Go back

50 Years of U2, Here's What They're Really Like

1h 20s

50 Years of U2, Here's What They're Really Like

The podcast explores the deep roots of U2’s music, tracing its evolution from punk rock influences to global spiritual and cultural experiences. The band credits early exposure to the Ramones, post-punk New York scenes, and international rhythms—especially from carnival traditions in Rio and Tenerife—as foundational to their sound and philosophy. Central themes like love, mortality, and rebellion are woven through songs such as "The Greatest Show on Earth" and "Beautiful Day," often sparked by personal moments like a 18th birthday or a visit to a church in Ireland. These experiences reveal a profound spiritual sensibility, where music becomes a path to connection, emotional honesty, and cultural exploration. Live performances are presented not as polished displays, but as defiant, communal celebrations of joy and spontaneity—each show unique and evolving with audience interaction. The band emphasizes that creativity is an ongoing journey, not a destination, rooted in humility, failure, and the courage to keep creating. They reject the idea of musical perfection, instead embracing authenticity, improvisation, and the belief that true art emerges through struggle and open-ended exploration. This mindset reflects not only their musical identity but their enduring connection to global traditions, personal growth, and the human desire for meaning.

Transcription

8616 Words, 45066 Characters

English
So what's it like being vinyl? Well, it's gone to his hair, but that's where the grand madness starts, the edge. And you need a bit of grand madness, if you want to make some madly grand tunes. So what is your favorite the edge guitar solo? I really like the one on another time and other place on our album boy. That's great. Larry, what's your favorite the edge guitar solo? Um, there are so many, it will be very difficult for me to choose one, but I get it. Yeah. Okay, thank you for trying. That's a show. That's a show. That's our coming guys. Welcome to Trackstar HQ, and the Trackstar podcast is a pleasure to have you guys here. Downtown New York City, we're proud of those wild. There goes wild. So the premise of this show is we just listen to music and we talk about it. And so I came up with a handful of songs that I wanted to play for you all, a couple of your songs, a couple other songs. And I was thinking, you know, what would be a good place to start? And I thought of this. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Can you hear the drums? If you can't, did it, did it, did it? You don't deserve it. To live, I've searched over, wow, it's an overpowering feeling for me because there are two schools of approach to music, we might call the European and the American. And if we were being really simplistic, and I represent the sort of pop discipline that comes out of, comes out of fear then, and then, and yeah, Northern Europe, and it's so precise, it's so, but in that, those songs are perfectly constructed, there is a beautiful ache, and that you can't really construct. It comes out of the sadness and the voice coming, you know, those two girls are incredible, and those composers, there's nothing like them. And I'm comfortable enough as an Irish male now to say that. Okay, Jack. Was it number one song in Ireland in 1976? Makes sense. I mean, they will play a head of Fleetwood Mac in terms of relationships, I have to say. Is that what they wrote the book on, interband relationships, yeah, they all married each other in Aber. This is the same thing. But all bands are like a marriage act. Don't we know that? It's sort of do. But what their journey is about because it's about saying that there's something in argue about the melodies and stuff, it's absolutely top level. But they were like the preserve of, you know, girls' nights out and like a pop world, and it took a while for the so-called Cognacenti of music to understand just how brilliant they were. And there's a couple of bands that took us a while to tune into them, and I have to say the Bee Gees. Yeah. Absolutely brilliant, but not necessarily cool for a prepared song. They are beyond cool. So are you the edge? Best Apple Guitar solo. Fernando. SOS. That's the worst. It's pretty great too. So, what would you have been listening to when this song was taking over the radio waves? Larry Mullen, Jr. What was on your mind in 1976 when you heard this song? So, I was in a kind of a transition period for music. So I loved Bolly, I liked Daba, but I was a glam rock, not. And there was this murmuring of punk, and I'd heard God save the Queen, and on the radio. God save the Queen, the fascist regime. It was uncomfortable for my parents in the kitchen, so I knew I was on the right track. So, that's where I went, and then it was there, you know, clash, the jam. What I always went back to glam rock. It's just it's in my jeans. I mean, there would have been a bit of Thin Lizzy in there. Yeah, I was going to say, live and dangerous, it's a big live album at that point of Thin Lizzy. Maybe anyone remembers Slade? Oh yeah. Yeah. A bit of Slade going on. Right. All remembers Slade, Oasis, you can't be, they can't be Oasis without Slade, don't you think? Bloxy. ♪ Make me a deal and make it spring ♪ Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. ♪ I take you to the moment that we are true ♪ It needs to develop a fringe, yeah, yeah, good. It just grabs you. Come on. Yeah. That does not start the line, we all going down to Rio. I think it might do. Yeah. And if you think about them coming from Huddersfield, however they came from, the Northern England, it's, it's, it is a perfect case for how to make up with your songwriting, the world that you wish to occupy. Yeah. Maybe this all over, I suppose Nile Rogers is the best example of it. He wasn't having good times, he wrote good times. He didn't, the family wasn't really happening, he wrote, we are family. It's the thing where you feel the songwriter, Brian Ferry, one of the great lyricists of the age, Roxy Music, one of the great artists, I mean bands of the age, featuring Brian Eano in that case, on dilly, dilly, dilly, dilly, and and they invented a, a world as, first of it was a sonic universe and, and eventually they, they occupied it and people did it with others like them, as was in New York, the Velvet Underground did the same. It is a sort of dream of the kind of world you want to live in, business that were in Jack. The choice of instruments, the sort of Baroque influences, like this obos and mad stuff, which they probably got from the Rolling Stones when they were doing Ruby Tuesday and all these kind of exotic orchestral instruments. But it's the refusing to say in your lane, you know, we are a guitar band, but we can use the other obos we want. Did you guys have this idea of traveling somewhere else through the music? On the astral plane. On the astral plane music. Or you mean geographically? I mean, geographically, I mean, I mean, I mean, like, well, like you talked about going down to real, but not actually going, do you have this idea in your head that you could travel through the song? I think you have to remember what we came from in 1976 was Ireland was coming out of such an incredibly conservative period. And Rock and Roll and TV were like these two little keyholes to look at the rest of the world through. So, absolutely, for our generation, we saw the world through television movies and music. And that gave us a sense of travel was everything. Over there. Travel. First of all, you travel there in the songs that you listen to and then you actually join a band and you get to go to those places, those mythical places. And if they're mythical from music, they're usually on rivers, the Mississippi, Liverpool, the Thames, the Sen, you know, all over the world. And we were just talking the other day about discovering London and myself and Larry ended at a U2 show in the Marquis Club, we used to play Monday nights and we did four Monday nights. There was 40 people there the first night and then, you know, that old story. And I remember we got out through the crowd, we walked through the crowd and walked out the door, just got into a taxi. Actually, no, before we got into the taxi, we just walked around. What was the area called? It's Soho. Soho. Soho. And we'd never seen those kinds of things. We'd never seen a red light area. We didn't want to see it, but we were curious, that kind of things. Just exploration and even now, to travel, to tour. I don't think I've ever woken up, I must have, but that would be an hangover or a headache or something, but I've never woken up thinking, this is not a city I want to be in, you know, there's no flyover country here in the United States. We've traveled through them in buses, but waking up in Madrid, waking up in Barcelona, waking up in Lisbon. These are incredible cities and we get to go there. We get to stay in nice hotels, I mean, it didn't always, but you do hate a winging rock stars, don't you Jack? I think the thing is though, if you teach a box that says the musician, I think you have to be prepared to travel, you know, that's part of it. I guess part of what I'm getting at is like it's infused, the idea was there before you went anywhere, and then it's been infused in the music throughout. I mean, the idea of what is carnival, what is the idea of a carnival, that's this thing that doesn't necessarily. necessarily come from where you guys grew up, that comes from a world you've been exposed to. - It's funny thing happened to us when we, we're making our first album, boy, we pictured ourselves in London, we pictured ourselves in New York, particularly, and then we suddenly were in New York, and we were in London. And as Bonnet says, we're like in Barcelona, we're in Berlin, wherever Europe. And we got back to Ireland to start our second album, and that's when we got fascinated with Irish music. It was almost like we had to leave the country to find an interest in what was happening, actually around us growing up. So we had the island pipes with Vinny Kildoff on the song tomorrow, and we made a much more Irish-centric record having been away. ♪ Once you come back tomorrow ♪ ♪ Once you be back tomorrow ♪ - But on the subject of Carnival, the first Carnival we explored was Santa Cruz, in Tenerife, we did a session there for "Acting Baby," and we had thought about it as the cover of "Acting Baby," so that's a while ago. And then I remember going to Sanba School in Rio, did we? - Yeah, yeah, in Rio. - We had them on stage with us. - And that feeling of these people really know how to be in their bodies. And as Irish people, we thought we could learn from this. And there was just, they were, you know, we can be in mosh pits, and we are a dance, a vertical sort of dance, you know, in punk rock. It's that way, right? But this swaying, and this moving, this rhythm, and you had had, Larry, you had had experience with the marching band. So it kind of made more sense to you, is that right? - Yeah, I mean, all those things, all those rhythms, they come from one place, and it's there. Everything stems from Sanba and those African beats. So everything we learn, and we spend, drummers spend their lives trying to knock it into shape, but the reality is, is that it's the looseness. It's the ability to be behind on top, and in front of the beat, that makes that so easy to move to. But we have spent rock 'n' roll people, I've spent a lot of time trying to tighten it off too much. - A very first rock 'n' roll beat, ba, ba, ba, ba, the bow-diddley beat. That's Cuban. (upbeat music) - And that's from this. So you have to kind of, I mean, rock 'n' roll stands music. I mean, rock eventually at some point, including with you two, I might add, lost the role. By the way, is this a sitcom? 'Cause there's a bit of a friends vibe going on, and I like friends, people watch it all the time in our house. - Yeah, there was a lot to learn from it, and it was one of the thrills of, yeah, being tourists, you know, is that people want to explain their country to you. It's a beautiful thing, you meet other writers, you know, singers, poets, you stay up late with them, and then you have to try, you have to try and explain where you come from to them, and if you're Irish, tricky. I just, I get the sense that it's like, it's there, and as you guys move on your career and discover more and write more songs, you realize that all this information about the world is in the songs already, it's in the music that you've been listening to your whole life. (upbeat music) - Let's go for a big, a little head of a little behind. (laughing) (upbeat music) (laughing) ♪ From day, morning, 18 years, I've done it ♪ ♪ I said how long, I said how long ♪ ♪ Those ones don't run in the world ♪ ♪ With boy, they were so sad, quite ♪ (laughing) ♪ I was so sad ♪ (upbeat music) ♪ And the Ramones ♪ ♪ Oh, oh, oh ♪ - All right, that, yeah, I specifically wanted to ask about that. - 18, birthday. - What you said? - On my 18th birthday, I began that, and I've told this story a few times, so many times that I wondered if it was true. - Yeah. - And edge, please finish this. - Yeah, yeah. But as I was upset, yeah, yeah, that song started that. There we come, my 18th birthday. So about, maybe it's about eight years ago, myself and my brother and sister are going to the parents' house. They've, my dad had recently passed, and so we had to do that thing we all do. The house was coming up for sales, we're going through the house. I opened this drawer in their bedroom, and noticed a pile of YouTube press cuttings and magazine cuttings dating back years. So I was going through them. It's like, wow, this is amazing. Then at the very bottom of the drawer, I found a diary from 1978. And I'm like, wow, that's weird. I don't remember a diary. I opened it up. - This bomb was writing. - It's my diary. - It was bomb was diary from '70, and I went to the page of his birthday, and there was the out of control lyric. Basically, you know, it dares, this little punk rock song dares to ask the big questions, you know, about how the two most profound moments of your life being born and exiting the world, you very little say over, often. And there was the 18, that was on my mind. What was on your mind, Jack, at 18? Are you still 18? - Probably, probably sex. (laughing) Probably the difficult stuff. - The third most important thing, but you do have some volition. - Well, it's connected to the other two, yes, it is, in some ways. - Actually, it really is, sex and death, particularly. - You mentioned the Ramones just playing that, you mentioned the time being in front and behind, a little bit. - Well, that was our first sign goal. And I don't think, well, we'd been in a studio, maybe two or three times before doing that. But, you know, in those days, you had like a studio for three hours, and you had to do everything in that time. So, you know, timing wasn't something that I was particularly good at, but I think all of us had issues with playing in time. - It was very good game. But it was before we started to use click trucks. So, there was a lot of excitement, but a giddy up, I think. So, it is humbling to hear. - Playing in time is overracing. - I think so, I think so. That's kind of what I'm asking about. There's this looseness to the Ramones. I don't know, like, were you listening to the Ramones? Is that a. - We wouldn't exist without the Ramones. Our band would not exist without the Ramones, and I think that might be some people out there that wish the Ramones, therefore, had not existed. In fact, on hearing the Joey Ramone passed away, listening to a song of ours called "In A Little While", it's a beautiful, slightly inebriated gospel song. ♪ Slow down my being far away ♪ - We heard this from his brother. There were some commentators who said, typically, you two killed Joey Ramone, but the Ramones birthed you to, because it was the first time the imagination was not limited by an education. So, the more original the thought, the better chance of it surviving. If it didn't depend on a level of musical sophistication, you know, if you just had three chords on the track, as we say, you know, as a surrealist anthem, three chords and the truth was the old joke, in not joke, but trope in punk rock, you know? Just what do you have to say? And is it original, is it interesting? And the fact that you couldn't play in time or the fact that you were just discovering each other and music, all the better, in hip hop. There was another, that was the same thing. Hip hop was a revolution because suddenly, people would use sample grooves, sample eight. So suddenly this imagination just blew open. The doors just blew off the minds of kids and around them, across the road here, you know? And, but punk rock was it for us, and the Ramones were it for us. [BLANK_AUDIO] and and and. Lest you not be suspicious of the most suspicious word of the more authentic, it is worth remembering that the Ramones were designed in part by a friend of theirs, Vega, and he did all their t-shirts, he drew them the names, Didi Ramone, Tommy Ramone, Joey Ramone, Johnny Ramone, and that t-shirt I think is the best sounding t-shirt on earth, so they were designed and we should be shocked or they didn't meet in a high school like you too. No, this is great art is sometimes designed, sometimes it's accidental like with you too, but sometimes it's designed, I'll take it from anywhere as long as it's great. They also saw themselves as a pop group, meaning that they really wanted to have a hit. They said if we just get tight enough, we'll have a hit song. They kind of, I guess they didn't realize how unique and quirky they were, so they did a cover of Let's Dance, which we heard in Dublin and we thought it was amazing. We at first didn't realize it wasn't their song, but absolutely brilliant, and that's what we learned. Let's Dance, first time, that was the first Ramone song. Yeah, I wanted to ask about the pop thing, like you're trying to make a song like "Growse People" that has a hook in it too. Yeah, I mean we were looking a lot to the American sort of explosion that was coming out of CBGBs and out of New York, so Blondie were a part of that. They were a very pop band. I mean we didn't realize it maybe until they started to have those big hits, harder glass, and that sort of thing. Another band we loved was Television. They were particularly poppy, and then Talking Heads came along. So there was a lot of American music that we were interested in. Isn't it wild how all those groups are grouped together, but they are so different. Like this idea, like what's punk rock? Well it can be it sonically, it can be anything. It can be all these things that I guess they get grouped together because they play in the same place all the time. Well you know there was there was probably like 500 bands originally, and they're like 10 bands that people remember. Doesn't it really make the same point that they were just dreaming of their own sound and their own, they had a vision of what they could be, and David Byrne an extraordinary lyricist. He doesn't want to play like the Ramones. He doesn't want to play kind of hardcore punk. For him, punk is taking a position that you know others wouldn't dare to take, and I remember the arriving in the punk scene in London and they had cameras on around their neck, and they were all playing American tourists in London, and people were interviewing them. They were taking you know they were taking photographs of them, and that's it's seditious in a different way. It's radical in a different way, and that's probably what it is. Why so when Debbie Harris says I want to be a pop icon, Andy Warhol will paint me, which he did, and this was this was unthinkable at the time that people could actually follow their vision of what pop is to its conclusion. I want to say I'm not going to rock right, and at the same, at the same time Disco was happening. Disco? Yeah. Disco, hip hop, all these things happening at the same time. Yeah, so you had Nile Rogers, because he couldn't get into studio 54, saying fuck off and calling it free count. I want to have you guys, like, I want to play that song, and then this song back to back. How does it, just hearing the back to back, do you hear it more different or more the same? I think it's just getting a bit better as playing together, but the same intention is trying to come up with something that we've never heard before. That's the hallmark of a lot of the punk bands. If punk had ripped it all down, it's like, well, what's next? We've got to dream it up. We've got to find something worth doing now that's different to what came before that. We're still infected with that kind of mission to create music that people have never heard, certainly from us. I was thinking about all the bands who were our contemporaries, our bands that we looked up to, a lot of them, you know, remounts in particular, like there were talented musicians individually, even sex pistols, apart from Sid, but before Sid, like, great songwriting, really good players. I think for you too, we engaged in the spirit of punk and believed that anybody could try this and do this. I think what we didn't fully understand is that the people who were making this music really knew what they were doing, there was real intent. So there was a huge learning curve for us, and that's why we made, you know, out of control and we were excited about it and felt that we were participating in our musical dream. But even at the time, it would have been unusual to hear about play like that, and for it to be so raw, and then you move on to, you know, a great show, and of course we've changed on this click tracks and so forth. But as Edge says, the intent is the same, we're still trying to find our way through, and that's why you too, Sid exists. We never feel that we've found the right recipe. We're always looking for different ingredients and you ingredients and the cake is never baked the way that we want it to be. We're always looking for a slightly different flavor, and that's what drives us. So when I hear, I'm glad you're showing that I go, wow, we really could have done that or we could have made it like that. And I think we all kind of feel the same way. If we'd spent a little bit longer, it would have tasted a little better. We're more about the journey than reaching the destination. So a big part of the difference is just the experience, like how the world has changed how your life, the things you picked up along the way. Like you couldn't have made this song when you made it on control. You know, putting them back to back, you know, one song is about, you know, bono looking at life at age 18. And greatest show on earth is a man who's been around the world a bit and sees things differently. And I think that's in itself an interesting journey, no matter what changes have happened in the music, but certainly seems to be a lot of drive in the music. Love is a business that works at night. I saw myself for less than was right. You thought me when I was worth and the greatest show on earth made a profession out of breaking your heart. You call it lies, I call it art. I was some of your best work. Thought we were the greatest show on earth. Love is a business you shouldn't trust. Breathe on me and I'm love and I'm lust. Forever or a flirt. It's just the greatest show on earth. The light scatters things can get worse. These dark matters of the universe cannot compete with us. We were once the greatest show on earth. For me, the discovery of that incredible song by the righteous brothers, you lost that loving feeling. Was that it was not a lament? It was a proposal. Because whoever would hear that song, if they were walking away, would have to return. It's just that's in my hand. When the lovers in the greatest show on earth, you just know they're going to return to each other. Even though the greatest show on earth has a go in religion because it was originally called Cathedral and it was originally a hymn to a female form. It went through lots of guises. But strangely, this broken circus, the old neon. still flickering and fizzing, but only just became the most romantic image in the whole world. And the cathedral referred to, is this, is that a smile or a tear? Is it all show business here? Is this a church of love or fear? Have we made God feel like a stranger here? That notion is, is, of the cathedral and stained glass, the cinema of stained glass, which is referred to in the lyric, this is the grandness of our ambitions, our, our, you know, falling in love and getting married and, you know, this, this grand madness that you think two people think I'm going to take on the world and take on all the data and everything that tells them, you're not going to get through the world and saying we're going to. It's, it's so exciting. It's so, it's defiance. And in that sense, the character was 18. It's still singing that. But the code at the end, the rather dare I say it, "brechtian Korda." That's an end, love is a business that works at night. That's, that's the wisdom. But, you know, I want to be, you know, you want to be a man of the world, but not this one. Okay, Jack? We're back to Roxy, back to Roxy music, right? The Baroque influences, the orchestral influences, we love that. And you just get out of your lane and you just draw from other disciplines and other places. That's amazing. Yeah, that, that doesn't happen to you very much in your life. You get completely puzzled by an artist's choices. And I heard about him from my daughter, Jordan, who went to see the motormometer and then I watched it online, became a fan, the rather embarrassing bit. But our song dedicated to her, called Rosalia, is that she wasn't as well known when we wrote this. And she's just starting to become this, you know, phenomenon. So we start to look like four staged or Johnny's kind of waning outside. I like, I had to call her friends and say, like, please, we're not stalkers. I'm not a stalker, but we normally only write about dead people or people in prison. But we just, we've written this song about the reenchantment of the world. And because that's what she's about. And it's called a mirrormaker because some artists, they are content to look in the mirror. And if you look, it's good, no. If you, you know, certain men narcissism is okay for any writer of any kind. But and the world that's reflected behind you, the world, that's what we do in the mirror. The mirror is useful. But then there's the artists that want to go through the mirror. They want to see what's on the other side of the mirror, not just the physical, the metaphysical. And there is Rosalia. But the best question comes, I sing, Rosalia. And Edge goes, who are you? Who are you? Which is a football chant on the terraces. If you follow a soccer as they say around here. But who are you? It's like, who are you? Where did you come from? And it's, I mean, look, hot for God. What a thing. It's like, you know, in the Caribbean and places, people still dress up for church. Something beautiful about it. Look at the state of us. And I was in the church yesterday in, is this important? Can I tell you this? 20 years ago, I'm very big hangover, massive, I would say. And I woke up and in a room. And I was on my own and I was thinking, the fear is big time. And I called an assistant, beloved assistant, but she was new to the game. And I said, could you get a church? I just like to go to a church. And she said, okay, watch religion. And I said, I don't mind. I really don't mind anything. She said, that Catholic or Protestant, I know that I said, don't care. If you can get me a synagogue, anything, just, I don't mind. Wrong day. And I went around to this place. I'm the way around. She said, I'll take you around. I said, no, I'm fine. So I'll take you around, I went around. And I said, what? What religion did you go to? What did you find? And she said, it's Presbyterian. Because the Presbyterians can be in Northern Ireland in particular. They can be a little rough. So like, whoops. And anyway, I went around the corner and I see a big rainbow flag. And I see this beautiful black man with a Mohawk, who's plays the organ it turns at. And they walk in and they're saying, in Jesus loves me, this I know or something like that. I'm in tears. I can't believe it. And this guy, the Presbyterians don't have collars or things like that. And he comes out and he's talking about the golden calf. And he's like, wow, he's quite radical. Then he comes down and he says, how are you? I recognize you here. It's the sign of the peace, which is always an uncomfortable moment in the church service. And if you're neurotic. He goes, how did you hear about it? He said, you know, we pray about you. And I went, really? And they were members of the one campaign, very right on church, right? Very, very right on church. He said, but how did you find out about us? And I handed over to my assistant, Katrina, and she said, Google. It's just brilliant. And I was there. So I went back yesterday. And I go back sometimes. And actually, the Sunday, the little paper pamphlet had about the light, you know, and kind of a light, you know, I thought, wow, our advertising's got to them. No, they're advertising off from on high. And they were speaking about James Talleriko. Because he, too, was from that same progressive, sort of seminarian. I just thought, wow, what a, what a thing, you know? And why am I telling you this story? I really don't know. You were talking about Rosalia, was it? Yeah. Yeah. Sorry about that. I should just go and just have a little drink. Well, I mean, it did make me think it does seem like there's something happening, like spiritually, at least here, in the world, at least here. It seems like there's a return to a business or something. I think everybody's waking up to the fact that fundamentalism is a bad idea for any faith. And that's based on dogma, based on effectively giving up your own critical thinking to a group. So this group think, you don't have to think about anything ever again. You're just part of the group. Don't worry. That's bad. I think none of us really are connected to any formal, um, denominational faith, because I think we all have a very personal faith, which is, as I was saying, very, very much wrapped up in doubt. You know, I feel of myself being, I'm sort of agnostic half the week, because that's to be free to take on board the fact that it is mysterious. Faith wouldn't be faith if it was wrapped up in certainty, you know? So it has to be, I think if it's an honest exploration, it has to be uncertain. You can't prove any of it. So it has to be an exploration of the unknowable. If she didn't like the song, we could have, we had a couple of things, we could have either just dropped it, yeah, dropped the mirror maker from our album, or we could have said it's about Saint Rosalia, because there is a saint Rosalia. She knows a lot about saints, and that saint lived in Italy in like the fifth, fifth century or something in a cave named after a sparkling mortar. Cave called Saint-Saint-Pelgrino, just if you're interested in that type of thing, but I'm not joking. But anyway, that's, there is a saint Rosalia. I want to ask you guys about the, about touring, about the show, about the broke aspects of the shows that you put on. It's sort of what drives that. Well, the songs are always the boss. With this collection we have a very strong overarching idea which is carnival, which is an opportunity to be in your body to acknowledge. Wow, edge, you are such a master. This is gonna be good though, that was good. I'm really good. This is. I know what I'm sorry about my friend, I'm sorry about my friend. So we were saying it's this is a sitcom. That was part of that was the gag that we had planned before. So the show. Yes, well I think. It's so carnival, I mean that's. It's gonna be a celebration, it's. we're describing the intention behind the album and the tour is a kind of defiant joy because right now there's so much despondency. I've turned around a little bit by the midterm elections which everywhere around the world is so delighted about because it's like democracy is back but there's so much reason to be kind of concerned, anxious and we all get reminded about all of those reasons all the time. So you can't give in to that. You've got to find a way to reclaim your mood from that negativity and that's kind of what carnival is, you know carnival is that joyful moment before a time of reflection. We want to have the joyful moment. We think it's like a reset for us. We've got a great pair of curtains. We have, we may have the largest curtains on earth. It is there's some show business, there is some shamanism and it's magic. That's what we all want from a night. And speaking of church, you know for a lot of people going to a festival, a music festival is church and community for my miss is a huge thing, you know. People get to meet each other, stay up late, talk, some people, you know turn over tables, whatever, you know they get into fights and whatever, it's okay. You're so generous. So we want to create that space where people will come along and we get to, I mean this quite seriously, we get a shot at the best night of our life. That's the one punk thing that you can, you know, because obviously we're overfared, over-rewarded, over-regarded, all of that. And it's, you can so you can forget where we came from. But our commitment to our live shows is the same as it was when we were, we started out in that punk and post-punk scene. And we have, no one's ever dialed it in, we give it everything. And we're, and it can't just be Tuesday night in wherever. It's not even Friday night, it's like New Year's Eve every night. And that is psychotic, by the way. And it has some, you know, there are some psychological ramifications. It's, particularly on the singer, I'm just saying, trying to, trying to give yourself to that night. Every night is probably not healthy, but it's, that's what we do. And that's, that goes back to the very beginning. As does the idea of, you know, not having a shit seat in the house. That's why we did these big shows. Because why would you come to a stadium and be, you know, and these are, these are challenges as artists to make, to make that these concrete sarcophaguses on the ad-scarce of town into this other kind of cauldron of, of, of music and chemistry and excitement. Are there things that you guys do on stage that surprise each other? In regard to, musically? Yeah, normally it's, to do with what I'm doing. There's a place. Yeah, I'm going, oh god, did I actually do that? And, I'm trying to, I'm trying to repeat. Yeah. I can't really repeat what I did the night before, although I do spend years on tour trying to get it right. And never quite getting there. But yeah, every night, there's always something that happens musically between us, unexpected. And of course, we, we have, in the final, has a long history of leaving the stage and disappearing into the audience or onto a roof somewhere. So yeah, there are, there are always unexpected things. And audiences are never the same. Yeah. And they do unexpected things. And that's the fun. You all have, like, such iconic moments in, in some of these songs, do you ever find yourself playing, playing those thousands of times and saying, this is, this is just an instinct at this point, or this is, I'm just, it's part of me, or I'm still working on something new. Like, even Sunday, buddy, Sunday, it's, it's beginning. Is that something that's just so inside of you? Or is it something that every time you do it, it's like new again? At the audience reaction to it, it's quite, it's just so mind blowing. Yeah. Not a relatively simple part. Kind of half such a visceral effect on an audience. It changes the vibe in the room. So when you do it, and there is a sense of awe, like, wow, this, this, like, people really, like, connect with it, and it's like, um, at the beginning of where the streets have known, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, the whole atmosphere changes. These are things when they happen, even on multiple nights. Different audiences. It's a different sensation and a different thrill, but it is just thrilling to watch it. People can get you used to it. You know, you, you, I never want to get used to it. It's a conversation that you're having with the audience too. So whatever they say back to you, it's going to be different every time. And probably around the world, different parts, resonate with people differently. It's people who speak different languages are connecting and coming in. Some people play different set lists, very, you know, quite a variety. Bruce Springsteen, you never know what he's going to play. And that's, it brings with it a certain excitement. With you two, it's more like we, we will vary, quite a lot over a tour, but not like Bruce Wood. It's more, we have like, it's more like a reading, an actor reading a play. It can change the same words can change. I mean, singers, forgetting Frank Sinatra, if you listen to his version of my way when he was retiring, and then years later in his 70s on the duets album, which I was on with him. And in one, it's totally like defiant. I did it my way. It's like a boast. I did it my way. And in his 70s, late 70s, it's an apology. I did it my way. It's the same lyric. It's the same melody. It's even the same arrangement there. But that's what interpretive singing. So that's what the mood of a city can do to you or the mood of a crowd or your own mood. It's the reading of it. I'm sure that will happen with you guys on the next tour. There'll be songs that are discovered. That are four years old that you has a whole new meaning. At the beginning, especially now, we've been playing out these songs. We just played in the tape modern in London, songs from the Unforgettable Fire that we haven't played. They just meant something completely different now. So that's the that's the joy in a for us is to remake and reimagine these songs years later. I'm also excited about seeing the new songs. How they translate to a live context because we've had some big surprises over the years. Songs that we didn't really understand, they're potential and suddenly you start playing them live and you get you get in that context where you've got the audience right there. You suddenly understand. Like it's not like bad. You know, it was a song that we liked the time. It was made way through side two of Unforgettable Fire. But once it started, you know, we played it live. It really took on a whole new main again, gravitas. So I think we're gonna see that happen with the new album. I gotta ask you about this person. ♪ In my Tennessee mountain home ♪ ♪ Life is a piece of that ♪ Well, I mean, it's spiritual. Yeah, it's a thing you can't put your finger on. She can sure put her finger on you and you don't know what's going on. We, I think Larry was the real first fan of Country Music. We got to stalk Johnny Cash for a while. He used to come to Dublin and Ireland, to Ireland when he was not as famous in the United States after his sort of peak here in the '70s. We got to know him. These are characters that are immense and there is a whole blessing you can get from the sort of laying on of their hands and we never got to spend any time physically with it's Dolly Parton but we had phone calls with her and to sing with her on this album was extraordinary and then we could hear something in her voice that was just hard to explain and she was really literally singing for her life and that's what you've sensed. Somebody just, I mean, he was that expression don't we all the time, singing for you, singing like your life depends on it. And I don't think she even knew that it was her last vocal or if there was any melodrama like that but it was and her last vocal recorded was about her country and how it cut up she was about the people fighting at the kitchen tables about politics or whether somebody was queer or straight or you know all these arguments that split up families which are so dumb and she was you know nothing breaks some mother's heart more than a family at war that's the line she sings Dolly Parton who devoted politics all her life and this is her last song and that's got an eerie feeling as you say it was somewhat touched she was clearly her life was somewhat touched but we got touched by it too. So before we go we're going to go downstairs and reach going to talk individually and I'm going to quiz you on your music knowledge. One of them was very important part of the show but I want to show you this picture and ask what you think these guys would think about this new record you think they would be fans. I hope so I think they would be look at those guys exhibit one exhibit one exhibit two you guys recreated a version of this recently yeah yeah the hair what do you think Blurry yeah that brings uh where is this it's my temple comprehensive it's where we went to school together and we came back for a visit in 1978 and we got an opportunity to redo it on the same roof with some of the same equipment it was quite an interesting experience playing two and the students holding signs saying my mother was in class and I have to say I was really relieved that I was something like what I was in class with you yeah I was a relief to to have to connect I think um but you know the the generation separation generation is no longer defined by music the way it used to be yeah some people are more conservative at 17 and their music tastes than some 70 year old yeah it's I think that's why this gender things become so big it's because people are it's their only chance to define these my names how how you call me how you treat me this is important to me because yes we do like you know they're all in songs together and we do like Nirvana or Pearl Jam or something so the divisions now are not between whether you're you know you arrive at high school as elder statesmen you know that that's not the division the division is mentally if if students will pick up if you think you you think they're their professors and we know we're not their professors we're with we're the students and still so and I think that's a feeling they know they they just know and that's the thing the you two thing can never be never be be you know masters you know we're we're we're just we can't be school school school teachers um we can any wisdom we've cleaned from walking through the world we can put into our songs but we're hopeless cases you know Larry walks in here he wrecks the place you know Adam check out the the very expensive tracktop there um but you know we we're never we're never going to be before and after cases like look this is what you can this you know it's we're we're all about what we haven't done rather than what we have I think probably it comes through it comes through and it's it's born out in the sustained success you've had at the incredible art that's come out over so many different periods some people say oh it's not it's impossible to do it again and again and again there's a new batch of songs that are just as good if not better than the ones that came before it's it's a humiliation I think involved sometimes in in art and the pursuit of great art is how much do you want it and I prepared for the humiliation that it often asks of you because if you're you know you know you're big shots why would you bother why would you bother walking into a studio with your mates and your mates you sing your art out and they go hurry up before bonner sends or whatever you know it or me them um that hasn't happened on this album so far I just want to say it's like you get there's no reason other than the music yeah you you guys to do it yeah there's no reason and but it requires that stooping do you know in the scriptures there's a there's a line it says about the it's harder for enrichment to enter into the kingdom of heaven than it is for a camel to go through the i of a needle that's worried me for some time um and I just recently discovered that the i of a needle was in the city walls when the when the gates are closed and the city walls traders the the big shots of their time the the the billionaires of their time you know that they would have the gates be closed they couldn't open them for fear of you know marauders and being attacked the city been attacked they have to get off their camels and they'd have to take unpack all their fancy stuff and they have to crawl through the eye of the needle and and some people I guess found that very hard you know very very difficult for age Adam and Larry but um just joking um but it's it's a you know that that's the you know that's it's not it's not humiliation it's just humanity is being comfortable with failure and that's okay because I think this is a great quote I think it's certainly said that success is going from one failure to the next without any diminishing of your enthusiasm just just keep going just keep going and don't give up on what you know you want to attain and you'll get there but you have to be comfortable with failure and Larry said something earlier about you know we we back then we didn't know what we're doing I don't think we we don't know what we're doing at all that's fine as long as you know what you want to hear but the actual approach is is always made up we're continuing with out of our depth and comfortable comfortable out of our depth well I think for for us as well when we when we do achieve something we're as surprised as anybody else we manage to do yeah we put the rabbits up the sleeves we put the thing in the hat and then when the rabbit jumps out we're like wow and you might say but you put the rabbit in there it's it's only the real magicians are surprised thank you guys thank you thank you thank you The drag star podcast is a presentation of Public Opinion created by me Jack Coyne, Kieran Coyne, and Henry Coynaros, produced by Haley Sobel, edited by Ryan Durgans, theme and original composition by Kieran Coyne, mixing by Devon Coyne. Our agent is Joanne Orland at UTA. Thanks for listening. See you next Wednesday.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The band draws inspiration from global music cultures, including carnival traditions in Rio and Tenerife, which shape their sense of movement, rhythm, and spiritual connection.
  2. Early influences like the Ramones and post-punk bands in New York (e.g., Blondie, Television) shaped U2’s raw, unpolished sound and belief in musical originality and accessibility.
  3. The song "Beautiful Day" and "The Greatest Show on Earth" reflect personal and universal themes of love, mortality, and spiritual awakening rooted in youthful experience.
  4. Live performances are seen as acts of defiant joy and communal celebration, offering audiences a reset from global despondency and creating unique, evolving musical moments.
  5. The band’s music evolves over time—reimagined with new emotional depth and meaning—showing a commitment to continuous artistic growth and improvisation.
  6. The integration of diverse musical elements (Baroque, country, gospel) reflects a refusal to be confined by genre, embracing cross-cultural and spiritual exploration.
  7. Personal experiences, such as a visit to a church in Ireland, reveal a deep, evolving spiritual awareness that informs their music and worldview.
  8. Success is not defined by perfection but by the courage to fail, remain humble, and continue creating with passion and authenticity.

Summary:

The podcast explores the deep roots of U2’s music, tracing its evolution from punk rock influences to global spiritual and cultural experiences. The band credits early exposure to the Ramones, post-punk New York scenes, and international rhythms—especially from carnival traditions in Rio and Tenerife—as foundational to their sound and philosophy. Central themes like love, mortality, and rebellion are woven through songs such as "The Greatest Show on Earth" and "Beautiful Day," often sparked by personal moments like a 18th birthday or a visit to a church in Ireland.

These experiences reveal a profound spiritual sensibility, where music becomes a path to connection, emotional honesty, and cultural exploration. Live performances are presented not as polished displays, but as defiant, communal celebrations of joy and spontaneity—each show unique and evolving with audience interaction. The band emphasizes that creativity is an ongoing journey, not a destination, rooted in humility, failure, and the courage to keep creating.

They reject the idea of musical perfection, instead embracing authenticity, improvisation, and the belief that true art emerges through struggle and open-ended exploration. This mindset reflects not only their musical identity but their enduring connection to global traditions, personal growth, and the human desire for meaning.

FAQs

The song was inspired by a moment of personal reflection at age 18, blending themes of love, mortality, and the desire to live boldly. It also draws from the idea of carnival as a joyful, defiant celebration in a world filled with despondency.

The Ramones were a foundational influence on U2, especially in their early years. U2 credits them with pioneering punk rock's raw energy, simplicity, and the belief that music could be original and unpolished, which shaped U2's own approach to songwriting and performance.

The song explores the complex, sometimes contradictory nature of love and relationships, portraying love as both a romantic ideal and a risky, emotional transaction. It reflects on how love can be both a source of joy and a form of struggle.

U2 draws from diverse styles, including Baroque orchestration, American pop, and global rhythms. This blending of influences allows them to create music that feels expansive and emotionally rich, defying traditional genre boundaries.

Their live shows are intentionally unscripted and emotionally intense, with unexpected musical moments and audience interactions. This spontaneity keeps each performance fresh and connects deeply with the audience, reflecting the band's belief in music as a living, evolving experience.

Working with Johnny Cash and Dolly Parton introduced U2 to the raw emotional power of storytelling in country music. Dolly Parton’s final song, in particular, deeply moved them and influenced their understanding of music as a vehicle for personal and societal truth.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.