Go back

Adam Grant Says You're Doing Relationships Wrong

1h 40s

Adam Grant Says You're Doing Relationships Wrong

Adam Grant, in his new book *Vibed*, challenges common myths about human connection, arguing that vulnerability, not perfection, is key to forming meaningful relationships. He proposes a nuanced framework—associates, allies, pals, and companions—to clarify how people connect across different domains of life. True bonding often arises from emotionally intense shared experiences, like haunted houses or retreats, followed by reflective conversations that deepen trust. Grant emphasizes that avoiding conflict—such as by agreeing to disagree—hurts relationships by preventing growth and emotional resilience. Instead, feedback should be offered with care, rooted in respect and shared values, not judgment. He highlights that men, in particular, struggle with emotional openness due to cultural expectations of strength, leading to loneliness. At work, effective teamwork depends more on shared mission and task alignment than on personal friendship, with rare, intense in-person interactions having a greater impact than daily low-stakes contact. Grant concludes that emotional intelligence—especially in social settings—should be taught in schools, as it fundamentally improves well-being and strengthens both personal and societal connections. His insights stress that relationships are not just tools for productivity or success, but intrinsic sources of emotional safety and joy.

Transcription

11100 Words, 59401 Characters

English
(upbeat music) Hello, everybody. Welcome to the 10% happier podcast on your host, Dan Harris. Today, we're gonna debunk some myths about how to manage your relationships at home and at work. Here's some myths. Never go to bed angry. A green to disagree is the right way to resolve conflict. It takes a long time to develop a close relationship. If you wanna have good teamwork, you should all be in the office together. And this is the one that really got me in order to have good teamwork, you need to like your colleagues. My guest today is Adam Grant, who's a professor at the Wharton School. He's written many, many, many best-selling books. His latest book, Sure to Be a Best Cellar, is called Vibed, The Secrets of Strong Connections in a Lonely World. Adam Grant, welcome back to the show. I think this is your sixth time on the show. It's always a pleasure to be here, Dan, but I'm especially looking forward to this one because I feel like we built a connection through podcast conversations, more or less. So this is a little meta to be here to talk about connections. You're absolutely right. I think we've met in person like a grand total of three or four times. You say this book, which again is called Vibed, you say it's your most personal yet. What do you mean by that? I think writing about this topic it forced me to be more vulnerable than I've been before. And frankly, one of the voices in my head while I was writing this book was yours, which is you gave me some very direct and helpful feedback that I'm pretty comfortable talking about my past struggles and mistakes, but I'm overly guarded when talking about my current challenges and sometimes that puts distance between me and other people. I don't want to be someone who puts distance between me and other people. And I took this topic on because we're in, I think, a lonely divided world. A lot of us are experiencing that. And in the age of AI, human connection is more important than ever before. And yet a lot of us are struggling at it. And I started thinking about my struggles with it. And yeah, sort of, it's smack me right in the face that I had a really hard time making and keeping friends as a kid as a very shy, nerdy introvert. Now, I'm in this incredibly fortunate position where people didn't want to talk to me when I was a kid. And now they show up to listen to me talk to other people. And sometimes that goes really well. And other times, it's a train wreck. And I care a lot about having effective interactions and meaningful relationships. And it's something I've been working on my whole life. And every time I think I figured it out, I stumble again. And so I think this, it's just a topic that's, you know, it's complicated, it's messy, but there was no way to write about it other than to say, yeah, and here's how I've fallen flat and continue to do that every day, even as somebody who professes to have some expertise on it. - I think you're making the right decision personally. I obviously lean on vulnerability myself, but I do think deployed correctly and we'll talk about its uses and misuses at some point in this conversation. But deployed correctly can be really, really powerful. I mean, as we've discussed, I, you know, we haven't spent unlimited amounts of time together. I think the first time we met was in 2018 when I came to Wharton to shoot a story with you, to interview you, and I found you charming and engaging right from the jump. Are you saying that before that, you actually or as a younger man or a child, you weren't that way and you really, you had, by the time I met you, learned some new skills? - I think so, I hope so. I think where you saw me was probably a big driver of whether you found me charming or not as a kid. I think when playing sports or trading baseball cards, I got along fine with my friends. In school, I think I was, I was a little annoying and some of that spilled over into, like into, actually baseball card trading. My friends called me Mr. Facts and that was not a compliment. (laughing) We would organize our own fantasy football and basketball leagues and, you know, keep track of the statistics by hand. And I was always jumping in and correcting people and wanting to be right even when, you know, when I wasn't. And I think that was off-putting and I got a lot of feedback that, I need to think about whether I wanted to be liked and respected, not just whether I wanted to have the answers. And I think that, yeah, that was something I had to unlearn. - As you came into the book, what would you have described as your biggest relational challenges and then what changed and where did it leave you? - I think coming into the book, I don't think this actually crystallized until I finished a draft of it, but my biggest challenge was just ruminating constantly about, did I say the wrong thing? Did I do the wrong thing? Did I, was I too eager to connect? Was I too stoic and aloof? Like what's the right balance? And I think one of the effects of writing vibe on me was I'm much more accepting now of the fact that social interaction is supposed to be complicated. It's part of the messiness and sometimes delight of being human. And I'm not afraid of awkwardness anymore. Like I used to be. I used to come out of interactions and think, oh my gosh, that was so awkward. I can't believe I said that, like why? What was I thinking? And now when that happens, I'm like, yeah, that was awkward. All right, like maybe that wasn't me, maybe that wasn't them, maybe it was us, maybe like, it was just something that happened. And when I see the same person in a different environment or when I see somebody else, there's no reason why we're gonna have the same kind of awkwardness. But even if we do, it's not the end of the world. I have lots of friends that I started off on a very awkward, uncomfortable foot with. Aquadis has never ruined my relationships and I'm not gonna let it ruin my life either. - Just to make sure I've got that, you're saying there used to be a lot of mental churn around how did that interaction go, et cetera, et cetera. Now you recognize some awkwardness is just part of the deal when you're interacting with other human beings and you don't let it send you down the toilet as much. - Yeah, I think I've learned some Dan Harris self-compassion for social interaction, how's that? - That's beautiful. I mean, because here's the thing, it really does become, in my experience, a toilet because in your head, thinking about how the last interaction went, which means that in your current interaction, you're less available and it's more likely to become into awkward and down you go. - Oh, I mean, it kills any ability to have flow in a conversation. It just jolt you right out of the absorption that's natural and necessary for having some feeling of chemistry. And it also, I think it teaches you bad lessons a lot of the time. I mean, to take the example of, did I come on too strong or, you know, was I too stoic? I think when I'm excited to meet somebody, I can be over eager and I come across like a fanboy. And I make that mistake once and then the next person I meet, I show no energy whatsoever in the interaction and they think I didn't like them and so I've over corrected. And I wasn't, I didn't know who they were and so not being a fanboy was not even a relevant concern in the next interaction. And I think that, I think we do this very often, the most recent interaction stumble we have is the correction we make as opposed to zooming out and saying, okay, if I have damaged relationships or failed to get off on the right foot in situations where it really matters like a first date or a job interview, what are the consistent mistakes that I've made? And let me triangulate that feedback before I act too quickly on it. - If you care about supporting independent media and if you care about being a node of sanity and an insane world, there are a few quick, easy and free ways that you can support me and my team which I would be really grateful for. One way to do it is sign up for my newsletter which comes out on Monday mornings. It's a little dose of sanity in your inbox at the beginning of a busy week. The second way to do it is to follow and subscribe to the show wherever you're listening or watching right now. That really helps. Three, share your favorite episode with a friend. This is a great and low stakes way to connect with somebody in your orbit and not for nothing. It also helps us grow. And all of these things take about 30 seconds and they really do help. You will be supporting me and my team and our mission and I, as I said, would be immensely grateful. You can find everything we do at DanHarris.com. It's all right there. Thank you. I mean, that seriously will be right back with more show. You don't consider yourself to be a self-help writer. And yet, at the end of the book, you do include what you call actions for impact. So nuggets of things you've learned that we can incorporate into our life. What advice would you give to people who experience what you experience, which is expose facto after a conversation, kicking your own ass for how you handled said conversation? What's the move? Well, I think there are a lot of different moves. I think one that I've found surprisingly helpful is actually to name the mistake with the person. I've actually found myself going to the person and saying, hey, I'm sorry, that was awkward. And usually one or two responses comes back. The first one is, I didn't notice what you're talking about. And I realized I've just massively overthought the whole thing and it's a past haunting of my friends dropped me in middle school and there's a voice in my head that still thinks that I'm that kid. Or we laugh about it. And they say, yeah, that was awkward. And it actually becomes a bonding moment. I wrote about this in the book, so you'll probably be familiar with it. But the the moment they kind of shifted my thinking about this was when I sat down with an acquaintance of mine, I didn't I didn't think we had a meaningful connection. And his wife showed up and she said, you two are so awkward. What do you mean? And she said, well, do you do you think your friends, the only thing I could think to say in response Dan was, well, now that you're asking, I'm assuming yes, because it would be even more awkward if the answer was no. Like, we must be friends. And she said, yeah, obviously your friends, I've watched you become friends and neither of you has acknowledged it. And you don't have to say it. It's not like, you know, you're dating and you're naming an exclusive relationship. But both of you want to be friends with each other. And neither of you is actually acting like it because you think the other person is not your friend. And there's nothing wrong with that. But I just want you to know it. And I came out of that thinking, oh, this is such a fun conversation to have of, wait, are you my friend? Wait, you thought we were friends? And what do I have to lose by just kind of putting the awkwardness on the table? So that is, I don't know that that is everybody's cup of tea. But I think that, you know, actually talking about the interaction or the relationship is much less terrifying than I thought and often leads me to a better place and us to a better place. What do you make of that? I'm just curious. I mean, I'm thinking about your, I mean, I love everything you said. I'm thinking specifically about this interaction you described with the dude within the wife who said, are you, are you guys friends? Do you think this particular thing friendship is more awkward among men? I don't think that women struggle with this on a adult women struggle with knowing whether their friends are not the way that you have an idea. What is that? I think it's probably male discomfort with vulnerability. It's reluctance to show weakness, having been raised in a culture where men are stereotyped as strong and tough and confident. And, you know, we're not supposed to talk about our feelings at all. We're not supposed to talk about certainly feelings that might put us at risk. It's a gamble to show that kind of vulnerability and say, hey, Dan, I'd like to be your friend or what is this relationship to you? And what's legitimate is to say, hey, do you want to go get a drink, which may or may not involve any meaningful interaction? Let's go watch the game or maybe we play a sport together. And beyond that, the lanes available for men to open up, they're just not as many. They're not as familiar. They're not as socially accepted. And so a lot of men just don't go there. I think that does obviously a disservice to half the population. I mean, there's a lot been written about the male friendship recession. And there was a great SNL skit about wives and girlfriends taking their husbands and boyfriends to a dog run in New York City where they can beat other guys and it's all really weird. Yes, a man part. I love that. I think that this is not to say that women don't run into challenges with connection to, but if our loneliness crisis is disproportionately affecting young men, which it seems to be, the inability to figure out how to vibe with other guys is a piece of that puzzle. And I think that we are facing these emotional constraints, but we're also missing the social scripts. What are you supposed to say if you want to become better friends with a guy? How do you cross the bridge from, hey, let's watch the game to I can have a real conversation with you. Not always easy. How do you answer that question? Like for anybody listening, you feel like you don't have good friends. You haven't found your people. What's the answer? Well, for me, for me, this is where it's really helpful to distinguish between allies, pals, and companions. I just love the fact that here's this self-described nerdy guy who writes a whole book about getting better at vibing with other people. And of course, he turns it into a four-part framework. What was the alternative? Did you want five? That, see, even that question proves my point. No, I mean, the alternative is to do what I do, just be much messier about it. But I love that you've turned it into a framework. And I think you're turning what you're doing here and it's quite beautiful is turning your quirks and foibles into something deeply helpful for other people. So having said all of that, please share us with us the framework. I'm just trying to be a good social scientist, Dan. But it's funny because you're right. I mean, I love to classify and categorize things. And people are so much more complicated than frameworks. But I have found this framework enormously helpful and clarifying in my own life. And, yeah, as I started talking about it with other people, they experienced something similar. So I thought, all right, I need to, I need to really put some teeth in it. I need to put the evidence behind it. I need to unpack how it works. So for me, friend, just as bit, it's always been too course of a category. A friend could be a casual buddy. It could be your bestie. It could be anything in between. And, you know, I think when we look at the domains of our lives, we often think about people in buckets of what part of our life do they fit in? So, you know, you've got your friends. And then you have your family at home and you've got your colleagues at work. And that framework just, it tells me nothing about why you connect with those people. It tells me nothing about why does some co-workers feel like friends? Why does some friends feel like family? Why does some family members feel like you'd rather not be related to them at all? And I thought I needed to, to really explain how to vibe, which I think is the heart of your question. I needed to try to unpack in a more nuanced way. What are the different kinds of meaningful connections that exist? So associates, I think, are the most basic connections. Those are basically people who just have compatible needs. So my painter is my associate. I, you know, I had a wall that needed to be painted. He had a business to run. We were able to align on that. My neighbor who, who has kids who do the same activity as our kids is my associate. Like we have a carpool rotation. And those, those connections are fine. They are not particularly infused with emotion because they're very much transactional. They, they serve a purpose, right? And when I think about meaningful connections, I think about three different wavelengths that we can bond on. This is where somebody can be an ally, a pal, or a companion. I think about allies as people who share your goals. You're on a mission together. Pals are people who share your interests and hobbies. You have fun together. And companions are people who share your values. You care deeply about each other. And of course, people can be in multiple buckets. But we run into a lot of trouble interacting with people and forming bonds because we're not on the same page about what this interaction is. So Dan, if, like, if we go back to the question of, okay, I'm a guy struggling to make friends. What I would say to try to enlist you as a companion and, you know, sort of confide in you, seek emotional support and compassion from you is really different from what I would do if I were trying to turn you into a pal. And I wanted to, like, to have fun together. And I found it enormously helpful to say, let's start there. Are you looking for allies that you can collaborate with? Are you looking for pals that you can chill with? Or are you looking for companions that you can confide in? And I don't know. Where do you want to start? So it seems to me the place to start is, what are your goals? You know, so what am I looking for? Do I want just people to chill with? So I want to up my pal quotient. Do I need somebody to talk to? And I think this is specifically a problem for men because we make our, if we're a straight man, we make our romantic partner, wife or otherwise, the only person that we're confiding in and that's putting too much weight on one relationship. It just can't be load bearing in that, in that way. And then, so if we want a companion, if we want to pal, if we want somebody, you know, to share our goals and be our ally, it seems to me like having the self-awareness is the first step. I think that's right. And I think we all need a mix of allies, pals, and companions in our lives. And because they serve different functions, but the paradox here is, if somebody is all of those things to you, you are likely to be closer. But to your point, you're also putting more pressure on that relationship because that person is your go to for everything. And there's research has come out in the last few years showing that if you go to different people in your life for different things, you actually have higher well-being because you have a more versatile network of support that's good for relationships. It might even make you 10% happier. And although I don't know if we can quantify it that precisely here. But I know you would like to. I really want to. You can, you can feel my frustration right now. But you know, Dad, it's, it's funny. I've never really thought about this before, but you said, do I want to up my pal quotient? And I think there are two different ways to think about that. One is to say, what am I missing in my life? You know, if you're a man who has some pals and some allies, I think the default is men are short on companions outside of, you know, straight men with their wives. I think the second layer of question that you just surfaced is also, do I need to diversify where I get that? I may have enough companionship, but not enough companions. How would one take a pal and move them into the companion zone. Ooh, this is fine. Okay, so. As far as I know, there are probably three good options that have evidence behind them. And that also I've lived, and it's been fun to kind of experiment with these and say, you know what, worst-case scenario? This is gonna be material. There's gonna be a good story that comes out of this, even if it's unpleasantly awkward. So first option is you put yourself out there and show a little bit of vulnerability. And you reveal something and most people reciprocate a little vulnerability with something in kind, and then that opens up a new channel of conversation. So you know the research on deep talk, you can skip the small talk, and you can start just by saying, "Hey, something really embarrassing happened to me." And you pick something that's not humiliating or mortifying, but it's not something you would necessarily share on a public stage. And then you have signaled to that person that you trust them. And they tend to respond in a way that opens that up. That's the first option. - I'm just thinking of, I organize a lot of dinners for men, well, two recurring dinners for men, actually more than that, but one of them of some dads in the suburban area where I live and another for guys in New York City who are interested in Buddhism. And the former, the dad dinner in the suburbs, I didn't do it with much of an agenda other than just, you know, I met a bunch of guys I liked and thought it would be nice to get together with some regularity. It seemed like a good community service on my part. And very quickly, I noticed to me and to each other, the guys were just starting to say things that I don't think they would normally say it. I remember on the first dinner, a guy I didn't know that well mentioned to me. We were just chatting and he mentioned that his daughter was going away to school and that chewed most likely doing that because there was so much fighting around the house. - Wow. - And immediately I was like, oh, I feel really connected to this person and I want to know more. And yeah, they just struck me as a very skillful use of a certain amount of vulnerability without oversharing that immediately got me invested in his life. - Yeah, I think that's a great example of bounded vulnerability, which I think is the antidote to the oversharing problem. We've all had people trauma dump and your reaction is TMI, there's too much information. And I think that just it's a little bit of, hey, I'm telling you, this is rough, but I'm not forcing you now to carry my pain. I'm inviting you to a conversation about it. And Dan, the thing that's striking to me about this is I'm willing to bat knowing you. You're not even accounting for the opening bid here, which is you have spoken so publicly and so openly about some of your own challenges, including panic attacks on TV, including being unkind to your employees. Then anybody who comes and talks to you has already been invited into the kind of, the cone of vulnerability, so to speak. - I think you're gonna start seeing more of that in the wake of this book because people always want, I think people have wanted to talk to you for a long time because you're writing these fascinating and really helpful books. But I think it's going to intensify now that people feel they know you a little better. - Gulp, for better or worse, more para-social relationships here we come. So I think that little gesture of putting yourself out there, that's the first option. I think the second option is to ask as opposed to share. And I think psychologists have studied lots of questions that can help accelerate moving from small talk to deep talk or password companions. And some of them are actually pretty safe. What's your biggest regret? Or my favorite one is, instead of asking someone, what do you do? What do you love to do as an opener? And then you can, as soon as you feel comfortable, you can get closer to one of the questions that shows up in the fast friend's research is tell me about your relationship with your mother. Everyone has something to say about that. And it's vulnerable, but it's not too vulnerable, in most cases, hopefully not in every case. But you either put yourself out there a little bit or you put a prompt on the table that makes the other person feel comfortable sharing. I like those too. Not everybody's a talker. Some people are much more comfortable being vulnerable, side to side, shoulder to shoulder, is opposed to face to face. And there I think my favorite step is to add some emotional intensity into what you do together. So I think the easiest example of this is the research on going to a haunted house. Take an acquaintance or a pal to a haunted house together. Even if they're a stranger, if you go to a haunted house together, you will come out with a tighter bond. But only if you debrief afterward. Because that's when you open up about the emotions. And that's when it becomes a shared experience that the two of you uniquely went through and then can make sense of as, yeah, this is something we did because we are, I don't know, we might be pals and we think it's hilarious to jump scare each other. But I felt real panic for a second in that moment. Now we're companions all of a sudden. Yeah, I think leading with that intent shared activity accelerates connection. That's really interesting. So you could do an intense activity like some two guys could go golf the world's hardest golf course or two women could compete together in a doubles tournament or whatever it is. And it's really intense. But if they're not talking afterwards, it almost doesn't matter at the level of their relationship. Yeah, unless it's a really unusual shared experience that they can reference without even having to talk about it, I think it's probably unlikely to have the same effect. I think a lot of the sweating together building relationships is real. I think if you are physically sweating, if you're doing some kind of exercise or athletic challenge, sweating together is social grease. But it doesn't have to be physically intense. It could be emotionally intense in a whole number of ways. I have met people who have come out of silent meditation retreats together and become best friends, literally sitting together not talking. Because afterward then they know what it's like to have suppressed the impulse to speak and they found that to be really taxing. Dan, you've done this. Have you made friends that way? Then I answer that question. Inevitably just thinking about our many year, almost 10 year back and forth on your aversion to meditation and I'm thinking of various ways to bait you and go to you. But I. We agree too much now, though. We agree too much. I mean, I think I have found almost everything you've ever said on meditation to be reasonable and compelling. And I think you've neutralized most of my objections personally. So I don't have a lot of ammo for this one at this point. No, your problem, and I agree with your beef with the meditation world and its proponents, is that many of them are over-promising and also getting too sweaty in their evangelism and pressure campaigns. And I'm just four square in your camp on that. To answer your question though about silent retreats, I every year do a pretty long silent retreat with two friends, neither of whom even lives near me anymore. And so I don't get to see them much outside of our retreats and when we're together, we're often not talking but the depths of those bonds, it's really hard to overstate. We do talk at the beginning and at the end and then we of course talk throughout the year. But as we've gotten better and better at doing these retreats every year, these are that kind of intimacy is really hard to replicate. I've spent hours and hours and hours sitting in silence with these men and then talking about it afterwards. - It's so interesting, I think, I mean almost, it almost sounds like you're orchestrating individually profound experiences and the connection comes then in the ways that those moments open you up to each other. - Yes, yes. You know this because you did me a huge kindness and took a look at a rough draft of a book that I've been working on for a long time and still haven't been able to put out. But so what I'm about to say is something you already know but I devalued my relationships for way too long and have spent the last seven or eight years just really focusing on making them stronger because it is just increased my quality of life immeasurably and I think in one key area, especially around anxiety, I'm such an anxious person and it's in my nervous system in such a deep way, the low grade anxiety but that also can escalate to panic and having strong ties at home out in the world of variety of strong ties at various levels just makes me feel much safer. - Well, I'll give you the personal reaction. First, which is, it's fascinating to hear you the way that you narrated that, which I think is one of the problems with bonding that we have in our culture, particularly among men, which is you said I've deprioritized and devalued relationships and I'm now investing because of how I feel. Dan, it doesn't have to be all about you. I mean, obviously, we live in an individualistic Western culture where if you can't justify something in terms of my happiness or my success, why the hell are you doing it? But I have come around to the view that even we overachievers who struggle with feeling like we're not accomplishing something every moment. of every day can accept the fact that relationships are valuable ends in and of themselves. I don't need to get anything out of interacting to say this person, I respect their values. And I think time with them is worthwhile, even if it stresses me out more because I see that they're accomplishing things that I'm falling short on, or, you know, they make me feel insecure. Like, you know what? This is just a quality person to be around. And I think that's something that should be valued in life. And so I guess my, my mild challenge to you here is to relationships have to relieve your anxiety or boost your well-being in order to be worth committing to. Definitely not. I just think there's the, there are these profound benefits on offer. But what's the, there's some expression atelic or something like that. There are many activities in life that are worth doing for the doing alone. And that is just also true of positive bonds or vibing. Hell said. Yeah. And I think for, for me, as somebody who actually has deprioritized pals over the years, that's been part of the fun of this is saying, you know what? I don't need to think about what's the relative happiness dividend of hanging out with a pal versus reading a book that I'm going to enjoy. I just think spending time with other people is something that we should do as social creatures. So less I have thought about how much am I going to enjoy this, ironically, the more I enjoy it. So I think there's, there's something there. But okay, the social science part of this is, this is, this is very gendered. Shelley Taylor's work on bio-behavioral responses to stress. Years ago, she first captured and there's been a lot of science following it. Men tend to default to fight or flight under stress, whereas women are more likely to respond with tendent and befrient. And I wonder if part of the antidote to our male loneliness crisis is saying, you know what? If you had 10% less fight or flight and 10% more tendent befrient when you are stressed, overwhelmed, depressed, anxious, not only would that have the kind of mood benefits that you're describing, but collectively, we would have a better functioning society. We would have less polarization, we'd have less division, we'd have a stronger sense of community. And so I actually wonder if the idea of tendent and befrient is something that we ought to be teaching. And you know, even just for me to say, okay, I'm stressed right now, I'm like, I'm either powering through it or I'm avoiding it. No, I need to reach out to somebody. I mean, do you think it's crazy that the quality of your relationships given the way we evolved is among, if not the top variable for the quality of your life, physiologically and psychologically and yet very few of us are ever given relationships in 101 in school, but we get trig. It is sort of unbelievable. And I think trig is at the top of my list of classes I would cancel and replace with social and emotional intelligence. I don't know why it hasn't happened yet, but it should yet. There's a whole course that was tested at Yale called Ruler. I don't know if you've seen it. It's demonstrated evidence that it not only builds social and emotional skills, but it's good for academic performance and it's good for well-being. How is this not part of our curriculum in every school? I don't know. It's crazy. And also I hate trig. Yes. I'm with you. Love Algebra. Love Calculus. No one needs trigonometry. Okay. Well, you lost me on liking Algebra and Calculus, but we can agree to disagree. Speaking of agreeing to disagree, you say that agreeing to disagree is not the right way to resolve conflict, just to step back for a second. You learn so much in the course of writing this book and we're not going to get to all of it. People should read the book again. It's called vibe. But I want to talk about some of the myths you identified and one of them is this notion that agreeing to disagree is the right way to resolve conflict. Why is that not true? Well, I think that there are relationships where at some point you just have to agree to disagree. Otherwise, you are not going to remain friends or family or even colleagues because the issue is so emotionally charged and moralized for both of you that you cannot accept and respect the other person holding their view. And so you just need to put it aside. I just want to acknowledge that there's a time and a place where that's necessary. I don't think most most disagreements meet that criterion. I think in many disagreements, people are afraid of conflict. They're concerned that if we argue, it's going to damage our connection. And therefore, they walk on eggshells or avoid it. And so they say, let's just agree to disagree. And what that guarantees is that you are at best compromising and not learning from each other and maybe finding some alignment that you have overlooked. But more importantly, it also guarantees that you are not building the muscle to have difficult conversations with each other. You are building a relationship that can't handle friction. And a relationship that can't handle friction is not a relationship, it's a charade. So I think that a lot of times what people do is they say, well, we're going to pick our battles. This is not worth fighting about. And what that means is you only fight about the big things that are really hard to do without getting heated, without maybe having a little animosity. And you never practice. You never hone the skills on the small stuff. And so for years, tried to fight this dynamic. And one of my favorite examples was my kids were in the car one day with me and they started calling each other names and the argument just got out of hand. And it was one of those moments where every impulse I had was to say, kid, stop fighting. You know, I got tired of doing that. And I ran out of synonyms, like, okay, stop bickering, stop picking at each other. And finally, I just said, you know what? You can say whatever you want to each other as long as you're both smiling. As long as the two of you are grinning, I don't care what insults you hurl. We can go full on Sandlot movie. You bought for apples in the toilet and you like it. As long as you're both laughing, I'm good. And you know what was so interesting about it is after that happened, they started having better fights because they realize they could they could be it out. They could be at odds about something, but they could still kind of communicate like pals as part of it and joke their way through it. And I don't think we do enough of that kind of rehearsal. I don't think we do enough of that that practice to say, let's argue about little things. Let's have silly debates so that we learn how to stay pals, companions, allies when we have to fight about really hard things. One of the key arguments in the book, and this is not new, but it's very, very important and it bears repeating is and you've said a little bit of this is that we need to learn how to have healthy conflict and to avoid what is sometimes been called high or toxic conflict. One of the key moves here, and this is a lot to say about this, but one of the key moves here is, you know, bringing something up with someone when they've done something you don't like. In other words, giving feedback. You have some stuff in the book about how to do this skillfully and this is something a lot of us struggle with. So can you just say a little bit about how we can give feedback without, you know, making everything worse? I think where most feedback goes off the rails is not actually the message. It's what the message means about your relationship with the messenger. So it's not that people can't hear hard truths. It's that they can't hear hard truths that make them feel like they're stupid or worthless or bad human beings in the eyes of the person who's giving the feedback. And so most of the time that we spend crafting the right message and sugar coding and serving up a feedback sandwich with a slice of, you know, with the meat of the criticism buried between two slices of praise, most of that gymnastics is unnecessary. What is necessary is establishing your intentions and saying, I care about you. This relationship is important to me. And I want to share something that I'm doing for your benefit or our benefit. And there are lots of different ways to do this. But one of my favorites is just to sit down with somebody and say, Hey, I noticed something. And if I were in your shoes, I would want to hear it. Are you, you know, are you up for that? Or I thought of something that would make you even more effective. Can we talk about that? Or, you know, for a long time, I've been the friend who never told other people that they had food in their teeth. And I realized I'm doing to do service to the people I care about. What is the harm in saying, Dan, you got a piece of broccoli there? I want someone to point that out to me. And so I'm trying to be more of that friend to other people, you know, can we have that kind of relationship? The tone of that conversation is completely different from, let me tell you, Dan, something you're doing that I think is very problematic, which is I have judged you. I have attacked you. I have put you in a position to, to be on the defense. And best case scenario, a little bit of my message is going to get through as opposed to I care about this relationship. For me, having healthy relationships is being able to be a report coming and us trusting that is coming from a place of, you know, of care, of kindness, of benevolence, of concern. And if we don't have that, we should not be having this conversation to begin with. I was kind of raised by wolves on this issue. I worked in television. news for many, many, 30 years. And at one point, I remember getting called into the office of a major anchorman. And he was preparing to send me overseas to spend time in Israel and the West Bank and then Iraq. And at this point in my career, I had spent a lot of time as a combat correspondent. And at the conclusion of the meeting, I was getting up and he said to me, "I hope you do a good job because there's a perception that you're not very good at this. Now go off and get shot at." Wow. That's brutal. Yes. Yes. And those kind of role models who are giving feedback in ways that we're just like devastating and not constructive at all. And by the way, there is a perception. You're the dude with that perception. Just own it. Yes. So fucked up on so many levels. So wrong. But those kinds of bad role models can make for somebody who goes off and is a bad role model for other people. And so I had to unlearn a lot of bad habits. And I love the little scripts that you came up with. And for me, really, it's been about saying to somebody, "There's something I want to tell you. If you're open to it." And the reason I want to tell you is because this is such an important relationship to me. Exactly. And that is the message that should come across anytime you give someone feedback or you raise a tough conversation is, "I'm giving this to you because I care." Otherwise, it wouldn't bother. Yes. I'm just stuck on that moment. I mean, it calls to mind the saying that people who take pride in being brutally honest are usually just interested in being brutal, which Bob Berg first introduced me to you. And I think that is spot on. I think this should never be something that people look forward to doing. No one should relish or rejoice in the joy of taking somebody else down. It should be a little uncomfortable because you don't want to hurt the feelings of the person you care about. At the same time, I have found it really important to say, "Look, part of caring about you, if we're going to have a strong bond, part of caring about you, Dan, is being willing to say things that make you feel bad today if they help you do better tomorrow." Yes. Yes. And I want to make sure we're on the same page about that. I want that from you. And let's talk about how we can make that a norm in our relationship. I had students years ago who took my negotiation class. And part of the class was you had to go off and play a role and negotiate with somebody else in the class. And then everyone would come back together in debrief because they all had similar starting points, but very, very different ending points. And very quickly, you realize, "Wow, I'm having most of my interactions in a vacuum. And I never learned what I did that was off-putting. I never find out what actually landed well." And so a bunch of the students just got together and they said, "We're going to start a norm that after any important interaction, we're just going to say can we feed back?" And that's going to be an immediate invitation to take off the kid gloves and tell me the thing I do not want to hear, but I really need to hear. And what I thought was so great about that was you have to ask for it. So the other person is not going to dump it on you, unwanted. And when you ask for it, you are saying, "I am here ready to receive this." And I would just love to see that norm in more schools, more workplaces, and more homes. My executive coach, Jerry Colona, often coaches people to say, "What is not being said that I need to hear?" And I've really tried to get in the habit of saying it. Okay, right. I want to ask you about a few more of these myths before I lose you. Never go to bed angry, bad advice. Terrible advice. If you never go to bed angry, then you are having most of your fights when you're really tired and you also lack the self-control to make sure you don't say something you regret. Go to bed angry, have the argument when you are capable of having a rational conversation. That makes complete sense. It's okay to go to bed angry, get up, deal with it once you've slept, hopefully you've slept, and nothing's been. I think the logic behind the expression is you could die in the middle of the night, but I feel like that's. I think what you're saying is it's worth taking that risk to have a better fight in the morning. I think that's true. And I would add that what's most likely to kill you is having a lot of late-night arguments. Well said. Okay. Another myth that I mentioned at the beginning is that it takes a long time to develop close relationships. Well, it's not true because of what we were talking about earlier with emotional intensity accelerating bonds. You can see this, for example, in studies of soldiers who go to war. You've probably seen this up close much more than I have. There's an elder and clip study where you look at soldiers and the question is, what happened to them when they were deployed? And oftentimes, you'll have a group that didn't know each other before they deployed. They show up in a foreign country. They have to very quickly get on the same page about what their mission is. And they may not be, they may not be together for long. Forty years later, the troops that have maintained the closest bonds are the ones who lost somebody in combat. They all grieve together. They experience that pain together. They showed companionship toward each other. And it might have only been a day or two together or a week together. But that intense moment is something that none of them will ever forget. It's made them lifelong friends. And they've said, you know what? We couldn't save this person, but we will always have each other's backs. And I think that that is what we see over and over again in the data that some people are able to make friends. I mean, you don't have to suffer trauma. It's not about adversity. You don't have to start azing people. We don't need fraternity and sorority. It was a worse thing that could happen to people. And then they'll really be close afterward because they shared suffering. No, it's, what's the intense experience we can have that nobody else can relate to that will lead us to say, wow, that person understands me. That person has seen the real me. And I think that those are, I don't know, there are more of those experiences than we realize, singing karaoke with somebody else really easy way to get that little bit of vulnerability, that little bit of intensity. And coming out of that and saying, yeah, yeah, yeah, we're like this. How do you do that in a corporate context? Because, you know, people have done trust falls and that's become a trope in the business setting as a way to have a little bit of intensity that people can then bond over. How do you do? How do you engineer these kind of interactions to get an employee base comfortable or a team comfortable with one another without making a forced and awful? I think from what I've read of the research on this, the best options have to do with the work itself. So people need shared projects. And within those shared projects can be shared challenges. So I think one of the most interesting examples I've seen is NASA is trying to build bonds between astronauts and cosmonauts. And this is not an easy task because at the time, the American astronauts were, they were ex-military and they had been trained to shoot at the Russian now cosmonauts who were their enemy and now we're supposed to be their ally. And so they said, well, what are we going to do to bring these people who are adversaries together as, you know, as real, real collaborators who are willing to trust each other with their lives? And they said they don't have to like each other. They do have to be able to rely on each other. And I think the mistake that most organizations make is they say, okay, yeah, we're going to do the trust fall. We're going to do the icebreakers. We're going to get people together for a happy hour. And the problem is that people don't really come out of their shells in those settings. You know, you don't get to see kind of beneath the surface veneer. So what NASA did was they said, you know what, we're going to take this crew into the wilderness and they're going to do their initial training in the mountains with an outdoor leadership guide. And they are going to encounter some challenges that simulate what will actually happen when they're in space. So, you know, the guy just ditches them one day and they're lost. And that's a simulation of what happens if you lose connection to mission control. And you say Houston, we have a problem and you get static back. They got to practice that, right? And they got very stressed. It was cold at night. And they had to really figure out, okay, how do I bring out the best as opposed to the worst in, you know, in my fellow travelers here? And then they had this great conversation where they said, let's talk about our origin story. And every, every person in the group in this particular crew anyway was asked, what was the defining moment when you knew you wanted to go to outer space? And they open up and that's the moment of vulnerability, but it is mission critical, right? You're not, you're not just talking about some random defining moment of your childhood. You are talking about an uncommon commonality, a similarity that you share that's very rare. And this is something that I think that any workplace could do is, you know, it requires you to have a meaningful mission, right? But to bring people together and say, what was the defining moment when you decided you wanted to work on this problem? Or what was the experience that led you to say, yes, this is the culture I wanted to join or this is the career I thought was worth spending most of my waking hours at. When people open up about that, people are able to say, OK, I understand where you came from to some extent. And I feel that we have a deep common interest that makes it really hard for me to imagine. trusting you. So just to say we obviously most workplaces are not going to have people go out into the wilderness together but simply asking people like how did you get interested in this thing that we're all doing together can reveal a lot. Yeah I think that oftentimes organizations start with future goals but it's easier to bring people together focusing on the past rather than the future because people haven't lived the future yet. It's a you know it's often a distant dream and it's often kind of hazy whereas the past is concrete it's vivid you can bring it to life you have an emotional connection to the story you're sharing and I think depending on the team or the kind of work you're doing it it might take a little bit of ingenuity to figure out what is the what is the most effective prompt for that but you know even thinking about I've done this with leaders and managers what was the moment that led you to say I want to be responsible for mentoring the next generation like did you have a mentor who changed your life or did you have a horrible mentor and you said I'm gonna break that cycle and I'm not gonna let that happen to anyone else and yeah that that's not about the organization it's not about the kind of work that's being done maybe people care about that or they don't but you get a group of people who are responsible for the development of young people together and wow everybody's got a story to tell about why they want to be a mentor or why they don't want to suck at that task and I think there's a there's an origin story for something that will bring people together let me ask you about a few more work-related myths before I let you go I mentioned these in the intro one of them is that if you want good teamwork you all need to be in the office together I'm asking this question on a day when I just spent the entire day with one of my colleagues a writing partner and we have found that working together in person has been just a game changer for us so I'm I guess constitutionally and viscerally I'm ready to disagree with you but you you probably have the facts and the data on your side so where am I wrong well first of all Dan that's such a such a refreshing way to frame the question because most of what I run into when I talk about this with CEOs is that's not what my experience has shown and therefore you're wrong well what would you rather learn from the most rigorous possible randomized controlled experiments and longitudinal studies across many organizations industries countries and people or your and equals one experience and I try not to say it like that anymore but I prefer your intellectual humility coming into this so I don't think you're wrong I think this the narrative that you gave is just incomplete which is in-person work pays huge dividends it's easier to bond with people it's easier to read people it's easier to develop a pattern that Anita Woolie has called burstiness where we just feel like literally our interactions are bursting with energy and ideas that's just harder when their technology in the way we don't need to be co-located all the time that's what the data show very clearly if you and I are in the office together four days a week instead of five days a week we are more productive and more creative because we're less likely to distract and interrupt each other right we get that day of deep work to focus and also our thoughts don't overconverge that one day where we're separate is more likely to prevent group think it allows us to you know to develop fresh perspectives and novel points of view and so I would just say look you work with people who you may know what they look like you may be very familiar with their thinking patterns and there is such a thing this is Goldilocks there's such a thing as too much time together just as there's such a thing as too little time together that all tracks and I think you're also saying that it is possible to do good work and collaborate even at a distance as long as there's some in person connection happening on some with some regularity yeah I've done some work with Atlassian and they're they're down this are really clear what they show is that the frequency of office attendance at their software company has no bearing on sensible longing and connection in teams what does matter is having a quarterly off site where you come together to two two things one is to bond and the other is to solve hard problems together and if people connect just for a few days at a quarterly off site the bump they get in belonging to the connection can last until the next quarter in their data and this is an intensity point intensity beats frequency when it comes to connection I will take a few days of intense interaction every couple months over like every day surface interaction last myth and you you touched on this when you talked about the astronauts and the cosmonauts but I was really surprised to read that you can really have good fruitful teamwork with people that you don't necessarily like yeah you may not want to but you can I think this really goes to the heart of the distinction between being allies and then pals and companions which is I think we assume that effective collaborations and great teams are built on a sense of kumbaya and empirically that's just false it is you know it can be helpful to be pals with your colleagues it can be helpful to be companions with them but it is not essential and in the research the distinction that's made which I really like is between task cohesion and social cohesion so social cohesion is about you and I are connected to each other this is an important relationship we you know we are at a personal level like we joke around together like pals we confide in each other like companions social cohesion is far less important as a predictor of team effectiveness and performance than task cohesion which is you and I are aligned around a common mission we are allies and then I think maybe the easiest way to capture that is to say people don't always need to bond within a group if they're bonded to the group if you know if they agree this task we're doing really matters this problem we're trying to solve we are all in on trying to do the best job we can at it their personal feelings about each other you know can be put aside and in fact there's research on SWAT teams that really bears this out which shows that in SWAT teams personal feelings are almost irrelevant it doesn't really matter whether people like each other because you know when you get the call and you could think about firefighters or police officers or any kind of emergency responders as similar you know exactly what the role is that everybody else is responsible for you know somebody's life is hanging in the balance and you're not spending a lot of time thinking about you know I don't really like the way that Dan talks to me okay how do we get this task done and that I think that is what great allies do Adam I'm just always a pleasure to talk to you and I look forward to pushing our relationship from PAL to companion as as the years pass that's so interesting I would have said I would have said we are allies first and foremost because we share a mission of I mean every time we interact it's around a mission of helping people get a little smarter and a little bit better off and I would have said yeah maybe we're companions a bit because I think I've been more vulnerable with you than I am with almost anybody that I interacted with as infrequently as you and I do and certainly men and I would not have thought of us as PALs because we don't hang out yes yes you're exactly right I got it wrong no I don't know I do enjoy our conversations yes but well I would think of PALs as like just hanging out to you know shoot the shit and you live in a completely different city and if you live near me I would force you to hang out and shoot the shit or go have dinner or whatever but is sadly not an option no you wouldn't you would force me to sit next to you in silence for multiple days and admit that meditation could even benefit me not just other people I would never do that I never voice meditation on anybody I do want to remind people that your book is called vibe the secrets of strong connections in a lonely world you should get it it's really good Adam you have a website where people can take some sort of test oh yeah I had a lot of fun creating a little vibe quiz which allows you to gauge is your instinct to seek out allies pals or companions and what might be missing from your web of relationships and what's the web what's the address is really clever it's Adam Grant net a link for that will be in the show notes a link to buy the book will be in the show notes are linked to the links to the many many pre prior podcast conversations about Adams many many prior books those will all be in the show notes to please go deep on Adam I have found his work to be incredibly helpful Adam Grant thank you for your time thank you Dan as always I've learned a lot from the questions you ask and the way you react to my ideas and I really appreciate all the ways that you make my work better and me better and if anyone is not happy with the amount of vulnerability I've showed along this vibe journey I am claiming you now I'm crediting you it's been great also a quick ask before I let you go if you've got a minute head on over to Dan Harris dot com and sign up for my newsletter it drops in your inbox on Monday mornings often a busy and stressful time for us. I try to write a short essay that has a little bit of wisdom actionable practical wisdom that you can immediately weave into your life on Monday mornings. A lot of people find them helpful and I hope you will too. You can sign up at Dan Harris dot com. It's totally free. Now to the credits. Thank you so much to everybody who worked so hard to make this show. 10% happier is produced by Tara Anderson, Marissa Schneiderman, DJ Cashmere, David Hart, and Hayden Brum. Post production is handled by the great folks over at Green Horn Creative and Nick Thorburn of the great Indy Rock Band Islands wrote our theme. Thank you for listening, deuces.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Adam Grant argues that vulnerability, not perfection, is essential for meaningful human connections and that awkwardness is a natural, often beneficial part of relationships.
  2. He introduces a framework of three connection types—associates, allies, pals, and companions—to help people understand and build deeper, more intentional relationships.
  3. Emotional intensity in shared experiences, like haunted houses or silent retreats, can accelerate bonding when followed by meaningful reflection and emotional debriefing.
  4. Agreeing to disagree avoids growth and weakens relationships by preventing learning, conflict practice, and emotional resilience in difficult conversations.
  5. Healthy conflict requires care, intention, and feedback rooted in mutual respect—not criticism—where the primary goal is strengthening the relationship, not winning an argument.
  6. Relationships are not just a byproduct of success but a vital source of emotional well-being, especially for men who are socially isolated due to cultural expectations of emotional stoicism.
  7. In workplaces, strong teamwork stems from shared mission and task cohesion, not personal bonding, and regular, intense in-person interactions are more impactful than frequent, low-intensity ones.
  8. Teaching social and emotional intelligence in schools is urgent, as emotional intelligence—especially in men—can break cycles of loneliness and improve both personal and societal well-being.

Summary:

Adam Grant, in his new book *Vibed*, challenges common myths about human connection, arguing that vulnerability, not perfection, is key to forming meaningful relationships. He proposes a nuanced framework—associates, allies, pals, and companions—to clarify how people connect across different domains of life. True bonding often arises from emotionally intense shared experiences, like haunted houses or retreats, followed by reflective conversations that deepen trust.

Grant emphasizes that avoiding conflict—such as by agreeing to disagree—hurts relationships by preventing growth and emotional resilience. Instead, feedback should be offered with care, rooted in respect and shared values, not judgment. He highlights that men, in particular, struggle with emotional openness due to cultural expectations of strength, leading to loneliness.

At work, effective teamwork depends more on shared mission and task alignment than on personal friendship, with rare, intense in-person interactions having a greater impact than daily low-stakes contact. Grant concludes that emotional intelligence—especially in social settings—should be taught in schools, as it fundamentally improves well-being and strengthens both personal and societal connections. His insights stress that relationships are not just tools for productivity or success, but intrinsic sources of emotional safety and joy.

FAQs

No, agreeing to disagree often avoids genuine resolution. It prevents learning, undermines relationship strength, and fails to build skills for handling difficult conversations. Healthy conflict requires open, respectful dialogue focused on mutual growth.

Start by identifying whether you're seeking allies, pals, or companions. These different connection types serve unique roles. Being clear about your needs helps you build more meaningful and balanced relationships.

Vulnerability opens the door to deeper trust and connection. Sharing something personal, like a mistake or a difficult experience, invites reciprocity and creates shared emotional experiences that strengthen bonds.

Relationships don’t need years to develop. Intense shared experiences—like surviving a crisis or going on a challenging adventure—can create deep bonds quickly, often more powerfully than long-term, passive connections.

Yes, it’s often better to go to bed angry than to suppress emotions. Having a rational conversation after sleep helps avoid impulsive regret and allows for more constructive conflict resolution in the morning.

No. While in-person interaction helps, regular, intense face-to-face meetings—like quarterly off-sites—are more impactful than daily remote interactions. Such moments build trust and alignment, which drive effective teamwork.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.