Go back

America Has a Masculinity Crisis

40m 26s

America Has a Masculinity Crisis

The conversation between Ruth Whitman and Frederick Joseph highlights the deep crisis in contemporary masculinity, rooted in systemic patriarchy that harms men, women, and trans people alike. While left-wing critiques of men as "trash" are grounded in real harm, they often fail to provide constructive alternatives, instead leaving young men psychologically isolated and emotionally stunted. Both speakers advocate for a shift away from gendered or restrictive models of masculinity, urging instead a focus on emotional intelligence, vulnerability, and relational competence. They note that the Me Too movement, though vital in exposing abuse, promoted oversimplified narratives that created confusion and division, particularly in how consent and power are understood. The absence of positive male role models—like supportive male friendships or emotional openness in media—further contributes to the alienation of young men. The left, they argue, must build a counter-narrative centered on active compassion, listening, and shared humanity, not just outrage. Ultimately, a healthier future for masculinity demands not just dismantling toxic systems, but reimagining what it means to be a full, emotionally grounded human being—regardless of gender.

Transcription

7536 Words, 40190 Characters

English
This is The Opinions, a show that brings you a mix of voices from New York Times Opinion. You've heard the news. Here's what to make of it. I'm not just begled in and I'm a culture editor for New York Times Opinion. If this is feminism, comment, stupid, and every possible way that you can. My retainer gives me the weirdest list. It's so funny. Let me try to say the word trash with my retainer, men. Then where does that leave men? I wanted to have a conversation about masculinity and opposed me to world. So today I'm talking to Ruth Whitman, author of Boy Mom, a book about raising young men, and Frederick Joseph, author of Patriarchy Blues. Frederick Ruth, thank you so much for being here with me today to talk about masculinity. Okay, just a little table setting. Where are we now? How would you describe the state of young men in this country right now? I think that we are in an abysmal state. I think the realities are, we've always had Patriarchy at the intersection of capitalism and white supremacy, how things feast on one another and lift one another. But I think right now, more times and not the role models that these young boys and young men have are not only divisive and toxic, but insidious and heinous disgusting. Truly, I mean, the president of the United States is an alleged rapist. What does that mean? What does that mean? The popular thing that boys are watching is largely MMA, right? So I think we're in a horrible place. Yeah, I mean, I would agree. I feel like young men are kind of caught between these two, like, competing, but like, both harmful narratives. Like, one of them is this kind of almost what you're describing is we're all like caricatured, masculinity, there's like, you know, these things that have always been in existence, you know, this like tough guy, you know, bulletproof man, but just like taken to this caricatured extreme. And you're seeing it almost on the left as well as on the right, but then on the other extreme, like more from the progressive left, I think you've got this like shut up narrative, which is just like, your problems aren't real, they don't matter. You have so much privilege, you know, you have everything, a time for everybody else to have a voice and for you to be quiet. And I think it's just really hard to navigate. I think they feel shut down from old directions, honestly. Before we get deeper into things, I want to hear a little bit from each of you, just sort of the like highlight real net graph of how you would approach a conversation about masculinity. So Ruth, you've done a lot of reporting on the subject and you also wrote a book about raising sons. Can you give us where you're coming from when you're talking about masculinity? Yeah, I think when we talk about masculinity, we have to talk about patriarchy. And I think we see this as this system, which harms everyone, including men. I think often people take a gender studies class in college or whatever and they learn like patriarchy harms men and then they're like, well, great, okay, put that aside and then move on, forget about it. And you know, and I know that when, you know, when we're kind of triaging these issues, like is harm to men the worst abusive patriarchy? No, probably harm to women and trans people and people of other genders is more urgent. But I think if we can see ourselves as part of a system of patriarchy that harms all of us and we are allies in this fight rather than like men versus women, men oppressing women, you know, then I think we can have a more productive conversation. Yeah. Fred, you wrote a book of essays and poems called patriarchy blues. You also spend a lot of time talking to men in the world. Where are you coming from when you're talking about masculinity? Yeah, I think for me, I look at patriarchy in the same way that many people during sort of 2020 moment were looking at racism and white supremacy. You can't dismantle patriarchy without an anti-patriarchy movement, right? And the thing, the thing that we were telling people was largely that there was a return on investment for dismantling white supremacy. It was a return on investment for dismantling racism. And that's my argument as well for patriarchy. I tell young men all the time, you're not in these systems allowed to be a whole human being, right? You know, the thing that you are entitled to, they teach you is your rage. And then even that, you're not really entitled to. They don't teach you how to cry. They don't teach you how to laugh. They don't want you laughing. They don't want you crying because they actually do sort of in capitalism want to monetize that rage of yours. That's how you get the manus fear. And I think we oftentimes teach it as like, do you want to do sort of like charity? Like you're not, you're not, this isn't charity that you're doing for women by like dismantling patriarchy. It's not charity by dismantling misogyny. This is actually the work of self. Yeah, right. You know, I really, I really relate to that. I mean, I think as you were saying in my own thinking around white supremacy, I had to come to like, this is just being a narcissistic millennial in the world. But what do I stand to gain from dismantling white supremacy, a system that seems to benefit me in so many ways. And for me, the answer to that is the fullness of my humanity. And I really was thinking a lot when approaching this conversation about how do we do the same thing for patriarchy? Because one of the questions I think a lot of young men have is what does positive masculinity look like? Like I don't think that we've necessarily, I know the image that the that the manus fear, posits of masculinity. And I think it's one that also encompasses a lot of misogynistic ideas. And I know so many men who are not misogynists and who want to be living in a gender equal world, but who are still men who still need an idea of masculinity that feels positive to them. Both have you have you sort of thought about this question and how to answer it and how do we get to a place where there are so few answers for it? For me, like positive masculinity as a sort of framework is not my preferred framework for thinking about this issue or like what to do for a young man. In the same way that if someone was trying to sell any like hypothetical daughter like positive femininity instead of feminism, I think I would push back on that as well. Because I think it's already like set in the terms in quite a restrictive way that sort of ends up like slightly reinforcing gender stereotypes. So like I think I would rather that we sort of move towards giving boys and men like a vision of being a full person, like a full human. And rather than like gendering qualities and being like these qualities are masculine and these qualities are feminine and like how do we navigate and pick and choose between those and like what's the sort of minimum amount of femininity that we can choose to in order to like not immasculate ourselves totally. I'd rather we're just like okay just be a person you know like these are minimum standards and minimum qualities that we expect from every adult and they don't need to be different ones for men and for women. I think that and I hear that I think for me you kind of have to have a sense of positive masculine only because we do live in the boxes of the society that we currently live in right I think that that vision would be beautiful if it wasn't for the fact that like we have femicide and in all these different things right and I think there is so much toxic masculinity and I hear boys all the time say I literally do not know what it means to be a good boy or man because a I think on the one hand all you see is these you know terrible role models who aren't role models at all. On the other hand you have people saying what isn't good but you have to tell people what can be good. Looking at race right and they're not a one for one but you actually have to have positive sort of like ideas of what it means to be like a decent white person right. And that was one of the things in my first book that I pushed heavily is that you can be a decent white person and being a decent white person is not going to be the same as being a decent person or a decent black person or a decent Asian person because the systems and institutions prop up and lift and are owned by ran by and controlled by white people. So if the systems of patriarchy well again like you're 100% right patriarchy impacts us all in various ways but men are the men are the men are the Asian and large part with patriarchy. So I do think that we have this show what a what a decent man is. One of the things that made me really want to have this conversation is that I just feel like I mean everyone is siloed into their own social media spaces but for me when I'm looking at social media so much of what I see online. And so much of what I hear women say is men are trash. Sabrina Carpenter said the key to her songwriting is just to call men stupid and as many ways as you can. I really understand where women's anger comes from. I have lived it but I also feel so much tenderness for my brother for other men I know and if I were hearing the same kinds of messages in reverse that were just women are trash I wouldn't know how to begin to approach the world and so I wonder sort of how specifically on the left because I think that there are different answers to this on the right but specifically on the left which is where I hear men are trash the most loudly. What effect is this having on boys? Do they hear it? Do they feel it? And is it empowering for women? Is there another way to be approaching this? I mean I think from the perspective of raising so I have three boys and I hear this all the time, we live in a very progressive community. And like, men are trash, men suck, you know, is just like just in the water. And it's really, really hard when you're raising sons. And like, they're young. They don't know the entire history of patriarchy. And nor do you want to like explain that in every single moment. And it's like the justification, you know, so they sort of like in a way it's supposed to be punching up, isn't it? Like, men have all the power, men have all the privileges, okay, to like, call them trash. And it's not the same as calling a man calling a woman trash, you know, which is punching down. But those distinctions are getting more and more like abstract, especially when you're like 12 years old. And you've never heard women are trash. And you've heard a lot of like man and boys are trash. And I think it's a really like, I don't think this is helpful. I think it's really harmful. It's not equivalent to misogyny. They're not the same, but it is still like, I think a real problem. It's really like a terrible negative. And I think it's like incredibly psychologically harmful for this generation of boys to just go around hearing that over and over and over again. - I think the reality is that women are entitled to a righteous and rightful rage. And this makes sense to me, right? I think that I'm not a woman. I've never lived in, you know, sort of like the throws of the worse, you know, iterations of patriarchy, right? I don't have to deal with certain things. I just want to name that to begin with. What it reminds me of though, is a lot of parents not wanting young white children to hear, you know, sort of about like the issues with like whiteness, right? And the argument became, and I'm one of the people who made the argument, if, you know, black and brown children are old enough at any age to have to suffer racism, then I think, you know, white children should have to learn and understand their place within racism. And I guess that's the same way I feel about, you know, sort of the idea of Miss Andre and what not is that. My conversation with my, I have a younger brother. He's 14, we have a huge age gap obviously. And I've been having conversations with him about who boys and men are in relation to women since he was probably about six years old, right? Because I do know he's going to hear and see on the internet, you know, men of trash, men of trash, men of trash. And I guess my answer or my response to that is, I'm going to tell you why, right? And so as opposed to putting sort of like the onus on, you know, women and what not, I'm placing it on myself and I suppose other men as well, I don't think that the owners should ever be on the victim, I get conceptually how we got here. And so I just sort of look at it like, I'll see the videos, this is not about me, right? This is not about me, you're not talking about me. I'm trying my best to be a decent man. I'm going to try my best to make a generation of decent boys. To go back just a step to, like if on the left, what men are hearing is men of trash. And this is actually, I think, related to what we were just saying. But if on the left, what men are hearing is men of trash, doesn't it make sense that the right is their safe space? And it makes me wonder, I mean, like clearly like there is, there is an increasing gender divide about how people's politics fall left or right. Men are moving more to the right. Women are moving more to the left. And it's only exacerbating these problems. And I think part of what I'm really interested in is like how do the left bring men back into the fold? I mean, when I was reporting for my book, I took in cells in these like, in cell communities. And they absolutely felt like that. I mean, they really felt like there is nothing for me outside of this. There is like, I'm lonely and I'm lost. And like one guy that I went quite deep with in particular, he was really like, I would like to leave this community. I would like to seek help. I would like to like find a therapist or like talk to another person. But I'm just so scared of hearing like your problems don't matter. You're a white man, everything is great for you. So like, you know, screw you basically from a therapist that I'm not even going to look. And I think part of that was like self-justification. But I think there was something really real in that. And I think that he had been hearing those messages. And it's like, yes, it's not the same. But it's also very real. And I think it is pushing young men towards the right for sure. Yeah, I mean, the right wing is a very intelligent collective of people, right? And I think that they understand human nature better than the left. There isn't really a pipeline on the left to lead you to the left. And you don't ultimately have, because of that and other things, you don't have an andrutate of the left. You don't have someone similar to a Dana White on the left, Conor McGregor, all these different people. And so I don't think that the left has created a strategy at all for we have lost a generation of boys, generations of boys and men. How do we get them back? What do we give them to believe in? And who do we give them to believe in? And I think that's also really important. My friends who have very young kids have told me that-- and it's just so different from how it was when I was growing up. But they've told me that when they're reading books to their sons, a lot of the narrative of these books are there was a very brave, courageous girl and a dumb, dumb boy. And it's like they have. And these are progressive books. And I understand where they're coming. From when I was growing up, I would only write stories with male characters, because a male character was a blank slate, whereas a girl had so much to overcome just to begin to enter the story. But things have swung really far the other way. There are now a lot of books that sort of promote feminism at the expense of young boys. And I'm curious if you found that in your-- I mean, I think like-- I don't know if you know the movie "Franchise Inside Out." Have you seen it, it's like a-- Like "Inside Out?" Yeah. Yeah, yeah. So that was a really good example. I was watching them with my son. And it's like this really complex story of this like young girls' interiority and her emotional life. And it's this great portrayal of like a young girl's emotions. And then you go inside her mom's head. And they have this like complex interaction. And she's tracking her mom's emotions. And her mom's tracking her emotions. And it's incredibly sophisticated. I don't know if it was every time, or if it just felt like every time that a male character appeared on screen in that movie, they were an emotional idiot. It's like, you go inside the dad's head. And he's like, oh, and all they're like emotion, the avatars have just got their like feet up on the desk and they're checked out and watching the game. And that's the joke. And I'm watching this with my like at the time, six-year-old son and thinking, what are we telling him here? Like everyone has a rich emotional life apart from you and you're an idiot. And I was like, that would never pass. Like if that was a mainstream like Disney Pixar movie, whatever that had like a sexist stereotype about a girl, then we would not stand for it culturally, you know? I think that some of the issue right goes back or rather goes this idea of a pendulum swing. Because when you're saying that, I'm like, you know what's so interesting? 'Cause as a Disney buff, we did have Snow White, right? And we did have, you know, Sleeping Beauty and, you know, sort of like even like the not only misogyny, but the rape culture of something like Sleeping Beauty even. And so I think now what has happened is, instead of us having a conversation our society about like how we create something equitable, I think a lot of people are interested in, okay, I'm gonna swing the pendulum in the complete opposite way, right? It's like, you hurt me, I'm gonna hurt you. And that, you can see, I think directly in sort of like how, you know, the father or the boys are represented. You're like, well, yeah, I can represent you this way because look what she did with Sleeping Beauty. - No way you think of Sleeping Beauty, right? - Yeah, I mean, speaking of the pendulum swing and thinking about how did we get here, one of the things I really wanna talk about is the legacy of Me Too, which I think was, for me personally, an incredibly important movement. I was working at the Paris Review when Me Too happened, the editor-in-chief left at that moment the culture of the workplace where I was working changed drastically. I have felt like an enormous benefit from that movement in terms of my ability to be taken seriously at work and to move through professional spaces. And I also think that there are a lot of things that we're feeling now in the culture that are the long tail of Me Too. And we're almost 10 years out. And I think it's worth talking about, 'cause I think that this is also the moment when women began to feel absolutely guilty of this, very empowered to speak very loudly about the things that men had done that had harmed them to a degree that perhaps now has just been sort of flattened down to just like all men are trash. And I'm curious, Ruth, and you're reporting, I know you've written quite specifically about this, like how you think about the long tail of Me Too. - Yeah, it's a really complicated thing because like you, I was like thrilled at the Me Too movement. And it absolutely named something that was so real in my experience. And there's just like normalization of harassment and abuse and all the rest of it. And I think I understand it was just this like groundswell of rage, but like navigating that as a feminist while raising boys and thinking, you know, all we're hearing, like there's this micro-generation of boys that were kind of going through puberty around the time of the Me Too movement, you know, 2016, 2017. Who are now like a voting age, of college age, and they have spent their entire adolescence like in the shadow of this conversation, which has been framed very much as like men are predators, men are harmful, men are trash, which much of which is true. And like so important to talk about, but I feel like there was this real piece missing in that conversation that has left a lot of boys feeling like shut down, rageful, disenfranchised and like unable to really like, Find how they're going to make their way in the world, you know? It's interesting. I think that listening to the two of you reminds me how important it is to understand our different spheres that we're in, right? My sphere is very progressive, but also very Black-centered, very, you know, brown-centered. I've been lucky enough to be very, very much welcomed by deeply intersectional feminists, and so I think a lot of times the conversations that we're being had in a more sort of like mainstream sense, which we're largely led by white women, and then there was a reckoning around that because of Tarana Burke and, you know, Tarana Burke having, you know, been the person who had, who largely started a lot of this work in many senses of the word. I had been a part of those conversations, right? I went to, you know, I was lucky enough. I went to Hunter College on the right where Audra Lorde went, so these were not, I went to a very, like, I think Hunter College is 70% woman, so I'm, I'm just lucky to have been in these spaces where I'm not the dominating person, right? But I do think it's important to name like those conversations in the mainstream sense aren't the only conversations that are happening, right? There was very much in my experience welcoming and and thoughts around not only like how some men have been harmed, but how trans people have been harmed, how queer people have been harmed, and and things like that. I mean, I think of the conversations that I was hearing happen around me, too, for me were revelatory in the sense that I was realizing how universal the experience was of sexual harassment, of rape, of feeling held back at work based on the power dynamics around gender, and I mean, I think that was the moment for me in my life when I realized I didn't know any women who hadn't experienced this, which is what me to the word is about. But that consciousness raising up like this is not an individual isolated thing. This is happening. So prevalently was enormously useful, and then at the same time it left, and it caused, I mean, I work, as I was saying, I worked at a workplace where my boss left around this moment and the culture of the workplace changed. But it left so many of my colleagues who were men, white men, who I really respected, and who really, to me, it was obvious respected women, confused about how to act. Like, I had one colleague who was like, I always take the interns out for drinks. Every year, I take the interns out for drinks, but I can't take the interns out for drinks this year, because it'll look like I'm trying to get interned drunk, and I can't get interned drunk, and he, and he was also like, and am I allowed to compliment your clothes, because I like your clothes, but I don't want to get in trouble, and I could just see that he was really trying to figure it out, and I had real empathy for that, because we were defining new rules, and the new rules left very little room for nuance. They were very strict rules, but this was something that I feel like anyone who has experienced any form of societal oppression understands that someone can compliment your clothes, and you can know that they mean that they like your clothes, and they can compliment your clothes in a way that makes you feel small. And it actually doesn't matter what words they say, it matters the intention behind how they say it, and I think across different forms of oppressed identities, this general thing can be understood, but how do you explain it to this straight white man who have never experienced this? Yeah, I mean, I would say definitely for teenage boys, I think that's this like real fair among teenage boys at the moment, and I think it's contributing to this like sex recession, dating recession, whatever you want to call it where teenage boys do not, you know, are feeling very fearful of approaching girls, and in some ways that's good and right, and absolutely, you know, it's a correction to a very real problem, but I think it also does come back on boys of color as well, especially on black boys, I've found like in the university context, I did some reporting on these like title nine proceedings in colleges, and you know, boys who've been accused of sexual violence, and often, these are really, really complicated situations, and I think that black boys are disproportionately accused of sexual violence by white women on college campuses, and often these accusations are found to be if not unfounded, then very complex. There's a lot of racist maneuvering going on in that it's not just like the stereotype of like the white man who, or like boo, who white man can't like harass anyone, he wants to anyone, but it's all this stuff is so layered and so complicated, but I really don't envy a teenage boy trying to date in this environment, you know. It's interesting, I agree with so much of that, and I think that there is definitely institutional racism that ties to much of this, but what I would say is in terms of sort of like the white man at that time, especially. I just as a cishead man, I just feel like it's a nothing you, but I just I'm not interested in infantilizing these people right like you can run a fortune 500 company, but you can't understand how to not do something, how to do something creative to take, you know, interns out who are women, I don't know, I just, I feel like a lot of white men suddenly became childlike during that time, right? You you took over the entire world, you can't understand how to navigate during the me too move and I just I agree with you and also I just feel like there were moments at the height of this movement when I would want to talk about nuance because I do think that these that there was there has to be nuance this conversation and the very word nuance was suspect like if I said the word nuance, it was as if I was being a rape apologist and I felt really confused by that because these don't feel like conversations that can be to me can be solved by like sort of the extremes of black and white. I mean, I did feel my little brother was in college at that time and he came home being like, I'm really trying to get this right, but they've given us so many seminars and they've said like if a woman is drinking, you cannot have sex with her, but we are drinking all the time and so everyone is drunk always and so like, I don't understand like how to reconcile these two rules and for me, I was like, it is so much about your intentions and so that like and like not you can it's very hard to put a very blanket rule on things like you are smart enough to know if a woman is consenting or not and we can really speak about what it looks like for to have active consent. But but instead people were being given these very blanket rules that were unnewanced and and I feel like it has created a lot of confusion, I know that comes back to for me, maybe just because I went to school for this communication, right, I think obviously consent so and so but I think we can't assume intentions necessarily because I think intentions change depending upon. Geographic location age all sorts of demographic things right like if if I'm walking and I give a head nod to another man and he's black, we have an understanding what that means and if I do it to white guys like what the hell are you doing, I don't know, I can communicate what I'm thinking I communicate like like like again I'm not going to infantilize some of these men I'm also not going to infantilize women if we're communicating you can give me your opinion on what you think is. In not even a taste but safe right like even as we're sitting here across from each other from the beginning of the conversation I originally said to you I think you should go first and you can tell me I don't think I should go first and so many instances you have gone first. But I hope that I gave my communicating that gave you the latitude to say like I agree or disagree and I think that that's the sort of like interactions that I will want people to have so it's not just like consent it's so much more than consent it's also active conversation. I mean one thing that I will say I think that we give boys in general are very very poor grounding in relational education in communication in social skills in emotional nuance in picking up signals in like you know and that is something that starts from birth there's like a real difference in the way that we socialize girls to like really track other people's emotions to understand body language to understand like what someone might be feeling to sit as their role to like act on what somebody else might be feeling. And these are things that as you know I'd sort of baked in so early that then I think by the time that kids get to college like girls have this huge head start on this kind of communication and these relationships and understanding and like caring what another person thinks and seeing as their responsibility to kind of track that and respond to it and so. Yeah it's something that has to start much younger you know and I think patriarchy rubs boys and men of that you know of those skills. Christine Ember wrote this really wonderful article in the Washington Post called men are lost here's a road map out of the wilderness that if people who are listening to this conversation are interested in I would highly recommend as further reading and part of what she talks about is specifically how do we create a leftist counterpart to the manosphere and what is that model of masculinity look like and I know you both have thought about this a lot Ruth what what do you think. I mean I think it's many many different things I don't think it's possible to just say okay here's the answer you know get a get a Joe Rogan of the left or an annotate of the left because I think those attempts often don't really feel authentic I think it's many many many conversations and individual acts and you know people coming together to talk about these things and I think it's possible because like I was just thinking you know you look back at like pretty much any movie from that 80s or 90s and you look at the thing that they could get away with as completely normal when it came to racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, which were just completely normal and that are not normal anymore, that we have moved on as a culture when it comes to those issues, by no means perfect, there's so much work to do, but we have moved on and I think we can do the same for the way we think about boys and men, but I think it's like lots and lots of little things all the time, lots of people doing the work, lots of people thinking, lots of conversations like this, lots of work like, you know, Frederick does and you know that just it's bit by bit by bit and I think there's one single solution to it. And I also want to just follow up on something that you were saying earlier of how you think about, how you think about raising your sons to be good humans and how you want them to have tenderness, softness, these qualities that we generally associate with feminine traits and I really want that for men too, I want them to have friends, I want them to feel like it's valorous to cry or be vulnerable and at the same time I think if we're fully honest, we don't really want a society where men are more just like women, like there is value to having a society where there are men and there are women and they are able to be in the grand scheme of things different from one another. And so I'm thinking really hard about how what other messages can we give men that aren't just be more like women? I wonder if you've thought about that. Yeah, I mean, there are things that exist socially conditioned within men and women, but I think that again, they are socializing conditioned, right? So I don't think that, for example, tears, right? I cried during hamlet just like the two women next to me cried during hamlet, right? And I think that what we have been taught is that me crying during hamlet is some oddity and that's sort of what I rail against and I don't think that we have done a good job of propping up the people rail against that, right? Like I'll give you a phenomenal example. There was a conversation recently about like people going to this website, right? It was like all these men, and I think we're all very familiar with all these men going to this website and it was like teaching them how to rape their wives. And I was wondering just as I'm watching all these like proper grievances by women and people I'm like, like all these men are garbage absolutely. And I was also like, where's the counterweight? Like what are we actually trying to like I see all the the rightful rage? What is the actionable thing here? Like where are we leading people to? Because it's not enough to stop at the point of just saying like these men are dangerous, absolutely. These men are frightening, absolutely, these men are disgusting, absolutely. What are we doing? Yeah, what are we doing? Yeah, and so, but if you just keep, if you just keep people in this perpetual state of anger, you can keep on writing about it. You can keep on making videos about it. You can keep on selling things pertaining to it. And people will click and people will talk and people will, you know, you're feeding the beast. You do not want people getting healthy. It's the same thing with patriarchy, it's the same thing with white supremacy. It all feeds capitalism. If white people are not great, and they keep on doing racist things, more people sell books, more people click on articles, more people go to websites, et cetera, et cetera. It's it's a perpetual cycle of of bigotry. Right. And also that whole Epstein commentary, like there was no real mainstream discussion of like patriarchy and how that informs that it was like a lot of people talking about class and about wealth and about money and about power. But there was no there was very little like naming of this systemic force and like just talking about it, you know, they were. And to that point, there was like even with Epstein and everything that's transpired over the last few years. And maybe you've seen something different. I've not seen a major push to dismantle or unpack patriarchy to your point, right? And that's the thing I'm saying. It's not like, oh, you're so angry and frustrated and in disbelief and harmed and hurt by what these men did to these girls. Okay. So where are the conversations? Because this is not just wealthy white men flying girls from an island. This is happening in your neighborhood. Right. This is the whole system. Why aren't we talking about? I completely agree. Yeah. So I know we've talked about this quite a bit in various ways in this conversation, but I wonder if we can just sort of quickly run through like what are things? What are traits and qualities? If not of positive masculinity than of like the kind of masculinity, the left should be promoting as a counterpart to what's in the manosphere. One of my colleagues has gotten really interested in the subreddit, our bald where men just compliment each up. Men are like, shave it off. It'll look better. And then they're like, bro, you look great. You look amazing. And it is a very sweet corner of the internet because it's one in which men just support and compliment each other through a difficult transition time in their appearance. And I'm curious, what are the other, like, so what are other qualities and traits of something that the left could be promoting as a vision for boys? Yeah. I think the male friendship and male bonding has got such a bad name because it's become associated with like locker room, so I can like gross things. It's just that that sort of brotherhood, that like loyalty and courage and support for one another is something that's really lovely. And I think, you know, I'm from the UK and I think there is a real culture of male friendship there in a way that I don't see quite so much in the States. Maybe some of it is because of like alcohol and drinking and those kinds of things, it really brings up a whole new range of problems. And I think some of it comes about from trauma, like boys being sent off to boarding school and that sort of thing. But I think there is this real culture of like male friendship and male bonding which is very lovely that, you know, I'd like to say. I give you a good example actually. Right now, and I can't stand this team for various reasons, but the Oklahoma City Thunder, who are in the Western Conference finals of the NBA playoffs, are comprised of a lot of Gen Z young men. And the ways in which they love on each other is such a positive sort of embracing of brotherhood, friendship and love for each other. I've literally heard them say like, I love you. Thank you for showing up for me tonight. Thank you for this. Thank you for that. And I think that we can be promoting that more, that there are great examples of young men and men in general who are not afraid to like love on each other. Before we wrap, I want to know one traditionally masculine quality you'd want your sons or your younger brother to take on and one that you wish they wouldn't. I think for the, for the one, I mean, there's so many great qualities associated masculinity, like courage and protection and strength and all the rest of it. But I think I'm going to go for fixing stuff. So I would love for my kids to be able to like have those skills, you know, those old school masculine skills. So that, and then the really wouldn't, I think it's got to be emotional suppression just like that feeling that you cannot connect with your animations. I think that's so unhealthy and harmful. And I really hope that my boys will be able to connect with their own emotions and those of other people. I love that answer. I think the first one being actionable. I think that we have this idea of men in our society historically like this thing is happening. I'm going to jump in and try to do something. Can you be actionable about somebody saying you harmed me? Can you be actionable about someone saying I felt unsafe in this moment? So that sort of like ability to like jump in and do the thing. I'd love to see that in maybe more emotional and like social ways. And then in terms of not passing down, and it's sort of like stubbornness, right? I think that a lot of men have been taught that sort of this like this personal manifest destiny, if you will, like the entire world belongs to you and you just got to go out and seize it. I kind of just want you to like stop and just listen to other people. Just like like stop, just stop, right? Like just stop. Like, you know, you're the only thing I think that you're promised in this world is the person in the mirror and what you do with that. And so, you know, um, just stop and listen, stop and listen. Yeah. That's beautifully said. Ruth, Frederick, thank you so much for being here with me today. This was a wonderful conversation. I really appreciate it. It was such a pleasure. Thank you. Thank you. These episodes will also be playing on our YouTube channel. If you want to see the beautiful loft where we recorded this, find us on YouTube at New York Times Opinion. If you like this show, follow it on YouTube, Spotify, or Apple. The Opinions is produced by Derek Arthur, Vashaka Darba, Victoria Chamberlain, and Jillian Weinberger. It's edited by Jillian Weinberger, Jasmine Romero, and Curry Pitkin. Mixing by Daniel Ramirez, original music by Isaac Jones, Sonia Herrero, Pat McCusker, Carol Saburo, Epheme Shapiro, and Amin Sahota. That check team is Kate Sinclair, Mary Marge Locker, and Michelle Harris. The head of operations is Shannon Busta, audience support by Christina Samuluski. The director of opinion shows is Annie Rose Straszer. (upbeat music)

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The current state of masculinity is deeply shaped by systemic patriarchy, which harms all genders, and is reinforced by toxic narratives on both political left and right.
  2. The left’s emphasis on "men are trash" creates psychological harm for young boys, undermining their self-worth and emotional development while failing to offer constructive alternatives.
  3. Both Ruth Whitman and Frederick Joseph argue that positive masculinity should not be gendered or restricted to "masculine" traits, but instead centered on emotional authenticity, vulnerability, and being a fully human being.
  4. The Me Too movement exposed widespread sexual harassment but left behind a culture of blanket condemnation, leading to confusion, emotional disconnection, and a lack of nuanced conversations about consent and power.
  5. Men are missing foundational relational skills—like emotional awareness, active listening, and empathy—due to societal expectations that suppress vulnerability and emotional expression.
  6. The left lacks a strong, visible counter-narrative to the manosphere, and there is little promotion of male friendship, brotherhood, or supportive male bonding as positive, healthy models.
  7. True change requires moving beyond anger and blame, focusing instead on actionable behavior, emotional intelligence, and shared responsibility within communities.
  8. A healthier vision of masculinity includes qualities like emotional openness, listening, and problem-solving, while rejecting emotional suppression and the myth of male self-reliance.

Summary:

The conversation between Ruth Whitman and Frederick Joseph highlights the deep crisis in contemporary masculinity, rooted in systemic patriarchy that harms men, women, and trans people alike. While left-wing critiques of men as "trash" are grounded in real harm, they often fail to provide constructive alternatives, instead leaving young men psychologically isolated and emotionally stunted. Both speakers advocate for a shift away from gendered or restrictive models of masculinity, urging instead a focus on emotional intelligence, vulnerability, and relational competence.

They note that the Me Too movement, though vital in exposing abuse, promoted oversimplified narratives that created confusion and division, particularly in how consent and power are understood. The absence of positive male role models—like supportive male friendships or emotional openness in media—further contributes to the alienation of young men. The left, they argue, must build a counter-narrative centered on active compassion, listening, and shared humanity, not just outrage.

Ultimately, a healthier future for masculinity demands not just dismantling toxic systems, but reimagining what it means to be a full, emotionally grounded human being—regardless of gender.

FAQs

Young men are in an abysmal state, facing toxic and insidious role models, including a president accused of rape, and being exposed to harmful narratives on both the left and right, such as macho stereotypes or dismissive 'shut up' attitudes.

Patriarchy harms everyone, including men, by reinforcing systems of power and privilege. While it disproportionately harms women and transgender people, men are also affected through emotional suppression, lack of emotional expression, and social conditioning.

The constant messaging that men are trash is psychologically harmful, leading to feelings of isolation, shame, and confusion. It undermines boys' self-worth and makes it harder for them to form healthy relationships or navigate the world with confidence.

Positive masculinity should focus on being a full, emotionally aware human being rather than conforming to rigid gender roles. It values vulnerability, empathy, emotional expression, and healthy male friendships over aggression or stoicism.

While Me Too was vital in exposing sexual harassment, its aftermath often reduced men to 'predators' without addressing nuance, leading to emotional disconnection and confusion among young men about consent, boundaries, and healthy relationships.

The left should promote emotional intelligence, vulnerability, male bonding built on loyalty and support, and active, compassionate responses to harm—rather than toxic masculinity, emotional suppression, or dismissive attitudes.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.