Go back

Atheist Bible Expert On Why God Doesn’t Exist, Wes Huff, & If Jesus Was The Real Messiah

1h 32m 38s

Atheist Bible Expert On Why God Doesn’t Exist, Wes Huff, & If Jesus Was The Real Messiah

The conversation explores whether Jesus claimed to be God, arguing that the evidence in the gospels does not support such a claim. Key passages like "I am" are interpreted as references to Old Testament language rather than direct divinity claims. The historical context, including John the Baptist’s role and the lack of "true worship" given to Jesus, further weakens the argument for divinity. The discussion also examines Mormonism, rooted in Joseph Smith’s claims of divine revelation and golden plates, noting its historical parallels with early Christianity—such as rapid growth, persecution, and religious succession. While both traditions are seen as historically complex, they share a pattern of emotional and communal appeal. Ultimately, the speaker emphasizes that religion, even when rooted in myth or unverified claims, can provide societal benefit by fostering community, offering moral guidance, and providing psychological comfort. This utility persists even when theological claims are contested, showing that religion's value lies not only in belief but in its social and emotional functions.

Transcription

19908 Words, 107130 Characters

English
As promised, here is part two of our episode of Alex O'Connor, it's a big one. We're gonna talk about Jesus and whether he even claimed to be the Messiah and maybe it was John the Baptist. We're also gonna talk about Mormons. You guys think they're where they might be right? Alex O'Connor is gonna tell us why and last and probably least, but the most fun, he's gonna talk shit about our boy Wes Huff. There's some Bible beef going on. Let's see what's happening. For religion is my real thing, yeah. That's why I'm specifically asking. I'm aware that you must have had tons of conversations with people and they've broken down what they feel their personal benefit from it is. Have you in your studies, have you read any stories that warmed your heart to be cliche and made you go, "Oh, I understand the societal utility for this." Yes, there are things that hurt people and ostracize people and that is bad, but is there a version where there is a net good for the individual? I had to debate the other day with a Christian who tried to get his dad with the hammer. He just attacked his daddy, speak to his dad's skull with a hammer. He was? Wow. And now he's a Christian and he's totally fine. So what was his dad doing? I can't remember, but I think this guy, he's like a sociopath or a psychopath, one of the other. He's like an actual sociopath or psychopath. So I don't know if there was anything particular or if he just did it for a good time sake, whatever, but for some reason. He did that and then he became a Christian and he still has that same brain, but Christianity, as far as I know, this is his understanding. The Christianity has given him this framework to abide by so that even though he's a sociopath, he just doesn't engage in that kind of stuff anymore. Right. So yeah, I mean, those kinds of people exist. There are also people who like, I just, I remember distinctly when I was when I was younger, when I first started thinking about religion, the first time I tried to write a book, I wanted to open it with this little story just because it happened fairly recently at the time, I was like a teenager, I just moved into a new new sort of area and we went to our local Catholic church and it was like East to Sunday or something and there weren't very many people there. I just remember sitting down and there was this old woman on her own. Just sat on this pew and she just like came up to me and went like, "Grab this." I hope that you and your family have a very, very happy Easter. I thought, man, that's so I don't want her to come an atheist. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You know what I mean? She's on her own. She's here in church. She's probably here every single week. She's got the, and I don't think she'd become unkind or something, but I just think it would be, it would be soul-crushing. And so it's, of course. So how do you grapple with that? By being violently agnostic. Agnostic meaning you don't know. So atheists is like religion is dumb. There is no God, nothing. Well, there is no God. Do you don't need to think they're religion? You can be an atheist who doesn't believe it's true, but still think that it's beneficial. There's a side of utility to religion. Got it, got it. So the agnosticism allows you to what? It allows me to not feel a duty in being honest to tell that old lady that I think she's wrong. Because she might not be wrong. She might be totally right, you know? As I like to say, I will die on this fence. I will happily just say that, like, look, if you think that God exists because of this reason or that reason, I'll say, I think that's bullshit, and I don't think that works. But I can't say that the conclusion itself is true or false. Right? Like if you think that the, the gospels are 100% historically reliable, I'll say, I think you're wrong. I think that's just not true. Right. If you say you think Christianity is true, I'd be like, okay, and then maybe it is, you know? But tell me why you think that. Right. And we get into the weeds. And does it matter why? It does because, I mean, well, it doesn't on the level of like, society or whatever, like if you're a Christian because you're parents or Christian. Well, what about us being emotivists? Well, emotivism is about ethics. So it's about what you think is right or wrong. Oh, okay. Because we're talking here about like what's just true and false. Oh, I think. Yeah. Some people, I've tried to apply emotivism to that in the path, but it gets a bit complicated. But they're sort of, there's ethical emotivism, which is just a linguistic claim about what good and bad mean, which is like expression of emotion. And this is just about what you think is true and false. You know? And most of my interests at the moment lies in New Testament studies and digging into the New Testament. And a lot of people just don't know what's in there. They've just got, they've just got no clue. Can you talk to us like, we've never heard a single thing about Christianity? So there are four gospels, you galeon in Greek just means good news. Okay. So the beginning of the gospel of Mark says the beginning of the gospel of Jesus Christ, the beginning of the good news about Jesus Christ. So these are the stories of Jesus Christ. And it's good news. It's just people saying like, good news. I've got some good news to share with you. Yeah. And there are four gospels in the Bible, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. The mark is probably the earliest written around 70 AD. So 40 years after Jesus died. And you've got Matthew and Luke, which are written 10, 15 years after that. And John's gospel, which is written 10 to maybe like 10, 15 years after that still, all of that is disputed. You know, dating is a very, very difficult thing to do. Sure. And they all tell stories about the things that Jesus said and did. Three of those gospels rely heavily on each other. They're all interconnected. They're called the synoptic gospels. Matthew, Mark, and Luke. John's gospel is like on its own. It seems to have its own sources, its own. Got five or three. Yeah. And so it was a little fuzzy. So what you've actually got is the Bible. But Bible just means like a library. So we get like biblio anything, you know, biblio, it means like book or library or something like that. So it's a library of books. It's lots of books. So when somebody says, "Oh, that's just because the Bible says that." The Bible is a collection of texts. So you have to refer to which texts are saying that? Yeah, but also it means that if you've got four different texts which all say the same thing, you haven't just got, "Oh, it's just the Bible that says that." It's like, "No, you've got four independent accounts which all say the same thing." So there's a lot more like evidence of history in the gospels and people give them credit for. So there are some stories that only appear in one of the gospels and none of the others. They might have happened, we don't know. But if you've got stories that are independently attested in every single one of them, especially if you've got other reasons to think that they wouldn't be made up, it's good reason to think that they're historically true. Now you said real quick, the synaptic. So synaptic gospels rely on each other. Yeah. So does that mean that like one thing could have been written in one and then kind of paraphrase? Mark's gospel is the shortest and most people think it came first. Around 95% or so of Mark's gospel is also in Matthew and Luke, like word for word. And then Matthew and Luke add extra stuff. But do you work off of Mark's, for example? I prefer to work off Mark's when I'm looking at the historical Jesus because it's the earliest report. The earliest thing in the New Testament is actually Paul's letters. You've heard about like first Corinthians, Ephesians and these kinds of things. These are letters that Paul writes to various churches. And these are actually the earliest sources. And what year is that? Uh, again, it's disputed, but probably around like 50 AD, something like that. So 50 years after the death of Christ. Or 20 years after the death of Christ. Sorry, sorry. Right, right, because it's 30. Okay, okay, okay, okay, okay. Got it. So he's like, listen, these things happens. I'm going to tell you exactly. But Paul is not writing a biography of Jesus. Paul is writing letters to churches telling them like how to organize themselves, what the theology should be, all of this kind of stuff. It's only later that you get these biographies. So you've also got different genres in the New Testament. The Gospels of Biographies that tell the life and times of Jesus. Paul is writing letters to people. You've got Revelation, which is this apocalyptic vision that John of Patmos has and then writes all about it. But the Gospels are most interesting to me because you've got these four different accounts. And sometimes they sussly differ from each other. And you figure out what you can learn about these different things. So like, you know, John the Baptist is. I've heard the name, but what is he? So a lot of people have heard of him, but don't know anything about him. John the Baptist baptizes Jesus. And it's the beginning of all four of the Gospels. This is something that they wouldn't make up. Because if you're writing a story about Jesus and you're trying to present this man as the son of God maybe got himself, it makes very little sense for him to be baptized by another known preacher. And so the fact that they all included it means that it must be something that actually happened. Right. So we have this historical fact about John the Baptist, which is kind of interesting now. Because you're saying people at the time would refute it. Because this is written in a time where John the Baptist could potentially stop you. Yeah, so it would have been around. But also like they wouldn't have made it up. Because why would you pull it? If it didn't happen, they wouldn't they wouldn't like make it up. It's sometimes called like the criterion of embarrassment. Yeah. If you include something that's kind of embarrassing or doesn't look good for you. Right off the entire. It's like in Matthew's Gospel at the end of when Jesus appears to his disciples. Matthew's Gospel says that the 12 disciples saw him and they worshipped, but some of them doubted. Which is like not something that the author would make up. That's even more believable. Exactly. That's like a that's really sophisticated story tell. Like if I was to lie, I would write that in it. Yeah, that's the thing. But you wouldn't you wouldn't want people to think. If you're trying to present Jesus as the the son of God, this is him. You wouldn't make up a story that some of his closest disciples doubted that. Right. So entering Jerusalem on a donkey, like having this sort of I guess like low status entries from Messiah who actually want to paint Jesus as like there's like this humble servant. And the the entering in on the donkey is a it's a call back to an Old Testament prophecy about like about riding in on a on a donkey because they could be made up. It could either you could read that as like it's either made up to try and fit Jesus within like the Old Testament and it's made up sorry for that reason. Or you could say that Jesus did actually do it, but that he did it knowing that he was he was doing a call back. But they're calling him the son of David. And there are also other reasons why people might dispute things. So for example, riding in to town, into Jerusalem, on the back of a donkey, and there's people lining the streets, Hosanna, and the highest. A lot of people think that if this event actually occurred, Jesus would have just been arrested. Like in an instant, a lot of people just are just like, there's no way this could have happened historically, just because Jesus would have been arrested. Like the Romans would have been like, what on earth is going on here? This man is like being worshiped. He needs to be arrested. So there are all kinds of ways you can try and figure out whether the story has actually happened, whether they didn't. And I find them all extremely interesting. And they can also tell us about the communities at the time. So John's Gospel, starting to have real quick about coming back in on a donkey, isn't that like the least attention-seeking version of coming back in? Like if you roll back in on like a white horse, then maybe people go, oh, Jesus is back. But if you come back in humbly on the donkey, maybe nobody even notices. - This is all the celebrations, I think they're saying. - Yes. - And the celebration, as he was coming back in. - Because he's coming in, like people are lining the streets. - And the fact that it means something to the high priest of Jerusalem. - Yeah, got it. - Got it, got it. - And he's doing a lot of feast day, I'm sure. So he's making a celebration. - This is like the, yeah, he's winning the World Series. - Yeah, but this is the parade. - Yes, yeah. It's around the time of the parlor. - And your observation on that is that that would not be smart given how much hysteria would cause and it would put him in a particular place. - But Jesus was no stranger to doing things which aren't small. He was happy to put himself in danger, but it's more like it probably didn't happen because that's probably when he would have been arrested. - Got it. - And he doesn't get arrested if he didn't arrest it then. - Therefore that might not have happened. - Yeah, that's one reason to think that it might not have happened. - But you were staying something I think about Mark and then we got it. - So John, John the Baptist is mentioned at the beginning of the World of the Gospels and John's Gospel in particular. It opens by really emphasizing that John the Baptist is not the Messiah. It opens saying like there was a man called John and he was not himself the light. He was making way for the light. And then people come up to John the Baptist and they say, are you the Messiah? And he says no, I'm not the Messiah. And he's saying, and there's this real emphasis. Like the author of John's Gospel is telling us, John the Baptist is not the Messiah. What does that mean? It gives us a clue that there were people at the time of the writing of John's Gospel who thought that John the Baptist was the Messiah. And John the Baptist is a really important figure in Christianity. Jesus in the Gospels calls him the greatest man ever born of one. Is John the Baptist. - Yeah, yeah, yeah. - He's doing it for him, that's fire. - But a lot of Christians say like, oh well obviously Jesus was excluding himself and you would say that as a Christian, but for me I'm reading that I'm like, you sure about that. Because I think Jesus was a disciple of John the Baptist. I think that's who Jesus historically was. John the Baptist is preaching. All the Gospels say, if you read like Mark's Gospel, which is the earliest, let's look at the earliest source. It will say right there in the very earlier source that John the Baptist is in the wilderness preaching a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins. What does that mean? No one really knows. But we know that he's doing some kind of water ritual for people of repentance for the forgiveness of sins. That's obviously something that Jesus picks up with the whole forgiveness of sins thing, right? But Christians will say, well yeah, I mean he wasn't, he didn't have the authority to forgive people sins. He was just like announcing the forgiveness of sins. Like priests would often do this. They would say to people, your sins are forgiven. They're not forgiven. - Was John the Baptist a rabbi at the time? - He was like a preacher in the wilderness. He was probably, he was like the son of a priest. - Was he religious? - Yeah, so he would have been Jewish. - So he's okay, but there's some, we don't actually know very much about him as a thing, but we know from Luke's gospel, although, when I hear priests, I think Christianity. - But this is pre-Christianity. - That's what I'm saying, so he would be of rabbi or some form of religious spiritual wanderer. - No, as in the father would have been like a spirit. - John the Baptist. - John the Baptist would have, yeah, just a spiritual wanderer. - Yeah, a guru. - And a rebel to the sins, so this guy. - This is what often people think. - Guys, tour dates. This weekend I'm gonna be in Cincinnati, Ohio, Liberty Township specifically. I'm gonna be there Thursday through Friday at the funny bone. Then September 11th through the 13th, I'm gonna be in Donia Beach, Florida. That is far from any who wants to blow up Florida. What kind of person would do such a thing? So as a safe show to come through, be there. September 25th and 27th, I'm rounding out my Ohio tour in Cleveland. October 5th, Dubai, hurry up and buy those tickets. They're selling out. We might have to move to a bigger venue or figure something out, but right now, we're about to sell out. And then all those dates and more, [email protected]. We got big things getting announced soon, guys. Big things. Also, Mark has tour dates. You can suck his dick in Montreal, Toronto, or Detroit. Those dates respectively are August 22nd, August 23rd, and December 6th. Why is there such a big gap? I don't know. Tour bookers, get your shit together. Comedy clubs, get your shit together. This guy got free open months. What is that? September, October, November, book the man. Mark, add non-live.com. So John the Baptist is described as wearing camel skin and eating locusts and honey. And he lives in the wilderness. Like he's this ascetic outcast. And there are all kinds of reasons why that could be the case. There's a book by a scholar called John McGrath, who talks about John the Baptist. And he thinks it might have something to do with some conflict with his priestly father and ending up like running out into the wilderness. But John is preaching this philosophy. And it's just that all of Judea were coming to him. He's this extremely popular Jewish preacher and people are coming to him. And he's baptizing them for the repentance of sins. And then Jesus comes along. And John is saying, there's one coming who's greater than I and I'm not worthy to untie his sandal strap. And then Jesus shows up and he's like, oh, here he is. This is the guy. And then he baptizes Jesus and the heavens open up. And God says, this is my son with whom I'm well pleased. And that's the start of Jesus' ministry. So that's the Christian version that you get in the gospels. That's going to be history mixed with myth. In my view, Jesus was a follower of John the Baptist because all the gospels report that he was baptized by him, which they wouldn't make up. And you've constantly got these ideas of Jesus saying, like Jesus talks about how the greatest students will one day come to surpass their teachers. And Jesus is talking about his disciples. And he also at one point says that disciples that they will do greater things than I. So you'll do even greater things than I. Sort of implying that there's some kind of battle to be passed on. Now Christians will dispute that they won't like this at all because Jesus is the guy. But I'm thinking historically, it seems like anything that Jesus does, which he seems to get from the father, he is willing to give to his disciples. So in John chapter 20, verse is like 21 onwards, Jesus says to his disciples, after his vision from the dead, ask the father has sent me, I'm sending you. And he breathes on them, says, receive the Holy Spirit. If you go and forgive anyone sins, they're forgiven. If you do not forgive them, then their sins are retained. So Jesus seems to give the disciples the ability to forgive sins. And he does it by breathing the Spirit on them. At the baptism, John the Baptist, who's preaching a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins, baptizes Jesus and what happens. The Spirit comes into Jesus at the baptism. And so it seems like there is this analogue between what's happening to Jesus and what Jesus is then giving to his disciples. - Like vampires. - Now, yeah. Why not? If you speak to a Christian, they're gonna come in and they're gonna be like, Alex, there's nobody's talking about like this is all not. But like, I understand that that's not the Christian interpretation, but this is how I'm reading this. - You're analyzing it from a historical record. - Yeah. But also, even if you're looking at the historical Jesus, this is a particular viewpoint. It's not like a given. This is just my understanding. But it's worth pointing out that this is something that people need to sort of realize there are lots of different views on, even within the gospels. - Yeah, yeah. Cause the gospels are saying all kinds of different stuff. And they give us all kinds of different clues into interesting facts about Jesus. - Guys, one question about John the Baptist real quick. You said he was popular at the time. - Yeah, extremely. - They're like ratings about him specifically. Is there a historical account? Like, how popular? Hundreds of people, thousands of people. - Well, the gospels say all of Judea was coming to him, which is obviously an exaggeration, but it means like, lots and lots of people. Also, when Herod Antipas, King of Judea, like, first hears about Jesus, this is again in the gospels. He hears about the Sky Jesus who's going around causing a ruckus and he says, this is John the Baptist resurrected. John the Baptist gets beheaded in the gospels, by the way. And so, who must John the Baptist have been? The one he hears about Jesus. He goes, that's another John the Baptist. John the Baptist must have been doing some crazy stuff. - He's probably the only one who's been a nuisance. - Are there any texts about John the Baptist kind of? There is a, there is a Gnostic group called the Mandayans who still exist today in small numbers and they believe that John the Baptist is their last and most important prophet. They think Jesus is a false prophet and John the Baptist is like their central figure. They historically claim to be part of the original following of John the Baptist. Anthropologically, that's probably not the case. Most of them were living in a ruck until the Iraq war and now their numbers have completely dwindled. These guys have their own literature. You can read it online. It's the Manday and Book of John. And they retail the story of the baptism. So Jesus comes to John the Baptist and they have a bit of an argument. And John the Baptist doesn't want to baptize Jesus not because he's unworthy but because he knows that Jesus is going to be trouble. He's like, no, he's going to have an argument about it. And he has a go at him. He starts saying that you've loosened the Sabbath and you've brought disgrace to these people and you've upset the Jews or disgrace the Jews or something like this. And they have essentially a bit of a debate. He doesn't want to baptize him. Now, is this a historical source? Like probably not. But it tells us something that people believe, which is this view of who John the Baptist was and that Jesus was a false preacher and sort of one of his followers gone awry. I find that really interesting, right? Because the most interesting thing is for me. John's a rebel. And then the next dude is a bit more of a rebel. I know that Jesus is definitely a rebel, right? I mean, why wouldn't John the Baptist have apostles or people that would be martyred in that way? Because so first of all, he did have followers. He does have disciples, I think Jesus was one of them. But also even in the gospels, Two of Jesus' disciples. the sort of poached from John the Baptist. - It's, it's, so two of Jesus' disciples were originally John the Baptist. Yeah, and in fact he's at the baptism that John says, "Let this is the man, let go and follow him "and then they go and follow Jesus." - He's in his, I don't wanna say his every religion, but like, isn't the same thing happened kind of with Mormonism where you got, who's the main guy? Joseph Smith? Joseph goes, "Hey, we gotta do this." And then he even dies before they get to Salt Lake City, but the next guy takes it. - By the way, Scientology is a no, do you know who the first ever US presidential candidate to be assassinated while running for office? - What? - While running for office? - It was Joseph Smith. Founded with a Mormon religion. He was running for president at the time. - All he was traveling out to Salt Lake City. - That's right, so they were, they were, they were sort of. - Paul's, the Mormonist, yeah. - The Mormonist might be honest about that. - Yeah, I don't wanna get into that. - Mormonism is, is, I don't wanna get a subtraction. - No, it's absolutely fascinating man, 'cause like, it's such a wacky story. Like, the history, and because it's relatively recent, it's like 1800s, like there's more records. Like, we know certain things happen, so we know that Joseph Smith claims to receive these golden plates. He's told by the angel Moroni, "Go and dig up these golden plates." The golden plates exist because in ancient Israel, just before the Babylonian captivity, some Jews, some Israelites were warned, and so they fled, and they built boats, and they sailed to America. - Jersey. - And they had entire civilizations. The Garden of Eden was in Jackson County, Missouri. - Of course. - They have an entire civilization. They were like, I'm talking about Lord of the Rings, like battles and wars and societies, and all this kind of stuff, and then the very last person, the very last, the very last knee fight, I think. I might be getting some of this wrong. I think this is actually the son of Mormon, but Mormon's the one who like puts it all together, so it sort of writes down the record of his people on these golden plates and buries them. 'Cause he's the last who's kind. And then Joseph Smith is in Upstate New York, and God says to him, hey man, like go and find these plates. So Joseph Smith has these plates, and they're written in something which is called reformed hieroglyphics, so they look a bit like Egyptian hieroglyphics. And Joseph Smith can miraculously translate them, and the way that he does it is not by looking at the plates, puts the plates aside, he takes his hat, he takes a special kind of stone called a sea of stone, he puts the sea of stone in the hat, he puts his head into the hat, and the stone starts glowing, and translating what's on the golden plates, and he starts dictating. He starts saying it out loud. - Got it. - Someone starts writing it. - Fire. - And he's the only one who can see it. He's the only one who can see the translation. There are, he's the only one who can see it glowing. - Yeah, yeah. - Because he's got a head, and he's got a head in the hat, right? - Yeah. - And you can see that he never showed anyone the golden plates. - There are, there are something like 11, maybe 13 witnesses to the golden plates. - Oh, there are. - Actually, if you read the book of Mormon, it opens with the testimony of the 13 witnesses to the golden plates. - Oh. - Apart from that, nobody saw them. But the funny thing is, it sounds really wacky, but what I love about what Mormons can do is they go to Christians. And Christians are like, this is the most ridiculous false profit, nonsense, whatever. And they're like, oh really? So how many eyewitness testimony written accounts do you have to the resurrection? Oh, oh, you've got none. You've just got a few second hand account. 'Cause we've got, we've got 13 eyewitnesses. Signed like affidavit like written down testimony as a people who are still alive and were questioned by like the press about it. And like, eat one of the guys who like, one of the guys who saw that he saw the golden plates. Later, falls out with Joseph Smith, is kicked out of the Mormon church. - But it's still like, I saw that place. - But he still says he saw the place in New Jersey. - I love it. - And there's some debate about this, 'cause one of them sort of says, well, he saw them with his spiritual eyes, which kind of means it might have been a vision. But then there are, he's asked about that, and he says, look, gentlemen, look at your hands. As truly as you see your hands, I saw those plates, right? So there's all of this going on, right? So Joseph Smith then like, found this religion off of the basis of it, and they don't like being called Mormons, 'cause Mormon is the name of one of the, I think he's a prophet, but he's like the guy that collates the book of Mormon. They are members of the church. - Like, can't Jesus Christ or something? - Yeah, or like calling them a Muhammadian, probably it's more similar, which is what they used to call Muslims, because they sort of misunderstood what they were all about. And, but yeah, like they sort of flip and flop about whether it's a gauge called the Mormons, because it's a bit clunky to say, a member of the church of Jesus Christ of life, of course, full out of the day saying, right? So Joseph Smith, they're sort of, they're setting up communities and they're trying to find somewhere to like set up their community. So they're traveling around the United States. And when they get to Missouri, they call such a problem in Missouri. There is something called, I think it's called the like, the Missouri Executive Order 45 or something. Otherwise known as like the Mormon extermination order, which is where the governor of Missouri, based on some like inflated reports about what the Mormons were doing, gets so like worried and paranoid about them, that he starts, that he issues an order to exterminate Mormons to drive them out of the land by force, which basically means that you could just like, kill Mormons, you just like go Mormon hunting, 'cause he wanted them gone. They were causing such a problem. Like in the United States, there was a law passed in the Executive Order that said, we're just going to kill Mormons and drive them out of our land. Kill white people, I don't know, come on. Which is like, yeah, it's not shocking for me. (laughing) That's why you're wearing that. It's just like a worsening American did, you know? (laughing) - Crazy. - You wouldn't believe. It's just wild. - Don't take us too far away from Jesus. I wanna. - Oh sure, okay, but yeah, we can definitely get back to Jesus. But Joseph Smith eventually, so part of the, when he decides to run for president, part of his running campaign is that he wants to annex Texas because he wants to make Texas like the land for the Mormon people, so that's part of his thing. And eventually, so you know Mormons are into like Pallegamy? - Yeah. - They were. Now, if you're a Pallegamist, you can't be a Mormon. Like it's anathema to them. Like the 1980s or something, they finally said it's not right. But they got, one of the reasons they got in so much trouble with the US government was because they had multiple wives. And that was seen as totally wrong. And so Joseph Smith is now, I can't remember which state he's in when he actually dies. I think it might be Illinois, but I'm not sure about that. - He dies in Illinois. I think the third spot, they end up, correct? - Yeah, they've sort of been all over the place. And I think Illinois is where he gets killed. - He's just Google this. - Yeah, yeah, I mean, maybe. - Okay, great. - They just get kicked out of places? - Yeah, they get kicked out. - Like the Christian Jews. - Yeah, seriously, but this is the thing, so Mormons will say, Mormons will point out that they have a history of like persecution and people sort of don't know about this, you know? It's quite, it's quite amazing. So I debate Christians quite a lot. And they talk about how amazing it was that Christianity grew from just a small group of people to taking over the Roman Empire. And I'm like, the sociologist Rodney Stark calculated that in the first two or three hundred years, I think, after the birth of Christianity, the growth rate that they experience is exactly the same as the Mormon church. And then people say, yeah, but they would be impersonated by the Roman Empire. I'm like, have you heard of the Missouri examination? - No, I can't really care. - All right, get back to the show. - There is a newspaper in Illinois that criticizes Joseph Smith for his polygamous practices. I think at this point, Joseph Smith is the governor of some kind of province of Illinois. And so he decides to like, shut down the newspaper. 'Cause he doesn't like the criticism. So he like bans it. Then there's like a riot because he's like, suppress this newspaper. Then Joseph Smith institutes martial law because of the riots and then he flees. And then I think the governor of Illinois says, okay, Joseph Smith, you've got to come back. You're going to face trial. You'll keep you're fine. But just you've got to come back. So Joseph Smith goes back, he gets put in prison and then this big angry mob descend on the prison and they break into the prison. They shoot his brother in the face. His brother says, I'm a dead man and then he dies. And then Joseph Smith tries to escape out of a window. They shoot him. He falls out of the window onto the floor and they shoot him dead again. So he dies and what is essentially a prison shoot out. And for the Mormons, this is a site of religious martyrdom. So you can now go to that prison. It's now owned by the Latter-day Saints. And it's a site that they go to as the martyrs, it's the point of martyrdom for their profit. There it is. There's the house. So Joseph Smith was killed falling out of that window. There's a, there's a, there he is. I think that's wild. Big mob sharp and kill him. So Joseph Smith becomes like a martyr and that's that. And then there's your typical religious like succession crisis who's going to take over. I think there's a point where like, I think it's Brigham Young who's, who's giving a speech saying, I should be the leader and like multiple people were reporting him like transfigure into the likeness of Joseph Smith. There's all kinds of wacky stuff going on, right? And yeah, like it's, it sounds kind of insane, but is that any more insane than some of the Christian stories that we know we hear? It's farther ago. Yeah, exactly. We have to speak of it. So it's better. Of course. People sort of go like, oh, but that's ridiculous. As if, as if God would appear to someone in upstate New York, that's ridiculous, it's like, well, that's how it sounded, like, to be born in Nazareth. But people are saying in the gospels like, is this not Joseph's son? Is this not the guy from Nazareth? Is anything good come from Nazareth? They're saying the same thing. They're talking about it like a standar with it. Yeah, they actually are. Yeah, that's what that's what's going on. Why is the Nazareth had a reputation of just like, it was just like a nowhere town. It was like a fentanyl town. Like the Jews are expecting a Messiah. And the Messiah, like, there are different views on what the Messiah was going to be but the general line on this is that they were expecting people because at the time they're being persecuted by Rome. So they are, we're waiting the Messiah to liberate them from. Who will come and liberate? So they're expecting like this military leader who's going to leave them into battle against Rome and they're going to win. They got a hippie. They got a hippie. Exactly. So was he really hippie or is that kind of the way of it? It depends on what we're going to be hippies like. He was, he was pretty like, he wasn't just like a sort of, yeah, peace and love, man. It's kind of badass all of it. He said some pretty serious stuff and did some serious things. But in the old example. Political revolution area. Flip in the table. Flip in the table. Flip in the table. He goes into the temple and he, in John's Gospel, he makes a cord. He puts some chords together and turns it into a whip and goes around with a whip, driving people out of the temple because they're trading in his father's house. He also says some pretty serious stuff. He says if anybody does not hate their mother and their father and their brother and sister, they cannot be my disciple. If anyone does not hate them, because hatred can kind of mean in this context like preference. It's used elsewhere. For them, so it's one of these slightly mystifying passages, but a lot of it has to do with how these words are understood and used at the time. So it means something. To say that you hate someone can mean that comparatively, you prefer me. So he's saying that you have to put me above your friends of army, which is very sort of culty, but the problem with cults is that they're wrong. That's the problem with the cult is that they're not actually true. If the cult is true, then that probably is what you should do, right? Yes, Jesus is a complicated figure who does all kinds of different stuff, but his main message is one of love. You make the claim in the Jubilee video that the Christ doesn't claim to ever be God. That's what I think. And that's controversial too. Amongst Christians, if you say Jesus never even claims to be God, even in the gospels, they'll look at you like you've said a triangle has four sides. In biblical scholarship, this has been a very mainstream opinion for the past few hundred years. And why do you believe that? Because there's no instance in the gospels where I think Jesus is claiming to be God. Christians think that they have examples, but I think that all of them don't actually apply. What are your examples and what are theirs? So there are constantly examples of Jesus seeming to separate himself from the Father where he says, like, the Father is greater than I am and stuff like this. And people like rattle these off. The problem is, the void of any context is difficult to know what they even mean. So Christians will point to verses like when Jesus says in John chapter 10, he says, Father and I are one. And when his disciple Philip asks him, when do we get to see the Father? He says to Philip, anyone who's seen me has seen the Father. And Christians point to that and they say, see, he's claiming to be God, but you just got to keep reading. How can you say, show us the Father? Don't you know that the Father is in me and I'm in the Father? Interesting. Skip to John chapter 17 where Jesus is praying for his disciples and then for all of his Christian believers. And he prays. He's praying to the Father and he says, I hope that they will all one day be in us just as I am in you and you are in me. I hope that they will be in us and will all sort of be one together. I hope. Yeah, like he prays. Yeah, like he's sort of praying for that to happen in the future, right? So whatever relationship Jesus has with the Father there and being in him and in him, it's something that he at least wants the disciples to one day achieve. So if that's Jesus claiming to be identical to Yahweh, the God Yahweh, then he must think that that's something that's available to the Father. So the rest of us, yeah. That doesn't make sense. So we've got to reinterpret that first. Okay. Like there are, there are, this is in John's gospel as well, like, and the interesting thing is that most of these important Christological claims only appear in John's gospel. And John's is the latest. John's is the latest. Which you said has potential. Yeah, so there's already reason to think it's less historically reliable in the latest, but also the fact that Jesus is making these claims in front of all of his disciples. And if in John's gospel he makes explicit claims to be God, like in John chapter 8, he says to his Jewish opponents, before Abraham was, I am. And I am is supposed to be like a call back to the name of God in the Old Testament. And he's claiming to be pre-existent because he exists before Abraham. And a lot of Christians say this is claiming to be God. And the first question that you should ask is, okay, if Jesus actually said to this, and that did actually, did actually mean that by it, did the other gospel authors just not think it was an important detail? If Jesus, like, said in the full view of his opponents and his disciples, I am God. Yeah, you'd think of the other authors and people say to me, well, I think that the other gospel authors were sort of focusing on different things. So they just neglected to mention the point where Jesus said I am God. So I don't think he historically said this, but I also don't think that means what Christians think it means for some quite interesting, tacky reasons. Oh, why? So there are two elements of the I am statement here, like in John chapter 8. Jesus is speaking to his Jewish opponents, and they say, and he's talking about eternal life. And they say, well, our father, Abraham, he died, he's saying you're greater than him. And he says, Jesus says Abraham rejoiced to see my day. And the Jews say, you're not even 80 years old, and Abraham has seen you. You've seen Abraham. And he goes, truly, I tell you before Abraham was I am, at which point they pick up stones to stone into death. So the Christians say they knew he was committing blasphemy. They knew he was claiming to be God. That's why they tried to stone him to death. There are a few interesting things that needs to be pulled out of this, right? The New Testament is written in Greek. So what Jesus actually says there is before Abraham was Ego Amy, which means I am. That is also a phrase that can just mean like it's me. It's a very normal phrase that is used in in Greek. So in the next chapter, Jesus heals a blind man, the blind man runs into town. And they say, isn't this the man who was born blind? And the man says Ego Amy. It's me. Yeah. In this context, it's a little bit weird, because he uses it in the present tense. He says, before Abraham was I am, or it's me, something like that, people think that what's going on here, ebonyx, in the old ebonyx, no, he's just going, I'm him. All right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I actually kind of think that's basically what he's going on actually. And say it. It's kind of approximated. Okay. But whatever. In the Old Testament, in the book of Exodus, which is written in Hebrew, Moses is talking to God. And God says to God, like, is speaking to him through the burning version, all this kind of stuff. And Moses says, when I go back to my people, who should I tell them something? Like, what's your name? And God says, Aisha, Aisha, I am that I am, or I am who I am. So go and tell them that I am has sent you Aisha, Aisha, Aisha, go and tell them that Aisha has sent you. And so when Jesus says, before Abraham was, I am, he's invoking the name that God gave himself in Exodus, which is I am. So that's the line. That's why they think that's the case. I'm suspicious of this for a few reasons. Firstly, it can also just be a normal statement. So let's figure out which one's going on here. The Old Testament is written in Hebrew mostly. And this passage, Aisha, Aisha, Aisha means something like, I am that I am. But the New Testament is written in Greek. So the people who wrote the New Testament were using a Greek translation of the Old Testament, right? Oh, God it. They're not consuming the Hebrew. They're consuming the Greek. And it's well known, we have good evidence that the New Testament authors are using a translation of the Old Testament called the Septuagint, which is the Greek translation of the Old Testament. And we know that that is their Old Testament. So Aisha, Aisha, Aisha translates to in Greek, ego, Amy, hot on, hot on is so, so this is where it gets really interesting in the, in the Greek version. Yeah. If you read the Septuagint, God doesn't say the same thing twice. So in Hebrew, he says, Aisha, Aisha, Aisha, I am that I am. It's the same thing twice. And then he says, go and tell them that I am has sent you. So he says it three times in the Greek version. He says, you know, watch, like, cool them. And God says in response, ego, Amy, hot on, which means something like I am the one who is, I am ego, Amy, the one who is hot on. So go and tell them, hot on has sent you. I is. It does. Who is? It doesn't say go and tell them, I go, Amy has sent you. It says go and tell them, hot on has sent you. So the version of the New Testament, yeah, authors were using, I think, if they were trying to invoke this, this passage, they would have had them say something like hot on, but he just said, ego, Amy. So in the Greek Septuagint, when God says this to Moses, the function of the phrase ego, Amy is just introducing itself. You're just saying, I am the one who is, it's like saying, I am Alex. My name is Alex and the I am bit there is just me introducing the phrase. So I think in the Greek version, ego, Amy, hot on, go and tell them that hot on has sent you. And so when Jesus says, before Abraham was ego, Amy, it's not obvious to me that he's making a call back to the, because firstly, I don't think Jesus said these words. I think that it's an invention of John's gospel and we know that John was using the Septuagint. And so I don't think that that adds up. But there is still a mystery there. Why does Jesus say that he existed before Abraham and why does he speak in the present tense? Why does he say, I am? Why didn't he say before Abraham existed? I did. What? Oh, sorry, do you have any answer for this? Cause I've got some speculation. What are you telling me? So I think that might what might be going on here is is an illusion to the fact that Jesus as the redemptive solution to mankind's problems was was was planned by God from the very beginning of time. So in the book of Revelation, there's a reference to the lamb who was slain from the beginning of time. Speak, speaking about Jesus. Jesus was not slain at the beginning of time. So why does it say he was slain from the beginning of time? Well, it's clearly getting at is that from the very beginning of time, God was just in the exactly same. So I think that Jesus is doing something similar here in saying before Abraham was I am before Abraham was the thing that I'm in body to say and there's some really interesting like indications that that might be what's going on because there's a there's a first century text called the apocalypse of Abraham, which is a Jewish text. It's not in any Christian canons, but it was a Jewish text that existed and you can read it online today. And it tells the story of Abraham. And importantly, this isn't canon, but it does tell us what some people believed. It tells us what some stories that people were familiar with. This is written around the same time as the gospels, probably around 70, 80, 70 to 180. And Abraham hears the voice of God and he leaves his home and he's terrified and he hits the floor. And then an angel appears to him. And God says to the angel who's called Yahoel, who has the name of God in him, which again, you know, Yahoel, Yah and El, like the same route was like Yahweh and Elohim. So he's got the name of God in him too. He says to Abraham like, "Get up!" And Abraham gets up. And he's terrified. And the angel says to him, "Rejoice and be glad." Because I'm like promising for you that someone who will like the generations that will spring from you will like bring some kind of redemption or something like this. He basically says, "Be rejoice." Be glad and rejoice because like redemption is coming, salvation is coming, and from your generations. So interesting then that in John chapter 8, the context of this divine claim is Abraham. Jesus is talking about Abraham. And what does he say to them? He says, "Abraham rejoiced to see my day." And they get confused. So like, you're not even 80 years old. How have you seen Abraham? And he says, "All Abraham was, I am." I think what he might be getting out of there is saying Abraham rejoiced to see my day in the sense that Abraham was promised, like he's the patriarch of the Jewish faith and he was promised what I am now bringing to fulfill. Before Abraham was, I am. I think that's what's going on. Now, to be clear, and Christians go push back on this. Of course. Yeah, Christians will listen to this and they'll be like, "That is complete and utter nonsense." Jesus is very clearly invoking the I am statement. It's so clunky that he would word it like that. And why would they pick up stones to stone in for death if they didn't think he was committing blasphemy? That doesn't make any sense. The key point I want to point out is that the thing about the Jews is upheld. The thing about the Jewish opponents is that they're constantly misunderstanding Jesus. And so people put a lot of weight on the idea that they stone into death and they accuse them of blasphemy. And it's like, yeah, but throughout the gospels, they're constantly getting him wrong. You think, in this instance, they suddenly were absolutely correct in their interpretation of what Jesus was saying. I don't think so. In fact, there's one point in the gospels. It's the only time this happens where Jesus is explicitly accused of claiming to be God. It happens. They say, "You're claiming to be God." And Jesus downplays it. I'm semi-complicated in that there's a Psalm in the Old Testament. This is Psalm 82, which opens by saying that Yahweh presides among the council of the gods, Elohim, gods. It's a bit weird. How is Yahweh? The only God presiding over a council of gods. And then later in the Psalm, it says, "I have said that you are gods. You shall be sons of the most high." So in the Psalm, what's clearly happening here is the word God's here. And some translation puts it in scare quotes. The word God's here doesn't mean God is in Yahweh. It means God is in a divine member of this council. And God clarifies in the Psalm is clarifies in Psalm 82. He says, "I shall call you gods." You should be called God's sons of the most high. So clarifying that what I mean is that you are not the most high. You are sons of the most high, right? Okay, park that and bear in mind that most Jews are familiar with Jewish scripture, right? Jesus is talking to his Jewish opponents. And this time he says, "I and the father are one." Because they're asking about his identity. They say, "If you them sigh, tell us plainly." And he says, "I and the father are one." And the Jewish opponents say to him, they pick up stones again. They go to stone him to death. And he goes like, "I'm just telling you the works of my father. What are you stoning me for? For which have I've been telling you things of my father? For which of those do you stone me?" And they say, "We're not stoning you for any good work. We're stoning you because you, a mere human, claim to be God." So they accuse him. Here it is. The most dramatic, most important moment of the gospel is for Christology. You're claiming to be God. What does Jesus say? Does he go, "Yeah, you're right." No, he says to them, "Have you not read your scriptures? Is it not written that you shall become gods or you shall be called gods?" So he quotes the Psalm that I've just mentioned, which expressly calls non gods, like non Yahweh beings, gods. And when asked about his identity, he chooses to quote that Psalm. And he says to them, "Is it not written, you shall be called gods." If God was willing to give those people that title, and the scripture can't be said at sight, then why wouldn't he give that title to me? He then says, "So why are you then accusing me of blasphemy for claiming to be the son of God?" So he clarifies. They say, "You're claiming to be God." And he says, "Have you not read your scriptures?" This is just a title that was given to the divine counsel. If he'd give it to them, why wouldn't he give it to me? Why are you accusing me of blasphemy for claiming to be the son of God because they're the sons of the most high? And so the one point where Jesus is explicitly accused of claiming to be God. In my view. In my view. He goes, "I'm not." Yes, I was just saying. I think he's saying he's not. So Christians again will interpret this and say, "Okay, he's answering in a very clever way," which sort of doesn't deny his divinity. We all are. But they don't want to say he's the world divine. They want to say that he is claiming to be God here, but he's probably answering in this way because he's being intentionally unclear because it's not his time to die yet, whatever. I read this as him denying that he's identical to the title. I see their argument too. I think it's really clever argument because he's basically gone, you can't say that I'm blaspheming if I am upholding scripture. So if you're going to kill me for that and you're going to uphold your law, point out in the book where I'm blaspheming. And the key thing to notice is that in this case, they pick up stones to stone him and he goes, "Why are you accusing me of blasphemy? I'm not doing what you think I'm doing." And so when it comes to race, and it comes to John chapter A and Christians often say, "Well, why would they throw stones at him and try to kill him if he wasn't claiming to be God?" It's like, "Well, because somewhere else in the gospel, they tried to stone him for claiming to be God, and they were wrong." So I don't think that they got it right, you know? And what about the worship of Christ, like the people at the time worshiping him? This is another big thing, like worship. Worship is something that's only given to God. In fact, when in the gospels of Luke and Matthew, Jesus is in the desert, being tempted by Satan, and Satan says, "If you just bow down and worship me, I will give you all of this land." And Jesus says, "Worship God and serve him only." And yet throughout the gospels, Jesus is worshiped and he accepts worship, so he must be God, right? Few things to note. First, how many times in, well, actually the first important thing to note is what the word "worship" means. It's difficult to define even in English, but in Greek, there are two words that are typically translated in the New Testament. One is "Proskineo" and one is "latruo". "Proskineo" just means to sort of bow down or prostrate yourself before a higher authority. "Latruo" tends to refer to like cultic, religious worship of the kind that you might give to God. In no instance is "latruo" worship given to Jesus in the gospels. There is arguably an ambiguous case in Revelation. We can get into that, but it's not a historical source anyway, and also it's not clear if Jesus is actually being worshiped there. But in the gospels, not once does "latruo" worship occur being given to Jesus. So we're just left with "Proskineo" worship. Now, "Proskineo", like I say, just means to bow down or prostrate yourself before somebody else. So if only God is supposed to accept worship. And let's look again at that Greek Old Testament, the Septuagint. Remember I mentioned it earlier. Throughout the Septuagint, the word "Proskineo" comes up all the time. "Lot" worships two angels. Jacob worships Esau. The whole assembly of Israel worship King David, "Proskineo", King David. This throughout the Old Testament, there are tons of instances of "Proskineo" worship being given to other people. So it's a different type. In the New Testament, Jesus tells a parable, the unmerciful servant, who comes back to his master and he "Proskineos" before him. He just falls at his feet. And so in some instances it is just translated as falling down at someone's feet. Because that is what "Proskineo" literally means, right? And so "Proskineo" as occurring to Jesus doesn't mean it's a worship of the kind that we would say is only due to God. It's just literally bowing down in front of somebody. Another thing to notice, this is really important. How many times does Jesus accept worship in Luke's gospel? Zero. It doesn't happen once. The word only shows up three times, twice in the temptation and the desert. And then once after Jesus ascends, his disciples worship him. But that's after he's gone. So he can't say anything about it. And crucially, that is a verse, that particular verse of the worshiping him is contested in our manuscript tradition. There is some manuscript we have that don't have that verse. Mark's gospel, the earliest gospel. How many times does Jesus accept worship? Twice. Happened twice. Okay, so it does happen twice. But one of those is a demon, Legion, who if you read most translations, he sees Jesus and the man runs at Jesus and throws himself down at his feet. And it doesn't say he worshipped him. Some translations will say that, but usually it's like he fell down at his feet because that's what it means. The only other instance of proskineo in the gospel in the gospel of Mark is Jesus being worshipped when he's being mocked by the Roman soldiers. Oh, so they're pretending they put a crown of thorns on his head and then they worship him. Why? Because he's the king of the Jews. Because kings are people that you worship you bow down before them. So they're making fun of them. They're like, oh, king of the Jews, king of the Jews. They don't think he's God. They think he's claiming to be the king of the Jews. Jews, and they're making fun of them. So even in Mark's Gospel, in Mark's Gospel, the early's Gospel, there are only two instances of Prosconeo. One of them is a demon, and one of them is sarcastic. In John's Gospel, there's only one instance of Jesus accepting worship. This is after the blind man who I mentioned earlier, he's healed. Sorry, no, this is the death and a mute man, I think. And Jesus finds him again, and he says, "Lord, I believe," and he worships him. First thing to note is, again, this can just mean bang down in front of somebody, but also that particular verse, the verse where it says he worshiped him, is not in our earliest manuscripts. Codex, Vaticanus, codex, synaticus, codex, Washingtonianus, it's not in there, it's not in the early manuscripts, implying that it's something that was added into the Gospels after the fact. Like, well, Florida's even with textbooks. Exactly. Exactly. It's kind of interesting, right? Sorry, I have a question. This won't jive with the Prosconeo, it's just that you were saying, but when you said, God said, you are also God, the group of people. Have you read the autobiography of a yogi? No. It's a Hindu guy who becomes a yogi, and he says essentially, "Yogi is a man who achieves God like not status, but God is within you, and you've realized it, you've reached that place." He says, "Jesus is a yogi, mama is a yogi." These guys are people who have achieved it, and they would have a following, and they would have, and it kind of proves that we can all do this thing. It was that jive with what I'm hearing from you. So that jives very heavily with what I think Jesus is doing. Christians will deny that interpretation because they think Jesus is the guy. He's like a very unique kind of person, God himself and the flesh. I'm much more in line with this, that Jesus is somebody who is essentially the idyllic example of what a faithful person should be. And there are lots of reasons why I think that, but I do think it's important on the Prosconeo point. I'll wrap that up just because I know I've banged on about worship, but it's important because remember how we started where I pointed out that in Luke and Matthew, Jesus is speaking to Satan, and Satan says, "Worship me," and Jesus says, "Worship God and serve Him only." So why does Jesus say that if worship is something you can give to other people? This is where I think this is something I think is really interesting. If your interpretation is Jesus is saying now that you should only offer Prosconeo worship to God himself, then all of those people that I've just mentioned, sinned, you know, lot sinned, Jacob sinned, the whole assembly of Israel sinned when they bowed down towards David, so that can't be it. So what's going on there? Well, notice how that's phrased. And he's quoting Deuteronomy, chapter 6, which actually doesn't say the same thing. It's kind of weird. But Jesus says, "Worship God and serve Him only." He doesn't say, "Only worship God." He says, "Worship God and serve Him." Let's look at the Greek. The word Prosconeo worship God, and then serve Him only. So the word only is affixed to the word "serve." Not worship. Can you guess what the word in Greek for serve is there that's translated into serve? Latruvo, which is the other one, which is the cultic religious worship that's usually only given to God or some kind of divine figure at the very least. So even in the language of the gospel, so there is a division in the idea of worship. So it seems in that instance, my interpretation is Jesus is saying, "Worship God because he is a higher author." And he's rejecting Satan's worship. He's saying, "I'm not going to bow down to you because you're not a higher authority over me." And it's written, "Worship God." Also, that's not written. It's really weird. He's quoting Deuteronomy 6.5, but Deuteronomy 6.5 says something like "fear God and serve Him only." He doesn't say worship, which is an interesting implication if he's rendered the word "fear" as worship. It can't mean the kind of worship that we're talking about. So it's a bit mystifying some people. Well, why did Jesus say that to Satan in the desert? The reason is because he's saying you should worship God, but you serve him only. Because if you think that Jesus was saying that, you should only offer a proskineo worship to God, then all of these people sin, including, by the way, people that Jesus mentions himself. Jesus himself tells the parable of the unmerciful servant who proskineo worships, proskineo worships before his master. In the book of Revelation, Jesus promises to his faithful believers that all of the other evil nations will one day proskineo before them. Jesus says all of these people will worship you. That's out of the mouth of Jesus in the book of Revelation. So it cannot be that proskineo worship is something that's only due to God. So in the book of Matthew, there are lots of instances of Jesus being worshiped. Mark, Luke, and John are totally unconcerned with worship. Matthew happens a lot, but I think you need to understand the context, which is that worshipping someone in the sense of proskineo is something that people just did to a higher authority. Someone who was of a higher status than you, like I don't know, maybe being the Messiah. It's no mystery to me in other words that Jesus would be worshiped in the sense of proskineo. Today, when we say the word worship, we mean something a bit different. Also, here's an interesting question. Riddle me this. If proskineo worship is the kind of worship that's given to God and only God, then why is it that after Jesus ascends into heaven, nobody offers proskineo worship anymore. There's no instance of the word proskineo shows up, but Jesus is not given proskineo worship. In the book of Acts, for example, the disciples are going around and they're not they're not going around offering proskineo to Jesus up in heaven. Why? Why not? In my view, it's because proskineo is just a physical action. It describes a physical behavior of bowing down and prostrating before someone who's of a higher authority. If someone's not there, you can't do it. If it were to mean like cultic religious worship to God, then they would keep doing it after he ascended into heaven, but they don't. There are instances so Christians will dispute this again because they'll say like in the book of Acts, somebody bows down before Peter, they proskineo before Peter the Apostle, and Peter says, "Get up." Because I'm just a human like you. And they say, "See, so Peter's saying that you don't worship other humans, you're only worship God." But I don't think that's what Peter was saying. I think he was saying, "Get up." He says, "I am also just a man. There's an I'm the same status as you." I'm not your authority. Like worship God, he's our authority. The other type of worship for someone. That's true. Yeah. How many times is that mentioned in the New Testament? It's mentioned a few times and in referring to. So the most interesting case for me is Revelation. So Revelation is a wacky, wacky book, and so I want to clarify by saying that even if Revelation just said, "Jesus is God," I wouldn't trust it as historical source. It does seem to resent Jesus as a very exalted being, probably God himself. Like at one point, Jesus seems to claim to be the Alpha and the Omega, which is a title of God. One instance, it's not entirely clear who's speaking, but in another instance, it's like Jesus saying, "I am the Alpha and the Omega." That's something only God says. It seems like He's claiming to be God in the book of Revelation, which is a vision that a guy called John has on an island called Patmos. And there is an instance. There are two instances of Latruo in Revelation where it's a bit unclear. What happens is you've got the Lamb who sort of sits on or in the center of or nearby the throne. So there's the throne of God, and there's this throne of the Lamb. It's not entirely clear what the organizational structure is. So there's like the throne of God, and then the Lamb is like either on the throne or in the middle of the throne, and then it says that Latruo worship was given to Him. So the only two times it occurs is when we're talking about Almighty God, the Father, and Jesus, and they're sort of together in a very ambiguous sense. And then it always uses the singular pronoun of Him. It never says them. It always says Him. So those instances of Latruo, I think it's defensible that the person actually being worshiped there is God to the Father, is the Almighty God. But it does seem a little bit weird that Jesus or the Lamb is like on the throne or near the throne. So maybe Jesus is being given Latruo there, but it seems weird that it would say that they worshiped Him rather than they worship there. And you've got God and the Son, and they worshiped Him. But it's never in the four Gospels. Never in the Gospels is Latruo worship given to Jesus. This idea of Jesus being not once. Isn't that fun? That is. It's not cool. It does not happen at all. The key text here, by the way, is Did the Early Christians worship Jesus by Jesus? It's fun if you look at Mark's face. He's Is this interpretation that you have of Jesus similar to the Muslim interpretation of Jesus? It isn't the sense of not thinking He claimed to be God. So yeah, this is an interesting thing. So Muslims don't believe that Jesus died on a cross. They don't believe that He was God. They don't believe He claimed to be God. They believe He was a prophet. And so they take a lot of the same lines I do here. But of course, they're motivated for different reasons. Of course. I'm just interested in the historical figure of Jesus. But yeah, a lot of these arguments, like if you, and the annoying thing is that a lot of the time this debate only seems to happen in the context of Christians versus Muslims, because atheists don't care. Jesus said, "Oh, I am in the Father." Whatever, man. Who cares? I'm going to go ahead and lunch. I'm interested. But it means that when Christians are debating with Muslims, so for example, when Jesus says, "I am the Alpha and the Omega," I'm the first and the last. A Christian could say, "But in the Quran, that's a title that God gives to Himself." In the Quran. So they're using Scripture. One of the names of God in the Quran is Al-Hak, which means the truth. I am the truth. Jesus says, "I am the way, the truth, and the life." And so if your God says that the truth is one of his titles, here's Jesus claiming to be God. So they have these kinds of debates. That doesn't do anything for me. So when Muslims are on the offence of on this point, they will use some of the same arguments. They will point out that, like, firstly, there'll be suspicions of John's historicity. They'll point out that when he says, "I and the Father are one," he seems to be saying that we can all be one all together. All of this kind of stuff. Is it possible that the early language of Christ had different, like, oral tradition that then when it was translated into Greek, some of those things got lost? Yeah, so that's really important, too, is that Jesus spoke Aramaic. So this is something that I always find incredibly interesting when people are really hanging on every word that Jesus said. Okay, you guys are listening very carefully to what I'm saying, right? You're paying attention? Yeah. Can any of you recite now? excluding this one, the last sentence I just said. - Mm-hmm. - Just tell me the last sentence. - We're still trying to pronounce the trunettes of the trunettes a little bit. - That's a question medication, you were just telling us. (laughing) - Yeah, okay, wow, so. - Side effects, including visions of God. (laughing) - So, okay, wow, yes, yes, yes. So, obviously, if you can't remember the words that I said to you 20 seconds ago, but I'm expected to believe that the New Testament authors who were writing at best decades after the death of Jesus could remember his exact words and write them down accurately in a language that he wasn't speaking. - In a language that he wasn't speaking, is it? - No way, now, what's important to note there, though, is that if I said something really particular, like if I was talking to you, if I were talking to you and then I certainly said, you know, I'm a famous songwriter or something. That might stick in your memory, such that in like a month or two, you could remember that I said that, 'cause it was important. So if Jesus said before Abraham was I am, that's the kind of thing that people could remember. - This is my body. - Exactly, but like the I am thing, like, oh, well, he was quoting, he was quoting the Old Testament. Okay, so we've got a Greek rendition. Well, actually, when we say it in English, we're using an English translation of a Greek text, quoting an Aramex-speaking man allegedly quoting a Hebrew scripture. - Yes, yeah. - There were a lot of chains of transmission that we have to investigate and see what's going on. - And I might have misunderstood you, but 40 years later at the earliest, I don't know when it's written down. - If I'm quoting something, you said last week, I don't know. - Some people think that John's Gospel is earlier. So John's Gospel tends to be dated to 90 to 100 AD. Some people dated earlier because there's one verse in John's Gospel, John chapter five. It opens up by saying, "Now, there is a pool by the sheep's gate." And it says, "At this pool, this is what happened." But John says there is a pool. The temple was destroyed by the Romans in 70 AD. And so if John's writing his Gospel, and this isn't like Jesus writing in a real time, he says, "Now there is a sheep's gate near the pool. If that sheep gate had been destroyed, then why would he have written it like that?" So some people, for that reason, put John pre-70, kind of interesting. But the important thing to note is that it's all speculative. But at the very least, yeah, we're talking, that's why I say, "At best, you know, decades after." - Some sort of way decades after the read it. - That's a good question. Why were the Gospels written in the first place, right? - Jesus is going around saying stuff, and he's got disciples and stuff, and there are different philosophies on this. One is that some people think that Mark's Gospel, which is the first one, was written in order to deal with the destruction of the temple. The temple is the most important site for Jews. Even today, right? But the temple at the time, like, part of being a Jew involved like practices that you have to do at the temple. So for them, this is like God's house. This is where it happens. And so when that temple is destroyed, how, what do you do? - Yeah. - Like, how are you going to interpret this? And in many respects, Jesus is presenting himself as the new temple. You know, and so some people think that Mark's Gospel is written as a sort of way to respond to the temple's destruction, because he talks about the temple being destroyed a fair bit. - Going back, you know, was it 60 years? What was happening at the time that allowed John the Baptist to rise in popularity? Like, what was happening culturally? Is there any conversation about that? Why, like, forgiveness could have been so important? - Well, forgiveness has always been important in religious traditions, but it's seen as the prerogative of God. - Right. - And so it's unlikely that the Christians won't think that John the Baptist was actually forgiving since. They will think that he was, like, announcing the forgiveness of sins, or helping people participate in a ritual whereby God would forgive them. Like, but why was this so popular then, where there are other people throughout history at that time, they were also implementing this? Like, what was the societal utility that rose, that made him rise to superstardom? As you said, everybody from Judea is going there. - We don't know because we don't have a lot of details about John the Baptist in particular. But we're not fascinating from what you're telling me right now. - He's my favorite character. - Yeah, why is there so? I mean, obviously, you're right next to the J-man, so it's gonna be tough to live in that shadow. But like, to me, you start something that seems to be a break off from Judaism. I don't know how many other of these religions are existing at the time, but he seems to be the one that's the most popular. And then his descendant becomes, or his disciple becomes God. So like, what is happening with him? - I'm fascinated by him. And the things we just don't have very much information at all because the gospels are so dense, and there are so much in them you'd be amazed at some of the things that you can pull out and things that people are still noticing today that they happen to know it's before about the gospels. And yet, for some of our most famous figures, like John the Baptist or Mary Magdalene, these people are hardly mentioned. We have like no information about them. We don't know where they get their names. We don't know why she's called Mary Magdalene. Was there a place called Magdalene? Maybe. There's a place called Magdalene, like in Israel, but it's unclear whether there's a connection there. Judas Iscariot. Why is he called Judas Iscariot? No one knows. There are theories about this. It could be because he was a member of a particular set that used to murder Roman officials with a dagger, and the word for dagger is something like Ikari-e or something. And there was a group of people called the Ikari-e, and maybe Iscariot kind of sounds like that's a bit. This is very derivative. No one knows. John the Baptist is someone that we just don't have that much information on. John the Baptist was residing in the woods around Nazareth. In the wilderness, yeah. But around Nazareth. Around like Jerusalem, I think. So then how does Jesus even come to meet? Sorry, no, he would be, yeah, I don't, I actually. Where's that place? I didn't know whereabouts. He's probably not Jerusalem. Oh, they're cousins. Oh, they're related. That's six months. Yeah, so. John the Baptist is six months older than Jesus. Oh, so we know each other their whole life. And he's watching this guy come up, and he's like, "Hey, this. " So, so they. Yeah, but then again, like the. So the story is in Luke's Gospel. So, you know, the birth story of Jesus, born in a manger, all this kind of stuff. That's only in two of the Gospels. It's only in Matthew and it's in Luke. And they tell slightly different stories with emphasis on different things. Luke's Gospel opens with the birth of. Or the pregnancy resulting in John the Baptist. Well, what do you mean resulting in John the Baptist? So like his parent. So, the priest. Oh, okay. Okay, okay, okay. So, John is born. So, John. John, John, before he's born, like there's the pregnancy, and it's like a miraculous pregnancy. For John the Baptist as well. Yeah, in the sense that, like, I think Elizabeth was not supposed to be able to, like, can she. You should've loved this guy. He also wrote a special about. Nothing happened. This is my guy. Did I? That's where the question is. Okay. Yeah, yeah. So, she wasn't supposed to conceive. It was very difficult to conceive. Yeah, and she conceived. And she. And it's all sort of. The thing to note is. And so. And this is. Yeah, they're cousins, because. Then Mary is pregnant with Jesus, and then Mary meets Elizabeth, and John the Baptist does a backflip in his mother's womb when she approaches Mary who's pregnant with Jesus, and John the Baptist does a little backflip. It's kind of wacky, man. But the thing is, these birth narratives. Yeah, yeah. Are basically completely methodological. Right. I don't think there's any history in them. Right. So I'm not sure if Jesus was actually related to John the Baptist. I certainly don't think that there was the backflip in the womb. But we can place them in the same city, at least. Like, there's a reason why they connect us. Yeah, I mean, they clearly historically were actually like. Like I say, I think Jesus is a follower of John the Baptist, because, like, John is in the wilderness of Israel, and Jesus comes and gets baptized by John the Baptist. I mean, Jesus is sort of all over the place in his childhood, like there's like a census, and so he has to travel, and then he has to go here, and has to go there, and then he goes to Egypt because he's scared that Herod's going to kill him. Yeah, how old, and before Jesus started claiming to be like that, dude. Well, it depends which gospel you read, because there is an indication that Jesus was like teaching in the temple when he was a teenager. So there's one story in the gospel. Of like, I think his family are like going back from Jerusalem. I can't remember all the details. It might have been the Passover or something, and they're all leaving, and they go in home, and then they suddenly realize that Jesus isn't with them. So they go back, and they find him, like, in the temple. Like, it's homalong. Arguing and talking, yeah, literally. But he's arguing and talking with the Jewish teachers, and they're all like, this kid knows so much. Like, this is incredible, and he's like impressing everybody with his skills and with his knowledge. Outside of that, the so-called missing years of Jesus. There's like no record of what he just shows up when he's like 30s. I thought he was just like-- And get baptized by Jesus. He's a Zeus for 33 years, and then all of a sudden-- Yeah, so this is where you get conspiracy theories, where Jesus traveled to India. That's where he got his-- We're just like, we're always there. That's it. I'm like, yeah. Unbelievable how right now. The source. Yeah. Well, it makes sense to think like, oh, well, he was preaching kind of-- He's the first appropriator. All of this. Yeah, like, where's he getting these ideas? He's always getting them from the East, and we don't know what Jesus was doing. I mean, the reason why I think we have the missing years of Jesus is because there was no reason to write about this Jesus figure until he started his ministry. The birth narratives were made up later and tacked on, as often happened with biographies of important figures. There were, like, mythological origin stories. And there's a miraculous birth of Alexander the Great or whatever. So I think we just didn't have any records of this guy, because he was a nobody until he showed up. And he'd pray love, dude. First, he'd pray love this long-haired white guy. I'm sure I'm in my DNA. Good food, God's spiritual. It's exactly what it has. That's right. So I think he basically just show up and start doing that. And if he was so clear that he wasn't divine, why did Christology come after his death? That is a hell of a question. And in fact, Brant Petrae's recent-- it's called "Jesus and Divine Christology," which is an attempt to show that Jesus did claim to be God. And he opens up with what he calls the paradox of how most scholars think that Jesus didn't make divine claims, but most scholars believe in what's called an early high Christology. So early on, people had a high Christology. They believed that Jesus was God. So why is it that if he didn't make any claims to be God himself, why is it that socially and afterwards people started believing that he was God? John the Baptist was also martyred. Yeah, he was around the same time. He was. And why do these beliefs develop up around Jesus? That's a historical question. And obviously, I don't know like the answer to it, but I think it's clear to me to see how like myths can develop over time. But this is where it gets a little bit speculative for my view, because Brant Petra is for you as well, the logical answer to this is that he was making divine claims. There are so many ways that you could you could interpret what's happened here. Firstly, I'm not sure exactly when it is that people start believing this. So remember, I said that Paul's letters are our earliest New Testament source. A lot of people read Paul's letters, and they say Paul is clearly presenting Jesus as God. And if that's the case, then you're looking like 50 AD already got the belief that Jesus is God. I'm not so sure. Other people look at Paul and see him as is not so so obviously like high Christology in the way that people want him to be. He might be more of like a mystic. Some people think he's more of like a visionary. There's a lot of theories about what's going on in Paul. So it depends on what you think of Paul as to how early this actually develops. And yeah, like it's probably within decades, certainly like a hundred years also that people start talking about Jesus as God. But then the nature of Jesus is also not entirely clear. You know, some people are like, well, will he, will he God, and he just appeared to be a human? Will he sort of half God, half man? Did he become God at the baptism? Will he God as soon as he was born? Did he exist beforehand? Did he come down to earth and in somebody or did he begin to exist in Jesus? Like, and none of this really gets sorted out until they start getting Christian councils together to decide on orthodoxy. And so you've got the council of Nicer and 325, which a lot of people think is where they developed the Christian canon. That's not the case, but they did develop the view on Jesus' relationship to the Father, which was quite important. They just define it 325. That's when they lack it. They have a big discussion. Yeah. And they bring all the traditions together in their discussions. They bring all the berserk together and specifically, I think, like the relationship with the son of the Father and the idea that so you get what's called the Nicene Creed, which Christians will recite today, which basically lays out, you know, we believe in one God. We believe in the Father. We believe that, you know, Jesus is eternally begotten of the Father. All of this kind of stuff, they just lay it out. The relationship of the Trinity for that kind of stuff. But the question is, well, why is it that in the early church people started believing that Jesus was God? Regardless when it's finally got solidified, how does it get off the rails? An important thing to know is that not everybody thought that. There were like all kinds of different Christian views. So I'm really big on the Gnostic Christian history because I find it really interesting and that like, so Elaine Pagels writes a book in 1975 called the 1970s, I can't remember when, called the Gnostic Gospels. And her big thing is saying there is this idea that in the early Christian church, Jesus dies, all of the, like Peter is the first Pope and the developer of these churches and they all basically agree and then, and then there are a few disputes so they iron them out and that's Christianity. And she's like, no, there are communities of people who believe the most wacky and incredible things about Jesus fairly early on. Like, if you've ever read the Gospel of Judas, it is a complete trip. It is a complete and utter trip. And it does present Jesus as like in the form of a human, but not really a human. He's God. He's sent from the realm of Barbello and he comes down to free people from their material prisons and bring them back up into the plethora to be there with all of the, all of the proper divine beings. Totally wacky, different few of Jesus. And we know that this text existed prior to 180 AD. We know that for a fact. And that same text doesn't he claim that Judas will supersede all the disciples because he's doing the will of the Father? So when the Gospel of Judas was first discovered, it seemed like Judas was the hero because this is discovered in like the 1970s. We know that this text exists, but it's been lost for thousands of years. There's a guy called Irenaeus who in 180 writes against heresies. And he's like condemning all these different heresies. And he talks about the Gospel of Judas. So we knew it existed, but we didn't have it. And in 1970s, it's discovered. People are trying to sell it. It goes back and forth. It goes all over the place. It spends about 16 years in a safety deposit box in New York City, which almost destroys it. Finally, it gets bought by National Geographic. And they bring in some experts, Bart Irman is one of them who I've had on my show. And to like find out if this is really the Gospel of Judas. So they're looking at this text and they're reading it. And it opens up by saying that it tells a story that the disciples are praying over their food. They're performing a Eucharist. Jesus walks in and sees them praying over their food. And he laughs at them. And they say, why are you laughing at us? We're doing what's right. And Jesus says, yeah, you're worshiping your God by doing that. You're worshiping your God by doing that. And they're like, and they start getting angry. They're like, what? And they're basically saying you don't understand any of this. And he says to them, if any one of you is clever enough and stand up and face me, I guess he stands up. It's Judas. Judas comes up to him and says, I know who you are. I know that you've come from the realm of Barbello. And I'm not fit to utter the name of the one who sent you. And then Jesus sort of explains the history of the cosmos to Judas explains how the world was created, explains how there is an ineffable invisible spirit who emanates divine beings. And one of those divine beings falls out of the plethora of divine beings and creates the material world. And the material world is the product of like an evil or incompetent, demiurgic, god-cooled cool, beelzable, wacky, wacky stuff. And you can imagine when they read this, when they first discovered that they're just like, holy, moly, this is absolutely insane. This is going to change everything. But the big thing is Judas is the one who gets up. Like you say Judas gets up, and says, I know who you are. So a lot of people read this and thought, wow, this retails the story. Judas is the hero. That's kind of disputed because later in the text, Jesus seems to say to Judas that you also are not worthy of like entering into this house. Like Judas is the best of the disciples and he's sort of understanding it, but he's still not like the hero of the story. He's still not actually going to like be one of the generation that get back to the plethora. So it's kind of unclear what the treatment of Judas is in that gospel, but the way it ends is the authorities show up and Judas hands Jesus over to them. And that's it. That's where it ends. It's incredible. It's incredible gospel. And we know that it's written in the second century at the latest. So Christians will look at this and they'll say, well, like I mean, the difference between something being written in like 70 AD and like 150 AD is massive because you're talking about eyewitness testimony versus like, you know, 100 years later, it's like the difference between writing about two puck, like now versus like 100 years from now. It's about only internet. Exactly. Like totally different. Right. So what it does tell us is that there existed communities who had completely different views of what Jesus was about. That's why the council knows he was important, right? Yeah. But he organized all these different opinions. Even within like orthodox Christianity, they were disputes about the nature of Jesus. Yeah. And that's what's ironed out. But there are just communities that just have like completely, completely different views. Yeah. And these nostics, the reason they're called nostics is because it comes from the Greek word "nosis," which means knowledge. And in orthodox Christianity, the way that people are saved is through the sacrifice of Jesus. That's how you're saved because Jesus dies for you. The nostics, it's not about what Jesus did, it's about having the right knowledge. He brings the correct knowledge. And if you have the right knowledge, that's what will save you. So some of these nostic gospels don't even mention the crucifixion. They're not important. It's not in the gospel of Judas. It's not in the gospel of Thomas. The gospel of Thomas is a saying gospel, though. So maybe that's not fair. But it's just got like weird and wacky stuff in it. The gospel of Thomas is discovered in Narkamadi. There's the biggest treasure trove of nostic gospels was discovered in 1945 and in the desert in Egypt, where there's a farmer, this teenage farmer is digging in the desert and he accidentally hits upon a jar. And he's scared to open it at first because he thinks he's got a gin in it, you know, like a demon. And eventually they open it, it's got this ancient papyrus and he takes it home and his mother's using some of it to feed the fire. And then they discovered that it's this treasure trove of ancient documents. But that story is wacky, man, because the way they tell it at first is like, oh, yeah, we were out there digging for some materials and then we found this jar. And then the teenager is like, they go and they find him some research and wants to find him and he mentions that there was like a corpse. And then the older brother of the farmer was like, no, no, no, there was no corpse. It's like, what's going on? It seems like what might have been happening is a grave robbing. And they kind of didn't want it. And they always need to discover all this stuff and they want to sell it. So they've come up with this story. So it's actually kind of unclear how it was discovered. So so the leading theory was the reason these are buried in the desert is because in like the fourth century Athanasius defines the 27 books of the New Testament and says all the other books are heretical. So they get buried in the desert. And that was the theory and that's what he discovered. But that changed and to some people now thinking that it was normal to bury people with with important like things to them. So like with papyrus that document. So somebody was probably just buried who had an extensive collection of nostic literature and they were buried with it. There was a grave robbing and they found this thing. And they lay out shit. It's worth some money. So they started trying to sell it. So this text, this collection of texts includes loads of important nostic literature including the Gospel of Thomas, which is probably the most famous. It's a so-called "saying's Gospel." So it's just a list of sayings of Jesus. So these are the secret teachings of Jesus of Nazareth, which Judas Didamous Thomas wrote down. And some of it is similar to what we find in the New Testament canon, but some of it is incredibly weird. It's also some people claim that Thomas was Jesus' twin. Yes. So the word "didimus" means twin. And in the New Testament canon, Jesus had brothers, we know that Jesus had brothers, and it's kind of, it's actually a point of contention because, like, if you heard of the perpetual virginity of Mary, so there's a dispute whether, obviously, the virgin Mary has a virgin birth of Jesus, but did she then remain a virgin? And Catholics say yes, she did, and a lot of Protestants say no, she didn't. And part of the reason for that is because Jesus is described as having brothers. It could mean that it could be that brother was just like a name that was given to them, it wasn't like a literal brother, or maybe there were other sons of Joseph or something like this. But the most natural interpretation to me is that he did actually just have brothers, especially because, for me, remember, I think that the birth narratives are invented, so I think the people who originally write the stories, they're not concerned with the virgin birth, so they don't even know it exists. I don't think the virgin birth happened for many reasons, one of which is that, like, at one point in Mark's Gospel, Jesus is performing an exorcism, and his family come out, his family come out, and they say that they think he's lost his mind. They're like, what's going on? What's he doing? Is he lost his mind? Because they don't understand. I'm like, if you've got this whole thing with, like, an angel coming down to you and telling you what's going to happen, and you should call them a manual, and you have a virgin miraculous birth, and then later on, you just forget all of that, and you're like, what's he doing? I lost his mind. It doesn't seem to line up for me, so I don't think the virgin birth happened at all, of course. There's also some dispute over the translation. It says that there's an Old Testament prophecy that says a virgin shall conceive. The Hebrew word there is "alma", which can just mean a young woman of marriageable age. But again, Greek New Testament, so the Greek Septuagin translates the word as Parthenos, which means virgin specifically. To some people think that the New Testament authors were reading a Greek version, when the prophecy only said a young woman, they read virgin, so they came up with the virgin. That's disputed as well. Who knows? Yeah, so Jesus has brothers, and Thomas isn't described as Jesus' brother, but he's called the twin. So even in the canonical literature, it's Thomas, also known as Didamous, and Thomas itself, the word that the name Thomas means twin, it's like a development of an aromatic word, which means twin. Old Ma, or something, means twin. So in the Aramaic language, his name's Thomas, which means twin. But the gospels take a lot of effort, like translating it into the Greek, given that Thomas already is a word that means twin. That's where the name comes from. The New Testament authors write down Thomas, also called Didamous. So in the Greek language, Didamous means twin. So when the Greek authors are writing it, they're like, he would call Thomas, which means Didamous. So it's important to the Greek authors to tell the reader that his name, that he was called the twin. That's important to them. So why? Why is he called the twin? Nobody knows. Some people think it could be a nickname, because he looked like Jesus, and so they called him the twin. Some people think he might have been the twin brother of Jesus. Orthodox Christians will dispute that, because that really puts a nail in the coffin for the version birth. Because if Jesus is born of a virgin, and Thomas is his twin, then Thomas is also born of a virgin birth. And then, of course, that kind, right? However, there is an apocryphal, it's the called the Acts of Thomas, which is another apocryphal gospel, which, again, not canon, probably completely a historical, but this is where Thomas travels to India, because Thomas is historically, traditionally, the person who brings Christianity to India. And if you go to India today-- Not from New Year's. He goes there to trek him. Yeah. Yeah. If you go to India today, you will find, like, really devout groups of Thomasites who really reveal Thomas as an important guy, because he's the guy that brings Christianity to India. And the Acts of Thomas is one book that recounts this, but at one point, I think they're sort of wedding, and somebody confuses Thomas for Jesus, they get them mixed up, because they look so similar. Well. So that either-- So that either-- [laughter] Yeah. All these Judeans look the same to hell with the word I was looking for. They either mix them up because they are actually twins, and that's why they look similar. Or maybe they just happen to look similar, and that's where we got the nickname. But for some reason, Thomas is called the twin. And so, again, in the Gospel of Thomas, it's Judas Didamous Thomas. So Judas is obviously some other name that he's somehow got attached to him, and then did him as Thomas. So twin twin, which is a little bit weird. Some people are a bit speculated, a bit suspicious of the fact that it says that it words it like that, but I think twin could be a nickname, it could mean that he's a twin, whatever. But Thomas is allegedly the one who writes down all of these sayings of Jesus. But most scholars date this to the second century, so it's probably not actually written by Thomas. Some scholars kind of think it's earlier, but that's a bit controversial. Again, Christians are going to watch this again, but it's definitely laid. There's no way it's ridiculous to suggest that it's early, but I think what you want to think. There's got some weird stuff in there. And how do you explain the miracles, like water to wine, and make it a blind man see and all that stuff? So, yeah, that's a bit weird. The water to wine only happens in John's Gospel. It's the first miracle that Jesus performs, and he doesn't want to at first marry his mother comes up to him and it's like, "Get the party started." And he's just like, "We've run out of wine, and he says to a woman, what does this got to do with me?" Which sounds a bit clunky in the English, it's some kind of rude, but it means something like saying, like, you know, like, darling, or what's this got to do with me? Like, my time hasn't come yet, and she's basically like, "Please, Jesus, come on, we're out of wine." It's like, "Fine." So it goes in terms of water into wine. Yeah, I don't know. I mean, whether or not you think you performed miracles, especially healing and exorcism, it is, like, beyond the shadow of a doubt that he was known for doing that. He was known as a healer. As a healer, as a miracle worker, yeah. He was known well for doing that. I don't know about Lazarus in particular, because Lazarus, the raising of Lazarus only happens in John's Gospel. Also, by the way, one of my favorite indications that Jesus isn't God, because he prays before he raises Lazarus from the dead. He, just before he raises Lazarus from the dead, he looks up to the sky and he says, "Father, thank you for having heard me." You know what he says? He says, "I know that you always hear me, but right now I'm saying this for the benefit of everybody watching, so they will know that you have sent me." It doesn't mean that he's not God, right? No, it doesn't mean that he's not God, but what it means is that a lot of people say that when Jesus performs miracles of his own authority, that shows that he's got, because Old Testament prophets like Elijah and Elijah raised people from the dead, but they prayed to God first. They're like God raised this person from the dead, but Jesus did it of his own accord. But Jesus, before he raises Lazarus, prays to God and doesn't just say, "Oh, I'm praying to you for a bit," says, "I know you always hear me, but right now I'm saying it for the sake of everybody else," implying that in instances where it seems like he's acting his own accord, he is still praying to God. He's just not doing so publicly, because he says in John's Gospel before he raises Lazarus. I know you always hear me, but I'm saying it right now so they'll know that you've sent me. Which is kind of interesting. Yeah, and I would joke, but the, I mean, she hears you have sent me in that necessarily by the yogi. Or constantly like Father has sent yogi's perform miracles as kind of things. Yeah. And so you were a Hindu. It's not like it's not like you know it. It's not like Christians don't like aren't aware that Jesus was constantly saying that the Father has sent him. They have their interpretation of that, but I think a lot of it lines up and converges on the idea that Jesus didn't claim to be God in this sense. Whether he performed his miracles is like kind of out of my purview, like maybe miracles happen. I mean, I probably don't think they did, but he definitely had a reputation for doing something. Mary was going on with this guy who was walking around and doing stuff. And all of these traditions develop around him. People want to write about him and then people start writing all of these gospels and stuff. But people have different ideas about what Jesus did. The gospel of Thomas, which again, I should clarify, is not canonical. Most Christians think it's like not no connection to history, but it's some weird stuff in there. Like at the very end, the, the last saying in the saying is gospel of the gospel of Thomas is the most famous where one of his, I think it's Simon Peter says to Jesus, you know, Mary, Madeline should depart from us because she's a woman and women can't inherit eternal life. They're not worthy of life. Now, from what you know of Jesus, what would you expect him to say? What are you talking about? Everybody's worthy of it. What he says is, I will draw her to me to make her a man so that she will inherit eternal life for any woman who makes herself into a man will inherit eternal life. Now, could that be a trans? It could. People say this is like, this is like the earliest indication of trans gender. But you know, man into a woman. But is that like his way of communicating to a bunch of dudes that don't think women are that they should be? Exactly. And he doesn't find a way to communicate it. So I've heard that the translation of the word man in that sense is like courage, like bravery. Yeah. That's what I'm assuming. I think a lot of that is going on, especially because so much less work has been done on the, on the, the thing about these Gospels, the Gospels, the Gospels. I'm going to get Wesley Huffing. He's going to refute all this shit. He will try. I, I, I've seen a lot of Wes's work. I, I like him. It seems like a really nice guy. I think he's made some, some blunders. Oh. It's a really important and I've, I've made as much, I've made as much known. There are some that I've spoken about and some that I haven't, sit at Pokkaz yesterday where I spoke in detail about this massive blunder that Wes Huff made. I think it was like a year or so ago, which kind of brought someone I know into a bit of disrepute, unfortunately, and he just made this like a really, really big blunder. But I don't like just like throw and stuff like that out there because it sounds like you're just sort of taking a jab or whatever. Right. I've always been happy to speak to Wes and I think it would be, I wouldn't want to debate him because I think you lose a lot of the interesting bits because you'd be too like prideful and defensive because you're like, I'm going to defend my view. I have a conversation with him though, but yeah, I think he's, I think he's made some, made some mistakes. But you are admitting on air that you would not debate Wesley Huffing. No, I mean, I would. No. I would. You're saying that a conversation might be more fruitful. I would be, it would be, it would be way better. I mean, I'd be cool to listen to both you. I would love to hear his perspective on it. So it's so difficult to be in. Our position because I know fear of it. So anything you say to me is gospel. So what's her thinks that Mark's gospel presents Jesus as God in every single chapter? Got it. And you guys just viewed that. He's got a video. Well, I don't have so much of a problem with saying that the gospels present Jesus as God. I just don't think Jesus claimed it for himself. Got it. So West relies in Mark chapter two on the fact that Jesus forgives sins. And says that this is quite an important moment. It's the story if you heard of when the when the the parallels John the Baptist doesn't forgive him. He says the father forgives him. Yeah, that would probably be the interpretation. Got it. And but it's like the thing that I think is that people often just miss important corollaries of what they're saying. So like in short, Jesus forgives someone's sins in a Mark chapter two. And the Jewish opponents accuse him of blasphemy. They do it in their hearts. They say like this man is blaspheming. Who can forgive sins but God alone? And the man's paralyzed. And Jesus says why are you thinking these things? Which is easier to say your sins are forgiven or get up and walk so that you know that the son of man has the authority to forgive sins. I say to you get up and walk and the man gets up and he walks off. So Jesus is saying like if you don't think I can forgive sins, watch me do this much harder thing and then you'll know that I have the authority to forgive him. I was stubborn or Jews to see that and be like, no, he's not the one. Yeah, that is. We don't talk enough about the Jewish faith. But that is that is how much faith you have to have in your religion. You see a guy who's paralyzed. Yes. He dude goes, yeah, check it. Oh God. Watch. Get up. Walk. That is the message. And they still go. This guy's great. That is the message of the Gospels. And as the Gospels go on, they get more anti-Jewish. And especially in John's Gospel, you have like Jesus is describing at least his Jewish opponents and possibly the Jewish people as like he says, they're like, we only have one father and our father is Abraham or our father is God. And he's like, no, your father is the devil. He says that your father is the devil. And so a lot of like Christian anti-Semitism has come has come from this idea that the idea that the Jews are responsible for the death of Christ also develops throughout the Gospels. Was there any like conversation back in the day, there's got to be some Jews writing to each other where they're like, this guy might be on a something like, yeah, he turned the water in a way. There's a call, there's a call, the Gospels. Okay, fair enough, fair enough. It's true. Do we can talk about this forever, man? We'd love to have you back on next time you're in town. Maybe we get a mess on and have another little conversation. I would love you guys to talk. Sometimes I do think things are lost in debate, but the two of us in a room together that really would be miraculous. That would be cool, but it would be miraculous. Anyway, Alex O'Connor, everybody.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. John the Baptist is historically significant because all four gospels mention him baptizing Jesus, a detail unlikely to be fabricated.
  2. Jesus may have been a disciple of John the Baptist, as the gospels consistently show Jesus following John and receiving baptism from him.
  3. The idea that Jesus claimed to be God is disputed; scholars argue that Jesus never explicitly claimed divinity, and key phrases like "I am" are better understood as references to the Old Testament or human identity.
  4. In John 8, Jesus is accused of blasphemy for saying "before Abraham was, I am," but this phrase is likely a reference to the Hebrew "I am who I am" and not a direct claim of divinity.
  5. Jesus is never given "latruo" worship (true religious worship) in the gospels, only "proskineo" (bowing or prostration), which is common in Jewish texts and does not prove divinity.
  6. The Mormon story, rooted in Joseph Smith’s claims of divine revelation and golden plates, includes elements of historical persecution and religious succession, offering a parallel to early Christian claims.
  7. The growth of both Christianity and Mormonism follows similar exponential patterns, suggesting that religious movements can expand through social and emotional appeal, not just divine authority.
  8. Religious traditions often serve a societal utility—providing community, moral guidance, and emotional comfort—even if their theological claims are debated or unverified.

Summary:

The conversation explores whether Jesus claimed to be God, arguing that the evidence in the gospels does not support such a claim. Key passages like "I am" are interpreted as references to Old Testament language rather than direct divinity claims. The historical context, including John the Baptist’s role and the lack of "true worship" given to Jesus, further weakens the argument for divinity.

The discussion also examines Mormonism, rooted in Joseph Smith’s claims of divine revelation and golden plates, noting its historical parallels with early Christianity—such as rapid growth, persecution, and religious succession. While both traditions are seen as historically complex, they share a pattern of emotional and communal appeal. Ultimately, the speaker emphasizes that religion, even when rooted in myth or unverified claims, can provide societal benefit by fostering community, offering moral guidance, and providing psychological comfort.

This utility persists even when theological claims are contested, showing that religion's value lies not only in belief but in its social and emotional functions.

FAQs

No, the transcript argues that Jesus never explicitly claimed to be God. While some Christians point to passages like 'I am' or 'I and the Father are one' as evidence, the analysis suggests these statements are either contextual or misunderstood. Jesus often references Old Testament language, and in one instance, he cites Psalm 82 to show that 'gods' were a title given to divine beings, not just God, thus challenging the accusation of blasphemy.

The inclusion of John the Baptist at the start of each Gospel is historically significant because it would not have been invented. The fact that all four Gospels mention him—especially his baptism of Jesus—provides strong evidence that it actually happened. This is considered a historical fact, not a myth, due to the criterion of embarrassment and the consistency across sources.

The criterion of embarrassment suggests that if a story is embarrassing or contradicts a person's reputation, it's less likely to be fiction. For example, in Matthew's Gospel, some disciples doubt Jesus after his appearance—something unlikely for a writer to invent. Such details strengthen the historical reliability of the accounts.

Mormons believe Joseph Smith received divine revelations, including the discovery of golden plates in upstate New York, which he translated with the help of a stone. These plates were said to contain ancient records of a lost Jewish civilization in America, and Smith is viewed as a modern prophet who restored the true faith through divine guidance.

Mormons point to 13 eyewitness testimonies, all of whom were living at the time and later wrote affidavits confirming the discovery of the golden plates. These testimonies, according to Mormons, are sufficient to validate their claims, though skeptics argue the accounts lack independent corroboration.

Yes, Joseph Smith faced significant persecution, including being banned from political office, having a newspaper shut down for criticizing him, and being involved in a violent incident where a mob attacked his brother and shot him. Joseph Smith later died under suspicious circumstances while being pursued by a mob, which Mormons view as a martyrdom event.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.