Go back

Anne Applebaum: All the Corruption, All the Time

56m 21s

Anne Applebaum: All the Corruption, All the Time

The transcript critically examines the U.S. foreign policy under the Trump administration, portraying it as authoritarian, opaque, and transactional. A key event—the Shenzhen summit with Putin and Xi—is described as a calculated performance echoing Cold War-era power dynamics, signaling a dangerous shift toward authoritarian global alliances. The narrative highlights how Trump’s rhetoric and actions, including calls to end the Ukraine war and support Russian aggression, undermine European security and democratic values. Meanwhile, the midterms revealed a public backlash against political corruption, especially in defense and military spending, with voters demanding transparency and accountability. The administration’s neglect of key institutions—like the EPA—adds to a pattern of institutional erosion, raising public health and safety concerns. In Venezuela, the U.S. is seen as propping up a corrupt regime rather than supporting democratic transition, contradicting its own values. Globally, the U.S. is increasingly viewed as a system driven by short-term gains and deals, not long-term principles. This shift is forcing allies to build independent defense and technological capabilities. The piece concludes with a note of cautious hope for democratic resurgence in Venezuela and a call for greater transparency in U.S. governance, emphasizing that democratic integrity relies on accountability, public awareness, and vigilance against corruption.

Transcription

10380 Words, 57484 Characters

English
Twas the night before Toyotathon and all through the land, not a creature was stirring, not even Jan, that's me. Winter plans were made, skiing, skating, hiking, and more, and they came to fruition with Tundras, Camrys, BZs, and RAV4s. In bed, dreaming of the places they'd gone, everyone knew Toyotathon is on. Dealer inventory may vary. Current offers on these vehicles end November 30th. Offers are subject to change throughout Toyotathon, which ends on January 4th. See your participating Toyota dealer for details. Toyota, let's go places. This is Matt Rogers from Las Culturistas with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang. This is Bowen Yang from Las Culturistas with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang. We've been talking about Kewpie Mayo for a minute now, and wow, so many of you already love this stuff. And if you're thinking, wait, what is Kewpie? Do you not have the internet? It's the OG Japanese mayonnaise, the one with the red cap. What makes it different? Egg yolks. Kewpie is made with egg yolks only, giving it this rich umami flavor that elevates everything. Shit. Chefs use it, restaurants use it, where chefs work, of course. Food and flavor lovers use it. You haven't tried it yet? Well, find the red cap and see what everyone's talking about, why don't ya? Kewpie. The original Japanese mayonnaise. Kewpie. Hello and welcome to the Bullwark Daily. I'm your host, Tim Miller. A few programming notes real quick. Reporter and the Spy, Raps. It launches on Sunday. Michael Weiss, Mark Polymeropoulos. It's going to be so good. So please go subscribe to it now, Spotify, Apple, wherever you get your podcasts. Also, Trump is having a press conference this afternoon that will probably be over by the time you hear this. So JVL and I are going to do a live stream over on YouTube. And if you want to laugh at Donald Trump with us, you can go to the Bullwark Take Speed and catch that. Okay, today's show. She's a staffer. She's a staff writer at The Atlantic, host of its Autocracy in America podcast. The fourth season just launched. Her most recent books include Twilight of Democracy and Autocracy, Inc. It is the Queen of Darkness and Apple Bomb. Now you're in the light now. It looks nice. Thanks for that kind introduction, Tim. Of course. It is good to see you. I wanted to obviously talk about the summit such that it was. But first, that's the first time we've spoken since the midterms, the big Democratic win in the midterms. And I just kind of wanted to pick your brain a bit. About kind of the view from the view from Europe, the view from other folks that you talk to and in the globalist liberal democracy community about, you know, whether it has changed perspectives, the scale of the victory. And if you have any other additional thoughts. So from the outside world, the primary reaction was it was relief. And it wasn't just about electing Democrats to the Senate. It was relief that. At least a lot of ordinary Americans feel the same way they do. So there was, you know, makes you feel less crazy. You know, it's just like I thought they were going to feel like we're going insane. It's like, how are you people still voting for this? Well, also, if you think about how do people in Europe or elsewhere read the news, right? They they don't see podcasts. They don't see they don't watch, you know, John Ossoff on Instagram. All they see are the kind of news headlines. And from their perspective, they just couldn't hear any Democrats. Speaking back, they couldn't hear any protest. You know, all they saw was the news of what Trump was doing. And so the election was a kind of huge surprise. Wow. There are all these ordinary American voters who feel the same way we do. And there are all these candidates that we never heard of. And they and they won. And so there was that that was part of the reaction. And then, of course, the second. I will have to object to one point to there, which is that there are some sickos who listen. Like any time I mention, I don't know, Talon, Estonia or something, I'll get three emails from Talon. So there there's a small. A small cadre of Europeans who were so distraught that they're like, yes, I am going to listen to a random never Trumpers podcast. So anyway, but I take your point about the broader populace. I mean, then, of course, the second reaction is, but Trump is still in charge. And unfortunately, the summit in Shenzhen really drove that that home. And so you're not going to see any policy changes or people suddenly saying, wow, America's back and we're happy to work with them again. Everybody's still very cautious. I mean, for me, the good news about the midterms was the number of people who in the in the polling showed this. And you could also hear it in the candidates and you could see it at the various election events. The number of people who were voting on not just the economy issues, who understood that corruption was a big issue, who understood that money in politics is a big issue, who understood that voting rights are big issues. You know, so you could you know, this this idea that Americans don't care about democracy. And this, I think, was proven to be untrue. And that's part of what foreigners see. But it's also, I think, great news for Americans. Yeah. And the exit polls corruption was number one issue, you know, came up and obviously see the big backlights to voting rights, you know, here in the South where I am in particular. What about just kind of at the elite level, you know, when it comes to foreign ministers and, you know, that kind of crowd in Europe, how are they reacting to everything? So they again, same reaction, glad that Americans have have qualms about about the current regime. But as I said, it was followed almost immediately by Donald Trump holding his hand out to Vladimir Putin and saying, my friend. And so it was like it was like a bucket of cold water on everything. So the general feeling is still we have to hedge. We need alternatives. We need different technology. We need new friends. We need new relationships. You know, Europe, Canada, India, Brazil, the way in which people now do business in which they think about defense and security has changed and pretty profoundly. I mean, the main issue for Europeans is Ukraine. And they have to have a plan going forward for how to support Ukraine in the total absence of U.S. support for at least the next two years. Let's go to the summit then that big bucket of cold water. I want to start with this for the audio listeners. I'm going to narrate it for you because, you know, it's only the propaganda music that you'll be able to hear. But this is what the White House put out following Trump's meeting with Putin and Xi. Let's watch. OK, we've got the three dictators there. Putin's the only one smiling. He's happy. Now we're around the table together. Oh, very serious. Xi in the middle. Yeah, Xi in the middle. Dominating. And now we have Xi and Trump cheerfully shaking hands with a gay Chinese soldier behind them at attention. So, you know, there was more like that. And there was a lot of really just proper authoritarian propaganda coming out of the meeting. But your article on it was headlined embarrassing and consequential cosplay Yalta. So the real Yalta summit was, of course, a huge tragedy and a catastrophe for Europe. It was the meeting of Franklin Roosevelt, Winston Churchill and Stalin. They agreed various things about the end of the war. But the most important thing that the summit is remembered for is these three big leaders. And Britain was a big leader at the time. It still had an empire. Making decisions about the borders and the fate of Eastern Europe over their heads. And so they redrew the borders of Poland at that summit. And later ones, they decided essentially that the Soviet Union would have control over, would be first the liberator and then allowed to take charge of Eastern Europe. You know, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, eastern half of Germany, then Yugoslavia. And it's remembered in that part of the world as this enormous tragedy. You know, these kind of. You know, big countries got together and they made decisions for us. And this Shenzhen summit looked like it was designed to do the same thing. And there are people in the Trump administration who would, I think, like that also to be true. They would like there to be a kind of tripartite division of the world. The U.S. gets the Western Hemisphere. Russia's in charge of Europe. China is in charge of Asia. But right. Why would we have Russia in charge of Europe? And I don't know, you know, even if we were going to play this game of fantasy risk. I don't know. We would think that we would want the EU to be the third. Well, and also the EU is many, many times wealthier than Russia. And even EU armies, when put together, are a challenge for Russia. There is no scenario in which Russia can control Europe, nor would we want Russia to control Europe or even Eastern Europe. Because when Russia controls Eastern Europe, as it did in 1945 and it does in Eastern Ukraine now, that means terror, concentration camps, the kidnapping of children. The murder of local officials. It's a full-on imposition of totalitarianism. So why would we want that any more than we would want Chinese control of Taiwan or Chinese control or influence over South Korea or Japan? So there is this game about spheres of influence. There was an advisor to J.D. Vance who I know talked about it. He told some Polish colleagues of mine that that was his vision for the world. There is a sort of idea in Trump world that this would be an efficient and good way to rule the world. But I think what the summit showed was. It's not possible anymore. I mean, they didn't. As far as we can tell, and maybe we'll learn more in coming days, almost nothing of real substance was discussed. They decided that nuclear weapons were bad. They wanted there to be more, you know, more sales of gasoline. You know, that also sounds, you know, pretty, pretty anodyne. Oh, and there was a conversation about the International Criminal Court, which has condemned Putin as a war criminal. And Trump has agreed with Putin and Xi that it's a very bad thing. So, you know. but you weren't hearing them divide up Europe. The real enemy, the International Criminal Court. The real enemy is the International Criminal Court. Actually, Marco Rubio was denouncing the International Criminal Court recently as well. Yeah. Well, I guess one thing of substance seemed to have been discussed with regards to Ukraine based on what happened in the following day. Trump on the flight home on Air Force One got on a call with European leaders. He said they could save money as well as lives by ending the war with Russia, according to five European officials. He lamented what he characterized as a waste of billions of dollars to provide Ukraine with weapons and cash for a conflict that is killing so many people. So, I mean, I just, again, this is a little bit of a Groundhog Day situation, but it does seem as if Trump was carrying Putin's message back to the European leaders. Every time he meets Putin in whatever context, this is what he says afterwards. Right. You know, whether he's talking, on the phone or whether he's speaking to him at an international summit, he always immediately afterwards says, why don't we end this war? And by end the war, what he means is that Ukraine should surrender. Stop aiding Ukraine, stop sending weapons to Ukraine, stop spending money on Ukraine. That sounds like a very, very attractive slogan. I mean, of course, war is very bad and so on. But what does it mean in practice? What are the consequences of that? The Russians would overwhelm the front line. The Russians would take over Kiev. The Russians would move their troops to the Western border. You would have, massive dislocation of people, huge refugee crisis, huge economic crisis, oil and gas crisis, probably grain crisis. You would have not less security spending in Europe. The Europeans would need to double and triple and quadruple it because the threat from Russia and from a reinvigorated Russian army would be 10 times larger. And that's without even talking about what would happen in Ukraine, the murder of the Ukrainian leadership. I'm not using the word concentration camp lightly. They set up filtration camps. And everywhere they occupy, they drag people through them. They interrogate them. They torture them. They impose a totalitarian system. They try to change the way that Ukrainians think and behave, much as the Nazis tried to change Poland during the Second World War, or indeed how the Soviet Union changed Eastern Europe after 1945 as well. So it's not like that's a neutral option. It's not like the option is, OK, we stop spending and we all save money and the war ends. The option is we stop spending. And the war gets worse and the consequences are more terrible. Yeah. Trump seems unable to understand that. There are many European leaders who seem unable to understand that. I mean, Ukrainians understand it. I think the Poles understand it. I think, you know, a lot of Germans understand it. And, you know, people are beginning to. Well, there was a meeting Thursday. There was a meeting yesterday. I was going to ask you about to this, where they're calling a coalition of the Willink, which we're not part of, in support of Ukraine. We created it, I should say, in 2022. But no, we're not part of it anymore. And it was Mertz and Macron and new prime minister of Britain, Andy Burnham and some others. But to this point, like talking about, OK, we have to be the ones that are representing the Ukrainian interests, right? That's essentially. So there is no U.S. funding for Ukraine. And so all of the funding now comes from Europe. And then it's a combination of European funding and Ukrainian ingenuity and innovation. And I think I've talked about the drone industry with you before. They've reinvented this way of doing war. So they are already preparing for a world without the U.S. because already the world without the U.S. exists, with the exception of Witkow and Kushner, you know, the two negotiators who are still playing a role because Putin wants them to play a role. So the negotiations continue. So we're calling them Kushnoff now. Kushnoff. I hadn't heard that. That's a good way to shorten it. We used to have Javanka. Now we have Kushnoff. Yeah, Kushnoff. Yeah. Yeah, it feels right. You know, it sounds exactly. If we could just get the double. Fs to a V. We'd really be in business. I want to get to what Jared said in a second. But the other thing that's been happening, you know, in the actual war, not in like the fantasy cosplay thing that Trump and the dictators were doing was Russia continued to attack Kiev this week and last night after the meeting ended. There's another wave of Russian ballistic missiles and cruise missiles targeting the city of Kiev. Three bridges linking the east and west sides, you know, were hit and hit. And then, on top of that, there have been some drone attacks, I guess, that hit Poland. Trump called that, as he said, a couple little missiles made through by mistake. A couple little missiles. And obviously, the Poles are taking that more seriously than our president is. So, I mean, like, that's the reality on the ground. Yeah, the reality on the ground, there's sort of three realities. One reality is that the Russians can't move forward on the front line. They're not able to move. They're still losing thousands of soldiers every month. They lost 50,000, something like that, last month, which is an incredible number. The Ukrainians are successfully targeting and hitting Russian refineries. They've taken out now 50% of Russian refining capacity, according to Catherine Belton at the Washington Post, who's a real expert on this. They hit the Crimean Bridge a few days ago and have made it now impossible for car traffic to go back and forth, which is the most important connection between Russia and Crimea. Long bridge, open with great fanfare and so on. And then the third reality is because of these, the Russians can't respond to their other two problems. They've taken to targeting civilian infrastructure, so heating and electricity plants, bridges, as you say, in Kiev, schools, hospitals. In Kherson, where the front line is very close to the city, they use drones just to smash into people's cars. It's almost as if for fun. And then they make little videos of them. The Russian soldiers put them up on social media. And so it's really a terror campaign of a kind that you would associate with, you know, the really the worst and most extreme terrorist groups of the 20th century. You know, it's absolutely aimed at civilians. It's absolutely aimed at creating suffering and fear. There's no military purpose to it because it's not helping them move forward or affecting the front line. And it is absolutely expanded into Europe. The Poles believe that the missiles, I think they think it's two missiles and a drone last night. Um, but there have been multiple sabotage attacks. There was an attack on a Polish passenger train. Just a mistake. No one believes these are mistakes. These are not mistakes. These are part of a campaign against Europe designed to undermine European solidarity, to make people afraid to help Ukraine and so on. And you've, you've seen that you've seen this stuff in France. You've seen it in, in, in Germany. You've seen it in Poland. You've seen it in the UK, assassinations, sabotage, Spain, Bulgarian ships in the black sea, which seem to be affecting Bulgarian politics quite a bit as well. It's ratcheting up. It's getting worse and worse. Everybody in Europe can see it. Uh, people react differently. Some people in Europe see it and say, right, we need greater solidarity. Some people in Europe see it and are afraid and say, oh, maybe we should step back. But it's, it's unquestionably happening and it's shaping European politics. Why the United States appears to be not interested, why the American president doesn't know or doesn't care why he keeps making excuses for Putin. You know, we're back to the same question we've been discussing since 2016. Why is he the first American president since the second world war and maybe longer back who doesn't care about America's alliances, who doesn't stand for any ideals or, or reality of, of democracy, uh, the rule of law? Why isn't he fighting terrorism? Why does he do what Putin said? And we're back to the age old question. Can I ask a more verboten question from a hawk standpoint, thinking about how Europe is responding to this, which is, is there any discussion or consideration of escalation from a European standpoint? I mean, Russia is vulnerable from a military standpoint and I don't know if they're going to be squirting missiles into Poland and, you know, having drones attack airports in Germany. I don't, is that the conversation even on the table? Yes. People do discuss it. It's discussed mostly privately. It's something, something that the European public is not ready for. Um, even if they're European politics who've begun to talk about, you know, what we could do. And obviously there's scenario planning because there, there are fears that there could be, as he ratchets up, he could, you know, what if one of those missiles struck the middle of a city? Um, what if the missile attack was accompanied then by some kind of cross border raid? The Estonians have just closed their border, by the way, with Russia, uh, for that reason. So there is scenario planning and discussion. But because of the extreme unpopularity of the idea of going to war, you haven't seen anyone do it yet. And so unfortunately it's one of those situations where it would, there would have to be an event that convinced people that it was really necessary. I think the Russians are deliberately keeping their attacks below that level. So there hasn't been like a mass casualty event yet. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, just thinking about the success that Ukraine has had taking up, you know, the bridge, if we're mentioned in Crimea, uh, to Crimea and some of the other military assets, it's kind of like the Russians seem, seem like they could have a glass jaw on all this stuff. I think you're right. But as I said, we're not, the politics don't work for that yet. Right. All right. You guys have heard many times about the degree to which I'm a disaster at the airport. Uh, most recent trip I had, it was just me and my daughter. She came to Denver with us a couple of weeks ago. And, um, my husband, and received a reprieve, he was at home. So it's just the two of us at the airport and getting the two of us onto a plane together like me and a child i'm i'm tweeting i'm holding a coffee she is like riding on her suitcase it's a mess okay it can be a mess and the only thing that is keeping us together is our noble all-in-one carry-on suitcase it's got a cup holder right there that makes it nice it has a charging port always be charging laptop pocket so i can pull that in and out so i'm not literally fully opening the suitcase on the ground at the gate and showing people my underwear because that's something that was happening before uh secure it's got zebra wheels it's great it's great this is what you need you're coming up in the holidays some holiday travel either a gift or something for yourself the noble suitcase is something to look at noble gives you a real travel peace of mind security design and convenience all in one every suitcase comes with a 100-day money-back guarantee and a free three-day express shipping do we mention it has a lifetime warranty it does it's the last suitcase you'll ever need to buy upgrade to luggage that looks better lasts longer and travels smarter for a limited time noble is having the biggest sale of the year head to noble travel.com for up to 67 off your entire order that's nobl travel.com for up to 67 off after you purchase that will ask you where you heard about them please support our show and tell them we sent you let's go back to kushnoff for a second as it relates to all this he was speaking at a press conference after the summit and talked about what the latest in the supposed progress that they've been making in their conversations many many many many many conversations with the russian side let's watch so that's a very big development that we've been able to achieve and i think we've gotten the russians comfortable with that concept where any security guarantee for ukraine would be based on article 5 and i think that that comes with at least what the russians are saying which is their intention is when this war is over to not have another war in the world in the future and i know that there's a lot of skepticism and disbelief uh on that concept in russia that was my favorite part of it everybody's focused on how he's like oh russia could be okay with article 5 for ukraine which is absurd and i thought he was about to acknowledge i know that there would be some skepticism among our allies and among americans that russia would go along with this but no he was saying i know that there would be skepticism among the russians for this kind of plan and it's just truly crazy to reinforce his point hours later the russians issued a statement saying no we will not accept ukraine and nato in any form so i don't know what who kushner was talking to or what you know pipe he was smoking but nobody in russia has ever said they would accept nato guarantees for ukraine also even if you think that sentence through for one second like if the russians wanted you know to make sure there was never a war again they could stop the war now they could stop fighting i mean the russians wanted to show goodwill and show they were willing to accept you know i don't know western troops in ukraine or whatever they could just stop you know the war could end the war could end next week the work could end in an hour if they wanted to stop it yeah they just have to stop fighting you know and the ukrainians have already said they would accept a ceasefire along the current front line um and with everything else to be discussed later on they would accept it right now and if the russians wanted to end the war and they were in good negotiating in good faith they would do that but they don't and that's because they don't want to end the war they still have never given up their main goal their main goal is the destruction of all of ukraine turning ukraine into a russian state or a russian satrapy or some kind of russian colony they've never stopped thinking that they've never stopped saying it putin says it repeatedly and the effect of this trump kushner witkoff the effect of all of their actions has been to reinforce him in this belief to prolong the war to give the russians belief that if they just keep fighting they'll eventually have the americans on their side and they will win there it has been a you know one of the most useless negotiating tactics i've ever seen yeah that's been kind um i know this is a serious podcast and and i hate to be a little petty but also every time i see jared speak i wonder more and more whether he's like he's a lizard person or a real human like i don't know what is happening with him but there's been a big transformation over the last four years i feel like something is trying to get out from inside i don't know maybe the truth is that there's been a big endoskeleton or something i'm not sure what but um it's rough okay speaking of kushner i want to do some corruption talk too and there is an atlantic story when your colleagues was writing about this but kushner in particular then i kind of want to broaden it out but he after the midterms his investment firm affinity that has all the saudi money uh did a filing that indicated they had a 32 million dollar stake in a american defense contractor filing relates that uh revealed that they had a 32 million dollar stake in a american defense contractor filing relates that uh revealed they had acquired 689 000 shares and the company arxis that makes mission critical components for f-35 fighter jets navy destroyers nuclear submarines anti-missile systems which have been deployed in the middle east and in russia ukraine a private citizen who is the son-in-law of the president investing in a defense contractor is not really a store and that's probably something people would report on to know about it but not really a story but the fact that this is happening that he has these huge massive investments there's also the story about investments in israeli firms but in cnn a couple months ago like while he's doing these negotiations it's just utterly insane it's insane and of course in addition to his own personal investments he's also negotiating with the russians pipeline deals oil and gas deals deals over the property of a russian company called luke oil and it looks like the u.s is steering some luke oil property that has to be sold because of sanctions steering it towards the russians and he's also negotiating with the russians and he's also negotiating with the russians and he's also negotiating with the russians and he's also negotiating with the russians and he's also to shape their negotiations and their thinking through the amount of money they think they're going to make. And that's really how most of the rest of the world now deals with the United States. For a lot of countries, it makes sense. I mean, if you're, I don't know, if you're Qatar or you're the Emirates, you just look at the United States and say, oh, okay, it's a system like ours, right? I mean, in order to get the United States to do something, you offer them a deal or you offer them money. I mean, I don't know if you want to go in the NVIDIA direction, but it looks like this is exactly the same thing that happened. How do you get NVIDIA to sell chips to China? Well, you persuade Howard Lutnick, whose son's company or his former company now run by his sons has big investments in Southeast Asian companies, which sell chips or known to pass on chips to the Chinese. So you influence the administration through money. And that's now how the rest of the world. Sees America. This is how you do American foreign policy. I mean, you asked me at the beginning about how Europeans see our elections. They say, great, democracy is coming back. And we're glad that Americans feel as upset about this change as we do. But this stuff is still there. Bribing Jared Kushner is still going to be seen by most of the world as a legitimate way to try to influence American foreign policy. Let's just talk about the NVIDIA thing for a second. An interesting subplot to all of this is the question of, it doesn't seem to me that Trump actually really cares about the sale to the Chinese. It seems like he kind of is for it, right? To me, it feels like there are two things happening. There are some people inside the administration who are either China hawks are concerned about security, who are serious, and even some unserious people, but who are China hawks, like, like are concerned about this at like that level, right? Like, it's not wise. And then there are other people who like want to perform it. actively demonstrate strength, but are in on the deals and like, frankly, want to prop up the companies as much as possible. And what Trump said about Jensen the other day is like, we need to protect our geniuses. I think that's like the actual policy of the administration. So the actual policy of the administration is how do we use this relationship to benefit ourselves? Trump has, I didn't remember the numbers off the top of my head, maybe they're in your notes, but he has many millions of dollars, tens of million dollars in NVIDIA stock. That stock went up when the deals were arranged that NVIDIA could sell chips to China. I already talked about Lutnick's arrangement. There may be many others. We don't know how the stock ownership of many members of the Trump administration might be affected. Well, and even in addition to the personal, Trump doesn't care about whether in four years, China is using this to help win the AI race or not. He doesn't care about whether in four years, China is using this to help win the AI race or if in eight years, this creates additional instability or threat. Trump doesn't care about all that. He has no sense of time. He's not interested in what happens in four years. He's not really interested in anything that happened before either. He doesn't have any sense of loyalty to the past. He doesn't know any history. And as far as he's concerned, after he's president, he doesn't care what happens after that. So no, he doesn't have any interest in the fate of the United States, in the future of our security, in what happens to American prosperity in four years or 10 years. None of that is of any interest to him. He's very much focused on what's happening right now. Am I winning? whatever conflict I'm in or conversation I'm part of? Like, am I, am I seen as the victor here? And am I making money? And are my friends doing well? But other than that, you're right. He has no, I mean, this is why the concept of national security is so hard for him. Because national security is something you think about long term, and you plan in advance, and you think about, you know, different scenarios, and you think about you watch the rise of China, you ask whether it's good or bad, he doesn't, you know, none of that makes any sense to him, because he has no sense of the future. He's not interested in it. I want to go back to the corruption stuff. But this thought just popped in my head, and the conversations with Europeans, is there concern about, like the way in which they're so far behind in the end when it comes to AI and security on that front? Because, again, 10 years ago, maybe that wouldn't have been a concern, because they have an alliance with America. And, you know, a lot, I'm sure that, you know, there'd be a lot of people working on it. But now, I would think that that would be a real threat that they have to be contemplating. It is a huge subject of constant conversation. And every European event or meeting or conference or anything that I'm ever at where they're senior business people, this is all they talk about, is the need to have European tech, European, you know, cloud computing, European AI, the need to move away from US technology, and not only military technology, but all technology, the French have invested a lot in their own AI. There's a whole bunch of German entrepreneurs working on new projects. If you talk to the heads of German banks, or any, any European banks, really, they'll all be talking about how do we find ways to move our, you know, to move our data onto European servers and onto European platforms. It's a it's an enormous topic of conversation. And you're right, I mean, this weakness came about, because the US has this enormous uncertainty and change. I mean, it's hard to start a tech industry from scratch. But in almost every country, you hear people talking about it. Yeah. And at some level, that also, I mean, it's hard to start a tech industry from scratch. Yeah. And at some level, that also, I mean, you know, there's a lot of uncertainty and change, right? So it's a lot of uncertainty and change, right? I mean, there's a lot of uncertainty and change, right? You know, China, Chinese models are open, right? And so that's probably a fact, like, rather than starting it from scratch, right? Like you would, again, this is not my area of expertise, but you would think that that would be the way that, you know, you would use these kind of open models that the Chinese are offering, and then build on top of that. And that creates other threats, obviously, too. But right, but for a lot of the world, that is going to be the way they move forward. And I mean, that's how what's why the Chinese decided to run their system that way was to immediately be more accessible to more, you know, countries in Africa, countries in Asia. That was the point is that this idea that the US is, is the cutting edge on AI, and always will be and will always be ahead of everybody, I think is wrong. Yeah, the Chinese we know are catching up. Others will be looking for ways to catch up or change or find or find a way to catch up. And I think that's the way that we're going to be. And I think that's the way the United States uses its technology as a weapon against its allies, whether military technology or civilian technology, the more you will see this kind of reaction. I mean, look at the reactions to Starlink. Starlink was a huge wake-up call. And this I know for a fact. I know of one European government which made a decision not to use Starlink as the center of its military communication system because of what Musk did in Ukraine. So if he's able to turn off Starlink in Ukraine just because he feels like it, then if you're Italian or if you're Norwegian, you're not going to want to use it either. And so there's already the move to move away from Starlink has already begun. There are a number of European projects. Ukrainians are already using some alternatives. They don't have as many satellites in the air and so on. But that's already begun as well. Just back to the corruption really quick. The bad news, good news is I do feel like there continue to be some like last days of Stalin style stories about the gold rush that we're happening uh that's happening right now like the washington post this morning jason miller is the kind of guy that was the trump spokesperson that doesn't have a chin that the big controversy about how the fact that he doesn't pay his child support to a woman that he impregnated during the first trump campaign and and so because of that like we get to see his books a lot because there's ongoing litigation and so we've gotten to see his books i guess this week he made 15 million this year he's in like after carolyn levitt left uh he is kind of a bridge communication strategist in the white house so it's not even he's just an advisor like he's a public servant made 15 million through september 2026 he's on the uh payroll of india romania paramount sky dance part of the corrupt media merger deal again and at some level it's like gross that this guy has made 15 million On another hand, it's just like, I don't know, with corruption as a top issue in the midterm, if this is just one example, we only know about it because of the child support issue. We're about to have a bunch of oversight hearings next year. I think that there is, it's one of these things where this is self-perpetuating on their end, and it's going to hurt them politically as people keep trying to grab little bits of cash on the way out. Is that too optimistic? I mean, this is the most corrupt administration we've ever had, and there isn't one in second place. And the stories of it, you know, I think we're going to be telling for a really long time. You know, I think part of what happened in the midterms was a backlash to this. Some American politicians are beginning to understand how important corruption is to Americans and how much they dislike it. They're beginning to make the link. And this is the really important part between these kind of sometimes very complicated stories of corruption, making the link between that and ordinary people. You know, they're stealing money. They don't care about you. They don't care about your prosperity. That's why the economy is doing badly. And I think they're they're right. I mean, I think there's I think the corruption in the economy are very closely related stories. It could well backfire. I mean, the trick for Democrats over the next two years is going to be how to hold the hearings in such a way that they're understandable. that they don't feel like an overreach, that they don't look like revenge, that they just look like citizens holding other Americans accountable for stealing. And, you know, the Republicans will do the opposite messaging and say it's revenge and so on. I think that's the main political story is going is going I think that's the main political story for the next two years. Great news for Warren G. Harding there on the, you know, most corrupt administration ever. Teapot Dome scandal? Who cares? Who cares? Nothing. Now he can disappear into history in peace. I'm not sure why, but this in my brain when I was reading this story, you know, was giving off Russia vibes for me. So I just want to throw this one at you. Washington reported on this. The Defense Department and the EPA have known since April that the U.S. Army was sitting on 68 barrels of degrading volatile lead explosive at its Middletown, Iowa, ammunition plant. Communities surrounding the plant and state leaders only became aware of this, that's right, after the midterms this week, that the Army plans to detonate the lead explosive on November 20th. And it could result in a plume of toxic lead dust that could travel well beyond the town and possibly into neighboring Illinois. Is this insane? Like, this is where we're at. Another instance of, you know, having a government that doesn't care about citizens and doesn't feel responsible for them. You know, that's another institution. We don't talk very much about the EPA, right, or the highway safety administrators. But all those institutions have also been dismantled. I mean, almost every part of the federal government has been badly damaged by this administration. And the side effects and results. Whether it's, you know, the measles spreading or whether it's more accidents or whether it's the deterioration of the airlines. All of that we're going to begin to feel over time. You know, they don't make good news stories like firing some EPA administrators or some government scientists quitting. You know, that's not a news story. But the impact of it down the road will be. I just want to pick your brain on a couple of the other things you've been working on lately. On the Autocracy in America pod, you had Jason Crow on. Recently, who represents my childhood district in Denver. Very serious congressperson. I saw him last week as well. You guys talked a lot about kind of what Democrats can do as far as de-politicizing the military, as far as the Iran war, what kind of leverage they have. Like, what were your takeaways from that convo? My takeaways were that this is one of the areas where the Democrats have really strong cards. They have a lot of Republican support and they have a lot of public support. And the politicization of the military is something that people understand very well. The ugliness of firing black and female officers is something people instinctively don't like, I think, all across America. The misuse of war powers, the mismanagement of the war in Iran is something we can all see and everybody's feeling the economic effects of it. You know, we were just talking about oversight hearings. One of the areas where Democrats will be very, very strong and have a lot of public support is by investment. And I think the impeachment of Hexeth is also something that we'll come back to. that will come up again in January. The military, American military is as popular as it is because it's always been a bipartisan institution. And it's understood that military culture is such that officers pledge their allegiance to the constitution and not to one president. And the idea that the president has his own generals, which is the language that Trump has used in the past, is something I think Americans find intrinsically ugly, including Republicans. I mean, this is not a partisan feeling. And so I know that Jason will have a role in pursuing that. And I have no doubt that's going to be a really serious project for them. What about the Iran war side of it? I do think it's more challenging. It is challenging. You've seen this. I interviewed Chris Van Hollen this week. I was talking about Josh Barrow. And it's like, okay, on the one hand, they can shut down the government over it. That creates potential political issues. The administration created a mess. Right. And so on the one hand, I think it's important for the Democrats to be a check and oppose it. On the other hand, you don't want responsibility for their mess, right? Because there's not a good answer for cleaning it up. So how did Congressman Crowe talk about that? Congressman Crowe talked about using the power that Congress has over the budget to cut spending. I mean, literally military spending. And his argument was that, you know, people will say, you can't do that. We have soldiers on the ground. We still have huge numbers of people who are, you know, in the Persian Gulf doing military blockades, naval blockades. You know, we're still spending a huge amount of money in Iran, even though, again, that's not in the news. His argument is, you know, people have always said, well, you can't do that in the middle of the war. We've invested all this time and money and people in fighting it. You can't cut them off now. And his argument is we made those arguments about Afghanistan. We made those arguments about Iraq. And all it led to was prolonged conflicts in which, you know, the American use and American, advantage from that was pretty unclear. And that it's time to use the budget power to block funding. I mean, if you don't fund the naval blockade, then it won't exist anymore. It would be a really radical thing to do. And that might, that would be less universally popular than ending the politicization of the military or investigating the strikes on boats in the Caribbean. But I think there will be a move to try it. You also wrote just for the midterms about what the U.S. is really doing in Venezuela. We talked about this a little bit last time, because I think you've just been back but hadn't written a piece yet. It was particularly striking to me, your conversations with people around the oil fields. So I'd be interested to hear you talk about that and kind of what you think is next at the political level. The Venezuelan opposition, actually, the Venezuelan people more broadly are probably the most pro-American people in Latin America, which is saying a lot. A lot of Latin Americans are very anti-American. And when Maduro was kidnapped in January, there were huge expectations, including from American oil companies. Somebody in Venezuela, when I was there, that there had been a survey, an opinion poll taken in Venezuela about what institutions do you trust the most. And round about February, March, Venezuelans said the institutions they trust the most are U.S. oil companies. Think about that. But if you think about it from their point of view, it makes sense. What do they associate U.S. industry and oil industry in particular with? Kind of environmental concern, adhering to the rule of law, paying good salaries. Relatively speaking. Relatively speaking. I was in Lake Maracaibo where there's gas bubbles on the water from the broken gas lines underneath the lake and where there's oil spills on top of the water and the shoreline is black and so on. So by comparison to that, you want something better. You want the oil to be taken out of the ground in a better way. And so they thought American oil companies would do it. And they imagined that the U.S. administration would be one would want to create a situation where there's a legitimate government in Venezuela, where U.S. oil companies want to invest long term because it will take 10 years and millions of dollars to to fix the industry. And they imagined that all that would happen. And instead, what they've got is this coalition of two kleptocracies. So you have this is also, by the way, an issue for defense oversight. The Pentagon is has signed a deal with a Venezuelan oil company, which is which is very famous crony of the Shavista regime, who had who's who's who's on the run from the law, on the run from the law in multiple countries has his homes were raided by the Spanish police outside of Madrid in August or September. He he's widely believed to have stolen money from the state when he was supposed to be responsible for fixing the electricity system, which still doesn't work. You know, so we really like one of the worst people in the country, the the fisheries. on Lake Maracaibo who were driving me around in their boats, they'd all heard of him. He wasn't an unknown person. And this is America's partner in Venezuela. And instead of bringing in a legitimate government, instead of speeding up a transition to a government of Venezuelans who care about Venezuela, instead, we seem to be propping up the current regime. Actually, Hegseth was in Venezuela a couple of days ago. Yeah, what was up with that? I saw that he was there, but I didn't lock in on that. It was hard to understand. I actually asked a Venezuelan friend of mine. He said he didn't understand it either. I mean, it looks like they want some arrangement with the Venezuelan military. I mean, that could be good in that the US military has at least historically a high culture and so on, and it would be great for them to have a relationship. But if it means that the US military is propping up the Venezuelan military in order to keep Delce Rodriguez in power, it's unclear what it means. And it's, again, a story that. It's not fully in the news, but really encapsulates what is wrong with the thinking of this administration. They don't look at Venezuela and say, what's good for America long-term? Long-term, we want a good government there, right? I mean, it's good for us. It means that refugees will come home. Migrants from all over Latin America, also the US, will go back. It means we'd have a partner fighting crime in the Caribbean and so on. And instead, they don't want to do that. Instead, they have some really weird, corrupt deal with somebody who's. Not trustworthy and who shouldn't be a partner to the Pentagon. And who knows? The other thing is, this is another just corruption black box. And there are bank accounts with Venezuelan money, but we don't know who's oversight of that. So another part of the story is that Venezuelan oil revenues right now go into a bank account in the United States. And there is supposed to be an audit of that account to say exactly where the money goes, how much goes back to Venezuela, what happens. The rest of it never happened, never appeared. Congress has been asking for it, and they just haven't produced it. And so this is. There are so many opportunities for side deals and for cutting people in. And there have been also weird stories. There was a Rick Grinnell story about a Venezuelan deal. And you keep hearing there was a J.D. Vance story about a friend of his who was given a deal in Venezuela after Maduro was kidnapped. I mean, so there's so many. Because it's dark, because it's opaque. We don't know what's going on. There are multiple opportunities for corruption. And I should say, opacity, lack of transparency, these are signs of autocracy. This is what. Xi Jinping is a very wealthy person. Do we know how he's wealthy or why? We do not. Putin has these palaces and supposedly all this money. Do we know anything about that? We don't. The autocracies are secretive. Democracies should be transparent. And one of the biggest. One of the big greatest crimes, I think, that Trump has carried out has been this blanket of obscurity that has washed over the US government so that we don't really know what's going on in Venezuela. And Venezuelans don't know what's going on in Venezuela. Yeah. And the other thing was, there's no evidence that there's been any economic improvement for Venezuelans. Very little. A little bit more oil might be being pumped just because the markets are open again, but ordinary people. I mean, I was told this over and over and over again. We don't see any improvement. We're not feeling any change. And people were still telling me. I was in one fisherman's house where a woman was describing her daughter and her daughter had been accepted to university, but they couldn't afford the tuition or they couldn't afford the books. And so the daughter instead had just been sent to Ecuador to probably work as a nanny or a cleaning lady in order to earn enough money to come back. So that's still happening. It's still going on right now. Maybe I'm just on the high from the midterm still, but when I was rereading your article this morning, I did. I don't know. The instability of the Delcy regime and the idea now that he's a lame duck and in 2029, there might be a clean. I don't know. It felt like that there was potentially a path back for a Machado-like figure. Oh, yeah. No, no. There's a path. There's a path. Well, Machado's back. She actually came back since I wrote the article. She created these street scenes with thousands, tens of thousands of people greeting her. Like her or don't like her, she's really. For Venezuelans, she's a symbol of hope and she is the legitimate leader. She will now, she says with her party, will be organizing big public debates. How should we change our constitution? How should we think about the future? And it's also a country that is very. I described this in the article too. There are a lot of people who've been working to make Venezuela better and build Venezuelan democracy for a long time. And Venezuelans have put a lot more effort into winning back their democracy than many Americans have put into keeping ours. And you meet these moving conversations with people all the time. All the time, people start telling sort of war stories, what I did during the 2024 election, how I smuggled the voting results, the true voting results out of the polling station in order to upload them online so that we would know how many people really voted. So it was a, you know, you meet people like that all the time. And these are very ordinary people who've understood why it's important. So I have a lot of hope for Venezuela, actually. I think it's a country that has a little bit like Ukraine. It's a country where there's a real grassroots organized civil society. Despite everything, despite this ugly regime and despite the system, I think they will eventually do a lot better. All right. We'll leave it on that optimistic note. I was going to play the Chinese doing YMCA for Donald Trump, but people can have that. People can imagine that. We'll end with the Anne Book Club. I want to shame myself. I have an embarrassing admission. I was going back through this morning. Last time you were on, I discussed it. I was right. I was reading The Disappearers by Marla James. It's great. I'm almost finished with it. I'm not finished. I haven't been reading. I have to read, obviously, for the podcast, but I haven't been doing any pleasure reading. I've been focused on the midterms. You know, life gets in the way. But this is inexcusable. Okay. I'm spending too much time on this. So I'm having you hold me accountable, right? This conversation is holding me accountable. The next time you come on, I'll have several different things that I've read. I was with Ryan Holiday, my guy over at Daily Stoic. People should go listen to my podcast. I'm with him on Daily Stoic. I thought it was really good. But we went to his bookstore in Bastrop. I got Stasi Land was there. And stories from Behind the Berlin Wall and a couple of other things. So this is a to-read for me. For people who are new, who want a reminder, past and Applebaum suggestions include The Captive Mind, The Oppermans, The Director, The Choice of Comrades, The Time of Cherries, Whistler. Whistler was, I believe, your last name. Whistler was the fun one. Yeah. The fun one. Because we wanted fun, too. So do you have anything for us today? I have a couple books. And I even have them with me. Amazing. Because I thought about it in advance this time. One of them is a serious book in the theme of how to deal with declining democracy. This is Profiles in Cowardice by Jacob Weisberg. You'll note that the cover is a pastiche of the Profiles in Courage book written by JFK many years ago. And it's little potted biographies of people who collaborated. You know, John Rawr. Roberts, Bezos, Steve Schwarzman, Brad Karp, you know, people who went along with. And this is going to be an interesting read to look back on as people like Musk and others say, what do you mean MAGA? Like, I was always against it. I was never MAGA. It reminds me, this is a long time ago. There was the final, the Gorbachev era chief Soviet ideologist was a guy called Igor Likachev, who I met some years later after the collapse of the Soviet Union. I remember this. And we had a conversation with him where we said to him, so at what point did you lose your faith in the Communist Party or the Communist ideology? He looks at it and says, what do you mean? We never believed in any of that. So even the people who were running it never believed it. And I think that's what's going to happen with the MAGA movement, too. What do you mean MAGA? I was always against it. And the second book, and this was a really fun read, and it's a little strange. It was given to me by my colleague, Jen Senior at The Atlantic. We love Jen Senior here. Yeah, me too. We love and honor Jen Senior. Yeah, we do too. So it's a novel. It's a novel called The Endling. Okay. And it's by a Ukrainian writer. And all I'm going to tell you is that it starts out being a novel about a kind of mail-order bride organization in Ukraine. So American men who come to Ukraine to meet Ukrainian women. And then it just goes off in eight million different directions, and the war breaks out. And one of the women is a scientist who's an expert in snails, and that's why she's been doing this mail-order bride thing in order to earn money for her lab. And there's a hunt for the last living member of a snail species and so on. Anyway, I was captivated by it, and it was the thing that I read before falling asleep for several nights in a row. So instead of looking at my phone. I've already ordered it. I just ordered it. If Jen Senior endorses it, and if it's about mail-order brides, I'm into it. So the next time you're on, I will finish The Disappearers, The Endling, and Stassi Land. That's my goal. That's a goal that I'm setting for myself. Excellent. And I always appreciate it. Enjoy the Thanksgiving holiday, and we'll stay in touch, all right? Thank you. Happy holidays to you, too. Thanks. All right. Everybody else, we'll see you back here on Monday with Bill Kristol. Have a good weekend. Peace. I let it ring, heartbreak and me, only one thing got me again, it's the end of the world. Done with this year, I miss drinking beer, missing songs for you, too slow to hate, summer came late, fires on the west side, I'm rolling the waves. Let's misbehave, catch it before it's almost gone, try to pretend it's the end of the world. So kiss me to death, there's nothing left to decide, nothing to prove, nothing to lose, only time will tell me your name. Burn our mistakes and destroy, through the end of the world. The Bulwark Daily is brought to you thanks to the work of lead producer Katie Cooper, associate producer Ansley Skipper, and with video editing by Dante DiCicco, and audio engineering and editing by Jason Brown.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The Trump administration’s global foreign policy is perceived as authoritarian and transactional, marked by alliances with dictators and opaque deals.
  2. The Shenzhen summit between Trump, Putin, and Xi was widely criticized as a propaganda event echoing historical power plays, reinforcing fear of a new world order under authoritarian control.
  3. Despite Trump’s claims of ending the Ukraine war, his actions and statements consistently support Russian aggression, undermining European security and democratic solidarity.
  4. There is growing European concern over U.S. neglect of alliances, rising use of bribery and opaque deals in foreign policy, and the need to develop independent technological and defense capabilities.
  5. The midterms revealed public distrust in political corruption, with voters demanding accountability, especially in defense spending and military politicization.
  6. American institutions like the EPA and military are being weakened, with decisions like detonating lead explosives in Iowa raising serious public health and safety concerns.
  7. The U.S. is seen as undermining democratic values abroad—such as in Venezuela—by supporting corrupt regimes and failing to promote genuine democratic reforms.
  8. A shift in global perception of U.S. power is underway, with allies increasingly viewing American foreign policy as self-serving, corrupt, and short-term rather than long-term or principled.

Summary:

S. foreign policy under the Trump administration, portraying it as authoritarian, opaque, and transactional. A key event—the Shenzhen summit with Putin and Xi—is described as a calculated performance echoing Cold War-era power dynamics, signaling a dangerous shift toward authoritarian global alliances.

The narrative highlights how Trump’s rhetoric and actions, including calls to end the Ukraine war and support Russian aggression, undermine European security and democratic values. Meanwhile, the midterms revealed a public backlash against political corruption, especially in defense and military spending, with voters demanding transparency and accountability. The administration’s neglect of key institutions—like the EPA—adds to a pattern of institutional erosion, raising public health and safety concerns.

S. is seen as propping up a corrupt regime rather than supporting democratic transition, contradicting its own values. S.

is increasingly viewed as a system driven by short-term gains and deals, not long-term principles. This shift is forcing allies to build independent defense and technological capabilities. S.

governance, emphasizing that democratic integrity relies on accountability, public awareness, and vigilance against corruption.

FAQs

Kewpie Mayo is an original Japanese mayonnaise known for its red cap. It's made with egg yolks only, giving it a rich, umami flavor that chefs and food lovers use to elevate dishes.

The global reaction to the U.S. midterms was one of relief that ordinary Americans are concerned about democracy, but also caution due to President Trump’s continued support for authoritarian policies and lack of commitment to democratic values or international alliances.

The summit appeared to mirror Cold War-era power plays, with a propagandistic tone and no real policy substance. It raised concerns about a new geopolitical order where authoritarian leaders coordinate to undermine democratic institutions and international norms.

Many countries now see U.S. foreign policy as being driven by deals and financial incentives rather than principles, with concerns about corruption, lack of transparency, and the influence of private interests on national decisions.

Europe is increasingly stepping up to fund and support Ukraine, as U.S. involvement has diminished. This shift reflects growing European awareness of the need for alternative alliances and a stronger, more independent defense posture.

Yes, several reports highlight financial ties between Trump administration figures and defense contractors, oil firms, and foreign deals, raising concerns about conflicts of interest and the use of personal wealth to influence policy.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.