Go back

#75 - Dr Kwon - Biomechanics of Club Head Speed

from Fit For Golf

1h 4m 30s

#75 - Dr Kwon - Biomechanics of Club Head Speed

Dr. Kwan, a leading biomechanics expert in golf, revisits his research on clubhead speed, emphasizing that it is primarily driven by peak angular velocity in the upper body—not by the timing or sequence of rotational peaks. His study of 66 skilled male golfers (handicap 3+) found no correlation between peak timing and speed, due to the extremely short downswing duration (about 250 milliseconds). Instead, the key benefits of proximal-to-distal motion occur during the transition phase, where stretch-shortening cycles and momentum transfer are most effective. He stresses that shoulder rotation is more critical than X-factor, which must be generated dynamically through momentum, not forced through isolated shoulder movement. For practical improvement, Dr. Kwan recommends indoor drills—such as rope swings, step drills, and medicine ball throws—that build rhythm, body control, and unified motion without a club or ball. These foundational patterns naturally lead to increased clubhead speed. He cautions against overemphasizing speed metrics early in training, as it risks disrupting natural mechanics. Ultimately, he advocates for a holistic, motion-based approach focused on functional movement and body control, with strength and conditioning supporting long-term performance. Golfers should prioritize mastering swing pattern efficiency before chasing speed, and he encourages learning through intuitive, self-directed practice rather than rigid instruction. His methods are accessible via his YouTube channel (Dr. Guan Golf) and website, where swing analysis and reprogramming are offered.

Transcription

8848 Words, 49272 Characters

English
Dr. Kwan is a professor of biomechanics at Texas Women's University on one of the world's most influential and respected golf biomechanists. He is not just a researcher, he also works in practical settings with golfers, helping them improve their swing. He joined the Fit for Golf podcast for episode 46 and is now back to discuss the biomechanics of clubhead speed and how you can improve yours. I'm very happy to be joined again by Dr. Kwan. How are you doing? Fine. Thank you. And thank you for having me again. Yeah, thank you very much for taking the time. This is your second appearance on the Fit for Golf podcast. You appeared about two years ago and we spent a lot of time talking about the biomechanics of clubhead speed. Things we're going to revisit today and also move on. So what prompted me to have you back on the podcast at this point was last week I sent a review of one of your research papers to my email list as part of my weekly review series. The paper full of excellent information is quite dense. There's a lot in it. It was difficult to whittle down to key summaries and takeaways. The title of the paper is association between the on-plane angular motions of the axel chain system and clubheads speed in skilled male golfers. So there was 66 male golfers all with a handicap of three or better and mixture of touring pros, college players and teaching pros, age 15 to 90, average driver speed was 110 miles an hour. Can you explain what the purpose of this study was and what you found? So in this study we looked at the relationship between the clubhead speed and the rotational motion of the the so called the excellent chain system. So here the trunk forms an axel and then the arms and club basically forms a chain. So essentially when you make a golf swing then the axle rotates and then the chain is rotating around the axel. So we can simplify this motion by mainly looking at the rotational motion of the upper body. So that was the main focus of this particular study. And you did actually an excellent job in summarizing the paper. So let me bring up what you were posted. So basically what we wanted to see here is how the clubhead speed is related to rotational motion of the upper body. And then in the summary in the simple words the faster you rotate your body and the higher the clubhead speed is. So what, sorry go ahead. Go ahead. Yeah. So what I found really interesting in this study and it was one of the key takeaways I had and thought was worthy of further conversation was that you found large correlations with the peak speed of the hip torso and especially arm rotation. But there was no correlation with when they peaked or the sequence of the peak in not just golf biomechanics but in biomechanics in general and in in strength and conditioning. We're frequently exposed to kinematics sequencing, the proximal to distal relationship and the stretch short incitle. That sounds like a lot for the listeners basically what this means is that in golf biomechanics we commonly see kinematics sequences referenced which is the order that the different segments of the body both reach their peak speed and the order in which they decelerate in the downswing. And it's commonly referred to as a one two three four sequence which would be first the pelvis, then the torso, then the arm, then the club. And the idea is that one segment builds on the acceleration of the one before it. As the one before it decelerates, the next one accelerates and so on and that's where we get the sort of chain-like effect of one after the other. Yeah. Can you go into what you found in your study and let us know your thoughts on that? Yeah, so this is particularly what happens in the downswing. Actually the peak angular velocity is correlated to a cleaver speed which is quite obvious. But in terms of timing, so naturally if your motion is faster then you have a shorter downswing phase. So essentially the peak, the timing of peak angular velocity should be also closer to the impact. So in theory you should see a correlation to a cleaver speed between the timing of the peak and the cleaver speed, but there are two conflicting aspects here fighting each other. So one is that we can basically divide the downswing into two phases. So the initial acceleration phase where the body accelerates and then the second phase is deceleration phase. So once the body accelerates and reaches the peak angular velocity then the body starts a deceleration while the club keeps accelerating. So what happens in this process is that as the body slows down the angular momentum of the body is transferred to the club. So while the body slows down but your club further accelerates. So on one hand you have to accelerate your body well in the early part of the downswing but at the same time you should have enough time for the deceleration of the body and then the further acceleration of the club. So normally when the motion is faster then you have less time in the downswing. So we don't have a damage time. The average downswing time is about 250 milliseconds so it's one fourth of a second. In that short time period you have to accelerate your body and then start deceleration for a third acceleration of the club. So the best scenario is you accelerate your body as quickly as possible in the first half of the downswing and reach as high angular velocity as possible, then have enough time from the peak to impact to slow down your body while further accelerating your club. So typically you will see that the shorter the certain phases, the higher the cleaver speed is, the more delayed onset of certain things is associated with the higher cleaver speed. But in the downswing you have to reach peak angular velocity as early as possible and have enough time from the peak to impact. So that's why you don't see correlation between the timing of the peak angular velocity and the cleaver speed. Now here's the problem. One common misconception in golf community is the chemical sequence. The chemical sequence does not just mean the more central body part reaches peak velocity first and then it goes to more peripheral segments one by one. But there is a reason for that. The reason why the chemical sequence is important is that there are two main aspects. One is how we use the muscles. And typically when you have a sequence, so central to peripheral sequence, or we call it the proximal to distal sequence, but when we have a sequence, then you tend to use the muscles in a more stretchy shortening cycle fashion. So the biomechanical benefit of this sequence is a stretchy shortening cycle in muscle contraction. But there is a more important mechanical benefit of a sequence, which is the so-called angular moment of inertia regulation. So in the rotational motion, the measure of inertia is moment of inertia. The moment of inertia is not constant, it changes depending on the body posture. So if you keep things more compact, so if you keep the body parts close to the body, then moment of inertia decreases, then you can achieve a faster acceleration of the body. So the reason why we have a gradual or sequential motion is that when the most central part part is rotating, then you keep the chain close to your body. [BLANK_AUDIO] minimize the moment of inertia, okay? And then when the role of the body rotation is done, then you have to use the shoulders and the arms to further accelerate the club. So as the center rotation more moves toward the more more distal joint, then you have to introduce the motion of the shoulders and the wrists. So in that case, because the main rotation is happening about the shoulders, you don't have to worry about the arm position, but the club position still matters. When the club is closer to the body, you can still maintain smaller moment of inertia. But when the rotation is mainly now about the wrist, it doesn't matter where the club is, because the main rotation is about the wrist. So in order to regulate the moment of inertia, I try to keep the moment inertia as small as possible. We have to introduce the motion from the most central body part and the gradually to the preferred part. So that's why the sequence is so important. But then, then in the down swing, do we expect these two benefits? Okay, so let's say, first the stretcher shortening cycle. In the down swing, you can perhaps rotate the pelvis first and then the thorax and then the shoulders. So with that, you can introduce a little bit of stretcher shortening cycle in the trunk muscles. But actually, since the down swing is really short, you don't have much time for that. So rather, if you go to maximize the effect of stretcher shortening cycle, then you have to use the end of the back swing to promote the stretcher shortening cycle. So in reality, down swing is not the place where you maximize the stretcher shortening cycle effect. You have to use the transition phase. By using the momentum of the body in the back swing, you have to introduce sequential transition. With that, you maximize the stretcher shortening cycle effect. So the down swing is not the best place to do that, because we have really short time period. And then, in terms of the multiminusual regulation, the body parts in the main axle, so the pelvis, thorax, and shoulders, these are on the same axle. So the sequence is not important, actually, because all these three parts are rotating the system about the axle. So there, in terms of the multiminusual regulation, we don't see much benefit when we have sequential motions of the pelvis, then thorax, and shoulders. Okay, I'm going to try and recap to make sure that both I understand and give the reader how their listener has chance to catch up. So we know from general biomechanics understanding that the proximal to distal sequence is important. In your paper, you found that there was not a relationship between the timing or sequencing in the down swing and clubhead speed. The reason for this is that because the down swing period before we slow all of the body down is so short that there's really not enough time for there to be much separation in these segments in terms of when they reach their peak. But when this proximal to distal sequencing can be achieved and is much more important is actually in the transition phase. So what comes up next for me then is how are you differentiating between what's the beginning of the transition and what's the beginning of the down swing phase? In my definition, when the pelvis starts rotating or changing the direction of rotation, that's the beginning of the transition phase. And then when the club changes the direction of rotation, that's the initiation of the down swing. So between, so I call it end of pelvis rotation, between the end of pelvis rotation to a club transition point, that phase is the transition phase. And we obviously have much more time in this phase because it's happening a lot slower because we need to decelerate the momentum of the body moving away from the target before the pelvis can start shifting and rotating towards the target. And this is where we have the opportunity to get the pelvis going a little bit before the torso, which creates that stretch shortening cycle that elastic effect to a certain extent that benefits the muscle swing. In the down swing, if you compare the timing of the peak angular velocities within the trunk segment, within the trunk, then the difference is about 100th or 200th of second. That time difference between the peaks in the trunk, but the length of the transition phase can be over 100 milliseconds. So that means over, you know, 10th of second. So we're talking about a lot longer time in the transition phase than the short time window where the peak angular velocities occur in the down swing. So, but if you want to maximize the effect of stretch shortening cycle, then you have to actually use the transition phase well and then create enough elongation of the muscles before you start the dosing. Is it fair to say that once the back swing and transition have finished and in your definitions that the transition has finished, the down swing has started once the club has changed direction? Is it fair to say that the majority of our clubhead speed is going to be dependent on what we do in the back swing and transition because by the time the transition is over and we're into the down swing, there's only minimal, minimal time before we actually have to slow everything with our body down to get the energy out of the clubhead in time. Imagine you have a airplane. If the airplane is a really powerful engine, then with the short runway is okay, you can quickly accelerate the lift. But if your engine power is limited, then you want to have a longer runway. So, you have to utilize the end of the back swing and the early part of the down swing for the acceleration. But if you have really strong muscles, you have powerful muscles, then it's okay to waste time in the transition phase and even early phase time, you don't have to immediately start the acceleration. But still, using the power of your muscles, you can generate the good speed. But most of the golfers, most of the golfers, waste the opportunities in the transition phase and the early down swing phase. So, then when they start accelerating the body late, then they don't have enough time from the peak to impact for the acceleration of the club. So, one simple indicator that I use in terms of assessing the efficiency of the swing is the ratio of the wrist angular velocity to a club angular velocity at impact. So, that ratio shows the proportion of the wrist angular velocity to the club angular velocity. And if you use your wrist well, then obviously that value will be higher. If you don't use the wrist well, because you don't have that much time between the peak and the impact, so you cannot accelerate the club in the second phase of the down swing, then your wrist angular velocity will be lower. So, that value decreases. And the elite golfers on the average is about 65 to 66%. But some golfers reach higher than 70%. But a lot of golfers bring a lot of muscular effort, but they fail to accelerate the club in the second half of the down swing, then their average is below 60%. So, you know, it is important to accelerate the body early on in the down swing and have enough time between the peak angular velocity of the body and the impact. So, while you can accelerate the club, you know, during that period. How could we picture wrist angular velocity? Is that wrist cocking and uncocking? Or is that more the speed that the wrist joint is moving through space towards impact? The way I calculate everything is I find all these angles on the swing plane. Because the swing plane is the main plane of rotation. And then on the swing plane, I calculate the wrist, wrist, the cocking angle, based on that calculate the wrist angular velocity. So, it's a combination of the wrist, the palm of flexion, dorsiflexion. And then deviation and also forearm pronation supination or ticket. We looked at the sequence of the segments and how they move in the transition, being of importance for clubhead speed. What about the degree of difference between them, which is commonly referred to as X-factor in the backswing, which is the angle between torso rotation and pelvis rotation at the top of the backswing, and then X-factor stretch, how much this angle increases in transition. So this is different to the timing that the segments change. It's how much separation there is between them. And this is something that's been written about and a lot of videos made about online in terms of this concept of stretching the rubber band or coiling and uncoiling. Can you dig into this for us? X-factor is also one misconception, you know, quite sort of prevalent in the golf community. So basically it is the rotation of separation between the pelvis and the shoulders. And so when it was introduced, it was embraced quite well even by the scientific community. So there are many studies on X-factors, but we also did some studies on the X-factor. And then also this particular study includes the X-factor data. So basically in short, the X-factor numbers are not correlated to a clever speed period. And then there's a concept called X-factor stretch that means it's a further increase in the X-factor during the transition phase. Because once you get into a transition phase, then the pelvis is already rotating in the bouncing direction. Because that's the beginning of the transition phase, right? So during the transition phase, the pelvis is already rotating in the opposite direction, while the rest are rotating still in the backswing direction. So with that, you have a further increase in the X-factor. So that's called the X-factor stretch. And then I classify, I divide the X-factor into two, the backswing stretch and bouncing stretch. The backswing stretch means during the transition phase, up until the top of X-ring, how much stretch we have. And then some golfers reach maximum X-factor after the top of X-ring. So that means it's already in the bouncing. So that increase in the X-factor in the bouncing is called the bouncing stretch. But both backswing stretch and bouncing stretch are not correlated to clover speed in the lead golfers. However, however, if you look at the rotation range of the pelvis and the shoulders separately, both are correlated to the clover speed. So how far the hips turn back and how far the torso turns back in backswing? These are correlated to clover speed, but they're not the separation between them. It's because in theory, if you have a larger X-factor, then that means the muscles are connecting the lower trunk and upper trunk elongated. So it's beneficial in terms of stretch and shortening cycle. But it depends on how you create the separation. If you sort of suppress the pelvis motion and just try to rotate the shoulders, that way you can certainly increase the X-factor. Or you move both parts actively, using momentum strategy, but using momentum strategy, you are moving both pelvis and shoulders actively. Then eventually pelvis starts rotating in the opposite direction, because of the momentum, shoulders keeps rotating in the backswing direction, with that you can generate the larger separation. So there are different ways of generating the X-factor, because of these, so there's no consistent correlation between the X-factor and the clover speed. In my perspective, if you just try to suppress the lower body and then just try to rotate the shoulder, then even if you have a larger X-factor, that's not a good X-factor. So the X-factor should be generated by using the momentum during the backswing. Using the backswing speed, you naturally generate the good separation. That means you are really taking advantage of the stretch and shortening cycle. So the solution of trying to maximize X-factor in the swing is also reducing your hand path length, if you're trying to keep your hips very, very restricted from turning and maximizing your shoulder turn to get as big an angle between them. It's highly likely your swing will be much, much shorter overall, and you'll have less time to build momentum with the club on the way down. And still rotate your shoulders quite a bit, so even excessively. And the hand path is a function of how much your shoulders actually turn, and then where your hands eventually end up. So the bottom line is when you try to increase the X-factor, it should be through a dynamic motion. So using the momentum, naturally, when you have active motion, so you have enough speed, then toward the end of the back, you have to slow down that motion by engaging the muscles on the opposite side. With that, you are actually generating the stretch and shortening cycle effect. But if you keep the pelvis more stationary and then just intentionally try to rotate the shoulder that you keep using the circle, the concentric contraction, so muscles are shortening. So it doesn't really give you the stretch of shortening cycle effect. So X-factor can be still meaningful if you develop the X-factor using the momentum strategy. I'm thinking of the more recreational golfer compared to the elite one here too, with how much range of motion they actually would have available if they were trying to minimize their pelvis rotation and maximize their X-factor by just turning their shoulders. I think where they'd end up would be very different to, you know, maybe a lot of the elite golfers that are used in the studies, the swings would look quite a bit different. So the priority should be the shoulder rotation. You should have enough shoulder rotation, no matter what. And if you divide it does not allow enough separation between the shoulders and the hips then you have to turn the hips more to promote the more rotation of the shoulders, because the shoulder rotation is directly related to the arm rotations and then also the club motion. So more than anything you have to generate enough shoulder rotation. And, you know, if you can generate enough rotation by using active motion and then enough separation between the hips and shoulders, then they're really perfect. But, you know, the priority should be maximizing the range of motion of the shoulders is a common for you to see golfers of any skill level rotate either the hips or torso too much. So, particularly this is true when your pelvis rotates flat. So this is typically coming from a spinning motion. So, in image that your body is leaning forward but you try to rotate more about the vertical axis. Then what happens is during the back swing your trunk will lean away from the target, right? Then the pelvis tends to rotate flat. When that happens, you can generate the large rotation but it simply causes a flat backswing to flat actually. And then it causes a series of problems because of that. So, so it's important to rotate the pelvis and the thorax and the shoulders more about the spine axis. And is there a swing the spine axis like this? Maintain it and then rotate about the spine axis. So, if you develop this type of motion, then you can maximize the stretch shorting cycle effect because the muscles really elongate with that. And also you can use the ground a lot better with that rotation. The findings we're talking about in your paper were all done with high level golfers. They were all better than three handicaps, some of them professionals, and the average clubhead speed was 110 miles an hour. So these are all relatively good golf swings. How would what you found change if this was 15 handicaps, maybe older golfers, would the relative correlations to clubhead speed with the sequencing change or do you think it would be similar? So, you know, in the paper, we. We looked at the kinematics sequence and all these things, but in reality, that has to be translated to more practical terms. That means the promotion of the rotation of motion, right? In doing that, one main difference between the elite coffers and the lay coffers or the weekend coffers is how you promote the upper body tone. We know the upper body tone is important, but how you promote the upper body tone. So, open times in low level coffers, high handicapers, the lower body is moving, but the lower body motion is not really helping the upper body rotation. So the body parts, as if they have their own thoughts, they are moving, you know, independent from each other. But the goal is to promote, again, as I mentioned just a moment ago, the shoulder rotation is important, because shoulder motion is directly connected to the arm and club motion. But the bottom line is you have to move the club head around your body. That your body has to work together to promote the upper body rotations. So then it comes down to how you can move your body in a sort of unified way so that it promotes the good upper body rotation. So this is where the weekend coffers lack a lot. So when I work with the weekend coffers, I focus on that aspect. How to really use the lower body and pelvis to promote the upper body tone. That's what I'd like to move on to. So you don't just conduct research in the lab, you also work directly with golfers coaching them on their swing technique. In a practical setting, what type of exercises or drills can we do to improve our body motion in the swing? I think this is relevant for a lot of golfers now, because we're coming into the off-season in a lot of parts of the Northern Hemisphere. Many people will be primarily restricted to practicing indoors. They may not be able to swing a club. They almost certainly are a lot of them won't be able to hit a ball. So for these golfers, water some drills, exercises that you commonly go through to try and help them improve their technique. So actually, if golfers want to improve the swing patterns, then they have to stay away from the ball and the club, for a while. And rather develop a good motion pattern first, and then the key is rhythm in the swing. And then luckily, we have two legs, we have humans that bite pads, so we have two legs. And then by using the legs one at a time, you can develop a good rhythmic motion, and you can repeat this a lot. So one of the best ways of practicing the golf swing is actually continuous swing. You repeat the swing back and forth continuously. And then your body will better respond to the swing rhythm in that way. So indoors, you use different drills using the steps. Now you can do the steps, just standing on a mat or you can actually move in one direction. You can gradually move left as you take the steps or you can gradually move right forward the backward. Or you use the steps and then try to develop the upper body turn, based on the step rhythm. So that way you can develop a good rhythm. And you can also use devices, the ones you can use indoors include many choices. So for example, I use a rope a lot, it's nylon, double braid, nylon rope, and then because the rope is flexible, particularly the nylon rope is really flexible. So you cannot manipulate the rope motion, so you have to really draw the end point well around the body, and with that you can establish a cool swing plane more than anything. If it's a club, because you can manipulate it with the wrist, so even if your pet is not right, but you can change the position at the end, but when you use a rope, you cannot do that, so you have to guide it correctly. And then when the rope hits under your armpit, both ways, that means you have really good swing plane established. So on one hand, by using the rope, you can establish a good swing plane, but at the same time also, you can really feel what it is like to promote the rope motion by using the body. When you use the body correctly and then draw the end point faster around, having the image of perhaps hitting a drum, the rope is the stick, and then you have a drum and try to hit the drum by using the rope that improves the timing a lot. So on one hand, you are establishing the swing plane, but you are also improving the timing of the motion, and you have a natural consequence. And also, the rope swing was important is maintaining the tension in the rope all the way. So if you lose the tension, that means you are not going all the way. You are just stopping somewhere and then you let the rope drop. If the rope loses tension, then the next motion, when you try to move in the opposite direction, the rope does not respond, by the way. That means you are wasting this precious time of early dowsing phase. So when you maintain the tension well, then as soon as you turn, then the rope will respond. So you can actually accelerate the rope early on. So the rope swing actually has many important benefits. And then you can use different devices with different characteristics. The rope, when it's a fold it is about three and a half feet. So it's a slide over a meter when it's folded. So it's relatively short compared to long clubs, but you can have the woosh stick I use, which gives this auditory feedback. You can use a bit more stiffer sticks like a rib stick, which is used for speed training. You can also use the orange whip, which has a little flexible shaft. So you use these different devices with different characteristics. If your body can handle these and develop consistent swing pattern, very much unified swing pattern, that means you are really developing a strong and healthy mobility system. So your body can handle anything you hold in your hands. And you can also change the weight, because you can use something light, then you focus on just snapping it. But when you have something heavier, then you really have to use your body to throw the end point. When it's heavy, you cannot overcome the inertia with your upper body muscles that way. So you have to use the whole body, and you have to wait and then find what timing. You image that you're pushing a swing. When a swing comes up and you have to wait and then push. So each time when you push, then you will be able to accelerate the swing. So you have to find the right timing, and then also when you have good timing, then you can accelerate the body with minimal effort. But when you fight, when you fight, then you waste a lot of energy, and also you will not be able to generate that much speed. So you have to learn how to generate continuous swing motion, comfortable swing motion, and how to find the right timing, how to develop more unified motion pattern. So these things can be done without a golf club and a ball. So you can do a lot of things indoors with these, and also sometimes you have to teach your body how to move. So one thing I do is put the hands on the wall, and then when you try to move the pelvis, and the shoulder rotates with the pelvis motion, but in their case, it does excess is from actually fixed here. You cannot lean away. So with this turn, this way here, then you will have to learn how to rotate about your spine axis. So there are many practical drills that you can do indoors. And with that, once you develop good motion pattern, then you start using the club and introduce the visual target, which can be a rubber team, start with the longer one, and then touch the tip as you swing back and forth, and gradually lower the team. And then if you can touch really short rubber team consistently, that means you are ready to hit the ball. So particularly those living in the Northern States, where you have a lot of snow in the winter and long cold winter. then actually the wintertime will be a good time to develop this good movement pattern indoors. Why do you think it's so important to start without a ball and maybe even without a club if someone is trying to change their swing pattern? Because when you help a ball, then you are so focused on hitting the ball. So you actually change the motion pattern. So instead of developing in a full motion, full swing motion, you shorten, you tend to shorten it. And when the vaccine is shortened, then you tend to use your arm muscles to try to hit the ball. Then you actually waste a lot of time. So this is oftentimes the mistake made at the beginning of the golfing career. When someone initially started learning, sometimes you just waste a lot of time trying to hit the ball. While your body motion is not really established. And that means that the same mistake is made by the instructors. So initially, instead of working with the ball, the club should be able to handle the full swing motion swinging back and forth continuously and establish the swing pattern. Then without worrying about where you have to go. If the motion can be executed without even thinking, then it's time to introduce the ball and then more focus on the consistent impact. Something I really like about your teachings and exercises is that they're very continuous motions. And there's not that there's no instruction from you, but there's very little implicit instruction from you when you're coaching. You're mainly setting up the task by giving the golfer a different type of implement to use and encouraging them to essentially figure it out for themselves by adjusting what you're asking them to do. Whether that's with the rope or a very flexible shaft, or even another one that I've seen you use that's even easier to do indoors, is the mini motion from site to site with a kettlebell or medicine ball that has a little bit of weight to get the shifting motion. And I think this is so much more effective for a golfer to learn by feeling and going through movements, rather than being given a series of positions or a set of checklists. It's a very, very dynamic movement-based learning environment and there's a lot of feedback as you're doing it that feels much more athletic than I would say maybe a lot of golf instruction is. Yeah, in our DNA, we have the inscribed, so we can generate the natural motion. We all have the capability to generate the natural motion, but for some reason, through instructions, you move away from the natural motion. So all I do is basically encourage the natural motion by just keeping simple verbal instructions sometimes, or by using certain devices, or sometimes using a simple visual target or something. So what I do is just promote this natural movement, natural motion pattern, then usually golfers will figure it out automatically. So one session, when reproving session can be up to two hours, but mostly people get tired because they have to repeat the feedback and forth. So get tired, but at the same time they already acquire the motion pattern in about an hour mostly. So that makes my job really easy because the golfers figure out the movements. All I do is giving simple verbal cues or giving different devices. So the key is the keys we have to regain our natural movement pattern. So one of the most popular ways that golfers try to work on speed is through what I would term intent-based speed training, which is swinging with a radar turned on for speed feedback. They're using either a driver or they're using a speed training tool. And essentially their intent is make the number read faster on the radar. Do you see a case for this allowing people tap back into the natural motion that you're talking about? Because the fear of hitting a bad shot is removed, people are encouraged to go through a bigger swing motion when they're not worried about contact. Or do you think it's likely that people would need a combination of this and the drills you're talking about where it's a much different task, like stepping drills, very different implements, maybe even things where they're not really swinging. It's more a body motion like the step drills with the kettlebells. Or do you not like that type of training for the vast majority of golfers? Like the reason I'm asking is that there's going to be a lot of golfers listening. I thinking this off season, I want to gain five, eight miles an hour of clubhead speed. And they're thinking, will I do predominantly this intent-based speed training, swinging with a radar, trying to make it go faster, documenting my progress over time, which many golfers have been successful with. Or would you be more thinking, I'd leave that for later. Let's work on reprogramming your patterns first. So my approaches, I don't allow them to really use the devices that measure the speed. Because as soon as they have that, then they use the muscles, try to hit hard. Once they go through reasonable training, and then once the motion is established, then they can certainly do that. But mostly, initially when you change the movement pattern, and then you are establishing new movement pattern, and then when you introduce the speed device, then they go back through all the habit and try to use the muscles a lot. So early on, when I started the YouTube channel, early on, a lot of people asked what's the before and after speeds. So I tried to show the before swinging the after swing intentionally, but eventually I stopped doing it. Because the key is you have to practice this enough and then acquire the new motion pattern, then along the way automatically the speed increases. Because I've seen this quite often. So the speed increase should be a pleasant side effect of improvement in the motion pattern, rather than you just go for the speed. So when you just try to increase the number, then oftentimes you break away from the natural movement pattern. And then to encourage the gophers out there, and sometimes I see the gophers who have fairly good climate control, but the speed is not high enough when considering the body size and the muscle conditioning level and things like that. So in that case, sometimes I use the simulator we have here. So to the reprogramming on the simulator, and sometimes I just tell them that okay, increase your vaccine speed. Then with the increase of vaccine speed, certainly the distance increases by 20 yards and 30 yards in the iron condition. So when I see the gophers not really taking advantage of what they have in terms of body size and then the level of muscle conditioning and also the athleticism, then sometimes I do the reprogramming on the simulator. So by showing the numbers and then also show the board pattern, things like that. When you change the motion pattern, then certainly the distance increases quite a bit. So don't worry about, this is my advice. Don't worry about the cleaver speed. If your motion pattern improves, then automatically the speed increases, or the direction controller improves. So the thing is, be more resilient and focus on the developing the motion pattern. And once you develop the pattern, then you'll have a lot of speed increase as a side effect. In my practical experience where I could see that being hugely beneficial for gophers is that I'm probably, I would say, more inclined to be in favor of people using a radar to work on their speed at certain times. But where I see a limit, In this for definite is that people make a lot of speed improvement early on when they do this maybe Maybe three months or so or an initial Four to five miles an hour, but then they hit a huge plateau And they they keep working hard and they wonder why their speed hasn't improved at all and I think this is when Digging more into how you're moving can pay bigger dividends Then simply continuing trying harder and harder and harder to make the speed on the radar increase Actually, I got the opposite way so Initially my recommendation more focusing on the technical aspect so improved the motion pattern and Then try to hit harder and harder once you develop good reason for swing pattern and then so Usually when the golfers have initial Rapid increase in the speed and then plateaus the initial part is more coming from improved motion pattern And then when you hit the plateau, there is time to really be serious about the muscle conditioning Because by improving your swing pattern you increase them much But then that's the limit your body can generate and then By having more systematic training and muscle conditioning With the still with the technical you know training as well you can further increase the speed So but generally the golfers do not reach their potential And I just this Often times say that that most people reach about 70% of their their potential So do you have any strong opinions on physical conditioning for golf what type of activities? Or how training programs should be structured for golfers trying to increase their clubhead speed from a muscle conditioning standpoint We've kind of talked about the mechanics side of it already, but it's really Generally the movement should be functional movements Okay, and promoting good rhythmic motion with the reason we're waiting so that On one hand the golfers still maintain good rhythm, but put more burden on the body so that the body can handle a you know higher load and then Often times what I see on the SNS is The training methods that are quite questionable on the which sorry you see this where On the SNS you know the social network. Oh, sorry. You'll see these video clips and then Trainers ask the golfers to do certain things, but oftentimes my head is So this is my response For example when you are use The device I don't remember the name, but which has a wire we handle in the wire cable pulley Yeah, a cable pulley. Yes, that's And then the direction of the pull is really really important Okay, but a lot of trainers they ask the golfers to do this here So in other words, the cable is running this way here You pull it this way So that means you're putting another effort in the follow-through. Yeah, that's that's a low-to-high Cable chop that Dr. Kwan just demoed for anyone listening and I'm watching in the video, but when you calculate the Talks generally write the muscles in the trunk The maximum occurs about here when the lead-ime is paired to the crown To when the club becomes vertical in the front of you so between those two You know events there typically the muscle talk becomes a maximum that means the cable actually should run this way here Yeah, totally this way And that ties in what we talked about earlier in that the vast majority of your clubhead speed is going to be determined by what you do in the backswing and transition Because once you've gotten past the transition phase There's really not much time to to increase how much force you can apply to the club head and you certainly can't do much once you're in the lay-down swing phase To speed up what the club head's gonna do because it's yeah, so it's the most generous the mixing up talk about here It's because you have to accelerate the body and the club on the way down before the impact, right? But if you pulled the wire this way here all the way here You're just wasting your energy in the follow through the follow through is not where you put a lot of muscular effort It's just the disseleration phase continuation of a down swing motion so you see some questionable practices in training is because Golf swing by mechanics and not well understood, but them by simply having the fact you will be able to develop a lab better training program, which is a more effective for the golfers, so but generally my recommendation is use Function and motion with the rhythm involved and also use various devices in weight so that the corporate can handle those You know without even thinking so that way you can really develop the mobility system. You can develop a healthy You know robust mobility system So the training should focus on you know their aspect The biggest mistakes in my opinion. I see with golf training is similar to what you just said actually and it's when people try to use In inverted commas golf specific movements But get the biomechanics of it wrong and they end up stuck in a gray area where The activity they're doing isn't really relevant to how force is produced in the swing But at the same time They're not doing an exercise that is either Challenging enough to their muscular system or a nervous system to actually create physical change So one of the Areas that I put a lot of focus in I'm part of this would be because I'm in a a different area of let's say golf improvement to you are is I actually think a lot of people can make very good progress by doing a lot of More general mobility and strengthening with their time in the gym. Yes, including some more golf specific exercises But I actually think they're nearly better off Using the type of Practice activities you talked about with the different implements that are of different weights and flexes to cover Let's say their ability to transfer their physical capabilities into the golf swing and make sure that with their physical training They're actually getting stronger and more flexible because I think if people Get toes honed in on golf specific movements in their physical training They're going to be losing muscle mass muscle strength and mobility as their age starts to increase So there should be a balance between general strengthening And then almost allow the practice activities that you recommended To be almost slightly separate from their physical training not to have no golf relevant movements or Simulation movements in their practice But to make sure there's a strengthening aspect of your body And then an improved mechanical aspect which I think is better done With the practice and swing activities you recommended Been trying to do it in the gym with Equipment in there because it often goes wrong. It's much easier to do with the swing type motion Outside of the gym Yeah, so Just to simply bringing in typical training practices into Golf Training for golf Is a bit different So you know generally when you have training your focus can be make the muscle bigger Or and the stronger and then improve the general fitness of the body But when it comes to a golf swing if the training really Should should help The golfer to improve the swing Then you should have a very specific focus and then you have to really see whether you are training Practice is really achieving that and so my general Recommendation is use more functional movements Involves the whole body and also always involve rhythm in the movements And then with the various devices with the different flexibility different weight different lengths Um and that way you can really develop the functional aspect of the body so um You know the Actually, corporates can benefit from training a lot when the training is a better focused. Do you like variations of medicine ball throwing and slamming because you can move in motions that are similar to the swing and overload different segments? Yeah. Always try to get attention. So when you throw the medicine ball, actually the medicine ball throw is really good. So with several swing motion and then throw the ball here. And you can intentionally change the direction of throw. So normally what I ask the corporates to do when I use the medicine ball is just to throw the ball horizontally. If the ball releases late, then it goes left and high for the right handed coffers. If it's too early, then it goes down and the right. But sometimes you can intentionally ask the corporate to control the release point. So throw it different ways. Okay, early throw, late throw, and then normal throw. But when the corporates can respond to your instructions and they can actually generate the motion, that means they have a good control of their body. So really the focus should be promoting the corporates control of the body motion is repeating the same motion again and again. And you can also ask the corporate to repeat the swing with different stance width, wider stance, really narrow stance or reasonable by experimenting all these corporates will automatically be able to find reasonable stance width. So in the train, you can have a lot of variations in terms of tempo. When you swing things, if it's not that heavy, then you can increase the tempo intentionally. When the tempo increases, then your body has to respond differently. And or when you have a large slow motion, then again, the body moves like different, but if you can handle that, that means that you have a fairly robust mobility system in place in your body. So always intentionally manipulate things with intention and promote the corporates ability to control the movements. Dr. Guan, I think we covered a lot there. I'm anxious to not have the conversation go on too long and allow people digest what we talked about. Just to finish, where can people find out more about you, your social media, if they want to come and get assessed, just tell us the different avenues people can go down to learn more from you. Yeah. I have a YouTube channel. It's called the Dr. Guan Golf, DRKW or N Golf. Or I have a website, Dr. Guan Golf, that info. So if you visit either the YouTube channel or my website, then you'll be able to see how I generally work with the golfers and also how you can sign up for the swing analysis. Or reprogramming. Excellent. Thank you very much. I appreciate your time. And I'm sure we'll be in touch soon. I might hold you to a third appearance, maybe next year. It's always fun to talk about golf mechanics. And so I welcome the teaser opportunities. Thank you for giving me again. The Fit for Golf podcast doesn't run ads. I don't try to sell you supplements or golf training aids. If you want to support the podcast and transform your physical fitness for golf and life, I recommend checking out the Fit for Golf. Here's how it works. Go to fitforgolf.app/33 to get a 30 day free trial. Download and log into the app and go through our program match your feature. This consists of a few multiple choice questions. I'm within 60 seconds. The app will provide you with the most suitable program based on your answers. There are programs for all ages and fitness levels, whether you want to work out at home or in a gym. This program is then added to your plan and your next workout will be waiting every time you open the app. There's a link in the show notes. You can click on to get signed up.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Dr. Kwan’s research shows that clubhead speed is strongly correlated with the peak angular velocity of the upper body, particularly the hips, torso, and arms, but not with the timing or sequencing of peak rotations.
  2. The downswing is too short to allow meaningful sequencing differences; instead, the most important mechanical benefits of proximal-to-distal motion occur in the transition phase, where stretch-shortening cycles and angular momentum transfer are optimized.
  3. X-factor (the angle between pelvis and shoulders) is not correlated with clubhead speed, as its effectiveness depends on dynamic momentum transfer, not static separation; forcing shoulder rotation without pelvic movement leads to inefficient swings.
  4. Shoulder rotation is more critical than X-factor, as it directly drives arm and club motion, and should be maximized through unified, rhythmic body rotation around the spine axis.
  5. Golfers should prioritize establishing a consistent, rhythmic swing pattern indoors using drills like rope swings, step drills, or medicine ball throws before introducing a club or ball to avoid shortening the motion.
  6. Speed gains should be a side effect of improved motion patterns, not the primary goal; excessive focus on speed metrics can disrupt natural biomechanics and lead to plateaus.
  7. Effective training emphasizes functional, whole-body movements with rhythm and varying loads to build mobility, strength, and control, rather than isolated, golf-specific exercises.
  8. Dr. Kwan advocates for motion-based, self-directed learning over rigid position drills, allowing golfers to develop intuitive, efficient swing mechanics through experience and feedback.

Summary:

Dr. Kwan, a leading biomechanics expert in golf, revisits his research on clubhead speed, emphasizing that it is primarily driven by peak angular velocity in the upper body—not by the timing or sequence of rotational peaks. His study of 66 skilled male golfers (handicap 3+) found no correlation between peak timing and speed, due to the extremely short downswing duration (about 250 milliseconds).

Instead, the key benefits of proximal-to-distal motion occur during the transition phase, where stretch-shortening cycles and momentum transfer are most effective. He stresses that shoulder rotation is more critical than X-factor, which must be generated dynamically through momentum, not forced through isolated shoulder movement. For practical improvement, Dr.

Kwan recommends indoor drills—such as rope swings, step drills, and medicine ball throws—that build rhythm, body control, and unified motion without a club or ball. These foundational patterns naturally lead to increased clubhead speed. He cautions against overemphasizing speed metrics early in training, as it risks disrupting natural mechanics.

Ultimately, he advocates for a holistic, motion-based approach focused on functional movement and body control, with strength and conditioning supporting long-term performance. Golfers should prioritize mastering swing pattern efficiency before chasing speed, and he encourages learning through intuitive, self-directed practice rather than rigid instruction. His methods are accessible via his YouTube channel (Dr.

Guan Golf) and website, where swing analysis and reprogramming are offered.

FAQs

The study found that clubhead speed is strongly correlated with the peak rotational speed of the upper body, particularly the hips, torso, and arms, but not with the timing or sequence in which these segments reach their peak speed.

The downswing is extremely short (about 250 milliseconds), leaving little time for distinct sequence differences. The peak timing doesn't vary significantly because the body must accelerate and decelerate rapidly within a tight window.

The sequence is beneficial for muscle stretch-shortening cycles and angular momentum regulation. However, it is most effective in the transition phase, not the downswing, where time is too limited for significant segmental timing differences.

No, X-factor (the angle between pelvis and torso at the top) and its stretch during transition are not correlated with clubhead speed. Instead, the amount of rotation in the hips and torso is more directly linked to speed.

Golfers can use drills like continuous swinging with a rope, step drills, or medicine ball throws to develop rhythmic, unified body motion and improve coordination before introducing clubs and balls.

Improving motion efficiency naturally increases speed as a side effect. Focusing solely on speed with devices can disrupt natural movement patterns and lead to plateaus or poor mechanics.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.