459: 4 Hour Assault By Her Own Father Results in Her Death | Makayla Settles
45m 41s
Michaela Settles, an 18-year-old aspiring entrepreneur from North Carolina, moved to California to live with her father, Steven Chavez, hoping for a new beginning. Two days after arriving, she was allegedly sexually assaulted by him after being fed excessive alcohol. The assault, which lasted four hours and left her physically and mentally traumatized, prompted her to call her mother in distress. Despite DNA evidence and a rape exam confirming the assault, Steven was not charged with sexual assault or rape. Instead, he was charged only with felony incest and furnishing alcohol to a minor—charges the family and advocates believe are grossly inadequate given the severity of the crime. Michaela returned to North Carolina and struggled with lasting trauma, eventually taking her own life five months later. After a guilty plea in 2026, Steven was sentenced to one year in county jail—served less than six months—and released in November 2026, with no restrictions on travel or contact. His release has sparked outrage, as the family sees it as a systemic failure to protect minors and hold predators accountable. Michaela’s mother and sister have since launched a wrongful death lawsuit and a public petition demanding legal reforms to prevent similar tragedies. The case underscores a critical gap in how sexual violence, especially within family structures, is defined and punished under the law, with many questioning whether the legal system truly recognizes the harm of such abuse, particularly when victims are silenced or dismissed. The family continues to advocate for change, emphasizing that justice should not be measured by time served, but by the protection of vulnerable individuals and the acknowledgment of real trauma.
When a young woman's cry for help, a shocking arrest in a family's fight for justice. She's just such a sweet, loving kind person. Her family says she called, terrified, and asking for help. I knew something was wrong. She's barely walking. The victim's family is seeking justice, and they're turning to the public for help, urging supporters to pressure the Ventura County District Attorney to take this case to trial. Hey, true friend besties. Welcome back to an all new episode of serialously. Hello, hello, hello, and welcome back to an all new episode of serialously with me, Annie Elise. I hope you had a great weekend. I hope you were settling into a good start to your week. Maybe you're at home cleaning. Maybe you're at work. Maybe you're driving to work. Maybe you're in traffic, or maybe you're, you know, at work already with your work bestie. And listening to this or watching this video wherever you are. I really want you to just take a moment, take a deep breath. Hopefully you're not eating because you definitely will lose your appetite. Or you'll vomit up what you have recently eaten because today's case is so truly disgusting and barbaric. Now I have talked about this case with you here and there over the last six months on headline highlights my Thursday episode where I break down what's going on in the true crime world that week. However, last Thursday there was a pretty significant update in this case. And I asked all of you do you want the deep dive even knowing that it is up as upsetting of a case as it is. And you have said yes, you want the deep dive. You want to know all of the information. So here I am. I'm here to break it all down for you. Start to finish. But again, I want to give you that warning that wherever you're at, take a moment, collect yourself. No doubt. Am I going to ruin your day? But it is a truly like just sociopathic type of case. And as a parent myself, I am, I lose sleep over it. I really am horrified by this case. And it's the case of Michaela settles. Now imagine this just for a moment. Imagine your own father. You move across the country to California to reconnect with him and to start college to start a new chapter in your life. You're 18 years old. You're like, hey, California, the golden coast. I'm going to connect with my dad. I'm going to start school. I'm going to kind of build my young adult life. But then two days later, he feeds you alcohol and he's sexually assaults you. And I'm talking a sexual assault that is so brutal that you have to be carried into the hospital. You go to the hospital and get checked out, get an exam and tell them what happened. But your father, your biological father tells everyone that it was consensual. That you're a liar, that you're making all of this up, that you aren't sexually assaulted, that you did this. You were complicit. You were a consenting adult in all of this. And with that, you struggle with that for months because how could your own father first of all turn on you and brutalize you in such a way. But then paint you as a liar and make people doubt you and question you and cast you as the villain in your own story. So you try to move forward. You try to figure out as an 18 year old young girl how to move forward and how to calibrate all of that. And you try to keep going, but ultimately you can't take it anymore. And you feel like there's no other way to end this horrific cycle than to take your own life. Well, that is the case of 18 year old Michaela settles. And just last Monday on November 9th, her father, Steven Chavez, he walked out of jail, walked out a free man. After only serving five months and three weeks of jail time and get this, that was the sentence for what he admitted doing. He was sentenced to one year in county jail, which he didn't even serve that full year. He served less than half of it. This is after his own admission, not to the sexual assault, but to incest felony incest, I should say, and also furnishing a minor with alcohol. So today what we're going to do, because there is so much more to it than what I just said, I'm going to give you the full story, who Michaela was, why she moved across the country to live with her father, what happened two days after she got there, and why prosecutors charged him the way that he did, which in my opinion was not severe enough, it was a slap on the wrist. He wasn't charged with rape, he wasn't charged with sexual assault, and a big piece of that is because Michaela was no longer available to testify, and I'm going to also share what happened after she died. Now, I want to be very careful with this one because there are a lot of versions of this story floating around online and not all of them are true. So what I'm going to do is I'm going to stick to what is actually on record court records, the district attorney's own statements, local reporting, and then whenever there's something that is an allegation or a family's belief or something that only exists on social media, even if it came from the family firsthand, I am going to disclose that just so that you can have a full understanding of like what is on record, what has been and deemed to be true, I guess you could say by the police and the court systems. Versus also what the family has alleged and their own statements, not to say that what they're alleging is not true, certainly I personally believe everything that they have said, but because he was never charged with sexual assault, you know, it gets tricky when you, you know, you know what I'm doing, I have to say allegedly, I have to protect myself and all of that too, as always do your own research, form your own opinions, but I do want to share with you the full story because Michaela deserves that her family deserves that and her family wants that her mom. Want Michaela's story to evoke change and I'm going to get into that in a little while here to so let's start with Michaela herself Michaela settles was 18 years old, she grew up in Rally North Carolina and she lived there with her mom Carolina sand of all and her younger sister Jada, she had just graduated high school and by every account from the people who loved her, she was just full of life. She was outgoing, she was funny, she loved pranking people, she loved scaring people even and she also loved Stephen King novels, so a fellow true crime girlie. Now her mom says that Michaela was a little entrepreneur, always dreaming about what she was going to build for herself. She wanted to be a stenographer and she also wanted to own her own nail salon, which at one point she even wanted to be an architect, so I'm talking like lots of ambitions, lots of things just saw a huge vast future ahead of herself right with no limitations, she could be anything, she could do anything. And the point in all of that is she had plans, she had plans to do something significant and fun and joyful with her life, she was going to be somebody's boss or her own boss and that's how her mom put it. She also had a father that she barely knew, she learned that Stephen Chavez was her biological father when she was just 9 years old. Now he lived on the whole opposite side of the country in California while she lived in North Carolina as I said, however the two of them did stay in touch, regular phone calls, holiday visits, things like that and this is all according to her mom, so they did have a relationship, it was just a long distance one, not one where it was super close or obviously nuclear in that sense. So after she graduated high school, Michaela decided she wanted more than that, she wanted more than this long distance relationship with her dad, she really wanted to get to know him, she wanted to start her young adult life, she wanted to live with him, she wanted a fresh start in California, start college and really start building a life for herself. Now according to Michaela's mom, her dad Stephen had promised her things to make this move happen, things like a car, a college savings fund, things like that to really entice Michaela to move. And I'm telling you that that was her mom's account and what her mom has said, not because I don't believe it and it's just an allegation, but because that part has not been independently verified yet. The move itself is of course not in dispute, but her mom is saying like, oh yeah, he was over promising her all of these things trying to make it like an enticing move for her. So on July 19th, 2025, Michaela moved into her father's house in Moore Park, California. Moore Park is in Ventura County, so LA County about an hour northwest of Los Angeles. She was planning to start classes at Moore Park College the following month in August. Her mom and sister also planned to stay in the area for about a month while she got used to the new area, living with her dad, just kind of a good, you know, easy transition period having her sister and her mom there as well. Because keep in mind, she was still, yeah, a young adult and an adult technically, but she was 18 years old. She had also just graduated high school, she was also starting this brand new chapter with someone that she never really knew all that well. And that's how everybody describes it to a new chapter for Michaela. So she trusted her dad to take care of her and protect her after moving across the country. Then she had been there two days, two days. And on July 21st, 2025, two days after Michaela moved in, everything changed. After a day of drinking at a family gathering together, apparently Steven bought more alcohol for himself and for his 18 year old daughter Michaela.
to drink at home. Then, after feeding her all of this alcohol, as a minor, copious amounts of alcohol, he allegedly sexually assaulted her. And look, I say allegedly because he has never been tried for the sexual assault itself, but it is a proven fact that he did have sexual intercourse with her, which he did admit to. He just said that it was consensual, not assault. Now, this sexual encounter reportedly went on for four hours and was brutal. I am talking rough, hard, just like a very brutal sexual interaction. So much so that Michaela called her mother that same morning, the following morning, because this happened into the early morning hours. Her mom, as I said, was staying nearby, so not in the house, but close enough. And Michaela told her mom what happened. Just distraught beside herself, saying, "Dad sexually assaulted me. I don't know what to do. I've been so much pain. What do I do? Where do I go? I need my mom. I need my mommy." So her mom and her uncle rushed over to get her and pick her up, and then her mom drove her to the hospital. And like I said, Michaela, this was brutal. This was four hours reportedly of a brutal assault, and Michaela could barely walk. So much so that allegedly her uncle had to carry her into the hospital because she couldn't walk. Can you just imagine that as a parent for a moment? Your young daughter moves across the country because she wants to get to know her father better and start this new chapter of her life. Then you receive a phone call from her, hysterically crying, distraught, saying her own dad just sexually assaulted her, and that she couldn't walk. She could barely move. Then driving over there, picking her up, taking her to the hospital, and like having to watch the uncle carry her inside, and like just trying to reconcile everything that had just happened. The parent, like that has to be some parents worse nightmare, wanting to just protect your child at all costs, only to be betrayed by someone that she should have been able to trust. And someone who abused his authority and power and trusted position with her to inflict such a horrific barbaric assault on her, it is devastating. It's heartbreaking. So she gets taken into the hospital and they do a full sane exam, which for those of you who are unfamiliar with that term, it is a rape examination. And according to Fox 11 and the family, that same exam, it confirmed Steven's DNA inside Michaela. And when that exam came back, it looked like, okay, good, there's DNA evidence. You have Michaela's internal injuries that show that this was a horrific, you know, very invasive assault. I want to just be careful with how I'm describing that. And you have her testimony of what happened like slam dunk of a case, right? That's what you would think. So Steven was arrested soon after that. And then he was charged in July of 2025, but this is where the case takes a turn and a turn that has made a lot of people furious. He was not charged with rape. Instead, he was charged with felony incest and one misdemeanor count of giving alcohol to a minor. That's it. Nothing about the sexual assault. Nothing about any of like the truly haunting things that he did to his own daughter, just the alcohol and felony incest. And I know what you're probably thinking because her mom thought the same thing. Her mom said, and I'm quoting her, she said, he got her drunk. She was intoxicated. She was taken advantage of physically and mentally. So if that's not rape, I really don't know what is. And look, that is a completely reasonable question, right? And I am going to answer it, but not yet. Because the answer to that question didn't come until after Michaela died. So first, let me tell you what happened with her and everything in the months after this brutal assault. Steven pleaded not guilty. And he was released on a $250,000 bail. So after this assault, Michaela went back to North Carolina to live with her mother and sister. She wasn't going to stay with this freaking creep and predator her own father, right? No, she was going to go back home where she felt safe, where she felt protected. And the truth is she tried to move forward. She completed nail technician training. She tried to build a life for herself. Her sister Jada said that she tried to move on after what had happened, but the trauma, it was so severe that she could no longer bear to live with it. Her mom said it very plainly saying, quote, she was full of life. But when I brought her back, it was a totally different person. And I had heard different rumblings that hasn't been confirmed. I've heard different things from various family members and reporting that over the course of the next few months, Michaela was introduced to therapy that it was, you know, intermittent that she tried to talk to family and that she just still internally was struggling with what happened to her so much. Not only the act itself, but layer on top of it that her dad was telling everyone she was a liar and that this was consensual, which imagine what kind of shame that also brought on to her, like people thinking, oh my God, this Michaela girl, she had sex with her dad, what a, like what a freak this and that, like, at just 18 years old, it is such an enormous weight to carry while you're also trying to grapple with the fact that your own father assaulted you in such a way. She tried to move forward, she tried to get on with her life, but as her mom said, she couldn't, she was just a completely different person, this changed her. And on December 22nd, 2025, Michaela attempted to take her own life, she then ended up dying in the hospital on December 28th, 2025 at just 18 years old. I want to tell you how she took her own life or where exactly it happened because no reliable source has reported those details and I think that that is something very private and personal to her family that they aren't releasing for the fact that they don't want it out there and I respect that there are different versions online that claimed to know, but I'm not going to verify them for you and I'm not going to repeat them on here. But the point is, her family believes that the assault is what killed her, not directly, not that night, not the actual physical injuries, but the trauma from the assault is what led to her taking her own life five months later. And there's also a wrongful death lawsuit that has been filed, which says exactly that and her civil attorney said that there is an absolute casual relationship between the two of them. Now I want to be clear, no corner or medical finding has been quoted and no court has found that causation as though her father and that alleged assault is directly what contributed and caused Michaela's death. The DA's office just says that Michaela tragically took her own life in December of 2025. They don't attribute any legal causation, which is very frustrating because like obviously this was a young happy girl who had her whole life ahead of her, she had plans and she didn't just, you know, dream this up out of nowhere. There was a chain of events that led to this and her mom also said that she said this to Stephen directly that in a phone call from prison, she told him point blank, you killed my daughter. Now let's go back to that question of why was he not charged with rape? Why was he not charged with sexual assault? Well, after Michaela died, the Ventura County District Attorney had his office do a full review. And 10 of their most experienced prosecutors looked at the evidence plus legal experts from another county as well, and all of them concluded the same thing that incest was the only felony charge supported by the law, the facts, and the admissible evidence. Now that's the DA's position in one sentence, full and clear that that's all that they can prove. They haven't given any sort of fuller explanation other than that. And I don't want to like invent one for them, but I would say based on my experience in covering similar cases to this where there is incest involved or, you know, sexual intercourse, even if it is consensual between two adults, that it's difficult to prove that it's not consensual. Especially because Michaela at this point now is no longer here to testify to that. So for Stephen, he was saying all along note was consensual. We got really drunk. We had rough sex. This and that. And although she had the same kid exam, although there was DNA, although there were these internal injuries, all that was indicative of, unfortunately, was rough intercourse. It didn't prove assault. And at that point, it was his word against her word. And you take into consideration the copious amounts of alcohol, which isn't full proof, but you know, like, look, prosecutors usually only will take a case that they are positive that they can get a conviction on. So if there's any cast of doubt, even for them, chances are they're not going to move forward with it. Then you layer in that five months later, she ended up taking her own life and she can't even testify to this being an assault. It diminishes their chances of a conviction even further. Now, I will say this. The family has told a different version of what the prosecutors told them. Crystal sand of all, Michaela's cousin said on a GoFundMe page that prosecutors told the family that even though they had the same exam kit and a statement to the police and a recorded interview, none of it could be used because Michaela was no longer here to speak for herself. That's what the family said. As far as the case goes, I really don't know how to feel if I'm being honest. So they did set a date for the preliminary hearing. That's May 19th.
that's the first time that that's happened so we are moving forward. They did however inform me that based on the charges the most that he can get is three years and 20 years as a registered sexist vendor. I said he's 40 in 20 in 20 years this is an all-go away for him and you know they really couldn't really answer me but they just kept saying based on the charges that's the most that he can get. So then I said why can't we do involuntary manslaughter? They said based on the evidence this is all we can charge. My daughter then asked why can't we do rape and they said based on the evidence this is all we can charge. So I don't know what evidence they're talking about maybe what Michaela said you know the day it happened but at the end of the day he got her drunk and even if you know he said let's go to this room or let's go upstairs or whatever she said and even if she did she was intoxicated she was taken advantage of physically and mentally so if that's not rape I really don't know what is I'm not really sure why they can't you know put that as a charge. The DA has not confirmed that wording what the DA did say though in April of 2026 is that the prosecutors charge what they can prove beyond a reasonable doubt and that after Michaela died they reevaluated the evidence and that their position did not change. So the implication and this is what the family and a lot of commentators have drawn from it is that a sexual assault charge would have required proving non consent and proving that after Michaela was gone would have rested heavily on her own testimony. So again the DA hasn't outright said that point blank the family says they told them that but they haven't made an official statement but I think that all of us who have heard enough true crime cases can you know understand that that is the direction that this was going. Now what I can't tell you is more on what these charges were the ones that they actually were going to prosecute this monster for. felony incest under California penal code 285 and misdemeanor furnishing alcohol to minor because remember Michaela was 18 which yes is an adult but she has to be 21 for alcohol so giving her alcohol was being treated as a separate crime now which there were two special allegations attached that Stephen took advantage of a position of trust and confidence to commit the offense and that the victim was particularly vulnerable. Those are not separate charges though they are aggravating factors but they do matter and they will matter as I get into sentencing in a little bit here so I have to be honest though for a while after Michaela died it looked like this entire case was going to fall apart because she was no longer here they were only going after him for these misdemeanor charges I mean felony incest yet yes but felony incest I think it only carries what a maximum of three years so bullshit charges in the grand scheme of things when this young girl is no longer here and alive and this four-hour barbaric assault that was allegedly inflicted against her like it seems like a slap on the wrist when you look at everything as like a total so in April of 2026 the family was terrified that the case could be dropped because Michaela couldn't testify there wasn't a lot of compelling evidence that was admissible they didn't know what was going to happen so crystal Michaela's cousin took the case to TikTok and it went viral hundreds of people pledged to show up at a court hearing on April 21st 2026 so that they could show their support for the family and make sure that this case didn't just go quietly away and you know brushed under the rug the DA's office said that they had no intention of dropping the case they said that the case had been filed since July of 2025 and they were going to try in a courtroom but they were also clear to say look we're not gonna do this on social media we know you guys are raising a huge stink over here it'll be tried in a courtroom we're not letting it go just like be patient but the family had other fears too after Stephen pleaded not guilty he was out on a $250,000 bail which let me remind you you only need a post 10% of that $25,000 which yeah that is a lot of money don't get me wrong 25 grand it's difficult to come up with that but you go to a bail bondsman you can put up collateral it's not unheard of and the family also said he still had his passport so was he gonna flee with what's he going to do they said nobody had restricted him from international travel the prosecutors had told him that he couldn't change his name or leave the country but still like there wasn't any like crazy restriction and that's what they were afraid of that he changed his name he'd flee he'd go off and there would never be justice or accountability but then on May 18th 2026 something happened that nobody expected Stephen advanced his court date his preliminary hearing had been set for May 19th but instead he came in a day early and at that hearing he pleaded guilty guilty to one felony count of incest and guilty to one misdemeanor count of furnishing alcohol to a minor and he also admitted both of those special allegations the one of him taking full advantage of a position of trust and also that the victim was particularly vulnerable so he was immediately taken into custody right there in the courtroom and sentencing was set for June 23rd which I need to tell you something about that plea because it does matter the plea had followed in offer from the judge judge cry and this offer was over the prosecutors objection one of the local news outlets actually had to correct an earlier version of their own story on exactly this point because it does get a little bit convoluted but the plea deal didn't come from the prosecutors it came from the judge prosecutors actually objected to it they didn't want a plea deal they wanted to go to trial I would imagine because they wanted a bigger sentence and they wanted more justice for Michaela but the judge overrode that and basically offered up this plea deal which is infuriating because isn't that the whole point of prosecutors to be able to try the case how they see fit because they know all of the nuances within it then on June 5th 2026 about two weeks before sentencing Michaela's mom Carolina filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Stephen now it was for wrongful death intentional inflection of emotional distress negligence and it was for unspecified damages which a jury trial was demanded within this filing her attorney is a man named Gerard Doherty and he has been very clear about what this case is and what it is not he said that the criminal outcome did not drive the decision to sue that this was going to happen regardless he said that the burden of proof in a civil case is significantly less than it is in a criminal case so this was always going to happen it wasn't just because the criminal aspect was now being not tabled but severely reduced right he said that the guilty plea is certainly a significant part of the civil case too and he also said this he said quote it's never going to result in justice in the sense that Michaela will never be brought back all we're seeking is monetary damages and that is really what a civil case can do and the point in a lot of them when there is unfortunately a death that occurs it can't bring the victim back obviously it can't put him in prison for longer it can only ask for money and also a finding on paper that he is responsible for her death and this lawsuit also alleges something else in December of 2024 which was about seven months before Michaela moved to California she spent Christmas break at her father's house in California and this lawsuit alleges that during that visit Stephen gave Michaela alcohol she passed out and when she woke up the next morning she was only wearing her underwear so the lawsuit argues that Stephen had been grooming her this entire time now that is just an allegation that hasn't been found proven in a court of law it's in the lawsuit and not a criminal charge no police report has been published about it and no reliable outlet has independently confirmed it however her mom has repeated this grooming part publicly specifically as sentencing but the incident itself has never been tested in criminal court but it does make you wonder because if seven months before she moved there Keith fed her alcohol she woke up in her underwear then he's trying to get her to move to his house as the mom alleges promising her a car all of these things just come move with me honey come move with me to wear for an 18 year old they're all oh my gosh a brand new car living in California yeah of course i'm going to do that it does to me at least illustrate predatory nature and activity like yes grooming but also that it's premeditated that he has this plan of what he wants to do and he's trying to lure her there and make her all of these promises which that is by definition grooming right promising special gifts special treatment all in exchange for getting something you want not necessarily sexual intercourse that is consensual but getting her to move there getting her to talk with you more and it's this progression that happens and to me look i'm i'm inclined to believe for the mom over the dad in all of this so even though it hasn't been proven in court it's like i do think that the writing is on the wall in a sense as for this civil suit Stephen apparently doesn't even have a civil attorney yet so he hasn't commented on this lawsuit and the first hearing in the civil case is scheduled for november 20th 2026 so literally the end of this week and i will be glued to that because that is the next place that this case goes so anyway now going back to the sentencing because we know he pled guilty and then he was going to be due for sentencing but the civil case happened right before that which is why i wanted to mention it the charges are insane
and alcohol, he pleaded guilty. So the question is, okay, well, how much time is he going to get? Well, the maximum sentence for what he pleaded guilty to was three years in state prison. That's what the prosecutors asked for as well. The prosecutor said the defendant exploited his position as a father, violated his daughter's trust, supplied her with alcohol, and engaged in criminal conduct that forever altered the course of her life. They also said, while we respect the court's decision, we continue to believe a state prison sentence was warranted under the facts of this case. And the family asked for the same thing, the maximum, which even the maximum was not, in my opinion, a sensible sentence for such a horrific crime, but I get it when you aren't prosecuting sexual assault and it's incest and it's furnishing alcohol to a minor, there is a maximum sent, but it's set for that. So it's like, yeah, we want the maximum no matter what. And her mom had already said it back in April that three years was absolutely ridiculous, which it was saying, you know, what my daughter's life is only worth three years. How does that math? So then the judge spoke. And even though the family, the prosecutor and everybody was saying the maximum, the maximum, the maximum, the maximum, which was still only three years, the judge sent in Stephen to one year in Ventura County jail, not even prison, but jail, which jail arguably, I mean, I know it's a lot of mixed opinions. I think it's softer than prison because it's not hardened criminals you're in with. It's people with DUIs, it's, you know, like a B&E charge, things like that. And like, yeah, dangerous, but not like hardened criminals. So he was sentenced to one year in Ventura jail, plus three years of felony probation, then layered on an additional 20 years that he'd have to be on the registry. But he also got credit for 88 days that he already served, which can you believe that one year in County jail and not state prison for what this monster did? Then the judge explained why he said that he could not impose the high term of three years in state prison without Stephen's consent, because Stephen did not have a previous criminal history. So the high term was off the table and Stephen didn't agree to it, which that is such an ass backwards rule in my opinion. Like, of course, no defendant is going to agree to a high term. Like, no, they're never gonna be like, you know what, even though the judge only wants to give me one year, I think I should do three years in state prison. Like, obviously, he's not gonna agree to it. It's the judge's job and the prosecutor's job and all of them to fight for justice and serve the maximum term. Like, it just infuriates me. And the judge also said something else in all of this. He's told the family that they were correct that Michaela should still be here that she deserved better and that what would happen in court would not be justice. He said that he could feel the anger and the frustration and the sense of injustice and that he understood yet he still only gave him one year. Before the sentence was handed down, the family got to speak and there were victim impact statements from her mom, her sister, who was also 18, her cousin and many others. Her sister, Jada said he ruined her life and now he's ruined mine. I don't have her and it's because of him. Her cousin crystal said, "This is exactly why we don't speak up." And her mom said to Stephen directly, "You were grooming her." All while Stephen sat there and said nothing. Neither did his attorney. They made no statements at the sentencing hearing. But we know what Stephen's position has been because other people have said it in court. Crystal said that it sentencing Stephen has shown not only no remorse but also continued to double down on the fact that this entire thing was consensual, that Michaela was lying. And the deputy DA told the court that Stephen blamed his girlfriend for breaking up with him, blamed alcohol for clouding his judgment and then even blamed Michaela herself. Which, again, like the audacity of this man, "Oh no, your girlfriend broke up with you. So now because you're not getting it with her, you have to sexually assault your own daughter. Oh no, because you're a grown-ass full-blown man adult and you drink too much, it clouded your judgment. I mean, get real." So after sentencing, a small group of people who had learned about the case from Crystal social media and all of the posts that were going viral had protested peacefully outside the hall of justice in Ventura. And I want to explain the sentence a little bit because I know the numbers are confusing and they are a reason that a lot of people are angry and, in my opinion, rightfully so. Right away by sentencing him to one year in county jail, the judge was signaling that this whole thing was going to be on the low end. Then in the credits that he was given, in California eligible defendants earn credits that reduce their actual time in custody by 50%. So a one-year sentence becomes a six-month sentence. That's the law. It's not something that the judge invented for this case. It just is a law that applies broadly to various cases. And on top of all of that, remember Steven had already been credited with 88 days that he had served before the sentencing. So one year, cut in half by credits minus the time he had already served, it comes out to five months and three weeks. That's how his one-year sentence, one-year bullshit sentence, I should say, became less than six months behind bars. And I'm not telling you this to make you feel better about it and the outcome, obviously not. You should be enraged. I'm enraged. I'm just trying to tell you a little bit about how the law works and how this all happened. I want you to understand the machinery behind it. Because when people hear one year, but then five months, they think, oh, somebody made a mistake, someone cut a deal in the back room, something happened. But this is just how it works legally. So that then brings us to why this case is back in the headlines. Because last week, last Monday, on November 9, 2026, Steven Chavez walked out of into her county jail. A free man. After serving, let half of his one-year sentence. So this, to me, sends a message that you can give alcohol to a minor. You can sexually assault your own daughter. You can be guilty of incest. And all you get is a slap on the wrist and you get to walk free after a few months in jail and get to live the rest of your life. Well, Michaela doesn't get to live her life. Her family has to live their life without her and with the trauma of knowing what she endured at the hands of you as a full fucking monster. It is just, I don't even think enraging is the right word anymore. It's just so incredibly disheartening that this happened and that this things like this happen all the time. Now, the conditions of his release are strict, at least on paper. Three years of felony probation, no drugs, no alcohol, no contact with Michaela's family or friends, no firearms, no pornography and 20 years on the registry. But here's the part that the family is most afraid of. As of last week, no one knows where he is. Fox 11 reported that his current location is unknown. And as somebody on the registry, that is terrifying to think about. He has five days to provide a new address, five days only, which at the time of this recording, he hasn't. The family said that they will publicize it when he does, which looking forward to that. But meanwhile, Michaela's family is not sitting quietly. They're not going to just sit by idly and watch this monster get to live his life and move on. So they're distributing beware flyers everywhere that has his photo on them. He wants to warn communities and make sure that people know who he is and what he did. Her mom also spent last Monday in a cemetery sitting next to Michaela's grave. That's where she was when her daughter's father walked out of jail a free man and she said, quote, it hurts all over again. It's yet another date that we have to remember and it's painful. My daughter's life meant way more than six months. She also said that she's worried about her own safety because of how loudly she has been speaking out about this case on social media. She's worried about the safety of any teenagers that Stephen made me in the future too, saying, if he starts drinking, I absolutely think that it would happen to someone else. She also said that the release motivates her to keep fighting, to advocate for greater accountability for sexual predators, especially those whose victims die by self-harm. She said she did everything right, and it still didn't matter. And I want to make changes in her name. I don't want this to happen again. And she's not just talking about change. After she learned that Stephen was being released, Carolina launched a change.org petition. It demands justice for Michaela and changes to sentencing laws around sexual assault. In it, she wrote that Michaela felt that she had no way out after what her father did to her. She called his punishment a gross miscarriage of justice and insult to survivors of sexual assault. And she's asking people to help make sure that Michaela's story leads to real change so that another family doesn't have to go through the same thing that they did, which that's why I'm talking about this case in a bigger way today, to be a platform for Michaela's story and Michaela's mom. I'm going to put the petition in the show notes for you too so you can see all of that. And really, it's about getting loud about this injustice because that's where this case stands right now. It's an injustice. A young woman who did everything right. He pleaded guilty to incest to giving alcohol to a minor. He admitted that he took advantage of a position of trust. He admitted that Michaela was particularly vulnerable. Yet he got one year in county jail served less than six months, and now he's out walking the streets. And again, if a guilty plea to incest and a dead 18-year-old Girl and a family that did everything right is only worth one
in jail and less than six months actually served? What is the system actually saying here? What kind of message are they portraying? This is why, as her cousin said, people don't come forward because there's no real accountability or justice. And look, I don't really have a clean answer for that. The DA says that they charged him with what they could prove. The judge said that he couldn't impose more of a sentence without Stephen's consent because there was no prior criminal history. The law says that credits cut the time in half, so every piece of it on its own does have its own explanation. But when you put all of it together and you look at what Michaela's family is left with, it doesn't feel like justice, not in the least bit. And the judge said that himself. So then where do we fill in that gap? Especially also knowing about the allegation from Christmas before Michaela even moved in with her father, right? That should illustrate pattern, premeditation, history. But I understand it's hard to prove that in court when Michaela is no longer here to testify. But then it's like, where do special circumstances come into play of proposing the question of like, or the statement rather of like, well, here's why she's not here to testify. Look at all of this. Look at all of these things leading up to it. As I said, the civil case goes to its first hearing on November 20th. And that is the next chapter in this case. I will keep you updated on it too because this story is not over. And at least in the civil case, maybe he will be held accountable on paper at least. Michaela Settles his daughter was only 18 years old. She was funny. She was outgoing. She was full of life. She wanted to own her own nail salon. She wanted to do things with her life and be her own boss. And she moved to California to start a new chapter with her dad. A new chapter that he abruptly ended and she didn't get to finish. And I keep thinking about that same question that her mom asked, right? If that's not sexual assault, what is? It's a fair question. And it's one that a lot of people are asking, not just in this case, but in other cases as well. There's a huge gap between what happened and what the law calls it. Yeah, Michaela was 18. She was an adult. She was drunk. Her father gave her the alcohol, but he's the one who had sex with her while she was intoxicated. She's the one who couldn't walk. She's the one who had to be carried into an ER and get a sane exam. She's the one who vocally said it was an assault. There was a forensic exam for crying out loud like, come on. There was a charge of incest clearly. The writing was on the wall here, but the DA said that they charged what they could prove beyond a reasonable doubt. And that even after Michaela died, they looked at it again, but their position did not change. So I don't know if that's not disheartening. What is? And I understand the family side in all of this because from where they are sitting, the system looked at everything that Michaela did right and still gave the man who did this to her less than six months. And this young girl, she just, she deserved so much more. And I can't help but think too about the aftermath of all of this and her family and what they're going through as a mom and her mom should certainly not beat herself up over this. I can only imagine myself being in that situation, wondering in those five months between her moving back home and her taking her own life like, could I have intervened more? Should I have forced more therapy? Should I have done something? What could I have done? What should I have looked for? And those are questions I would imagine her mom is battling with day in and day out. The responsibility though, of course, is not on her. It never was on her. It's on this monster of a father who groomed and lured his daughter to him to only two days later, inflict a four-hour sexual assault on his daughter. And you know what, Stephen? I know I'm not dropping the word allegedly. Come for me. Try to assume me for defamation if you want. Like, your name needs to be known. It needs to be heard. And this is so crazy to me that this guy is just out walking the streets right now. It is infuriating. This poor girl, what she went through, only to then be called a liar by her own dad, saying no was consensual. She wanted to have sex with me too. It was just really rough sex. It is so sinister and dark and torturous. I don't even know how else to describe it. It just, as you can see, I'm kind of going off the rails here. It just enrages me so much. So posted, I will let you know where the civil case goes. I will let you know if we hear more information whether a civil court agrees and we'll just have to wait and see. But like I said, the family is not waiting quietly. Her mom is speaking out. She's advocating for change. She wants the law to be different for the next family and for the next girl who does everything right, but still doesn't get justice. So that is today's episode and today's case. That is Michaela settles story. I'm not going to forget her name and I hope that you don't either. Thank you for tuning in to another episode with me today. I know that it was an upsetting one, but Michaela's story deserves to be heard. And this creep deserves to have his name broadcast everywhere with a huge warning label across him. Predator. Predator. Predator. Predator. Until the next one. Be nice. Don't kill people. And stop inflicting incest on your family members. Consensual or not consensual. I don't even care. It's gross. Stop it. All right. Bye.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Michaela Settles, an 18-year-old from North Carolina, moved to California to live with her father, Steven Chavez, believing it would be a fresh start, only to be subjected to a four-hour sexual assault after being given alcohol.
Steven Chavez admitted to felony incest and furnishing alcohol to a minor, but was not charged with rape or sexual assault, with prosecutors citing lack of evidence for non-consent due to Michaela’s absence.
After the assault, Michaela returned to North Carolina, struggled with severe trauma, and died by suicide five months later, with her family claiming the assault directly contributed to her death.
The case drew national attention when the Ventura County District Attorney reviewed the evidence and affirmed that only incest and alcohol charges were legally supported, despite allegations of grooming and premeditated abuse.
Steven pleaded guilty to incest and alcohol charges in May 2026, was sentenced to one year in county jail (served less than six months), and was released on November 9, 2026, with strict probation and registry requirements.
Michaela’s mother and family launched a wrongful death lawsuit and a Change.org petition demanding systemic reform and accountability for sexual predators, emphasizing the lack of justice in the outcome.
The family believes the legal system failed to recognize the severity of the abuse, especially given Michaela’s vulnerability, the assault’s brutality, and the psychological trauma inflicted.
The case highlights a significant gap between the reality of sexual violence and legal definitions, where trauma, intoxication, and familial power dynamics are not adequately reflected in sentencing.
Summary:
Michaela Settles, an 18-year-old aspiring entrepreneur from North Carolina, moved to California to live with her father, Steven Chavez, hoping for a new beginning. Two days after arriving, she was allegedly sexually assaulted by him after being fed excessive alcohol. The assault, which lasted four hours and left her physically and mentally traumatized, prompted her to call her mother in distress.
Despite DNA evidence and a rape exam confirming the assault, Steven was not charged with sexual assault or rape. Instead, he was charged only with felony incest and furnishing alcohol to a minor—charges the family and advocates believe are grossly inadequate given the severity of the crime. Michaela returned to North Carolina and struggled with lasting trauma, eventually taking her own life five months later.
After a guilty plea in 2026, Steven was sentenced to one year in county jail—served less than six months—and released in November 2026, with no restrictions on travel or contact. His release has sparked outrage, as the family sees it as a systemic failure to protect minors and hold predators accountable. Michaela’s mother and sister have since launched a wrongful death lawsuit and a public petition demanding legal reforms to prevent similar tragedies.
The case underscores a critical gap in how sexual violence, especially within family structures, is defined and punished under the law, with many questioning whether the legal system truly recognizes the harm of such abuse, particularly when victims are silenced or dismissed. The family continues to advocate for change, emphasizing that justice should not be measured by time served, but by the protection of vulnerable individuals and the acknowledgment of real trauma.
FAQs
After the assault, Michaela returned to North Carolina with her mother and sister. She struggled with severe trauma and mental health issues, and in December 2025, she attempted suicide and died in the hospital five months later. Her family believes the assault directly contributed to her death due to the lasting psychological trauma.
No, Michaela was not charged with rape or sexual assault. She was charged with felony incest and a misdemeanor for furnishing alcohol to a minor. The prosecutors stated they charged only what they could prove beyond a reasonable doubt, and no criminal charge for sexual assault was filed.
Prosecutors argued that the lack of direct testimony from Michaela—since she died—made it difficult to prove non-consent, especially given that she was intoxicated. The legal system prioritized charges that could be proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and sexual assault requires proving lack of consent, which was not established in court.
He was sentenced to one year in Ventura County jail, but served less than half due to credits and early release. After serving 88 days, he was released on May 18, 2026, after pleading guilty to incest and furnishing alcohol to a minor, and was given 3 years of probation and 20 years on a sex offender registry.
The family alleges that Steven Chavez began grooming Michaela as early as Christmas 2024, giving her alcohol and leaving her in her underwear. This pattern of behavior, combined with false claims of consent, suggests premeditated abuse and a history of exploitation before the 2025 assault.
Yes, a wrongful death lawsuit was filed by Michaela’s mother, alleging that her father’s actions caused her death through intentional emotional distress and negligence. The civil case is scheduled for a hearing in November 2026 and seeks monetary damages, not criminal punishment.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.