#79 What's next for Offshore Wind in Norway? (with Arvid Nesse, Norwegian Offshore Wind)
from NTNU Energy Transition Podcast
26m 11s
Norwegian offshore wind is rapidly evolving, driven by deep waters that make floating wind technology essential. The country’s pioneering Med Center, the world’s first floating wind test site, has laid the foundation for technological development and industry collaboration. The Norwegian Offshore Wind Cluster, built from oil and gas expertise, now supports a broad ecosystem of companies transitioning into wind energy, focusing on supply chain growth, innovation, and international exports. While initial projects like Utsirano face delays, there is strong interest and progress, with multiple consortia competing for development rights. The main challenges lie in reducing costs through industrial scaling and technological innovation, ensuring long-term commercial viability beyond subsidies. With a clear vision for global leadership, Norway aims to achieve cost-competitive floating wind by 2030–2040, positioning itself as a key player in the global offshore wind market. Speed and collaboration remain central to success, and the industry is confident that with continued investment and acceleration, Norway can lead in both domestic deployment and international expansion.
What is this status quo of sure wind in Norway? Where are we coming from? What are the
next big steps and what challenges do we see in the net five to ten years coming towards
us? And what could be approaches to tackle the future challenges that we are looking
into right now? To answer these questions, I invited Arvid Nessent to the podcast who
leads amongst others the Norwegian offshore wind cluster. So he's the guy to talk to when
he comes to these questions. So you might have guessed it today, it's all about offshore
wind. I'm your host, Yudu Svisha and this is the Entenew Energy transition podcast. Let's
go. I think the most important now for developing here is that we have a speed and that we have
full scale floating projects as fast as possible. That's important for the cost reduction
and it's also important for the developing their supply chains in the industry.
Folks, it's been some time since we talked about offshore wind. I remember we had Jan Olav
Tande on the podcast like episode 10 or 12 or something. So it's time to see again where
we are with offshore wind. Maybe you not only have a research perspective, but maybe you also
have a bit of a more business related perspective. That's why I'm happy here to sit with Arvid
Nessent. Hi, Arvid. How's it going? Hello. We are at ONS and a little booth again. It's
the second third recording here and you have a booth here as well. We are in hall four where
all the low carbon technologies are and that's where you are also here because you work a lot
with offshore wind. So you started studying political economics in Bergen University and
then you worked at Housen commune a couple of years ago and then you went to Gasnour which
is an LNG company, if I understand correctly. And now you're the cluster manager and cluster
manager of Norwegian offshore wind and you also head of the Med Center. So what is Norwegian
offshore wind and what is the Med Center? Yeah. It all started with Med Center, the test
center and those first floating wind turbine hyven. That was the starting of a test center
because we saw that there might be a market for the test center and actually it was, it
was a canoe at that time combined with a local community calmly and also the rural
encountered which had the idea of starting a test center. What year are we talking? When
the youth learned 2009, 2010, 2010, the company was started and I was hired as a part time
project manager at that time. So I was working with all our business development projects
in parallel and this was a part time project. Was that the first floating offshore wind
site all across Scandinavia, Norway or the world even? It was the world wide first
floating wind project, yes. But that was an external project. But based on that, we saw
the possibility or the founders, so our possibility to start the test center. Because they expected
that time there should be a lot of floating projects upcoming, becoming yes. But now we
know that it took a lot more year before the steam or floating projects were coming but
it seems that now it's now there are coming. Let's talk about that in a second, yes. So
give us an idea of floating wind. I think most of the people who listen to this podcast
have an idea of a floating wind is but why do we need floating wind and how is floating
wind different from offshore wind? We most of the oceans are deep water. But the wind
sector started with the onshore wind and land-based and it's still the cheapest electricity
pollution from wind. But early to about 2000, I started with offshore wind in Denmark,
a bottom-fixed project with piles in the sandbags there. And that's also still the most
mature and there are more than 3000 turbines installed, mostly in Europe but also in China.
But southern Patonotsi is very well suitable for bottom-fixed wind because you can pile
in the sandbags. But if you have more than 60-70 meters of water depth, you need to have
floating and most other countries and most other oceans are more than 67 meters depth.
And especially Norway where the water depth gets deeper quite quickly, isn't it? That's
why it's one of the cases to focus on that here in Norway, is that correct?
Yeah. In Norway we have the southern Patonotsi close to Denmark that we have areas where we
can do bottom-fixed rest of the coastline we need to do floating. And I'm actually there,
the energy director when they have not picked suggested areas, 75% of them are floating.
Yeah, that's like the pipeline of project development in the future, isn't it? So that's
what's coming now. I just realized that talking about this episode that we did with Janal
of Tander, one of the first ones, was not the only one on which offshore platforms, or
the way how you would build these floating winds. So there was another episode with Sundehogge
from Neubau, from Sinterf as well. So just that, just popped into my head.
Okay. So we had this met center, and what was then the goal of it, of that met center?
Like what was the mission from Equinori, if you will, for developing there?
The mission for Equinori in the start was to prepare the ground for more floating technologies.
And actually it was a combination of local communities, Equinori, and the county, almost
the other founders. And all of them had a vision that they should prepare for floating
offshore wind and make Norway in front of this. And you see, if you're bought from Norwegian
technologies and foreign technologies, if you do the testing, then you also, it's, you
can combine the local industry and then prepare them for the global business possibilities.
And how many of these floating offshore wind turbines were then implemented at the met center
site? I'm going to talk about one, two, three, five, twenty.
Yeah. And at the moment, there are two. So there, this high enough still there in production,
new one on now. So it's called UNDEXA fields. And we also have a Danish technology, Tetraspa,
which has been fined by Adoree Shell and Teppko. We also had the Google Macarney, a kite
turbine in 2019. But we still have now available constant for five more projects. And we expect
the next one not to be installed in 2027.
What type is that then? So I understand it's the project is not over, but you continue
putting out floating turbines just there. Yeah, because floating offshore wind is still
not so mature. So it's still necessary to do. There are still a lot of technology development.
And you need to do to install a demo to gain experience bought from the production part
of it or the manufacturing and installation, but also from the first years of operation.
Then you will have a lot of experience that you will use and you will do the improvements
before you have a design for yourself, a full scale of informer, let's say 30, 40,
50 units. Yeah. And then the met center was not enough of it, but you thought about
building the Norwegian offshore wind cluster. So how did that come apart?
Yeah, that's based on the mission or the test center to prepare the Norwegian industry.
The idea of starting a cluster came in 2016. There's a pair with low oil and gas prices,
low activity in oil and gas. And a lot of interest for the new possibilities in the industry.
And based on that, we started the cluster, Norwegian offshore wind cluster and with 10, 15
members at the start in 2016. But there was a lot of interest and the cluster grow fast
and I was close to 400 members. And what do these members represent? I guess they represent
everything along the valley chain, but can you give us some ideas and some insights
of the amperees that joined? It's in Norway, we had not have a lot of turbine production,
but if you're looking into a floating wind from, I think the cluster vendors can do everything
except for the supply there, the turbine.
itself. And I think the majority our members have some background from their oil and gas
business. They have, and they're using this experience to go into, to, to, to off show in.
And the episode today is called Norwegian Offshore Wind just for Norway or for the world.
So how, how can these, or like what's the vision for, for the cluster or for the members of the
cluster? Is it, how much is it focused on Norway and how much is maybe focused also on developing
industries that could eventually be having a good, good grip of maybe dominating international markets
or at least telling international markets? I think it normally has been in front of developing
floating wind and we are still in the front and for example, high wind tampon is still the
largest floating wind farm in, in, in, in the world. But then our, our, our projects upcoming,
for example, in Scotland, France, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Greece, US, Japan, Korea, and many,
and other, other countries. And, and we see that we can use this experience also to, to develop
an export industry from home to what you're doing and floating. What is kind of kind of interesting
when you go on the web page of the Norwegian Offshore Wind cluster, you see there's a number of
working groups and six of these working groups focus on, on supply chain, like on technology pretty
much. And there's 11 groups that actually work on different markets. So what you just mentioned,
like, so it's, like, it's Greece and there it's, yeah, yeah. So it's like, it feels as if it's very
much about an export, export idea, export idea there. Yes. Yeah, we are doing both. So, and we
are doing both, we are doing development of the supply chain, we are doing innovation,
and we are doing exports. And we see that and, and sort of the core of the idea or the core idea
or the cluster is to develop collaboration. You see that you can, you can, you can put in some
efforts in doing collaboration activities and you will gain more than you put in. That's, that's
the IID. And there has been a very high interest for the working groups for export. And we also see
a going to new markets and you can gain to, to collaborate with a bit of finding partners. So
the, these working groups are, has been for export has been very popular. Yeah. You mentioned that
and good number of the members of the Norwegian offshore wind cluster are companies that have been
active or are still active in the oil, oil and gas sector. And one come, when you go to energy
conferences, I very often hear this idea of like, okay, we need to use the expertise that we
have in Norway with these online gas companies, when it comes to things, subsidy, when it comes to
the mooring system, all that, how can we use that for, for, for, for offshore wind to then maybe create
a new, a new industry that then sells to, to other parts of the countries. What is your idea,
like what's your experience when you talk to your cluster members, when it comes to re-skilling
people or reusing skills that are being used in, in, in, in subsidy missions, for example,
for offshore wind. Is that really happening or is that more like a pipe dream and it's not really
materializing? What's your experience there? I think it's really, really happening.
Also, and we see a lot of examples on that. But the other, these days there are high activity in
oil and gas. And it's a boom and it's, it started with this, with Covid and this tax or support
systems for gas. You have a lot of projects now and it's very busy. But what we see from our members
is that they are still interested in offshore wind because they know that this will happen to
continue a couple of years more. But after that, there will be a low activities in oil and gas.
And I see that they need to have more feeds to, to stand on. So, and I think that's
most of our members has that attitude. So, you feel it's like a strategic decision by them,
by these companies to continue in, in, in your offshore wind, yeah, arena, just to make sure that
in the long run they still exist as companies. Yeah, yeah, we, we see where we're clear.
There's a high interest for, high interest for, for, for offshore wind. Even if it's, you have some
bad news about cost, really, cost increase and then delays in project and like that. We still see
that there's a, there's a high interest. But, but of course, there's also, um, already now an export
industry. And there's also an export industry not only for floating, but also for bottom fixed,
which is, uh, which is a large industry today. And many of our members are, are working with,
also, the bottom fixed. Okay, yeah. So, let's maybe dive in and have a look at like where are we
right now with, with offshore wind, in, in our way? You mentioned that, um, they were, they were
ideas in maybe 2009, 10, 11, that this will only take a couple of years. Now, it took a couple
of more years, but I would say that's kind of very normal in a technological development process.
And especially since these apparatuses that we're putting there into the sea are not, they're,
they are quite complex, uh, pieces of engineering. So, where are we right now? All together,
are we more, he said, are we more in the boom, are we not in the boom? What are the big challenges
that we are, we're maybe wrestling with? Uh, uh, I think that, uh, we are, uh, sort of, uh,
the, the Norwegian government has been working for, for many years now to, uh, to prepare for, for
the first, uh, first projects. And we are very glad that Salonotse, uh, where, uh, I've ordered this,
this year, and the project has, uh, has started. What does that mean? It was been awarded for just
the people who might not be so, yeah, what does that mean? It means that there was a competition, uh,
there were two, to have this piece of sea, uh, to, uh, and the possibility to, to, to, to, to develop
a project. And I was, um, a competition, uh, about who needed less, uh, support from the government,
um, uh, to, and they won the project. How many consortia run for these kind of pieces of sea?
Is that like three consortia? Is it 20 consortia that kind of a play?
I, I think in, in, uh, in the last part of the, uh, this competition, it was two or three,
you know, for this, but in, in the starting point, uh, there were more about 10, 12, I think for
the next floating project, Utsirano, there are, uh, about 12 consortias competing. Okay, Utsirano,
how's it going? Yeah. And, and we are very glad that, uh, and we, and of course, there has been some
delay with, um, with, uh, Utsirano, uh, there are some, uh, you need to have an ESA
notification, uh, which has taken some time. And we are a bit disappointed that this was, uh, an issue.
But, uh, we hope that, uh, that we really next year, uh, we'll start the process and that
will be awarded an Arias, uh, yeah, first off year next year. And, and, uh, these, there will
be a world of three Arias, uh, for, for this floating in, uh, uh, Utsirano. And when we talk about three
areas, then we will have three wind parks there. And, or is it, does one area have the opportunity
to host several wind parks? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, the whole larger. There will be three, uh, um,
separate wind parks with, uh, owned by three separate consortials. Okay. And if you apply for that,
then you apply to one of the three. Or do you apply to be in general, be allowed to, to be active
there? Yeah, you, you apply, you apply with, uh, priority for what your children, you want to,
want to have first on second and, and, and third. And these, the ones that apply, what kind of companies
is that, is that the big names of the Ecuador's and the shelves? Or is that like, like, join venture
companies between different companies that, uh, have maybe different types of qualifications or
things they bring to the table? Yeah, it's, uh, we see that, uh, most of them, uh, well known,
international developers of, of showing are present. And we also see a lot of, of, uh,
new vision, uh, energy companies. So most of the consortia are, uh, a combination of an international,
uh, uh, name with, uh, long reputation and, and a new vision. And one example, for example,
is that the shell, uh, is in a consortium with the loose energy and avenue, which are, uh, and, um,
but they don't necessarily have the, the engineering capacities to, to do that kind of project,
isn't it? So they probably then ask companies like Ramburg, or something to, to, to do the development,
or is the development really done by avenue, by shell in, in that consortium? Ah, I think,
just in general, you, and you said the process, I think, uh, from point of view, that's so different,
from consortium, true, true, true, true, true. So what the engineering capacity has, but I guess,
most of them will, uh, hire engineering capacity, but there will also be a lot of sub suppliers,
There will be for environmental investigations, sea bed investigations, a lot of engineering
based on that.
They need a lot of specialists in the progeny.
Yeah, so you said Cylian Oshoye 2 was awarded, you see, Ranua will be awarded next year, potentially, who knows.
Is this the expectation that you had five years ago that this is the process I would like to look like or pan out,
or were you hoping for, I don't know, substantially more areas that would be made available for development?
Yeah, it's already said that there will be one more, or one more areas in 2025, because this process started in 2023,
and originally the plan to be awarded in 2023, and the next one was planned to be in 2025.
But since 2023 is delayed, then it's likely that both of them will be awarded in 2025.
So two years, two years ago, we met at Andatsuka, and with the cluster, you had organized, I understand, a cluster meeting with companies and not families,
but with friends of the cluster, or members of the cluster, and I interviewed you and a couple of other people, like just short,
and then what I understood was like, everything is working, it's just not working as fast as it could.
Do I understand that there's no real big challenges? It's just that the speed overall could be higher?
Yeah, I think the most important thing for developing here is that we have a speed, and that we have this full scale floating projects as fast as possible.
That's important for the cost reduction, and it's also important for developing the supply chains and industry.
Okay, so when we say that now it kind of, well, we're kind of not on the bad process, maybe, and it kind of works up.
When we think more strategic about it, what are challenges that you could see coming in maybe not now, but maybe in five years or maybe in ten years?
I think the most important challenge for floating is to reduce the cost, and you need to do the industrialization and learning for the illustration,
but you also need to do in parallel innovation and new technology. So you need to do both.
And that's why it's important to have Utsurano as a full scale farm, but it's also important to have this Metsanto test center to test new technology.
Okay, so I understand that you don't really see a lot of big challenges ahead if you will, like in five years or ten years, for example.
There will be enough skilled labor, there will be enough offer, like the North Sea is big enough to build a lot of construction and a lot of projects.
There's like material shortages, and you know, that kind of stuff, all of that can also be challenges.
But I think for the industry as a whole, it's to reduce the cost and make it profitable, because you cannot depend on governmental support systems.
You need to be a commercial individual. But of course you need to solder about the labor, you need to solder about the materials, of course, and that's also correct to the price.
But since you mentioned price twice now, what is the kilowatt hour going to cost in ten years from floating offshore wind? I know if you have a guest or a guest emit and a good guessing estimate.
Yeah, I think that has been the sound and some analysis.
But I hope that we will see about 50 over kilowatt hour in a couple of ten to twenty years. So there will be five, ten Euros and more live.
Because onshore wind is a bit cheaper, is that correct? That's a bit cheaper, onshore wind that's cheaper.
Yeah, but obviously if it's so hard, like in order to build offshore wind, then onshore wind, excuse me.
So really an alternative comparing it, is it? I don't, it's not easy to get acceptors for onshore wind projects.
So your class is in the Norwegian offshore wind class. Does an Norwegian onshore wind class actually exist?
No, not anymore. That was like last year earlier, but it's, I think also for the Norwegian companies, I think the highest opportunities are in offshore wind.
So if, if you meet with Andreas Björn and Ericsson, who's climate minister right now, or maybe if you meet with Terrier, what's his name? Ausland? I think that's how he says the name. What will be the one two things?
Like, what's your elevator pitch? Like, what is it? What, what do you need? Or is it just like, let us do the work and we don't need anything?
Yeah, I know, I think what we need now is to have the speed in the process. But I, this has been a priority from the minister and I trust that they are doing what they can to, to do this as far as they can.
That sounds good. Okay, so, have it. Last question, let's again, the question that we had in the title, Norwegian offshore wind, just for Norway or for the world, what's the answer?
It's about for all around the world, and I hope that the Norwegian industry will be, will be a big player in the global business.
Okay, beautiful. Class of manager of the Norwegian offshore wind and the MET center. I have it nested. Thanks for joining me today on the podcast.
Thank you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Norway is focusing on floating offshore wind due to deep waters, with 75% of proposed projects beyond traditional bottom-fixed installations.
The Med Center was the world’s first floating wind test site, launched in 2010, and now hosts two operational projects with five more in development.
The Norwegian Offshore Wind Cluster, established in 2016, includes oil and gas companies transitioning into wind energy, leveraging existing expertise in mooring systems and engineering.
The cluster emphasizes supply chain development, technology innovation, and global exports, with active working groups targeting markets in Europe, the US, Asia, and beyond.
Key challenges include reducing costs through industrialization and technology innovation, while ensuring commercial viability beyond government support.
Projects like Utsirano are progressing, with awards expected in 2025, and multiple consortia are involved, combining international developers with emerging energy firms.
A major strategic goal is to accelerate the deployment of full-scale floating projects to drive cost reductions and strengthen domestic supply chains.
Long-term vision includes achieving a levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) of around 50 EUR/MWh in 10–20 years, making floating wind competitive globally.
Summary:
Norwegian offshore wind is rapidly evolving, driven by deep waters that make floating wind technology essential. The country’s pioneering Med Center, the world’s first floating wind test site, has laid the foundation for technological development and industry collaboration. The Norwegian Offshore Wind Cluster, built from oil and gas expertise, now supports a broad ecosystem of companies transitioning into wind energy, focusing on supply chain growth, innovation, and international exports.
While initial projects like Utsirano face delays, there is strong interest and progress, with multiple consortia competing for development rights. The main challenges lie in reducing costs through industrial scaling and technological innovation, ensuring long-term commercial viability beyond subsidies. With a clear vision for global leadership, Norway aims to achieve cost-competitive floating wind by 2030–2040, positioning itself as a key player in the global offshore wind market.
Speed and collaboration remain central to success, and the industry is confident that with continued investment and acceleration, Norway can lead in both domestic deployment and international expansion.
FAQs
Fiks vindparker bruker piler i fysisk underjordisk sand, og er beste i dyper vann som maks 60-70 meter. Flytende vindparker er nødvendige i dyper vann, som i Norge, hvor vannhøyden øker raskt.
MØT-centeret er verdenes første testcenter for flytende vindparker, startet i 2010. Det har testet teknologi og har hjulpet til å forbedre norsk industri og forberede seg på fremtidige flytende prosjekter.
Det er nå to flytende vindparker i drift på MØT-centeret, og flere prosjekter er planlagt, med det neste forventet i 2027.
Målet er å utvikle samarbeid mellom industrier og forbedre forsyning, innovasjon og export av flytende vindteknologi, både i Norge og internasjonalt.
Mange medlemmer har erfaring fra olje- og gasssektoren, og de bruger denne kunskapen for å utvikle teknologier som gjelder montering, fastholdning og off shore prosesser.
Den største utfordringen er å redusere kostnader og industrialisere teknologiene. Det kreves både læring fra produksjon og innovasjoner for å gjøre vindenergi kommersielt.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.