Beyond Isotretinoin: Long Term Management, Controversies, and What’s Next in Acne
from The Spot Check
30m 7s
Dr. John Barbieri, a leading dermatologist and expert in acne management, discusses critical aspects of isotretinoin therapy in the second part of a two-part acne awareness series. He emphasizes that while isotretinoin can cause mood changes, robust data show it is actually linked to lower rates of depression and suicidality compared to other acne treatments, making it a safer choice for patients with acne-related mental health concerns. He debunks concerns about inflammatory bowel disease, noting no strong evidence links isotretinoin to increased risk and highlighting shared inflammatory pathways between acne and IBD. Routine lab monitoring is deemed unnecessary due to minimal and transient changes, with no documented serious adverse effects. For supportive care, Dr. Barbieri recommends simple, non-irritating products like moisturizers, humidifiers, and lubricating eye drops to manage side effects. He advocates for a patient-centered post-treatment plan, with many patients benefiting from topical retinoids to reduce recurrence anxiety, though long-term preventive efficacy remains unproven. Additionally, he reviews LED light therapy as a safe, effective adjunct to acne regimens, comparable in efficacy to benzoyl peroxide. Finally, he highlights emerging therapies—particularly fatty acid synthase inhibitors—as promising, well-tolerated treatments that could complement hormonal therapies and offer a non-antibiotic alternative for acne management. The conversation underscores the importance of balancing caution with clinical pragmatism, prioritizing patient well-being, and adopting evidence-based, individualized care.
(upbeat music)
You're listening to The Spot Check Podcast,
powered by Derm squared.
Ciao ragazzi, and welcome back to the latest episode
of The Spot Check Podcast,
your source for clinical insights you can use
in your practice the very next day.
I'm your host, Jamie Restivo,
board certified physician assistant,
and today we are continuing our special
two-part acne awareness month series
with Dr. John Barbieri.
In part one, we focused heavily
on optimizing isotretinoan outcomes.
Everything from dosing strategies and recurrence
to absorption and side-effect mitigation.
Today we're taking the conversation one step further
and diving into some of the most commonly debated
and rapidly evolving topics in acne management.
Once again, I'm joined by Dr. John Barbieri,
board certified dermatologist,
director of the Advanced Acne Therapeutics Clinic
at Brigham and Women's Hospital,
associate professor of dermatology
at Harvard Medical School, co-chair
of the American Academy of Dermatology Acne Guidelines Work Group,
and associate editor at JAMA Dermatology.
That is a mouthful.
Dr. Barbieri, welcome back for part two of this series.
- Thanks for having me again.
- It is such a delight.
I can't wait to get into this with you.
So we can not have a conversation
about isotretinoan without addressing
the elephant in the room.
Psychiatric safety.
How do you approach screening prior to initiation?
- Yeah, so I think let's just start with the data
on the really outcomes that we worry about,
which are like depression, anti-depressant use,
and suicidal use isotretinoan.
So first off, I really do believe that isotretinoan
can cause mood changes.
Both anecdotally, I feel like I've seen people
who have developed mood mobility, including sadness
and depression, as well as irritability from it
and have had improvement when they stopped it.
And there's certainly these challenge studies
that I think are compelling, where people take the drug,
they have these symptoms, they stop, they feel better,
they take it again, they recur.
So I really do think that this can happen.
That's the first thing, right?
That being said, when you look at the observational data,
so you look at these big core studies
that compare people who are treated with isotretinoan
versus people who get treated with other drugs,
like oral antibiotics, other treatments for monitor acne,
those who get treated with isotretinoan consistently
have lower rates of depression, anti-depressant use,
and suicidality.
So if the decision is to be an isotretinoan
or be on something else for acne,
they are, I think, the expected values,
you're actually less likely to get a psychiatric
comorbidity that are complication on isotretinoan
than other treatments.
And that's because acne itself is associated
with all of these mood symptoms.
And so that's, to me, a huge caveat
when making this decision-making.
We do have to be thoughtful about these side effects,
but from what should we do standpoint?
To me, someone who's depressed and is acne,
that's a reason to use isotretinoan,
not to be afraid of it.
Right.
And I'm so glad that you touched on that.
I mean, acne really impacts us in terms of just going out
to being social dating, applying for a promotion,
going to high school prom.
It impacts people more than one might think.
So we have to be really thoughtful
about approaching it aggressively
and taking it seriously.
Sometimes just a few pimples are enough to ruin someone's day.
So I do think the data is very supportive.
As you said, we do have to be mindful of this.
We have to counsel, we have to watch for it.
Some of the volatility or liability in the mood,
something we have to watch for,
and then re-challenging, I think,
is when we really take a step back and say,
maybe this isn't the right approach for you as an individual
because you've had this now on two occasions.
So do you tell the families, patients,
what to watch out for?
And if this happens, we stop you.
How do you approach that?
- Yeah, so I think two things to come up for.
One, if someone has pre-existing mood symptoms,
do you give them this medicine?
And I've seen some people who will require,
I don't know, like psychiatric clearance to be on the drug.
And to me, that doesn't make a ton of sense
'cause again, the expectation of this drug is improved mood.
So I think someone who has baseline depression
or anxiety or mental health comorbidies
and 20% of people with acne
have these mental health comorbidies.
It speaks to the incredible impact
that this condition can have on individuals.
To me, that's a reason to just use it.
Making them have to go find a mental health professional
which can be incredibly hard to do,
can be stigmatizing in and of itself,
to be allowed to be on the drug.
I don't think it's practical.
If they have a mental health professional work with great
to coordinate care to collaborate with them,
but I don't think requiring them to get like approval
to be on this drug makes a lot of sense to me.
I think if you think it's right medicine for them,
they think it's right medicine, just do it
and don't make them go through the steps.
That being said, I do think it's important
to counsel about these things
and I talk about really mood swings
to be the main ones to depression sadness,
but I also think ear to ability can happen.
And so I talk about both of those
and mentioning, if you're feeling those things,
please let me know.
This medicine might not be the right one for us
and we can think about we have lots of other options
and if they have, if they're an adolescent,
working together with their parents
to keep an eye out for these things too.
- These are all really good points
if they're connected with psychotherapy,
making their parents aware that hey,
be mindful of these.
Let us know if these things are happening.
I think that the biggest issue here
is the medical legal aspect.
So it's a CYA, cover your Toshy Tosh Tosh.
So if they are aligned with the medical professional,
maybe they're on an antidepressant getting kind of approval
from their pediatrician or PCP and saying,
hey, is this well managed before we started?
I think a lot of clinicians will do that,
but it does delay treatment.
So I personally think this is a CYA issue
because that just comes down to the crux of it.
- Yeah, I can appreciate the medical legal concerns.
Why people do it?
- I'm not sure there's ever been a successful lawsuit
against the dermatologist on that basis.
Well, I've not seen that.
I mean, there's all that gray literature of legal stuff
and I will pretend to be a legal scholar,
but I don't think it's a common reason
for malpractice suits.
And the other thing is,
you know, I think if you have adequate documentation
about the risks and it helps create that medical
legal protection and you have a good relationship
with the patient that again,
that's probably the biggest predictor of medical legal things.
- Yes, that is true.
- I can totally appreciate that concern,
but I'm not sure that it's that grounded
in something that's likely to happen.
And I think there is likely harm
that happens from delaying things.
Like we talk about the need to start it
because of scarring and then we're delaying it
because of this medical legal concern site.
I do think we're a little bit overly cautious there
by totally understanding where people come from too.
- It is a very litigious aside.
And I do think unfortunately that can get in the way
of prescribing some of these medications.
So but I appreciate your approach there.
I think it's a very pragmatic approach
and one that our listeners can benefit from hearing
from an expert like yourself.
So talk to me, we talked a little bit in segment one
about IBD inflammatory bowel disease.
So all sort of colitis and Crohn's disease.
What is your counseling with patients in that regard?
- Yeah, some people bring it up
and then I'll talk about more.
And people don't, I've described really briefly,
which is that there have been some concerns about
inflammatory bowel disease that's got health problem
with this medication.
Unfortunately and the data that we have,
the most rigorous observational studies trying to look at
does this medicine actually increase someone's risk?
There doesn't seem to be any compelling evidence
that it causes a meaningful increase
in risk of these conditions.
And front people, they're happy there.
There's some people we dive into it more.
- It really depends and there's no causation or causality
between your own isotretino and you are therefore
going to get IBD.
So we have to be thoughtful about that.
And then there's some recent genetic research
that suggests that acne and inflammatory bowel disease,
so all sort of colitis, Crohn's may actually share
overlapping immune and inflammatory pathways.
In other words, acne itself may reflect
a broader systemic inflammatory profile
rather than the relationship being driven by isotretino.
And so I think it's worth mentioning that patients
that have acne may be at greater risk for IBD.
- Yeah, 100%.
We've done some of that work too,
showing that association between acne
and inflammatory bowel disease, just those two conditions.
And they share some inflammatory pathways like IL-17.
So it totally makes sense mechanistically
and then there's both some genetic data,
Mendelian randomization data, it supports that,
and some epidemiologic data support that association.
The other thing here too is like the antibiotics
that people get.
- There you go.
- You know, oral antibiotics,
there's been some associations with inflammatory bowel disease.
And so if you get oral antibiotics,
and you get isotretino, and people like the blame
isotretino for anything bad that happens,
it's sort of just this like unfortunate.
Because it has some real side effects,
it kind of gets blamed for all sorts of things
that it probably doesn't do too.
- Yes.
- And so, you know, that's the thing you see
when you look at the literature on this,
studies that don't really adequately consider
prior antibiotic exposure are more likely
to identify potential associations
between isotretino and inflammatory bowel disease
and studies that do.
So I do think that's a really important caveat
when considering this literature
and also considering your choices.
Like if you can be on doxycycline or isotretino
and your fears inflammatory bowel disease,
I would pick isotretino and every time.
- And day.
- Yep.
And you know, there are other patients out there
that are like, oh, give me more doxycycline.
It's like, no, this is going to put out the fire
when we take this away,
that acne-causing bacteria,
populations are gonna come right back.
So this is just kind of the one-border topicals,
give that time to work,
and we are taking those antibiotics away.
So I think that's a really good point.
And, you know, patients in the old days,
you know, when I was offered isotretino
and I had to fail, you know, a bajillion things out there.
Now I think clinicians are more steadfast
in offering this, you know, before they normally would.
So if they're scarring psychosocial impact,
we're choosing this option a little bit earlier
than we have maybe in the past.
but those are really good points.
Are you monitoring for any GI symptoms
when patients are coming in for follow-up
or are you asking them certain questions?
And if so, walk me through that.
- I actually asked if they're having any stomach pain.
I won't get too much into it again,
'cause I don't think it's a really clear association.
So I'm not like searching for something
that I don't really expect to happen anyway.
- Right.
- So if they bring it up, you know, we'll look into it,
but I'm not necessarily just like
really trying to find a you there.
I'm not like every visibly like,
are you having blood in your stool?
If you ain't change this here about,
like I'm not going to like that kind of detail,
I just like, do you have any, you know, abdominal pain?
You have any belly pain?
- Just kind of as an overhead bird's-eye view,
just inquiring about it.
- Yeah.
- I think that's a good approach,
because sometimes the more you talk about something,
the more they think it's gonna happen,
and the more they kind of bring it to fruition.
So that can be a dangerous approach to.
Your approach is very calm and collected,
and if there's an issue, you address it.
If it's not an issue, you don't go after it.
So we alluded to labs in part one,
and I think this is where practices here
seem to vary dramatically.
Historically, many of us were trained at monitor labs,
very aggressively throughout isotretino.
And so baseline labs, monthly labs, what is your approach?
- Yeah, my kind of baseline approach is to check,
really an ALT, though often I'll check in ALT and ASD,
and then a triglyceride, so often I'll check
a lipid panel just because of some ordering practicalities
at baseline, and then again, at peak dose.
So basically, I'll check ASD, ALT, and lipids
at baseline in peak dose.
And if those are both really acceptable,
we can talk about what to me that is,
which is true in about 99.7% of people,
I won't check any further labs.
That's sort of my baseline.
There might be some individuals where we monitor things
more closely, where we monitor some extended labs.
There might be some people where I monitor no labs,
depending on certain circumstances,
and we can kind of talk about what those might look like.
- Very bold, Dr. Barbier.
(laughing)
- But you know, you believe in this therapy.
- Think about this a few years ago.
- It is such a hot topic.
It's so different from every clinician,
from every practice, and I wish that there were something
that we could hang our hat to and say,
"Okay, look, this is what we're gonna do in every patient."
But that's the way medicine is, we have to individualize.
So to your point, when you're doing ASD, ALT,
you're doing a lipid from practicality,
'cause we're really watching that triglycerides,
what numbers start to freak you out and say,
"Okay, we might have to stop or do a dose reduction."
- Yeah, their triglycerides are going to like 400, 500 or more.
That's where I start to feel like,
"Okay, are we doing this really fast thing?"
'Cause sometimes that can influence it.
And do we need to think about adjusting dose thing,
or using other adjuvant things to try to address that?
- Right.
- Exactly.
- And then for ASD and ALT,
if they start becoming really just above normal,
then we start to think about it.
But, you know, we look at the data of these,
so just changes in labs.
Changes in ASD and ALT are just as likely
before people start like having a normal lab
will happen to about 1% of people.
And it's just as common before they start is on treatment.
So I think a lot of this is background noise,
not a really meaningful impact of the drug.
There's not really any clear evidence
that it does anything meaningful.
And there's basically zero reports ever
of someone having a lasting liver injury.
So like, Turbinephine,
like people get their case reports
of like, hepatic failure in the hospital.
They're just are not those case reports that I said try to know.
There's lots of like,
their ASD was like 2x the upper limit of normal
and then it was normal again.
But there's none of this like real liver problem
kind of stuff coming up.
And so for checking ASD and ALT,
it tried to prevent like a real meaningful liver thing.
And those things don't even seem to happen.
Is this a valuable practice?
- Right, and what's the cost to healthcare?
So it's like, why are we checking these labs?
I mean, to your point,
it might be an incidental finding.
Maybe they took a little Tylenol or, you know,
something else happened on in the background.
So actually we're trying to get all kinds of things
can make these mildly elevated.
- Exactly.
So we're doing these labs and it's like,
okay, how is this actually going to impact
our clinical management?
And sometimes it's just kind of another burden.
So, you know, maybe you can work on that, Dr. Barbier.
He put out, you know, guidelines for labs
that we can all follow because I think
it's a really tough issue.
And you know, Turbinephine,
you can check labs before, during, after,
it doesn't predict who's going to have an issue.
That's the other thing about checking.
Do you check CBC with differential?
Talk to me about that.
- Yeah, so I don't check CBC with differential at all.
And that's because there's been a variety of studies
highlighting that there's really no meaningful changes
to CBC parameters I used to try and know on.
There's not really clear evidence
that there's any meaningful rates of, like,
leukopenia and cytopinias
and through what people worry about.
There's certainly a couple of like case reports
out there about it.
But just looking at more population-based data sets,
it's extraordinarily rare if it happens.
And it just doesn't seem like a high-value practice.
And it's unclear if it's even meaningful.
- Excellent, love it.
That was fantastic.
So we're going to continue this rapid fire episode.
I want to talk to you a little bit
about your favorite supportive therapies.
Because patients are always asking,
what can I actually use while I'm on the medicine?
We tell them upfront, you're going to have dry eyes,
you're going to have dry nose,
you're going to have dry skin, dry lips.
And to some effect, we want that to happen
because it indicates absorption.
If the patient before you does not have
a little bit of that going on,
we wonder about are you actually taking it?
Is it getting absorbed?
You know, and I think the shift with skincare
has really been a focus on supporting the barrier.
When I was younger, it was like strip the barrier.
If it doesn't sting, it doesn't burn, it's not working.
And that's just not the way it is.
We need to support the skin barrier.
Patients tolerate their therapy better.
They're more adherent and we have better results.
So I'm curious as to what your approach is.
Do you have any go-to cleansers that you like to recommend?
- Yeah, so I mean, the first thing,
a little what you're getting at,
making sure they're not doing stuff that's causing a problem.
'Cause especially now,
there's so much of like, I saw this product on TikTok
and it's like a good product, so I'm using it.
And so I think everything has to have a purpose
so I tell people, if this doesn't have a role, don't do it.
Don't do it because you're supposed to use a serum,
do it 'cause it's trying to accomplish something.
So that's the first thing is like,
I basically just want people using cleanser, moisturizer,
and sunscreen, and I used to trend on.
And not really anything else unless it's
to like address dispigmentation or something.
So, cleansers, I don't think matter that much honestly.
Like, just get something that's affordable,
that's, you know, has a hydrating kind of cindet cleanser
and there's lots of those and that you like to use.
That's to me it.
So like, just pick a brand that you like
that you can get that isn't too expensive
and that isn't something like,
don't use like ivory soap on your face.
But as are like, you know,
Ios friend or something like that.
But outside using things that are really like harsh
and drying, most like cleansers are gonna be fine
in my perspective.
Do you send them home with samples?
Do you verbalize like, hey, these are some options?
Or you just kind of let the patient decide
what they're going to use?
I guess that's my question.
I give them a list of options.
I have a handout and I'm like,
people often ask me about cleansers,
moisturizers, and sunscreen.
And here's some ones that I like.
And if you have ones you like, that's awesome.
But in case you're looking for suggestions
here or some you can use.
So that's what I do.
We don't really have great samples in our office
because of where we are and all that,
which is a general, I think, limitation
of sometimes academic practice places.
So that is not as easy to do though.
I do think it'd be helpful
'cause then they can try it out.
They can like see the bottle
or if you have those little sheets that are like here,
you can check it out.
I do think those things are really nice.
I don't totally have access to that stuff unfortunately.
So I just give them this handout.
- Okay, so, but I think to your point being intentional,
I mean, we see, you know,
kids that are like 11 to 13,
they're using vitamin C, retinoids.
They have a 13 step, you know, drunk elephant routine.
And it's like, oh my god,
your barriers are just gonna be totally out of whack.
So you basically give them a handout
and just make sure that they're being intentional
about the products they're using.
- Yeah, have a plan, not trying to pick great products,
have a great plan.
- Right, exactly.
What do you like for lips, key lightest?
Do you have any favorites there?
- Just, you know,
ointment kinds of things.
So, you know, Vaseline, Aquaforce,
Airway Healing Ointment,
pick your favorite, one of that kind of product class.
- Okay, perfect.
- I tend to have to use those
as opposed to like a chapstick kind of thing.
- Yes, oh certainly.
- And then I'm prescribed them hydrocortisone,
like point, 2.5% ointment sometimes,
if it's more bothersome.
- And do you like the Cordy Bomb?
I have a lot of patients ask about that.
- Yeah, I think that can be a great,
like actually on my handout I have those,
like if you want to try in your own,
like next step thing for dry lips,
you can go and buy that kind of a product.
Or you can tell me and I can prescribe you something,
which sometimes works a little better
and a little less expensive.
- Okay, perfect.
And dry eye, we talked about the Omega-3 in part one
of the series.
What else do you like for dry eyes?
Anything in particular over the counter prescription?
- Yeah, I think those lubricating eyedrops
and I'm no expert in ophthalmology,
so I go out but some of the ophthalmology people
have told me like refreshing, sustain or good.
- Yeah, they're great.
- But not that I have independently verified
that I like science,
those are the best for anything like those lines.
- Yeah, I think, you know, that's common practice.
So the artificial tears, there's some out there
that are more of like an ointment base.
So I have dry eye, these are some of the things
that my eye doctors have recommended over the years.
So like sustain has an ointment
that you can put on at night.
Gentile has an eye gel that's a little bit more,
you know, thick, it's an ointment based.
So this can be helpful.
And nose, like nasal dryness, nose bleeds,
what do you like there?
- Yeah, so, you know,
humidifier can be helpful and make the air
and the environment less especially.
I'm in the northeast of the winters here
can be pretty dry.
So humidifier can be something the bedroom can be helpful.
There are these nasal saline moisturizers,
which I think can be a little helpful
to kind of like these nose spray type things.
- Yeah. - I actually really like to use
these sort of nasal like gel moisturizers,
which are almost basically like super sergy loop
in the end.
And I thought that was to be incredibly,
but the point of asking your nose is like yucky.
These aren't, don't feel as bad.
And I really do think they work quite well.
I've used them a lot and had good success with them
for people with dry nose and nose bleeds
and even just like oxygen in the hospital dry nose
kind of stuff.
Oh definitely. And you like the Neal Med. Is that one that you recommend the nasal gel?
That's one. I think there's lots of products similar to that. That's an easy to find one that's
pretty affordable. Excellent. Those are great pearls. And do you tell patients to avoid anything if
they're like, "Hey, can I do a sal acid wash, BPO wash? Are you telling them to avoid that?"
Generally, so both, as we talked about in the first session, for those that will actually go
check it out. But for me, I still try not to be clear on nothing because I go as long to
remission. So I don't want them using products with active in it because then I don't know
where they actually clear or not. I don't want them to have to keep using them long-term. So I want
them to be off of that stuff for that reason. And because they're irritating, it's often that
just exacerbate things. I say, "This medicine is so good at treating acne that I don't want you
doing anything else because all those things are going to do is give you more side effects."
Perfect. I think there's a really good clinical pearls that we can implement in the office.
So post-acerotretinone protocols, it's eerie to me that there's no maintenance protocol that
happens. And I think a lot of the problem with that is patients really think this is a quote-unquote
cure. They're never going to have a pimple afterwards or permanently cured. And in the study
that we talked about in part one, there's a meaningful subset of patients that go on to fill
topical prescriptions oral medications that may even require a second course of medication.
So a vizotretinone, excuse me. So we need to be putting them on some kind of maintenance therapy.
I personally like to use a lot of araslo. And again, no conflict of interest there. I think it's
a very effective medication. It's much better tolerated due to the formulation. And it does a
great job with cleaning up any post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, scarring, texture. What do you
like? Is there certain topicals that you reach for every single time? Do you have a standard
approach? Yeah. So what do you do there? Because everything I will share is my favorite topical
too in terms of topical red noids. For me, again, because Michael is to have long-term
mission, I will often people do nothing because a lot of them, that's their goal. I want to think
about acting anymore. So if I'm using these acne products, it's still in my mind. So I want them
really to be like, this is not in your life anymore. And interesting. I like to give them a chance
to do that because we don't have any data that doing anything afterward prevents recurrence. We
have it, you know, it can treat the recurrence. You don't notice it, but not that immediately prevents
it so it doesn't happen. So for me, I encourage people to do nothing. And if things come back then,
I'll add the, you know, topical red noid, whatever, you know, we think we want to do next.
But there are people who are like really scared. They're like, right. Exactly. When I stop this,
I'm so worried, Max, it's going to go back. And those people who are feeling that way, I'll often
start them on a topical red noid. You know, pick your favorite topical red noid product. Exactly.
I do think that's a good next step. And what we just don't know is is doing that change the
trajectory of things. Does it make it so if they were going to have a recurrence, they don't,
or is it just treating the recurrence, they were going to have anyway. So that's the thing we don't know.
And that's why I encourage people to do that thing.
So I have the patients that are like, Jamie, I don't want another pimple. So I, you know,
I'm the type of individual who, especially, you know, like if it's an older patient, female,
they're getting these undergrounders. It's been difficult to treat their acne before I
used to treat noid and they've been on every topical and systemic known to man. And they're really
panicked about having acne. I will say, look, you know, we should start you on this.
It'll get any nuisance stuff that you could, that could arise thereafter. It can help with pigment,
you know, anti-aging, scarring, texture. I mean, the benefits go on and on when we talk about
red noids. So I think we have to be thoughtful. Yeah, they're an easy sound, especially people
have like sequelae still like red marks or dry marks. We might want to use as like acid,
red noids or different things to help address that. So totally, there's lots of things you
want to add to a dress sequelae. And I agree, those people who are worried about recurrence,
just giving them something and like make them feel a little extra safe, I think is helpful.
Yes, busy hands are happy hands. So give them something to do. Give them, you know,
one of your favorite sunscreens that you like to help declare up to Scromia, you know,
you can't go wrong. You're going to help with photo-aging and patients are happy. But I think it's
interesting that you kind of do like a wait and see approach because to your point, you know,
you're giving them the straw because you want them to get better. So you want to see if they're
getting better. But it's, it's everyone's approach is unique. So that's why I'm always just
elated to have these discussions because it's interesting to see what people do out in the trenches
out in the wild. So I appreciate your approach. I think both of us that comes back to the patient
in the end with this, you know, it's really definitely is the patient sick of using red noids
and that's why they're on ice a trend on or do they actually like to use things and be active
about stuff. And I think that's the key to distinguishing factors. What is the patient's goal?
Yes, we have to be very patient centric. So yes, she hit the knee on the head with that one.
And as always, we are running out of time because I just want to pick your brain about everything
known to manacutane. So before we wrap up, I just want to touch on a few rapidly trending acne
topics. So patients, they're constantly asking about these LED light therapy devices, ads are so
prominent on social media apps, you know, they're constantly popping up. What are your thoughts on these
devices? Did they actually provide meaningful benefit? Or are they just type? I think they work,
we just did a systematic review on this topic. And they seem to be about as effective as like
benzoproxide. So like, are they ice a trend? No, no. But can they like play a role in acting
regimen and they very well tolerate it? Yeah. So for someone with more mild acne or needs a little
bit extra around the edges and isn't quite there or has more sense of skin, I think you need a
great option. If you're going to do it, you want both red and blue light because the studies show
that the two colors together work better than either alone. And what we don't know is what's the
best device because almost none of the ones on the market have clinical trials. So we're basically
all basing this on other studies for other devices. But I would look for something that's
modestly priced like that's $50 is probably not enough flu and so work. If it's $1,000 is probably
more expensive than it needs to be. And something that's red and blue, that would be the way I think
about this. And something in the middle, you know, cost cost price point to. So something not
exuberantly expensive, but something that's, you know, not extremely cheap that's going to burn
your face off. So, you know, kind of going right in the middle there. But patients ask about it.
And, you know, you're basically saying it's, it's about equivalent to one over the counter,
like a BPO. Yeah, like any single Asian topical regimen, it's about that effective.
As effective as retinoids? Well, retinoids are about the same as
benzoproxide in, you know, network metanalysis. So I would say so. Okay, that's a good, good
thing to know to tell patients. They're a little different though. Like, you know, someone
that's comedones, probably not as good. Like, retinoids, if someone's like a million comedones,
retinoids are amazing. But just like on average, it's about the same as any single Asian topical
thing. Okay, so that's, that's a good kind of pearl to tell patients. Like, if you want to use it
and make sure you're going kind of middle of the range, you know, I don't think it's going to work
wonders. But if it's something that you have the time and money to invest in and you want to do
it, it's not going to be harmful, right? Yeah. Is what you're saying? Exactly. Okay.
And then lastly, what emerging therapies or developments are on the horizon and the acne pipeline
that really have you very excited? Anything we should be watching for? I'm really excited about
these fatty acid synthase inhibitors and in full disclosure, I've done some work for some of the
companies that are developing them. But, you know, these are really interesting. They block
some of the pathways similar to like what we're trying to do with anti-androgen therapy,
but a little bit further down. So instead of rocking like the hormones that are turning on,
the way we're like blocking the oil gland and they seem to end some of the clinical trials from
China to work a little bit better than oral antibiotics. But you can use them in men and women.
They're pretty well tolerated. They cause a little bit of dryness, but not like Isatranone kind of
level dryness. So I think they'll be a really great addition to our treatment armantarium, especially
for male patients where we can't use hormonal therapy and can complement hormonal therapy too. So
I think a lot of times where we use oral antibiotics, these might be a great alternative.
And, you know, some people see me talk about dermatologists, for example, oral antibiotics and
any other specialty medicine. And also that's right. So it would be great to have some more
non-anabetic options that aren't Isatranone because that's not right for everyone that work really well.
Right. Exactly. Do you think it's going to be kind of Isatranone, maybe efficacy without the
side effects or we're just not there? I think not quite there. I think it's like a little bit better
than oral antibiotics. So not Isatranone, but really effective and quite tolerated. It seems like
another tool in our toolbox. So yeah, we'll look forward to seeing more on that. And it's so
exciting. We've had so many novel therapeutics for acne. I love treating acne. It's a huge part
of what I do. So I'm always excited when I have a new toy to play with and then something else in
the toolbox. So Dr. Barbiri, thank you again for joining me for this two-part acne awareness
month series. This has been exceptional. I know that our listeners are going to benefit from
both of these episodes. There's so many pearls in there. So very insightful. Such a joy to have you
and we would love to have you quite possibly in the future because I know we didn't get through
everything I wanted to talk to you about today. So thank you to our listeners as well for tuning in
to yet another episode of the spot check podcast. If you found these conversations helpful,
help us continue to grow this podcast by subscribing or following on your favorite podcast platform.
Downloading the episodes for easy future reference. These are ones you're going to want to review
believe me and sharing them with colleagues and trainees who may benefit from these discussions.
Graziemi Liragatsi. And as always, I look forward to bringing you more clinical insights in our next
episode. So stay tuned. Ciao, ciao. Looking for more conversations like this one. Don't stop here.
Explore the full lineup of podcasts from Derm squared where dermatology industry leaders,
innovators and experts share insights you won't hear anywhere else.
Visit Derm squared dot com slash podcasts.
(upbeat music)
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Isotretinoin can cause mood changes like depression or irritability, but observational data show it is associated with lower rates of psychiatric comorbidities compared to other acne treatments.
Patients with pre-existing mental health conditions should not be denied isotretinoin due to legal or procedural barriers; instead, it may be a beneficial treatment given the psychosocial impact of acne.
There is no strong evidence that isotretinoin increases the risk of inflammatory bowel disease, and shared inflammatory pathways suggest acne and IBD may reflect a broader systemic inflammatory profile.
Routine lab monitoring (ALT, AST, lipids) is generally unnecessary for most patients, as changes are common and transient, with no documented cases of serious liver injury.
CBC with differential is not recommended due to lack of meaningful changes or evidence of hematological adverse effects.
Supportive therapies like moisturizers, humidifiers, and lubricating eye drops are essential to manage dryness and improve patient adherence.
A post-isotretinoin maintenance protocol is needed to address recurrence risk; topical retinoids are often recommended for patients with anxiety about relapse, though evidence on long-term prevention is limited.
LED light therapy is as effective as topical benzoyl peroxide and can be a safe adjunct for mild to moderate acne, while fatty acid synthase inhibitors represent a promising, well-tolerated future therapy with broad applicability.
Summary:
Dr. John Barbieri, a leading dermatologist and expert in acne management, discusses critical aspects of isotretinoin therapy in the second part of a two-part acne awareness series. He emphasizes that while isotretinoin can cause mood changes, robust data show it is actually linked to lower rates of depression and suicidality compared to other acne treatments, making it a safer choice for patients with acne-related mental health concerns.
He debunks concerns about inflammatory bowel disease, noting no strong evidence links isotretinoin to increased risk and highlighting shared inflammatory pathways between acne and IBD. Routine lab monitoring is deemed unnecessary due to minimal and transient changes, with no documented serious adverse effects. For supportive care, Dr.
Barbieri recommends simple, non-irritating products like moisturizers, humidifiers, and lubricating eye drops to manage side effects. He advocates for a patient-centered post-treatment plan, with many patients benefiting from topical retinoids to reduce recurrence anxiety, though long-term preventive efficacy remains unproven. Additionally, he reviews LED light therapy as a safe, effective adjunct to acne regimens, comparable in efficacy to benzoyl peroxide.
Finally, he highlights emerging therapies—particularly fatty acid synthase inhibitors—as promising, well-tolerated treatments that could complement hormonal therapies and offer a non-antibiotic alternative for acne management. The conversation underscores the importance of balancing caution with clinical pragmatism, prioritizing patient well-being, and adopting evidence-based, individualized care.
FAQs
Isotretinoin can cause mood changes like depression or irritability, but observational data show it is associated with lower rates of depression and suicidality compared to other acne treatments. Clinicians should counsel patients about mood changes and encourage early reporting, especially in those with pre-existing mental health concerns. Requiring psychiatric clearance is not recommended, as it may delay necessary treatment and is not supported by evidence.
There is no compelling evidence that isotretinoin increases the risk of IBD. Studies show no clear causation, and some research suggests acne and IBD may share overlapping inflammatory pathways. The concern may be overstated, especially when considering that prior antibiotic use is linked to IBD risk. Isotretinoin is often a safer choice than long-term antibiotic use for acne management.
Baseline and peak-dose checks for ALT, AST, and triglycerides are recommended. Triglycerides above 400–500 mg/dL warrant dose adjustment. Elevations in liver enzymes are common and often benign, with no reported cases of lasting liver injury. Routine CBC with differential is not recommended due to lack of meaningful changes in patient populations.
Patients should use gentle cleansers, moisturizers, and sunscreen. For dry lips, ointments like Vaseline or Aquaphor are preferred over chapsticks. For dry eyes, lubricating eye drops like Sustaine or Gentile gel are recommended. Nasal dryness can be managed with humidifiers and nasal gel moisturizers like Neal Med. Avoiding active ingredients like salicylic acid or benzoyl peroxide is advised to prevent irritation.
There is no evidence that maintenance therapy prevents recurrence, but it can help manage post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation and scarring. For patients anxious about relapse, a topical retinoid like tretinoin may be added to provide reassurance and improve skin texture, though its impact on recurrence prevention is unclear.
LED light therapy (blue and red light) is about as effective as benzoyl peroxide or topical retinoids. It works well for mild acne and as an adjunct treatment. Devices should be moderately priced, with red and blue light combinations being most effective. It is safe and well-tolerated but should not be expected to replace core acne therapies.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.