Apology Not Accepted | Was it Real? The Hills Rewatch Podcast
48m 29s
Season two, episode 10 of The Hills Rewatch, titled "Apology Not Accepted," is a pivotal and emotionally charged episode that reshapes the show’s core relationships. It centers on Heidi’s internal conflict as she chooses to stay with Lauren instead of moving in with Spencer, despite earlier commitments—highlighting her emotional struggle between loyalty and personal desire. The episode also features Jen Bunny’s visit to Heidi’s workplace, where she tries to apologize for perceived betrayals, particularly around Brody, though the exact nature of their relationship remains ambiguous and confusing for viewers. Producers clarify that real emotional moments, such as Lauren’s frustration and Jen’s apology, were rooted in authentic cast experiences, not scripted manipulation. The episode culminates in a joyful surprise birthday party at Hide, where Spencer delivers a heartfelt toast, symbolizing a hopeful resolution in the friendships. This moment, along with the emotional depth of the conflicts, sets the stage for the turbulent third season. Producers emphasize that while some scenes were edited down for pacing, the raw emotions and real-life dynamics were central to the show’s authenticity. Fan questions about past relationships, like the rumored hookup between Justin and Lauren, are addressed with partial transparency, revealing ongoing mystery. Overall, the episode exemplifies the show’s strength in portraying genuine, complex human emotions, making it a defining moment in The Hills’ narrative journey.
Hey, Prime members, you can listen to WasitReal, the Hills Rewatch, Add Free on Amazon Music. Download the Amazon Music app today. Welcome back to WasitReal, the Hills Rewatch podcast. I'm Frankie Delgado here with my co-host, my favorite person, Adriana Patrick, Heidi Monteprat. We'll be right with us and Brody Jenner, who is available to join us today, unfortunately. He's still on his little baby moon, but he will be with us in the next episodes. Today, we are breaking down season two, episode 10, Apology Not Accepted, and it originally aired on March 19th, 2007, so it's been a while. It's been 16 years. Yes, well, and we have Andrew Perry here with us today. And I was about to do that. I was about to say, we have the magical and amazing. I like your introduction better, Stuart Frank. Producer. It's great to be here. Steve Hart, Andrew Perry. Yes, he was one of our favorites on the show, and he's actually been for our new listeners. He was on a few of the previous podcasts. Yeah, which it's really nice to have you, Andrew, because you clear things up for us. Things get a little blurry sometimes, and we have a lot of questions about Jen Bunny, and she pops up in this episode again. A lot of questions. I'll answer everything I can, contractually, of course. No, it's great to be here. Thank you. It's fun watching the show again, even though it was, as you said, a while ago. I'm sure it was, I was crazy for us too, but I'm sure as being a producer on the hills, it was crazy for you guys going through just everything with editing, and then we were talking about the paparazzi, whenever we were filming, and just having to. There's a ton of moving parts, and also as I was watching it, I was realizing how much how we shot, played a role, and how we told the story. The night of Lauren's party, birthday party that's in this episode, that all happened. It all happened in a row, but a lot of the prep for it was a day before I'm sure we did prep stuff afterwards too, which is the stuff that you don't usually think of. We're guiding the story, we're trying to form it into something, and it was a trip, because I remember that night at hide. I remember all of that stuff, but it was, you know, again, it's a while ago. Andro, Adriana, this is a very, very, very important episode. It changes a lot of things in life. It really does. This is when Frankie Delgado actually pops in at Lauren's birthday party at hide, and you finally can put my face on. Finally Frankie's on all the episodes and seasons and places where I was just there on the background. You guys finally use my beautiful face. And, you know, hey, I love that. You know, when I was watching at home, I freesed it, of course, just so I can make sure it was you. You're glowing front. You still look great. I mean, it's, you know, it's you were younger. It's was younger, younger, younger thinner. I had a job back then and no facial hair. So yeah, I still look good. Frankie, you're handsome. Well, let's, so this episode for those of you guys tuning in, it's basically Heidi throws Lauren a surprise party for her birthday. She's turning 21, and Jen Bunny, it decides to apologize and tries to level with Lauren about what really happened with Brody. So this is a very juicy episode. Very juicy, because there's so much little details that really change by the, you think it's about to change. Yeah, it really does. After this episode, the next two or three, really, it just changes everything, every friendship, relationship. And that's wife, Ep's season three was one of the biggest seasons the hills ever had, because it leaves you on this like, was this the end? And everybody goes their own separate ways or is this coming back? And they have, and they want more, right? Everybody wanted more. This is right. I feel like this really, right? Andrew is when it started really kicking off and people were interested. And it did in between seasons after Lauren, you know, didn't go to France. I think that build, it built up a lot of viewer expectation for the beginning of this season. And then the thing that I liked about this episode and this season is that we were getting into bigger, real heartfelt problems. It wasn't just, I'm going to drop out of school or, you know, Jason is sometimes my boyfriend or sometimes isn't. We were getting into the real dynamics that we really wanted the show to be, because the show is, you know, we wanted to tell the story of four women living in Los Angeles, and, and the dynamic of that. And I think you see a lot of that with, with the relationships of, you know, different things are pulling Heidi in different directions, different things are pulling, you know, Jen Bunny in a different direction too. So, I mean, this episode, it's the scene that kicks off this whole episode is when Heidi breaks it to Lauren, that Spencer wants her to move in with him. Spencer asked me to move in with him. Yeah, load told me. I was surprised he's told low before me though. And Lauren expresses how she was disappointed that she told low before her. That was in the New Year's Eve. But Heidi tells Lauren that she's decided to stay at the Hillside Villas with Lauren. And she's not moving in with Spencer. And then Lauren was relieved. And she just says, and Lauren had the best quotes like the one liners always. Yeah. She said how finding a good roommate is like a good pair of jeans. You hang on to them. That is true though. It is. A good pair of jeans is isn't just out there. And when you do find one, I know, I know, I know for fact that I have my pair of jeans that I will not let go. And they're my cotton citizen jeans. They're the best jeans ever. Yeah. And I can never find another pair of jeans like those. I have a good pair. They're really ripped and beat up. But I still wear them. You got to wear them. You do. You got to. Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, and when Heidi, Heidi's going to join us, she's with the baby right now. But when she joins us, yeah, we got to ask her about like what she, what made what made her change her mind in that moment to say, Hey, I'm not. She had already kind of committed the other way in her heart with low telling low that she's going to move out. And now she's like, No, I don't know, never mind. Bamboozled. Yeah. I think she's kind of in a pickle. She loves Spencer and wants to give him that, you know, move in with him. But then and she'll, she'll be able to speak for herself when she comes on. But she did love Lauren as well. Yes, she did. So she does. I don't know. She was, yeah, in a pickle. Didn't know what to do. So true. So true. So what do you remember of this Andrew from the Heidi Lauren moments that we shot? I know that those, you know, I'm sure that we told Heidi, let Lauren know what you want. Like if you want to move out, let her know that if you don't want to move out, let her know that too. So it was a free will. Yeah. I'm sure we shot. I'm sure we shot both ways. Yeah. Well, I'm not sure if we did that. If we said it that way, we would do both ways sometimes. Let's try it this way. Well, we're, you know, I, we're trying to craft a story, you know, and it's, it's trying to make sense out of chaos. And so we want options when we're editing. But also it's like we're not going to fake that Heidi's living there. If she's not, or we're not not going to fake that she's living with Spencer if she didn't truly want to. It's not like, and now go live with Adrina and Frankie and Brody's going to be your new friend. It's like we're trying to thread the needle through. It's already what's happening. Yeah. Is this close enough to what they're really, to what Heidi was really feeling. And I'm sure she'll tell us. I know that that for Lauren, not to speak for her, but it was a very, you know, I'm sure the low thing was upsetting to her. But, you know, I'm sure also this was probably shot months afterwards. So it wasn't news to Lauren. But it was news the way she was finding out inside the show. That's what I remember. And the other parts of like I don't dispenser move in with me moment. I don't remember that one. But I, you know, it obviously happened. And I'm sure it's something that we knew was going to be in that scene. Like he might have told us that too. Okay. Yeah. And in this episode, Heidi comes to my apartment and she's planning Lauren a surprise birthday party. And I thought it was she fooled me when I was rewatching this. I got fooled. Really? Yeah. Because I thought she really wasn't going to go. Oh, because she was talking in the scene. Yeah. Saying that, you know, she's going to bail on Lauren. Like last minute. And then I was going to swoop. And I'm be like, okay, well, I'll take you out. Hello. Oh my god. She totally body. It's going to be fun. Should I bring her? I'll bring her like at 915. Perfect. She totally won't know. And make it seem like, you know, just a surpriseer to really make her surprise. But I knew I was like, Lauren is going to be mad. Right. And she was in the show. I mean, that wasn't, we didn't say now, now Heidi's going to pretend to tell you something.
and now get angry. That was Lauren's reaction. We wanted to keep the surprise party, a surprise party. I mean, I'm sure we shot the scene where you say, "I'll go out with you," Lauren, but it's not in the show, right? I think in this scene, it was, yeah. She calls you. Oh, she does. I guess what? Oh, okay. She's on the stairs. She calls. Oh, that's right. Yeah. Heidi. I went to go meet Spencer, blah, blah, blah, and then I'm like, "Well, I'll take you out," right? So that's kind of how it. I forgot that. Yeah. I know sometimes though, like it wouldn't be like a real, we would do the call, but it would be like Sophia. Yeah. Sophia, the talent producer. Yeah. She'd be like, "Okay, I'm going to call you and pretend like I'm Lauren." Well, we have to keep things going. And also, I mean, for that one, I think we didn't want to have our producer fingerprints on it. So if we said Lauren, "Call Adriana," why am I calling Adriana? I thought I was going to dinner with Heidi. Like, she would know that we're trying to do something, and we didn't want to show our hand that the party was a surprise. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, putting this puzzle together. Yeah. Well, that's, I mean, that's the gig, you know. Like, you're shooting stuff mostly in order. You're editing it, and then you're figuring out what, yeah, what section are we missing? Do we know that Heidi feels this way, or Lauren feels this way? And, you know, we've talked about it before. Without interviews, I don't, we can't get inside the cast member's head. You know, we can't cut to, I was bummed that Heidi left me, and I didn't even know what I was going to do the rest of the night. That's me being Lauren. It's, it's, so we, you know, we had to think about maybe we need a scene that explains that. We didn't that time. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It was very, it was very much like a soap opera. Yeah. I mean, I think we thought of it that way. We knew you guys are real people, but we also wanted to, to tell the story that, that we could tell with your lives. You know, it's not like we're gonna, and now you're this person, and now you're that, no, you're who you are. Yeah. Exactly. Well, this next scene is when Jen Bunney decides to drop by Heidi's workplace to kind of, she's frustrated because she hasn't talked to Lauren, and she wants to know if Lauren is upset, and that, I mean, she basically says that she can't believe that Lauren would be upset with her over sloppy thirds. I haven't talked to my best friend of 15 years for like, what, three weeks for what sloppy thirds, like that's good. That's way. I don't understand that. Well, this is where it's really confusing because Andrew, we had Jen on for the last couple episodes, and she said she never, ever kissed Rodi. They never hooked up, like absolutely nothing ever happened. Some of it was manipulated by the producers, and well, as you know, as producers, we, we never say manipulated. No, what, I mean, what I remember, what I remember, you made a show. Yes, exactly. But what I remember from that time was that we were going off what we thought had happened between Jen and Brody, which we thought was a kiss. I mean, I don't know if there was more, but we did, I don't think we were manufacturing that. And then when, when, yeah, that's when I remember there was a kiss in the back of a car, like it was nothing, you know, it was just a kiss. It wasn't that's how I, I mean, I don't remember because I wasn't there, but that's how we were thinking of it in story. And then we needed Jen to tell someone, in this case, it was Heidi. And Heidi's really quick in this scene. She doesn't want to, you know, she doesn't want to be there. It feels like because she wants, she doesn't want to get in the middle of Lauren, right between Lauren and Jen. And, and, you know, I, we didn't feed Jen the line. Oh, use the line sloppy thirds referencing Brody, which she didn't kiss him. And why would she call him sloppy thirds? Right. We I'm very confused. No, I'm surprised that that that's how Jen remembers it. That's, you know, I'm not, I'm not. But she was very affected by it. Like she seemed affected by it by how it all went down, how it all turned out at the end and how she lost her friendship with Lauren. And, and, and in that perspective, I did feel, you know, a little like damn, like something like this could really. Yeah, it affects it. 16, 17 years later, you're still like totally, I mean, I know that no one on on the producerial side was like, let's bust these people up. And how do we do that? We, we make up a relationship. No, we're trying to take real actions and understand those repercussions. And, and the stuff that comes later is also all real. Like, and when I say all real, I mean, we're doing a scene with Jen and Lauren. Lauren knows that Jen's coming. Jen knows that Lauren's going to be there. And Lauren has something to say. And I'm sure Jen had something to say. And that's what that scene is. You know, and the same with this one, Heidi knew this was going to happen. But you still don't want, you know, somebody coming by work, if you don't. Oh, no, you could tell. And when Heidi comes on, she could like say how she felt, but it seems like she was so uncomfortable with Jen just showing up there. But in the episode, she's like, I'm just going to wash my hands. Right. I want nothing to do with this more drama. Like, I'm not giving you advice. I'm not doing this. I'm staying out of this one because she knew that Heidi. It's a hot potato. Yeah. Heidi knew that the Jen made a mistake. Like Jen seems in this episode, like she's admitting that she did something. No, no, she's saying sorry for something. Right. Right. So you're saying sorry. What do you say sorry for? What is it for? And no one just no one saying Jen going and apologize. And Jen wasn't going, oh, I didn't do anything, but we need an apology. We're not we're not making it up like that. Yeah. We're we're we're presenting. We're shooting schedules. And like, okay, Jen, you know, the come by the house at four Lauren. That's what's happening. We'll be set up. That's the part we're controlling. Well, I think they really did want Jen really did want to have a conversation with Lauren, but Lauren wouldn't talk to her outside of filming. Oh, correct. Yes. So when she showed up, that was her only chance to talk to Lauren. And that's I mean, that's I'm sure you guys remember, we've we would encourage you not to talk before scenes because we talked about that. Yeah. We wanted all in the scene because we don't know how much of the story we're going to be able to tell. And and if if if you guys are doing, um, if you're whatever beefs you have or disagreements or or anything, if that gets cleared up before we can shoot it, the show isn't as good. When you you feel it from watching the episode, you feel the emotions like, you know, but that that affected the cast members in the not me, by the way, the cat, the the the actual girls who like really wanted to talk about it beforehand, maybe and some of them didn't because of how it would portray on the show. It's not authentic. And yes or no, but sometimes it was like for for Heidi, a lot of what I'm listening to with Heidi's on Heidi's side is that she really wanted to talk before because she was real and she felt real and she wanted to say whatever she needed to say before the because before the camera. She didn't want it to be for the camera. She wanted it to be for her real life. For the sake of their friendship and so everybody, I mean, so people have different needs, right? So when when cast members like you guys and we're encouraging you, why don't you save it for the scene because we want the real emotion. We we don't want Lauren remembering 10 minutes ago or Jen remembering. I said a good line. We want it to feel real. That said, that's the the that's what the show needs. Is it what your friendship needs? That's, you know, probably not. That's what was always hard for me filming personally is like even with Justin. It was bringing people on that I truly, truly had a connection with or truly like where I was involved with because with filming, they don't always understand the filming aspect of it and it's like there's a lot of blurred lines and there's a lot of chest issues and confusion of what's like, did you really mean that or like, you know, it's like hard. It is, I mean, I do this and and and the show, I think takes that into account. But it's also, I mean, Justin, I know is he you knew him before we started shooting, right? Yes. And we really liked him, as I'm sure you know. And and it was like, well, then what what story can we tell with them? And then it is also after shooting, there's nothing stopping anyone from going, you know, that I, you know, I'm sorry this happened in front of in front of the camera. This is what what I think needed to happen. But there are also people, you know, I'm not sure we haven't gotten into later seasons where, you know, someone comes in to a scene, you're not expecting them. They're miked. And you're like, oh, I remember those. Yeah. And so, I mean, I'm not saying that's the way to do it. I'm just saying, there's a, you know, I don't know, there's a lot of dynamics. I'm not trying to defend it all because I enjoy what I enjoy making shows, you know? Yeah. I think that's why I was a little hesitant or just kind of. I was trying to be politically correct with my with my cast members because I didn't want to have those issues of problems with them. And I think that's why I sucked for reality TV because I wasn't as as just blunt as you had
to be a certain location where you really wanted to say something and have somebody else's back completely and you're like, I'm not going to do that because if I do that, you got hate me now too. And I'd just rather be like, hey, try to piece it out in the most positive way possible. And maybe it worked or not, but for me, it just always felt like, yeah, that's why I'm not shooting a hundred scenes and the people that we're being honest and being blunt. Well, right. I think we're as producers, we're leaning into, we're leaning into the cast members who are less, have a less of a filter and are more, more ready to sort of walk that tight rope with either their friends or their friend of me or whoever they are. And it's like, yeah, does it screw with your head? I'm sure that it does, you know, but we're not. And you know, you've got five producers going, yeah, go ahead, yeah, sure, it's fine. Who cares? You know, like, it'll be finally at her. Yeah. Just say sorry. I'll be right. I don't, I don't want to. Well, Jen, when she was like, whether she was encouraged or not to flirt with Brody or to hook up with Brody or be with Brody or hang out with Brody, whatever it was. At the end, there was a real friendship behind those words. Right. And she decided to go with, I am going to flirt with Brody for the show's sake, whether she was encouraged or not. She did that. And for Glory. And I think that's where she was like, hey, dude, whether it was for the show or not for the show. Right. You did that to me. And I'm not going to put up with that because you betrayed me. Yeah. I mean, you see Lauren is genuinely like upset with her. She's betrayed. And that's, and it wasn't just because of Brody. I think, and I think in this episode, Lauren talks about her low rings it up someone that Jen bunny and her had issues prior, but they don't talk about what those issues were. Right. I mean, we didn't, I didn't, when, when Lauren talked about it, I didn't know any of the, did Jason make out story that she tells? Oh, yeah. I didn't. We had no idea about that. I forgot about that. Yeah. So it's in the episode. Lauren tells Brody at the lunch. Brody and Lauren go to lunch. And they talk about New Year's Eve and Jen bunny. And Lauren tells Brody that when she first met Jason, Jen knew that she had a crush on Jason. And then she went and made out with Jason and then Jason made out with her later. Did you know that the night I kissed Jason, Jen kissed him first? I tell Jen, I kind of like Jason, she's like, I got you back, got you back. She went to another room to talk to him, apparently made out with them. So it's just like as a friend, you don't do that. So I think Lauren had resentments. Yeah. And she brings it up when she, when her and Jen are talking to when Jen's line that we used is don't even talk about that, which I get. Jen doesn't, I mean, you know, she doesn't want to talk on camera about that. And I'm sure that's something that obviously if Lauren's bringing it up, I'm guessing it's on set. And it hasn't been settled with the both of them. It's, you know, it's, it is. It's a fine line because you don't want to be a cheerleader for someone's getting into an argument. You know, but that moment that ends the show is a real moment. It's, it's not made up. You can tell you can feel it from cold, it's yeah. It's cold in there. Yeah. Gosh. Well, in the next scene, I, I, so I end up getting Lauren, we're driving in the car and I'm like, okay, I'm just going to go along with her being mad. How do you cancels first? Oh, yeah. So Heidi cancels on Lauren. And I thought that was like, I'm like, how could she? Is her birthday? I'm aware you're falling for it like a little, and it's Spencer. Oh, that is a good, yeah. And you know, that's definitely something Lauren believed because that is believable. But that, how good is the show that you're like, you're, I'm watching again, I'm 41 years old now. And I'm like, what? I know. You get sucked in. I'm sucked in too. And so then I end up taking Lauren to hide, to go out one, two, one, two, three, four. Little does she know that all of her friends are there and she walks in and she's so surprised and so happy. And she's my face. Is it? What? Frankie on the heels. Frankie Delgado. I got to freeze this moment. Yeah. I know it's my birthday, but Frankie Delgado's here. And that was her 21st. That was a fun night at Hyde. That was so much fun. And you guys rented that out. It was just, it was all Lauren and her friends. Yeah. But we had the deal, you know, Bolt House was friends of ours. It was a fun night also because we weren't, there was no agenda that night. It wasn't like, oh, let's, let's troll with Lauren and find this moment or let's, we need looks of people being angry. Yeah. There was no stories really going on either. And I mean, Spencer gave, I'm sure we didn't like Spencer gave that toast that was I thought truly heartfelt and kind and really like, and that's what I wanted to ask you. How, how, how was Spencer there? And this is a question for Hyde, I guess, but how was Spencer there at Lauren's birthday party and everybody was cool with him being there because they, they had no relationship up to then. Yeah. Except for on New Year's, she was like, hey, peace by, and they said, by to each other. And now he's at the birthday party, which is an intimate situation and he does the toast. Yeah. That for me, watching it. And I think it almost gives the viewers hope that like, oh my gosh, they're all going to be friends. Like everything's going to smooth over and she's fine. I mean, that's how we, we, I mean, we wanted it to feel that way. We also didn't want it to be a weird thing every time Spencer and Lauren were in proximity to each other. And I think it's also when you're watching it, it's like, that seems very adult, very grown up, very like, okay, Spencer's, you know, he, he says that they're not the best of friends, but because Lauren or because Heidi loves you, so do I or some version of that. It's what you would hope with guys, you, you know, like, I'm sure you've been to birthday parties and you're like, why is that person here? But, but it doesn't, right, but your head doesn't explode and you don't, you know, life continues. Yeah. And, and, and I thought that was a very mature play from both sides of like, he showed up for Heidi because it's, Lauren says, Lauren is very important to Heidi. So Spencer makes it a mission to, if it's important to you, it's important to me now. So I'm going to, I'm going to, I'm going to get up here in front of everybody and see a little toast. Yeah. And Lauren really had no idea, like no idea when I was watching it, because I haven't watched it in, in a while, um, 17 years, I was like, watching it, I was thinking, Oh, God, what's he going to say? Because it's, you never know with Spencer, that's part of the fun of Spencer. And it's like, is he going to screw this up? But he doesn't. I mean, that's what, I mean, I, I love that moment, you know, there was a really sweet moment. This episode's next three episodes, just change everything about the future of the show. So what we were talking about earlier, so Jen comes into this next scene and this is what closes the episode out, but she does arrive. And this is where they have that conversation and Lauren is like, she's really upset. Well, I just have been trying like, really hard to like talk to you. I know. Well, I'm saying like, you've tried really hard, so like, talk to me now. How long was that scene like sometimes, you know, you film for a while and then with editing it's cut down, but did Jen have anything else to say? Because in this, in this scene, she really didn't have much to say. You know, I don't, I didn't keep notes, but I would guess that was a very long scene because that means that we were probably shooting for, you know, an hour, at least of just the content of them on the couch, because we wanted to get it out. I mean, that's part of the, you know, the show's 20-something minutes, we're cutting down a lot, we're giving you the best of, but it's a very concentrated moment and we wanted it to feel that way. But I mean, I kind, I remember that night and I'm sure we were all, you know, the crew was, the producers were on the balcony watching monitors thinking, okay, you know, Lauren said a lot of the points, Jen's responded as you would think she would, you know, it felt, you know, and then the closing of the door at the end was also, I mean, that wasn't us, that was, that was like I said, it was a cold moment. Yeah, but with that cold moment, Luke, who just walked in the door. Hello. Hi. Hi. Hi. Hi. Hi. Hi. Hi, Heidi. It's been a while. Nice to see you. Hi, Heidi. Hi. Hi, Heidi. It's been a while. Which is great. I hope your baby isn't sick for long. Thank you. So, Heidi, we needed you. We needed you for a lot of these questions and we're crazy. So I mean, at the top, this is whenever Heidi breaks it, you break it to Lauren that Spencer invited you to move in with him. And then Lauren expresses her disappointment that you told Lo before her. But then you actually tell Lauren that, you know, you've decided to stay put and you're not going to move in with Spencer. Do you want to? And I told them that I wasn't going to go, so I'm happy that I decided to stay here with you. But this is what we were saying earlier before you came on. It's like, this is where you're in that pickle of wanting to please Lauren and save your friendship and be with her. But then also, you know, having Spencer who loves you and wants to start a life with you and that. Do you remember what do you remember from this scene? Did you change your mind for real? Yeah, because I think later you do change your mind.
your mind. And you end up obviously moving in with Spencer. But in this moment, you get married. Yeah, right. And then they had kids too, I think. Yeah. Yeah. But in this scene, it's like you're kind of back and forth in this episode with Lauren and then with Spencer. You know, it was just a really challenging time. And I think I was just really excited and told low and I didn't get a chance to tell Lauren. So it just wasn't strategically telling low and not Lauren. You know, when something happens and you just get excited in the moment, you just want to tell somebody and you know, I just think that Lauren and I weren't able to have that moment. And like you saw in real life or off camera. So drinks are flowing. It's fun. You know, I'm excited that even had that conversation with Spencer not having conversations about who knows what else. And it was a really hard decision to make. And so I wanted her to know like I'm not just jumping ship. And that I did need to have that conversation with her. Well, and you're planning her surprise party to in this episode her 21st. So you are like trying as a friend to, you know, make her happy and show that, you know, you're making effort and you want to be a part of her life and her a part of your life. The party was amazing. I totally forgot about this episode until I watched it. But I remember that night. It was so much fun. Everybody got along. Spencer had the speech, which was really surprising, right? And Lauren didn't mind it. Heidi, the love of my life loves Lauren more than any in the world. So that makes Lauren an amazing person. We don't see eye to eye, but they do. So in the end of the day, we all see eye to eye. I, you know, Lauren and I, I think this is right when we had a trip to, I know, Utah or somewhere. And I think right in between here, we just had it like in a lone trip together. And it was a time for us to kind of just be together. We didn't like talk about a lot of heavy things, but it just reminded us of our friendship and that bond. And I think that was a really healing trip for us. And just to get a chance to get out of LA and out of producers and out of the cast and everything away from that. So here is a moment where I just thought, okay, everything's good. I can have the best of all worlds. I can have my relationship with Lauren and be able to stay with her and live with her and show her that I am making a big effort, which is what she wanted and have Spencer come in, kind of wave the white flag a little bit and have them coexist because at the end of the day, they never had a direct problem. Like Lauren really liked Spencer to a point where I was like, "Whoa, that's my boyfriend in the beginning." I mean, she wasn't like, okay, don't take that wrong, everybody. And those two got along and they got, you know, it was the four of us for a while, like we always say. So just the pull of me and the things that happened in between made them really kind of have this resistance between each other. But it was nice to be able to have that be set aside and regardless of how they felt for each other, letting Lauren have spend to be able to show up was a big deal and on camera. Well, and how did you, because watching this too, and I know we had a scene talking about how we were going to, you know, fake her out and like you were going to bail on her last minute and say get a call from Spencer and I was like, "Oh, she's going to be mad." Like she was genuinely upset. That was real. Like she really thought that was like real. Probably not the best plan. I know. Looking back and watching it, I'm like, "Wait, we were happy with it." Yeah, I'm sure. Yeah, I'm sure. I'm thinking we're just like, what would be happy? Yeah, well, what could I do to like get her out and we're going and like party fun mode and have her like be dressed up and ready to go and celebrating that and then get her there. And then I thought like it could kind of play as a joke on everything that's happened and hard feelings. And I think it's one of those jokes that like happens too soon. You're like, "Oh, that was kind of like the burn." But I was just, yeah, we're just, and also for TV and, you know, we're trying to just keep it exciting and entertaining and make a TV show. Yeah. Okay, so then Jen Bunny comes to your work in this episode. I mean, you seemed really uncomfortable with her being there because she wants to know what's going on with Lauren. Do you remember this? I think you told her that you just didn't want to be a part of it, but that's between them basically. I didn't expect the fallout to be so catastrophic with Jen either. And at this point, I just thought, yeah, I think that we didn't think Lauren had such a thing with them. Rody at that point, you know? So like from that time to watching how it played out and how upset Lauren really was, I think she was obviously more upset with Jen than me. And Jen even says like she couldn't believe that Lauren was so upset over sloppy thirds about Rody because it just kind of like seems like Jen maybe, and then at the end kind of apologizes for something, but I know when we had Jen on, she said that they never kissed or anything happened. So I don't, it's like for the viewers and listeners, it's just confusing. But you can tell on the show that there's it, there's, there's intent of like, oh, yeah, you really think Rody would want to be with me? I'm watching this scene. It was confusing because you really think that like, I mean, she did, it seems like she did maybe hook up with Rody. And she's excited about like, like the fact that she has a shot at Rody. And she's excited about like when they're at the LADU upstairs and they're talk, you guys are talking and she's like, oh, am I going to make a move? Or like, you see, you know, like, you know, I mean, like, she didn't seem like she was, and maybe that's what upset Lauren, you know, that like, yeah, you're going to come into this show, which is my show. And you're going to go after my guy that I've been like, yeah, maybe that's what it was. I mean, I, yeah, I'm the public guy, right? Are you asked Andrew? What did you say? I, what I liked about the scene that ends the show between Jen and Lauren is that it, it feels real. I mean, and that to me means it was real. Lauren's not faking it in nor is Jen. And Jen is actually apologizing for something, which I now, you know, it seems that she's saying nothing happened. We weren't saying to her, go in and, you know, try to clear the air. That was something Jen wanted to do. I mean, I'm sure Lauren wanted to speak her mind too. But if Jen is saying she didn't hook up or she didn't kiss Brody, then what's the, what's the anger about? I think the anger from Lauren was feeling blindsided by her friends, right? She's feeling frustrated that we were with Brody and Spencer and even asking her like, hey, like putting her on the spot. I think, I think that's where her frustration came from. Like, all right, you guys know he's like my on camera, whatever boyfriend that I did have a crush on because she did. She really had a, a thing for them. And I didn't play out. And she was with me with other guys. And I also think in Laguna, like because it's so small probably, like a lot of their friends growing up hooked up with friends and hooked up with friends, like it just wasn't such a big deal from what I took when I spent some time down there. But I think you're right. I think that she was mad that that whole thing happened and it felt kind of like behind her back even though we were trying to like call her and be like, hey, is this really cool? Or is it not? Like, what do you think? So yeah, I think that was frustrating for her. Her and Jen of them best friends since preschool. And she just felt like, you know, betrayed by her. And again, looking for a reason to just be like, I'm done with this. So I think there was genuine anger with the whole situation. And I think that with the falling out with me too, like a lot of it had all been put together with Lauren's emotions and not compartmentalized. Like, okay, no, I'm angry about this with this. I'm angry about this with this. You know, she's going through a lot quickly on camera and sorting it out. And it's kind of all bleeding into each other. So to me, that seems like a big, you know, it's still, it's still so unfortunate that Jen and Lauren haven't buried the hatchet. I mean, like, there's no reason in my mind. Like, it shouldn't have gone that far. Okay, whatever Europe said that maybe she thought Brody, who half of Hollywood was trying to hook up with, you know, and Jen's flattered, you know, she'd never had a guy like Brody. And we were all hanging out. And it was cool. And, you know, they lived near each other. And Laguna, like they should still be kids the same age. Yeah. Yeah, this was, there was a lot going on in this episode. Yeah. But I think, I think we should get into the fan questions at this point. Lots of questions. Yeah, lots of questions. Lots of this episode, this next three episodes are going to be rough for like, I think just yeah, just for and then it third season gets crazy. Yeah, but if for the new listeners out there, if you guys have any questions, you can always ask us a question or leave us a voice mail at speakpipe.com/thighills. Or you can message us on our Instagram @thighillsrewatch or on YouTube.
- Here's our first question from Christine Bordrenand. Was the rumor that Justin Bobby hooked up with Lauren real? If not, who started it? - It was real. So what happened? We had a-- - Oh, see how mad it is. - We had a mutual, this, okay, our friend Dino, Justin and I is friend Dino. He's passed away now, but he's the one that told me. And he was a pretty good friend and he was acting so weird for me to me for three weeks. And then he finally fessed up because he couldn't hold it in. And he said that just him and Justin were in Vegas. And I guess Lauren was there too for agenda, or one of those trade, I don't know, one of those shows out there in August for fashion stuff. And they ran into her and then they went to the planet Hollywood and that they hooked up. And so when I found that out, I called Lauren and I called Justin. Lauren hung up on me and then she went answer and then Justin, remember, I told you guys immediately. - I have done sincerely, I have no memory of this. - And then Justin would not talk to me either. And so nobody would talk to me or give me answers and tell me like, but they waited until the cameras were there to talk to me. So that's been Lauren would actually speak to me. That was when the cameras were rolling. And then Justin did the same thing. He wouldn't talk to me either until the cameras were rolling. - That is so frustrating. - And they just said that I was delusional and what I was making things up and like on it. And I was like, I'm not like, I wish that we could get Dino to clear this up and say so. - Well, I've never heard any of that. Sincerely, I knew there was a rumor. That's what I'd heard. - Yeah. Yeah, that was, that's it. - And it's kind of constant. It's not gonna divulge any more information on this. - Me? - I don't know. Sincerely, I had no idea if that happened. - I mean, I talked about it to Chiara and one of the, this will be in the later seasons, I think. But I talked to Chiara about it on camera, about the details and then I filmed this scene with Lauren on camera and then Justin on camera to try to get answers and like, I was really upset. Sorry, and maybe that's after I was off the show. - But no, I think that was when you were off the show. I don't remember you being there for that. But I mean, yeah, Dino, our mutual friend Dino told me. So I don't know, maybe he assumed it happened. I don't know, but I was like really, really, I just felt like betrayed by both of them. - Andrew, what was one of your favorite memories about The Hills and what do you think sparked the magic of the success of the show? - Wow, that's a good question and thank you. I loved the first season. I think the beginning of it and discovering the friendships of the four of you was really, although, you know, some of that was definitely manufactured, meaning we put you all together. We introduced Adrina to you and Lauren. Whitney was just, you know, wasn't something we had planned for it, it all just happened. And I loved when all of that came together as a story. I think because we were trying to tell the story of four young women in Los Angeles. And the first season and Teen Vogue and that, you know, the party of letting people in or not, whatever that dynamic was like, it was just, it was so new, prior to making The Hills for myself and most people who work in the world of alternative television or unscripted. - I had alternative television, I've never heard that one. - Is we were just trying to shoot a series and it was just, you know, did it look good? That was never on your mind, you know? You were just trying to capture all the action and then try to tell a story. I think this show enabled the people to make it. I'm talking about everyone, the crew and the cast to start thinking about, this is really beautiful. How can we visually tell a story? And so that to me, that was the part of it. It was mind expanding when the show began. I've mentioned this before because we didn't have interviews. You know, we were trying to tell stories without, you know, you looking at camera and saying, that lunch didn't go very well. You know, we needed you to then tell someone else in a scene. Oh, Jen Bunny came over and I think this isn't gonna be great. Something, it just, it expanded in my mind, at least that. And I think part of the reason of its success was, as I'm sure you guys all know, there are many real moments in the series, huge ones that are heartfelt from both sides. And around that, we have other scenes that we're trying to tell the story with. And so, were those as real, they're used as a story tool, you know, if that, does that make sense? Yeah. Sure does. You can cut that down a lot too, I hope. (laughing) No, that's a good, that's a good, that's a good, that's a good explanation. Okay, well, this could be again for Andrew Perry, you know? Okay. Do you, do you have anything that you would have wanted to keep in an episode that just never made it that you remember that you're like, oh, this would have been so great for the episode. Good question. And it is a good question. What, when we were editing, I don't have a specific, oh, you know, Whitney falls down the stairs or something like that, God forbid. But the things that we cut out of the show when we were editing it were usually humor, because humor, we saw the show as having real moments of, of. Soba Bra. Yeah, of, but of a laughter and of like, that's a funny moment, that's charming, but if it didn't address story, it was the thing that had, it, only for time. If, if we were able to squeeze time somewhere else, we would leave in that moment. And also, I think, you know, we're shooting a few scenes a day. There were lots of fun moments, and some of them didn't make it into the show, unfortunately. I don't have, there isn't like some, you know, we all went, oh, this thing should have made it. Right, we all went zip lining and we had to cut it. No, I don't have anything like that, sorry. Okay. Thank you so much for coming on. We're excited to get the BTS and everything from you. My pleasure to be here. Thank you so much for having me. We love you, we love having you with, it's twice now. So hopefully we have your third time. Yeah, especially third season. I would love to, it's great talking about it. And I'm learning stuff too, sincerely. Oh, amazing, amazing. So now you can listen to exclusive bonus content. Plus at free episodes by signing up at cast media.com/castplus. And that's cast with a K media.com/castplus. Thank you so much for listening and watching. Please follow, rate and review. Was it real? The Hills Rewatch, wherever you listen to your podcast. Five stars please. Five stars. If you're a list of stars, if you're a listener, remember you can watch us too on YouTube and now on Spotify. You can listen to the podcast on Spotify. And when you want to watch, you just turn the phone landscape and boom, it's a video. See you guys next week. I hope Brody's back next week. But if not, he's still probably going to be in his baby baby for a while. And Andrew, maybe you come next week. I'm around. So let's see how it goes. For coming and clearing the air about all the questions we had. We really appreciate you. Thank you so much. Heidi, thank you for showing up today. Appreciate you. Hi, you're welcome. You're welcome. Well, a better late than never. Hey, that's insane. I'm wrestling a baby over here. That's insane. All right, guys, bye. Bye. Bye.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Season two, episode 10 "Apology Not Accepted" marks a turning point in the series, shifting dynamics among key friendships, especially between Heidi, Lauren, and Jen Bunny.
The episode centers on Heidi’s decision not to move in with Spencer, despite prior commitments, highlighting her emotional struggle between loyalty to Lauren and her feelings for Spencer.
Jen Bunny visits Heidi’s workplace to apologize for unresolved feelings, sparking real tension and emotional depth, though the exact nature of her relationship with Brody remains ambiguous and debated.
The surprise birthday party at Hide is a pivotal, heartfelt moment where the cast reunites, showcasing genuine chemistry and emotional healing, especially with Spencer’s touching toast.
Producers emphasize the authenticity of the emotional conflicts, noting that real-life tensions, like Jen’s apology and Lauren’s betrayal, were not manufactured but stemmed from genuine cast experiences.
Key plot developments in this episode set the tone for the third season, shifting relationships and raising questions about loyalty, friendship, and trust.
The production team worked to maintain emotional realism by avoiding pre-emptive conflict resolution, allowing raw, unscripted emotions to emerge during filming.
Fan questions about past relationships (e.g., Justin and Lauren) reveal ongoing confusion, with producers confirming some rumors were real but not fully detailed due to privacy and on-set dynamics.
Summary:
Season two, episode 10 of The Hills Rewatch, titled "Apology Not Accepted," is a pivotal and emotionally charged episode that reshapes the show’s core relationships. It centers on Heidi’s internal conflict as she chooses to stay with Lauren instead of moving in with Spencer, despite earlier commitments—highlighting her emotional struggle between loyalty and personal desire. The episode also features Jen Bunny’s visit to Heidi’s workplace, where she tries to apologize for perceived betrayals, particularly around Brody, though the exact nature of their relationship remains ambiguous and confusing for viewers.
Producers clarify that real emotional moments, such as Lauren’s frustration and Jen’s apology, were rooted in authentic cast experiences, not scripted manipulation. The episode culminates in a joyful surprise birthday party at Hide, where Spencer delivers a heartfelt toast, symbolizing a hopeful resolution in the friendships. This moment, along with the emotional depth of the conflicts, sets the stage for the turbulent third season.
Producers emphasize that while some scenes were edited down for pacing, the raw emotions and real-life dynamics were central to the show’s authenticity. Fan questions about past relationships, like the rumored hookup between Justin and Lauren, are addressed with partial transparency, revealing ongoing mystery. Overall, the episode exemplifies the show’s strength in portraying genuine, complex human emotions, making it a defining moment in The Hills’ narrative journey.
FAQs
Heidi plans a surprise birthday party for Lauren at Hide, pretending to bail on her last minute to create drama. However, Lauren is unaware of the plan and is genuinely upset, only to be surprised when she sees Heidi and Frankie at the party.
The producers believed there was a kiss between Jen and Brody, though Jen herself has stated they never kissed or hooked up. This created confusion, as the scene shows Jen expressing frustration over being betrayed by Lauren.
Heidi was torn between her feelings for Spencer and her loyalty to Lauren. She chose to stay at Hillside Villas, staying true to her friendship with Lauren, even though she had feelings for Spencer.
The scene shows genuine emotion and real tension between Jen and Lauren, with Jen apologizing for her actions. The producers emphasized it felt authentic and not fabricated, highlighting the deep friendship wounds and betrayals.
The producers aimed to tell a real story and did not fabricate relationships, but they did interpret events based on what they thought had happened, such as the Brody-Jen kiss, which was not confirmed by the cast.
Lauren felt betrayed because Jen had been closest to her since childhood and she believed Jen was pursuing Brody behind her back, which she saw as a violation of their friendship and trust.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.