171. Achilles tendon ruptures: Rehab & recovery with Prof. Peter Malliaras
1h 27m 24s
Achilles tendon ruptures are often misdiagnosed, especially in patients who retain dorsiflexion ability, leading to delayed treatment and poor outcomes. While re-rupture risk remains low (2–5%), tendon elongation is a more significant issue affecting strength, efficiency, and function. The rupture site—insertional, mid-portion, or muscle-tendon junction—determines treatment pathways, with insertional tears typically requiring surgery and others managed conservatively. Imaging does not improve outcomes or reduce elongation risk, emphasizing the need for early diagnosis and immobilization. A progressive, safe rehabilitation protocol—starting with isometric holds in plantar flexion and progressing to loaded calf raises in a Smith machine—is critical. Early mobilization (3–4 weeks post-injury) includes controlled range-of-motion exercises, avoiding dorsiflexion to prevent elongation. Over time, elongation may reverse with consistent, progressive loading, especially in the early healing phase. Tendon healing is highly adaptable, with ultrasound showing a transition from disorganized tissue to parallel collagen alignment over 6–12 months. Outcomes are better with structured rehab than with delayed or inappropriate loading. Patient education on the risks of elongation and reassurance about pain tolerance are vital. A key clinical takeaway is that conservative management with proper rehabilitation is as effective as surgery, and functional recovery depends more on rehab quality than on surgical intervention. Research is ongoing to validate these protocols in large-scale trials, with a focus on measuring elongation, strength, and function over time.
You're listening to The Physio Edge Podcast episode 171 with David Pope.
Hey you and welcome to The Physio Edge Podcast. I'm your host David Pope and Australian Sports
and Musculoskeletal Physio. And on The Physio Edge Podcast, I interview the leading experts
on Musculoskeletal and sports injuries and get their expert import into how you can best assess
and treat patients injuries and get great results. And on this podcast, we're talking
all about Achilles tendon ruptures. You've had those patients they come in, they're running,
they're playing sport, maybe they're jumping or lunging forward. And they feel like they've
been kicked in the back of the leg. They look around, no one's there. They have some trouble walking
off and they've snapped their Achilles tendon. These patients often present to you next. How do you
actually assess them to make sure they do have an Achilles tendon rupture or not? We've been pretty
comfortable managing those for a while with putting patients into boots and we've had studies
confirming that often we get just as good results with putting Achilles tendon rupture patients
into a boot as we do with surgery. But there are actually some patients that are going to require
surgery and there are other patients that might opt for surgery. So the question is what's the
best way to guide your patients when they ask you should I have surgery or should I have conservative
management? How do you go about answering them? We're going to also look at some of the other
aspects that you're going to encounter when you go through your rehab of patients whether they've
had surgical and on surgical management. One of the major concerns patients have is re-rupturing
their tendon. No one wants to go through this again. So they're going to be fearful about re-rupturing
their tendon. So you want them help to address those fears and understand how to educate them
oftentimes as physios. We're looking at helping patients to regain their strength and their
range of movement. Maybe we're looking at doing some stretching to make sure that they maintain
that range. But elongation with a tendon is actually too long is actually more of a problem
than any lack of range. Now this is actually a bigger risk or a more common problem than tendon
re-rupture. So we're going to dive into all that how you can help to reduce the risk or the amount
of elongation, how to guide them through that whole non-surgical management and their rehab if
they do have surgery. And then what happens when they come out of the boot as well? On the podcast
we've got Professor Peter Meli-Aris. I've had Peter on before in episode 23 talking about
tendonopathy. Peter's a specialist physio, a fellow of the Australian College of Physios,
he's also a clinician and a researcher with a PhD in tendonopathy. I met Peter at a recent conference
and we got discussing his interest in Achilles tendon ruptures. And I thought this would be a great
topic for us to explore on the podcast and help to reveal what's been happening in the world
of Achilles tendon ruptures and help to share with you some great ways to approach it.
So he's got lots of clinical experience. He's set up an Achilles rupture specialist service
at author's Sport Victoria and he's been really looking at ways of helping to get the best results
with your Achilles tendon rupture patients. If we're going to talk about your diagnostic tests,
so you want to make sure that you don't miss them and they're actually quite commonly misdiagnosed.
We're going to look at surgical versus non-surgical management,
complications you want to look at for. If they're going through a non-surgical rehab process,
what do you do while they're in the boot? How to load the Achilles in those early phases of rehab,
objective strength criteria that you can use to help to guide and progress your rehab.
Then when patients want to know how much walking can I do when I get out of the boot,
you'll know exactly how to guide them and how to tailor their treatment around what their
strength is and what their particular impairments are at that time. We've got a few great resources
to go along with the podcast and the first ones are summary handout. So you want to grab that one
where we summarise the key principles and the recommendations from today's podcast and you can
get that on the podcast page, over at clinicledge.co/171. If you're interested in Achilles Tendons,
we've also got a free video series with Tom Goome on Achilles Tendon Opti,
taking it through the assessment and treatment of Achilles Tendon Opti. That's over at clinicledge.co/running.
And Tom's also got some other free video series over there on tricky tendons,
we've got a video and an infographic series on those. And our other resource is your clinic
ledge membership. We've got tons of great resources there. We're really aiming to give you all the
tools you need to assess and treat all the patients that come into your clinic and so you know
exactly what to do and you can get great results. For instance, we've got presentations on a
doctor-related growing pain with Andrew Wallace, FAI assessment and treatment with Dr Adam Weir,
accelerate conservative management of medial knee injuries with Chris Morgan,
and we've got a whole module on how to treat low back pain. The moment we've got presentations
coming out on manual therapy for low back pain. We know it's a controversial topic,
so if you are going to use it, you want to know when and how and the best ways to actually use it.
Or if you're wondering whether manual therapy has a role in modern low back pain treatment,
that's a great one to dive in and explore the research and explore a practical way to apply
with your patients that doesn't make them reliant on it. So you can get that over at clinicledge.co/free-trial.
And now it's time to dive into the podcast with Professor Peter Meliarz.
Hey Peter, how are you? I'm really good. David, how's it going?
Great thanks. We're coming back on the podcast. It's been a while since we've had you on the podcast
and really enjoyed our last chat and then when I met you and heard that you've got a focus now
or you've been exploring some Achilles tendon rupture research and I wanted to get you back on and
have a chat about some of that. Tell us a little bit about that journey he went from
diving into tendopathy to exploring more research around Achilles tendon ruptures.
Yes, sure. So I've always seen lots of Achilles tendopathy in general in the clinic and then
it just was a natural progression. People started referring more ruptures over the last 10-12 years
and I've just started seeing more ruptures and initially I didn't really enjoy them that much.
But then over time I started enjoying them more and started thinking these are actually quite
interesting. It's a bit like the ACL rehab because it's all about progressions and criteria.
So I really enjoyed that. There's lots of measurements that we do as well which is really interesting,
keeps it keeps it interesting and lots of really good objective criteria. So I started enjoying it
and then more recently started doing some research in the area as well.
Yeah, awesome. So what are the problems that Achilles tendon rupture patients experience or
that there are a percentage of experience when they're treating patients that have had Achilles tendon
ruptures? It is a catastrophic injury. People are very fearful. Patients are very fearful of
that re-rupturing, doing the wrong thing. The clinicians are very fearful of doing the wrong
thing as well and there's a lot of uncertainty I think in just generally and even from the top down
if you speak to surgeons they are also uncertain about how we should be loading and how we should
be progressing and then if you speak to the physios they are also uncertain. So it's no
surprise that the patients are uncertain about what they should be doing because no one really
seems to know how to progress, how fast to progress, what to do. So a lot of it is based on
historical just we should be careful to allow tissue healing. A lot of it is very dated in terms
of what we do. So I think that's what I see a lot. So I was in cont yesterday. I saw out of my list
of 15 or so people I would see a handful of Achilles ruptures within that. Yeah they just present
with Am I doing the right thing? I saw a guy who was six weeks down the track yesterday and he's
gone to a big local private hospital which is the Alfred here and they've done a good job. They've
reassured him but he still didn't quite get enough in terms of answers to some of the questions
that he needed. So for example, we asked the guy how much walk him can I do and how much can I
wait there and the way he relayed the story to me, the guy sort of wasn't sure and said to him oh
just you know see how you go type thing and make sure it's not too painful. So there's that type
of thing that happens I think quite often because people are just not sure. Providing similar
assurance and some certainty in terms of the program that people have is really beneficial. So that's
the sort of problem you see but I mean in terms of problems in healing there's lots of those.
The two main ones are re-rupture and then elongation. So people end up at a long tendon or they end
up with a re-rupture. So they're the main things that we see in terms of people not having good
outcome. People underestimate how big a problem it is to patients and it's a massive psychological
and mental problem for them when they're going through an Achilles rupture. It's similar to an
ACL and the type of pathway and mental struggle that people go through with an ACL. Yeah definitely
especially when it's impacted the ability to walk to be able to do pretty much all their
activities are daily living for a while and like you said it maybe the patient's not sure about
how much they can walk even their therapists are not sure how much they can actually do and how much
to load them up and how much to let them rest that sort of thing. So I'm really looking forward to
diving to some of those questions because they're the questions of patients are going to ask us
all the time. So if we will get some clarity so physios out there will know how to answer patients
and how to guide them on the best way to progress through their rehab and progress their function
and their walking that sort of stuff. If we talk about the common presentation so someone comes
into a physio what are they likely to report first off when they've had an Achilles tendon rupture?
The classic is they will report that they're running along so it's usually non-contact they're
running along and someone's kicked them in the back of the leg. Someone's kicked them in the back
of the leg or they felt a snap they've heard something and usually they have a limitation in
pushing off and weight bearing, walking straight after so they'll feel all those things they'll
report those things
The guy yesterday I'll just give you an example because he was an initial that I saw yesterday.
He was playing paddle and he'd lunched and he basically felt that someone kicked him and he looked at his partner
and then he looked back in his partner. I was way too far away and he realised it wasn't his partner
or something else had happened. So that's like a typical history. In terms of mechanisms,
it's basically dorsiflexion. So people usually are doing some eccentric
or some concentric fast activity in dorsiflexion. It's usually that change over from eccentric
to concentric where people get a rupture. ruptures don't occur in plant afflection and that's
a really important point because that plant afflection loading is safe. That's what I define as safe
loading when we're loading in plant afflection and that then transfers to our rehab and stuff we'll
talk about later but when you load them in plant afflection generally they're okay. They're not going
to get any problems there if you do it in a safe way. So they will generally report that typical
mechanism loss of ability to plant afflex. It's interesting how commonly though these types of
injuries are missed. There's reports out there if you look at emergency departments up to 20-30
percent of people with an Achilles rupture are missed which sounds shocking and surprising because
you just think to yourself these people generally can't push off but a lot of people can still
plan afflex and that's one of the issues. They will be able to plan afflex because they've still
got their long flexes, their long deep flexes so they will retain explicitly young people some
ability to plan afflex and that puts some people off and also the Thompson's test or the Simmons test
that people do is quite equivocal for some people. It can be negative even when someone has a rupture.
So you do need to look and I guess we'll get on to diagnosis so I'm not going to talk about it now
but we do need to look at a thorough diagnostic workout to make sure you're not missing them.
Is it more common in specific age groups like if you've got a patient come in and they're
in the early 20s are they likely to have one or is it what's the common age groups they can have
that? Yeah it's a really good question. We are currently doing a review looking at the incidents
in different groups and different age groups and that data we're looking through at the moment.
It's not led by our group it's one that I'm collaborating on from overseas people but
partly at Asperta, partly in Greece. What we're fighting there is that it's it's surprising
actually some people can get a ruptures young as 12 13 years old and then you get it right up to
people in their 90s so effectively the key age groups are your late athletic so late 20s early 30s
that are still quite active and then the other key age group is the 45 to 60 year old people
when they start to get a little bit more degeneration and issues with their tendon.
Yeah interesting it's probably a lot younger with some of those age groups than what you think
or especially you mentioned some of the around the 12 to 13 year old I mean that's probably not
most of us are probably thinking those 30 to 40 year olds that are playing basketball or whatever
rather than the 12 to early adolescent phase athletes. That was really surprising actually and I
think if you look at some of the data you do get a lot of gymnasts that actually get ruptures
and they get it quite young track athletes get it quite young as well so you can have track
athletes in their late teens who get ruptures so it is quite common it doesn't happen that much
in distance runners so distance runners because they're not doing maximal activities generally it will
happen when you're young when you're doing maximal activities now maximal activities are maximal
jumping maximal sprinting maximal cutting so if you're doing those activities that involve lots
of dorsiflexion and powerful calf contractions in dorsiflexion you're at risk of those injuries
but the older demographic they can get it doing all sorts of activities not necessarily these
maximum activities so it might be just walking along it could be just running going for a run
I'll tell you a bit of an anecdote that happened to me I had a patient recently in the clinic
he was probably in his early 50s he's a hairdresser so it spends a lot of time standing and I was
treating him for an insurgent Achilles pay and we were treating his rider Achilles and the second time
I saw him he was progressing well and I asked him to hop on his right side which is his painful
side and it was absolutely fine he hopped on his right side it was a bit laid bit a bit painful as
you would expect with an Achilles but it wasn't too bad and then I got into repeat that on the left
side and he's left Achilles snapped right there in the runes our had a student with me he went
white I went white the only one that was semi okay and not freaking out was the patient himself
and he he was completely fine he was so so nice about it and we've got him a booze and we
spent another hour with him and then he ended up going off and having surgery coming back
and now he's done all the rehab he's completely fine but I guess the point of that story is that
you really can rupture it with just a very very something that doesn't seem very much at all
just a hot test that everyone does in clinical practice but you can if someone's tendon is weak
it will rupture without this is that over 45 45 to 65 year old group where that
needs to be doing maximum activities if they put a bit of stretch shot and cycle through the
tendon that they're not used to the tendon can rupture so that that was that was definitely a
bit of a shock for me I always tell that story when I'm teaching and everyone asks me do you still
do hot tests and I still do hot tests because they are safe and I've been hopping patients for
20 years now and that's the first time that's happened so they are very very safe tests to do
but if a tendon is ready to go it will go regardless of what we're doing could be walking could be
doing anything so that that is something to keep in mind the interesting thing about his case as
well was that I I scan everybody that I see within Achilles and when you look at his scan on the
insertional right side he had some typical insertional pathology when I looked at his left side
it was pretty normal it was pretty healthy so there wasn't much going on and that was interesting
because the mantra at the moment is that and we might get on and talk about this as well but the
mantra is a healthy tendon does not rupture that's what people say and that's what the evidence
shows so if you look at the classic canis 1991 paper that paper they looked at almost 900
attendants from all around the body that presented to emergency that eruptured and they took a sample
a biopsy of part of that tissue and they looked at it and in all cases of rupture I think it was
like 90 something percent 98 percent or most of the cases of rupture had pathology when you looked
at it under a microscope so that that's where that mantra that healthy tendon doesn't rupture
comes from but if you look at it with ultrasound which I did for this guy he had a tendon that looked
healthy so I think there's a difference between what we're seeing with scanning what's happening in
the tendon itself now the other possibility is that it's just weak so he's got this tendon that he's
structurally mechanically weak even though it's healthy and that can be from deconditioning that could
be from not enough loading from various factors so so that that was interesting to me as well because
I guess before that one thing that's changed in my practice from that experience is I
I would generally say to people if your tendon looks good really good on ultrasound
is probably less likely that that tendon's got a rupture but I'm not so confident in saying that now
so now I think what we need is that mechanical evidence of stiffness in the tendon and we might
talk about stiffness because that's really the best measure of how strong a tendon is
yeah and do we know much about the predisposing factors you mentioned there that if we've got an
unhealthy tendon in that kind of study that the large proportion of those people who had Achilles
tendon ruptures had some tendon issues or tendon optically going on within the tendon so when
patients ask why is it my Achilles ruptured how do you tend to answer them yeah it's a good
that's a good question as well I think we do know something about why people rupture and it's
definitely mechanical loading and it's the stuff that we talked about earlier that real high stress
sprints in maximum efforts that will that will definitely be a factor the other factor is age
is a factor prior pathology in the tendon that is a factor any disease process metabolic disease
all those things are related as well so if you've got cholesterol you'll start to get tendons that
are less healthy and we know that they mechanically they're not as strong so all those things
are factors as well medication use steroid use long term steroid use all those things relate
to Achilles tendon rupture we don't have great evidence that mechanical by mechanical factors
would like to wrap.
a side from that really heavy high loading in dorsiflex positions.
And you mentioned before that in ED's 20 to 30% of these are missed.
What are they often misdiagnosed as?
Yeah, look, they often can be misdiagnosed.
I had one recently misdiagnosed in an ankle sprain.
So, especially if the person is a bit vague about the history, so they say, "I'll look
I tripped, I tripped off a curb or something like that and they got swelling around the ankle.
That can be a bit misleading for an ankle sprain.
I've had them diagnosed as a killi's tenopathy or killi's problem, killi's partial tear."
So, various things.
I remember one guy I had, this is when I was working in London about 15 years ago, I worked
in a tendon clinic there and there was one guy, older guy, I was probably in his seventies,
he had been misdiagnosed for six months.
And that was the worst case that I've ever seen.
He also had two lots of imaging, right, and was still misdiagnosed.
And the reason he was misdiagnosed, even though he had imaging, was that with ultrasound.
The tendon tears in different places.
So the tendon can tear in the middle, the mid portion, which is the most common, the tendon
can tear at the muscle tendon junction to the cilius.
And then the tendon can also tear at the insertion, so it can pull off the bone.
So there's those three places, so this guy here had had ultrasound and they just looked
at the mid portion and they had it looked further up where he had his muscle tendon junctions
here.
So you can miss them even when they do get imaging.
They can be misdiagnosed, so you've got to be careful.
I had a really interesting one recently.
This guy's in his seventies as well and he's got some comorbidities that we're just talking
about.
He's got diabetes.
He's even had some surgery to amputate some toes because of his diabetes.
So he was in that group of people that was deconditioned after one of his surgeries, got
up and about.
After that, ruptured his achilles.
So then I saw him a few weeks after and he came in with his imaging report from the radiologist
and the imaging report said mid portion achilles rupture.
So I looked at it with a scanner in the clinic and he had a clear insertional achilles rupture.
So the mid portion was completely fine that the insertion was ruptured.
I then took my images and I took a dynamic video just looking at what I was seeing there
and I checked it with a radiologist that I worked with David Connell, really closely and
confirmed this is an insertional rupture and then I went back to the imaging place because
the guy was really confused because I was saying to him, look, you've got this insertional
rupture and then the imaging place was saying you've got a mid portion rupture.
So we ended up clearing it up but it took quite a few phone calls to sort that out.
It can be difficult to get a really good diagnosis and handle on what's going on with
ultrasound if you're not careful and you're not looking carefully.
So that was an interesting one and it does matter where the injury happens because it influences
management.
So with the insertional ones, they are generally repaired.
So generally people will repair those.
Now this guy here that I'm talking about, he didn't have surgery because he had so many
comorbidities and he's got diabetes and etc.
And he's now doing conservative treatment but the insertional ones are usually repaired.
The mid portion ones can be either repaired or they can be non-surgically treated.
And we know now the trend is more for non-surgical because there's no real difference in outcome.
Whereas the muscle, tendon, junction injuries are not repaired.
So they are not repaired.
They cannot repair those.
Generally, they don't do surgery for those, they are non-surgically treated.
So it does make a difference for this guy as an example.
Where exactly that injury is?
Interesting.
And you mentioned there about the different locations of tear and how they might impact
whether they go down a surgical pathway or a non-surgical pathway.
Are there any other findings or any other aspects of the tear that might make someone more or
less likely to go down one of those pathways?
I think the main things that people look at are age and how active someone is.
So if you're younger and more active, you're more likely to have surgery.
They're the main things.
There's other things that rule you out of surgery to say you've got comorbidities like
we're talking about diabetes and things like that.
You're poor healing, smoking, surgeons will look at all those factors.
But generally, the trend seems to be that a lot of people are going non-operative because
we know that the outcomes are just as good with non-operative, but if they're younger
and they're more active, then they're more likely to be repaired.
So for example, if you look at elite sport, most people in the elite sport contexts will
have a repair rather than non-surgical.
My advice to people is even with elite younger, non-surgical seems to be as good in terms
of outcome than surgery.
I think people just have that feeling that surgery is going to lead to a better outcome.
And it's that real ingrained thought process of people that if they have surgery, it's
going to be better.
But I think the outcomes are probably quite similar.
Surgery versus non-surgery outcomes are quite similar.
It's going to come down to how the rehab goes.
What about the size of the tear?
Is there any cut off if they're over, if they're around 10 millimetres or less or more?
Does that impact whether they get an surgical or non-surgical pathway?
That is a good point.
That's another factor.
So the other factor that people consider is, has there been a delay in presentation?
So a delay in presentation will mean that people are walking around on this rupture,
and it might be that it's irreducible if you just put them in planiflexion.
So generally the treatment is, if you catch it early, you go into planiflexion straight
away in a boot, or a backslab, frontslab, or a cast for two weeks, and then you go into
a boot, whether it's a back appeared or whether it's a moon boot, you're probably going
to have a good outcome, getting it early is very important, because what happens is you
start to get swelling in between the ends of the tendon, and that swelling then forms
a scar, and you also get fatty tissue that goes in between the ends.
So the sooner you can get it into a boot, the better.
So one advantage of the guy who's tendon I ruptured in my clinic was that he got it diagnosed
immediately, and we got him straight into the right position, and he healed really well,
healed in good position.
I think there's a lot of reasons why people get elongation, but one of the major ones
is delayed presentation.
That's one of the key things that surgeons also look at.
And I think that's important, and that's where imaging comes in.
So generally, I don't advocate imaging, because there's been a couple of studies in from
the UK, and actually one recent one, from Copenhagen, the Carter study, people want to
look it up, that there's a couple now that show that even if you do image and you base
the decision on the imaging gap, it still doesn't reduce the risk of elongation.
So imaging does not reduce the risk of the elongation.
We know that now from a couple of studies and trials.
So I don't generally advocate imaging, but I do think that if someone has been walking
around for weeks, they need to get imaging, and they probably will do better with surgery.
Okay, so the size of the tear on imaging doesn't tend to impact it like the treatment pathway.
It doesn't seem to, so if you look at the study recently from Copenhagen, they looked
at, so basically their pathway was ultrasound examination, showing that the tendon ends
could overlap if you wanted to plan a flexion.
They also looked at elongation of greater than 7% in the tendon, and they measured that
with ultrasound, and if they had either non-overlapping tendon ends, or elongation of gradients they
went to surgery, and then if they didn't, they went to non-surgery, and they found no difference
in the outcome at the end of elongation.
So I think that surgery is part of it, and elongation at the start is part of it, but I also
think that you can mitigate the effects of elongation initially by good rehab.
So I've seen in clinical practice people that sometimes people come to me at 10 weeks
or 12 weeks, and it's not too late, but they have some elongation already, because I'll
measure it with ultrasound, so I'll measure how long the tendon is with ultrasound, and
they have elongation that's substantial, but then at 26 weeks, 6 months that elongation
has gone down.
So you can reverse some of the elongation if you do the right type of rehab, I believe
as well, so they're mitigating factors, and elongation is complex, it happens at multiple
parts of the pathway, it happens initially when they're walking around, it can happen
at surgery, so if the surgery is not good, that can lead to elongation, and then that's
also hard to reverse. It can happen in the boot if they're doing the wrong thing in the boot.
it can also happen when they come out of the boot. It tends to happen right up
until at least six months, some studies have shown that it might happen even up
to a year. So elongation, we don't fully understand it, but it doesn't seem to
be as simple as, okay, if they're long at day one, we're going to put them in the
surgery pathway and it's going to be a better outcome. That doesn't seem to be
the case. What has been really good points about elongation and you've mentioned
particularly that that can be an issue and sometimes when people have a
physio hat on, they're thinking that some of the issues are often around
restricted range of movement or restricted strength and they think, oh, maybe
we need to stretch it to maintain their dorsiflexion. So it sounds like an
actual fact that elongation or lengthening of the tendon is more of an issue
than restricted dorsiflexion. Is that how it is and tells a little bit about
elongation? Yeah, yeah, for sure. Elongation is, in my opinion, the biggest
problem that happens with the Achilles tendon repair. Risk of re rupture is
actually quite small in the order of 2% to 5% in most good studies. Sometimes it
can be bigger, but generally, if you're doing something sensible, the risk of
re ruptures is quite small. What is more of a risk is elongation. Now, everyone
gets elongation. Everyone gets some elongation, but it should be small. So we're
looking at, depending on how you measure it, you can either measure it directly
with ultrasound and then you get a millimeters of elongation measure, and you
want to be within one centimeter of elongation. Or that's what I look for. Or
you measure it with something called the Mattel's Test, which measures, if you
put them just relaxed over the end of the bed, it's how their foot dangles.
It's how one foot is dangling in more dorsiflexion because they've got a bit
more slack in their Achilles and calf complex. So they're the two ways to
measure it. One's direct, one's indirect. So I track both of them over time and
generally with elongation in terms of preventing it, which is what we want to
do. I think the key things are you've got to be in the right position in the
boot. So they've got to be in a good plan of flex position in the boot. Now my
go-to is to be a bit more conservative. So it's funny, I've been seeing at the
moment one of the secretaries of a surgeon that I work with and it's been an
interesting experience because he's a great surgeon and she's a typical patient,
not sure what to do in the boot and she's now at six weeks. I saw her yesterday's
wealth and she was relaying to me that the surgeon thinks I'm very
conservative and that he's wanting her to take wedges out and be a bit more
aggressive. My go-to is to try and keep them in the boot until some criteria is
reached and my go-to is to have the wedges in for longer rather than shorter. If
you look at something like the Willets Protocol, which is a really common one,
that people would be aware of, that was one of the first, what they call,
accelerated rehab programs. So in the Willets program, they try and get them out
of the boot at eight to ten weeks. They get them mobilizing full weight bearing
pretty soon after that initial two, three, four week period. It's all based on
how they feel. They get them out of the boot quickly and they also take out the
wedges quite quickly. So I think at week four, maybe you take out one and then
week six and then week eight. It might even be sooner than that. I can't remember
the exact days but my go-to at the moment is don't do anything for six weeks,
keep them in the three or four wedges. So five centimetre wedge for at least at
six weeks. Take one out at eight and then take one out at ten and then keep the
last one in for the duration till 12. The other thing I try and do is have a
criteria for getting out of the boot. So when they're getting out of the boot,
they should be able to push through planiflexion in a seated position around
about 70 to 80% of their body weight. So that's my criteria for getting out of
the boot. So some people will stay in the boot for 13 weeks. Some people will
stay in the boot for 11 weeks but obviously you don't want to keep them in the
boot for say 14, 15 weeks because then they'll get a lot of atrophy. So if they're
getting close to that criteria, I'm happy to take them out of the boot but I
think it is important to have some criterion to say okay you're getting
stronger. So one of the things that I've done over the last five or so years
progressively has got a little bit more and a little bit more a little bit
more aggressive with them in the boot. So it's just been an experience thing just
trial and error seeing how they go and they generally respond quite well but we
get them into planiflex positions. What I call safe planiflex positions where
there's something under their heel. They're sitting down with their with their
thigh parallel to the ground. Their tibia is vertical. They've got something
under their heel like a weight plate or a couple of books. So their heel is raised
by about an inch or an inch and a half and then they start to raise into a
calf raise and they just hold that position. So initially they're just holding
without any weight at all and then you start to load them. So you start putting
weight on their knee and it might be five kilos initially, then 10 kilos etc
until they get to around about 70 to 80% of their body weight. Now at some point
what we do is we transfer them into a Smith machine where they can do the
loaded because at home you're limited to about say 30 kilos safely putting
weight on your knee. So we transfer them into a Smith machine. So that's been
our program over the last little while. That's a key key difference to all the
programs that are out there at the moment. It's a lot more progressive. So I often
have to and this is this is where coming back to the conversation that we had
with a surgeon whose surgeon is sort of saying that I am too conservative but I
think in a way that when you look at the loading in the boot I'm probably more
aggressive than what a lot of people are at the moment because in the boot what
you tend to get is people doing therapy and planar flexor type contractions or
even active movements generally in the boot. So I try and go a bit harder with
the planar flexion in safe positions initially but I'm a bit more
conservative when it comes to walking because I think the walking is the thing
that's going to be more likely to get elongation. So that's a summary of what I
try and do when they're in the boot. That's fantastic clarity and nice
progressions for people to give ideas about why you might be interested in
preserving the wedges in there so they're not getting that elongation and then
how you actually load them up. You mention there that you're doing the holds, how
long do you get them to hold for and what are your guidelines to the person
about what's a safe load and how do you identify that safe load and when to
progress. Yeah yeah it's a good question so people can be quite anxious about it
and the first couple of times I did it I was quite anxious about it as well
because you think how much load can this actual Achilles sustain but then you
start to get the confidence because you start to think in this planar flex
position it's actually quite robust and it's actually quite strong because
the tenders are not elongating and the tradeoff there is that you're not
putting as much strain through the tendons so it's not as much stimulus for
the tendons to adapt and to heal but you're still getting enough stimulus and
enough load through it to have some signaling and mechano-transduction to get a
bit stronger. So I guess there's a lot of reassurance initially just to make
sure they're comfortable and safe getting something under their heel making
sure they're comfortable with something over their legs so they've got the
weight on there and they feel comfortable. So it does take a bit of time I'll
spend a whole session just going through the right position and teaching them
what to do so they can go home and replicate it and then I also get them to
take a video of exactly what they're setting up like at home because the last
thing you want is for them to go into dorsiflexion and that's what I try and
really drum into them you don't want to put your foot into dorsiflexion so you
don't want to put the heel back so you've got to set yourself up in the right
order and make sure that they are in planar flexion that safe position so I
think anything in planar flexion is fairly safe they're not going to do any
major issues in planar flexion the reason we have something under the heel just
in case they get fatigued in their heel drops make sure there's not a
sudden dorsiflexion we try and build that up really gradually really slowly so
the receptionist of the surgeon that I'm seeing at the moment she's on to now
30 kilos I saw her yesterday so she's doing really well so I transferred a
yes down to the smith machine and she works in with us so she's gonna be able to
go down and use a smith machine and all they need to do is generally they'll do
three times a week with the smith machine once they get to 30 kilos she's
doing 20 second holds you can do 30 second holds generally 20 to 30 seconds by
five is what I go for and try to get them to 70 to 80% of their body weight so
20 to 30 seconds by five they'll do that three times a week now they'll also do
some loading at home she'll continue to do some lighter loading at home with
as much weight as she can because it's lighter at home she'll probably do that
loading with it increased durations as you might go to a minute and do that a
few times generally it's once a day but because
Because some of the sub-maximal loading that we're doing at home, it's not that high,
it's not that taxing in terms of fatigue, we can do that a couple times a day as well at home.
And when to progress the weight. So you're thinking, okay, she's start off with
body weight and you've gone to five kilos. When do you think, okay, we can progress you to 10
or to how do you tend to progress that? Yeah, so look, it's all based on initially how they feel.
And one of the things I try and relate to them with the reassurance is that it's quite normal
to feel some sensation around the healing of Achilles. So that's quite normal. It's okay,
because a lot of them will be super sensitive and super on alert about any sensation from
that Achilles tendon. So it's quite normal to feel something. What's not normal is sharp pain.
So if they're getting sharp pain that is localized, that's a problem. We give them that reassurance.
Generally they'll start to feel the calf working. It sometimes takes a little bit of time because
the calf hasn't been working very well just to activate the calf and get a little bit of
sensation and feel. So they'll start feeling the calf working and they can then start to do that at
home and make sure they're safe and they're not overloading. But generally that reassurance about
it's fine to be a bit painful. It's okay if you're feeling something in that area, he's very,
very important. I've gone off track, I think. What was your question, Dave?
I think you've stayed on track, I think that's it. But I was mostly interested in your progression
criteria and when it's okay. You've definitely covered when it's okay to learn what they should feel,
but it tells a little bit when it's okay to progress them. Yeah, so basically the pain is part of it.
So as long as they're comfortable and it's still that minimal, small amount of awareness they're
getting, that's absolutely fine. They can still progress and then it all comes down to how much
load they can actually sustain for that rep range and that amount of time. So my advice to them is,
and this is what I said to the lady yesterday, you're doing 20 to 30 second contractions.
Now if you can get through your five sets of 20 to 30 second contractions and you feel like
you can do more after the next time, the next session, you're going to add some weight to that, okay?
And even if it's two or a half kilos onto the Smith machine or five kilo onto the Smith machine,
add some weight and see how you go. And sometimes I'll add weight for just the first or the second
set of those 20 seconds and just based on how they feel. So it's a very incremental increase
of weight based on really how they're coping with the exercise. How soon after the initial injury,
do you actually start to get them exercising into plan inflection? Yeah, good question. I tend to go
quite early and that's again, something that has got a little bit more aggressive over the years
that I've been doing it. So initially it was probably five, six weeks. Now it's more like three,
four weeks depending on how they're going, how they're coping, how they're feeling, how the
scar is feeling if they've had surgery. So there's a few factors to consider. I usually start them off
with just a isometric push. So I'll get them out of the boot and I'll get them not any weight
and not weight bearing. So not seated and they're just pushing their toes down and they're holding
that for 10 seconds and then relaxing doing it 10 times. Once they're used to isometric pushing
without any weight, then we start to progress and we get them to seated. So that could take
a nice and metric push could start at week two. Okay, so pretty soon I'll start with that. The other
things that I'll do is just some range of motion. So inversion, he version as well in that early phase.
I don't really do a lot of teraband. So most of the protocols are about teraband to do plan
reflection. I don't do a lot of teraband because I do the seated work. So you're seated in at
home or in the spith machine. What else do I do in that early phase? I try I generally avoid doing
things into dorsiflexion. That's a really important part of that overall management but expressly
that initial management. So I think you alluded to it before. A lot of people are quite concerned
about flexibility and not and making sure that people are not getting stiff when they're when
they're in the boot. Most people don't have a huge issue with flexibility though. And most people
once they get out of the boot, they start to walk a bit. They might be a bit stiff initially
with need of wall and dorsiflexion but it's not really something that lingers for a lot of people.
So it's quite rare for people to get a joint contracture where they have a real stiff ankle
that's quite that's quite rare for it to kill each rupture. So my advice is don't worry about
dorsiflexion. It will probably just come over time. It improves over time as you start to do over
the step car phrases which I start to do generally a few weeks after they've come out of the boot.
So coming out of the boot is a key time. You want to protect their gates. They don't want to be
walking too much. So volume of walking is important but also protecting the way they walk.
So small steps still using the boot if they're walking a long distance or using some support if
they're walking a long distance. Making sure that we're going to wear our shoes, heel wedges.
So I do that for a good few weeks after whilst they're developing single leg strength ability
single leg car phrase. So once they can do a single leg car phrase and they can do a few of those,
then we start going into negative territory with dorsiflexion. At that point they've already
been doing a little bit of walking and the dorsiflexion looks after itself. You don't need to worry
about dorsiflexion very much. So when you're looking at their dorsiflexion range and you
worry about elongation what are some of the risks of actually having an elongated tendon
and was a problem. So with an elongated tendon it basically there's a couple things that happen.
So if you think about, if you think about the tendon and muscle in series, so you've got
the Achilles tendon and you've got the fascicles of the gastrochonocelius. So if you have the tendon
being longer then that means the fascicles are operating at a shorter range. So therefore they're
less efficient and what happens with a lot of people when they first come out of the boot
is they get a lot of fatigue with car phrases. Even just a two or three car phrases is enough
to fatigue them and that's because of the efficiency of the muscle tendon unit. So it's not working
at its optimal length in terms of the fascicles. So there's some evidence that that adapts over time.
So what that means is you've got sarcomies in series. So the muscle sarcomies are in series and
the muscle reduces the number of sarcomies in series over time and that then reduces this
effect of less efficiency of the of the fascicles. So that happens but that's a slow process
and that probably takes a year or two. In the meantime you have this really weak inefficient
calf muscle. So you can't really walk long distances without getting tired. Your tendon is
overstretched and therefore not efficient at storing and releasing energy. So it's just not a very
good and efficient situation to be and we know there's really strong relationship between the
elongation that people get and also their strength. So people who are elongated are much weaker
and find it a lot harder to then develop some of the calf strength again.
So sometimes in fizzo we think about increased range being a great thing but in this case elongation
they've got more resting dorsiflexion it just sits in a more dorsiflex position and they've got
a less efficient calf and muscle tendon unit and so functionally what's the image that they're
often weaker any other functional issues they have with the elongated tendon. Yeah yeah so they do
they do have a lot. If you look at them hopping they will hop in much more dorsiflexion so
their heel will touch the ground sooner. They just can't develop hour as well. If you look at
them calf raising they're not going to get very high. So they've got very low heights with calf
raising. Some people I've seen some extreme elongation like really and this is what we're
talking about before. Elongation happens to everyone so everyone's elongated to some extent. You
don't escape elongation after a kill each rupture but you can minimize it. I've had a couple of
people who almost have no elongation but that's quite rare. So my advice to surgeons is always
if you can make it as tight as possible if they're going to have surgery that's going to help in
terms of a long term elongation. Elongation affects everything they do in terms of strength
in terms of how much they can calf raise in terms of power. The extreme ones are unable to do a
calf raise. If you have extreme elongation so you've heard about the surgery that people do
where they elongate the calf muscle when you've got real tight calf like the
Aquinas of the calf. Now some people that in historically that was used as a treatment for
things like planifacio.
and things like that, if you've got a really tight calf, lengthening the calf muscle basically.
I had, this is just an example of an extreme elongation. I had one girl who was just in her 30s
and she had, she had undergone this procedure where they'd lengthen her calf muscle, it just
became too long. She ended up not being able to do a calf raise at all, so she was unable to lift
her body weight and that was a real difficult thing to overcome for her. So we did a year of rehab
and she did get to doing a calf raise and she even got back to running but she was always going to
have a limitation of calf strength because if you think about the muscle tendon unit, the only
place these people have strength is in extreme extreme dorsiflexion and this is what I do to test them,
put them into a position where they're leaning on the wall and their foot is about a meetup
meter and a half away from the wall so they're in full dorsiflexion and get them to do a calf
raise and they can do a calf raise in that position. But if you get them to stand up straight as we
usually test people for a calf raise, they're unable to do a calf raise. So they, they have this
muscle tendon unit that is only able to function in that extreme long position so it's not functional
at all. So it's a real problem. If you get someone, I've only seen a handful of people who were
young and at a point where they're probably going to have a permanent problem with their calf
because of elongation. I've got one guy at the moment who came to me probably about 12 weeks
after getting out of the boot and he's got quite severe elongation as well and it's just hard,
it's hard because it takes a long time to get back the function they need in dorsiflexion.
So I do a lot of stuff where I do isometrics in very inner-range positions where they're right
up on their toes. I do isometrics in flat positions. I do isometrics in dorsiflex positions
just to try and recover strength. But initially, and this is what I was talking about before,
I believe you can reverse some of the elongation for some people, especially in the early phase,
when the tendon is still really pliable and still healing, you can reverse the elongation
if you do a stack of loading in an inner-range position. So you do stacks of stuff in a range
and it starts to stiffen up the tendon and I think you can reduce some of that elongation
that we see. What about is a long-term, short-term thing we still haven't handled on that.
But I've got a couple of pair of sessions now who are doing Achilles rupture type projects.
The first thing we're going to do is test the way that we do it in the clinic.
Our rehab protocol for Achilles rupture in a pilot and then hopefully go to a full-scale trial
after that. So that's going to be the first thing. But we're also testing a bunch of other things
like elongation and how elongation goes over time and what factors relate to elongation.
So it's at OrthoSport Victoria where I work now. We've set up a, it's almost like a specialist
rupture clinic with myself, some PhD students and some other staff that are there. OrthoSport
Victoria is a clinic owned by surgeons in Melbourne and some physios and other people. They've
he's already done a bunch of ACL testing. So it was perfect for us because I started work there
a year and a half ago and they're doing all this ACL testing. They had all the equipment,
like all the VELD force plates through the emotion. So now we just do similar stuff or with
starting to develop processes for Achilles rupture as well. So people come through and get tested,
ultrasound of the length of the tendon and healing over time. But also they get all their rehab
and performance measures like hopping, strength measures, etc. Yeah, perfect. Your aim or
clinical reasoning is that by targeting that in a range of plant inflation strength that
potentially you can improve the efficiency or maybe help to decrease the elongation of the
tendon by getting the strength up in that range. And particularly targeting with a bent knee
like you're looking more around that subtly as rather than gastrocs or rather than with the
knee extended. I do mostly bent knee when they're in the boot because it's just easier for them
because you can add weights based on how much they can do. When they're as soon as they're out of
the boot I start standing and it's usually double leg to start with and then they progress quickly.
So one of my key progressions is standing isometric in different positions with double leg using
scales to make sure that their weight bearing is much as possible as much as they can tolerate on
their affected side and getting to full weight bearing. So a good progression target is you're able
to get them on their toes putting their full body weight through their Achilles. So that's that
usually happens if everything's going well within two weeks of post boot removal. That's a really
good outcome. So then they can start to do a lot more in standing. So then I've got the standing
stuff going the seeded at the same time. Back to your initial point with that. I do think that
the tendon we know is so moldable and there's a lot of still mechano-transduction and adaptability
that's going on the tendon for about a year or two. So if you follow it if you track it with ultrasound
you see that the tendon just looks like mush. I used to work with a radiologist in London
Otto Chan and he would say that the tendon looks like a dog is as chewed it and that's like that
for the first six months and then it starts to look like a normal tendon with parallel alignment
of fibers. To get to that point it requires a lot of signaling to tell the tendon that it needs to
the cells need to align the collagen in parallel to the force. So you need to put the force in
consistently for that signal to occur. So I think it's a very adaptable tissue
if you give it the right signals and most of the time what we see is when you see these people
year down the track they've got a really strong tendon and their tendon on the affected side is
actually stronger than their unaffected side and really stiff and it's not going to be a problem
for them. There's they really worry about it happening again. I had one guy as probably one of the
worst ones that I've seen. He came to me I think about two years into his rehab and he had suffered
three re-ruptures already. So he had surgery, re-ruptured, he had a skin infection which didn't help
as well to end up having a skin graft. He then had another surgery re-ruptured. He then tried
conservative and it re-rupted again and then he came to me and he was in his 30s wanting to get
back to basketball and has young kids and had been told by the surgeon the last one that he would
never be able to walk again without a limb. Let alone go back to basketball. So we basically just
went through the program that we do from scratch again and he ended up getting a good outcome.
He ended up going back to basketball. It took ages but he got there. Then two months after he went
back to basketball he ruptured the other side and this goes to can you prevent Achilles ruptures
because we were doing all the heavy loading all the stuff you need to do so that we think would
mitigate the risk of rupture on the other side but he's still got a rupture and his tendon looked
good on that side as well. So if you asked me can you predict a rupture I probably have to say no
because I mean someone with a fairly healthy looking tendon who's done stacks of loading still
got a rupture and there's probably a deconditioning element because he hadn't got used to that
maximal maximal maximal even though we did maximal plyometric progressions he probably just wasn't
right at the point where he needed to be for some of the things he was doing on the court but I guess
the point that I'm trying to make there is if you rehab and Achilles because it gets so thick
it's not going to rupture again once it's rehabbed but the other side that might rupture and that's
the problem it's a bit like ACL in that way as a strong genetic component to it. What a nightmare
for that poor Blake. Yeah and why do you think rehab was successful on that third do you think was
that the surgery hadn't had comprehensive rehab through the first couple of surgeries or was it
petty managed that in the third one or what do you think was the factor that made the difference here?
I think based on what he was saying about his prior rehabs and what we have been doing I think
it was just the case that we we were using criteria and more progressing him really a lot more
intensely than he was before so a lot of people will as I say do the therapy and in the boot do
lots of standing work maybe with a bit of load when they come out of the boot whereas we were
getting him to do carphrase in leg press machine in seated carphrase standing carphrase Smith
machine he was doing all those progressions he progressed to adding faster concentric movements
he progressed to plyometric work he was doing just a really good solid rehab and he was focusing
on inarrange initially so some of the things that yeah we've talked about before I think were
different to what he had done before so in patience I ask you am I likely to be able to get back
to be able to play explosive sports.
or to get back to those sort of things,
what's your normal response to them?
- Well, it probably depends on how,
on what stage they're at and what they're like.
And so for example, say the guy I saw yesterday,
he's come from the Alfred.
He's one of those guys who super conscious about his health
and wanted to do the right thing
and he's followed the instructions.
And I said to him yesterday,
he's got almost no elongation.
So he's really healed in a really good position.
And he's six weeks, so for him, he asked me that question.
I said to him, "You'll have no problem whatsoever."
He wants to get back to rackets for us.
So pad all tennis and squash.
He'll have no problem.
He's young as well as 39.
But the other guy, and then I was talking about
who I saw six weeks after,
removal of boot and he's got stacks of elongation.
That's more of a borderline one.
So you just got to see how the rehab goes
with someone like that.
So he really has a lot of work to do.
It's who gets as much function out of the calf
as he possibly can.
And it's a mental battle and strain for them
because you see them coming back
and they're doing all this calf work over so long
and the benefits are just so incremental and so small.
It's a motivation thing as well for them.
So some people just can't really keep up with it
or just lose track after a while.
And they won't get a good outcome.
And that's probably why if you look at elite sport,
if you look at the percentage of people
that return to elite sport after rupture,
it's quite small.
Most of them do.
Some more than 50% that return.
But in some studies, up to 30%, 40% will not return
after a rupture.
And that's partly because they're older.
So it happens when they're in their early 30s
and it's towards the end of their elite sport career.
But also it happens because some will get suboptimal healing.
And elongation.
And they're just not the same athlete
as what they were before.
So it's really important to make sure
that we are doing as much as we can to reduce elongation.
- When they ask you if I'm able to get back
to sport playing basketball or soccer or whatever it might be
and they say how long is it likely to take me
if everything goes well?
What's your normal response is there?
- Generally around about six months,
they can start to do a little bit of plyometric running.
Generally around nine months,
they can start to get back to trading.
Generally around 12 months,
they can start to be really, really able to return to sport.
But a lot of people in the elite sport will try
and reduce the timelines and they can.
There's obviously reports in the elite sport
where people have got back sooner as well.
And I think that's fine.
The risk there is that they will go back
and they will have less strength than it appears
as powerful the performance might be a bit lower.
So yeah, the famous one was Aaron Rodgers.
He was quite old.
He was steady eight or 39 when he ruptured his killings.
He was doing all this stuff to try and get him to up back
and he just committed so much time
to it was doing all this additional stuff
and all this rehab.
But it still ended up taking 12 months to get back in the end.
And maybe that was partly because
his team didn't actually make the playoff.
So there wasn't as much pressure.
But it did take a while.
So there's no shortcuts to a killings tendon healing.
It's going to take time to get a strong tendon.
- And how do those time frames compare
when you're looking at conservative
or non-surgical versus your surgical management?
Is there a difference there
or are they both got to work through the similar process
and with similar time frames?
- Pretty much identical in my view.
Yeah, pretty much identical.
Some people say that with surgery,
initially you can push them a bit harder
because you've got the surgical sutures there
and the sutures can take up to 30 or 40 kilos in themselves.
Some people say you can push them harder,
but I do identical rehab for both.
So my rehab doesn't change.
And I think because it's in a safe position,
I'm happy to load even the ones
that are treated non-surgically from an early time point.
I don't think it makes a huge difference
and therefore then the outcome,
because the rehab is the same.
The outcomes are also similar in terms of time.
- Beautiful, and I just want to step back a few steps
because we've explored some awesome parts
of the rehab process and the recovery and return to play.
But I want to just come back a little bit more
to some of the factors that we slightly touched on earlier,
which was around the assessment
and some of the diagnosis and misdiagnosis.
Anything else you want to add before we move back
to the assessment stuff about that rehab?
- No, I think we've covered a lot of bases there.
Yeah, happy to talk about this.
- You mentioned sometimes patients still have
some active plan of flexion.
So a patient comes in and they report
that common mechanisms of injury that you discussed earlier,
and you're working through your objective,
you're suspecting an Achilles tendon rupture,
what are some of the tests that you're going to do
to help to identify or to rule out
some of the other potential differentials?
- Yeah, so there's three things
that are really important to do.
One is Mattel's test or the way that the Achilles rests
when you have them lying over the edge of the bed.
So if you look at the angle,
it should be in a bit of plan of flexion
'cause there's a bit of tension in their calf.
If you see that one foot is in dorsiflexion,
that's pretty much a giveaway.
And most people will have that.
The other one is palpation.
So you palpate for a defect.
Okay, that's quite useful.
The last one is the Thompson's or Simmons test.
And that really is a classic one that most people do,
but that can be misleading in some people.
And you gotta be careful 'cause if you got someone
with not much calf bulk,
you're probably pushing on their deep long lexes as well.
And that might give you a negative on the Thompson's test.
So you've gotta think about all those things together.
The other thing is gaze and push off.
So just look at them, try and look at them walking.
You know, if you suspect it already,
I'm not gonna get them up and do a calf raise
because you wanna try and reduce the amount of load
going through and put them in plan of flexion
as quickly as possible.
But if you're not sure you might look at that
or just observe them when they're coming in
off in the waiting room,
if they haven't got a push off, that's also giveaway.
There's also the mechanism, which is quite important.
So all the stuff we talked about earlier
with that dorsiflexion mechanism,
that's also very, very important.
That's usually quite present and quite characteristic.
The other thing you can go to is then imaging.
So ultrasound, if you've got access to it in your clinic
or MRI, looking at soft tissue imaging for the tendon.
But generally, you don't need imaging to diagnose
and Achilles rupture.
You can diagnose it just on clinical,
based on the history and based on some of those tests as well.
With Mattel's test, that's performed, you've got them prone.
- Yeah, so Mattel's test, the classic one is
you get them into knee flexion.
So you get the knee flexion and their shin is vertical.
They're the shin's vertical.
And then you just make sure that the foot is nice and relaxed
and then you measure, I put an inclinometer
on the top of the foot and it measures the angle.
So say on the good side, it might be 17 degrees.
So 17 degrees of planiflexion.
On the affected side, it might be 10 degrees.
So they've got seven degrees of deficit
of that planiflexion.
So that would be an indication
that there's something going on there.
The resting angle varies a lot as well.
Some people have almost no resting planiflexion.
In those cases, there's not much of a difference
between resting and the affected side.
So that can also be a little bit hard with some people.
But generally, it's a more sensitive
or more reliable test than the Simmons or calf squeeze.
- And that's without any pressure.
You just basically resting that inclinometer
on the foot and just assessing that
with the angle rather than any pressure.
- Yeah, exactly.
And you can also do the same just lying over prone
with the feet dangling over the edge of the bed.
The only difference is you're picking up a bit more,
you're picking up a bit more gastroc there.
Because the gastroc is on a bit more tension.
So you can do both.
I generally would do the knee flex one, primarily.
- Yeah, okay.
And then to say your patient comes in,
they've had that history that's pretty common
with the Achilles tendon rupture.
You've done those tests and you suspect now
that you're pretty confident that they've got
in the Achilles tendon rupture.
You've done metals tests
and it's got increased dorsiflexion.
You've done, you've palpated,
you can feel it may be a defect and maybe your Thompson
test is positive.
So you've got a bunch of strong positives.
You think, yeah, okay, we're likely to have this year.
What's your first stage of management there in the clinic?
- The first stage of management is lots of education.
So it's like, okay, this is the pathway.
This is what's gonna happen.
Then it's a patient-centered decision around treatment.
So surgery versus non-surgical.
Then it's education around,
most people say, look, I want to see a surgeon anyway.
Just for an opinion.
And I encourage that.
I think it's very important to involve a surgeon
just to say, look, give an opinion.
They're experts in Achilles ruptures.
I see a foot and ankle surgeon.
So then the next step would be getting them into a boot,
make sure the boot is fitted properly.
And it could be a vac compared,
which is the hinged boot,
or it could be just a moon boot,
as long as they're in the right amount of planiflexion.
Some people, if you're in hospital, they go with like a cast.
initially for the first two weeks and non-weight bearing,
but I don't think it matters too much
if they're in a boot, as long as you're in the right position.
The other huge bit of education is around
what they should be doing.
So making sure they're not weight bearing in the boot
initially, making sure they're keeping the boot on
all the time, including when they sleep.
Some people will say, take the boot off at night.
I tend to tell them to keep the boot on at night
'cause I think that things can happen
when you're sleeping and moving around.
Then there's education about walking with the crutches,
like how to walk with crutches.
There's education around activity, keeping active
with whatever aerobic and other stuff they can do.
Keep making sure they're doing anything they can
to the other side.
So there's all that stuff that I try and cover
in the first session.
There might be something for swelling.
So some ice coming out of the boot.
There might be something for maybe some compression
depending on how much swelling they have around the ankle.
That can vary as well.
And it can be, swelling can be an issue that stays
with them for a few weeks after the rupture
as well, sometimes even after they've got out of the boot.
So that often related to being on their feet of loss.
So education about that as well.
So there's all those things that I'll try and cover
pretty much day one with them.
You get them into the boot
and you give them all that education.
You talk to them about the surgical versus non-surgical pathways
and what's your advice to patients that are thinking,
"Ah, I don't know if I need to see a surgeon.
Would you manage them yourself?"
Or do you say you really should be under somebody particularly?
What's your general advice there?
My advice is always give them the option to see a surgeon
and I encourage that because I think it's important
to involve multidisciplinary team.
There might be something you'll have missed.
There might be something about that particular case
that might be more amenable to surgery.
Or so I would always get the surgeon's opinion
or at least offer them.
If they say, "Look, I really don't want to see the surgeon,
that's fine," but that's the way that I would approach it.
It's also good because then they've got the surgeon's protocol
and the surgeon will then come back
and they'll say, "Look, this is the protocol
"and you can work together and try
"and individualize that protocol with them."
Often I'll have a conversation with the surgeon to say,
"Look, this is the protocol, but we're going to try
"and accelerate a bit by doing this type of loading."
So some of the citacalfrase loading that we've talked about
and maybe accelerate some parts and try and slow down
some of the other parts.
I think it's good to have a conversation with them about that.
My go-to is to always get someone else involved as well.
Imaging wise, do you find that you will tend to request imaging
or they go see the surgeon, the surgeon requests imaging
or how commonly these imaging use
and what are the best types of imaging that you've found for that?
Yes, look, the most common one,
'cause it's a accessible ultrasound,
people will tend to look with ultrasound
and it's fine, it will pick up a rupture
if done by someone who knows what they're looking for.
So ultrasound, if you need to confirm the rupture
that it's really in cases where you're not sure
if there has been a rupture or if you're thinking
this person's been walking around
has been missed for a long time.
Let's see what's going on to see how much,
how much retraction of the muscle there has been.
So it's in those cases that generally would go for imaging.
Lovely.
Do you notice with the ultrasound that there's any misdiagnosis
very commonly or that there's errors within it?
It's a bit of, look, it is a bit of an art
more than a science ultrasound.
So for example, people talk about the gap
but it's not clear, everyone's got different ways
of measuring the gap and where does it start,
where does it finish.
Some people do dynamic ultrasounds
where they go in planiflexion and see the air position
and again, how much planiflexion do you go in?
So what position is the footing?
So there's all these variables that are not clear
from the literature but I think if you do a good ultrasound
dynamic assessment, you can pick it up.
Sometimes you see there's a few fibres
hanging on like a partial tear and that would be a case
where you don't have a positive metals test
and you won't have a positive Thompson's test either.
So you can't see several of those cases
and that's where ultrasound can be quite useful
'cause you're thinking this guy can't really do a car phrase
but he hasn't got any of these positives
for any of these other tests.
So then that makes it a little bit clearer
when you look with ultrasound.
- Lovely and there's just two, two final things
that I want to chat through with you before we wrap this up
'cause we covered a lot of great stuff.
So time frame, so if someone comes in
and they've cutely ruptured,
they've got lots of options on the table.
When they come in and they're a little bit down the track,
maybe it's been a while, it's been missed.
How does that impact their treatment options?
- So generally if they down the track a bit,
it will be more important to go and see a surgeon
and have imaging.
So definitely get them to see a surgeon.
The other good thing about imaging actually,
which we haven't touched on is it does localize
where the tendon rupture is.
So if you've got clear, clear palpation of the defect
in the ropey part of the tendon,
you don't need imaging.
But if you can't feel that,
but they've got all the signs of a rupture,
it's most likely it's an insurginal
or muscle tendon junction rupture.
And they will then need imaging to confirm that.
So that's where imaging can also be important.
Make sure you do imaging
if you're not getting that palpable gap.
- Yeah. - If they've been a delayed presentation,
then you're going to send them off to the surgeon
to just make sure we find out what their best options really are.
- Exactly. - So I think that answers that really nicely.
And finally, just when we're looking after patients,
whether they've had surgery or a non-surgical pathway,
what are some of the things that people need to keep an eye out for
when they're going through their rehab process,
their potential red flags,
what things that could pop up that we need to be aware of?
- Yeah, there are a few complications to consider.
So the most common one is DVT.
People will get a DVT because it's a stuck in the boot for a while.
So making sure they're not getting any symptoms
and signs of DVT is important.
Surgery does have more complications than non-surgical.
So you've got things like obviously infections
and you've also got nerve damage
that can occur after surgery.
So just being conscious of those complications,
look checking the wound
and checking healing of the wound is important after.
The complications that happen more commonly
with non-surgical are the re-rupture.
So with non-surgical,
and this is a contentious debate topic.
People have reported in the literature
pretty consistently that there's a bit more re-rupture
with non-surgical, but it's very, very small.
So this is what I explained to patients.
And there's a really good patient decision aid, actually,
by Josh Zadrow from Sydney Uni,
which is about the decision of whether people should have
surgery or non-surgical for Achilles tendon rupture.
It goes through all the risks,
but the key one to consider if you had to go non-surgical
is that you have a higher chance of re-rupture.
But the chance is, I think it goes from two out of 100
to five out of 100, so it's still quite small.
And when you put it in those terms,
most patients are happy to take that risk on
as they're then reducing the risk of some of the other things
that can happen from a complications point of view.
So there are the main ones.
And obviously, elongation is also a risk,
but that is the same regardless of whether you have surgery
or you don't have surgery.
So there's no difference in elongation
with anything in the literature.
Pretty much people have been looking to try and do things
to reduce elongation for years, if not decades,
but there's really nothing that we know of at the moment
that can really reduce elongation.
So we don't have a good handle on it.
And that's where all the accelerated rehab stuff
came into it years ago.
The Willets-Pate Bar, that we've talked about,
that was the first one in the early 2000s.
The whole rationale behind it was to reduce elongation
and improve outcomes and reduce re-rupture,
but you can do any of those things unfortunately.
And all the rates were exactly the same.
So accelerated rehab basically means accelerated walking
coming out of the boot, which does not help elongation.
You brought up a good point there,
because that was actually one of the things
from early on in the interview where you brought up
one of the questions that patients ask their episodes,
how much walking can I do,
and they're often not sure how to answer that.
I said we're gonna wrap it up,
but I think we've actually got two more questions
that are, and one of those is about that walking
and how you can guide patients on that.
Yeah, yeah, no problem at all.
As soon as they get out of the boot,
my priority and the patient's priorities,
minimal walking, and what I call protected walking.
So protected walking is small step length,
wearing really good high shoes,
wearing the heel wedge, all that stuff.
And I just progress based on their comfort.
Usually they'll get a lot of calf cramping, fatigue,
soreness, and just progress gradually.
So they might progress a few hundred meters,
or a little bit longer.
I tend to track either.
how far they're going in terms of meters or steps.
So it's quite fine for them to progress up
to two, three, four thousand steps in the first six weeks,
but I try and put a cap on it.
And the reason is if they're walking too much,
that's when elongation occurs.
So if you think about what usually happens
when you go to the surgeon at 12 weeks,
the surgeon will say, or even at eight weeks,
if you're doing the Willett's program,
the surgeon will say, right, you're out of the boot, off you go.
You don't need to worry about anything.
And that's usually the advice they get from the surgeon.
And that's why surgeons, if you really talk to them,
they love working with physios
who have got some more advice around that,
because they usually say, go to the physio,
the physio will tell you what to do.
And they want us to fill the gaps
in terms of what to do after.
So then the patient comes to me and says,
the surgeon said to me, just go off do whatever you want.
And I say to them, right, just let's just,
let's just slow that down a little bit.
We'll start with a little bit of walking
and we'll progress gradually.
I think it's the elongation happens
when people are gun-ho,
they come out of the boot
and they think they can do everything.
So that's a key, key risk time for elongation.
So that's also a very important education point
to tell patients that we've got to slow them down
around that point.
- Finally, when you've got patients
they've come out of the boot
and you're progressing through their rehab
and you talk through some nice ways
that you guide patients while they're in the boot
and into that in a range plan of flexion
and increasing their plan of flexor strength.
After they come out and you're starting
to get them working into more isotonic exercises,
what sort of sets and reps do you help to guide them
with do you tend to have a go-to that you tend to use with patients?
- Then it becomes a bit like a Achilles tendon rehab.
So it's a bit like a strengthen conditioning type approach
on trying to build some endurance
or trying to build some higher heavy load strength
with six repetitions type dosages.
I'll try and do that two or three times a week.
We'll get to one leg really good strength
and then we'll put in some power after that.
So it's just just structured rehab after that
and yeah that's the process.
It becomes very similar to just looking at an Achilles tendon
in terms of recovering strength.
- Are you worried about targeting hypertrophy specifically
or that comes if it comes or what's your thoughts there?
- Yeah, I think hypertrophy, that is a real,
that's important.
So I'll include some dosages where initially
I start eight to 12 repetitions then work down.
But we also know that hypertrophy will still
be there most likely, pretty much forever.
Just like the tendons gonna be thicker,
pretty much forever.
Although if you look at them two or three years down,
the track, the tendon is almost,
almost looking healthy for some people.
It's much thinner and really healthy.
So it's amazing how I can recover.
But we know that Achilles tendon is so complex,
you've got some tendons, you've got the tendon
from gastroch, medius, gastroch, lateralis,
you've got the Celeste and male intertwined
and you're never gonna reproduce that in a ruptured Achilles.
So you're never gonna get intricate tendon arrangement
and hierarchical organization of tendon back again,
but you can get a functional tendon
that is working well, just like you can get a functional tendon
that looks not very good on ultrasound.
So it's amazing how adaptable the tissue is.
I think the problem we have at the moment
is we just don't give ourselves long enough
to rehab things like this.
And I think that's a great place to wrap it up.
And there are any sort of key messages
that you wanna reinforce for people that are seeing these.
My message would be have that dialogue with a surgeon,
involve people and think about the tissue here,
like think about tendon stress,
think about what's gonna get those tendon cells
to start to signal that this needs to be a tendon
that we're gonna get stronger again
and putting some load through the tendon a little bit earlier.
So I guess take-home messages load more in safe positions
but delay the walking until they've got a stronger tendon.
- Perfect.
And that's lovely, it's been a fascinating chat.
We've really explored a lot around Achilles tendon ruptures
and it's obviously some exciting stuff going on within the space
and it's great to see people applying that clinically
and seeing where to portion what makes sense clinically
and how to target those deficiencies
and their elongation that often happens.
So it's been really interesting chat, really enjoyed it.
Tell us Peter, we can people find out more about
what you've got going on and that's sort of thing.
- Fantastic, thank you so much for having me on, David.
It was a pleasure and that one and a half hours passed
very quickly, so that's good.
I guess the main thing is if you've got an Achilles rupture,
if you wanna get in touch,
we do our Achilles rupture service
at OrthoSport Victoria in Melbourne.
If you want to learn about Achilles ruptures
or Achilles or just tendon opathy in general,
I've got online courses that are at tendonopathyrehab,
oneword.com.
And I do stuff there.
We've got a new course coming out on Achilles rupture.
- Absolutely.
- Excellent, very soon.
And we've also got a new tendon course coming out.
So yeah, that's probably the best place.
But if you're finishing, you just got questions,
just email me.
That's absolutely fine.
- Excellent.
I'm holding encourage people to check those all out.
You've got some great resources there
and lots of great thoughts.
And what about on social media work,
what's the best place for people to follow you?
- Social media.
The main one I'm getting into these days linked in,
but I'm also on X and I'm starting to get into Instagram.
But I think I'm, no, it's not something
that comes naturally to my Instagram.
I think I'm a bit old for Instagram.
- All right, well, there's some great places
to follow along.
So jump on over and give Peter a follow
and check out these resources
and online courses coming out.
Once again, much appreciated Peter.
It was awesome to share so much great information
with people and I hope people have got lots of awesome ideas.
Thanks again.
- Thanks very much, David.
Thanks, Peter, that was awesome.
I hope you enjoyed that podcast.
Peter shared a ton of great information
on Achilles tendon ruptures, lots of stuff.
It really accelerates the knowledge that we have
about how to approach these sort of injuries
and how to get the best results with your patients.
So lots of great stuff.
Remember, check out Peter, say hi to him on LinkedIn
and also check out his website,
where he's got a ton of great resources there
to have a look at.
To go along with the podcast, you've got your free resources,
you've got your summary handout.
So make sure you grab that one
when we summarize the key points and the take-home messages
and that's over at clinicaledge.co/podcast
and we've got our free video series with Tom Goom
on Achilles tendon opathy
and also your tricky tendons, video and infographic free series
and grab your access to your clinicaledge membership
that's gonna help you with all the other patients
you're gonna see in your clinic
to help you know how to assess them,
how to treat them and how to get great results.
So grab your access to that at clinicaledge.co/freetrial.
So grab all those resources
and I look forward to seeing you
on the next physio edge podcast.
See ya.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Achilles tendon ruptures are commonly missed in emergency departments, with up to 30% of cases going undiagnosed due to normal dorsiflexion and equivocal diagnostic tests.
Re-rupture risk is low (2–5%) with proper management, while tendon elongation is a more significant and common issue affecting function and strength.
The location of the rupture (insertional, mid-portion, or muscle-tendon junction) influences treatment, with insertional tears typically requiring surgery and mid-portion tears often managed conservatively.
Imaging does not reduce elongation risk, and early diagnosis and boot immobilization (with wedges) are crucial to minimize tissue damage and healing complications.
Progressive, controlled loading in safe plantar flexion positions—such as isometric holds and Smith machine exercises—improves tendon strength and helps reverse elongation.
Early rehabilitation (starting at 3–4 weeks) includes isometric pushing and range-of-motion exercises, avoiding dorsiflexion to prevent further elongation.
Elongation leads to inefficient muscle-tendon units, reduced calf strength, fatigue during activity, and long-term functional limitations despite improved range.
A growing body of clinical evidence supports conservative management as equally effective as surgery, with outcomes driven more by rehab quality than surgical intervention.
Summary:
Achilles tendon ruptures are often misdiagnosed, especially in patients who retain dorsiflexion ability, leading to delayed treatment and poor outcomes. While re-rupture risk remains low (2–5%), tendon elongation is a more significant issue affecting strength, efficiency, and function. The rupture site—insertional, mid-portion, or muscle-tendon junction—determines treatment pathways, with insertional tears typically requiring surgery and others managed conservatively.
Imaging does not improve outcomes or reduce elongation risk, emphasizing the need for early diagnosis and immobilization. A progressive, safe rehabilitation protocol—starting with isometric holds in plantar flexion and progressing to loaded calf raises in a Smith machine—is critical. Early mobilization (3–4 weeks post-injury) includes controlled range-of-motion exercises, avoiding dorsiflexion to prevent elongation.
Over time, elongation may reverse with consistent, progressive loading, especially in the early healing phase. Tendon healing is highly adaptable, with ultrasound showing a transition from disorganized tissue to parallel collagen alignment over 6–12 months. Outcomes are better with structured rehab than with delayed or inappropriate loading.
Patient education on the risks of elongation and reassurance about pain tolerance are vital. A key clinical takeaway is that conservative management with proper rehabilitation is as effective as surgery, and functional recovery depends more on rehab quality than on surgical intervention. Research is ongoing to validate these protocols in large-scale trials, with a focus on measuring elongation, strength, and function over time.
FAQs
Achilles ruptures are frequently missed, especially in younger patients who retain dorsiflexion. Diagnosis requires a thorough clinical assessment, including the Thompson’s test, and careful evaluation of the mechanism of injury. Imaging may be needed if there’s a delay in presentation, but it doesn’t reduce the risk of elongation. Ultrasound is essential to identify the exact location of the tear, as ruptures can occur in the mid-portion, muscle-tendon junction, or insertion, and misdiagnosis can occur if only one section is assessed.
No, surgery is not always required. Outcomes between surgical and non-surgical management are similar. Surgery is more likely in younger, more active patients, especially those in elite sport, while many patients—especially older adults—do well with conservative treatment like boot immobilization and rehabilitation.
Tendon elongation is a more common and significant issue than re-rupture. Re-rupture risk is low (2–5%), but elongation can lead to long-term weakness, poor calf function, and reduced efficiency in activities like walking and hopping. Elongation often occurs due to delayed treatment or improper loading in the early rehab phase.
The tear location influences management: insertional ruptures are typically repaired surgically, mid-portion tears can be managed conservatively or surgically with similar outcomes, and muscle-tendon junction tears are rarely repaired and are usually managed conservatively.
Early rehab can begin as early as three to four weeks post-injury, starting with isometric calf pushes and range-of-motion exercises in a safe, plantar flexion position. Avoiding dorsiflexion initially helps prevent elongation and protects the healing tissue.
Elongation can be reduced by maintaining safe, controlled loading in plantar flexion, using progressive resistance training (e.g., Smith machine exercises), and ensuring patients achieve at least 70–80% body weight during calf raises. Early and consistent loading in a controlled range helps signal tendon adaptation and reduces long-term elongation.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.