Abdul El-Sayed Trolls Trump With an Offer He Might Actually Accept
18m 52s
As a new Democratic Congress takes shape, healthcare policy debates are reigniting with renewed energy. Senator Elect Abdul-El-Sayed’s satirical "Trump Care" proposal, calling on Donald Trump to endorse a Medicare for all plan, serves as both a political troll and a strategic move to broaden the appeal of universal healthcare. It underscores a broader trend: even within progressive politics, there’s growing recognition that policies like Medicare for all could gain traction if framed as broadly acceptable—even with conservative figures. Trump’s own history of intervening in prescription drug pricing through Trump Rx shows a willingness to use government action in healthcare, suggesting a shift from pure market conservatism. Inside the Democratic Party, three distinct camps exist—full Medicare for all, incremental reform, and centrist compromise—though there is now a stronger consensus on achieving universal coverage. In the near term, Democrats are likely to push for achievable reforms such as lowering Medicare eligibility age, expanding Medicare to include dental and vision, or automatically enrolling children into health programs. These steps serve as both policy milestones and practical training in legislative negotiation. While major reforms remain politically challenging, this period offers a unique opportunity to rebuild party cohesion, strengthen bipartisan communication, and lay the groundwork for future legislative success. The outcome remains uncertain, but the strategic openness and cross-ideological experimentation signal a pivotal shift in how healthcare policy is being approached.
Hi, everybody. Welcome to Bullwork Takes. I am Andrew Eger with the Bullwork joined by my colleague, Jonathan Cohen, our policy reporter extraordinaire to talk about health care. We have a new blue Congress coming in, lots of new democratic representatives and senators, these policy fights that have been sort of shoved down for a while. They're coming back to the surface. We're going to be doing a lot of fighting over Medicare for all or maybe not fighting, maybe just negotiating over Medicare for all things like this in the weeks, months, years ahead. But we're going to talk about that first. We have a little bit of a wackier thing about all of this, a little bit more fun because one of these incoming senators, Senator Elect Abdul-El-Sayed, has been pursuing his own interesting bespoke. Let's make a deal strategy on Medicare for all and it is Trump care. This is a tweet he put up just yesterday. This is a message for real Donald Trump. Donald, this is on the table. Trump care, the Trump care card, guarantee health care for every American from cradle to grave. You get credit as the president. We'll name it after you in perpetuity. Jonathan, I don't know if people really think this is likely exactly or plausible at all or going to happen. But it is sort of an interesting move that we are seeing from Abdul-El-Sayed right out of the gate here. Yeah, yeah. So what says I think a lot about our current political moment and our current president that I had to think about two minutes. Like, huh, if they passed a Medicare for all-build and called it Trump care, would he sign it? And I had to actually contemplate that because it's crazy, but you know, this is Donald Trump, you never know. Now, honestly, no, of course that's not going to happen. But you know, I think a few things are going on here. I mean, look, I covered El-Sayed in his Michigan Senate race. The guy likes to troll people this party. So this is a troll. Number one, number two, I do think there are, we can talk about this later, but you know, there are smaller, more discreet healthcare reform pieces that the Democrats could pass that you could imagine a version of those Trump signing. So maybe this is kind of seeding the ground for that. But then I think most of all, El-Sayed is a passionate long time believer wrote a book on Medicare for all, he thinks about the long game. And I think this is part of his effort to build a broader constituency for this, in part by saying, "Hey, this idea is something that even a mega Republican could like." So I think that's all what's going on there. I mean, I do think it's, it is an amazing troll in, in several respects, because one, you do actually have to stop and think about it. Like, I think you're totally right. I don't think this is, you know, the way we're going to pick the lock of healthcare policy in this country after the last, you know, 20 years of brutal, grinding trench warfare in the House and send it over some of these policies and the way that it divides the parties now. But it does speak to a lot of different things about Donald Trump. One is just this rabid desire that he does have to put his name on all sorts of things. And two, it's also true that Trump has broken in some interesting directions, some heterodox directions for Republicans on healthcare stuff specifically, so long as, as he has been able to put his name on it, right? I mean, Trump Rx is sort of the quintessential example of this, this, this, a far more, I mean, actually, let me just ask you to talk about that, John. I think he's like, "Why in the clock back 30 seconds on what Trump Rx is and was?" People haven't really been paying attention. Yeah, it's a great example. So Trump Rx, you know, Donald Trump campaigned, I'm going to bring prescription drug crisis down and what he did was he created a website called Trump Rx, where you can go to this website. Now, the way he sells it to you, he would have you believe that Trump Rx is going to bring you the lowest priced drugs anywhere in the world. You go to that website and you get them. No, that's not true. What Trump Rx does allow you to do is it basically, it lets you download coupons or go to other websites where you can get discounted drugs and we pay for them directly. Originally, it was just prescription drug. I think now they've started adding generic drugs. I don't think I need to check that. But, you know, it is a way for people who don't already have discounted drugs through their insurance companies to get lower drug prices. Yeah, it's helpful to some people. It is part of a larger effort to bring down drug prices that he has engaged in. Mostly what he has done is made these deals with some of the drug companies. These deals are secret. We don't know the terms of them on from the consumer facing end. God, could I just say consumer facing? I have been spending too much time with healthcare ones. From a normal person buying drugs, you know, what you'll find is that actually you can, you know, these deals have resulted in, in particular, GLP one drugs and other weight loss drugs, have some prices now have come down, some infertility drugs. For the most part, it's kind of, it's stuff around the margins, right? But like the interesting thing about it is just that Trump is willing to explicitly have the government get involved with these things at all. Whereas, you know, the normal conservative, the old school conservative approach would be just let the markets do it, let the markets work. And Trump is like, no, I want to, I've made this promise to get prescription drugs down. I have to do something to say that I've done that. So let's let's roll out this program. Let's call it TrumpRX. And I think the the Abdul thing speaks to that in interesting ways. This message is brought to you by Fair Harbor. So fall, obviously, it's the best time of year. I've been very open about my love of fall. There's the cooler weather. There's the football back on the TV. There's so many fun things to do outside. Apple picking, pumpkin picking, nice walks in the fall foliage. I admit, I like it. This podcast is brought to you by Fair Harbor. It's built for the shore made for the season. Now I feel like this time of year is all about being comfortable while looking good between holiday travel, family gatherings, dinners and friends, and everything else packed into the season. I want clothes that can do a little bit of everything. And that's exactly what Fair Harbor is all about. They've taken the comfort and quality that made their swimmer a favorite earning thousands of five star reviews. And they brought it to an entire collection of cold weather staples. Think about incredibly soft flannels, cozy sweaters, hoodies, pants and more. These are pieces that look great, but feel like you're wearing your favorite weekend clothes. And if you're still looking for gifts, well, you know, Fair Harbor is the great place to start. Their pieces are comfortable, thoughtfully made and practical in the best way. They're the kind of gifts people will genuinely get excited about and end up wearing on repeat long after the holidays are over. Head to fairharberclothing.com/Borwerktakes and use called Bullwerk20 for 20% off your first full price order now through November 30th. Once again, that's Fair Harbor, H-A-R-B-O-R clothing.com/Borwerktakes for 20% off and make sure you use the promo code Bullwerk20 so they know that we sent you. The other thing that's interesting before we turn away from Abdul is just there's almost this sense now that like if you are a centrist Democrat, almost the worst thing that you could do is be seen as working to openly or constructively with Donald Trump because that plays into the critiques that you get from your left that you're basically just like, what good are you? You know, you're you might as well basically be a Republican at this point, that kind of thing. Whereas if you are a progressive like Abdul El Sayed or someone like Zoran Mamdani in New York, you have more wiggle room almost to do these weird moves where maybe you can sort of zag and come out of left field and say, you know, here's a thing we might be able to agree on policy wise and get something done here. Again, I don't know whether whether any of that will survive contact with the real grinding policy negotiation when it comes to actually trying to get anything passed in the new year, but I thought that was kind of interesting too. Yeah, yeah. Well, like, yeah, it's like only Nixon could go to China. Maybe only Bernie Sanders can make a healthcare deal with Donald Trump, right? Because if you're a centrist or negotiating, it looks especially, oh, but if Bernie does it or Abdul El Sayed does it, whatever. Oh, well, they must see me among Donnie does it. And you know, drag maybe or maybe only Donald Trump can make a healthcare deal with Bernie Sanders on the other side of it, right? I mean, if he's if it's going to be socialized medicine or something like this that that would usually be kryptonite for the Republican base well until until it's a policy Donald Trump support. So I don't know, we're building these castles in the sky about all of this imagining these sorts of futures that almost certainly will not come to fruition, but it does just show. I mean, it's it's a very strange, very strange moment in policy in healthcare policy and elsewhere as we head into this new Congress. So I wanted to ask you, Jonathan, about this piece that you have written because you have actually done yeoman's work. You've done a great job laying out basically the camps, not not for this strange sort of bank shot, make a deal with Trump thing, but the different camps inside the democratic party. I mean, you've made the case that really there are perhaps more overlap in terms of the proposed policies between the Medicare for all camp and the let's not go so crazy camp if you could maybe call it that on the democratic side specifically. So who are the groups as we're as we're coming into this new Congress? Who are the groups and what are the fault lines here? Yeah. So I mean, the democratic party for a while now has kind of had three different camps, I would say. You know, there's the the Medicare for all camp that's Bernie Sanders, Pramila, Diapal, now Abdul Elsaid, they they they want to have a what we call a single pair system. The government is everybody's insurer. You know, maybe there's a vestigial small role for private insurance, maybe isn't, but you know, that is the goal and they want to get there anyway they can. You have on the other end, you have people who are interested in expanding healthcare, getting to universal healthcare to varying degrees, but for reasons that may be philosophical or practical, they think you know, talking about Medicare for all right now, it's it's too big a hill to climb. You know,
They may at the end of the day also think we should have private insurance as a choice. They don't want the government insuring everybody. But even there's a lot of people who, yeah, I like the idea of Medicare for all, but you know, this is one sixth of our economy. Really gonna rearrange it. Such a hard political fight we don't want to do that. And we have a bunch of people who are somewhere in the middle of that. And we have seen this fight play out before. And I think a lot about the 2020 Democratic presidential primaries, Andrew, I don't know if you remember them, but before COVID, there was this knock down drag out over Medicare for all. It was like a litmus test, right? And either if you weren't for the Bernie Sanders plan, then you did not believe in Medicare for all. And if you did not believe in Medicare for all, you did not believe in universal coverage. And the party kind of split. And in the end, it was Bernie and Joe Biden, Joe Biden gets the nomination. And then COVID comes and kind of, we don't really move forward on that debate. So now we're coming back to it. And for all kinds of reasons, you're debating healthcare reform again. And you saw it play out on last weekend, Adam Hamilton, newly elected senator from Kansas. We shouldn't do Medicare for all Bernie Sanders. We should do Medicare for all. But if you listen to both of them, and pretty much I think everyone in the party right now, everybody really is on board with it. We should get to universal healthcare somehow. They really, that is, I would say even more so than 10 years ago. That is a unified position of the Democratic Party. And you look at it like Hamilton, for example. He ran a campaign in which that really centered medical debt was like a really big part. Remember because he was running his Roger Marshall, who had, you know, whatever. And then Bernie Sanders is out there saying, if you listen to Bernie Sanders, he's saying, I want to get to Medicare for all. But let's take some first steps. Like, you know, lowering the Medicare age of eligibility into Medicare down to 55. And, you know, that's a lot of common ground. And you could start there. That's a place for the party to move forward while they work out the bigger differences. And there's all kinds of advantages to that. - Yeah, yeah, it does seem like this weird area where the term, the concept Medicare for all, is this black and white like chivalent in the party. Like, it's hard to think of something that sorts you into one Democratic camp or another more than how you react. Kind of what look flashes across your face when you are encountered with that term. Medicare for all those three words. And yet, it is, as you get to in your piece, it is basically a giant, sliding scale, a giant bag of different sliding scale policies, any combination of which you could put in a policy package, any combination of which you could leave out of a policy package or turn up or turn down or, you know, make more disruptive or less disruptive. I do sort of wonder like, yes, it does seem true that when it comes to actually negotiating these policies, you could find a lot of common ground here. But isn't it also the case that like, the signaling device is almost helpful for some people as well, like in terms of carving out real estate in these factional fights in the party. And like, I almost wonder whether it might be hard to actually go in and do the policy work of, you know, finding common ground between these different segments on some of these specific issues, just given how much of a polarized thing among different camps in the Democratic Party, it is turning into or has turned into. But maybe that's too cynical. I don't know. What do you think about that element of it? - No, I think you're right. And I think that's why the leadership matters. I mean, that's why I think it's really important for someone like Bernie Sanders or Abduel, say it, or Hacking Jeffries, or, you know, as you go, you know, sort of, you know, or newcomers like Annie Andrews and Adam Hamilton, to sort of, it's really important the way they talk about these things. You know, these are, as you get down the road and actually trying to write legislation, and you go bigger, there are real differences here, right? I mean, there's a real difference between what Bernie Sanders wants and probably what, you know, Hamilton's news, so we don't know exactly, but you know, there are real differences. They're going to have to work that out. But the language they use as they are advocating for their positions, it's just very important if they, you know, I would say if they want to be successful, to sort of walk that fine line of saying, okay, I'm Bernie Sanders, I disagree with Adam Hamilton here, but you know what, Adam greets with me on XYZ, so let's go down the road on that. And for Hamilton to say, I'm not where Bernie is, but you know what, he's got some good ideas on this and that. And I do, but it could go either way. And especially in this environment, especially with social media, the way we know things where everything becomes, you know, centripetal, centripetal, centripetal, centripetal. I used to know this, I took physics and college. But, you know, centripetal, centripetal, centripetal, I think. Yeah, you can get pushed towards the outskirts, towards the outskirts. Except that I think there is, right? Isn't that like a, it doesn't exist in physics? Okay, I'm going to show the comment. This is so far beyond. Oh my god, yeah. The commenters will set us straight on this. It's been a long time since college. But, so that's why I do think I'm mad. I think I manage what the leaders say. I think I manage what people like us say. And that's sort of one of the reasons I wrote the piece was to say, hey, be mindful of this if you care about this. And if you don't care about it, go nuts. You know, you know, blow it up. Yeah, what, just one question on this sort of timing here, I assume most of this is looking forward to a future where theoretically Democrats recapture the presidency and protect these majorities in 2028. That is when they're going to be having this big fight. Obviously, there's a lot of positional fighting happening right now. For instance, about who's going to be the Senate leader in the New Year, whether Chuck Schumer will carry on in that role, or whether it'll be someone like Senator Chris Van Hollen. So that, the conversation matters for that sort of thing right now. But for the most part, the actual policy fight is down the line. Are there any specific things that you see as stuff Democrats might try to push on healthcare that's more than just messaging stuff in the next two years? Where they actually will try to peel off enough Republicans or even Donald Trump to get some stuff passed? Yes, I mean, I can think of a list of them, including lowering the Medicare, you know, eligibility age for Medicare, potentially adding dental and vision to Medicare, trying to pass a law that automatically enrolls all children into an assurance program, whether it's Medicaid or Medicaid or whatever, doing more on prescription drugs to get more government negotiating power. And there's like three reasons to do that, which is number one, there's a chance Trump could sign some version of some of these. I don't think it's a big chance. But, you know, like the drug stuff, for example, like he's actually consistently talked about doing being aggressive on drugs. So there's number one, it might pass. Number two, if it doesn't pass, you get those things passed. Now, they're teed up. Those of them become week one votes for whoever becomes president in 2029. And you know, there's a history of doing that with these kind of reform. But there's a third more subtle part of this, which is legislating requires, it's a process, right? You know, it's not easy to write a bill. It is not easy to negotiate. You have to have the knowledge base. You have to have build the relationships. You have to know how to work with each other. And those muscles in the Democratic Party have come to atrophied, and you've a lot of new people into this process. It would be good for them to go through the exercise of writing and passing these bills, so that if they get a trifecta or whatever situation in 2029 where they can actually legislate, they know how to do it. And it takes practice, it's like any other skill. You get better at it the more you go. And you know, historically, when they've succeeded, you will often find that sort of the key deals that got made whereby members of the Senate and House who five years before had worked together on a bill, similar bill, they got a kind of good working relationship out of that, and then that carried over. - Yeah, yeah, no, that makes a lot of sense. - It is crazy, I mean, this wide open policy field that we are in right now where nobody really knows where the Republican Party actually stands, other than just sort of a vague hostility to the concept of socialized medicine, which is obviously still very strong, anything that they consider socialism is basically dead on arrival in the party, and they are willing to consider a lot of different things socialism, including actual socialized medicines. I mean, that's, it's not like it is a completely off-label descriptor for some of the things that we're talking about here, but at the same time, you have these weird cross, cross ideological impulses from the president. You have this completely open field on the Democratic side, so it's gonna be very interesting to follow for the next couple of years and beyond. We can leave it there for now, though. Thanks, Jonathan, for coming on and talking us through your reporting. You can go to the bulwark.com and read his piece. We'll drop that in the description as well. Really good primer on some of these fights that we are about to see in the Democratic Party, or maybe not fights, maybe just really constructive, helpful, mutually beneficial work between camps all around. I'll believe it when I see it, but it'd be nice, so we'll see. Thanks, Jonathan. Thanks all of you guys for watching. Thanks for subscribing if you already do. Thanks for going down and subscribing in the near future. If you don't already, we appreciate it and it helps us out a lot. Thank you and we'll see you all next time.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Senator Elect Abdul-El-Sayed has proposed a satirical "Trump Care" plan as a political stunt to demonstrate that even a Republican could support Medicare for all, highlighting the potential for bipartisan appeal.
The proposal reflects a broader strategy to build public support for healthcare reform by challenging political assumptions and showing that progressive policies might resonate across party lines.
Donald Trump’s past actions, like launching Trump Rx to lower drug prices, reveal a willingness to use government intervention in healthcare—contrary to traditional conservative market-based approaches.
The Democratic Party is divided into camps
Despite ideological differences, there is growing consensus among Democrats on achieving universal healthcare, with common ground emerging on issues like lowering Medicare eligibility age or expanding coverage.
Democrats are likely to pursue smaller, achievable reforms in the near term to build momentum and political capital, including automatic enrollment of children in health programs and stronger drug price negotiations.
These incremental steps serve both as policy winnowing tools and as training grounds to rebuild legislative skills and bipartisan relationships within the party.
The current political environment offers a unique opportunity for cross-ideological collaboration, though long-term success remains uncertain due to deep party polarization and voter sentiment.
Summary:
As a new Democratic Congress takes shape, healthcare policy debates are reigniting with renewed energy. Senator Elect Abdul-El-Sayed’s satirical "Trump Care" proposal, calling on Donald Trump to endorse a Medicare for all plan, serves as both a political troll and a strategic move to broaden the appeal of universal healthcare. It underscores a broader trend: even within progressive politics, there’s growing recognition that policies like Medicare for all could gain traction if framed as broadly acceptable—even with conservative figures.
Trump’s own history of intervening in prescription drug pricing through Trump Rx shows a willingness to use government action in healthcare, suggesting a shift from pure market conservatism. Inside the Democratic Party, three distinct camps exist—full Medicare for all, incremental reform, and centrist compromise—though there is now a stronger consensus on achieving universal coverage. In the near term, Democrats are likely to push for achievable reforms such as lowering Medicare eligibility age, expanding Medicare to include dental and vision, or automatically enrolling children into health programs.
These steps serve as both policy milestones and practical training in legislative negotiation. While major reforms remain politically challenging, this period offers a unique opportunity to rebuild party cohesion, strengthen bipartisan communication, and lay the groundwork for future legislative success. The outcome remains uncertain, but the strategic openness and cross-ideological experimentation signal a pivotal shift in how healthcare policy is being approached.
FAQs
Trump Care is a satirical proposal initiated by Senator Elect Abdul-El-Sayed, suggesting a Medicare for All program named after Donald Trump. It's a political stunt designed to show that even a Republican could support universal healthcare, highlighting the potential for bipartisan agreement on healthcare reform.
No, there is no credible chance that Donald Trump would support or sign a Medicare for All law. The proposal is widely seen as a playful, troll-like strategy to provoke thought about political possibilities rather than a realistic policy path.
Trump Rx is a website that offers prescription drug coupons and discounts, allowing users to access lower-priced medications. It reflects Trump’s willingness to engage government in reducing prescription drug costs, marking a departure from traditional conservative market-driven approaches.
The Democratic Party is broadly unified on the goal of universal healthcare, though there is a spectrum of approaches. While some support full Medicare for All, others advocate for incremental reforms like lowering Medicare eligibility age or expanding coverage for dental and vision.
Democrats may push for lowering the Medicare eligibility age, expanding Medicare to include dental and vision, automatically enrolling children in health coverage, and increasing government negotiation power on prescription drugs.
It challenges the traditional party divide, as most Democrats oppose socialized medicine. A deal with Trump would signal political compromise, which some progressives view as undermining their principles, while others see it as a pragmatic way to build public support.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.