The story of Heidi Lang and other residents of Paradise, California, illustrates a growing crisis in the U.S. insurance industry driven by climate change. Once a stable, low-cost system, homeownership insurance is now failing in fire-prone regions due to escalating wildfire frequency and severity. Insurance companies, constrained by regulatory limits and unable to use climate models to project losses, are either canceling policies or raising premiums by hundreds of percent—sometimes from $1,000 to nearly $10,000 annually. Homeowners respond by seeking the state’s Fair Plan, a government-backed safety net that offers only limited coverage and is rapidly overwhelmed. Despite widespread adoption of fire-resistant building standards such as those promoted by the Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety (IBHS), premiums remain exorbitantly high, and insurers offer minimal discounts. Community-led efforts like “firewise” initiatives fall short of creating financial relief. A turning point comes when insurance executives, after visiting Paradise and seeing its fire-safe rebuilding, begin to offer new policies—particularly to homes that meet strict safety standards. This signals a potential shift in how insurers respond to climate risk, though it remains a fragile and localized solution. Ultimately, the crisis exposes a deeper systemic failure: as climate disasters grow in scale and frequency, the traditional insurance model—built on risk diversification—may no longer be sustainable, raising urgent questions about whether certain communities will become too costly to live in or insure at all. The future of insurance in the face of climate change may depend on regulatory reform, more accurate risk modeling, and a rethinking of how risk is priced and shared across communities.
This is Planet Money from NPR. A few months back, I went to visit a woman named Heidi Layne, who lives in a small town in the forested hill country of Northern California. I met up with her at the home she built there herself. It's canning season, so my house is consumed by pickled jalapenos, cowboy candy, pepper jelly, and I think that was it yesterday. It's this cute little one story ranch house. In the backyard, she's planted persimmon and pomegranate trees. She's got a rowdy little flock of chickens running around. Is that a silky? Um, no, that is a feather foot. Apply named? Yes. It's kind of like Heidi's personal slice of paradise. And like many Americans, her home is also the most valuable thing she owns. The store of decades worth of wages and work. So naturally, she's never thought twice about having insurance on the place. Well, a few years ago, when she got a letter from her insurance company in the mailbox, she takes it inside, opens it up and printed right at the top. It's just this daunting thing and says notice of cancellation. Her insurance company, Farmers, which had covered her home for almost a decade and a half, was dropping her, canceling her policy, which is a scary prospect. Heidi's community is located in what wildfire experts consider a high risk area, but setting right up against the highly combustible wilderness. So she goes to her local insurance agent to figure out what's going on. And I was probably a little snappy with my agent, like I'm being canceled. What is this? The agent looks it up and tells her the company had apparently taken some aerial images of her home lot and had identified piles of what they called scattered debris near her house, which could present a fire hazard. And I was like, what? I mean, scattered debris. What are you talking about? This is ridiculous. When Heidi saw the photos in question, she recognized almost immediately what they'd picked up. These were piles of wood chips she'd ordered for landscaping. But that had been all the way back in 2019 or so. I was like, that mulch pile has been gone for years. This is not a current photo of my house. And I was like, let's go to my house. I'll show it to you right now. Heidi explained to her agent that she'd actually gone to great lengths to build her home with wildfire safety in mind. So she and her agent put together a little packet of evidence in order to appeal farmer's decision. And it does take a couple of weeks. But when they get back to her, Heidi learns that her appeal was, in fact, successful. She's going to get to keep her insurance. OK, that's great news. But then, not too long after that, Heidi gets a second notice from farmers. She says the annual cost of our home insurance, her premiums, were about to go way up. For over a decade, she'd been paying around $1,000 a year. But next year, it was going to be nearly $10,000. I think I was in shock. I never would have even entertained not having insurance before. You just have homeowners insurance. That's what you do. But that type of an increase just catastrophic. There's no way I could have come up with that. Heidi quickly realizes she is by no means alone in this. She hears that people all across her town are also getting kicked off their insurance or getting priced out by these massive spiking premiums. And she eventually learns that what's happening in the insurance market is much bigger even than just Heidi's town. It's part of a story playing out all across the West and beyond. Because the growing number and scale of climate catastrophes is changing the basic math of the insurance industry. Having the rates nationally for everyone and raising the question of whether some places may become too expensive to exist. It just feels like this is the beginning of the end for our insurance industry as we know it. Like, what do you even do about something that is a national industry nose dive? Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Alexi Horowitz-Gazzy. You can think of a story of Heidi Lang in her town kind of like a warning from our collective future. A story that explains the collapse of the insurance industry in the face of accelerating climate disaster and what everyday people are doing to try to survive. Today on the show, how communities in some of the most fire prone places in the country are trying to conjure the private insurance market back into existence, what actually happens when a mega fire comes knocking at your door, and what all this means for the biggest question. In the age of climate change, will the future simply become uninsurable? When Heidi Lang found out that her insurance company was going to raise her annual home insurance rates by more than 800%, the person she turned to to explain what was happening was her longtime insurance agent. A woman named Don Foster. You must see people's homes in a very particular X-ray vision. I do. After you get your license, you're driving down the street and you're like, "Ooh, that roof's not good. Oh, I couldn't ensure that house." So it's inside of you. Don moved to the Golden foothills of Northern California over 30 years ago. And for a long time, her job as an insurance agent was pretty mellow. Like back in 2007 when Heidi Lang and her then husband bought their house, for example, home insurance was kind of an afterthought. Something that was required to get a mortgage, but not expensive enough to raise an eyebrow. So when Heidi arrived at Don's office back in the fall of 2023, trying to figure out what had gone wrong here, Don explained that the conditions that led to her spiking premiums had been brewing for a long time. As an insurance agent, I look at the insurance industry and what it's been going through. It's been breaking for years. You see, for decades, wildfire had been a relatively small line item in the risk portfolio of the global insurance industry. Over around 2% of the annual natural disaster losses covered by insurance companies. But since 2016, the scale and frequency of those disasters had started to grow dramatically, becoming a steady drum beat on the news. Crews are on scene of a new brush fire burning in the sand. So everything burned, the town hall was burning when I left and I just had to leave. Property damage is estimated in the tens of billions of dollars. The fires in California in 2017 and 2018 caused over $20 billion in damages, and wiped out decades of insurance profits in one fell swoop. So insurance companies were on the hook for billions of dollars more than they'd expected every year, and at the same time Don explained, they couldn't raise their premiums enough to make up for all those new costs. See, to raise premiums, insurers had to submit a proposal to the state insurance regulator, but if they asked for an average rate increase across the state of more than 7%, it triggered a public hearing process. And for decades, that had put a kind of artificial limit on annual price increases. Don says the massive fires and huge losses were growing faster than the premiums could, and that started to threaten the whole business model. Don gets why customers like Heidi want to keep paying the lower rates they'd been paying for a long time. But on the insurance side, there's no way they can stay in business, right? They can't do that. I oftentimes share with my clients, if you paid $5,000 a year for your homeowners insurance, for 30 years, you will have paid $150,000 to the insurance agency, right? Now, that insurance company will take all the premiums you've paid and invest them. But when a disaster does happen, and thousands of homes are destroyed all at once, the insurer might have to pay out hundreds of thousands, if not millions of dollars per policy, to make their customers whole. I mean, insurance, they have to have enough money to pay, and by keeping the rates too low, they haven't had that. Now, as a consumer, yes, please lower my insurance. But I do also understand that if I only give you $150,000, and you can only earn 2% off that money, and I expect you to pay me $2 million when my house burns, that's a broken system. Right, you magnify that across the state or around the country, you got a problem. Right. It was kind of a grim conversation. She was basically saying that this is a greater problem, and this is happening to a lot of people right now, and it's looking like the majority of the people we're having to go to the fair plan. The California Fair plan is what's called the state's insurer of last resort. It's a home insurance option mandated by the state as a way to offer coverage for people left behind by their private insurers. Heidi says she had heard of it before, but. I really didn't know much at all about it, except for kind of the stigma that it was like government subsidized, you know, just you don't want to be on that. And maybe to some extent, that's just because it's not a choice, you know, like there's something psychological about when people force you to do stuff that it becomes negative. Don explained to Heidi that the California Fair plan is neither subsidized nor run by the government. The idea goes back to the 1960s, in the aftermath of things like the Watts riots, insurance companies started abandoning a lot of black and brown neighborhoods. Without insurance, it was difficult for people to buy or sell houses or run businesses. Insurance is this kind of fundamental lifeblood for all other economic activity. So to address this kind of insurance redlining, the government required private insurers to take their fair share of the riskier properties in order to get a license to do business in the state. The government wanted a stop gap until people could get back onto the private market. It was a last resort. They met with lenders and they figured out what color
Do you need to where you would loan people money so we can rebuild downtown Watts right because of the riots and so they created the California fair plan? The fair plan is actually made up of the same major insurers from the private market, but fair plan coverage is much more limited. Don says it does cover homeowners against the threat of fire, but it's missing a lot of very important coverage for an individual like liability. Sudden and immediate break of a pipe inside your home, destroying your floor, theft, those things are missing. So homeowners who have to go on to the fair plan often also need to get a second policy from a private company. Heidi knows that getting these two policies together is probably going to be pretty expensive, and as she does some research she hears that the California fair plan seems like it might be starting to financially buckle under all these new customers. So before making a decision, Heidi decides to make some calls of her own to see if anyone else would be willing to write her a new policy. She remembers a call with one company in particular and they kept cutting me off when I type in the zip code and I thought there was something wrong and so I went through the phone tree and didn't put one in like to try to get to somebody and I explained to them and they were like, "Oh yeah, we don't write there." I'm like, "Okay, so we're just like blacklisted. This is just not insurable, and I found that with countless companies." Heidi determines she basically has no other choice than to go on to the fair plan. With the supplemental policy added, she'll still be paying over three times what she paid before, but at least she'll be able to afford coverage at all. And Heidi says she knows intimately what a difference having insurance can make when calamity does come, along with all of her neighbors. Because the town she lives in, where she's lived for over 30 years, is a place called Paradise, California. Years earlier, back in 2018, it became a symbol of the growing scale of wildfires. How did the threat of wildfire bloom or not bloom when you were growing up here? It was always something that was talked about in town. Like, it's inevitable, it's going to happen. Paradise was built up on a ridge line between two steep canyons in the middle of a super dense forest of towering pine and oak trees that had been prevented from burning for decades, smoky bear style. And Heidi says some people in town used to say that made the place a kind of ticking tinderbox. On the morning of November 8, 2018, Heidi went to her job at the school superintendent's office, where she started to hear about a fire burning a couple canyons over from town. But first, it seemed like it might not be a big deal. I could see the fire, I could see the plume of smoke off in the distance, but it wasn't like, you know, anything evident at the time. But within just an hour, the wind had picked up and flaming embers were starting to land all over town, starting spot fires in every direction. It started to feel like a disaster unfolding, and it was Heidi's job to help figure out how to get all the kids to safety. We realized that this was unprecedented and that we needed to get them off the ridge. Soon it becomes clear that everyone needed to get out. My boss said, "You guys need to leave now." It's 9.30 in the morning, and it was black as night outside, and there was burning wood falling in the sky, and it was really bad. Heidi and her colleagues jumped into their cars and started driving. But everyone was evacuating at the same time, and she soon found herself stuck in this massive, barely moving traffic jam on one of the few roads out of town, with tall forest on either side. The fire is seemingly everywhere. The sky is black with ash and smoke. People are abandoning their cars, hopping in with anyone they can find. At one point, there are just people running down the road. You could feel the heat from the fire through the windows of your car, and you could smell hot metal. And I just kept praying that these people would keep going, and thank God they just kept going. Because if any of the people in front of me, which were thousands of people, if any of those people stopped, we were all going to be in real trouble. From her car, she'd been texting with her teenage son. He'd been trying to make it back to their home. And as he gets to the driveway, he calls Heidi. And he said, "Mom, I'm home. What do you want me to get?" Then I said, "Get the animals and get back in the car. Do not worry about anything else." So he grabbed the dog, the cat, and his lizard. And I will never forget how grateful I am that he got our animals, because many people did not get home to save their animals. And that would have just added a whole other layer of grief to the whole thing. At some point, Heidi says her husband, a sheriff's deputy, went to the house to grab whatever he could. And the neighbor's house over here was fully engulfed and it was blowing up to our house that our house was catching on fire. Heidi's husband couldn't stay to try and save the house. You had to help with the town's evacuation. Everyone was just trying to get out of paradise, out of the smoke. Earlier, Heidi herself got stuck in that hellish traffic jam. It took me about four and a half hours to make it from my office down to Chico. And I finally came down out of that black smoke and was able to connect with my son. And we all met at Target in Chico. And we went in and bought some water bowls for the cat, dog, and the blizzard. And literally just were in complete shock. That day was so surreal. Even as emotional as it is, I feel like I'm talking about somebody else. A few days after the fire, Heidi and her son made their way home and they found it burnt to the ground, along with nearly every other house in the neighborhood. It was literally just a pile of ashes. And I guess it was probably as traumatic to see the whole greater community. It was just complete devastation. I just eerie gray, everything was gray, just a profound absence of life. In total, over 11,000 homes and around 90% of the structures in paradise were destroyed. 85 people died. It was named the campfire and it was one of the deadliest and costliest fires in California history. In the aftermath, Don Foster, Heidi's agent at Farmers Insurance, set up a new office to help the customers in our portfolio who'd basically just lost everything. I lost 1100 homes, 352 cars in one day from my agency. I lost six humans in that fire. It was horrific. Yeah. It was very devastating. One of the hundreds of people Don helped file a claim with the insurance company was Heidi. The day, maybe two days after the fire, they had wired us like $10,000, I sent them a picture of the pile of ashes of the house and they validated a total loss and were like, we'll get the claim going, but we're wiring you $10,000 right now. So you can get whatever you need. So I'm grateful for that. And this is the point where you can start to see how mega fires and other climate catastrophes are changing the basic economics of the insurance industry. How's your home insurance situation? I mean, I live in San Diego. So this is first order. You know, I have colleagues who have trouble getting insurance. We've been lucky to keep our insurance and I hope that stays true. Knock on wood. Judson Boomhauer is an environmental economist at UC San Diego who studies insurance markets. I went to a lecture of Juds this summer that inspired this episode. Juds as wildfires like the one in Paradise ushered in a new era in the insurance industry, where billion dollar losses went from rare events to annual ones. And here's the problem. The basic insurance model is predicated on the idea of spreading risk. National insurance cover homes at risk from hailstorms in the Midwest and hurricanes in Florida and fires in California, in part because that is a way to diversify their portfolio to lower something called correlated risk. That's the likelihood that too many of their customers get caught up in the same loss event at the same time. That possibility, it's the kind of thing that can actually put insurers out of business, if they're not careful. They can get more people making claims at once than they're actually able to pay out. And that actually threatens the financial solvency of the insurance. But as climate change has increased the frequency and severity of wildfires and hailstorms and hurricanes, those risks are increasing. And that's left insurers more financially exposed. Normally, they might be able to offset all that financial risk by raising premiums, but regulations in California meant to help consumers make that difficult in a couple ways. The first is the process insurers have to use to apply for average rate increases of more than 7%, which is made at kind of de facto limit. And the second is that, for the past few decades, insurance companies could only use historical fire data to justify new rate increases. They haven't been allowed to use computer models that factor in climate change and project their future losses more accurately. Judd says this kind of forecasting that insurers
been blocked from doing? It's called catastrophe modeling. It's kind of like Dungeons and Dragons. It's kind of like a role-playing game. You're going to roll the 12-sided die 100,000 times. And every time you do that, you're going to have some realization of how bad the wildfire season was in your model that your how many fires started, how many houses burned down, and how much money you did in churros pay out in claims in this simulated version of the world. And after you roll the die over and over again, what you get is basically a distribution of possible states of the world. And that stands in for a historical loss record. In light of those limits, insurance companies have responded in a few ways. Some have started drastically clearing their books in certain regions to offload some correlated risk. And all of them have started taking a closer look at how much risk each particular property represents. Insurance have started to be a lot more surgical in how they price this risk. Judd says before this string of mega fires, insurance companies would often group their customers into big buckets of risk at like the zip code level. But now, insurers have a financial incentive to figure out the precise wildfire risk for each property. Judd explains that's kicked off a sort of information arms race. Companies are gathering things like aerial photos and local climate information to set just the right premium for each property. And the last big thing insurance companies are doing is trying to incentivize homeowners and communities to harden their homes, meaning to build new homes and retrofit existing ones in a way that mitigates the damages from wildfire. It becomes much more important to do everything we can to collect all the low hanging fruit to make houses less likely to burn down. There's this nonprofit research organization funded by all the big insurers called the insurance institute for business and home safety or I.B.H.S. for short. They have a giant campus in South Carolina where they build houses and subject them to all kinds of trials by fire like literally to figure out what kinds of roofing or vents or foliage are more or less likely to help a house survive in Emberstore. We actually visited the research center and did a whole episode on how it came about last week. And in the aftermath of the campfire, people in paradise started rebuilding with that same goal in mind to make their homes and businesses less susceptible to any future fires. People including Heidi Lang. Not long after the fire, Heidi and her husband split up and after she got her insurance payout, she decided she was going to rebuild her home on her own. I consciously made an effort to be fire resistant, you know, to a significant cost. It's, you know, doing stucco was more expensive, doing a metal roof was more expensive, doing the Vulcan vents was more expensive, all these things. Within a couple years, the town of Paradise itself decided to adopt a new building code. So every new home is supposed to be a kind of fortress against wildfire. The code was modeled after IBHS standards and when they heard that IBHS had come up with a new certification program for individual homeowners called wildfire prepared, the town asked one of its residents if she'd let them make some tweaks to her home so it could become the first one ever to be officially certified to that standard. That resident, a woman named Casey Taylor, told the city, "Sure, why not?" So sometimes I'll introduce myself, Casey from Paradise. I live in the first IBHS wildfire prepared home in the universe. That's big. I know. It's a big deal. Casey's house quickly became sort of like the poster house for this new way of building around fire safety. They had a big press conference to announce when it was first certified and she started seeing it on industry websites and literal posters. Now Casey's insurance premium started out around $800 a year, but it wasn't long before that changed. Because just like Heidi Lang, who is accused of harboring scattered debris in her yard, spiking premiums came for people all over Paradise. In the aftermath of this succession of fires, some insurance companies have started asking for rate increases way higher than 7%, despite the lengthy public hearing process. And others have lowered their rates elsewhere to be able to price higher risk areas without changing their average across the state. Casey says in early 2024, Farmer Center letter informing her that her premiums would soon go from $800 a year to $8,000 a year. And people in Paradise of course understood that their premiums couldn't stay the same level as before the fires, but she says increases of this magnitude didn't make sense to her, especially given how they rebuilt in such a fire conscious way. Casey's house was the literal model of fire safe construction. And so I sat down with farmers and was like, okay, you got to do something for me because I can afford this. So can I just like have the tiniest, tiniest little coverage? Really nothing? And honestly, if I hadn't had a mortgage at that time, I would have just said forget it. I'll take no insurance. Casey also ends up on the fair plan, which remember only really covers fire. She needs an additional policy to cover everything else. And in total, she's still paying $7,000. And she says that in the months that followed, this wave of non-renewals only seemed to be getting worse in communities all around the state. The fair plan, which was started as a last resort, is getting inundated with all these new people who were forced out of the private market. Regulators are warning that eventually it could become financially unsustainable. One night, Casey goes to a meeting to hear about strategies from a consumer advocacy group trying to get homeowners to get off the fair plan and get private insurers to take them back. Low and behold, they throw a picture of my house up on the screen and they're like, so we're encouraging homeowners to become IBHS-YL fire-prepared, certified. Insurance companies are asking you to do this, and then we'll get you off the fair plan. I raise my hand and I'm like, so that's my house on the screen right there. I've done all the things and I'm on the fair plan at $7,000. And everybody's like, right? And then she's like, wait a second. And there's all this like hubbub. I feel like terrible about it. But then it's like, no, this is important. This is a disaster, right? Like this insurance is a disaster. All the things insurance companies are asking us to do. We're doing. They're still not covering us. So something has to give here. The scale of this crisis was clear. Things had gone to the point where even the poster house for the insurance industry's own building standards could not find a place in the private insurance market. After the break, the people of paradise try to bring this fight to the insurance executives themselves. A visited paradise in part because it's already experienced the consequences of a changing climate firsthand. But really, I went because the town feels like it's a few years ahead of the rest of the country, living on the frontier of this new crisis over how to ensure an ever more catastrophic world. And one of the people who spent the last few years trying to help solve that crisis is someone named Jenny Goodlin. I almost felt like a duty in a sense to return and help. Jenny grew up in paradise. After being away for more than a decade, she decided to move back after the fire to help rebuild the town. She got a job running a non-profit called Appropriately, the Rebuild Paradise Foundation. And pretty soon, she started hearing about this wave of dropped home insurance policies and spiking premiums that had hit people like Heidi Lang and Don Foster and Casey Taylor. I like started hearing these crazy numbers. Like, my policy went from 1500 to 15,000. I'm like, what? And then it happened to me. My policy went from 3500 to 12,000 in one year in a brand new house. Wow. Jenny started hearing from real estate agents around town that their home sales were falling through in the middle of escrow. When buyers found out they likely couldn't get private insurance. I started to see the enormity of the insurance crisis for our recovery. Like, if people can't move here and stay here, which was what was starting to happen, how are we going to keep growing? And if we can't grow, how do we get businesses here? And if we can't get businesses and homeowners here, how's the tax base for the town going to grow? Like, this is our biggest hurdle. So Jenny starts looking into every discount insurers offer for home hardening and wildfire mitigation, which in theory should be substantial. But also one of the big takeaways from wildfire research over the last two decades is that an individual homeowner can do almost everything to fortify their house against fire. They can use the right building materials, maintain five feet of empty, defensible space around the house. But if their neighbors don't do that stuff as well, their home is still at risk of burning down. Hardening houses against wildfire is a collective action problem. So I called my agent. She said, if you are a firewise community, you get a small discount. And I said, okay, how do you do that? And I figured it out. Firewise is another voluntary certification program that tries to incentivize groups of neighbors to do fire mitigation tasks together, like clearing brush or trimming trees. In theory, there could be both the carrot of getting small discounts from some insurers and the stick of being judged by your more fire conscious neighbors, the power of pure pressure. Not too long after Jenny starts the first fire wise community in paradise in 2022, Heidi Lang, who lives a few blocks away with her feather
footed chickens starts a second one. Others followed. Now, starting fire-wise communities and making home improvements that reduce the likelihood of your house burning down clearly has some value. But Jenny says she soon discovered it wasn't clear these things would necessarily translate into significant insurance discounts. Some are a 1% discount, some are 10%. It was just all over the place. So there's no consistency to even tell a homeowner do this and this happens. The best we could say was do this and hopefully it will pay off. And Don Foster, the local insurance agent in Paradise agrees. She says the discounts and insurance premiums have not come anywhere close to offsetting the costs. I have not seen one carrier give higher than a 5% discount for hardening your home. So I have clients that spent upwards to $17,000 because their home survived and they wanted to keep their carrier. And do all of these changes to their home, replace their siding with cement board, everything. 17 grand to get a $42 discount off of their policy. It seems like it then it's not really incentivizing you to harden your home. Not at all. Not at all. Jenny says despite everything she was doing, everything the town was doing, more and more people in Paradise were still getting kicked off or priced out of the private insurance market. What kind of sense were you making of that? I wasn't. I felt like I was a crazy person. I did. I was like, I'm a crazy person. Honestly, like, are we just doomed? Some people were opting for the fair plan. Some were opting to go completely without insurance. And Jenny says her frustration finally came to a head during a virtual meeting with insurance consumer advocates in the summer of 2024. A couple of reps from an insurance company called Mercury were on the call talking about the home hardening techniques homeowners should do to get coverage. I felt inside my blood boiling. And they allowed me to speak. And I had a very concise message to give this insurance company. And I told them we are doing everything we are being told to do. Yet here we are not insurable in your regard. Underneath her frustration, Jenny says she was trying to give voice to this even bigger question with implications way beyond paradise, for all the other places around the country facing retreating insurance markets. If you're the burnt downtown that reconstructed to fire safety and did everything right and you can't change insurance, why would anyone else change their way of living? If the place that is actually doing everything the insurance industry seems to be wanting them to do, still can't get insurance. Then who can? Then who can? Yeah, that's the question. One of the Mercury insurance reps from the meeting asks to chat with Jenny offline. They get on a call about a month later. And so she's like, what do you want from us? I said, I just want you to come here. I just want you to come see. Yeah. That's what I want. And to Jenny's surprise, they agree to visit paradise. A few months later, Jenny gets ready to host a group of Mercury insurance executives to show them everything that paradise has been up to when it comes to wildfire safety that they've somehow missed from their proverbial 30,000 foot perspective. I just wanted them to see. I kind of wanted to understand. I wore my best pants. If there's any day to do it, Jenny plans to give them a little driving tour around paradise. We met at the Starbucks, which I always take people to. And they're like, Oh, our president's coming. He's on his way. I'm like, Oh, wow, like, I'm going to get the president of Mercury. Okay. Here I am in my, you know, nice pants, my nice pants, thankfully, but the president of the insurance company is coming. Yes. Well, the president arrives and Jenny takes them on the driving tour to show off all the new wildfire informed construction around town. And as we're driving Victor Joseph, the president, he's like, I'll ensure that house and that house he had to stop the car. He got out of the car. He's like, look at this house. There's like nothing around it. It's got a metal gate driving around. The president saw something the company seemed not to fully understand and the fog of the insurance industries actuarial abstractions. Even though paradise still sits in what seemed a very high risk area, the town has taken the industry's recommendations almost as far as you could imagine. Finally, they stop in front of Casey Taylor's house, the so called first IBS wildfire prepared house in the universe. You know, we made our way over to Casey's house. He gets out of the car and he's like, how much is she paying? And I'm like, like $5,000 and she's little house. And he's like, what the heck? He's like, give me her information right now. Casey gets a call later that day. It was Jen saying, I just took them all, you know, did the tour. And we went by your house in Mercury's like, we'll, we'll write that policy right now. And like, great. It took a little while, but she eventually got the news from Mercury that her rate would be going back down to $800. And not too long after Mercury's visit to Paradise, Jenny's mission to get private insurers to reward all the town's efforts got a big boost. The state of California announced a new deal with the state's private insurers to try and fix one of the big regulatory problems that's been exacerbating this insurance crisis. They're going to allow insurance companies to use those future looking climate models to calculate premiums and argue for charging higher rates. In exchange, those companies would have to start writing new policies in wildfire prone areas in order to take some of the weight off of California's fair plan. Around the time of that deal, Mercury announced they were going to be the first major insurer to start writing new policies in Paradise since the campfire, starting with a couple hundred people who'd hardened their homes. Heidi Lang, who got priced out of her private insurance plan three years ago, says she did see the news as a hopeful development, though she herself didn't put her name in the hat. She says, as a member of the town council, she didn't want to get any special treatment. Because it felt like exclusive or like getting an inside seat on one of the Titanic lifeboats or something. Yeah, that's a good way of putting it, yeah. And Heidi says, given the fact that there are 10,000 people in Paradise, this first little glint of the private market returning still feels far away from a real solution to the problem, which gets us back to the big question on a lot of people's minds these days. As the world gets warmer and warmer and climate-fueled catastrophes become more frequent and more destructive, will there come a day when some places become so risky and so expensive that the insurance math simply stops mathing? I put that question to environmental economist Judd Boomhauer. Yeah, a lot of people ask, "Is the future uninsurable?" And I'm pretty sure that the answer to that is no, but that we are going to have to solve a bunch of really important problems. In some ways, you can think of the story of Paradise not just as a cautionary tale, but also potentially as a glimpse into what it might take to keep living in places made riskier by climate change. It might take redesigning regulations and building codes. It might take following things like IBHS's standards in order to get coverage at all. And even with all that, some places may eventually become too risky and expensive for many people to afford. And for those of us living along the coast or near the forest, it may mean coming to terms with this new financial reality. One sign that the market has healed will be higher prices. This is the new normal of insurance pricing. It is going to be more expensive to have homeowner's insurance because we're living in a riskier world. It's just become riskier. And it's also that's affecting a lot of people in the US, in Canada, in France, in Spain, in Greece, in Australia, and scale at which these losses are starting to increase is honestly pretty scary. And I am an optimist that we're going to find ways to respond. They're going to manage this risk going forward, but it's a real thing. Jenny Goodland for her part says her experience with Mercury gave her enough momentum to start to convince executives from other insurers to come tour the town with her, including AAA and Capital Insurance Group and Travelers Insurance. She says a few of those companies have since started writing a handful of new policies. And earlier this year, Mercury Insurance made a new position for Jenny herself, basically to work with other communities around the state to help them mitigate wildfires and get back onto private insurance. She's hoping she can do one policy at a time, what she was able to do for her friend, Casey Taylor. Casey told me that after years of anxiety and struggle over insurance and paradise, what finally brought the first glimpse of the market back was someone from an insurance company actually seeing all the work that was happening on the ground. It was super easy and fabulous and a miracle. The miracle of insurance. Yes, I know. You know, I always go back to any time we're talking about insurance. It must have been in December where we were talking about what we were grateful for, because Christmas was coming. It was going to be hard. Casey runs a charter school in paradise. She says about a month after the fire, she and some fourth grade students were writing down on post-it notes. Some of the things they were grateful for. And it was things like, I'm thankful that my pets got out alive. I'm thankful that we had a place to stay. I'm thankful that I had some of my toys. But then there were a number of post-it notes that said, I'm grateful for insurance. And this is little fourth graders. These kids hearing all this conversation about insurance and how blessed they were to actually have insurance. So when you say the miracle of insurance,
insurance, it was the miracle of insurance, and then insurance almost wrecked the rebuilding of paradise. Just in case you missed it, we did another story last week about how the insurance industry is responding to the growing threat of climate disaster. For that episode, we go inside the Destruction Laboratory in South Carolina where research scientists light houses on fire, help them with hail, and blow them apart with artificial hurricanes. That's how they create these new certifications and building standards in the first place. If you haven't heard it yet, it's in the feed now, go and check it out, make it part of a planet money banish. This episode was produced by Vito Emanuel and edited by Jess Zhang. It was engineered by Travis Hagen and fact-checked by Sierra Huatas. Alex Goldmark has our executive producer. Well thanks to Amy Balk and Ryan Oliate, I'm Alexi Horowitz-Gazzy. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Rising wildfire frequency and severity due to climate change are driving massive insurance losses, forcing insurers to cancel or drastically raise premiums in high-risk areas like Paradise, California.
Traditional insurance models, which rely on spreading risk across populations, are breaking down as climate disasters create correlated losses that insurers cannot financially absorb.
Regulatory limits on rate increases—particularly the 7% cap in California—have prevented insurers from adjusting premiums to reflect rising risk, while insurers are blocked from using climate models to project future losses.
Homeowners in fire-prone areas are increasingly turning to the state’s “Fair Plan” as a last resort, though it offers limited coverage and is financially strained by growing demand.
Despite widespread adoption of fire-resistant building standards like IBHS certification, homeowners receive minimal insurance discounts, making mitigation efforts financially unviable.
Communities like Paradise are now forming “firewise” groups to collectively reduce risk, but these efforts fail to translate into meaningful premium reductions or private insurance renewals.
Insurance executives’ visits to communities like Paradise—after seeing firsthand fire-safe rebuilding—have led to renewed policy offers and a tentative return of private coverage.
The long-term future of insurance in climate-vulnerable regions remains uncertain, with some areas potentially becoming too expensive to insulate, raising the question of whether certain places will become uninsurable.
Summary:
S. insurance industry driven by climate change. Once a stable, low-cost system, homeownership insurance is now failing in fire-prone regions due to escalating wildfire frequency and severity.
Insurance companies, constrained by regulatory limits and unable to use climate models to project losses, are either canceling policies or raising premiums by hundreds of percent—sometimes from $1,000 to nearly $10,000 annually. Homeowners respond by seeking the state’s Fair Plan, a government-backed safety net that offers only limited coverage and is rapidly overwhelmed. Despite widespread adoption of fire-resistant building standards such as those promoted by the Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety (IBHS), premiums remain exorbitantly high, and insurers offer minimal discounts.
Community-led efforts like “firewise” initiatives fall short of creating financial relief. A turning point comes when insurance executives, after visiting Paradise and seeing its fire-safe rebuilding, begin to offer new policies—particularly to homes that meet strict safety standards. This signals a potential shift in how insurers respond to climate risk, though it remains a fragile and localized solution.
Ultimately, the crisis exposes a deeper systemic failure: as climate disasters grow in scale and frequency, the traditional insurance model—built on risk diversification—may no longer be sustainable, raising urgent questions about whether certain communities will become too costly to live in or insure at all. The future of insurance in the face of climate change may depend on regulatory reform, more accurate risk modeling, and a rethinking of how risk is priced and shared across communities.
FAQs
Her insurer identified piles of old wood chips in her yard as a fire hazard, though the debris had been removed years earlier and was not a current risk.
It's a state-mandated insurance program for people left without coverage by private insurers, created in the 1960s to address insurance redlining in vulnerable communities.
More frequent and severe wildfires, hurricanes, and hailstorms have increased risks, leading to higher claims and financial strain, making traditional insurance models unsustainable.
Insurers face massive losses from climate disasters and can't raise premiums enough due to regulatory limits, forcing them to either cancel policies or charge exorbitant rates.
Yes, but the discounts are minimal—often less than 10%—and do not offset the high costs of fire-resistant construction or the overall financial pressure on insurers.
It uses simulations to predict future wildfire risks based on climate data, helping insurers set more accurate premiums—but this has been restricted in some states for years.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.