By a team that has been perfecting their craft for over 20 years.
No middleman means better control over quality and a price more families can afford.
Unconditional's 100% air-dried recipes start at just 40 bucks.
No subscription is required, so you can buy it when you need it.
If you do subscribe, you can pause, skip, or cancel any time.
Give your dog the unconditional love they deserve.
Head to unconditionalpetfood.com slash bulwark to get 20% off your first purchase.
That's code bulwark for 20% off your first purchase.
You can also find them on shelves at your local Petco, PetSmart, and Pet Supplies Plus.
I want to talk about Marco.
He had a speech at the Federalist Society National Lawyers Convention in D.C. over the weekend
where he was talking about how international law doesn't apply to us, obviously.
I mean, he's overseeing the murder of fishermen in the Caribbean
and doesn't seem to give a shit about human rights or any of our animals.
Like traditional arrangements with democratic allies.
So the way that he explained, though, his contempt for international law
was pretty noteworthy, and I want to play it.
If they're foolish enough to try to enforce their paper decrees on Americans,
our answer will probably be the same as the Roman general Pompey
when he said to those who were trying to invoke their city's charters against his legions,
he said, stop quoting laws to men with swords.
Not politically correct to say that, but that's what he said.
That's what he said.
Not that funny for me.
Disgusting.
Unbelievable to say it to the Federalist Society, an organization that claims to be deeply committed to what?
The rule of law.
That's the whole point of the, you know, they're a bunch of lawyers, literally lawyers.
You could tell the first time he said it, there are enough people in that room, maybe,
who still have some vague memory of what they're supposed to believe
and not just be Trump administration acolytes and job seekers.
That they were kind of, you know, a little uncertain, I thought, the reaction to Rubio.
Maybe even you can't tell how much applause that was, even when he sort of repeated it or elaborated.
But no, it's beyond disgusting to say that.
And what does it even mean?
I mean, well, what it means, I guess, is it just makes right, right?
Rubio is the kind of polite version of Stephen Miller,
or the version of Stephen Miller who reads stuff that's written for him
by some creepy Miller-like speechwriter who finds some Pompey quote that, you know,
they think it's cool to quote Rome, you know,
when the point of the quote is exactly the opposite of what America stands for, you know?
Yeah.
He has a little Cheshire cat grin after he says it, like, oh, I'm a troublemaker now.
It's just like, it's so unserious.
I don't know, Mona Charan had a great column this week I'd recommend people read
where she writes, never Rubio.
And I thought it was powerful coming from her in particular,
because a lot of people would think or wrongly think or accuse, like, Mona or some others,
being like, ready to, now we've won the midterms, ready to go back to Rubio.
And it was just amazing.
And accounting of the degree to which Rubio has debased himself,
but also is fully on. on board, as you say, with the Stephen Miller vision for the Republican Party in the country.
And Jonathan Swan said this when he was on this podcast, that they're the closest allies in the
administration. And Rubio's reputation is only different just because, you know, he's a little
bit more jocular in how he just talks about it. And 12 years ago, had or claimed to have a whole
different set of views. Right. Your newsletter this morning, I want to talk about a little bit
because you discussed the summit, which we've already covered, but then also what the role of
Congress is and what oversight is going to look like. And there's a bunch of elements of that I
want to get into. But I just want to start by letting you cook again on on the Democratic
Congress getting getting their backbone stiffened. Yeah, just that we have a very rough two years
ahead and Congress needs to do everything it can to halt the damage and even get us going a little
bit on the right course. And that means, obviously, the oversight accountability stuff that
everyone's talked about. But also, it means actually doing things, exercising the power.
They have a lot of power, Congress, power of the purse, power of passing laws, power of
trying to make sure laws are enforced and followed. Obviously, removing official impeaching
officials, removing officials, limiting their ability, clawing money back from one place and
sending it to another zillion things. And they really need to have that attitude, not just of
we're going to bring things to light. We're going to have oversight, which is important, but real
I mean, acting, not just viewing or publicizing. And I think they can stop. I look into this a
little bit. Last few days, I just started asking people who've worked on what has Congress does a
lot, right? They pass legislation. They'll have comfortable majorities in both houses. Some
Republicans will vote for some of this legislation. Trump may veto it. Let's see if he if they can't
override it. Let's at least make clear that Congress is really trying to stop the damage
that Trump is doing and even going in a different direction. And final point, I'd say is,
and Congress needs to make clear, I think now to foreign leaders, for example, Trump can go say all
these things and suck up to Putin and Xi, but he doesn't speak for America. Congress also speaks
for America. Congress also acts for America. And they shouldn't expect that Congress is going to
roll over and have a little hearing in three months about what, you know, Lutnick did and so
forth. Congress is actually going to pass sanctions legislation and override Trump's veto if necessary.
And if they don't enforce it, impeach people. And really, you know, I think that has to be the
case. Congress needs to be billeted, I would say, over these next two years.
I mean, you just kind of listed out the Article 1, Section 8 duties in the newsletter, which is,
okay, you know, you can chuckle. But I think it's probably worth a reread. We have a whole new
congressional group. We have 260 now Democrats coming in in the House. Do you think all of them
have read what Article 1, Section 8 in the past couple years? Probably not. So I think it is
worthwhile for everyone to see like the extent of what the constitutional powers of Congress
should be. And I think that to me, the overarching point you're trying to make that I think is
compelling and important is like Congress has given away its power little by little going back
to before Trump. We were writing about this during the Obama administration and the Bush
administration, certainly. So I mean, at least throughout the entire century, basically,
Congress was giving away powers. And so the right thing to do is to not like just try to claw them
a little bit at a time, right? It is to remember, you know, what the congressional role was and looked
like in the 20th century and use that as a guide for kind of throwing around your weight and using
power over the next two years. And also to understand that this is a crisis. And so
there were times when giving away some of those powers or yielding them or let's say renting them,
you might say to the executive branch, made a certain amount of sense. Congress isn't going to
rule on, isn't going to pass every tariff measure. And so when presidents were basically following the
outlines of what Congress watered on trade, they let presidents make adjustments and set the actual
precise numbers and have some exceptions for national security. If some stuff's getting
exported, it shouldn't be. Some of that stuff was a reasonable way of Congress to handle
the complexities of the modern world. So they don't have to apologize for everything they've
done for the last century, though they should apologize for some things, obviously, but in
terms of yielding power. But this is not a normal president. What JVL likes to say, you know,
we forget how much of our system operated on the honor system. And that was true of some of the
Congress's yielding to the president. Some of it wasn't unreasonable. Congress has the power to
approve promotions in the military. It didn't really get involved and it shouldn't have probably
in promotion boards as long as the military is doing it in a professional and nonpartisan way
under the supervision of a serious secretary of defense and an honorable commander in chief.
But if that's not happening, Congress has to step in. So yeah, they have to really, I agree, step in
now, take back the power, exercise the power, exercise the power, powers that they have. They
have to think about power. They have to think about power, not just about oversight, I guess is the way I put it.
Aura Frames reminds us that everyday moments make life amazing. They offer a daily dose of joy
through these little moments. It's kind of joy microdoses when you have an Aura Frame. And I was
in Sarah's office the other day, and she's got an Aura Frame up that's just kind of office highlights,
you know, things that have happened with the bulwark. And it's kind of fun. You see a little
change since taking over the Daily Podcast, which is kind of a microdose of something other than joy.
But it's pleasant, you know. So you get the Aura Frame, you can send it to grandma or an aunt and
update them with baby photos. That's a useful purpose of it. You can send it to a buddy and
update with a bunch of old college photos you've got sitting around that you have no good use for,
and they can put that in their office or in their home. The Aura Frame is versatile. Life is full of
moments, and the Aura Frames make it easy to relive them all. Aura is the number one digital
frame loved by millions of families, and their Black Friday Cyber Monday deal is the best of the
year. For a limited time, visit auraframes.com and get up to 50 bucks off select frames plus an
additional five bucks off your order with promo code the bulwark. That's auraframes.com promo code
the bulwark. Support the show by mentioning us at checkout terms and conditions apply.
Which takes us to the
question of who the Democratic leaders should be in the House and the Senate. I haven't become a
chucklehead. You know, I don't have a Chuck and Hakeem tattoo on me or anything like that. But
is that the nature and the size and the scope of the wins that the right approach, it seemed to me,
the prudent approach would be, okay, let's get in there. And they have these two huge majorities,
they're going to be really smart and good and powerful people running these committees now.
And like, let's just kind of press forward on all these
obligations that you just laid out for the Congress has because it's a big job, like rather
than get into a food fight inside the caucus immediately. I've had like, just maybe the
slightest rethinking of it as the as things have played out. I basically agree with that still.
And I also am kind of annoyed with the troublemakers online that are like doing bad faith attacks at
Hakeem and Chuck immediately. Like for example, around the Hegseth impeachment, like for Hegseth
to be impeached during the lame duck, which I'm not even sure was a good outcome. By the way, I think
it might have been better to to do this impeachment when the Democrats are in charge. But if you
thought it was a good outcome, like you needed Republicans to do it. And it was annoying that
11 Democrats didn't show up or whatever. But Republicans held the vote at a time when they
knew that they they controlled the floor still like they're still in charge. They held the vote
at a time when they knew they had the votes to defeat it. And there were no Republicans that
flipped, right? It's not as if, you know, the Massey had done something wrong. It's not as if
they'd recruited four other Republicans and Hakeem had the votes and he screwed up. Like that's not
what happened, right? And so there's a lot of I just think kind of hair on fire criticism of them.
It is inaccurate. That said, you know, having been at this conference, and Lauren and Brendan
wrote about this for us, you can read about it at thebork.com. But they're just people are ready
for a fresh face, you know, and people are ready to move on. I just I'm not that sure. I think that
it's an open question. I don't think it's an open question. Whether Chris Van Hollen would be particularly good at this job. Like, to be honest, like, I think
maybe he could, maybe he wouldn't be. I just I don't think anybody really knows. But like that
said, if there was a way to kind of turn the page that does not result in just a total derailing of
all the Democrats duties, I'm like, slightly more open to at least hearing the case than I was last
week, just because I think that the stakes are high. You know, you do want to have the best
possible team for going forward. And if it's worth kind of kicking the tires on that a little bit,
I'm not quite as hostile to it as I was last week. I guess that's where I'm at. I don't know. What
about you? No, I've been sort of ambivalent for the same reasons. Fresh faces make sense. On the
other hand, you know, which faces and Chris Van Hollen isn't exactly like, hey, let's go to the
next generation. Chris Van Hollen has only been in Congress for 24 years, as opposed to Chuck
Schumer. And I think that the notion that Chris Van Hollen is in like a different wing of the party
than Chuck Schumer also isn't really true. I mean, Chris Hollen has been correct on the Iran war,
where Chuck, I think was way too accommodating to Trump at the beginning of that. And so if you if
you want to make this that case, like in this instance, and also Chris Van Hollen got, you know,
props for going down to meet with the Berger Garcia and all that before. So like, my friend,
when he was on social media over the weekend, I was like, when he went to interview to run the
committee back in 2016, like the interview was with Chuck and Chris Van Hollen. They are pretty
aligned, right? With the exception of, I think, basically kind of foreign policy. So anyway,
whatever that's worth. No, and Chuck, you know, they voted eight times or something to end the
Iran war under Chuck's leadership of the conference and voted for it. So yeah, I think people are
being a little, I don't know, overdoing the meaning of the race. I guess my only addendum
to what you said is we don't need to have leaders who are on TV all the time. You know what? I think
Chuck Schumer is probably a pretty good inside baseball manager of the conference and will be
an okay majority leader. Same with Hakeem Jeffries. They do not have to have press conferences all
the time. I'm old enough to remember when people, I don't think the Speaker of the House had,
remember this? He used to have like one week, once a week, what do they call that? Pen and pad
meeting off. There was no cameras. I don't think it was off the record, but it was just with print
reporters or TV people using the pen and pad. And there was, they didn't do TV press conference.
I mean, they didn't run out every time there's an issue that I've got to be the one to go to the
floor to give a speech. They let the committee chairs do the work. They let people who do a lot
about issues who are more photogenic, perhaps, who are more colorful, who are better speakers,
get out there and be in front and center. And I think, honestly, if Schumer and Jeffries just said,
we're, you know, we're going to do it. We've got a full-time job here. We're going to let a lot of
other people, you know, if someone has to talk about account about investigations, Garcia will
do it in the House and Raskin will do it. And some various members of the Senate will be front and
center, depending on what they're doing. So, you know, I think it's a good idea.
What issue it is. And people who serve in the military will take on the Hegseth thing. And,
you know, Mark Kelly will be out there on the, on what's happening in the military. I mean,
that would be a much better model. It happens anyway, naturally, because of course they can't
stop these people from this being, holding hearings and going on TV. I'm okay with Hakeem,
with Jeffries and Schumer, honestly, but I think they should both not feel they have to be there.
Those stupid press conferences with each of them, with their, like their fellow leaders standing
behind them at a little semicircle. It's like a joke. It's like a parody of Washington. It's
totally unnecessary. Just, just do the work. Let other people speak up. I was thinking about
Watergate as a kind of analogy, both the Watergate hearings in 73-4 and then the post-Watergate
Congress in 75-6, which was the last Congress, I think I said, I mentioned this in the newsletter
that in which a Congress controlled by the opposition party really passed legislation
and changed the, you know, the balance of power in government in many ways in 75-76 post-Watergate,
that class, which is the, was the biggest incentive of the election.
Victory since 2026 is the biggest one since 74. So it's not a bad analogy. And yeah, but what do we,
what do I remember from those Congress? I remember Sam Irvin chairing the Watergate committee along
with Howard Baker. I don't honestly even sure I know who the majority leader, the Democratic
majority leader of the Senate was that I guess it was Mike Mansfield, but I don't remember him ever
doing or saying anything. He obviously helped Irvin make this thing work, but Irvin was the
colorful guy who ran, who did the Watergate thing with the help.
I mean, Bill, a more recent example of this is the January 6th committee.
Step back and let, and let Liz Cheney and others be stars, but also in 75, there's the church
committee, which famously held hearings on the CIA. That was Frank Church. He wasn't leader of
the Senate. I mean, I think they should go back and look at that model because it worked pretty
well. I've got to say, I think. And anyway, so that's, that's kind of, so I've been sort of
relaxed about the leadership thing, hoping that ultimately these leaders don't matter as much as
we all think they do, but they could make leaders themselves could help by just stepping back and
letting other people come to the fore, including a lot of the new members. Don't we want to see
Cologne and, and Hamilton and people on issues where they have, which they've run on where they
have knowledge or can get up to speed very quickly, be the face of the party.
Well, and then on top of that, and this was another one of my reasons why I was a little
bit less pressed about this, uh, was the people who are setting the message to the party are
going to be the people running for president. Well, that's the other thing, right? So it's
different than, than, you know, if this was two years ago, I don't know, my feeling would maybe
be different about the importance of the communication side of it. So they have a
part of this and there should be a lot of pressure on them to do it well. And I'm open to hearing
Chris Van Hollen's pitch on the Senate side and, uh, and we'll see how that goes. But I think that
as long as, uh, it is a healthy and honest pressure being put on them and not food fighting for the
sake of food fighting and exaggerating their failures and like creating imaginary failures,
you know what I mean? Like that's, that's sort of how we're going to be handling it here,
how I'm going to be monitoring, uh, that race. I wanted to laugh at Pete Higgs,
Seth for one second. Can we just do that? Is that okay with you? Always, always, always good for
that. You can even do it for more than one second. You don't have this. Okay. We have some housekeeping
I need to get to at the end, but I do want to, uh, I just, I didn't have a chance to play this
last week and I've played it for myself so many times on the phone that, um, I just thought that
if there was even one listener of the show who has not seen Pete Higgs, Seth get chastised at
the tomb of the unknown soldier, well, you get to see it now. Let's play that.
That was Pete doing some selfies and laughing with his friends and just getting shouted down.
And I first thought I'd like a PTSD trauma response from, you know, being in high school
and going, uh, going to visit monuments and stuff like this and joking around with my friends and
getting yelled at. But after that, thinking about it, I was like, oh, I'm going to go to
the fact that it was the secretary of war that just gets shouted down. It's pretty enjoyable for
me. Others, Mark Erling, so others, uh, veterans, you've talked about how James Garville was talking
about this, how I really pissed them off, you know, cause I honestly, I mean, he's Pete Higgs,
Seth might act like a high school kid and have the brain development of a high school kid, but
you would think that the secretary would have a different level of appreciation for where he was
on veterans day. Right. I mean, was this, was this just after the ceremony, I guess they're
taking some, but I mean, they've just literally had a very solemn ceremony on veterans day. Right.
It's not like they, I don't know, you know, in the middle of the afternoon, they go on a little
expedition and it happened to go by this or something and they're laughing. Right. I mean,
that soldier was fantastic. Huh? What a moment for him. I can't, I can't wait to add him to the
list of people who are up for promotions in 2029. I guess I'd say get Julia Curley back in there.
Get that guy on the promotion list. Uh, we have much to do on that front. Do you have any updated
thoughts on Higgs, Seth and Pete?
Impeachment or Trump impeachment or impeachments broadly?
It should never be ruled out. It's ridiculous to say that we're not going to impeach X. I love
people. Everyone wants to be like a little strategist here in mid November. Things change.
You know what? We're talking about the scandal. I've written five times this week, I think on the
scandal, uh, the chip China chips scandal. I don't believe anyone was even mentioning that 10 days
ago. We don't know what, what grounds for impeachment they will all give us by January,
February, or give the Congress. They certainly should not retire that mode of accountability
from their, from their rucksack or whatever. And, you know, they, they need to keep that option open.
And certainly this stuff that Lutnik and Higgs have done and that Trump has done that warrant
impeachment and conviction, whether you go after all of them or some of them, I that's, I don't
know. I would combine going after them with, with passing legislation that at least going forward
might address the problem, tighten the screws, fix, you know, make it harder to end run everything and
to avoid the law and, uh, and see what, you know, maybe if Trump signs a lot of that legislation,
it's less necessary.
I don't know. But I, I would say my only point on this is I'm slightly more open. It's like you
were saying about Jeffries and, and Alan, I'm, I'm, I guess I sort of, except for now, this
conventional wisdom, they shouldn't focus on Trump to start with and heck Seth or Lutnik or more
make more sense. But I am not ruling out that as a matter of honest, good conscience, one might
come to a point where one has feels one has to for both for, for what's right, but also for the good
of the country impeach Trump or other folks. When you look at oversight, I just wanted to mention
on the immigration stuff too, because we don't know, like we don't really know exactly what is
happening in all of these camps. Like they have, they basically have black sites in red States and
part of the country. We're going to get to learn a lot more now, particularly in Texas, where a lot
of these camps are because Democrats now control Texas. Shout out governor, you know, so I'd
mentioned this short story of a, a new Orleans family. The mother is Karen and the daughter is
Charlotte. Charlotte is seven years old. They've come from Venezuela or a Siley,
uh, seekers at a humanitarian relief. They're working as Walmart delivery people in new Orleans.
Karen got nabbed going into work at Walmart. And then they pressured her and bullied her into
signing something that, that meant that they could also go get her daughter Charlotte. And now the two
of them have been sent to Dilley, a lawyer that I was talking to that just visited them and Dilley
and send me this. So the Charlotte, the seven-year-old wrote a note to president Trump that
says, president Trump, I want to visit you. I want to visit you. I want to visit you. I want to visit
my dad and study in my school. She drew a picture with a similar message, Mr. President Trump. It's like, okay. So we have a seven-year-old child in a, in a
prison camp now for like coming up in a month. And there are other examples of this Miriam and her son
who I've talked about there over 200 days. Now I've heard some really bad horror stories that I
haven't shared on here. Cause I don't want to like be totally irresponsible. I'm talking about what's
happening in the camps. But I think that once we learn what's happening in the camps, right,
maybe the only thing that could be done is to impeach Mullen depending on the human rights
abuses that may be happening there. So I just think that we have so much to learn and this
China chip, as you mentioned, story, it's just such a prime example of that. Nobody was talking
about it before the election two weeks ago. And now it's like very clear. We have a corrupt deal
happening between Trump and Lutnick and the biggest,
company in the country, you know, to sell advanced chips
China. So there's going to be much, much more to uncover. I feel like a lot of podcasts and
radio shows you listen to, eventually over time, the show becomes like a meta commentary about the
show. The Jim Rome show, this is famous for any Jim Rome heads out there. This was a famous thing
on his show when I used to listen to it in high school. So anyway, I try to do this as little as
possible. But I did get some emails on a couple of things. And I just want to cover really quick.
I was kind of surprised by the amount of news coverage account that we changed ad vendors.
I just do want to note that Vox, which is owned by James and Catherine Murdoch, also recently bought
New York Magazine, is now going to be doing our ad distribution. I think people kind of misunderstood
the story and thought that like, because they had recently bought New York Magazine or something,
they'd also bought us. The opposite of that is true. And so we basically changed from audio boom,
selling our ads to Vox selling our ads. We appreciate that the Vox folks are really
excited about having us on board. I think Kara mentioned this on her show. So no shade to the
people over at Vox. But really, this doesn't change anything at all for the board. It's just a
different ad vendor. The only difference for you, the listener, will be who knows what kind of ads
will be happening. Maybe more different kinds of cat food. I don't know. I think we'll probably
still be selling you Quince shirts and one skin. But we'll see. So maybe we'll get some new brands
in there for you. And hopefully, it can help us expand out our events so we can do more coming to
your communities as well to do more sales around that. But besides that, nothing changing at the
Bulwark. But we appreciate everybody's interest in what we're doing. Speaking of which, the other
housekeeping item I had was Sarah was speaking at the aforementioned What's Next conference in Denver
this weekend. And she had a video of her being happy. And that went viral because people don't
like it when women are happy.
I guess. Let's watch.
She goes on to continue cheering people and saying, come on, libs. I was there going,
hell yeah. I was like, let's get excited. We're all getting together. This was a monumental win.
We should be celebrating it. And it was well received by the people in the room. On the
internet, a lot of MAGA folks basically made sexist jokes about Sarah and said that this was cringe or
whatever. I'm sorry that happiness and success and joyfulness is cringe for some people who are
living sad lives. But I don't really take that critique that seriously. I don't know, Bill,
do you have anything on that? There was one element of this discourse that I did want to
talk about, though. No, I did. Sarah feel they needed that the conference needed to be juiced up
a little. It seems like that she was a little, yeah, too many earnest conferees worrying about
everything. And it's good. There's a lot of panels. Yeah, panels. Exactly. And so, you know,
I just think we're trying to get the party, get the party started. That's one of our many roles
at the Bulwark, you know? Exactly. The party did continue since the administration can't handle
basic technical upgrades and all the planes were grounded on Friday. I will say, speaking of libs,
there were a lot of libs.
Drinking on Friday night in Denver because they were stuck there away from their families. So the
prominent liberals that you see on your screen were definitely enjoying themselves in the
altitude on Friday night. There's a serious part of this because there is or the libs that led to
this also spinoff discourse of a lot of people, particularly the brand of like conservative who
never really liked Trump that much, but, you know, didn't want to go all in on opposing him in the
way that we had.
And many of them were criticizing her and discussing and us, Bill, you and me, too. We didn't get a pass
on this. And their critique was that we have abandoned our principles. Our principles were
abandoned by being so supportive of the Democrats this midterm in the last 10 years. And I did just
want to address that briefly because I don't, I really don't understand what principles were being
amended when you were being neutral in the face of Trumpism. You know, when you look at a wannabe
authoritarian strong man who's trying to end American democracy, who ran a campaign of racist
libel against American immigrants, and plan to run a campaign of retribution, where they use the
Department of Justice to go after their political foes. And the other side of that coin is a liberal
running within the tradition of American politics. I don't understand
what principle led to neutrality there. Right. And to me, I think that that word liberal, like
liberal values were always closer to my principles than what exactly the top tax rate is or whether
we have a Green New Deal. I don't know what principle there was in supporting Mike Rogers
as he ran the most overtly racist Senate campaign of the century. That was one that folks kept
saying we abandoned our principles for opposing Mike Rogers in that race. Again, I don't know what
principle was that undergirded supporting somebody that was doing election denialism
and advancing racist libel against Muslims. For me, I just think that the conversation
really is silly. And I think that it misunderstands what the central issues are
that we have been facing this last decade. And to be honest, I am pretty contemptuous of somebody who
has been at the forefront of this. And I think that that's just the way it is. And I think that's just the way it is. The right thing to do in 2024 was like right in Paul Ryan for president. To me, that is a complete
abandonment of the foundational principles of the country when like one of the two candidates had
instigated a violent assault on the Capitol and was promising to, you know, rip apart the core liberal
democratic values that have made this country special, that have made this country successful.
And instead, it was trying to turn us into kind of a authoritarian nationalist blood and soil
nation state. You know, if that is one of the visions for America and the other vision is a
liberal democratic social democracy, like the choice is very, very, very clear to me. And I
am happy to be on the side of the liberals. And I think that the people that are neutral in
the face of that choice made a decision that was extremely catastrophic and unprincipled.
So that's where I'm at when it comes to the libs. And it's really, it's one of these things where
it's like, not actually a very close call for me at all. And there are other people out there who
are like, well, the most important issues to me are like right to work and whatever, like the EPA
WOTUS and, and all of that sort of stuff, then like, okay, like that, then we just have a
disagreement because to me, like the principles of the country are, you know, what was written
by Madison and Jefferson. And this version of the Republican party is the greatest threat to that,
that we've seen. And certainly my lifetime.
I'm with you. That was really well said and proud to be with you and proud to be with Sarah,
obviously fighting for liberal democracy and conservatism at its best was always a defense
of liberalism, you know, properly understood a little modified perhaps, and then we can
quarrel about the modifications, but that's all fine.
There was another, I see one strain of the attack wasn't quite, they weren't neutral exactly between
Trump and never Trump though. Sometimes they, sometimes what I got to this controversy later,
I wasn't even aware of it until like, you know, 12 or 24 hours after it popped up, I guess it
popped up Friday night and I found out about it Saturday, but, but then there were people who,
they weren't really neutral. It was very important to show a huge amount of hesitancy before you came
out full for full war against Trump or full war for the necessity of electing Democrats in 2026.
You have to really agonize.
You have to really agonize about it publicly and wring your hands a lot and explain with great length
how you have all kinds of problems with all these, with some Democratic candidates somewhere and some
of what they've been saying and some of the implications of what they've been saying. And
you can't just say, look, we need a Democratic Congress to stop Trump from turning this into
an authoritarian country, you know, and to stop ICE from doing what you were just describing
10 minutes ago and, and, and to stop, you know, the denigration and desecration of the U.S. military
and all this. So, yeah, I'm, I'm a little impatient.
With the hesitancy fans. I don't know, you know, it's really kind of complicated here. I'm a little
uncertain about our left. Some of the people on our left flank aren't perfect fighters, so we can't
really, you know, we can't, we can't just fight authoritarianism. So anyway, the whole thing is
insane to me. And I guess my final thing that I would just say is like, Hey, for starters, I would
work for John Huntsman. I don't know. This wasn't quite as big of a transition for me as some might
want to make it. I was always for the squishiest Republican possible, even when I was a Republican.
But lastly, like
I just, when I posted on Instagram, when I went in to vote, that's gonna make me sad thinking about
it, actually. But I went in to vote with my daughter in November of 24. You know, we voted
together in the booth, and I walked out and she got a little sticker and she put her sticker on
and I posted a picture of her with the sticker. And I said, this was the easiest vote that I've
ever had to make. Like, there was absolutely no close call here at all. Like the everything,
everything that matters to me, everything that I care about everything that is good about the country
in 2024. Um, and so I couldn't have been more proud to be on the side that was trying to help
defeat Trump, even if we were unsuccessful. And, um, you know, unfortunately that was,
that didn't turn out right. But, um, I think that it is certainly appropriate now that we are
pushing back successfully to enjoy that and to, um, celebrate it. There's more work to do as well,
but to also be unapologetically joyful and even a little cringe if necessary, um, in kind of
soaking in those victories. So that's where I'm at. Speaking of soaking in those victories,
I want to close with this as enough navel gazing. There isn't officially a 56 seat, uh, Senate
majority because Mary Paltola, um, that race has been called in Alaska. And so with Cologne and
Paltola, it is, it's pretty remarkable accomplishment. So I don't know if you have any
final words on that.
24 was, was a terrible defeat, honestly, for the country. I mean, for us too, of course,
but really for the country, much, much, much more importantly, 26 is a big victory and it's got to
be, you know, we have to be as resolute in doing the right thing. I would put it this way for the
next few years as Trump and Stephen Miller and Russ Vogt and all these creeps have been in doing
the wrong thing. And they have been pretty resolute. Doesn't mean we should be mindless
like they are, or certainly not, you know, authoritarian like they are. We need to fight.
We need to be tough. And in that respect, I'm, we're both, I think a hundred percent where I'm
you and I'm with Sarah and with the whole bulwark with, with a lot of other people out there,
including not just squish Republicans like you, but right-wing Republicans sort of like me and
stuff. We, I think we're fighting for the right thing. And I'm proud to be part of it, honestly,
really as proud as, as of anything else I've done in, in Washington or in politics. And I think
that's true of most of us at the bulwark and all of us, I think at the bulwark, I can say that.
And I take their, I take their, the scorn of those who don't want us to be too resolute and to fight
too hard as a, as a badge of honor.
I do as well. Full speed ahead. Thank you to Bill Crystal. We've got quite a lineup coming for you
guys this week. It's been bangers only since the election. So we're going to keep it going.
Look forward to seeing y'all back here tomorrow. Peace.
I don't know that much, but I know about keeping score.
And if there's one thing I know for sure, it'd be a long, cold day in hell when I take you back.
The Bulwark Daily is brought to you thanks for the work of lead producer, Katie Cooper,
associate producer, Ansley Skipper, and with video editing by Dante DiCicco
and audio engineering and editing by Jason Brown.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The "China chip conspiracy" involves a coordinated effort among Trump, Howard Lutnick, Jensen Huang, and Elon Musk to prioritize personal gain over U.S. national security by enabling advanced chip sales to China.
The core of the scandal is not sexual misconduct or espionage, but willful disregard for national security and a shared agenda of self-interest, with Trump, Lutnick, and Huang openly supporting China despite U.S. export controls.
U.S. intelligence recognized the risks early, with reports from Rubio and others detailing the illegal chip transfers, yet the administration downplayed or ignored these warnings.
Trump's personal stock sales of NVIDIA shares before a market crash—while publicly promoting the company—raise suspicions of insider manipulation and self-dealing.
The upcoming trilateral summit with Trump, Xi, and Putin is seen as a dangerous display of political cozying with adversaries, undermining U.S. values and military interests.
Congress is urged to reclaim its constitutional power, enforce accountability, pass sanctions, and resist executive overreach to protect American institutions and national security.
The episode highlights a broader crisis of democratic norms, with figures like Marco Rubio promoting contempt for international law and undermining human rights.
A seven-year-old girl in a U.S. detention camp wrote to Trump expressing a desire to visit him, underscoring the humanitarian abuses occurring under current policies and the need for urgent accountability.
Summary:
S. chips to China, driven by a conspiracy among top figures including Donald Trump, Howard Lutnick, and Jensen Huang. Rather than being a mere sex scandal, the core issue is a willful, self-serving disregard for national security in exchange for personal profit and political advantage.
S. values and democracy. S.
military forces. Meanwhile, Congress is urged to act decisively, reclaiming its constitutional powers to oversee, regulate, and enforce accountability, especially in areas like immigration and foreign policy. The narrative also highlights troubling human rights abuses, such as a seven-year-old child’s message to Trump from a detention camp, and critiques the political hypocrisy of figures like Marco Rubio who dismiss international law.
Ultimately, the piece calls for a resolute, principled Democratic response—one rooted in accountability, transparency, and the defense of American democracy against authoritarianism. The underlying message is that national security and democratic integrity are at stake, and institutional oversight must be strengthened to prevent further damage.
FAQs
Toyotathon is a promotional event celebrating Toyota vehicles, with activities and offers running until January 4th. It includes special deals on vehicles like Tundras, Camrys, BZs, and RAV4s.
No, current offers on Toyota vehicles end on November 30th. After that date, the promotions are no longer available.
The controversy centers on the alleged willingness of key figures—Jensen Huang, Donald Trump, and Howard Lutnick—to prioritize personal gain over U.S. national security by facilitating advanced chip exports to China, despite known risks.
No, the document suggests that the core issue is not seduction or blackmail, but rather a deliberate, conscious decision by individuals to advance personal interests at the expense of U.S. national security.
There is concern because these meetings appear to elevate China and Russia as strategic partners, despite their support for actions that harm U.S. interests, such as targeting U.S. military forces in the Middle East.
Congress is expected to assert its oversight power, pass legislation to counter national security risks, and potentially impose sanctions, especially if the executive branch is found to be acting against U.S. interests.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.