Go back

Accountability, Boundaries, and That Person You Don't Want To See

22m 22s

Accountability, Boundaries, and That Person You Don't Want To See

In this solo Q&A episode, Whitney Goodman addresses controversial social media comments and listener questions about accountability and family estrangement. She argues that holding children accountable for typical childhood behaviors is often unfair, as kids are not little adults and lack the capacity for adult-level responsibility. Instead, parents must model accountability and avoid blaming children for their own reactions, such as yelling or name-calling, which can damage relationships into adulthood. For estranged adult children, Goodman advises preparing for accidental run-ins by role-playing scenarios, setting boundaries, and building self-trust to manage anxiety. She emphasizes that while anticipation of encounters is often the worst part, unpredictable family reactions may still occur, and support networks are crucial. Addressing a listener’s concern about a wife reluctant to reconcile with willing parents, Goodman explains that the wife’s fear and lack of trust are likely rooted in past failed attempts at repair. She encourages partners to be patient, curious, and supportive without pushing, acknowledging that the desire for family healing is natural but must respect the individual’s timeline. The episode concludes with an invitation for listeners to submit their own questions.

Transcription

3544 Words, 19107 Characters

English
(upbeat music) Hey everyone, welcome back to The Calling Home Podcast. This is Whitney Goodman. Today we are going to be having a solo Q&A episode. I'm gonna dive a little bit into some of the comments that I got on social media, go into some of the posts that I put up lately that have been maybe a little bit more controversial or evoked some strong emotions in people. And then I'm going to take real listener questions from The Calling Home Voice Mailbox. So let's go ahead and get started. I put up a post on TikTok last week that I got an interesting response to. And this post was about parents taking accountability for the parenting choices that they made. And someone commented back and said, I also find it curious that it's always the parent's fault. Never do you hear accountability or ownership of the kids and the role they played. So I wanna dive a little bit deeper into this idea of accountability and accountability especially of children about things that they did in their childhood. Asking a child to be accountable for what they did in childhood often doesn't really make sense. Because at that age, the child was acting in a way that was probably developmentally appropriate. They were just being a kid, right? So what types of things are we trying to hold kids accountable for? Let's really think about that. Is it that they are being loud? That they didn't put their toys away, that they didn't listen on the first try? These are all things that we would expect from a child's, their kids, their not adults. And what gets really tricky in this conversation is that when we expect children to be held accountable for how they were behaving, we are expecting them to do something that they are not capable of doing. And we're also taking the accountability off of the adults and putting it on to the child. So this gets really problematic when a parent does something and then blames the child for that parenting decision. So let's walk through an example. Let's say that I have a kid that yells and they're being really loud and they're throwing things and I snap at them and we've all been there, right? I'm a parent, I understand what it's like to get to that point where you feel like, oh my gosh, I'm not even control myself anymore, I'm just gonna snap. And so let's say you then yell at your kid, you scream at them, you grab their arm, whatever it is that you do. And then you say to them, I wouldn't have done that if you didn't yell and throw that toy. That's the only reason why I did that to you. So in that moment we're saying, I'm not accountable for my actions. I don't have to be held accountable for how I just parented because this child set me off and they are the reason why I did that. And when these conversations happen in childhood between parents and their kids, they often continue into adulthood. And so that's usually who I work with as a therapist, right? Are the adult kids who are wanting to have better relationships with their parents or wanting to navigate that relationship in a different way. And so if you're an adult child and you bring up a situation where you say, you know mom, I'm really upset about how you used to yell at me every day when I got home from school and you used to tell me that I was a bad kid and you go into all this stuff and the parent says, well, I only did that because you were bad. You were a really hard kid to parent. You were so difficult. You made my life so hard. I didn't have a choice. We are in that moment asking our children or your parent is asking you to hold all the accountability for why they did what they did. And this is totally unfair dynamic, right? Because kids can't be as powerful as adults. Kids are not little adults. Kids cannot be held accountable in the same way as their parents. And so you cannot put that accountability on your child. The other thing I see happening here that is tricky is that there is a huge power differential between parents and their children. And this is especially true in childhood, but this continues into adulthood. And so you as the parent or for any kids listening, your parent is always going to hold some power over you, even when you are both adults. And I think we have to remember that when we're having these conversations, is that the parent is coming to this with a different perspective. They're having a totally different conversation with their adult child. You are remembering things differently. You have more context likely of the situation. You are not coming to this in the same position as your child. And it's important to remember that the adult child might be coming to you as an adult to say like, "Hey, mom, this bothered me, but they're not feeling the feelings of an adult in that situation." They're thinking about how they felt as a child. And so we as parents have to think about how would this have felt for that 12-year-olds? How would this have felt for that five-year-olds who didn't have any power, who didn't have any context, who didn't have any options in this situation? And how can I put myself in that position when I'm having this conversation with my adult child? I want to dive into another comment that I got on this topic. And that is someone's side. I think it's completely expected that it's 16, they have the capability to be accountable for lots of things, being honest, disrespectful, rude, et cetera. And 100%, like kids, teens, young adults, they have to learn accountability, but that accountability has to be developmentally appropriate, and accountability has to be modeled and taught in the home, right? So the parents have to model accountability, and the parents also have to have reasonable expectations for what a child can be accountable for, and what the consequences to that accountability look like. So I think sometimes we expect way more out of kids than we'd even do out of adults, right? We expect them to never be loud, to never make a mess, to never forget something. We expect them to always listen on the first try, and we as adults don't do that. We hold ourselves to much looser standards, and we often want much more forgiveness than we're willing to give our children. And so when we're talking about holding kids or teens accountable, I think it's important to think about what is a reasonable level of accountability for this person at this age. So there are certain things that a, quote unquote, regular teenager could be accountable for, right? You know, maybe that's cleaning up after themselves, getting places on time, handling their own lunch for school. Like there are things that they can be held accountable for. Now that being said, a teen being held accountable for their own actions doesn't mean that they also have to be held accountable for evoking a reaction and emotions in us. So I want to go back to the example that I used when I was responding to that last comment is that if my teen messes up and they do something wrong and they upset me, and I decide to scream and throw things and call them names, that's not their fault. They don't need to be held accountable for that. I need to be held accountable for how I chose to respond in that moment, and the teen needs to be held accountable for the mistake that they made. So let's say they didn't get to school on time for a week. And now there are consequences to that. They may not get privileges on social media or maybe they're going to get in trouble at school or whatever the natural consequence is to that lack of accountability. But we cannot blame our children for evoking certain reactions in us that are extreme and cruel. And if they come back to us later in life and say every time I made a mistake, mom, you would call me names, you would berate me, you would criticize me, you would withhold love and affection from me. It is incorrect to say, well, I wouldn't have done that if you weren't such a bad kid because there is no child on this planet that isn't worthy just by their mere state of being alive, of our love, respect, and our consistency as parents, the way that your child acts does not negate that. And so I think for the adult in the world who are struggling with reconciling their relationships with their parents, this is a big belief and a big like really deep conditioning that you have to unravel is that You were not so bad. bad that it made your parents treat you bad. That's a reflection of them. It is not a reflection of your worth as a human being. This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance, Fiscally Responsible, Financial Geniuses, Monetary Magicians. These are things people say about drivers who switch their car insurance to Progressive and Save Hundreds. Visit Progressive.com to see if you could save. Progressive Cash-Ultime Insurance Company and Affiliates. Potential savings will vary, not available in all states or situations. I've been using the Jones Road Maricle Ballm every single day. I love how easy it is to put on. It never looks cakey. I can use it on my cheeks, forehead, eyes, and put it on with my fingers. I can do it from anywhere and everywhere. It really is the best and has changed how I use makeup. Especially on those really busy mornings where I'm dropping off my kids, but I still want to look semi-put together. I love using it. They also have a full line-up of effortless skin for staples. They're just enough tinted moisturizer, which is lightweight. It smooths an even skin tone with a soft touch of coverage and hides redness, looks natural, and feels like nothing is on your skin. Modern day makeup that's clean, strategic, and multifunctional for effortless routines. For a limited time, our listeners are getting a free, cool gloss on their first purchase when they use the code "Calling Home" at checkout. Just head to jonesroadbeauty.com and use the code "Calling Home" at checkout. After you purchase, they will ask you where you heard about them. Please support our show and tell them our show sent you. All right, now let's dive into some listener questions and play some of those voice mails from the "Calling Home" mailbox. This might sound weird, but I'm trying to make myself kind of small. All looked down, I won't try to make eye contact with anyone. I get kind of anxious. It's really because I'm worried about running into my mom or my sister. We've had no contact for a while. Now a few years, the relationship was toxic. They were gaslighting me. They were belittling me. I was getting blamed for everything. It was just awful. But I'm struggling with how to best handle when I actually end up running into them on accident. I've been avoiding family gatherings, like funerals and reunions and all of that. I've also distanced myself from relatives, except for my brother, because I just don't know how to respond to the questions as to what happened. I just don't want to get into it. Is there anything I can do here to feel more comfortable in my own town where I'm living and not have that constant anxiety of running into them? Any help would be super appreciated. Thanks. So the first thing I want to say is that it makes complete sense that you would feel anxious about running into family members or people that you're estranged from and not wanting to answer questions from people or have those run-ins. I think so many people feel this way. So if you're estranged and you live in an area where you might run into someone that you don't speak to, I think this will be helpful for you. The first thing I would do is realize that the anticipation of the event and wondering when and if it will happen is often one of the worst parts. So this feeling that you're walking around with where you feel like when am I going to run into them? What will happen if I run into them? What will they do? What will I say? What will they think? That is one of the worst feelings that can come from all of this. What's also happening here is that you likely don't trust yourself or believe in your ability to handle what's going to come at you, which is also very normal. So what I would want to do is have you get more in touch with what would be your ideal scenario if this were to happen because it probably will at some point. And what options are available to you and how much control can you assert over the situation. So this person mentioned that they live in a smaller town and that you may run into someone on the street at the grocery store, whatever. I would want to roleplay. This could be helpful to do with a therapist or with someone else that you trust. If you could roleplay what might happen if I run into them on the street, if I run into them in the produce aisle. What I want to say hello, what I want to just keep walking, what would I do if they said something to me? What am I comfortable sharing? What are my hard limits and boundaries in this situation and trying to practice what this would look like? What feelings might come up for you? What are the things that you definitely do not want to do or say in this situation? And the more you rehearse this, the more comfortable you feel about your ability to respond in a way that is congruent with your values and your beliefs and how you feel as a person, the less scary that it will feel. It's also important to practice this belief of, I know this is going to happen at some point. I will run into them. I will see them and I will get through it. I will handle it even if it sets me, even if it's really difficult for me, I will get through this and building your confidence in that situation can be helpful. May also be good to think about, is there someone that I could call if this happens? Is there someone that could support me, someone that understands my situation and that could validate what I'm going through or the difficult decision that I had to make? Now, of course, the really unknown wild card factor here is that you don't know how your family will respond in these situations. And I think for some people there is a fear that they could yell or say something mean or do something really rude. And I don't think there's really anything that can totally prepare you for a family member doing that, especially in a public place when you are estranged. And so to anybody that's going through that or has gone through that, I think it's just hard and I can't sugarcoat that. And that is a moment when if when that happens, it's good to surround yourself with people that can really bring you back to that deep place of knowing of like, this is why I can't have a relationship with this person. I am not the crazy one here. If someone has chosen to be abusive to me in some way to yell at me to call me names, that is further evidence of what I need to do in this situation. It's also very common for people to be engaging in fantasy making, you know, when it comes to this stuff, whether that's negative or positive. So thinking about all the things that could go wrong, all the things that they could say to you that are bad and also maybe hoping like maybe I'll run into them and they'll hug me and we'll say, I forgive you and everything will be good again and they will magically be this other person. And I just want to validate that if anybody is doing that, I understand why you would do that. And I think it's important to live in this space of like, I can have hope for that and wish for that and dream that and like really would love if that happened. And I also make space for the other reality that this person may not become the person that can give me something like that. All right, let's go ahead and take another call. I'm calling about my wife. She necessarily have the best childhood growing up wasn't really the best situation for her rough. Her parents have asked for forgiveness and they reached out and they're open to talking to my wife about the experiences that she had as a child and why it sucked and all of it. And they're willing to do therapy and do whatever it takes to make things better. She's just not open to it and it makes matters worse. I got a buddy who's in a similar situation and I was just wondering if you could have learned some advice to, you know, how do I help them move forward? Thanks. I'll go forward to hearing. I think it's really wonderful that your wife's parents want to go to therapy that they're willing to make amends and they're willing to move forward. I think it's also wonderful that you're concerned about this and that you want to be supportive of your wife. And I imagine that there is a deep level of pain for you as well that probably doesn't get acknowledged enough that this is also hard for you and it's hard to see your wife go through something like this. The insight that I want to give here is that when I hear people whose parents are ready to move forward, they want to make amends and the child saying, I'm not ready. I can't do that in this case. Your wife, I imagine if I had to put myself in your wife's shoes that she's feeling a lot of fear and trepidation and anxiety about moving forward and maybe not feeling like she can trust that her parents are really ready to make amends and heal. And I would imagine that that belief is formed possibly from faulty attempt at repair, not being able to trust in the past, something like that. I don't know the details of the situation, but this tends to be what gets people tripped up. I would also bet if I made an assumption that your wife probably wants things to be better, and she doesn't want things to be like this. She's just scared of the fallout or the feelings that could come up if it doesn't work, and she lets them in again. For you as a partner with that knowledge, I think it's about supporting your wife in the space that she's in and knowing that even though you understand and you're there for her, you'll never really understand what it was like to have her parents as her parents, and you'll never understand maybe what she went through or what led to this fallout. Her parents might be making compelling arguments to you or you might feel like they really genuinely want to move forward, but it's hard for you to totally put yourself in that position. No, that being said, I think it's okay to make room to have conversations about what scares you about letting your parents back in. What would it look like? What has happened in the past when you tried to make amends with them, and really just try to get curious about her experience and what she might be going through and have extreme patience. I know that's really hard because I think deep down everyone just wants their family to be okay and to be functioning and to be healthy, and we want that for our partners as well. Thank you so much for sending in your questions this week. I hope listening to those questions and the insights helped you feel less alone and maybe gave you the confidence to navigate a difficult situation you're having in your own family. If you would like to leave me a voicemail or ask a question in an upcoming episode, please call 866-225-5466. I'll see you at home again soon. [Music]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Parents should not hold children accountable for developmental behaviors (e.g., being loud, not listening) or for triggering parental reactions; accountability must be developmentally appropriate and modeled by adults.
  2. In parent-child conflicts, there is a power differential; adult children often revisit childhood feelings, and parents must take responsibility for their own actions rather than blaming the child.
  3. For estranged individuals, anxiety about accidental encounters can be reduced by rehearsing responses, setting boundaries, and building confidence in handling the situation, while accepting that family reactions may be unpredictable.
  4. When one family member is ready to reconcile but another is not, it is important to respect the hesitant person’s fear and need for trust, supporting them without pressure.

Summary:

In this solo Q&A episode, Whitney Goodman addresses controversial social media comments and listener questions about accountability and family estrangement. She argues that holding children accountable for typical childhood behaviors is often unfair, as kids are not little adults and lack the capacity for adult-level responsibility. Instead, parents must model accountability and avoid blaming children for their own reactions, such as yelling or name-calling, which can damage relationships into adulthood.

For estranged adult children, Goodman advises preparing for accidental run-ins by role-playing scenarios, setting boundaries, and building self-trust to manage anxiety. She emphasizes that while anticipation of encounters is often the worst part, unpredictable family reactions may still occur, and support networks are crucial. Addressing a listener’s concern about a wife reluctant to reconcile with willing parents, Goodman explains that the wife’s fear and lack of trust are likely rooted in past failed attempts at repair.

She encourages partners to be patient, curious, and supportive without pushing, acknowledging that the desire for family healing is natural but must respect the individual’s timeline. The episode concludes with an invitation for listeners to submit their own questions.

FAQs

Children's behaviors like being loud or not listening are often developmentally appropriate. Expecting accountability for such actions ignores their capabilities and shifts responsibility from adults, creating an unfair dynamic.

Parents should model accountability by owning their own reactions and setting reasonable, age-appropriate expectations. For example, a parent should take responsibility for yelling instead of blaming the child's behavior.

Practice role-playing scenarios with a trusted person to build confidence in how you'll respond. Remember that anticipation is often the worst part, and focus on your ability to handle the situation in line with your values.

Acknowledge their fear and lack of trust, and avoid pressuring them. Get curious about their past experiences with failed amends, and offer patience while respecting their readiness.

Plan your ideal response, such as a brief greeting or walking away. Have a support person to call afterward, and remind yourself that any negative behavior from them confirms your need for distance.

They may fear that past patterns of hurt will repeat, or they lack trust in the parents' genuine change. The emotional risk of letting them back in can feel overwhelming.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.