Go back

Bill Kristol: A Blue Wave vs. the Toxic Red Tide

59m 38s

Bill Kristol: A Blue Wave vs. the Toxic Red Tide

The hosts analyze the 2024 midterm election as a potential wave year for Democrats, driven by declining approval of President Trump, rising public dissatisfaction with his foreign policy and economic management, and a growing sense of political fatigue. They highlight that past midterms, such as 2006 and 1994, were similarly shaped by crisis events—like Hurricane Katrina and the Iraq War—and internal scandals that eroded trust in the Republican Party. In 2006, the Mark Foley scandal and the Iraq War, coupled with the Harriet Myers nomination controversy, significantly weakened GOP credibility, leading to a major Democratic wave. In 1994, a historic Republican takeover was fueled by disillusionment with decades of Democratic pork politics and a cultural shift toward conservative ideology. Both years show how voter base mobilization and turnout patterns—especially when the opposition base is depressed—can dramatically shift outcomes. The hosts note that current projections underestimate the potential for Democratic gains, particularly in key swing states like Texas, Florida, and Colorado, where demographic shifts and realignment may lead to unexpected upsets. They emphasize that while the Senate remains uncertain, a strong wave could push Democrats to 52 seats, creating a more stable and cohesive majority. The discussion concludes with a reflection on how midterms are not just about policy, but about trust, crisis, and the emotional resonance of political events—making them more unpredictable and impactful than economic indicators alone. The hosts also invite audience feedback on future retrospective episodes, signaling a deeper engagement with historical political patterns.

Transcription

12811 Words, 69105 Characters

English
Hey, everybody. Just a real quick note. I pre-taped this upcoming pod with Bill and so, you know, assuming was a blowout LSU victory on Saturday night. That's why I didn't mention that because I don't know what has happened yet. I don't know what's happened in the world. So, you know, if we got the cheeseburger from heaven or whatever, I don't know about it. So it is a great show. We're talking a little bit about the midterms and it's a retrospective on 94 in 2006. I think that you're going to really enjoy it. Also, reminder, we got these events coming up, tickets are starting to go. So if you want to come join us at Liana Columbia, Charlotte, the Borg.com/events. And one last thing, I'm after the pods over. Let me know you think about kind of the retrospective part of this. I have another little brainchild for something that I think you guys might like that is in a similar vein. And so I'm interested in your thoughts. So you can, if you didn't like it or who's boring or whatever, you can, you can let me know. So I appreciate you guys very much. Have a great Labor Day. Stick around for Bill Crystal. Hello and welcome to the Borg Daily. I'm your host Tim Miller. It is Monday. It's Labor Day. And I have for you, of course, at a large Bill Crystal. We have a very special episode. By popular demand, it's the Labor Day kickoff getting ready for the midterms. And Bill and I on several episodes have been discussing the 2006 wave year that led to the Democrats taking the House in the Senate, as well as some other midterms. And, and I've suggested kind of cheekily like maybe we should dedicate a full episode to that. And people are like, yes, please do. We want that. And so we're going to do it right now for Labor Day. It'll be a little holiday bonus. So that sounds good Bill. Sounds good. So do 2006, where you'll, which is the least modern history, then we'll go back to 1994, the ancient times before you were born and I can discuss what happened then. And then you also told me you wanted just a little bit on your first campaign, 1948. Thank you. I set you up. I set you up so well for that. I mentioned 1948 in Morning Shots this week. And that's why, too, a good time. Having a good time with that. I was not quite around yet. We also for the YouTube viewers and this Borg Plus subscribers, we don't have a picture of me from two thousand sex in video of Bill from 94. So you can go see what we looked like. We're both hands rather than ever now. And before we do that, I thought it would be good just kind of set the table with a little bit of, you know, just pure politicans, some prognosticating looking ahead to this year's midterm. And then kind of we can talk about how like our various experiences in past midterm sort of inform these projections. So I don't know. We need to like a state by state. I'm kind of wondering what Bill like your big picture thoughts are as we sit here on Labor Day for how the November election will go and maybe specific states that are catching your eye. I thought it would be a big democratic year for quite a while. Based on nothing other than just the obvious facts. And then the main fact being that Donald Trump's approval rating has just gone down steadily since he was inaugurated. And the approval rating would incumbent president is a good predictor of what happens in the midterm election, especially when his party controls both has the Congress. So it is a referendum on do you approve of what they've been doing for two years? And more importantly, probably do you want the Republican, especially when the Republican Party Congress is so attached to Trump, do you want them to continue rubber stamping what he's been doing for the next two years? Or do you want a party to check him? That was very much my experience in 2018. The last Trump midterm. And so I've always assumed Democrats had a pretty good shot at a pretty good victory. And then as Trump got into the Iran war and decided to monkey around with tariffs some more and inflation didn't go down. And he made a generally seem disconnected from people's lives and so forth. And gas prices went up by quite a lot. I thought a good year could become a very good year. And that's kind of for the Democrats. And that's kind of where I am. Yeah, so let's just do the House first. I'm I agree with you on all that on the big picture. I'm a little bit of two minds at the House and the Senate. And it's a little bit because of the playing field. I do think that the Democrats are going to see big gains among Latino voters. So, you know, in the parts of the country where there are a lot of Latinos like Texas. Look at that. That is maybe relevant for the Senate. But I think that they're going to overperform there. There'll be a lot of Trump backsliding. And I think the prognostications are wrong. A lot about what's happening in South Texas. Maybe even South Florida. Some places like that. And so I expect the Democrats to even overperform in in the House for that reason. And if you look at a lot of the projections right now, Nate Silver, the Democrats need to win four seats to get to 18. A lot of these projections have them only netting like eight seats or something. And ending like to 22. And the reason for that is to win the cheating that Republicans did. The gerrymandering did work a little bit. That's going to offset some gains. That's one. And another reason for that is just this kind of. And you discussed this with, oh, shoot, it was a duck show. It was on your cover station. And just like the nature of this is very different than 06 and 94. And just how polarized we are. And there's been districts in play. And there's been gerrymandering. And before the cheating gerrymandering, there's regular old gerrymandering. And so I see that and I recognize it. But I just look at the map and some of these places that Cook, for example, has is leaning towards Republicans, you know, in in South Texas, as I mentioned, in Eastern North Carolina in Colorado, in a couple of districts in Colorado, Florida. I think there would be a bunch of surprises. We'll get into why. So I think that the Democrats could net as many as like 16 seats and end up at two 30, which would be less than still those other wave years we're going to talk about that more than what is being projected. So that's kind of where I'm at the house. I'm less bullish on the Senate. We'll get to that in a second. But what's your review on that? Yeah, same on the house. I just think people are underestimating. They look at a district that's gone Republican in the last few years. It's a Republican now called Republican plus six maybe Republican plus eight because Trump might have been strong in 2024. And they underestimate that if the whole country moves Trump won't buy a point in half, right? Yeah. Let's say the generic ends up plus eight, that is the Democrats win the national house vote by eight, which seems to squeeze the whole. That's a nine and a half point move. That means that a lot of districts that are Trump, you know, plus six seven eight are in play, right? In fact, not only in play, but might you might even maybe should be almost favored to go Democratic. So I tend to think also that people are being a little too, what's the word I'm looking for? Deterministic from the past in this respect and not understanding that when you get to a wave, you know, districts toppled that we're a little beyond the, you know, of course they can win this one because it's only plus two Republican and or or or Republican's holding a seat that Harris actually won. There are some of those. So yeah, I'm sort of in the two. I've been saying just to be a little optimistic, just to make the numbers round 235 to 200 in the house. Oh, well, the 235 making me seem cautious with my two. My job is to make you my job is to make you the same prudent, you know, reasonable. I just look at some of these districts. I mean, I don't know. Anna pulling the loon isn't a close race in Florida. That's in the likely art category on cook. The fifth Jeff Crank has been in this Colorado spring seat forever. There's a lot of like sprawl into Colorado Springs and from the rest of Colorado, you know, it's like places like this start to fall. The mills see that talked about a lot. They tone a beach. I think that's potentially winnable. Democrats were strung into their bail Dalton. So I just think that they're a lot of potentially getable dem seats in this kind of likely dem category. There's there's the toss up category, the lean category than the likely. I think there's a lot of potential them seats to pick up there. So we're we're in the same page, even if not the same number on the house. Here's my nervousness about the Senate. We talk about this in a lot. So people who listen to the show should be pretty familiar with the playing field, but I'll just I'll just lay it out. Democrats need to pick up four to get to 51. And really, they need to pick up five because John Federman's been acting pretty squarely. And I don't know if you it's kind of one of those damned if you do, damned if you don't, if you're Chuck Schumer, if you have 51, it's like either you got to get past everything by John Federman or John Federman switches parties and puts it back at 50/50. So you really want to try to get to 52, which means you got to win five. Yeah, net five. Yeah, net five. Okay, so that means you have to protect Georgia. That seems safe at this point. And you have to protect Michigan, which seems other people think is less safe than me. I think that's pretty safe at this point. Okay, then you go into the pickups. You've got North Carolina. It's the one that it seems like you're going to get that's one. You've got Maine, Susan Collins is tough. I think that that Maine is going to be a flip this year, but that's not a guarantee. Then you got to get two more to get to four three more of Ohio, Iowa, Texas, Alaska, three of those four, the best four. Then after that, you get into like, Kansas, which you and I have talked about in Nebraska, it's an independent running Montana. It's an independent running Florida. Maybe you know, the map is tight. And a lot of those places you mentioned eight nine earlier, most of those places are 11 12 Trump states. They won by 11 or 12. I'm a little nervous that they end up running up into running a bunch of really close races and a bunch of losing by three points. A lot of 51, 48 losses in those center races. If I sat here today and you forced me to choose to prognosticate, I do think that they get Ohio was shared brown. And I kind of look at Texas and Alaska. I think I don't think they're going to get Iowa. That would be if you're just asking me today, look at Texas and Alaska. I think those are pure coin flips. And you know, just to be cheery, I'd say they go with the Democrats, but I think that they're I think both of them right now are like really neck and neck. So it's kind of the state of play. You'd win both of them. If you if you You did win, hold the same seats when North Carolina, Maine, Ohio, Alaska, Anta. access that does get you to 52 and a real majority that you can work with, where I mean, who is the next biggest trouble making Senator after Fatimen? There really aren't any. I guess that would be Peltola, probably. You have a pretty cohesive Senate conference where you're just kind of dealing with Peltola, you know, working with Peltola. And who knows? In that case, maybe Murkowski dips, honestly. So I think that would become a state of play. What about you on the Senate? I basically agree. And, you know, obviously predicting races that are basically 50-50 just fools errands. So, I mean, there's some historical precedent, I guess you'd say, for when you get a wave, things tend to tip over to 51-49 in your direction. You know, I mean, that seems like that's, can't mathematically or scientifically be determined that way. It just happens, feels that way, though, the car, you know, whatever, the weird dynamics of these races. They do tend to tip one way or the other for some reason. And so I kind of think that you could split those, the big four, two to two, which is sort of what you were suggesting might be the most likely outcome, but they could also go 4-0 either way, honestly. But if the wave continues, this is where it's so important, what happens late? And, you know, but since everybody's over, aren't that important in the sense that I feel like we know 90%, 95% of what's going to happen already, and I'm exaggerating a little bit here. We know a lot of what's going to happen in 2026. But that last delta, that last bit is awfully important if you're looking at four, but I would even say five, maybe six, very close. I mean, Kansas was closer than Iowa, I think, in 2024 in the presidential. They have a Democratic governor. It's not like no one in Kansas is ever like, well, voted for a Democrat, that would be crazy. So I kind of think that I put that up with the same category as those other four, make it five. Something else that will be some surprise, like the Democrats will lose the state they were supposed to win, maybe Michigan in this case, but maybe Maine, and then still get the majority because Kansas and somewhere else will come through. You know what I mean? That's sort of what happens in these in these years. If it's a dynamic wave like year, if it reverts a little bit, I think you said this on the last podcast. I'm going to, does the wave continue a little bit in those last two months? Or does it refer to the, to what's the question we're looking for? It referred to the mean, you know, referred to in the last two months. And that, that makes all the difference. Does it go plus eight to kind of drift down to plus six? Or does it go up to plus nine? You know, that just makes a big, big difference in these close state Senate races. And that's a good transition to 2006, because I do think that the scale of that wave for the Democrats change based on what happened in October. I know what from what was going to be a really, really good year for the Democrats, no doubt, kind of like this year to, to a bunch of seats falling. And producer Ansel, you just kind of pulled this for me. If you kind of look at going back to that cook political report, which I referenced and we love Amy Walter and everything that they're doing there is really great at leave and no sex. So it was Charlie Cook, you know, at the end, they looked at their own projections. It's all like how many they got right and they got wrong. And in '06, there were a bunch in that kind of likely Republican category that were surprising, dropped at the end. It gets attributed to this October, you know, kind of momentum for the Democrats. So we'll get to what happened in October in a second. I just want to start on both years of the basic facts. So the Democrats in '06 gained 30 seats in the House, which is more than we're both projecting for this time. But for the reasons we laid out a lot, a lot because of gerrymandering, they gained six seats in the Senate. Right. Now there's no gerrymandering in the Senate. So that's more of an apples to apples situation, right? Like if you match the '06 number, you should get about six, which is kind of what we're talking about. That would get you to 53 if you, then that's really what you're saying is this sweep, maybe, of Iowa, Ohio, Alaska and Texas. Or maybe you went three of those and Kansas and you get to six. So that was the 2006 year. Compared to this year, in both cases, the presidential approval rating is above this current president's W on election day of '06 was at 38 in Gallup, which is above where Trump is right now is 30 56. So that's a say to play. I'll give you guys some names and then we'll do a big picture to get your mind in the right time space. In the Senate, Claire McCaskill, my MS now buddy, beat Jim talent, John Tester wins that year, shared a shared brown defeats Mike DeWine. So time's a flat circle in Ohio. I don't know if it's a current governor, Sherrod's back running. Sarah's friend Rick Santorum goes down to Bob Casey. This was a devastating one for me personally. Sheldon Whitehouse defeated Lincoln Chafee. The running joke on that campaign that year, because I was always like the house moderate. And it was like we need to moderate more. We need to moderate more more. And they called me a Lincoln Chafee Republican and a campaign that year. And then Jim Webb defeated George McCaca Allen in 2006. And I was set to that year. I was working in Iowa. We will put this picture up for Jeff Lamberti is running an Iowa three, which is a Des Moines district, challenging a vulnerable incumbent Leonard Boswell. So there it is. Whoa, look how much handsomer I'm looking. Man, thanks to our friends at one skin. My plan there, there was a political consultant that I knew and was just like, you should go to Iowa, you should meet the reporters. This was the first campaign I got to do PR. I was before that. I was just kind of a little, little, little assistant, funky field person. And to be a comms person, to go to Iowa meet the reporters. And he's like, then whatever presidential campaign I end up running. He's in line to be a presidential campaign manager. I'll hire you to be the Iowa person. I was like, great, this is a great deal. And so he has looked like that was going to be George Allen and then George Allen did a racial slur campaign trail kind of a weird one. McCaca, it's not like a common racial slur. And that was enough to crush him. Different simpler times in 2006 to think that that would be a, like nowadays George Allen would go up with the Republican voters after doing that. But he goes down and then that consultant ends up working for McCain and dressed history and up working for McCain. So there is a six. Before I go through the full timeline, what is your, what are your big picture memories of a six? Well, just on out. So I lived then as I do now in Virginia. I knew George Allen some and thought well of him. And it was a pretty good, it was a good governor. And it's father who had been a great residence coach, obviously. And a very affable guy and a very good politician actually Jim Webb, I respect it. I knew him slightly too. He had been Reagan's Secretary of the Navy, I think. And then a quick protest over something. It was sort of an erasible kind of old-fashioned democratic hawk sort of and kind of a populist. You're a hero. Like, do you write, like, erotica? Do you see the erotica guy? I can't remember which was exactly like that. He was in history of like the Irish, the Scotts Irish in America fighting something. I don't know. He was, like, an amateur historian. He was a smart, very smart, is a smart guy. I think he's still there. Yes. Jim Webb did write erotica. Okay. I don't know if that helped. So, George Allen was, I'm going to say, I don't know what mid 50. I mean, the height of his career had been governor, then Senator. As you say, a lot of the smart money was on him for president possibly. And, you know, H and he was VP. He wasn't going to invent a succeed wish. Obviously, so quite open race on the Republican side. As Senator for Swingish State and more Republican, then the Democratic unlike Navigene, but, you know, sort of representative state. And everyone liked Allen. And then, and Webb had a pretty good campaign, but I remember thinking in the summer, what if this could be close? I mean, I want to zoom down a little bit easily. So, Webb was kind of an odd candidate, right? It wasn't like the attract of 38-year-old Talameco against the corrupt tax. And this was, that one liked George Allen, and he hadn't defended anyone much. And then the wave happened. That was part of it, I think. I think Virginia is a state because it's got a lot of earth. So, in North of Virginia, phrase the stuff people to waves, as it was later on in 2018 and so forth, you know, it's kind of a lot of upper middle class. It tuned into politics voters who were like more, had maybe voted for Bush in '04, had voted Republican at the Senate level and thought, oh, man, this has gone really badly. So, that helped. But then he did have the slur, which was crazy. So, do you remember the story? Of course, yeah. This young guy was a tracker. He went to, he was from North of Virginia. He went to the same high school, our son went to T.J. He's a little older. He had graduated and was 22 years old, I think. And Aaron, he seemed to get along fine, actually. But then he was bothering Allen. Trackers, you know, the guys who go around everywhere and try to record everything and find you and catch you in some stuff up. Yeah, look at the camera. And this is pre-i-phone, but they got the little camera and all this. And Aaron, I can't wait to say something like, oh, come on, Makaka. We got Makaka over here. Yeah. I got little Makaka over here. I mean, I think it's plausible. We didn't even know kind of what it meant. Like someone said, his mother had used this term about Indian, Indian Americans or Indian, you know, people from the South Asia. I don't know. Anyway, it became a big thing. And it kind of then, he handled it very badly. That's my man-member. He didn't explain it. This is always the case with, often the case with these things, right? And then the wave just kind of carried web onto a, onto a victory. But I remember Earl, like around now saying to someone, I guess, web will be fine, right? And this person who was older and had been around for 94 and for a couple of other digital elections, Reagan, 80, I suppose, said to me, yeah, I don't know, Bill. You know, on a wave, the stuff that looks shaky on Labor Day goes down. You know, that's sort of what it means to have a wave. And so that's my memory of the Virginia situation. I don't know if the time of it, just the house people. Anyway, just because it's kind of fun to go back and OSEC. So here are some of the Democratic winners that beat Republican incumbents. The heavy efforts, the Jim Colby, Republican, that year. Another race that I had a friend working on in Colorado, seven Ed Pearl Mudderby Bob Bow Price is the start of Denver suburbs going blue. I've talked a lot about this race Iowa two. I was working in Iowa three, which was the big race. I already spent money. Nobody spent money on Iowa two. Dave Loeb sack was a professor in Iowa. It's literally is not on. I should have went to look to see where it wasn't cooked. It had to have been like not lean or likely but solid Republican. It was a solid Republican. Jim Leach had been there 100 years, moderate Republican, popular. He loses today. Loeb sacked Minnesota one. You know who won that one in 2006? Tim Waltz. Tim Waltz. Oh yeah. Goods and a beat skill good necked. Kristen Gillbrand is that year. Fun for football fans. He's Schuller wins in the rural North Carolina 11 district, which is the same one. I think the Democrats could surprise them again this time. Okay, here's the timeline, about 6.05. And I think this is part of what prompted this, we love this, like, just kind of, our memories were different on like, like, why did Bush get so impopular in this period of what happened? So I'm gonna run through the timeline, we can kind of go through our memories of it. He's real elected, he gets it in January, and things working kind of good in Iraq, actually, they hold their first parliamentary elections. I think that's the blue thumb election. Yeah, that's purple thumb. Yeah, purple thumb. Yeah, purple thumb, sorry, as January of '05. But then, like, pretty much immediately after the insurgency intensifies, some IEDs, suicide bombings, then you get to August of '05. And this is the last month where a majority of Americans approve of Bush and the polls. And this is like mostly Iraq stuff. Sydney Sheehan, like her big protest starts then, August of '05. And then August 29th, Hurricane Katrina, which is like now, basically a year ago, the same time. Obviously, everybody knows how it was there. My sleeper event of this time is October three, the Harriet Myers nomination. Everyone looks to Katrina, because it was like where he got such bad PR, like in the media. And I do think that like, you know, whatever, there's some swing voter types that, I don't think there are a lot of Republican voters. So like, I'm bailing on Bush over his handling of Katrina. That doesn't feel right. To me, there's some, you know, some of this kind of proto-populous right, isolation is right, we're unhappy with the war. And the Myers thing, he gets just flayed, including you, and conservative media over this. You know, and I think this is where you start to get, maybe the Myers parallels like the Epstein files in a way. And just in a weird way, because like it upsets the base, right? And this for the base now is trying to get frustrated, followed the first year. Okay, John Murtha then first calls for withdrawal in November, a Scooter Libby indictment. So now you get into some controversies there. That is that's October. And then the Abramoff lobbying scandal is December. So oh, five was a rough year. Lots happening there for Bush. Not a ton, then, in '06 happening. I mean, Iraq keeps getting worse. Is approval rating going down a little bit? Gas prices arise a little bit. To me, there's the gas price issue. It's a parallel to this issue. And then really, you know, kind of nothing of note as far as like scandals or whatever until October, until a month out. And Bush's numbers are low, but they really, the bottom falls out late September, October 1st, where the Mark Foley page scandal happens. Mark Foley was sending inappropriate texts to young male pages. He resigns. House Republican leadership had covered it up. One of the House Republican leaders had covered it up, pedophile Danny Hastert didn't know that at the time. Republican circle of the wagons around him. I remember this ruined the last month of the campaign for my candidate, Jeff Lamberti. It's like every interview, you know, what do you think about this? Like we do go to a local news interview. We'd want to talk about whatever, you know, national security and the clip that they'd show in the local news is whatever his response to was to Mark Foley, you know, sending messages to teenagers. So deaths in Iraq go up that month. And then maybe a final two days, Saddam is convicted and sentenced to death two days before the midterms. I've forgotten this. A final breath of optimism, maybe, but now November 7th was the blot and then and then November 8th from Stelder sides. So, no, what is not there is much economy talk. Gas prices were up a little bit and you pointed out to the war, so it's a little bit of a parallel to now. But inflation was 2.5% in '06, like math. I mean, standard what you're looking for. Unemployment rate was low. Economies pretty good in 2006. So, this is a lot of foreign policy, scandal, disappointing the base, you know, wanting to have a check, looking like things are out of control. That's kind of my overview. But what jumped out to you in that timeline? No, that sounds absolutely right and front in some of those things. As you spoke, I was thinking to myself, the economy wasn't that bad, no 506. And so all the talk about it's all kitchen table, you know, it's all businesses. I don't know, yes, sort of, somewhat. It wasn't great as I recall. We didn't know '07, '08 was coming, right? I mean, I don't think, I don't think people felt that way. Didn't feel ominous or anything. It's just, the only two tiny points I'd make is Harriet Meyer, I think it has slight, this is not crazy. It's a little bit like Trump with the ballroom or something like that in the sense that it was bush indulging his personal like juices counsel from back in Texas. And then he made a right house counsel. And she didn't have the normal qualifications for Supreme Court justice, I mean. And so, it's a little bit like Trump just, you know, feelingless, I'm not going to just go with the kind of normal practices of the president. I'm going to put my personal friend in there, right? I may be exaggerating that. I don't know how much hurt anyway, but it feels a little bit, a little bit, just a quick on Myers. I just don't expand on the Epstein thing. To me, it's like, obviously poor Harriet Meyer, she's still alive. So I'm not like comparing you then. Yeah, no, no, we're not. To me, it's the comparison, isn't it, like, midterms are different than presidential and several effects. But one of them is like, turnout is important in both, but turnout like really matters. Like turnout is a little bit more important. And so depressing your base matters. And I do think it did. It happens that you're coming off of the first summer. It's the fall of the first year. Like there are other things to be worried about. And then it's like, what we want to do to follow, like one of the things we cared about being the Republican base, this time is like, to deal with this Epstein issue. Like you said, you were going to do, we wanted you to do it. And I think that the Republican base at that time in '06 was like, we want good Supreme Court justices. Like, this is our stand-in for social issues. Like, we care about the court. You ran on the court. Ran on anti-game marriage stuff, whatever. And it's like, OK, we wanted you to do-- we don't want another shooter. Like, this was a big thing, then. And it's like, OK, and now you're just like, oh, you're going to give it to your friend. And that's something that's horrifying with these young women. But like, in just the way of kind of letting down of something that they expected. No, I think that's well. That's a good point. I think it's-- I mean, he began. People forget this the second term by saying, let's privatize social security. Now, it's perfectly reasonable. Respectable, I don't know who's reasonable to that. No, and the think tanks loved it. The sort of things-- he had not mentioned it to my knowledge during the entire campaign. And it had this weird-- and I remember saying, I will say to him-- That's kind of like the Iran war, apparently. --one of the few things-- it is. One of the few things I got right. Early on in Fox, I was on the Fox Sunday round table pretty much every week, then. And I said, February, this is going to fail. I mean, the country is not ready for this. Yes, prepared for it. It's such an easy issue for the Dems to scream and yell about social security. It's like, they go to issue was back then even more than it is now, you know? Protect the social security. They'll gamble it away in the stock market. He's just rewarding his rich stock market friends. The idea was not a crazy idea. And you can make-- Well, it's actually a really good idea. It would have been wonderful. Well, in a much better place if they had assigned it right now. But OK, whatever. Right. I mean, we're our savings that are in our IRAs. And for one case, probably, ended up growing fast in social security, whatever. But anyway, but I think it's just like this little, like-- And it was also like six-- I think like 10% or 20% of going for memory. I think it was a good idea. The Democrats did an excellent job of attacking it. The Republicans weren't ready to defend it, because none would have even talked about it. It sort of got popped out of the Treasury Department. And I don't know, sometimes. February is like-- and so I remember early on saying, this is a political damage. And it had that same character, though, of, hey, we re-elected you. We sort of thought you were better than the other. It kind of likes the direction you were going more or less. They weren't thrilled with everything. But, you know, and we wanted you to kind of do more stuff along those lines, maybe. And it was just the surprise, the kind of willfulness of, I think, willfulness of it hurt. And as you say, that's a little more like a ride. It wasn't exactly that he promised not to do it. So in that respect, it's not quite like no more forever wars. But it's a little like just, what the hell? Where'd that come from? So I think it did some damage. It was like a candidate for it. It didn't hurt. Right, it didn't-- yeah, that's good. It didn't hurt Bush, in the sense that people left him. But I think it prevented him from having any momentum at the beginning of the second term. And at the other point, just make what you make about this. Is a small apart, what is it? 2/3 usually is the turnout in an off-midterm elections. What 2/3 is that of a presidential, sometimes even less. Which does mean almost by definition that what the basis of each party think matter more. Because that missing third is going to be less involved voters. And because if you can turn out 90% of our Republicans, like, or whatever, or Democrat, you're going to win. You're going to have a good year or a good year. You don't get all those other voters in the middle who are kind of diluting as it were, the true believers. And so the best thing you can have going for you is you persuade some people. That's good. Then you turn out your base big time. And then you depress the other-- something the other party does, as usually is something you do in the opposition, depresses its base. So in '26, just to figure it back to the president for one second, that would be if people are furious by its things-- Democrats are furious by a million things Trump has done and correctly. And they'll turn out. There's some swingish voters who don't like particular policies. And then he's got a little crazier. I can't maybe you should check him, not support him. Yeah, that's right, it's an economy. Yeah, that's good. And then some Republican voters who still will probably vote Republican in the 2028 still think of themselves as a Republican, but just, you know, I don't know, just stay home. So you get the Democratic turnout up and the Republican turnout down. If you can get both of those happening at the same time in an electorate that's two-thirds of the size of presidential electorate, that's where, again, the 2024 number plus 11 is a little misleading. But some of that plus 11 for Trump in Iowa, in Kansas, in Ohio are voters who will not vote this time. Correct. So-- Yeah, I think it was-- I apologize to everyone. It was one of the data people I saw on social media was putting this out, and they're like, well, what if-- what if the electorate in Iowa is actually only a plus 5? That's the correct way to put it. Yeah, you know what I mean? Yeah. It's like it fits a plus 11 Trump state, but the term, because of the depressed turnout and the increase in the Democratic side, then I'll say, you know, can you get enough independent voters to get there across the line? And I think that, you know, the Harriet Myers thing, which is why I wanted to talk about it, was part of that depressing-- the Republican way said that. All of it, I think Iraq was part of that as well. Like, we are seeing that. [BLANK_AUDIO] time on both sides. And to me, this is why I'm kind of even in 18 again, because of the nature of the map, and Jerry meandering and how we're, you know, like a big part of the 18 gains for the Democrats, when 18 gains were about this kind of realignment to the suburbs for the Democrats and places that, you know, you were probably going to do well because of Trump. And so they did better there, but like the Trump base was still pretty excited in 18. So I do think that was a little different. So that's part of the reason I'm more bullish and think that Democrats are going to overperform their polls. So anything else there, and Katrina is something that everybody talks about when they kind of reflect back in that time, obviously, and of course, like here, New Orleans, of course, and, and, you know, such such a traumatic and visual event, and, you know, then there's the W the flyover and, you know, Kanye saying W doesn't care about black people, and so like, there's all this. I don't know. I'm, maybe I'm, this is counter-conventional wisdom, but I think that that ended up actually mattering less than the economic stuff, the scant, the abrum off, and, and, and page scandals, and then Myers. But where, where are you on that? People have the sense that the Iraq War wasn't being fought well, whatever the justification, the moral case for it almost might have been. I think Katrina made it more plausible to say they're kind of, you know, they, the push sold himself, it's confidence, toughness, but also commitment, but not just toughness, kind of confidence. Condolees arise, serious people call in power. It was, you know, grown-ups administration. And suddenly, like, she's the Iraq war, they didn't power leaves, of course, after the first term. And suddenly, the grown-ups, little less grown-ups in charge, and then Katrina, total, just screw-up just in terms of execution, obviously, as well, as clearly talked about and handled it. Without Iraq, Katrina makes, wouldn't have made as much difference. And without Katrina, Iraq would have, maybe, but they, they felt they came together in a pretty bad way. And then the scandals, you don't really want incompetence and some bad policies and scandals all happening at the same time. Yeah. And you're right on such security. I, I, I overlooked that. I think that was another key inflection point. November 8th, Rome, Selda, signs, do we, is that, is that kind of a relic of an older time, where somebody has to fall on the sword, or is that, oh, do we possibly get a hexade, resignation this November? I remember that at the time I was very anti-Rome, so I called on it to be fired. After the victory in November 04, so I thought he had mismanaged Iraq and it could get a fresh chart and prevent things from getting worse. They kept Romsfeld and Casey. Things got worse over the next two years. I think Bush planned to fire him for months, but just felt you somehow couldn't do it until after the election. I don't, to this day, I understand why he thought, what, what, what, better to do in September? I mean, I don't know, but somehow it was like some weird, I don't know, you can't do it. Or honestly, after the Mark Foley scandal in retrospect, gosh, we need to get rove on here or something. Was there ever a meeting, you know, to do this? Was there a meeting about that? It's like it wouldn't, wouldn't firing Romsfeld be a better news story than talking about, you know, Congressman Dittle and teens? Things like it. I'll say in slight defense of Bush, which I'm done quite a while, but I have the sense that I, I mean, I saw Bush a few times in those, and that's the term of this. He, first time I never saw him because I was a McCain guy, but second term, he, I was the supporter of the war, so I got, I got an indication for these swallish meetings with, you know, people like me, magazine editor types, think tanks types, and he, he really did care about the troops. He's cared about their morale, and I think one, I remember one point having a weird argument with him where I think it, I'm not sure it was Romsfeld exactly, but it was something about acknowledging they'd made mistakes in the first three years of the war in terms of strategy. And he said, I, I can't do that. It'll make people feel like they're, their loved ones, died in vain somehow, and I, I just need to suck it up, and I'll take the hit, I understand people think I was wrong, but I just, I can't say to people. I was a kind of weird, I don't think he's right psychologically, exactly, but on the other hand, I sort of respected, he, he thought a lot about that. And so I think maybe he thought just dumping Romsfeld where it would have looked like he was doing it to help in the midterms with, like, weak political. Yeah, yeah. He should have done it. He was kind of like an honor and principle guy, whatever you think about him, and it is almost like he did, like, that stuff did matter to him. Interesting. Okay. Well, there's 2006, God willing. I mean, a 30-seat house game. That would be the dream, but that's even better than your eye. It's a little better than my projection. I have a 240-242, something like that. That'd be exciting. Yeah. Okay. Let's move to 1994. This is the classic year people talk about when they talk about waves. I was in short pants back then. I was, I was just after my last democratic vote that I had done before Trump came around, which was actually, that's not true. My last democratic votes were 92 in the school election. I voted for Bill Clinton and bet my grandmother $1 on it. It was very proud when she sent me the dollar. You know, then I started to get red pills there later in the middle school. And then I did vote against our own lieutenant governor candidate in the 2004 race that I was interning on, because he was such a dick. But that's neither here nor there. Those are my two other democratic votes. 94. I really found out that I don't remember anything, but I was told later on about a lot of stuff. So we'll see if other people agree. I knew the gist about the fact that was a big wave. 54 house scenes, seats gained. New house majority was 230 to 204 then. So that Republicans were coming out of a big hole. I should have mentioned this in '06, because this is what I was in, in wave years. And neither year did an incumbent of the party that was doing the waving loose. You know, so no Republicans lost in the House or Senate 94 or in 2006. Because of the redistricting mid cycle this time, like there will be some exceptions this time. But to me, that is again where I kind of fall on Michigan, Georgia. As just like when you're in a wave, you know, the people that are in incumbents are the incumbent party usually stays through. So 54 house seats gained for Republicans defeated 34 democratic incumbents that gained eight Senate seats. The New Senate majority was 5248. The total house popular vote. This shows you how different things are. It was only 53% in favor of Republicans. Isn't that amazing? This year of the Democrats only got 53%. I mean, they'd be squeaking out of five vote majority probably. Those are kind of the facts. I mean, the most interesting anecdotes, like the two things I knew about 94 were big waves and contracts with America. And the contract with America was unveiled. Everyone listened to this to gas. Bill might know. So I'm not going to quiz him. When do you think it was? The answer September 27th, 1994, not three. The contract for the America came out like right now, like three weeks before the election, which goes to show the Democrats could still do something. And maybe this is a little bit of, I don't know, to my, my view, just learning that now as I look at it and it just made me completely change my whole thinking about Gingrich and the strategy. It was just like Gingrich might have just like jumped in front of a parade. Total. It was already happening. So anyway, Bill, take the floor. I think it was good because it gave for Republicans a chance to say we're not just running against Clinton. We have a positive agenda. The agenda itself was mostly silly if you look at the 10 points and a lot of it was very minor. It's a procedural stuff and what I've termed limits, stuff that wasn't going to happen, you know, and a couple of semi-series things, including I think producing the, you know, greater growth of Medicare or something, which got them in such trouble a year later when they actually got in the fight with Clinton. So that was sort of not as important. It was helpful at the end to allow all these candidates. Well, there's a lot of stupid stuff in here. You're right. Yeah. Now, total number of house committees. Right. It was really, I remember looking at it at the time. I had nothing to do with it. And I knew nude. I was pretty involved in some of the fighting in '94. I'd been fighting against Clinton. But yeah, I remember thinking, oh, come on, but it did help a little rhetorical. I'm sorry. I have to read all of them. It helped by like half a point. It was not important. It would have had, it would have been a wave anyway in '94, but go ahead and read it. Please, let's, because again, I don't, my memory, this was totally wrong. Okay. Eight major reforms. It's like, it's literally nothing. Require all laws that apply to the rest of the country also apply to Congress. I don't even know what is that? It's like banking privileges and some better health care plans. That kind of thing. Okay. Select a major independent auditing firm to conduct a comprehensive audit of Congress for waste fraud and abuse. Great. Cut the number of house committees. Limit the terms of all committee chairs. Ban the casting of proxy voting in committee. Require committee meetings to be open to the public. Require a three fifths majority to pass a tax increase. Guarantee an honest accounting of the federal budget by implementing zero baseline budgeting. There's a fiscal responsibility act. This is balanced budget, truth and sensing. So there are, there are additional other 500-hour per child tax credit. So there are, you know, some job and wages stuff. But no, that was just the congressional accountability point of it. And then a citizen legislature act, which is a term limit to you referenced. I mean, they were trying to capitalize and they did it on the anti incumbent anti. There were some congressional scandals, some of them real, some of them slightly fake. I mean, they had some like bank they could use was just a banking. They weren't like ripping off the taxpayer, but they got a little bit, I don't know, it's nice. They got cheated. If you got to the little congressional bank, you got, I don't know what, you could float your check for a week or something. It wasn't just like dealing with your local branch bank, where they were not so nice to you. Anyway, these minor scandals, the pretty minor retrospect that happened. Jim Wright had been forced out as earlier as speaker. I mean, there was the Democrats were vaguely tainted with congressional scandals having been there forever, Ross and Kowski, right? Committee chairs who had been in, there were no term limits on committee chairs. They'd been there for 10, 20 years. They'd been in Congress 30, 40 years. So I think that was the, the part of it you read, the account of the congressional accountability is really pretty small ball. But it captured a little bit. They ran, I'd say this is one analogy. So they did run against the status quo in a pretty big way. How could they do that? So let me just go back to 94 for one second. If you want, I mean, it's just, it was different from 2006 or for that matter 2010 or 2018, which were sort of waves in many ways if you want, within the context of the modern series, the Democrats had controlled the House for 40 years. They had controlled the Senate for 34 of the preceding 40 years, except for that six-year stretch in the first six years of Reagan. Congress was democratic. I came to Washington in '85. That was how it was. Republicans had won the presidency, Eisenhower 8 years, then the Kennedy Johnson, Nixon 8 years, then Carter IV, then Bush, Reagan Bush for 12 years. How did Reagan not take a House? He took the Senate, he took the Senate in '80. Yeah, the House was so, because those Southern seats were still democratic. That's one thing that happened in '94. 34, I believe, Democratic and Congress lost. That's pretty amazing in '94. And about half of them were in Southern seats, where they'd been there forever. And then finally, people just decided, well, I was very nice, you've done a great job of bringing pork to this district for 25 years, but you know what? With someone who's actually a conservative like us, and not part of this Hillary Clinton, healthcare, Bill Clinton, pro-God knows what you know what I mean? There was a kind of a certain cultural caricature of the dams with Clinton, especially, and the really tried to cap us in that. So it was a big change in that respect. I mean, Congress, when I was studying politics, they first got into it. The presidency was often Republican. The Congress was democratic. And the House was really democratic. It was the bulwark of old Democratic power, powerful committee chairs, Austin Kowski and all these characters, and then obviously, and speakers and so forth. And when Nude started to say two years out, we can win the House. People just thought, no, that's not gonna happen. And one reason they thought that it said at least, there was no precursor to this. 1990 had been a mediocre year for Denver Republicans. That off-year election. It didn't lose much, they didn't take up much. 92, two years before Bush had gotten 38% of the vote. Bush had gotten 54% in '88. The Republican Party was an utter disarray. The incumbent Republican president had gone from 54% to 38% and that's partly a perot thing. But still, it was-- - That's not really just mean that the House Republicans end up being Bush, plus, reparao, the like. - Pretty close, yeah, yeah, pretty close. And yeah, then with a differential turnout sort of thing there too, yeah. So they expected it by September '94, but no one expected it in early '93. When Nude started to say those people thought, you're crazy, the House has been 40 years. That's two generations of political operatives cycling through. There were people in Washington who had come as very young people to work in the Hill or in the executive branch and literally had never, of course, seen a Republican majority just seem to incopreasable. And even the Senate had only been that one six-year period. So I think this degree of surprise was at just novelty of what was happening. It really can't be overestimated. It just felt so different from these more modern swings, which once you have one of them, then you have another one, right, 2006, 2010. OK, well, that's another just kind of counter-wave. It didn't feel like that. Clinton was in the low '40s. He wasn't that unpopular, though. And then we weren't fighting some terrible war. There'd been some really minor scandals. I mean, well, white water was beginning to bubble up on all this. But it was funny how people turned against them, though. I mean, how much they did. But having said that a lot of it was catching up to what had happened. I mean, it was like these districts had democratic incumbents who had been there a long time, Tom Foley, the speaker of the House, who lost, I think maybe the only time or one of the very few times the speaker has lost a bit more than his own seat, you know, had a district in Eastern Washington, I believe, which was becoming quite conservative. It's not Seattle, you know. And he'd been there forever, and they loved him. And he'd, you know, got out as a speaker, or before that as a majority leader. He brought a ton of pork there and all. Yeah. And it didn't matter. They wanted a sort of Republican, you know. This was the end of old interest group pork barrel politics, I think, in some ways. In the beginning of modern ideological parties, ideological waves. And that respect, it really was a precursor of what we were going to see for a federal worse, maybe mostly worse over the next three decades. So that's, so my memory is just what a surprise it was, not at the very end. Though I think I was on stuff on, I don't know, some show, I think it was me, the press, maybe, or with Stephanopoulos, who was then the White House spokesman. And I was running this little project for the Republican future, but I'd become sort of prominent as a critic of Clinton and a Republican strategist, you know, that's great how you could be a Republican at one, like, one failed Senate campaign had been quills. Chief of Staff for the presidential campaign, we got carbon in, but I nonetheless got to call myself a Republican strategist and get that guy around on TV. And as a Republican strategist, I said, we're only going to win both houses. And everyone just, like, Stephanopoulos said, of course, he didn't even said that wouldn't happen because he was a Republican Clinton. But actually, the people there, I guess, who was roster probably were like, come on, Bill. I mean, really, I mean, maybe pick up seats, sure, win both houses, yeah. That's something we, it's hard to recapture. The degree of surprise and kind of novelty about what was happening. - Interesting. There, again, not a economically challenging time, get economy. And 934, you mentioned a couple of the scandals. I mean, some of these Clinton, you know, the white water, you mentioned the cattle futures. Like, that stuff was being investigated in the news, but like, you know, I mean, nothing at all like this. And the thing that people point to is the failed health care plan. So I think you're kind of looking at two things, really. One, and that's, since it's like, Bill, it's a feeling that the administration was not competent. Maybe that's the Katrina parallel, but like, they're not going about their business well. And then I do think that there's this kind of demographic, like, you know, these sort of populist right people are aligning with Republicans and then some of the races. So they're, you know, white people are aligning with the Republicans. But talk about, you were involved in the health care stuff. Like, what was, was this just kind of like a big government? Little government was just a feeling that Bill betrayed his voters because they thought he was going to focus on other stuff. He ended up focusing on this. Like, how do you judge that? - I mean, I think a little of both. I think it was a big government thing. It was, I mean, Hillary's plan, I was pretty big critic of it, but it was a pretty big overhaul. The system wasn't really like Obamacare, which, you know, at the end of the day was insurers for 30 million people who couldn't otherwise buy it on individual markets. It was a complicated plan. It was a big deal, Obamacare, but Hillary's thing really was embracing pushing people into HMOs. Again, I can't remember honestly the details, but it was, it was a bigger overhaul. It was huge hoopla. Hillary, big speech around Labor Day a year before in '93. Hillary Clinton testifying to Congress as the first lady. He'd put his wife in charge of the task force to devise this. It all had a slight, you know, - She's more polarizing than him. - She's much more polarizing than him. - Some of this is misogyny, but also just like culturally, he is governor of Arkansas. You know, she comes off as very liberal and like putting that up. First, as a policy thing, it's like more of a signal that like, no, this is not a DLC governor of Arkansas. - Right, and she was more liberal and it was the inside baseball, his wife in charge. And moderates who had voted for Clinton, which they were, you know, saw him obviously some, some Bush voters made A to it, just served a Bush, not all, somewhat the pro, but somewhat the Clinton. They thought welfare reform, that was the kind of signature DLC moderate democratic. We're willing to take on the welfare state and we're going to reform welfare and you know, it'd be a little tougher on welfare. Such a big issue for Reagan, he used to have a Democrats over it. And putting healthcare ahead of welfare was as became symbolically very important as he's gone to the left. He's betrayed his moderate supporters. And there was some truth to that as an ally. - And in that case kind of in a weird way, that is depressing the democratic vote. But not in the way we were talking about in '06, and this year, because it's not depressing the base vote, right, 'cause they were presumably mostly for that. But it's depressing this kind of other part of the coalition, the Southern Democrats, the more populous to Democrats, you know, that, that we're, that we're thinking it was going to be something different. - Yes, I think that's right. And then the healthcare proposal was sort of funny because in, I don't know, they thought they could get Bob Dole and moderate establishment for Republicans on board. Those people had often been in favor of performing healthcare in that direction, as Romney was later on, right? And with Obama, you know, sort of precursor of Obamacare. And there was a lot of talk about compromise, and I was running this little project for the future. And I advised them not to compromise. The healthcare system was not that broken. There was no healthcare crisis. That was a memo that I wrote. And we sort of argued to Republicans that she was just hanged off. And that was a contrary interview, I will say. And most people with you get killed if you just don't do nothing. You can't do nothing. There's a healthcare problem. Republicans have lost the 1991 Special Senate election in Pennsylvania over healthcare. That was Carval's first great upset victory against Thornburg. And so Clinton talked a lot about it in '92. This wasn't a case. It wasn't a case where he was doing something he hadn't. He said he wouldn't do, but the big government character of it and the Hillary character of it, I think. And so whatever the Democratic Republicans ended up going in the do nothing, just say no position on healthcare. And the one inside I had was, if you ask people in poll, this is the thing about polling. And it shows why people shouldn't take posters, shouldn't take one polling result to care too seriously or too literally. Two thirds, three quarters of Americans wanted healthcare overhaul. Two three quarters of Americans were unhappy with the healthcare system. Three quarters of Americans had gripes with the insurance companies. Are you neighbor with whatever cost, obviously. It's tough to say. Two thirds of or three quarters of Americans like their own health insurance. That's because they mostly work for businesses and corporations that provided decent health insurance. And so they didn't have to see, there's any great need if you were working for General Electric or Coca-Cola, you know, your health insurance is adequate. You're a big university, big state government. And I sort of had the insight that the Republicans should run on that second half, that second poll result. He's endangering your health insurance that you're satisfied with. And there's a way, as we've seen this in a lot of public policy areas, both from the right and the left, right? The status quo. was easier to defend than to say. Let's risk everything by overturning, overturning the whole thing. And maybe you won't get insurance for your employer, but we got a better idea in mind, it's done up by this fancy think tank, and Hillary Clinton's got an old work down for you. And we were able to caricature it, honestly, in that way, pretty successfully, I think. - Well, we talked about the October surprise in '06, and in 1994, Clinton tried to drop an October surprise to protect himself, but I don't know that it landed. Let's watch. - When we started, they helped care to it. - They didn't, they said it was secretive. - No, that's not true. We met with him in advance. We even offered to work with him on drafting a bill. We were told, no, you go ahead and put your bill in, then we'll put our bill in, and then we'll work. They announced an approach where more than half the Republican senators supported universal coverage. The bill never came, but the time came to talk about the bill, there were zero senators from the Republican Party on that. So, and by the way, then they released the memo of their strategist, Bill Crystal. He wasn't even ashamed to release the memo and say, you must not cooperate on health care, because if the middle class ever gets security about health care, they'll probably support the Democrats again. Whereas if we keep them all torn up and upset and angry, we can either keep them home or get them to vote for us. So, I want, let me just say this, I want more than anything to have a bipartisan effort. - He blamed you, he also has a different clip. I saw just the text of where he tried to go after you in the final days, because you came out against farm subsidies, which is, you know, anti-farmer welfare bill. - That's acceptable. - That was on the tarmac in Iowa five days out. I remember like, why is it kind of a, and this is pre-cable really, I mean, this was Larry King. See, and it was the one cable network. That was like the one political show basically that anyone watched. Yeah, and then that was two days before election day, I think where he's kind of amazing. - Yeah, I'm their top political shadow. I was running this little 12, 14 person, you know, a little so quasi-think tank there, project for the public of the future. I was not really the top Republican strategist, but it was nice that President Clinton-- - Well, I know we're talking, New College. - Yeah, that's true, no, I was involved. But anyway, that was a funny moment. But so the dynamics were pretty different, honestly. I think that was, in all these different respects, the historical character at 40 years in the house. The novel, the fact that a lot of it was history catching up to the Southern Democrats, the fact that Clinton hadn't done, it was more that they had tried to do something that scared people, and that we were honestly helped scare people about. That's all what did him in. So I do think in this respect, the double back, I think 2006 is more of a similar situation. '94 was kind of a, '94 was the end of an era. It was an important election, just a little different from a kind of a normal reaction against the incumbent president. And incidentally, as '94 also shows something that '06 doesn't, which is it's not always a precursor of what happens next. If you're a Democrat and you look at '06 and you think this is going to be like '06, yeah, what's the good news? The next, they went in the presidential election by seven or eight points two years later. So, hey, it's great to double header to '06 and '08 to pick up a lot of more seats. '94 was great. And then Clinton probably won re-election by seven or eight points as something in '96. So kind of a good cautionary tale there that you can do well in a midterm. - Yeah, it is. It also, '06 is also more compareable, even though this is none subsequent terms. You know, the second midterm in '06 versus the first one in '94, there's a difference in the dynamics between the second midterm and the first. I don't know. To me, I have the '94 lesson as, and some of this is just things outside of strategist hands. Like this, just the kind of changing, tectonic plates of politics and trends and media and it's global, a lot of stuff that's happening here is having in other countries. But like, if you look at that number that, you know, the Democrats had before in '92 that included these other parts of a country. Like, if they want to get to, you know, a place where like they're, they're really advancing like permanent policy changes and big policy changes. It's like the people that want progressives that want big policy changes should want this the most, right? Is like, there has to be a way to reconnect with these, you know, parts of the country that they've lost. Like, they had managed this coalition from like FDR through LBJ, like, all the way through Tip O'Neill, like, all the way to Bill Clinton's first term and it finally collated like, but it's fucking a half century, right? Where it's very different ideological and demographics of people in the coalition and at the sorting of the parties that started '94 has been very bad for the Democrats and it might be feel unfair and asymmetric and I hear JBL whining about it already, but like, if the Democrats want a governing majority, like, they do need like a more diverse coalition like they had before '94. - And, you know, then they lost the House in '94, they lost it, they stayed lost for 12 years, people, you know, and then they got it back by doing exactly what you just said, right? Rahm Immanuel recruited a lot of candidates for the House and then some Senate candidates appeared on their own who disordered from the. Sociological testers, the cast, the two people running in '06 and winning and the Democrats, and then they held those seats and increased them in '08 with Obama, which is a little more complicated, but they had the advantage of a massive financial crisis, obviously. - Even Tim Walls, right? Like, think about the different kind of race that Tim Walls runs and in '06 from how he runs his commos VPN. He runs as a very moderate kind of rural farmer teacher guy. That's Minnesota one, but, you know, look, they went in Kentucky that year. I already mentioned, he's Shuler, Redneck kind of, football player, winning in North Carolina to Texas seats. They beat, oh well, you had mentioned how fully lost, delay lost in that '06 year in Texas, too, took on a Nick Lampson. That's a good Jeopardy trivia question. I would have never been able to pull that. But, you know, three Indiana seats. So, like, that's the way back. Okay, what do we forget? 1948 and the 1948 last match? - To mention that in warning shots, I was trying to make the point that Mike Johnson such a wet noodle. As we said in the headland of the piece, and he said a couple of idiotic things about how, we don't really have a view on anything, you know. If Pete, I trust Pete, I trust the Secretary of War. I trust Trump. I'm not gonna, I don't know anything about the Iran war, why I'm just Secretary of the House. And I do think they should pummel the Republicans. I try to think what's the, Truman pummeled the Republican Congress, the 80th Congress, as the do nothing Congress. He was in combat pressure running for reelection. The do nothing Congress had failed to pass any legislation that he wanted, including on health care, and so not a lot of things. And he famously hit them as they do nothing Congress. And one of the famous combat victory, obviously against Tom Dewey in 1948. And the Democrats, this was a different era, right, with more party switching and less, you know, less followers. Democrats picked up 75 seats in 1948 in the House and took the Senate. And so that was a wave with Truman beating Dewey in a combat presence. It doesn't really, it's a present for years. It doesn't quite compare to what we've been talking about. So what's the equivalent of the do nothing Congress? I mean, the Republican Congress now is kind of more like a rubber stamp Congress, I guess, and maybe it's a better term. So we could think of it. So rubber stamp and do nothing. Well, that's another two weeks. There's another two weeks on very good point who gets this much of vacation. Speaking about health care, you know, my health care and issue. All these guys get a free health care without working. I'm in Chicago. What kind of health care system see on that at all? We don't even know what's happening with them. They're not even working. It's crazy how little that they've worked. I do think calling it a, yeah, rubber stamp and do nothing Congress. That's not been set up in a way for the democratic challengers. They should run it. They got to run against Trump. They also have to run against the Republican Congress as a debling Trump and is doing nothing to check Trump and will check Trump and also making it worse in some ways. It's this that depending on which members of Congress, I wanted to find a quote of true when using do nothing Congress came across just this thumb speed. You used it all the time. Of course. So you just get a thumb speech. You gave somewhere. And in the thumb speech, the two issues on which he most complains that the Republican Congress did nothing, are health care and housing, housing prices. Isn't that amazing? Health care. And so, and he also throws in inflation actually. And so I feel like the Democrats, they're looking around for the message. They always have that interanalyst internal, you know, hand ringing about the message. They should go read Harry Truman's speeches from 1948. They're excellent. They're economically populist. He's big on the people versus the corporations and versus the elites and versus the big shots. But the true and also, of course, was a cold warrior and a middle American guy. He wasn't some lefty kind of cult, you know, and cultural stuff. So I feel like they should run his Harry Truman for the next two months. That's a great place to leave it. Bill Crystal, appreciate you. I hope everybody enjoyed a little holiday pod content. And we'll be back tomorrow. We got a double header. We got another guy tomorrow that is very keen on this. And this kind of, he's tired of us talking about the Democrats like getting the 52 Senate seats. He's like, why not 60? Why not 58? So we'll talk to him about how the Democrats get that done tomorrow and we got one of my buddies coming on the show. It's going to be a good one. Bill Crystal. Thanks so much for other. We'll see you next week. Great. Thanks. [Music] The board daily is brought to you thanks to the work of lead producer Katie Cooper, associate producer Anzaly Skipper, and with video editing by Don Tade.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The upcoming midterms are expected to be a strong democratic year due to Donald Trump’s declining approval ratings and growing public dissatisfaction with his policies.
  2. Democrats are projected to gain significantly in the House, potentially winning up to 16 seats and reaching 230–240, surpassing current projections due to underestimation of voter shifts and wave effects.
  3. Key swing states like South Texas, Florida, and Colorado show potential for Democratic upsets, driven by voter fatigue with Trump and realignment in conservative-leaning areas.
  4. The Senate remains more uncertain, with Democrats needing to win five seats to reach a majority, though gains in North Carolina, Maine, Ohio, and Texas could shift the balance.
  5. Historical parallels from 2006 and 1994 highlight how midterms can be influenced by scandal, economic issues, and political fatigue, with waves often materializing late in the election cycle.
  6. The 2006 wave was fueled by Iraq War criticism, Hurricane Katrina, and the Mark Foley scandal, which eroded Republican credibility and mobilized a broad base of disaffected voters.
  7. In 1994, a major Republican wave restructured Congress by ending decades of Democratic control, driven by ideological realignment and public frustration with pork-barrel politics and perceived inefficiency.
  8. Turnout dynamics—especially base depression and increased Democratic mobilization—play a critical role in midterms, often outweighing economic or policy factors in determining outcomes.

Summary:

The hosts analyze the 2024 midterm election as a potential wave year for Democrats, driven by declining approval of President Trump, rising public dissatisfaction with his foreign policy and economic management, and a growing sense of political fatigue. They highlight that past midterms, such as 2006 and 1994, were similarly shaped by crisis events—like Hurricane Katrina and the Iraq War—and internal scandals that eroded trust in the Republican Party. In 2006, the Mark Foley scandal and the Iraq War, coupled with the Harriet Myers nomination controversy, significantly weakened GOP credibility, leading to a major Democratic wave.

In 1994, a historic Republican takeover was fueled by disillusionment with decades of Democratic pork politics and a cultural shift toward conservative ideology. Both years show how voter base mobilization and turnout patterns—especially when the opposition base is depressed—can dramatically shift outcomes. The hosts note that current projections underestimate the potential for Democratic gains, particularly in key swing states like Texas, Florida, and Colorado, where demographic shifts and realignment may lead to unexpected upsets.

They emphasize that while the Senate remains uncertain, a strong wave could push Democrats to 52 seats, creating a more stable and cohesive majority. The discussion concludes with a reflection on how midterms are not just about policy, but about trust, crisis, and the emotional resonance of political events—making them more unpredictable and impactful than economic indicators alone. The hosts also invite audience feedback on future retrospective episodes, signaling a deeper engagement with historical political patterns.

FAQs

The Democrats are expected to perform well due to President Trump's declining approval ratings, rising inflation, and a disconnect from voters. Economic concerns, such as gas prices, and political scandals like the Mark Foley and Harriet Myers controversies in 2006 are seen as key factors that have historically shifted voter sentiment during midterms.

Gerrymandering has historically offset Democratic gains by diluting their voting power, especially in key states. However, the hosts suggest that despite these challenges, Democrats could still overperform due to a wave of voter discontent and unexpected shifts in swing districts like South Texas and Florida.

Turnout is critical in midterms, where base dissatisfaction can disproportionately influence results. A surge in Democratic turnout and a decline in Republican turnout—driven by anger over policies and scandals—can shift the balance, even in states where the overall vote is not heavily skewed.

The 2006 midterms were driven by a wave of dissatisfaction over the Iraq War, Hurricane Katrina, and political scandals. Unlike today, where economic issues dominate, 2006 saw strong emotional and national-level events that significantly impacted voter behavior and led to a dramatic Democratic wave.

Key Senate races include North Carolina, Maine, Ohio, Iowa, Texas, and Alaska. Democrats need to win at least five seats to reach a majority, with Maine and Ohio seen as particularly vulnerable and potentially flipable due to shifting voter sentiment.

Scandals like the Mark Foley texts and Harriet Myers nomination significantly damaged Republican credibility. These events, combined with public frustration over the Iraq War and Hurricane Katrina, helped shift swing voters toward Democrats and contributed to a historic wave of gains.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.