590. Are American Tech Billionaires Beyond All Control?
from The Rest Is Politics ·
1h 9m 3s
The conversation explores the growing influence of tech billionaires like Jensen Huang and Elon Musk, whose unchecked power and wealth have distorted politics and culture. These figures operate within corporate systems that grant them immense immunity, often evading accountability and public scrutiny. Their rise is linked to a speculative AI bubble fueled by fantasy, exaggerated valuations, and a narrative of technological utopia, despite limited real-world revenue or practical outcomes. Public fear of AI is primarily driven by job displacement and data center concerns, not existential threats, highlighting a gap between hype and reality. The cultural roots of tech leadership are deeply tied to science fiction and fantasy, emphasizing conflict, individualism, and dominance—values reflected in their communication styles. Politically, this shift has led to a move away from policy-focused discourse toward entertainment-driven performance, exemplified by Trump’s dramatic, wrestling-inspired style. Meanwhile, political communication remains fragmented, with misinformation and algorithmic bias undermining trust in media. Environmental issues like COP are being sidelined, despite being central to corporate priorities just years ago. This decline reflects a broader societal shift in values, where sustainability and governance no longer dominate public and corporate discourse. The conversation concludes that while tech power is reshaping politics, the public’s skepticism and disengagement suggest a need for greater transparency, accountability, and cultural realism in both governance and innovation.
Welcome to the Restless Politics Question Time, me, Rory Stewart.
And me, Marina Hyde.
So, Marina, today, so much to discuss, but I wanted, given that you've done a lot on
the Tech Bros, to begin with this extraordinary story about Jensen Huang stepping down from
the most valuable company on earth.
I then wanted to move on to talk a little bit about communication in politics, about
what makes politicians tick, how Trump performs, how Andy Burnham performs, how politics is
being changed by the world of entertainment.
Then I thought maybe after the break, we'd talk a little bit about the environment.
COP is happening.
Why is it that environmental climate change seems to be dropping down people's list of
priorities so fast?
Welcome, welcome, welcome.
Thank you.
Amazing.
First time I've ever done it without Alistair.
So nervous moment for me.
Thank you for coming.
I know it's like going to the theater and you have the understudy and it says Sir Ian
McKellen is unavailable tonight.
The part of King Lear will instead be played by Steven Seagal, which I would watch.
Would be great.
Yeah.
Would be great.
Yeah.
Would be great.
That's like the chef.
Is that that guy?
Yeah.
He's the chef.
He's a chef in one movie, An Under Siege.
Yes.
He also cooks.
He's a former Navy SEAL.
Yeah, that's cool.
And I believe a real privilege to have you on because actually.
There's also a bit, you know, we like a bit of promotion here on the show.
Something is happening because you have just launched a new product called.
It's called Always On.
Always On.
Because I am always on, even on your podcast.
Yes.
I have all my writing you can find now at marinahyde.com.
And I have also launched a new show called Always On where I've covered this in sort
of some of the stuff we're going to talk about today.
I think in episodes on YouTube, you can get it wherever you get your podcast.
If you just search Marina Hyde, Always On.
And yeah.
And people can still listen to you on the Restless Entertainment.
Of course.
It's my first love.
They can always listen to me on the Restless Entertainment.
Restless Entertainment for the double act and for the solo Marina Act, Always On.
Always On.
And writing at marinahyde.com.
I am quite literally always on.
I mean, really.
Now, question for you.
Hit me.
How much does it matter that the people running the biggest tech companies, from Robin, seem
to operate in a reality pretty warped by their own wealth and power?
Is that distortion actually changing?
How is it changing politics?
How is it changing culture?
So let's start on the kind of warping.
Do you think they are pretty warped by that?
And what's warping?
I don't know.
Peter Diehl literally believes in the Antichrist.
So I, yeah, that to me seems a comparatively extreme position for someone whose technology
is kind of knit into all of our states quite deeply and seem to be becoming more so.
This episode is powered by Fuse Energy.
Fuse Energy is rated 4.9 on Trustpilot.
Higher than 4.9.
Higher than any other UK energy supplier.
And it's easy to see why.
Fuse offers some of the lowest tariffs on the market.
And that feels even more important given the energy price gap is set to rise by 29% in
January.
This is when energy policy stops being an abstract debate and starts showing up on your
bills.
Yet many of us seem to be a bit too accepting of very expensive energy bills because switching
providers can feel like an unnecessary hassle.
Fuse wants you to expect more from your energy provider.
And it only takes three minutes.
Three minutes to switch.
And with day and night customer support, you can get your questions answered whenever you
need.
You don't have to choose between cheap energy and great service.
As an extra incentive for our listeners to switch to the number one energy supplier on
Trustpilot at FuseEnergy.com slash politics and use the code politics for a free trip
plus subscription.
Visit FuseEnergy.com for full terms and conditions.
Hi, this is Gary Lineker from Goal Hangers.
The rest is football.
This episode is brought to you by Fuse Energy.
This episode is brought to you by WISE.
It's only when you start moving money between currencies that you really think about the
exchange rate, the fee, and what might be hidden away in the small print.
Whether you're living abroad, paying someone overseas, or just trying to manage your money
across borders, you want a fair exchange rate, an easy transfer, and no surprises along the way.
WISE keeps things simple.
WISE is a smart way to move the currencies you need around the globe.
It works in more than 160 countries.
And with over 40 currencies, most transfers arrive instantly.
WISE uses the mid-market exchange rate, like the one you see on Google, with no markups or hidden fees.
So when money needs to move, you can see the rate, know the fee, and get on with it.
Join millions saving billions on hidden fees by downloading the WISE app today.
Be smart.
Get WISE.
T's and C's apply.
For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms, every choice matters.
Tramphya offers self-injection or intravenous infusion from the start.
Tramphya is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks,
followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks.
If your doctor decides that you can self-inject Tramphya, proper training is required.
Tramphya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease
and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis.
Serious allergic reactions.
Increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them and liver problems may occur.
Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis.
Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine.
Explore what's possible.
Ask your doctor about Tramphya today.
Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit tramphyaradio.com.
It's often said of celebrities that their development freezes in time
at the moment they become famous.
And this is why child stars have very different. Can I interrupt on that?
Yes.
I mean, this is really interesting because you're right.
Zuckerberg becomes super rich when he's sort of 20, 21, isn't he?
And Musk a bit later, but it's still pretty young.
I mean, he's a pretty big deal when he's in his late 20s.
And this will be true for lots of these people.
I mean, I just saw a guy called Leopold Aschenberger,
who is like 26 and just set up a multi-billion dollar fund.
Why is it, do you think, that people are sort of frozen at the moment they become famous?
Is there a kind of psychological mechanism?
You stop hearing the word no a lot, I mean almost entirely.
And the way they set up their companies, actually someone like Jensen Wang is…
It was a slower burn, wasn't it?
Yeah. And he actually, because he became, but because he's been running that for much longer, you know, he can be ousted by his board. Zuckerberg's now, they've all set up their worlds now with these kind of super voting shares that if Zuckerberg was ousted from his company, I think he could just say, well, I tell you what, I don't accept that. And we'll have a different board who will reinstate me.
And I think that they live in a, that actually some of the younger ones or the ones whose companies, who are going at it less long than Jensen Huang, are set up now in a way that they are, they've had impunity sort of hardwired into their corporate structures.
I think it's really interesting, but they don't hear no at all.
They are like sort of megastars.
And so, as you've often said, this is an incredible amount of unaccountable wealth and power, right?
NVIDIA, in which Jensen Huang has just been fired, hit $4 trillion, biggest company in the world.
5.7 it was at one point.
The only national economies that are bigger than NVIDIA are the US and China.
Incredible.
It's extraordinary.
So much bigger than the British economy, bigger than the German economy.
Yeah, and when people talk about, you know, oh, it's like the Gilded Age.
It's like those, you know, first of all, those guys had an, they might have been monsters in many ways.
In fact, they were, but they had an amazing cultural mission as well.
you know, if you think of Carnegie and the libraries and all these sorts of things,
you're not at all aware that these guys have any form of cultural life at all, a hinterland. And
there's a reason we call it a hinterland. It's, you know, it's something that backs you up. It's
something that's different. You never think of them as having anything like that at all.
And furthermore, they are so much more powerful. Like Standard Oil is nothing compared to these
companies, nothing. Standard Oil, which was this big monopoly, and they broke it up in
1911 something like that that was far far smaller than these people could ever be uh we can't we've
not really lived in an era of power like this uh they're bigger than all i'm i remember um
reading a really interesting book by someone who was sort of like the 40th employee or something
of um facebook and she it's called boy kings and it's her memory of her time and there's a point
where she she is sort of hired to sort of sublimate mark zuckerberg's floating thoughts
into some form of corporate philosophy.
And he'll just sort of walk by her
and say things like companies,
not countries and whatever it is.
So we've never really treated these people
in the way that they should have been.
And they were also never scrutinized.
They were not scrutinized
in the manner of heads of state
or world leaders as they should have been.
They were always talked about
as cuddly inventors.
Like, oh, look at this kid
who still dresses in this funny way.
And, you know, we invented this tool
to socially connect people in his dorm room.
Or look at Elon Musk. He's a sort of cuddly inventor. And it was only when things had got far too out of hand and they had amassed far too much power that people started realizing like, oh my God, this person is so much more important than a number of world leaders.
One thing that comes out of this when we look at Jensen Huang is it turns out that one of the things that was suddenly revealed when it came to the time of people calling for him to be fired is that his board had kind of been in place since NVIDIA was a much smaller company. So, you know, again, for listeners just to explain, NVIDIA is a chip maker and it began designing chips first.
for video games and by a complete accident basically fluke it turned out that these chips
designed for video games were perfect for the new fashion of ai which was this large language model
transformer architecture ai really worked very very well on these advanced video gaming chips
so nvidia which he's been out for like more than 30 years but and when you look at his board
suddenly all these kind of old um corporate dudes that i talked to completely shocked because
normally the boards the biggest companies in the world they're always like an ex-secretary
of the treasury the ex-ceo of walmart they're kind of these big old kind of establishment
figures not so these are these kind of dudes who were friends of jensen 20 years ago and who
you're never really going to once you're getting to a five trillion valuation you're never really
going to say you know what i think someone else would do this job better than me exactly so
they
sort of stuck around another version of this that i came across was with open ai so open ai
again the company that makes chat gbt and people will remember this incredible moment a couple
years ago where they uh fired sam altman who's the ceo and they fired him on the grounds that he was
uh taking incredible risks and they thought what he was building was unbelievably dangerous and he
was deceitful so the board did what boards theoretically the only thing they're really
meant to do which is get rid of their ceo but it turned out that the
board did it in such a cack hand away they forgot to keep minutes they didn't follow proper legal
procedure and within a week sam altman's back and the whole board's been thrown out yeah well that's
what will happen with zuckerberg that's what will happen with any of them now those these guys who
set them up to have the super voting shares which lots of them did later on those guys now live in
an age of impunity and we talked with you on us that when he did his big spacex launch it was set
up that you could buy shares in it but you weren't going to have any control of it and now we see
that jensen huang is trying to get back in again there's a big move yes there's a big
move to get jensen hung back into nvidia um and this whole question of are these people or are
they not indispensable but it's a really really weird because they have been so successful at
making people parrot their lines and their lines are you can't regulate us regulation is luddite
and if you're regulating us you're against technology and you're against innovation
and they have this fantastic
argumentative style where they say what do you want to regulate them do you understand this
which bit of transformer architecture do you want to regulate oh which bit of the weights and
parameters do you want to regulate do you understand what you're regulating and so they've
got this incredible thing where they're able to move from a sort of techno-optimism to then relying
on incredibly specific technical details yeah which nobody else can keep up with to try to
circumvent this and i mean when you're you're looking at these people on capitol hill these
you see these absolutely ancient politicians sort of shuffling in because they won't make way
the gerontocracy who's supposed to somehow say well yeah actually that bit is that is the bit
i'm interested in and let's get really deep on that but they can't because they can't even
understand what the technology is in the first place you can see it even in our own parliamentary
committees when they're scrutinizing something i've appeared before one not that long ago and i
was quite shocked by how little they knew i was just talking about charter renewal how some of how
little they knew about charter renewal and i was quite shocked by how little they knew about charter
renewal and i was quite shocked by how little some members of the committee knew honestly just
about television and how things rated and how much of our country actually watched netflix
that's on something so basic that it would really be very very easy to find out you could they could
have just asked chapter gt in fact but they haven't okay so we we have this big scandal
in which it is alleged that jensen huang's uh girlfriend mistress it seems clear that he was
having an affair with her it's alleged by people in the american intelligence agencies
that she was a chinese state asset so pretty unclear what that means does that mean that she
was working for a business and they recruited her or she was a chinese spy who was put into this
business or and what was she trying to do was she trying to influence his policy was she trying to
find out industrial secrets or was she simply a route of smuggling but top line it's bad top line
it's bad rory top line it's bad so what's your sense how all the others are responding to this
whole thing well i'm sure they're bitching behind the scenes but i'm sure they're bitching behind
his back but in public you know they've rallied around the broligarchy has rallied around and i
find it really extraordinary some of the people you know trump just saying oh you know he he dealt
with her but everyone does it thank you so much mr president bill ackman saying you know we just
need to support him and his family now onwards that's what i don't think it's my job to support
this guy and his family i'm you know i'm sorry for his wife but that's their business then like
completely he's a big tech investor saying he's completely indispensable to america's ai leadership
and elon musk saying i agree it's like it hasn't affected their the broligarchy friendship group at
all and there's sort of a circling the wagons and just saying oh it just doesn't matter you know
elon musk spent probably tweeted 3 000 times about the odyssey but doesn't think this is important
and if they decide it's not important you know that guy nikita beer who used to run most of x
he said um i just i'm going to read this quote because i find it so hysterical he said about
jensen wang the fact he only had one extramarital affair with a state asset after leading the
greatest technological revolution in history is what impresses me for anyone else that number
would be double even triple digits triple digit affairs with foreign state assets how would you
run that well so i i know jensen wang a little bit um and and i think the first thing that i
push back on a bit is they're not really a group of friends
i mean they massively hate each other most of them i mean one of the weird things about the ways that
i i spend quite a lot of time in silicon valley with these people and one of the things is so
striking yeah is that they're not a unit with the same view of the world they're actually people who
have a lot in common but they have such deep resentment and suspicion towards each other and
in a sense the whole ai industry is the story of people who are really against each other so
the beginnings of open ai come out of effectively elon musk and then sam altman getting very angry
with demis hasabis and larry page at google and thinking that what they're going to build is really
evil then sam breaks with musk then dario modi who's part of sam's setup leaves in disgust and
sets up his own company saying sam altman is a massive uh
threat to humanity then the board of open ai which includes people like greg brockman his friends
fire him put in his other friend as the ceo who then resigns he comes back
and then dario modi and jensen huang i mean unbelievable i mean i was at a conference
with jensen huang recently where he was saying everything that anthropic was saying was complete
nonsense ai models don't pose any kind of threat this is an easy engineering problem to solve this
is all scaremongering etc so part of the thing going on the back of my mind is the extent
to which really the story may not be here is a genuine national security threat and all the tech
bros are defending him so much as actually this is something that will delight an enormous number
of the tech bros particularly people like dario who really disagreed about him selling
nvidia chips to china and and yeah everybody hated nvidia but why aren't they saying it publicly
if they circle the wagons actually isn't that
what they must be doing it for a reason i i get that they all love to pick up the phone to each
other and bitch about each other just like all those billionaires did with trump and the second
in his first term when they used to call him at night and then just put the phone down and say
oh he's such an idiot to the next one i get that they do that and that it's kind of like high school
and it's really mean they won't most with the exception of i mean so obviously some of those
people are not tech bros bill ackman's not tech bro um he's a big tech investor he's kind of the
infrastructure but he's like an elderly investor he's not part of the kind of engineer silicon
valley group within the engineer silicon valley group a lot of them won't even sit in a room with
each other i mean that's one of the reasons why it's almost impossible to do the safety stuff is
that you can't actually sit around the table and when they do sit around the table they literally
talk past each other with these kind of radically different agendas i mean giving the impression of
being like then they can feel like a woman in a meeting i know there aren't any women in the
meetings there aren't any there aren't any women it's lucky
there aren't any women they have to talk past each other that's for sure so let me come back on the
on the on the chinese state asset thing jensen huang has forever been completely open about
saying he wants to sell more chips to china there's been no secret about it at all i've seen
him standing up again and again saying sell chips to china and for at least four years he's been the
bogeyman for the people like darryl motor who don't want to sell chips to china so
and that's my first thing so there's no secret here about what he was doing the second thing is
what's the claim about but there is something around the edge of it isn't there if you're not
allowed to sell chips to china you may say that you wish to do it but if they found a way to go
via mega speed which was this woman's company or whatever and people are saying it's 12 billion
dollars worth of chips then that's a different thing that is covert
yes exactly so if the claim is that what's happened is that for whatever reason either because he fancies
it uh or because he was i think he did more than fancy how i'm gonna have to break this to you
exactly but is that the motivational
or is it that he's working for the Chinese government? So if he has, and maybe has,
illegally broken US sanctions by deliberately smuggling forbidden chips through this company
to China, that I would think is the story. But I would be very surprised if he was doing it
because he was somehow a Chinese state asset by being manipulated by the Chinese intelligence
service. I'd imagine he's actually, I mean, what we know is that he's been desperate to,
well, there's been the other joke, which is the Chinese refusing to buy his chips. I mean,
there's a very weird thing going on where he's been saying, we've got to get the Chinese to buy
my chips because then they will be totally dependent on the US and we'll be able to
weaponize that dependency and they'll never develop their own industry. And it's really
good for the US if China's dependent on American chips. And the Chinese, of course, hear that and
they're like, okay, we don't want to do that. And they're like, okay, we don't want to do that.
We don't want to do that. And they're like, okay,
buy your chips because we want to develop our own chips. So with these spy stories,
I don't know what's going on. I think there's a very strong bit of the Democratic Party that
doesn't like selling chips to China, doesn't like Jensen Huang, have found a connection
between this woman and the Chinese intelligence agency, but that they somehow dressed it up
as though he's somehow a Chinese state asset or he's leaked industrial secrets to China.
You're saying the main thing is the smuggling?
Something. Yes. And I think that if you are, I have to say, I'm still an old fashioned person
that believes if you are having an affair with a state asset, it is a biggie. It is still a bad
thing. And saying, oh, it doesn't matter. And everyone has affairs, triple digit affairs with
state assets, seems to me kind of a weird position to take. But with all of these people, anyone who
is too big to fail as an individual, and I mean, Nvidia is such an extraordinary thing. I read this
thing in The Economist that 15 cents,
of every dollar made by the US stock market since 2023 has been Nvidia stock. I mean,
I think that what we've done for a really long time with these guys, and what's weird is that
we're seeing the movie again. We did it with the sort of first generation of these guys, Zuckerberg
and all the sort of social media guys. And now the same thing is happening again, where they say,
we must grow at all costs. We can't talk to you about it. One of our models has escaped its boundary
and we can't talk to you about it. We
don't really, you know, no one really knows what we're building, but we have to be, we have to be
permitted to do whatever we want, or else we'll be eaten by the other side's technology. And you
can see now it's really filtered through. And obviously, we saw in the midterms, but you see
everywhere people thinking, hang on a second, I'm just not, people are really sceptical about it now
because of the way that they behaved. And also, because we've seen this movie before.
The AI thing, I think is really weird, because it seems to me that it's possible that it's a
irrational fantasy. So $750 billion odd is supposed to go into this technology.
And I was sitting with some Japanese business people on Friday, who were saying that they had
completely missed the AI race 10 years ago. Because when they were encouraged by Shinzo Abe
to push ahead with it, they pointed out that there's no income stream, that there's no revenue
attached to this thing. It's very difficult to work out how you make money out of it, or big
money out of it. And we're recording this before the IPO from Anthropic, which is supposed to be
going for about $1.4 trillion, so $1,400 billion. And its actual annual revenue is a tiny fraction
of that. So the only way it can justify that valuation is somehow if it's doing something
that nobody can define. And one of the interesting things is that although there's been huge progress
on fundamental maths problems and on coding, the rest of it, it's quite difficult to see.
You could imagine maybe a valuation, I don't know, of $200 billion, not $1.4 trillion.
So what's happened? I mean, how have all these investors, all these companies, all these
politicians essentially been sucked into a sort of. The fantasies were very few, kind of slightly
weird, geeky engineers who want to build a kind of super intelligence. How did that happen?
It's hard to say, isn't it? But it's like, it could be a bubble. We don't know. But we're so
deep into it now. The circular financing is so extraordinary, the way video has structured
everything. People have to pay their money, and then they'll invest in your company and
so that you can buy more chips. And it's really interesting now, I think, the language that's
around it. It's reminded me of the language when people, obviously, in the midterms, when people
were saying, we don't want a data center anywhere near us. This is what people would have said of a
nuclear reactor. I don't want a nuclear reactor anywhere near me. It reminds me of a lot of the
kind of Cold War, nuclear era panic about those sorts of things. And actually, the language now,
I saw somebody saying, oh, I mean, if this NVIDIA sort of structure collapsed, it will be like
Fukushima. And people are constantly talking. I think subconsciously, they're constantly using
the language of nuclear disaster, that the idea that there's this kind of technology that
we, and there's a structure of it all that we can't control now, and it could destroy us. And
it could destroy you locally, but it could also destroy the world. It's really interesting that
the language has gone over you. So often, you'll see nuclear language now used. And it just reminds
me of a sort of heart back to that era of thinking nuclear power will destroy us.
I mean, let's say it is a bubble. Let's say somehow, Elon Musk, Sam Altman,
Dario Mode, and a dozen other people, Demis Hassavi,
and his co-founders and others, were obsessed with superintelligence, were obsessed with the
idea that they were going to build this kind of the species that was brighter than humans,
that they were going to be gods, going to create a new species. And suddenly, this thing was going
to become, and they convinced everybody. I mean, somehow messianically, like a religion, they
convinced people to put hundreds of billions of dollars behind this idea and just basically finance
their toy. Like, I get rid of this thing, I get rid of this thing, I get rid of this thing, I get
really into Lego. And I convince everybody that they've just got to give me hundreds of
billions of dollars, just like build the biggest Lego thing in the world. And when you're like,
where's the revenue going to come from? I'm going to be like, well, I don't know,
you know, maybe people visit my Lego, you know, maybe I could use it for some stuff.
Yes, it's like the South Park. I don't know if you've seen the South Park episode when the
gnomes arrived in South Park, and they have a business plan, which is number one, collect
underpants, number two, question mark, and number three, profit. And that's really the business plan.
I think about that quite a lot when I think about these companies.
Do they get investment?
I'm not going to do any spoilers. If you haven't seen the episode, it is a particularly
iconic episode of South Park. But yeah, I don't know. It's not great, Rory. It's not great.
And what, I mean, what, so you're somebody who's, I mean, I think quite interested and watched a lot
of disaster movies and thought about a lot about this stuff. Do you have a sense of what's happening
in the imaginative world of, I don't know, Elon Musk dressed in an Iron Man suit, or these people
trying to build super robots?
It's really interesting, isn't it? Because if you told me the things that are actually happening,
obviously, disaster movies are always kind of overblown and what have you. And the things that
we've seen over the last few weeks, which is lots of supermarkets, lots of stores, supermarket
fridges have been taken over. I, you know, if you told me I would watch that movie, I don't think
so. Although, you know, if you do green light it, please cast Gerard Butler in it. But all the
things, again, that we were sold, this is great. It's going to make things so much easier for you.
We're terribly afraid that it's going to take away even the basics. And this is,
the fear is really big now, I think. It's amazing how many, when you look at all these recent polls
of people who just want to pause AI development completely, it's like, it's a big majority.
And do you think, do you think why they're trying to pause it? Because they actually think there's
a 20% chance it could extinguish humanity? Yeah, I think they're really afraid of it.
They think it will take their jobs and they're really afraid of it.
I think there's two different things going on. I mean, one of the, one of them is,
this is a horrible data center and my job's going to go.
The other is killer robots, the end of the world, Terminator, which is-
Yeah, I don't like either of these realities for us.
My sense when I talk to people about the second, they just laugh.
People are in denial about that. People don't really want to process the fact that Daria Modi
is saying there is a 20% chance this could extinguish humanity. And the godfathers of AI
are saying this could kill us all. We could all be dead in five years. That isn't really what's
driving this. In fact, when I say this to people-
What's driving people's fears about it?
Yeah.
Is that you think it's a-
It's jobs, data centers. I hate the-
Can it not be both?
I don't know. What I noticed when I raise it, like at a dinner party or chatting to someone,
they kind of laugh nervously. They don't really want to take seriously
the possibility that this could actually kill us all, that we could all be dead in five years time.
I think we live in really conspiracist era, more than we have done for a very long time.
And I actually think the popular imagination, people are afraid of these things. Look at
everything on TV is-
It's a bit dystopian. These are the big sort of trends of people thinking they don't, it's got so
bad that actually people don't like listening to stuff about it. Maybe they felt safe watching
things about Skynet and the rise of the machines in the 80s and the 90s with Terminator, but now
they really don't like hearing things about it. I mean, you know, often what we find, if you talk
about AI in the entertainment industry, people don't really want to listen to it and it will do
less well than episodes that don't have it because people just, they can't stand it on any level.
They do really fear it and they actually want-
And also they have no control over it. You're constantly told that a machine
can escape its guardrails. What can you do about it?
it it is like the nuclear fears of of decades ago that you can't do anything about it there's a
cloud coming for you and some kind of Chernobyl is going to happen and you cannot do anything
about it and flip it around put put yourself on the head of Elon Musk what she thinks going on
when he's how serious is he when he's like dressing as Iron Man appearing in Iron Man movies
what he's such a basic I I can't I mean he's a he's a kind of simple guy in lots of ways on those
on those fronts I I wouldn't describe him as having a complex or interesting cultural cultural
in or entertainment hinterland you know he has a lot of half-formed cultural thoughts I would say
and then that's being generous quarter formed if you ever see him when he's talking about when he
had to host Saturday Night Live and he's talking about like I had all these great ideas for jokes
and you're just like no you didn't because there's all this backstage stuff and his him and his bros
are saying oh we had so many great ideas I was going to say here is my cock
and get a chicken out of my it's like okay I mean wow that's really really what a brilliant joke
what a brilliant joke so you're I don't think he is a sophisticated uh cultural thinker in any way
but it isn't isn't actually more likely that you're maybe more vulnerable if you're not a
sophisticated cultural thinker I mean let's say he and the others were completely brought up with
the diet of science fiction they were lonely they read all these books at home late into the night
they became very very unhappy they became very very unhappy they became very very unhappy
identified with Isaac Asimov they were maybe I actually think fantasy is something that I think
the genre of fantasy is something that appeals to them more I think if you look at what Elon Musk was
doing before you um bought Twitter he was playing this game called Elden Ring which is a video game
which is a sort of very very elaborate fantasy they're actually making a movie of it now I
actually think things like kind of quasi fake historical things like Game of Thrones things
like that really influence those guys
they really like the idea of a world where um you know the strong survive you can do what you want
women are treated appallingly but that's just history because that's what it was like then
even though it's not real history I think they're really into all of that because they are set in
worlds which are don't have the morays and conventions and and real to use the word again
guardrails that our world has and I think they like fantasy a lot I actually don't see them as
being particularly influential and I think they're really into all of that because they're
influenced by that whole science fiction tradition particularly except in a very sort of basic way
that anyone might be I actually think that fantasy worlds are where and the worlds of a sort of first
person shooter or a first person video game where you fight your way through the fancy one you can
kind of do what you whatever you want and you live in a world of license and individualism
is much more significant well I think it's a beautiful way to to transition to the next
question because a couple of things there I mean one is that Elon Musk actually
in communicating with Britain tweeted out and said you know you are the shire you are the hobbits and
you need the rangers to come in and protect you and Stephen Miller Trump's chief of staff
like Musk fundamentally believes that the natural state of the world is violence and war
and that peace was an illusion an aberration that everything that happens since the second world war
the European Union NATO peace dividends all of us is us living in la la land it's not real
you know real is
and Bannon believes all that as well yeah this is rooted in the fantasy in you know fantasy epic
which is almost always war now I'm going to ask a question from we're going to move on to talking
about personality and style in politics because lots of people have got things on that Harriet
says do you think for a politician to be successful today they must be an internet personality Lucy
says what makes a political personality connect with voters and Lewis says has politics become a
more about entertaining than effective policies and tough decisions
I think the first thing is I'm always very skeptical about you know effective policies
tough decisions there's a kind of and I can see where people are coming from but it's often sort
of thing you hear from business people you know if I was a politician I wouldn't care about the
votes and tough decisions and it's all too much about entertainment my sense is politics has
always been fundamentally right back to the ancient world and I think that's a very important
Greeks about communication. They take complicated policy ideas and they translate them into the
public. They live and breathe from the public. That's who they are. And this idea of the sort
of effective clear politics is the kind of anti-democratic tradition. That's kind of Plato's
philosopher king. Plato's very anti-democratic and it's how China thinks about it, you know,
the technocrat. The engineer has the right picture. And particularly today, I think with
social media, styles change. It's 100% a question of fashion. I agree with that. And the ones who
are able to tap into the currents of their age or maybe to slightly surf ahead on them
are the best. And then there are figures who I think never worked in any age. I mean,
it's true that, you know, Churchill's communication style or Macmillan's
communication style are the best. But I would argue Keir Starmer's communication style has never worked.
There was one. I mean, yes, you weren't aware that there was one.
Literally, I can't think of any time in two and a half thousand years when that style,
you know, people were like, oh, he would have been great for the radio age or, you know,
maybe didn't really work in social media. No. I mean, he couldn't perform in the House of Commons
either. I mean, one of the things that surprised me when he was Jeremy Corbyn's Brexit minister is I
would turn up in the House of Commons and say, "You know what? I'm going to go to the House of
Commons and sit on the front bench because I was in the government." And everyone would be like,
"Oh, Keir Starmer, he's so forensic." It was also forensic because I guess he was a lawyer.
He was a lawyer.
Right. So boring.
Yeah.
Unbelievable. Right. And that was well, well before he became Labour leader. It's one of
the sort of weird things that kind of, we talked about the delusion of AI, right? The possibility
of the whole thing as a bubble. That humans sort of suddenly be like, "Oh, AI, AI, AI, AI." And
right, and everyone's like, "Keir Starmer, Keir Starmer, he's so forensic, he's so forensic, he's
so bright, he's so bright."
They really talked themselves into it. But it was a reaction. That vote was, we know
and could see even at the time, that it was a reaction against what had gone before. And
they were just sort of hoping that, you know, maybe it would be all right on the night and
it wasn't. But the ones I think who, someone like Trump who comes from, in every meaningful
sense from reality TV.
And the narrative is hero, conflict, hero overcomes conflict, and it happens
every week. And then next week. We like the conflict because the conflict is the drama. And what became interesting
is that, and this definitely happened here as well, when you had once Rolling News started,
they too adopted the conventions of drama, which is that we need conflict because otherwise
it's very boring and you're watching nothing unfold. So you have people with very, very
polarized views on because then they'll have a big argument and it will be a big deal.
And so we became sort of gradually kind of culturally desensitized to people arguing
and fighting about everything. And someone like
Trump who also understood the unreal nature of the world. He gets so much from wrestling,
which I find absolutely fascinating. You know, he appeared so much for WWE, for the world
wrestling entertainment.
And he did even. I'm sorry, again, for listeners who don't pay full attention, this form of wrestling
is not real, right? It's staged.
Well, I suppose there's Greco-Roman wrestling, Rory, which I'm sure you've picked
me up on, but yeah. No, wrestling is not real. It is staged and we sort of know it, but we
sort of pretend we don't know it.
And this is the kind of wrestling, again, for British listeners where people put
masks on, they have identities, they jump into. Well, they have characters. Yeah. They may not always be. It's not like Mexican
wrestling where they've got a mask, but yeah, they've got characters and you've got huge
things, and they have engineered kind of battles all the time.
And they've decided in advance who's going to win and who's going to lose and who
the villain is and who the hero is.
Yeah. And there is a person in the case of WWE, a guy called Vince McMahon, who's
this incredible American story. He's a huge impresario, a kind of awful man in lots of
ways. I think Linda McMahon, his wife, ended up running education or something for Trump.
Yeah. I'm Secretary of Education for Trump.
Yeah. Very good.
Didn't Trump just announce briefly that he thought that one of them was going to be his
new press secretary?
That's Dana White. That's something different. That's UFC, which is a different form of fighting,
Rory. And that is real.
Trump's very interested in both of those.
But he's interested in that because it's sort of pure power and muscle, but he's interested
in wrestling because it's real and it's not real. And everyone kind of gets the joke and
does it matter? You know, like Netflix now have WWE Raw as one of their properties. And
the person who's in charge of that at Netflix is called the vice president of fictional
sports. And I sometimes think of Donald Trump as the sort of president of fictional politics
because we all know it's a joke, right?
So I've read an earnest article on this, on the idea of kayfabe.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's a big deal.
So the idea was that there are moments in the wrestling fight where the villain half
comes out of character and half doesn't come out of character and starts attacking the organizers
saying the whole thing's fake and this is corporate sponsorship. And there's this kind
of weird thing where it's not quite clear to what extent the actor has kind of stepped
out of the arc.
Yeah, you have to keep metaizing it or else it just, it starts to feel, so you have to,
it's a ratchet. You have to keep.
And Trump's speech is a bit like that too, because when he's reading a speech, he's often
commenting on it. So he'll say, oh, the Chinese economy is almost larger than the American
economy. It says here, that's what these
guys think. But, you know, and then on he goes and he comes back and forth and you're
never quite sure whether he's endorsing the speech, undercutting the speech.
I mean, even just before the midterms, you get so kind of inured to his speeches. But that one he did by the reflecting pool with a sort of Comic Sans presentation about it. I remember thinking, I mean, this is the trouble is, as a lot of comedians and comedy writers will tell you, he is very funny. And I don't love it. But that's the trouble. I mean, there's so many times I've thought you're just you can't at moments that are really of critical national importance.
I remember there was a bit at the start of the pandemic and having said all sorts of things about, you know, obviously having downplayed it for a long time.
By this stage, he realized he had to say something. But he was he said at one point, you know, you can't you can't touch your face.
I haven't touched my face for a week. I miss it.
Like, I can't please don't do this now. You know, it was obviously a very serious moment.
But he's very, very funny. And it's very difficult that he is funny and he is extraordinary.
And he says things in a way.
It's true on The Apprentice. He could be quite funny there, too.
Yes, it was. It was a shtick. You know, he had a character. He was playing a very successful billionaire, which, as I say, having bankrupted two casinos in Atlantic City.
It's incredibly hard to bankrupt a casino.
And then there's this weird thing, which I found when I was traveling around East Kentucky and West Virginia with the team just for the midterms, which is people would say to me, well, I'm very disappointed.
You know, I thought here is this very successful businessman.
He's not a politician. He's a businessman. He's going to come in and sort stuff.
He doesn't need the money. He's so wealthy.
You know, he's the one guy you can't corrupt because he doesn't need the money.
He's going to come and he's going to sort it all out. Right.
And then there was the second thing that was interesting.
So they would produce lines.
So this farmer, I was sitting in his cab of his combine harvester going through a maize field.
And he I said, well, where'd you get your news from?
And he says, well, you know, the thing is, I believe in getting a very balanced news.
And literally every American, there's no American you talk to.
At the moment, in my experience, who doesn't say, you know, the news is very biased.
It's too polarized right and left.
I do my own research.
Those are the deadliest words.
I listened to all sorts of sources.
And his conclusion was President Trump didn't start the war.
The Iranians started the war 41 years ago.
And at least President Trump's dealing with it.
And they have nuclear weapons.
It was all the talking points that week from Trump.
But when I said, where'd you get it from?
He didn't know.
And then I was talking to someone.
Who worked focus groups.
And then I listened to an Ezra Klein interview with her.
Where she said, nobody knows where they get their news from anymore.
Now you're like on TikTok or Instagram.
You're trying to follow something on dieting.
Or you're getting cooking advice.
Or you're following basketball.
And somehow you wake up in the morning with a view on the Iran war.
But you no longer know where that's come from.
They have incredibly, an incredibly polarized news market.
We have something really enormous that sits in the middle of our culture.
The BBC.
Which an overwhelming majority of people check into during the week.
And it's trusted.
Whatever you might feel from reading various news sources.
It is actually trusted.
Much more than anything.
They have nothing that's bigger than something like 20%.
And if you like the New York Times.
You absolutely hate Fox News.
And if you like Fox News.
Then you hate the New York Times.
So there's no.
Even what they were starting from.
Was nothing that anyone could agree on.
But now having been polarized.
It is now completely atomized as you say.
It is impossible to see where they're getting it from.
These tiny little snippets.
So how do you.
How do you control it?
How do you regulate it?
We're very lucky here.
That we have something.
A base that you can work from.
And yet presumably even here.
Probably be almost half the population.
Who aren't really interacting with the BBC.
And I mean I see this.
You know when I'm arguing with Tommy Robinson's followers.
The algorithm gets me in really weird ways.
And I suddenly.
I'm now clearly considered by the algorithm to be a jihadist.
Because I was fed a video recently about how Saddam Hussein.
Gave a heroic speech at the moment of his execution.
Where he recited the Shahada and you know.
And this is like designed for me.
Presumably because X is like.
This guy is going to be really into the vision of Saddam Hussein.
As a good Muslim being brave at the final moments of his.
You've now obligingly disseminated it.
So perhaps you do work for the algorithm like everyone else.
It's going to come all down in the content mines.
Yes.
Am I right in saying that for some reason.
Andy Burnham somehow seems to be much.
It's only much better than Keir Starmer.
But also in a way that surprises Alistair.
I mean Alistair I think would be the first to say.
He didn't see Andy Burnham coming.
Known him for 30 years.
He's very astonished by this guy suddenly.
Putting it off.
And yet there's something that's sort of.
Working.
Have you got a sense.
And do you agree there's something working.
And if so what is it.
I think that our fundamentals.
In this country is so bad.
That talking about the sort of vibes of it all.
Yes for sure.
Keir Starmer had none.
And Andy Burnham is a much more authentic communicator.
And he finds ways to reach people.
I don't mind that he does Gogglebox.
Things like that.
Nonetheless.
The sort of vibes based approach.
Is only going to take you so far.
And I really don't.
It's not enough.
So I'm kind of.
I'm interested to the extent that he is a better communicator.
Than the one before.
But you.
You can't go all the way on communication alone.
And we know this.
Trump has gone an enormous distance.
But he's a sort of superhuman communicator.
And a unique and kind of extraordinary bizarre force of nature.
And Andy Burnham isn't that.
So yes.
I think he's doing much better as a communicator.
But it's not enough.
Just before we go to the break.
You've talked very powerfully and interestingly about Trump.
And a bit about Burnham.
Is there anyone else that you think is a really great communicator?
I feel like if you'd asked me.
This a few months ago.
And I would have said that.
Even though I am not a fan of either Farage or Polanski.
They had clearly found a way to not speak in the dead language of politicians.
There is a dead language that when you hear people talking in it.
And I was trying to think back to when the high point of.
I suppose that getting to the high point of both of their fortunes.
When it seemed like everything was completely factoring.
And I remember the Gorton and Denton by-election.
By the way.
That was this year.
And I remember first of all the Greens won.
But the two formal.
What we thought of the time were becoming the two formally main parties.
The words that they used to describe it.
The Tories said it showed only the result.
It showed that only the Conservatives have the experience, the plans and the team.
To ensure a stronger economy and a stronger country.
Rory, they lost their deposit.
So I find it so extraordinary that politicians can talk like this.
Just look at what football managers do.
They've got a terrible result.
And they've got to go out afterwards on Sky Sports.
And they say, look, you know, this hurts.
It's definitely not good enough for the fans.
And it sure as hell isn't good enough for us.
And you can say that.
You do not say this result proves that.
Labour speak in an even more desiccated language sometimes.
Lucy Powell said, what I take from it is that people want to see the Labour Party.
The Labour government shouting more loudly about our values and our stories.
Like, what is shouting about our story?
What is it?
It's a word salad.
This is a nonsense way of talking.
And at the time, the next morning, Hannah Spencer, who won for the Greens,
actually gave a speech that sounded like a normal person.
And whether or not you agree with any of our positions,
and, you know, it's not necessarily my cup of tea,
it sounded like a normal person.
Farage was good at sounding like a normal person.
He now sounds like a normal person who's always in a bad mood.
So people are not interested in it.
But what I did take from them was that there are prizes on offer
if you manage to unlearn the language, the obscurantist language that politicians,
Jews, so they don't have to say anything, so they can't get in trouble.
It's so weird, isn't it?
Because I couldn't agree with you more.
And I always felt that the thing to do in politics is to acknowledge.
So if I was President's Minister and someone said,
President's a disaster, I'd be like, you're absolutely right.
In fact, they're worse than you think.
They are a catastrophe.
They're disgusting, right?
But then I just went to hear the Trump rally in Chillicothe, Ohio.
And what was extraordinary.
What was extraordinary about that is he did not, in an hour and 15 minutes of talking,
and I was captivated.
I thought he was a wonderful speaker.
But at no point did he acknowledge a single problem.
He's an outlier.
We can't even compare him to anyone else because he's so good.
I thought he was going to say, listen, you know, I know your diesel prices are up.
I know your petrol prices are up.
I know you're hurting.
But he was just like, the economy is tremendous.
Things have never been so cheap.
The jobs have never been so good.
But he can mesmerize.
He's a hypnotist.
Others can't.
And in the end, we've seen the limits of it.
But yeah, comparing him to anybody else.
To Lucy Powell.
Yes, comparing him to Lucy Powell.
Yeah, she's not quite there yet.
Could try harder.
As we go to the break, there is a fantastic opportunity for Trip listeners.
If you want to do some Christmas gifting, of course, the greatest gift you can give
is a membership in Trip, which will allow access to all our wonderful new miniseries.
Early sign up for events, tickets.
Early sign up for live shows.
Live events.
And of course, most of all for Christmas, you get a free Trip Christmas T-shirt.
So if you're a loved one who might be interested in the rest is politics, dad, mom, son, daughter,
go to therestispolitics.com forward slash gifts or find the link in the description.
Now let's take a quick break.
This episode is brought to you by Barclays Premier.
Now you might look at your pension as some sort of end goal, but there could be a lot
of future left to plan for.
A lot could change from personal circumstances to new rules around how you
save or how you invest and pass on your wealth.
So we're aware of things like policy changes, wealth
in advance, but you cannot predict everything. And that's where planning and advice exclusively
for Barclays Premier customers comes in. A dedicated wealth planner builds you a personalised
plan around your goals, while your wealth manager helps it evolve as life and the world change.
They're here to help you navigate your next steps because it pays to be a step ahead.
Search Barclays planning and advice today to learn more.
You need to be a UK resident with at least £150,000 available to invest.
Other eligibility criteria apply. Money invested for over five years has historically delivered
greater growth than cash savings, although investment values can rise and fall over time.
The secret society of semi-homemade? Listen up. Sam's Club has pre-made dishes for a Thanksgiving
feast that's ready in two hours, all while tasting suspiciously homemade.
Come join us. Sam's Club. Individual oven times may vary.
Welcome back to the Restless Politics Question Time. Me, Rory Stewart.
And me, Marina Hyde.
Okay, Marina, question from Philip. It's COP this week, but there is a lack of coverage or discussion
across the media. Now, again, actually, there may be some people who don't even remember what COP is,
and it was the big UN Environment Conference. Why is no one talking about ESG anymore,
Environment Sustainability Governance? Has the environment dropped steeply even in young
people's priorities? Now, I'm really interested in this. So, I had a meeting, which I did a year
ago, two years ago, three years ago, with the same organization that works with 350 CEOs.
Three years ago, literally all of them were just talking about ESG. ESG was the biggest thing.
And when I did it last week, nobody mentioned ESG. And then it's not just the CEOs. It's like
the politicians, too. It's like the Tory party all votes for net zero. I was one of them. I voted
for net zero. And now, literally, all the people who voted for net zero have been told by Kemi
Badenoch that if they support net zero, they can't run again to be MPs. So, they're going to have
to say to their constituents, totally coincidentally, I completely changed my
mind on net zero. And it's nothing to do with the fact that Kemi Badenoch told me I can't run
again for the Tory party. This is my conscience at play here. What's happening here? Is it that
nobody believed in it in the first place? Or is it that we get captivated by ideologies and then
ideologies change?
No, I do think they did believe in it. I think the evidence is overwhelming. But I really,
honestly, think that we have lived in an era of such failure of mainstream politics,
to solve so many things that we are now just condemned to be in this cycle of short-termism.
So, we're having to just deal. We are like Gromit building the tracks in front of us.
And we are constantly having to deal with kind of immediate problems and immediate things,
because there's been no long-term thinking. We are incapable, really, of long-term thinking. I
mean, everything we talk about becomes more and more short-term by the day. I mean,
I agree with the question. You would not know this conference was happening.
If you wanted to hide pictures of Robert Pattinson doing something completely illegal,
the new James Bond, we are going to talk about it. You would hide it in a cop speech. You're
not aware of this. And there was a point where it dominated everything. But it's almost. First of
all, we know, measurably, that it has slipped down people's list of priorities. And people
are talking. And young people, particularly, who I think that people felt were the people
who were driving this, or certainly it was being done for. There was a UK poll of
18 to 24-year-olds and said that 18% said climate change was their top concern. It would have been
much higher a few years ago. Now it's financial worries, 45%. Job security and housing instability,
23%. These are more important priorities. And it's sort of slipped down. And I'm afraid that
you can see that climate change coverage has dipped massively.
I saw something similar, I felt, with Afghanistan, where we went from Afghanistan as an
existential threat to global security after 9-11. We're going to spend $2,000 billion. We're going
to deploy 150,000 troops, because if the Taliban control Afghanistan, literally the world ends.
And then we just wake up one morning and we're like, oh, we're leaving Afghanistan. We're going
to leave it to the Taliban. And now if you say to people, what happens if we leave Afghanistan
and the world ends? They're like, oh, it doesn't really matter. Taliban control Afghanistan.
And you're like, well, what happened to 20 years and $2,000 billion? And I wonder whether that's not
what it felt like in 1989 with the fall of communism, that suddenly one moment everyone
in the Czech Republic is talking about workers of the world unite. And two years later, they're all
talking about pragmatically regulated free markets. And is the same thing going to happen
with how we think about China, that suddenly China's a massive threat to the world and then
two years later it isn't? Or suddenly we're all like, oh, we didn't spend enough on defense and
we've got to spend more on defense. And then maybe two years later, everyone's like, what was all
that about? We didn't need to spend all that money.
There is no real long-term thinking. There is sort of partisan long-term thinking. If you look
at how strategic the Republicans can be when they pat the courts and then they think, how am I going
to get Roe versus Wade overturned? And they have a plan that's like a 30-year plan. The last few
years has felt to everyone that we do have a 30-minute plan. And a lot of people feel that way.
One of the ways to think about it for me is that people are saying that much fewer people find
climate change a significant
issue. But if you ask them in a different way, they're really worried about heat waves. They're
really worried about flooding. It reminds me a little bit of times like, I don't know, say before
Brexit when people said, oh, I don't mind if something happens to the economy, but I really
believe in this thing. I want us to leave. And it became clear when you asked sort of deeper
questions that they didn't really believe this kind of notional abstract of the economy had some
effect on them. So if a rising tide lifts all boats, then a receding one leaves lots of people
high and dry.
And they didn't really see themselves as part of the economy, which is really interesting.
The downstream effects of climate change, the flooding, the heat waves, people are talking
and thinking about all the time. But the strategic and political planning is now, I feel like people
have just put it aside because they are dealing with so many short-term problems and everyone's
just trying to win their next election. And once Trump won, you knew that we would stop talking
about this. We all knew, right? And I'm not sure that under the Democrats, any of these things
are going to return.
Oh, well, they're the least strategic people. They just go from convulsion to convulsion. They
are not strategic. I specifically use the Republican Party as an example of long-term
thinking. I would love them to have a 30-minute plan. The Democrats would love them.
Yeah. I mean, my fear is that we think it's going to, when Trump's no longer president,
we're going to return to the 1990s. Bill Clinton's going to be back and it's going
to be Middle East peace process.
Does anyone still think that? They might have in 2020, but I don't think they do now.
I don't think people think that any longer. I think people think that the. The arc of history is not having a normal one and it's going all over the place for quite some time
now. Yeah. It would be nice to think that we could return to the idea of long-term strategy, but
you see it in non-democracies, long-term strategy. But I don't, I'm not particularly aware of
great long-term strategies in the West. But I have to say, I do believe in human ingenuity and I do
sort of slightly feel that humans might fix some of these problems.
But that does mean that it's. It's going to be a really big decision on whether Mark Carney gets his middle powers thing going or
not, because that's a bet that something fundamentally has changed forever. And there
will be many other people saying, oh, no, no, it's just a Trump aberration. Once Trump goes,
we can return to business as usual. We don't need to put all this energy into trying to create
a non-American future.
Yeah. I mean, how many times do they have to learn that lesson?
So we've got three questions here. Right. Question from Anonymous. I've heard a rumor that Marina was
at her 21st birthday party. What was it like? Do you even remember my 21st birthday party?
I do remember it, Rory. That is the correct rumor. Would you like me to. Yes, it was at the
Athenaeum. Do you remember this? You must remember your own 21st birthday party.
And was. Do you have a sense of what I was like?
If you can remember it, you weren't there. Is that what you're telling me?
Do you have a sense that. I remember I didn't like what I was wearing. I found it too staid. And I was just on the point
of where I wanted to wear outrageous clothes to absolutely everything. I think I met a couple of
ambassadors and generals, as you can imagine. Yeah.
At my 21st birthday. Yeah.
Yeah, I think so. And I remember I was going with a mutual friend. I think it was afterwards,
or maybe this was the next day. So maybe the memories have elided. I remember going to Funland
at the top of the Trocadero. Do you remember that?
Oh, that's great. Yeah.
Yeah. It was a big amusement arcade and I played shoot-em-ups for many hours.
And do you think I'm a recognizably the same human being that. Oh, yes. I don't think people change, do you?
Not actually. I think you're a recognizably. So I'm now like the kind of person who would invite generals and ambassadors to my 21st birthday.
Well, maybe you didn't. Maybe your parents invited them.
Who knows?
You can't remember.
I mean, you know, processing. Can you remember your 21st birthday party?
I have anxieties about my 21-year-old self.
Do you?
I'm not sure my 21-year-old self was. What is it?
I think it was very arrogant. I'm not comfortable with my 21-year-old self.
You think your 21-year-old self was very arrogant?
Yeah.
Okay.
Yeah. But you don't think that's unfair to my 21-year-old self? You don't really have a strong sense there?
I think we're all, you know, I don't know.
I don't love my own 21-year-old self, Rory.
So, no, I don't.
I, you know, I, you've, you are the same person.
Thank you, Marina.
Or not.
No, you are the same person.
I'm sure we both are.
Good.
Okay.
Westminster Reality TV.
Yes, all right.
A.M.314159.
It's one of Elon Musk's children.
Yeah.
Asks.
Yes.
That's a good joke.
I like that.
Thank you.
If you were casting the real housewives of Westminster,
who should you be looking out for?
Oh, well, you need certain things in any real housewives franchise.
I don't know if you, I don't know how many you were involved with at any one time.
I'll tell you literally, if you were testifying to my committee,
like when I was on the culture committee, you would be so horrified.
I don't think there's a lot of real housewives in the culture committee.
Would you allow your child to watch, be your housewives?
Yeah, absolutely.
You learn everything.
It's the most widespread study of female midlife friendship in the world.
I would, there's a queen bee, there's a main character energy one, there's an agent of chaos.
And is the real, like in inverted commas, like the rest thing you were describing before the break?
What the, is the what?
The real in real housewives, like in inverted commas.
Yeah.
Well, it comes from, there was a show called Desperate Housewives, which was a fictional drama, comedy drama.
And somebody went along to a dinner party, the guy who created this, and thought, hang on a second.
He went into a sort of gated community and thought this, we should do a real show.
And they started with the first franchise in Orange County.
They've got like 44 of these around the world now.
It's absolutely massive.
But it's, but it's real in the sense of wrestling thrill, that they're slightly acting up and it's structured.
Yeah, it's, oh, I see.
Is it, it's a, yeah, yeah.
It's like, it's unscripted reality, but there are, there are very, they create certain situations.
They go on trips.
They, they, they are creating.
I had a question for you.
Okay.
I was asked to go on Celebrity Treasures for the first season.
Oh my God, please do it.
Should I have done it?
Yeah.
I want to watch you.
No, I thought it would be.
I want to watch you on it.
I would have thought it'd be really bad.
For you personally, you must speak to your agent.
But for me as a viewer, you've got to go on it.
Thank you.
Come on, please do it.
Please do it.
So if you were casting reality Housewives of Westminster, who would you be looking out for?
So you need all these people.
You need villains.
You need people who sort of know each other.
I, they don't really have to still be in Westminster because like it's, you know, I think you'd have to have Nadine Doris.
Jacob Rees-Mogg.
They've got to be women.
I'm so sorry.
It's so, it's so unfair, isn't it?
They've all got to be women.
Yeah.
It's kind of in the title.
It's Lucy Powell and Nadine Doris.
No, I'll tell you who should be.
Rachel Rees.
You need chaotic people.
No, you need Nadine Doris.
Okay.
I would, without any question, have Michelle Moan.
I can't actually believe she hasn't been in one of the franchises, the London one.
What about that Sasha Soir?
She was a liability.
She's the baroness who did COVID sales.
Yeah, who did the COVID contract.
She started as a sort of bra in Plasalia.
And then Sasha Soir, because she'd said, she'd said, you remember she wrote that book.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
She had a book.
She's a bit of a go at me too.
Yeah, yeah.
Well, she'll say any old stuff for attention.
So she's perfect.
Yeah.
So those three, I think, would be my core group.
Yeah.
And then, I mean, I'd want Carrie Johnson, quite honestly.
Why wouldn't you?
But no men appear?
Like the Jake Rees-Mogg fit doesn't appear in the background?
Oh, the sort of wet husbands are kind of to the side sometimes.
But it's not really about, it's hard to explain it, isn't it?
It's not really about the men, actually.
This is really just a show about women.
I see.
Yeah.
All right, good, good.
Okay, thank you.
Final question from Alice.
Which politician?
Would make the best James Bond?
Oh, my goodness.
Well, I mean, I really can't think of this.
Who do you think?
Who would be good?
I'm not going to count you in this, Rory, because you're not a politician any longer.
Who do you think would be the best James Bond?
I mean, you need to want to have sexism.
That's the thing.
So that makes it tricky for a start.
So Al Khan's is like, really, he's like, he's more like Daniel Craig, right?
He's that kind of model of Bond, isn't he?
Yeah, I mean, are we going to have to go for him?
Yes.
I mean, he's like the genuine action man in Parliament, right?
Yeah.
And who would be like your kind of smooth, kind of Sean Connery, good-looking kind of?
Well, I mean, are there any?
Am I missing someone here?
Very few.
One of the things I discovered. It's like the politics of showbiz for ugly people, right?
We're not in America, though.
I discovered when I took my parliamentary committee to America, and I walked into the
House of Representatives through the security, and I was like, we are British MPs.
The security guys were like, no, you're not.
We are British MPs.
Let us through.
You're a Jedi mind trip.
It's like, you're not.
Because we were all really short and ugly.
Whereas American politicians are all over six foot tall, and they're all kind of square
jawed.
They all look like John Ossoff.
They mug you guys, do they?
Okay.
Right.
So all American politicians basically could play this role.
Vance can't play this role.
Gavin Newsom could probably do it.
Are there no sort of square jawed, good-looking British politicians?
Not that I. Listen, hit me up if there are any.
I think they need to be quite damaged.
That element of Bond's character, I think we'd be long and strong in.
Drinking in the Stranger's Bar.
Drink too much and are quite damaged.
Yes.
We've got lots of choices there.
It's like harassment problems.
No one is immediately suggesting themselves to me, which suggests to me that, I mean,
maybe politics is doing its job in weeding these particular kind of liability characters out.
So when you were looking for Bond, why were you not looking for Eddie Redmayne?
Okay.
I'm a big fan of Eddie Redmayne, but he does not have the right energy to be Bond.
He's got a much more sort of fae screen persona in lots of ways, and that's great.
It's a different thing, but he's not that particular character.
Timothy Chalamet?
Chalamet?
Don't be ridiculous.
Chalamet can't be Bond.
You can't. No, come on.
He's brilliant, by the way.
He is a proper screen star, and people turn out for him, and he's an A-lister, and he opens movies.
But no, he can't be Bond.
You can't just have anybody who is a star.
They have to be right for it, right?
The casting has to be right.
Who was the guy you were being really rude about before the break?
Gerald?
Gerard Butler.
No, listen, Gerard Butler.
Jerry Butler was never going to get it, but I love it.
He could do you a disaster movie in a heartbeat.
I'm a fan of his.
I'm a fan.
I've watched a lot of Gerard Butler movies.
Okay, so who is it we need for Bond, then, just to finish?
What's the character of Bond that we're looking for?
Well, there's sometimes the Bonds that end up being a reaction against the previous Bonds.
So Roger Moore was, you know, he tried to do something completely different to Sean Connery, which is good.
And I actually love Roger Moore's James Bond as well.
My kids love him.
That's the only one they ever watch.
Yeah, because of the humour, right?
It's the humour.
So maybe, I don't know, Robert Pattinson can do humour.
We might see more humour, because they're always a bit like Archibald Bishop's Canterbury.
They have to be able to do a reaction to the one that went before.
But so Daniel Craig was not, he didn't really do lots of jokes.
He was very intense and very serious and very kind of obsessive about how difficult the role was.
You know, you'd think it was going down in mine.
But I quite like it if there was someone a little bit sort of laconic and Roger Moore type about it
and just thinking that it's actually quite fun to go around the world having sex with girls in seven-star hotels.
You're pro-Rob Pattinson, but who would have been the alternative choice that could have been exciting?
Jack Loudon, I think.
Did you watch Show of Horses?
Oh, yeah.
Jack Loudon would have been great.
Jack Loudon would have been really good.
Callum Turner would have been really good.
Jack Loudon would have been really good as well, I think.
Where's he from?
He's done lots of things.
Did you see Masters?
I'm trying to think of things you might have watched.
Did you watch Masters of the Air?
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Yeah, he's in Masters of the Air, right?
So he's very, very good.
He's married to Dua Lipa, who I don't know if you listen to.
No, I've definitely seen those two in like pictures.
In pictures together.
They're wonderful, right?
They're a very cool couple.
Yeah, he would have been very good.
But Pattinson for me is the right choice.
Very good.
Thank you for coming on.
I'm honoured.
Thank you to Alistair Campbell for letting me sit in his chair.
We've covered a lot of ground.
We've covered tech bros and their imaginings and their power
and their accountability.
We've covered politics and communication.
We've covered environment, Cop and James Bond.
Thank you very much.
Thanks so much, Rory.
Thank you.
Listen up.
Sam's Club has pre-made dishes for a Thanksgiving feast
that's ready to be served.
Ready in two hours.
All while tasting suspiciously homemade.
Come join us.
Sam's Club.
Some personality quirks are really funny.
Like, I talk to my left foot more than I talk to my right.
You know what's not funny and not a personality quirk?
OCD.
Although the term OCD is widely recognised,
it's misunderstood by most people.
It doesn't mean being tidy or clean.
It's having obsessive fears, thoughts and urges.
You question yourself.
You question your character.
You question your safety.
That's OCD.
Breaking the OCD cycle takes effective treatment.
Go to nocd.com to learn more.
Give the gift of the cosiest bed with Boll & Branch Luxury Organic Cotton Sheets.
Only 1% of the world's cotton meets their standards of softness.
Treat the people you love to the comfort of Boll & Branch signature sheets, pillows and
more.
Feel the magic in every moment.
Save 25% site-wide at BollandBranch.com with code CHEERS.
Exclusions apply.
See site for details.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The immense power and wealth of tech leaders like Jensen Huang and Elon Musk have created a distorted political and cultural landscape, operating with near-impunity due to corporate structures.
These figures are often shielded from public scrutiny, with their influence amplified by a lack of accountability and a deliberate avoidance of political oversight.
The rise of AI and tech dominance has been fueled by speculative investment, exaggerated valuations, and a cultural fantasy of superintelligence, suggesting a potential bubble.
The public’s fear of AI is largely rooted in job loss and data center concerns, not existential threats, despite claims from AI leaders about a 20% chance of human extinction.
Tech leaders, including Musk and Huang, are influenced by fantasy and science fiction, which shapes their worldview and values, emphasizing individualism and conflict over cooperation.
Political communication has shifted toward entertainment, with figures like Trump excelling through drama, conflict, and performance, while others like Keir Starmer struggle with authenticity.
A fragmented, polarized media environment makes it difficult for voters to discern reliable news, with algorithms and personal biases shaping perception.
Environmental issues like COP are being sidelined, reflecting a decline in public priority despite past widespread commitment to ESG, especially among corporate leaders.
Summary:
The conversation explores the growing influence of tech billionaires like Jensen Huang and Elon Musk, whose unchecked power and wealth have distorted politics and culture. These figures operate within corporate systems that grant them immense immunity, often evading accountability and public scrutiny. Their rise is linked to a speculative AI bubble fueled by fantasy, exaggerated valuations, and a narrative of technological utopia, despite limited real-world revenue or practical outcomes.
Public fear of AI is primarily driven by job displacement and data center concerns, not existential threats, highlighting a gap between hype and reality. The cultural roots of tech leadership are deeply tied to science fiction and fantasy, emphasizing conflict, individualism, and dominance—values reflected in their communication styles. Politically, this shift has led to a move away from policy-focused discourse toward entertainment-driven performance, exemplified by Trump’s dramatic, wrestling-inspired style.
Meanwhile, political communication remains fragmented, with misinformation and algorithmic bias undermining trust in media. Environmental issues like COP are being sidelined, despite being central to corporate priorities just years ago. This decline reflects a broader societal shift in values, where sustainability and governance no longer dominate public and corporate discourse.
The conversation concludes that while tech power is reshaping politics, the public’s skepticism and disengagement suggest a need for greater transparency, accountability, and cultural realism in both governance and innovation.
FAQs
Tech leaders wield immense power due to their wealth, control over critical technologies, and corporate structures that grant them immunity from accountability. Their influence is amplified by a lack of public scrutiny and a cultural shift that treats them as 'cuddly inventors' rather than powerful figures.
Tech CEOs now operate at a scale surpassing national economies, creating a new form of power that bypasses traditional political oversight. This imbalance challenges democratic accountability and shifts policy debates toward technological control and innovation over public welfare.
The rise of AI reflects a deep-seated cultural fascination with technological progress and utopian visions, often fueled by science fiction. This has led to overinvestment in speculative technologies with unclear real-world benefits, creating a bubble driven by hype rather than practical outcomes.
Skepticism stems from fears about job loss, loss of control, and existential risks. People are especially wary of AI's potential to disrupt daily life, and many perceive the narrative as exaggerated or based on unrealistic assumptions about machine intelligence.
Strong, dramatic, or emotionally charged communication—like Trump’s wrestling-inspired style or Burnham’s authentic tone—can captivate audiences. However, authenticity and relatability are more effective than polished traditional rhetoric, especially in a media-saturated, polarized environment.
Yes, environmental issues like climate change have significantly dropped in public discourse, despite political commitments. This shift is partly due to economic priorities and a lack of media coverage, especially among younger generations who feel the urgency is not being adequately addressed.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.