Beethoven’s Sixth Symphony, the "Pastoral," is a deeply evocative and revolutionary work that captures the essence of nature through simplicity, repetition, and emotional sincerity. Composed during the same period as the Fifth Symphony, it contrasts the latter’s struggle with fate with a joyful, serene immersion in the countryside. Beethoven’s love of nature is central—his music reflects not just a setting, but a spiritual connection, where nature becomes a source of peace and transcendence. The symphony unfolds through four movements that mirror natural experiences: the arrival in the countryside, a meditative brook, a joyful folk dance, and a dramatic storm. The storm movement stands out for its vivid, almost cinematic portrayal of wind, rain, and thunder, using minimalism and dynamic shifts to convey awe and terror without overreaching. Throughout, Beethoven employs recurring rhythmic cells and harmonic stillness, creating a sense of timelessness and unity. Despite its pastoral themes, the work is not naive; it contains profound emotional depth and complexity, especially in its handling of minor keys and sudden shifts. The final movement, a shepherd’s song, returns to the brook’s rhythm, closing the piece with gentle, grateful reflection. While often seen as an outlier due to its different character from Beethoven’s more dramatic symphonies, the Sixth is actually his most compositionally radical—unprecedented in its length of harmonic stillness, its focus on natural imagery, and its ability to invite listeners to co-create the emotional landscape. Beethoven’s genius lies not in literal imitation, but in evoking feelings of wonder, stillness, and joy that resonate deeply with human experience.
Hello and welcome to Sticky Notes, the classical music podcast.
My name is Joshua Weilstein, I'm a conductor, and I'm the artistic director of the Lozan
Chamber Orchestra in Lozan, Switzerland, and the music director of the Phoenix Orchestra
of Boston.
This podcast is for anyone who loves classical music, works in the field, or is just getting
ready to dive into this amazing world of incredible music.
Before we get started, I want to thank my new Patreon sponsors, Daniel Bob, Jan B.,
Timo, Rodney, David, Scott N, Scott K, and Alan, and all of my other Patreon sponsors
for making Season 7 possible.
If you'd like to support the show, please head over to patreon.com/stickynodespodcast.
And if you are a fan of the show, please just take a moment to give us a rating or review
on Apple Podcasts.
Every rating or review helps more people find the show, and it is greatly appreciated.
So I literally just landed back in London from a long trip from Indianapolis, had a wonderful
time.
My first concert in front of a live audience in about six months.
With the Indianapolis Symphony, we did a program of Chevalier de Solon Georges, Second Symphony,
Reveilles-Thombo de Coupeurre, and Beethoven's 7th Symphony, which is coming up on Thursday.
Then tomorrow, I'm heading off to Denmark to record a new harp concerto by the wonderful
Danish composer Martin Stounning.
So it's kind of the back-to-work world tour at the moment.
With all that said, let's head on to Beethoven's 6th Symphony.
It's December 22nd, 1808, in Vienna.
Inside of a freezing cold teata undervin, a four-hour long concert is going on.
Featuring a hastily put together and severely under-rehearsed and under-powered orchestra,
led by a conductor who can no longer hear the music that he is conducting.
During this concert, the organizer and composer of all the works on the program will also conduct
or perform as a soloist for each work.
I'm speaking about a concert that I've mentioned before, but it bears repeating just how remarkable
this Beethoven concert was.
This concert featured the premiere of his 4th piano concerto, his choral fantasy, two moments
of his mass and sea major, a concert aria entitled Apefido, the 5th Symphony, and the
topic of today's show, the 6th Symphony, the pastoral.
Three of those pieces, the piano concerto and the two symphonies, are three of the most
beloved and most often played pieces in the whole Western classical repertoire.
All of the others are performed regularly.
Now, it wasn't a particularly successful concert for Beethoven financially, but his legacy
would be intact just from these works alone.
And today we're going to tackle his 6th Symphony, a piece that unbelievably he wrote at the
same exact time as his 5th Symphony.
These polar opposite pieces do share some very similar traits though, something we'll
explore in detail, along with Beethoven's tone painting and mastery of turning repetition
into a transcendental appreciation of nature in all of its glories.
As Beethoven said quote, "No one can love the country as much as I do, for surely woods,
trees, and rocks produce the echo which man desires to hear.
We'll hear all about this, and more coming right up on Sticky Nuts."
One of the things that I've known for a long time, and which is fairly common knowledge,
and yet still blows my mind every time I hear it, is that Beethoven wrote his 5th and 6th
symphonies practically simultaneously.
In fact, the 6th symphony was finished before the 5th symphony was.
The incongruents of the characters of these two symphonies, one constantly striving for
triumph, one reveling in almost uninterrupted joy and calm, one anxious and often despairing,
one sweet to the breaking point.
I've often led people to wonder how a composer could have thought in these opposing terms.
But remember that Beethoven was one of the first composers to put any sign of personal
turmoil into his music.
Mozart, Hayden, or Bach wouldn't have dreamed of personalizing his symphonic work in such
a way.
And Beethoven didn't really either, even though romantic critics and then the composers
who took after him certainly did personalize their works and personalize his works.
Beethoven's music was about humanity in a way that no one else has had ever been, but
its universality and expression of the poles of human existence in these two symphonies
are what sets him apart, not any sense of autobiography.
I want to start here because it's always important to dispel the myth that composers wrote
about or in the character of their current situation in life.
There's no better evidence of that than in these two symphonies.
But actually, as we go through the sixth symphony now, I think you'll find these two polar opposites
actually have a bit more in common than you might think it first hearing.
Take the beginning.
It couldn't be any more different from the opening of the fifth symphony, right?
Well yes, in character and speed.
But both openings are in two, both openings start after arrest, and both come to a complete
stop almost immediately, something that was unprecedented in Beethoven's symphonies
to this point.
There's definitely some cross-pollination going on between these two pieces.
And the other parallel is something I've talked about many times before in shows about
Beethoven, his obsessive use of tiny, motive cells.
In the fifth symphony, of course, this is the famous "bapapapam".
In the sixth symphony, it's a rhythmic figure that isn't much longer, and in fact, it's
actually multiple figures, though one is used much more than any of the others.
And all three of these figures in the first movement are found in those first three bars.
It's like a writer laying out their first argument, pausing for you to take it in, and
then diving into explaining it, taking it apart point by point and then putting it back together
again.
The three cells are this one, which I'll call cell number one, cell number two, and cell
number three.
Just every note of this movement will feature some use of these cellular motifs.
Don't believe me?
Let's go on, and I'll call out the numbers for each cell as they are used.
One, three, one, two, two, two.
Two, two, two, two, two, etc.
Now this amount of repetition shouldn't work in a symphony, and this is always the thing
that blows me away about Beethoven.
What is it about this motif that he has created that allows him to repeat the same motif
on the same notes with just a crescendo and a diminuendo nine consecutive times?
And then to add four more measures of a total lack of harmonic movement with the same motif.
It's worth dwelling on the fact that we've played 33 measures by now, and we've barely
strayed for a moment from the fundamental harmony of F major.
This might be a good time to mention the title of this movement, and also the unusual circumstance
of Beethoven actually titling a movement or a symphony at all.
He never ever did this except in this sixth symphony.
The first movement of the pastoral symphony was originally entitled Pleasant Feelings
which awakened in men on arriving in the countryside.
In the published version of the score, it is titled Awakening of Cheerful Feelings upon
Arrival in the Country.
It's this sense of almost childlike wonderment that leaves us in this same harmony for
so long, and why it works.
There is a sincerity about it in a touching simplicity about the music that makes us fall
in love with it almost in spite of ourselves.
Beethoven known for so long as the crotchety and cranky fighter against fate and destiny
is taking a breath of such ravishing beauty that we can't help but to stop and smell the
flowers for a while.
Beethoven will use cell number one to take himself from his home key of F major to the correct
key for the second theme in this clear as days and out of form movement, C major.
And now Beethoven will introduce a new theme, one of the simplest he would ever write.
It's a G, then a C, then it goes down to a B, and then back to a C. It quite literally
could have been written by a child. Above it, the rest of the strings float overhead with
watery eighth notes. It both gives a feeling of serenity and of motion, something that often
bedevils composers when they try to write music about nature. They usually have to focus
on one or the other. But Beethoven, in his use of the most simplistic harmonies, evokes
na evite. In his use of a static theme, he evokes serenity. And in his accompaniment,
he evokes motion and inevitability. Beethoven walks the line here where even one Iota
more simplicity might make this music corny, but as always, he walks the line perfectly.
Beethoven is at his most gentle here, giving off images of ecstasy and comfort, followed
by folksy playfulness. This playfulness is something that I'll keep coming back to throughout
the piece, and in fact, it's something I've noticed as I've been studying all nine
Beethoven symphonies at once. Beethoven rarely gets credit for how playful and simply
funny his music can be. Take this section, which Beethoven develops rhythmically from that
gentle comforting oboe and bassoon line. He changes it to something a little more bouncy
and cheerful, and then to a folksy peasantish romp. He doesn't change one harmony, just
the rhythms, which slowly get compressed until the music has a sort of mini-temper tantrum.
If this kind of music doesn't bring a smile to your face, you might be at a bad performance
of the symphony.
Beethoven will finish the exposition with his most repetitive music yet, and in performance
is essential to keep this kind of music going. Interestingly, this symphony is probably
the most difficult of all of his symphonies to conduct, something that I'll come back to
later on. Beethoven uses a combination of cells number two and three to get to the end of
the exposition, where the same harmony is repeated for twenty-three consecutive measures,
with only a diminuendo to add any sense of variety. Interestingly enough, it never feels
too long or boring in the slightest. A mystery I have to admit, I've never felt I've been
able to unravel.
The development takes the obsessive repetition to new heights. Beethoven first uses cell
number one for some silly harmonic play, and then begins a sequence where cell number
two will be repeated for thirty-six consecutive measures. That's around forty seconds depending
on your tempo. So now we all know how long twenty seconds is thanks to handwashing guidelines.
So double that, imagine washing your hands, saying the words time to wash hands, time
to wash hands, thirty-six consecutive times. Even more remarkable is that Beethoven only
changes the harmony twice in the whole sequence.
I was told by the wonderful conductor Larry Rackliffe, that the best way to understand
this section is to feel the celebration of the changes of harmony. Some have compared
the section to taking a beautiful view on top of a mountain and then turning 180 degrees
to a new vantage point. And Beethoven achieves this kind of pictorial music by patiently
holding on to the harmonic changes until we are all washed in the ecstatic joy of the
peasant dances. And then remarkably he repeats the entire sequence, with the exact same number
of measures and harmonic changes. This isn't a development. It's a long and transcendental
meditation on the beauty of nature everywhere you look.
Finally, we get some true Beethovenian development, as he extends the short departure from his
three motive excels through a couple of new harmonies. And as we get close to the end
of the development, we reach our first minor key chord that lingers in the entire movement.
No composer would either be brave enough or capable enough to hold back from going to
a minor key for almost the entire exposition or development, but Beethoven does hear. And
its appearance and moment of uncertainty is so striking in context with the serenity
and joy of the rest of the movement.
But that really will be the only moment of true contrast in the movement, as Beethoven
in pure ecstasy takes us back to the recapitulation using cell number two. And once again we pass
through these vistas of beauty without any interruption.
In the Coda of the movement, Beethoven will linger on B flat, what we call a four-chord
in F major. This harmony, four to one, is the Amen Plagal Cadence.
Beethoven lingers as if in meditation again on that B flat, while the clarinet imbussunes
meander around their instruments. It's as if everyone is taking a deep breath. And
when the orchestra exhales, it leads to a moment that I consider to be full of naive
passion and excitement. Other conductors perform it as a pinnacle of serenity. Both versions
and everything in between are valid, but this is one section that speaks to everyone
in a different way. For me, I remember my time in Iceland looking at some of the most
extraordinary nature I've ever seen in my life, feeling an overwhelming sense of privilege
and joy at being able to take it in.
And with a playful solo clarinet who takes from the rambunctious triplet motif from
the end of the exposition chattering away, we come to the end of this movement, which once
again features four bars of music in a minor key, almost no harmonic development whatsoever,
and a fixation on three tiny motifs. And yet, after around 12 minutes, we feel like
you could go on forever, and that would be no problem at all.
1.
Beethoven's friends often commented on his love of nature in hatred for city life.
He found nature a refuge from his debts, his daily struggles, and from the people he
so idealized but also so often hated.
It was also a refuge from the constant trauma of his deafness.
He wrote in the letter, quote, "My miserable hearing does not trouble me here.
In the country it seems as if every tree said to me holy, holy.
Who can give complete expression to the ecstasy of the woods?
Oh, the sweet stillness of the woods."
Beethoven's student, Anton Schindler, which means take this with a little bit of a grain
of salt, claimed that Beethoven's favorite book was "Reflections of the Works of God
in the Realm of Nature and Providence" by Christian Storm.
Whether it was his favorite book or not, he did copy this passage into his diary, quote,
"Nature is a glorious school for the heart.
It is well.
I shall be a scholar in the school and bring an eager heart to her instruction.
Here I shall learn wisdom, the only wisdom that is free from disgust.
Here I shall learn to know God and find a foretaste of heaven in his knowledge.
Among these occupations by earthly days shall flow peacefully along until I am accepted
into that world where I shall no longer be a student, but a knower of wisdom."
Interestingly put, Beethoven reveled in nature, and the respite provided him from city living
his palpable throughout this symphony.
Some have even compared the fifth symphony to city life and the sixth to life in nature.
In the second movement of the sixth symphony, seen at the Brook, Beethoven takes many of
his ideas from the first movement, repetition, harmonic stillness, inevitable flow, and takes
them if anything even further.
This movement has often been described as lazy, and it certainly has a quality of serenity
that is unlike any of Beethoven's other symphonic works.
But instead of lazy, I would again compare it to more a kind of meditation.
This isn't really music written for our extraordinarily fast-paced age, and honestly
I'm not sure it was music written for Beethoven's Vienna, either.
The movement is around 12 minutes long, and like the first movement, the general character
almost never changes.
Beethoven instead spins out another version of transcendental meditation, using an ostinato
line that clearly is meant to evoke the Brook itself.
This line is written with a gorgeous instrumentation, that shows that Beethoven was a much better
orchestrator than he was ever given credit for.
The Brook is portrayed by the second violins, the violas, and just two cellos, all of
whom are muted.
This creates a kind of muffled sound that is extremely gentle and soft.
Using just two cellos gives the music a kind of lightness, while also still retaining
the colour of the cello sound.
Over the top of this gentle flow is the theme, which is broken into fragments.
One of the great challenges of this piece is keeping these fragments sounding like they
belong to just one line.
Now, I want to keep emphasizing that the harmony in this first phrase almost never changes.
Beethoven, known for such rapid harmonic changes and for his constant motion, is using some
sort of motion, but it is a sort of pictorial, rhythmic motion that nevertheless is completely
harmonically still.
In this way, this symphony is a precursor to the operas of Wagner, and of course to a piece
like Debby sees prayerly to the afternoon of a fond.
The key to the second movement of the symphony is its variety and orchestration, rhythm of
the accompaniment and counter melodies, not its harmony.
In the second iteration of the theme, the second violins, violas, and cellos now transform
the Brook into something slightly more babbling.
The clarinet and bassoon take over the tune, while the first violins twitter away like birds.
It could not be more peaceful.
Very few composers could get away with the naivete Beethoven shows in this movement.
The A section culminates with what sounds nearly like a waltz, but in four, followed by
Beethoven's symphony.
But to me, what makes this movement work so remarkably beautifully, is that just as you
might be wondering if this is going anywhere, Beethoven doesn't actually go anywhere, but
he gets very passionate about not going anywhere, and one gets the feeling like in the first
movement of an almost overwhelming love and appreciation of the nature around us.
By this point in the movement and concert, the audience in the orchestra should be in
the state of brilliantly glowing calm.
The development of the movement, which is in Sonata Form, is developed not in terms
of its theme, but in terms of orchestration and accompaniment more than anything.
Through it all, the theme retains its original form, again a striking departure from the
norm for Beethoven, who loves normally to obliterate his themes almost past recognition
in the development only to put them back together in the recapitulation.
But in this movement, the magic comes from those accompaniments.
In the first iteration of the development theme, the second violins and cellos take the
music of the brook.
A solo oboe takes the theme, and a solo flute takes another bird call adjacent line.
In addition, the first violins and violas play a gently rolling line in longer notes,
and the horns play a softly syncopated line.
That's actually a lot that's going on here, and it's important for the orchestra to
not allow things to get too cluttered.
But in the end, all of that motion was to set up for a moment where everything suddenly
clears.
The theme stops, the brook's motion doesn't stop, but it changes notes much less often,
the horns disappear, and the flute and oboe play a duet of an aching sweetness that
is responded to passionately by the orchestra.
This is music that borders on the sensual, and it's yet another quality that the orchestra
should be able to bring out for the audience.
Are you starting to see why this movement is considered difficult to pull off?
[Music]
The second development iteration tries a different way.
The violas now take the flute's bird-like line, the solo clarinet has the theme, and
the bassoons in the first violins now trade off with that solo.
softly rolling slower line.
The horns are back and everything seems to be rolling along again.
But no, and yet another heart-stoppingly beautiful moment, the clarinet plays a long and touching
solo alone, which ends with yet another passionate response.
It's not hard to see why Fantasia used this symphony to tell a story.
[Music]
Now in a parallel to the first movement, Beethoven uses a minor key for just a couple of measures
in the entire movement, and it's also at the same moment just before the recapitulation.
Suddenly the first violin's shift to B minor, and a cloud passes over the sunny skies.
[Music]
But it's just for a moment, and with a rush of motion, bird calls, syncopations and warmth,
the music returns to the recapitulation supremely unbothered.
[Music]
One of the most famous moments in this entire piece comes at the end of the movement.
We've had steady motion from the Brook for nearly 11 minutes by now.
But without any warning, Beethoven stops the motion and we observe three birds, which
Beethoven actually names in the score as the nightingale, the quail, and the cuckoo bird.
These aren't exact imitations, but Beethoven actually was often criticized heavily for this
moment, and some people do find it to be on the saccharin side.
But for me, it actually all depends on the moment, and whether the previous ten minutes
have worked successfully.
We live in a pretty cynical time, often for good reason, and somehow this moment has
to jettison all of that.
There's nothing ironic or sarcastic about it.
It's just a simple, earnest attempt at something playful and joyful, and that needs to be interpreted
and heard.
[Music]
[Music]
The great composer, Hector Berlio, is described with this movement so well.
Quote, "The composer probably created this wonderful ladageo line on his back in the grass.
His eyes turned to heaven, his ear listening to the wind, fascinated by countless reflections
of sound and light, observing and listening at once the white ripples of the river as
they break gently on the stones of the bank.
This is delightful."
The final three movements are all played together without pause, and it is in this section
of the piece where the music becomes slightly more narrative.
It also clearly becomes based on an obscure symphony by Justin Heinrich Kinecht, entitled
"Pastoral Symphony."
It has a five-moving form, and it includes movement descriptions like, quote, "A beautiful
country where the sun is shining, brooks traverse the veil, the birds twitter, a waterfall
tumbles from the mountain, the shepherd places pipe, the lambs gamble around, and there
the sweet voice of the shepherdess is heard."
And another movement title called, "The tempest bursts in all of its fury.
The wind howls in the rain beats down.
The trees grown in the waters of the streams rush furiously."
Beethoven probably knew this piece, and in formal terms there are a lot of similarities
as you can hear, but Beethoven's symphony stood the test of time for a few reasons.
For example, here is Kinecht's storm.
Kinecht's symphony was written in 1784, and is in an early classical style, where the
storm is written with a huge amount of energy, but in a major key and with a kind of fire
that is almost joyful.
When we get to Beethoven's storm, you'll see how everything had evolved.
At first we have to meet the merry gathering of country folk of Beethoven's third movement.
Simplicity is again the name of the game, and Beethoven takes a page from his third symphony,
which also began with nearly a minute of soft and under the surface plane before exploding
into joy.
Beethoven does the same thing here, beginning with a softly creeping line of fallen arpeggios,
followed by a softly singing line of "what else?", rising arpeggios.
Beethoven does nothing more than repeat this sequence three times.
Three times in D major and then once in C major, raising the tension more and more.
Where is this merry gathering and when is it going to start?
Well with just four measures of music, Beethoven explodes to a raucous fortissimo in the peasant
dance begins, complete with stamping, feet, and a rustic feeling that is unmistakable.
It's important in a movement like this to take note of Beethoven's metronome marking,
which is not particularly fast.
Done at a speed close to his metronome marking, it has that kind of rustic earthiness that
I think he was trying to portray.
The second section of the scarats in movement is another tour to force for the winds.
We hear first an obo solo, clearly a peasant dance and one way or the other, punctuated
by a comical bassoon punching away on the wrong rhythmic bars.
Each time the bassoon tries to find the right place to play, until finally the strings come
in to try to help him or her out during the clarinet version of the theme.
The horn now takes over the tune in a notoriously difficult solo, all the while the strings
have just been repeating a simple rhythmic figure as obsessively as any piece by a modern
minimalist composer.
And all of this is a preamble to the middle section of the movement, a raucous and
rambunctious folk dance that is played almost exclusively in the lowest register of everyone's
music.
repeating over and over the same rhythmic figure and getting more and more out of control
until the dance leader sounds the trumpet and the sequence is repeated again.
But the third time through this sequence something happens to cut the revelry short.
The horns are rumping away through the countryside when suddenly everything stops.
The second violin start to play in harmonies that are almost totally unrecognizable to us
after the stasis of the previous three movements and we realize something terrible is about to happen.
Barelyos wrote this about the storm that follows "I despair of being able to convey an idea of this prodigious piece.
It has to be heard to understand how realistic and sublime imitative music can become in the hands of someone like Beethoven.
Listen to the gusts of wind, gorge with rain, the dull growl of the bases, the shrill hissing of piccolos announcing the fearful storm that is about to break out.
The hurricane approaches and increases in intensity, a huge chromatic scale, studying the upper instruments, plunges to the depths of the orchestra, picks up the bases on the way, drags them upwards like a surging whirlwind that sweeps everything in its way.
The trombones then burst out with a thunder of the timpani intensifies in violence, this is no longer rain and wind, but a terrifying cataclysm, a universal deluge in the end of the world.
In truth, the piece induces dizziness, and there are many who unhearing the storm are not sure whether the emotion they experience is one of pleasure or of pain.
But how does Beethoven do this and how does it make such a contrast to the other movements?
Well, first obviously is the minor key, which we have heard for about one minute out of 25 minutes in the piece so far.
So as the cellos and bases with their three against two rumbling take us towards the terrifying outbreak of the storm, that is one of the first things we notice.
The second thing we notice is of course the thundering timpani, making its first appearance in the piece so far.
It also doesn't appear in the last moment, so Beethoven might as well have marked for the instrument to literally be thunder rather than timpani.
Beyond the obvious things, there is also the fact that as much as the harmonies in the first three movements were static, now they are constantly changing as the merry gathering scatters in all directions.
The harmony changes now every four bars or even every two bars, and sometimes do extremely dissonant chords, as each peel of thunder heightens the terror in the music.
There are strokes of lightning that are as vivid as anything Strauss could create with a dozen percussion instruments, including a thunder sheet in his alpine symphony.
Beethoven does it with just a classical sized orchestra.
Beethoven also vividly portrays the lulls in the storm as well, where the wind is swirling in the rain is falling, but the terror abates momentarily.
He does this with more repetition of eighth notes, but always rumbling underneath is the cello and bass 16th notes, ominous reminders of what is still out there.
In the most terrifying moment of the movement, Beethoven begins to portray sheets of rain falling with the violins and violas, while the winds and timpani play accents off the beats, emphasizing the unpredictability of the storm.
A piccolo makes its first appearance in the symphony so far, a shrill shriek of terror that is unlike anything we've heard before.
Beethoven then compresses those sheets of rain into a series of chromatic scales, until as Berlio says the trombones burst out, their first appearance in the symphony as well, and the deluge truly begins.
But this storm isn't a hurricane, it will not last forever, and slowly after the final collapse of thunder and dissonance, things begin to calm down again.
Beethoven brilliantly manages this come down by using silence and rhythm. We hear one clap of thunder, then near silence.
Then another clap of thunder, but more gentle this time, and a flash of soft lightning than silence.
Even though he resolves to see major, the rain continues in the low strings, until finally, really for the first time in the entire piece, the motion stops, and a gloriously sweet and tender line emerges in see major, full of gratitude for the end of the storm.
The scales that were so threatening just a minute before now will take us to the final movement, entitled Shepherd's Song, cheerful and thankful feelings after the storm.
In many ways, this movement is a reprise of structural motifs and ideas from the first movement. It is in a modified sonata form called the sonata rondo form, which means that the main theme will recur three times without a formal development.
Though the second time it appears it has changed a bit, which we'll get to. It features very little harmonic motion, and is a picture of simplicity.
It does have one fascinating predecessor, though, which I will talk about on my Patreon exclusive mini episode, so if you'd like to check that out, head over to patreon.com/stickingoutspodcast.
In the meantime, I want to talk a bit about why this movement is so difficult to conduct, and why it is so difficult to perform in a convincing way.
Most conductors you talk to will say that the sixth symphony is the most difficult of Beethoven's symphonies to pull off, and there's some reasons for that.
One cannot rely on the churning energy and visceral impact of Beethoven's other symphonies here. In a way, you feel as naked as you do when you play a Mozart symphony. Take this theme from the last movement.
It's played on the E string of the violin, right in a spot that can sound a little bit tinny and unpleasant, yet it must sound like the most tender music on the planet.
It is written in a relatively slow tempo, and yet the music has to swing forward with just a tiny little bit of inevitability, but not too much inevitability, because then it would feel too agitated.
And when the rhythmic swing actually starts up in the first violin in the low strings, one must find a way to get the music moving without pushing it too much, so that when it finally reaches the climax, it feels majestic and glorious.
not here.
buried in any way.
The second theme is a bit easier. It returns us back to the earthiness of the third movement and
flows much more easily than the main theme does. But actually, even though it does flow, it can
often get dragged down inside of its earthiness. It's very rare to find Beethoven that walks the
line like this between too much and too little, and it's no wonder that we conductors get nervous
about this symphony.
In the second iteration of the theme in the Sonata Rondo, Beethoven makes a couple of small
changes that should in a way make life easier for the performers. The cellos play a swinging rhythm,
and the second violins play a little hiccuping figure that leads us to the next bar.
Also, we are in the flow of things now, and this music moves quite easily.
The slight development that occurs here isn't really a development, but the appearance of a new theme
that seems borrowed from the character of the second movement. The cellos return us to the rhythm
of the babbling brook, and the clarinets of bassoons play an achingly gentle singing line over the
top of the music, punctuated by rustic interjections from the rest of the orchestra. This is another
playstick and really drag, and in a piece marked by serenity except for a few minutes of storming,
we're reaching about the 35 minute mark now, and it is challenging to keep the interest going.
None of this, by the way, is meant to denigrate the symphony, which I really think does approach
perfection, but it's just really challenging to bring off exactly in the way it seems Beethoven
envisions it.
In the third iteration of the Sonata Rondo, Beethoven transforms the theme into the babbling brook
itself, in a magical moment where measurements seem to disappear, and we all float off into the sky
and enjoy the views around us.
Let's now go to the Coda, another moment of difficulty for the conductor. Beethoven
again stops the motion here for a declamatory version of the main theme.
The theme then transforms itself into a truly ecstatic expression of joy and gratitude,
which is quickly weakened by a diminuendo and a return to uncertainty.
Is this the same kind of moment, like in the first two moments?
No, not really, but it kind of has to be treated that way. Even though we're still in
a major key, the music has to feel anticipatory, as if we thought we reached the top of the mountain,
but as soon as we got there, we realized there were a few more steps to go.
And finally, using the babbling brook rhythm we arrive there, at the climax of the entire symphony.
If it's possible to have the most passionate and most calm music going at the same time,
this might be the place. It feels like there's a distortion of time and space that takes place
throughout the symphony in a magical performance, where time seems to stop and move forward all at
the same time.
And finally, the music comes to rest. We reach a stretch from this moment to the end of the piece
with no babbling brook, no swing, no rustic dances, just the piece. And a feeling that, as Nicholas
Hardinghorse says, that the music, the villagers, and Beethoven is going off to sleep. The music is
marked to be played in an undertone, and with a supreme gentleness and tenderness, a solo horn closes
the book on this fairy tale. Now, it's pretty common to think of this symphony as an outlier,
only because of its character being so different from the symphonies that surround it.
And yes, the fifth symphony and the seventh symphony are radical in their own right,
and the fifth practically reinvented what a symphony should aim to do.
But in my mind, the sixth symphony is Beethoven at his most compositionally radical.
The long stretches of harmonic stillness are unprecedented. His obsession with a single rhythmic
cell pervades almost every bar of the piece, which was also completely new and an evolution on his
earlier obsessions with this same idea. The almost complete lack of a tonal contrast had
never been approached before in a symphony, and to have about four minutes of a 40-minute symphony
feature uncertainty is a hell of a gambit to make. And it all could have failed. It could have
been too saccharine, too imitative of nature sounds, too fake. But Beethoven said this about
the symphony. Quote, "Pestoral symphony, no picture, but something in which the emotions are
expressed, which are aroused in men by the pleasure of the country, in which some feelings of
country life are set forth." This symphony works because it evokes those feelings. It's not like
Beethoven took a camera and pointed it at this beautiful vista, this beautiful brook, this beautiful
bird. He allows us to fill in those images and feelings of our own. And that's what makes this
symphony such a powerful and transcendental experience. I'll leave you with Barely Oz's words
on the symphony, which I think can sum up this whole show, where I tried to show you some of
Beethoven's techniques, but often found myself struggling to say just exactly what Beethoven was
doing. Here is Barely Oz. Quote, "Isn't really necessary after this to write of the stylistic
oddities to be found in this mighty work. The groups of five notes on the cellos clashing with
passages of four notes in the double bases, which grind together without being able to blend
into a genuine unison. Must one mention the horn call which plays in our peugeot on the
court of C while the strings hold that of F? In truth, I cannot. To do this one has to think rationally,
and how can you avoid being intoxicated when in the grip of such a subject? Far from it.
If only one could sleep and go on sleeping for months on end and inhabit in one's dreams the
unknown sphere, which for a moment genius has allowed us to glimpse."
Thanks so much for listening to Sticky Notes today. We'll have some more exciting stuff
for you next week, so don't miss our next episode. If you liked what you heard today,
please feel free to rate and review the show on iTunes. It really helps the show game
more visibility. And please send any questions you have to Sticky Notes podcast at gmail.com
or my Facebook page at Sticky Notes podcast. And if you'd like to support the podcast
monetarily, just head over to patreon.com/stickynotespodcast. Thanks and I'll talk to you again
after a while.
(gentle music)
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Beethoven composed his Sixth Symphony simultaneously with the Fifth, completing the pastoral symphony before the fifth, showcasing a contrasting yet deeply interconnected creative process.
The symphony is rooted in Beethoven’s profound love of nature, which served as both a refuge from personal struggles and a source of emotional and spiritual inspiration.
Beethoven employs obsessive repetition of short rhythmic motifs throughout the work, creating a meditative, almost hypnotic effect that underscores the theme of nature’s peaceful, cyclical rhythms.
The second movement, modeled on a brook, features harmonic stillness and a gentle, evolving ostinato, achieving a serene, almost meditative state that stands in contrast to Beethoven’s usual harmonic complexity.
The storm movement is a masterful depiction of natural chaos, using dynamic shifts, dissonance, and orchestral textures to portray the terror and beauty of a storm, while maintaining emotional authenticity.
The symphony avoids traditional tonal contrasts, with only brief moments in minor key, emphasizing a unified, transcendent experience of nature rather than dramatic tension.
Beethoven’s use of simple, childlike melodies and folk elements highlights his playful and human side, making the music accessible and emotionally resonant.
The Sixth Symphony is considered one of Beethoven’s most difficult to conduct due to its need for precise balance between stillness, motion, and emotional nuance, especially in the final movements.
Summary:
Beethoven’s Sixth Symphony, the "Pastoral," is a deeply evocative and revolutionary work that captures the essence of nature through simplicity, repetition, and emotional sincerity. Composed during the same period as the Fifth Symphony, it contrasts the latter’s struggle with fate with a joyful, serene immersion in the countryside. Beethoven’s love of nature is central—his music reflects not just a setting, but a spiritual connection, where nature becomes a source of peace and transcendence.
The symphony unfolds through four movements that mirror natural experiences: the arrival in the countryside, a meditative brook, a joyful folk dance, and a dramatic storm. The storm movement stands out for its vivid, almost cinematic portrayal of wind, rain, and thunder, using minimalism and dynamic shifts to convey awe and terror without overreaching. Throughout, Beethoven employs recurring rhythmic cells and harmonic stillness, creating a sense of timelessness and unity.
Despite its pastoral themes, the work is not naive; it contains profound emotional depth and complexity, especially in its handling of minor keys and sudden shifts. The final movement, a shepherd’s song, returns to the brook’s rhythm, closing the piece with gentle, grateful reflection. While often seen as an outlier due to its different character from Beethoven’s more dramatic symphonies, the Sixth is actually his most compositionally radical—unprecedented in its length of harmonic stillness, its focus on natural imagery, and its ability to invite listeners to co-create the emotional landscape.
Beethoven’s genius lies not in literal imitation, but in evoking feelings of wonder, stillness, and joy that resonate deeply with human experience.
FAQs
Beethoven's 6th Symphony was premiered on December 22, 1808, in Vienna during a concert that featured multiple of his works, including the 5th Symphony and the Choral Fantasy.
Yes, Beethoven composed the 6th Symphony before the 5th Symphony, and both were written practically simultaneously, reflecting a period of intense creative energy.
Beethoven obsessively repeats short rhythmic motifs throughout the symphony, using them in nearly every bar, creating a sense of natural rhythm and meditative flow that is both striking and deeply evocative.
The second movement features a still, harmonically unchanging 'brook' motif played by muted strings, creating a meditative, serene atmosphere that mimics the quiet flow of a natural river.
Beethoven uses dynamic contrast, dissonant harmonies, thundering timpani, sudden shifts in rhythm, and a piccolo to depict the storm, creating a realistic and emotionally powerful storm that contrasts sharply with the earlier calm.
The final movement, 'Shepherd's Song,' serves as a joyful reprise of earlier themes, evoking gratitude and peace after the storm, and reflects Beethoven's deep connection to nature and rural life.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.