Go back

3 - Meet the Top Troll

31m 38s

3 - Meet the Top Troll

The podcast explores the operations of elite PR strategists like Grace, who run highly organized, sophisticated digital campaigns for political candidates. Grace, portrayed as a "digital pioneer," leverages meme accounts, hashtags, and signal scrambling tactics to dominate social media narratives and discredit opponents. Her strategies—rooted in media valuation and influencer networks—demonstrate a professional, almost scientific approach to online influence. These operations are conducted through unregulated boutique PR agencies, which provide plausible deniability and operate without formal accountability. A key theme is the systemic passing of blame: political figures deflect responsibility, attributing harmful content to external actors like influencers or PR firms. The research highlights a broader industry failure where PR professionals are seen as tools of disinformation rather than ethical communicators. Despite the tactics being technically effective, the study raises ethical concerns, questioning whether such strategies could have been redirected for public good—such as during the pandemic—had more accountability and transparency existed. The findings suggest that disinformation thrives not just from individual actors but from systemic gaps in media regulation, industry ethics, and public digital literacy. The researchers argue that prevention—through better regulation and responsible practices—is more effective than relying on individual discernment to combat misinformation.

Transcription

4652 Words, 26126 Characters

English
the setting was super fancy. My colleague, Jason, I scheduled an interview with this PR strategist for our research. We'll call her Grace and we got a voice actor to read her lines directly from our transcript. I was like very good I felt in marketing. Even if I'm a peer person I would handle the shoots, I would handle the concept, the bags and everything and even the taglines and then the hashtags. I always guarantee a hashtag to a client because I'm sure it's gonna go number one. Grace first told us she'd have us over in her apartment that she changed venues. Said she would treat us to drinks in their hotel bar. Yes, the hotel bar she actually lives in a luxury apartment connected to a five-star hotel in the business district. We asked her how she got into doing PR for politicians. I felt that they were all ignorant with social media. They had no creative juices. What I see in the province are the usual faces. One thing about marketing, you just need to win in anything. There's a lot of political things, showbiz for ugly people. So I was at the peak of one mountain in San Monica. I felt that I've overcome a lot of the competitions with the other industries. Every time I enter a war I find a way to win. To me everything is warrior like in marketing or whatever. A lot of times I won. This is where our story begins. Hello, I'm Jonathan Ong. This information researcher and professor at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst and Harvard University. And I'm Kat Ventura, a journalist and executive producer at MOA Podcast. In this podcast we take you deep into the shadowy world of political campaigns, patrols and disinformation networks in the Philippines. This is catch me if you can. Powered by MOA Podcast. Hello, Jonathan. We're back and this is episode three. Yes, I'm so exciting. Thank you everybody for listening. We're already getting so much engagement and tweets from everybody. So good to be here. So we started with trolls and then we went to influencers and now we're at the top here. These are the big guys. No, Jonathan. So these are the head trolls, the trolls behind the trolls in our research. We call them the chief architects of network disinformation. And we reveal in our report that they're likely to be coming from advertising and PR agencies. So these are people who do corporate PR and also do sidelines for politicians, especially during election cycles, like right now. Yes, definitely. As we unpack the top here, just something to note, we are using transcripts from Jonathan's research before. So what we're doing now is, and you heard it a while ago, we got a voice actress to read some of the transcript and to sort of try to bring life to their stories as well. We will also respect their anonymity because we understand the industry and how it works. And of course, as we've been saying, from the beginning, they don't want to be called trolls. No one actually calls them trolls. And it's like an open secret, but the secret nonetheless. Yes, so this week, we have a very special guest, my co-author for Architects of Network Disinformation, Jason Kabanias, who is professor at Dallas Health University Department of Communication. Welcome, Jayce. Thank you, Jonathan, and that's so very happy to be part of this podcast of yours. Yeah, thank you for joining us. Jayce, we want to take you down memory lane and hearing the transcripts come to life with this voice actress, let's revisit the story of how we met Grace and what we learned from her story. So we first heard of Grace during an interview with another participant for that project. This guy was a tech expert and he said that he knew someone who was involved in doing political campaigns. This tech expert writes a lot about the role of technology in society and was also concerned actually with this information. It's quite interesting. His concern was how to stem this information. And we were talking to him about that, but he knew the people who also who were doing this information as well, which kind of tells you also how intertwined these kinds of things are. People who are writing about it and the people who are actually doing it. When you were thinking of this study, when you were outlining the kind of interviews that you needed, did you think you'd come across someone that Grace, someone from PR? I think our original understanding of trolls is how people usually imagined trolls, right? They're like, you know, digital sweatshop code and code, all these rows of people working to troll others. And we didn't really realize at the start that there was this very highly professionalized system behind it. And Grace was one of the first ones we got to talk to that gave us an understanding of how organized these operations were and how it really involved different themes of people who might not know that they're working together, but are being orchestrated right up from from the top. Yeah, so she was very excessive in terms of like flaunting her wealth in terms of flaunting the people she knows, the celebrities she has spent time with. She of course, but as a PR strategist, it took us through her corporate portfolio, like these are the celebrities from Hollywood that I work with. After taking some time to, you know, flaunt her, you know, friendships and endorsements with, you know, Hollywood celebrities, she started talking about the presidential campaign that she run. So she was very proud of this candidate. And this was a presidential campaign that, yeah, it did a good job. I thought it was pretty effective, but didn't quite land it. Obviously, Hindi, it does sit dirty and therefore, Hindi nanalo, the presidential candidate, and then over the course of the interview, we were actually surprised that her vice president candidate was actually for a different political party. So Hindi aligned, the president and vice president, Hindi unified your ticket. So she was running two campaigns at that time. This was back in 2015, 2016, yes, from two different parties, two different candidates, but was the strategy different now? I think the strategies for both were different, I remember correctly, but also because although she was the chief architect of the online campaigns, there was someone else higher than her in each of these different campaigns. And that was actually what she was complaining about when we had a conversation, there's having, if she were given a more prominent role, maybe she could have made one or both of these people win. And so in a way, what Grace was telling us was she was casting this person of herself as a pioneer of digital politics of digital campaigning rather than seeing herself as a troll. She sees herself as a digital pioneer. And she had all these different tactics that she could use. Unfortunately, she was tiny by the more established political campaigner, so weren't so much into the online. So it's okay if you put your campaign, because there are a lot of the dictate, but she was also saying that given the chance, she could have done so much more and could have made these candidates win. We have that on the transcript. Let's listen to it. Cause I knew in my heart, we won. Yes, because I know our numbers, I know our strength. And I knew we were cheated. As in, yes, because I was at the forefront of his campaign. I think that's it there. And I'm proud of how we launched specific hashtags. If I launch specific keywords, moving on and progressing to greatness, I'd overcome it. And it worked. So that's the kind of strategy that I'm able to offer on top of just trending. Because trending is useless. If there's no inner message, something to do with the champion, she did have, like, very interesting points. I mean, reading through the transcript, just her sort of philosophy on who she will get for these campaigns. Like would she go for a celebrity, would she go for a for a parody account? She didn't really like working with celebrity endorsers for her political clients. Mahir Raplau and Machado Do Mahal, the celebrity endorsers. And instead, she would use meme accounts, meme pages, parody accounts. And to us, I think that was the biggest ethnographic surprise as we say in academia. That was a big discovery for us. It's from her that we first heard of this also that crucial really to the campaign strategy is the discipline of no messaging. That's how you the big tape, right? She ruled through hashtags. That's how she dictated and orchestrated what was happening online. Meron siyang Sariliyan Twitter Account, right? Tapos dun lumala ba sa Twitter Account Lian. Whom ano yung main message and main hashtag na i-papakalat. And then you would have these influencers. So I think more than actually the stature of the people that she got, which to her didn't really matter so much. It was about how these influencers would really carry the message. Kaya in preference, elegant, anonymous influencers. The very name of the handle, if you remember what we were talking about, because if you were talking about what the universe is, or something like that, it's not the exact name, but what's the flavor of accounts? Yeah, I actually just checked one of them. Universal shits. It's been the platform by Twitter. So well done, Twitter. And then of course, Meron Sila ng Yung 360. Meron paren on Facebook, then, and on other social media platforms. And yung isang account under her was so popular. It became so popular. And I'm sure if we name it, but we don't. Many people will know this particular account. So what do you think of influencers? I made a mistake of using the same millennials to administer. Because of the sheer number of accounts, I cannot be the one to handle. I can, because I'll have to talk to clients and my Tagalogs bad. So, of course, they're their own language, which the fellow judges can understand or the humor. So I have to contract kids. All they do is tweet every day. It doesn't have to be a trending topic just to keep the numbers going up. But the mistake there is because they gave them access. It's easy to hack the account. That's what I think of the account, which I haven't talked to Twitter too much. It's just that I have to retrieve it. I don't have 1.7 million. Okay, so it was all very organic still, no? I guess because my impression of trolls is they're all robots. They're all bots. You get AI to do this. But it seems like a philosophy in Greece. It was through her that we got to meet operators of some of the most popular parody accounts. And again, it speaks to her level of confidence, right? Yeah, she's able to introduce us as academic researchers. Obviously, studying digital operations. Whatever academic study we publish won't have much repercussion to her operations. And she also trusted the loyalty of her influencers of the people that she works with. But what I'm sure is that we pick up Denomen while talking to the influencers. There is really this underlying kind of tension between them and the chief architects. Because the digital influencers, one day, they want to become chief architects in their own right. And so there's a lot of tension that on one hand they really work together and they rely so much on Greece for the kinds of gigs that they get. But on the other hand, they are plotting a future path. That's how they learn how to earn money. And Greece is conscious of that. If you remember, John, she talked about how she could feel this. And that's how the rules of the game, how she works together with the influencers. She changes up the schemes, the payment matrix. She changes up the way that she relates to them. But they're also always on their toes. And they don't know exactly how she operates things. To me, Jay, like we discussed this as our strategy. But because we interviewed different campaigners and we would always ask during our interview. So how does it work when you meet a political client? How do you pitch to them? And it depends on the answer, on this specific answer. Whether Jason, I would be really impressed by how savvy their operations will be. The Yung Iba, what we'll talk about, you know, like a very dry PowerPoint or we'll try to lead with statistics. I know this big data approach to digital campaigns to understand online users. That's not how grace operates. Yeah, see, Grace. I know how good. I know how good. I'm going to demo to you what I can do for you. And so what she'll do is tell a particular potential client to watch out for it. This 7 p.m. I'm going to make this particular message trend. And it's going to be about you. So Parang Galaansha. And then she backs that up with what she calls the media valuation. Now, it's the most analytical tool to show you the kind of influence and reach that the campaigns that she operates can actually give you. So go on your style. You impress Kamuna Nyana. If you hire me, this is what I can do for you. Actual demo. How that's done. And then she goes ahead and explains that through media valuation. Oh, that's one thing about me when you hire me as a PR. I don't give you a PR plan. I'll give you media valuation plan. A media valuation predicts the X number of million set. Whatever I do will gain you in terms of coverage. My record was a million dollars under 24 hours. Twice I did it. That's how I do PR. It's like I have scientific most publicist's casseroa whether in the U.S. or in the Philippines. Mahilig sa PowerPoint. Ako na tatangahan ako sa PowerPoint. Tapos yung isap niya kasi yung talent or skill that she rolls out. Is she can torpedo yung pagtrending ng messages from opposing political camps? I think we call it signal scrambling. Very simple yung technique, but very effective. Is kung ko niya remainon kang hashtag na pinapatren. And she's going against him. What she'll do is she'll launch a similar looking hashtag. Maybe change an o to a zero or an S to a five. And because of that, the people who are tweeting that hashtag, their count gets broken apart. So they don't end up in the top 10 or something like that. It's her hashtag that will become number one. So marriage and counter-attack measures on Twitter. Okay, so we have this image of Grace. And we more or less have an idea of the kinds of clients that she usually takes on. These are celebrities, these are for brands. And now suddenly she's pivoted to politicians. So I guess not. I want to try to understand that. How does she deal with politicians? How does she deal with these clients? I mean, first of all, is she working under the PR firm? That she's part of? Or are these operations just on her own? I think it's important to understand dres, merechang seriling boutik local agency. And so, shampooing front nito, she does our legitimate operations to speak, in our brands, celebrities, et cetera. Pero meron din chang back room operations, which are more about politics. So, ganon yun yun yun yun yun yun yun yun, but it's kind of an open secret. People know that she owns this boutik that does other kinds of campaigns. But also, on the down low, she does these other things for political clients. What's a boutik agency compared to a non-boutik agency? Yung mga local boutik agencies, mas gray area salah, because, you know, they operate on their own. And so, they self-regulate themselves also, which means, kaya ni lang gawintong mga on the side operations with not much accountability. Medyo shadi din yung kanilang farm business and financial transactions, dahil nalining naman from Grace and her collaborators, na sometimes at DM lang sila naku-usap, walaong paper trail, na, you know, like an official receipt, leba, especially for politicians. Parang nagli-DM lang sila sa Twitter, sa Instagram, and magde-deposit ng nangpera, magbibigay ng bonus iPhone. And actually, a lot of clients, habi niya pein hold cash de ba, and the only paper trail, maybe for investigative journalists to look at, is yung pagtrans for actually, from her to the digital influencer, sa ATM-yoon. Pero yung linking her to the clients to the principals, that will prove very, very challenging, kasi halos walaong trace. Right, and it's interesting, because these are the kinds of services that politicians would go for. Bakit yung piniti nila, bakit yung sabutik kapa. Does that say anything about the kind of campaign they were expecting her to run? I think for boutique agencies, they're much more flexible, and there's a level of plausible deniability that they offer to politicians as well. And it's also interesting. We found other examples of, you know, a boutique agency that is running a political campaign, especially for local election, that they're working with, not the politician they were. But a business person supporting the local mayor, the local politician, a business person with real local financial interests, you know, to advance, to real estate projects at the local level and therefore this is their way of contributing to the campaign. So again, when we talk about you asked about ethics and transparency, he wrapped it up because even at that level, there's a distance between the politician who's supposed to be responsible for all the messages of their campaign. The fact that we should be able to demand politicians, why is your campaign so dirty? Why are you, you know, doing so much smear campaigns against your rival? But in some cases, the politicians don't even sign off formally in terms of the actual meme and content that their campaigns are producing because there's a level of distance between them, the PR firm and also the influencers who are doing the actual dirty messaging. I see what you're trying to say. I have been thinking about this as well. When one of the PR strategists said that the certain politician is running a virtuous campaign, when clearly that is not the case, that's not what we are seeing, but just how well that these politicians are able to distance themselves from that kind of dirty campaign happening online, because you could easily say that I never signed off to anything. It was them. It's nobody's fault cat. Yeah, that's that's the theme of this entire study. Everyone is passing the back. Oh, it wasn't me. It's somebody else. Oh, it's the other person is the real troll. I actually remember at some point during the research, we were trying to ask them, "So, who do you think is the actual trolling content?" The memes, who does that? The videos, the very vitriolic and very toxic content. And the chief architects like Grace would say, "Oh, I'm not American. I talk about strategy. I talk about an indirection of campaign." So, how do you influence your translators into the actual content, right? So, it's not. And then if you talk to the digital influencers, someone else in their team, they don't even know how to do it. And they don't even know how to trace it. No one will ever say that they only know how to do the actual content. I think, and you've been calling for accountability since you released this paper, right? And it's been six years. You've been telling people to police. Yeah. You know, one of the things that we've been really talking about since the report came out is really the importance of looking at the broader ecosystem that has allowed people like Grace to emerge, right? And to flourish. And there's not been a lot of focus on that. It's not just these individual personalities, no matter how colorful they are. But it's the kind of media industry that's allowed them to happen, right? In fact, it's the same people who are in this industry, at the intersection of rolling and adding PR who say, "Really what's the difference between fudging the truth in relation to brands, in relation to celebrities, and fudging the truth in relation to politics and democracy?" A lot of the initiatives that I have to do with how we consume it, meet the literacy, fact checking. But I think I'm not sure if John shares this with you. It's a losing battle because you're pitting us ordinary people trying to equip us with all of these skills versus these experts from the industry. There's a lot going on here, so we'll just focus on our own problems, both on production, so that we can reduce the creation of this information, rather than asking people to be more discerning. So in other words, prevention is better than a cure, right? Yeah, definitely. You've been calling for more regulation in these activities. That has been your main thesis, that has been your battle cries since you released this study. But how did the PR strategy set you interviewed? How did they feel when you released it? Did they say anything? Such a great question, and I remember the launch of our study. It was in an attenuio disinformation in democracy forum. It was one of the first kinds of research forums that was talking about fake news and disinformation. And one of the respondents in that forum was actually a very well-known advertising guru, but I'm kidding, I'm not an industry, both for her corporate portfolio, but also for her political loyalties. And my heart just broke, Jay, I remember when she said, I think this study gives too much credit to advertising and PR professionals, because actually the real people who are the queens of fake news are people in the media and it's all influencers. So once again, there's this passing the buck dynamic. There was no self-reflection. Absolutely not. It was all this study. Yes, it captured some examples, but this is not the whole picture. You know, I think we need to be going after influencers and platforms are at fault here. Hindi, Kame, Hindi, a whole. So we never identified her, but she was super defensive. Okay, so we know all of these things and we've talked to people like Grace and yet they're still around. What do you think gets them going? I think one of the most heartbreaking things that we learned in this research is that for these people, this is a game of glory for them. For someone like Grace, she got into digital political campaigning as she would call it trolling as others would recognize it. Because she was bored. She said that she was very bored making brands, making celebrities trend. She wanted to see if she could do the same for politicians with tarnished names, for political causes that people might not like, will she be able to hyper extend the strategies, the weapons, the tools of ad NPR to promote these things in politics. So she saw herself as a digital pioneer, not to make the world a better place, but just because she wanted to be known. Okay, so we are nearing the end of this podcast. And of course, we'd like to thank Professor Jason Cabanyes for joining us in this conversation. Again, Jason is a professor at the Data Cell University Department of Communication and he is a co-author of Architects of Network Disinformation. Now, I just want to go back to you, Jonathan. How did you feel after meeting someone like Grace? Like what impression did you have? I'll be honest, God, part of it was, oh my God, she's spilling the beans and this is gold. Yeah, when she started spilling the beans, she was so confident and arrogant, bragging about her abilities, but which were impressive. So she has a way as well of, you know, seducing you with razzle dazzle and impressing you and being funny and snarky. So you think it's the same thing, it's the same thing. So do you see yourself like Olivia Pope of scandal or gossip girl? Olivia Pope, I don't think I'm gonna have an affair with the president. I hope not. But I love Game of Thrones. Oh, Lena. Oh, I love Lena. Oh my God, who am I gonna poison? Are you fans? Oops, no spoilers. I love Lena because she's the bomb at Andang maldita. I love her. She works in the shadows. All of you Pope is weak. Because I mean, I asked because I was reading through these transcripts that you sent us. And I'm just thinking to myself, wow, I genuinely impressed. How well she's been pulling this off. And I'd hate to root for her, but I actually was at one point, thinking that it's like, "I can't help but, you know, I'm also conflicted because I know for well that what she has done, the campaign she launched was really dirty and it was wrong. And I also can't help but feel now that if we had, if the media worked with PR strategists like her with advertising firms instead of maybe distancing ourselves from them, we could have launched so many good campaigns for the Philippines. If this had happened during the pandemic, we could have sent a message for more vaccination, right? To get people to get vaccinated. If you don't know your hashtag, that you'll get vaccinated and it could get that kind of fake impact, why didn't we get to do that then? Let's see what we need in the pandemic. Why haven't we thought of using this for good instead of just for this information? That's my frustration right now. I agree with you Kat. We need to be finding ways in which we think about strategic goals. communication skills. They might not like as a dirty work as well, even though much of our podcast is about the dirtiest of strategic communications and PR. But, you know, the skills of messaging, relatability, authenticity, the power of stories and narratives. I think that's what the skills of Grace had. Yeah, she'd been doing it for, quote, unquote, the good. You know, it could have done really powerful things for our country. Yeah, exactly. And that is a great way to end the first three episodes of this podcast. I'm really happy I got to do this with you, Jonathan, and excited for the rest of the episodes that we will be doing. Again, I'm Kat Ventura. And this is Jonathan Ong. And this is Catch Me If You Can. This is funded by Internews and Powered by Puma Podcasts. This episode was produced by myself, edited by Presh Kapistrano. And we want to give a shout out to Nina Toralba for the amazing work she did for voice acting. Follow Puma Podcasts and catch me if you can on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, or wherever you listen. We love to hear from you listeners, feel free to send us questions or comments on Twitter @Johnathan_C_Ong. We'd love to respond to your questions and comments. Thanks for listening.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Grace, a PR strategist, operates a highly professionalized, organized system for political campaigns, blending celebrity and meme-based tactics with strategic hashtag manipulation.
  2. She positions herself as a digital pioneer rather than a "troll," emphasizing her expertise in media valuation and campaign strategy to demonstrate influence and reach.
  3. Her approach relies on anonymous, influencer-driven parody accounts—particularly on Twitter—where content is spread organically to dominate trends and disrupt opposition messaging.
  4. She uses tactics like signal scrambling (creating similar-looking hashtags to break trends) to undermine rival campaigns, showcasing a deliberate, technical strategy for online dominance.
  5. Grace works through boutique PR agencies that operate with low accountability, enabling secret political campaigns without formal oversight or paper trails.
  6. There’s a deep tension between her and the influencers she employs, who desire to become chief architects themselves, creating an unstable, evolving power dynamic.
  7. The study reveals a systemic passing of blame
  8. The research highlights the ethical and structural failures in the PR and media industries, where digital campaigning is normalized, and accountability is lacking, enabling disinformation to flourish.

Summary:

The podcast explores the operations of elite PR strategists like Grace, who run highly organized, sophisticated digital campaigns for political candidates. Grace, portrayed as a "digital pioneer," leverages meme accounts, hashtags, and signal scrambling tactics to dominate social media narratives and discredit opponents. Her strategies—rooted in media valuation and influencer networks—demonstrate a professional, almost scientific approach to online influence.

These operations are conducted through unregulated boutique PR agencies, which provide plausible deniability and operate without formal accountability. A key theme is the systemic passing of blame: political figures deflect responsibility, attributing harmful content to external actors like influencers or PR firms. The research highlights a broader industry failure where PR professionals are seen as tools of disinformation rather than ethical communicators.

Despite the tactics being technically effective, the study raises ethical concerns, questioning whether such strategies could have been redirected for public good—such as during the pandemic—had more accountability and transparency existed. The findings suggest that disinformation thrives not just from individual actors but from systemic gaps in media regulation, industry ethics, and public digital literacy. The researchers argue that prevention—through better regulation and responsible practices—is more effective than relying on individual discernment to combat misinformation.

FAQs

Grace acts as a chief architect of digital campaigns, using hashtags, parody accounts, and meme strategies to influence online narratives. She focuses on tactics like signal scrambling to suppress opposing messages and promote her client’s content.

Unlike automated bots, Grace operates with a professional, strategic approach. She uses human influencers and carefully designed content, treating digital campaigns like a sophisticated, organized system rather than random trolling.

Signal scrambling is a technique where Grace launches a similar-looking hashtag with minor changes (e.g., swapping 'o' for '0') to break the trend of opposing campaigns. This causes the original hashtag’s reach to drop, allowing her campaign to dominate the rankings.

Boutique agencies offer flexibility and plausible deniability. They operate with less accountability, allowing politicians to distance themselves from controversial messaging while still benefiting from strategic digital operations.

The primary concern is the lack of transparency and accountability. Politicians often don’t formally approve content, and PR strategists operate behind the scenes, making it difficult to assign responsibility for harmful or misleading campaigns.

Influencers are often anonymous and operate under strict guidelines. They carry out daily posting without needing to understand the full strategy, relying on Grace’s direction and being kept in the dark about the full operations to prevent rebellion or exposure.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.