Go back

Ben Shapiro reassesses the president he campaigned for | Newsmakers

39m 11s

Ben Shapiro reassesses the president he campaigned for | Newsmakers

Ben Shapiro, a prominent conservative media figure and co-founder of DailyWire, offers a nuanced analysis of the Republican Party’s struggles following the 2024 and 2026 elections. He argues that the rejection of President Trump in 2026 is not a full embrace of democratic policies, but rather a reaction to the administration’s inconsistent and often overreaching implementation. Shapiro blames partisan media for creating unrealistic expectations, portraying political failure as a betrayal of promises, which fuels public disillusionment. He critiques conservative media’s tendency to prioritize performance over substance, citing figures like Tucker Carlson and Megan Kelly as examples of "weather veins" who amplify outrage rather than promote reasoned debate. Shapiro emphasizes that Trump’s policies are reactive and non-ideological, making it impossible to abstract a consistent conservative philosophy from his presidency. He believes Republicans must rebuild coalitions beyond Trump’s base, with candidates like Marco Rubio offering broader appeal. Central to his analysis is the idea that Americans desire "normalcy" over radical change, and that both parties must adopt consensus-driven, practical policies to regain legitimacy. He also expresses concern over institutional erosion, particularly in Congress, which has increasingly deferred to executive power. Ultimately, Shapiro calls for media accountability, urging truth-telling over audience appeasement, as a necessary foundation for a healthy democracy.

Transcription

8968 Words, 49017 Characters

English
I do not think that the whole-scale rejection of the Trump administration, which is what 2026 was, is somehow a full-scale embrace of democratic policy. Do you regret your vote given the way the president is performed? I regret the way the president is performed, and I don't regret my vote. People would say, "The Maga movement will survive Trump." No, it won't, because Maga is Trump and Trump is Maga. Why the Steve Inskipe sharing a brand-new episode of our sister's show, Newsmakers? In each episode, we sit down with somebody at the center of this moment, in news or culture, to find out how things look from the inside. Our guest, this episode, is Ben Shapiro, the podcaster and co-founder of the conservative website DailyWire. For more interviews like the one you're about to hear, make sure to follow or subscribe to Newsmakers, wherever you watch or listen to podcasts. And now, here's our episode with Ben Shapiro. Ben Shapiro is trying to make sense of the Republican Party's disaster in this year's elections. Shapiro is a popular conservative podcaster, co-founder of the DailyWire news site, and also a screenwriter with a new film. We sat here in NPR's New York Bureau to talk about where he thinks Republicans went wrong, and where they go next. Ben Shapiro, welcome to our New York Bureau. Well, thank you so much for having me. Thanks for coming by. There is a lot to talk about. You have a screenplay, a new movie out called Confession, and we're going to talk about it. You have a lot of media business, and I want to talk about that. But I want to begin with current events. There was a huge election recently. Yeah. You may be heard. And notice the app. There are a lot of people who supported President Trump in 2024, who said one way or another, I didn't get what I voted for. Who campaigned for the President? Did you get what you voted for? I mean, in some ways, yes, in some ways, no. What I said on my show, and I maintain, is that I probably agree with 80% of his policies, but I disagree with probably 90% of how he's implemented it. I think that you see that in his sliding approval rating throughout his presidency, President Trump has seen a slow and steady decline, basically all the way since Liberation Day in February March of 2025, and that really has never ebbed. There's never really a tick back up. There was never really a stasis that was reached, and I think that's because, again, the rollout of even policies that many Americans like, like, for example, closing the border, has been matched with, shall we say, I would say an over, I mean, himself sort of an overwrought implementation of ice procedures in Minneapolis. And so even the stuff that people like, they don't really like, and I think that that came out in the election. I wonder if the word is unrealistic. The President has pursued a lot of things that might sound nice to him in theory, but turned out to be unrealistic. Why are Earth to change the economy to give one exam? I think that's true, but I think that actually is a bipartisan thing, and I think what we are watching right now is the pendulum in American politics swinging unbelievably quickly. And I think one of the things that's happened on sort of a broader ideological level is that politicians have always found it very useful to promise the world to constituents. And it turns out that our system was built for gridlock and for consensus, and the American people being promised the world and then being delivered a certain amount of gridlock, and then presidents attempting to fill in that gap with executive policy, it tends to disappoint people. I wonder, since you're in media, I'll ask, if you think that the media and the media environment has something to do with this. I mean, of course. I mean, the partisan media particularly get people fired up and encourage their followers or listeners or viewers to believe that the politician can deliver on everything right now and that they're a failure and a traitor if they don't. I think that is absolutely true. And one of the things that I try to do with my audience at least is say, listen, here's what I would love an ideal world, and then here's how actual politics works. Politics, as we all know, is about trying to get as much of the pie as you can, but you're never going to get even close to 100% of the pie. So if your politicians deliver you 65% of the pie, that's a pretty big win. But most people who consume political media are being told each and every day that if your politician fails to deliver 100% of the pie, that is not a feature of the system. It's a feature, not a bug. It's a feature of the system. They're being told instead that this is a failure of willpower. And again, I think this is why you've seen the rise of the DSA and the Democratic Party is because again, the idea is the Democratic leaders are not delivering for their constituents. 100% of what they promise, therefore there must be an internal revolution to overthrow the establishment. Ron DeSantis, governor of Florida, in his post-mortem of the election, talked about conservative media, and I want to read some of a quote. He said, we need a big change in conservative media culture because he went on to say a lot of it is a grift, a lot of it is pay for play, and not serious about ideas. I mean, I certainly agree with that. And I've been doing this for 25 years. I'm 42 years old. I started writing a syndicate at Column when I was 17 years old. I would say that some of my iteration of my ideas back when I was 17 was over the top, but my general values have not changed basically at all since the time I began writing about politics and thinking about politics. There are certain areas where probably I've moderated, maybe some areas where I've gone the other way. I read an article from 2019 in which you critiqued some of your own early statements. Yeah, that's right. And mostly that's about the articulation of the statements rather than the sort of underlying values, but I would say that an enormous number of people in the right wing media ecosystem are weather veins more than they are actual light towers. I think that there's a lot of wave surfing very few people are willing to just stand where they stand and remain where they stand, and again, that may manifest itself in different ways. Obviously, my evolution on my sort of feelings about President Trump and his implementation of policy have changed radically over time, meaning in 2015, 2016, I voted from neither candidate. In 2020, I endorsed him at the end of 2020 during the election denialism phase, I was extremely critical of the president. And then Joe Biden was the president. I thought he did his terrible job. I thought Kamal Harris was a horrible nominee and I ended up campaigning for the president in 2024. I don't think any of that is a fundamental shift in values. I think it's a manifestation of the top of the iceberg sort of stuff. My feelings about President Trump have not really changed very much in certain ways from 2016. I think a lot of the ills that I diagnosed from a Trump presidency came to pass. I think what he gave me was a lot more policy wins than I expected. I'm about to ask if you regret that vote, but I want to do it in a very specific way. I get that you feel that Harris would have been a terrible president and it was a binary choice for you. So I've heard you make that argument and I understand it. Nevertheless, the president has performed the way that he has performed. I saw you show the other day you went on for more than 20 minutes about everything that the president has screwed up, the corruption and everything else. Do you regret your vote given the way the president has performed? I regret the way the president has performed. I don't regret my vote. I don't have a time machine. And so, again, there's sort of two questions embedded that one is, do I wish that he had done better? Of course. The other is, if I could go back in time and a time machine and reverse my vote and make Kamala Harris presidents of the United States, no, I would not do that because again, unfortunately we've been presented with a number of binary sources that I would not particularly love over the course of the last 20 years. When you talk about weather veins in conservative media, names and names, who do you mean? Megan Kelly is the most obvious one. I think that there isn't yet to be a parade that has been launched without Megan Kelly at the front that ends without Megan at the front twirling a baton. I think Tucker Carlson is actually not a weather vein. I think that Tucker has his belief system as nefarious as I believe those beliefs to be. I think that there are some other members of conservative media who are sort of smaller in iteration who are smaller in reach, who have been moving their positions relatively radically on a wide variety of positions. I mean, again, I am a traditional conservative. I'm a free market private property conservative when it comes to economics. I'm socially conservative when it comes to social policy and I am a traditional hawk when it comes to foreign policy. And that has not changed. But, as I've said before, I'm not sure that there are many people who would say, you know, what happened to Ben Shapiro in the same sense they say what happened to Tucker Carlson or what happened to him. I'm interested in your analysis of Tucker Carlson because people do say that about him. We had a long interview with Tucker Carlson on this program and there are people who will look at Tucker and say, you know, his private texts show that he loathed Trump, but somehow he loved Trump, but now he hates Trump. They see him all over the place. You don't see him that way. No, I think that there's a through line for Tucker and I think the Tucker has a quite conspiratorial view about the workings of American power and that stretches well back into his fox days. I think there may be some of the excesses that he's, you know, put on display since his fox days were sort of taken out of the system by fox, but I think once he left, all that became clear. My first editor is what you're telling me. That is what I'm saying. But back in 2018, I mean, I've been saying to people since 2018 that I thought that he was quite a dangerous figure. I mean, I remember having him on my program. He had a book out where he was talking about economics in particular and he has always taken this very sort of populist economic perspective, mirroring a lot of Elizabeth Warren. Specifically, you know, for a Republican, you seem quite warm toward the plans of Elizabeth Warren. He said, I totally agree with a lot of Elizabeth Warren says, oh, anyway. So I asked him one one of the topics in his book at that time that I believe 2018 was self-driving cars. And I asked him, would you outlaw self-driving cars? And he said, yes, to save trucker jobs. And I said, on what basis would you outlaw self-driving cars? And he said, on the basis of safety, and I said, but that makes no sense because self-driving cars are significantly safer, obviously, than human driven cars, tens of thousands of lives a year if we're all driving self-driving cars. And he said, well, you asked me on what basis I would ban it, now it's true. And this, to me, is a fundamental violation of core values, but again, it speaks to the idea that Tucker, I think, has been promoting for a long time, that there is sort of a right-wing version of grievance politics that ought to be justified and fed. And in the end comes down to conspiratorial theories about elites in our society with a disproportionately Jewish last names. In our interview with Tucker Carlson, I want to try to summarize what I understood his worldview to be, it's that there is a unaparty the Democrats and Republicans are essentially the same, some figures who he doesn't define very well are calling the shots except it's Israel, telling them what to do. What do you think about when you hear that view of the world? I mean, I think that when you talk about anti-Semitism, which is a term that has sort of lost all meaning because it's been misused and abused, anti-Semitism, classically defined, is not racism against Jews. Anti-Semitism is a conspiracy theory about the world. It's a conspiracy theory that suggests that Jews bear inordinate responsibility and use inordinate power in order to control all of the mechanisms by which the world works. When I hear Tucker Carlson say that Donald Trump is a slave to Israel, for example, which is the thing that he has said, or when I hear him suggest that Israel or APAC control all of American policy, then again, I'll let his words and speak, I gave you the definition and now the question is how well his words match up with the definition, I think there's pretty close overlap. What is the right way to describe Israeli influence in the U.S. government? I mean, I think that there are a lot of people in the United States who are pro-Israel. I think that the argument that Israel itself has been capable of somehow manipulating the United States is so species on historical grounds as to be laughable and Joe Biden was routinely rejecting requests from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. You've seen in the past few weeks and months, rejections by President Trump of certain things that Prime Minister Netanyahu was asking for. He talked about cutting off age just the other day, yeah. 100%. Again, I can list chapter and verse of times when Israel has wanted one thing and the United States has wanted a completely different thing. I mean, the current war in Iran actually is a pretty good example of this. I mean, Israel obviously its end goal would be the toppling of the regime and Israel has made that incredibly clear. The United States' end goal is not the total toppling of the regime. That's something President Trump keeps saying over and over and over and over. Except for the time when he talked about the toppling of the regime as he was declaring the beginning of the war. I mean, I think that was his hope, but I don't think that was ever his explicit goal of the war. I think those are two different things. I mean, if he actually wanted to direct toward toppling of the regime, then he presumably would not have called off the plan to unleash the Kurds or to unleash the Belouj or to arm insurgents inside Iran, all of which he did early on in the war or to call off the bombing in the middle of March, April. He did that against again in the advice of the Israelis. He signed an MOU against the advice of the Israelis. It's kind of notion that a small country in the Middle East is controlling all of American foreign policy. I think that's a to liars way out of a dilemma for people who don't like Israel very much, which is maybe the politician disagrees with you. Maybe it turns out that Israel isn't control of American foreign policy. It turns out a lot of people in the United States are still pro-Israel, still see Israel as an ally in the Middle East. Now again, that could change. I think it is changing in large part inside the Democratic Party and to a certain extent even inside the Republican Party. Again, it goes to the idea that if Israel's controlling the world, they're doing an awfully terrible job of it. I mean, if the idea is that Israel is in control of all auspices, of public relations, why is Israel so wildly unpopular, why if Israel is so good at manipulating everyone, then why is it that Israel finds itself on the short end of the stick? I wonder if the Iran war resembles Trump's tariff policy in your view in that it might have been nice and theory if it had worked, but in practical terms, it was never going to work. I do think that you cannot adjudicate, quote unquote, whether it has worked until we get to the end of it. Meaning that I still think that there is the possibility that the Iranian regime, which is economically, incredibly fragile. I mean, the Iranian reall is trading at close to $3 million per dollar right now and they are running out of money to pay their people. They have massive fuel shortages. I'm not sure everything is quite as hunky-dory over in Iran as the mullahs would like to have to make. And the question is whether that destabilizes the regime is still sort of an open one. So if we're sitting here two years from now and there's a different regime in place, then the war was certainly successful along those lines. What I said way back in March, April, is the stated goals of the war were to destroy, as it stood, the Iranian nuclear program to destroy their ballistic missile arsenal and production facilities to destroy their army, to destroy their navy. I think those goals were largely achieved. I think one of the problems is that there was some level of mission creep and I think also the president basically made the decision not to deliver the final hammer blow that would have essentially ended the capacity for the Iranian regime to recover. Do you really believe that a little more bombing or maybe a lot? I don't know. Another few days of bombing might have made a difference. I think that the not time period of the bombing, I think targets of the bombing, where the president got very hesitant about the bombing was around particularly Harga Island and South Park's gas field and pickaxe mountain. So I think if you want to destroy their nuclear facilities, you do have to destroy pickaxe mountain. And I do think that there was a case to be made that we should have gone after Harga Island and South Park's gas field and that we should have essentially demonstrated their ability to produce the oil instead of simply blockading it. And if oil went up to $200, then it would have come back down because the pipelines the other way, which is exactly what's been going on throughout Saudi Arabia. It's been happening from Qatar. It's been happening from UAE. It's moving pipelines all the way across the peninsula the other way. And also I think that if the United States wanted a quick end to the war where we're not all that involves, I think we should have left oversight to our allies. We have allies there for a reason and it turns out that our friends and allies in Europe and Asia, I have much more of a stake in the free flow of oil from these straight form moves than we do. I don't want to go on and on about this, but could you have made, could the president have made a different calculus that whatever you thought of the Iran nuclear deal that was in the past, there was this big strike on Iran's nuclear program in 2025. And if it wasn't exactly a steady state, like the damage had been done and the downside of another war was going to be excessive. Well, I mean, you certainly could have made that case. I think that the actual reason for the war was the quick build up of ballistic missiles that was going to create a shield preventing strikes against future nuclear development. I mean, it's something the Secretary of State has said openly. So I think that if you're going to do the most sort of contained version of this war from the outset, then we certainly could have just done a very significant bombing campaign against their ballistic missile production facilities, their drum production facilities, all of their ballistic missile launchers. And as I say, pickaxe mountain and some of their other nuclear sides. And again, that is not a sort of strange thing in the Middle East. It's been called mowing the grass. And that might be something that has to happen routinely with regards to the Iranian regime to keep them from going nuclear. I want to ask about another aspect of the election. One way to describe the 2024 election, and there was a famous Republican ad that played on this in fact, was that Democrats were too focused on identity and Republicans were focused on practicalities and making people's lives better. One way to describe the 2026 election is that the Trump administration and Republicans broadly focused way too much on identity and Democrats took advantage by focusing on making people's lives better. I mean, I think that there's some truth to that. I think what I'll say is that I do not think that the whole scale rejection of the Trump administration, which is what 2026 was, is somehow a full scale embrace of democratic policy. Any more than I think that actually the rejection of Kamala Harris in 2024, as it turns out, was a complete embrace of Trumpian policy. I think this is a mistake we make in a two-party system, generally, is where we believe that if there's a wipe out on behalf of one party, that is now, quote, unquote, a mandate to govern. I'm old enough to remember several rounds of this. So as a program host, as someone who's influential, as the head of a media company, everything else that you are, what do you see as your responsibility in this moment? Looking ahead over the next couple of years? I mean, I've always felt that my responsibility is to tell the truth to my audience. And that means I say things that sometimes they don't want to hear. I mean, there's a number of times where, of course, my audience and I've lived to tell the tale. I think the audience capture tends to be, in partisan media particularly, something that you have to worry about. But I think that it applies to legacy media as well. And so, you know, I've really, I feel a strong compulsion to say what I believe to be true and to back it up with as much evidence as humanly possible. We should define that term for people. Audience capture means you're captured by your audience, you're trying to cater to them. Yes, that's right. Like, your audience wants you to say, for example, that the election of 2020 was stolen and you say that it wasn't, which is the thing that I said, or you, or you say that your audience wants you to say that the tariffs are a genius idea that is going to bring manufacturing back to the United States. And you say, I don't agree with that. I think that is just wrong headed in the extreme. Your audience may not agree with that. And the, or your audience may say that the Iran war in its inception was, was, was wrong, not just in its, in its sort of pursuit, but actually the, the general reason for it. I made a disagree with that. I mean, I'm going to tell the audience what I believe is true. And, you know, if people listen to listen, if they don't, they don't. That's the, that's the breaks. There's been some reporting about a decline in your YouTube subscribers and daily wire page views. And I know that's in the context of a lot of media struggling with AI and other things. But do you accept that there has been a decline that it's something real and that's a bad concern? There hasn't been a decline in our, in our viewership on YouTube generally. There was a decline in subscriptions, which I think is sort of fascinating because people don't tend to unsubscribe from YouTube. It's actually not the way that YouTube is typically operated these days. It felt more frankly like a concerted attempt to create a number in that particular respect. But, but sure. I mean, what do you mean somebody was like coordinating? Well, I mean, there were people who were calling for people to unsubscribe from my YouTube page. But that doesn't actually change the number of hits that you get on a particular video. Uh-huh. Right? Your followership does not actually, subscriptions on YouTube 10 and 15 years ago meant that you got fed all the videos from this person in particular way that has now changed algorithmically. So, it was sort of a weird metric to use as sort of evidence of decline. Obviously, the 2024 election was a rising tide lifting literally all ships for political media and for news media because it was the most insane election cycle of our lifetime, except for maybe 2020, which was also the most insane election cycle of our lifetime. Yeah. And so the year after that is always going to be bad. But, yeah, sure. I mean, I would, I would imagine that there are people who were members of my audience who were just paptic with my viewpoints and, you know, as I say, them's the breaks. I wonder if, uh, Trump has been bad for conservative media in that if you're all in for Trump, somebody is going to lose faith in you at this point. And if you're criticizing Trump, somebody is going to cancel you. I mean, I think that's always true for the party in power. Yeah. I don't think that's unique to Trump. I think that's probably true for Bush. I'm sure it's true for Obama as well. It is always easier to be opposition media than it is to be the party in power because you have to make sort of a nuanced critique if you're honest with yourself about the people who you helped elect. And then you're an audience, some of them voted more, many of them voted for them. And so when you're saying, I think what he's doing right now is dumb. Right, or as I've said, I think that the kind of whiff of corruption that surrounds the administration is truly awful. Now if you say that sort of stuff and a lot of your own audience might be mad at you. So yeah, that's sort of just the way it works. So do you see anything here that's a crisis or a concern? In which way? In terms of the audience. No. I mean, our business is an extremely solid footing thing, God. Let me ask about corruption because this is something you'll be talking about over the next couple of years. I was very interested in your immediate post-election analysis. You went at some length about one thing after another and there's so much discussed when it comes to corruption and this administration. The daily wire in recent days had an article and it was a columnist and it's not you, but it's someone saying Democrats are gearing up to investigate this corruption that's weaponizing the government again. That is certainly not my perspective. I mean, it depends on the nature of the investigation. Not all investigations are critical, obviously. You can't weaponize the government against political opposition and you can make them spend an awful lot of money on spurious lawyers fees. But to pretend that there is no smoke surrounding the administration of silly, I was talking about this last year, like pretty early into last year. I was very on top of, for example, the World Liberty Financial, which I think is, for the lack of a better term of a scam. I mean, I think that the fact that the president, while he was president was listed on their website as chief crypto advocate is not only not a good look, it's a very bad look. And the fact that there are foreign powers that were able to own a chunk of World Liberty financial and that the audience was told, the general kind of consumption based audience was told, you can own an asset and the asset was a token that was completely valueless. But the money was flowing into the pockets of members of the Trump family, I think that's terrible. I think there are a lot of problems surrounding the administration. And I think that all of that's going to come home to roost. I've been pretty vocal about that. Certainly more vocal, I think, than most other conservatives. - When Democrats dig in and start investigating as they are sure to do, would you urge Republicans in Congress to go along with that, support that, try to make sure it's a careful, but a real investigation? - I mean, careful, but if the answer is careful, but real then yes. I mean, but that's always the sort of rub, right? It depends on the nature of the investigation and whether we're chasing people or chasing actual crimes. And one of the things I think that people on the right objected to about many of the efforts that were directed at President Trump's, it seemed like it was it find the man and then find the crime about the man. Something that, for example, when let's issue James was campaigning for Attorney General, and she said, I'm going to get Trump. I mean, it's like get Al Capone. Like the way that's not the way law enforcement is typically supposed to work, originally a lawyer. And then typically the way that this is supposed to work is that you identify a crime. And by identifying the crime, you have now identified the criminal, not you identify the criminal and then go find the crime. - I wonder if this is a standard you would agree with the idea being that if you're investigating corruption, you don't come up with a novel legal theory to take in everything, but if you find a really specific crime, you prosecute. - I think that's right. I think it's also true about impeachment, by the way. I think the failure of the first two impeachment attempts against President Trump was probably kind of in fact that a crime was not even alleged, right? It was a bunch of bad activity was alleged, but there was no actual criminal activity that was alleged. I think everyone ought to be a little more careful about how they use these tools. Are the incentives going to work against the approach that you just described? - Yes. I mean, the incentives always work against my approach. So, no shock to me, but yes, I mean the-- - And it's a conservative media as well as money and everything else in politics. They will want Republicans to really, really resist whatever happens and Democrats will have their own set of incentives. - Yeah, I mean, I think the incentive structures for everyone right now are generally quite terrible. And I think that that is a problem. And one of the things that I say on my show a lot is log off, even if it costs me money, that people need to log off and touch some grass. And that, again, I think that's why we are watching that pendulum swing so wildly, because the vast majority of people don't watch politics at a granular level, the way that you do or that I do. The vast majority of people went into the voting booth a couple weeks ago or last week. They went in and they said, I think that the Trump administration has basically stunk up the joint throw them out. And I think it was really that simple. I don't think that it was a bunch of different issues. I don't think that it was a bunch of complex matters. I think that people who are in politics like to abstract from that, kind of what they want it to be. But I think that's the wrong way of looking at it. - So I mentioned at the top, you've got a screenplay that's now become a film. You do lots of different things, which is great. I write books as well as doing broadcast and everything else, so I understand that. But I wonder if you have some larger goal in mind. Are you trying to influence the culture in some broader way that relates to your politics? - Sure, that's always been a goal. One of the goals has always been to simply provide another side to many of the cultural influences that people see. So what's different about this film, I mean, you've seen it. I would say it's certainly not overtly political in the way that say my show is. The film Confession, which stars Rob Lowe and James Franco and Jennifer Jason Lee and Nignalty, but the film revolves around a drunken former Russian literature professor in the Soviet Union who is in 1938 dragged into the Libyanca, which was the Center for the NKVD, the precursor for the KGB. - It's an interrogation film. And they try to force him to inform on his priest, who secretly converted him, and who also they believe is writing dissonant pamphlets against the Soviet state. But I think that there is an attempt to bring something deeper to the film world, and yes, another perspective, because there is no way that traditional Hollywood would ever have taken a look at that. - When you write history, you often are writing about the present as well. You're at least writing from the present back to history and may be commenting on the present day. Did you want to say something about modern America, modern world? - No, I wanted to say something was about the bottom of the iceberg that lies at the base of all politics. So in that way, I wanted the movie to be somewhat timeless, meaning that I think the politics is all of us arguing at the top of the iceberg. I think that when we're arguing about tax rates, obviously they're deeper values that are implicated in those arguments, but we're never arguing about those. We're just arguing very often about efficacy or we're sloganeering what I really wanted to do. And I think that the movie does this in, you know, pretty dramatic ways, his make arguments about what is it that drives human beings, right? You have one character who says that human beings are driven by bread and you have another character who says human beings are driven by justice and you have another character who says human beings are driven by faith. And it's like these are really deep questions and of course they have political implications because big ideas have political implications, but it certainly wasn't written as some sort of discourse about modern day housing policy in New York City. - I want to get a big picture again of where you think we're at as a society and where Republicans are, where conservatives are at this moment, and here is one way to think about this moment after this big midterm election. The Trump era is ending, or many people have said so anyway, and Republicans and conservatives have to figure out what they stand for next and they have to do it while Trump is still here and very powerful. Is that fair? - That's a fair assessment, sure. I mean, and it was going to end naturally anyway. I mean, it's his second term, so he's done. So the question of what came after Trump was always sort of an open one. And I always thought that it was conceit when people would say, the Maga movement will survive Trump. No, it won't, because Maga is Trump and Trump is Maga. And this is why every time you see anyone try to abstract a sort of Trumpian philosophy from President Trump, it always fails because that's silly. Trump is a particular figure. He's tremendously non-ideological. He's extraordinarily reactive in spolitics. And so trying to then abstract from that, oh, what Trump is means is isolationism abroad or hawkishness abroad or it means free markets at home or it means heavy government subsidization. What if it's like all of these things depending on how he feels that day, which is actually more accurate to actually his policy, right? You mentioned before that his terror of policy is very much in line with sort of democratic historically in the past few decades, more democratically in policy. That's true, but his regulatory policy is obviously much more in line with sort of traditional Republican regulatory policy or his tech policy, which has been extremely hands off. In ways that I think it's mostly good and it turns out has some downsides. You know, like I think that that is because he's a grab bag of policies, and again, I grew with more of them than I disagree with, the attempt to say, well, now he's created a movement that will help live him. I think that's the greatest mistake actually that any Republican politician or democratic politician can make is to say, my predecessor had this coalition. Therefore, I will duplicate the coalition and I will waltz into office on the back of that coalition. It's incredibly stupid, it never works. Hillary Clinton tried to do that with Barack Obama. It totally failed. If JD Vance tries to do that, for example, with Donald Trump, I'm just going to duplicate his coalition. That's not going to work either. Every politician has his own program, every politician has his own set of, you know, things that are appealing and unappealing, every politician has to build it on coalition. - What do you think could work? - If I were looking at the sort of Republican side of the aisle and just gaming out who is the most electable, obviously I think the Secretary of State is far more electable than the Vice President. I look at the coalition that the Vice President is relying upon and it looks like a much smaller version of the same coalition the President Trump had. And I've made this critique clear to the Vice President's own team for probably two years at this point. I look at Trump's coalition and I say, I'm not sure where Vice President Vance doesn't shrink that coalition. Does he do better with Hispanics than Trump did in 2024? There's no way. Does he do better with blue-collar white voters than Trump did? There's an outside argument, but is it possible to do better with blue-collar white voters than Trump did in 2024, very difficult to imagine that? Is he going to do better with married women? Probably not. Is he going to do better with single women? Given many of his comments, I think probably not. Is he going to do better with college educated people? Because he's steered so hard into sort of the populist online right, I think it's going to be very difficult for him to pull that out. Then I look over it at Senator at Secretary of State Rubio. And what I see there is, I don't know if he would win, but I know his coalition will look different, right? The Secretary of State's coalition would, can you see a world where he does better with Hispanics than Trump? Sure. Do I see a world where he could do better with suburban audiences? Absolutely. A world where he does better with college educated. Sure. A world where he does-- better broadly speaking with women i think almost certainly what he do worse with with non college educated white voters probably right so it you know if you're building a coalition and basically have a set of knobs the turn up and down for for the vice president i see pretty much all the Trump knobs turned down and with the secretary of state i see some knobs turned way up and some turn down can you define the vice presidents problem what is it he does wrong that makes him less appealing i think is extraordinarily online i think the vice president spends an in northern amount of time worrying what the podcast grows think like the talk of carlsons and i think that he steers directly into that i think he's entire affect uh. has been uh. militantly militantly quantum quote anti-establishment in ways that are designed to appeal to twenty one year old joe rogan listeners and i think that that is not how you win a broad scale national election i think that joe rogan listeners were important to president trump in twenty twenty four but guess what you know who's even more important to president trump by the numbers his panic voters and it's amazing to me that nobody in the vice presidents orbit has actually taken a look at the actual demographic breakdown of the vote shift from twenty twenty twenty twenty four apparently is it possible that anyone in this administration is going to be damaged by association with it because it is so i think that it's very difficult to imagine that won't happen i'm not going to pretend the republicans don't have an uphill road in twenty twenty eight obviously they do it is very difficult from anyone to do i think that the president is likely to write the ship and suddenly have a fifty two percent approval rating going into twenty twenty eight i think that's unlikely the president is very set in his ways i think there's things he could do certainly to improve his standing if you were to successfully and the aron more for example and the prices were were to go down that would be good would it would restore him to you know a forty five percent approval rating i have doubts he also seems to be surrounding himself with people who are more likely to to facilitate his desires than check them i think administration number one by the end of the administration had a lot of people there who like them or hate them actually said no to them right william bar the ag would actually say no to the president is like mr. president is a bad idea enraged him by the right and i think that that's why when he came in in twenty five he said i don't want any of that i want people who are just going to tell me yes and how how fat how high do i jump and i think that that comes with some pretty significant downsides but yes of course i think that running on the back of a undoubtedly you know fairly unpopular president that's always a rough road for for the incumbent party i mean bill clinton at sixty six percent approval rating we left office in alibur lost so the Barack Obama's approval rating in twenty sixteen was pretty high and Hillary Clinton lost it on the drums uh. bill clinton uh. had a terrible midterm in nineteen ninety four and in some ways changed course after that uh. it sounds like you don't think steven miller is the new chief of staff signals a change in course i don't think that that steven is a change in course guy i think that it's it's more sort of you know we're here for a particular period of time let's get as much as done as we possibly can also you know i think that pretty much all comparisons between first term adjustments in second terms are mistaken and what would bill clinton have really radically course adjusted in nineteen ninety nine as opposed to radically course adjusting in nineteen ninety five really what he did when he left the president isn't subject to reelect so he doesn't have the incentive when we get back to incentives again to make a big change i want to ask about the government as it will be left once uh. president trump leaves office you have said that in the second term in spite of things that you disagree with that the guardrails have largely held yes let me offer an alternative analogy that the guardrails have been severely dented and damaged all the way along the way and congress literally took out their guardrail and jump down the cliff themselves um well i mean which guardrail that for example the republicans did not kill the filibuster you want to talk about removing the guardrail except when they had exceptions that they wanted but sure well actually no i mean there was reconciliation in the person who removed the judicial filibuster was was very reary read the truth but there's an exception to the filibuster in this congress we don't have to go through the details and i said generally speaking the public in the public and the president railing against it by the way the president was railing against john thune and demanding that he killed a filibuster on behalf of the saviac and republican senator said no will democratic senators be quite as institutionalist you know i got one one of the questions i think that one of the reasons why republicans or were many of my fans were arguing with me because i said don't kill the filibuster is there saying well the democrats are going to kill it the minute they get in here and i'm not sure how good that counter argument that that counter argument might be right if democrats decide to destroy you know institutions i think that there's unfortunately a habit that basically says when my side destroys institutions it's fine when the other side does it it's a violation of institutional integrity and when i hear Alexander Ocasio-Cortez say she didn't last 48 hours the democrat should impeach supreme court justices not on the basis of crimes or corruption but on the basis of the fact that she doesn't like what they're doing that doesn't seem particularly pro-institution i mean i guess i'm thinking in terms of policy decisions that republican lawmakers voted for even as many of them publicly said this is a bad idea but i'm going to salute and vote for it i mean i did not choose to have an institutional opinion or defend the race i think congress has ceased to be an institution that resists the president's in most cases and i think this is true across the obama administration as well i think that that unfortunately american politics has become a game of follow the leader which is why when congress you know quote unquote can't get things done a Barack Obama picks up his patent his phone or or Donald Trump just starts signing executive orders the executives become far too powerful in our system of government congress has become a vestigial organ of government that signs gigantic checks once every six months and i wish it did not work that way because i'm actually a classic constitutional is this another way in your view uh. that the president has been not just tactically wrong but fundamentally wrong democracy and this republic is supposed to be a big argument with input from lots of other people use the word consensus actually on your show the other day uh. and the president's point of view is he was elected and therefore he decides everything i mean i think that's true and again i think that in this particular critique i mean a lot of critiques for president trump is unique this one he is one hundred percent not unique Barack Obama did this well before well before donald trump uh. i really think that when when we look back a hundred years from now at sort of where the fundamental breaks in american politics came i've used the phrase before that that everyone sort of wants to see donald trump is the murderer of american politics i've suggested that donald trump is actually the corner of american politics that he stumbled upon the the body of american politics bleeding out in the gutter doesn't he didn't go over and pull the knife out and start doing cpr but he certainly was able to declare dead and i think that there's a lot of that okay this democracy did no democracy certainly not i mean i i'm not a person who believes that this is quote unquote the last election this was my this was my you know critique of of governor Gavin newsroom so i was on his podcast earlier this year and he was saying all the republicans are going to steal the election i said so are you running right if you if you truly believed that the republicans were going to afford the elections in the way that you suggest you why are you bothering to run it's already rigged this is one of the things that drives me crazy is is it makes me crazy when the right says every election is stolen and drives me just as crazy when the left says that there's going to be mass voter suppression that prevents people from voting it is not true it has not been true right in modern era it is not true right now voters are getting to do what they want to do and i'm you know there's a big hubbub over gerrymandering and gerrymandering was the end of the world and how terrible it is and that backfired on republicans because it turns out when the american voter doesn't like a thing the american voter just goes and votes it out people did find a way to show up that is true because of that effort to press your vote or make their vote less or that would be a better way putting it but again democrats do the same thing in democrats it's like gerrymandering has been a feature of the system like it or hate it since legitimately the beginning and again it backfired on republicans let me invite you to give one piece of advice to democrats and one piece of advice to republicans over the next two years so my advice is kind of the same to to both um if you're the democrats don't misread the electoral shallacking republicans took for a vindication of all of your central principles that is not what that is the rejection of republicans does not mean that americans are suddenly in line with all of the dsa proposals or even sort of traditional left wing proposals they just are looking for some sense of normality and if you're smart what you'll do is you'll focus your attention on consensus measures that are designed to say target affordability you'll probably focus your investigative measures on the most egregious cases where you can actually evidence them and if you act in thorough goingly normal fashion then the voters will reward you and my advice to republicans has been the same for years and years and years and years which is all the american people want is normal that's all they want and i know that everyone's pissed and i know everybody wants to you know run directly into a wall screaming headfirst in order to demonstrate just how pissed we are but all the american republican want is a semblance of normal and this is the only constant threat of american politics over the course of the last twenty years the american people begging and crying for whichever candidate seems more normal and then never being given the thing they want benschapiro that's a place to stop thanks so much appreciate it just a reminder that new episodes of newsmakers drop whenever they're available we share them on up first when we can but the best way to stay caught up is to follow or subscribe to the show on spotify youtube or wherever you watch or listen you can also find it in the npr app and remember newsmakers like up first relies on supporters who value independent journalism and a free press join npr plus today to support our work and get perks from the podcasts you trust go to plus dot npr dot work i'm steve in skip thanks for listening to up first from npr news

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Ben Shapiro argues that the rejection of the Trump administration in 2026 does not equate to a full embrace of democratic policies, emphasizing that political shifts are often complex and not binary.
  2. Shapiro criticizes the role of partisan media in amplifying political failures, claiming that the narrative often frames any policy shortfall as a betrayal of promises, creating unrealistic expectations for leaders.
  3. He identifies the rise of "weather veins" in conservative media—such as Megan Kelly and Tucker Carlson—where figures prioritize performance and trending narratives over substantive, principled discourse.
  4. Shapiro contends that Trump’s policies, while flawed in execution, reflect a reactive, non-ideological style that cannot be abstracted into a coherent conservative philosophy; his success stems from responsiveness, not ideology.
  5. He believes Republicans must rebuild coalitions beyond Trump’s base, noting that figures like Marco Rubio offer more diverse appeal, especially among Hispanics and educated voters, while the Vice President lacks broad appeal due to an over-reliance on online, populist messaging.
  6. Shapiro warns that the current political environment reflects a deep cultural shift toward seeking "normalcy," not radical change, and that both parties must focus on consensus-based, pragmatic policies to win public trust.
  7. He critiques the failure of institutions like Congress to act as checks on executive power, describing the current system as increasingly dominated by executive overreach and political games of follow-the-leader.
  8. Shapiro stresses the importance of media integrity, advocating for truthful, evidence-based reporting—even when it contradicts audience preferences—because accountability is essential to democratic health.

Summary:

Ben Shapiro, a prominent conservative media figure and co-founder of DailyWire, offers a nuanced analysis of the Republican Party’s struggles following the 2024 and 2026 elections. He argues that the rejection of President Trump in 2026 is not a full embrace of democratic policies, but rather a reaction to the administration’s inconsistent and often overreaching implementation. Shapiro blames partisan media for creating unrealistic expectations, portraying political failure as a betrayal of promises, which fuels public disillusionment.

He critiques conservative media’s tendency to prioritize performance over substance, citing figures like Tucker Carlson and Megan Kelly as examples of "weather veins" who amplify outrage rather than promote reasoned debate. Shapiro emphasizes that Trump’s policies are reactive and non-ideological, making it impossible to abstract a consistent conservative philosophy from his presidency. He believes Republicans must rebuild coalitions beyond Trump’s base, with candidates like Marco Rubio offering broader appeal.

Central to his analysis is the idea that Americans desire "normalcy" over radical change, and that both parties must adopt consensus-driven, practical policies to regain legitimacy. He also expresses concern over institutional erosion, particularly in Congress, which has increasingly deferred to executive power. Ultimately, Shapiro calls for media accountability, urging truth-telling over audience appeasement, as a necessary foundation for a healthy democracy.

FAQs

No, Ben Shapiro does not regret his vote. He regrets the way the president has performed, particularly the implementation of policies, but believes his vote was a necessary choice in a binary political context.

He disagrees, stating that 'Maga is Trump and Trump is Maga,' and that the movement cannot be separated from the individual. He believes it won't survive as a distinct political force.

He argues that much of conservative media is more focused on 'weathering' trends than offering serious, long-term ideas. He criticizes it for being reactive and lacking ideological depth.

He believes Tucker Carlson has a conspiratorial view of power, promoting grievance politics and a belief that elites—especially those with Jewish last names—control U.S. policy, which he sees as a violation of core conservative values.

No, he argues that Israel does not control U.S. policy. He points to historical disagreements, such as on Iran, and cites instances where U.S. leaders have acted contrary to Israeli requests as evidence of U.S. autonomy.

He sees the election as a rejection of Trump’s identity-based approach, not a full embrace of democratic policies. He warns against overinterpreting voter rejection as a mandate for ideological change.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.