Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project, one app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Odo comes in, an all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together, from sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all-in-one powerful platform, no messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and, best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. For free today at od.com/box, that's od.o.com/box. I'm Aina Garten, and each week on Happy Hour, I invite new and old friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City. And this week's episode, I'm joined by Rose Byrne. We talk all about her love of mixology, doing a stoop sale in Brooklyn, and her dislike of marshmallows on sweet potatoes. New episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday. You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers. Welcome to Profty Markets, I'm Ed Elson, it is November 19th, let's check in on yesterday's market vitals. The S&P 500 and the Dow fell again, with Nvidia shares weighing on the indices, Nvidia slid another 3% following its earnings report, still the Nasdaq managed to post again. Meanwhile Brent Crude declined, so did the yield on tenure treasuries, and finally, companies close to Anthropic, climbed in anticipation of its IPO. Amazon rose 4%, and Broadcom rose 3.5%. Okay, what's happening? The moment for Anthropics, public debut has finally arrived. The company is set to start trading at $83 per share later today. That should put the valuation at about 1.5 trillion dollars, and reportedly, the IPO is close to 7 times over subscribed. Years of last month, Anthropic was on pace for $81 billion in annual revenue, up roughly a thousand percent from last year, but investors still have plenty to worry about, Anthropic posted a more than $500 million operating loss last quarter, and it has committed to spend roughly $900 billion on compute and infrastructure in the coming years. So what will the public markets make of Anthropic? Here to answer that question, we're speaking with Paul Kadroski, managing partner at SK Ventures. Paul, Anthropic will finally go public. Many thought maybe it wouldn't, or that it would be delayed. In fact, that was my prediction. That appears not to be the case. I got that wrong. This is happening. They're going public. Any thoughts, takeaways, predictions for what this is going to look like? They're going to regret doing it the same day as GTA 6. Although I will say, I mean, one of the things that's really startling to me, and I was looking at the data earlier today about the IPO, was comparing, and again, Google Trends data isn't great because apparently no one uses Google anymore, but the Trends data, if you look at the level of, as a proxy for retail interest, is really interesting because you see that SpaceX was roughly about 4x the level of interest that Anthropic has at the same point in the cycle, day of IPO. Again, it's a very loose retail proxy, but it is interesting because I think a lot of people in the industry, in particular in the institutional side of finance, see this as a much more interesting IPO because it represents the first chance to get access to a frontier lab in terms of AI. To see that, I found really striking, and there's lots of ways you can look at it. Retail interest is just one aspect of a successful IPO. I will say one of the things that I find interesting about it that frankly annoys me is this idea that it being over-subscribed. As I said, I think maybe on this show before is that being over-subscribed is required to go public. If you're not over-subscribed, you don't get to go public. So saying that you're over-subscribed, which they very noisily have leaked repeatedly to the point that it's like, "OK, I get it already, just run hot air balloons and tell me you don't have to keep leaking it anymore," is to say that that's just what you do. Because when you're the underwriter, you engineer the price, you engineer the allocation, you know the quantity. If you can't figure out a way to make sure there are more bids than there is stock, you need to get out of the business." Having said all of that, this for me is not much of an indicator in terms of what's going to happen. I still think it'll be successful, but the field of need to bang the drum so much with respect to it being over-subscribed is a proxy for retail interests because it's a way of attracting more retail investors. And the reason why you want them is because the institutions are getting the allocations in large part. So you need someone to flip it to. And so for me, it's a cynical exercise in making sure there's enough people waiting in the pond whenever you want to flip it after the IPO who can pick it up. And so by promoting how over-subscribed it is, it's a way to create this, you know, just add water, feeding frenzy around it, and that's the way they should be interpreted. And turning it around, what the data says in terms of really dramatically over-subscribed IPOs is that they actually tend to underperform badly over the next 12 months. Worldwide data on this, the US, China, or sorry, Hong Kong, Europe and so on. So even in so far as it tells you anything, it mostly tells you that you're looking at an IPO that's likely to underperform if it is that over-subscribed. Well, this is the thing because it does seem that this IPO, all IPOs are engineered by the underwriter. Yeah. They're always priced such that the first day you got to get pop and ban. You have a successful IPO. If you don't have a pop, then something went horribly, horribly wrong. Right. But this does seem especially engineered. And two reasons it seems like that to me, at least, one, they have $26 billion coming in investment, coming in from a lot of their partners, Google, Amazon, Nvidia, all of these tech giants. So that helps the price. And then number two, the float-like SpaceX is very small. It's around 5% of the company averages 15 to 20% for most IPOs. So it seems as though they are setting this up such that it cannot go wrong. We'll have so much price support from the institutions coming in to support a relatively small amount of shares compared to the number of shares that they could be selling in this IPO. Which makes me think this is going to be, they're going to be fine, but it might not actually tell us that much about the company, fundamentally, it might not actually tell us what the markets are really thinking. Would you say that that is accurate? That could hardly be more accurate. That is exactly what's happening. It's engineered for exactly that purpose, it has no relationship to the value or fundamentals of the business. It's purely an exit event. It's an engineered exit event, partly for the series A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, investors, and partly for the people who are coming in at the late stage and hoping to flip it to retail or whomever that happens to be on the other side of it. So it's engineered for that exit, but doesn't tell us anything about what people think in terms of the prospects for the business. And then more fundamentally, we also know that when this phenomenon happens, it is highly predictive of underperformance over the next 12 months. We saw that with SpaceX. We've seen that with a host of others. So that gets to probably the more important question is, what do we think is going to happen over the next 12 months? Because this thing will go out, it sounds like you and I both agree. It'll be fine. It'll get that pop. It'll probably people will say, okay, okay, good, it was a success. By the way, anchoring from a much smaller number than previously reported, which was two trillion dollars, so we've reduced the price, quite significantly. We'll see exactly what it goes out of the course of the day. But what is your expectation for this company and this stock over the next 12 months, and perhaps even longer than that, because that's a time frame in which you might see something closer to true price discovery and where the true feelings and emotions of Wall Street are actually reflected in the price. Yeah. So I think you probably will see that kind of at least modest spike on the day. I'll hang my ass in the breeze and say that. But I also think you'll see a SpaceX like 20 to 30% decline over the next sort of six months as price discovery actually happens that's separate from this phenomenon of artificial scarcity and an engineered price. And so you'll see something like that. And then as you look forward and you say at the current run rate, what's a reasonable price, you know, 10X, the current run rate wouldn't be too far. I would put you to a one to 1.2 trillion dollars, something like those kinds of numbers. It still looks, I'll say rich at the price. And that's all not even talking about these two things we've talked about before. One is they're in this rapid transition from Anthropic 1 to Anthropic 2. Anthropic 1 largely leased compute and sold access to models. Anthropic 2 is building compute and is selling applications that sit on models. So you're in the middle of this really dramatic transition between two very different architectures of the same company. So the opportunities for revenue to look much less predictable than is implied by the valuation or dramatic. So I feel really comfortable with that kind of number. What do you make of the business at this point? Because as you say, they reduce their losses last year, but that doesn't really
and tell us much about what's going to happen in the future because they're going to spend roughly $900 billion. So things are going to look very different, which tells me they're going to have to go out and raise a lot more after this IPO. - And not only that, people are, they're also going to be, if you look at the data, they've been in the last 18, 24 months, launching more apps, if you will, more verticalized products, than they have new frontier models. And most people haven't noticed this, but it's really dramatic. This is a company already in the process of launching products that compete directly against people for whom they are distributors, Microsoft and others. So Microsoft distributes the product and yet competes with them. So they have to be very concerned about having their oxygen supply cut off by their own distributors as they race up market. And then at the same time, as the people they're competing with are also users of their product and say, wait a minute, am I providing you with data that helps you compete against me more successfully? So the old game of being able to ingest lots of data to compete more effectively is already over. And so this is going to make it so much more difficult for them to pull this transition off for those two reasons. Lots of distribution and competitors, or former customers who now see you as a competitor and are less much more leery, but giving you data. - This, I think, brings us to what many are, would say, is the more interesting news, or at least the most sensational news, which is what is happening to Nvidia and what is happening to AI at large. I mean, Nvidia has gotten clobbered. It's lost more than a third of its value. A lot of the AI names, many of them have been cut in half, particularly the Neo Clouds over the past six months. All of the semis are, most of them at least are in decline down around 30% over about six weeks, which raises questions for anthropic. I mean, we agree that this IPO will be fine, but if they have to go out and raise lots more capital in the future, then that means that they have to go out and find money from investors who right now appear to be very anxious about this whole AI thing. And so it does raise questions, can they do it? Is the euphoria, is the exuberance surrounding AI coming to an end? Is this what it looks like when a bubble pops? - Oh, it does, but I think there's a really unusual aspect to this, and it has become an overused metaphor. And I mean, I like to think I was one of the first to say it, but I probably wasn't, was that in video is the kind of central bank of AI, this idea. And so it operated a fractional reserve system with GPUs as currency, and it tried to peg the currency back in the summer when it put a flow under it. That didn't work. It tried to run fractional reserve system when an extended credit with no payment terms to many people in the circular financing cycle. What we've now entered with Collette as the interim CEO and Jensen on the out is what I would call in banking terms a tightening cycle. So we've entered a tightening cycle. So the cost of capital becomes more expensive to your point. It's not that you can't get the capital, but the price just went up. It became much more difficult, and so that change is the underlying economics, 'cause if your assumption was I can have 20% margins and a 10% hurdle, and I, this is my revenue not by 2031, it just went up by 30%. It just went up by 30% because of this tightening cycle. That's what's changed. - Who is most at risk as a result of that tightening cycle? I mean, who gets hurt? Across the board, the Neo Clouds. And she tried very hard on the call last night to say, we, other than she could have only done more, like maybe put in a heart emoji and say, we still love Neo Clouds, but that didn't happen. So instead she said, you know, we're still big supporters of Neo Clouds, but we're going to be much more discriminating in future. That butt was the telling butt. That's the one that told you that it's all about to change in terms of the cost of capital for the Neo Clouds because the central bank just decided the cost of capital needs to be different. And there's the group most at risk, and they are both the marginal providers of compute, as well as already having the most expensive cost of capital, they just got more expensive. - What do you make of the entire Nvidia scandal? I mean, I would love to just get your top blind thoughts, especially this question of the return of Jensen Huang, which has a lot of investors very fired up right now. Many think that he has to come back. He is the essence and the soul of Nvidia. Others think, no, this is a major scandal. He can't be see, yeah, what do you make of all of it? - Oh, I don't think he can come back. I mean, for me, this is an anithetical to a whole idea of board governance. I mean, why have a board? What's the point of having a board if something that the board has decided on its own was worth investigating? And to be clear, he didn't resign because he resigned. He wasn't fired. He decided that he didn't want to be part of the process. But his actions, I think, are so difficult to defend from what we know in terms of his engagement with respect to what was going on in terms of loosely transshipment, but in particular, just gaming US regulations with respect to, if not the letter of the law, the spirit of the law, in terms of being a cloud compute provider to China via Southeast Asian data centers and clouds. And he said this very clearly. I don't know, six, eight months ago on the Warkish Patel's podcast where he defended it straight up and said, we're going to provide compute to China. And this was a kind of regulatory arbitrage using clouds to do it. And the FT reported recently that something like 50% of their revenue this year, which they longer report this way, is now go through their Singapore subsidiary, granted some of that significant fraction of that ends up back in the US again. But the point is there were things going on where he was essentially wrapping himself in the flag of nationalism and saying, this is good for the US. And it's also good for me. Don't worry, you're pretty little heads about it. We'd let us continue to do these things. So I think he was very aggressive and rast-knuckle player, trying to say that things that were good for Nvidia were definitely good for the US. And I disagree. Polkadroski is managing partner at SK Ventures. Paul, appreciate your time. Thanks, Ed. After the break, I look at the business of GTA VI. By the way, we are also recording our annual "Ask Me" anything episode soon. So be sure to submit your questions for me and Scott. You can leave them in the comments on YouTube, or on Spotify, or you can email them to
[email protected]. We would love to hear from you. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Auto comes in. And all in one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Try for free today at odu.com/vox. That's odl.o.com/vox. Hey, everybody. Super here. Birds Eye View, 30 years of the W series, continues. This week, my former Seattle Storm teammate and three time WMBA champion, Swing Cash, joins me to talk about Erritu, years 2003 to 2009. Swin and I discussed the gameplay that defined the Detroit Shock's dominance, the players who helped evolve the game, and the gaps between the on-quart talent and the off-quart business. Plus, we react to photos from our very first WMBA campaign together. And let's just say, what were we thinking? Why did we let them do that to us? Anyways, check out this week's Birds Eye View on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts. Support for the show comes from base 44. Starting a business used to mean raising money, hiring a team, finding developers, and spending years just getting the idea off the ground. With base 44, starting something new has never been simpler. It's an AI platform where you describe the software you need and it delivers. Base 44 goes beyond standard prototyping by converting your vision into fully functional software. It lays out the pages, the data, who uses it, and what the tool should remember. At its full potential, base 44 becomes your business's operating system, powering everything from day one launch essentials to technology that runs the business. The best part is base 44 is made to grow with you. As your business takes off, you can create an effective workflow that supports your needs from selling your product, serving your customers, or running your team. And you stand control, use it, change it, and keep building. Go to base44.com/markets for 30% off the builder plan for your first year. That's base44.com/markets for 30% off your first year. Thanks to base44 for sponsoring this episode. We're back with Profty Markets. The day the world's been waiting for is here. And I am not talking about Anthropics IPO anymore. After 13 years, Grand Theft Auto 6 launches today. Nearly one in three US console and PC gamers say they plan to buy it. And in one survey, nearly one in five US workers said they are taking the day off to play it. The Grand Theft Auto franchise has sold more than 470 million units worldwide. And this installment has already pulled in an estimated $1.5 billion in pre-orders for anyone has even played a minute of it. Shares of Take 2 Interactive, which owns the maker of the GTA franchise, rose 6% yesterday following early credit to reviews of the game. Here to discuss the blockbuster release and what makes the GTA franchise so iconic. We are speaking with Yost Von Drunen, Professor at NYU Stern, who writes about the business of video games. Yost, thank you for joining us. So 13 years and Grand Theft Auto 6 is back.
Put this into perspective for us, how big is this release, how important is it? There's a good question. The closest comparison I can think of is Taylor Swift. Taylor Swift had her biggest tour for two years and generated two billion dollars over the course of those 24 months. GTA 6 is set to make two billion dollars by Monday. So it's an order of magnitude that makes even Swifties weep. What is it about GTA 6 that has turned this thing into such a joke now? I mean, this is one video game that is bringing in numbers that entire companies would dream of. Why is this game such a big deal? Why is it so iconic? I mean, the easy explanation is that Grand Theft Auto has long been sort of a key component to the gamer identity and the culture of gaming. It is sort of fringe activity. It's frowned upon by generations of parents and it just grows and grows into its own momentum. I think what's really happened is that it's matured over time. It tells the story of the American Dream every time casting you as the player in the role of a protagonist that's trying to figure out their life, trying to make it into US at the same time holding a critical lens. And so there's a lot of cultural gravity and weight behind it. And people really seem to enjoy that. Well, then that's a sort of bookish answer to saying, it's an open world's immersive environment. You have free agency. You can kind of play as you see fit. You can go, of course, live a life of crime and that's part of the campaign. But mostly people will be, you know, saling, fishing, hunting and just driving around for fun and enjoying this sort of open range that the game affords. So PS5 and Xbox sales increased 14% following the reveal of GTA 6. So it seems as though this one game is transforming the entire gaming industry. Is that the right characterization? Is gaming kind of resting on this? The game industry has had a couple of rough years since the pandemic. Right. So we had this influx of free capital of cheap money and there's been a lot of consolidation and demand hasn't really caught up with the ambition. But here now 13 years later we have Grand Theft Auto coming out and sort of the high watermark of what can be done of the, this is the highest brow version of what this capable, what this industry is capable of today. You know, imagine the Christopher Nolan release at iMacs, right? It's the best version of what we have. Much of what the game's industry has been working on is mobile games and they're much more low brow, much more, you know, pedestrian in some ways. And so this is a cultural high watermark and people are really hanging their ambition and creativity on to this and against the background of layoffs and cutbacks. What has been happening to the gaming industry over the past few years? Why has it been in a slump? The slump really comes from an overexertion of acquisitions. Large companies are sort of buying other smaller subsidiaries, take too interactive, bought Zingga and that's worked out reasonably well. But Xbox spent $70 billion on Activision Blizzard at the time, the largest game publisher. You know, $70 billion later, you know, they tell you, well, it didn't quite work. The acquisition strategy they told me didn't work. And it has everything to do with, you know, large companies losing track of their empire. You have too many fief terms, it's too large. Quality control goes out the window and all of a sudden you get a bunch of mediocre hits that don't make any return and suddenly investors, shareholders, and the C-suite get very suspicious. So what that of course means is you start cutting into human capital. The talent that makes this industry tick is also the most expensive resource. And so we've seen a decline in demand, met with a decline in just a headcount. And now at the end of this period where sort of Grand Theft Auto sits as an exclamation market as a book end, AI is right there to exacerbate that circumstance even further. So it touches on a lot of these different mechanics at the same time. Is the video game industry unusually exposed to AI? Would you say is AI about to massively disrupt this industry? Yes, that's the short answer. The AI owes the game industry a great debt. As you can imagine, chess computers have been built on chess and so deep blue and all these AI models. They go back decades in terms of their relationship. What do you see now with companies like Epic Games and Maker Fortnite? You see Unity and a bunch of other companies like it heavily emphasizing AI is a way to offset development costs and making the argument that it democratizes game development, which to a degree is a fair way to say, but very much creates what they call AI slop. Across platforms, both creatives and consumers are very skeptical of what this will bring them. It's mostly more stuff that nobody is asking for. And we're still figuring out what the correct formula I would look like. But certainly all the large platform orders are all in on making AI the next phase. Just looking at Tech2 Interactive, the company that owns Rockstar Games, which made GTA 6. So the stock was up 6% yesterday, but it is down 14% year-to-date. Hearing you describe some of the problems of the gaming industry, it almost sounds very similar to the issues in the movie industry. And I even look at GTA 6 today, which incredible hit from everything we've seen in the reviews and the gameplay looks like an incredible game. But it's similar to what we're seeing in Hollywood where it's a reboot of everyone's favorite property from before. It makes me wonder, have we reached peak gaming? Are we in for a decline? Or is there going to be some sort of resurgence is gaming set to expand over the next several years? That's a good thing. It's a fair question and it's a tough one. So the answer to as I see it is that gaming will be more than just play, where previously you'd have a product-based business where you have this 2D kind of experience. You rescue the princess, you kill the dragon, and that's sort of the end of the experience. Then we have multiplayer coming in, we have these three-dimensional environments and you and I can play World of Warcraft together and do all of that. The next era seems to be more multimedia in nature. So what that means is Nintendo makes a billion, a billion and a half of the movies that it launches at the box office. It develops theme parks. People are increasingly invited and incentivized to create in-game assets. They share this with others. They make money off of this in some of these contexts. So what play used to be as an isolated, insular experience is now taking place across different disciplines and media categories. So my mind, we're seeing the beginning of what's next. It's met by, say, large tech platforms that are really leaning into making that possible, whether that's Xbox, or whether it's Netflix, or whether it's Amazon. They all want to have TV series and new ways to engage audiences. Final question. Will you be playing GTA VI? Is that your job? Do you need to know how this game gets out of this game works? Listen, listen, it's a racket. You called it out. It's true. So, unfortunately, on Thursday, I teach my class at Stern. So I'm already getting a lot of people calling in sick for mysterious reasons. So I'll allow it. So I'm hoping to get a few hours earlier in the morning, but I've been watching it very closely. I can't wait for this to begin. Just fun, Drew, and his professor at NYU Stern who writes about the business of video games. Yost, really appreciate your time. Cheers. Let's shift gears and end with a quick check-in on tax policy here in New York. You might remember the Pierre de Terre tax. This was the tax that was implemented this summer by Zora and Mamdoni, which placed a surcharge on non-primary residences in New York City. In other words, it taxed people's second homes. Now, some people were quite upset about this tax. They saw it as an example of targeting the wealthy, which, I mean, yeah, that's the whole point of aggressive tax, but they also argued that if you were to implement this, then all of those wealthy New Yorkers that New York needs, they were all going to leave. They'll say, "I've had it. I'm moving to Florida," to which my response was back in the summer. They already left. They left years ago, because remember, this is a tax on second homes. It's taxing non-New York residents, most of whom live in other states or even other countries where they don't have to pay into New York income taxes. And these are people who are wealthy enough to own a second or a third or a fourth home in New York City. In other words, this is exactly the kind of tax policy that we need. A reasonable, precise piece of legislation that redistributes wealth from those who are already very wealthy and who are not contributing that much to the New York tax base. So, as far as taxes go, in my view, this is basically perfect. Well, yesterday we got an update on how the Pierre de Terre tax is going. In just a few months, the tax has raised more than $500 million from owners of second homes worth more than $5 million. So that is half a billion dollars to help pay for New York's roads, for its bridges, its hospitals, its fire departments, its police departments. In fact, it is almost enough money to pay for school lunch for every kid in New York City for a year. And it was that easy. And the reason I bring this up is because this is the kind of thinking that we need when it comes to taxation, as I have highlighted many times on
this show before. Inequality in America is untenable. The top 1% now control more wealth in the entire middle class. Our genie coefficient for wealth inequality is now up to 0.83, which is equal to what it was in revolutionary France. This is not acceptable anymore, so we have to redistribute. And we have to do it in a way that is substantive, in a way that is effective, but also in a way that is fair. And this policy meets all of those criteria. And above all, it is a sign that new ideas and new policies can actually work. This is what good legislation looks like. My recommendation to Congress, take a look at what's happening in New York. Okay, that's it for today. This episode was produced by Claire Miller and Alison Weiss and was engineered by Benjamin Spencer. Our video editor is Brad Williams. Our research team is Dan Chalon, Christian O'Donohue, and Mia Salverio, and our social producer is Jake McPherson. Thank you for listening to Profty Markets from Profty Media. If you liked what you heard, give us a follow. I'm Ed Elson, tune in tomorrow for our conversation with Professor Aswath DeModeray. That's where Odo comes in, an all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all-in-one powerful platform, no messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Try for free today at od.com/box. That's od.o.com/box.