Go back

Are We in an A.I. Bubble? We're About to Find Out.

54m 21s

Are We in an A.I. Bubble? We're About to Find Out.

Anthropic’s impending IPO represents a turning point in the AI era, offering the first transparent view of a large language model company’s financials and risks. While the company reported an $80 billion net loss due to accounting practices, its operating losses have significantly decreased, signaling improved business health. However, demand growth is slowing in key markets due to competition from OpenAI and open-source models, raising questions about the sustainability of AI-driven economic expansion. The S1 filing includes a strikingly detailed 93-page risk section, highlighting existential threats, AI safety concerns, and even the philosophical idea that AI models may be sentient—reflecting the company’s deep-rooted commitment to AI safety. This philosophical undercurrent is mirrored in its governance structure, where founders retain extensive control and have a secret succession plan, suggesting long-term dominance. The IPO will test whether AI hype can translate into real economic value, with Wall Street evaluating whether the multi-trillion-dollar valuation is justified. Investors are now seeking new growth narratives beyond coding tools, such as AI in healthcare and legal services. Meanwhile, public sentiment around AI and data centers is growing, but remains largely fragmented, with limited impact on elections. The broader tech industry is also facing systemic vulnerabilities, including a major PHP security flaw and internal breaches at Anthropic, exposing weak defenses despite its AI leadership. These events suggest a period of reckoning: AI’s promise may be real, but its risks, governance, and economic viability remain deeply unresolved.

Transcription

10704 Words, 58260 Characters

English
In a few weeks, we're finally going to get some answers on whether we're in an AI bubble. That's because the Frontier Lab and Thropic is going public. And Thropic gets ready to make its Wall Street debut as the AI giant. AI giant and Thropic. That's the company's. It might raise $100 billion at a $2 trillion valuation and rescue a whole slew of companies floundering in the dead market, or it might raise a lot less and send the entire stock market into a tailspin. We just to say, a lot is riding on this IPO. The near future of the American economy, the medium future of the tech industry, and given that the risk factors in Anthropics S1 include catastrophic and existential risk to humanity, maybe even the long-term future of the human race. At a minimum, the Anthropic IPO will mark the end of an era. The venture investment driven, hype accumulating start-up phase of the AI century is nearing completion. But what comes next? In today's episode, we're going to try to wrap our minds around the most important company in the economy, at least for now, and look at what's at stake in its big moment. Are we in a boom or a bubble? Will tech's big bet on data centers work out or fizzle? And can Silicon Valley's most militant AI believers be a normal public company? Or are we entering a new era of AI hype, mysticism? I'm Max Reed. This is Hard Fork. We are live in studio with Aaron Griffith. OK, that's a really good start. We are here in studio with Aaron Griffith. It's so good to see you in person. Yeah, likewise. There are two big developments in the Hard Fork universe this week. First is that you finally followed me on Instagram. Oh, yeah. We can get to that later, maybe in the second big. Yeah, I was on the fence. Yeah. Well, there's a lot of referendums that we're going to talk about today. I think that was an important one. The second thing I want to talk about is that Anthropic announced its Intentical Public, which means the rubber is finally heating the road after however many years it's been of hype and doom-saying, an argument you have been reporting on Anthropic and the AI world for a long time. I wanted to pick your brain about this company today because this feels like a huge inflection point for AI, for tech, for the stock market, the economy, humanity. Yeah, the stakes are only that high. Yeah, exactly. So what is riding on this? I mean, everything. Everything. I think that was our headline was nearly everything. Practically speaking, this is the first pure play like LLM, large language model company to go public, to open its book so we can actually look at the underlying business of this AI boom that has been going on for four years and attracted trillions of dollars and investment and sort of reoriented our entire economy around itself. And Anthropic alongside OpenAI and arguably Gemini from Google are kind of the companies that are driving this. They're like the pillars that are you could call that. I've heard many metaphors. You could call them the the bottom piece of the Jenga tower. I've heard them described as like the tip of a pyramid with like a bunch an entire ecosystem of companies supporting it. But either way, like they are sort of the quintessential AI companies. And now for the first time, we have kind of a look at the underlying business model that so much money has gone into. So are the investors you talking to? Are they nervous about the IPO or they worried about what might come out of it? Well, I mean, last week they were definitely nervous. Yeah. Now we've had a day or two to kind of look at these numbers and see. And some of them have leaked already along the way. So we had kind of a sense. But this is the first time we see like in a 300 plus page document, the full picture of what Anthropics business looks like. So let's go there. What are the sort of big important things that we can take away from the S1? Okay. Well, first of all, I guess it's okay to say that business looks kind of healthy. I mean, it's arguable. There are people that have, you know, made the case that it's not. But I think like generally speaking, people have been kind of pleasantly surprised to see that this company is capable of making money. And I mean, when we've seen how much money these companies have raised over the years, we've seen how much they've been spending to build their AI products. I think the general consensus has been like these companies can never make money. And just to be clear, Anthropic posted an $80 billion net loss. So maybe let me unpack that a little bit. An $80 billion net loss seems insane. But it's actually kind of a weird accounting quirk where they have to count some convertible debt that they issued to some of their shareholders as a net loss. And that will essentially be cleared in the next quarter or then ever by the time they go public. And so that's not a reflection of their health of their actual business. What we've actually seen is that they, in the first half of this year, had an operating loss of around six to $700 million. And that's shrinking from the same period last year, where it was like over $2 billion. So they're shrinking their losses of the actual business that they're operating on the flip side. They are still showing out enormous sums of money. And they're on the hook for enormous sums of money to build out their AI infrastructure. So this is the data centers, the chips, the compute power, the very, very expensive stuff that they need to keep training new models and to support the old models. So it's kind of, and Dario has talked about how the company is sometimes on a knife's edge when it's making these decisions and signing these deals. And so they have signed so many contracts in anticipation of the demand. And it's like a very high risk game. If the demand's not there, then they're going to be sitting on all these contracts. And some of many of them are non-cancellable. If the demand is there and they don't have enough, then they're going to be losing business. And so that's kind of what's like underlying all of this is like how much AI are businesses and people going to be using. And has the company, you know, basically laid the groundwork for that? Right. I mean, it's interesting because on the one hand, the S1 seems to confirm that there's an enormous amount of demand. I mean, we're talking about $16.3 billion in revenue for the first half of 2026. And that is an enormous amount of growth, too. Like, you know, we're seeing a company grow 14X. I mean, that is insane, especially for a company of this size. So we've never, I mean, I hate to like, say, unprecedented, but it feels like we haven't seen a company growing like this ever before. Right. So we can say there's demand for this, right? But with a question that you're saying is we don't actually know how much it is. And it might be that there's more even than we've already seen. It might be that there's actually less. But we're building a certain number of computers. I mean, to be very simple about it, no matter what. Building a computer. We're building a lot of computers out there in the desert. And anthropic has committed a ton of money to those computers. And so is that the biggest risk they're facing? Definitely. I mean, this is, I think, what everyone's looking for. And so the S one that we saw did not have Q three numbers in it. And they've already kind of previewed those numbers to their investors. And our reporting and others have shown that the growth is actually slowing in the third quarter. And that's because first half of the year, Claude code just was growing like crazy. They basically took the entire industry by storm and everybody is using their coding product. Now competitors like OpenAI are starting to catch up. Companies are trying to pull back on how much they're spending on tokens because they realize that token maxing got out of control. And so the growth is a little bit slowing. And they're getting some competition from open source models or cheaper options. And so I think in Q three, they grew 44%. And so that's pretty significant slowdown from again, gangbusters growth down to like just just great growth. But is that going to continue on that trajectory? In that case, okay, the growth story isn't like as exciting. And perhaps demand isn't going to be through the roof forever. So that's one question investors are looking at. And I think just in general, they're looking to see how in topic explains that slowdown. Because if anthropic just comes in and says like the whole market is pulling back, that's very, very bad for this whole ecosystem, the Djenga tower or the pyramid that I'm talking about for like all the demand and all the investments that everybody is making, all the debt that everyone's taking out to build the stuff out. The reason that the growth is slowing is just because of competition because open AI or open source companies, you know, companies are kind of eating market share, but the demand is still growing. Then like great party on the AI, you know, boom continues to boom. So they're looking for new avenues for growth potentially. They're trying to sell different stories about what the next big product is. Yeah. And I think we're going to see this on the road. So I'll be watching that pretty closely. I think that's going to kick off in probably a week or so before you start, what is a road show? So in a week or so, anthropic is going to basically go on this tour where they meet with all the public market investors and kind of tell their story and they call that a road show bankers, like kind of take them around on a little private jet and they're, you know, meeting with like insurance companies in Iowa or whatever and telling them about the machine God. So that's going to be just like kind of amusing on its own. But you know, they need to tell I think a new growth story because they're going to say, okay, we had this like coding product that's incredible, but like it's already kind of slowing down in growth. What's our next growth story? Well, they believe that AI is going to, you know, solve many, many, many problems in the world. And so one of the stories that they're pitching to investors now is this bio thing, you know, AI is going to cure cancer, like AI is going to develop new drugs. So that's like a big story. They're going to probably be pitching. And then they have other products to like, you know, legal tech or like other other ways that AI is going to kind of disrupt the economy beyond just coding, which has been again, like a blockbuster hit for them. Right. One thing I want to talk about with the S1 is the 93 page risk factor section. So you've read a lot of best ones before. Are they every word of everyone just to be clear? Obviously, your capacity as a reporter. Are they usually 90 pages long? I mean, they're usually pretty long. And it's a lot of legal ease. It's just like a lot of ask covering, basically. I mean, it's like it's basically anticipating all the potential things that shareholders could get mad and sue over and saying, we warned you. Right. Exactly. And there's a lot of those for anthropic. I'm just going to read to a couple of them right now. >> They're very unique in their specificity, let's just say. >> Yeah, and I would say too, it's funny reading them if you've been following AI for a while. It's kind of like getting six years of Twitter and blog posts and sub-stack, like compressed into like a document of legal ease. Because they're listing everything from, you know, the resource constraints on building out compute to the various sort of AI safety problems, to just sort of like your basic business problems with, you know, customer satisfaction. But the ones that caught my eye, for example, are concerns have been raised both within our organization and by other researchers that sufficiently advanced AI systems could, if not developed, deployed and operated with appropriate safeguards, oversight and security measures, pose catastrophic or existential risks to humanity. This is a pretty rare kind of thing to do. Another one that I was really, it was really best. >> But wait, can we just go back to that really quick, though, because one thing that the great Matt Levina, Bloomberg pointed out was that this is written in passive voice. It's not anthropic saying we think that our products, it says like some people may be saying. >> Within our organization, some people, I mean, I don't know if it's our founder and president Dario Amade or anybody, but some people have raised this question. >> Who could it be? >> Yeah, another one that I like is, in addition, considerations relating to model safety, interpretability, alignment and welfare may lead us to limit or delay the deprecation of older models. So just to translate that a little bit, when they're talking about model welfare, they think the models might be alive and they're not ever gonna shut down some of the product lines because they want to make sure they get taken care of. >> I miss this one. >> Yeah, I have to credit Joe Weisenthal at Bloomberg for picking this one up. They're not saying this out loud, but they're saying consider relations relating to welfare may lead us to limit or delay the deprecation of older models. This is a little like Apple saying the iPhone 12 is alive, so we're just gonna keep making it forever. >> Oh my God, imagine trying to explain that to some analyst at Goldman Sachs and be like, we need to put this in here. >> I mean, the thing that I wonder about a lot is how much people who are spending their time talking to chatbots all day start to buy into and belong to this stuff. And so you actually will have activist investors who are saying, we have to make sure that we're taking care of model welfare and whatever else. This is a future coming soon. >> Well, the activist investors won't have a whole lot of ability to do much because of the governance of the company. >> I actually want to get into this. But let's start before we get there. Let's start with just a quick word about the founders because this is a company that has a really specific philosophy around AI risk and AI safety that's sort of the core, not just the core of the business, but it's kind of their origin story. I'm sure a lot of people are familiar, but will you just give us the 22nd version of where Anthropic comes from? >> Sure, and this is kind of the story of AI. Also, Google's working on AI, Elon Musk and Sam Altman see it and they're like, man, I don't think they care enough about the future of humanity, so they split off and start open AI and they're like, we're going to build AI, but we're going to do it for the good of humanity. We're the principal at once. And then within open AI, Dario and all of his friends are looking around and saying, wait, Sam, doesn't care enough about the future of humanity. We need to build the safe AI before they can. So they split off and do that. And that has kind of continued on down the line. So that's where Anthropic is. Their roots are truly in like AI safety. And they are probably most extreme on that spectrum of their fears inside the company at the top of the company and around it. >> Well, let's talk about how this relates to governance 'cause they have this very unique governance structure. >> I'm like losing my voice now. And hopefully they can use some AI to make my voice sound less gravely. Yeah, so Anthropic is kind of following a trend that has been happening for the last 15 years at tech companies, which is that founders want to retain control even while selling shares, which would in general, the classic form of governance means that if you sell shares, those shareholders get more control. This started kind of goes back to Mark Zuckerberg and his multiple class of shares. But Anthropic has taken it even a little bit further. They have five classes of stock. Their seven founders have 50.1% voting share. They're going to be in charge of electing all the directors to the board. And then they also have this independent trust that controls the majority of the board seats. And so it's a little bit convoluted. And I think no one's gonna push back on this because over the years, every time startups have tried to do this, investors have made a big stink about it. Like, oh no, we hate this. And then they just go along with it anyways. And so it hasn't, yeah, there has not been a line in the sand. Even with SpaceX, they were a little bit more extreme about that some of the exchange or some of the indexes tried to put their foot down. And then at the end of the day, they're just like, I have fine. - So this is not necessarily new in Silicon Valley, but it is for Anthropic seems to be distinctly sort of connected to the AI safety philosophy at the heart. Which you should say, I'm not sure we said it out loud, but like really specifically, Anthropic is the company that believes most strongly in the possibility of total AI annihilation, Armageddon. And additionally believes most strongly in the possibility that the LLMs are alive or conscious or sentient in some way. - Yes, and they lay out that they believe their founders are best suited to sort of shepherd this into the world in a way that is a little self-aggrandizing when I was reading and I was like, wow, you guys are special. And I guess you are because you're at the helm of a potentially two trillion dollar company, but they are even able to name their successors. They have a secret list of successors that they all have to approve if somebody leaves the board. And so they're setting this up to be in control of it forever. They don't want to lose control of the AI or of the company. - Yeah, I want to return to the philosophy, the sort of question of the philosophy because one of the questions I have about Anthropic is beyond this governance structure here. To what extent are their philosophical commitments around AI safety? Like how do they inform the company itself or inform the business decisions or do they? - Well, I think in the beginning, it was a huge piece of the company because it was the only place where they could get money. Regular Silicon Valley investors were kind of the company as a science project for the first couple of years and the only place that they could find money was from people like San Beckman-Freed, Yon Talon. People who were deeply enmeshed in the EA kind of philosophy in that world. And then their first product was very specifically and purposefully like an enterprise business product. They weren't building something for consumers. They weren't trying to build an AI companion necessarily. And that has proven to be an incredible business. And then when the VCs got word of that, they were like, "Oh, great, let's dump all the money in." And most of those VCs that came in later are looking at this as an enterprise software SaaS business and they're not really that hung up on the philosophy. They're like, "Yeah, we like that. We're back in the good guys, the good guys." But they don't really like buy into this sort of stuff that's a little bit more weird about that. - The woo woo stuff. - Yeah, I mean, is there a word for like AI woo woo? - No, I don't think there is. - What's your problem with the one? - I can feel a hard forcing in terms of that. - Yeah, exactly. I mean, it's very interesting because you could look at all the decisions that they've made from the governance structure on down to like the specific things that they're doing. And you could tell a story where it's all about their philosophy, it's all about their fear of AI or their belief in AI. But you can also tell a story that this is just a very straightforward, smart Silicon Valley company that wants founders want to retain control. It wants to be very efficient. It wants to clear path to profitability through, you know, enterprise sales and not trying to become the next Facebook or whatever. And it seems like investors-- - And that's certainly what the investors that I talked to say. Like I remember when Jacob Cox and Quitt and everyone was kind of freaking out about like, "Hey, I was gonna kill us all." I'm mentioning this to some of their investors and then sort of being like, oh yeah, you know, hacking, that's a big risk. We're definitely worried about cybersecurity but like I don't really know what you're talking about on the other stuff, like we're not worried about that. - Let's zoom out a little bit. So, you know, this feels as we were saying before like an inflection point. Like we've spent the last half decade in this, in this big time hype moment, VCs, executives, researchers are selling this crazy story of a technology that's gonna change everything. Now we have a big document with a lot of real numbers in it and pretty soon we're gonna know what the stock price of Anthropic is. So, how would you characterize this? What is happening right now with the IPO? What questions are being asked and what questions are being answered? - I mean, it is sort of like a demystifying moment because we have, you know, seen these companies in the private market get these trillion dollar valuations in such a short time and it's kind of being set by like a handful of VCs, right? And so, like, yes, VCs believe in this company but they also believed in the metaverse and like a lot of crypto stuff and that has not worked out. And so, this will be the first time that we have like Wall Street and public market investors and you know, pension fund investor, all the professional money managers, like modeling out the financials of this company and deciding whether it's worth investing at a two trillion dollar valuation or maybe 1.5 trillion. And so, that's part of it is like we're actually going to see like some real evaluation of the company. Although, I guess you could also argue that Wall Street sometimes invests on Hype and Momentum 2 as we've seen in many stocks. So, like, who knows? But in general, this is like a time when we're finally getting like to look inside the business that's underlying the AI boom and decide whether or not it is, you know, a valuable contributor to our economy because there are a lot of people out there that I think it's not. - So, what are you looking for in the weeks after the IPO? - Whether or not AI kills us all. (laughing) Big question. Still on everyone's mind. You know, I doubt that that's going to be talked about too much on the road show. I mean, I'm sure that there are some advisors at Goldman and Morgan Stanley who have been telling Dario like let's reel it back on the old extinction talk. - Should I invest in a company that has a 10% chance of killing everybody? - I mean, it's in the risk factor. So, you can't say they didn't warn you. there was a Wall Street Journal headline arguing, the headline is the bull case for A or McGueddon, for investors mulling exactly. For investors mulling the anthropic share offering a 10% chance of extinction, maybe a 90% win for your portfolio. How can you argue with that, really? If you're gonna die, you're gonna die, but if you can become bigger in there, yeah, exactly. Aaron, thank you for coming into the studio and talking to you anthropic. We're gonna take a break and then we'll be back with Mike Isaac and Jasmine Sun to talk about the rest of the week's news in tech. (upbeat music) We're back with Aaron Griffith and joined by tech writers Mike Isaac and Jasmine Sun. Mike and Jasmine, we were just talking about the anthropic S1. Mike, what was your big takeaway from the filing? - I thought it was way front loaded with rosier sort of paintings of AI at the top compared to the past. Like, you guys tell me, but I feel like Dario Amadez painted as like the biggest doom and gloom guy of AI in the valley and my perception was everyone around and was like, hey, you need to like pump the brakes on this a little bit, especially as we're getting the average person or trying to get the average person excited about it. So like the whole top was like, hey, by the way, we do wanna cure cancer, we do wanna like create these amazing drugs. And then like, they back into, oh, it has like a 10% chance of blowing up the entire world, basically. But I don't know, someone told me to mjaz hands a little bit at the top, right? - Yeah, I mean, how much do you think it was like worked over? Like, I was interested that the adjective they use at the very top is, he says, we believe that AI is one of the most consequential technologies in human history, which is a very funny, neutral adjective, right? Consequential goes a lot of ways and it's not necessarily how I would be selling my product. - We should do like a real close reading of all the language in this, 'cause I do feel like, Dario's like definitely a micromanaging control, control enthusiast, let's say, and like every word probably has a few different nested meanings in there for sure. - Jasmine, what was your big takeaway from the S1 if you had one? - Yeah, I mean, kind of similar to what Mike said, I was just thinking about how Anthropic has a very odd relationship to money and being a for-profit company. Like the founders, when they broke off from open AI, they spent a bunch of time debating whether they should be a nonprofit or a for-profit. Of course, they have invented some crazy multi-layered governance structures as they all do, which is something they reinforce law in the letter that the founders have pledged 80% of their equity to charity, the employees have all this interesting matching. There's a famous culture fit interview that all of the Anthropic employees go through where they say, "Hey, would you work here if your equity went to zero?" And they make sure that everybody says yes before they accept the job. And so, mostly it just made me think about how weird they are about like the status of being a sort of profit-seeking corporation. - I know, I can only imagine what the meetings with the bankers were like, you know. I mean, I assume the meetings with the investors were very similar. - How do you tell a labor union that we're gonna be post money in like three hours? (laughing) I think that's hard, so. - This is coming, by the way, like in the midst of a little bit of anxiety, and let's call it a jittery moment in the market. The elections are next week, and I really want to talk to you guys about what we're looking at and what we're waiting to see. Jasmine, what are you tracking for the midterms next week? - Yeah, I mean, these are interesting midterms, 'cause I think it's the first election where people's feelings about AI, about data centers could plausibly have shown up. I mean, I think the top level on it is, even though we saw a lot of discourse, a lot of anger about data centers in particular that's been building up over the last year, I did some reporting on it over the summer in Wisconsin and Michigan, two states where data centers were actually a really big factor in the primaries in the majority of states. I don't think they are yet shifting people's votes. They're an 80/20 issue in the sense that people feel very negatively about data centers. People feel very negatively about AI. This is bipartisan, and in that sense, it seems like a unicorn, but it's also not something that is quite salient yet. I've looked at, you know, a million polls, and AI usually ranks like 22 out of 39 issues. - Oh my God. - It's like, even in states like Ohio or Pennsylvania where data centers are a big issue, I think it's usually something like between one or five percent of voters will list it as their number one thing. And so while we're seeing data centers really impact like your mayoral election, like we're seeing recall campaigns, city council reshuffles, I don't think like a big Senate race is gonna be determined by data center sentiment. - Right, it's like a mun-- I mean, this came across in the reporting you were doing that this is a really a municipal issue, and it's gonna get a lot of town managers voted out and council boards, select men or whatever else. But it's interesting because this was, at least in the summer, it felt like this was a focus of some Senate campaigns. Some Senate campaigns were, in fact, putting a lot of resources into being anti-data center. Do you think that was wasted money or is it just not ultimately the issue that matters? - I mean, I think it really depends. I think there are races where there's, they're close enough and rural voters in particular, you can get a lot of normal rural Republicans or low turnout voters to maybe turn out if there's a data center in their backyard. I think the races that people are really concerned about, Sherrod Brown and Ohio might stay to come back in particular because of data centers or a big motivation for Greg Abbott to restrict approvals and connections to the electricity grid, even though he's been very, very proud to build. He's been welcoming the data centers for years, but because of a potential threat from both his democratic opponent, plus all of these rural techs and farmers who are like, what's up with these power lines and data centers, he actually did a pseudo moratorium, which because he was worried about the midterm. So, I think there are a few elections in purplish states where data centers could swing things, but the other thing I'm tracking is like, data centers are very concrete, whereas AI generally is still feels so abstract to people that I'm not really sure if like, data centers are barely swinging some elections, I'm not sure that like AI in general is gonna be a voting issue yet, even though some people suspect it. - Yeah, I mean, it's a very funny, as you say, if you're on Twitter or if you're like reading too much about this, it does feel like a life or death issue. Certainly it is for some people writing, introductory letters to S1's, but as you say, it hasn't really trickled down, except in a sort of indirect way through the effect on the economy of AI. Mike, what about you? Are you tracking anything in the election next week? - You talked about this in last week's episode a little bit with the head of policy at MetaLeaving and sort of imagining which new regime of like, you know, democratic operatives, they might replace them with, but I just wanna see if they're-- - That's a list by the way. - No, of course, I am a loyal hard fork listener. - That's right. - That's what we're telling you, we got one. - You've got one. Let's get to two by the end of next week. - I'll get my wife to listen. I do, I really, really wanna see the theater of all the tech companies that have been trying to cater to Republicans, suddenly be like, actually we love the new democratic, potentially democratic regime in all of these states, and because they have a hold on, again, potentially have a hold on Congress, this is what we really believe in, you know? I think these swings are valuable because it sort of shows, you know, these are corporations that don't necessarily believe in anything except self-preservation a lot of the time. - Yeah, I mean, are you seeing any indications besides say, so we're talking about Joel Kaplan, who is the head of policy at Facebook, 15 years has been a sort of conservative whisperer. He announced his departure last week. Are you seeing any other kind of movements that suggest a little bit of, I don't know what, I don't know how to put it at team switching or sort of trying to make inroads among Democrats? - I think all of the companies are looking hard at their DC teams and saying, who do we need to sort of elevate and put out front? They're never gonna like cut all of their conservative, sort of, you know, relations, people or whatever, but it's sort of like, actually look at this guy, the guy who wears a blue pin instead of a red one or whatever. - That's like, that's all the companies and like, that's just the game, I guess I shouldn't be so cynical, but it is worth looking at and saying. - Why wouldn't you be saying it? - This seems like exactly the right thing to be cynical. And do you feel like there's a shift? I mean, I think we all are aware of what felt like, I'm sorry to use such immaterial language here, a vibe shift in Silicon Valley. - Vibes of somebody. - Is there a vibe shift swinging back? I mean, if any of you feel like that might happen or is this, was that the first five shift in illusion? - I mean, I've seen headlines to that effect, but I think like Mike said, it's gonna be a little bit more on the DC side of things, because I mean, just from my perspective, a lot of the VCs were really excited to be able to not care about stuff like that Democrats care about, like DEI. Culturally, it seems like we're kind of gonna be still in that vibe. - Yeah, it doesn't seem like that's changed. Jasmine, we were talking before we were taping about, like a sense that there's a question about how Republicans are gonna react to this. They're likely to lose the House of Representatives. There's gonna have to be a shift in how they approach AI regulation in Silicon Valley. - Totally. Yeah, I mean, this is one of the big open questions I have about the 2028 primary two. I mean, primary season's gonna start basically two weeks from now, and our JD VCs, and Marco Rubio going to break from Donald Trump's extremely, extremely unpopular positions on AI regulation and data centers, right? Like, in spite of the vast, like the majority of Republican voters do want to regulate AI. They would prefer slower with more safeguards versus some kind of abstract and material beach and narrative. And yet, basically, every Republican in Congress or every Republican leader has been unable to say any of that because the president sort of sets what the party line is. And if the Republicans think of beating in the midterms, I could imagine some more folks deciding to break off and say, like, actually, like our constituents are angry at data centers. They're worried about kids safety, if they're social conservatives. But I am starting to see a bit of a split in the Republican party between the more traditional libertarian, free market, letter-ip types who are still very excited about deregulation versus some of the more new right folks. I spent the weekend with some folks from American Compass, the new right think tank. And they are all thinking, actually, maybe after the midterms, this is a time for the Republican party to get serious about AI regulation on kids, jobs, safety, things like that. Were they saying AI or were they saying SI? It was actually really funny. It was, um, it was a chat and has workshop that there's a split in the room and then you could tell there's a bit of an internal tension between the folks from the admin and other places who were saying SI and the folks who were a little bit too staunchly, like, we're not caving to that. I've never seen a better metaphor for people talking over each other and not being able to communicate than not even being able to agree on what we're calling this thing. It was kind of amazing. Yeah. So one of the issues on the ballot next Tuesday is this tax in California on, uh, billionaires. Aaron, can you explain what the, what the, what the proposition is, what the measure is? And what, I mean, I think we can all guess, but why or silly, why are Silicon Valley so interested in this tax on billionaires? Yeah. I mean, it's, it's been actually pretty fascinating. Um, prop 40 is a proposed one time, uh, 5% billionaire tax on wealth, including unrealized gains, you know, that means like, you know, private startup stock for billionaires in California. And as you can imagine, um, the billionaires are a little bit mad about it. And so what better way to fight back than to use their vast wealth. And so they've gathered this group that we reported on building a better California has gathered $333 million, which is so, so, so much to fight a state proposition. Um, mostly from, you know, Sergey Brin, but then he brought in John Dorr and Patrick Collison, the founder of Stripe, John Dorr's, um, a very famous VC investor from Kleiner Perkins. And so and they have been over the last couple of months recruited this like kind of who's who of Silicon Valley, like very high powered famous VC's founders, many of whom are not even billionaires. Um, there's some like mere 100 millionaires and even billionaires. Yeah. Yeah. And, um, you know, aspiring billionaires, but they are, they're mad about this for a number of reasons. You know, they think it's poorly written that they don't believe that it's going to be a one-time tax. They don't like how the money's actually going to, like the money's not, you know, specifically earmarked well enough to do the things that they say they're going to do. And they don't trust, they basically just don't trust the politicians to do the right thing with it. And so they're really mad about it. And they don't like to press it in its sense because California is kind of known for, you know, as being a trendsetter. And so they're worried that it's going to turn into this cat and mouse game where other states are going to do it. And because a lot of them have already left the state, but they're mad about essentially the principle of it. The principle of the math. Yes. Yeah. They believe that, you know, this is going to hinder, um, aspiring billionaires, uh, founders, builders from moving to California and wanting to, um, you know, get rich. And so I think, you know, there's a lot of reasons that they're fighting it and they're all kind of like banding together and getting on these weekly calls and like talking about their strategy. And like one of the really interesting things that we found in our reporting was like, they are aware of how it looks. They, they, there's this quote in one of the documents that they're circulating to other donors that says billionaires are seen as having a net negative impact across issues. So they're not trying to be the face of this. They don't want to be out front. They're, they're not like, you know, talking publicly about this. Like they might, if there were some other, like, you know, any issue, like, including data centers, um, they are trying to go through other groups that they're partnering with, like, uh, plan parent head is a really big one that they're working with to kind of, um, that's opposed to it. Um, and so why, sorry, why is plan parent proposed to it? I mean, for some of the same reasons, it's not sustainable. This one time taxing is like supposed to make up for, um, some of the Trump administration cuts. And they don't believe that it's, you know, it's not setting them up in a position to like be sustainable going forward. So they just think it's poorly written. I think a lot of the people that are opposed to it are not opposed to the idea of a wealth tax, including actually some people that I spoke with for this story. They, um, they just think this is a crappy one. And they wish that it was better, like that, that it was just structured better and made more sense. But do you feel like they're always going to say that I feel like it's always a, well, this bill is poorly written. And if they could only legislate it better, I just feel like I've heard that from Andreessen or whoever a million times, you know what I'm saying? Totally. It's, I mean, it's, it's almost sort of like respectability politics where it's like, I like, I agree with your message, but I don't like how you're doing it. Yeah. I was interested to learn that about the about plan parenthood though, because I hadn't, I hadn't realized that this was more than just a, a cabal of billionaires plotting against it. No, there's like a bunch of, I mean, ever since I wrote this story weirdly, my phone has been blowing up with like, you know, political tax messages from different groups. And there's like a lot of healthcare groups that have lined up against it. That's interesting. Yeah. I mean, from a democratic point of view, this is a nonpartisan podcast, of course. From a democratic point of view, it's sort of nice to put one of these ballot measures on every year so that the billionaires all get distracted and focus on that instead of putting money around the country. The way you want muskets. That's pretty good game theory. Yeah, there you go. Feel free to call me, you know, Senate election committees. There's one other big thing I want to talk about today. And that is the, is what is being called Black October, the phone apocalypse, the PHP vulnerability discovered last week. Mike, I'm going to put you on the spot. Can you explain? Obviously, we all know what PHP is. We know what's going on, but for anybody who doesn't know of this stuff. Can you explain what happened last week and why it made everybody who works in information securities life hell for the, I mean, it continues to be hell. Well, look, look, I think the way I like to think about it is how the entire, let's say, internet and infrastructure that computers run on to this point is pretty Byzantine and built on a lot of old code that has, let's say a lot of holes and stuff in it, right? And that's, that's just the nature of computing. You figure out what are called bones vulnerabilities and you fix them over time. You know, Microsoft has dozens of fixes to their main software a year. Now it's ranging up into hundreds because AI is finding more of them. What happened though? Black October is not trying to get a Furby for your shopping for your kids. Like, come on. Was that on the spot? I'm going to do better. No, no, no, no. I hope it works. Shop that we're on squishies. We're on squishies now, Mike. It's dumplings squishies. I was working. My son did his, his birthday wish list this week and dumpling squishies. That's the big. I'm showing my lack of children on this podcast. But then you're seeing just showing brother. So it is, it is, it is essentially a vulnerability that goes far wider than just any one little system tweak that you have to update your individual software on. This is stuff that, you know, folks in the industry said could break the internet. It could like affect how we get on websites and use websites and have them be, have our accounts take it over. You know, it's like, it's much wider. My big takeaway is like, this is the type of stuff that's going to be much easier and more commonplace to find in the age of AI where you can have these programs just scrape the internet. And we should say specifically what we're talking. So PHP is a programming language that who that God, this is every time I start like this, I think about the, the dozens of men with huge beards that are going to be struggling and emailing me the meanest things. You see why I'm so smart enough for you, them or my friends. Like I'm thinking about specific people who are going to, who are going to be like texting me about how wrong PHP is a programming language that's used on a ton of different websites. Yeah. And it is, as Mike is saying, it's much easier to find vulnerabilities in these sort of infrastructural languages with AI, which can sort of run a bunch of different ideas and figure out what, you know, what the exact problems are. And when that happens, all of a sudden you have these really intense, really serious vulnerabilities that now need to be fixed, not from the top down, but across the bazillion websites. And so, you know, I don't want to make this podcast about me, but on one day last week, I do a daily logic puzzle called Clues by Sam. And Clues, I wasn't able to record my score that day because the, because Sam was fixing the PHP, like, the real victim. Well, you know, I'm just trying to bring this down to earth for everybody listening. So they really understand what's going on. I mean, imagine if you couldn't do your whirtle every day, that is what you need to be. Yeah, exactly. Um, I mean, are you talking to people? Are you guys talking to people who are, who are in the midst of this? What, like, I'm interested in, in, in, whether this is like, either from the perspective of cybersecurity people or from AI people in general, like, how much we think this is just a new normal, that every month is now just, you know, 85 hour weeks for people who work in security. And, uh, and all the AI companies throwing up their hands. and being like, we told you so. - I mean, I love to hear what you guys think, but I think the flip side or the counter argument, and this kind of happened in the open versus closed source debate a few weeks or months ago, was like, well, guess what? AI is also going to enable us to solve all these problems and to quickly defend against them and to fix them faster. And these vulnerabilities already existed. It was only a matter of time for someone to find them. So there are arguments from folks saying these fixes can happen. We just sort of need to enlist the advanced tools we have now to fix them faster rather than, you know, random websites across the internet not being able to do that in enough time. But like, I don't know, that feels a little rosy to me. I do feel like we're gonna just see this more often and the old internet breaking much faster than before is my point of view at least. - I mean, one of the crazier news stories from this week that I thought about was that startup cathedral made of ex-doge staffer. So our nation's best and brightest, literally hacking into anthropic Slack and IT systems. And anthropic is supposed to be the ones that are building the best cyber defense internal models that they can't even release to the public. And yet their own technical systems were not secure enough to be able to block this crew of like young startup guys from accessing trade secrets in their Slack. And so I don't even think, you know, before I would have thought, like, man, some, you know, municipal governments are gonna really struggle if they get hacked by some people with an open source model. But now it's actually like the best and most AI-flored companies in the world are also as vulnerable. So that's a great point. It's gonna be a very long few years, I think. I mean, I think the argument, I read a great piece that I want to recommend by Joshua Sachs, who's a former meta AI guy. And his argument is basically that we are as bad as it seems, we are still in a sort of defender's, a defender dominant window that even though there's all these vulnerabilities being discovered, it in fact, I mean, his point, which I admire because I think it's true, is that it takes cyber criminals actually a very long time to like figure out how to do their jobs because generally speaking, they're not that smart and they're not that competent at like running businesses. So we have a certain period where we can lock down defenses and prevent certainly on the level of cyber crime, protect against some of the worst vulnerabilities. But he says on the other hand, this is not a wholly positive story. We're still thinking about nation state actors that have the resources and the will and desire to, as Jasmine says, like hack into municipal government infrastructure and whatever else. So I suspect this is not the last time we're going to be talking about AI discover vulnerabilities on this podcast. Great. That's exactly. Go back to Hawaii Mike, that's where there's nothing left there. The last thing I want to talk about is the sort of, I felt like it flew under the radar amidst a bunch of other news this week. But Microsoft offered bio packages to 60,000 people. Aaron, what did you make of that? Well, I mean, that is an enormous number and when you put in perspective of the fact that Microsoft has like 230,000 employees, it just reminds you of how enormous these companies are. But just to be clear, bio packages doesn't mean 60,000 people are going to take them. They expect three to five percent of their employees to actually take them. So in reality, it's going to be like, at most probably 3,000 playoffs. But that's still so many. And I feel like to your point, Max, over the last three, four years, we've just become so numb to these rolling layoffs from the giant tech companies because that is just the new reality that started after the ZERP era kind of deflated all these tech companies that got super bloated because they thought they needed a million engineers decided, OK, now we're just going to be in this environment where we just cut 1,000 people every six months or something and tech used to be this cushy job, especially at a place like Microsoft, which is very geographically focused where you can just have a 30 year career. And there are a lot of people at companies like Microsoft, Amazon, even Google and Facebook, which are a little bit younger that have been there for so long. And that is no longer the case. That is maybe a sign of what's to come for the rest of the economy because tech is always a little bit out ahead on workplace trends as well. So that's a little bit depressing. And I guess the other thing that I'll add is something that it's kind of darkly funny about the announcement, which is that Microsoft said it was part of their efforts to give employees more control over their future. Oh, what the-- What the-- That's not the control I'm looking for. That's not the control I'm looking for. Really, really, really grim. The silver lining in there, I would say, as far as your harbinger of what's to come is like, a lot of this is because of their AI spin and infrastructure spin. And so perhaps, whatever, Accenture or some giant employer that's not spending billions of dollars per quarter on AI is not going to do the same level of layoffs. They're just going to use the tools to justify different types of layoffs in less than a number. Oh my god, my Accenture is the worst example because there's any company in the world that's going to be fully taken out by AI. It's consulting, right? Sorry, good lord. See, I'm going to get taken out by AI because I can't even think of a good company. No, actually, your mistake is that's what makes you human. That's what people love. I'm going to serve. OK, on that cheery bit of news, we're going to go to break. When we come back, we're going to be talking about stories that we're tracking this week. Welcome back, I'm with Aaron Jasmine and Mike. And we're going to be talking about stories that we're tracking this week. Mike, what story are you tracking this week? So this is kind of nerdy, but that's my thing. I found this memo from the VP and Distinguished Engineer at Amazon this week that most normal people are not tracking. But I think it's really interesting because it's essentially a very long manifesto on the use of AI among software engineers inside of the big companies. And what they essentially cop to is token maxing is kind of a terrible metric to measure how you're doing as an engineer. As is LOC lines of code, the amount of code you are contributing, building these products. Also a messy metric, which basically means you're larding up these systems with a bunch of stuff that someone's going to eventually have to delete. And so in this long memo, they essentially tell employees, look, what we care about are long term outcomes. This is like what really matters in the end and this is what we need to be judged by. The problem is, you can't really judge how long term outcomes on a quarterly basis when you're trying to figure out who should still be employed here. So I think after thousands of words, we end up kind of back where we started. And I'm very curious how they judge these engineers in the coming quarters. I mean, that's so interesting because I feel like when the token maxing trend started, everyone with any common sense was just kind of like, this seems absurd. Just spending as much money as possible to write as much code as possible, playing the volume game just obviously that's going to end badly. And we call it all new as a short term pump. And the token mining or whatever they call it, a token mining, the reverse of that trend happened so fast. At the time, we could barely get our first story up. It was already reversed. But it seems like they're still struggling to figure out where the balance is. Is that your upshot from this? Well, what better metaphor for the tech industry than spending billions of dollars to find out something is a terrible idea and ending up back where you started? They're in the arena trying things, Mike. Yeah, that's true. I am tired. This is, I have to say, you say this is nerdy, but this feels like the most relatable possible thing to me. Everybody has a job where they introduce a new metric and you know the metric's stupid. And you fulfill the metric and then your bosses are like, actually, we're going to do the opposite metric. And so you do that and you're like, this is still stupid. And then they're like, then they're sort of like, actually our metric is the long term health of the company and you're like, well, I'm still just going to do my job. And let me know. Max, you're self-employed. What are you talking about? You are your own boss. Well, I am also self-hating. So I think I can actually-- Jasmine, what are you tracking this week? Oh, man. I saw that this new research report that a team at Anthropic put out, they did a randomized controlled trial trying to understand how much experts defer to AI systems. So they basically gave a bunch of professional like statistical analysts access to AI's to give them advice on a decision in a scenario. And what they found was that not only did the experts, I think over 80% of the time make the same decision as the AI, which was split half half. They also over 70% of the time use the AI's arguments to justify their decision, but only 15% of the time did they say, oh yeah, I was influenced by the AI agent. And so we have this world, which I think is one that we're going to be in increasingly, where humans are oftentimes almost becoming rappers on AI agents and AI systems, where all we're doing is being the faces and typing the thoughts. And I feel like there's all this concern about AI takeover and rogue AI's, and I think that a lot of the times we're just going to let the AI takeover, because we'll just be out for a singular decision, and we won't even realize, so that's what I'm worried about. - That is a cheery thought, I mean, Somebody who professionally takes other people's opinions and repeats them as though they were my own. I do kind of sympathize. It's just usually the people I'm stealing from are people, not, you know, not artificial intelligence. I think so many people say that like, "A.I. makes everybody a manager. Like here we are." Yeah, exactly. That's exactly what this is. This is exactly what it meant for us to do. Wow. Aaron, what about you? What are you tracking? So I cover venture capital as, you know, and one of the most famous firms, injuries and Horowitz recently made a big change to the branding and the name of one of their sub-fons, which is their A16Z crypto fund. They're one of the biggest crypto boosters and have been for many years. But now they are going by A16Z frontier. And this was pretty notable to me. I mean, hard fork listeners might remember, Christix and their top crypto investor coming on for an interview a few years back, talking about, you know, the importance of the blockchain and crypto for the future of the internet. And so this would kind of make it look like they're backing away from that promise. And that's kind of a thing that happens in VC a lot where, you know, VC's chase trends and they change. And, you know, it's not just a trend chasing business. It's also a marketing business because all money is kind of the same. And so in order to stand out and get the entrepreneurs to come to you, you have to kind of put a stake in the ground and say, like, this is what we're interested in. And this is what we're really excited about for the future. And so they were really, really big bulls on crypto. And they, of course, despite the fact that crypto is super out of vote right now and that, like, you know, something like 80, 90% of all VC dollars are basically going to AI. They have, you know, been very careful to say, we're not backing away from crypto. We're just expanding our mandate. It's just all frontier now. Yes. And, like, this is something that other crypto funds have also been doing. They're not alone in this. There's a fund called Paradigm that, you know, was started by a Sequoia investor. In 2023, they very famously removed some of the crypto language from their website and people noticed and freaked out. I will say a big part of it is that there's probably just not that many people building crypto, investable crypto startups right now because everyone wants to build an AI. So it kind of is necessary, like, the crypto industries, like one of their many problems with crypto is that without the hype, without the number going up, there's just less people that are interested in, like, working in this industry and building on this industry. So, like, in order to find the opportunities to, like, deploy billions of dollars into startups, you have to kind of, like, change your mandate. Yeah. When, when crypto is two talks, like, even for Andrews and Harwitz, that's when you know the vibe is shifted. I mean, here at HardFork, we embrace our crypto-nominated bars. Right. That's right. Exactly. Our roots tend to block this. Oh, my God. We'll be sticking with this name forever. Oh, my God. We're the world. Wow. Well, guys, thank you for coming through. This has been a really fun discussion. I'm so glad to have you on. I hope you all come back soon. This has been Mike Isaac, Jasmine Son, Aaron Griffith. I'm Max Reed. Thank you for listening. This episode of HardFork was produced by Whitney Jones and Sawyer Roquet, and edited by Viren Povitch, with additional editorial support from Brendan Plinkenberg, Lisa Tobin, and Brooke Mentors. We were fact-checked by Will Peishel, and engineered by Daniel Ramirez, original music by Marion Luzano, Alyssa Moxley, and Dan Powell, an additional video production by Chris Schott. [Music]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Anthropic’s IPO marks a pivotal moment, offering the first public glimpse into the business model of a pure-play large language model company.
  2. Despite an $80 billion net loss due to accounting quirks, Anthropic’s operating losses are shrinking, indicating improving financial health.
  3. The company faces significant risks tied to AI demand, with growth slowing in Q3 due to competition and overinvestment in compute infrastructure.
  4. The S1 filing includes a detailed 93-page risk section highlighting existential AI risks, model welfare concerns, and philosophical anxieties about AI consciousness.
  5. Anthropic’s governance structure—featuring founder control and a unique trust—reflects deep philosophical commitments to AI safety, not just business strategy.
  6. The IPO will test whether AI hype translates into sustainable economic value, with Wall Street evaluating real financial performance amid speculative valuations.
  7. Investors are seeking new growth narratives beyond coding tools, such as AI in healthcare and legal tech, to justify long-term value.
  8. Public sentiment around AI, data centers, and regulation is still fragmented, with limited direct influence on elections despite growing public concern.

Summary:

Anthropic’s impending IPO represents a turning point in the AI era, offering the first transparent view of a large language model company’s financials and risks. While the company reported an $80 billion net loss due to accounting practices, its operating losses have significantly decreased, signaling improved business health. However, demand growth is slowing in key markets due to competition from OpenAI and open-source models, raising questions about the sustainability of AI-driven economic expansion.

The S1 filing includes a strikingly detailed 93-page risk section, highlighting existential threats, AI safety concerns, and even the philosophical idea that AI models may be sentient—reflecting the company’s deep-rooted commitment to AI safety. This philosophical undercurrent is mirrored in its governance structure, where founders retain extensive control and have a secret succession plan, suggesting long-term dominance. The IPO will test whether AI hype can translate into real economic value, with Wall Street evaluating whether the multi-trillion-dollar valuation is justified.

Investors are now seeking new growth narratives beyond coding tools, such as AI in healthcare and legal services. Meanwhile, public sentiment around AI and data centers is growing, but remains largely fragmented, with limited impact on elections. The broader tech industry is also facing systemic vulnerabilities, including a major PHP security flaw and internal breaches at Anthropic, exposing weak defenses despite its AI leadership.

These events suggest a period of reckoning: AI’s promise may be real, but its risks, governance, and economic viability remain deeply unresolved.

FAQs

Anthropic's IPO marks the first public debut of a pure-play large language model company, offering transparency into the business model behind the AI boom and signaling the end of the venture-driven, hype-heavy startup phase of the AI era.

While demand appears strong—shown by projected $16.3 billion in revenue for the first half of 2026—growth is slowing due to competition and over-spending on tokens. This suggests the market may be overheating, not necessarily in a bubble, but in a transition phase.

Anthropic reported an $80 billion net loss due to accounting treatment, but actual operating losses have shrunk from over $2 billion to $600–$700 million. This indicates improving financial health despite massive investments in compute infrastructure.

Anthropic has five classes of stock with founders holding 50.1% voting control and an independent trust managing majority board seats. This structure reflects a strong commitment to founder control and concerns about AI safety and existential risk.

Investors are concerned about slowing growth in Q3, with previous explosive growth in coding products now plateauing. Anthropic is shifting focus to new areas like AI in drug development and legal tech to sustain investor interest.

The S1 includes detailed risk factors, such as catastrophic AI risks, model safety, interpretability, and the potential for AI systems to be sentient. These reflect deep philosophical concerns about AI’s long-term impact on humanity.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.