Go back

7 - Parallel Public Spheres: Pseudo Experts, Senators, and AFAMs (Part 1)

from Catch Me If You Can

28m 44s

7 - Parallel Public Spheres: Pseudo Experts, Senators, and AFAMs (Part 1)

The study introduces a new framework—“influence operations”—to move beyond the outdated notion of “misinformation” and address the complex, often subtle ways political content shapes public opinion in the Philippines. It identifies key actors such as academic influencers, foreign YouTubers, and elected officials using satire or recontextualized media to spread partisan narratives. These operations exploit algorithmic platforms, campaign finance gray areas, and the credibility of experts to mobilize audiences, often without overt falsehoods. The research also highlights the rise of “parallel public spheres,” where Filipinos inhabit fragmented, isolated information ecosystems—each with its own cultural, political, and social norms—making national dialogue increasingly difficult. The study critiques reactive measures like fact-checking and deplatforming, arguing instead for a holistic, community-centered approach that includes policy reform, media literacy, and cross-sphere engagement. It calls for reflection on harmful practices like cancel culture and brigading, which risk deepening division. Ultimately, the study emphasizes that the transformation of public discourse requires not just technical fixes, but a reimagining of civic participation, trust, and shared reality in a digitally fragmented society.

Transcription

3705 Words, 21996 Characters

English
So Jonathan, you and your fellow researchers are avoiding the term "this information" from now on. Did I get that right? I wouldn't call it "avoiding" but more like broadening the term. So we've been seeking for a new frame that is more expensive and more inclusive. Because you know, in this election cycle, we saw stuff that's more than just misleading information and outright lies. What we saw was campaign innovations that were really exploiting great areas of content. Policy of social media, campaign finance, regulation, you know, fact-check or intervention. So it's more than just blatant lies. It's not just fake news that we saw it, because it means that it's true, and the cleverness of grievances and societies that are true. Right, and all sides had their own army of trolls, influencers, meme content creators, as we have been hearing from our podcast. So it's important we come up with a plan. So we're also presenting and keen to discuss our community engagement plan. Something that can serve as a starting point for a new creative collaboration for us to bridge our divided publics, our parallel public spheres. Hello, I'm Jonathan Ong, this information researcher and professor at the University of Massachusetts Amherst and Harvard University. And I'm Kat Ventura, Boa Podcast. You're listening to Catch Me If You Can, where we take a deep dive into the world of online trolls and talk to personalities involved in influence operations on social media. In this episode, we talk about a launch of our new study called parallel public spheres, influence operations in the 2022 elections. So in this episode, Jonathan, I will be interviewing you. And we will also be taking excerpts from the Twitter space we've done with Nicole, Ross and Ferds, and your presentation in Harvard. Yeah. So Madam, you know, from last October, we actually launched this new study in Harvard, Kennedy School, where I'm a research fellow, that event was just the first part of our launch. That's a formal academic launch. But we have also been busy communicating our findings and connecting with Filipino researchers and different communities of journalists, activists, civil society, you know, inviting new collaborators to learn from our study and also connect with us for our community engagement plan. What was the reception? Like how did they feel about the report? I'm working in the disinformation space. Actually, imagine the use of the idea of publishing open access reports in this particular field of communication studies and disinformation studies. And so a lot of the conversation in this space was being publishes open access reports, you know, just thinking about how urgent the issue of disinformation is and how we need to publish beyond, you know, academic paywalls of journals. But with a risk of newer and wider audiences of research that comes with a lot of complications, the benefit of, you know, we've had examples of an Oxford study, you know, exposing the 30 trolls, natural, big, loud Oxford. So it's not just about the actual findings of the research, but how you communicated in such a way that, you know, you're actually still protected in your organization. And, you know, that it's not going to bite you in the ass down the road. I think it's also just the idea of releasing this study and leaving it up for interpretation because there's so many ways to interpret what you just wrote Jonathan. And I understand that as researchers, you are just telling it as a test. But, of course, the only mistake is to misappropriate the data that you're using for something else. So I think that's another layer to the dangers of a head. So we're doing this podcast. This podcast, it's just a reflection. It's a reflection on the report, but the links to the actual report are there on the description. You can read it in the Filipino version and in its English version. So, you know, we have three of five are junior researchers. I'd like to shout out J. M. Lanusa, who is a PhD student at UMass Amherst. And then we have two master's students in U. P. Dileman, Ferdinand Sanchez, the second and Ross Valerina. Of course, the other researcher is Professor Nicole Corato. So, we have the same senior researchers. And we have to look out for specific risks and potential harms on our junior researchers. So, it's important for us. So I guess we can begin with this. It's not this information. It's now influence operations. And Ross explains it pretty well. We can be part of a disinformation. We just don't know about it. And it's not just deliberate disinformation, because say what we're arguing in this report is going beyond this information, but moving towards the framework of influence operations. It also includes information that might not be illegal or more like questionable, but the intention behind that information is to really influence you to take a side and for you to double down on it. And also talk about how, for example, professionalize our opinions or standpoints or perspectives of political pundits or even PhD holders can also be included into the fold of influence operations. Because it might not be the case now, for example, a professor or an academic is spouting misinformation or disinformation. And because it might sense that, what we're saying is that the information that the political comes for their own particular game. So, when we try to expand our definition, for example, or try to define what the problem is. But we found it appropriate to not restrict it to the frame of this information, that aim for attention hacking and audience mobilization. And by defining it in that way, we also open the flooddates of recognizing that we're not only talking about bloggers here who can be spouting this information, but we can also talk about content creators on YouTube TikTok, right? And all those people are trying to grab your attention. They're trying to mobilize you to do a specific thing or to take a specific standpoint. And that's why we're talking about the influence operations of our people. Okay, so let's talk about the influence operations. Who are the people behind this? So, this is the experience of credentials and PhDs, or if you're looking for experts, but they are the pandits who are also providing various justifications for politicians, policy positions, they sound really smart. They offer their expert opinions on various topics of the day. And sometimes they're even platformed on broadcast channels. So these are existing experts, but also new ones? Yes, so some of them are legit academics and are actually credentialed and have formal titles. Some of them are alternative knowledge influencers. They are on YouTube or on TikTok. And they have a green screen function on TikTok, scholars call this evidence collages. So, apparently they are showing various linkages from various examples and images to push various conspiracy theories. Yes, and you're saying that they're part of the influence operation as what's led to? So, the contribution of knowledge influencers is they provide a sense of legitimacy and an air of respectability to various narratives that are circulating, including historical distortion narratives. If you are in the past, you know, historical distortion claims or attacks on legacy media or mainstream media, they're often expressed as crude memes or attack posts. But, here's the justification. The academic study I'm talking about is that it seems like it will assert and construct new content. yung political realities. When I do think about these knowledge influencers, they can justify it because there are ways to justify it. Not to say that it was real, but also. I'm trying to bring back another term that you did talk about in our earlier episode. Yung re-recontextualized media. Yung nagawarin by yung re-contextualized media. Nakaw kawakad ang nasnipet sa nang isang video de ba. Tapos gagawin mo shang TikTok, gagawin mo shang video justification, or gagawin mo shang beam. But here in knowledge influencer, a historian could have a paper that was he mentions one little thing about the certain candidate. And it gets misinterpreted because it was re-contextualized. Like, is that something that happens? And is that a danger that we see with knowledge influencers? For sure, yeah, the idea that scientific knowledge and empirical research, especially when interpreted by these knowledge influencers, what should clue you in? If this certain kinds of research are increasingly politicized for partisan ends, the bandaparang they are really advancing a very specific interpretation. Sometimes they pick and choose the kinds of data that they advance. They choose a certain methodology. They reject election survey methodology. Some of these knowledge influencers were guilty of that. To advance a new interpretation based on Google data analytics. So the idea that knowledge influencers are all to be trusted, we need to be much more critical as to how these experts sound. Some of them are actually affiliated as consultants for politicians or consultants for big business who seek guidance from them during critical events such as elections. So when they're platform even by legitimate news channels like EBS, EBN, or Rappler, some of them are not disclosing that they're actually working for a politician. Okay, so now let's move on to another personality. That came out of these elections, the Affemary Actors. See you when I discover that. I don't know. Yeah, I don't know that. So for the obviously there's five people in this report, but I will happily take credit. I'm credit grabbing for that section on Affemary Actors. These are attractive foreigners who stream Penoipolitical content with intercultural commentary. So these are YouTubers who obviously are popular in the genre of reacting to music videos. So these are other YouTubers who stream the news of different bands. So I happen to, yeah, the YouTube rabbit hole that I was in, yeah, drove me to a foreigner who was streaming a lot of Marcos content, including content about Marcos' talk shows, Marcos' guess things like Tony Gonzaga' interviews with Boy Abunda, his performances in debates on SMNI, but sometimes even on conspiracy theory documentaries about the Marcos Gold. That's interesting. Yeah, so for me, it sounds quite trivial to talk about Affemary Actors in the context of, you know, bigger issues such as knowledge influencers. But for me, these content creators are really exploiting the YouTube ad algorithm for them to cash in on Penoipolitical fandoms and their intense engagements with Marcos content, right? So I'm going to produce some reaction videos. Alam nila, kasinamaraming fansibong-bong Marcos kikitan asila through Google, through the YouTube ad algorithm. What's their role in the influence operation? I mean, I don't think, I don't think they're hired. Yeah, they're not hired by the Marcos official campaign machinery, but it's all exploiting the YouTube ad system. And their trust in Marcos fans as really intense and passionate on social media. Yeah, it's interesting, no. Because it's yet another personality that sought to exploit the Filipino fans, exploit them with not. Because it may monetary gains in an awful adito. That was their only goal. They were just writing the cloud. Now, let's go to the last personality. There are three here. So we have knowledge influencers, Affemary Actors. And the third, Asanator Sataris. Can you tell us more about this? Asanator Sataris is a real innovator when it comes to the use of her official social media channels. So, yeah, this Asanator Sataris, I'm used her official social media pages to deliver coded satire to attack her family's opponents. And Jamla News talked about the Asanator Sataris personality during your presentation of the report at Harvard. Let's listen. We haven't observed this before. But now we see a sitting incumbent Senator use her social media account, official account to post professionally produced skits. Where she role plays as a sassy tita or a sassy ad. Delivering real talk and spilling tea. But in the process, delivering coded attacks against VP Roberto. This campaign innovation evades fact checks. It evades social media takedowns. How do you take it down? And it's not doing anything overtly malicious or wrong, right? Through its use of satire, through its use of its cloud, because it's in an elected official media page. So, this information in the Philippines has taken on quite a specific baggage. It caused a mind the idea of troll hunting, of fact checking as the ways to respond to blatant lies. And to us, it's a bit narrow. The kind of associations that we have come to have when it comes to this information. And that's how we arrived at Influence Operations. Because we think it's a broader term to discuss the real innovations of 2022. It's not only blatant lies. It's not directly expressed in attacks. But they are justified. They have citations, Papaminsan, they have justification. The people who are spreading these kinds of narratives are people with credentials. And the strategies are exploiting the gray areas of social media content policy, but also campaign finance regulations. So, it's not just clear cut that falls versus true love, unlike in earlier styles of this information campaigning. And for it encourages more people to think beyond fact checking, to think beyond de-platforming, that Facebook has many other controls. It's not only the solution when it comes to Influence Operations. We're advancing a much more sociological and community focused set of interventions with the idea of Influence Operations. We'll see what we call a whole-of-society approach. It's a different strategy. It's a different legal approach. It's a different focus on workers. It's a different focus on counter narratives. And this is why we communicate in our study. Okay. So that was for Influence Operations. And now, let's talk about parallel public sphere. It's another term you introduced in this study. And I just love how Nikol Corato explained it during our Twitter space. I think it's such a powerful way to describe the Philippine public sphere at the moment, because if we see that, even though the political perspectives of the Filipino, our political views still live in the same public sphere, we're like, "We've been waiting for 12 o'clock." We're like, "We've been waiting for 6 pm, prime time, newscast." And it's like, "There's a lot of informs to us if something happens to us." So even though we're waiting for our opinions, our baseline of facts is similar to that. But of course, with the social media, we have a fragmented consumption of news and information and even entertainment, because of the curation of feeds on Netflix or other streaming sites. There's nothing that connects us anymore. There's no common topic of conversation. Even when you look at Twitter trending topics, it's like, "I don't even realize that there's a vlogger here." And that's because our public sphere has become so fragmented. We don't have a common language to make sense of their reality. at Twitter, siyunong bayong mga blogger niya, siyungat ba sila? But in reality, or even doon sa mga spheres of influencers nila sabay natin, yung doon sa verse, universe nila, indeed siyikat sila. And nong ten nare namin tingnan, dito sa reporter, dito sa study nga. Yung actually tried to, na actually navigate the different algorithms. Kasi I think, 'kay, langan din init din, na koan yung usuali ng nila like or shina-sharko. Yung din yung nakhifid, doon sa profile, doon sa wall na ikita ko. So we actually had to navigate different kinds of spheres. Like, even to subscribe to different kinds of YouTube channels, pages on Facebook, and even yung mga users dito sa Twitter. So we also had to follow or even look into the other universe or even different supporters. So yes, it is difficult, because make it a new difference in yung fragmentedness on different spheres, and you have to actually navigate yourself with it. Naparang, sa nabaho nal dito. So it is eventually, maka-kara na effekin sa personal animal profile mga. Na meron kina-palang kina-follow. And actually, it's a good way to actually break your own system, na hindi lang isa yung fina-follow mga value systems. That last person you heard is Fred Sanchez. It was also in our Twitter space, and he helped work on the digital ethnography of the study. But before we get to that, anubayatong public sphere na pinagusaapan natin. Yeah, a public sphere is the political space where people made to exchange their views, listen across different and solve collective problems. Obviously, this is a concept where we draw a lot of inspiration from Yurgen Habermas who developed the concept of public sphere. In the Philippines, parang social media, radio programs, town halls, barang gai assemblies, as well as everyday discussions in the workplace, are comprising of the public sphere in the Philippines. So to us, the idea of, and we talked about this a lot, na parang should it be fragmented public spheres na watak-watak natayo? But then we actually discussed it and said, actually, we need to make a bolder claim, na even the past, we imagine, legacy media as being the gatekeeper of the public sphere, that they hold the political center where, you know, different politicians across different political camps come together, to stage a national debate, a political conversation across political divides. The fact that in 2022, the eventual president missed out and, you know, was an absentee for these national debates and chose instead to discuss his political program on a talk show, on a different broadcast media channel, that to us signaled the breakdown of legacy media and their control of the public sphere. And it's not just on social media. From your examples, we can see that this is a reality happening on the ground, and that's exactly what Ross Fallorina shared in the Twitter space. I lived through the effects of social media, that's it. I lived there in Fallor, and then this is a Marxist country, this is the 30th country, and even the political opinion, I have a different political opinion than the people around me here. So in terms of the first hand experiencing effect, then this is why the report means so much to me, and it really resonates with me, because my parallel public sphere, not just online, but also offline, because it's not in my household, I'm just speaking. We can see the political opinion of my parents, and at some point, I'll wait right before the elections, to the point that I'm not talking about my mom for several months, because of a discussion that I didn't want to have, but she wanted to about politics, and when we were looked, when we were listening to the news, she just had to say things about specific candidates and all those things. So I'm talking, the report resonates with me so much, and after you're having that experience, I was also thinking about in terms of, how should I respond to the transformation of the public sphere? So eventually, I learned to live with the differences, and I hope other people can as well, because it's much as it's easy for people to unfriend, people who have a different political opinion, let's say, with Kakaampinka, yeah, unfriend, you know, Kakaelalamun, to 30 supporters, a Mark of supporters, and all those things, you say that as if it's easy, but if you really want to live in the Philippines, and if you really want to bridge the parallel public spheres, you shouldn't. But just this idea of a parallel public sphere, when you say something as parallel, it's two lines that will never meet, but they are adjacent to each other, meaning they do mirror one another. That kind of spoke to me, to be honest, when I was reading the, when I was reading the report, the idea that everything happening on this side is also being mirrored on the other side, and what really scared me, and what really concerned me a bit was the fact that if both sides are living in their own echo chambers with the sort of resources that will sustain it, how are they ever going to meet? You know, okay, I'm fragmented by all of them, because they can be rich, but if parallel, we don't really have to be rich, it seems like I'm wrong. Exactly, and the discussions took up a lot of our energy and, you know, and a lot of self-reflection is, should we discuss also your practices, your liberals, yeah, including liberal academics, liberal institutions such as As in academia. Part of the discussion of research team, and it's also a kind of, how can we encourage some self-reflection through our study? Now, what are the practices that might exacerbate these divides? The idea of fighting fire with fire has been a theme of our season deba-kat, and that we are in influencers, what's going on in influence operations is to fight fire with fire, or mata-sa-matah, is this the right way moving forward? And so we made space in our report to discuss the practices of cancel culture, also the practices of brigading, or it's mass reporting of accounts, now, are these practices as, you know, recognizing them as citizens' efforts to preserve the public sphere, to preserve spaces that, you know, defend the principles of the public sphere, to correct historical distortions, are these legitimate ways of seeking accountability, or pinapa iting banila-lalo ang divisiveness na ating na e-experience today? And we'll talk about those two practices, cancel culture and brigading in part two of the Elections Report episode. Again, I'm Jonathan Ohm, and I'm Kat Ventura Boa Podcast. This episode was edited by Carl Sayah, it was funded by internews and powered by Boa Podcast. Follow catch me if you can on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts, and if you have suggestions or comments for the show, we'd love to hear them. You can also follow me on Instagram at John C. Ohm, Manaming Salamat For.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The study shifts from focusing on "misleading information" to a broader framework of influence operations, which includes content designed to shape opinions, mobilize audiences, and exploit social media policies.
  2. Influence operations are not limited to blatant lies but include legitimate experts, influencers, and content creators who recontextualize or selectively present information to serve political agendas.
  3. Key actors include knowledge influencers who use academic credibility to justify partisan narratives, and Affemary Actors who monetize political fandoms through YouTube content and algorithmic targeting.
  4. Asanator Sataris exemplifies a new form of influence through coded satire on official social media, evading fact-checks and de-platforming by blending humor with political attacks.
  5. The concept of "parallel public spheres" highlights how Filipinos now live in fragmented, isolated information ecosystems, lacking shared discourse and common ground across political divides.
  6. These parallel spheres are sustained by algorithmic curation, social media platforms, and echo chambers, making national consensus and civic dialogue increasingly difficult.
  7. The research calls for a whole-of-society approach to address influence operations, moving beyond fact-checking or deplatforming to include community-based, sociological, and policy-level interventions.
  8. Practices like cancel culture and brigading are critically examined as potentially divisive, raising questions about accountability versus polarization in the public sphere.

Summary:

The study introduces a new framework—“influence operations”—to move beyond the outdated notion of “misinformation” and address the complex, often subtle ways political content shapes public opinion in the Philippines. It identifies key actors such as academic influencers, foreign YouTubers, and elected officials using satire or recontextualized media to spread partisan narratives. These operations exploit algorithmic platforms, campaign finance gray areas, and the credibility of experts to mobilize audiences, often without overt falsehoods.

The research also highlights the rise of “parallel public spheres,” where Filipinos inhabit fragmented, isolated information ecosystems—each with its own cultural, political, and social norms—making national dialogue increasingly difficult. The study critiques reactive measures like fact-checking and deplatforming, arguing instead for a holistic, community-centered approach that includes policy reform, media literacy, and cross-sphere engagement. It calls for reflection on harmful practices like cancel culture and brigading, which risk deepening division.

Ultimately, the study emphasizes that the transformation of public discourse requires not just technical fixes, but a reimagining of civic participation, trust, and shared reality in a digitally fragmented society.

FAQs

The study introduces the term 'influence operations' to describe a broader range of content strategies that aim to shape public opinion, even if not outright false or illegal.

It includes content that may not be illegal but is designed to influence public opinion, such as expert opinions, recontextualized media, and content from influencers that justify political narratives.

The study identifies knowledge influencers, Affemary actors (foreign YouTubers streaming political content), and 'Asanator Sataris'—an official politician using satire to deliver coded attacks on opponents.

They provide a sense of legitimacy to political narratives by citing research or using expert-like language, often selectively presenting data to support partisan views and sometimes working as consultants for politicians.

It describes how the public sphere in the Philippines has fragmented into separate, isolated online and offline communities with different political views and information sources, making cross-communication difficult.

The breakdown is evident in the shift from national political debates on legacy media to fragmented online spaces, where political discussions are now isolated in different digital and social circles.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.