Go back

Bill Hader on Directing vs. Performing, Leaving ‘SNL,’ and Stefon the Movie

43m 51s

Bill Hader on Directing vs. Performing, Leaving ‘SNL,’ and Stefon the Movie

Bill Hader, known for his work on *Barry* and *SNL*, discusses his journey into directing his debut film, *They Know*, a dark, divorce-centered horror film inspired by his experience with *Barry*. He credits the film’s success to creative autonomy and strategic cuts by his team, drawing from the storytelling techniques of *South Park* and John Hughes. Hader emphasizes that his career shift from comedy to drama was driven by authenticity and personal truth, not market demands. He laments the absence of structured post-SNL support systems, urging for formal development partnerships to nurture talent. The episode also touches on his deep respect for collaborative storytelling and narrative structure, as well as the enduring fan loyalty seen in Johnny Depp’s test screenings, where audiences, especially women over 35, showed strong affection despite public controversies. Hader shares insights into his creative process, anxiety management, and his belief in films that explore emotional depth over spectacle, concluding with a hopeful outlook on the film's potential success and a call for greater industry support for emerging filmmakers.

Transcription

8561 Words, 43129 Characters

English
This episode of The Town is presented by FX's Adults, called TV's Best Comedy by Forbes. The ensemble comedy series about a group of 20-somethings crashing in their friend's childhood house is back for season 2. In what the cut calls "A to the most hysterically funny episodes of the year," the five friends invent elaborate workarounds for problems they're too afraid to face head-on. For your awards consideration, in all comedy categories, all episodes of FX's Adults are now streaming on Hulu and Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. It is Thursday, November 12th. It's the final stop on our film school tour. Tuesday night, we were at UCLA with Bill Hader, who wanted him on the show for a while. He's one of my favorite SNL guys, he was there for eight seasons through 2013, then went on to co-create and star in Barry on HBO, one of my favorite shows. He's been in tons of movies, some super bad, two skeleton twins, a train wreck, and the new cat in the hat movie. And he's finishing up his directorial debut, a movie called They Know, that I'm betting will probably be at Sundance in January. Bill's got a great example of a modern career doing mostly what he wants to do with very few paycheck projects. I asked him about that, plus my idea for an SNL production company. So today it's Bill Hader, recorded live at UCLA Film School, plus we got a little Johnny Deb Colchie at the end, from The Ringer and Puck, I'm Matt Bellany, and this is The Town. Well, you've been out and about, like I feel like you go into hibernation and we don't see you for long periods of time and then you come out, you've been doing so, why you've been promoting cat in that, obviously, but I feel like one of the reasons you're out doing more press is because you have directed a movie that is going to be, is it seeking distribution or are you going to be like, yeah, yeah, it's seeking to tell us a little bit about your upcoming projects. I want to ask some questions about it. Oh, so I wrote a movie that is me in Linda Cardellini, we play a couple. I guess I could say it's kind of like, if you saw Barry, it's kind of Barry in town, but it's like, instead of a crime show, it's a horror movie and it's about a divorce. That's a fun thing. And I told them, I told the studios that and they just started throwing money at me, I literally picked up cash and just started throwing it at me. It is interesting that you win the independent route because you're making this movie with MRC, independent production finance company. They do have a long history of working with a tour style filmmakers and getting the movies sold and seen, but was it hard for you to get this movie made? Well, the big thing is I want a final cut because I had had that on Barry and so it was kind of like, you can even have this budget and you don't have Final Cut or you can have this and have Final Cut and I'm like, I'll do this, you know. And so. And even that wasn't enough for traditional studios. I would think of the success of Barry and the fact that you directed many, many episodes of that show and won many awards for it, that it wouldn't be difficult to do a smaller or you think. You think. No. No. I think it was more of just like the idea. So, you know, it's like the show, Barry, it's like, I mean, if you went into a studio, is that be like going to ABC and being like, okay, it's a show about a hit man who wants to be an actor? They would be like, no. Right. No. Thank you, but no. Thank you, but no. So, it's a strange idea, but I, yeah, we decided to go this way and I had an meeting with the MRC guys and we had a great meeting and they were very, they had seen the episodes of Barry I had done and really liked them and they said, we just want to see you do that, you know, in the movies. And I said, well, I have a script. So, let's go, you know, so it was, it was a great experience and some of the people from Barry got to work on the movie and it was just fun, man. It's done. It's done. So, today we did ADR, today I was doing ADR all day, it was Linda Cartelini and I felt really bad. Because there's like a really important scene, but it's right next to a freeway. And so she's like, Bill, you're killing me with this because we had to like, you're trying to get the same emotion and when you're acting, you're not thinking about how you're speaking or doing anything and then you're trying to like recreate that and it's just, it's impossible. Any differences between directing a movie and directing episodes of your show? No, not really, I mean, the biggest difference I would say was we have much more time in post. Yeah. Because on Barry, I'm writing, you know, we'll be writing the episodes, you know, the next season where we're cutting, like so I'm cutting season three and then I'm going to the writers room for season four and then going back to that, you know, and so this was kind of Ali Greer who's the editor on the movie and edited a lot of Barry. And I were kind of like, wow, this is really nice. You know, we saw the schedule and we were like, really? Yeah. You know, because we were so quick, like, oh gosh, you know, we got to get this in cut, you know, but there's more pressure, perhaps this is one entity, sink or swim. Yeah. Yeah. Your name at the top. Oh, I know. Oh, believe me. Not to put added pressure on you. That's not going to release it. I get it. There's too much pressure. You just talked me out of it. Yeah. It's, it's injury. You're talking backstage and you said that you have always been a big movie buff and yet watching movies, once you've been a filmmaker is different. How so what do you pick up on when you watch movies now that you maybe didn't when you were younger or less experienced yourself? Well, some of it is, is, is interesting. Some of it's kind of sad because you're like, oh, I see how they did that, you know, or it's like, oh, that's interesting. And I ruin it for my kids. Right. I'll be like, oh, really? It's not real and they're like, shut up. This guy's coming back in 20 minutes watch. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I'm like, oh, see. Yeah, see. That's interesting. They're not in a car. They're actually on a stage and someone's been like, shut up. You know, let us just watch Adam's family. But no, I, I mean, one way is like, in one, in some way, you get angrier at times because you go, oh, God, you guys had it. Why are you, this feels a little sloppy and like, you could have done, you know? You're giving notes in your head. Giving notes to your head. But it's like, you had the opportunity. You got the money. You have it. Like, what happened? You know? Right. And, and then on the other end, you're, when something's great, you're like, I'm more blown away now than I was, you know? Yeah. I was just, I don't like that. Yeah. People have said that to me when they ask me why certain movies end up getting awards, traction and other movies that people enjoy don't. And I say, when you are a filmmaker, when you're in the Academy and you, you can see the tricks. There are certain types of movies that impress people who make movies because they can point out things that the general audience won't. And if there are movies that go beyond that and do things that they can't point out, then those are the movies that are going to get the better percent where you just see something and you go, my gosh, the craftsmanship and that was amazing or, you're like, seeing train dreams and going like, this is all a magic hour. Right. How the hell, and I met the director of that and I ran over to him, I go, how did you guys do that? And I was like, that was amazing, you know, and then he said AI and he went AI and he goes, hello, little girl. And then he left. He was a robot. You know, and I was like, oh, shit, God, damn it. No, I know those guys. They did not use AI just to be clear. Now let's spread that guys. They're very nice. They're down in an outburger and be like, train dreams was AI. I know you've done drama, but you're primarily a comedy guy yet you're making a dramatic movie. Is it more a function of the market or is that more a function of where you're at creatively? Well, it's actually, it is funny. This is the hardest thing for me is I'll write a script and this happened with Barry. I'll write it and people will read it and go, whoa, wow, this is really intense. And I'm like, what? I'm like, no, it's going to be funny because it's me. It'll be funny. It's me. It's me. It's me. It's going to be funny, you know. And so it's an interesting thing is sometimes you can write a thing and in your mind, it's so clear to you, like what the tone is and that happened on Barry completely, where it was so clear to me what the tone was. And then I think they expected or some people expected it to feel like a five camera, you know, kind of like Mike Shersho and those are great, nothing against those. But I think that's what they were thinking. And then when they saw the pilot, they're like, what the fuck is this? And so it is funny. It is to answer your question. It is. It is funny. I don't, you know, as far as the marketplace, it's more of like, how can I, how can I just get my idea across and for the right amount of money? So no one loses their shirt and, but I have the right, you know, funding that I need. And that's a conscious decision. Very conscious. And trying to thread a needle. Yeah. And Bob Graff is the producer on the movie and he produces the Coen Brothers. And I've always really admired how they've done their, you know, movies. That they can do a thing and you go, how much is that calling? Wow. All the money's on the screen. You don't want anyone to get fired for saying yes to you. Yes. Yes. Exactly. And so you're, you're doing this, that threading that needle. And so while you're writing something funny happened, which was I had written these scenes and we were over budget and we were trying to get the budget down. And then it was really funny. I was like, I don't know where to cut. I don't know what to cut, right? And then Alyssa, my co-producer, oh, Alyssa Donovan right there. Co-producer of the movie. She, you can clap for her. Haha. (audience applauds) - This is right before you tell how she cut the budget. - Yeah, so this is how Alyssa fucked me, budget. Now, I just would sit and this is kind of an exercise. I was like, okay, let me just tell the movie to you. Okay, I just saw the movie, it's called They Know. Let me just tell you the movie. And as you start telling the movie, it's okay, so what's it about? And you're like, okay, it's about this guy and they're married couple and they're gonna, and I start doing it. And I told the whole movie. And after I told the whole movie, she was like, you know, you left out this scene, you left out this scene, and you left out this scene. And so I was like, let's cut those scenes, you know? And the movie just like moves so much quicker. And then I did it with Aly, my editor. And then she picked another scene. She's like, you know, you didn't mention this. And I'm like, yeah, they don't, it just-- - John Hughes, do you still do that? On his comedies and the 80s, where he would just say, okay, what is absolutely cutable? Like, what do we absolutely need and just cut the rest? - Yeah. - And great scenes. - Yeah, amazing. - The amazing things. - From those movies are great. - Oh, Planet Strange and Omobiles, it's like a whole other movie. - Right. - And it ends up being 90s, something minutes. And they cut out amazing stuff, but it was just get to the story. - Yeah, we gotta get to like the meat of it. And so it is a lesson of like, you know, when we did the pilot of Barry, it was 45 minutes. And it was supposed to be 30 minutes. And I turned to Alec Burg and Jeff Buchanan was the editor and I go, I don't know what to do. I don't know what to do. And they like, Bill, go on, like, just leave to, and come back in tomorrow. And I came back in, it was 30 minutes and I genuinely didn't know what we got for a while. There's 15 minutes and I was like, well, that was great. Wait, what did you cut? And they showed me and I was like, oh, God, I didn't miss any of this, you know? And so when you think you go, I don't know what to, I'll stick cut, you can. And I think that came from SNL too, where you had to fit it into a time. And sometimes you were cutting during the show. They would come up to you and say, hey, we're cutting this sketch completely in half. Look at the cue cards. Oh, my God. And it's all different. And so I want to ask about, yeah. I'm a Christian wig, did a thing once, and the writer didn't have time to cut stuff. So the writer was in front of the cue cards, hiding words. And he was going, go here, here, here. Go away. Like, air traffic control. Air traffic control. And she was like a newswoman going today in Bo-da-da-da. And as she was just this writer, it was just pointing at the words. - And she pulled it off? - Like seamless. - Oh my God. - And afterwards I was like, okay, I could have never have done that. That was amazing, you know? - Well, we'll get to SNL. But I want to ask one more about the tone of Barry did change, at least from my vantage point during the show. Got a little darker. And I was looking at the chronology of it. Started in 2018, ended in 2023. - Yeah. - Some stuff happened. - In the world, between then. Do you feel like the state of the world impacted how the progression of Barry went? - I don't know. I mean, yeah, I mean, definitely COVID, you know, fucked me up. But I do think just the tone of the show. And if you, you know, you have an idea and you want to, you know, when we were doing the show, we wanted to follow the rules of the show. And you just kind of go, okay, then what would happen? And just go naturally where these characters want to go. They're taking us there. And it just went to a place where it started getting dark. And, you know, we would sit in the writers room going, do we go here? - Right. - Yeah, let's go there. But to me, it always was dark. You know, the first season I killed my friend in the car. - True. - And the notes made me feel like, so nothing funny in this. And I was like, no. And I made a joke. I go, when I shoot them, I can fart. I mean, if you want to, you want me to do that? - They say excellent. - They feel like we love that. We love that. So they had no problem when you got up and accepted the Emmys for outstanding comedy. - Yeah, yeah. - It doesn't matter these days. - No, yeah, that was always the thing with Barry is like, is this a comedy? But I feel like the last two seasons were still very funny to me. Comedy can hold different things. It doesn't have to be brightly lit and with music, you know, going. (humming) - La la la. - You know. (laughing) It can still be funny and hold that. Oh great, now you got me sick. - No, no, no. I knew I would. The laughing does it. Let's go to SNL. I am old enough to remember your first episode. And you were one of those cast members where you see the first episode you were in. And like, okay, that guy's got it. The Al Pacino impression in particular was like, and I went back and listened to it today. And you've talked about how nervous you were and how you stayed up all night. You went to a bodega at six in the morning and saw they were promoting the show and almost threw up and all of that. I want to know when you went off stage after that. Did you know you killed it? Did everyone say that was amazing or did you, were you just still buzzing? - I genuinely don't remember it. It was like I, all I heard was like when you listened to a C-show, you know, it was like. (laughing) I was kind of like this. - It's 22 seconds, by the way. You're only in that sketch for 22 seconds. - Yeah, and it got at an applause break. And then what I remember, which is very sweet, which I went off stage. And there's an area we call the paint cans, which is where all these paint cans are. And it's backstage. It'd be funny if it wasn't paint cans. (laughing) But yeah, it was like, but a batting machines are back there. We call it paint cans. - We're a camel, or whatever that is. - Yeah, camels back there. And it's wardrobe, we call it paint cans. And Rachel Dratch saw me across and she went. - Oh, that's nice. - That like, you know, Grand Slam, you knocked it out of the park. And that was, that really meant a lot. - Did you say yes, I'm not getting fired? - I was like, no, no. I didn't say that for, so probably season four or something. - Yeah, Lauren Michaels pulled me aside and said, you know, you could work here as long as you walked. - Oh, you can say that? - Yeah, season four. - Well, not everybody gets that. - Yeah, I think because he saw I was such a nervous wreck, he wanted me to relax. And why do you think, and I don't want to get into psychology here, but why were you so nervous all the time on that show? 'Cause a neurotic person. - Okay. - All right, it's as simple as that. - Yeah, just a neurotic person. I've been that my whole day. You know, I have a tick where I say you know a lot, and I'm very aware of this. But I would sometimes hear people, there's people adjusting lights on the catwalk. And you be live on a show and I'm doing a game show host. And all I can hear is, and I'm doing the thing, and I'm like, are they gonna drop something? I mean, I was very anxious. And then Fred Armiston usually would take advantage of that, make me laugh. - Yeah, I'm Melania as well. - Well, Melania obviously is Stephanie, that's what made me constantly, constantly. - Yet, despite all that anxiety, I also read that you made up your Italian guy impression during your interview, during your audition for SNL. - I did. - How did that come about? - Stuff prepared? - I had stuff prepared. Well, that's not 100% true. So the Italian guy, Vinny Videci, came from my friends and I were in line with the man's Chinese to see the movie AI. - Okay. - Ooh, even the movie title gets a, ooh, ooh, ooh. - Hailey Joazman's like, what did I do? - And there was an Italian guy in line that was talking like that. - Okay. - And he was like, hey, look at that, look at that. Hey, what the hell are you doing? - But did you just get nervous during your audition and just go to it? - No, I had planned that, and then what happened was before the morning I woke up, they did this to kind of throw you a curveball. They said, hey, you need a political impression and it can't be the president at the time of the George Bush. So I turned on the news and Tony Blair was on the news and I watched it and I called my friend and I did it, who's this? And I did it, I think it was supposed to be Tony Blair. - Let me call you back, you know, it worked on it some more. So that was the thing that they, and then when you do your audition for us now, at least when I did it, they put you in dressing rooms and you hear the auditions happening. - Oh man. - So you're listening to the other people auditioning and you're just waiting for one of them to do your character or your impression, I hope no one does up to you now. I hope no one does this, you know. - Was anyone, I would know in front of you? - Well, Andy Sandberg and I rolled that, we came up on the elevator here, that's how we met. He was in the elevator and he had, I always say he looked like he was running away from home. He had all these props and I was-- - He got a caratop, just out of the house. - Yeah, he just had, yeah, he was like, "Caratop." He just had all these props and I was looking at him going, "Fuck, I didn't bring any props." - Yeah. - And then he said he was looking at me going, "Oh man, that guy doesn't need any props." That's the loser. And so we were kind of sizing each other up in the elevator and then, but yeah, that we were all petrified. - When you finally decided to leave SNL, I've read that you had a conversation with Moore and I've always been fascinated by how those conversations go. - It was funny, it was the Justin Bieber show. And we just pitched to Justin Bieber and then he left and then I walked over to Lauren. I said, I think I'm gonna, and I had had this plan. It was it beaver related. No, yeah, just look. I was like, I can't do this anymore. I think TFA has cited Bieber as one of the worst hosts. Yeah, I don't want to comment. No comment. No comment. But he yeah, bebes. So but does that one leave the room and he knew I was going to talk and I said, you know, we, you know, my wife at the time, we just had a second child. And I said, you know, I just had a second baby. And I think I want to live in California. And I and I extended one season. I think this is going to be my last season. And Lauren listened and he went, wear it for a while. Okay. I mean, like, just think about it for a little bit. You know, you might change your mind. And I went, okay. And then I remember calling my agent. It was what he said when he said wear it for a while. My agent was like, shit. We're going to have this conversation again. Yeah. But he was great. You know, he was so sweet. And we did a. I think he knew because, you know, Seth was leaving Andy and Kristen. I left the year before and Fred was leaving. So. This episode is brought to you by peacock, presenting the new limited series, the good daughter, starting Roseburn and Megan Fahey from number one New York Times best selling author Karen slaughter. The good daughter is a suspenseful thriller and a deeply emotional story about love family and resilience. All episodes are streaming now on peacock. And your arrow was right at that end where you left SNL and there was an expectation that you would do something and usually do something big right out of the gate. Did you feel that pressure when you left? Like, oh God, I got to be Will Ferrell. I got to be Sandler. Not really. I just had these two kids and just like, okay, let's just make sure they're okay and and I have families. So. I did documentary now. So clearly I wasn't like, I wasn't trying to make a bunch of money. Yeah. Yeah, I don't think it was like, this is going to this is like the old school of or whatever it is. You were doing movies too. And you were train wreck was the first one that I did right after that was the, oh, wow, I, you know, Jugg call me the lady man. Right. And so that's a great jet aperture. Usually gets a bigger laugh. You clearly worked on that a while. I work on it. So then I did that. And then the documentary now is where we put all our energy into right after we left the show. And there's no like, I've had this idea that I want to pitch you that I don't understand why it doesn't happen or why it hasn't been formalized because back in the day. Lauren would take people from SNL and he would produce with them. He would do movies sometimes based on sketches from the show sometimes not. But obviously he's slowed down on that he doesn't make the paramount movies anymore. No one has filled that gap. Right. And SNL is the biggest still the biggest incubator of comedy talent in the country. And there's nothing that there's not they don't take advantage of that after people leave the show. They don't help them. They don't produce with them. They don't develop. There are pods. There's like the item of K people, the Tina Bay people that, you know, that go off and do stuff together. But there's nothing formal around that like I'm for, first of all, I'm nominating you to do that. Great. I got to take every minute of my name later. I'm not not on the show. You don't have to do that. But you, but like there needs to there should be something where you get on SNL and when it's time to leave, then you produce with the show or you do stuff where they support you. Well, we did, I mean, documentary now Lauren was the thing back in the day. There was that and he and hot rod. He did the hot rod. Oh my god. That makes me so happy. That's the thing. Lauren used to do that. And now he doesn't. So somebody should be doing that. It's my point. Yeah. They should. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. Yeah. I was, yeah, part of the era that did it. And I don't know if it's because I mean, I'm speculating. I don't know. I don't know. I don't really know what I'm talking about. I think it's because people are so afraid to even like go close to stepping on Lawrence. I see you do that. And while until he retires, it will just be business usual. Whatever he wants to do. People will orbit around that. Yeah. I know he works with other people. I mean, I saw him in LA and he was sitting with, you know, somebody working out something. So, yeah. I don't want to get murdered. I was going to get I just get a picture of my child sleeping. I'm like, oh no. If you were going to get murdered, it would have been for not going to the reunion, which was very disappointing to me. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And you said you had a family or one of your daughters had something that night. Yeah. Well, our house burned down in the palace. Oh, well, that's oh, now who's the asshole? This guy. No, don't worry about it. No, it's like the, yeah, that our home's burned down. Yeah, we're fine. We're fine. But no, but I'm going to complain about no Stefan. There was no Stefan, but still there was no Stefan at the 50th. No, but I to be fair, I was before the house burned down. I was kind of going, I don't know. I was just, yes, my daughter had something going on. And I, I'm always, you know, resistant to go back. You know, I've always been that way. Yeah, I just I'm kind of twice. I did host twice. Yeah. But I don't know. I don't know what it is. And it changes. You might catch me in a moment where I'm like, fine. And anxiety or is it just a desire to move on? It's a bit of a bowl. I talked to my therapist better. It's like, you're really funny. You'd be great. You know, she's like, I know the house burned down. And I know you guys are living in a hotel, but Stefan. Like you now you're going to do it. Yeah. It's like, uh, yeah. I'm not going to say it. But have there ever, have there been moments in the culture where you see something going on in the news. And you say, I'd be really good doing that that person. Oh, I was never that person to be honest. I was, I, I would show up on Monday. And Seth Meyers would run up to me and go, oh, it's, you're going to do all those bits of this weekend. And I go, great. You know, or you're going to do James James Carville work on a James Carville. Or when there will be blood came out. I mean, you're going to we're doing the Danny Plainview. You go learn that. And I was much better in that where I, because I would get my head too much if I. But, but when I would see Dateline, is he like Keith Morrison that it's like, I'm just doing it around the house. You know, I'm in the shower going, oh, whatever. Or Alan Alder, whatever, you know, but. And you would come. Yeah. And then I would go, I can do Alan Alder and everyone who. And I go, come on. You know who fucking Alan Alder. But Lauren was always like, I just, just please do an impression of someone who's alive. Yeah. No more Vincent Price. That Vincent Price James Mason. Yeah. My audition was all. Yeah. Cause those are my favorite actors. Yeah. And you, you famously passed on as to find movie as well. Yeah. You're just denying us. You think you want that. You don't. Okay. You know what? It's funny. You said that before. But isn't that every SNL movie that was ever made? Like I would have said a Wayne's World movie would be the dumbest thing ever. Here's what John and I said, John Mulaney and I thought about it and we went, it bear it. It didn't work as a sketch. We tried it as a sketch and it worked with, with Ben Affleck and it played to total silence. Right. And people were going, what is this? And then we tried it with Bradley Cooper and it didn't go to air and they tried it again with Justin Timberlake and it didn't go to air. And so as like a last ditch effort, Doug Ables, who ran update one, I love, we didn't, we didn't have a name for it. I love that club kid guy you did. Do you want to do him on update? And I went, sure, not the movie club kid. That phone is a club kid. No. Club kid. You just gave some Oscar awards campaigner an idea. Yeah. Yeah. I'm going to like, yeah. This Oscar season's biggest. Yeah. Conan's going to call you for the Oscars. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Like I want. Yeah. Lauren's like, oh, you won't come back to host, but you'll do the fucking club. No, but, but yeah, so that's how that worked out. So we couldn't just, we tried to think about it and we just couldn't. Honestly, it just got too sad. Right. And you got really into Stefan's life. It was just really sad. Also, yeah, you don't, yeah, it's. And he's lying. Before thing is someone not being good at their job and lying. And then it's also me laughing. Like just people me laughing and John trying to make me break by doing weird, like turns afraid. I was just saying next week or this week, he hosted this week. Yeah. Do you go back and forth on ideas? Not really. I mean, he's such a good writer. I mean, I don't know what I would tell him that he wouldn't already know, but I am on a text chain with him and Jimmy Kimmel and Fred Armies and. Oh, he's the funniest. We all just, man, John is just the funniest guy on the planet. How many you seem like a guy who knows a lot of people and people like you and how many text chains are you on with Hollywood people? That's the main one. Oh, that really I would, I would guess dozens. No, I'm not. Yeah, I know. - Because again, Kimmel is on dozens, I think. - He is, yeah. I get, we were talking to us on the show. I get really the etiquette of it. And then I get, why didn't I get a ha-ha on that? But Fred got a ha-ha, and I got a ha-ha on Fred's thing, but he didn't ha-ha on my thing. And then I get in my head, you know, and so I-- - It's also kind of Kimmel's job to be friends with everybody. - Yeah, he wants us to come back to the show. He doesn't really like me. - He just wants to. - Every three years, he knows he's got to have you on the show. - I do have a nice one with, one of a nice text for a friend is Paul Giamatti's become a really good text friend. We just talk about books, and it's all just books. - Not books in and out? - No, no, no, no, oh not yet. - He famously goes in and out after all the award shows. - Yeah, no, not that. No, it just random books and we get very, and we don't talk on the phone. We just send voice text. So it's very funny game like-- - How did that start? - We just became friends. Paul Rudd said, "You would love Paul Giamatti because you guys read the same weird books." - What kind of books? - All books, no, like old MR James and weird ghost stories and weird sci-fi and strange tale stuff. And then strange crime books. And like we get very in the weeds. And so yeah, he and I have this very funny thing. We get very excited about talking about books. - Okay. - So it's not that exciting. - How closely do you follow the business, like the everyday ups and downs? - Not a lot. I talk to my agent, Julian, who's here. Julian, he's right there. - Yeah. - Julian thing. So Julian and I just say, "Julian, what's going on?" - And does he say that the market is hot for this? - Yeah, yeah. - You should be doing this because I gotta say-- - Doing, what are you doing and how do we position this in the right way and, you know, I think? - I gotta say your Wikipedia is a wild ride. That's what a lot of people tell me. - It's just, I mean, you've done a lot more than most people realize and you've done a ton of animation and you are a writer on South Park and you've popped up in a lot of different places. So what is the strategy to the career of Bill Hader? - I mean, the South Park thing for me is I wanted to learn how to write because I saw very early, if I could write, I could kind of control my destiny in town 'cause as an actor, you were just dependent on the scripts you were getting. And even though there's a great script, there's so many unknown variables. And I went, man, if I could learn how to write, well, one, I would be able to read these scripts better and understand how to give notes and I watch a lot of movies. And so because I watched a lot of movies, I thought I could write and it turned out I can't, you know, so I went to South Park and Pixar 'cause I had done stuff with them. And just sat in and learned to write and the South Park Room was the best screenwriting for those. - 'Cause they do it fast. - Yeah, and even if it's an episode about like, you know, (laughing) something insane, you know, it's still about emotion and trademark wrestling, you know that feeling you have when this happened, like how can we dramatize this feeling between two friends? And then the big thing they drill into is it's never this, this and this, it's this, leads to this, leads to this. So therefore this happens, so now this happens. And all these, all these kind of rules or whatever you want to call it, that lent itself to Barry big time. And then working with Alec Burg on Barry, I learned so much. And so how to write for television. - Do you think you could have directed a movie when you left us now, or did it take this whole journey? - No, I needed the journey. I think if I had made movies, so I moved out here and I actually lived right down the street on the top of Glen Rock. I lived, you know, if you go to the topic Glen Rock and there's like, do you know that the area at the very top, there's just a, where there's nothing there and there's like spray paint on the thing? Okay, there used to be an apartment there and I lived in that apartment. Yeah. - It was so nice they tore it down and didn't put it in there. - They tore it down, didn't tell them. Yeah, I brought my kids, I go, oh, you want to see where you say, hey, it's well, there's nothing there. And it's, you had your madman moment where you stood on the side and stared up. - Yeah, I know. If I had made something in it, it would have just been a movie about other movies. You know, it would have been, the inspirations would have been so obvious. And I had written scripts and friends would read it and go, there's a lot like this movie, which everybody starts out that way, but then once you start having, and I know it's the thing that drove me nuts, right, what you know, which I hated, but it is having a truth to it and having your own experience to put in it. So with Barry, as Alec Bergen, and I talking and me talking about SNL and how anxious that was in SNL, but I was really good at it, because I did impressions and I could be funny, but the irony was that it was, I wasn't sleeping, I was so nervous. And what I wanted to do was be a filmmaker and I was trying to get into that, but it wasn't really working. And I understood that emotion, and then we just made it, you know, a murderer trying to be an actor, but you still got that emotion as you could write to it. And that was, that really was what clicked for me. And I watched those guys do it in the South Park Room every week, those were the best episodes that I worked on, that was Matt and Tray talking about a guy they knew in college and how, you know, they had this weird falling out because of XYZ and that it, and it's like, oh, the boy should go through this. And the other thing that those guys do, which is interesting, I was like, why is, how can they get away with all this dark stuff? And, and the main character is always innocent. The main character is always a nice innocent person, you know, Book of Mormon. And he's like a nice guy who's just like, you know, looking at the world in a new way than you, you know, coming across all these horrible people. Yeah. Also, the animation thing helps you get away with it. Oh, yeah, yeah. That was real of you. Horrible. One thing I did notice, and I'm a cynical person looking at your Wikipedia, I always try to find people's paycheck jobs. I can't find a lot of paycheck jobs. Can't? I can't. There they are. Feel free to disclose that. I don't want to say it on the thing and then get a call. No, I'm not going to say it, but yeah, there's. The only one was you didn't do inside out two. Right. Apparently because they wouldn't pay you in Mindy. Right, right. Yeah, I can't get into that. Yeah, that was true. But now there's a couple movies that are one. There's one or two movies. I won't say which one that my agent's laughing so hard right now. Oh, there is one movie or two where I. Yeah, yeah, they're. Okay, thanks, but I don't want to say what they are because then. That's mean. I feel like I go, I thought. Yeah, right. I thought you loved our project. You told me this. Yeah, yeah, yeah. What's left for you to do? What's been in the drawer that you haven't been able to do? That you've always wanted to? Well, I like to make a movie that I'm not in. I'd like to direct. I haven't. I have some ideas that. I don't there's no part for me in it. And I'd like to. My favorite filmmakers are the people who swear, you know, the movies are never. They have the same kind of DNA, but the stories are different. And so that would be interesting. And I hope people see with the movie. People who have seen the movie. And we have had these friends and family screenings, which were very helpful. Those. Yeah, I could see how it was buried, but it's also so different than bury the themes of it and the feeling. And that that I would like to continue doing that. Well, I see you with Sundance then. I don't know. Hopefully they got it. Well, come on. I want to be there. They will take it. I will see. I. Yeah. I don't want to make you nervous. Oh, I'm nervous. The minute I showed up here. I was standing in the back going. I mean, that's the irony about me is I'm the very, I have massive, yeah, I get anxious on stage. And so people go, why didn't you stand up comedy? And I'm like, are you kidding? But I don't want to get too personal. What does your therapist say when that question is posed? That's the most personal question. Why is it that you do the thing that makes you so nervous? I'm trying to figure that out. I don't know. Yeah, you're good at a thing that, I mean, that's what Barry was about. You're like, oh, you know, but at some way, I'm good at a thing. And you got to push through. And then either friends are, oh, man, I see your friends are like, dude, shut the fuck. You're fine. Those are usually guys. Shut up, bro. Right. Just do it. Just do it. You're doing fine. Stop being a baby. Okay, we are back with the call sheet Craig. I went one for two last weekend. I went on a lift on Godzilla minus zero. I took the over. No, I took the under on 30. No, it took the under on 25. And it got to 31 bad. But I also hit on taking the under on 34 cat in the hat. And that was an easy one. Apologies to our guy, Bill Hader. I know apologies to Bill Hader. But yeah, we didn't really talk about that. This weekend, Johnny Depp. You ready for the deficits? I feel like some people are. I feel like what we learn in Hollywood is that most people don't really give a crap about personal issues. And we'll go to the movies if they like them as a movie star. Yeah, you know, it's interesting. I did some reporting on this movie in the summer. And it was because, you know, we don't know. talk about test screenings on this show because I think they are, it's irresponsible to report on most test screenings because that's what they are. They are tests. You are still working on the movie. It is not an indication of whether it will be good or ultimately bad, but this one was interesting because they tested, Paramount tested this movie in the summer specifically to see what people thought of Johnny Depp. And most lead characters in movies, they tested about a 67. That's a positive or high positive. Let me guess. Depp was in 80. 86. Yeah, two thumbs up. Very high for any actor. And the biggest group that loved him the most was women over 35. It's remarkable. You think that they would be the most put off by some of the personal behavior that came out in the amber herd trial and that has been reported about him over the past decade or so. Nope. They love him. Yes. I don't know what you say to that. Art from the artist or it's the fact that every time you see Depp on screen, he doesn't look like himself and he disappears behind characters who are doing again here. His persona is weird. It's not like this is sort of a shock to people that, oh my god, Johnny Depp's a weird guy with some pretty off-putting personal behavior. Like, that's not a shock to people. What's interesting though is that we'll see whether that translates into a good movie and be something that people will see. They curiously embargoed the reviews of this movie till Thursday before the Friday release, which is never a good sign. Where I'm not counting the psycho fans and ass kissers that they bring to the premiere and they do the first reactions. Those people don't matter. But this movie is not a huge risk for Paramount. They spent about 40 million to make it. Paid Depp about five. Wow. Five. I feel, I mean, I feel like for a long stretch of time, Johnny Depp was like one of the highest paid actors in Hollywood. This has to be his lowest fee in 25 years, right? For a Hollywood movie. Yeah, but he's been like banished. He was doing like European no-budget movies and like, you know, Dior ads. That was his business. Yeah. Like, he was not doing real movies. This is his on-trade back and he's got another movie coming out this next year called Daydrinker. That's why I bet on him. I picked him as one of my my buys at the buy-and-sell at the the stock market. Yes. Only in the world of the entertainment business. Not as a person. Yes. No, of course. Thank you, Craig. I'm not endorsing any of his personal behavior. But the tracking on this movie is about 20. And RG has it at 22. Screen dollars has it about 23, 24. I've seen lower. Let's set the line at 20. Well, you go first. You're the expert. I'm going to say over. Yeah, me too. I think it'll go over 20. I think that if anything tracking might be underestimating the Johnny Depp crowd and I don't know, ma'am canceled or not, I think over 20. Yeah, it's like his first big thing in a while. You know, this is like kind of a a Gothic ghost Christmas story. It's Thai West's directing who's like a horror guy. It's movies PG-13. I think this will have enough lucky lose if people interested in the genre. Plus Johnny Depp fans that I think it'll get over 20. Yeah, my only concern is the review embargo studios. We know what you're doing. If you put the embargo the day before release, we know you think it's not great or that critics aren't going to love it. But we'll see. Yeah, I just think that the the pent up curiosity for Depp and they've been plugging it pretty hard for. I think it's going to get to 20. Yeah, I know. All right, that's the show for today. I want to thank my guest Bill Hader, producer Craig Horobak, artistry's Jesse Lopez, and stuff from Los Angeles. I want to thank UCLA, Tom Newton, and the whole crew there. We'll see you next week.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Bill Hader reflects on his career evolution from SNL to directing his debut film *They Know*, a dark, divorce-themed horror movie that blends elements of *Barry* with independent filmmaking.
  2. He emphasizes the importance of creative control and final cut, highlighting how his experience with *Barry* gave him the confidence to pursue a film that traditional studios rejected.
  3. The film’s development involved strategic cuts by co-producer Alyssa Donovan and editor Ali Greer, echoing John Hughes’ approach of focusing on emotional core and storytelling efficiency.
  4. Hader notes that his transition from comedy to drama was driven by personal creative vision, not market demands, and that he values authenticity over commercial appeal.
  5. He criticizes the lack of post-SNL support systems, calling for formal development partnerships between SNL and its alumni to nurture talent and sustain creative momentum.
  6. Hader credits his success to learning screenwriting through *South Park*, where he discovered the power of emotional structure and narrative logic in shaping compelling characters.
  7. He remains committed to directing films rooted in personal truth and emotional resonance, with a desire to make a movie where he is not the lead.
  8. The episode concludes with a discussion on Johnny Depp’s strong audience reception in test screenings, underscoring how fan loyalty can persist despite personal controversies.

Summary:

Bill Hader, known for his work on *Barry* and *SNL*, discusses his journey into directing his debut film, *They Know*, a dark, divorce-centered horror film inspired by his experience with *Barry*. He credits the film’s success to creative autonomy and strategic cuts by his team, drawing from the storytelling techniques of *South Park* and John Hughes. Hader emphasizes that his career shift from comedy to drama was driven by authenticity and personal truth, not market demands.

He laments the absence of structured post-SNL support systems, urging for formal development partnerships to nurture talent. The episode also touches on his deep respect for collaborative storytelling and narrative structure, as well as the enduring fan loyalty seen in Johnny Depp’s test screenings, where audiences, especially women over 35, showed strong affection despite public controversies. Hader shares insights into his creative process, anxiety management, and his belief in films that explore emotional depth over spectacle, concluding with a hopeful outlook on the film's potential success and a call for greater industry support for emerging filmmakers.

FAQs

It's a horror movie featuring Bill Hader and Linda Cardellini as a couple going through a divorce, blending the tone of his show 'Barry' with a dark, emotional story.

He wanted full creative control, especially final cut rights, and the film's concept was seen as unusual by studios, making independent production a better fit.

The biggest difference is more time in post-production, allowing for deeper editing and refinement, which is less possible in the fast-paced environment of TV episodes.

The tone was influenced by his experience with 'Barry,' which often explored dark, emotional themes, even within a comedy framework, and the idea of a divorce in a horror context.

His co-producer, Alyssa Donovan, helped by identifying and cutting scenes that didn’t advance the story, a technique inspired by classic filmmakers like John Hughes who focused on essential, 'cutable' moments.

Yes, his anxiety and stage presence during SNL shaped his comedic instincts, and his experience with live performances helped him develop a nuanced, emotionally grounded humor.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.