Go back

A Stoic Mantra For Your Sh*ttiest Moments (And Other Ancient Wisdom That Holds Up) | Jonathan Haidt

54m 7s

A Stoic Mantra For Your Sh*ttiest Moments (And Other Ancient Wisdom That Holds Up) | Jonathan Haidt

Jonathan Haidt’s *The Happiness Hypothesis* bridges ancient wisdom and modern science to explore what makes human life meaningful and fulfilling. At its core, the book examines the "divided self"—a metaphor where our automatic, emotional mind (the elephant) drives most behavior, while our conscious reasoning (the rider) can guide us toward better choices. This insight leads to practical tools like the "stoic challenge," where individuals pause and reframe negative reactions to setbacks, fostering resilience. Haidt also emphasizes the importance of companionate love over fleeting passion, arguing that deep, slow-burning relationships are key to long-term happiness. He explores how adversity is essential for growth, citing anti-fragility and post-traumatic growth as vital to emotional resilience. Meanwhile, he critiques modern technology for eroding human connection, noting that constant digital exposure undermines social bonds and leads to anxiety. Haidt revises traditional views of non-attachment, suggesting that a balanced, compassionate middle path—where we care deeply but remain open to impermanence—is more realistic for modern life. Ultimately, true flourishing comes not from detachment, but from engaging with life’s challenges, relationships, and emotions, especially in a world increasingly shaped by uncertainty and technological disruption.

Transcription

10748 Words, 58266 Characters

English
Hey, hey, everybody. Welcome to the 10% Happier Podcast. I'm your host, Dan Harris. This whole show, and in fact, my whole post-TV news anchorman career, is based on the mix of ancient wisdom and modern science, which really are two great tastes that taste great together, as they used to say in the Reese's Peanut Butter Cups ads when I was a kid. And there's so much to be learned at the intersection of these two fields, which is why I was really excited when I heard from Jonathan Haidt, who wanted to come on to talk about his book, The Happiness Hypothesis, which really takes pillars of ancient wisdom and then pressure tests them against modern research. You might know Jonathan Haidt. He is a social psychologist at New York University's Stern School of Business. He has written many, many bestselling books, including The Anxious Generation. But today, we're really going to focus on The Happiness Hypothesis, which is actually 20 years old. It's celebrating its 20th anniversary, and he has just put out a revised edition of the book. Jonathan Haidt, welcome back to the show. Dan, thanks so much for having me on. Tell me about the idea for this book. I think I might have given away the headline, but the basic idea, as I said, is let's look at some pillars of ancient wisdom and see how they hold up in light of today's science. Mm-hmm. That's right. So the book grows out of my teaching Psych 101 at the University of Virginia. My first academic job, beginning in 1995, was there. I was assigned to teach Psych 101. I have to teach a room of 319-year-olds everything from physiological psychology through love and dieting, everything. And I would often quote Shakespeare or Buddha. So it was clear that there are certain ideas, like, for example, there's nothing good or bad, but thinking makes it so, from Hamlet. And that is the foundation of Stoicism, of Buddhism, of cognitive therapy, like that idea. And when I was coming up for tenure, I didn't have a lot of experimental publications, and I thought I might not get tenure. And if I don't get tenure, I don't want to just transfer to a lower-ranked university. You know what? I'll drop out, and I'll try to write up this trade book, collect all these ideas and write it up. So I did get tenure, although it was just barely. I happened to know my vote because they made a mistake and revealed it to me accidentally. But anyway, I got tenure at UVA, and I decided to write the book anyway. And it was so much fun. I basically just read every work from ancient China, India, everything that, you know, religious texts, anything that had sort of statements about humanity in it. And I had a big, long WordPerfect back then, a WordPerfect file with all these quotes. And I organized them, and it turned out they really fell into clusters, and they were all true. Like, none of the, you know, if an idea has survived for 2,000 or 3,000 years, it's not going to be, like, wrong. But in every case, there was nuance you could bring in from psychology. So that was the origin of the book. If it's cool with you, let's go through some of them. Okay. Let's do it. So let's start with the one you just mentioned. There's nothing good or bad except for thinking makes it so. I think that's chapter 2, Changing Your Mind. That's right. So, okay, page 38. So it starts off with a quote from Marcus Aurelius. The whole universe is change, and life itself is but what you deem it. And this is Marcus Aurelius in the meditation, sitting alone in his tent at night, trying to improve his own mental health, trying to psych himself up and stop making mistakes. And he's telling himself, like, you know, don't be anxious about this. Don't be. It's like, okay, this is under your control to frame this. This is not the reality. And then here's a very similar thought from Buddha. What we are today comes from our thoughts of yesterday, and our present thoughts build our life of tomorrow. Our life is the creation of our mind. Exactly the same idea from, you know, many thousands of miles apart, both from 2,000 years ago. And both of those are the foundation of CBT and so much modern pop psychology. Two foundational truths of the book are the first one is about the divine. And the second one is about the divine. And the third one is about the divine. And the second was this one about appraisal. Maybe we'll get to the divided self, but let's stay with this one, which is, as you say, appraisal. CBT is cognitive behavioral therapy. I am not an expert in this, but as I understand it, it's really about changing your relationship to your thoughts. What's the practical takeaway if we agree with the Buddha and Marcus Aurelius and Shakespeare? Yeah. So the practical, okay, so let me give you an example. I teach a course at NYU called Flourishing. I taught it back in UVA when I was writing the book, and then I moved to the Western School of Business, and I resurrected it as a course for business students. And over time, we've settled on a few texts that are just fantastic. And one of them is called The Stoic Challenge by William Irvine. And it really sort of makes super accessible stoic thinkings. And he tells you, whenever you face a setback, what happens is we have a setback, like, you know, you missed your train, and now you're going to be late for a job interview. And that really sucks. Okay, so that's bad. But then in addition, we get upset. And we suffer. Why didn't I do or goddamn the that's two harms. And the stoic challenge is to say, okay, I missed the train, stoic challenge, the stoic gods are giving me a chance to prove myself. Can I get through this without the second suffering? How am I going to do that? And so I've assigned this book for the last eight or 10 years. It's wonderful. So this morning, I taught the class, I have an MBA version, undergraduate. So this morning was the MBA version. And I asked for stories from the class because they were starting the book. And one woman said, it was a really simple thing. But I come in from Queens every morning. And like half the time, the subway gets stuck under the river, we just sit there for a while. And it makes me really upset. And I said, okay, so what do you do? And she said, well, this morning, when it happened, I just said, stoic challenge, stoic challenge. And then I took out a book because I've started reading again, I haven't really read any novels in years. And I used to love reading novels. And so I took out a book, and I had 10 minutes to just sit there and read the book. What would have happened, before is she would spend that time stewing the double loss sheet, she now is late, and she's upset. But instead, she actually got 10 minutes of reading. And so that's a super simple example. But it applies to almost everything, where our mind reacts instantly, our minds are very quick, our minds react almost instantly to setbacks, problems, people. And now these students are learning how to have that little pause, just you say stoic challenge. And that gives you a moment to reflect. So the next time something shitty, happens, just get in the habit of saying stoic challenge. And really what you're sending a message, you're sending a message to your mind and your nervous system. How can I make the best of this situation? Exactly. You're saying, life itself is but what you deem it. What am I going to deem this situation? Right. Right. It's that simple. Have you heard of the Buddhist concept of the second arrow? Exactly. That's it. The second arrow, you're going to get struck by one arrow. Okay, you don't have to invite the second one in. Yeah, that's it. I feel like I, deliver fifth and sixth arrows to myself on the regular. Yeah. And just to have a little thing to say in, I mean, another thing you could say, I've heard, I can't remember his name, but there's some podcast host who has this little thing that anytime something quote unquote bad happens to him, he says, good. Oh, I've heard that too. I don't know who that is. I think it's the former military guy. Oh, yeah. Is it Jocko? Jocko Willett. Yeah. Okay. Well, I've never met Jocko. If you want to come on, you're welcome. I've always really liked that. I've never, I've never been able to do it. Okay. So here's why that works. Let me bring in the first truth now. Okay. So the foundational, most common, most important ancient wisdom truth that is essential for understanding modern psychology and all the stupid things that we do is truth number one, the divided self. Here are the quotes. So I always open the quote with two, the opening chapter with two quotes. So these two happen to be both from Western sources, but you find this everywhere. So one is St. Paul Galatians, for what the flesh desires is opposed to the spirit and the flesh, for these are opposed to each other, to prevent you from doing what you want. Or other translations, that ye cannot do the things ye would, is the more common translation. And here's Benjamin Franklin, if passion drives, let reason hold the reins. So every society has noticed that we want to do something, but then we don't do it, we do something else. And they generally contrast passion and reason or something like that, the spirit and the flesh. And so here's a case where modern psychology really helps us go further, because really what's happening, it's not so much like passion and reason, because the passions and the emotions are actually really rational. The passions, the emotions involve a lot of cognitive processing, a lot of meaning making. As I go through it in chapter one, I go through, it's not exactly emotion reason. What it really is, system one versus system two. Now, these are the terms used by Dan Kahneman, who took it from an earlier cognitive psychologist. System one is pattern matching automatic, the automatic mind. Our minds are neural networks. They're 500 million years old. They work really well in all these animal species that don't have language. That's the way the mind works. Pattern comes in, pattern goes out, neural network in between, syncs those up. Humans, in the last million years, we don't know when, we got language. We got the ability, the second system where we can think through and we think, you know, I really shouldn't have that dessert. My cholesterol is high, I'm overweight, whatever. We think that, but then I don't know about you. Once there's a sweet dessert in front of me, I cannot stop eating. I will, you know, I'm good at not ordering dessert, but if it's on the table, I will eat it. And then I will keep going. I cannot stop. I used to be that way with cocaine too. I don't know whether you're kidding. I'm not kidding. Okay. So yeah, I'm glad mine was just sugar. So the point is, most of our mind is an animal brain, which does pattern matching automatic, and that's what controls our behavior. But we have the second system. I make up the metaphor in the book that our mind is divided into parts that sometimes conflict, like a small rider on top of a very large elephant. And the rider, and you see it here on the cover of the book, on the older edition, it was clearer. There's a small rider on top of the elephant. The elephant is super smart. A lot of previous metaphors, like Freud used a metaphor of like a carriage driver and the horse. A lot of people have used horses because humans are so familiar with horses. Horses are kind of dumb, but I wanted a metaphor. The elephant's really big. It's really smart. It has a great memory. So I thought I made that up myself, although it turns out Buddha used that metaphor too. I might've gotten it from him in college. I don't know. But here's the point. Most of what we do is governed by automatic processes. We're not really in control, but we do think we have this consciousness. And so I tell my students, because the course is organized around, you have to improve yourself. You have to make a change in your habits, make a change that will make you happier over the course of the semester. But you cannot just use willpower. You cannot just say, I'm going to stopping and smelling the roses. I'm just going to remind myself to do it. That's not going to work. I'm going to be nicer to my girl. No, that's not going to work. I'm going to eat less and extra. You have to have a system. And so the rider can make the resolution, but you have to have a plan. And so if you practice doing stoic challenge, what happens is the rider is saying like, you're riding along with this giant elephant. And all of a sudden there's an obstacle. And you know that the elephant's about to rear up and get all upset. But the rider can say, stoic challenge, here's a peanut. Okay. Pause. Okay. And then over time, it becomes habitual to take a deep breath and look for other ways. So the rider and the elephant work together in people who are mentally healthy, and they are not well-coordinated in people who are not mentally healthy. And is the elephant in this case, are unconscious? Is it our passions? Is it both? Yeah. The way to think about it is, it's everything the mind does other than conscious verbal reasoning. I see. And so everything about motivations, desires, everything about emotions. So there's reasoning in emotions. There's cognition in emotion. So it's not emotion cognition. It's automatic processing versus controlled processing is the way that modern psychology talks about it. And so we're not helpless in the face of the elephant, but we do have to recognize that the elephant is larger and more powerful than our CEO mind. Exactly. And if you've ever seen videos of how they train elephants or how they train dogs, it's behaviorism. There's a behavior, the elephant begins to sit back, you give him a peanut. He sits back a little further, you give him a peanut. He lifts one leg up, you give him another peanut. He lifts both legs up. So this is how B.F. Skinner, the behaviorist, this is how they train animals to do amazing things. Small rewards given quickly will change your behavior. That's the way the way neural networks work. Very practically, you've walked this through a little bit. I'm just going to put a fine point on it on this. If we want to change and grow, we really need to be treating ourselves like a toddler or a kitty cat or a dog that we are or an elephant that we are training using these behaviorist behaviorist or behaviorist concepts. That's right. Especially for a change that involves behavior. So habits, you know, like biting your fingernails or forgetting to brush your teeth or improving your diet. So things that are behavioral, absolutely. But things that are purely mental, it's a little harder. It still works, but it's not quite as obvious how to do it. And with so with CBT, with a lot of methods in pop psychology, what you do is you so something happens and you begin to have these negative emotions and you get in the habit, take some practice, takes a few weeks, but you get in the habit of pausing and identifying the distortion. And you become aware of that. And then you pause for a moment and you'll say, you might say, okay, so what actually happened here? Or you might say, oh, there I go again, doing catastrophizing. There I go again, doing emotional reasoning. And so my friend, Greg Lukianoff, who is the president of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, he had the insight that led to the Coddling the American Mind. We wrote this book together. Greg is prone to severe depression. He had a suicidal depression in 2007, which led him to learn CBT. Greg says what he does is whatever thought is going through his head, these ruminations, these repetitive thoughts, these negative thoughts, what he does is he'll say it to himself in a Daffy Duck voice. He'll say the same thing, but in Daffy Duck's voice in his head. And that allows him to sort of laugh at it. And that gives him a little bit of distance to now do the work of CBT, which is, oh, that's catastrophizing. Yeah, it might be bad, but it probably won't be. Let's look at what's really happening here. What are the options? Another hack that I've learned along those lines is to sing your worries out loud. That's right. That would be a similar, similar approach. If you're a regular listener of this show, you know that we're always adding amazing new teachers and new guided meditations and hosting live sessions over on my app, which is called 10% with Dan Harris. What you might not know is that we also now have a full library of not just guided meditations, but also short courses and challenges. We've got a meditation master class with Joseph Goldstein. We've got Sharon Salzberg covering the Eightfold Path. We've got Diana Winston with her Reset Challenge. And next week, we are dropping a new course from Sharon Salzberg and Andy Gonzalez. It's called Taking Care of Yourself So You Can Take Care of the World. It's an eight-part course to help you develop skills for resilience and clear seeing. And remember that you're really no good to anybody if you're not taking care of yourself and your mind. You can get started taking care of your own mind by signing up for 10% with Dan Harris at danharris.com. I don't know if this is going to make sense to you because this may be too deep end of the pool Buddhist, but it just came to my mind. I struggle a lot with anxiety and depression and have since I was a little kid. One move that I make sometimes when I'm feeling despair, particularly despair, but anxiety too, is there's a quote from the Buddha, not I, not mine, not myself. It is a refrain that runs through the Buddhist texts and is a way of reminding myself that emotions are like meteorological phenomena. They're coming together of impersonal conditions. They will pass at some point. So it kind of depersonalizes, but not in an unhealthy way. It makes it more tractable. Does that make any sense what I'm saying? It does. That's an interesting case of where I think the Eastern and Western ideas differ. So as I just tell my students this morning, stoicism, Buddhism, they're like almost the same thing. They have all these same ideas. That one, I don't know, I don't know. I don't know. I think is different. That's a more uniquely Eastern Hindu Buddhist notion of the self is imagined. The Stoics didn't say that. The Stoics said, you don't have a self. No, they didn't say that. So at least, especially if you're raised in a Hindu Buddhist Eastern culture, that might be particularly resonant, especially if you have meditated, if the religion all around you told you that. That may not work as well for Westerners. I think the idea of this illusion of the self is really hard for a Westerner. It is. Yeah. I have never been able to see myself as illusionary. Like, no, I don't get that personally, like as an intuitive idea. And it's hard. I'm not going to argue you into it. It's really it's one of the reasons why I've seen these studies and you're the researcher. So you'll know if I'm recapitulating the research correctly. But these studies where they take people from Eastern civilizations, Eastern countries and Western countries, or let's just say Asian and America or European countries, and they're asked to draw themselves in relationship to their community. Yeah. And in the West, we draw ourselves huge and everybody else around us small. And in the East, it's everybody's drawn at the same size. And I think in a culture where we're so individualistic, consumerist, it's really hard to get the idea that the self isn't primary. That's right. There's a lot of research in a field called cultural psychology, which began with those sorts of studies showing that if you ask, if you give people 20 lines, I am blank, blank, blank, I am tall. I am, you know, a good guitar player. But in Eastern countries, it's, I am a brother. I am a son. I am a, it's your roles in relationships. Westerners generally have a, what Hazel Marcus calls a big, thick, padded self. And there are many advantages to that in terms of achievement and, you know, Western nations are generally pretty happy. But I think in, there's a relevant here, there's a really good book. And I talk about it in the happiness hypothesis by Mark Leary called the curse of the self. And it's about how, self-consciousness ends up being the cause of so much of our misery. Our minds are incredibly social. A lot of our evolution is not for surviving lions and tigers and bears. It's for dealing really skillfully with other people. And we were always enmeshed in networks of other people. We never spent time alone. Like until very recently, people were not alone. And now we spend a lot of time alone. And we do have, I'm not sure it's, we do have problems and increasing problems with depression and anxiety. And they do seem to be related to our lack of embeddedness and healthy relationships and networks and networks of meaning. That's a huge problem. It's a huge getting worse, getting worse. Yes. I can't on the getting worse tip. It just seems to me like AI. It's hard to imagine that helping things. I'm not anti AI holistically. I have concerns at least not yet. Maybe I will be. Yeah. When it tries to turn me into a paper clip. Yeah. Maybe tomorrow by one glimmer of optimism, I was at an event this morning with a bunch of young people who are social media creators. And they were, many of them were arguing to me that they're so sick of digital technology that they think it's going to lead to a resurgence of IRL in person. It's happening. Yeah, that is definitely happening. So here's the way that I look at it. In the 20th century, technology was always amazing. Setting aside the nuclear bomb, technology meant better everything. And, you know, I'm a little older than you, but I was born in 1963. But, you know, technology was always exciting, promising and made our lives better. And these were technologies that helped us do things that we wanted to do. And then we get the internet. And the internet was the most incredible thing ever. And you could get everything instantly. For a minute. My God. So the internet in the 90s was incredible. And then we get into the 2000s and now different business models come in. It gets, the word is inshittified. That's by Cory Doctorow. The business models allow the attention, create the attention economy companies like Meta. And they suck a trillion dollars of value out of people's attention. So now it starts getting more predatory. And then we get the smartphone in our pockets, which now allows us to be linked up all the time. And when you take most of people's time and attention, that is taken from everywhere. That means they get less sleep. They get less movement. They get less sunshine. They get less time with other people. I can't remember who I was reading recently who pointed out, young people today haven't touched very much. Almost everything is glass. You know, when you and I were growing up, like, I remember like taking apart like a doorknob in a radio and a television, like we, like we were dealing with material things. We used our hands and there were smells. Things smelled like something. And if you grow up almost all on a screen, there's not much touch, not much smell, not much sensory, very little touch of other people. There's a lot less sex, a lot less love. And so I think what we're seeing is just in the last few months, especially really here in 2026, we're seeing almost an allergic reaction from humanity. Like, this is too much. This stuff, which we thought was so wonderful, it's overwhelming. It's crushing our kids. It's making us all feel we can't focus. We can't read books. We don't have time with each other. So I'm actually really excited. You know, I'm extremely negative about digital technology now, what it's doing as a social psychologist, what social media did to social relationships, and what AI is doing to education. Horrific, cognitive offloading, cognitive surrender, and what it's doing to relationships as AI. It takes relationships, is so horrible. But I'm excited now that we are seeing this allergic reaction. And, you know, the data center thing, that's probably, you know, it's unrelated to what we're talking about, but yet it's all part of a human shrug of, like, saying, like, stop, stop. It's not unrelated in that I think I'm not sure data centers are more insulting to the environment than any other industrial innovation. It's just our anger to me. And I could be wrong, and people are probably going to at me over this. But it seems to me that people are upset about data centers because they're really upset about AI. Yeah, I think so. I think that's right, too. And, you know, what's striking to me is that this AI backlash, this techlash, as some people are calling it, is truly bipartisan. Yes. The one thing we agree on. Yes, that's right. That's right. There was a, so one of the initiatives, so after the anxious generation came out, the first thing that really took off was phone-free schools. Because all of the teachers hate it. You know, they went. They went into teaching to teach, and they don't get to, you know, the kids are watching TikTok and porn in class. Like, it's insane what we let happen. And there's a headline in Politico about a year ago that said the last bipartisan issue in America. Because, and one thing I learned when I was writing the book, I thought, we're never going to get any help from government. Our Congress is broken. Things are corrupt. We're not going to get any help from government. What I didn't realize is that there are 50 governors. Almost all of them are parents. Almost all of them see the problem. They jumped into action. The teachers, the school, everybody sees the problem. So, at least with phone-free schools and kids, it's completely bipartisan. And you're right. The data center thing is unrelated to the phone-free schools issue. But yet, I think it is a common bipartisan frustration. Standing athwart history yelling stop. Like, that's kind of what's going on. Yes. Yes. All right. So, let's talk a little bit about, since we're talking about the importance of relationships for flourishing. You have a chapter about love and attachment in the happiness hypothesis. And I believe. I believe the ancient hypothesis you're playing. Well, actually, you're pulling out the book. You tell me. What is the ancient hypothesis that you're pressure testing in that chapter? So, let's turn to that. Page 149. The first is from Seneca. No one can live happily who has regard to himself alone and transforms everything into a question of his own utility. You must live for your neighbor if you would live for yourself. And so, the idea that we. And then the second was John Donne. No man is an island entire of itself. Every man is a piece of the continent. A part of the main. So, and I don't have an Eastern quote here in the opening. But everybody talks about, you know, love and neighborliness and relatedness. But what I was surprised by is that there wasn't a lot in the ancient sources on romantic love or passionate love. That actually Western philosophers really distrust it. And they often urge young men. Of course, they're always writing to young men at the time. To like avoid it. Like this is going to be a corruption. You know, you should really, you know, love philosophy or God or knowledge or something like that. What I do in the chapter is I bring in. The attachment system, which is incredibly fascinating and so important for anybody raising kids. And I start off with the Harry Harlow experiments in which at the time in the behaviorist era in the 1930s, 40s, people thought, well, the child bonds to its mother because of the milk. The milk is reinforcing and that's why they bond. They didn't understand back then that there is an innate need for touch, love, contact, comfort, cuddling. We're mammals. We do this. And so once you understand the attachment system, how kids have sort of built into. Their minds, a system that says like, OK, who is responsive? Who is the who is the adult? Who's who's my caretaker? And then they lock on to that. And that's a healthy attachment. So once you understand the attachment system in infants and children. Now, the really interesting discovery in the 70s and 80s by Phil Shaver and I forget who else was that adult attachment. When you fall in love with someone and you have a romantic, an adult romantic relationship, we're actually reusing the same cognitive model. That we used as a child. And so if you were insecurely attached as a child, if you know when your parent goes away, you're alone in a room, you get upset. And then when they come back, you don't settle quickly. You're still upset. Or maybe they go away. You don't even seem to notice because you're not attached. If you don't have healthy attachment as a child, your brain develops these models of the world and how people are responsive. We often use those for our adult romantic relationships. And so there's a lot of advice in the book on. On adult love, because that's certainly what my students care most about. And so especially I think the advice that seems most to resonate, what people tell me a lot about the book is that the most important thing they got out of it was the difference between passionate and companionate love. So passionate love is the love that you fall into. It's falling in love. It's the pop songs. It's the movies. It's like a drug. You can fall in love with anyone in the world who's attractive, even if they're wildly inappropriate for you. That's what so much of pop culture is about. So that's not attachment. That's a mating system that is very ancient. And it makes us want to have sex and it makes us fall in love for a couple of months. That's the amount of time it takes to make a baby. On average, we don't make a baby just from one act that often. It often takes multiple acts. So there's this one system that kind of makes us create babies, but doesn't keep us together. And then there's companionate love, which is where your life gets enmeshed with another person and you come to depend on them and they on you. And it grows slowly over time. And a happy marriage is not predicted by. A wild sex life in the first weeks like that can happen with anyone. It's going to be if you get a mix, if you get the companionate love, that's really more important thing for a lasting or stable marriage. The companion, of course, you want some passion in it. You want the passion to to stay around to some extent. But anyway, that's the sort of stuff that I go into in in chapter six. My wife and I have long seen this couple's therapist who we love, and he talks about how in the West we have this idea of that we're going to go from one enchanted evening to happily ever after. But that is often not. The case, we need some sort of bridge between the passionate love that gets us into the thing in the first place and the companionate love that will stop us from getting divorced. So what what have you learned about what that bridge might consist of? Absolutely right. So when I teach this to undergrads, I say, here's what we think is possible, you know, happily ever after you fall madly in love, you stay in love forever. Maybe it'll get a little bit weaker, but we think it'll be like that. And that doesn't happen instead. What typically happens in here, I'll show this to the camera, although I know this is too small. Is, you know, there's like a big spike and then it then it drops. And when it drops, people often think, oh, I guess it wasn't true love. But there's always going to be a time when when that that passion cools. And that doesn't mean that person's not right for you. So sometimes we make a mistake by at the peak saying, oh, my God, this is my soulmate. Let's get married. And then sometimes it's hard to stop that train. Or we make a mistake of like, oh, you know, the magic is worn off. Therefore, this is the wrong person. But while the passionate love goes up. It goes up instantly and is wonderful and amazing. The companionate love grows more slowly as you intertwine your lives. The Little Prince, if anybody has read the little, you know, Le Petit Prince, the is it the fox talks about taming like, no, no, you have to come every day and I will come to expect you. And then when you're late, I will feel like, oh, where is he? And so that's this gradual coming to expect things, gradual sharing your life. And that's more like, like, you know, plants growing together or like a cutting. Growing up. I mean, there are ways that we grow together. And then that's a totally different psychological system from the crazy hormonal falling in love, wanting to touch, kiss, have sex. The graph that John has been holding up, it shows the intensity level for passionate love spikes and then dwindles and quite quickly, whereas companionate love just kind of steadily grows from a low point to a sustained. That's a sustainable point. start even long-term companionate love with a spouse or some sort of romantic partner starts with passion and then can move into companion okay yes for westerners where we have love marriages that's our ideal our ideal you know most of the world had agricultural societies had arranged marriages you don't expect these young how can we trust these young people to make the decision they don't know anything so you know marriage is arranged between families the parents pick like you you know and in many cases in some like in india i spent a little time in india in india when i was there in the 90s it seemed like the norm was becoming the parents arranged the marriage but the kids have a veto if they really don't want it we're not going to force them but the parents arrange the marriage and then sometimes and you know hindi films are all about you know sometimes there will be wild crazy passionate love other times it will it will grow slowly that's very different from what we have what we have is it's up to the kids we expect it to start with love and with passionate love and sex but obviously there's subcultures there are ones that don't think you're in love with them but there are subcultures that don't think you're in love with you should have sex before marriage and so it's it's up to kids to figure it out and i think we don't have a very good track record no you know in terms of the divorce rate in terms of the declining amount of dating and sex and love and marriage so our system is not working very well we teach a lot of things in school but we don't teach this and it seems like we maybe should yeah i think so and especially i think we all need to really think about how technology is changing and so this is this is a point that i we talk a lot about in my class when we do the section on the day on love so most animals are not monogamous most mammals are not very few mammals are monogamous even humans aren't really that monogamous over time we tend to do like cereal but we have courtship and any species in which male investment isn't necessary you tend to have courtship because if we're gonna do this thing you know the female wants to be sure that we're not just getting the sperm we're getting some commitment here right guys like you're gonna help me out right and so we're going to have courtship and we're going to have courtship so birds have to do that because you couldn't possibly be a bird and raise a child on your own you have to have two parents for birds chimpanzees no male involvement really at all but humans variable from a little to a lot never 50 percent um it's always mostly female okay but so what i'm getting at is we have courtship and in courtship that's flirting and it's you show some interest you show some excellence you show some virtues you you brought you somehow convey that i am a person that you will want to pair with and it takes time and when it goes in steps it's exciting and when it works it's thrilling and okay what happens instead okay swipe swipe swipe yeah you look good enough okay let's have lunch oh but you're not as good as you know and all young people have stories of being out on a date and they go to the bathroom when they come back the person's is swiping and looking for someone else to go out with tonight the technology cuts off courtship the technology makes it difficult to display virtues the technology makes it difficult to fall in love with someone else and that's why we have courtship and we have courtship i was texting with my brother recently about something around ai and he just wrote i'm glad i'm not young it's just that's what my millennial students say they say they say thank those who got married in their 30s they say you know like i got the last chopper out of nam like they see what dating is like these days it's horrible but you started this section of the conversation talking about how the ancient idea was hey romantic love they're not there there be dragons like let's watch out but you don't actually agree with that per se that's right that's right so what the book is really about is the conditions of human flourishing and this is actually what all my books are about in a sense and the conditions of human flourishing are not absolute and unchangeable across eras and cultures and economic structures there are a lot of similarities a lot of commonalities because we all have the same underlying psychology in ancient civilizations where economic survival was so vital and so uncertain marriage was an arrangement between two families you can't leave it up to the kids too many people would die they would fail to have good good unions so flourishing had love played a very different role in those societies but once we get a very high level of material prosperity such that women can live independently men can live independently it's not an absolute hundred percent urgent necessity that you form a union of a man and a woman in order to raise a child like that for much of western history that was essentially you had to have that and you had to have a division of labor because someone had to do all the laborious cooking and and cleaning and food you know but once we get technology to say you know what actually everyone can live independently if they want and this of course frees women to pursue careers to live the way they want so that's all great once we've changed the the way things used to be the which is more consistent with how we well i don't want to get into how we've all because hunter-gatherer is actually very different from agricultural society so let's leave that aside my point is just that in a modern western wealthy free society love passionate love opens up possibilities for joy and pleasure that were not really available in many societies and are not necessarily available widely in some societies today falling in love is like the greatest possible thing you can experience and and we want our kids to have that and we want our kids to have that and we want our kids to have that and many of us want our kids to have that multiple times like you know don't you know don't fall in love at the age of eight of 17 and then marry the person like no you know live a full life you know get your heart broken like have experiences and and that makes sense for us as a full passionate lived life that doesn't make sense for you know traditional agricultural societies so chapter six is the one we've just been talking about which is about love and attachment the preceding chapter chapter five is about the ancient notion you hear the buddha talking about this all the time if you look at the ancient buddhist texts that actually we shouldn't get overly attached to anyone yeah i really struggle with this aspect of the dharma aka buddhism so yeah i'd be curious to hear your thoughts let me hear yours first because this is a real puzzle so how do you what do you think okay so here's a question i've posed to some some buddhists and i i didn't really get clear answers is it okay for a buddhist to feel like pain when his spouse or child dies there's a great story about a buddhist master who loses his daughter his students find him weeping and they say to him well didn't you tell us it's all an illusion and he says that some illusions are more painful than others okay that's a nice story what does it mean does it mean that buddhists actually say yeah you know it's it's okay to have your heart broken it's okay to to feel intense pain when your child dies do they say my understanding and i would call myself a practicing buddhist but not a buddhist scholar my understanding i'm actually right now in the middle of reading a biography of the buddha and in it he is very very clear that having children and romantic entanglements is a fetter yes like he names his child fetter oh my god rahula oh rahula right yes rahula is means fetter in the ancient language of of poly and so i mean from a strict standpoint i get it like the basic buddhist idea is everything that arises will pass away impermanence is ceaseless relentless unremitting and given the ground truth of impermanence clinging is a reliable source of suffering so i get with the with the buddha saying sounds really cold yeah but it actually can be construed as compassionate when you view it through the light of impermanence and yet in my lived experience it's very hard to swallow yeah okay so this is a great example of how the environment we're talking about is crucial for understanding advice for flourishing because i remember when i took a it took a course on tibetan buddhism or buddhism when i was in college and i remember reading some of these ancient texts i was really shocked at how austere and and cold and sort of alien many of them felt like this was not attractive but yet you also find a lot of you know like the dalai lama is full of love and light and yeah and as i understand it you know the ain't the really ancient you know the terravada buddhism is like is like not something you'd necessarily might want to practice in today's modern world it's those other buddhisms that are more out in the world that are more like yeah you can have a job you can have you know a family so so i think there are obviously many different kinds of buddhism one of the few places where i disagreed with ancient wisdom in the book and and right it's in chapter five i think is where i say i you know when i started this or i used to think you know the buddha was like the wisest person who ever lived without how to flourish but i've come to believe that at least for people in western societies a better life is one in which you commit to things and you strive and when you succeed you're exultant and when you fail it's painful and miserable that a life with these ups and downs is a better life on average for most people than one in which you cut off all attachments so that you don't feel the pain of loss so i had this i had this amazing conversation in my class today with the mba students and i and one of them asked the question he said we were talking about stoicism and the stoic challenge and how to cut off the negative emotion he said but how do we deal with the fact that a lot of our we had all these expectations and now they're being dashed how do we deal with the fact that you know we came to grad school and we had ideas about like what jobs we were going to get and now it looks like all of that might be out the window because of ai how do how do we you know you're saying we should just like just like accept it and and what i realized is that we're not going to be able to For all of history, people lived with the name knowledge that they could die tomorrow. People lived with the knowledge that there could be an earthquake, a hurricane, an invading army, a plague. Nobody had a 401k plan. Nobody expected to be alive in 30 years. Nobody expected to see their kids. You couldn't expect to see your kids grow up. You had no idea what was going to happen. And that was true for all of human history until sometime in the 20th or 19th or 20th century, I'd say. And what came out in my discussion with the students today was, in a sense, it's back because none of us can be confident that we will be here in 30 years, even 10 years. We just don't know. With all the talk about what AI is going to do, nobody knows. But suddenly, it's back on the table that we can't necessarily plan for the future. And so what I'm coming to see is that reading the ancients, reading the best ideas, the best writing from people who lived this way, who could not count on life, who had to live with uncertainty, how did they deal with it? And that's what Stoicism and Buddhism is all about. And many of us, you and I, we got to live in the period between the bomb and AI. And the bomb was very scary for a while. And then by the late 80s, it was calming down. And then the 90s were amazing and wonderful. And oh, technology and end of history and all these wonderful things. Well, now history's back and existential threat is back. So we did have this period of a few decades that was fantastic, but it was kind of an illusion. Now we're back to the way that the student is. Reading the best ideas and writings from the people who lived this way is even more important now. Certainly, I wrote the book in 2006, the year before the iPhone came out. So the iPhone and the internet have changed our civilizations radically, mostly in negative ways, I believe. So I think looking to ancient wisdom is very helpful right now. I agree. As I said to my students, Buddhism and Stoicism, I found writing the book, Buddhism and Stoicism are the two richest veins to mine. If you want to think about consciousness, relationships, those are incredible, incredible sources. Judaism, Christianity, Romanticism, there are all kinds of other sources of wisdom. But these two really stood out to me among the ancient sources. But the one place that I disagreed was I came to believe that if you grow up in a society that has prosperity and security and a range of things you can throw yourself into, that if you grow up in a society that has prosperity and security, that it would be a poor sort of life. It would be a failure to live to your best if you achieved non-attachment. That it's better. And it was very influenced by a philosopher named Robert Solomon, who I saw gave a talk. You know, philosophers are usually very analytic, but he was like a passionate romantic philosopher about like, go life, like throw yourself in, have experiences, have challenges. That's a rich human life. And I would say that is a rich human life for a modern Western person. Person who can have that kind of life. So yeah, I don't, I did not resonate with the highest goal should be non-attachment. The best way I've heard this described from modern Buddhist teachers is, and this is going to be hard for people listening, so I'll narrate it. The difference between holding a relationship with a closed fist, really, you know, clinging tightly or holding it with an open palm. So I love you. I, I care about you, but I understand that I can't control the fact that you too are subject to the forces of impermanence. Yeah. So, okay. So what I would say is we have, we have general tendencies and biases. We tend to dwell more on the negative. Bad is stronger than good. We tend to judge too quickly. There's all sorts of, of ways that we tend to be. And if you take Buddhism as a constant pull towards a to hold things more lightly, that doesn't mean we should go all the way to complete non-attachment. The idea that you would not be, that you could reach a state where if your child is kidnapped and you know, something horrible happens that you would not feel horrific. I'm sorry. Again, I apologize to Buddhists who, who have an explanation for that, but I'm just saying it is directionally right. Like we need, we Westerners need it as a directional pull. Yes. I think that what a Buddhist scholar would say, is there's a difference between non-attachment and detachment. So non-attachment just means you aren't overly attached, but you're not detached either. And so it's a, you know, the Buddha talked a lot about the middle way, the middle path. So the middle path between detachment and clinging would be non-attachment. Easier said than done. Let me ask you about one last ancient idea that you talk about in the book, which is you need adversity in order to have a meaningful life. Where do you come down on this? Oh yeah. This is chapter seven, I think it is. Let's see. It is chapter seven, the uses of adversity. Chapter seven, the uses of adversity, 186. And so of course, I'm sure I started off with the quote from Nietzsche. Yes. What doesn't kill me makes me stronger. And then there's one from Mencius or Mengzi. I'll read it if you don't mind. It's long, but it's so good. When heaven is about to confer a great responsibility on any man, it will exercise his mind with suffering, subject his sinews and bones to hard work, expose his body to hunger, put him to poverty, place obstacles in the paths of his deeds so as to stimulate his mind, harden his nature, and improve wherever he is incompetent. So that's the exact same as what doesn't kill me makes you stronger. My third book, The Coddling the American Mind, is based very much on this idea, which Nassim Taleb, who wrote The Black Swan, he wrote a book called Anti-Fragile. The idea of anti-fragility is the key thing. That's what's being expressed. That if you think about the immune system, it's the ultimate anti-fragile system. If something is fragile, you need to protect it. Glass is fragile. We don't let kids play with it. If they drop a glass, it breaks. Nothing good happens. We give them plastic, a plastic sippy cup. If they drop it, it doesn't break, but nothing good happens. And Taleb was asking, what's the name for things where if you drop them, they get better? And the immune system is like that. If we protect our dirt or germs to touch my child, you're crippling the development of the immune system because the immune system is like that. It's designed, it evolved to take in threats, react to them in a small way, and now it can react quickly later to larger threats. Our muscles are anti-fragile. Our bones are anti-fragile. We take it easy on them, they weaken. You need to stretch them, strain them, stress them to make them grow. So adversity is absolutely essential for life. Stress is essential for life. But this is where the psychology brings in some nice qualifications. So first, we need to understand there's a field called post-traumatic growth. So of course, there's post-traumatic stress, there's trauma, there's damage. Most of the time when something bad happens, people end up growing from it. There are some exceptions to that. We need obstacles and adversity to grow. We need them to have a better life story. One of my students was saying nothing bad has ever happened to her. She doesn't really have much in her life story. I don't want to glorify or dramatize adversity, especially not severe or traumatic events. And I tell the story in the book. I had this discussion with my students at UVA, the undergrads at UVA back in 2006. And there was one young woman in the class who was a student at UVA. And she was a student at UVA. And she was who'd had brain cancer. And she had to take three years off from school. She had multiple brain operations. And we talked about the adversity hypothesis, which is that the highest levels of human flourishing are only open to people who have suffered. That, of course, you can have a happy life if you've never had any suffering. But that people have gone through hell, people have gone through war, through cancer, that there are levels of engagement with the world that are more open to them than to the rest of us. And she was a strong believer in that. She said, absolutely, that is true. I mean, this is what she'd been through. She was so full of love and just the joy of life. Yeah, I think that we need to be thinking about adversity differently. And this is why it's so important in the Kali American mind and in the anxious generation. We have to give our kids a lot of independence so that they can make mistakes. They can get hurt on the playground. Because if you can get hurt in a playground, that means every day you're learning how to not get hurt. But if we keep them in super safe playgrounds, they don't learn how to not get hurt. And that's why I think it's so important to not get hurt. They don't learn independence. We have a new closing segment on the show called What's Good. It could be something that's good in your life, or it could be a book or a TV show. I know exactly what I want to talk about. Okay. You do yours, and then I'll give you one. Okay. So here's mine. I am falling more and more deeply in love with my dog. And so here's, so we got this wonderful dog, Wilma, three years ago. And I write about this in the anxious generation because it's like, there's all this great attachment system stuff happening with her. She's adorable. And she's kind of dumb. And we did a terrible job training her. So she's not obedient. And she's not even fully toilet trained. So I cannot say that this is the best dog in the world. She's not the best dog in the world, but she's my dog. And what happened this summer, I've been so busy with the anxious generation. I've been traveling around. But this summer, finally, I really took the summer off. And I spent almost the whole summer with Wilma. And my wife would come and go. My kids And by the end of the summer, I looked at her, and I just realized, wow, I just really love you. And the other thing, which is part of the pleasure, is I loved being a father to two to four-year-olds. I miss those days so much. Once they start running, that's when dads become the best. Because we play the chasing game. We pretend to be monsters. We pick them up and throw them up in the air. So I love that. My wife says, I don't miss that. at all those years. overwhelming for her. But, you know, but for me as a dad, like, oh, it's so much fun. And so what I realized is the way that I am with Wilma is very much the way I was when my kids were two to four years old. What kind of dog is Wilma? Wilma is a Pouton, which means half toy poodle, half coton de tuliere, which is a little white French fluffy breed you'll see around on the streets of New York City. She's just the cutest. She looks like a teddy bear come to life. That's what she looked like as a puppy. And she still looks that way. And so it's just a joy to have her in our in our lives. And again, it's like relatedness, like this is the source of our pleasures being embedded in relationships that grow slowly over time. All right, I'll give you I'll give you one. This is every every time we have this is a new segment. And generally speaking, people come on and give me something highbrow and beautiful, and then I give them something lowbrow and stupid. I watched a documentary with my son recently on Mr. T. Oh, my God, Mr. T. T from the 80s, who was a huge. So you're eight years older than me. For me, Mr. T would just came at the perfect time with Rocky three and then the A-team right around the time that I was maybe 11, 12. So it just really lodged in my consciousness as this larger than life. Masculinity. Yes, cool masculinity. But what I didn't realize is that he was kind of a radical figure. First of all, he was not a trained actor. He got cast in Rocky. Three by Rocky Balboa, because Rocky Balboa noticed that Leon Spinks, the real boxer, had a really cool bodyguard who was. Oh, my God. Oh, my God. Who is this guy who was raised in abject poverty in the projects of Chicago, I believe, who gets thrust into this global panoramic fame through being Clubber Lang in Rocky three and then the star of this huge primetime TV show called The A-Team. And he. He used his fame to talk about race and the way, you know, he used he he wore all these gold chains. Oh, yeah. Yeah. And he's and he was asked about that. And he said, my ancestors were brought to this country in shackles. I'm turning that into gold. And he was unrepentant and unapologetic about who he was and the way he was. He and black people were viewed by the culture. And his job was to change that. His hero is Muhammad Ali, who said, I'm not going to Vietnam. I have no quarrel with the with the Vietcong. They never called me the N-word. And so it was fascinating to watch with my son. And Mr. T is now in his 70s and preaching the gospel in Chicago. That's a beautiful story, in part because it connects across generations. It connects your son to an important thread in American history. It's beautiful. Jonathan Haidt. The book is The Happiness Hypothesis, but he's written many other books, all of which I recommend The Anxious Generation, The Coddling of the American Mind and The Righteous Mind. The Righteous Mind, which is the first one I read and had a real impact on me. We talk about it in our first interview, which I will put a link to in the show notes. It had a real impact on me in thinking about these polarized times. So thank you for your contributions. Thank you for coming on today. It's always a pleasure to see you. Dan, thanks for a great discussion. Thank you very much for listening to the show. If you care about supporting independent media and creators who are trying to make the world a little bit saner, you can hook us up by liking or rating and reviewing. And following the show wherever you watch or listen, subscribe me for my newsletter on Substack, following me on social media. All of these things really do help us grow. It's a big deal to us and would just take about 30 seconds if you have the time and inclination. Thank you again for watching. Thanks for supporting what we do. Now to the credits. Thank you so much to everybody who worked so hard to make this show. 10% Happier is produced by Tara Anderson, Barissa Schneiderman, DJ Kashmir, David Hart, and Hayden Broom. Post-production is handled by the great folks over at Greenhorn Creative. And Nick Thorburn of the great indie rock band Islands wrote our theme. Thank you for listening. Deuces.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Jonathan Haidt’s *The Happiness Hypothesis* blends ancient wisdom—like Stoic and Buddhist teachings—with modern psychological research to explore enduring truths about human well-being.
  2. A central idea is the "divided self," where automatic, instinctive system one (like emotions and habits) dominates behavior, while conscious reasoning (system two) acts as a rider on top of a larger, more powerful elephant.
  3. The book emphasizes practical tools such as the "stoic challenge" to pause, reflect, and reframe negative reactions to setbacks, reducing suffering through mindful awareness.
  4. Haidt argues that passionate love is fleeting and often misjudged, while companionate love—built through slow, deep connection—is more essential for lasting, stable relationships.
  5. He highlights the importance of adversity and stress in human growth, citing post-traumatic growth and anti-fragility as key to resilience and meaningful life experiences.
  6. Modern technology, especially social media and AI, disrupts social relationships and diminishes human connection, leading to increased anxiety and depression.
  7. Western cultures often misinterpret Eastern philosophies like non-attachment, and Haidt proposes a more realistic middle path—non-attachment without emotional detachment.
  8. True flourishing, especially in modern societies, involves embracing experiences, challenges, and emotional ups and downs, rather than complete disengagement from life.

Summary:

Jonathan Haidt’s *The Happiness Hypothesis* bridges ancient wisdom and modern science to explore what makes human life meaningful and fulfilling. At its core, the book examines the "divided self"—a metaphor where our automatic, emotional mind (the elephant) drives most behavior, while our conscious reasoning (the rider) can guide us toward better choices. This insight leads to practical tools like the "stoic challenge," where individuals pause and reframe negative reactions to setbacks, fostering resilience.

Haidt also emphasizes the importance of companionate love over fleeting passion, arguing that deep, slow-burning relationships are key to long-term happiness. He explores how adversity is essential for growth, citing anti-fragility and post-traumatic growth as vital to emotional resilience. Meanwhile, he critiques modern technology for eroding human connection, noting that constant digital exposure undermines social bonds and leads to anxiety.

Haidt revises traditional views of non-attachment, suggesting that a balanced, compassionate middle path—where we care deeply but remain open to impermanence—is more realistic for modern life. Ultimately, true flourishing comes not from detachment, but from engaging with life’s challenges, relationships, and emotions, especially in a world increasingly shaped by uncertainty and technological disruption.

FAQs

The book explores ancient wisdom from cultures like Buddhism and Stoicism and tests how well these ideas hold up against modern psychological research, showing that many timeless principles are still valid today.

It means that our perception and thoughts shape how we experience events—whether a situation is seen as positive or negative depends on how we interpret it, a core idea shared across Stoicism, Buddhism, and cognitive behavioral therapy.

It describes the human mind as having two systems: an automatic, instinctive system (like an elephant) that drives emotions and behaviors, and a conscious, reasoning system (a small rider) that can reflect and make decisions to guide behavior.

When facing a setback, one can pause and say 'stoic challenge' to reflect on the situation, creating space to respond thoughtfully instead of reacting emotionally, which helps shift from suffering to resilience.

Passionate love is intense and fleeting, often driven by attraction and hormones, while companionate love is deep, slow-growing, and based on shared life experiences and mutual dependence—key to long-term, stable relationships.

No—it argues that in modern, secure societies, emotional attachment and experiencing life's ups and downs are more beneficial than complete detachment, advocating for a balanced, open-hearted approach to relationships.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.