Anxiety, Overthinking, and Overwhelm: Buddhist Hacks For Changing Your Mind | Joseph Goldstein
1h 9m 33s
In this episode, Dan Harris interviews Joseph Goldstein on powerful, accessible mantras to manage overthinking, anxiety, and emotional reactivity. Central phrases like "up and out" and "tiny dictators" emphasize non-judgmental awareness, helping practitioners release attachment to thoughts and memories. Goldstein explains that aversion feeds suffering, and mindfulness—rooted in observing the feeling tone of thoughts—creates space for discernment. The concept of thoughts as "tiny dictators" reveals their automatic power, which diminishes when we observe them with awareness. Humor and counting thoughts serve as practical tools to disrupt self-criticism. Key reframes like "the thought of your mother is not your mother" and "if it's not one thing, it's another" offer perspective by grounding suffering in its inevitability. The idea that "things are always becoming otherwise" underscores impermanence, while "it's okay" fosters emotional acceptance, reducing reactivity to fear. Finally, reflecting on one’s core values—what truly matters most—enables wiser decisions and alignment with life’s deeper principles. These phrases, rooted in Buddhist teachings, provide a practical, compassionate toolkit for navigating the chaotic mind and finding peace in uncertainty.
(upbeat music) This is the 10% Happier Podcast, I'm Dan Harris. (upbeat music) Hello everybody, how we doing? This is an episode for overthinkers, warriors, the anxious, basically everybody. In this conversation, I talk to my long time friend and meditation teacher Joseph Goldstein about some time tested hacks he has for overthinking anxiety, overwhelm, and the like. For those of you unfamiliar with Joseph, he is the co-founder of the legendary retreat center, the Insight Meditation Society. He's also written such books as One Dharma and Mindfulness. This episode is part of an occasional series we've been running with Joseph where I interview him about the various teaching phrases he uses. Let me explain what I mean by that. Joseph likes to teach using pithy little mottos, Buddhist earworms that weasel their way into your brain and surface just at the moment when you need the most, these are incredibly helpful, little mantras that I use all the time in my own life. And by the way, the eventual goal of these interviews is to turn them all into a book, a collection of Joseph's phrases. So this is a great episode, you're gonna love it. Speaking of Joseph, by the way, you can learn from the man himself in his outstanding seven module meditation master class over on my new-ish meditation app, 10% with Dan Harris. From sensations to thoughts and emotions, this series gives you all the tools to build a practice, choose a focus, or simply begin again. In addition to Joseph's meditation master class, the app also includes a growing library of meditations from a bunch of world-class teachers, add free access to this podcast, exclusive live stream events every week with me and my many amazing meditation teacher friends. And one of the coolest things about it is we've got a robust, supportive, non-judgmental series of discussion threads where you can ask questions, share tips and struggles, and connect with our team and one another. There is a free 14-day trial if you want to try before you buy. Check it out at DanHarris.com. We'll get started with Joseph Goldstein right after this. Hello again, Joseph. All right, so I have compiled a bunch of phrases that I think, and it's possible that you'll have to correct me that I'm misusing the phrases, but I think these phrases all have to do with a not just trio of overthinking, overwhelming anxiety. And I've put the overthinking phrases, I've front-loaded those. So one that has been really helpful for me, and this is, I think I've heard you use it as specifically as a meditation instruction, but I think in my own life I've used it off the cushion, and it is up and out. - So there's an interesting backstory to this phrase. As there is with almost all of them, because they came out of kind of the lived experience of trying to put all this into practice. So this goes back to my early practice days in India. So I was quite young. My 20s were getting into long-term intensive meditation in India after the beginning period when my mind had really settled in this kind of in the flow. All of these ridiculous memories started flooding by mind, like receding old TV shows that I had seen as a kid like Father Knows Best, and you're probably too young to even know of that. - I've heard it. - Actually it was just one of these early, that my sitcoms, and the fact that they were still in my mind unbeknownst to me, you know those memories, but in the course of sitting they just started coming and coming and coming, and there were a lot of things like that when the mind gets a little more calm and collected and mindful and concentrated and all that, and still it seems like it opens the door to the emergence of all of these memories, images, thoughts that we've been carrying around have been carried in the mind over all these years. And some of them were just so ridiculous. Why are these coming up to the mind, you know? But that's when I began to get the sense, oh yeah, it's all in there. And now I really have the belief that everything we've ever experienced is stored somehow in this mystery called memory, which is kind of a mystery how all that works, but it's all in there. And when we make the space, it just all starts coming up and that's what up and out, because over time, it felt like a cleansing in a certain way. So they came, came, came, and then they stopped coming, you know, and then some other memories, so it was like that, and that feeling of allowing things to come up, be with them, be mindful and out. Sometimes it's about very unimportant things like we run the Father knows best, but sometimes it can be, you know, even difficult memories, or sometimes it've been traumatic memories, you know, that come up with practice and over time, if we can develop a kind of equanimity and being with them and seeing them, it deconditions the power they have in the mind, because we learn to see them without reactivity. So that's another example, okay, up and out. I found that over these many years, it really has freed the mind from a lot of these situations in the past that were difficult, or some kind of emotional struggle involved, and in having come up in the meditation and being with them in an equanimous way, again, it was up and out, and I think that's what creates that sense of more space in the mind, and more ease, and more freedom. - The way I have used it until now, it may be a somewhat limited deployment of the phrase, but when I'm bird-dogged by particularly persistent thoughts that are no longer useful, it's just a rehash up and out, up and out. - Yes. - It's not hostile, it's just like, let's move it along, kids. - Yes, yes. - No, it's a phrase that can both suggest to us, but also reflect what's happening, that it's a way of letting go, it's just a way of letting go of whatever attachment or identification with them, was there that keeps them lodged in. So I think it could be used to describe on a lot of different levels, how that process happens. - It seems key to me, this is an error I've made many times, it seems key to me not to have a creeping aversion. - Absolutely, there's one principle, and I think in meditation and in life, that when we have aversion to something, it's actually feeding it, it's strengthening it. And so, not only is aversion, itself and unto my state, it's also counterproductive in terms of relating to whatever it is that we have aversion to. It's actually strengthening our connection to it in that negative way. But I think often we don't see that if we have aversion to something, yeah, I wanted that rid of this, I wish this would go away, and all the time we're feeding it. So it's really interesting to watch that. - How do we make sure we're not feeding it? - Well, my fullness and equanimity, we have aversion to things because in one way or another, we feel them as being unpleasant. We generally don't have aversion to pleasant things. So as we've spoken in previous episodes of Discussion's, they'd now are the feeling tone when we're not mindful of it. Conditions reactivity, so pleasant conditions desire, unpleasant conditions of aversion. So if we can be equanimous with the unpleasant feeling of whatever it is, then we're with it, but without aversion. And that's how the mind stays free and more effective in seeing, okay, what's the best response here without our feeding it? - Just to fill in your refresher on Vain that, in the Buddhist view, everything that arises in the mind, everything you notice or even the things you don't notice, physical sensations, thoughts, et cetera. Has a so-called feeling tone, a kind of valence to it. It's either pleasant, unpleasant or neutral. So we either want it, don't want it or we don't care. And aversion arises when the feeling tone is unpleasant, often our thoughts, especially when we're overthinking our unpleasant and we maybe tempted to use a phrase like up and out with hostility. You're saying one way to not have this process backfire with some unseen aversion is to be mindful of the feeling
tone and the underlying thought process in this case. I often find that I'm using up and out to kind of usher things along when I feel like I've already processed it. I've already sat with my ancient resentments of the bullies in seventh grade, and I don't need to run through a big process of being mindful of it, investigating its feeling tone. This is more like, oh, I know what that tape is. I'm just going to kind of pleasantly move things along. Am I saying all of this correctly? Yes, except for one thing that I'll clarify. Please. No, that's basically it. And so then you're really using that phrase. It's just in a way, an acknowledgement of what's happening. You're not using it to have it happen. You're just noticing, oh, yeah, this is what's going on. This is coming up and out, which I think can be helpful because it reinforces the understanding that that kind of awareness will result in that letting go of it. Just the one slight refinement about Vedina or the feeling tone. Sometimes people may think that the quality of pleasant or unpleasant inheres in the object, but the feeling tone reflects how we're experiencing the object. So two different people may experience the same thing. One may find it unpleasant, another may find it neutral, or perhaps in some cases even pleasant. So that's an important distinction because in some way it's giving us agency in the process of working with it, of realizing that even on that basic level of how it's experienced as being pleasant and unpleasant is a result of our own conditioning. It's not about the object itself. But that's included. It does seem clear. Yes. Let's step back and say you have a bunch of phrases that are really helpful for overthinking. But let's just step back for a second and talk about a phrase that I feel is more descriptive of thinking generally. And this is a phrase that you actually referenced in one of our earlier episodes in this series on the phrases. And it is tiny dictators. Can you talk a little bit about that one? Just to clarify, I use the phrase "little dictators." Oh, little dictators. My bad. Little dictators. That's the one. The listener to know how often you have to correct me. I don't know who they're going to feel bad for you or me. So what was the question about this phrase? Just the derivation and what you mean by little dictators. The phrase came to mind when I realized that when we are really investigating the nature of thought as a phenomenon, and this is what we've talked about, we see that little more than nothing. And yet when we look at our lives and when I look at my life, when I'm not seeing thought in that way, it's like all these thoughts will come. This is an example that goes way back, but it shows the point. I remember one time I was teaching this is when the Roper University was first starting in Colorado, this new Buddhist college in the university. So I was teaching there in the opening summer sessions and I had a little apartment. Yeah, but they were housing me in. And I remember one evening, I'm just sitting comfortably in my apartment and the thought comes. Oh, pizza would be nice. And it's like the thought lifted me up, took me out the door, downtown, to get a pizza, started eating it burned my mouth. So it just went on. Where did all that come from? It came from that one little thought which in itself was a little more than nothing. And that's a trivial example of what happens. So, so often in the course of a day. And so the contrast between seeing it's essentially empty nature when we are aware of that and how much power thoughts happen in our lives when we're not aware. And we don't have the space in that moment to discern is this worth going for? Do I really want the pizza? So it's not to say we should never act on our thoughts because of course we're doing. We need to. But most of the time it's automatic. Being not mindful of thoughts gives them this tremendous power in our lives. And as we are aware, it just opens up a lot of space for wise discernment. I have a question before I ask you the question just to insert. But if anybody heard Joseph say their empty nature in reference to thoughts, we have a bunch of episodes on what emptiness is, but very, very quickly a sentence meaning in this case empty of inherent substance. There is no, you can't find your thoughts. It's a mysterious little quantum burst of energy with no inherent substance. And it is not yours. By the way, there's also no you take others other episodes if you want to hear about that. Anyway, my question is how do we know which thoughts which dictators to obey and which to organize a coup d'état? Well, first to say that when we are in that mindful space, they're no longer dictators. We might think of them as suggestions. Because we're aware, oh yeah, this is just a thought. Okay. Is it helpful? Is it not helpful? So it's lost. It's lost. It's dictatorial powers. I mean, there are lots of frameworks by which through which we can assess, you know, is this good thing to do? Not a good thing to do. A very basic one within the Buddhist context. The foundation of the meditative journey and really the foundation for wise living in general is framed in terms of the five precepts, five ethical precepts. And that's pretty fundamental in the Buddhist teachings. And just to reiterate what they are, it's refraining from killing and stealing and sexual misconduct and unskilledful speech and taking intoxicants that just confuse the mind. So that's just the very broad framework in terms of ethical behavior that we can see. Okay. Is this action that's being proposed by a thought? Is this in alignment with those precepts or not? That's one framework. Another framework could be just a very kind of ordinary assessment of if I act on this thought, will it actually be effective in achieving my aims? Because sometimes we may have ideas of what we'd like to accomplish and a whole range of thoughts can arise about accomplishing them, but some may be effective and some not. It just gives space for this discernment for this assessment. Another very general framework stems from the Buddhist understanding that wholesome and unwholesome actions could say wise or unwise actions or skillful and unskillful actions can all be traced back to three roots. The three roots of unwholesome actions are greed, hatred and delusion. So this is the Buddhist framework of understanding that, so that could be another assessment. Is this just more greed that this thought is, you know, or is it aversion? If it's delusion, we're probably too deluded to even know that it's delusion. And likewise, the wholesome non-read, you know, generosity and non-version hatred love, non-delusion is wisdom, so that just having in mind, even in a general way, having the background of our mind, do we check in with the motivation, you know, and the quality of the motivation? So there are many, there are many ways of assessing whether we should act on the thought or not. That's very helpful. This job goes to you. Just a teaser. We're not going to talk about this phrase now. You talked about evaluating the thought in terms of, does it help me with my goals, my aims? There is a great phrase to help one clarify one's goals on aims, but I'm not going to do that now because we're going to stay with overthinking. What I have found to be a very useful tactic strategy suggested by you for, specifically with self-criticism, is to count the thoughts. Yes, I love this one. A very common pattern. In people, and it comes up very clearly on meditation retreats, or even for oneself just sitting at home, and if we're paying attention to our thoughts and the kind of thoughts that are rising.
The judging mind is just so prevalent, it could be judgments of others, it could be judgments of ourselves. Just as an example of this, again I was on one retreat at IMS and you really being as mindful as I could go into the dining room for lunch and on this one day I noticed that my mind had a comment about everyone I saw, about what they were wearing, how quickly they were moving, how much food they took from lunch camp, it was ridiculous and it was just this run, they weren't allowed in my mind to kind of soft background thoughts but it was ridiculous. So this is a little aside from the counting which I'll get to but what I found very effective in that regard and it might be applicable in different life situations. When I saw just what my mind was doing I started investing, well why are they coming? And I realized they were rising in the mind because I was seeing in this case all the other people, mindfully I was not mindful that I was seeing. So when I saw that for a while every time I went into the dining room all I would note, seeing, seeing, seeing, from the time I walked in getting the food, bringing it to the table, seeing, seeing the judgments were gone and it was such a good lesson in how we have to really practice being mindful at each of the same stores. And for some reason even in the way we teach some reason we underplay being mindful of seeing. We talk a lot about hearing body sensations and movement at thoughts but actually seeing for most people with working eyes vision is the predominant sense field we're wandering around in the field of what's being seen. And if we're not mindful and we can observe this very clearly we're continually reacting to what's being seen. I like it, I don't like it judging, commenting and it's all because we're simply not being mindful that we're seeing. So that in that situation was the antidote to all those judgments. But sometimes it's not from seeing. Sometimes we're just sitting with eyes closed and all these judgments and often self judgments coming up. So at one point when there was just a run of them for whatever reason I just started counting them. Judgment one, judgment two, judgment five hundred and thirty eight, judgment ten thousand. And at a certain point one just has to smile. One sees how ridiculous it is. And as soon as we can smile at them they lose their power. Because it goes back to what we're saying just before. Those judgments are fed either because we believe them and are identified with them or we have a version to them to the fact that they're arising. And it's pretty easy to understand, oh yeah if I believe them and are identified with them that's going to feed them. But often people don't realize that are a version to them equally strange. So that's why the sense of humor and the smile that's just the magic key. But how to get to that place I found the counting really helps because it just makes it so obvious how ridiculous it is. So humor is a huge aid as we're watching all minds. Well here's a funny phrase along those lines. The thought of your mother is not your mother. Yes. Yes. There was something my teacher and an injury would say very often to remind us it's just a thought. But we invest so much in the thoughts when we're not seeing that it's just a thought. And again I want to reiterate I'm not suggesting that thoughts are infuseful. Thoughts can be a powerful force in our lives for the good. I mean people have gotten enlightened just hearing certain teachings which is a thought process. The hearing teachings were understanding them through our thoughts. They can be a direct pointing to the deepest truths. So it's to be clear that I'm not suggesting that they don't have value. We just have to be a little more discerning. And that discernment only comes when we aware that we're thinking. So it's all a package. Does the phrase painted tiger feel apropos? Probably. So it's apropos particularly with regard to the thought of your mother is not your mother. It's a thought. So there's a Zen story. It's probably apocryphal but it's a good story. It's about the Zen monk living up in the mountains in a cave and he was a great artist. And for whatever reason he was using painting as his practice. So he's up there in the mountains in his cave years painting this tiger on the wall of the cave. And he was a really good artist. Then he spent all this time. And so by the end of it, he looked at the tiger, the painted tiger and got frightened. And so a good mental note with regard to thoughts might be painted tiger. There was no tiger there. It was just a painting. Whatever we're thinking about is not the thing itself. It's just a thought. And so I find that just again another slightly humorous way of reminding ourselves not to simply believe every thought that comes into the mind because many of them, they're all painted tigers in some way because they're not the thing itself, but particularly with thoughts that are not helpful. But for whatever reason we're believing them, they're painted tiger. So there's some phrases here that I have found provide perspective in the face of overthinking or rumination. One of them is consider your seal. Is that for you? Yeah. So I was, this was a time when I was in Burma for a couple of two, three months. Tense of practice with side of Banduta. And my practice was just in the doltrums. Just to say Burma was home to a meditation master named side of Upandita with whom you were studying. Yes. And this is I had already been practicing many, many years, but still there are always ups and downs in the course of the practice that's normal. So I was just going through a phase of kind of the doltrums. I kept sitting and walking, but it didn't feel like anything was happening. So it wasn't so much being down on myself. It was just wondering, not that I'm putting it all as, you know, effort in intense meditation and it just felt flat. So after a few days of my reporting this side of Banduta said, reflect on your seal and seele here means ethical behavior. So my first reaction when he said that, oh no, did I do something wrong? That was my very first reaction. I came to realize that he was saying it as a way of encouraging the mind. If we reflect on a seal and realize I've been practicing ethical behavior as a way of uplifting the mind and encouraging the heart. The principle here in a way is sometimes reflecting on one's wholesome activities, you know, and wholesome actions, school full actions, people might think, oh, that's just an ego trip, which that in the wrong way could be. But that kind of wise reflection on, yeah, that's, you know, I've been doing something, wholesome here, been doing something skillful, beneficial. That's not an ego trip, that's reinforcing faith, it's reinforcing wisdom, it's reinforcing kind of an appreciation for the value of the path and what we've been doing. So that's really what contemplated your seal was about as a way of uplifting the heart. Well, let's talk about whether this is applicable to a regular person who's not in the middle of a meditation retreat, you know, contemplating your seal. Some of us might be fraught because maybe we are not living in alignment. However,
I could also imagine it, and the way I've used it, to the extent that I've used it, is a kind of cousin to gratitude to, yeah, I spent a lot of time reflecting on my terrible behavior of laws, but let me just take a second to think about, oh yeah, you know, if I think back at this day on this very day, I did a bunch of good things. Yeah, yeah, so there's an interesting connection here to the loving kindness practice, because it said that the condition of the cause for meta-loving kindness to arise, both towards other people and towards ourselves, is appreciating the good qualities in others and in ourselves. And when we think of that and contemplate that, there's a natural, almost spontaneous, friendly feeling that arises, and it's very instructive to see how often with other people and with ourselves, we don't focus on the good qualities, we focus on what we don't like, we focus on the bad qualities, and just realizing it would be helpful to see that pattern and the way of coming out of it would be, just as you said, what to use it as a way of appreciating the good qualities in ourselves, appreciating the good qualities in others, and it changes, it changes the dial. Here's another phrase that I think is perhaps more center of the bullseye that can jar you out of a state of rumination and kind of give you some perspective. It's not fill in the blank. This is something I've used forever, but especially after I began teaching and working with people and I extended it from just applying in my own practice as a teaching tool, if people are struggling with some difficulty and really caught up in the struggle and they don't, they don't have perspective on it, so I'll use a reference to whatever current situation is happening at that time, and so for a long time I would say, it's not Bosnia, it's not the Sudan, it's not Gaza, you know, and just reminding people of the situations where the suffering was a much, much, much greater magnitude than our little struggle. Now that has to be used also wisely because if people are really involved in something, for example, it's deeply traumatic, that would not be an appropriate because it might feel like the situation because of the intensity of the suffering. So this is useful for mundane, run of the mill, suffering in tankalments, kvetshin about one thing or another, kvetshin for the non-Jewish or non-Jewish adjacent is Yiddish for complaining. A phrase that was used a lot on me when I was a boy. This expression that I'm going to propose to you next feels really apropos to me, the wisdom of the non-toothache. So to my understanding as the wisdom of the non-toothache is, can you appreciate when things are going well, when you don't have a toothache, to me, that can put my obsessive thoughts into perspective? Does it make sense? Yes, it does make sense. You've expressed it perfectly. It's actually right in line with some teachings right from the Satyikatana Sutta, the discourse on the foundations of mindfulness. So the Buddha actually addressed it directly, but not using toothache, as an example, but in the third foundation of mindfulness, which is mindfulness of the mind, one of the categories is be mindful when, for example, the hindrances, one of the hindrances, like desire or version restlessness, be mindful when they're present, be mindful when they're not present. And it's interesting that it's much harder to remember to be mindful when they're not present. Because when they are present, they make themselves known, you know, with a lot of fanfare. When they're not present, there's nothing strikingly obvious about it, unless we pay attention. You know, and so that emphasis on being mindful when things are going well, when the mind is calm, when the mind is peaceful, when there's not a lot of suffering, or any mind at that particular time, as you said, to acknowledge that is really helpful. And we have many more moments of that in the day than we realize. So again, it's encouraging to be including the non toothache in our field of awareness. Here's another phrase that I've heard you use that is quite useful when one is caught, you know, like a thought storm, which can last, these can last years, really. And I remember the first time you used it with me, I was a little pissed off because I didn't really understand what you were saying. I remember we were standing on a street corner in New York, it's very early in our friendship. And I was just describing the fact that my wife and I were in the middle of a long infertility struggle. And you were very sympathetic, you did not dismiss it at all, but toward the end of the discussion, you said, if it's not one thing, it's another. And I didn't really take it in the spirit in which it was intended, but it's something I've thought about a lot since then. So what do you mean by that phrase? That phrase relates to another phrase, which explains it perfectly. The other phrase is what I think is a fantastic expression of the first noble truth of the Buddhist teachings, like core foundational teachings of the Buddha. And this is across almost all Buddhist traditions, other teachings on the four noble truths. The truth of suffering, dukkha in Pali, the cause of suffering, which is craving the end of suffering, which is coming to the end of craving and then the noble eightfold path, which is the way to accomplish this aim. So that first noble truth, the truth of dukkha, the definition of dukkha that I came across and I thought it was just so brilliantly succinct that dukkha is the inevitability of unwanted experiences. And I think that's something everyone can relate to in their lives, there's no one who goes through life free of unwanted experiences at times. They are inevitable. So that's really what if it's not one thing, it's another, if it's not one unwanted experience, there's going to be another one because they are inevitable in this conditioned world. And I love that because it normalizes the fact that it happens and that it will happen inevitably. So it's not a mistake that they're happening. And so once we see it in that broader perspective, I think it helps us have a perspective on what the particular unwanted experience is. And if we have a broader perspective, I think we can better see how to address it. Is this something I can do about it, is it not? What would be the right course of action? So all of that can be considered, but that's very different than thinking it's a mistake or getting worked up with a lot of aversion to the fact that it's happening because we think it shouldn't be happening. So another example of this, and again, it touches into a basic teachings of the Buddha. And we may have talked about this a little bit before, I'm not sure. Now the Buddha suggested certain reflections on the inevitability of unwanted experiences. The Buddha suggested that we reflect on this daily, when he said, "What has the nature to grow old will grow old, and I am not exempt. What has the nature to become ill will become ill, and I am not exempt. What has the nature to die will die, and I am not exempt." So what's interesting to me, as I reflect it on this, and have it come to mind, the first part
was quite obvious. But what has the nature to grow old will grow old. It was the tagline of "I am not exempt", which even now, of course, intellectually, I knew that I am not exempt. I could often detect an underlying feeling, almost subliminal. Well, I should be exempt of somehow framing it as "why is this happening to me?" So that "why is it happening to me" is a reflection of some holding to the idea that I should be exempt from what is this completely natural unfolding. And this is all about coming to realize the first noble truth. So to me, these feel like a sweet "SUIT" of interrelated phrases when you're in or when I'm in a "woe is me" state. So the inevitability of unwanted experience--this is just the truth of things--unwanted states are going to happen. I am not exempt. I would just say as a cyber and I am not exempt, the contemplation of your mortality is not a bad way to jar you out of overthinking, to create bolless of perspective. And then finally, if it's not one thing, it's another, you know, we live, I have lived much of my life, and I still do this, with the lie that if I could just solve this problem or maybe this suite of problems, illusion fields like it's all good. Of course, there's going to be another thing. And so it just kind of just settle back into the situation with a little bit more sanity and patience. Let me just deal with this problem because I know there's going to be something on the other side. And then I would add, I know I said, finally, I would add maybe one other phrase that we haven't discussed yet as the fourth in this little package. Anything can happen any time. Yes. It's all a package of phrases addressing this issue. So, do you want into a little backstory? Please, please. Again, it comes back quite a few years. I was teaching a retreat for social and environmental activists at this wilderness retreat center in Northern New Mexico. Beautiful place, Vice-Citos Mountain Refuge. Beautiful in the middle of Carson National Forest, 9,000 feet alpine stream running through it. It was beautiful. So, doing the retreat and then on the last day, we did a hike on the very last day of the retreat. There was a small river running through the property. And so we were hiking up along the small river and kind of scrambling over the rocks, crossing back and forth. It was fantastic. On the way back, it had rained the night before so some of the rocks were a little slippery. In walking back, I slipped on a rock and hyper-extended my knee. And I knew something. An unwanted experience had just happened. Anywhere I'd make it back to the center, that evening I was giving the Dharma talk. And I had the thought, don't see it cross-legged. It won't be good. But I overrode the thought. I didn't listen to it. It sat cross-legged. At the end, I couldn't get up. I had to be carried back to my room, which was very embarrassing. First, I'm 6'3". I forget how exactly I was carried back to that home night. I had a busy summer schedule planned. And I just kept thinking, how am I going to manage this? I couldn't even walk from the meditation hall to my room. So a lot of thinking and worrying and anxiety. And then at a certain point, and I took most of the night to come to this, at some point, the thought came to my mind. Anything can happen anytime, completely unexpected. With ramifications, for how the rest of my summer was going to unfold, anything can happen anytime. But surprisingly, some people might hear that. And I might think that at least to a kind of paranoid state, fearful to say, "Oh my God, anything can happen anytime, we have to be on the watch out." It was exactly the opposite. It was the acknowledgement of the truth of it. And it just led to this quality of acceptance in my mind. The inevitability of unwanted experiences, anything can happen anytime. So if we're aware of that and realize this is the truth of how things are, then when these things happen, we can deal with it with much more equipois. We deal with it as best we can. But it's from a much more peaceful place of mind. And my mind did become peaceful. And then I just took care of it as best I could. Things were fine. This is a massage. And then we find so that I was scheduled to teach in Germany that summer. Anyway, managed to go with a lot of accommodation. For my name, taught this course in Germany. At the end of the chorus to the dawn of biscuit, there were two of us, and I put in two fifty thousand dollar checks in the dawn. He had just, he came from the super wealthy family. Parents had just died, I think. He had inherited his fortune. And I had had to thought, "Oh, maybe I shouldn't go." So sometimes anything that happened at any time can be on the good side as well. That was an amazing one. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Just a reset. I think you know, we started this conversation talking about dealing with overthinking specifically. And we're moving into an area that kind of is inclusive of overthinking. But also, you just have to navigate a complex chaotic world more skillfully in the face of the non-negotiable truth of change, flux. There's another phrase that's coming to mind that I find really beautiful. And it comes directly from the Buddha becoming otherwise. Yes. So I came across this phrase in the text. And to reiterate, just a point I made in a previous discussion that I've been in the practice now of listening to the teachings rather than reading them. Because I must have read that phrase many, many times and it didn't impact me. But when I heard it in the Buddha's description of change of things always becoming otherwise, when I heard it, it really struck me in a completely new and vivid way because it's a bit unusual in English. It's not a typical way we would talk of change and impermanence. And because of that, we could say, you know, everything changes. And it's kind of flat. It's so obvious when we say it that way that we don't really appreciate what it's saying. But things are always becoming otherwise. As a phrase, for me, made it very immediate. Like in every moment, things are always becoming otherwise. I have found it to be a really good reminder at times. For example, I might be going for a walk and then I have a little twitch at my knee or my back or something. Oh, becoming otherwise. So instead of, oh no, what just happened, you know, and do I have to do something and all of that. Oh, just things becoming otherwise. So it reinforces our awareness that this is the nature of things. And again, it doesn't imply that in certain situations, we do want to do something about it. But it frees us from that reactivity of why me, which is really helpful because even though we may not even articulate why me to ourselves, very often we're thinking it silently. Yeah, there's some flavor of it in our minds. And just things becoming otherwise, this is just the nature of things. So I find it very helpful and youthfully pointed phrase to highlight that. I find it really helpful in my relationship with my parents. I have a very clear visual of the first time I think that you met my parents. We were in the backyard of my childhood home. Yes, yes. It was our first meeting to discuss launching a meditation app in like 2014 or something. And my parents were still living in my childhood home and they were healthy and active. They were both academic physicians at Harvard. And really, for me, my whole life, the kind of my alpha and omega, I heard this beautiful phrase, not from you. There was some writer talking about some.
other important person in his or her life, and he or she said, they are the theater for my actions. Nothing felt real unless my parents knew about it. And they're now living in an assisted living facility near me in suburban New York. And my mom's pretty sharp, but my dad is, you know, he has become otherwise. He's still lovely, loving, I think, quite happy person. But, you know, he's had a lot of health problems stroke in a Parkinson's like diagnosis. And I felt so unward by their transition and still do at times, but it's just things becoming otherwise. Yes. Yes. It's so interesting that I don't know if resistance is right word or just believe in that somehow with something so obviously true that we don't take it in. We don't live as if it's true. So that's quite mysterious. And also, kind of a reason why the practice of mindfulness and awareness is so liberating because we're just giving ourselves a framework for investigating what is so obviously true that we have been overlooking. True and painful at the same time. Yes. Although in opening to the truth of it, some dimensions of the pain are eliminated, which is our reactivity. Yes. I think unless resistant and more tuned in, more sad. Yeah. The pregnancy. Yes. But for me, the emotion of sadness, there's a certain soft beauty to it, which distinguishes for me from unhappiness that you can be sad and not unhappy. To me, that's just a useful understanding because many situations in our life are sad. Even when we realize their inevitability, that's fine. None of what we're talking about implies that we become emotionally flat. But there are certain emotions, which are afflictive, which really causes suffering and are not particularly helpful. But other emotions, which may be acknowledging the same situation are quite natural and even have a beauty to them. The first time you said that to me, I did not like it or I didn't get it, but it makes sense when you think about the term bitter sweet. They've combined bitter and sweet for a reason. Where this leads me in my mind in terms of having an ongoing flow in the conversation. As I'm sitting here feeling sad talking about my parents, you have a phrase that has been very helpful for me with all kinds of emotions, whether they're afflictive or not. And this is going to sound simplistic, but it's not. And the phrase is, it's okay. As with many of the others, there is a story. I think the story will help to elucidate what that really needs. So for many years earlier on in my practice, the strongest afflictive emotion was fear. So fear would just come up in so many different ways. But on summary truths, you know, I was really practicing intensively so things get magnified in that context. Fear would be coming up and it would come up so strongly. There were times when I was afraid to go from sitting to standing. So it's completely irrational. Completely. I mean, it doesn't make any sense at all. But somehow that was the energy that was coming up for whatever reason. I have no idea why that was so strong. So it's just to say I was working with this emotion over a long time, over many years, not at that intensity mostly, but was still there. So on one retreat, a couple of years after that intense experience, I was doing walking meditation and I could feel different aspects of fear arising in the mind and then something shifted in my mind. I could feel the shift and it was expressed in the phrase, if this fear is here for the rest of my life, it's okay. It's okay. And I realized that that was the first moment in these years of practice that I genuinely accepted it. And this points to another really important distinction in meditation, the difference between recognition and mindfulness. In all those years, I recognized what was there. I knew it was fear and I could name it as fear. But it was always through the filter of not lighting it and wanting it to go away because it's a very unpleasant emotion. So I was looking at it through the filter of aversion, which as we just discussed earlier, aversion feeds the very thing we're averse to. So unknowingly, I was keeping it going through my aversion to it and through the delusion of thinking I was being mindful when I was not. I was just recognizing it. So in that moment, if this fear is here for the rest of my life, it's okay. In that acceptance, it was amazing. In that moment, the net shift, the whole ball, compacted ball of fear, washed through. And just my heart relaxed, it's okay. And it's not to say that fear never comes again because it does times, but relationship to it is now completely different. When it arises, it's okay. It's okay to feel a fear. It's okay to feel unpleasantness. We don't have to default to aversion towards it. In that acceptance, everything becomes more workable. And later, we'll let it go of that strong identification with it. So it's okay. I call it the magic mantra. It's okay. It's okay to feel it. And again, it doesn't mean that we never do anything in response to what may be happening. But when we're coming from the place of it's okay to feel it, then our response will be more effective, wiser, more skillful. Right. The passivity is a misunderstanding. Yes. This is about not being at war with reality at first. Yes. And then responding wisely. Yes. I like that. I like your phrase at war with reality. I still have from somebody. I'm sure. But this phrase, it's okay. I think reminds me of at least two other phrases that I've heard from you. Both of them I think are borrowed. One is a borrowed from a poet and the other is borrowed from your next-door neighbor, Sharon Salzburg. The one from the poet, I think it's Robert Frost is the only way out is through. I don't know where that comes from. So you may have said no, no, I'm sure that I read it someplace. Doesn't quite sound like Robert Frost, but maybe I have no idea. I don't read poetry other than yours. Anyway, it's a good phrase, whoever first coined it. So what's interesting is unpacking a little bit is what the room means. The only way out is through, because you could get through by bulldozing your way through, which may create its own problems, or the way out is through, through a mindful acceptance of what's there. Seeing its impermanent empty nature so that we're not contracting in response to it, we're staying with whatever it is in a balanced, mindful, aware, equanimous way. And then we do. That leads us through in a very skillful way. Another phrase, the one from your next-door neighbor is, well, I can say the phrase, I'll just have you tell the story and the phrase at the punch line, it harkens back to our discussion of your struggles with fear. You are in a retreat with Sharon, where it came up. You want to tell that story? Yeah, this was during those years when I was really working with it, and then not yet come to it's okay. So I was still trying to figure out, you know, we were teaching together in Texas. And after lunch, we were just going for a walk together, and I was going on complaining about all this fear and, you know, because I was building a whole superstructure of self on top of this emotion. This is the way I am. I will always be this way. Exactly. I thought I was just going on and honed about this. And at a certain point Sharon turned to me and she said, "Joseph, it's just a mind state." And, you know, sometimes it's just the right moment to hear something. That was one of those moments. All right, this is just a mind state, and I'm making up this whole big self story about it, and that really helped to reframe.
the whole thing is just a mine state. It was really helpful just having a reminder. Well, I hear it not only in as useful in terms of it maybe taking a few of the jenga pieces out of the structure of self, the superstructure of self, but also the relief in knowing, yeah, this is a mine state and like everything else, it will pass. Yes, yes. That is how I heard it also. The meaning of it's just a mine state includes that. Yeah. I want to get one phrase in because I kind of teased it earlier. You might be in the ballpark of a non-sec order, but earlier we were talking about how to in the face of our constant flurry of thoughts, how to figure out which ones to listen to, which ones not to listen to. You said being mindful of them is really step number one. There's a phrase that has been helpful for me once I'm mindful of my thoughts to pick and choose a little bit more carefully. It's a lens, a pair of goggles that has been really helpful for me. And at first, it sounded a little anodine to me, but it actually has, as with many of these phrases, the more I've sat with it, the more meaning it has accumulated. And it is what matters most. Yeah, I'm always interested as you give the build up to the phrase, and I don't really know what phrase you're leading to. I'm always waiting with excited anticipation. You know, and I'm always sitting here thinking, is he going to shake his head at me disapproving? What are you talking about? Nothing to do with anything, which has happened in the course of these recordings just to say. So what's the first reason? Are you asking that seriously? What? The phrase is what matters most. I think the use of that phrase just really is a way of just in the moment stepping back from whatever the decision is that has to be made. And just taking a moment and can be quite intuitive. I don't think this requires a lot of thinking. I think we would know quite intuitively and quickly if we take that moment to step back, does this really align with my values? Is this an alignment with what I value most? I think it's a very intuitive thing, but very illuminating. I think we know, you know, for about to do something and it's just really being motivated by greed. And it couldn't be a big greed, you know, it could be a little greed, but often in the course of the day, we're kind of on autopilot. We're just going through the day doing what we do, you know, reacting and doing this and that. And I think we often don't take the time to just having the background of our minds, the framework of what is most important, you know, what our values really are. So even occasionally, to stop with, if one could remember before doing something to ask that question, can be really helpful. We've talked in earlier sessions about the right speech, you know, in some pop-up the useless talk and all the other kinds of right and wrong speech. That's such a good, very simple arena. Oh, what I'm about to say, does it really align with my values? Does it unite people or divide people? Just some very simple things. And as I say, it's not, I'm not suggesting that we spend 10 minutes trying to figure out our values and does this align or doesn't align. I think it's a much more intuitive process that could come quite easily if we just practice taking that moment to allow for it. I agree. It is an intuitive process. I would only add that I have, especially when I'm working with my team and, you know, I'm in the process of, you know, an early stage startup, it's very helpful in order to divine or discern your values to ask the question. Yes, yes. And in that situation, there could be a whole process, a whole reflective process of actually sitting down and writing down. Okay. What are my values in this situation? Ethical values or the service values, compassion values, whatever they may be. Yes. So in certain situations, I agree that it could be helpful to expend it beyond that momentary intuitive sense, to a real reflection and examination of what our values actually are. Been a great conversation, in my view, on sort of, we started with overthinking and moved into, how to manage an anxiety producing world and anxiety itself. Before we take a break, anything you feel like getting off your chest, anything else coming to mind. He's looking at me and I can read his mind when he's thinking, there are a lot of complaints about, I have about you hairs, but they may not be relevant to this conversation. Am I reading you correctly? No, no, no. Okay. Not in the slightest. It wasn't even in the bold part. Yeah, that this was looking your face. Yeah, no, but the look was, I was thinking of an example, of that reflecting on values. So it might have been a little quizzical look. I wasn't sure whether it would be worth adding to it or not. So let's talk about that. Let's talk about you. Now that I brought it up, I rarely have the thoughts that you would strive for me, just enough so you can relax. I mean, that just doesn't, it's not a strong pattern in my mind. No, I know you met, even if I had been guessing correctly, I was guessing that you were going to say from a standpoint of humor. Yeah. Anyway, let me give that a little example. As an example of a situation where reflecting on one's values could be really helpful and it's something I suggested to this friend. He's in quite a senior position in a company and was thinking about the next step possibly moving on to a different position. There were a lot of pros and cons to the different opportunities that were presenting themselves to him, which involved, you know, perhaps moving or dealing with the school's first kids, just a lot of considerations, but there were situations which might have afforded him more, a higher position, something like that. So as we were talking, he was just talking it over with me and I suggested to him, you know, I think you and your wife together should sit down and just look at, okay, in your life now, what is it you most value? And then consider these different opportunities in the light of those values. Because I think it's very easy to become seduced by the glitter of some possible outcome and ignore other values that we might have. So I think it can be a really helpful way to navigate through life so that we, as much as possible, are doing things in alignment with what we value rather than being caught up in the ice, I say, the glitter of some possibility and overlooking. Yes, reverse engineer from the first. Thank you so much to everybody who works so hard to make this show. 10% happier is produced by Tara Anderson and Eleanor Vasilie. Our recording and engineering is handled by the great folks over at Pod People. Lauren Smith is our managing producer. Marissa Schneiderman is our senior producer. DJ Kashmir is our executive producer and Nick Thorburn of the great Indy Rockbad Islands wrote our theme. Also one last thing before you go. Remember to sign up for my new app, which is called 10% with Dan Harris. You can sign up over at DanHarris.com. On the app, you'll find a growing library of meditations from world-class teachers, add free access to the full expertise of our podcast guests, meaning you'll get this podcast from no ads, exclusive live stream events, which we do weekly, sometimes twice a week, robust discussion threads to connect you with our team, with our teachers, and with one another. There's a free 14-day trial if you want to try before you buy. (upbeat music)
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The phrase "up and out" encourages allowing thoughts and memories—whether trivial or traumatic—to arise and pass without aversion, fostering mental freedom through equanimity.
"Tiny dictators" highlights how thoughts often operate with automatic power, emphasizing that mindfulness transforms them from commanding forces into mere suggestions that can be evaluated.
Counting thoughts or self-judgments reveals their absurdity, with humor and awareness breaking their hold and reducing reactivity.
The phrase "the thought of your mother is not your mother" reminds us that thoughts are not reality, helping to de-identify from unhelpful beliefs and reduce emotional investment.
"If it's not one thing, it's another" reframes suffering as inevitable, normalizing difficulties and reducing despair by recognizing impermanence and recurrence.
"Things are always becoming otherwise" underscores the nature of impermanence and change, offering peace by accepting that all experiences—good or bad—are transient.
"It's okay" is a transformative acceptance that allows for emotional presence without aversion, creating a foundation for wiser, less reactive responses to fear and distress.
Mindful reflection on values—asking "what matters most?"—helps individuals make decisions aligned with their deeper principles rather than reacting to surface-level impulses.
Summary:
In this episode, Dan Harris interviews Joseph Goldstein on powerful, accessible mantras to manage overthinking, anxiety, and emotional reactivity. Central phrases like "up and out" and "tiny dictators" emphasize non-judgmental awareness, helping practitioners release attachment to thoughts and memories. Goldstein explains that aversion feeds suffering, and mindfulness—rooted in observing the feeling tone of thoughts—creates space for discernment.
The concept of thoughts as "tiny dictators" reveals their automatic power, which diminishes when we observe them with awareness. Humor and counting thoughts serve as practical tools to disrupt self-criticism. Key reframes like "the thought of your mother is not your mother" and "if it's not one thing, it's another" offer perspective by grounding suffering in its inevitability.
The idea that "things are always becoming otherwise" underscores impermanence, while "it's okay" fosters emotional acceptance, reducing reactivity to fear. Finally, reflecting on one’s core values—what truly matters most—enables wiser decisions and alignment with life’s deeper principles. These phrases, rooted in Buddhist teachings, provide a practical, compassionate toolkit for navigating the chaotic mind and finding peace in uncertainty.
FAQs
It means allowing thoughts, memories, or emotions to come up without resistance, simply letting them pass through mindfully. This practice helps reduce attachment and fosters equanimity, especially with difficult or traumatic memories.
It reminds us that thoughts are not automatic commands but fleeting mental events. When we become mindful, thoughts lose their power and become just suggestions, allowing for wise discernment instead of reactive behavior.
Counting thoughts makes them visible and absurd, helping you recognize their irrationality. This awareness naturally reduces their power, and a smile or sense of humor can further dissolve the grip of self-judgment.
It reminds us that thoughts are merely mental representations, not real entities. The thought of a person is not the person themselves, which helps prevent over-identification and emotional fixation.
It reflects the Buddhist truth that unwanted experiences are inevitable. When we realize suffering will recur, we stop seeing it as a personal failure and respond with patience and acceptance.
It grounds us in the reality of impermanence and uncertainty. Recognizing that unexpected events are part of life fosters acceptance, reducing anxiety and helping us respond with calm rather than fear.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.