The story of *The Messenger* centers on a short film based on a real World War II anecdote where a teenager, Thomas E. Jones, delivered a surrender message in Washington, D.C., but was delayed by a U-turn. Michael, a young actor from Cleveland, was cast in the role after an audition where he resonated with the character. Director Quincy, inspired by a brief mention in a book, sought to include a real interview with Thomas Jones but found him deceased. Instead, he hired a man with a similar death certificate and staged a fake interview, leading to a major ethical failure. The film gained widespread attention, but when the deception was exposed, the real Thomas Jones’s family was outraged, and the movie was canceled. Michael was devastated, but the experience ignited his passion for filmmaking, leading him to a successful career in TV. Quincy, meanwhile, struggled with guilt and spent years hiding from the fallout, admitting he had a lifelong pattern of lying to compensate for his insecurities. After years, he reconciled with his past, and a heartfelt conversation with Michael revealed how the film, despite its failure, became a catalyst for personal growth. The story illustrates how a flawed moment of opportunity can lead to lasting change, emphasizing the power of truth, accountability, and redemption in shaping lives. It also underscores the profound impact of a single decision—whether born from ambition, ego, or need—on the trajectory of one’s life.
Pushkin
Hi dear
Happy birthday to me
Oh my god, it was your birthday last week, wasn't it?
It's kind of why I was phoning
Happy birthday
I'm sorry buddy
It loses something when you have to call
a week later to receive
to get your own birthday wish
from someone, you know, it hurts
Okay, honestly, I feel like
your birthday's not that important to you, am I wrong?
Well, it's not as important to me
as the first night of Hanukkah
and the second night
not the third night
I hate the third night
You know what?
As a birthday present to myself
I'm going to hang up on you
Happy birthday to me, indeed
Happy birthday to me, indeed
From Pushkin Industries
I'm Jonathan Goldstein
and this is Heavyweight
Today's episode
The Messenger
Right after the break
This is Jacob Goldstein
When you're a business owner
interested in expanding to new markets
there's a lot to consider
and countless questions to answer
before making the call
The most important one being
Are you ready?
That's where ChatGPT comes in
Give it a goal, add your files
and ask Chat to help you map out
different scenarios for the future of your business
So when growth is on the table
you've got an expansion plan ready to implement
Get started today at ChatGPT.com
If you love music
and great artist interviews
check out Before the Moment
hosted by Niall Rogers
This new series follows Niall
as he travels across the country
talking with some of today's most fascinating artists
about the moments that shape their lives
and careers
From hitmakers like Miguel
to rising stars like Alex Warren
Niall explores the stories behind the careers
the songs
and the moments that changed everything
Because every musician remembers
the point where everything changed
and this podcast tells the stories that came before it
Listen to Before the Moment
a Lincoln Original series on the iHeartRadio app
YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts
You probably have an app for streaming
and an app for podcasts
But does your audio bundle include an app for radio?
An app for what's happening right now
An app for breaking news
that'll change your daily routine
An app that starts your morning
with what you missed last night
That app is iHeartRadio
The app that starts your morning with what you missed last night
The app that lets you listen to thousands of live radio stations and more
Download the number one app for radio
The free iHeartRadio app today
iHeartRadio
As a kid growing up in Cleveland
Michael loved acting
The only problem
I wasn't very good
In fact, he stank
In every summer camp show
he was placed in the back row
In a children's production of The Hobbit the Musical
Michael was the only one who was placed in the back row
Backstage, a kid dressed as a dwarf told Michael
My mom says your singing is awful
But it didn't stop Michael
He nursed his acting bug
all the way through senior year
when one day
he heard about a movie being filmed in Cleveland
and the director needed lots of teens
to be extras
Straight after school
Michael made his way to the auditions
He was shown into a room with the director
and some of the crew
They gave him a script
and he started acting
And their eyes lit up
And I was asked to keep reading
And so we did the scene again
We did it again
And again and again
And all the while
Michael was overcome by a curious feeling
I was doing a good job
Had you ever experienced this before?
Like been in an audition
where people were responding this way?
No
I was usually in auditions
where they're like
we can make him a tree
We can make him a tree
At the end of the audition
the director told Michael
that he was not going to be an extra
Michael was going to be the star
of the whole movie
Why was he going to be the star
of the whole movie?
Was it his Brando-esque brooding?
His Shia LaBeouf-ian intensity?
They showed me the storyboard
and I looked exactly like the kid
in the drawings of the storyboard
I was like, oh my god
I think that's the reason I got it
They were just like
you look like the kid we drew
The film was called
The Messenger
based on a true story
And the true story it was based on
was a little-known World War II anecdote
about a teenager named Thomas E. Jones
Jones was a telegram messenger
in Washington, D.C.
On August 14, 1945
he was sent to deliver the telegram
that announced Japan's unconditional surrender
to the Allies
But on the way to deliver the message
he got pulled over for an illegal U-turn
And thus, the end of World War II
was delayed by ten minutes
Michael played the role of Thomas
as he navigated that fateful day
I show up to set
and I just was immediately involved
in the magic of film
They had to fake the daylight
by putting lights outside the window
and I remember being like
oh, you're not just like
capturing a moment
You're not just like
you're creating a moment
And the custodian of this exciting new world
the director of the movie
was a 25-year-old wunderkind
named Quincy
Quincy took to Michael immediately
Throughout the production
he'd check in with Michael on the phone
and take him out for wings
Michael looked up to Quincy
To meet someone who was orchestrating
this giant production
and then for him to take time
talk to me
I felt part of
Even after filming ran
Quincy stayed in touch
calling Michael with updates
about the movie's release
We were going to premiere
at the Philadelphia Film Festival
I learned that it was a big production
$100,000 short film
which is a lot of money
for a short movie
The executive producer
was this man named Pat Croce
Pat! Pat! Pat!
If you don't know the name
Pat Croce was a media presence
an entrepreneur famous in the world of sports
because he was a media presence
he owned the Philadelphia 76ers
in the late 90s
He was a motivational speaker
I get up, I slap my palms together
It's going to be a great day
A noted pirate enthusiast
People ask me if I'm a pirate
and I say yes
But 300 years too late
And the kind of beloved
pre-MeToo macho man
who'd show up unannounced
on the set of the local news
just to scoop the anchor woman up
into his arms
Accident on the Jersey term
My God!
Because when you have that much
joie de vivre
what choice do you have?
You know whenever Pat comes in the room
you never know what's going to happen
He just doesn't have any rules
Because Pat Croce
because he's involved
the movie gets a lot of press
For a short film by an unknown director
The Messenger received
an unheard of amount of press
ESPN carried a story
with footage of Michael on set
and there was a huge write-up
in USA Today
My dad was flying that day
He was in an airport
He picks up the USA Today
He flips it open and sees
a two-page spread with my picture on it
So the family's excitement
the friends' excitement
everyone starts to just be like
this is a very big deal
Michael was planning on college in the fall
but as anticipation around the movie grew
he started to reconsider
Leading up to the
Philadelphia Film Festival
talking to Quincy
He's like
Tom Hanks wants to meet with you
This is a real chance
This is a real opportunity
This is bigger than I imagined
I was like maybe
maybe I try and pursue acting
Maybe Michael had been wrong all these years
Maybe everyone had been
Maybe he really was a good actor
And it took Quincy to discover it
Michael couldn't wait to walk the red carpet
see himself on the big screen
and enjoy a virgin appletini with Tom Hanks
Did your parents come with you to the premiere?
Well, we didn't make it to the premiere
The movie was canceled
So the week before the Philadelphia Film Festival premiere
I got a phone call from Quincy
and he was clearly crying
and he was like, "I'm sorry"
And he told me that the movie wasn't going to come out
and nobody was going to see it
because it turns out that Quincy had lied
and told a really big lie
The lie Michael's referring to
had nothing to do with the historical anecdote itself
That part was true
But over the end credits
Quincy played footage of the actual present-day Thomas C. Jones
being interviewed on his deathbed
The only problem?
That guy was an act
It seems Quincy had just found a random old man,
slipped him into a gown, strapped him into a hospital bed,
and christened him Thomas E. Jones.
But there was one thing Quincy wasn't counting on.
Because the movie had received so much attention,
Thomas E. Jones' real family found out.
And Thomas E. Jones' real family wasn't happy.
Because as it turned out, the real Thomas E. Jones was very much alive.
Breathing, eating, sleeping, and not on a deathbed,
but just a regular old bed bed.
And so Pat Croce decided to pull the movie.
I mean, it was crushing disappointment.
I had the ticket to go. I had the suit.
I had all the expectation I had in my brain,
everything that could be possible after.
And it's all gone. It's all, it vanishes.
And then it's a wave of,
it's an embarrassment because I have to tell everybody.
Michael had to go back to his friends, family,
his grandmother, who'd been clipping every article about the movie,
and say, remember how I was going to be a big movie star?
It was all a fraud.
And the guy who thought I had talent? Also a fraud.
And I never talked to Quincy again.
Michael abandoned his dream of becoming an actor.
But his time on The Messenger still had its impact.
It allowed him to do what he wanted to do.
It allowed him to realize how much he loved being on a set,
loved the magic of creating a whole world from thin air.
And that pushed him towards a career in TV,
writing for shows on Disney and Nickelodeon.
Meanwhile, Quincy's IMDb credits have grown sparse.
I always wondered what happened to Quincy.
Because I looked up to him,
there was part of me that wanted to tell him that I've, like, succeeded,
that I've pursued movies because of him.
But along with that, Michael has a lingering question for Quincy.
I never understood why you would take such a big risk like that,
to make such a big lie.
It's like, you've set up a film crew to film this guy on his deathbed,
and it wasn't him.
Like, it just seems like a bad plan.
As Michael has climbed the ranks of show business,
this question has only gained in poignance.
Why risk your reputation,
especially when the story was good enough as it was?
Why did you lie?
After the break,
searching for Quincy to become the messenger's messenger.
But first, the best messages of all.
Promotional messages from our cherished sponsors.
We really do love you guys.
Ew.
Too gross?
It's a little gross.
Eh, keep it in.
If you're a music fan,
here's a new podcast to check out.
It's called Before the Moment,
a new series hosted by the legendary Nile Rodgers.
You know him as the producer, songwriter, guitarist,
and co-founder of Chic.
But in this series,
he's hitting the road to sit down
with some of today's most fascinating artists.
From hitmakers like Miguel,
to rising stars like Alex Warren,
Nile,
Nile explores the stories behind the careers,
the songs,
and the moments that changed everything.
Because every artist can point to that turning point,
that moment before the breakthrough,
before the success,
before everything changed.
Through candid conversations and personal stories,
you'll hear what happened before the moment
that made them who they are today.
Listen to Before the Moment,
a Lincoln Original series on the iHeartRadio app,
YouTube,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
This is Jacob Goldstein.
With ChatGPT, you can do more than get answers.
You can get things done.
When you're running a business and looking to expand,
you need a clear view of the landscape
before making any decisions.
ChatGPT can help you prepare.
Connect your Google Drive,
point to relevant files and reports,
and ask it to research competitors,
industry forecasts, and market signals.
It can turn the findings into a strategic deck
in your team's template
that you can review before presenting to your leadership team.
Growing a business,
is ambitious.
And ChatGPT can help you do it with confidence.
Get started today at ChatGPT.com.
Most women wait years
before seeking relief from menopause symptoms.
That's years of hot flashes,
sleepless nights,
brain fog,
and mood swings.
Some not knowing where to start.
Some who asked their doctor and got dismissed.
Menopause happens.
The suffering doesn't have to.
Alloy was built by women who dealt with all of it.
It's an all-in-one platform
that connects you with a board-certified
menopause-specialized physician
and real, effective treatment.
Not guesswork.
Not a rushed 10-minute appointment.
Care can start in hours.
Not weeks.
Just complete a simple online intake.
Get matched with a menopause-specialized physician
who builds a treatment plan around you.
And get unlimited messaging with your doctor.
Always included.
Once approved,
your prescription ships straight to your door.
No pharmacy.
No hassle.
Join the women who found real relief.
Head to MyAlloy.com
and use code
ALLOYPOD
for 20% off your first order.
That's MyAlloy.com
Code ALLOYPOD
Valid on products only.
Why did Quincy lie?
The more I think about it,
the less sense it all makes.
Why go to the trouble of hiring an old man
and building a hospital set?
Why not just use the real Thomas E. Jones?
Hello?
Oh, hello.
My name is Jonathan Gouldstein.
I've so far been unable to speak to you.
I've been unable to contact Quincy,
so I reach out to someone else
who might have the answer.
I was looking for a Thomas E. Jones.
He's deceased.
Oh, I'm very sorry.
Yes, I'm his widow.
When he died,
we would have been married
almost 70 years.
Thomas's widow, Nancy,
is 89 years old.
She says she doesn't know
why Quincy didn't just go to Thomas himself.
But we get to talking
and she tells me the story
of how she fell in love with him.
She tells me how she first met Thomas.
It was through his work as a messenger.
It turns out Nancy's father
was Thomas's boss
at the telegram office.
She tells me how in 1945
there was a dedicated telegraph machine
standing by for the sole purpose
of awaiting the Japanese surrender.
And when that machine started ticking,
my father,
he handed the message first
to my husband,
who was a bicycle messenger
at 16 years of age.
Since a bike was too slow,
for such an important message,
a co-worker agreed
to drive Thomas in his car.
Unfortunately,
he set out in the wrong direction.
And thus,
the most famous U-turn
in American history.
Or at least the only one
I've ever heard of.
And I've read my Howard Zinn.
The U-turn got Thomas
and his driver pulled over by a cop.
Of course, they were saying,
we've got the Japanese
peace surrender message here.
Yeah, I've heard a lot of stories,
but the police realized
it was the truth.
They just told me,
they just tore up the ticket.
Wow, what a story.
Yeah.
And it's a pretty different story
than the one in the messenger.
Not only were the Joneses
angry about the fake Thomas,
but they were also angry
about what they considered
the fake story.
In Quincy's version of events,
Thomas is in no hurry
to deliver the message.
He makes a casual pit stop
at a diner,
where he hits on the waitress
and enjoys a large breakfast
of pancakes,
all while the war rages on.
The Joneses read about that scene
in the media coverage
of Quincy's movie.
Newspaper write-ups
with headlines like
Boys' Pancake Breakfast
Delayed the End of World War II.
Well, you know,
my kids were just serious
about that.
We're not talking about kids.
We're talking about people
now 60 years old.
We were outraged.
The kids were outraged.
This is Victoria Jones.
She's one of Thomas and Nancy's
six children.
All of whom,
when it came to the messenger,
were in agreement.
Which was unusual
for the six of us.
This is Thomas' son,
Mike Jones.
He says that the only one
inclined to let the whole thing go
was Thomas himself.
That was kind of my dad's attitude.
Like, oh, don't make a big deal.
Don't get this person in trouble.
We said, no,
this is altering history.
It just kind of portrayed him
like as the slacker,
you know, like,
oh, the heck with that.
I'm going to go and flirt
and eat pancakes.
Victoria says that
although Quincy never reached out
to her father,
he easily could have.
Just like you found my mother
by getting a few phone calls,
Quincy could have found my father.
And he never tried.
When she found out about the movie,
Victoria messaged Quincy several times.
But she says he grew defensive
and eventually stopped answering.
And then when my father died,
I sent him a message and said,
you know,
my father is now deceased.
Huh.
And he did not respond to that?
No.
Oh, I should go back and look.
He might have said I'm sorry.
And that was it.
I tell the Joneses
the story about Michael
and how I'm trying
to reach Quincy myself.
Good luck with that one.
I'm sure he'll think
this is a better left
than dead story, don't you?
It turns out Nancy Jones is right.
When I finally get through
to Quincy via email,
his response is emphatic.
I'm not interested in talking about that project anymore, he writes.
And that's the last I hear from Quincy.
What happens next is years go by.
Unrelated to my failure to speak with Quincy, but you never know,
heavyweight is canceled and I lose my job.
And while the story never entirely leaves my mind,
without an ergonomic office chair and a long-distance phone plan,
there's not much I could do about it.
And then one day, while trying to decide on a fun font for my resume,
I receive a message from Michael.
He says he has an important update to share.
Hey, Jonathan.
Hey, Michael, how are you?
Good, how are you doing?
It's been almost three years since Michael and I have spoken.
You have a son now?
I've got a wife, I've got a son.
The whole family is currently in New York,
where Michael's wife, Katie, is producing a movie.
It turns out that Katie's movie is the reason for Michael's update.
The associate producer on the movie, his name's Dan.
Michael explains that while out for dinner with Dan,
they started talking about the industry,
by which I mean the show business industry.
And one of the things people in the industry enjoy chatting about most
is how they got into the industry.
So Michael told Dan the story of The Messenger,
about the director, Quincy,
about the producer,
about the producer, Pat Croce.
And Dan is from Philly.
Dan's parents are family friends with the Croces.
You're kidding.
Show Biz Connections.
In this life, there's not a thing that doesn't come down
to Show Biz Connections.
It's not what you know, when you know,
where you know it, or why you know it,
but whom you know.
Pat Croce was the executive producer on the movie,
the one who ultimately,
shut it all down.
So with Quincy unwilling to talk,
he's our best shot at figuring out why Quincy had lied.
At some point,
Pat had to have demanded an explanation from Quincy.
Dan agrees to talk to his mom,
who agrees to talk to Pat's daughter,
who agrees to talk with Pat,
who then agrees to talk with me.
Mr. Croce?
Call me Pat.
This is Pat.
Pat.
Pat.
Croce.
One thing I'd like to say,
about your heavyweight podcast,
is that it always inculcates a high vibrational frequency.
Can you say more about the high frequency?
Well, in the realm of form,
if we're going to transcend form. Pat Croce has a white goatee
that ends in a point at his chest.
He's in the Zen Den,
a large room above the barn on his 53-acre estate.
His walls are covered in Chinese and Tibetan calligraphy.
He says that these days,
he seldom makes any media appearances.
Is there any reason for that?
It's a great question, you interviewer, you.
Well, ten years ago, something happened.
My mind cracked.
Pat's mind cracked in a meeting for one of his restaurants.
He owned several.
Among them, the Rum Barrel,
which is pirate-themed.
And I'm sitting there,
thinking to myself,
what the hell am I doing here?
I don't really give a shit about the next great grouper sandwich.
This is just more.
I always was. Seeking more.
Another win.
Another standing ovation.
Another bestseller.
Another.
Another.
More.
More.
It. There was never enough.
Never.
What Pat realized was that in spite of all his successes,
he wasn't really happy.
And so he tried to change his way of thinking.
But it was a slow process.
The ego in me was,
if I can change my mind,
that'd be another great bestseller.
And I would go back on the speaking game.
It was all ego,
all commercialization,
but that's how grace hooked me.
Everything that unfolds is perfect.
I have this adage,
the past has served its purpose perfectly.
But most people are cherry pickers.
Well, I wish that would have changed,
or I wish this were. No!
The purpose of the past, Jonathan,
there's only one purpose.
To bring you and me right here and now.
Okay.
The past.
The past to me is smoke off the end of my cigar.
For me, the past is also smoke off the end of my cigar.
Juicy wafts of precious smoke
to be hysterically clawed at
like a rabid raccoon
attacking a helium-filled garbage can.
And so I ask Pat to go back to the past
and explain how he became involved
with Quincy, Michael, and the Messenger.
He says it all began in Key West
at the pirate-themed museum he owned
that sat beside the pirate-themed restaurant
he also owned.
And you get to know
all the piratical personalities on that island,
one of which was Reef.
And Reef is a salvager,
and he's really got a piratical nature.
He would even dress as a pirate.
I really loved him.
One day, Reef asked Pat for a favor.
Could Pat meet with his son Quincy,
who wanted to make a movie?
And we got talking,
and he turned me on to this script
that he has been writing.
And you liked it.
Oh, sure.
Are you kidding me?
It's talking about this. This young boy who has an effect
on the ending of World War II.
And you hadn't known that story.
I hadn't known that story.
Oh, no.
I had never heard of it.
What was your impression of Quincy
when you first met him?
Oh, I liked him.
And so. And I believed everything Quincy told me.
When Quincy's lie came out,
Pat was furious.
Prior to 10 years ago,
before, you know, my mind cracked,
he's lucky he didn't cross my path
or else he wouldn't be walking.
You mean that. You mean that literally?
Let's say no,
since this is being taped.
Ha, ha, ha, ha.
I'm pretty street savvy.
I couldn't believe
that I got buffaloed like this
as someone I thought was a friend,
you know, a friend,
a Key West friend.
I was so hurt that I was angry.
And when I. The old Pat Croce,
the old corner guy,
man,
not only did I lose the money,
but all the contacts that I made
for him to get him in USA Today.
I opened all these doors
through all my relationships
and then all of a sudden
when I realized
that it was a fraud,
that it was phony,
I mean, I had to go
and apologize to everyone.
But Pat says
that these days
he doesn't have time
for rumination or regret.
And even though I am here,
at peace,
my body
has bone marrow cancer.
I'm on chemo
every 12 hours
of chemo meds.
Incurable.
However,
I don't regret that.
I don't. Nothing.
Oh, wow.
Uh. Jonathan,
it's only my body.
It's not me.
Before we get off,
I ask Pat,
Michael's burning heart,
why did Quincy lie?
But Pat says
he doesn't ask
the why questions.
Only Quincy, Pat says,
if he goes deep,
can answer that.
Pat and Quincy
haven't spoken for decades.
Their last interactions
were angry ones,
right after Quincy's lie came out.
All the same,
Pat offers to reach out to Quincy.
He contacts a friend
who he thinks
might have Quincy's phone number.
I don't have high hopes,
but Pat and Quincy
do end up speaking
and afterwards,
for reasons I can't discern,
Quincy agrees
to speak with Michael.
From hitmakers like Miguel
to rising stars
like Alex Warren,
Nile explores the stories
behind the careers,
the songs,
and the moments
that changed everything.
Through Kansas City,
and the conversations
and personal stories,
you'll hear what happened
before the moment
that made them
who they are today.
Growing a business
is ambitious,
and ChatGPT
can help you do it
with confidence.
This is Malcolm Gladwell
from Revisionist History.
In military families,
service is more than a job.
It's a legacy.
At American Military University, that legacy can have
help open new doors through education. If someone in your family served in the military, you could
be eligible for reduced tuition. Take the next step with flexible online programs built for real
life. Learn more at amu.apus.edu slash military. A video call between Michael and Quincy is
arranged. And while we wait for Quincy, I ask Michael the opening question I learned in J
school. Are you in a bathroom? No, this is our tiny little kitchen in our apartment. It's late
at night and Michael gives me a tour of his darkened New York apartment. There's our Carson's
little lunchbox. Very sweet. Where is he right now? Carson is asleep. What a lazy bones. And then
Quincy enters the chat. It's been almost 20 years since he and Michael were together on set.
Quincy was 25 at the time. He's in his 40s now. It's nice to see Michael's face. I haven't seen
his face in a long time. I know. It's good to see you. Michael and Quincy begin by reminiscing about
their time together, about making the movie. There were two scenes that really stand out for
me. One is when all the kids were in the diner. They exchange memories from what feels like
unfraught territory. Stuff like the casting and the fun of being on set. My favorite scene was
doing the U-turn. You had me drive. stick shift, and I lied. When I auditioned, you were like, "Can you drive stick?" And I was like,
"I can drive stick." I couldn't drive stick. I was. Really? Oh, I never hear that.
I know. And I was like stalling out, like grinding the gears.
It feels like Michael is trying to make Quincy comfortable,
show that Quincy wasn't the only one capable of a lie.
I was like, "I'm a fraud. This is a disaster."
I remember the guy that we rented the car from was like pulling his hair out, too. He was like,
"I thought this kid could drive."
I remember the guy that we rented the car from was like pulling his hair out, too. He was like, "I thought this kid could drive."
But it doesn't take long before the conversation turns to the elephant in the room,
and it's Quincy who brings it up.
I remember wanting to reach out to you in the years that passed.
Yeah, I felt a lot of guilt because, like, this film, everybody had put so much
sweat and tears into it, and it was just nothing. It, like, evaporated. And I thought, "My god,
I've failed every single person." And then I became, like, national news. And then the blogs
were writing about me.
Because The Messenger got a colossal amount of press, when The Truth came out, Quincy received
a proportional amount of backlash. Similar to how the tidal wave of The Messenger's success hit
Michael, the bad news about The Messenger's failure hit Quincy. He was at the airport,
reading that day's newspaper over someone's shoulder.
And they were reading the article about me, and how I had lied. And that hit me, like,
I'd say a ton of bricks, but a ton of bricks would have felt like a pillow compared to what that was.
How were you coping?
I was in denial. I kept going back to this, like, excuse of, "Well, the Titanic,
right? The Titanic, it's a fake movie. It's based on a true story. There was no Jack and Rose." And
yet, what I had done was totally different. I mean, I was literally trying to pretend that
this other actor I had hired was Thomas Jones. And, uh. It took me a year or two to sort of come to terms and just be like, "Man, I really fucked up."
Which brings us to the question of why. Why swap a random old man for Thomas E. Jones?
To explain, Quincy starts with how he came to the story of The Messenger in the first place.
I had been working that summer at the Truman Little White House in Key West,
and sort of in my onboarding at that museum, they told us to read David McCullough's
Truman biography. And, uh, it was in that book that I saw this one sentence
about Thomas E. Jones in The Messenger.
And it was literally one sentence. One sentence, in parentheses,
in the middle of a thousand-page book.
And I thought, "God, what an amazing story."
But, Quincy thought, you know what would make it an even more amazing story?
If he could find Thomas E. Jones, interview him, and include that interview in the movie.
And in Quincy's telling, he did look for him.
I had hired literal investigators to go find this person. Two different guys, and they both said,
like, you know, we can't find him, but we found these two death certificates that kind of match up.
So the death certificates felt like enough. Quincy concluded that the Thomas E. Jones
he was looking for probably was dead. And I didn't share that with anybody,
because in my head, I just saw the story rolling out. It was like,
we were going to tell the story, and then at the end you saw the real guy. And that
I just couldn't get away from that story. And in the absence of the real guy,
the next best thing was a fake guy. Oh, well, the deceased Thomas
Jones will never know. And anybody that sees the movie, it's going to be so great,
and they're going to be crying and laughing at the end of it that they won't care.
For this role, there was no casting, no auditions. In fact, the part of Thomas E.
Jones wasn't played by an actor at all. He was actually a tour guide at the Truman Little White
House. Quincy had asked a work friend from the museum to do the job.
And then the real Thomas Jones found me. And I certainly remember that feeling.
It was like a disgust I felt for myself.
In the aftermath, Quincy left the film world for many years. He was fired from his job at
the Truman Museum. He eventually found work clerking in a bookstore and making wedding videos.
While this was the first time a lie of Quincy's had been so brutally exposed,
he admits that the lying itself was something he'd been leaning on since his teen years.
You know, I had come from a fairly poor family in Key West, and I had attended a
very exclusive prep school up in Western Massachusetts called Deerfield Academy,
where I had no business being there. And so I felt this, like, sense of just, like,
always needing to exaggerate. It would be like, "Oh, I'm going to Paris for one of my movies."
And I'd be like, "Oh, gosh, you know, Paris is great." You know, I didn't even know what country
it was in. It was like a daily thing. Freshman year, someone had a picture of Jimi Hendrix,
a poster. And I remember looking at his name and thinking it looked kind of French. And I was like,
"Oh, I love Jai Mai Hendrai." And I remember him looking at me and being like, "What?"
For Quincy, lies became a beautiful,
beautiful wall between himself and everyone else. Lies protected him, but also isolated him.
It took the collapse of the messenger to finally get him to stop.
And it was actually very relieving, because it took a lot of weight off my shoulders,
that I didn't have to make every story 10 percent better. I didn't have to just — as
hard as that was, that was the most important lesson, full stop, period of my life.
After we did the messenger, I didn't take that as anything that stopped me.
When Quincy is done sharing the effects the messenger had on his life,
Michael shares the role it played for him.
Seeing the camera, seeing the crew, it blew my mind. I didn't know that this was
possible. I didn't know that this is what it looked like. And I was in.
It's Quincy and the messenger that inspired Michael's career.
But it isn't just that Quincy gave him a professional life. He gave him a life.
I married this beautiful person who, she's a movie producer, and we have this
amazing kid called Carson, who's two and a half years old. And all of this life that I have,
this partner, this career, this kid, it comes from this wild, weird, random moment
in Cleveland, Ohio, where you decided to cast me in this short film. And it's all this to say,
like, I never got to just thank you. I've always appreciated that door that you showed to me
and allowed me to walk through. That moment, that time, that invitation that you gave me to be on set
changed the entire direction of my life.
That means a lot to me.
I look back on that time and totally with totally different eyes.
It was one of the most difficult things in my life. And I can't tell you like how
meaningful it is to me to hear that someone had something good come out of it,
because it certainly didn't feel like that. I was convinced that it would ruin everyone's life.
Because that's what I was feeling at that moment.
Quincy just assumed anyone involved with The Messenger would still be furious with him.
And so a few weeks back, when he saw Pat Croce's name pop up on his phone,
he says he almost felt too scared to pick up. But when they spoke,
instead of yelling at him, Pat told him it was time to let it go.
As soon as he said those words, "Let it go," I sat out in front of my house and cried for a good 20 minutes.
I didn't know before we talked today actually genuinely what you were
going to say today? You know, I met you as this person I looked up to. You're going to make me
cry. I'm really, really genuinely happy for you. Thank you for taking time just to talk to me, but
really thank you for the life I got to have because of it.
Recently, I got to share in that life. One day leaving our New York studio, Michael says he's
off to meet his wife Katie. Her crew is filming just a few blocks away, and Michael asks if I'd
like to come, and I say sure.
On the corner of 20th Street and 7th Avenue, shooting is in full swing. The movie stars John
as an aging pickpocket who ends up with a thumb drive containing a crypto wallet on it. Michael and
I are waved past the protected perimeter, and Katie gives me a pair of small headphones. As I
watch take after take of John Turturro slamming down a payphone and screaming fuck in fake fury,
I feel like a 10-year-old on a field trip. All around us, the city bustles as normal,
while we're tucked away in our make-believe world, watching make-believe things.
It's all a lie, of course, but one that we're all in on.
And action!
Now that the furniture's returning to its goodwill home.
Now that the last month's rent is scheming with the damage deposit. Take this moment to decide
if we meant it, if we tried.
So long, man.
This episode of Heavyweight was produced by Kalila Holt and me, Jonathan Goldstein,
along with Mohini McGowker and Phoebe Flanagan. Our supervising producer is Stevie Lane.
Editorial guidance from Emily Condon. Special thanks to Lucy Sullivan, Karen Shikurji,
and Nazanin Rafsanjani.
Our production counsel is Jake Flanagan.
Emma Munger mixed the episode with original music by Christine Fellows, John K. Sampson, and Bobby Lord.
Additional scoring by Blue Dot Sessions, Bobble, Principal, and Shanghai Restoration Project.
Our theme song is by The Weaker Thans, courtesy of Epitaph Records.
Follow us on Instagram at heavyweightpodcast or email us at heavyweight at pushkin.fm.
We'll be back next week with a new episode.
We'll be right back.
It's a legacy.
At American Military University, that legacy can help open new doors through education.
Whether you're leading a big project, planning an elaborate trip,
or trying to balance work and life,
ChatGPT can help.
Give it a goal, plus things like files, notes, or project plans,
develop a trip itinerary with daily updates,
or create a prioritized schedule,
so you can spend less energy sorting out the details
and more on bringing your biggest ideas to life.
Get started at ChatGPT.com.
This is an iHeart Podcast.
Guaranteed human.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Michael, a young man from Cleveland, was cast in a short film called *The Messenger*, based on a true World War II story, after a heartfelt audition where he was chosen as the perfect match for the character of Thomas E. Jones.
Director Quincy, inspired by a single sentence in a book, wanted to include an interview with the real Thomas E. Jones, but when he couldn’t find him, he fabricated a story using a man with a matching death certificate, leading to a major ethical failure.
The film gained massive media attention, but when the truth about the fake Thomas emerged, the real family was outraged, and the movie was pulled from release, leaving Michael devastated and questioning his career path.
Quincy admitted he had a long history of lying, stemming from a sense of insecurity and a need to appear more successful from a poor background, and the lie in *The Messenger* was a culmination of that pattern.
After years of silence, Pat Croce, the film’s executive producer, reached out to Quincy, and the truth about the lie came to light, with Quincy expressing deep regret and a painful realization of his actions.
The experience profoundly shaped both Michael and Quincy
Michael and Quincy eventually spoke again after years, and the conversation revealed how the film, though a failure, became a turning point for both men—offering redemption and personal growth.
The story highlights how a single moment of opportunity, even when flawed, can change lives, and how truth and accountability ultimately heal both personal and professional wounds.
Summary:
The story of *The Messenger* centers on a short film based on a real World War II anecdote where a teenager, Thomas E. , but was delayed by a U-turn. Michael, a young actor from Cleveland, was cast in the role after an audition where he resonated with the character.
Director Quincy, inspired by a brief mention in a book, sought to include a real interview with Thomas Jones but found him deceased. Instead, he hired a man with a similar death certificate and staged a fake interview, leading to a major ethical failure. The film gained widespread attention, but when the deception was exposed, the real Thomas Jones’s family was outraged, and the movie was canceled.
Michael was devastated, but the experience ignited his passion for filmmaking, leading him to a successful career in TV. Quincy, meanwhile, struggled with guilt and spent years hiding from the fallout, admitting he had a lifelong pattern of lying to compensate for his insecurities. After years, he reconciled with his past, and a heartfelt conversation with Michael revealed how the film, despite its failure, became a catalyst for personal growth.
The story illustrates how a flawed moment of opportunity can lead to lasting change, emphasizing the power of truth, accountability, and redemption in shaping lives. It also underscores the profound impact of a single decision—whether born from ambition, ego, or need—on the trajectory of one’s life.
FAQs
Quincy believed the real Thomas E. Jones was deceased based on death certificates and wanted to include a real interview for dramatic effect. When he couldn't find the man, he created a fake character to maintain the story's authenticity and emotional impact.
The real Thomas E. Jones was alive and his family discovered the lie. They were outraged by the fictional portrayal of him as a slacker who delayed the end of WWII with a pancake breakfast. The film was pulled to avoid damaging the family's reputation.
The experience inspired Michael to pursue acting, leading him to a career in television writing for Disney and Nickelodeon. He credits the film as the pivotal moment that changed his life and gave him confidence in his creative abilities.
Pat Croce said he was furious when he discovered the lie and lost trust in Quincy. He also admitted that he had hoped to cover the film’s success with media appearances, but the scandal damaged his reputation and relationships.
Quincy had a long history of lying since childhood, using exaggerations as a way to fit in at a prestigious school. He believed the lie would be a harmless, creative choice that would still serve the story emotionally.
The film’s success made Quincy a public figure, but the exposure of the lie caused deep regret and emotional pain. He admitted it took years to accept that he had failed everyone involved and damaged their trust.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.