#332: "All Instinct, No Rational Thought," and Other Myths About Intuitive Eating - with Elyse Resch
38m 21s
Intuitive eating is not about blindly following hunger and fullness cues or rejecting rational thought. Instead, it's a balanced, dynamic process that integrates instinct, emotion, and rational analysis to support true autonomy and well-being. Elise Rash, a registered dietitian and co-author of the intuitive eating movement, shares how the latest edition of her workbook now includes critical content on social justice, food insecurity, and eating disorder recovery, challenging outdated and harmful narratives. She emphasizes that intuitive eating is compatible with eating disorder healing and should never be reduced to a hunger-based diet. A new app, "Savvy," is being developed as a supportive, accessible tool to help individuals engage with intuitive eating principles through daily exercises and interactive prompts—offering a counter to diet culture apps that co-opt intuitive eating as a marketing tool. The app is designed to promote self-compassion, emotional awareness, and personal insight, especially for those navigating diet culture or recovering from disordered eating. Key to this model is the recognition that rational thought, emotional regulation, and context (like illness or stress) are essential components of intuitive eating. Rash also addresses the misconception that ultra-processed foods make intuitive eating impossible, arguing that such language creates false dichotomies and reinforces shame. Ultimately, intuitive eating fosters long-term health by empowering people to make informed, compassionate choices rooted in self-knowledge, not restriction. The conversation underscores the importance of evolution in both personal and professional practices, highlighting the need for ongoing learning, empathy, and inclusion in all aspects of food and body wellness.
The grand opening of your neighborhood mites is here, and this is your grand
invitation to experience a new kind of complete auto care. It's your grand
introduction to our team of skilled technicians. Ready to let you know what needs
fixing now and what can wait. And with everything from routine oil changes to
brand new tires, there's no grander opportunity to feel more confident in your
ride. Visit mites now at 170 East South Loop and get a 29.99 synthetic blend or 64.99
full synthetic oil change with tire rotation and visual break check. Welcome to
food psych, a podcast dedicated to critiquing diet and wellness culture and
answering your questions about intuitive eating and the anti diet approach. I'm
your host Christy Harrison and I'm a registered dietitian certified
intuitive eating counselor journalist and author of the books anti diet, the
wellness trap, and the new emotional eating chronic dieting binge eating and
body image workbook, which are all available wherever you get your books or
at Christy Harrison dot com slash books. That's Christy Harrison dot com slash
books. And by the way, on this show, we avoid diet culture details like weight and
calorie numbers, but we don't censor swear words or other adult language, so
listener discretion is advised.
Hey there. Welcome back to another episode of food psych. This one is
cross posted from my other podcast rethinking wellness and in it, I'm talking
with registered dietitian and intuitive eating co author Elise rash who returns
to help dispel myths about intuitive eating, including that it means only
listening to instinct and not the rational brain that it's incompatible
with eating disorder recovery that it's impossible in an environment rife with
quote unquote ultra processed foods and more. She also shares her definition of
gentle nutrition plus some behind the scenes looks at the latest books in the
i.e. series and her new intuitive eating app and development. This was a great
conversation and I can't wait to share it with you. First, I want to let you
know about some resources you might find helpful. One of which is my third book,
the emotional eating chronic dieting binge eating and body image workbook,
which I co authored with therapist Judith Matt and Amy Pershing. They're both
longtime leaders in the field of diet culture recovery binge eating disorder and
trauma informed care and also multi time guests on this podcast and it was
really honored to work with them to create this workbook. We designed it for
clinicians and general readers alike in a way that we hope will help you break
free from the diet binge or restrict rebound cycle recognize sneaky diets
designed as wellness plans better understand the role food plays in your life
and in managing emotions unlearn harmful messages about when and what you're
supposed to eat dispel myths about weight health and fitness and lots more we've
heard from general readers and clinicians that this book has been so helpful to
them in the process of recovery or helping their clients recover and we hope you'll
check it out as well. You can learn more and buy the book at christieharrison.com/workbook
or click the link in the show notes. I also wanted to let you know that my
online course Intuitive Eating Fundamentals is now open for enrollment. The
course is designed to teach you how to recognize and reject a diet culture take
pleasure in food and stop fighting your desires tune back into your body's
signals of hunger and fullness and the restrict rebound cycle. Navigate
emotional eating and learn new coping skills while also making peace with food
in your body and most importantly avoid turning intuitive eating into a sneaky
new diet. Sign up for instant access to hundreds of hours of supportive
content including 13 modules on the principles of intuitive eating deep dives
into how to handle common things that come up when you're trying to make
peace with food and a live monthly Q&A to help answer all your questions. This
cohort also includes a special members only forum so that you can connect with
others and support each other through the course and alumni will get access to
future forums as well. Learn more and sign up at christieharrison.com/course or
click the link in the show notes and now without any further ado here's my
conversation with the lease rash. You were last on the podcast in January of
2024 actually January 1st of 2024 so it's been about a year a little over a
year and I'd love for you to just catch us up on what you've been up to since
then because you've had a lot going on right you just had a new edition of the
workbook that came out tell us about that. Lots of things well let's start with
that yes January 2nd was the official publication date of the workbook and
interestingly I just opened my mail this morning and found ventures is a newsletter
for nutrition entrepreneurs which is a practice group of the American Academy
of Nutrition and Dietetics. They came out with this just wonderful review of the
book and I had I had a couple of just quick lines from it that I thought would be
helpful to read to your you know to your listeners this is not the whole thing
obviously but particularly notable is the addition of a chapter on social
justice which explores how systemic issues like weight stigma intersect with
personal experiences. This perspective is crucial for practitioners aiming to
provide equitable and inclusive care I thought that was so important and then
toward the end they say overall this workbook is more than a guide it's a call to
action for practitioners to challenge harmful norms and foster healthier
more sustainable relationships with food so I thought I thought they did a good
job they set some other nice things in there too so I'm really excited about it
it's updated we sent it out to four different sensitivity readers to make
sure that you know anything in the book was appropriate and got some
wonderful feedback worked very hard on it and that's now out and then in
May we're going to start writing the fifth edition of Intuitive Eating. Oh my
gosh you guys don't stop. New Harbinger is the is the workbook but St.
Martin's we talked with our editor there and she's like yeah we love this
book of course they love selling books and we're very excited about that and
we'll be adding a lot of stuff in their social justice of course I want to I
really want to update the eating disorder chapter by the way on the workbook we
have a chapter on social justice as I just said and then there's a chapter on
incorporating Intuitive Eating into Eating Disorder Treatment which I think is
so important because there's so much misinformation out there about you know
Intuitive Eating in relation to eating disorders one of my bugaboo's is when
it's said oh no you can never use Intuitive Eating with eating disorders and it's
such a reductionist way of thinking about it yeah so that's that's gonna be in
there too and I want to write some other things I want to write about polyvagal
theory a little bit not so much that it would bore people but just to
understand a little bit more about how our bodies work and you know how Intuitive Eating
actually helps us regulate ourselves so I really would love to dig in a little
bit about the eating disorders and Intuitive Eating piece because I know that is
a common misconception and I don't think we've talked about it we certainly
haven't talked about on this podcast maybe we talked about it a million years
ago on food psych my first podcast but you know for people who haven't and I don't
even know if we have actually haven't gone back and listen to those but I'm just
curious to hear your perspective on like why is it such a method you can't use
Intuitive Eating with eating disorders well because the narrative out there is
that Intuitive Eating is all about just hunger and fullness and sure obviously
ultimately we want to help people you know become attuned to and trust their
bodies the signals of you know if their bodies give them but when someone is
engaged in eating disorder or you know in the beginning stages of healing those
signals are not accurate there's so many physiological and neurochemical reasons
why the signals aren't accurate so okay you're not going to be able to trust
those signals until you're more nourished for anyone with the needing disorder
however Intuitive Eating brings up so much else you know challenging
diaculture making peace with food respecting the body understanding your
emotions and there's so many other aspects that can be used day one there is a
treatment program out there I don't know if I'm supposed to mention any that's a
wonderful one that gives each of their clients a or yeah the people that are in
their copy of Intuitive Eating from the beginning they talk about the whole
concept of Intuitive Eating versus just hunger and fullness so I think that's the
main reason and then it says to me that people who say that really don't
understand Intuitive Eating yeah they're just treating it as a hunger and
fullness diet right and they're just saying like you can only eat when you're
hungry you have to stop when you're full this is like the only aspect of Intuitive
Eating it's important and it's not just in the eating disorder world it's just
out there in the world you know in the disorder eating world or that it's turned
into yes social media turning it into the hunger fullness diet and there are
a number of myths about Intuitive Eating but one of them is that Intuitive Eating
is the way that you're gonna be able to lose weight and it's so the opposite of
that I do want to say that when the first book came out the first edition that
was in 1995 30 years ago there was something in the first edition I think was
even on the cover that said something about find your natural weight or
something and this is I do have to have you know a sense of compassion
self-compassion compassion for both of us as writers co-author Evelyn and I
that we were not as evolved as we are now and it was never to be said that
this is about losing weight in fact your weight could say the same it could
go up it could go down but because the word weight was on the cover it was a big
problem and that's of course been taken off for many years all the additions
you know on the fourth edition as I said going into the fifth edition and next
one
So maybe that's where that myth came from.
But that is not what intuitive eating is.
It is not another diet for weight loss.
Yeah, I know.
Thank you for sharing that.
And I think I think that is the problem with being an author of books,
like physical things that exist in the world when you're evolving past whatever you wrote
in there. Like it's, it's a tricky thing.
I mean, online too, you know, if you write online.
And but at least with that, sometimes if it's your own content online,
you can update it yourself.
Whereas with books, you have to rely on another edition and people understanding
that the new edition supersedes the old edition and that they're probably going to find
much more relevant and current information in the new edition.
I think sometimes people don't really understand that.
I mean, I know when I was like in college and shopping for books too,
I was like, what can I just get the cheapest book possible?
And oh, it's an earlier edition, okay, fine, I'll just do that, you know?
So I think that maybe those editions are still floating around out there too.
And how full to know just like, yeah, don't look at that.
Look at the newer ones.
And I think it's also very important that it kind of showcases how we need to have empathy,
compassion for ourselves, for others, for not judging, for looking at things and with
clear eyes and taking in all the changes and nuances and all of that.
And not, I mean, there are some people that just, well, that's what you said then.
And so I'm going to believe that and have no empathy for the fact that we need to
be honoring what we need to change based on how we learn.
That's what life is about.
We have to evolve on a regular basis.
I don't want to be around anyone who doesn't evolve, you know?
I feel like the people who evolve are the most interesting and I don't think anyone really
doesn't evolve.
I think some people just don't really understand other people's evolution, you know?
Well, there's plenty of people today that are devolving if that's a word, you know, going
backwards.
The TNT fiber brings the whole neighborhood together on Gain Day.
And we're underway here on Maple Drive folks, looks like Cindy's already introducing
the new neighbors.
That's right, she'll have them feeling it home by half time.
And Steve's making the walk across the street carrying a folding chair and what appears
to be homemade potato salad.
Oh, that's a veteran move.
Across the way the Garcia's have the game on outside.
One screen on the patio, replay on the tablet, and Grandpa, he's joined in from Phoenix,
hasn't missed an opening kickoff in five years.
That's four screens and counting.
It doesn't seem to be slowing him down one bit.
Nobody's missing a moment.
Here we go, replay coming up.
Half the neighborhoods watching it on the TV, the other half's already checking every
angle on their tablets.
Afternoon, fellas.
Oh, hey, Ted.
Well, you're broadcasting too.
Mostly ourselves.
We take Gain Day seriously.
Yeah, I'd say the neighborhood does too.
Never miss a moment on Gain Day with unlimited, hyperfast, reliable AT&T fiber internet.
Learn more at ATT.com/internet, limited availability in select areas.
Well, thank you for sharing that.
And I think that's useful for people to hear, you know, like how the, how the new edition
has changed.
And I'm curious why you felt it was important to include that new material.
I mean, obviously, evolution is happening and your own evolution.
Was there anything in the last, the previous workbook that, in the intervening years, because
it came out in 2017?
Was there anything that started to feel like it was really missing or, and that's why
you wanted to include it?
Well, I think it's more about my own personal journey of being an advocate, you know, for
social justice and framing so much of my work through a lens of social justice.
And knowing that it's a topic that had to be, you know, addressed, included, understanding
how much oppression there is in the world for anyone with a marginalized identity.
And poor people who are suffering from weight stigma and the, the physical and mental effects
of being rejected and things projected on them.
And we can't look at just simply the importance and I don't mean the word simply as I'm saying
it, but the importance of being in tune with your body and, you know, having satisfaction
and enjoying your food.
I mean, we have to recognize, first of all, that there is food insecurity in the world.
This is mentioned in the book too, we need to talk about the fact that not everybody can
get enough food.
So it's part of the social justice, you know, concept in it.
And look at how, I was mentioning compassion before, it's like, we have to have compassion
for people in the world who don't fit that, you know, stereotypical, who does anyway,
you know, I don't know that there's anybody who really does.
So I think it was more coming from that.
I spent a lot of time with my teenage clients by the way, talking about social justice,
which has been so interesting for me, the openness of some of the teenagers, you know, when
they're coming to me because of their eating disorder and their focus on being as small
as they can be.
And I talked to them about this, it's like a light bulb goes off in their minds.
It's, oh, yeah, I mean, I believe everybody should have, you know, equal treatment and
justice and respect and all of that.
But here I am promoting something that actually in the opposite of it affects so many people.
So I think it's that it's also, this is going to sound pretty too large, maybe, but I'm
Jewish and in my religion, one of the values of it is something called, and I may have mentioned
this before on a podcast, I don't know, but it's called Tikkun Olam, which basically says
repairing the world.
That is our job while we're on this planet to do something when we leave that has, you
know, helped the world.
And so that's always been part of my value system and always part of what's driven my work.
And so I think repairing the world includes taking a look at all of the oppressions in
the world, including, as I said, weight stigma and all of that.
You're also working on a new intuitive eating app, which sounds very exciting.
Can you tell us about that?
Well, this is the most exciting.
I mean, not that the books aren't exciting, of course they are.
This is something new and different.
It's something I will say has always been my dream.
I've always wanted to have an intuitive eating app, but I have to admit that I am very technologically
challenged.
I'm kind of proud of myself that I know how to use a computer and a iPhone and all that.
But so there was no way that I was going to be able to do it on my own.
And I'm not this incredibly lovely woman who comes from a different world, she has an
MBA and understands technology and all of that.
I've been collaborating for a year now to bring this forward.
The name of the app is savvy, S-A-V-V-Y, intuitive eating.
And I love the word because savvy, you know, it's a knowing, right?
We built the app as a companion for anyone who's on an intuitive eating journey.
And it includes daily exercises and lessons.
So people can get, really get in touch with their psychology, you know, the root of their
thoughts and their feelings and around food in their bodies and change their mindset and
habits so that it serves their whole well-being.
And what's so important about having this app is the accessibility.
Not everyone can work with a certified intuitive eating counselor.
Not everyone can necessarily have reading skills that helps them stay focused on a book.
So this is accessible to everyone and we really wanted to include younger generations, especially
who are, they spend so much time on their phones.
I think of it as they're kind of velcroed to their phones.
We can pull the phone off of them but, you know, it goes slapping back on them.
And there are so many competing diet apps and posts and social media that are diet culture
oriented.
In fact, let me say this without mentioning that there is an app out there, a diet culture
app that has actually used my words, words I have written in one or two of the books.
And it's infuriating.
They're out there, some of them saying that they're about intuitive eating, but they're
really not their diet culture.
So we want to have all of these, all people, and especially the young people who are so
entrenched in diet culture to, you know, create an alternative, it's a compliment in the
books, and I'm not saying that people won't be reading the book, but it's a compliment.
And there's so many things that can be done in technology in terms of personalization
and interaction and feedback and live support that obviously as the app, you know, grows
and proves over time we're going to be adding so many more of these components to it.
So it's super, super, super exciting and I can't believe it's actually happening.
We're going to have a soft launch in March, and Christy, if you're interested, I'll send
it to you.
I would love to see it.
Yes.
Yes, absolutely.
What's so great about working, her name is Caitlin, and what's wonderful about working
with Caitlin is that she's been on our own intuitive eating journey, which she's very
public about, and she brings her own lived experience to it, but she also brings a lot
of wisdom from the work she's done in her life in other ways, you know, in her field
and her professional fields.
And I bring in so much content and it's so much fun.
We meet every week for two hours, so it's quite a commitment.
It's been going on for a year.
And it's brainstorming sessions that we have.
And she'll ask me a very important question about, well, how do you think we should present
this or that?
And we go back and forth and we come to agreement that's going to be the best for
the world.
So thank you for asking about it, but it is, it's just so exciting.
That's really exciting.
I'm excited to see it because what you describe with the prompts and the activities and
stuff like that.
I'm thinking when you said psychology, and my mind immediately went to noom, right?
The diet app that calls itself anti-diet, it co-ops into a intuitive eating that, you
know, says that it's about intuitive eating, but actually is twisting it in service of
a diet.
And it says that it uses psychology.
and, you know, has these prompts and stuff, but it's actually just like diet tips, you know,
that it's giving people. It's not anything new or different. It's sort of recycling old
diet tips and, and diet culture ideas with a little sprinkling of, like, cherry-picked
intuitive eating thrown at, right, or co-opted into an intuitive eating.
Yeah, and it puts so much responsibility on the person rather than understanding that,
you know, diet culture society has, you know, and the person is a failure and you just have to do
this right. That is, well, since you mentioned it, that is the one I was referring to. And
interestingly, both Evelyn and I decided, well, we're going to sign up for this app to see what
they're doing just, you know, for like a week or so. I couldn't stand it. I mean, I had to get
to just deactivate it very quickly. But when I saw my words, literally my words, you know,
not just generalized, but literally, I was furious. And so the great hope is that savvy
intuitive eating will be something that is such a counter to that and that really gives
what it promises versus, you know, something like gnome, which never anybody gets what they're
promised on a better psychological understanding, you know, better connection with their bodies now.
It's just a reduced calorie restrictive plan. Yeah, good and bad food, rhetoric, all of that stuff.
I'm excited to check it out. Is there, you mentioned, there's sort of an interactive component,
like, almost live coaching or something, is it AI or is it? No, no, no, it's not live coaching
at the moment. It's more of understanding technology to me, oh boy, but it's what the user
is putting in, the information they're putting in, they're going to get responses connected
to what they've said because of so much we're putting into the app. I mean, if I had Caitlin on,
she could explain it to you in a word, technological way. Ultimately, we are going to want to
find a way to connect people to intuitive eating counselors if they need to be. We also are before
anybody starts looking at whether they have an activating disorder, which the app is not for people
with activating disorders that where they need, you know, higher levels of care, because they're
not being monitored on the app, you know, when they go into a program, like I mentioned earlier,
and they're utilizing intuitive eating principles, they also, you know, have people there who are,
whether it's the dietitians or the counselors, the therapists or caregivers or whatever,
who are able to guide them. So, you know, when you're on an app, you're on your own. So we really don't
encourage people who have an activating disorder to start with the app, but eventually,
with any help, anyone who has an eating disorder and is getting treatment and is evolving from,
and, you know, healing from it, this is a great companion for them to help solidify so much
of what they've learned. And can they work through with our treatment team as well? Is there a way to
like collaborate on it or? Well, I think that right now, it's not, you know, there's not a collaboration,
I was not even out yet. So we're going to be improving it and changing it as time goes on,
but it is something that they can bring with them. It's something they can do on their own,
going through the intuitive eating, you know, the lessons and the exercises and bring that to
their counselors. And I am, you know, hopeful that there will be a lot of counselors who will be
encouraging their clients to get this app and bring what they know, bring what they've learned
into sessions. It's just a, it's a companion, you know, read the book, listen to the book,
you know, use the app and it's really going to help you get a deeper sense of yourself and deeper
sense of intuitive eating, you know, what it's, what it's all about. So I wish I could answer your
questions more technologically. I'm sorry. No, no, that's totally fine. I'm curious to see
when it comes out. And I know I know that the tech stuff is, yeah, different skill set. But it
sounds like to me like it's almost sort of an interactive workbook type thing. And I probably
shouldn't say this as someone who's written a workbook in the presence of someone who's written
multiple workbooks, but I'm like not really a workbook person. I don't, that's not how I learn the
best. I think like I do like to interact with material, but I kind of am more like I'll walk around
listening to it. And so when I did my intuitive eating course, I did audio versions of all the
workbooks too, so that people could do what I do and like listen in the car and just think about
it. And I would create space to kind of answer the journal exercises in my head and stuff like that.
Because that's how I like to do it. And if I'm listening to an audio book of something, I'd like
pause and think about it and jot down some notes or whatever. But I don't really just like sit down
and do a workbook. So I feel like an interactive app could be helpful for someone like me.
I know. Absolutely. And here's the thing. I don't really expect my clients to do the homework
in the workbooks. You know, I have my intuitive eating workbook for teens as well as the grown-up
intuitive eating workbooks. And they're so bombarded with schoolwork that we will often do something
together. You know, we'll do an exercise together in a session. And it's very, very helpful. But I
don't give out assignments, you know, go do this because as I agree with you, we're all so busy,
whether they're teenagers or college students or we're all busy. So having extra homework like that.
But to have this, you know, people carry their phones around. I remember now I'm going to be showing,
you know, showing my age. When I got my first phone in my car, some young people not even understand
this. There was an actual phone that was attached to the car. And it was great because, you know,
it made me fail so much safer in case there's an emergency. I can pick up the phone. And then the,
you know, the mobile phones came out and I thought, oh, I don't want that. I mean, what do I need that
for? And then it was, well, maybe I'll get one. I'll leave it next to my bed in case, you know,
the regular phone goes out and I have, you know, there's some kind of emergency. Well, I don't go
anywhere without my phone now, except when I'm losing it, which is 12 times a day. Where did I come
from? But, you know, it's just a different world. And so I think most people who can of course
afford to have a telephone, well, I actually wonder, well, like there's so many things out in the
world where you have to do it on your phone. What about people who can't afford it? It really
upsets me. But in any case, if you can and you have a phone and, you know, a smart phone and
it's with you all the time. So you could be sitting in somewhere waiting for something to begin,
whether it's a doctor's appointment or a class or whatever, waiting to pick up your child at school
or and you've got it right there and can go into it and, you know, grow with it.
Yeah, that's great. I'm so excited to hear about that and experience it too when it's available to try.
One thing that I would love to dig into today a little bit that we've talked about offline
is the relationship between intuition and rational thought, right? Intuitive eating
and, you know, the idea of rationality. And I think that, I mean, specifically when it comes to
eating, but there's also all these other ways that like intuition is sort of pitted against
rationality and science and stuff like that. I think there's this mistaken notion out there
that intuitive eating means just completely leaning into instinct and cutting yourself off
entirely from the rational part of your brain, right? I know you've heard that criticism before,
but neither of us agrees with that. So can you talk a bit about the role that rational thought
plays in intuitive eating or intuition? Well, I have this model that I think of as intuitive eating
is a dynamic interplay of instinct, emotion and thought, which speaks to several parts of the
brain, the survival part, which is what the, you know, dinosaurs had. It's the part that just gives
you your hunger signals, your fullness signals, your likes, your dislikes. It's, it is instinctual.
However, we have to recognize that emotions and not just emotions, illnesses too can interfere
with our instincts. So we can't just simply say, oh, yeah, you don't have to do anything else,
your body will just tell you. And some of the time it will, boy, mine does. When my blood sugar
starts to drop and I recognize that, I am hungry and I need to eat something, you know, but sometimes
for example, in the beginning of the pandemic, I had clients who had COVID and lost their taste
and their smell. And so they really had no appetite because I think so much of appetite comes from
that those other parts, you know, tasting something, smelling something. However, they had to use
the rational part of their minds to say, oh, gosh, illness has now, you know, interfered with my
instincts. I cannot just trust my instincts right now, but I intellectually, rationally,
which is the neocortex, the rational part of the brain, I know I need to eat. I have to eat
in order to nourish myself and in order to feed my immune system and get better. So I will eat.
And emotions, I mean, we all know that emotions impact our appetite, our hunger signals,
whether it decreases them or increases them or so much of this, you know, the vagus nerve coming
from, you know, messages from the brain to the gut. And so I think that we have to honor these
emotions. We have to look at what may be interfering with our instincts and then be wise enough
to use what we know rationally to feed ourselves. So much of my work is to help people look at all
these three parts. And I teach a lot of what I do is teaching. By the way, I probably said this
on every podcast, but I used to be an elementary school teacher when I got out of college. I taught
second grade and then went back to graduate school later. And so much of what I'm doing is also
giving information to people that they can use rationally to help them make the best decisions
for themselves. For example, talking about how when they're in primal hunger and their
starve, the, you know, instinctual part of the brain is going to release a chemical that's
going to get them to
to eat as much as they possible can to stay alive.
Well, that's a good reason they can call upon
to make sure that they're eating enough throughout the day.
So emotions, how do they affect everything?
How are you feeling when you're really, really anxious?
Okay, I've had a couple of clients
who've had to take exams.
One of them is someone who has a licensed clinical social worker
and she's been one for many years,
but she had to take her exam to,
well, she wasn't licensed yet to get licensed
and she's had an eating disorder for quite a while,
but she knew, and we talked it through,
that she was gonna be anxious,
she was gonna have no appetite,
but she needed to eat really well
before she sat down for a three hour exam.
So, you know, that's a really good example
of where we're using our rational minds
to take a look at our instincts to honor them
to see if they're working for us or not.
Totally, yeah, it goes back to that idea
that in two different meetings,
not just the hunger and fullness diet, right?
There is also this aspect of self-care
and using that rational part of your mind
to say, okay, I'm gonna be hungry,
I'm gonna need to fuel myself for this exam,
but I'm also gonna feel anxious
and so how can I get myself the fuel that I'm gonna need?
And like, I'm probably not gonna feel hungry,
I'm gonna eat when I'm not hungry, you know,
but that doesn't go against intuitive eating.
It actually is intuitive sometimes
to eat when you're not hungry.
- I call it practical hunger.
That's in the journal.
I wrote the intuitive eating journal.
I called it practical hunger.
Look at this interestingly,
so many of the diet culture, you know, models out there
are basically telling you what to do
and you're having to remember, eat it this time,
eat only this food, don't eat that food.
It completely pulls it away from the instincts
and it pulls it away from autonomy
and intuitive eating one of the deepest,
basic psychological foundations of intuitive eating
is autonomy is that we can make decisions for ourselves
without being told what to do out there.
Yes, we need some facts, as I said,
sometimes we need to be taught some things
that we have not learned.
But then it's up to us to make decisions
and die culture, it takes that completely away from you.
So die culture takes away your trust in your instincts
and the hungerfulness diet is only about instincts
and that's not the whole intuitive eating as we just said.
So so many aspects.
And it's also like sort of making hunger and fullness
into this rigid construct that is somebody's telling you
what to do again, you know,
it's sort of an autonomy stripping practice actually
by being like, you can only, when you're hungry,
you have to stop when you're this amount of full
or whatever.
Yeah, and they'll use numbers.
I mean, yes, there's an into, you know,
hunger and full of the scale just to give a person an idea.
Mostly we talk, you know, in the scales we describe,
it's more descriptive of what are you feeling
when you are, you know, like you're neutral.
No, you know, no feeling of hunger or fullness
or you're starting to feel hunger
or you're starting to feel fullness.
So it's unfortunate that some people misinterpret it
and they go, no, I'm only at a 4.2, you know,
so I can't eat yet.
Therefore, I'm not allowed to eat, right?
Right.
And so again, you know, going back to the app
so much of this is explained in there
to people who have misinterpretations of intuitive eating.
And of course, that's in the books, too.
Totally.
I could see an app actually being misinterpreted
as like, do I need an app to tell me
because it's supposed to be just about, you know,
listening to my body or whatever.
So I'm glad you said that that the app is also about
taking away these misinterpretations.
Well, yeah, and it's, there's so many aspects
of intuitive eating that people need to hear
and explain to them and they've grown up.
So many people have grown up in homes
with very rigid eating rules and or family members
who are entrenched in diaculture
and they need to have some new ways of thinking
that they won't get in other places necessarily.
Right.
It's important to have that modeled for you
and then you can kind of decide what to do with it or not.
I've had a few people participants in my courses
or clients be like, well, why do I need all of this
instruction or intellectualization?
Why can't I just eat what I want?
And it usually is people who are sort of looking to like,
listen to their eating disorder actually
or the disordered part of their mind.
I found, you know, that like when people
really shopping at the bit to just throw out
every sort of not restriction,
but throw out every part of knowledge
or like that rational part of the brain,
I feel like it's wanting to go all in
on the hunger and fullness diet or something like that.
And some people wanting to go all in
on making peace with food.
So I'm just gonna eat anything I want
and I'm never gonna stop.
That's not exactly what making peace with food means
and it doesn't honor the concept of habituation,
which is the definition, the greater the stimulus,
the less the response.
So the more that you have permission
for eating what you want,
that's where your body kind of kicks in
and your taste buds kick in
and things, you know, your psychology,
your emotions, it's just not as exciting anymore
because you get to have whatever you want in it.
It doesn't ever go to that place of out of control eating
unless somebody is pseudo intuitive eating.
They're not really digging into intuitive eating.
They're just kind of cherry picking what principle
that they're gonna go with and not look at the whole picture.
- Right, well, that leads us into another sort of criticism
of intuitive eating I would love to talk to you about,
which is that there is this misconception out there,
I think about intuitive eating
and I think this misconception is gonna become more prevalent
as sort of anti-processed food discourse ramps up.
Is this idea that people can't possibly trust
their hunger and fullness cues in this food environment
because there's so much quote unquote bad food, right?
There's all these terrible processed foods
that are engineered to make us not be able to stop
and the real solution is supposedly
to avoid these foods completely, right?
Because you can only be intuitive
with whole minimally processed foods
and you and I would not agree with that
and would not call any foods terrible
and you know, don't subscribe to that rhetoric
but that is the argument I think that's out there
and that I have seen it become more prevalent
over the last few years.
So I'm curious to hear how you respond to that.
- Here's the thing, when that language comes out
it only makes this divide between good and bad foods.
So people hearing that ultra processed foods are bad
and still wanting them.
When they start to eat them
they feel all the same shameful feelings
that diets of any kind produce.
That was the first half of my interview with Elise Rush
and there's lots more juicy stuff to come.
To hear it, become a paid subscriber
at rethinkingwellness.substac.com
or click the link in the show notes.
And if you're already a paid subscriber
and you happen to be hearing this,
look at your welcome email for instructions
on how to set up your special podcast feed
so that you can hear the whole episode seamlessly
in your player.
In the meantime, you can find Elise and learn more
about her work at EliseResh.com
and explore the intuitive eating books
at IntuitiveEating.org.
Thanks so much to her for coming on the show.
If you liked this episode,
I'd love for you to subscribe or follow
rethinkingwellness on Apple podcasts, Spotify,
or wherever you listen.
Thanks for being here and I'll talk to you soon.
Take care.
At Cox, your internet and mobile price
won't change for five years.
That's five new year celebrations.
Five Valentine's days.
Five Fourth of July.
Five Halloween's.
Five Thanksgiving's.
And five summers that go by too fast.
Through it all, your price stays the same
with our five-year price lock guarantee.
Cox, a step ahead.
Requires two gig speeds and gig unlimited mobile.
Taxes and fees excluded from price lock.
Mobile data speed reduced after 20 gigs.
The grand opening of your neighborhood, Midas is here.
And this is your grand invitation
to experience a new kind of complete auto care.
It's your grand introduction to our team
of skilled technicians,
ready to let you know what needs fixing now
and what can wait.
Visit Midas now at 170 East South Loop
and get a 29.99 synthetic blend
or 64.99 full synthetic oil change
with tire rotation and visual break check.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Intuitive eating is a dynamic interplay of instinct, emotion, and rational thought, not just reliance on hunger and fullness signals.
The new edition of the intuitive eating workbook includes chapters on social justice, food insecurity, and eating disorder recovery, emphasizing equity and compassion.
Intuitive eating is not a weight-loss diet and is fully compatible with eating disorder recovery, challenging common misconceptions.
A new intuitive eating app, "Savvy," is being developed to offer accessible, interactive tools for self-reflection and mindset shifts, especially for younger generations.
The app avoids diet culture by focusing on psychological understanding, personalization, and body autonomy, not restrictive rules or calorie counting.
Rational thought is essential in intuitive eating to navigate emotional and physiological disruptions, such as illness or stress.
Misconceptions about intuitive eating—especially regarding ultra-processed foods—can reinforce diet culture by creating false binaries of "good" and "bad" foods.
Intuitive eating promotes autonomy, self-compassion, and long-term well-being by honoring both bodily signals and rational decision-making.
Summary:
Intuitive eating is not about blindly following hunger and fullness cues or rejecting rational thought. Instead, it's a balanced, dynamic process that integrates instinct, emotion, and rational analysis to support true autonomy and well-being. Elise Rash, a registered dietitian and co-author of the intuitive eating movement, shares how the latest edition of her workbook now includes critical content on social justice, food insecurity, and eating disorder recovery, challenging outdated and harmful narratives.
She emphasizes that intuitive eating is compatible with eating disorder healing and should never be reduced to a hunger-based diet. A new app, "Savvy," is being developed as a supportive, accessible tool to help individuals engage with intuitive eating principles through daily exercises and interactive prompts—offering a counter to diet culture apps that co-opt intuitive eating as a marketing tool. The app is designed to promote self-compassion, emotional awareness, and personal insight, especially for those navigating diet culture or recovering from disordered eating.
Key to this model is the recognition that rational thought, emotional regulation, and context (like illness or stress) are essential components of intuitive eating. Rash also addresses the misconception that ultra-processed foods make intuitive eating impossible, arguing that such language creates false dichotomies and reinforces shame. Ultimately, intuitive eating fosters long-term health by empowering people to make informed, compassionate choices rooted in self-knowledge, not restriction.
The conversation underscores the importance of evolution in both personal and professional practices, highlighting the need for ongoing learning, empathy, and inclusion in all aspects of food and body wellness.
FAQs
Midas offers complete auto care services including oil changes, tire rotation, and visual brake checks. Customers can get a 29.99 synthetic blend or 64.99 full synthetic oil change with these additional services.
No, intuitive eating is a dynamic interplay of instinct, emotion, and rational thought. It doesn't ignore rational thinking or emotion, and it emphasizes autonomy, self-care, and understanding the body’s signals in context.
Yes, intuitive eating can be used in recovery. It’s not incompatible with eating disorder treatment and helps challenge diet culture myths. It supports emotional regulation and body respect, especially when used as part of a broader treatment plan.
The app is called 'Savvy Intuitive Eating.' It offers daily exercises, lessons, and psychological prompts to help users connect with their body, emotions, and food choices, and serves as a supportive tool for intuitive eating journeys.
No, the app does not offer live coaching or AI support at launch. It provides personalized feedback based on user input and includes guided exercises, but live interaction is not available yet.
Yes, common myths include the idea that intuitive eating is just about hunger and fullness, or that it leads to weight loss. In reality, it’s about autonomy, emotional awareness, and rejecting diet culture, not losing weight.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.