The podcast challenges the validity of General Physical Preparation (GPP) as a training philosophy. It argues that periodized blocks of GPP are physiologically unfounded—adaptations vanish when training stops, and athletes regress to the effects of recent workouts. Work capacity is misinterpreted; true endurance gains come from cardiovascular adaptations, not from doing more in a session. Many GPP workouts—like farmer’s walks or slow eccentrics—are ineffective, poorly targeted, and fail to transfer to sport-specific performance. Coaches often design overly complex or intense sessions that appear effective but are actually flawed, leading to fatigue and poor results. Coordination and body awareness do not transfer from general exercises to sport-specific activities, as shown by examples like skateboarding and surfing. Long slow cardio is superior to high-intensity intervals for building endurance, offering better physiological benefits and lower mental cost. The podcast concludes that GPP is redundant and can be replaced by a consistent strength training program twice a week, combined with moderate cardio—preferably long slow cardio. This approach is evidence-based, practical, and aligned with how the body adapts. The idea of GPP persists due to coaching misconceptions, not physiology, and is best discarded in favor of simpler, more effective training.
Hello, and welcome to the high performance physiology podcast. I'm Chris Beatsy, I'm
here with my co-host Rob Mauseri, and we're going to talk about GPP, general physical
preparation today. So this is, I'm not going to do a physiology introduction because there's
nothing to really introduce. It's a training philosophy concept rather than a kind of physiology
or sort of something that we would more normally talk about. We have a lot of questions about
this, so we're going to cover it and basically it's going to be more of a conversation. So
Rob Mauseri is going to talk about this and see where it goes. Notice that the software
we're using is making sort of a difference today because the video is popping up in a strange
place. I keep looking for more people to agree to make sure everything's working properly.
Hopefully that won't distract me too much. Anyway, so basically then general physical
preparation, what we're going to do is we're just going to talk about three separate concepts.
We're going to talk about the periodization aspect of it, which is kind of this idea that
you would have blocks, so you would do a block of general physical preparation, and then
you would have a block of special physical preparation, and then you would perhaps end up
doing sports, more sports, specific stuff, even more sports, so we could talk at the
end. It's about that as a periodization idea. Secondly, what we'll do is we will move
on and talk about work capacity because that is often described as being the main purpose
of general physical preparation blocks, or even workouts if they're doing them concurrently
with other training types. And then finally, we'll actually talk about the GP as a concept
whether it is even valid, and if it's not just superfluous, if we're not just saying
something we're doing already. So, periodization side of things. Basically, what we're going
to talk about here is where people do a program, a general physical preparation block, and then
they go on after that and start moving the athletes training in the direction of the actual
sport that they're going to do. We've talked about periodization before. It really makes
very, very little sense to do this block periodization is just lunacy because what happens
is the athlete just ends up losing all the adaptions that you got for them in that general
block and they end up just getting whatever adaptions they've got from the follow-up
blocks at the point. Whenever you test them, whenever you test them they're going to have
the adaptions from the last few weeks, if you did something different month or two prior
to that, almost none of that is really going to show up. So, we've talked about this
before. Do you have anything to add rope or are you kind of like just, yeah, whatever?
We've talked about periodization plenty of times on the podcast and then, yeah, in terms
of the GPP side of things. Like you said, just like anything else. If you do a GPP block
and you do, you know, kind of like you're relating to specific exercises and then remove
them, you know, whatever that exercise is doing, whether it's hypertrophy of an area,
whether it's, you know, strength, whatever it is, you take it out and switch it for something
else, you're just going to lose it. If you're doing, you know, I'm going to add a cardio
and then you just remove that. Yeah, it's not really going to stick around too long. If
you're doing speed work and then, you know, remove it for too long or most of the time
you would have no speed work and then add it later, you know, just get towards a sports
specific thing. Yeah, then if you have it out for your whole GPP block and you do a bunch
of kind of the typical things, you know, higher reps, timed rest periods, all that stuff,
you know, maybe going to failure or doing, you know, silly things, past failure, you
know, you might spend six, eight weeks, whatever it is, get quite a bit slower and fatigued
and then, sure, you add back in that speed work at the end of the GPP block and then all
of a sudden things don't shooting up and you're like, oh, yeah, that really prepared me.
That made it so that I can have all these increases. No, you probably just got really
fatigued during a bad GPP block and then now you're in a little less fatigued and you finally
have some work that's actually doing something, you know, all kinds of specific exercises
and things I've seen people do like sled work and band work and kettlebell work and whatever
may be, it's just not really doing anything. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, essentially physiologically
we know that if you do all those, you know, stud pushes and pulls and what, what have
you in your general block and then you stop doing those and you do other stuff instead
then whatever adaptions you got from those things, almost all the adaptions you got from
those things will simply just go away and you end up with just the adaptions that you
got from your second block or the third block or wherever it is that you test the athlete.
I mean, the athlete will just display the adaptions from last few weeks of what they've been
doing. Well, yeah, they can be a little bit of coordination stuff but that doesn't transfer
to us, it's pretty much irrelevant. So it just ends up in this bizarre situation where
you do a whole bunch of work and then you just abandon it and it all just goes away
and you don't, you know, keep any of it, it's just mad. But we've talked about this
periodization before. Same problem with block periodization applies whether you're describing
the block as a GPP and an SPP block. I mean, it doesn't matter what you call it but any
label you like on it. But ultimately the same problem applies. The adaptions just kind
of dissipate after. And also, I think it's worth mentioning that the looking at differently
opposite perspective is helpful because if you've spent like a dedicated, you know, kind
of month or have you on those, you know, general physical preparation concept ideas, training
methods, exercises, whatever they may be, and you haven't been participating in your sport,
you haven't been doing sport drills, you haven't been doing sports practice because you're
thinking in terms of it being a general kind of physical preparation block and you mustn't
do specific things because you're in a general block because you're looking at the names
on the labels basically. Then you've missed an enormous amount of opportunity to be moving
forward in your sport. I mean, you know, as, as someone who has participated in sports
and multiple sports and you yourself again, that can be the same, you know, neither of us
are going to say, oh, well, you know, I'll just stop playing my sport for a month or whatever.
No, it's such a ridiculous idea. And you know, anytime I have stopped, you know, skateboarding
stopped doing, you know, anything athletic for whatever reason. Usually it's because of
I'm going to get injured because I'm going to stop for a little bit. You go back in your
worst. It's not really that hard to understand. No, even if you've been doing other stuff,
you go back in your worst. I mean, that's it. And okay, fine. You can get back to where
you were, depending on how kind of what your level of performance was. I think you can get
close to where you were relatively quickly, but there is still a reduction. It's like, well,
why, but fundamentally, why would I miss that? Not only, but yeah, I guess what I'm saying
is not only am I going backwards a little bit, which is obviously bad, but I'm also missing
an opportunity to have moved forward. If I compare myself, not just with where I was,
but where I could have got to if I dedicated that time to improving, then that bothers me
more. It's like, well, I've just missed. Yeah, exactly. I'm now comparing, you know, different
things. So the periodization thing, I mean, as I've said many, many times about silly ideas
in the fitness industry, people will be periodising training programs long after I'm dead. I mean,
they're going to carry on doing it no matter what I say. They're just going to carry on, but it
is silly, and it makes literally no physiological sense. Anyway, so that was the kind of the
periodization thing. The other thing where I was going to kind of move on to them was the
work capacity issue. So a lot of people treat general physical preparations like improving
work capacity. Again, we've done a whole episode on work capacity. So if you want to go
back and visit there, but ultimately we struggle with definitions of what this actually is.
So I think, again, we talked about this in that podcast, but very, very quickly to recap,
a lot of people think that work capacity means that you can now do more.
No, that's not what it means because that isn't modifiable. If you're saying, well, I want to be
able to do more in my training sessions so that I can kind of recover more quickly. And then over
the course of the week, I can now do more in a petite stay, or know that that doesn't exist.
You've got that, that adaption would be pushing the repeat about effect to an extreme,
which it doesn't support it doing. You can't really do that. But if you want to say, well,
I just want to not get kind of out of breath through my work. Well, okay, fine. That's actually
relatively easy to do. That's just cardiovascular adaptions. That's an endurance adaption.
We can absolutely do that. Honestly, if you're talking about an athlete in that state,
I will be questioning what you've even been doing. But if your athlete is in a state where
they can't get through a workout because they're all getting cardiovascular adaption, but maybe
we're talking about sort of parallel to the absolute top end of their kind of weight classes
could happen. But most of the athletes, I think, that's unlikely to happen.
I think at the same time, if you're having trouble getting through what you need to do in a
strength training session or in a practice and stuff like that, you should probably also look at
what is being programmed. I think a lot of the times people are just sure they can't get through
some crazy demanding session because the session is insane. It's bad, the body is terrible.
Whatever it is, it's just the coach has done a really bad job there. So the athlete might feel
I do not have a shape.
they should be able to get through, you know, what, five, six sets of eight or something like that
on a squat or like something leaders don't need to do or, you know, five sets of Nordics, you know,
crazy that you could do whatever you want, but if the session is really, really bad, so
difficult that you can't get through it, could just be a terrible session design.
Yeah, I think that's probably the root cause of a lot of this is that coaches are programming
insanely stupid workouts and then they're trying to push the blame onto the athlete and so on
and the athlete's not got enough work pasty. It's like, no, no, no, your session was just silly.
I think that's not true. I've never had someone say they can't get through three sets of five and two
RR to none. Exactly. I mean, and yeah, absolutely. So I think there's, but yeah, coming back to just
summarise work pasty issue, we've got to make sure we understand what it is we're actually saying,
you know, and you can't, you can't actually provide the adaptions to an athlete to be able to do more
across the weekend of T-State. All that's going to happen is you're going to get more fatigued
with the try and do more. That's that's impossible. Secondly, on the endurance side,
yet you can get an athlete to point where they can do more without getting out of breath,
or if you want to phrase that as doing more in less time, you can do that as well. It's the same
concept. But ultimately, again, it's like that's probably a session issue, as you were just saying.
It's more about whether the athlete really should be doing silly amounts of strength training
work or whatever in the context of their training. I mean, it's like they can get a lot more
with a lot less if you just structure the session properly, which is what we talked about
in that previous episode on my performance physiology method. So yeah, those are the two kind of
interesting things. Pidization and work pasty. Let's now sort of dig in a little bit more into the
kind of general physical preparation, kind of sort of workouts that people might actually be doing.
So this is, I think, where you've got a lot of examples of what people are doing at the moment
that are potentially quite silly. So, I mean, just kind of, I guess, introducing this,
what we've seen, I think, is that people do tend to program a lot of different exercises.
So, rather than doing the exercise that is kind of the most closely related to the sporting
activity, they start doing other exercises as well, or instead of the exercises that they're
planning on doing, I mean, this is argued in the context of powerlifting, we think it's absolutely
mad. You know, why you wouldn't just stick with your actual power, they're still going to compete in,
I do not know. But anyway, the walkers to a couple of the things that you've
picked out online, Robyn, will kind of take each one in to.
Yeah, I mean, so you were just saying the idea that you need separate special exercises besides
what you would normally do, you know, for a power after its SPD for, you know, someone is a
sprinter, maybe they're usually doing hip flexion and, you know, hip thrust, whatever it may be.
Instead of that, you know, you have people do most of the time, a lot of what I see is kind of more
like whole body focused, you know, exercises, things like that. You know, I see, I've seen
farmers carries, I've seen kettlebell swings, I've seen, you know, off-loaded, like, you know,
you're carrying a farmer's carry of one arm, maybe people do band work, you've seen that a lot in
powerlifting, you know, goblet squats instead of a back squat, all kinds of things like that. And
usually, a lot more high rep work, a lot of things like time, rest periods, you know, things where
people seem to be just having the goal of getting a heart rate up. And again, like you were saying,
when it comes to like that thought of improving work capacity and like cardio vascular fitness,
instead of doing cardio, people kind of blend it into the strength training session.
You know, that's a lot of what I see slower tempos and things like that. So I think, you know,
people are trying to address a million different things with all those, you know, if they want to
work through like an extended range of motion and, you know, whatever it may be. But really, you know,
like we're saying kind of the periodization part of this year, not really targeting, like with all
those things I just mentioned, you're not really targeting any specific adaptation. Yeah, they're very
lukewarm aren't they? They're kind of very weak sort of poor, poor ways of doing everything at
the same time. Rather than doing, I mean, literally, I mean, we'll get onto this later on, but I mean,
like rather than doing like a high performance, um, physiology method type worker, where you are
actually covering all your bases and every single worker. And then doing a bunch of long slow cardio
on your off days, you know, with that combination, you are going to basically accomplish all the
stated goals of, of GPP, um, literally everything. I mean, there's, there's nothing really,
unless you want to get good at farmers walks, obviously, in which case, because you potentially
doing a strong man competition, okay, fine, I mean, that, that is your sport. So, I mean, that's
a separate issue, but, you know, like trying to do like a, I mean, I think the farmers walk is a
really good example. So, you want to do that? You want to do that? It's like, okay. And people
look at it and go, oh, no, it's fantastic, because it does all these things simultaneously. I'm like,
it, it kind of gives you like some small stimulus across a whole bunch of different places
simultaneously. And it's also going to, like in training terms, it's also going to give you
the cardiovascular kind of effect, um, but it's doing all of that relatively badly. Like, if you
were to just pick a bunch of, you know, really good strength training exercises, like we talked
through last, last time. And then, as I say, do your cardio separately from that, you would accomplish
the exact stated goal to a far better extent. With the provider, as I say, that you wouldn't get
better at doing farmers walks, okay, fine, but as I say, unless that is your sport, then what's the
point? Yeah, you're never going to need a farmer's walk, um, just carry some groceries, same thing.
Do that a couple of times a week. Yeah, it does have how many groceries you buy, but I don't think
I'm right enough to do that. Yeah, then, you know, all the GDP workouts and stuff I see are just
they don't, they don't really make ever any sense. And then, you know, when people are saying
they're targeting things, another popular one that I see is, you know, like the idea of preparing
joints, preparing tendons, increasing tendons, strength, a lot of people will say, I think maybe
they mean stiffness, things like that. And, you know, they do slow e-centrics and pauses and this
that other thing. Just respond to load, though, connective tissues, just respond to loads. So,
you're going to get again, exactly the same thing to a better extent, because you'll be in a more stable,
sort of exercise, you know, that we would program. Yeah, the adaptions to a far greater extent,
she'll get, you know, kind of higher muscle forces going through the, through the joint,
if you're in that context. And you end up with a better adaption than you would get. I mean,
again, it's like the high performance physiology method is literally doing this better than the
state of goals of this training method, this training philosophy. Yeah, it doesn't, no, it doesn't
do anything. I mean, if, if I were to spend, you know, six weeks doing high rep gavel squats,
you know, I squat close to 500 at the moment, what am I going to get out of that? What could I
possibly get? And what could any of my athletes get out of that? You know, really nothing.
It's, there's nothing you can possibly do. No, you're going to get a little bit of
local muscular endurance adaptions that you know before, which is not relevant if you're,
yeah, no, they'll go away when you stop doing. I mean, again, it does come about to this period of
this idea. People think that they can magically kind of keep some kind of benefits of stuff that
they're not doing. And that's not how it works. You know, adaptions just go away if you stop,
you know, training that particular, providing that stimulus to the body.
And then some of the, I guess another one of the very silly ones that I see mentioned is,
you know, the idea of stability, joint integrity along with that, but stability, I don't know if
we did a podcast specifically on stability, probably not, because it would be two minutes,
which is not, not a trainable quality. You're not using an unstable service to get better.
It's not a generic, the trainable quality. No, it's not like you can say, oh, I'm training
for stability. And then you can, you can do the training exercise, whatever, however it's set up.
And then you can go into a different scenario that uses maybe the same joint or, you know,
part of the body and somehow be more stable. I just weren't like that.
Yeah. Like a man with our bench press.
In all bench press?
Or, you know, they're different things. They're totally different things. You're not getting
a transfer. I mean, like, I mean, ultimately, the bench press is a good example, because the bench press is
the kind of exercise that had done most of the stability specific testing on. You know,
and the transferability is not, is not amazing, really. It's like, if you train the underlying
muscle and maybe a little bit of recruitment, you're going to get transfer. But that again comes
back to what we're talking about with like, if you're doing a strength training program,
then ultimately, those are the adaptions that are going to transfer across from one,
from one movement to another, as long as you keep doing those exercises, you'll have transferable
strength from the hypertrophy and the recruitment and whatever you've been doing. And similarly,
if you do a decent chunk of long-circuit, you'll have endurance that will transfer. Any scenario
you find yourself in, your heart lungs and kind of basket of chill function better, and they would
would have done if you hadn't.
done that, Cardio. So do some Cardio, do a proper straight training program, you know,
twice or even three times a week and do the same kind of program all the time. And that
will be your GPP. I mean, that's like, and now you keep that for as long as you're doing
the program. But if you kind of do a whole bunch of goofy exercises and then stop doing them,
then a, the adaptions that you got would have been worse than what you would have got from a
proper S&C program and be the go away because you stop doing. And even if you pick great exercises,
so I think a good example where people sometimes will pick good exercises in a, you know,
called a GPP phase would be if they're going to try to improve just hypertrophy,
which you should be improving a little bit all the time. Obviously, but, you know,
people love these big offseason blocks where they try to gain as much muscle as possible.
And the idea that you can even do that with it, the idea that you could even do that with it
like an athlete has been training for, you know, at least a few years. It's just mad. I mean, like,
there's no scenario in which you can take an athlete. There's been doing strength training for
a few years and through six to eight weeks of some silly high volume training program at them
and explain them to be meaningfully, you know, kind of more muscular at the end of that six to eight
weeks block than they were at the beginning. All this going to happen is going to be a ton of muscle
swelling and they're going to be tired, teaked and there were I've been out to do anything else.
And even if like, you know, even if in that phase for the, you know, the exercise such and maybe
you did choose, you know, good things like, you know, you chose maybe a stable lateral raise to
build the shoulders and you chose chest press and things like that. And then all of a sudden,
you go to your SPP phase and you take all that stuff out, take it all out. Yeah, you were going some
muscle that could have been useful. And then the idea, you know, people saw the idea that the
muscle is going to hang around for so long. It's not. So you take all that stuff out. And within a
few weeks, you know, whatever gains you made in six to eight weeks is gone. So you really didn't
do anything at that point. Exactly. You just took it out of the program.
And this is really what it all comes back to is that we need to get away. Well, we don't,
I mean, people are going to carry on doing this whatever I say, whatever we say. But, you know,
for people who are listening to this podcast and actually taking away ideas and concepts and
using them to get their athletes to make their athletes better, you know, what we're saying is that
the entire kind of periodization model just needs to go. You know, the work past itself is just
something to put on the shelf and a very, very occasionally, if you've got an athlete's
decondition, then kind of okay, but then it's just cardio. I mean, it's not anything more special
than that. And really, the GPP concept can be entirely replaced by just doing a proper,
all inclusive, in the sense of it covers all the bases, strength training program like we've
described last time on the high performance physiology method. Combine that with a couple of other
days of long slow cardio. If you really want to do some mentors, then okay, fine, put those in, but
I'm not a cardio vascular guy. I don't, you know, kind of talk about that. But I would just say,
I think that there's been a tendency to, and again, I think this links back to what you were saying
earlier about often it's the coach's desire to build silly workouts that drives a lot of these
kind of concepts and ideas and, you know, beliefs. But I think that a lot of coaches have moved away
from programming long slow cardio when it, you know, clearly works, providing the athlete's
cardiovascular adaptions. And instead, they just want to throw in a tiny, not tiny, but
they want to throw in a much shorter duration of intervals. And like, well, we can get, you know,
the athlete to the same level of cardiovascular fitness in the shorter period of time. And, you know,
therefore, we can then spend, you know, that time that we saved on doing other silly stuff that they
want to do. And so I wonder whether the drive towards pushing the athletes to do high intensity
intervals instead of long slow cardio just going back to this idea that they want to try and fit
more in the week. And therefore, they're trying to, you know, shrink the long slow cardio sessions
because it feels like waste of time. And the issue, the problem is though, as far as I'm aware,
and again, I'm not a cardiovascular guy, but the underlying adaptions are slightly different
away that the body responds to long-so cardio is slightly different what you get from
intervals. And I think that, you know, if you look at endurance athletes, they aren't building
their routines around intervals. They're building their routines around long slow cardio. And then
they do a little bit of intervals to sharpen up to kind of like, you know, push adaptions that
they may not have got from the actual base work that they've been doing. You know, if endurance athletes
are still doing that, then I think that is a strong indication that, you know, if you want to improve
cardiovascular endurance, that will be the starting point, you know. And I think that, that for me,
is something that I'm, you know, quite, again, I'm not a cardiovascular guy, but I think that would
be my preference, would be to, to kind of pruring on the long slow cardio rather than the intervals.
I didn't know how you feel about that role. People, I mean, I use a lot of intervals, but I don't
never, I mean, I say a lot. I mean, you know, a couple of times a week, but I don't ever, you know,
tell someone to not do long slow cardio. And if I think they need more cardio, generally,
like I will program it or you know, he's told them to do more. It's, I mean, I think it's always
worth it to have both when I was, you know, kickboxing, all that stuff. You do plenty of,
plenty of long slow cardio, and you're in incredible shape, you know, all the endurance. That way,
it's like you said, do it. Take boxers, mixed martial artists, boxers, you know, there's a reason
it's popular. It works, it works great. I think people stay away from it because they still have
that idea, which I think we mentioned before about long slow cardio, you know, inherently making you slow.
Burning out muscle, you know, whatever you want to say, all this stuff. And it just, it doesn't do
that until it's really, really large volumes of long slow cardio. And you know, even then you have
like marathoners and that who are tremendously jacked. It's not, it's not that much of a concern.
I think people, you know, like you said, they get away from it because of the session structure.
They tend to use it. They get away from it because of beliefs around what it's going to do negatively
and it just doesn't really stack up. Yeah. So I've no, I see no reason not to use it. Yeah.
Well, yeah, I mean, there's there's ways of means of making it more barrel. But yeah, I guess I
think that, you know, hi, I think that intervals are, I think that the coach 10, I think the coaches
tend to look at the time spent and go, oh, we're doing this again, the same benefit. You know,
actually getting the exact same benefit, but getting a similar cardiovascular benefit from doing
a short amount of intervals versus a long amount of psychology, therefore I'm going to pick the
intervals instead. I'm like, well, I don't think they are exactly the same. I think that you get
far more improvements over a longer period of time with the long, so I think the intervals
give you a little bit of a boost and then they'll stop in your stopping breathing after a certain
point. And then secondly, you know, I think that what you're, if you're literally just looking at
time spent across the week, then I think you'll, um, ignore the impact on the athlete. I mean,
you just said you hate long slow cardio, okay? Just for me. Yeah, sure. But I think that if you,
if you do intervals like, um, with a lot of commitment, you probably would hate them more.
Yeah, I don't like them either. I just don't like cardio. So that's if that's just me, but if I was
going to, I guess, I'm just saying that like, I think that the, if you want to kind of look at
the athletes, not just the athletes, kind of time spent doing stuff, but like what it costs in terms
of mental energy and, you know, kind of like you can do an hour on, you know, the cross-trainer,
it's like, okay, as long as you've got something to watch is bearable. You know, whereas, you know,
doing sort of 10, 15 minutes of intervals at max intensity, you, you, this commitment and motivation
required for that. That isn't required for the long-term cardio. I guess I just went to do this.
Real enough. Other costs. You'll feel like death. Like you will feel, if you're actually a person,
you should feel, you should feel hot. There's only ever been two, there's only ever been two
exercise sessions that I was ever scared of doing. Like I could feel the apprehension as I walked
into do the exercise session. One was, um, max effort day lifting. And the other was, um, concept
two rowing in tools. Yeah. I can see that. There was the only two exercise sessions that I've
walked into being like, I don't want to be here. I don't want to be here. I want to be somewhere else.
So that's worth just bearing in mind. It's not just about, oh, we've got this time we can do more
in less time because we're going to do in tools instead of long-term cardio. I'm like, yeah, but
just think about the impacts on the athlete and like, you know, how they feel about it. It's not
the same. Yeah, definitely. Cool. Any other things that you wanted to raise about GPP?
And I think we, you know, I think we got most of it. I guess the only other one we could mention
that I don't think we did yet is another idea I've seen about, you know, kinesthetic awareness,
which we mentioned a bit on other episodes, but you know, the idea that like getting good at these
things in the weight room, especially general exercises is going to give you better body awareness,
playing your sport and all of them. And that just not going to happen.
So you realize you are now my favorite example of that.
it's impossible. Yeah, Chris and I were laughing before the podcast because of all the things
I'm decent at, I dance and I have not been dancing very long. And clearly if you watch
me skateboard versus dance, we're doing everything.
It's just insane difference. It's such a brilliant, is such a brilliant example. You know,
like your skateboarding is just god tier. And, you know, you posted that video, you're
dancing. I'm like, yeah, not god tier. It's, you know, it's, it's 20.
It definitely, it definitely does look different. And I think that's super, super important.
You know, obviously, you know, that is not what is generally believed. People think that
they can do a bunch of different unusual exercises or put themselves in a whole bunch of different
situations. And that will then transfer to their sport. And it doesn't work like that.
You know, coordination doesn't transfer. Even if it's similar, a good example I have
actually is, so I went years ago with surfing with a guy who rode for the, the same companies
as me skateboarding. We assumed because I'm a good skateboarder. He's a good skateboarder.
He's also a very good surfer that I would be good at surfing. I am not good at surfing.
I'm not even close to good at surfing. And it's, you know, it's both, it's a board.
It's, you know, they're board boards. I'm sure one's concrete and one not one's water.
But I was terrible at surfing. No transfer at all. So, yeah, it's really interesting.
Similar ash. It just, it didn't, it had literally zero transfer. I can't even stand up for 10
minutes. I was like, what are we doing here?
That's really cool. No, that is, that is very interesting. But yeah, so, but again, I would
argue that that probably again is going to be an idea that persists long after my death.
That people are going to be, you know, thinking that your strength training is loaded movement.
You know, car training is, it's coordination training with, with load. But coordination,
you know, benefits, transfer across scenarios, different to their sports. But they don't.
I mean, you have to do the thing. You have to do the thing that you want to do the thing all
the time. Yeah. And that's really what it comes down to.
It's like, from what we said last time, you want to be practicing your sport. You want
to be doing a strength training workout that covers all your bases at least twice a week.
You can do it three times if you've got more capacity, but twice is great. And then you
want to do some cardio. And I think I would push long slow cardio as the least offensive
option. But if people are happy doing a bit of in-tools in early, that's cool as well.
I think it'll work. It's just, they are slightly different and you won't get exactly the
same benefits from both. So yeah, we think the idea of GP can basically just go away, but
you can replace it with a proper SNC program. Just do a strength training workout with a cardio
and you're done. Is that fair?
Definitely.
Awesome. Well, let's stop there and we will come back with another episode next week.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
General physical preparation (GPP) as a periodized block is physiologically illogical, as adaptations fade when training stops and athletes regress to the effects of recent workouts.
Work capacity is often misdefined—true cardiovascular endurance can be improved, but claims that athletes can "do more" across the week are unsupported by physiology.
Training programs filled with generic exercises (e.g., farmer’s walks, band work) fail to target specific adaptations and offer poor transferability to sport-specific performance.
Coaches frequently design overly complex or intense workouts that appear to improve fitness but are actually poorly structured, leading to fatigue and false beliefs about progress.
There is no valid transfer of coordination or body awareness from general exercises to sport-specific activities, as demonstrated by examples like skateboarding and surfing.
Long slow cardio provides superior, sustainable cardiovascular adaptations compared to high-intensity intervals, which offer only marginal gains and greater mental cost.
True GPP is redundant and can be replaced by a consistent, well-structured strength training program combined with moderate cardio.
The entire concept of GPP persists due to coaching habits and misconceptions, not physiological evidence, and should be replaced with practical, evidence-based training.
Summary:
The podcast challenges the validity of General Physical Preparation (GPP) as a training philosophy. It argues that periodized blocks of GPP are physiologically unfounded—adaptations vanish when training stops, and athletes regress to the effects of recent workouts. Work capacity is misinterpreted; true endurance gains come from cardiovascular adaptations, not from doing more in a session.
Many GPP workouts—like farmer’s walks or slow eccentrics—are ineffective, poorly targeted, and fail to transfer to sport-specific performance. Coaches often design overly complex or intense sessions that appear effective but are actually flawed, leading to fatigue and poor results. Coordination and body awareness do not transfer from general exercises to sport-specific activities, as shown by examples like skateboarding and surfing.
Long slow cardio is superior to high-intensity intervals for building endurance, offering better physiological benefits and lower mental cost. The podcast concludes that GPP is redundant and can be replaced by a consistent strength training program twice a week, combined with moderate cardio—preferably long slow cardio. This approach is evidence-based, practical, and aligned with how the body adapts.
The idea of GPP persists due to coaching misconceptions, not physiology, and is best discarded in favor of simpler, more effective training.
FAQs
GPP is a training philosophy that involves a block of non-sport-specific workouts. It's controversial because it lacks physiological basis—adaptations from these workouts fade when training stops, and there's little transfer to actual sport performance.
No, periodization of GPP blocks doesn't improve performance. Athletes lose adaptations from earlier training phases, and when tested, they only show the improvements from the most recent training block, not from earlier phases.
No, gains from GPP workouts are not lasting. When athletes stop doing specific exercises, the resulting adaptations disappear, and no meaningful carryover occurs to sport-specific performance.
These workouts primarily build local muscular endurance, which is not transferable to sport-specific demands. They also lead to fatigue and offer minimal benefit, with adaptations vanishing when training stops.
These exercises provide some cardiovascular and coordination benefits, but they don't deliver significant, transferable improvements. They are inefficient compared to targeted strength training programs that cover all necessary bases.
No, there's no evidence that general exercises improve sport-specific coordination or stability. Skills like balance or body awareness require consistent practice in relevant contexts, not generic workouts.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.