Speaker 1A fiery exchange during PMQs today as Kemi
Speaker 2Begnok attacked Andy Burnham for talking a load of waffle.
Speaker 1Is the PM planning to fight the next general election on rejoining the EU as the SNP indicated they'd be willing to support it, along with the dreaded Ed Davey? In the minds of the Reynoldses and the Burnhams of this world, the state should have responsibility for everything from creating jobs, this mythical idea that the state creates jobs. No, it doesn't. It creates public sector jobs, but it's the private sector that creates the vast majority of jobs in this country. Oh, the state should step in and parent your children. The state should brush their teeth and give them breakfast. The state should come in if you're having some mild anxiety or ADHD. Issues are every step of the way. The state should come in and tell bosses how to behave in accordance with their workers, even though we've got very good workers' rights in this country. There's a very important poll just in. It's not the Westminster Poll of Polls, although I do believe that Labour and the Conservatives are ahead of reform. Newsflash. And that reform may have retreated into the teens for the first time since whenever. This is the more important survey. Who wore the tux better? Hollywood's Robert Pattinson, 33%, our very own Tim Stanley, 67%.
Speaker 2Amazon, are you listening?
Speaker 1Well, they should be.
Speaker 2Come on. Yeah.
Speaker 1I'd quite like to wear a tux.
Speaker 2Can you send bonds back as easily as you can return something from Amazon?
Speaker 1That's a very good question.
Speaker 2If we don't like him.
Speaker 1Do you know what I love? When Amazon says you can have a refund and you don't need to send it back. I had that experience with some eggs this week. Two out of 12 were cracked. Cracked and broken.
Speaker 2Oh, no. Yeah. Hang on. You're getting eggs in the post. Are you really?
Speaker 1I do sometimes order groceries on Amazon if I'm short of time, which is literally the story of my life.
Speaker 2I didn't even know you could do that.
Speaker 1Yeah. And then I said, well, these are broken. I'd like a refund, thinking they'd just give me some money back for the two eggs that were broken. I actually just got 10 free eggs. And by the way, me being, you know, budget conscious mum, I scooped up the remnants of what was left of the broken eggs, put them into a little jug, scrambled them the following morning. Oh, actually, I lost nothing in eggs.
Speaker 2Your kids had floor eggs. They weren't from the floor, did they? I ordered something from a well-known Scandinavian furniture store. Yes. And I got a message saying, it'll be at your house in 15 minutes. I was around the corner, so I went there within five minutes and received a follow-up message saying, we tried you and you weren't in.
Speaker 1There's nothing more annoying.
Speaker 2This is despite me leaving on the form something that said, either leave it in the front porch. Yes. Try a neighbour or telephone me. They had three options and they went with turn up, knock you not in and we're driving away. But the best thing of all was to prove that they had been there. They sent me a photograph. It was a photograph of a random fence. Yes. I don't even recognise the fence. Could be anywhere in the south of England. It could be a fence in Guildford.
Speaker 1Amazing. Is Burnham having a little bit of a problem with his own ticker? I mean, his heart is broken, isn't it? Because he so wanted Kemi Badenock. Today's PMQs, yes. Well, he so wanted Kemi Badenock to like the car. And where is lots of people warm to the man and say, oh, isn't he lovely?
Speaker 2She's not having any of it, is she? That's interesting, isn't it? He got very tetchy in this one and he attacked the Tories a great deal. And the critics, Rob Hutton, put it very well. Having solved all the problems, Burnham now only has points to score.
Speaker 1Oh, I see. So we have moved into that stage of politics within seconds of him becoming prime minister, ladies and gentlemen. That is so often the case.
Speaker 2With virtuous people, the one thing that really gets under their skin is not recognising their virtue.
Speaker 1Yeah, just how great they are.
Speaker 2Because he's doing his best to bring this country back together and put hope in every heart.
Speaker 1He is bringing hope. By the way, the word hope was mentioned 11 times in one session.
Speaker 2He's actually allowing Britain. He phrased it as allowing Britain, letting Britain, he said, feel hope again. As if up until now we've been going, no, no, sit. Sit. And suddenly we're going, all right, then go out and play outside and feel some hope. But as is so often the way with virtuous people, you know, he lays it all out as I'm doing this for you. You know, we can work together. Why don't we just get everything I'm doing is for the common good. So I presume. And if you get someone like Kemi who just keeps going, nah, nah, nah, not having it. Nah. Eventually you break down. It's like the teacher in the class who goes, well, you, you try and reason with the kids. And finally you just break down and go, shut up. Sit down. This is reminding me of a great sketch
Speaker 1from Harry Enfield's live show, which my husband and I watched last night. And he talks about how he was inspired to do the Scousers by a meeting between George Harrison and Paul McCartney. Calm down, calm down. Which initially started with them being like really just kind of like Liverpudlians in lullaby speak sort of like, oh, come on in and have a cup of tea. And then it turned into them both getting drunk and angry and going, calm down, calm down. Is the prime minister suddenly becoming an angry Scouser?
Speaker 2It did kick off today in question time. Kemi seemed to get under his skin by saying your plan to get young people into work doesn't save any money and is going to take 10 years.
Speaker 3Mr. Speaker, I think he said the quiet part out loud when he said he'll consider it in the round. I'll probably take another 10 years as well. They want to have reviews to consult, to create reports. And then. They come here and say, oh, it's a landmark report. No, what it is, is yet more kicking things into the long grass. We don't have 10 years. We need to get jobs now. And the cheek of him to say that unemployment has gone down. He doesn't know why.
Speaker 1I mean, in a way, it was convenient for the prime minister to be able to say that in the last quarter, unemployment is down. And yes, it is down. But if you actually drill into the detail, Tim, as I did, as I was watching this exchange in the House of Commons, it should be pointed out that although technically, yes, for the last quarter, unemployment is marginally down. Vacancies have dropped by 22,000. They've reached their lowest level outside the pandemic since 2014. Yes. OK, because companies are delaying hiring. Meanwhile, redundancies are at an all time high. 300,000 because of employers being worried about the introduction of the Employment Rights Act, which comes into force in January. So just dumping staff in advance. We've also got the number of payrolled employees continuing to tick downward. Wage growth has stagnated. It's slowed to 3.5 percent. And by the way, that whole quarterly drop in unemployment, according to the Office for National Statistics, so the government's own stats compilers say that that's down to sample rotation changes in the labour workforce survey rather than a reflection of actually there being more jobs being taken by more people. This is the argument, isn't it? And it's the argument that has been taken. It's the argument that has been plaguing Burnham since the very beginning. Are you actually tackling these issues at source? Are you taking the big decisions required to fix broken Britain? Or are you just tinkering at the edges, dithering and delaying? And as we said yesterday, to be honest, regardless of the good intentions behind the Milburn report, cutting welfare by 200 million in 10 years time doesn't really cut the mustard. As I pointed out, the bill is going up from 180 billion to 220 billion. And then when she put that to him, this was his response.
Speaker 4Can I say to the right honourable lady, she reveals time and time again when she comes to that dispatch box why she doesn't understand this issue, because she only she only ever she only ever stands at that dispatch box asking for cuts. That's all she ever asks for. Her shadow work and pension secretary on the television confirmed that hundreds of thousands of disabled children will lose funding under her her proposals. The Milburn report, the Milburn report says to reduce the welfare bill, you have to improve support. And here's where they really don't understand it. The report also says the biggest rise in needs came between 2022. And 2024, and that is and that is because a report commissioned by the party opposite by Sir Kevin Collins recommended major investment in support for young people coming out of the pandemic to prevent them becoming neat to hundred and fifty thousand people became neat because they failed to provide that support. We will give hope to young people and we will. We will oppose the cuts only approach of the party opposite.
Speaker 1But what is she to talk about when faced with a burgeoning bill, but cuts and
Speaker 2getting the bill down? Yes, which involves spending less money. But Labour's response to the welfare crisis has been to promise to spend more money. And that itself ought to give you hope. I was very struck by this line of Milburn's. He said, quote, Finally, we have a landmark report. As if that itself is the crisis solved.
Speaker 1Yes, it's a former minister. A Blairite has come. out with a report yes and in the land of we must put it out to consultation and review just the act of the report being published yes solves the problem is that what
Speaker 2you're saying yeah precisely look labor isn't the party it once was it isn't the party of people who've ever done anything in their lives
Speaker 1yes it's not the workers it's the
Speaker 2party of people like me it's the party of post grads who've worked in journalism yeah the public sector or the think tank world and in this deranged hinterland writing the report is doing the thing yes so he really went all in on it we should be grateful and i want to say a huge thank you to alan milburn for writing this report as though alan milburn had i don't know opened a business yes uh put satellites in space yes this invented a cure for cancer no alan look the milburn report is great as we said yesterday i i agree with a great deal that's in it but all the man has done is write a report it is not in and of itself an act of work no that's
Speaker 1right and also by the way this kind of lanyard classization of the cabinet also explains why you then have people like chief secretary to the treasury emma reynolds coming out with nonsense like employers aren't working people and that was another yes little thread that they've not can be raised having
Speaker 2met a cafe owner who was furious that they had been told they weren't working but again this this makes some sense in think tank the world in which you're constantly trying to put people in boxes and identify where the new lines are in the class war so that you can take the right side but it doesn't actually achieve anything i've also noticed this this creeping venn diagram crossover of the government's employment strategy and its education reforms which really wasn't there before you remember when they first came in and reforming education was just all about music and dance yes not enough kids do music and tap yes well lucy pearl said
Speaker 1they didn't do enough oracy right
Speaker 2which most people had to look at seriously in the election they were really were saying things like just not enough kids play the recorder anymore well and they might have a point of that but it was it was all about class-based opportunity why is it middle class but it's
Speaker 1also a massive play to lefty lovies continue it's a big
Speaker 2play as well to teachers those small number of teachers who would prefer to do the discount recorder than teach kids how to pass an exam but either way i've just noticed that that's now bleeding into actually it's about upskilling it's actually it's actually it's about teaching kids lifelong skills rather than just obsessing about whether or not they can count or read yes it instead becomes things like are they skilled enough to work in the exciting future of ai design or something so i just think it's very curious how those two things are becoming wrapped together but also in the labor hinterland world growth is thanks to a government and he you know he kept claiming responsibility for good strong growth but as kemi pointed out you didn't do that business does that government doesn't create wealth they they also will insist that unemployment is falling and therefore that is the sign of economic health which don't get me wrong it absolutely is but as kemi pointed out at the same time it can be that fewer people are looking for the work and this is her counter argument is that the size of the state has grown to the point where it's now burdensome upon the private market yes and upon civil society because if growth is good if as he said unemployment is falling why have the milburn report yes what what alice in wonderland world are we in in which the economy is going gangbusters and everyone has a job and it's well paid now thanks to the government's reforms but one million people are not seeking work and when interviewed by sky news the prime minister appeared to row back slightly on angela rayna's employment reforms which again does tie in with milburn arguing that in the future tax relief must be directed at making sure that it's cheaper to employ young people so so so they've bought the argument about actually they've priced young people out of the market but they're not
Speaker 1going to do anything about it well
Speaker 2are they actually going to do it but also it's just infuriating that this is so reactive to something they have done the further we get away from and how funny to see him leaning back into 14 wasted years in the liz trust budget but the further we get away from it the more you have to account for the decisions you have made in two years and one of those was to push wages up and make it harder to hire and fire and the one part of the population that really gets locked out of the labor market that way is young people but then if you're
Speaker 1a business person just as you would react to reynolds suggesting that anybody that would be a business person would be a business person would be a person that runs their own business isn't a working person with a degree of incredulity and horror you also look at the current labor government and you say to yourself why can't you see this very obvious stuff and then burnham finally wakes up to it and in an interview with beth rigby in which he did or didn't shush her there's a debate going on about that on x right now he then says well we'll look at it but we'll look at it is just a kind of you know it's we can all look at things he's not going to change any aspect of that it's just a kind of you know it's we can all look at things he's not going to change any aspect of that that because are we really seriously suggesting that a socialist prime minister who wants to go back to the 1970s who thinks there was something inherently evil about margaret thatcher's efficiencies produce growth plan yeah is actually going to turn around to the chancellor john healy and say actually we're going to have to reverse that nic increase and you know that extra silly 70 billion pounds worth of tax yeah we're going to have to do that and i'm we're going to turn around to the unions and say you know we put up the minimum wage by three percent a couple of weeks ago we're actually going to reverse that as well because in the minds of the reynolds's and the burnhams of this world the state should have responsibility for everything from creating jobs this mythical idea that the state creates jobs no it doesn't it creates public sector jobs but it's the private sector that creates the vast majority of jobs in this country oh the state should step in and parent your children the state should brush their teeth and give them breakfast the state should come in if you're having some mild anxiety or adhd issues at every step of the way the state should come in and tell bosses how to behave in accordance with their workers even though we've got very good workers rights in this country so it's a slight slap down to angela rayner but there's no real enthusiasm behind it because at the end of the day he buys into all of this leftist nonsense yes we have to just
Speaker 2quickly listen to the bit in which kemi calls him out and he gets angry in reply mr speaker again
Speaker 3i'm just going to clear up some confusion uh for the prime minister so he said yes he said we do need jobs that requires growth no the the growth is created by the businesses who create the jobs it is business that creates growth not government that growth comes after the jobs it doesn't just happen but mr speaker after all these years labor still don't understand that there is only one way to reduce youth unemployment and that is to make it easier for firms to hire people and all they have done is make it harder and harder for firms to hire people the government is in a mess on welfare because the same people who led the welfare rebellion against kirsten are now in charge the same people who think social security is more important than national security so let's see how they're doing today we learn the energy bills are going up by 26 inflation is up interest rates are up young people aren't working isn't the truth mr speaker that it is the labour party and this labour government that isn't working that i
Speaker 2think is going to be the emotional tone of the weeks to come is a ratcheting up of low-level annoyance and it comes partly out of frustration with the fact that we're going to be working for the government and we're going to be working for the government and we're going to be working for the government with the government realizing that what it wants to do it can't do and other people noticing that it isn't doing it or it contradicted what it said before so something else that didn't come up pmqs but came up later shabana mahmoud giving the police addressing down and telling them that first of all they have a low quality of senior leadership which is a fantastically rude thing to say but entirely correct given all the scandals we've had but also that in her words there is a perception of two-tier policing now of course that's labor being loyally and not conceding the point everyone's made for a very long time which is there is two-tier policing yes but even that concession is important and brings us back to you know talking about the the labor world of think tanks and everything because she's also told the police you mustn't engage too much with activist groups who do you think those activist groups vote for who do you think when they enter the world of politics they choose to run for the activist groups are part of the labor coalition yes this is labor noticing a problem generated by part of its own coalition yes and then stepping in and giving us all hope by promising to clear it up well it's your fault to begin with isn't it trying to just
Speaker 1throw a little bit of meat to the red wall in the hope that some of it might be gobbled up also it's probably quite cynical because it's the first anniversary of henry nobap's murder yes okay so then she needs to say as a home secretary that she acknowledges the perception of two-tier policing so she's not actually acknowledging that two-tier policing exists but she's saying if there's a perception that it does then the police must do something about it yeah i mean that's it's mealy-mouthed isn't it but we're seeing that quite a lot we're seeing that quite a lot with well i might have a look at national insurance, and I might consider having a word with Angela Rayner. And yes, we must have a go at police officers if they're not running their constabilities very well.
Speaker 2And you must give me 10 years to do all this in. And again, that's Kemi's very good point, is that the so-called savings don't really take place for the 10 years. The vision for getting everyone back into work doesn't really take place for 10 years. So again, I want to stress, I do see a lot of good in the Melbourne report, but it's the classic left-right divide of the left saying, let us build a new state structure whereby we lead young people into work by the hand, versus the right saying, why don't you just cut taxes?
Speaker 1Rather than spending the money on all of that.
Speaker 2And I bet that we could grow fast enough, like America is doing, that we wouldn't have that problem.
Speaker 1Yeah, just make it easier for businesses to hire people, because that would help. Also, don't you think it's interesting, as ever the case, maybe Badenock could have done a little better to have mentioned rising inflation, because of course, that brings the prospect with it of everyone's mortgages going up. Interest rates were already put up, weren't they, very recently, and they could go up again. And of course, the government's always very, very happy to take credit when inflation comes down, but not so much when it goes up. So when it comes down, it's all because Labour are brilliant. When it goes up, it's because of global headwinds. Oh, yes. I mean, just as classically cynical. And didn't you also find it interesting, and we'll get on to Ed Boring-Davie in just a minute, because the bingo card comes out for the Lib Dem leader. Once again, it's got Brexit and Trump on it in triplicate, and that's all he bothers to ask about. And then, of course, it's music to Burnham's ears, because doesn't this man's eyes light up when talking about Brussels? It's extraordinary. And on that, by the way, I found out a very fun fact for the day as we approach the EU reset, and it's one from John Redwood, former economic advisor. John Redwood, former economic advisor. to Thatcher. The UK growth rate halved over our 48 years in the EU compared to the 20 years before we joined. Right. Okay. So it's not this great growth nirvana that the Remainers are making it out to be. And it certainly isn't now, because the German and French economies are going back. I mean, how many times do we need to state the obvious? It's a bit like the whole workforce issues that Labour can't see, because even though they're staring them in the face, they're too socialist to understand it. But equally, they're too. They're too Romaniac to see that the Eurozone is flailing. It's like a car that's on the side of the road with the bonnet up, and Ursula von der Leyen and everyone is looking in going, oh, what's gone wrong? You know, growth has tanked. Why would we want to align ourselves with that dynamically or otherwise? It's just. It doesn't make any bloody economic sense.
Speaker 2One could reply to Redwood and say that a lot of that time outside of the EU, when our growth didn't do as well as it was before, was under Tory governments. So we could ask, what went wrong with domestic policy as well as the EU? And of course, a lot of things happened at that time, like the oil shock of the 70s, et cetera. So, yeah, I don't know. But I am now convinced that the next election will be fought on the EU.
Speaker 1Oh, no. I think.
Speaker 2I have no doubt about it. Hang on. We had previously agreed it was going to be fought on something else.
Speaker 1What did we
Speaker 2previously agree? Well, that was yesterday.
Speaker 1We said it was the economy, stupid. At one point, we thought it was immigration.
Speaker 2But did you hear David Lammy?
Speaker 1Who has ruled himself out as trying to stand as the next mayor? David Lammy. Of London, by the way.
Speaker 2Sad. I think he'd be a very strong candidate. But he has said, I think we should run on the EU. And I think if you look at the figures, as we were discussing yesterday, it doesn't make sense to you and me because we don't want it, but it would galvanize the progressive left. And I think the way the government is talking, it feels as though they are laying the groundwork for it. And although whenever Ed Davey gets up to speak, it's like that scene in Airplane, when they cut away minutes later, I'm hanging from the ceiling, right? Or I'm covering myself in gasoline.
Speaker 1Exactly. With a cigarette lighter ready to go.
Speaker 2And he did literally ask about the EU followed by Trump. Nonetheless, the EU question is one that's clearly close to the prime minister's heart. You can see he's excited about it. And you can see it as the basis for the forming of a coalition because later the SNP picked up on it and said, if you did this, prime minister, if you tore up your red lines, the progressive members of your cabinet, it's nice, isn't it? Rather than the nasty reactionary Brexiteer ones, the progressive members would support it. The Lib Dems would support it. Even the SNP would support it. Well, there you are. What a lovely little. What that's telling us is if you want to build a future coalition around rejoining the EU, then we're here for it.
Speaker 1Yes. It's like a little, it's like a big bed with all of those progressives in it. It's not a second referendum. Wanting to reverse a once in a lifetime mandate that was supported by a majority of the population in the biggest turnout. Now, this nation has ever seen.
Speaker 2The SNP's definition of a generation, don't forget, is two weeks. That's right. Because they were pushing for a second Scottish referendum within a few years of having lost quite badly the first one. But this, I can see this as laying the groundwork for the next election.
Speaker 1But what would it look like? I think it would look like the Emily Thornberry approach to relitigating Brexit, which is basically to turn around, just stick it in the manifesto, not offer a second referendum because my goodness, we wouldn't want. The wrong result a second time around
Speaker 2and see what people make
Speaker 1of it.
Speaker 2But this time, what's interesting is how would the immigration issue play out? Because it was always a, it was an assumption in 2016 that the pro-immigration control side was leave. This time, the Remainers will be claiming falsely to be the ones who want to control immigration. And they will point to the Tory record on mass migration as proof that Brexit actually weakened the border. Now, I don't agree with that argument. The people who were let in were let in because the government chose to let them in. We built a gate and then we opened it.
Speaker 1Yes, but then the counter-narrative to that will be.
Speaker 2The record will be used against them.
Speaker 1Well, also, the counter-narrative to that will be, well, if you have to accept Schengen, then you're going to have to accept passport-free travel across European borders. And by the way, that doesn't look like it looked in 2016. We're not talking about French students coming over with their backpacks on both shoulders. Yes. We're talking about a huge amount of migration from the Middle East that's already in Europe that could be coming to a UK town near you. So, of course, the Brexiteers will weaponise that against the Remainers. Similarly, it's again going to be all about what opt-outs are we going to be offered? Yeah. Are Brussels seriously going to turn around and go, yeah, you can keep the pound. You don't need to sign up to that. Yes. You don't need to pay into this. So, if we are going to sign up to that, then we don't need to sign up to that. If we are going to go down this road, then do not underestimate the battle that will be fought on both sides. We've already got the likes of Bill Cash, Bernard Jenkin, Lord Gove, Oliver Lewis, probably Boris Johnson. He's written for us already this week. They're already galvanising the stay out campaign against those saying, no, let's go back in. And actually, it's funny enough how weird that you would have these kind of Spartan mavericks campaigning for the state government. And then the Remain campaign supporting the previous status quo.
Speaker 2But God love each and every one of the people you've just mentioned, but they are all politically yesterday's men. And I don't think one you said is actually in Parliament.
Speaker 1I know, but then Ed Davey is a ridiculous figure. I mean, what, are people going to go over the top for Ed Davey? Are you serious?
Speaker 2I think 10 years does make a difference and the argument will be very, very different.
Speaker 1So, you don't think that a massive amount of capital can be made of the grotesquely illiberal, and undemocratic nature of everything this man comes out with. I mean, I don't think I have witnessed political hypocrisy like it.
Speaker 2But Camilla, my point with it being something that comes up in the next election is that going into the EU will not be a one choice referendum to put to the people. It will be a general election. So, it doesn't matter that you and I and probably millions of other people can't stand Ed Davey. It doesn't matter. What matters is the 35% of the people who are going into the EU, the 35% of Europhiles, who will vote in a government, possibly a coalition, that will cheerfully go back into Europe and won't care, by the way, about losing control over the currency because they always wanted to surrender control over the currency. Yes, possibly. It was only Gordon Brown, bless him, who prevented them from doing it in the 2000s.
Speaker 1Okay, but then a lot of Project Fear was based upon the economic arguments against leaving and I don't think you can make them as cogently. Secondly, and we've discussed this already, the bloc will be beyond recognition by that point because we could have Marine Le Pen in charge in France. We'll obviously have the infiltration of the AFD continuing in Germany. We've got five EU nations now supporting the Rwanda scheme. So, that's not going to strike anyone as particularly progressive. I know. I agree with all of that.
Speaker 2The irony of this is, though, that we pay no attention to European politics in this country and many people voting will just not be a part of that.
Speaker 1No, but hang on a minute. No, but I'm talking about a situation where if the next general election does become about this singular issue, then, of course, the public will be made aware of all of this by campaigns.
Speaker 2Well, we can point to Le Pen. Well, campaigns on either side.
Speaker 1If we're going to have a ramping up and a relitigation of Brexit, of course, all the arguments will again be made and all the for and against rejoin. But the other big question of the week is, if your plan is to rejoin all along, what on earth are you doing the reset deal for? Yes. Because the reset deal is meant to be preventing us needing to reset. join right it's a little bit like a glorified attempt at what cameron did you know let's reform
Speaker 2our relationship it's plain that that this is my point it's plainly not that okay it's plainly uh it's been paving the way paving the way setting it is an appetizer to the main feast yes it's about sending the prime minister over there so he can shake hands have some good photographs and create warm vibes and give the impression to the public that the eu has mellowed and it would let us back in on fair terms because look what we've already got yes so that's that's what i think that's what
Speaker 1i think unfortunately the reset is a capitulation not a negotiation it doesn't give us much at all and it's meant to be costing 21 billion and this is the other big question for the electorate come 2029 if we're still in the grip of a cost of living crisis if inflation is still high if interest rates have gone up and people are all struggling and by the way because of the government's seeming reluctance to drill anywhere apart from the forklands we're still playing sky-high energy bills yes is there going to be an appetite to be spending 41 billion pounds a year according to the bow group on rejoining the eu not
Speaker 2in my house but i guarantee you can find 35 percent of the public mad enough to say that there is briefly i also want to mention that it is international men's day tomorrow i mean in my house every day is international and in my and in everyone's i mean that's the problem right uh but a couple of mps did raise this and andy burnham took it as an opportunity to do some tash shaming an mp who is growing a mustache for movember asked a question and the pm retorted with this can i
Speaker 4compliment him on his movember efforts he's got 12 days to go it might even turn into a mustache at some point
Speaker 2this is the problem with men camilla we're so savage about each other's looks yeah there's no solidarity among men there isn't you're so
Speaker 1horrible and bitchy and you
Speaker 2should hear the things we say behind each other's backs we just don't support each other men we try and grow a mustache or a beard yeah and you've got another one cattily bitching about it to everyone else it's what is wrong with my gender this is this is why i know this is why one should never shame
Speaker 1another man's facial hair or lack of it can i speak as somebody who is the daughter of a man who resembles a cross between george galloway and the pringles man he's been mustachioed all of my life and continues to be so do you know what with all of this men bashing that was going on i was actually having this thought as i was leaving the office yesterday about how much i love men and how being the being the younger well being the the youngest child of three and the daughter with two older brothers i spent my whole life sort of in a way just being influenced and dominated to an extent by men in terms of they would always be striking i'd be in gold pair of dad's dark blue gloves on i'd go could i have a go at shooting no male girls don't shoot which i know sounds very sexist people but these men made me the woman i am today you know i sort of whereas i think i
Speaker 2grew up in a very feminine household yes
Speaker 1you did
Speaker 2there weren't many men around no all the strong characters were female
Speaker 1i know and then also like i've been promoted a lot in my career by men because men tend to be editors and women don't and we need to correct that you think you're a man's woman well i also have girly mates and girly moments but maybe i am a man you play
Speaker 2football with the women
Speaker 1i do play football with the women or i used to i don't know i just thought you know um in light of all our recent discussions i just thought you know i do love men yeah and i'm not afraid to tell you that tim thank
Speaker 2you i just all i want to say on the subject because it is apparently so controversial is the two questions that were asked at pmqs were one about male suicide which is a very serious problem there is an appalling rate of suicide among men um and the other one was about men learning to behave lovingly and positively and it's all about men should talk etc and those are two messages one cannot not endorse they are indeed correct but it does slightly frustrate me that whenever men are discussed in the public forum now the conversation is always so depressing yeah it's so depressing it's always about violence yes and it's always about being inarticulate i just i just okay that is helping it's important to have those issues aired but there are positive things to say about masculinity yeah of course there are there are some successful thriving men out there i'm talking about it's like we're a tiny minority like i'm talking about albanian shoppers or something here we are half the pop we hold up half the sky all right and we tell everyone we're doing well just
Speaker 1as we shouldn't let bitches tar the sisterhood we shouldn't let bastards tar the brotherhood and i think that's that's the way we should conclude it
Speaker 2yeah that's very true there are some proper dogs there as well among the men i
Speaker 1know there are can you why can't you grow a tash
Speaker 2oh i know i can um
Speaker 1if you really wanted to see one
Speaker 2i'll tell you why frustratingly it goes white so i could and there's nothing stranger than a man with a white mustache it's a very odd look
Speaker 1you'd look like des linem which is something i'd quite like to see actually
Speaker 2prefer to think of it as the omar sharif but yes i i take your point the risk the return of mustaches is fascinating as a phenomenon isn't it yes i suddenly feel like i'm in a gay bar and i'm like oh my god i'm in a gay bar and i'm like oh my god i'm in a gay bar and the 80s everyone i was gonna say people start wearing denim what i'd have been a child but if everyone starts wearing denim yeah and banging on about thatcher then it's a gay bar
Speaker 1in the 80s but also can i say can i be canceled for that probably you you have chosen by the way the month of november yeah to buy that super duper electric razor that you've recommended to me whisper it i have bought it for my husband which he knows how annoying is this by the way i bought this razor for my husband whose birthday is next month and then amazon knock at the door and go oh hello we've got an electric razor here and we need a code for it we need a six digit pin so my husband then phones me and goes oh hi have you bought an electric razor and i'm like you should have said it's for your legs well it's a bloody heavy duty i mean what are you saying about my her suitness
Speaker 2believe me this razor could cut a hedge i
Speaker 1tell you what you came in the office on monday and i literally thought it was your younger brother what's happened to dim stanley he's lost 20 years anyway i'll be borrowing that uh at some point so we're intrigued him aren't we to find out from our audience whether they think this pmqs was a close shave or whether they'd not left him with a terrible case of stubble rash that sounds
Speaker 2like they've been snogging we'll see you again tomorrow at 5 p.m you you