Alaskan Teen Snatched By Killer Cop? The Murder Of Sonya Ivanoff
39m 54s
Sonia Ivanoff, a 19-year-old native Alaskan woman from Nome, Alaska, was murdered in 2003 under circumstances that initially appeared to point to a known friend with a history of domestic violence. However, a pivotal witness report revealed she entered a police vehicle with a police decal, a detail ignored by authorities. This led to a deeper investigation that uncovered extensive misconduct by Officer Matt Owens, including illegal activities, sexual assaults, and a history of using his police authority for personal gain. Evidence such as blood traces, a stolen patrol car, and personal items matching Sonia’s clothing tied him directly to the crime. Though initially acquitted due to legal challenges and a deadlocked jury, Owens was eventually convicted in a second trial after new testimony, including a recorded conversation revealing he had kept Sonia’s ID in his home. The case exposed systemic failures in the Nome Police Department, including a lack of response to abuse reports and institutional bias. It prompted significant reforms, including the Sonja Ivanoff Law, which mandates 99-year sentences for police officers convicted of murder. Sonia’s tragic death highlighted the dangers of police abuse and the urgent need for accountability, especially in marginalized communities.
You're listening to this podcast, so I know you've got a curious mind.
Here's a helpful fact that you might not know yet.
Drivers who switch and save with Progressive save over $900 on average.
They make it super simple.
Pop over to Progressive.com, answer some questions,
and you'll get a quick quote with coverage options tailored to your choices.
Plus, you'll see which discounts you may qualify for,
like the online quote discount or savings for paying in full.
In fact, 99% of Progressive Auto customers earn at least one discount.
See if you could save when you switch to Progressive.
You'll feel good about making a savvy choice.
Visit Progressive.com and see if you can enjoy a little extra cash back.
Progressive Casualty Insurance Company & Affiliates.
National average 12-month savings of $946 by new customers surveyed
who saved with Progressive between June 2024 and May 2025.
Potential savings will vary.
Labor Day deals are looking good at Lowe's.
Save $10 on 1-gallon cans and $50 on 5-gallon pails of select interior paint
via rebate.
Plus, get two 2.5-quart or 3-quart mums for just $8.
A fresh look and savings?
Even better.
Labor Day deals are on now at Lowe's.
In-store and online.
Valid through 9-9.
While supplies last.
Mum sizes vary by location and exclude Alaska and Hawaii.
See store at Lowe's.com for more details.
Hello, everyone.
Hello, everyone.
And welcome back to True Crime with Kendall Rae.
Thank you so much for joining me today.
And if you're new to the show, then welcome.
I'm so happy to have you here.
And make sure to click subscribe so that you never miss an upload from me.
So, you guys, today we're going to be talking about a case that is truly so shocking.
And that's mainly because of the wildly ridiculous way
that the investigation led to the most unlikely suspect.
We're going to be going over the case of Sonia,
and her case is so deeply upsetting because it was so unnecessary.
Her murder never could have been predicted by her friends and family.
And there was just absolutely no point to it.
There's no reason why she shouldn't be here with them today.
She was a wonderful young woman with a lot of promise.
And, of course, I want to start out by talking about her.
Sonia Ivanoff was born on 8th.
April 13th, 1994 to her parents, Maggie and Larry Ivanoff.
And they lived in Unalakleet, Alaska.
Unfortunately, there isn't that much information out there about her younger years,
but I will share what I was able to find.
So, she was the fourth child of six children in her family.
And her and her older sister, Christine, were the only two girls out of all of them.
And the town that they grew up in was a very small village in Norton Sound,
which is on the western coast of Alaska.
And not only is it interesting,
but it has a population of just 700 people.
And most of the community is Native Alaskan.
And Sonia was well-known in the area,
mainly because of her very outgoing and bubbly, friendly type of personality.
And people who knew her described her as goofy, as fun,
and having a positive attitude pretty much all the time.
But she wasn't just known because she was an extrovert.
She was also a star athlete on the local basketball team,
which made her a very important part of her life.
And she was also very prominent throughout Norton Sound.
Then in 2002, Sonia graduated from high school and she moved to Nome, Alaska.
Now, even though Nome's population in 2003 was about 3,554 people,
it is considered a city in that area.
And Sonia decided to move there for better job opportunities
so that she could save money for college.
And eventually, her goal was to move to Hilo, Hawaii.
And I don't blame her.
Beautiful place.
And she was taking that goal very seriously.
When she first got to Nome,
she started working at the administrative desk of a local hospital.
And then shortly after that,
she entered the Arctic Native Brotherhood pageant
with the hope of earning some scholarship money for college.
And this isn't what you would typically think of when you think of a pageant.
Instead, it was really a celebration of the Native Alaskan heritage
and something that Sonia was really proud of.
So this was really an exciting time for Sonia in her life.
I mean, she was prepping towards new goals,
but she was also doing a bunch of new things in the meantime.
And it got even better because just a couple of months after she arrived in Nome,
her best friend, Timory, moved there too and started living with Sonia.
The two of them were extremely close,
and they shared everything from makeup to clothes and even a bed together.
And they both really settled into their new town very easily.
They started to make friends very quickly.
They were starting to save money.
And since neither of them had a car, they were walking everywhere,
which was something that was really important to them.
And also something that they felt safe doing.
But unfortunately, everything changed for them on August 10th, 2003.
That night, they went to a friend's house.
And according to Timory, it was a very chill night.
They were hanging out.
Sonia only had one beer.
They were playing board games.
And then a little bit before 1 a.m., Sonia and Timory decided it was time to call it a night.
So Timory actually had work really early in the morning.
So she decided to go to a friend's house.
She decided to crash at a friend's house nearby.
But Sonia wanted to go back home.
So the two of them parted ways.
And I thought this was really, really sweet.
But they had this secret handshake.
And they would also say,
Peace out, pal.
And they would do this whenever they left each other.
And of course, they did that before walking away from each other that night.
And Timory later said that it was raining that night,
but that Sonia was happy because she loved the rain.
And she actually watched Sonia happily jump into a puddle
as she started to walk in the direction of their home.
But in that moment, Timory had no idea that this would be the last time
that she would see her best friend.
Early the next morning, around 5.30 a.m.,
Timory went back to their apartment before she went to work.
She just stopped by.
And she noticed that Sonia wasn't there.
And even more strange, it seemed like her bed wasn't slept in.
But she didn't get too concerned about it right away.
And she left for work.
And also, you've got to keep in mind, this is 2000.
It was practically a different world back then.
Not everyone had cell phones,
so she couldn't just easily call or text Sonia to see where she was.
And sometimes the two of them would either call each other while at work to check in,
you know, from whatever phone was available at work.
But Sonia never called that day, which made her start to get even more worried.
And then later that day, when she came home from work,
Sonia still wasn't there.
And stuff like her makeup bag,
and her hair products seemed untouched,
which indicated that she hadn't been home at all.
And that's when Timory started calling some of Sonia's friends and family,
including her older sister, Christina.
But Christina and her husband weren't that worried right away.
They figured that maybe Sonia just needed a little space,
maybe a little space away from Timory for whatever reason.
But that thought went away the next day
because Sonia didn't show up for her shift at the hospital,
which was incredibly unlike her.
And so at that point,
her loved ones went ahead and started just driving and walking around Nome looking for Sonia.
Timory was so desperate for any information that she even called the Nome Police Department
to see if Sonia had been arrested.
But she hadn't been.
And soon it seemed that everyone was coming up empty.
So on August 12th, Timory went to the Nome Police Department to fill out a missing persons report.
And according to her, and unfortunately we hear this more times than we don't, it seems,
but they did not take it very seriously and seemed,
to just kind of brush the whole situation off.
Even Sonia's brother-in-law ended up going to the department that evening and he said he had the same experience.
But the next day, Sonia missed another shift without calling in.
So her employer also reported her missing and that seemed to get the police's attention a little bit more.
So they, at that point, jumped right into action.
Now, the Nome Police Department is incredibly small with only eight officers.
So they requested help.
From the fire department and volunteers to search for Sonia.
But they weren't out very long.
At around 8.30 that evening, a volunteer firefighter was about three miles outside of Nome
when he saw tire tracks going down a remote road.
And he followed them.
And that is when he came across the body of Sonia Ivanoff,
who was dead at just 19 years old.
And the crime scene was rather strange.
Sonia's body was hidden under some bushes and she was completely naked.
Except for one sock on her left foot.
While she had bruises on her face and chest, the cause of death wasn't immediately obvious.
So the Nome Police Department went ahead and called in the Alaska Bureau of Investigation
to help process this scene.
But here's the thing.
The ABI's headquarters are in Anchorage, which is about 500 miles away from Nome.
So they wouldn't be able to make it over there until the next day.
So the police had to do their absolute best to preserve the crime scene until then.
And they did a really good job.
They covered every inch of it with tarps.
And the officers took shifts guarding the scene throughout the night.
And luckily, all this effort did pay off.
And the ABI was able to collect evidence when they arrived.
And like I said, there were tire tracks on this remote road.
And as investigators looked closer,
they realized that there was a pool of blood next to Sonia's body.
And that the tires actually drove over.
So that led them to believe that the car probably belonged to whoever killed her.
And the. tire tracks were very
very distinct. One tire was mismatched from the other three. They also found blue paint marks on
high branches. And because of the placement, investigators believe that the car was most
likely a blue truck or SUV. And after processing the scene, Sonia's body was flown to Anchorage
for an autopsy. And that did end up providing investigators with a lot more answers.
So a couple
years ago, I randomly decided one night that I was going to start journaling, but it literally hurts
to hold a pen. So I decided to download an app as my journal. And I had this whole idea,
oh, I'm going to do it every night. I'm going to type in my thoughts at the end of the day.
Yeah, never used the app. Signed up for it. Signed up for the free trial. Then just forgot
it was on my phone. And I ended up paying for this journaling app for like a year.
But if I had Rocket Money, that would not have happened to me. Because Rocket Money can track
all of your subscriptions and gives you the ability to cancel the unwanted ones within the app,
with just a few taps, giving users an easy way to stop paying for things that you don't use.
The app consolidates your checking, your savings, loans, and investments into a single dashboard,
giving you this great clear view of your financial picture, which is great for someone like me that
really doesn't do well with numbers. The fact that it is easy, it is simple, just works so well for
me. And like I said, with Rocket Money, you can track your subscriptions and you have the ability
to cancel within the app with just a few taps, which is going to save you time and save you money.
You can set budgets, you can set goals, and you can get personalized insights and regular reports.
Also receive real-time alerts for large transactions, upcoming bills,
refunds, low balances. It's so nice to have someone in your financial corner.
Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps you find and cancel unwanted subscriptions,
monitors your spending, and helps you to lower your bills so that you can grow your savings.
Let Rocket Money help you reach your financial goals faster.
Join at rocketmoney.com slash kendallray. That's rocketmoney.com slash kendallray. Once again,
rocketmoney.com slash kendallray.
Help is within reach and within budget. Most insured members receive Talkspace for free.
Talkspace supports individuals, teens, and couples. Talkspace is in network with most
major insurers, and most insured members have a $0 copay. No insurance, no problem.
Now get $80 off of your first month when you go to talkspace.com and enter promo code SPACE80.
That's S-P-A-C-E-8-0. Match with a licensed therapist today at talkspace.com.
They discovered that she had died from a single gunshot wound by a.22 caliber bullet
fired at point-blank range to the back of her head. The wound had been
hidden behind her beautiful, thick, dark hair, which is why investigators didn't notice it right
away. The autopsy also revealed that there was no foreign DNA on her. There was nothing under
her fingernails. There was nothing
The rape kit showed that she hadn't been sexually assaulted, which obviously led investigators to
believe that whoever did this really knew how to cover their tracks, knew what they were doing.
And with such little forensic evidence at the scene, police weren't exactly sure where to start.
And while all of this is happening, Sonia's friends and family are just absolutely reeling
from such a sudden and shocking loss, trying to make sense of it all. The day that Sonia's body
was found, Timmery and another friend were out driving around looking for her, and they went to
the hospital that Sonia worked at, and one of her co-workers told her to go to the police station.
And as they were heading over there, she had high hopes that maybe they found Sonia. Maybe she was
okay. But when she got to the station and learned the horrible truth, she was just absolutely
devastated. I mean, there are no words. And then, of course, Sonia's family were also devastated.
They were just so heartbroken and so confused about what had happened and why. Her brother
Jacob said that the only way he knew how to cope with it was to get outside and go hunting. And
while he was there, he saw vibrant northern lights. And he later said it felt like Sonia was
dancing over the world. And the love that her family had for her was so, so incredibly strong
and so apparent.
Especially when it came to her funeral. Because, oh my god, this just really chokes me up. But
her family was originally planning on doing a closed casket funeral because of the bruising
on Sonia's face. But her older sister, Christina, knew how much Sonia cared about her appearance,
so she decided to do her makeup. I cannot even imagine doing anyone's makeup, let alone your
sister's, for years.
That is, oh god, one of the most heartbreaking things I've ever heard. One of the most admirable
things I've ever heard. I mean, that must have just been beyond difficult. But also, I'm sure in
some ways it was an honor for her to do that for her. It just really shows how much Christina
wanted to take care of Sonia. And tragically, the funeral service was also held in the same gym
where Sonia played basketball just a couple of years before. And while her loved ones are trying
their best to process this horrible loss, they were still trying to make sense of it all,
wondering who could have possibly wanted to hurt Sonia and why. And not only were they trying to
wrap their minds around all of that, but they were also a bit concerned right out the gate about
how the case was being handled. Because a week after Sonia's body was discovered,
Christina's husband, Tom, went to the police station and he put a photo of Sonia on the wall
because he wanted to see her. And he put a photo of Sonia on the wall because he wanted to see her
and to remind them of who they were working for. And get this, an officer actually yelled at him.
Yelled at a man who has just lost a loved one. Who is just trying to simply hang a photo of them
on the wall. And the reason for yelling at him? Because he was worried it would ruin the drywall.
Okay, what? Fuck the drywall. Who cares? But this experience did not stop Tom. And he continued to
fight until they got answers. And around this time, it seemed like there was a break in the
case when investigators found a viable suspect. While talking to Sonia's friends and family,
there was one name that just kept coming up. A man who went by the nickname Kunik. Apparently,
he was a friend of Sonia's who had romantic interest in her, but she didn't feel the same way.
And Timree even told investigators that she believed Sonia once had bruises on her that were
caused by Kunik. And he was also known by the police for having a relationship with Sonia.
Because he had a history of domestic violence charges against the mother of his child.
So investigators went over to his house and that's where they found some
very interesting things. Turns out he had a blue truck. And not only that,
it was a blue truck with mismatched tires. Just like the car that was at the scene.
And while they were searching the truck, they ended up finding a lot of blood. There were
drops of blood on the floor of the car, on a tarp that was in the trunk of the car,
and also on a tire and the wheel well. But it didn't stop there. Blood was also found on a
pair of Kunik's sneakers and one of his rifles. And on top of all of that, he had scratches on
his back. So based on all of this, you would think that Kunik was Sonia's killer. And
investigators were starting to think that as well. But he insisted right from the jump that he had
nothing to do with it. And that he hadn't seen her in weeks. As for all that blood,
he had an explanation for it. He said that he was out of town on a hunting trip on the night that
Sonia disappeared. And he said that while he was out, he had either hit a rabbit or a porcupine
with his car. And he ended up hitting it in its head to put it out of its misery, which is how
blood ended up on his shoes and his rifle. He also stated that those scratches on his back were from
his ex-girlfriend. Now, investigators at first, they were not buying this at all. They were pretty
sure that the blood was actually Sonia's, not a random animal. But shockingly, Kunik's
Kunick was telling the truth.
All of that blood was confirmed to be animal blood.
And investigators even went to the area and they were able to find the carcass of the porcupine.
And as for the tire impressions that were found at the scene,
it turns out that they had nothing to do with the murder.
A random couple had driven down the road after Sonia was murdered
and they had no idea that they had driven past her or that her blood was on their tires.
So now that Kunick was cleared, investigators were back at square one.
And at this point, Nome PD had two officers assigned to the case,
Byron Redburn and Brian Weyavana.
But it really wasn't a good setup because they could really barely work together
because they had completely opposite shifts, which makes no sense.
Plus, Officer Weyavana felt like Officer Redburn
wasn't really communicating anything that he was investigating,
which is obviously not.
Now, Officer Weyavana was actually friends with Sonia's sister and brother-in-law,
so he was very committed to solving the case.
And he just felt like there wasn't enough movement happening in the case.
So he decided to go through the case file again and see if there was anything that was missed.
And thankfully, he did.
It always just blows my mind when there are cases like this
where someone decides to take a second look at the case file and they find something huge.
His second look led to. a very significant piece of information being found.
And it would actually break the case wide open.
In the files, he found a witness report that it seemed no one had bothered to follow up with.
It turns out that a local woman named Florence
reported seeing Sonia the night that she disappeared.
So Weyavana went to talk to her and she had quite a story.
A little before 1.30 a.m., Florence and her sister were sitting out on their porch,
having a cigarette, when Sonia walked by their house.
And Florence's sister actually knew Sonia, so they waved at each other as she passed them.
And while Sonia kept walking down the street,
Florence noticed that a car was driving slowly behind her.
Then that car drove up ahead and cut Sonia off.
The driver rolled their window down and started talking to her.
And then after a few minutes, Sonia actually got into the passenger side of the car
and the two of them drove off.
But the most shocking thing?
The only thing that Florence noticed that night was a decal on the car.
And it wasn't just any decal.
It was the Nome Police Department logo.
And Florence knew that what she saw was important.
And she contacted the police as soon as she learned that Sonia had been murdered.
She said she even spoke to the chief of police and told him a lot of details,
including what Sonia was wearing.
Yet with all of that, nobody in the police department bothered to follow up with her about it.
Now, thankfully, Florence is a smart, smart person.
and she knew how important this information was and she wasn't just going to sit back and wait
for them to do something about it. If they weren't going to interview her, she was going to interview
herself. So she ended up videotaping herself talking about what she saw that night so that
it could be properly documented, which is just so brilliant because now there is a timestamp on her
story, right? She has documented herself saying it on a specific day and it will show in the future
that her story hasn't changed. It's really incredible that she thought to do this, but
at the same time, it's painfully ridiculous that a witness had to handle their own statement
because they cared more than the police did. But now that Officer Wayovana was on the case
and took that second look at the file, he was going to make sure that something was actually
done about it.
So he informs the police chief that this tip points this investigation right back
at the Nome Police Department. So the ABI was called in and took over the case.
Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. National average 12-month savings
of $946 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between,
June 2024 and May 2025. So a couple years ago, I randomly decided one night that I was going to start journaling, but
it literally hurts my hand to hold a pen. Signed up for it,
signed up for the free trial, then just forgot it was on my phone. Because Rocket Money can track all of your subscriptions and gives you the ability to
cancel the unwanted ones within the app with just a few taps, giving users an easy way to
stop paying for things that you don't use. The app consolidates your checking, your savings,
loans, and investments into a single dashboard, giving you this great clear view of your
financial picture, which is great for someone like me that really doesn't do well with numbers,
the fact that it is easy, it is simple, just works so well for me.
Rocket Money is a personal finance app
that helps you find and cancel your money. And it's a great app for you to use. So if you're
and cancel unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps you to lower your
bills so that you can grow your savings. They soon discovered that two officers
were on duty that night, Stan Pesquia and Matt Owens. And both of these men actually had a
questionable history when it came to this case. Pesquia was the one who took the report from
Timmery and didn't take it seriously. And Matt Owens was the officer that yelled at Sonia's
brother-in-law for putting her picture up at the police station because he didn't want to
ruin the drywall. So the ABI requested that both officers come to Anchorage so that they
could take a polygraph test. But the day that they were set to go, something very
unexpected happened. That night, a sergeant on duty noticed that Nome Police Department's
21 cruiser was missing. So he radioed the other officer on duty, which happened to be Matt Owens,
and he didn't know where it was. And before long, everyone in the department was out looking for
the cruiser, but it actually didn't take long for it to be tracked down. Matt Owens radioed everyone
to say that he had found the car in an isolated area called the Bessie Pits, which also happened
to be pretty close to where Sonia's body was found. And before anyone could meet him there,
he radioed in again, saying,
that shots were being fired at him. So of course, everyone jumps into action at this point and gets
there as fast as they possibly can. But when they arrived, the scene was quiet and a gunman was
nowhere to be found. Then Matt Owens just walked up to the scene and told officers that he had run
into a nearby tundra to avoid being shot. And he didn't have any injuries, but he was very shaken
up. And he said that he was so scared of leaving his son without a father that he was even second
guessing if he should even be an officer. And he said that he was so scared of leaving his son
And even though Matt Owens was okay, the 321 cruiser was not. A rock had been thrown through
the driver's side window, and on that seat under the broken glass was an envelope with a letter
inside of it, almost like something out of a crime thriller. It was written by Sonia's killer,
but it was bizarre to say the least. It said,
It was easy for me to take your pig car keys right there. It was not her fault. She thought I was a
pig, and it just happened. She was just a person, and I just wanted to see if I could that night.
Every one of you should be more careful. I watch every move. You leave me alone,
and I will leave you alone. I will shoot you in the head if you get close. And in that envelope
was Sonia's recreational ID card, proof that whoever this was had something to do with her murder. But
right away, this whole situation felt very off to investigators. They extensively searched the area
by foot and by helicopter, and nothing was found. And then a few days later,
investigators even conducted a reenactment of how Owens described the events,
and they discovered that didn't make much sense. First off, there were many places where Owens
could have taken cover instead of running off into the tundra. Also, the person recreated his
supposed actions at the scene had a lot of dirt and scuff marks on his pants, while
Owens' uniform hadn't. It was pretty clean. They also realized that the cruiser would have had to
back into the spot it was found in, which didn't make sense for someone to do if they were on the
run with a stolen police car, right? So pretty soon investigators began to believe that this was
most likely staged to get him out of the polygraph in Anchorage and redirect the ABI from looking
into known police officers. But that didn't work, and the ABI were more determined than ever to
speak with Officer Pescoia and Officer Owens. Now, this is no surprise, but Owens canceled his
trip to Anchorage the next day, stating that he was too traumatized from the shooting and
he needed to speak to a therapist. But Stan Pescoia still made the trip out there and gave
investigators his account of what happened the night that Sonia disappeared. He said that he
and Owens had responded to a domestic violence call and that the perpetrator tried to attack
them. So they apprehended him, brought him to the local jail,
then put him in a cell and then put him in a cell and then put him in a cell and then put him in a
cell. So they apprehended him, brought him to the local jail, then put him in a cell and then put him
Pescoia stayed at the department to fill out a report while Owens went back on patrol. Pescoia
said that he was at the department from about 1.30 to 2 a.m., which the ABI was able to verify.
And since Florence saw Sonia enter the police SUV around 1.30 a.m., that meant it couldn't
have been him, which of course leaves Matt Owens as their only suspect. And of course,
investigators start digging into his past a little bit more, and they did learn some more about him.
Turns out that Officer Owens had done some pretty,
awful things during his three years on the force. Apparently, it was pretty well known that during
his shifts, he would have his friends drive around with him in his patrol car, which is
absolutely not authorized. And the chief of police, I guess, warned him to stop, but
that didn't change anything. He didn't stop, kept giving joy rides to his buddies. And it just gets
worse because the ABI learned that Owens was also picking up women and having sex with them in his
car.
So this made them wonder if he had tried to make a move on Sonia, and things got out of hand and
he killed her to keep her quiet. So after they learned all of this, it was far beyond time to
finally talk to Owens. So he was forced to go to Anchorage and do the interview and polygraph test
that he had been avoiding. And the Alaska State troopers were actually so worried that he might
try to get out of it that they had an agent go to Nome just to make sure he got on that plane.
But of course, while sitting with the ABI,
he tried to talk his way out of everything. He claimed that while, yes, he did have some of his
buddies ride around in his patrol car with him, he never had sex with any women on duty. And as far
as Sonia, he said he did know her because sometimes while he was on duty, he would have to bring
people to the hospital and she worked there. But he completely denied having anything to do with
her murder. Now, interestingly, he said that he had never had sex with any women on duty. And he
did bring up the letter that was found at the scene of the shootout to remind the ABI that
Sonia's killer was someone who hated cops. Officer Owens really thought he was smart when doing that,
right? He thought that he was playing chess when in reality he was playing tic-tac-toe,
and he wasn't good at it either. And as I'm sure you've probably guessed at this point,
when he took the polygraph test, he failed it. No shock there. But even though the suspicion
was that he was a good cop, he wasn't good at it either. And as I'm sure you've probably guessed
you know, strongly on Owens at this point, after his interview, especially, they didn't have enough
yet to arrest him. So they had to let him go. Instead, he returned to Nome and the police
department placed him on administrative leave. But the investigation was still ramping up
and the ABI actually received some very significant information from Owens' ex-wife.
She stated that one afternoon he randomly called her up to say that he would have to drop her
off with her earlier than expected because he had been called into work to assist in looking for
a missing girl. And this call took place before Sonia was even reported missing. So he shouldn't
have even known about it. Big red flag there. And then another woman calls up investigators and
tells them that Owens was asking her to leave Alaska with him. So they're like, oh shit. Okay.
Before this guy can potentially flee,
we need to issue an arrest warrant. And they did. And then finally, on October 25th, 2003,
Matt Owens was charged with first degree murder. And while this was a big step forward, it of course
didn't mean the investigation was complete. And people did keep coming forward with new
information. Just a few days after his arrest, multiple women came forward with disturbing
accounts of their experiences with Matt Owens. And just as I explained, it was sort of known
that he would pick up his friends in his squad car. It was also, I guess, sort of an open secret
that he was picking up women while he was on his shift. And he was also coercing and assaulting
them. In one account, he had arrested a woman and then sexually assaulted her when she was in
the patrol car. Another woman said that after he had forced himself on her, he told her that if
she tried to tell anyone, no one would believe a drunk native woman over a police officer. And
this one is really horrific. But another woman said that Owens held her at gunpoint and demanded
that she perform oral sex on him. And multiple women even said that he threatened to kill them
if they said anything. And I wish this was a shock to me. But it turns out some of these
survivors had informed the Nome Police Department about what he was doing. One person had even
reported the incident to someone who worked in the department, while another had filed a
formal complaint and no action was ever taken. And hearing something like that, you can't help
but to wonder if someone had actually stepped in, had done their job, had stopped him, had upheld
the standards of the department to any degree, maybe there would be a chance that Sonia Ebenhoff
would be here today. And while this was all major information for the case, even more was uncovered.
Someone called in a tip to report that they had seen Matt Owens burning gloves at an area known
as Coffee Creek, approximately 75 miles outside of Nome. So investigators decided to thoroughly
examine the area. They treated the burn pit like they were panning for gold, scooping up parts of
it and sifting through it. And thankfully they did because they ended up finding a small but
crucial piece of evidence.
You'll feel good.
about making a savvy choice. Signed up for it. Because Rocket Money can track
all of your subscriptions and gives you the ability to cancel the unwanted ones within the app with
just a few taps, giving users an easy way to stop paying for things that you don't want to pay for.
The app consolidates your checking, your savings, loans, and investments into a single dashboard,
giving you this great clear view of your financial picture, which is great for someone like me. That
really doesn't do well with numbers. Also, receive real-time alerts for large transactions, upcoming bills, refunds,
low balances. They were able to find a shoe eyelet. And if you don't know, a shoe eyelet is a tiny metal
circular part of a shoe that the laces go through. And this eyelet had a Skechers logo on it, which
was the brand of shoes that Sonia was last seen wearing. And this discovery made them continue
searching the burn pit, which uncovered more shoe eyelets, the metal clasp of a bra, pieces of a
zipper, and a pair of shoes that were not worn. And they were able to find a shoe eyelet that was
button with the brand Tilt on it, which was a brand that Sonia would wear. But get this,
They also found a P.O. Box key belonging to Matt Owen's uncle.
And if all that wasn't enough, another witness came forward to say that they saw Owen's burning clothes there.
So clearly, the evidence against this man is really starting to mount.
But there was one significant piece of evidence that had yet to be found.
The murder weapon.
And while investigators were looking for it, Officer Byron Redburn made a pretty chilling suggestion.
He raised the possibility of Owens taking a gun from the police evidence locker to use.
And when investigators looked into it, they found a gun that used a.22 caliber bullet, the same type that killed Sonja.
They also learned that the evidence locker key was kept in a mailbox in the chief's office, which anyone could access.
And while this doesn't prove necessarily that Matt Owens definitely did that, it still showed that it was possible.
And given this guy's. character, it was not a stretch to think that he would have stolen something out of the evidence locker, right?
But unfortunately, not everyone saw it that way because his family and people in his church community were strong defenders of him.
And they were mad.
So mad that when his trial started in 2005, Sonja's family said that Owens' supporters treated them as if they were the bad guys when they were in court.
Which had to have been so difficult.
Difficult for them to deal with, on top of worrying about getting justice for Sonja.
Now, during the trial, the prosecution argued that Matt Owens killed Sonja and staged the theft of patrol car 321.
Which I think seems pretty obvious to all of us.
But it might not have been as obvious to the jury because, first of all, the judge ruled that the accusations of sexual assault from all these women weren't admissible.
So they weren't able to hear that this was clearly a pattern.
of behavior for Officer Owens.
And he hired a strong defense attorney who was prepared to pull out all the stops for his client.
They argued that investigators were correct about a known police officer killing Sonja.
But they said it wasn't Matt Owens.
They pointed the finger at Byron Redburn, the same officer who suggested that Owens may have gotten the gun from the evidence locker.
And they claimed that he had a motive to try and frame Owens because it turns out that Owens was having an affair with Redburn's own wife.
So all of this, coupled with the lack of DNA evidence, made it difficult to secure a conviction.
After deliberating for 10 days, the jury was completely deadlocked.
So the judge declared a mistrial, which was just so upsetting for everyone, especially Sonja's loved ones, to have to go through this again.
Sonja's brother Jacob said to the press,
I knew from the beginning Noam wasn't the place to have the trial.
Jurors attended the same church as Matt Owens.
I knew there could be some kind of buddy-buddy system going on there.
But of course, prosecutors weren't going to give up, and Matt Owens was tried for a second time.
This time, his defense attorneys actually requested the change of venue, which I think is an interesting choice for them, but a big win for Sonja.
But the judge agreed, and the trial was moved to Kotzebue, Alaska.
And it began on October 17, 2005.
And this time, both sides presented their sides of the case again.
But something really interesting happened.
After the prosecution rested their case.
Officer Weyivana was chatting with one of his neighbors, who started asking about the case.
And that's when he casually dropped a bomb.
He asked him if a woman named Charlotte had ever said anything about finding Sonja's ID in Matt Owens' room.
Which, hearing that, you're probably really confused.
And Weyivana was too, because no one knew anything about this.
And you might be asking, who even is Charlotte?
Well, she's a family friend of Owens.
And. When him and his wife separated, she rented him a room.
She also happened to be friends with Weyivana's neighbor.
And one day, she told him that she had seen Sonja's ID card with his belongings.
Which was the same one that was later found at the shootout scene.
And even though this was a big piece of information, and I mean big,
investigators weren't sure if it could still be used in the trial, since the prosecution had already rested its case.
But even so, they decided to go ahead and pursue this information.
And I have to say,
the way they went about it was really clever.
They didn't trust that Charlotte would tell the truth because she had a friendship with Owens,
and she might want to protect him.
So, instead of just interviewing her,
they decided to have Weyivana's neighbor call her while recording the conversation.
And while the two of them were casually talking,
she didn't deny finding the ID at all.
She even told him that she had never come forward because she figured there was already enough evidence against him.
So,
make of that what you will.
And like I said,
it was clever that they decided to record this conversation because the prosecution was able to call her to the stand.
And while she was under oath,
she completely denied ever finding the ID.
But then they got to play the recording out loud right after for her.
And it proved that she was lying.
Which might have helped convince the jury that Matt Owens was responsible for killing Sonja Ivanoff.
After all the testimony,
they found him guilty of,
and he was sentenced to 101 years in prison.
And of course,
he did try to appeal,
claiming ineffective assistance of counsel,
but that was dismissed.
And luckily for everyone,
Matt Owens will spend the rest of his miserable life behind bars.
And that's exactly where he should be.
Now,
in the aftermath of Sonja's murder,
the community of Nome has dealt with a lot.
Free women brought a lawsuit,
against the city claiming that they had been harassed,
stalked and threatened by Matt Owens.
And the city knew or should have known he was a danger to women.
The Ivanoffs also brought a lawsuit against the city over its hiring of Owens.
And overall,
the city paid out $750,000 between the suits.
And after this,
understandably,
the people of Nome and the surrounding areas as well,
really lost faith in the department.
And they had plenty of good reasons for that.
I mean,
for one,
because of Sonja's murder,
it really shed a light on the lack of police resources that were being put towards sexual assault cases.
I mean,
the fact that multiple women had reported Owens and nothing was done about it was shocking to people.
And between 2008 and 2017,
the Nome Police Department received 372 calls about sexual assault,
but only 30 of those led to any arrests.
And of course,
this case,
drew a lot of attention to the horrible reality of missing and murdered indigenous women and girls,
which is a massive problem in Alaska.
Sonja's story really highlights that reality and the reality that the police don't always protect everyone they're supposed to be serving.
Matt Owens used his uniform to get what he wanted,
and he didn't care about anyone he hurt,
even though he took an oath to do the exact opposite.
But thankfully,
there were some positive changes that came from Sonja's case.
In 2007,
the Sonja Ivanov law was passed in Alaska,
which mandated that any police officer who was convicted of murder would automatically receive a sentence of 99 years.
And I would hope that most of you would agree with me that this should be implemented in all states.
In fact,
it should be implemented all over the world because police officers at the end of the day should be held accountable for betraying,
their communities.
And maybe if they were afraid to have to face harsher consequences,
maybe it would put a stop to some of the abuse of power that we see all the time.
Sonja might have gotten in his car because she felt that an officer was safe to be around when Matt Owens was the exact opposite.
And that is a sad reality.
And because he is a selfish,
sick monster,
the world lost.
It's just an amazing young girl with so much potential and so much life ahead of her.
And it is just beyond tragic.
And there is no reason for it.
I know you guys are going to have a lot to say on this case.
And I'm really looking forward to hearing what you think and hearing some of your thoughts on some of what we just talked about here at the end,
because I think it's a really important discussion that needs to happen.
But that is going to be it for me today,
you guys.
I am still on.
Leave.
But I will be back soon or someone will be back next week.
There will be an episode for you,
hopefully next week,
I think maybe.
And hopefully I'll be back for real pretty soon.
And I will see you soon.
Stay safe out there.
Bye.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Sonia Ivanoff, a 19-year-old native Alaskan woman, was murdered in Nome, Alaska, on August 10, 2003, under suspicious circumstances.
Initial investigations pointed to a man named Kunik, a friend with a history of domestic violence, due to evidence like blood, a blue truck with mismatched tires, and reported bruises—though he was later cleared when animal blood was confirmed.
A key breakthrough came from a witness, Florence, who reported seeing Sonia enter a police SUV with a driver wearing a police decal around 1:30 a.m., which was ignored by officials.
Investigative officer Brian Weyavana uncovered a critical piece of evidence
Further evidence—including shoe parts, a personal ID card, and a burn pit with Sonia’s clothing—linked Owens to the crime. He failed a polygraph test and was ultimately convicted of first-degree murder in 2005 after a second trial, despite initial legal setbacks.
The case exposed systemic failures in the Nome Police Department, including poor handling of abuse complaints and lack of police accountability, leading to policy changes like the Sonja Ivanoff Law mandating 99-year sentences for officers convicted of murder.
Summary:
Sonia Ivanoff, a 19-year-old native Alaskan woman from Nome, Alaska, was murdered in 2003 under circumstances that initially appeared to point to a known friend with a history of domestic violence. However, a pivotal witness report revealed she entered a police vehicle with a police decal, a detail ignored by authorities. This led to a deeper investigation that uncovered extensive misconduct by Officer Matt Owens, including illegal activities, sexual assaults, and a history of using his police authority for personal gain.
Evidence such as blood traces, a stolen patrol car, and personal items matching Sonia’s clothing tied him directly to the crime. Though initially acquitted due to legal challenges and a deadlocked jury, Owens was eventually convicted in a second trial after new testimony, including a recorded conversation revealing he had kept Sonia’s ID in his home. The case exposed systemic failures in the Nome Police Department, including a lack of response to abuse reports and institutional bias.
It prompted significant reforms, including the Sonja Ivanoff Law, which mandates 99-year sentences for police officers convicted of murder. Sonia’s tragic death highlighted the dangers of police abuse and the urgent need for accountability, especially in marginalized communities.
FAQs
Drivers who switch to Progressive save an average of $900 to $946 over 12 months, based on data from new customers surveyed between June 2024 and May 2025.
Customers may qualify for discounts like the online quote discount or savings for paying in full. Over 99% of Progressive auto customers earn at least one discount.
Visit Progressive.com, answer a few questions, and receive a personalized quote with coverage options tailored to your needs in minutes.
A local woman named Florence reported seeing Sonia walking past her house and entering a police vehicle with a driver who had a police department decal. This information pointed investigators directly to the Nome Police Department as a suspect.
Officer Matt Owens was charged with first-degree murder in 2003 after a series of suspicious actions, including the staged shooting of a police cruiser and the discovery of Sonia's ID card in his possession.
Evidence included the presence of Sonia’s ID card at a scene where a police cruiser was found with a gunshot, his history of inappropriate conduct, and the discovery of her shoes and personal items at a burn site.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.