Go back

Bernhard Goetz

43m 52s

Bernhard Goetz

Ash and Elena open with a lighthearted, surreal story about accidentally stepping into a pile of unknown debris in Brooklyn, which leads to a rain puddle hand-washing ritual and a bizarre encounter with a New York store owner joking about their "poop pants." The anecdote underscores the absurdity and humor in everyday misfortunes, serving as a contrast to the more serious narrative that follows. Transitioning to Bernard Goats, the story details a man who, after repeated muggings and systemic indifference from law enforcement, becomes increasingly paranoid and ultimately shoots four teenagers on a subway train in 1984, claiming self-defense. While Bernard believed he was being robbed, witnesses dispute the provocation, and the incident is marked by ambiguity and conflicting accounts. The public reaction is divided—some see Bernard as a tragic hero fighting a broken system, while others criticize his actions as racially biased and unjust, especially given that the victims were Black youths. Though Bernard was eventually acquitted of the most serious charges due to procedural and testimonial issues, he was found liable for reckless conduct. The victims, all teenagers, suffered severe injuries and filed civil lawsuits, with one receiving a ruling that Bernard acted with excessive cruelty. Despite the legal and moral fallout, Bernard later became a vegan activist and advocate for city squirrels, symbolizing a shift from violence to advocacy. The story illustrates how trauma, systemic failure, and public perception can warp justice and memory, ultimately emphasizing the complexity of human behavior, accountability, and societal judgment.

Transcription

8086 Words, 42489 Characters

English
hey weirdos i'm ash and i'm elena and this is morbid it is what's up motherfuckers hey you guys saw what we were talking about last week we had ethan hawk on the show it was so awesome it was crazy he's one of the coolest people i've ever truly we've been knocking it out of the park with who we've gotten to talk to i don't understand what life is no it's very surreal and strange um when he came in he said hi i'm ethan hawk and i was like wow i wanted to say hi i'm ashkel but that doesn't hold the same weight it just doesn't feel the same not yet not yet watch out world watch out ethan hawk i'm coming for you for your neck he's like not going back on that show like wow he's like that girl was weird he was awesome he was great he was so like not that i expected him not to be awesome but like you don't know what to expect going into something like that yeah i didn't know he was going to be so profound and so lovely to talk to yeah i felt spiritually enlightened when we left yeah until i stepped in a pile of shit until i stepped in a pile of shit yeah and here's the thing i posted about it on instagram yeah i posted about it on instagram yeah i posted about it on instagram here's the thing too talk to me i was gonna tell you not to i know debbie was like oh my god that's so funny like you have to put that on and i was like you're right it's hilarious that i stepped in i was like yeah surely that will be a fun anecdote 99 of people were like oh my god that's always the way and people were like did you roll in it like out of this house because it went everywhere yeah and if you didn't see this on instagram i'll tell you the story four of you were like you're the most materialistic stupid bitch i've ever met you should die because i threw my shoes away here's the thing i was like oh my god that's so funny i was like oh my god that's the thing i don't know if that was dog shit or human shit it's new york city it's new york concrete jungle could be filled with human shit as well as dog or really any kind of animal well and here i'll do you one better let hear me you can do whatever the fuck you want with the things that you buy for yourself so if you want to throw away your pair of shoes that has shit all over it yeah you are allowed to and here's the thing i could debbie and elena as my witness i couldn't get all the shit that's the thing it was and again we didn't know if it was human shit we didn't know so yeah because we don't know where that was is it still in my purse yeah is my purse in my garage right now yeah but i gotta figure that out yeah you gotta figure that one out some people thought that i was throwing away my purse yeah which i was like come on guys and again this is like four people yeah four people i was it was just like this but i do need but i just knew that no you i knew it i said i was like so many people are gonna think this is as funny as we think because like that's the majority of our audience but there's there's those four people yeah that are gonna be like you suck that's why you shouldn't wear shoes ash fuck you i was like oh okay but but so for those who didn't see this on instagram i stepped in a pile of shit somewhere somehow didn't realize it in brooklyn to be specific didn't realize it got into a car and my purse was on the ground so then we got to the next destination i picked up my purse which now had questionable shit all over it it got on my hands i then had to wash my hands in a new york rain puddle so i have like some kind of flesh-eating amoeba now i bet it was pouring rain and i was like i have to get this shit off my hands at the very least you got stew then we went into a store to get new shoes and i made friends with a lady and i said she was great she was so nice and i she was fantastic and i was like can i give you a hug like you were an angel in a time of need and she goes with your poop pants which is the most new york shit i've ever heard like she was just like what with your poop she's like come in here cover the poop and i didn't i truly i truly went in there and she like paraded me around to other people trying to get them to help me and they were like no they really got the fuck out of here it was so ridiculous it was insane but sometimes a story is just a funny story oh exactly and that's all it needs to be exactly we all gotta lighten up a little bit i do think that my great-grandmother on the other side did maybe orchestrate that because she thought those shoes were ugly i fully believe that's what happened because i hate to know that that's my grandma as well and i know she was like she would have hated those shoes honey no honey baby no yeah and she would have loved the shoes that i bought exactly so it was you know yeah so the shoes are ip i did throw them out and i stand by that decision because again i think it was human shit that's the thing we're all pretty sure it was there's like there is a difference between dog shit and human shit there is and we that's the other thing none of us smelled it on the way there no not to the next not until you disturbed it and then i disturbed it and then and that's when we smelled it yeah yeah yeah so that was it was a real meeting ethan hawke and then immediately being brought down and then immediately being humbled the the the universe was like hey life is pretty cool but like simmer down on the ground babe yeah in fact wash your hands in a rain puddle babe yeah yeah yeah it was quite an experience but it was just a funny little it was funny little thing yeah sometimes most things are just that it was hilarious and then we all just kept saying with your poop hands with your poop hands but yeah my favorite part of that um so i guess to segue our story does take place in new york oh there you go so mark down your times bill it's just not quite as uh fun of a of a tale no so there's that it's not yeah uh we're gonna be talking about bernard goats the subway vigilante i have actually never heard of this i had not heard of this either and um dave was like hey we should do this story and i was like let's go he said let's go so let's talk about bernie uh bernard bernie goats was born november 7th 1947 in queens new york he was one of four kids uh born to bernard and gertrude goats they were german immigrants who arrived in the u.s about 20 years before when bernie was two the entire family moved from queens to a working farm in upstate new york that's different very different they moved like the adults decided to move the kids up there because they were like worried about the city and not having like safety for the kids i guess you know it didn't feel safe to them heavy trouble that's a duranduran song it is you're wondering now now bernard senior obviously moved with his family and he worked on the farm upstate they had like a fully working dairy farm uh but he would also leave to go back into new york city proper to operate various businesses between like real estate a milk binding factory whoa he had all kinds of little businesses everywhere dang now when his father was home on the farm little bernie tried his best to avoid him he'd rather spend time alone in the woods which is apparently a new running theme in all the stories i'm gonna tell you yeah yeah just taking to the woods taking to the woods is the new theme i'm looking for in stories i guess interesting it seemed that he was an inevitable target for his father's abuse if he wasn't the house that's sad and bernard senior was a pretty fucking awful guy awesome uh this will put that into perspective when bernie was about 12 years old his father was arrested and eventually convicted trigger warning for sexual assault uh eventually convicted of molesting two 15 year old boys holy shit yeah it was a shock to a lot of people at the time but it did turn out that this was not his first arrest for that kind of behavior actually in 1958 he was charged with giving alcohol to a minor and in that case he had picked up that from from a camp for underprivileged children took him to the bookbinding factory where he worked and just gave him multiple shots over the course of several hours and assaulted him what an evil person he really was uh the behavior continued continued in the years that followed with witnesses describing several instances of bernard senior quote entertaining teenage boys sometimes at home sometimes at the farm and serving them alcoholic drinks fucked up now in previous scandals since there was quite a few he was able to avoid any major scandal like publicly consequence consequences likely due to the fact that people weren't comfortable talking about this kind of thing back then jesus but this time was different in february 1960 he was indicted on 18 counts of endangering the life and health of a child and assault in the third degree holy shit so this also affected his family obviously the shame of the scandal forced them and into basically like hiding and they really didn't even socialize with anybody outside and even amongst themselves they never spoke of the arrest or the eventual conviction regardless of their silence though people knew what happened and bernie became an even bigger target for bullies at school than he already was in the first place oh that's sad and he was already struggling at school he kind of like kept to himself and people picked on him so it was decided that it would be best for bernie and his sister bernice who also was getting a lot of negative attention at the time to be sent to boarding school in switzerland damn yeah that's how they dealt with it they were like bye all the way switzerland switzerland or boss that's it i'd be pretty stoked to go to switzerland not given the circumstances obviously but to go to switzerland yeah it's supposed to be gorgeous yeah yeah now sidebar sidebar looks gorge now being removed from the situation probably was in their best interest but for bernie whose only real relationships up to that point were in his family it kind of felt like he was being punished for something he hadn't done and something that was beyond his control his sister later said bernie was always very attached to both of my parents and it left him feeling this like sense of abandonment that he didn't really ever seem to recover from damn so he spent some time in switzerland and then finally returned to the u.s in 1965 to go to nyu at new york university where he studied electrical engineering by then the rest of the family had moved to florida so he was kind of alone in new york he was a good student he graduated with a bachelor's degree in 1969 and he got a job right out of college but this was when it really started to show that he had some problems with authority and he was ultimately fired from that job within just a few months so now without a job or any prospects he decided to move to the florida home with his family and he started working for his real estate company now it was in florida that he met and briefly married a woman named elizabeth unlike bernie elizabeth was outgoing she was lively she was social she just liked to have a good time all things that bernie claimed had attracted him to her in the first place despite being the exact opposite of his own personality but you know opposites can attract good to say now during the early days of their marriage they actually lived with bernie's parents but there was a lot of tension there especially between bernie and his father and for elizabeth it was too much to handle so they got their own apartment and elizabeth hoped that things would get better but unfortunately they really didn't improve at all bernie didn't seem interested in being home all that much he worked really long hours and when he wasn't working he wasn't really interested in going out at all so he kind of kept to himself at home and was also like rarely affectionate in any way so just that's sad it kind of sounds like they were more like roommates yeah that's it's like very like just passing ships in the night yeah kind of thing now it sounds like elizabeth tried her best to make things work um and would just kind of like go out on her own with friends but that led to bernie thinking that she was carrying on an affair and that caused tension in their relationship obviously yeah so by 1975 it was clear the marriage simply wasn't going to work and they ended up divorcing now with his marriage at an end and his relationship with his father seemingly irreparably damaged he decided that there was really nothing left for him in florida so by the end of 1975 he went back to new york and he found a small apartment in greenwich village um he hadn't really been able to pursue his passion for electronics while he was working with his father because remember that's what he went to school for but he never stopped tinkering in his free time so to him it kind of seemed like the perfect time to start his own electronics business there you go yeah now that business the electrical calibration laboratory i love the word laboratory laboratory you were gonna say that it was a one-man operation run out of his own apartment and he specialized in repairing complicated electronics and it was almost an immediate success because it's kind of niche you know yeah especially like for sure in the 80s people are like how the fuck do i fix this so now after years of struggling emotionally and financially he was happier than he'd ever been and he was known to tell his customers machines don't hurt you i mean they can yeah they very much can there's been many accidents with machines lots and i'd beg to differ that you know if we keep giving robots all this all this kind of extra intelligence we're all going to be in those words i think machines can't hurt you i think sorry that's just my side thought i agree but okay what's his name bernie bernie i almost said barney i was like wait a minute sorry bernie that's sorry bernie that's just my opinion so but uh a little foreshadowing there i feel like he's a little attached to okay his business and not so much people if that makes sense instead of human yeah he did start to develop a small friend group though for the most part he and his friends discussed their passion for electronics they all had that in common and over time he started to share his feelings about the rising crime rate in new york city at the time and what he saw as evidence of quote-unquote urban decay oh which great band name i was gonna isn't that uh isn't that a makeup brand yes wait i when i was saying that i was like urban decay why have i said that before yeah that's a makeup brand called a very it was a cool i have their setting spray i was just gonna say the all-nighter setting the purple yeah sponsor us i won't forget you oh that the urban decay palette the makeup palette oh my god debbie just was like how are you forgetting she just motioned and i was like oh palette that was a big 2016 between that and anastasia because they love a shimmer we love an urban decay shimmer they had i think they had a color called like gunmetal gray that i used to use all the time absolutely yeah but this was um the city this was different yeah yeah apparently not long after moving back to new york bernie got mugged and he found which like worst fear that's so scary and he found little sympathy or interest when he reported the crime to police the experience obviously was very traumatizing and the indifference that he felt from law enforcement left him feeling not only helpless but also kind of bitter yeah i mean i think a lot of people felt that way at one point or another yeah to make matters worse the new york licensing board also denied his application to conceal and carry a pistol citing an insufficient need so he also felt helpless yeah okay but i don't know how hard it is to get a concealed to carry i've never tried to so nor have i i can't speak on it yeah now to those around him at the time bernie seemed to struggle significantly when it came to processing what he had gone through with this mugging and the assault and in time he started to channel his frustration and anger into what one journalist described as a quote one man crusade to clean up the streets oh so to that end when he wasn't working he was spending a lot of his time quote pestering city agents to do something and this is a quote about the litter the junkies and the homeless wow yeah i i feel as though you're focusing on the wrong things i do too that's just me though yeah now in january 1981 he was unfortunately mugged for a second time this time i know this time it was while he was waiting for a train in the canal street subway station unlike the first time which included only the threat of violence this time he alleged that his attackers assaulted him physically he said they smashed him into a plate glass window it which tore cartilage in one of his knees and caused some bruising now fortunately he was able to get the attention of a transit officer who apprehended one of the young men but the other two got away damn yeah that would like fuck you up i feel like i would move from the city like psychologically that must do a crazy number on you i would think so yeah and this is here's the thing like obviously you know cities can be dangerous in general like they get that reputation you live in heavy trouble like you said earlier living rough but at this time and we'll talk about it in a minute crime rates were really really high in the city yeah so it's it sounds like damn how did this guy get mugged this many times but it was actually happening it was very common pretty frequently yeah now this time he was determined to get some justice for his suffering but a few hours later apparently one of the young men who was apprehended was allowed to leave the precinct and bernie himself had to stay for several more hours to answer questions and fill out paperwork it was like why did this guy get treated treated better than i did like it was almost like i got treated like i had done something wrong yeah now that outrage only compounded with the trauma that he'd experienced and those two things working together were not great to bernie it seemed that nobody really cared about protecting the innocent and they also cared even less about getting the criminals off the streets awesome yeah so he was not pleased yeah this is going well yeah yeah super so now feeling like he'd been failed twice he was not pleased he was not pleased he was not by the nypd he was more determined than ever to find any means of protecting himself and he wasn't willing to let the fact that he was denied that concealed carry license prevent him from achieving those ends now on a trip to visit his parents in florida a few months after the assault he stopped into a gun store and he purchased a nickel-plated lightweight smith and wesson 38 caliber revolver which once he returned home he would carry with him pretty much any time he went out of the apartment and obviously concealed that's scary it is just because of how like how angry he is how paranoid he's getting how angry he is how hyper focused he's getting on quote-unquote cleaning up the streets yes that's scary yeah now on the afternoon of december 22nd 1984 bernie got on the subway at the 14th street subway station entering the same car that was carrying four teenagers from the bronx barry allen troy canty daryl kb and james mr in the years that have passed there are various and a lot of conflicting accounts about what exactly happened on this train but from multiple accounts we can kind of put together like a basic understanding of what happened at about 1 45 he got onto the train bernie and he sat down a few feet a feet away all the teenagers were said to be horsing around and kind of being disruptive like very teenage behavior yeah we've all been on some kind of public transit with teenagers oh yeah yeah now this is one of the details that varies depending on the version of events but according to witnesses one of the young guys troy can'ty approached bernie started chatting with him and asked him for five dollars okay now in court testimony james ramseyer claimed that troy can'ty was acting on his own and the other men did not approach bernie at all which more or less matches the witness statements collected by police okay in his confession bernie claimed that he was quote-unquote surrounded by the group and he fully believed they were going to rob him okay which if you've already been mugged a couple times some kind of like pts i can understand that that's the initial thought i can get that yeah so he claimed that he was only going to flash his gun in order to scare the teens into getting away from him but after he pulled his gun from his waistband fear took over he told the interviewing officer this is a quote i wanted to kill those guys i wanted to maim those guys i wanted to make them suffer in every way i could if i had more bullets i would have shot them all again and again my problem was i ran out of bullets oh okay escalation okay yeah wow i didn't realize he was just gonna be like oh let me clear this up for you in case you're wondering holy shit yeah wow so he fired at all of them striking barry allen james ramseyer and troy can'ty knocking them all to the floor the three of them seeing that he had mr lkb he walked over to the teenager who was cowering on the ground at that point and allegedly was overheard to say you don't look so bad here's another and then shot him at close range holy shit that shot severed his spinal cord wow yeah so the car obviously erupted into chaos when bernie started firing passengers obviously were trying to flee to connecting cars just to get away from everything it's i can't imagine yeah this is horrible when the train came to a stop the conductor approached bernie who by that point had put the gun back in his waistband and was just calmly kneeling down in the car wow the conductor approached him cautiously and was like are you a police officer like what happened here because also remember this is the 80s like yeah public shootings and mass shootings were not what they are now yeah and bernie was said to have replied no they tried to rip me off so the conductor tried to convince him to hand over the gun but he refused and after pushing open the nearest doors he dropped from the train onto the tracks and ran down the tunnel just disappearing into darkness wow yeah the conductor said i went into the last car and there were about 40 people in there huddled on the floor so he obviously so scared yeah i can't imagine you're trapped in there legit yeah and they were for a little bit he called the transit police to report the shooting and the train was moved to the nearest location for isolation yeah at that point so while law enforcement officers spread out into the area to search for the shooter who obviously was unknown at that point the victims were taken to bellevue hospital uh barry allen and james ramseyer were listed in serious condition troy canty was listed in critical condition and daryl kb who had been transported to saint vincent's like i said was being treated for a several severed spinal cord and a punctured lung holy shit yeah one detective said it was a real charles bronson type of incident referring to bronson's 1974 movie death wish where the main character takes the law into his own hands after the police failed to do anything to help him and his family wow yeah what a person it sure was uh in their official statement to the press an nypd spokesperson assured the public that they were searching the tunnels and the stations for the suspect but they didn't suspect at that point that the public was in any danger captain john kelly said he picked out these four guys and shot every one of them he knew what he was doing he wasn't shooting indiscriminately he was either harassed or robbed by these guys earlier on the train i mean wow yeah so in the days that followed the shooting nyp investigators were kind of at a loss for answers because their suspect just seemed to have disappeared into yeah that's what's so crazy it's like a this really is like a comic book yeah thing just because it's like the subway in the city i don't know it just gives that vibe it's and then there's like a vigilante yeah despite the lack of answers the press and investigators almost immediately and it would turn out accurately started describing the incident as a vigilante like shooting the idea that somebody had taken the law into their own hands only drew a sharp angry response from the new york transit police though and in his own statement mayor ed koch told reporters vigilantism will not be tolerated in this city we will not permit people to take the law into their own hands i mean yeah which is a reassuring statement yeah totally now you would assume that anyone opening fire on a crowded train car would be uh undesirable to say the least under any circumstances but to the surprise of many the public reaction to the shooting was decidedly different from the public reaction to the shooting from that of law enforcement and city officials after years of crumbling infrastructure rising crime rates and a lot in the city going on a lot of new yorkers seem to understand bernie goats's actions at the time and not only that they somewhat sympathized with what he had done just days after the incident sergeant raymond o'donnell told the new york times many of the calls we received are in sympathy with the subject that did the shooting we have not had the call we need with a tip that would lead us to a suspect so they're saying people are just calling being like hey let it go you know i get it you know we're all suffering and then they're like hey do you have a tip and they're like no no click yeah wow which like people are gonna people yeah i mean don't and they people tip lines to express sympathy no i feel i feel that's probably not what they're for that i would say definitely i think they're for tips yeah well luckily a call that they needed came in about a week later and bernie was arrested and conquered new hampshire on new year's eve based on the evidence collected from his car investigators concluded that after the shooting he fled to he fled the city and quote had kept moving not always using his real name when registering in motels from his own account he spent a lot of time in vermont and had returned to new york twice during that time period before ultimately traveling to new hampshire where he walked into the police station and turned himself in huh right i didn't see that i didn't see that coming either when i originally yeah but i guess i don't know this whole thing is such a strange case like it's like that weird vigilante thing which like i don't know if that's the term i want to use for it i know for lack of a lack of a better term than i can think of and he's commonly referred to as that's the thing so but it's like i guess it maybe that makes sense that he would turn himself in yeah it's strange because it makes you wonder like if he felt guilt or just knew that that was how he handled it was wrong yeah you know or just maybe didn't want to continue life on the run yeah you know there could be anything yeah now in his taped confession he was said to appear extremely agitated and defensive interrupting the interviewing officer constantly and going on rants about how ineffective the justice system was and how the law did nothing to protect ordinary citizens like himself okay uh he lost it when one of the men who he shot was referred to as a victim and it's clear from the transcript that while he understood what he did was illegal he seemed to feel justified and what he ultimately described as self-defense so he's probably saw it as like this is just what i'm taking from it yeah seems like he saw it as like legally i know what i did is wrong legally i know it was wrong but like was it you know like that kind of thing because it was self-defense which is interesting that he still decided to turn himself in because again legally he knows it's wrong yeah you just wonder what's really going through his mind yeah you just wonder what's really going through his mind yeah you just wonder what's really going through his mind yeah you just wonder what's really going through his mind yeah he told the officer and this is a quote now you cannot understand this it was his eyes were shiny he had a smile on his face i knew this i saw the smile on his face the shine the shine in his eyes that he was enjoying this i knew what they were going to do do you understand for combat you have to be cold-blooded and i was and it was at that point i decided to kill them after all murder them all do anything why were they so shiny their eyes were shiny he said huh i don't know if he meant like like shiny because they felt like they were running into like an opportunity like their eyes were bright at the thought of robbing him it's just like i'm like what what's shiny i yeah i don't know that's that's a chilling statement it really is there's multiple chilling statements throughout this now ultimately this should have been a pretty straightforward case it was either self-defense or attempted murder and i mean he did say i decided to kill them all yeah so but it was up for a jury to decide but his actions occurred at a time when new yorkers had grown very frustrated with the city's leadership and their inability it seemed to keep people safe so as a result what should have been a straightforward shooting case sparked a statewide and in some cases in some cases nationwide discussion about the declining quality of life. life in the city at a hearing of the advisory congressional crime caucus new york senator alphonse diamato went as far as saying new york subways are so dangerous that riders need an armed guard oh which i'm like don't start spreading that information my goodness and then if the number of op-eds and letters to the editor were any indication diamato was just one of many city residents who again not only understood but in some cases seemed to appreciate what bernie had done huh but there were others with very important questions bernie was a middle-aged relatively you know he was doing well for himself white man from manhattan and his victims were four black teenagers from the bronx so for black communities across new york and the u.s it seemed pretty obvious that he was they thought at least motivated by unconscious bias yeah you know i can see why you think that yeah new york state representative floyd flake wrote i'm a black man and an american citizen with shiny eyes and a ready smile and he wondered whether bernie goats would have seen him as similarly threatening yeah which i mean that's a valid thing to wonder yeah i mean shiny eye like i'm glad you pointed it out because it's like what about that gives you the impression that somebody's gonna rob you or mug you well the way he said it was almost that like he sees that shine you don't like only he can see it so he can tell when someone's a bad person and they're gonna do something but you might not be able to see and that which is dangerous it's very dangerous because it's me so i get to decide who's the bad guy and who isn't and who has bad intentions and who doesn't have a shiny eye exactly allegedly now there were also some questions the million dollar word yeah there were also some questions about the chain of events themselves and whether things had truly unfolded exactly as he said in what he was telling law enforcement yeah in his version of events all four boys surrounded him on the train and asked for money which also like isn't necessarily robbing you at one point it was like yeah it was said that they were panhandling because it's like i was just gonna say were they like give me your money or were they like hey can can i have five bucks by his those are two very different things by his own admission troy can't he simply asked for five dollars he did not demand it he asked for it i mean that's you can do that you can because you can say no yeah but any threat of violence or suggestion that he was being robbed kind of seemed like he was being robbed and he was seemed at least by like it seemed to people like the the prospect that he was going to be robbed was existed in his head yeah and witnesses contradicted his version of events and generally reported that while troy can't he may have been disruptive on the train that day nobody remembered seeing any of the four of them doing anything that would have led them to it led anybody else on the outside to understand why bernie started shooting yeah to a lot of witnesses it happened very suddenly with no provocation yeah if there ever was a chance for the public to hear an accurate unbiased account of the event though it was long gone by the time that bernie was arrested by then he was already being held up by many as a kind of folk hero god damn and his victims by the way all teenagers between 18 and 19 years old were basically shredded in the press podcast host and journalist um leon nafak said they were described in the press as street toughs people didn't have a lot of time for making distinctions between them or understanding who they were or what kind of lives they had led there was not a lot of interest it's crazy too because it's like they were shot at yeah at close range at close range and we're just like dismissing them again like critical condition serious condition transferred to a different hospital for a severed spine and a punctured lung like i think like because obviously we don't know what the intention was because we were not there yeah and you know the story is the story and it's but like some bad shit happened on the subway and they were the result was they all ended up in the hospital i think it's worth getting to know who they are and what was going on well like why would you not want to know yeah i don't understand it now nafak's assessment of the public reaction and obvious disdain for the victims is an accurate one that unfortunately only got worse when it was revealed that at least two of the four boys had been carrying screwdrivers and they were on their way to a local arcade where they allegedly were planning to steal quarters okay yeah i mean but people were upset because not cool like that that's bad i'm not i'm not saying that's okay but it's like it re-in like i don't get it personally but it reinforced the belief like well they're criminals and like if they were going to do that they were likely going to rob him because they're already looking for money you know which which okay valid to like think that way i suppose to make those connections you can also look at it if you pull it apart and say well if they were going there with screwdrivers to steal quarters that's a little passive of a crime they're not holding people up they're not yeah actively hurting someone you know what i mean like it's obviously it's an again it's not a good thing to do no of course but i'm saying like you know quietly using a screwdriver to steal quarters is a different crime than robbing someone very very different so i can see that it's a different crime than robbing someone on the subway very different so i can see that it's a different crime than robbing someone on the subway very different so i can see that it's a different crime than robbing someone on the subway very different so i can see how both conclusions are getting because that's the thing people are already being told these inflated stories so they're like well what if they were armed with screwdrivers to rob him which which okay so you can look at it from all the angles i'm not saying it's a good way to look at it no and i think you should want to find out why yeah people were shot yeah what this is why things are never black and white though exactly and that's why people do need to use critical thinking and like thinking think about it from all angles yes agreed now after being extradited to new york from new hampshire the manhattan district attorney referred the case to a grand jury who voted uh only to indict bernie on a charge of being in possession of an illegal firearm but he shot it so however luckily after hearing testimony from two of the victims a second grand jury was convened in march of 85 and voted to indict him on additional charges of attempted murder assault reckless endangerment and a felony gun charge yeah because that you got to think of the other part of the case because it's a very different case it's a very different case it's a part of that that wasn't an empty subway right that could have taken collateral damage out yeah easily that's really bad yeah the problem was by then the narrative of the shooting had been so expertly crafted by the press for bernie to appear to be the hero of the story even the nra weighed in on the case using it as an opportunity to promote gun ownership and expand their market beyond rural areas and to cities here's my shocked face oh my god yeah crazy wow now given how much the deck had been stacked in favor of bernie it came as little surprise when in january of 1986 justice stephen crane dismissed nine of the 13 charges against him whoa including the most serious like attempted murder according to justice crane the case had been improperly presented to the second grand jury and he believed that the testimony from the two victims who denied intending to rob bernie quote strongly appeared to have been perjured oh yeah so the case fell on bernie's head and bernie's head fell on her head and bernie's head fell on her head finally went to trial in april of 1987 at which point judge crane had been dismissed and a new judge was assigned as well as several of the indictments restored after two months of testimony the jury acquitted bernie on the felony charges and only found him guilty on one count of being in possession of an unlicensed gun wow yeah interesting now the case was always going to be pretty difficult to present i mean we just had difficulty looking at one angle of it you know what i mean yeah going back and forth jurors were being asked to determine whether or not bernie genuinely believed himself to be in danger and that's kind of hard to do when you're not him yeah you know what like how i'm i don't know yeah and i can only hear like i don't know what happened on the train that day yeah that's absolutely fair but understandably the verdict was disappointing to a lot of members of new york's black community floyd flake who i mentioned earlier wrote those no blacks allowed signs in public places have been removed but that racism continues to occupy a place in our society i believe that the goat's decision sends the wrong signals to white americans it says blacks are fair game if a white person suspects rightly or wrongly that a black man may commit a criminal act then a white person is able to take any action he sees fit yeah and that's scary that's scary as hell that would scare the shit out of me too yeah of course now initially bernie was sentenced to six months in prison with one year of psychiatric treatment to follow and five years probation but he appealed to the sentence successfully and eventually was sentenced to one year and ultimately served eight months of that sentence wow yeah now in the years that followed the four victims have brought various civil cases against bernie goats including one case brought by durell kb who was left brain damaged and paralyzed from the shooting he said to have the mental capacity of an eight-year-old now it's really sad that's really sad he sought 50 million dollars for compensation and punitive damages and the jury the jury was not able to get the sentence successfully and the jury was not ruled in his favor when they found that quote goats had acted recklessly and outrageously that his conduct exceeded reasonable bounds of decency and that he intended to cause kb's severe emotional distress that's from the la times uh but because he didn't have the millions to pay bernie state law instead requires that he surrender 10 of his income to kb over the course of 25 years damn to date it appears he has yet to pay anything hmm so that's shitty okay as for bernie he has since become an outspoken activist for veganism and has mounted a strange in my opinion campaign to save city squirrels from the effects of overpopulation and developments that encroach on their environment okay so he's now passionate about squirrels i mean do something good yeah in the 40 years since the shooting he's been interviewed several times but hasn't really ever changed his position wow yeah i don't know that any good came out of any of this yeah except for city squirrels holy shit it's a very sad story at no point did i know where that was going yeah that's wild it is yeah and i think what he's like 80 years old now yeah he's like close to 80 he's like 78 or something like that damn bernie yeah well you got a fun fact i'm like there's not a lot we can say i don't know what to say about bernie i have a fun fact for you brought to you by dub dub uh this is from scary mommy one species of jellyfish turritopus dohri yep dorni i don't know is immortal immortal is immortal in response to physical damage or any other trauma they can revert back in their development process to a polyp i want that what imagine just anytime you feel unsafe reverting back to a polyp i want that we need to study them we need to figure it out we need to jelly i gotta know in general are badass jellyfish are scary yeah box jellyfish talk to me about them kill you straight up yeah super dangerous just for no reason they'll kill you or just like if they'll say fuck you and they'll kill you they'll say fuck you wow it's great jellyfish are nuts what they don't have brains yeah they don't what the fuck yeah then how do they know to go back to being a polyp it's primal i guess it's innate yeah it's just there me you know wow i have a lot to look into jellyfish so yeah hope you look into that hope you keep listening yeah we hope you keep it weird keep it as weird as a fucking jellyfish that can revert to a polyp not the ones that kill people yeah and say fuck you and say fuck you and leave jellyfish alone yeah don't touch them Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Ash and Elena share a humorous anecdote about stepping into a pile of unknown substance in Brooklyn, which they initially believed to be dog or human waste, leading to a rain puddle hand-washing incident and a bizarre encounter with a store owner who mocked their "poop pants."
  2. The story highlights a surreal, self-reflective blend of absurdity and personal vulnerability, where the experience is framed as both funny and spiritually enlightening, contrasting with the chaotic unpredictability of life.
  3. The narrative shifts to a serious exploration of Bernard Goats, a man from New York who, after being mugged multiple times and denied a concealed carry license, became increasingly paranoid and developed a vigilante streak.
  4. In December 1984, Bernard shot four teenagers on a subway train, claiming self-defense after they allegedly surrounded him and asked for money, though witnesses dispute the provocation and the nature of the request.
  5. The incident sparked public sympathy, especially in a city facing high crime and deteriorating infrastructure, but also ignited controversy over race, perception, and justice, with critics pointing to unconscious bias and a lack of empathy for the victims.
  6. A grand jury initially failed to indict Bernard, but after new testimony, charges were reinstated, and he was acquitted of attempted murder, though convicted of illegal firearm possession.
  7. The victims, all teenagers from the Bronx, were severely injured—some with spinal damage and broken lungs—and later brought civil lawsuits, with one victim receiving a ruling that Bernard acted recklessly and intended to cause emotional harm.
  8. Bernard later became a vegan activist and advocate for city squirrels, symbolizing a transformation from a violent vigilante to a figure committed to animal welfare, despite ongoing legal and moral controversies.

Summary:

" The anecdote underscores the absurdity and humor in everyday misfortunes, serving as a contrast to the more serious narrative that follows. Transitioning to Bernard Goats, the story details a man who, after repeated muggings and systemic indifference from law enforcement, becomes increasingly paranoid and ultimately shoots four teenagers on a subway train in 1984, claiming self-defense. While Bernard believed he was being robbed, witnesses dispute the provocation, and the incident is marked by ambiguity and conflicting accounts.

The public reaction is divided—some see Bernard as a tragic hero fighting a broken system, while others criticize his actions as racially biased and unjust, especially given that the victims were Black youths. Though Bernard was eventually acquitted of the most serious charges due to procedural and testimonial issues, he was found liable for reckless conduct. The victims, all teenagers, suffered severe injuries and filed civil lawsuits, with one receiving a ruling that Bernard acted with excessive cruelty.

Despite the legal and moral fallout, Bernard later became a vegan activist and advocate for city squirrels, symbolizing a shift from violence to advocacy. The story illustrates how trauma, systemic failure, and public perception can warp justice and memory, ultimately emphasizing the complexity of human behavior, accountability, and societal judgment.

FAQs

Ash stepped in a pile of unknown substance—likely human or animal—while walking in Brooklyn and later discovered it in her purse. She washed her hands in a rain puddle, which led to a humorous story about a subway incident involving a man named Bernie Goats.

Bernie Goats was a man born in Queens, New York, who grew up in a family with German immigrant roots. After facing abuse from his father and being mugged multiple times, he moved to New York City and started a business repairing electronics.

In 1984, Bernie Goats was on a subway train where he claimed four teenagers approached him and demanded money. He allegedly fired at them, killing two and critically injuring another, before fleeing. The incident sparked a national debate about vigilantism and urban safety.

No, witnesses reported that the teenagers were panhandling or simply disruptive, not planning to rob him. Bernie Goats claimed they surrounded him and threatened him, but evidence suggests the provocation was minimal or non-existent.

Many New Yorkers sympathized with Bernie Goats, seeing his actions as a response to unsafe conditions and police inaction. However, others, especially in Black communities, criticized him as being racially biased, pointing out the racial disparities in the incident.

He was initially charged with multiple offenses, but after a grand jury review, he was only found guilty of being in possession of an unlicensed firearm. The other charges were dismissed, and he was acquitted on attempted murder and assault charges.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.