Go back

America Watched Their Fight On TV. Hours Later, She Disappeared: The Michelle Parker Case

1h 27m 40s

America Watched Their Fight On TV. Hours Later, She Disappeared: The Michelle Parker Case

Michelle Parker, a devoted mother of three, disappeared on November 17, 2011, just days after appearing on a People's Court episode where she accused her ex-fiancé Dale Smith, Jr., of severe domestic abuse, infidelity, and violence. The episode, which highlighted their toxic relationship, revealed that Michelle had endured years of emotional and physical abuse, including threats, manipulation, and violent outbursts. Despite her efforts to leave, she stayed due to her children’s needs. After her disappearance, digital evidence—including cell phone records showing her phone moving with Dale’s and being tracked to a location near Lake Conway—raised serious red flags, contradicting Dale’s alibis and timeline. Investigators found inconsistencies in his statements, including claims about her whereabouts and phone use, and discovered that he had searched for Michelle Parker’s name and created folders with her nude photos in the months prior to her disappearance. Dale’s criminal history, including prior domestic violence convictions and military court-martial, further signaled a pattern of dangerous behavior. For over a decade, Michelle’s family fought for answers, filing a wrongful death lawsuit and pushing for visitation rights under a new law, only to be denied. In 2026, new interviews and digital analysis led to Dale’s arrest and charges of second-degree murder, marking a long-overdue breakthrough. Though Michelle’s body has never been found, the case stands as a tragic reminder of the dangers of domestic violence, the importance of believing victims, and the critical need for systemic justice reforms to protect women and children.

Transcription

15460 Words, 84273 Characters

English
On November 17, 2011, the once quite popular reality TV show People's Court aired an episode called The Missing Ring, and it featured a couple arguing over the cost of a missing engagement ring which had been thrown off of a balcony into an atrium of a hotel never to be recovered, and anyone who watched that episode could see that tensions were high amongst these two, and that the woman, Michelle Parker, was describing a relationship filled with domestic violence at the hands of her ex-fiancé, Dale Smith, Jr. But that ring would be the least troublesome battle that she faced because hours, I mean hours after that episode aired, Michelle Parker vanished, and she was never seen or heard from again. The details of Michelle Parker's case are incredibly tragic and very disturbing, but it's also a great reminder that it is never too late to get justice, and I believe, as many others do, that justice is on its way for Michelle. Before getting into this episode, I just wanted to thank you all for listening to and supporting my show, and also any of the mile hire media shows. Your support makes it possible for us to continue funding grants through my foundation Higher Hope, which supports victims of violent crimes, their families, and like-minded nonprofits. And with that, let's get into today's case. On January 20, 1978, Michelle Parker, daughter of Yvonne Stort, and Brad Parker, was born. She was one of three siblings, she had a sister Lauren, and a brother Dustin, as well as a stepfather Jeff, and a stepmother, Dale. And according to her stepmother, Dale, Michelle was never the type to treat either of her stepparents any differently, and they did come into her life at a relatively young age. I know that's not the case, and sometimes doesn't need to be the case with every family, right? But from a young age, she really accepted both of her stepparents as equal parents, and she really listened to them and respected them, and Gail said that she really made her feel like part of the family. Tell me about your relationship with Michelle, because in the post you mentioned she was a daddy's little girl. Tell me about your relationship. She was my first daughter, she had my same feet, my body, and her bones are my bones, and I raised her. She helped me raise her. Yeah, I wasn't just someone that came along that was married to Brad. She was in my world. She was part of my life. How long had you been in Michelle's life? Oh, since she was like 14 years old. I didn't come along just because I married him. We spent a lot of time together, I was with her on many occasions, watched out for her, as a mother, made sure she was safe, and she respected that. That's one thing about Michelle that I always appreciate is she never treated me, or any of her stepparents, like as if you don't matter to me, or I don't have to listen to you. She was very loving, sweet person. According to her loved ones, she was also a bit mischievous, but fun, motivated, and highly responsible, and Michelle's also been described as an excellent daughter, sister, and friend. And above all else, the love that she had for her three children is definitely how she'll be best remembered. Her first son Austin came from a relationship that ultimately just did not work out, and then in 2006, she met Dale Smith, Jr., who she'd eventually go on to have two more children with, a pair of boy girl twins. Now, unfortunately, we don't have a ton of insight into what their early relationship was like, but from what her friends and family have said and what they know, it sounds like it was never that great, and they themselves described their relationship as on again, off again, which often is how people describe a toxic relationship, and that is certainly what this was. However, during an on period in June of 2010, Dale proposed Michelle on the beach in Cocoa, Florida, and she said yes, and by the following June, they were on the set of the People's Court, filming an episode over a $5,000 engagement ring dispute. "This is the plaintiff, Dale Smith. He says the defendant is X, P, on, C, through the engagement ring, he gave her up about any of the hotel rooms during a big fight they had. This is the defendant, Michelle Parker. She says the plaintiff is a vindictive mean man, and she owes him nothing. She's accused of throwing it all away." Now I wish I could play longer snippets for you, but unfortunately it is copyrighted, so I've been able to pull some bits and pieces to play for you, but I will definitely have the full episode linked for you in the show notes or description box, and it's definitely an interesting watch. I think it tells you a whole lot about their dynamic and where they were both at at this time. However, the context definitely matters. We need to talk about why they were on the show and what happened on the show, so let's go over that now. So back when Dale and Michelle were still engaged, the two of them drove to Atlanta, Georgia, to attend DragonCon, which is a sci-fi convention that Dale was super into. And just 15 minutes ago, I was talking to one of my team members who's really into these conventions and cosplay in general, and she has heard a lot about DragonCon. She's never actually been to it herself, but she was telling me from what she's heard it's a pretty wild time. It's known as a party convention, and not only that, this convention is massive. I'm sure there are many of you out there who have heard of it, have been to it, love it, hate it, whatever. Now Michelle wasn't a cosplayer herself, but she went along for the adventure, and while they were there, they got into a heated argument while drinking. Now Dale's version is that she got angry over a comet he made and threw a drink in his face. And then she showed up at their room with a police officer. In Michelle's version, however, Dale was a lot less innocent. She claims that he made a derogatory comment towards her about sleeping with another guy the year prior, but that she never raised her voice at him. She also told him that she couldn't believe he would say that to her and tried to walk away from the situation, and that's when she says he grabbed her by her arm, yanked her, and proceeded to scream at her. And during this altercation, Michelle says that a security guard actually had to throw Dale out because of his behavior. And I definitely believe her version of events fully. But to explain how everything else unfolded, long story short, Michelle said that she found him waiting outside of the convention, outside of the building. And that's when she says that he told her she could not go back up to their room. And that's when she gets to police officers involved. I can just imagine how unsafe she would feel in this man's presence, especially due to his violent history, which we will be unpacking later. But with the police escort, she was able to safely go back up to their room and gather a par belonging so that she could leave. And in the people's court episode, Michelle goes on to explain that as she was gathering her stuff, Dale was being a total dick to her. And that's when he asked her or the rain back. So she gave it to him. She pulled it off her finger and threw it at his chest. The problem, though, was that when she threw the ring at him, it bounced off of him and fell down nine stories off of their balcony of their hotel, which was facing an atrium into the hotel lobby. It went all the way down there, Dale and down there tried to find it, couldn't find it. Ring is gone. And that is what led Dale to file a lawsuit against Michelle for the value of the ring. And that's how they ended up on people's court. This was all outlined in the episode, of course, and by the way, her family said that she was very embarrassed by the episode itself, by going on the show, the whole experience. She actually didn't even tell a lot of people in her life that she was going on the show because she was so embarrassed by it. But she did it because she knew that fighting a lawsuit was going to be expensive. And if you didn't know, which I didn't know this, I've always been curious about why people would go on these shows. But these types of court shows actually pay for people to go on them. And this show in particular used to pay the financial judgment ordered by a judge, meaning the losing party never paid out of pocket. So that's why she agreed to do it, which makes total sense to me. And again, I'll have that episode linked below because I think it really does give you insight into their relationship a little and how it key Dale is and just how horribly he treated her. And I'm sure people are wondering like they always do, and I'm sure some of you know exactly the reason, but she decided to try and stay with him for the kids as so many people try to do. And I think that always comes, most of the time comes from a good place, wanting the best for your children, the best life for them. But in the end, and for good reason, she just couldn't do it. And she knew it would actually be better for all of them if they were not together. In the episode she accused this man of cheating on her with seven different women in their home. And she also brings up finding and criminating emails, pictures, text messages, and even Craigslist ads that pointed to his infidelity. And Michelle also mentioned physical violence. She described him as malicious and vindictive, especially when he's been drinking and said that a lot of their problems were alcohol-related. kind of fight well he gets pretty malicious and vindictive and he's a mean person especially when he's been drinking any of the problems that we've ever had it's always been alcohol related she gave more examples of Dale being a dirtbag like packing her and her kids stuff into a u-haul and leaving it out her moms or when he drove back to Orlando alone after dragging con leaving her in Atlanta and yeah this judge wasn't having it and I was really grossed out by this judge's behavior I don't know if she has fans or what she's doing now I feel that she wouldn't have acted the way that she did in 2011 in 2026 I would hope not because she really didn't seem to have much sympathy for Michelle at all especially for a woman who is in a violent relationship she was actually quite offensive to both of them which I think Dale deserves but I don't think Michelle did she told them that they were like drugs to each other which okay yeah and she also said that her own 14-year-old had a more mature relationship that they did and yeah okay but what really crossed the line for me personally is she called them both complete idiots and I just thought that was so gross to say that to her clearly this woman is in a lot of pain and trying her best to get out of this relationship for good and already has taken the steps to do so and to be called a complete idiot on TV is so so nasty she did say what is so obvious that this wasn't a good environment for their kids to be raised in but in the end she ordered Michelle to pay half the cost of the ring saying they were equally at fault and yeah this is the only episode of People's Court I've ever seen so I don't know much about this judge but yeah it was just kind of gross to me I do understand that it's for TV and they're playing everything up and they've got to make it entertaining but for a situation like this I will though give judge Milan some credit where credit is due since everything has come to light she has spoken out and she has said that she's devastated by what has happened and wondered if there was anything that they could have done differently much potentially but I don't know if that would have actually I really don't think it would have changed the outcome of things unfortunately Dale is who Dale is so for the past couple of years in my strength training journey I have really targeted the same muscle groups and I am such a creature of habit I really just did the same thing for every lift you know I had my leg day and my arm day and that was it and I did the same things on those days but I am now trying some new things and I have learned that you can really hurt yourself trying new things when you don't know what you're doing and you don't have the right form specifically I've been really trying to target my triceps and that's something that I have neglected over the past couple of years and that's why I'm so glad I have the latter app because I've been able to get direct coaching from the comfort of wherever I am my home my office on exactly how to target my triceps safely and maybe you don't know what to do with the gym or you're just getting started or you're tired of doing the same workouts from YouTube or Instagram with no results while ladder gives you a real plan from an expert coach that's the real difference here ladder is an expert strength training plan not a content library these aren't influencer workouts or challenges it's real progressive programming designed by certified coaches and you get a new plan every week that builds on the last the workouts connect each week progresses from the one before through structured training blocks and it feels like having a coach right there with you because you can have in ear coaching guides through every set with cues reminders and motivation and what I personally love about it is I can still play by music and it just kind of turns it down when I get that cue and then turns it back up when it's over and your progress is tracked automatically the app remembers your weights your reps your sets you can actually see yourself getting stronger over time and it costs less than a dollar a day okay that's crazy that's elite level personal training at a fraction of what you would pay in person so remove the guesswork with ladder get a real coach in your ear telling you exactly what to do for every workout no thinking everything planned for you if you have an iPhone head to ladder.fit/tckr to take a quick quiz and find your perfect ladder plan and then if you use my link you get a free seven day trial with no credit card and ten dollars off your first month if you join in the moment though that's how it all shook out and it didn't appear like Michelle or Dale were particularly thrilled by the outcome but in the episode you can tell from Michelle's side at least that she was glad to just have this over with try to move on with her life and to her credit she was absolutely done with Dale after this her only tie to him now would of course be co-parenting their two kids that however would not be easy because co-parenting was already becoming a fight and the custody battle over their children was anything but straightforward Michelle had previously filed but a judge dismissed a domestic violence injunction against him and as you'll hear tensions were high but from a personal standpoint once Michelle had moved on from Dale it sounds like she was really taking her life in a much much more positive direction and was taking this new chapter of her life very seriously for her and her children after some time she began dating someone else a guy named Nate who she was planning on introducing to her dad and stepmom soon and she was really focusing on her career now Michelle worked at a bar called the barn in Sanford Florida which is about 20 minutes away from where she and her kids were living with her mom in Geneva and then she also was starting her own small business a tanning business called glow mobile tanning which she advertised with this massive decal on the back window of her hammer so she was working really hard trying to better her life and create a better future for herself and her children however on November 17th 2011 which is 15 years ago to the day on the day that I am uploading this episode and yes I did plan that on purpose but that day Michelle's life and her future was taken away from her everything that she deserved everything that she was working for gone and as you could probably guess the person who is believed to have been responsible for her disappearance and presumed murder has always been her ex fiance Dale Smith junior it wasn't until October of 2026 this year after a fresh set of eyes looked over the evidence that he was finally arrested and charged with second degree murder and Michelle's remains have never been found to this day but after you hear what I'm about to share I think you'll agree that his arrest and this charge is so long overdue so let's go back to 2011 and talk through all the evidence that brought us to where we are today at approximately 10 17 PM on Thursday November 17th 2011 Michelle's sister Lauren Erickson contacted the Orlando Police Department to report that her sister was missing she and their mommy Vaughan then met up with two officers at a nearby 7-11 to explain their concerns and in their report they mentioned having seen Michelle earlier that day they had seen her at the family hair salon Michelle was there and had to run an errand for her mom and Yvonne remembers bringing up the fact that the people's court episode was about to air but Michelle was very clear to her she was not planning on watching it when she left the salon she ran errand for me I needed color she went to the store brought it back went out the door turned around and I said some sort I said oh my god I said it's almost I don't know one o'clock or two o'clock I think that people's court thing is errand today and she said I don't ever want to see it it was the most humiliating day of my life I don't care however despite not planning to watch the episode she did have plans to see Dale later that afternoon because according to her sister Michelle stated that she was dropping their three-year-old twins off at his apartment for their scheduled custody exchange now for context these exchanges were historically very quick and very contentious they honestly sounded horrible and very scary and according to the arrest affidavit actually it typically took Michelle anywhere from a few minutes to about 25 minutes to do the handoff but never more than that and it also noted that Dale's behavior during these exchanges could become quite hostile just for one example and there are a few Michelle had mentioned to a friend that there was one instance where Dale had thrown a car seat at her windshield when she was dropping the kids off with him and I hope that the kids didn't witness that but knowing him they probably did and her mom and her sister were of course aware of all of the violence that had previously gone on between them hence their concern when Michelle went missing sometime during or after this visit to his apartment and according to the affidavit her 10-year-old son was unable to reach her by phone after he got off the school bus and Lauren had also received a call from Michelle's co-worker at 1023 p.m stating that she failed to show up for her shift both of which were super out of character for Michelle she took her job very seriously and she also took her main job very seriously being a mother she would not have just not shown up for her child now earlier that night around 9 p.m. as their concerns were you know really starting to mount Yvonne actually called up Dale and had planned to ask him if he had seen her daughter and at first he didn't answer his phone so she ends up calling his mom and had to make up a lie that Austin was injured so that she could actually trick him into getting onto the phone but anyway he ends up telling her a few things [BLANK_AUDIO] and that included the fact that Michelle was maybe going shopping that day at Waterford. And that's a detail worth remembering, okay? He claimed that he didn't know where she was now though, and he insisted that the last time he saw her, was when she dropped the kids off at 4 p.m. But ultimately, with all of this information and the weirdness around it, the investigation into Michelle's disappearance kicked off very quickly. Around 11 p.m. that same night, Orlando police officers went to Dale's apartment to look for her, and that's when he explained that they, quote, do not talk anymore. He said she only comes by to drop their kids off, and he doesn't know where she might be. He even allowed them to search his apartment, although nothing of value was seen. And then that night, they entered Michelle and her 2008 Hummer into the missing person's database as a missing person under suspicious circumstances. Then the following morning, her family went directly to the Orlando PD headquarters, asking for further assistance, and that's when Detective Michael Marreci with the homicide unit was assigned to her case. Now, of course, during his preliminary investigation, he very quickly learned of the history of domestic violence and toxicity that existed between Dale and Michelle. Their relationship was described as, quote, tumultuous with the suspect Dale, oftentimes being violent and controlling toward the victim, Michelle. And Dale's criminal history tells you exactly what kind of monster he is. Get this, you guys, while he was serving in the military, he was court-martialed for distributing ecstasy and sentenced to three years in prison with a dishonorable discharge, and then found guilty of domestic violence against his wife at that time. And in addition to being married previously, Dale was also engaged to another woman named Jill, who, when interviewed, also detailed a history of violence, and she said, and keep this in mind, that he would manually choke her, and made threats to kill both her and her father, as well as made threats to make them disappear. And there would be more interviews too, but just to give you an idea, the picture that was forming for investigators of Dale was one of a true monster. In the meantime, though, as their understanding of him is starting to develop, there was a significant finding and it happened November 18th, the day after she went missing when her hammer was found. It was abandoned in an apartment parking lot on Walden Circle, and her purse, along with several personal belongings were found inside, including her credit and debit cards, as well as her checkbook. The car was locked, the keys were missing, and to investigators, this did not look like a robbery. And it's important to note that her family explained that she didn't have any ties to this area in Orlando. It was on the west side of Orlando, about 12 miles from where she was last confirmed to be, which is Dale's apartment, and speaking of Dale, he was interviewed that same day, the 18th of the phone, and he was asked to re-describe the events from the day prior, and here's what he said. Quote, the suspect told the detective that he last saw the victim on November 17th, 2011, when the victim dropped off the twins at 4 p.m., according to the suspect, he had a brief conversation about one of their twins having an ear infection. According to the suspect, the victim told the suspect she had to pick up a few things for the ear infection before going to work. The victim was not specific about her destination. Dale then told this story again under oath when he came into the station later that same day. And in this interview, we learned slightly more information about his version of the timeline, specifically, that Michelle arrived around 4 p.m., and that she left about 10 minutes later at 4.10. Then, according to Dale, he left a few minutes after her to drive with the kids to his parents' house in Orlando, where he stayed until 9.45 that night. He told detectives that the only time he left his parents' house that afternoon was when he and his dad made a one-hour trip to a warehouse to drop off roofing supplies. His dad, Dale Smith Sr., would later provide a similar statement, that described the warehouse as a storage unit. But this is where things took a weird turn, okay? When Dale was asked what route, he took home that night, he said that he took surface streets. And then he did say that he took the toll road, sometimes depending on the time. And when he was asked if he took the toll road that night, he said that he did. So here he is in the same interview, saying that he took surface streets and the toll road. He went one way, but then he also went the other way. Make it make sense, Dale. And then another thing that he mentioned in the interview was the people's court episode. He told him that it aired the day prior and explained that they went on it. And when he was asked if he watched the episode, he said, "I watched it, I deviated it, and I watched it." And before the interview wraps up, he agrees to be photographed. And when he was detectives, notice scratches on several parts of his body, actually. He had two scratches above the right corner of his mouth, one on his lower lip, a scratch on his left wrist, and another scratch above it that was starting to bruise. There were also abrasions on both his elbows. Weirdly enough though, and this really takes me off, his detectives didn't bother to ask him where those injuries came from, or if they did, it was never put on record, which I would think if they asked him about it, they would have been smart enough to record that, but whatever. However, the record now reflects that detectives believe that these were defensive wounds. And this isn't as big, but still very strange. The affidavit also shows that Dale lied about having Michelle's mom's phone number. He said that he didn't have it, but when they searched his phone, they found it. At this point in time, I haven't been able to figure out why he would need to lie about not having her number. It's very odd, but the dude's a loser and losers lie. Sometimes there is no sense to make out of it. But yeah, that interview wrapped up and to conclude it, Dale said that he did not know where Michelle was. He said he thought she was embarrassed by the airing of the people's court episode and that she could just be laying low. And he said that he wanted her to come home safe because their kids needed their mom. Now the nerve of this man, the audacity to have said that. Hmm, makes me want to throw up. But that same day, his apartment was officially searched via a search warrant. However, like the day before, nothing of value was found. A search of the home that Michelle shared with her mom also showed no signs that she planned to leave, which just furthered everyone's concerns. I'm sure every single one of us has had this situation, right? I mean, some of us more than others. I have these situations often where you lose your wallet and you have to cancel all of your cards. Or sometimes, if you're like me, you think you lose your wallet and you're panicking. So you're canceling all your cards just to then find it, you know, under your car seat or something. Well, that's why I love the cash app card. Because if your card is ever lost or stolen or temporarily lost under your car seat, you can lock it. And then maybe it'll turn up, maybe you'll find it. You don't have to cancel all your cards. And if you weren't up to speed already, cash app is way more than just a safe way to send and receive money. With the cash app card, you unlock a ton of perks without all the hidden fees. Enjoy benefits like early access to nationwide concert pre sales like Kendrick Lamar and Sabrina Carpenter to name a couple of the recent examples. Plus discounts on everyday purchases and popular brands that you're probably already spending money on. Add your card to your digital wallet to make your money moves easier. Cash app also adds security to your money by declining suspicious card transactions and sending you a notification to make sure that payment is really you. If your card is ever lost or stolen, you can lock it with just one tap right in the app. New cash app customers can earn $10. If they use the code cash app 10 in their profile, it's sign up and send $5 to a friend within 14 days. Terms apply, download cash app today and make your money work for you. Visit our link in bio. (gentle music) None of her loved ones were able to reach her by phone. And the last any of them had heard from her or from her phone, I should say, was at 4.26pm on the 17th. Her brother Dustin had sent her a text message asking where she was and all he got back was a one word answer, which said, "Waterford." Now, if you remember, Yvonne said that this was the same thing that Dale had told her when she spoke to him on the night of 17th, that she may have gone shopping at Waterford, which is referring to the Waterford Lakes Shopping Center. I called Dale, but his answering machine honestly sounded like a foreign language. It was all garbled and it didn't make sense, so I thought I had the wrong number. So that's when I called his mom. And she said, "What?" She said, "I asked her if Dale was there. I needed to talk to him." And that Michelle was with him earlier that day, was she still with him. And she told me, "I'm in bed." Well, I'm not going to sugarcoat this. She was never friendly to me. And I made up a lie. And I said, "Listen, Austin's hurt. He's need stitches. We have to go to the ER. I need to talk to Michelle. I need to talk to Dale." That time he was home and he came right to the home. He was at his house. So she called him to tell him that? Yeah. He said that he had been at his dad's warehouse. And I said, "Listen, Michelle's not at work. Michelle's not answering her phone." Michelle's not home, something's happened in Michelle. Because she said she was going shopping or something. So then he said, I think she was going to water her. He did. What was on the cell phone, the one word that was on the cell phone. When her brother texted her, he said, where are you at? I didn't know that at the time. But connect those dots. He said to me. She said she was going shopping or something at water. Well, guess what, guys? Detectives would later say that this is not where her phone was pinging. After obtaining a trap and trace order for Michelle's cell phone, records revealed that it pinged off of a tower on Hoffner Boulevard, about 11 miles west of Waterford Lakes and west of Dale's home. And it's not just the location that matters here. It's also the timing of her phone's movements, starting with when she arrived at Dale's apartment. And if you recall, he said that she arrived there at 4 p.m., right? But these records showed that her phone had pinged off of a tower in the area of his apartment at about 3.15 p.m., 45 minutes earlier than he said that she arrived. Her phone then stayed there until 4.18 p.m., just over an hour. Which directly contradicts his version where he claimed she only stayed for 10 minutes. Also, that is significantly longer than it usually took for her to drop off the kids. As I explained earlier, it normally was a couple of minutes, maybe 25 minutes at the max. The data then reveals that her phone traveled to a tower in the Belle Isle area, which was another 7 miles west of Dale's apartment. And it remained stationary there from 5.08 p.m. to 8.46 p.m., at which time it was shut off. However, the affidavit also states that her phone was connected to this tower only until 8.19 p.m., although I can't make sense of this. This contradiction is never explained. Could just be a mistake of some sort, but regardless of that, the bottom line is that the movements of her phone were strange, and they did not match Dale's story whatsoever. And it gets worse because they discovered that her phone didn't move alone. It moved along with Dale's phone. When his phone records were later searched, they discovered that his phone traveled with Michelle's phone to the Belle Isle area. However, his phone then went towards his parent's house, whereas her phone stayed there until it shut off. Now, it is heavily implied in the affidavit that Dale had her phone in his possession, and they even went as far as saying that they believe that Dale was actually the one who texted her brother. If you remember, he had texted back as Michelle, or someone from Michelle's phone, I should say at this point in time. It's not confirmed to be him, but I mean, they are saying it in an affidavit, so of course it is, right? Allegedly, don't come from me. But he was obviously the one to text her brother, saying "waterford" from her phone. Now, interestingly, Michelle had asked Dale to meet her in "waterford" for lunch that day. However, that clearly didn't happen, so I don't know. Maybe that's where he got the idea to say "waterford" maybe it was just on his mind, or he had some type of strategy behind that. I don't know, that's my speculation, but if we're just sticking to facts, though. It is a fact that on December 2nd of that year, a team of divers located Michelle's phone in Lake Conway. It was in shallow water north of the Nella Bridge, and you guessed it, Bell Isle, Florida. So basically, their phones traveled together to this area where her phone was later apparently thrown off of a bridge. Coincidence? I think not, and speaking of searches before her phone was even found. A canvas of Dale's neighborhood on November 19th proved to be quite successful, because it turns out that his neighbor had a security camera on his balcony, which captured a video of Michelle's Hummer arriving at their apartment complex at 3.18 p.m. It was never seen driving away, but detective spoke with another woman in the neighborhood who remembered seeing a Hummer still parked across the street when she left at 4.40 p.m. And her daughter also reported seeing it there between 3.30 and 3.45. So all that further proves that Michelle was not in and out in 10 minutes, the way that Dale had described. Now, given this, my guess is that their suspicion of Dale had to have been through the roof pretty immediately. But I'm certain it only grew more as they continued to find out more about him. In an interview that her sister Lauren gave, she remembered times where Michelle had bruises on her. And there was one time when Michelle confronted Dale after catching him with another woman. And she said that he grabbed her by the neck, pinned her against a wall, and then threw her out of the house. And then in another interview with one of her friends, that friend told detectives that she thought Dale must have done something to Michelle because he had threatened her, quote, "many times." She also reported seeing bruises on Michelle and remembered that she used to save Dale's text just in case something happened. Michelle had also confided in her that during one verbal fight, Dale told her, "Oh, your time is coming." However, despite his monstrous behavior towards her, it wasn't proof that he did anything to her, at least not yet. As we know, when Dale's father, Dale Senior, was interviewed, he corroborated his son's story. He stated that Dale had arrived in his red Ford F-150, around 4.30 p.m. on the 17th, and that they drove together to that warehouse/storage unit around 5.30-6-ish. After that, he says they went home, where Dale stayed with the kids until about 9.30 p.m. And if you're wondering, yes, they did search that warehouse and they found nothing, and his dad's property was also searched. And according to witnesses, I'm assuming neighbors may be, they were actually taking people out of the house in restraints in order to complete their search. To be clear, not arresting anyone, just restraining them in order to be able to search it. But the reality is, because of the very little physical evidence that has been found to this day, this case really had to rely on mostly digital evidence to move forward. And Dale's phone was a big piece of that. Okay, like I said, we already know that his phone was seen traveling with Michelle's phone after he said they weren't together. And part of the reason we know that is because, according to his phone records, Dale called his father at 4.21 p.m., and the data reveals that it was traveling west towards Bel Isle. We then know that he traveled to his parents' house and arrived at 4.44 p.m., which is when he called his dad again. Here's what's weird though. After arriving at his parents' house, his phone did not move for the next five hours, meaning he left it behind. While they were going to this warehouse, after arriving at 4.44 p.m., it only pinged again at 9.46 p.m. When cell tower records placed him traveling back east towards his house, which was also confirmed through ePass records and his neighbor's security camera. So it's pretty easy to see here that Dale was not looking good. So why did it take so long for things to move forward in this case? Well, it did take a decade and a half for anything definitive to happen. But it actually only took 10 days for police to officially name him a suspect. On November 28, 2011, the Orlando Police Chief officially named Dale as the only suspect in Michelle's disappearance. And once that happened, the investigative efforts only continued to ramp up with digital evidence being the main focus. And of course, Dale's laptop was one of the things they made sure to search. And there was some super weird shit on there on June 1 and 2 of 2011. So five months before Michelle disappeared, he searched for Michelle Lee missing. And I'm sure you're confused. Michelle Lee, who is this? Well, for my understanding, Michelle Lee was a nursing student in California who had gone missing just days earlier back in June of 2011. And according to the affidavit, they don't believe he was mixing up the two Michelle's. Because on June 3, he ran Michelle Parker's name through PQ, which is a people's search site. And then on the 27th of that month and twice on August 1, he searched for a thumbnail image called Michelle Dash Lee Dash Mini. But five days later, a folder was created on his computer, which included several nude and minimally clothed photos of Michelle Parker. And the same content was found in another folder called Shell Bags. To be honest, this is all really hard to understand. I think maybe we'll get more clarification on this in the future. But the implication here is that he was looking up missing persons cases in the months before Michelle actually disappeared Michelle Parker. And then like the free key is he was making folders of her naked photos. And speaking of computers being searched, Michelle's computer and her phone were both searched as well. And nothing on those devices suggested that she was planning on leaving her only plan for the afternoon of the 17th was going to work, which her family later confirmed during their interviews. And it wasn't just her side of friends and family who were spoken with people in Dale's life were spoken to as well, including an interview in early December with a guy named Christopher Hawkins, who stated that just before Thanksgiving of 2011 after Michelle went missing, Dale asked to borrow $7,000 from Michelle. from him for an attorney. He didn't end up loaning him that money, but bank records show that Dale did pay a law firm on November 23rd. And notably, this was six days after Michelle had vanished and five days before he was named a suspect. And of course, I just have to say that hiring representation does not make you guilty of anything, but this was something that detectives definitely made a point of mentioning in the affidavit. So again, I found it worth including, and the affidavit also mentions that during this time, they got a wiretap authorized for Dale's phone. And it was active from November 25th to December 17th, 2011, and there were a few memorable conversations. And I'll be honest, the timing of this first one is a little confusing and doesn't really make sense because it states that the call happened a day before the wiretap was granted. So maybe it was a typo or something, but either way, on November 24th at 803 PM, Dale called an employee of the towing company that had towed Michelle's hammer when it was discovered. In the affidavit, it states that Dale was asking about the vehicle to which the employee said, quote, "I don't know if they even processed the fucking car yet." Last Sunday, when I checked, I told you it was still locked up. So very strange and agitated response from this employee, but I mean, this is just my speculation and opinion here. I'm assuming Dale was acting crazy towards this employee, asking him over and over these questions that he couldn't answer and he was getting irritated with him. Second of all, detectives found it strange that Dale was contacting him to ask about the hammer, especially because his attorney had literally just contacted detective saying that all communication would go through him, the lawyer. So why would Dale now be going behind all of their backs? I see what I'm saying. (dramatic music) So this weekend, I dragged my whole family to the mall, had to get our Christmas shopping done, and the mall opens at 10. And getting my family out the door by 9.30, where the baby is very difficult work. And so I had very minimal time to get ready myself, and it's those days where I rely on merit beauty, because with my merit beauty products, I can get ready and put together a polished look in like five minutes. Maybe 10 if I wanna go a little above and beyond, but I can do it in five. And you guys, it is that time of year. It is here, merit beauty's biggest sale of the year. You can save up to 25% site wide. And right now, my listeners are getting exclusive early access. On November 21st and 22nd, merit is giving you a chance to shop before everyone else with code TCKR at checkout. Get a head start on merit's biggest sale of the year and snag your favorite shades before they sell out, because let me tell you, they do sell out. A lot of their most popular lip shades sell out, their flush bomb definitely sells out in their most popular shades as well. Their five minute morning routine and set makes getting ready simple with elevated essentials that deliver effortless results without extra products and extra steps. And all of the merit favorites are on sale. The great skin serum, one of my faves, the minimalist foundation stick, that has to be my favorite one, although the flush bomb is a close second, and then of course, their clean volume mascara and so much more. So don't wait, early access for up to 25% off is November 21st and 22nd, only with my code TCKR. Head to MERITbeauty.com and shop this sale early plus for a limited time, get merit's new signature make up bag free with every order that's meritbeauty.com. (gentle music) And then in another strange call on December 6th, Dale was speaking to a woman and he stated, "We had nothing to do with it." Yes, you heard me right. "We had nothing to do with it." And then he changed the statement to, "I had nothing to do with it." Now let me be clear, at this point in time, no one else has been named a suspect in this case. However, it has been suggested that Dale may have had help. And in my opinion, that would make sense. Back in 2013, Detective Mureshi described this as a two-person situation. After a red light camera was released, showing Michelle's Hummer stopped at an intersection around 8.56 p.m. Less than a mile away from where it was later found. However, this falls in a window where Dale was supposedly at his parents' home. Hmm, what I should mention though is the area where her Hummer was actually found was only 3.4 miles away from where his parents lived. And in the affidavit, it describes this distance as walkable and even says that this could align with when he started using his cell phone again, which was a little less than an hour later at 9.46 p.m. Now this would suggest that someone drove Dale back to her Hummer, which was parked by his apartment and then he, either alone or with someone else potentially, drove it to the place where it was dumped. Then in this scenario, he would have had to have walked back to his parents' house, then got into his car, and then went back home from there. However, the affidavit's own map shows this walk taking about an hour and 15 minutes and we do know that at 9.40 p.m. Dale is on record at his parents' house using their phone. So, and I know this is confusing, stay with me, but if the Hummer was dumped at 8.58 and it took over an hour to walk back to his parents' home, this just wouldn't align. And again, this is just my speculation and as you guys have probably realized, I don't do much speculation, but in this case, I just have to say this. I think it is possible that someone else totally could have dumped the Hummer without him. Obviously, there's no evidence of this, but that's just where my brain goes and I feel a lot of you will agree that that is a possibility here. And we could have an answer to this, but what's really frustrating is that it was too dark to see who was actually driving the Hummer in this red light footage. What you can see though is that the glow-mobile tanning decal on her car had already been removed, which detectives believe was strategic, of course, to make her vehicle less recognizable. And if you're wondering how they were even able to tell that this actually was Michelle's car, get this, okay, even though her Hummer didn't have an active on-star account, on-star data still tracked her movements in the last 10 minutes before the car was shut off, which I thought was really interesting. I did not know on-star did that, but it showed that the Hummer was moving west on I-4 at 849 PM on the 17th, then was in the area of the red light camera, and by 858 PM, the data showed a vehicle was on Walden Circle where we know they found it on the 18th. And again, I know this is confusing in a little hard to follow, but it's pretty crazy when you add all of these little pieces up. Okay, so I've definitely drifted a little bit, so let's reel it back in here and go back to the wiretapping because there are a few other notable conversations. There was one in particular where Dale complained about his financial situation. He was upset that Michelle's family was raising money for her case and not giving him any money for the kids. Mind you, he would later take full custody of the twins and make it so that Michelle's family couldn't see them for years upon years. To do that to her family and to your own kids is so despicable, so disgusting, absolutely breaks my heart at all that time that was lost and they can never get it back. And he would also later go to court to petition to stop paying child support because he said he desperately needed the money. But anyways, in that wiretapped call, Dale then mentioned the possibility that Michelle had been seen in Daytona and that he hoped she was found in order to show that he was not involved. The truly weird part though is when he talked about his alibi. Quote, the suspect stated he had an alibi. He was at his parent's house where the neighbor saw him. Then at the warehouse, a guy at the warehouse saw his dad but not him because of the way he got out of the truck. The suspect reiterated saying, he saw my dad there so I was there. And again, just my opinion, but that is definitely giving, I was not actually there. But anyway, later that day, the wiretapped captured yet another conversation and this one was between Dale and his daddy. And in that call, Quote, they discussed their testimony and say detectives are going to try and catch them in lies. The suspect tells his father detectives will compare his new statement, which was to take place the following day under subpoena to his original statement. Dale's senior responded, they won't catch him in a lie because he ain't lying. Dale also spoke with his mom where they allege. He coaches her on tricks and tactics used by police to get information. Then the next day, he calls up one of his friends. I'm surprised this guy even has friends to be honest. But when he did, he didn't seem to be concerned or questioned where Michelle was or wonder if maybe she was coming back to help with the twins. You know, just anything normal. And then in a less notable call, Dale was speaking with a woman they believe he was trying to pursue a relationship with. And she, along with his other family members, were later subpoenaed. But the affidavit states that nothing new or contradictory was learned. They did learn that his dad owned a vacant lot in the area. But a search of that on December 22, 2011 yielded no results, which would be true of every search over the years. There was a search in 2015. near the Orlando Airport, a search in a wooded area in 2022, and another in August of 2023, where police dug up a concrete slab on a property belonging to Dale Senior. But besides finding Michelle's phone and Hummer in those early days, nothing else of evidentiary value has been located. And because there haven't been signs that she's alive, the court did declare her legally deceased on August 27th, 2015. But between then and now, Michelle's loved ones have never given up on her. It's heartbreaking and also inspiring at the same time. I mean, they have so much love for Michelle and so much fight in them. Her mom, oh my god, some of the interviews with her mom just have broken my heart. She has fought so tirelessly for her daughter. And she even filed a wrongful death lawsuit in March of 2013. The mother of Michelle Parker says the lawsuit she filed has one goal to force her daughter's ex fiance to start talking. Michelle is still missing. And I want answers. And this is how we're going to try to get them. Ivonne Stewart filed a wrongful death lawsuit last week against Dale Smith, Jr., claiming he's responsible for her daughter's death. Parker, a 33-year-old mother of three, disappeared in November of 2011. On the same day, an episode of the People's Court aired in which the couple argued, police still consider her a missing person. And Smith is the only suspect ever identified in her disappearance, but he's never been charged. Through the civil lawsuit, Parker's mother hopes to force Smith and his parents to start answering questions. His family and Dale, they haven't been honest and I want them to answer my questions under oath because I think they know to have somebody do something to your daughter or your son and not tell you, I am really surprised that I'm just not putting the sanitarium, but you know what, I'm going to fight, I'm mad and Michelle deserves this and our family deserves it and her children deserve this. Now that lawsuit was voluntarily dismissed in 2020, however, her desire to seek justice has never wavered. She, along with other families, continued fighting to get answers in Michelle's case, and they also fought for a visitation of the twins. Dale did briefly lose custody the day after he was named a suspect, and at that point they were put into Ivonne's care, but the kids were given back to their dad the next day, unfortunately. You represented him when DCF had briefly taken his children away, after he was named a suspect in the case by police. We scheduled for the next day, so that it was a peaceful, and then of course he had the children back because there's no proof that was produced in court that he had anything to do with any of this. And that day we went to court because the DCF people had given me the twins the night before, and I had to be at court at 9 o'clock in the morning. After that thing, you remember it's on camera, I went over and I hugged him, the only reason I did that was to let him know I didn't do this. This was all DCF, are you okay? And he started to cry. And then it became a fight for years for them to see the twins. In 2015 there was a bill signed into law that Ivonne actually helped petition for, and that law extended the visitation rights to grandparents of minor children under certain circumstances. One of them being if one parent is dead and the other is a convicted felon. This petition for grandparents visitation is far from being some sort of sympathy ploy from Michelle Parker's mother. Instead it is highly adversarial against the children's father and sets up a potential courtroom showdown here at the Orange County Courthouse. The ball is in our court now as it should be. Ivonne Stewart is talking about the court action filed today under a grandparents rights bill she lobbied heavily for that allows her to sue Dale Smith, the only name suspect by Orlando police and her daughter's disappearance for the right to see the couple's young twins. I think he just wants to get us far removed from Michelle's disappearance and he doesn't want to deal with us. Her attorney and powerful ally in this fight is the former chief judge of the ninth circuit, Belvin Perry, who says he expects a preliminary hearing, mediation, than possibly a trial before judge of necessary. These individuals are the linked to their mom and they should be entitled to have that link. In this legal action, Perry says their prepared to prove Smith has a violent felony conviction and still poses a potential risk to Stewart's grandchildren. But painfully, in the end, they were denied their request, preventing them from having a relationship with their grandchildren. And I just have really no words on that, that is unbelievably tragic, that the kids have missed out on that, that they have missed out on that, all because Dale is a maniac. But despite all these battles, these hardships, these challenges, and heartbreak that this family has been through, they have continued to push on for her. During this time, a few rewards for information were offered, including in 2022, when an anonymous donor offered $200,000 for information leading to an arrest, or Michelle's whereabouts. But little did anyone know, that arrest was actually coming. This year, in 2026, the case was given a whole new set of eyes and the benefit of updated technology. Evidence that they had back in 2011 was processed further, and new interviews were conducted, and that made all the difference. So let's talk about all the new evidence here, shall we? Between February and April of 2026, eight new interviews were conducted, and that included interviews with her mom and her sister. On February 16, they met with two investigators, and they went over the photos that were taken of Michelle's hammer when it was found, and it was interesting. I just love when my episodes are sponsored by Aura, because Aura is one of my favorite brands. I get so excited to talk about Aura, I'm such a geek about it. I currently manage like 22 frames, maybe even 23, and those are frames that I have given to others as gifts. I have six around my house, I'm planning on adding two more, because I have one of my daughters in them, and of course my son needs one, even though he's only eight months old. But I have a black and white frame, I have a video frame. I have the ink frame, which is so cool, if you've not heard of their ink frame, you've got to check it out. It makes your photos look like they're actually printed. It's how I keep our family photos organized, and stay in touch with my relatives that are out of town. Like, for example, my mom lives in Florida, and so I have an Aura frame where I can send her pictures of, you know, everyday events. And that's what I think is so cool, because you know those pictures that you wouldn't necessarily print out and hang on the wall, because they're kind of mundane or something kind of goofy. Well, there's unlimited storage on the Aura frames. So I put everything that I want on there, even if it is not technically a frame worthy picture, because I have three frames that I consider just anything goes frames, whatever I want to put on there. And they have over 8,000 photos on them. And I obviously wouldn't print out 8,000 photos, right? And if you're starting to think about Christmas gifts, and you want to get something that is going to be a gift that keeps on giving, and I know that's kind of a tacky thing to say, but it really does get someone in your life, the Aura frame. It's like giving someone a daily dose of joy. I mean, life is full of these tiny, amazing moments. And Aura makes it easy to relive them all. I love that you can upload videos. I love that I have a frame that's specifically for our home videos. And I have that one in our kitchen. So while I'm cooking, I can watch our home videos. All these little moments that I have forgotten about. And it's just so fun to revisit all of those. Aura is the number one digital frame loved by millions of families. And their Black Friday Cyber Monday deal is the best of the year. You're not going to want to miss out on this. For a limited time, visit AuraFrames.com and get up to $50 off select frames plus an additional $5 off your order with the promo code TCKR. That's a-u-r-a-frames.com promo code TCKR and support the show by mentioning me at checkout terms and conditions apply. When Lauren saw a picture of the mud on the driver's side of the car, she stated that's weird. And that is weird because the property they lived on didn't sit on dirt. It sat on white sand. It was also strange that there was dirt on the interior handle because they said Michelle kept her car very clean. And the inside of the Hummer looked strange to them as well. They both noticed what looked like ashes on the front passenger seat, noting that Michelle wasn't a smoker. And Lauren pointed out that her sister's work shoes were in the car, but not the rest of her uniform. This supported the idea that she planned to go home, but obviously she never did. Another thing her mom and sister were shown was a picture of the backseat of the car like the inside of the backseat. And just based on how it looked, they personally didn't think that her body had been back there, considering nothing had been disturbed. Now the next interview came from Michelle's friend Heather on February 24th, who gave additional insight into their toxic relationship. Heather reported that Dale was very jealous and controlling, and that his use of cocaine and injectable steroids worsened his behavior. Another friend of hers, Angela, was interviewed in March, and she also shared stories about Dale's terrifying behavior. And she was actually with Michelle the day before she went missing, and she said that Michelle was a nervous wreck about seeing Dale the following day. And she was also worried about the people's court episode airing. So much so that Angela told her not to leave the driveway when she dropped off the kids. His former fiance, who I've mentioned, Jill, was re-interviewed as well, and she mentioned more of his violent tendencies and even that he wants sued her. Rue a courtroom TV show because she also refused to return the ring. But one of the most damning interviews, at least in my opinion, came from Michelle's eldest son, Austin. He first mentioned how unusual it was for his mom not to answer his calls, which we know happened that day. But he also recalled that when they were living with Dale, he had a lot of rules for them. And that any time there were custody exchanges of the twins, they were always very hurried. He remembered that Dale was quick to get angry, once having, quote, "slammed" a new TV because he couldn't make it fit in the car. And he mentioned that he heard that his little half-brother thinks that Dale was involved in their mom's disappearance. Now in terms of him witnessing physical violence, Austin said that he never personally had seen that. However, he did remember hearing, smacking, and thudding against the wall. And that his mom would be covered with red marks afterwards. And I just feel so bad for him. That is something that no child should ever have to witness, I mean, how traumatizing. And oh, he recalled that his mom would be scared to take the twins over to Dale's and that she would tell Austin not to mention other men in her life when they were around him. So clearly, she was terrified of what this man was capable of, and for good reason. According to Dale's friend, Billy, who got interviewed in April of 2026, quote, "Billy stated "within two weeks of the victim going missing, the suspect had told him I wish someone would kill this bitch." So yeah, the writing, in my opinion, is on the wall. As for other interviews, there were two more that were conducted in September of 2026, one with two neighbors, Laura and her mom Beth. Laura and Beth, both mentioned having seen Michelle's hammer parked in Dale's neighborhood, quote, "Well, after," he left for his parent's house. So again, we're just getting more proof that she did not leave when Dale said she did. And the new findings and insight didn't stop there. In 2026, an Orlando PD homicide analyst went through the original cell data records and realized that some of it hadn't yet been analyzed. And not because it was forgotten, but it sounds like they just didn't have the technology to do that yet. Or at least I hope that's the case, but I'm pretty sure that is what had happened. But either way, in processing that, they uncovered more precise location and user data. And among those records were text messages between Michelle and Dale. And I am going to redo some of these. I do want to issue a trigger warning that some of them are very upsetting. The language that is used is disgusting and some of the messages I am just going to omit entirely because they're too disturbing. And I don't think they'll add any value to this episode. Also I want to warn you, there's a lot of spelling errors and a lot of old school texting. Keep in mind, this is, you know, 2011. So on September 25th of 2011, Michelle, text Dale, "Don't threaten me, asshole, to which he responds, you can meet me at the gas station, which is five mined from your moms." Obviously, minutes. And then it continues, or I'll keep the kids and file a police report on October 7th, Michelle sends. It's court ordered ass. Open communication. I'll have you held in contempt. Try me. The next day she texts, "Call you again, left another message. Have the kids call me Dale and stop being a selfish piece of shit." And then on November 3rd, she sends him a ton of messages. And a few of them read, "You're a fucking liar. You're going to tell me a few hours prior to having them, you're not taking them. You're a real piece of shit as a person and father. I'm so over your BS and you it's unbelievable. No you won't see us. And by the way, we're moving, so enjoy life bastard along with your fucked up family." Right, you're so full of shit, it's pathetic. See ya, Dale." And it doesn't end there. On November 7th, Dale texted her, saying, "You and your boyfriend have fun. Talking to me last week, saying you didn't have one, so I would loan you money, LOL. Come on now. Do I look that stupid?" And lying about moving to Deltona by yourself? Another good one. I don't believe any of it, Michelle. So please leave me alone and if you need to talk to me, contact my attorney unless it's about me getting my kids. Oh, and one last thing. Can we please get the Hummer out of my name? To which Michelle replied, "Don't have a boyfriend, but I'm talking with someone. Probe be official very soon." And I am moving by myself, eventually he may move in and will rent his house out. I wanted the loan to get your name off the Hummer. It would have been legal and you would have made extra money in the process. And then I got to these next text messages, which are so disgusting and blew my mind. And what's crazy is despite how clearly volatile things were between them. Dale had the insane idea and the audacity to bribe Michelle for sex. And here's her response, thought about your offer dot dot dot and we'll have to decline. I'd rather have a personal legal loan than feel like a whore. I can't do it, I won't. It's not ethical or right. Dale then said, "Okay, I wasn't trying to make you feel like a whore. Sorry, I was just going to help you out. All I wanted was one last time to be with you. Sorry, you feel that way. That wasn't my intention. I don't think you're a whore and I don't think you would be one either by doing that. And it's okay. No big deal." To which Michelle replied, "Having sex for the exchange of money makes me a high dollar prostitute. I can't do it for the money against my morals." Then Dale responds, "Who said having sex for the exchange of money? You said you'd rather have sex because you wanted to. And you said you wanted me to help you because I wanted to, so it wasn't anything like that." Michelle then said, "You said one more night sex and give me two K. That's sex for money." And Dale wrapped up with, "Yeah, I said I wanted to spend time with you. You don't want to hang out. That's fine. No big deal. It's all good, Michelle. Have a good night." And there are so many things wrong with Dale. Like, I can't even comprehend this person. And there's more. They also exchanged messages on November 15th talking about custody of their kids over the holidays. And Michelle tells Dale that he's selfish and impossible. But then came data from her phone from the day of her disappearance. And this provided a much clearer timeline of what went on. Based on the information that was provided in the affidavit, her text on her phone that afternoon pick up at 1.19 p.m. And that's when Dale texts Michelle, "I'm sexually frustrated, lol. Michelle responds, "That's your fault. You were never frustrated before, even while with me. And half the time it wasn't me you were fucking, I'm sure you're fine." Then, at 2 p.m. the People's Court episode airs, at 2.07 p.m. her friend Jim texts her, "You're every bit as beautiful on TV as in person." And she responds, "Ugh." And then, thanks. At 2.16, Jim says, "You're amazing. Any guy should be proud to walk beside you. Hell, I'll walk behind you. See you tonight." At 2.25, her friend Sean then texted her asking if he just saw her on the People's Court episode. Michelle responded at 2.45 and told him, "Sad winking face, yes, I hate my ex. Had to do it. They paid him not me." Michelle then calls Dale at 2.56 and at 3.14, she texts her friend Amanda and then sends another text one minute later. At 3.16, she texts Sean stating that she's doing great and that's also when her phone connects to the AT&T tower in Dale's neighborhood. And the interesting part about her message threads from that day is the fact that they were all deleted up until 4.27 pm. After that though, everything was there and so pretty obvious here, but detectives believe that Dale must have deleted everything before throwing her phone into the late. And another discrepancy that they pointed out was the fact that between October 1st and November 17th, 2011, Dale and Michelle exchanged over a thousand text messages. But after the 17th, when she goes missing, Dale never tried to call or text her even once, okay? The mother of his kids is missing and he never tries to reach out. Are you kidding me? Now as far as other new evidence, the affidavit does state a few things, some of which I will say are a little contradictory. These are things that get mentioned but then not explained and I'm hopeful that in time we'll come to understand what exactly they mean. But anyway, it states that after reviewing her new cellular data, they found video showing a Hummer turning from Nella Avenue northbound onto Orange Avenue at approximately 336 pm. But remember, witnesses put her Hummer in Dale's neighborhood until around 6 pm and unfortunately, it's not explained how both can be true. The affidavit does say, though, that Dale's phone places him on Nella Avenue at that time and remember, Michelle's phone was found in Lake Conway in shallow water just north of the Nella Avenue bridge. Detectives also say that Dale's red truck, the one that he said he drove to his parents' house that day, wasn't seen on surveillance footage collected from a looking to in, which sits along the path he said he drove to get there. So they believe he lied about when he left his home and what route he took to get to his parents. And just to make this clear, because I'm sure this is getting really confusing at this point, but earlier I mentioned his route back home was confirmed, but this suggests that his route there was not. And that's not where his lies ended, because they were also able to catch other discrepancies in his story by reading through the deposition transcript from that wrongful death lawsuit. When reading through that document, Dale stated that Michelle arrived at his apartment at 3 a.m. Not 4 p.m. like he initially claimed. And not only was this strangely the exact time she did show up, but it's also clearly a change in his story, right? And he also said that they met at the door and she brought the kids inside, which contradicted what he told detectives in 2011 about meeting in his driveway. Then he refused to answer basic questions about when she left, how long she stayed, if they had a discussion about the episode that aired that day, and if he was angry with her about it. Okay, I know we have gone through so much information and it has been a little on the confusing side, but thank you for sticking with me, props to you, proud of you, you got this, we're still going, okay? Buckle in. Two more things happened in October just before his arrest and their crazy first of all, his son, one of the twins, actually, who is now 18. I mean, think about it, 15 years have passed, he was three at the time. So he came in to the Orlando police department on October 2nd, just randomly, wasn't a scheduled interview, nothing planned. And he just came in asking questions about his mom's case. And it's just absolutely wild timing because apparently the last question he asked them was if his dad was a suspect. Now, keep in mind, nobody at this point was aware that the investigation into Dale was really starting to ramp up. So yeah, just kind of bizarre timing that he had just come in on his own asking that. A lot of people dream of owning their own business. I definitely did before we started ours, but if you are dreaming up your business or you're running a business and thinking about what you used to dream of, you probably weren't dreaming of running payroll because I didn't realize that when we started our company that we were also picking up five jobs that we've never done before, you know, payroll benefits, HR, time tracking. We have been using gusto since about 2019 for my company and it has never failed us. We absolutely love it. We've had such a great experience with it and paying your team is really just the baseline. Taking care of them is what makes them stay, right? And gusto brings payroll benefits, HR and time tracking together in one place. So small business owners can spend less time managing their workforce and more time growing their business. Gusto automatically calculates files and pays your payroll taxes and offers unlimited payroll runs for bonuses and off cycle checks without extra fees. And on average, it takes just eight minutes to run regular payroll, which is crazy. It's ranked number one for satisfaction and best small business products in 2026 according to the fall 2026 G2 awards. Payroll benefits compliance all in one place. Get started at gusto.com/tccr and get three months free. When you run your first payroll, that's quite a deal. Three months free of payroll at gusto.com/tccr one more time gusto.com/tccr. Second and this one may have been what pushed them to go ahead and arrest him when they did, okay? Detectives discovered that Dale purchased a flight to Columbia on October 13th, 2026 to leave October 16th and return on the 19th. And they said they didn't know if Dale was actually planning on returning. Now to be fair, his attorney did later counter this heavily stating that Dale was dating a woman from Columbia and had made many trips over the years, all of which he returned from. But either way, it was this evidence and everything I have just spent the last however long explaining that detectives say points to his guilt. So here is what detectives ultimately believe. Quote. The suspect killed the victim in his house after days of offensive messages, declining sex for cash, the embarrassing people's court episode airing, and the threatening to restrict his access to his children. It is believed the suspect choked the victim to death, likely resulting in the scratches and abrasions observed on him while the victim thought back. And I'm sure a lot of you had this possibility on your mind. It was definitely what I thought of first hearing about the scratches on him and the abrasions. It just shows that she definitely tried to fight back. But like we know, an arrest warrant was soon granted and on October 14th, 2026, a now 55 year old Dale Smith Jr. was arrested at his workplace and charged with second degree murder, which he entered a written plea of not guilty the following day. And I've just got to say looking at a picture of Dale 15 years later, hmm, you'll look busted. Time cast a spell on you. Now they also said they would upgrade his charges to first degree murder if that were to be supported by evidence. But until then, he remains in the orange county jail without bond. Good afternoon. Today, we are announcing significant development in the disappearance of Michelle Parker. This morning, opening his fugitive task force and SWAT team arrested Dale Smith Jr. Michelle's ex-fiance on a charge of second degree murder. Smith was the last known person to see or hear from Michelle on November 17th, 2011, after she dropped their children off at his home. Over the past year, we expanded our investigative team looking into this case and took a fresh, focused look at all the evidence. We re-examine testimony and conflicting statements made by the suspect and used advanced, in digital forensics to uncover and analyze additional evidence. New evidence was found using advancements in technology, especially in our digital forensics, related evidence, so vehicles, electronic devices, phones, computers. We were able to better interpret that evidence today than what we were able to do back in 2011. We had evidence from back then and again, advancements in technology specifically related to digital forensics was allowing us to better interpret some of the data we had back then. Some of that information revealed more detailed location data and communications between devices that were used back then. Since then, his attorney, Rajan Joshi, has argued that his client has been cooperative from the start, and that it was clear that detectives failed to consider other possibilities, you know, the use. Man, I just cannot get over how bad he looks after just 15 years. Dude is chocked. And his attorney also wanted the arrest affidavit to be released after prosecutors had fought to keep it sealed. And to explain that, prosecutors didn't want it to be released until at least October 26, so that they could finish up two more interviews, stating that they strategically waited to conduct them until after his arrest. Quote, so as not to incentivize the defendant to flee prosecution. The judge also issued a temporary gag order, barring attorneys and law enforcement from discussing the case or evidence. That being said, though, we have received a few updates on the case since then. Specifically, Dale's attorney has filed a motion for an Arthur hearing, which is a special type of bond hearing in Florida for defendants charged with non-bondable offenses. Now, this is another 20 page motion, and I could easily do a whole other episode on just that, but at this point, I'm just going to sum it up for you guys. Essentially, his attorney went line by line naming all the ways the arrest affidavit failed to prove that his client is guilty of second-degree murder, and therefore he should be given a monetary bond. In essence, it states that they didn't establish that Michelle was killed, let alone what kind of fatal injury she suffered. And on top of that, there's no evidence linking Dale to any such event. It also says that searches of Dale's home produce no evidence that she was killed that minor cuts on him were never followed up on. No DNA has ever linked him to her car that he never made any statements implicating him in any crime, neither his vehicle nor his father's contained evidence that her body may have been transported in them, along with many other claims. All right, guys, I'm coming to you after I recorded this episode from the set of my pop culture podcast The Sash, so a little different vibe, but I have to include this information in the episode, the craziest thing just dropped. Now, of course, at this point in time, not totally sure if this is going to go anywhere, you know, this is alleged, but this is weird. It was revealed that the Orange County Sheriff's Office has opened an investigation into the death of Dale's former wife, okay? Not Michelle, former wife Shannon, medical examiner had previously ruled her death as accidental as a result of a drug overdose on MDMA. However, investigators are now looking into these details further. And I am definitely, you know, I have thoughts. I think it's too early for me to get into those thoughts, considering this is just breaking news and they're just starting to investigate, but hmm, I'll keep it out that. Now, I definitely will be following this case. I am invested at this point and I definitely plan on doing trial coverage at some point on this show. As of the morning that that I am recording this. No. November 11th, I actually just saw that he was granted a bond hearing for December 7th. So we will see how that all shakes out. But at the end of the day, I just could not be more excited for Michelle and for her family to get the justice that she deserves so so badly after all of this time. Her family has waited 15 years for this moment. They have put in the work, they never gave up on her, they have fought so hard and they know that this isn't the end. This is just the beginning. It was a mixed emotion, of course, that he got arrested, it was kind of like shocking. What? He's actually, what? He got arrested, he's arrested for second degree murder. Oh my God, he has to own up now, he has to take responsibility. So I mean, of course, that's like, thank you, God. But at the same time, I'm just kind of like, why don't we know about this? Why aren't we told? We need to be told so that it's not like a shock. And there's a lot, it's like this is a new can of worms, it's going to be court cases and trials and want to be there, want to be there to be part of watching this whole thing go down and it's going to be difficult because there'll be times where you want to scream and times where you want to cry and it's all about finding answers from Michelle and actually getting her justice. Daddy, have any more to add to that? I mean, what she called me and told me that Dale had been arrested for second degree murder. First thing I said, where is the body? And why is it second degree instead of first degree? And I was happy that he's finally got arrested. He's been telling lies for 15 years and it's about time the monkey's got his back. And I always told Dale, I said, Dale, you can run, but you can't hide and he's been to Tennessee and back to Tennessee and they caught up to him. And even though the judge said his mouth is going to get even trouble one day, and guess what? It did. And I'm sure this brings up a lot of different emotions for them. I'm sure a lot of, you know, joy in a lot of ways and relief. And just overall pride at everything that they have done to keep Michelle's case at the forefront. But at the same time, I'm sure it brings up a lot of emotion. I'm sure they are going through a lot of mixed feelings and grief is coming back up. I'm sure, you know, that's just my guess. And so I just wanted to send them, you know, if they see this episode, all of my support I am with you guys 100% cheering for you here in Colorado. I want to see Justice for Michelle for all of you so badly. And as you can imagine, Michelle's mom was just beyond thrilled to see Dale finally get arrested after all of this time. They told me that they arrested Dale Smith on second degree murder charges for Michelle Parker. And it's like the happiest day because she deserves this. Obviously, I have a lot of, you know, prayers that go unanswered and I just knew that one day everything dark would come into the light and to not lean on my own understanding and to just trust in him and all my ways. And it's been hard. Let me tell you. It's not easy to lose a child this way and her children didn't deserve to lose a mother this way. For me, you know, as someone who never got the opportunity to meet Michelle, just feel very emotional. It just, I just had to take a little break and turn off the camera because I was starting to tear up just thinking about what this must be like for all of them and knowing that this is just the beginning of her getting justice. And I know that her family all agree that finding her body remains a top priority. They want to finally put her to rest. They deserve to finally put her to rest and they are confident as I am as well that Dale knows where she is. Now as for why he did this in the first place, obviously we don't actually know at this point. As I said, I don't speculate very often and I'm not going to but I certainly have my own theories. I'm sure a lot of you do as well. I have a couple different ideas of how this may have played out and what led him to actually take her life allegedly but her family definitely has their own speculation as well. You know, when they were on the people's court, the judge really kind of thought how crazy it was that they kept going back and forth with each other, making up and crying and getting back together. Michelle turned around and said, "No, I'm done now. I am done." And the only thing that the fact that she's disappeared after that, the thought pattern is he tried, this is just a speculation that he tried to get her controlling vice, a controlling factor, a narcissistic controlling factor, that he wanted her to come, to agree to come back to him and she finally said, "No." And then he just snapped and didn't want to handle that. Nobody says, "No, to me." You know, if I can't have you, nobody's going to have you. And then he took the twins and he refused to let anyone in her family have any relationship with those twins. At the end of this day, this whole case is absolutely soul-crushing. I've got to just say there is something about Michelle's energy just watching that people's court episode and hearing everything about her that I really like, I just feel so, I don't know how to explain it, she just seems so strong and so awesome and I am just devastated that she even met Dale to begin with, it's, you know, you got to wonder what it would have been like, what her life would be like today if she had never crossed paths with him. Michelle deserved so much better, her family deserved so much better, her kids deserved so much better, and everyone in her life deserves to finally be able to put this behind them and move on. And then I just have to mention one more time how devastating, how cruel, how evil it is, that the twins were never given the opportunity to spend time bonding with their mom's family. That's just, it's so horrible. I have learned that her eldest son Austin has gone on to have a daughter of his own whose middle name is Michelle, which I think is incredibly sweet and a really beautiful way to honor her. And I imagine they'll always find ways to honor her as time goes on and that her memory will be kept alive even though her physical presence isn't. But like I said, this isn't the end of my coverage on this case. I want to see Justice from Michelle so badly and, you know, I'm just going to continue with the mindset that she is going to get it, you know, but that is it for me today guys. Would love to know your thoughts on all of this. Thank you for sticking with me through a more complicated and longer case. I will be back next week to talk about another case, but until then stay safe out there. [Music]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Michelle Parker, a victim of domestic violence in her relationship with ex-fiancé Dale Smith, Jr., vanished on November 17, 2011, shortly after appearing on People's Court over a disputed engagement ring.
  2. The People's Court episode revealed a toxic, violent relationship, with Michelle alleging physical abuse, infidelity, and emotional manipulation by Dale, who was known for a history of domestic violence and criminal behavior.
  3. Digital evidence, including cell phone location data and phone records, shows Michelle’s phone moved with Dale’s, contradicting his claim that she briefly dropped off their children and left, and points to possible abduction or coercion.
  4. Dale’s criminal history includes military court-martial for drug distribution and domestic violence, and he was previously convicted of assaulting a spouse and threatening the life of another woman.
  5. After a decade-long investigation, new evidence in 2026 led to Dale’s arrest and charges of second-degree murder, following updated analysis and interviews that revealed a pattern of abuse and suspicious behavior.
  6. Michelle’s family, particularly her mother Ivonne, persistently sought justice through a wrongful death lawsuit and a grandparents’ visitation petition, both of which were denied, highlighting ongoing trauma and systemic failure.
  7. The case underscores how domestic violence and toxic relationships can go unaddressed, especially when victims are pressured to stay due to child custody concerns, and how justice can be delayed for years.
  8. Despite lack of physical evidence, digital and behavioral patterns, including phone movements, financial activity, and alibi inconsistencies, strongly support Dale’s guilt and the theory of his involvement in Michelle’s disappearance.

Summary:

, of severe domestic abuse, infidelity, and violence. The episode, which highlighted their toxic relationship, revealed that Michelle had endured years of emotional and physical abuse, including threats, manipulation, and violent outbursts. Despite her efforts to leave, she stayed due to her children’s needs.

After her disappearance, digital evidence—including cell phone records showing her phone moving with Dale’s and being tracked to a location near Lake Conway—raised serious red flags, contradicting Dale’s alibis and timeline. Investigators found inconsistencies in his statements, including claims about her whereabouts and phone use, and discovered that he had searched for Michelle Parker’s name and created folders with her nude photos in the months prior to her disappearance. Dale’s criminal history, including prior domestic violence convictions and military court-martial, further signaled a pattern of dangerous behavior.

For over a decade, Michelle’s family fought for answers, filing a wrongful death lawsuit and pushing for visitation rights under a new law, only to be denied. In 2026, new interviews and digital analysis led to Dale’s arrest and charges of second-degree murder, marking a long-overdue breakthrough. Though Michelle’s body has never been found, the case stands as a tragic reminder of the dangers of domestic violence, the importance of believing victims, and the critical need for systemic justice reforms to protect women and children.

FAQs

Michelle Parker vanished on November 17, 2011, just days after the People's Court episode aired. Her disappearance was never resolved, and her remains have not been found. She was the last known person to go missing in connection with her ex-fiancé, Dale Smith, Jr.

No, Dale Smith, Jr. was never formally charged in Michelle Parker's disappearance until October 2026, when he was arrested and charged with second-degree murder. Prior to that, he was the only suspect identified by police but never prosecuted.

Multiple pieces of evidence linked Dale to the case, including phone records showing his device traveled with Michelle's phone, a search of his laptop revealing he searched for Michelle Parker's name and created folders of her nude photos, and a red light camera showing his vehicle near where her Hummer was later found. Additionally, he made false statements about her whereabouts and had a history of domestic violence.

Michelle's family remained determined and active in seeking justice. Her mother filed a wrongful death lawsuit in 2013, which was later dismissed, and continued to fight for answers. They also successfully petitioned for a law that extended grandparents' visitation rights in cases involving a violent felon, though the request was denied.

The People's Court episode highlighted the toxic nature of Michelle and Dale's relationship, with Michelle accusing him of domestic violence and infidelity. The episode was a turning point, as Michelle had agreed to appear to avoid legal costs, but it deeply embarrassed her and became a key point in the investigation.

Michelle was deeply embarrassed by the episode, which portrayed her as the one who threw away the engagement ring. She had told her family she would not watch it, as she felt it reflected poorly on her and her relationship with Dale.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.