Go back

Aswath Damodaran On Nvidia’s Collapse & Anthropic’s $1.5T IPO

from Prof G Markets

1h 2m 13s

Aswath Damodaran On Nvidia’s Collapse & Anthropic’s $1.5T IPO

Nvidia's market value has plummeted due to a combination of CEO Jensen Huang's controversial personal conduct and potential China-related regulatory risks, which threaten its operations and global reach. While a CEO change may have only a short-term impact, the lingering uncertainty—especially around legal investigations—adds significant risk to the company's long-term outlook. The stock trades at a discount to traditional firms, suggesting potential undervaluation, but its high-margin business model is vulnerable to shifts in supply chains and competitive pressures, such as AI-driven alternatives. In contrast, the broader market has shown surprising resilience despite AI and tech sector crashes, driven by rotation into defensive sectors like healthcare and energy. This reflects a more diversified economy, where downturns in one sector are offset by others. Analysts caution that AI remains the central driver of growth, and its slowdown could trigger a broader market correction. Therefore, investors are advised to maintain diversified portfolios, allocating only a small portion to high-risk tech stocks like Nvidia or Anthropic. The market’s stability in 2026 suggests a potential buying opportunity, but long-term success hinges on AI's sustained growth and corporate governance adaptability. Zero, a financial management platform, is highlighted as a tool for small business owners to gain better financial insights, enabling more informed decision-making in uncertain economic environments.

Transcription

10571 Words, 57372 Characters

English
Support for the show comes from zero. The big companies we analyze on this show don't operate according to different financial criteria than everyone else. The metrics that drive their performance are the same as the ones that drive performance over your small business. You just need the tools to see them. Zero, spelled with an X, is a simple but powerful platform built for small business owners that makes managing business finances easier from day one. Counting, payments, payroll and analytics are available in one connected platform. Join the five million customers worldwide using zero. Learn more at zero.com. That's x-e-r-o-dot-com. [MUSIC] >> Listen to me, markets are bigger than what you have here as a structural change in the world. If you should cash, it's trash. >> Stocks look pretty attractive. Some things go to break. Forget about it. Welcome to Profty Markets. This has been one of the wildest weeks in business in a long time, and there is no shortage of news to unpack. We finally heard from Jensen Huang after his departure as Nvidia CEO. He made clear that he was open to returning, but the board said during the earnings call that he would not be coming back. Meanwhile, Anthropics highly anticipated IPO adds another major development to an already momentous week. This is also our last chance to catch up with our next guest before the end of the year. So we're going to get his take on all of these developments and look back at some of the biggest lessons from 2026. What he thinks investors should be watching as we head into 2027. So let's get right into our conversation with Professor Aswath DeModerin, the Kurshner Family Chair in Finance Education, and Professor of Finance at NYU's Stern School of Business. Professor DeModerin, great to see you. Thank you for joining us. I'm going to start with the thing that everyone's talking about, which is Nvidia. Lots of directions we can take this, but I'm going to keep it open-ended. What do you make of this? What are your thoughts? It's a story with multiple dimensions to it. If it is Jensen's personal foibles and you are thinking about the company setting aside because of his breaking corporate rules by having affairs with employees, this would be much smaller story. Because in many ways, you can talk about who's going to replace a man, what they're going to do that's different and how much he could work with them. I think what makes the story potentially more dangerous for Nvidia investors is the China Twist, which is the other affair. The facts are murky, I'm not going to pass judgment, but clearly it's broadened something into this story that is not going to go away even if you've got the perfect replacement CEO. In fact, I was just finishing up a piece last Sunday and I'm glad I didn't post it because so much change over the last four days on how to value CEO of a company. How much value does a CEO bring? I start with the general presumption, which is CEOs matter more at young companies, growing companies that admit your companies because as far less you can do as a CEO to change value to mature company. If you start with that premise, the question is, where is Nvidia in the life cycle? It's a huge company, but if you look at growth trajectories behaving like a young startup in terms of growth, clearly CEOs matter at that stage and especially we have a CEO's founded and essentially built a company in his own image. You can hold two competing thoughts at the same time. One is that Jensen's been an amazing CEO. I mean, he's built one of the great companies on the face of the Earth at the same time. You can say, well, clearly he's human and he made some very big mistakes that is costing him and the company at the same time because I think there are people who are passing judgment and Jensen and also they say he wasn't that great of a CEO because of what he's done now. But I think we need to keep the two things separate. So at this point we ask me, what is the effect of Jensen leaving or potentially, because now that's become uncertain as well, is he actually leaving or is he just coming back? And I think that adds a layer of uncertainty that can't help investors because you now don't know whether he's coming back or not coming back. I think the odds are high that he can't come back, that it's too difficult to come back from something like this. But there's still the question of what will it mean for Nvidia's value, whether he comes back or not, you know, how much damage has been done. And that's where the China story has a lasting impact because I think they're going to be hearings in Congress. It's almost a given. They're going to be potentially more, you know, more examination of what exactly happened. And I think that at the end of the process, it might very well mean that Nvidia is to give up some operating value to get back into the good graces. That might mean giving up sales to China. I mean, Nvidia, even in its existing structure, has sales to China. Will that mean that half or two thirds of those sales go away? What will that do to Nvidia's value? It might also affect their relationship with companies in Asia, which can affect their margins and their value. So I think the China story has legs, no matter who runs the company. And what we will be seeing in the next few weeks is how much of that story is true and how much is just, you know, people essentially coming to a judgment far too quickly. I'm so glad to have you on while this has happened because so much of your work is about evaluating things that are important to a business, but that are largely intangible. I mean, I remember reading one of your great posts on trying to value the risks associated with a company being located near to a volcano. And how do you assign numbers to that? How do you figure out how that is reflected in the price? And that does seem to be exactly what is affecting this company right now, and it just happens to be there's one of the most valuable companies in the world because you've got the value associated with how valuable is Jensen Huang as a CEO. You got the risk of is this guy going to be tried as a criminal? Is he got what is going to happen in his congressional investigations? What is Congress going to do about Nvidia as a company and whatever ties they may or may not have had with China? So I'll just focus on the CEO question because this is really animated investors. A lot of people believe that without Jensen, it's over, or at least a significant amount of the value of the company disappears without him, which is why we've seen literally hundreds of thousands of people signing a petition to bring him back. I'm skeptical of it, but what is your estimation of the value of Jensen Huang to this business today? I think today the effect of just the CEO, so let's put the China story to the side. If it's just a CEO replacement, the effect is going to be small partly because there are three things that are going to happen assuming it's going to get replaced and new CEOs going to come in. It might be somebody from Nvidia either works in Nvidia right now used to work at Nvidia. The second is to the extent that this is not a hostile environment, Jensen's still going to be around, he might be able to provide strategic help to that CEO. And the third is, how good of a management team has he built? I mean, if I asked you how critical Jeff Bezos was to Amazon in 2005, you'd say, "It is no way this company can live without Jeff Bezos. He is the company." But he walked out in what 2017-18, you see him wearing speedos on a yacht in France and the company goes on and that is what good founders do is they create a second layer of management that can do it. We're going to find out what that second layer looks like at Nvidia. I think notwithstanding all of the bad stuff that's come out of Nvidia, the sense you get from Nvidia at the second layer is there are competent managers in place and that many of them will be able to carry the operating efficiencies, the competencies of Nvidia going forward. What they will miss is Jensen's been that the culture that drives how Nvidia thinks about big markets. Do you think about the last 20 years? I've called Nvidia the opportunistic chip company. It seems to find big markets just as they get started. It's uniquely positioned to take advantage of them as they grow. It happened with gaming, it happened with crypto and it happened with AI. The first time around, you can say, "You got lucky." The second time, you got really lucky. The third time around, you have to say, "There's something in the company's DNA that allows it to find these new markets ahead of me." I think a big part of that comes from Jensen and Woody brought to the company. That is essentially what you lose with somebody else's CEO. How much will that mean? Less than it did when they were a hundred billion dollar company. When you're four trillion, you're not talking about opportunities that are going to quadruple your value. The effect is going to be smaller because you're building off bigger scale. I think you can have a scenario where the effect is more benign. It's short term, the new management comes in, Jensen hangs around, he provides the strategic direction. You don't have a loss of employees because he's left. The second layer of management essentially does its job. It's not that there will be no effect. I create a spreadsheet where people can decide for themselves what the effect is. On two dimensions. One is the effect just short term or is it long term? If the effect is just short term, the effect and value is 3%, 5%, if it's long term, then where is it going to shop? Is it less revenue growth? Is it lower margins? Will they have to reinvest more because without its connections, you might have more reinvestment? And I let people turn those switches off and on. And I have a table, which essentially says, if this causes revenue growth to drop by 10%, and margins to decrease by 5%, you're going to see a much bigger impact on value. But that's the kind of effect that you're trying to trace to. And that's why I said, if it were just personal foibles, even with those breaking corporate rules, the effect would be far smaller. The wild card here is, what does China do? Because that's out of the hands of any CEO or second layer management, or what Jensen decides to do with the new CEO. Because then it goes, we even if it doesn't end up in the criminal courts, it ends up in regulatory places where you don't want to be as embedded. Whether there are restrictions and what you cannot do that can affect your value as a company. And that's what I would worry about as an embedded investor. And unfortunately, bringing Jensen back-- and this is what I would emphasize-- is not going to make the China problem go away. In fact, it might make it worse. And that, I think, is what the board is deciding. And that's why I think it's so critical that you break the scandal into two parts. One is the corporate scandal. You broke corporate rules. The other is, potentially, the question of was there some evasion of laws and restrictions they should have followed that they broke? That's the second is more, I think, the more damage you. I mean, this question of what value do investors assign to the loss of Jensen Huang and also the risks associated with an investigation and to the extent to which they were doing this outside of mega speed? Again, nothing's proven in court yet. But this appears to be what happened based on the reporting. Investors said it was worth $1.5 trillion, essentially. It's a drop in value, just so they've right started. So I think today, Nvidia's market gap is 3 1/2 trillion. It was 4.8 trillion, not that long ago. 4 1/2 trillion to the start of the scandal. Investors have clearly decided that this is not something that's going to blow over. And I think they're right. I have a feeling that if the China-- and this is where the China wildcard comes to be-- the China scandal essentially turns out-- it fizzles. It turns out to be a nothing burger. Then I think that this is an overreaction. So at this point, the Nvidia investment becomes a bet on, what do you think about the China scandal? And how much do you think it less? Because that is what can explain a trillion dollar drop in market gap. Just changing, see, or doesn't do it for me. Just looking at the valuation of Nvidia at this point, it's trading at 20 times earnings on a trailing basis, 11 times earnings on a forward basis. It is trading at a significantly lower multiple than Coca-Cola, which trades at 29 times trading at a significantly lower multiple than Walmart at 46 times. I mean, it is quite striking how these traditional legacy, as you say, when you talk about the corporate lifecycle, these old middle-aged companies that you wouldn't think would be receiving these premiums on their multiples, and Nvidia's way behind, despite the fact that it is at the cutting edge of AI. This, I think, implicitly brings up the question of whether this is a buying opportunity, whether there is some dislocation here. What do you make of the valuation at this point? Here's the key difference. Coca-Cola is a boring company, but its business model is set in store. Its margins are stable. So if you tell me this year's margins, I can pretty much predict what the margins are going to be for the next 10 years. Nvidia has an astonishing business model. The business model that I've described it to you before Nvidia came along, you'd say, there's no way a company can pull that off. I mean, just what it does, right? It designs the chips. It gets TSMC to make the chips. So it doesn't have any of the manufacturing facilities. It marks those chips up 800 to 900%. And it sells it to meta and alphabet and Microsoft. This model is right for tension at both ends, right? If you're TSMC, you're saying, why are we letting Nvidia take all of this upside? And if you're meta or alphabet or Microsoft, you're saying, why am I accepting these marks if the answer is right now? You're so desperately in need of building data centers and you've decided that Nvidia chips are the only way to do it. You're willing to accept this business model. That's always been the case. Even in its glory days, a question is, not whether the margins will close, but what are the forces that will cause it to close sooner rather than later? So it's a model that's destined to see a margin decline over time. I'm not saying that it's good to collapse. I mean, remember, a typical chip company has operating margins of 40%. Nvidia's margin operating margins of 70%. That's amazing. That's why we give them the premium. But the 70 cannot stay 70 because you're going to get tensions on both ends. Met and Microsoft are working on their own chips because that we don't have to pay the premium. I'm sure TSMC is trying to negotiate a better deal for itself because they know without them the chips will not be made. So I think that's where the personal connections might become a factor for Nvidia because Nvidia's connections with TSMC go back 30 years. You read the stories about how Nvidia's a small company reached out to TSMC. There is a relationship between TSMC's management and not Nvidia's management, but Genshin Wong that is personal. So the question is, are all of those things going to start to come and address sooner because Genshin's no longer there? So I think you're right, it looks cheap, but it's also built on a precarious business model where you keep asking, will. I mean, there was a part in the anthropic, I don't know whether there was an actual prospectus and whether there was an overstatement that they'd found a way to get clawed to take traditional non-inverteid chips and with the power of AI, they got the non-inverteid chips to do what Nvidia. That is a terrifying thought because if AI can become self perpetuating and it can replace inverteid chips with much cheaper chips, that goes your business model. So it's in very great as the company looks on paper. And it's an amazing company in terms of growth and margins. You keep holding your bread saying, what'll cause this model to implode and I think the market right now is holding its bread. It's worrying about the things that can cause it implode. So 11 times earnings might look cheap, unless there's an implosion. So I think you've got to build in some kind of a risk effect here into the earnings, which will make the 11 times earnings to go back to 25 times earnings if you build in a breakdown of the business model. - When you look at all of those questions, and this is part of the problem with the stock right now, is that there are so many questions that are so significant to which no one actually knows the answer because you can't. What do you make of stocks like that as an investor? I mean, is that the kind of situation where actually you can't answer enough questions so you can't invest? - No, that's not true. I think this is the kind of stock where concentrating your portfolio is deadly. I mean, I've said that about an Nvidia through the glory days. Don't have a third of your money, half your money in Nvidia, no matter how great you think the company is. And here's the reason, it's right for the uncertainties. You're absolutely right. You can make your best estimate, but you know you're gonna be wrong 100% of the time. You could convince me that Nvidia's cheap, but if I have to put all my money in Nvidia, there is zero chance. I'm gonna do it because there are too many unknowns that can come back to bite me. But if I'm adding Nvidia to a portfolio of 30 companies, the uncertainties become a lesser factor because you're using the law of large numbers in your favor. I did put a limit by an Nvidia at 140. I've sold all my Nvidia holdings that I bought in 2018 over the last two years. But in a 140, I'm willing to live with the uncertainties because I think there's enough power left in the business model for me to make my money plus more. But that's because I have a portfolio that's diversified. And I think that if you're gonna make a better Nvidia, make it from a position where it's not 30 or 40% of your portfolio. You reduce your upside, but you can live with the downside. And you need to be able to live with the downside with this stock, at least in the near term, for you to be able to make your money back. We'll be right back after the break. And by the way, we're recording our annual Ask Me Anything episode soon. So be sure to submit your questions for me and Scott. We can leave them in the comments on YouTube or Spotify, or we can email them to [email protected]. Numbers don't lie, but there are easier and harder ways to post them. If you're running a small business, you already have enough hard things on your plate, like trying to decipher the napkin scribble that you circled and wrote important above. Make keeping track of your financial numbers easy with zero. It makes accounting, payments, payroll and analytics available in one connected platform. Zero also lets you tailor your data for your business's specific needs. Zero's reports, visual dashboards, forecasts and AI insights can all help business owners better understand cash flow and make smarter decisions. The information is presented in ways that feel like they were designed for actual humans to read and understand. According to a 2024 customer survey conducted in the US, the UK and Australia, 91% of customers agree that zero is easy to use. We don't have data on what percentage of people think napkins scribbles are easy to use, but I feel comfortable guessing that the answer is lower. Join the five million customers worldwide who love using zero. That's x-e-r-o dot com. We're back with Profty Markets. I'm going to move us on to Anthropic, which just priced its IPO at $83 per share. We're recording this just before the stock actually goes out. So when this episode airs, it will be trading. But what we know at this point in time is that it is going to go out at roughly $1.5 trillion in market cap. You valued this company earlier, and you valued it just below that, $1.475 trillion. So I guess walk us through your evaluation there, and then we'll get into how you think this thing will trade over the next 12 months. - I valued Anthropic on November 2nd, the day before the midterm elections at 1.475 trillion. The reason I emphasize that is he's saying, that's three weeks ago, that wasn't that long ago. It's a three week period, which was extraordinarily eventful from an Anthropic AI standpoint. - Yes. - You have an election that's brought to a Congress, a legislature that is going to be much more hostile to both data centers and to AI as a technology. It's going to get more expensive to build data centers. One of the inputs in my model is how much will Anthropic have to spend as incremental investment in compute power to get its revenue? Because I told a big uplifting story about Anthropic, a story where they can get to a trillion dollars in revenues. And just for perspective, that would make them the large, there's no other company right now on the face of the earth that makes more than 800 billion revenues. The closest you get is Amazon and Walmart. I'm giving them a trillion dollars in revenues. I gave them margins that reflect premium pricing in the AI market, though I adjusted for the fact that there might be a regulatory drag. So end result is a margins of 27 and a half percent. And I did assume that they would be able to keep adding compute power if not easily at about the same rate as they do today. - That's a 1.475 trillion. I revalued Anthropic about 20 minutes before I came on here. I made two changes. One is I said it is going to get more expensive, at least in the near to build data centers in compute power. So basically you will get less revenue per dollar. And the other is the drag from, I don't know what form the regulatory drag is going to take, but it's going to make your margins lower higher cost. So slightly higher drag, slightly more reinvestment. That lowers my estimated aggregate value back, could be about 100 billion. So I'm moving in the other direction. I'm going towards 1.35 trillion. So difficult to get the word trillion out of a month, you know, such an uncommon word. And I did compute the value per share this time. I could not do that on November 2nd, because the prospect is still hadn't fleshed out share count. Now we have the share count share, you know, class A, class A and class D, class E. And of course the famous founder share. So I bring in the updated share count. My estimated value, if you bring in the share count and the fact that there were big chunk of options outstanding came up with the value of $77. That was five minutes before I came on. Is I, I got that number. I hadn't seen the $83, because the pricing came out just as I came on here. It's 83, I think, is the listed price. That terrifies me. It terrifies me that I'm so close to a banker's price. I'd be much more comfortable. But it tells me that, I mean, to show you the trajectory of that banker pricing, if you go back to the start of last week, they were shooting for like 1.15, 1.25 trillion. They went from two trillion to 1.1 trillion. And now we're in the middle. And the question is what change? And people think that bankers sit in little alcohols, valuing and thropic with business models. Here's what change. They put the 1.1 trillion to 1.25 trillion out there on Monday and Tuesday. They heard from a lot of institutional investors. And they heard too much enthusiasm. So they reprised it. This is a pricing game. And my guess is if they've done the job right, there's only one job bankers doing this IPO, which is to get the pricing to a level where tomorrow when it opens, you get a pop. - Yes. - 10%, 15%. So if they've done their job, I would expect the price to open up. No, $90, $95. Whether it stays there is different because this entropic also has unlocking happening right from day one. People are going to be allowed to sell their shares. So there's going to be this pressure from people trying to cash out and people trying to get in. It's going to be really, really busy at the exit door and entrance. So it's the same door. People are coming in, people are leaving. So it'll be interesting to watch what the stock does during the course of the day. Not just at opening because the net effect, what it closes at tomorrow would be the number that I would be comparing my 77 to. The offering price is irrelevant, the opening price is irrelevant when it ends up tomorrow evening. And if it ends up tomorrow evening at 71 or 72, which can happen, that's a really bad outcome for banks, then it starts to get interesting for me. But it needs to drop a lot before I buy it because the governance structure is one designed in health for shareholders. With since Google, we've had voting shares and non-voting shares. We're used to that, right? This is a single share held by seven founders with 50.01% of the voting rights. The closest thing I can get to comparing it to is golden shares that were issued by governments when they privatized companies in the '80s and the '90s. Margaret Thatcher introduced it in some of the British privatizations. And what a golden share gives the government, it's a single share, but it gives the government veto power over big decisions, acquisitions, expansion into new geographies. The anthropic founder share is a golden share with even more power. And I don't want to give governments and regulators ideas, but I don't know whether the anthropic founders thought through this. But let's say that you have an activist government or regulator and they decided at some point that AI is doing things that are not in the public interest. And there will be scandals, there will be breakdowns of things. What if that activist regulator then says, we're going to expropriate that one to founder share. And we will pay the market price on the class A shares. That one founder share should be worth a couple of hundred billion. But the regulator's going, it's not traded, we pay the price of a class A share. I know the founders can contest this in court and argue it's expropriation rightly. But then I would worry about the target you've given an activist regulator or government that looks at that share saying, we'd like to control, we'd like, I mean, this talk of making AI utility, the easiest way to do it is actually by that founder share. And the government then essentially controls the big decisions of the company. No, it's a, it's, it's I think the way it's been structured, I'm not sure what the incentive was to set it up this way. I'm sure there was a reason for it. But what I see from the outside is a target and that target might effectively make that founder share something that's coveted by regulators and governments. It's really interesting. I mean, I would think that the reason they set it up way that way was to consolidate and protect power. But to your point, they might have actually made themselves more vulnerable to giving up that power. But going back to just looking at the anthropic business and your evaluation, one of the risks that I've been obsessed with is the fact that they told us that over the next several years, they're going to spend around $900 billion on compute and infrastructure. And they said that, you know, by before 2030, so that over the next three years, it's going to be around $400, $500 billion in spending and a lot of that spending, they cannot get out of or at least it's contractually set. So they're going to have to spend hundreds of billions of dollars, which is a completely different business from the business to this today, where they're spending a couple of tens of billions of dollars. This thing has been around $9 billion in the first half. Maybe it'll be a little higher. So the entire cash flow profile of the business is about to completely transform. And we're going to see you essentially. entirely different company, which means that we're going to need to see a company that is either one going to have to raise hundreds of billions of dollars from the capital markets, which basically opens yourself up to the whims of investors who can be very annoying and moody, or they have to generate, as you said, a trillion dollars in revenue. And I'm not so sure of that or I'm not convinced. So how do you think about those risks going forward? Let me separate the two issues. One is the compute power commitments are an issue. They're an issue because they're a mismatch. Mismatch, in what sense, young companies, companies that are not making money should not be borrowing money. That's a first corporate finance principle. And in effect, Anthropic is violating that principle by entering into contractual commitments without the earnings to vacate them. That'll put most young companies out of business, right? There are two things that I think would buffer Anthropic from the risk. The first is, after this IPO, the cash balance should be about 200 billion dollars. That's going to cover them. The big charges for the next two or three years are the compute commitments. They're covered for the next three years. But there's a breathing room. But it's breathing room only if their revenues very quickly start to ramp up because getting to a trillion in 10 years means that you have to be basically doubling revenues pretty much every year, at least in the near future. So this is the combination you're going to be looking at. If revenues climb, it's not a problem. If revenues don't climb, then of course they're going to be squeezed because it's not that the compute commitments are a promise that they can't get to the revenues they need to justify their commitments. But I can see why they did it. In this business, the I business, I think compute power is going to become the scarce resource. They were way behind open AI a year ago in terms of compute power lined up. It's about a third of the compute power. They've caught up and they've gone ahead of open AI with the commitments. So to them, this is the way of saying we've got a lane setup. So when we grow, we'll have the compute power because we don't have the compute power. Even if the growth is there, we will not be able to deliver on the growth because compute power will become scarce. So I think it's a reflection of them seeing, looking down the road and saying we need to lock up that compute power. But it is a risk in the company. In fact, I compute a debt value for the leases of close to 500 billion. And I subtracted it from the equity. So when I came up with a $1.475 trillion dollar value for the equity, that was after I subtracted out the debt value of 500 billion. But you're right, the key assumption in this whole story, because when I did my entropic valuation, I made it an open source where people could come in and pick their own story. And I let them say this is the input that I disagree with on the monster. And I was surprised that so many people made this about the cost of capital that I used to 9.74% cost of capital. And be quite honest, that wasn't even my top 10 list of worries. As around the 90th percentile for U.S. companies, they're risky company. But I think people in the gut want to give cost of capital of 14, 15, 16% for risky companies. But you gut doesn't equate to real, you got to live in the world you're in. The world we're in at 10% cost of capital is at the 90th percentile. I gave them a pretty high cost of capital. To me, the central input that drives this valuation, the number that I would watch the most, is a revenue number. If I can get towards that trillion dollars in revenues, everything else gets taken care of. My profits will come. I'll be able to meet my compute commitments, my cost of capital will stay low, default risk will go away. If revenues don't start to come in, everything else falls apart. So this is a company that drives almost entirely on, will there be enough of a market for AI, products and services, or clawed agents around the world, that I could keep doubling my revenues every year for the next five years. So I can get to this trillion dollar end revenue of all the numbers. I'll be watching in the financial statements going forward. That's the number that I will focus on because that's the number that drives everything that's the valuation. I 100% agree, which is why I was concerned to see that the revenue growth is slowing down as much as it is. I forget what Q1 revenue growth was, but it was enormous, and it came down to 47% growth, which is still obviously huge, but it was a significant slowdown. And now it appears it's going to come down to between 15 to 25%. We'll see what happens in Q4. If they can continue that, I guess we're looking at a doubling next year, which I guess is good, but that assumes that it doesn't continue to slow. Don't they need to change something quite substantively to get those numbers back up? If you asked anthropic, they would say it's because we ran out of compute power. There was a combination of open AI, underpricing us, and compute power becoming a scarce resource. I think the truth is, both can be true. Open AI is going to continue to be there. They keep underpricing. You're going to have an issue because you're going to have to bring prices down to massive prices. And this isn't even opening the door to the other source of competition, which is open source models that are less powerful, but just as effective. Most businesses don't need Claude. Even if they decide to use AI, in-house to do what they need to. It's overkill. And I think one of the things anthropic has to learn is not build frontier models that are essentially state-of-the-art models. It's like building a car with every single potential add-on. When people just want four wheels and a vehicle that works, I think anthropic has to learn to create models that are powerful enough, but not too powerful, because why add that extra power? Put the extra knee for compute power when you don't need to. There is a side business, and this I think is this fascinating side story. And I'm not even sure how the story fully plays out. We're anthropic in addition to providing AI agents, AI tools to other companies, plans to enter businesses as a player. Business we're talking about is the drug business, where they say, "Look, we're going to actually not just provide agents. We're going to be providing if not doing what former companies are doing. Do what those lead into former companies are doing." I mean, San Diego is full of these young biotech and former companies where you build up a drug and then you sell it to Pfizer or Merck or one of the lead players. And anthropic seems to be convinced that they can enter businesses like that and essentially be able to do what young former companies are doing. And make revenues because now you're no longer a tool. You're not being paid for as a replacement or a tool. You're being paid for for something you do. The problem with that story is if anthropic tells a story about the drug business, that they're going to be a player. If I were consulting from, "Do I really want Claude to be somewhere?" If I'm McKenzie and I invite Claude in, I use it. I'm worried about, "Hey, what if Claude learns enough about my consulting resources that I am facing anthropic consulting and anthropic banking?" It actually gets in the way of the sales pitch that anthropic is making to the rest of the world. How they balance that, I don't know. But I think part of the, in fact, much of the excitement I hear from anthropic bulls is, it's usually a story about how AI is going to give a cure for cancer much more quickly. And that anthropic will reap the benefits of that. Even if the first part of that is true, that anthropic AI can find a way to come up with a cure for diseases quicker, because if you pull the data together, do what human beings will have tough time doing, I'm not sure the value created from that, it crews to anthropic. It might just be great for all of us because it's consumer surplus. But you might, in a sense, take a business and make it less profitable across. It might be bad for pharmaceuticals collectively, because you now have a player in the game with lower costs, who's willing to underpress you. But I think people make too much, it took quick a leap from, there's a lot of value that is created and therefore anthropic will claim the value. There's going to be lots of claims on that value creation. And by the time you're done, I'm not sure what percentage of the value created from AI actually accrues to the AI companies. I 100% agree with that, which is why I'm interested that you saw a pathway to this company achieving a trillion dollars in revenue, because when I look at the current growth rate, the risks that you lay out, it's clear that in order to do everything that they want to achieve, given the amount of their spending on compute, they're going to have to enter new businesses, the likes of which we haven't seen before. They're going to need to clearly dramatically change this business. Lots of different businesses that are going to be solving lots of different problems. And to me, so many stars have to align for that to occur. And to be clear, they have to align in order for this business plan to work, which to me is quite a bold pitch. So I guess on your end, how is it that those stars aligned for you? I think ultimately this business is going to become a business with two or three big players in it. It's going to be a big business with two or three players. And with Anthropic, I see it as one of the players. It's the most focus of the eye companies in terms of saying, look, we're building things for enterprises. This isn't a neat thing that you're going to have on Zoom or some add-on. It's the most focus. And I'm a feeling that once you get your feet into a company, let's say you're selling replacements for bankers and Goldman Sachs invites you into the company. And the way you train is you give the agent access to data as a bank and access to bankers. And it learns from them. It's sticky. It's a business where once you get into companies. So I think being the first player here will give Anthropic. That's inherent in my story. I could be very wrong. Maybe this is the kind of business where companies are going to essentially use agents, not give the maxes to data, proprietary data. But you need some stickiness in this model. And I'm assuming that stickiness will develop. And that stickiness is two side effects. One is, it becomes much more difficult for later players to come in and under price you because you're too immersed in the company. I mean, that's partly why if you make yourself, where you look at a calendar in the government, it's once you get to become part of that system. It's very difficult to think of, how are you going to switch? So my gut feeling is you're going to end up with two, maybe three companies in this space with lots of stickiness in their models. I think there are lots of risks, lots of disruption risks that you have to face along the way. So it's the way I would describe the 1.475 trillion is it's my optimist had his firmly on and you needed to stay on for this to work, which is the reason I'm also worried about governments because it's also going to be a business, even in its best case scenario where you're going to take a path and it doesn't work. You have to be willing to adapt and change and take a different path. That's why governance comes it, right? People pushing back saying you have to change. Yeah. I think the way I entrop it is structured, I worry about whether the people running entropic will be willing to change because what's the incentive? We know how do you make them change when they don't want to? Eventually, the market might be the only mechanism to get them to listen, the market price dropping. But that's a blunt instrument. I mean, you saw that with Facebook how much damage had to be created before Mark Zuckerberg gave up on the matter of us. If you multiplied by that by 10, that's what you would need in the AI space to learn the same lesson. So I think that, you know, that's why I said this is not an investment if you're thinking about five stocks that happen here portfolio. But it's an investment I'm willing to consider at a discount on that 1.475 trillion as one company in the space because if AI delivers on even half of its promise, it is going to be a big business. And right now, I can't think of it because the rest are building the factory, right? The rest of the AI space is either companies building the data centers or companies supplying the stuff for the data centers. This is the first really big pure play product and service company out there. And at the risk of, you know, of worrying about missing out on this entire space, that's why I think there's an advantage to going first year as well. When open AI goes public next year, there will be a repricing. And there'll be more comparisons. Right now, there's nothing to compare to you. You're saying, what about SpaceX? SpaceX has clearly become a builder. It's not a product because almost all of XAI's revenues come from leasing out compute power space to entrap they can out for but not from, no, revenues to generators to stand alone and that. We'll be right back. And for even more market's content, sign up for our newsletter at ProfTMarkets.com/subscribe. This is advertiser content from zero. Sometimes the hype cycles can make us forget that a stock represents a real business. But whether you're an investor or a business owner, if you understand how to draw insights from the financial data of the underlying business, the rest is noise. So I'm going to talk about some of the ways I evaluate the business. And I'll show you how zero can help you apply the same criteria to your own businesses finances. Zero spelled with an X is a platform that connects your businesses accounting, payments, payroll, and analytics under one umbrella. Let's call this exercise Ed's business health checklist. First on the list, nobody can or should know your business better than you do. With zero, not only our profit and loss reports easy to generate, you can track trends over time. Second, you want a business that understands how its customers behave. With zero, you can track your average revenue per customer, very important. You can even sort and visualize your top customer accounts across areas like sales, cost of sales, and expenses to help you figure out where the best opportunities for growth are. Third, you need to be flexible. As Dwight de Eisenhower once said, plans are worthless, but planning is everything. And you know that's coming from a solid source because one of Dwight Eisenhower's best friends was supposedly a guy named Edward Elson. Staying on top of your finances isn't about sticking rigidly to a plan. It's about having the confidence to respond when things inevitably change. Zero is dynamically linked to your accounts with instant bank reconciliations. When something changes in your accounts, it's immediately reflected in zero. Those are a few of the ways that I think about the health of a business. And a few of the way zero can help you keep your business healthy. Lesson adjourned. Learn more at referrals.xero.com/profgmarkets. At the time of recording, you can get 90% off for six months on a zero subscription, terms and conditions apply. We're back with ProfG markets. I'm just going to zoom out and look at the broader stock market. So we're coming up on the end of the year. The S&P is up around 7% year to date, which is quite striking after this incredible sell-off in AI. And part of my view of what's happening here, I mean, we're all wondering when is this bubble going to pop? When are we going to see a correction? People seem to still be asking that question. I look at what's happened to AI. To me, the bubble has popped. I mean, Nvidia losing more than a third of its value, neoclouds coming down. A lot of these AI names just getting crushed. What's just striking though is the fact that the stock market is a whole is doing fine. It's been the most impressive year I've seen in stock markets in the last decade. And that includes yours where markets up 25%. The fact, I mean, at the start of this year, the story was, as the Mag 7 goes, so goes the market. Now, this year, the Mag 7 is pretty flat. In fact, it's down. The market is up. As tech goes, so goes the market. This year, the market's managed to go up. The fact that the market has been able to hold its own, and it's a number that's going to be shifting as we're talking, right? It was up 10%. Just four days ago. It's up 7%. I think that continued selling in AI will spill over elsewhere. But I think that the fact that it's held its own is extraordinarily impressive. That investors have been able to rotate out of technology into other businesses. Those other businesses have been able to absorb the pain of losing trillions of dollars on five or six companies and be able to increase to offset. I'll be quite honest. I didn't think the market could pull it off. If you told me at the start of the year, what AI and tech companies have done is say, what will the market be? I'd say it'd be down 10%. That's how much the magnitude of the drop has been in AI and tech. The fact that it's up 7% is incredibly impressive. It shows you that the US economy has legs that go beyond AI. We've talked so much about AI for the last five years. We forget how diverse the US economy is in terms of delivering value across the board, across different businesses. I think it's a testimony. If you want to look at a market that's been decimated by tech's meltdown, take a look at the cost fee. You can see what happens when you have a market that's concentrated in tech. When the tech drops, there's nothing else that can absorb the pain. The US has been able to. Will it continue to do so? It'd be tough to keep doing this on a month after month. Tech and AI has to bottom up for the market to find its legs again. That's what we're going to be watching over the rest of this year. I've been feeling the market's going to get tested as we go through the last few weeks of this year. We're just looking at some of the sectors that have outperformed this year. Consumer staples are 16%. Health care up 18%. The biggest performer has been energy nearly 40%. You can make an argument that that is and AI trade but also maybe some defensive in some ways. But, you know, healthcare, consumer staples, I mean, these are, it's the opposite. And so it seems as though investors have been rotating out of AI and rotating into some of these more defensive stocks. And I guess that would explain the resilience. I mean, I guess two questions for you. One, how do we account for this extraordinary resilience in the stock market? And then two, now that the defensive stocks have gotten all of this juice in this rotation, where what's left in terms of defense going into 2027? That seems to be the risk. When you ask people how many publicly traded companies that are in the US, they're often underestimated how many there are by a magnitude of three, four, five. There's about 6,000 publicly traded companies in the US across sectors. There isn't another market in the world that has the kind of spread across businesses of companies that are publicly traded. And I think that's part of the resilience is, and the resilience comes from the fact that AI, in spite of all of its issues, has created an economic boom in certain sectors and certain parts of the country. And those people have money to spend, they're spending it on consumer staples. And of course, healthcare is something you have to spend. It's not something you do discreet. It's part of a healthcare problem we have. I'm not sure that's good news that healthcare is up 18% because it suggests that there's freeing in the healthcare system. But I think it's a fact that AI has also kept the economy afloat. It's estimated that 1% of real GDP growth each of the last four years has come from the AI boom. So we're reaping the benefits of that boom in other businesses because people have money to spend. You can't keep doing that. I mean, as I said, you know, unless AI has to bottom out, if tech keeps dropping 10% every quarter and AI keeps, you know, has days like yesterday or two weeks gone on that Thursday. Markets can't hold up against that much selling and that much money because, you know, that's a lot of market cap leaving the market, two trillion, three trillion, four trillion. That's tough to make up on a continuous basis. So what we're looking for as investors is when will this tech AI correction bottom out? And I think that's the question that's going to drive market discussions for the rest of this year and into next year. Do you have an answer to that question? I do think we're getting closer to the bottom than we were just a month and a half, two months ago. Yeah, I agree. And I think that I can't tell you exactly when it happens, but waiting for the exact bottom is often one of, is an exercise in futility. You end up losing everything. So if you've never invested in AI and tech because you've always felt the max seven was too expensive and you had that view for the last 40 years, your portfolio is probably lost because of that view. Now's your chance to start adding those companies at prices much better than the need of God two years ago, three years ago, four years ago. So I think people have to be willing to look past the bad news stories and say, I'm willing now to put some of my money. And as I said, don't make this all of your money. Make some of your money into tech into AI. No, whether it might not be a topic. It might be a pal interior. It might be a constellation energy. It might be the builders. It might be the suppliers. Pick a piece that you think is reasonably enough price for you to enter and find ways to enter that space if you've never been there. Going into 2027, I think I mean, my prediction for 2026 is that returns would be meh. I single digit, okay. I believe I think you out of similar prediction. And it's exceeded expectations. We'll see what happens. Towards the end of the year, we'll have it in December. And I also said it would be good to have a mayor is also what I said at the start of the year. It's good to have a single digit return year for two reasons. One is it lets investors consolidate. Think about what they've done. And second, it teaches people what risk actually meets. Risk is a word for most people. The only way you understand what risk does is to live through a downturn. If you're on an immediate, no, four weeks ago, you know what risk is. I don't have to describe it for you because you've seen what it does to your portfolio. That's good for investors to get that, you know, get that prod saying, hey, you can't overreach on risk because it looks good today. But what will it look like? Two years from now. So I think the mayor return might bear with five, six weeks left, let's wait and see. It could become double digit returns or become a negative year very quickly because of the way things are moving. But I think it's going to be a year that is definitely not like the years we've had. No, we've had three, four years of, you know, 15, 20% returns, which historically, you know, we had, we've had a three-year stretch which ranks up there with some of the best three-year stretches in history. So I think if it's time for an easing time to take a breath, then I think 2026 the market eased up and took a breath and you've got to give it credit that even though AI and tech had that big collapse that it was able to do that and still not implored. But it still rose quite, I mean quite somewhat significantly. And I guess going into 2027, the question becomes, I mean, when's the last time we saw an actual correction that was broad-based, I guess, 2022. So we're going on four years of pretty good returns. If you invest in an index fund or even invest in a diversified portfolio. Yes. 80% of the world doesn't do that, right? So what might seem like a painless, a relatively painless year for you, if you're diversified, has been an extremely painful year for many people who've invested. Because now that's the other thing about tech doing so well for so long is your investors and the entire portfolio is composed of tech stocks or the Mag 7. And it's not been a good year for them. In fact, it's been a pretty damaging year. So you can have damage that is deep in big segments of the market. And I'm feeling a lot of investors. If you look at even though the market is up 7%, I'd wage 80% of investors this year. I'm going to underperform. I'm going to have negative returns for the year. The one reason you can tell is even though the market was up, so this was actually a month ago when the market was up 11, 12%, 52% of stocks this year was still down for the year. It's not a market where stocks are all climbing. It's a market where depending on the sector, depending on the stocks you pick, you can get a return very different from the return you're seeing for the overall market. So what do you think will happen? I mean, we're a little bit early to be making predictions. But what would be your expectations going into 2027 for the broader stock market for the S&P? Some feel very worried. Paul Tudor Jones, for example, has, I forget exactly what his words were, but he said with all of the capital raising, coming down the pike, hundreds of billions of dollars that are going to be raising the capital markets by not only the anthropics in the open AIs of the world, but also the big tech companies. We're going to go out and raise more money to build more data centers. So given all of that happening, what are your expectations for this market going into 2027? I think that notwithstanding the AI investor collapse this year, AI continues to be the big story driving the economy in markets. If the AI story really slows down, and I'm talking about the building of data centers slows down, the supplying of the data centers slows down, the products and services don't take off. Then I think there's an economic hit we're going to take to the overall. And that's going to cause a market correction. So really, everything goes back to AI. This is much as we like to run away from AI. It's not as big as it used to be. We've managed pretty well with that AI. AI is the undercurrent that's driving the economy in the market. Then I think 2027, the question is, can AI keep doing it? Or will a substantial slowdown in AI result in a recession and a market correction broadening because people don't have the income? And that I think is I think the big question hanging over 2027. What happens? Because it is going to happen. AI is going to slow down. The earnings effect of AI is going to go away. And all of a sudden, you're going to see price earnings ratio rise even though the market might not be, you know, might not be going up because earnings are giving up some of those gains because a big chunk of the growth and earnings this year. This was the, I think the highest growth rate in earnings for the aggregate earnings for the S&P 500 that I've seen in the last 40 years. It's like 56% it's missed on. But much of it came from AI. People spending the CapEx reporting reported as revenues and earnings. And you start to slow that process down. It's not that people, you know, stop building data centers, but they slow the process down. You're no longer, it starts to catch up. The depreciation on existing AI CapEx is going to go up. The revenue benefits from new AI CapEx is going to go down. The earnings effect is going to go away. The question is, what does the 56% growth look like next? It's definitely not going to be 56%, but is it going to be 4% or 5% or are we talking about 15 or 20%? That will be the number that ends up driving what the market does I think next year. Aswath DeModern is the question of family chair in finance education and professor of finance at NYU Stern School of Business where he teaches corporate finance and valuation. You can read his research on his blog, Musings on the Markets. Aswath, thank you so much for joining us. Thank you. This episode was produced by Claire Miller and Alison Weiss and engineered by Benjamin Spencer. Our research team is Dan Shalon, Cristino Donahue and Measel Vario. Drew Burrows is our technical director and Catherine Dillon, it's our executive producer. Thank you for listening to Profty Markets from Profty Media. If you liked what you heard, give us a follow and join us for a fresh take on Markets on Monday. Live time. You have me. And kind. Reunion. Aswath DeModern. Aswath DeModern. Whether you're an investor or you're running a small business, you never want to lose track of the financial fundamentals. It doesn't matter how great your product or idea is if you don't have a clear picture of how cash is moving through your business. Zero can help. Join the five million customers worldwide who loved using zero. That's x-e-r-o.com.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Nvidia's market value has dropped significantly due to uncertainties surrounding CEO Jensen Huang and potential China-related regulatory issues.
  2. The personal and corporate scandals involving Huang add long-term risk, particularly if investigations lead to operational restrictions or loss of market access in China.
  3. Despite the drop, Nvidia's stock trades at a lower multiple than traditional companies, suggesting potential undervaluation despite a fragile business model.
  4. Analysts emphasize that a CEO's departure has limited impact at scale, especially with strong internal management in place, though cultural shifts are notable.
  5. Anthropic’s IPO pricing and business model raise concerns about overcommitment to compute spending and lack of revenue growth, with significant governance risks.
  6. The broader market has shown resilience despite AI and tech stock declines, driven by diversification across sectors like energy, healthcare, and consumer staples.
  7. Market resilience reflects a shift in investor sentiment, with rotation into defensive sectors, indicating that AI-related volatility is not systemically destroying the economy.
  8. The key investment insight is that high-risk, high-growth tech stocks should be held in diversified portfolios, not as concentrated bets, to manage downside risk.

Summary:

Nvidia's market value has plummeted due to a combination of CEO Jensen Huang's controversial personal conduct and potential China-related regulatory risks, which threaten its operations and global reach. While a CEO change may have only a short-term impact, the lingering uncertainty—especially around legal investigations—adds significant risk to the company's long-term outlook. The stock trades at a discount to traditional firms, suggesting potential undervaluation, but its high-margin business model is vulnerable to shifts in supply chains and competitive pressures, such as AI-driven alternatives.

In contrast, the broader market has shown surprising resilience despite AI and tech sector crashes, driven by rotation into defensive sectors like healthcare and energy. This reflects a more diversified economy, where downturns in one sector are offset by others. Analysts caution that AI remains the central driver of growth, and its slowdown could trigger a broader market correction.

Therefore, investors are advised to maintain diversified portfolios, allocating only a small portion to high-risk tech stocks like Nvidia or Anthropic. The market’s stability in 2026 suggests a potential buying opportunity, but long-term success hinges on AI's sustained growth and corporate governance adaptability. Zero, a financial management platform, is highlighted as a tool for small business owners to gain better financial insights, enabling more informed decision-making in uncertain economic environments.

FAQs

Zero is a platform that consolidates accounting, payments, payroll, and analytics into one connected system. It helps small business owners track finances easily, with tools like visual dashboards, forecasts, and AI insights to understand cash flow and make smarter decisions.

Yes, according to a 2024 customer survey, 91% of users in the US, UK, and Australia agree that Zero is easy to use. Its interface is designed to be intuitive and accessible for non-experts.

Zero provides tailored financial reports, visual dashboards, and AI-driven insights that help business owners understand customer behavior, revenue trends, and operational performance to make informed decisions.

Key benefits include simplified financial tracking, real-time bank reconciliations, automated reporting, and the ability to analyze data by customer segment to identify growth opportunities.

Traditional methods like napkin scribbles are unreliable and hard to track. Zero offers structured, accurate, and accessible financial data that ensures better visibility and control over business performance.

Nvidia’s market value has dropped significantly, from $4.8 trillion to around $3.5 trillion, due to concerns over CEO Jensen Huang’s conduct, potential regulatory investigations, and China-related risks, which have created uncertainty about long-term growth and margins.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.