The 2024 U.S. election delivered a decisive Democratic victory, with major wins in red states like Texas, Georgia, and Michigan, flipping control of both the House and Senate. This outcome reflects broad anti-establishment sentiment, particularly resentment toward President Trump’s financial practices, war policies, and perceived lack of accountability. Despite Trump's rise on populist grounds, he was repudiated by voters who rejected his governance, especially on issues of economic hardship and elite wealth. Michigan’s win by Abdul Al-Sayed—a candidate with strong anti-Israel views—signals a shift in the national political landscape, though analysts believe his confrontational style and narrow victory limit his long-term influence. The new Democratic Congress, led by figures like Kevin McCarthy and Chuck Schumer, will face intense pressure from progressive and anti-Israel factions, though moderate leadership may help maintain bipartisan support. Israel’s role in U.S. policy remains a flashpoint, with future decisions likely shaped by the balance between party ideology and public sentiment. The 2028 Democratic nomination field appears to center on Gavin Newsom, Pete Buttigieg, and Josh Shapiro, with a critical question being whether a Jewish American candidate can emerge as a viable nominee amid rising anti-Israel rhetoric. Meanwhile, the Republican Party faces internal instability, with JD Vance’s path to nomination now questioned due to his distance from Trump’s policies. The election has exposed deep fractures in American politics, prompting a reevaluation of party alignments, policy priorities, and the future of U.S.-Israel relations.
Join ARK Plus to get early access to our second weekly Call Me Back episode,
Add Free Listening, and our members only ask me anything episode. Join at ARKMedia.org.
You are listening to an ARK Media podcast.
Look, it's a repudiation of the president and the way he's governed on a range of issues.
And I think the one that's most under discussed so far is if you look at most of the issues
with one big exception that put the president and his party on the wrong side of the electorate.
It wasn't because he went too far to the right. It's because he wasn't populist enough.
The very same issues that angered Democrats and independence also angered a lot of mega.
What are those issues? They don't like the war. They don't like the high prices that come from the war.
They don't like the way he handled Epstein. They don't like the way he's made a lot of money.
And his family has made a lot of money while he's in office. There was just a big anti-establishment.
And the irony, of course, is Trump is president because of populism.
And last night he was fully repudiated because of populism.
It's 7 a.m. on Wednesday, November 4th here in New York City. It's 2 p.m. on Wednesday,
November 4th in Israel. Before we get started, one quick housekeeping note.
On Wednesday, November 11th, call me back or record a live episode at the Israel High Yom Summit
at the Intercontinental Hotel in Times Square here in New York.
Israel High Yom is one of Israel's leading newspapers. It's a source I rely on quite regularly.
And it's also where our media contributor Amit Segal serves as chief political analyst.
Amit will be on stage with us. The timing is hard to beat. It will be two weeks after Israel's election
end, one week after our midterms here in the U.S. and of course, all of this against the backdrop
of anticipated escalation intentions with Iran. The summit is a full day event focused on the future
of the U.S. Israel relationship with speakers including former Mossad director Dady Barnaya,
Pfizer CEO Albert Burla, and Ambassador Yehuda Kaplan, whose U.S. special envoy to monitor and combat
anti-semitism. Dr. Miriam Adelson will also be in the audience and on stage. If you're in New York,
come join us. Follow the link in the episode description and use promo code ISH50. That's for Israel
High Yom. That's ISH50 for 50% off the registration. And if you can't make it, we'll be airing this
as an episode of Call Me Back in the coming weeks. Now onto today's episode. Last night wasn't
just a blue wave. It was a blue tsunami. Democrats didn't just take back the House and Senate.
As of this morning, they've secured at least 228 seats in the House of Representatives.
Well, past what's necessary to win a majority and are on track to a shocking 240 and possibly
even 250 seats and 54, which could become 55 or 56 seats in the U.S. Senate. They won in places
Republicans considered untouchable for Democrats, from Texas to Kansas to South Carolina.
Two years after Donald Trump's extraordinary political comeback, American voters seem to have
delivered an equally extraordinary rejection of his presidency. In Michigan, Abdul Al-Sayed,
a fierce critic of Israel. In fact, he doesn't even recognize Israel's right to exist.
One, his Senate race. We've never had someone with these views on the U.S.
Israel relationship in the U.S. Senate before. And candidates backed by the Democratic
Socialists of America scored victories across the country, including several congressional seats
here in New York. But what exactly did American voters reject last night? And what did they actually
express support for? And what does this mean for Israel, as the Democratic Party's progressive
wing will certainly gain influence? And looking ahead to 2028, what does this mean for the Democratic
and GOP presidential primaries? To make sense of this political earthquake and try to get an
understanding of where things may go from here, we're joined by longtime political journalist and
analyst Mark Halpert. Mark is the editor-in-chief of Two Way and the worldwide news premium newsletter.
I'm a consumer of both products. He's also the host of his own podcast. He's also, as I said,
longtime political journalist at ABC News and Bloomberg News and Time Magazine and the co-author
of best-selling books about presidential elections. Usually, our Wednesday episode, the one you're
listening to now, is only released to ARK+ subscribers. And then we release it on Friday to the
main call-me-back feed. But we are releasing today's episode to everybody as a public service.
If you liked this early access experience, we encourage you to subscribe to ARK+ so you can
always get these episodes two days before they go out on the main feed. My conversation with Mark
right after this short message. Hi, I'm Daniel Hartman, president of the Shalom Hartman Institute
in Jerusalem. And I'm Yasi Kline-Halevi, senior fellow at the Shalom Hartman Institute.
What's more important, to be feared by your enemies or morally true to yourself? Should
Israel strive to be a nation among nations or should it accept the fact that it is now a
fortress apart? What do Israelis and they ask for Jews owe each other? If you're Jewish or a friend
and ally, these questions have been annoying at you these past few years. For some of you like
for us, these questions have been keeping you up at night. And for some, they've been simmering
in the background, waiting for answers. What the lemons don't always have clear answers.
What they do deserve are honest and respectful debates. And as it happens, Yasi and I love to
challenge each other to get to the bottom of things. We look at current events through a lens that
speaks to us most deeply, a Jewish lens. So if today's Jewish dilemmas are on your mind,
tune in to our conversation on For Heaven's Sake, a partnership between Arc Media and the Shalom
Hartman Institute. You can find For Heaven's Sake on Apple, Spotify, YouTube, or wherever you
get your podcasts. See you there. And we're back with Mark Halpert. Okay, Mark, quite a night.
Since you and I are sleep deprived, I'm going to let you navigate me through what actually happened.
So Americans voted yesterday. Democrats took the House and the Senate. They flipped many red
states. They won in places that I thought while they were likely to win, I thought it was going to
be a lot closer. What's your overall impression of the election results? It's honestly it's too big
to describe it. I compare it to what's going on with AI. We all know there's 100 extraordinary
stories there and it takes a while for the human brain to get their arms around it. I think you
got include in your litany of what happened to governors races where now it's not of the 10 most
populist states will have Democratic governors and all the presidential battleground states will
have Democratic governors. In addition, the down ballot races, every statewide office in Texas
where they haven't had a statewide officer in 30 years is now will not be a Democrat. The state
legislators, the political cultures that were so red in places like Ohio, Texas, Georgia will now
all be Democratic dominated. And I think the one that's most under discussed so far, but I'll be talking
about it a lot today is if you look at most of the issues with one big exception that put the
president and his party on the wrong side of the electorate, it wasn't because he went too far
to the right. The same very same issues that angered
Democrats and independence also angered a lot of mega. They don't like the way he's made a lot of money and his family has made a lot of money while he's
in office. They don't like the data centers and the cab towering to billionaires. These are all
populist mega issues that I hear about from mega people on two way every day. And there are also
the issue a lot of the issues the left doesn't like an independent like so the Republican party and
the Democratic party and all these governors as they as they make a lot of policy and the new Congress
they're going to have to decide is the lesson for them that everybody should be a Sanders Trump
old Trump populist or not because that that's what carried the day those issues. So one exceptions
tariffs were populists like the tariffs on both the left and the right and the establishment does
it. But otherwise it was just a big anti establishment. And the irony of course is Trump is president
because of populism. And last night he was he was fully repudiated because of populism.
Were you surprised by the results? No, not in the least. I've been reporting it for almost a
month talking to Republicans. What I'm actually surprised at is no almost no one besides me.
I'll just say with as much modesty as I can muster almost no one was touting this. And I said
this is likely to happen not a prediction not something I was rooting for but just talking to my
sources and both parties. This is not a hard one to explain. The president was unpopular and seen
as not doing a good job on the issues voters cared most of bed primarily the economy. So I'm not
surprised by a single outcome. I'm sort of surprised by the fact as always happens in a
soon on political tsunami. There were some survivors like the governor of the new governor of Florida
the reelected senator in Florida but no. But you got to wonder mark had the democrats decided to
really invest in Florida which they didn't who knows what would have happened. Invest at all.
Invest at all. You know, one of the crazy stories of this cycle is the Republican billionaires
and one trillionaire came in big.
and kept the party from being blown out even more. Most of the Democratic money stayed on the
sidelines. And if they had put a little money into Louisiana, they almost won the Senate seat in
Louisiana. If they had put a little money in for David Jolly, who was at spent by tens of millions
of dollars, they would now control all 10 of the biggest governorships. And they'd have at
least one more Senate seat, maybe two. Okay. Michigan was a race that you and I talked about
back in August. I during that conversation, and I was struck by the reaction I got to, because
a number of folks, I guess, were not as dialed into the following point. You and I made together,
which, which was that if El Sayed wins in Michigan, the implications for 2028 are extraordinary.
The implications for the future of US policy in the Middle East are far bigger than anything,
you know, Mamdani is mayor of New York City, yells and screams about. I mean, it's it's we're in
a whole new world. So let me just say we are in a whole new world. It was a race that I was watching
closely. You were watching closely. And many of our listeners of this podcast were watching closely.
It was a scene, it was seen as a test of, you know, whether Democrats were taking a huge gamble
by back in candidates like El Sayed. He won. He didn't win as by as wide a margin as his peers did
in states that have like similar demographics to to Michigan. And he didn't win probably by
the same margin that someone like Hayley Stevens would have won by shooter by 10 or 15 points likely.
But I don't think anyone will remember that. They'll say they threw everything at El Sayed.
El Sayed ran on agenda that many on the right and even on the center and even the center left
said could never get elected a and be especially not in the heartland, not in a swing state,
a swing presidential state, not in state that Donald Trump won twice. That's all people will
be talking about. What's your read of that race and its outcome? I'll say something reassuring
to your audience which last time I know, I got a lovely reception for my appearance, but I know a
lot of people were troubled by the the realities I was sharing. I think the totality of the results
and the fact that there'll be so many new Democratic senators who may share some of his issue
positions, but not his style really delutes the impact of his victory. I don't think he's going
to be nearly as powerful. I don't think he'll be as nearly as big a threat in part because
there's so many other Democratic senators who new senators who coming in who don't share his
views in a totality. Because they're all conciliators, they're all people who want to get along
with the other party. Last night, I'll go outside and his victory speech attacked and mocked
Mike Rogers, attacked and mocked the vice president. I think he's going to have trouble
being as influential as he would have been at, he'd been one of a handful of winners and I think
stylistically, I just don't think that's going to be an effective way to be influential. Now,
he could still run for president if Sanders and AOC don't. He's still get a lot of attention from
the press. He'll still have a megaphone, but I don't think he's going to be the center of gravity
of the new class as he would have under other circumstances. But I say that, I say that with a
little bit of humility, because I could be wrong. His positions are turned out to draw the base
support that would sway others. But my current view is that's not going to be the case.
So just to explain this because we have, as Alana often reminds me, we have an audience, a large
audience outside the US. I just want to put this in context for folks. What you and I, Mark,
talked about in August was that if LCA had one, he would be like an end of one in national politics
and democratic politics, and that would contribute to this kind of rocket ship that his career would
begin to really advance the path to advance on. And I think what you're saying now is
there are a lot of al-Saheads that one less say. Now, not al-Sahead in the way that the people
listening to this podcast, I think, are worried about, but there are a lot of interesting, unexpected
Democrats who won in places they shouldn't have won. So to give an example, the Democrat won in
Texas. Like I can't remember the, who's the last Democratic senator from Texas? Lloyd Benson.
I don't know. I mean, Lloyd Benson. Lloyd Benson, right? Yeah. Who was Mike DeCoccus' running mate
for president who's vice president to running mate in 1988 just to give people a sense.
So that's the last time a Democrat has won a Senate seat in Texas. So I think Mark, what you're
saying is like someone like Teleriko who won that Senate seat, he will be very interesting.
Yeah. Let me go down the list. But in addition to a lot of them winning in red states,
let me tell you just the thumbnail biographies of the people al-Sahead will be competing with for
attention. Two ministers, one from a state that hadn't had a Democrat senator in 30 years,
one from a state that hadn't had a Democratic senator in 90 years. Two very halogenic ministers,
very smart ministers. Kansas and Kansas and Texas, a pair of athletes, gold medal, two-time gold
medalists, a basketball player in a wheelchair from Iowa, a logger from the Canadian main in the
right on the Canadian border, a female pediatrician. Okay. These are going to, it could be if he wins
in Mississippi, a black prosecutor from a deep red state. So he's going to, he's not going to dominate.
And again, he does not play nicely with the press, a freshman senator who doesn't play nicely
with his colleagues and given his temperament. I don't know that he will. They tend not to be rewarded
with access and influence and and prime speaking slots, etc. So he showed during the general
election that he wasn't willing or didn't want to calibrate his behavior to try to expand his
appeal to others. And so again, those folks are all folks who want to get along with with
the dev republicans want to get things done for their constituents. I don't know that he's going
to have nearly the influence I thought last time you and I talked about it. And Mark, when you say
he doesn't play well, he's a hothead. So it's, can you say a little bit, because again,
I assume people here haven't been following him like you and I are describing, I've been struck
by this throughout the election. And I thought he was going to change his style after the primary.
And he did. So can you explain a little bit, describe a little bit? He's every day the way Dan
Seanor is on his worst day. Now just kidding. You're never, you're not like that. You know, when reporters ask him
tough, but fair questions in a respectful way, he just lies and he filibusters and he tries to
change his subject in a way that's cartoonish. I mean, it's, it's akin to Donald Trump. But in some
ways, it's, I find it even more cartoonish. He's pee-vish with people. And not, and again, I don't
remember. It's not unprecedented, but to, to be the greatest night of your professional life,
you're a senator elect, first Muslim American senator. And you, you mock Mike Rogers. I think
he said, literally, I hope we never see you in this state again. He mocked JD Vance. JD Vance
is the president of the Senate. And so again, this is a temperament. We all know people like this.
I don't know too many people in elective office like this. It's just not the style usually of people
who are trying to get whose jobs depend on other people liking them. So we'll see how he does. But,
but, and, and like I said, I don't, I don't want folks to, to who are concerned about his role
on the national town square. I don't want people to think he might, he might run for president. He
might, he might be able to whip up anti-Israel sentiment in the Congress. He might. But like I said,
in, in, in looking at how he's conducted himself and looking at the circumstances of his victory,
which was more narrow than some, I'm just not as sure that he's going to be influential. And
some of it might be based on Senator Sanders who supported him. And how much Senator Sanders
takes him under his wing and works in coalition with him. I think that'll be a critical factor.
In terms of demographics that, that delivered for these candidates, obviously they, they,
there was a surge in democratic turnout and independence everywhere. Independent voters broke
heavily, you know, strongly for, for the Democrats. What, what are you seeing so far? I know it's
hard because we're all kind of trying to make sense of these exit polls. But in terms of,
of Republican voters, did we see Republicans in meaningful numbers, either just not turn out
or actually in some cases break for the Democrat? Yeah. This is all very simple. And again,
I talked about this at length before the election. I just, I'm not going to hurt myself patting
myself on the back, but I have to, yeah, that's all right. You deserve it. I said, I said along,
there are four dials that have to be turned for Democrats to win in, in red states. And the four
dials are more Democrats have to vote as a percentage of the electorate in politics that call
the contributions of vote. So need to be more democratic votes as a overall percentage of the vote
than, than say in 2024. Second dial that has to turn, it's the one that has to turn dramatically
is many more independence have to vote Democrat than Republican. Then the share of the electorate
that comes from the Democrat, from the Republicans has to go down, which of course happens as a share
for the Democrats go up by math. And then some number, not a big number, but some number of Republicans
have to vote Democratic. I'll give you an example. If you'd like, this is in South Carolina,
where everybody told me there was a zero percent chance that any injuries that Democrat would win.
Okay. And so here are the comparisons we're comparing what Kamala Harris got two years ago in South
Carolina, to what any Andrews got. First dial, Democratic share of the electorate went from 36
percent to 40 percent, plus four, not a big change, not a big change, but significant. The
Republicans share of the electorate, of course, went down by four. Mathematically, that's going to
happen, right? Republicans who voted Democrat went from five percent to 14 percent. That's pretty
significant. But this is the big one. And this is what I told people, this is the one dial that needs
to turn a lot. And it would require an historic shift in a two year period. Independence voted
Democrat for Kamala Harris. Kamala Harris got 53 percent of the independent vote. Any Andrews
got 71 percent of independence. Wow. That's actually one. All four dials turned and I'm sure I haven't
We're on the numbers yet, but that's it.
going to be the pattern in all these other states. And I say to people, you go into place
like Iowa, Ohio, Texas, South Carolina, very red states, very Republican states in some
cases forever. All you need to do is turn those four dials three a little one a lot. And
you go from the Democrat can't win to the Democrat can't lose. This is wild. Mark, to what extent
you mentioned the issues that mattered in this race. And I've, that's an interesting frame
that that Trump wasn't populist enough. Where does Israel's fit stand on your list of issues?
And how much should we read into whether or not Israel, the US is a relationship, US policy
in the Middle East, you can take that wherever you want. That that was there was a referendum
on that last night. I don't really see it as a big issue except in, um, in the Michigan race.
Now obviously came up in the main Senate race as well. I think it's up for grabs in the new
Congress in the lame duck session that will begin next week and go to some towards the end of the
year in the new Congress. I think a lot of a lot of decisions related to Israel will be predicated
on what the two new majority leader, you know, the speaker, the new speaker of the House and the
House, Ikeem Jeffries from Brooklyn, New York, Farah Manageuse there and Chuck Schumer, the new
Senate majority leader, Brooklyn, New York Farah Manageuse there. Both long time supporters of
Israel, but both on that issue as on so many others in the last couple of years acted as if the
base of the party called the shots and the base of the party is not pro Israel. The president on
Tuesday said no more foreign aid to Israel because that's what BB asked for in an interview.
Let's see. And obviously it's caught up in two big questions that will impact how much of a
front burner is your issue. Israel is and how the American people and therefore the Congress
react. One is the new government. When do we get a new government? What does it look like? What are
its policies? And two is the disposition if there is one anytime soon of the Iran war, they're on
conflict. I don't I think that the interplay between those three factors, not just what the president
does, but what Schumer and Jeffries do on the sort of the sense of the new democratic caucuses
and the House and the Senate on Israel, how much of a priority they make it Netanyahu or not,
and they run conflict. That'll tell the tale. And you could have you could have BB and Trump and
Schumer and Jeffries on here as your guests with me. And they wouldn't be able to answer the question
either. Mark, I want to read you in response to that. I want to read you one tweet that
the member, like congressional member, like from New York posted. So this is in response to Trump
saying he's going to cut off eight to Israel at Netanyahu's request. Ending military aid is not
enough. We need to end US taxpayer funding for Israel's war crimes, a full arms embargo,
and the Palestinian right of return. Not getting into the merits of all those issues, but let's just
say those are those are issues way out. That means Palestinian right of return means not only should
there be a Palestinian state. That's that's table stakes. It's that the Palestinians anywhere in the
world are descendants of Palestinians should be able to move into Israel. So you basically can like,
you know, swarm Israel's population. My question is, so that's a very extreme position. I shared
that with a number of friends of mine, Democratic friends in office, elected officials. They of course
were alarmed. But the only comfort they took is that unlike because I, you know, I've been concerned
Democrats went in the house and had Kim Jeffries who would be the new speaker of the house. You
know, many would view regard him as more moderate. He would be squeezed by those on the extreme.
And his Democratic caucus, the way Kevin McCarthy went through when he was speaker of the house,
where he was squeezed by some Republicans in his caucus. And he had too small of a majority.
So you'd have any cushion and he had to be overly responsive to those, you know, more extreme
pressure points. And I was concerned that people like derelides, I would be able to exert the same
kind of pressure on the speaker, Jeffries. How concerned are you by that concern? Do you think
that's a real direct or do you think the majority is so big in the house that he keeps Jeffries
has so much cushion that he's not going to have to be as responsive to people like derelizing.
Right. Let me say a couple of things that they go into the factors I listed before. First of all,
both Schumer and Jeffries will have larger majorities than some thought they would. And,
and I think that gives them some flexibility. They don't, they can't be, I'll use the
shorthand blackmail that are extorted by the new member you cited from New York and others who
have those kinds of positions on Israel. They can't, they can't say to the leadership,
you must give us what we want on Israel. We won't vote for you on other stuff. So that's for those
who don't want her to carry the day. That's big. Number two, really it's, and truly, and you can see
this, your, your audience can see this as an upside or a downside. The vast majority of members
of the House and Senate who are Democrats, vast majority who cow cow to the far left on issues
related to Israel don't really feel that way. They do it because they're afraid of the base.
And so if they're given an opportunity such as to say, well, BBs, no they're anymore, for instance,
I think a lot of them will revert back to the decades long, you know, bipartisan consensus
of support for Israel. I think that's a real possibility because that's really where they want to be.
And they'll, and they'll, because we're past them in terms, they'll be less afraid of the base.
But the other big factor that I should have listed before is the fight for their democratic
nomination. You know, I've talked about this. There are seven or eight serious potential candidates
who are Jewish Americans, almost all of whom are pretty supportive of Israel. I continue to be told
by many democratic strategists and analysts and politicians that a Jewish American cannot win
the nomination, need not apply. And you told that by non-Jewish democratic strategist, both, well,
Jewish and non-Jewish both. Yeah. Governor Shapiro weighed in yesterday on El Sayad in a way that
I think people should find it discouraging. It was worse than discouraging, Mark. And I like
Governor Shapiro. It was chilling to me. Yeah. Okay. So just for our listeners, Governor Shapiro,
yeah, in the last couple of days, Governor Shapiro, for those again, for our listeners who don't know,
he's Jewish Democrat, Governor of Pennsylvania, reelected overwhelmingly, always talked about,
you know, usually talked about, I think, more so after yesterday as a possible democratic candidate
for president in 2028. He was on Kamala Harris' short list for vice president in 2024. He was asked
in the last couple of days, does he support El Sayad for the Senate in Michigan? And in so many
words, I mean, I don't go through all the, you know, the throat clearing, but he said yes. Yeah.
I was sad to see that because I know where he stands on these issues. Yeah. And the fact that even
he felt it necessary to check the box and say, I'm with El Sayad was to me an interesting data point
in terms of where the conversation is in the Democratic Party. 100%. And but once Barack Obama,
when campaigned with the guy, the permission structure was there for all Democrats to get on board
with him, not all the most, look, even wrong, Israel, Emmanuel has not been a profile on courage on
this. Right. Governor, Governor Newsom has not. So I think a big factor will be, and I think I
think that now the Democratic field will be big. I didn't think it was going to be so big before,
but now I think it will be big because they'll see the nomination is worth having. When you say
that, the nomination is worth having meaning, meaning a Democrat really can get on with in 2028.
It's worth going through it. And it's, and it's not worth missing the prime, missing the process
for, for worry that you, you missed your chance to be present if you're someone with that ambition.
I really do believe that there is no one, not Pete Buttigieg, a previous candidate who's
going to run again, not Governor Shapiro, not Governor Newsom and those I think are the three
most likely nominees today, not the other potential candidates who are also Jewish. I don't see
a one of them who I could tell you with any confidence would enter this process and say,
I'm going to tell the young people in my party who have turned hostile to Israel and others,
but particularly then people, no, that's not right. This is our ally in the region. This is an
important strategic ally. It's a democracy. There are many reasons why we've had a long-standing
alliance with the country. I want to restore that and I'm going to fight for that in the heart and
soul of this party. I can't tell you with any confidence that a single candidate will do that.
And maybe even to the contrary, which is why a big part of why people tell me a Jewish American
can't beat the nominee, I think the contrary, they'll all be rushing to the left. They'll all be
rushing to the anti-Israel left. Now, and this is where those of your listeners and your audience
and you have many people and your audience who would fit this, I think if people need to pressure
them, if they want them to do this, they need to be told if you want to earn our votes and our
financial support and our public support for you, you need to adopt this. This is about the
heart and soul, not just a not just for Israel, not just for the Democratic Party but for the world
and for future generations. But as I said, left to do its own current political
physics, I don't see anybody having that fight and that's in some ways a lot more important,
I think, in terms of settling this in a positive way than is what's going to happen in Congress.
We'll be right back after this short message. How people come to understand Israel and Jewish life
right now depends on who is telling our story. Today, that work requires more care and integrity
than ever before and that doesn't come cheap. Our ARC+ members are the ones who fund it. They support
our mission and get early access to our second weekly episode, ad-free listening and our weekly
members only ask me anything episode. Join ARC+ at ARCMedia.org. And to our members, thank you.
What's happening in Israel and the Jewish world right now matters.
But it can be hard to keep up, let alone make sense of it all.
That's why we started ARC News Daily.
Every weekday morning, I walk you through the most important news,
give you the context you need and let you know what to look out for next.
I don't try to convince you of anything and I don't waste your time.
On most days, I'll be in your ears for about 10 minutes or less.
Then you can move on with your day, hopefully a little bit smarter than before.
Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts or follow the link in the show notes.
I hope to see you tomorrow.
Okay, I want to come back to the different candidates for 20/28
and what the field will look like in the size of the field has changed.
I want to come back to that.
But in terms of Trump and the next two years,
he will obviously be constrained as any president who loses Congress
during the last two years, especially of their second term,
gets constrained on domestic policy to some degree on economic policy.
But as we've seen historically, what happens in these environments
is the presidents where they have much more leeways on foreign policy.
They wind up engaging much more and getting much more ambitious about foreign policy
in the last two years of their administration.
Interestingly, Trump got very ambitious about foreign policy in the first two years of his term.
But what do you think he does now?
Because last night there was some commentary out of Israel,
which I thought was I person that was preposterous.
Now there's no way Trump will deal with Iran any further.
There's no way he'll try to get expansion of Abraham Cords
or possibly normalization between Israel and Saudi Arabia.
There's no way he'll just going to dial everything back.
He's going to be so distracted with all the investigations
and everything happening in Washington.
I'm saying because of the investigations or in spite of the investigations
and because of everything happening in Washington
or in spite of everything happening in Washington,
he's actually going to get more engaged in foreign policy.
Before last night, the central challenge of the Trump presidency,
foreign and domestic, was how to get leverage over Tehran, Beijing, and Moscow.
China being absolutely a number one.
But leverage over Putin, Xi, and the Itolla, a number one.
Most important thing.
It's been the most important thing for the entire presidency, actually.
And it's still the most important thing.
And yesterday's results do nothing in any significant way
to either help or hurt Trump with that project.
It maybe will hurt him on the margins
because Congress will be chipping away at his authority as best they can.
But I think, as you said, this is what his focus has been,
except for the ballroom in the Kennedy Center.
This is what his focus has been to the entire two years or nearly two years.
So I think he'll keep focusing on it.
But he doesn't have any solutions.
He doesn't have a solution for the straight.
He doesn't have a solution for the regime.
He doesn't have a solution for China and Russia's leverage over him.
Just as they had leverage over his predecessors.
So those three projects are still paramount.
But I don't know that yesterday helps him in any way.
It probably hurts him on the margins.
So he's got a big challenge.
But yeah, he'll still can spend a lot of time on those
because the economy of the United States can't take off until he solves Iran.
And to his credit, he also believes in the original,
original mission, which has got to keep Iran from being a nuclear power.
He also believes he's got to end Russia, Ukraine, war, conflict.
And he's willing to suck up to Putin for that.
And then again, the ultimate goal of the entire four years
and every respect was beating China in the existential struggle for supremacy
by beating them at points in the term
and then negotiating a settlement where the world gets carved up
and the United States does not need to constantly be trying to check China diplomatically
in terms of intelligence, in terms of espionage, in terms of military diplomat, et cetera.
Those projects are done make a lot of progress on those projects
and times running out.
Just to underline this point, there were many pointing out critics pointing out last night,
actually quite disappointing, leaving some critics from inside Israel
who said, "Oh, this means Trump is going to resent being pushed into the Iran war
by Netanyahu, and this is going to be a more damaging for Israel
that the fact that he experienced such an electoral bloodbath in part
because of the Iran war and Israel is going to get blamed."
This is Trump on Fox News last night, Mark.
He said people may blame it on Iran, but it was very important to do.
I'm paraphrasing here.
It was very important to do fully, and he was fully defending his decision
that this should have been done a long time ago.
And here I'm quoting, "I was given the task and I had no choice
because they were two weeks away from a nuclear weapon."
Others message, I reposted that last night.
People messaged me this morning saying, "That's ridiculous.
Iran wasn't two weeks away. I'm like, you're missing the point."
The point is Trump believed they were two weeks away
and this is a reminder that Trump has been talking with the Iran issue
for decades.
And the idea that this is something he was manipulated into
is that for several a moment for him to say, "Boy, I took a swing here
at the American encouragement of our ally Israel
and I'm now suffering politically."
He seems to not going anywhere near that.
Yeah, all his predecessors knew that the Iran nuclear threat
was an existential problem that had to be solved,
not just for Israel and the United States, but for the world.
Unless you're a big believer in the Obama agreement,
no president got close to solving.
The Obama agreement was a partial solution,
but certainly wasn't a complete solution.
And it left Iran in power, the regime in power.
And to his credit, President Trump took on the political risk.
Now, he thought it would be easier.
But for a guy who often does not tell the truth in public,
I believe he's telling the absolute truth when he says,
"I don't regret doing it."
Even with the political costs, even with the drag,
it's causing an economy.
I don't think he regrets doing it because he believed he said,
"I am not going to be like my predecessors."
And like I was in my first term and leave office
with Iran still possessing nuclear weapon.
Okay, Mark, just generally speaking,
what do you imagine the Trump presidency
to look like over the next two years?
No idea.
I've answered all your other questions.
You really have.
Yeah, but I have no idea.
I think he's going to try to work with Schumer and Jeffries
and I think the base of the Democratic Party
is going to say absolutely not embarrass him politically
as much as possible to elect a Democratic president,
keep a Democratic House and set it.
Have the trifecta and get stuff done.
So I assume that's what's going to happen,
but I don't know how Trump's going to react to that.
He could start offering.
The bizarre could be open.
He could start offering them Obamacare subsidies
and restore the Medicaid cuts and whatever.
Defund ICE.
I mean, who knows?
But it's right now.
Again, I say on this topic as two,
you could book Schumer, Jeffries and Trump
and Thune and Johnson as your guest
and say, and ask that question, Mr. President,
in conjunction with these four leaders,
what were your Presidency be like?
You don't know idea.
It's got no idea because he doesn't know what he wants to do.
He doesn't know what the traffic will bear within his own party,
what the traffic will bear with the Democratic Party.
It's unknowable.
Okay.
I want to talk to you a little bit about 2028.
And I know it's early days.
And there'll be names over the next two years
that we'll be talking about on the Democratic side
that we weren't even thinking about before last night.
But generally speaking, how would you sum up the field?
I love your eight for 28.
Mark, for our listeners, we can link to it in the show notes.
He does these regular updates where he does his eight top candidates.
What he assesses is the top eight contestants
for the Democratic nomination in 2028.
And he's constantly revising it.
Maybe Mark, why don't you summarize for us
the most recent eight for 28 that you presented?
I think in recent weeks.
And whether or not you think any of that's going to change
as a result of last night.
Yeah.
I think I alluded to this earlier.
I think the three top contenders are and will be regardless
of who runs assuming they run Gavin Newsom,
the governor of California, Pete Buttigieg,
the former Transportation Secretary in Indiana mayor
and Josh Shapiro.
Now, Buttigieg will run.
I don't know that the other two will.
But if they do, I think that will be the top tier.
That is my top tier now.
I think those will be the finalists.
There's three big questions that have to be answered before.
We really understand the countries of the field.
One is, who will the socialist candidate be?
I don't think Bernie Sanders or Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez
are inclined to be the socialist candidate.
But I suspect they'll talk now that the midterms are over
and say, we must have a strong socialist candidate.
Can it be one of us?
Either of us really want to do it?
And if one of them wants to do it,
I think that will be the socialist candidate.
But if they don't, I have to find one.
And that's how we could end up with the Abdul-Elsaad.
And I think the socialist candidate will have a very. If it's a strong socialist candidate,
well, a very good chance to be the nominee.
Number two will Kamala Harris run?
My sources are mixed on whether if she does run,
she'll be a strong candidate or not.
Some say she's the frontrunner, some say no.
But I think we have to see what happens there.
And then I think we have to have the Jewish question answered is,
can a Jew be nominated?
Because if a Jew can't be nominated,
I've had months where I think I've had six of the eight slots
of the most likely Democrat nominees filled by Jews.
You've got to have to answer those three questions
before we can truly understand the contours of this field.
You know, when President Obama was in Michigan 10 days ago,
campaigning for Al Sayed, he had this line.
I'm not going to get it exactly right.
But the gist of it was just imagine Michigan,
you could have in Alissa Slocke,
and who's the other senator from Michigan,
you could have in Senator Slocke in a Jewish senator
and in Senator Al Sayed, Abdul-Elsaad,
you can have a Muslim senator.
Michigan will be the only state with the Jewish senator
and a Muslim senator working side by side,
you know, on behalf of the state, you ought to get it.
And after last night, I was just thinking,
you know, could you see like a John Assoff,
Al Sayed ticket for the Democrats in 2028?
I mean, you can just start imagining the way that this could go.
I don't think Al Slocke's going to get it.
Iran. So no, really, unless I'm wrong, yeah, I think family, I think his families and
kids are too young, I think in his youth karate. He could change his mind, but I don't think
he will. It's based on my reporting. Look, if you took, if you took this guy's bio and you took
out his temper and you took out his positions on Israel and Jews, it'd be an extraordinarily
beloved and fascinating figure by many, including a lot of Democrats who don't like him now,
pluralistically to have a Muslim senator, fantastic. His bio is quite incredible. His American story
is quite incredible, but you can't take away the biographical stuff and the statements and the
issue positions and associations with Hassan Piker. You just can't take those away. And as you and I
just discussed earlier, there's no indication that he's trying to sort of remediate those things
through changed conduct. So I don't, I doubt he'd be on anybody's ticket, but I also know that
Michigan is going to play a key role, both in the nominating process and the general election,
and he, you know, he's a skilled guy with the following. He may be a kingmaker in both the general
election and both the nomination fight in the general if he doesn't run himself. It's super early
days, but in your view, just your media reaction, how this could shape the 2028 race on the Republican side?
I think it's one of the most profound effects of last night. I had thought that JD Vance would be
with Trump's endorsement, President Trump's endorsement, be the nominee. I think this raises a lot
of questions about how he had his path to the nomination. His, his, his, his team has been saying
for a while as, as I've, as I've talked to them and they've talked to others about the prospects
of a tsunami. This is good for us because this gives us a foil. You know, we can now run against,
you know, the liberal Democrats in Congress. I think this really complicates thing. Things for
him, and I think now you'll see people like Ted Cruz and Ron DeSantis really have an argument to
be made about why they should be the nominee ahead of JD Vance. And, and I think he's going to have
to figure out how he talks about what happened. You know, he's not going to be the nominee of the
Republican party. We don't have another election, national election before he will, if he runs,
he stands for denomination. So he's going to have to tell Republicans and the country. Here's what,
here's, here's what happens. You know, this is what happened. This is where I stand on some of
these things, particularly those populist issues where we have strong reasons to believe. At
least on some of those issues, he's not, he doesn't actually stand with the president. As a loyal
vice president, he has to toe the, the line of the, of the, of the, of the Oval Office, but he's
not with the president on the war. He's not with the president on, on Epstein, how Epstein was handled.
He's not with the president. I think on exploiting the office for, for personal financial gain,
I don't really know where he is on data centers. I think he's maybe more in line with the president
there, but he's going to have to navigate that. And he may decide navigating that is too complicated.
And he doesn't run. I've reported repeatedly that he, and he said to me in an interview a few days
ago that he may not run. But I think now running is a lot more complicated. And I believe his vulnerabilities
if within a Republican nominating contest are put in much sharper relief by what happened
yesterday. And do you imagine there being names start popping up that people just weren't focused
on, say, like a Glenn Youngkin or just, just folks that were viewed as kind of out of, out of fashion.
Yeah. It's possible. It's possible. It's hard to be an incumbent vice president with the
president's endorsement for somebody like Glenn Youngkin. In other words, are they running?
It's hard to be, it's hard to run against someone. It's hard to run and, and run and have a
reasonable chance to win. So sure, I could see a world where the Glenn Youngkins of the world look at
this. I'm sure they'll look at it. Chris Christie's talking about running. So yeah, we could go from
a field that I thought would basically be Vance and one or two others with very little chance
to a more robust field. I've never done eight for 28 for the Republicans because I couldn't get to
eight. It's possible that within a couple of weeks, I'll start doing it because I'll be able to get
to eight. Yeah. And then before we wrap, Mark, you see, you mentioned that the Vance or the people
around Vance want to think they have a useful foil, which are these Democrats who, by their
calculation, I assume, will overreach and therefore there's, there's a response. So our, our
mutual friend, Ron Fornier, who's a, who is a longtime White House correspondent for, for the
AP. I think that's where you know him from. It's where I know him from. And he's from Michigan. So he
lives in Michigan. He moved back to Michigan once he left journalism, but he writes this substack
that I, that I read regularly. I don't agree with everything he writes, but he's done a lot of on
the ground reporting in Michigan. And he has a keen, in, in, in, in size of political reporting
eye. And I know you've been relying on his, on, and he's, and he was clearly a champion for
L.C. Ed. I don't think he would, he, oh, come on. And he Mars, he Mars is political gifts,
but I don't know that he's a champion. I, I, to me, at least it was hard to not read between the
lines and, and see him rooting for him, but whatever we, that's, that's not the point of my question.
I want to read, I want to pull up what he wrote late last night. Okay. So he says four things,
so he wrote this piece in the substack. Maybe, maybe we can link to, link to it in the show notes.
Four things the Democratic Party must do to make tonight's shellacking stick. Okay. So this was his,
and I'm not going to read his whole substack. People read it. First, they must accept and address the
fact that their party's brand is on, is in the toilet, even his voters hand the major victories.
Second, they must avoid overreaching. Third, every Democratic governor and lawmakers elected
tonight must deliver on their promises to lower the cost of living while governing,
competently and cleanly. Fourth, they need a leader in the 2028 presidential race who can repair
the party's damage brand and reform the US political system. That is a pretty tall order.
And, and I think it raises a point that, you know, despite the shellacking to use his to Ron's word,
you know, just last night, it's hard to, it's sometimes hard to remember that we, it's how hard
it is to reconcile the fact that the Democrats show overperformed last night. And as Ron says,
the Democratic brand to quote him is in the toilet. How is that? How do you reconcile those two?
And what do you think of his checklist here? They won with a brand in the toilet and no ideas
because the weakness of what they were running against it because in terms, tend to be left
to their own devices, referendums on the incumbent party. I think their opportunity is there for
Schumer, Jeffries, the presidential candidates and the donors of the party to create organizations
and projects to try to rehabilitate the image of the party, develop policy ideas, and to consolidate
these political gains. And, and there's already conversations going on about that. Let's see if they
do that. Let's see if they execute on that. The Republican party and, and these organizations are
fragile in large part because they're so Trump dependent. And, and you're going to see a lot of
donors, maybe even Elon say, we put in hundreds of millions of dollars and we got shellacked.
And it's going to be the opposite for the Democratic billionaires who are going to say,
we sat this out for the most part and we won, but we left seats on the table. And now we have an
obvious route to electing a Democratic president and, and, and maybe locking in some of these gains.
So let's see if the president, the, the, the, the Democrat elders and, and leaders read what Ron
wrote or think of it themselves and try to consolidate this stuff. I think if they do, at a time of
vulnerability for the Republican party and the MAGA movement, they could, they could make some
real inler roads and have a huge impact, not just on 2028, but beyond. Okay. Mark, we will leave it
there. Thank you. As always for this. I know you barely slept as did I. So next time we have you
on, I promise there'll be not at 7 a.m. after you've been a honor, honor to be on. I know how,
how engaged and, and intensity your audiences. So I'll always honor to be on your program. And
as I head to Zaybars, I'm sure people will tell me, I heard you on Dan show by people. You're
people. Dan, thank you. Good to see you. All right, Mark. You can do a live podcast there at Zaybars.
You'll get a real crowd. All right. Thanks. Thanks, Mark Takeer. Thank you.
There's never been more coverage of Israel in the Jewish world. And I'd say there's never been
less of it worth trusting. But because our ARK+ members fund most of what we do here at ARK Media,
we're free to cover the stories that need to be told honestly and without compromise. When you
join ARK+ you support that mission. And you also get access to members only episodes of Call Me Back
and other shows in the ARK Media Network. Each of these shows covers everything from Israel's
security and rising antisemitism to American politics and what it means to be Jewish in this moment.
If you're able to, consider becoming a member. You can sign up for ARK+ at ARKMedia.org or
follow the link in our show notes.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The 2024 U.S. election results represent a sweeping Democratic victory, flipping multiple red states and securing majorities in both the House and Senate.
Voters rejected President Trump not because of extreme right-wing policies, but due to widespread anti-establishment sentiment, including disdain for his family’s wealth accumulation and handling of the war, Epstein, and economic issues.
The victory highlights a shift toward populist, anti-establishment politics, where independent voters overwhelmingly supported Democrats, signaling a major realignment in American political culture.
Michigan's win by Abdul Al-Sayed—a candidate with strong anti-Israel views—marks a significant but potentially limited political milestone, with analysts noting his narrow margin and uncooperative style may limit his influence.
The new Democratic majority, including figures like Kevin McCarthy and Chuck Schumer, faces internal pressures from progressive and anti-Israel factions, though moderate leaders may retain influence through party cohesion.
The U.S. relationship with Israel remains a central issue, with the new Congress likely to face intense debate over aid, policy, and public support, especially as ideological divisions grow.
The 2028 Democratic nomination field is expected to include Gavin Newsom, Pete Buttigieg, and Josh Shapiro, with a key question being whether a Jewish American candidate can win amid rising anti-Israel sentiment.
The Republican Party is now facing internal uncertainty, particularly with JD Vance’s viability in the nomination challenged by the election’s outcomes and public perception of disconnection from Trump’s policies.
Summary:
S. election delivered a decisive Democratic victory, with major wins in red states like Texas, Georgia, and Michigan, flipping control of both the House and Senate. This outcome reflects broad anti-establishment sentiment, particularly resentment toward President Trump’s financial practices, war policies, and perceived lack of accountability.
Despite Trump's rise on populist grounds, he was repudiated by voters who rejected his governance, especially on issues of economic hardship and elite wealth. Michigan’s win by Abdul Al-Sayed—a candidate with strong anti-Israel views—signals a shift in the national political landscape, though analysts believe his confrontational style and narrow victory limit his long-term influence. The new Democratic Congress, led by figures like Kevin McCarthy and Chuck Schumer, will face intense pressure from progressive and anti-Israel factions, though moderate leadership may help maintain bipartisan support.
S. policy remains a flashpoint, with future decisions likely shaped by the balance between party ideology and public sentiment. The 2028 Democratic nomination field appears to center on Gavin Newsom, Pete Buttigieg, and Josh Shapiro, with a critical question being whether a Jewish American candidate can emerge as a viable nominee amid rising anti-Israel rhetoric.
Meanwhile, the Republican Party faces internal instability, with JD Vance’s path to nomination now questioned due to his distance from Trump’s policies. -Israel relations.
FAQs
The Democratic victory was driven by a significant shift in voter turnout, especially among independents who leaned Democratic. Key factors included a surge in Democratic support in red states, a decline in Republican share of the electorate, and a strong performance across both state and federal offices.
The results indicate a major anti-establishment backlash against President Trump, especially over issues like war costs, wealth accumulation, and handling of scandals. Voters rejected what many saw as an overreach of power and a lack of populism, signaling a shift toward more progressive and economically focused policies.
Populist issues—such as opposition to high war costs, family wealth accumulation, and perceived favoritism toward the wealthy—were central to the backlash against Trump. These issues resonated with both Democrats and independents, driving a broad base of support for the new Democratic majority.
Al-Sayed’s win signals a potential shift in the Democratic Party’s stance on Israel and U.S. foreign policy in the region. While his influence may be limited due to his confrontational style, his victory marks a symbolic moment for a more critical, progressive voice in national politics.
The new Democratic leadership, including Speaker Kevin McCarthy and Senator Chuck Schumer, is expected to maintain strong support for Israel, though internal party divisions on anti-war policies may create pressure. The balance between moderate and progressive members will shape policy decisions.
The 2028 field is expected to include more diverse candidates, with potential strong contenders like Gavin Newsom, Pete Buttigieg, and Josh Shapiro. There is growing debate over whether a Jewish American candidate can win, and the party may face internal pressure to address its alignment with Israel and progressive values.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.