3 Disturbing TRUE Scary Stories to Listen to in the Dark
82m 27s
A homeowner, during a yard sale in Kentucky, sold a large oak cabinet to a man who later returned to collect it. The man arrived late, appeared normal at first, but during the load process, the homeowner noticed unusual sounds and movements inside a sealed trailer. He observed a woman’s shoe beneath a blanket and heard breathing, which led him to believe someone was trapped. After the man attempted to enter the house with a pry bar and threatened the family, the homeowner called 911 and locked himself and his wife inside. The man broke through the door and attacked, but was eventually stopped by the homeowner and the police. It was later revealed that the man, Brent Nolan, had kidnapped his estranged wife, Kara, who had been imprisoned in the trailer. She had been bound and hidden behind the cabinet, and the trailer had been used as a covert confinement. The homeowner’s actions—particularly noticing the shoe and alerting authorities—were critical in preventing further harm. The case resulted in Nolan pleading guilty to multiple charges, including kidnapping and assault. The woman survived with injuries, and the homeowner credited her proactive behavior for breaking the facade of the crime. The incident highlights how ordinary events can mask violent crimes and underscores the importance of vigilance, especially in isolated or unmonitored settings. The story also reflects on trauma, trust, and the hidden dangers of domestic abuse. Despite the emotional toll, the family was relieved that the danger ended, and the perpetrator was brought to justice. The narrative serves as a cautionary tale about the potential for abuse to go unnoticed until it escalates.
Star Wars The Mandalorian and Grogu is now streaming on Disney+.
What are you waiting for? Hop on.
The must-see galactic adventure comes home on Disney+.
This is the way.
Our only chance is to work together.
I like this kid.
Always wear your seatbelt.
Star Wars The Mandalorian and Grogu, now streaming on Disney+.
Rated PG-13.
It turns out, that's very illegal.
So there goes my big idea for the commercial.
Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch.
Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, or $180 for a 12-month plan required.
$15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra.
Initial plan term only greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. See terms.
This happened in September of 2021,
when my wife, Allison, and I decided to have a baby.
We decided to have a yard sale at our house outside Lexington, Kentucky.
There wasn't any special reason for it.
Our garage had slowly filled with things we no longer used,
and we wanted to clear enough space for Allison to park inside before winter.
We had an old dining set, two bookcases, boxes of children's clothes,
some tools, and a tall oak cabinet that had been against the back wall
since before our daughter was born.
The cabinet was the one item I really wanted gone,
so I decided to leave it at that for now.
It stood a little under six feet tall, and was about four feet wide.
It had deep shelves behind two solid doors,
and whoever built it had used much more wood than necessary.
Allison and I had moved it once after buying the house.
It took both of us, a furniture dolly, and most of an afternoon.
Since then, it had become a place to store paint cans,
extension cords, and all the other things we didn't know what to do with.
Our daughter Callie was four at the time.
She had recently started riding a bicycle with training wheels,
and every time she tried to get it out of the garage,
either Allison or I had to move something.
Holding a yard sale seemed easier than making another trip to donate everything,
and we figured we might make enough money to take Callie somewhere fun that weekend.
We put signs at the entrance to our neighborhood early that Saturday morning.
By 7.30, we had folding tables across the driveway,
and most of the time, we were in the car.
The rest of the larger furniture arranged along the edge of the lawn.
Allison handled the money while I carried things out.
Callie sat near the garage with a plastic cash register
and pretended that several of her old toys were for sale,
although she changed her mind whenever someone tried to buy one.
It was all very normal.
We had a steady crowd for the first few hours.
An older couple bought the dining chairs.
A college student took one of the bookcases.
Someone offered me $5,000.
I paid $5 for a nearly new socket set marked at 20,
and then acted offended when I said no.
By late morning, the driveway looked much better,
and the cash box was fuller than I expected.
The man who bought the cabinet arrived a little after 11.
He came alone in a dark blue pickup,
parked at the curb,
and walked straight toward the garage.
I noticed him because he didn't browse the tables first.
He looked at the cabinet,
opened both doors,
and ran his hands around the cabinet.
He was probably in his late 30s.
He was taller than me, but not by much,
with a heavy build and short brown hair.
He wore work pants, a navy shirt,
and boots with dried mud around the soles.
There was nothing about him that seemed especially strange.
If I had passed him at a hardware store,
I doubt I would have remembered him.
He asked how much I wanted for the cabinet.
I told him $80, expecting him to offer $40.
Instead, he pulled four 20s from his wallet and handed them to me.
Then he asked if I could hold it until later that afternoon.
He said he needed to get his enclosed trailer and one of his furniture dollies.
I told him that was fine as long as he returned before 5.
We planned to close the sale around 4,
and we were supposed to have dinner at Alison's parents' house that evening.
He said he would be back well before then.
He wrote his phone number on the back of one of our price stickers.
I stuck it to the wall of the house,
and put it on the floor.
He said he was going to be back in a few weeks.
I said he was going to be back in a few weeks.
He wrote his phone number on the wall of the house,
and put it on the floor.
Then he asked how much it weighed. I said I didn't know, but it was heavy enough that he and I would
probably be able to move it with a dolly. If not, my next door neighbor was usually home on Saturdays
and might help. The man looked toward our neighbor's house when I said that. It was only for a second.
Then he said two people would be enough. I didn't find that odd at the time. He had paid the full
price without arguing, and I was happy to have the cabinet sold. I placed a piece of masking tape
across the doors with the word sold on it and went back to helping Allison. The crowd thinned around
two. By three, we were mostly sitting in lawn chairs and waiting to see if anyone else stopped.
Callie was tired and starting to complain about the heat. The day wasn't especially hot,
but the driveway was in direct sun and we had been outside since before seven.
At a little after four, Allison took Callie inside for a bath. We still had dinner plans,
although we had already called her parents to say we would be late.
I packed the remaining clothes into boxes and carried the folding tables into the garage.
The only things left near the driveway were the oak cabinet, a small desk, and a pile of items
we planned to donate. The buyer still hadn't returned. I called the number on the sticker.
It rang several times. I left a short message saying that I would wait another half hour. Since he had already paid,
I didn't want to lock the cabinet inside and make him return another day. At five, there was still no sign of him.
I called again and got the same voicemail. Allison came into the garage with Callie,
who was wearing pajamas, even though it was still light outside. She asked how much longer
I planned to wait. I told her I would give him until 5.30 and then move the cabinet against
the garage wall. We agreed that she and Callie would eat something at home and that we would
visit her parents the next day instead. I remember feeling irritated, but that was all. The man had
my address and I had his money. There was no reason to think he wasn't coming back eventually.
I assumed his trailer had a flat tire or someone who had promised to help him didn't show up.
At about 5.40, I heard a diesel engine outside. The dark blue pickup turned into our street with
a gray enclosed trailer behind it. The trailer was around 12 feet long with a full-width ramp
door at the rear and a smaller door on the passenger side. It had no business name or
other markings. The man drove past our house, backed up, and stopped along the curb with
the rear of the trailer near the bottom of our driveway. He shut off the engine when he got out.
He was wearing the same clothes as before, but he didn't look the same. His shirt was damp
around the collar. There was a thin scratch on the left side of his face, and the knuckles on
his right hand were red. He looked exhausted and angry. He apologized for being late. He said he'd
had trouble with someone who was supposed to lend him a trailer, although the way he said it made
it unclear whether this trailer belonged to him. I told him it wasn't a problem and that I just
wanted to get the cabinet loaded before it became dark. He stared into the garage behind me. Most of
our belongings were already inside again. The door leading from the garage into our laundry room was
open, and through it, you could see part of our kitchen. Allison had put on a children's movie
for Callie, and I could hear it from the driveway. The man asked if anyone else was available to help.
I said my wife was inside with our daughter, but the two of us should be able to handle it.
I told him I had a furniture dolly. He nodded and went to open the trailer.
The rear ramp door was secured by two metal latches and a padlock. He took a large keyring
from his pocket, opened the lock, released the latches, and pulled the top of the door toward
him. It lowered on two support cables and formed a wide ramp from the trailer floor to the street.
There wasn't much inside the trailer,
from what I could see. A few plastic storage tubs were stacked near the front.
There were moving blankets, a folded hand truck, two gas cans, and several lengths of lumber
secured along one wall. The inside had no windows. With the sun behind our house,
most of the trailer was dark. The man climbed in and moved the hand truck.
While he was doing that, I heard a dull impact from somewhere near the front of the trailer.
It wasn't loud.
I assumed one of the
storage tubs had shifted and struck the wall. The man stopped moving for a moment and looked
toward the front. Then he picked up the hand truck and brought it down the ramp. He said one of his
toolboxes must have fallen over. I didn't question it. I brought my dolly to the oak cabinet, and
together we tilted the cabinet forward enough to slide the base underneath. We wrapped a strap
around it to hold the doors shut. When the man crouched to feed the strap beneath the cabinet,
the bulky keyring dug into his leg through the tight front pocket of his work pants.
He pulled it out, complained about it catching when he bent down, and set it on my workbench
beside my phone. Then he said he wanted to lower the cabinet onto its back. I told him that would
make it harder to get up the ramp. We decided to keep it upright and tip it only when we reached
the trailer opening. Moving the cabinet across the driveway took several minutes. The small wheels
caught in every seam in the concrete.
And the cabinet leaned whenever one of us tried to turn it. The buyer seemed distracted. Twice I had
to tell him to stop pushing because the cabinet was getting away from me. When we reached the
bottom of the driveway, another sound came from the trailer. This time, it was a quick series of
impacts against the metal wall. The man immediately let go of the cabinet. He climbed halfway up the
ramp and called out, asking if everything was all right. I thought he might have an animal in there.
That was the man. He said,
the only explanation that came to mind. I asked if he had a dog. He looked back at me and said no.
Then he stepped inside, moved one of the blankets near the front, and said the lumber had come
loose. I couldn't see what he was doing because his body blocked most of the opening. After a few
seconds, the noise stopped. He returned to the ramp and said we needed to hurry. His tone had
changed. He wasn't openly threatening, but he was no longer trying to be friendly. I should have
stopped then. I've gone over that part many times, and I know how obvious it sounds now. But there
are many ordinary explanations for noise inside a trailer. Something had shifted. A tool had rolled.
An animal might have climbed in without him knowing. I didn't immediately believe there
was a person hidden behind those blankets. Nothing in my life had prepared me to reach
that conclusion. We rolled the cabinet up the ramp. At the opening, there was only a few inches
of clearance above the ramp. I couldn't see anything. I couldn't
love it. I climbed into the trailer and pulled, while the man pushed from below. The cabinet
tilted toward me, and for a moment, I had most of its weight against my arms and chest.
I backed up until the dolly wheels reached the plywood floor. The air inside smelled of gasoline,
damp fabric, and sweat. Once my eyes adjusted, I could see that the storage tubs had been
arranged across the front of the trailer. A thick, moving blanket hung from a rope behind
them, forming a rough divider. It didn't reach the floor. As we turned the cabinet, I saw the
toe of a woman's shoe beneath that blanket. It was a plain white athletic shoe with a light blue
stripe. At first, I thought it was just a loose shoe. Then it moved backward. I stopped pulling.
The cabinet rolled several inches toward me, and the buyer told me to keep going.
I looked at the gap beneath the blanket again, but the shoe was gone. I asked what was
behind the divider. He said it was personal property and told me to watch the cabinet
before it tipped. We moved it another two feet. He wanted the cabinet turned sideways across the
width of the trailer, close to the rear ramp door. That made no sense if he planned to unload it
later. It would block nearly the entire opening, and there wasn't enough room to turn it again
without taking out the tubs. I said it would be safer against the wall. He told me he knew how he
was going to do it. I said it was a good idea. He said it was a good idea. The man was between me and the trailer,
but there was nothing stopping me from walking
back into the garage.
I told him I had another strap he could use.
He said he had plenty,
but I was already moving up the driveway.
I tried not to hurry.
The keys to his truck and trailer
were still sitting on my workbench
beside my phone.
I picked up my phone, placed the key ring
in my pocket, and stepped behind a
tall stack of flattened boxes near the
garage wall. I called
911. The dispatcher
answered, and I gave her my address.
I kept my voice low.
I told her there was a man
in my driveway with an enclosed trailer
and that I believed someone was being
held inside it.
She asked why I thought that.
I said I had seen a woman's shoe move
behind a divider and heard breathing.
She asked whether the man
had a weapon. I said I hadn't seen
one. She told me to go inside,
lock the door, and not
confront him. I said my wife
and daughter were already in the house.
Then the buyer spoke from the
open garage door. He asked
who I was talking to. I turned
around. He was standing
about 15 feet away, holding
a long steel pry bar in his right
hand. He must have walked up
the driveway while I was listening to the
dispatcher. His eyes moved
from the phone to the workbench.
He saw that his keys were gone.
He told me to hang up and give them back.
I ran for the laundry room.
I heard him come after me.
I got through the doorway, pulled
the heavy door shut, and turned
the deadbolt. Less than
a second later, he struck the other
side hard enough to move it in the frame.
Allison was standing in the kitchen
with Callie beside her.
She saw my face and asked what was wrong.
I told her there was someone
trapped in the trailer and that the man
was trying to get inside.
I told her to take Callie to our
bedroom, lock the door, and call
911. The
buyer struck the laundry room door again.
A line split in the wooden
frame near the lock.
Allison picked up Callie and ran down
the hall. Callie started
crying and asking what was happening.
I heard our bedroom door close.
The dispatcher was still
on my phone. It had
fallen on the laundry room floor when I
shut the door. I could hear her
asking if I was there.
I bent to pick it up, but the buyer
drove the pry bar between the door and the
frame. The wood around the
deadbolt cracked. I grabbed
the handle and pulled back.
The door opened inward into the
laundry room, so if the frame
failed, there was no way I could hold
it closed against him. I
planted one foot against the wall and
used both hands. He hit
the door again. The deadbolt
tore through the damaged frame
and the door moved several inches.
The edge struck my
shoulder and knocked me backward into
the washing machine. The
phone slid under a shelf.
The man forced the door open far enough
to get his arm through. He
swung the pry bar at me.
It struck the top of the washing machine and
left a deep dent.
I backed into the kitchen as he pushed
the rest of the way inside. He
closed the door behind him.
That small action frightened me almost
as much as seeing the pry bar.
If he had only wanted to get away,
he would have grabbed his keys and run back to the
truck. Closing the door meant
he intended to stay long enough to take
control of the situation. He
told me to give him the keys.
I said the police were already coming.
I tried to sound certain,
although I had no idea how much the
dispatcher had heard after I dropped the phone.
I didn't know whether she had
sent anyone yet, or whether my
call had disconnected.
He stepped farther into the kitchen.
He held the pry bar low against
his leg. Up close,
I could see that the red marks
across his knuckles weren't from moving
furniture. The skin was
split in two places, and there was
dried blood along the side of his hand.
He said I had misunderstood
what I'd seen.
The woman in the trailer was his wife.
They were having a private family
problem, and I had no right to interfere.
He spoke quickly, but
kept his voice low. He didn't
want Allison to hear. I told
him people didn't lock their wives inside
cargo trailers. His
face tightened. He
said she was trying to ruin his life,
and that he only needed time to talk to
her. Then he held out his
left hand and told me again to give him
the keys. He promised he
would leave if I did. I
didn't believe him. Even if he
left without hurting us, the woman
would still be trapped behind the cabinet we
had just loaded. I also
knew I had already given the dispatcher my
address, and told her about his truck
and trailer. Returning
the keys wouldn't undo that.
Our kitchen had an island in the
center, with the sink and stove along
the far wall. I
moved around one side of the island,
keeping it between us.
The man followed from the other side.
He asked where my wife had gone.
I said she had left
through the back door. He looked toward the hallway. Callie was still crying somewhere in
the back of the house, so the lie didn't help. He raised the pry bar and told me that if I made
him search the house, things would get worse. I reached behind me and grabbed one of the wooden
chairs from the kitchen table. I held it by the back with the legs pointed toward him.
It wasn't much protection, but it kept him from walking directly at me.
He swung the pry bar into the chair. One of the legs split near the seat.
The force pulled the chair out of my hands and sent it across the floor.
I turned toward the hallway. I was trying to get between him and the bedroom,
but he caught the back of my shirt and pulled me into the edge of the island.
My right side struck the countertop. Before I could get away, he drove his forearm across
the back of my neck and pushed my face down. He searched the front pockets of my jeans.
The key ring was in my left pocket. I felt his hand close around it.
I twisted and shoved backward. We both lost our balance. He fell against the cabinet under the
sink, and I went down on one knee. The keys landed on the tile between us. He reached for them.
I kicked them first. The ring slid under the stove. The man hit me across the upper back
with the pry bar. I didn't feel much at first, only the impact and the sound of metal against
my shoulder. My left arm stopped working correctly. I fell forward and struck my forehead on the
floor. He dropped to one knee and reached under the stove. His fingers couldn't fit beneath the
lower drawer. He pulled at the handle, but the drawer caught on a baking sheet inside.
That gave me enough time to crawl away. I got to my feet near the hallway and yelled for Allison
to get Callie out through the bedroom window. The man stood and came after me. He struck the wall
beside me. I was able to get out of the room. I was able to get
my head, leaving a narrow hole in the drywall. I grabbed his wrist with both hands. He pushed me
backward, and we hit the small table near the hallway entrance. A lamp fell and broke beside us.
He was stronger than I was, and he wasn't trying to protect himself. I was afraid to let go of the
arm holding the bar. He used his free hand to punch the side of my face twice. The second punch split
the skin above my eyebrow. Blood ran into my left eye and made it difficult to see. I pulled him
toward the floor instead of trying to push him away. We fell into the hallway, with me underneath
him. The pry bar struck the baseboard and came loose from his hand. It stopped a few feet away.
For a moment, neither of us had it. I rolled toward the bar. He grabbed my ankle and dragged
me backward. My fingernails scraped across the floor, but I managed to put one hand
around the curved end. He climbed over me and tried to take it back. Callie screamed from the
bedroom. The man looked up at the sound. I used both hands to pull the bar against my chest and
drove my knee into his stomach. He released my ankle and moved away. I got between him and the
hallway again. I held the pry bar out and told him the police were almost there. I didn't actually
know that. I was saying anything that might make him leave. He looked toward the kitchen and then
toward the front room. His breathing was heavy. Blood from his damaged knuckles had smeared across
his shirt. The confidence he had when he entered the house was gone. He seemed to understand that
too much time had passed. Then the house went quiet. Neither of us moved, and there was no
longer any noise coming from the television or the back bedroom. In that silence, he heard the
dispatcher. Star Wars The Mandalorian and Grogu is now streaming on YouTube.
Disney Plus. Hop on. The must-see galactic adventure comes home on
Disney Plus. This is the way. I like this kid. Star Wars The Mandalorian and Grogu, now streaming on Disney Plus. Rated PG-13.
Supergirl, now streaming on Disney Plus. Rated PG-13.
Rated PG-13.
way. A homeowner saw him crawl underneath and directed police to the spot. He still had the
pry bar when officers found him, but he dropped it after they ordered him out. I was taken to
the same hospital as the woman from the trailer. I had a cracked rib, a deep bruise across my upper
back, and a cut over my left eye that needed seven stitches. Nothing was permanently damaged.
The doctors kept me for several hours because I had hit my head, and Allison stayed with me
after her mother picked up Callie. An officer spoke to us at the hospital that night. He said
the woman was the buyer's estranged wife. Her condition was stable. She had a concussion,
a dislocated shoulder, and injuries to her wrists, but they expected her to recover.
That was when we learned that the buyer's name was Brent Nolan. He was 38 and lived about 40
minutes from us. His wife, Kara, had left their house three weeks earlier and
moved in with her older sister. According to the officer, the separation followed years of
controlling behavior that had recently become physical. Kara had spoken to an attorney and was
preparing to ask the court for an emergency protective order. Brent knew she was trying
to leave him for good. The police didn't tell us everything that night. More of the story came out
over the following weeks through investigators and the prosecutor assigned to the case.
On the morning of our yard sale,
Brent had been driving through our part of Lexington without the trailer attached.
He saw one of our signs and stopped. Investigators believed he bought the cabinet for the ordinary
reason he gave me. He had recently rented a small building outside town and was moving
tools and household property into it. At that point, no one could prove he had decided to
abduct Kara. Later that afternoon, he drove to the duplex where she was staying. He waited until
her sister left for work, then approached Kara when she came outside to take out trash.
He had the cargo trailer connected by then. He threatened her with the pry bar,
forced her into the side door, bound her hands and ankles, and drove away.
Kara told police that he kept saying they were going somewhere quiet to fix their marriage.
She believed he intended to take her to an empty hunting cabin that belonged to one of
his relatives in western Kentucky. He had previously threatened to keep her there until
she agreed to come home.
Officers later searched that property, although I was never told what they found. During the drive,
Kara worked one shoe off and used her feet to strike the rear ramp door.
Brent stopped twice and warned her to be quiet. At some point, he remembered the cabinet he had
paid for at our sale. Investigators believed that was why he arrived so late and why he insisted
that we strap it across the rear of the trailer. He wasn't simply collecting something he had bought.
He was using it to make the ramp door inaccessible. That detail bothered me more than almost anything
else. I had helped him do it. I had pushed the cabinet into place while Kara was only a few feet
away, bound behind the blanket. If she hadn't moved her shoe into the gap, I might have finished
tightening the straps, watched him lock both doors, and waved as he drove away.
Kara said she heard us talking outside. She couldn't make out every word,
but she understood that Brent was at someone's home.
She began hitting the wall because she knew it might be her only chance to get someone's attention.
When Brent climbed inside and moved the blanket, he pressed the cloth tighter around her mouth
and warned her that he would hurt the people outside if she made another sound.
She stopped while he was standing near her. As soon as we moved the cabinet farther inside,
she pushed one foot beneath the blanket. She didn't know whether I saw it.
The short breath I heard was her trying to call for help through the cloth.
Brent refused to answer most questions after his arrest.
At first, he claimed Kara had entered the trailer voluntarily
and that we had attacked him after a disagreement over the cabinet.
That explanation didn't last. Her injuries, the restraints, the locked doors,
and the damage to our house made it impossible to take seriously.
There was also the original 911 recording. The dispatcher had heard most of what happened in
the laundry room and kitchen, including Brent's and Kara's. The dispatcher had heard most of what
Brent's saying that Kara was his wife and that he only needed time to talk to her.
Destroying my phone hadn't erased the call. The cabinet remained inside the trailer while
it was processed as evidence. Police later asked whether I wanted to make a property claim because
the price sticker from my yard sale was still attached to one door. I said no. Brent had paid
for it, and I never wanted it back in our garage. The legal case took more than a year to finish.
I had to give a formal statement several times,
and both Allison and I were prepared to testify. In the end, Brent pleaded guilty to kidnapping,
burglary, assault, and several related charges. He received a long prison sentence. I was relieved
that Allison and Callie wouldn't have to sit in a courtroom and see him again. I met Kara only once.
It was at the prosecutor's office a few months after the attack. She was still receiving
treatment for her shoulder, but she looked much healthier than she had when the paramedics
carried her to the hospital. I was relieved that Allison and Callie wouldn't have to sit in a
the trailer. We spoke for less than ten minutes. She thanked me for noticing her shoe and for
taking the keys. I told her that she was the reason any of it worked. If she hadn't kept
trying to make noise, I would have believed Brent's explanation about a loose toolbox.
She said she hadn't known there was a child in our house. Learning that Callie had been there
made her feel responsible for what happened. Allison told her she wasn't responsible for any
part of it. Brent had told her that she was responsible for what happened, but she didn't
know what to do. I told her that she was responsible for what happened, but she didn't know what to do.
I told her that she wasn't responsible for what happened, but she didn't know what to do.
gaps where buildings had
been torn down and nothing had replaced them. The directions brought me to a narrow street
with only one working streetlight. The house number was 1428. I slowed twice because I
couldn't find it. Then, I saw the number painted on the curb in front of a gray two-story house.
It was obviously vacant. Plywood covered the first floor windows. The porch railing had
fallen away from one side, and a blue city notice was attached to the front door. The
yard was high enough that weeds had grown over the walkway. There were no cars nearby
and no lights inside. The delivery instructions said, "Bring to the back door. Don't knock."
I parked at the curb and checked the address again. It matched. I sent the customer a message
saying I had arrived and asked whether they had entered the wrong house number. Less than
ten seconds later, the customer replied,
"Back door." I wrote that the house appeared empty and that I wasn't comfortable walking
behind it. The next reply told me the front was being renovated and repeated that someone
was waiting in back. There was no sign of renovation, no dumpster, no lumber, no work
lights.
The city notice on the door had been exposed to the weather for a long time. I decided
to leave the food at the front. I carried the bag and drink tray up the walkway, set everything
on the least damaged part of the porch, and marked the order complete. I did not knock.
As I walked back to my car, I heard movement in the narrow space between the vacant house
and the property next to it. A man stepped into view near the rear corner. He wore a
dark sweatshirt with the hood up and kept both hands in the front pocket. He didn't
greet me or thank me. He stood there watching until I got inside the Forester. I locked
the doors. The man walked to the porch, but he didn't say a word. He said, "I'm sorry,
picked up the food, and carried it back along the side of the house.
I remember feeling relieved because, at least, someone had actually ordered it.
I assumed he was staying in the building without permission and didn't want anyone to know.
That happened often enough with delivery work. People ordered to motels under false names,
asked you to meet them behind closed businesses, or gave an address that belonged to someone else.
I wasn't paid to investigate. If the order was delivered and nobody threatened me, I moved on.
The customer added another $3 to the tip after I left. That made the whole thing seem less serious.
Hop on.
This is the way. I like this kid.
Rated PG-13.
On PrizePix, you can make all the picks you want, all in the same app.
And now, PrizePix is available nationwide.
So what are you waiting for?
Lock in for kickoff, because everyone and everything is on PrizePix.
What you want?
Download the app today and use code SPOTIFY to get $150 instantly in lineups if you win your first $5 lineup.
PrizePix. Run your game.
I told Marissa about the boarded-up house when I got home,
and she said I should stop going into neighborhoods like that after dark.
I agreed with her, but the app didn't always show the exact destination before I accepted an order.
Declining too many could also cause a problem.
It also means sitting without work during the busiest part of the night.
The second order came eight days later.
It was a Friday, close to 11.
I picked up two pizzas and a bottle of soda from a place where I regularly received orders.
The customer name was different, and the address appeared as 1430 Benton Street, Unit B.
I didn't recognize it until I turned onto the block.
1430 should have been the property beside the vacant gray house,
but that house had already been torn down.
There was only an overgrown lot with part of a foundation near the center.
The delivery note said,
Use driveway at 1428, door in rear.
I stopped before reaching the house.
The gray building looked exactly the same.
The first floor windows were still covered.
The city notice remained on the front door, and no lights were visible.
A dark sedan was parked farther down the street with its engine off.
I could see someone sitting in the driver's seat.
I sent the driver to the driver's seat.
I sent the customer a message saying they needed to meet me at the curb.
The reply came immediately.
Come back. Door open.
I told them I would wait two minutes.
Nobody appeared.
The person in the parked sedan opened his door and got out.
At the same time, another man came from the overgrown lot next to the vacant house.
He walked toward the passenger side of my car, while the first man approached from behind.
I put the forester in drive.
The man from the passenger side of my car said,
"I'm sorry, I didn't know you were here."
The man from the lot raised one hand and called out that the pizzas belonged to him.
I kept the doors locked and lowered the passenger window about two inches.
I said I would hand the food through the gap if he gave me the customer name.
He didn't answer.
He came directly to the driver's door and pulled the handle.
I accelerated before the second man reached the back of my car.
The man at my door struck the rear driver's side window with an open hand as I pulled away.
I saw both men running after me in the mirror.
They stopped before I reached the end of the block.
I drove to a gas station and contacted the delivery service.
The support worker canceled the order, told me I would still be paid,
and asked if I wanted to file a safety report.
I said yes.
I described the house, the sedan, and the two men.
The support worker said the address would be reviewed.
I also called the police non-emergency number.
An officer met me at the gas station, took down what happened,
and then drove to Benton Street.
He called about 20 minutes later and said the area was empty.
The sedan was gone.
He had checked the front and side of the vacant house but hadn't found anyone.
The officer said trying my door handle was suspicious,
but it wasn't enough to prove they intended to rob me.
The customer could claim they had been trying to get my attention.
He told me not to return if I received another order for that block.
I didn't deliver for the next week.
Marissa wanted me to quit completely, and I considered it.
But the furnace bill was still there, and my hospital job wasn't offering overtime.
I decided I would stop working after 10 and reject any order that took me toward Benton Street.
I also changed the way I handled deliveries.
I kept the doors locked even when I was parked at a restaurant.
I stopped leaving the engine running while I walked to a porch.
If a customer asked me to enter a backyard, an alley, or an enclosed stairwell,
I required them to come outside.
Those rules cost me a few tips and led to several complaints, but I followed them.
The problem was that none of those precautions could make a false address look false before I arrived.
For the next two weeks, nothing happened.
I stayed in the better-lit parts of town,
avoided apartment buildings with enclosed hallways,
and required every customer at a questionable address to meet me outside.
I began to think the two men on Benton Street
had been trying to steal the pizzas or frighten me for their own amusement.
It was easier to believe that than to think people were using the delivery service to arrange robberies.
The third order came on the first Saturday in December.
I had broken my own rule and worked past 10 because the night had been busy.
Shortly before 11, I accepted a large order from a Chinese restaurant.
It was going to Grant Avenue, which was several blocks south of Benton Street.
The restaurant was closing,
so the employee placed three tied bags and a drink carrier on the counter as soon as I arrived.
The order paid unusually well.
Between the delivery fee and tip, I was supposed to earn almost $20.
I decided it would be my last stop of the night.
The address was 1510 Grant Avenue, Rear Apartment.
When I reached the street, I found a closed tire shop where the house should have been.
I checked the number on the building.
It was 1510, but there was no apartment attached to it.
Then I read the customer note.
Rear Apartment reached from service lane.
Enter beside tire shop.
Last grey house on left.
I should have left then.
The words "grey house" should have been enough.
But Grant Avenue was on the other side of several blocks,
and I didn't realize the service lane continued all the way toward Benton Street.
I thought there might be a small rental behind the table.
There was a small rental behind the tire shop that shared the same address.
The entrance was a strip of gravel between the tire shop and a chain-link fence.
It was wide enough for one vehicle.
I turned in and drove slowly because the ground was full of holes.
The service lane continued behind several buildings,
then narrowed where the commercial properties ended.
On my right were the rear fences of occupied houses.
On my left were empty lots, sheds,
and the remains of old garages.
There was nowhere to turn around.
I drove another hundred yards and saw the grey house.
I was approaching it from behind this time,
but I recognized the plywood and the broken porch immediately.
The lane ended at a tall metal fence
just past the property. I had driven into a dead end with the front of my car pointed toward that
fence. I stopped about 30 feet from the rear of the house. For several seconds, I did nothing.
I was angry at myself for not recognizing the setup sooner. The order still showed that the
customer was waiting. I began typing a message saying I would return the food to the restaurant
unless someone met me on Grant Avenue. Before I sent it, I noticed that several areas of grass
behind the house had been pressed flat. A cardboard drink carrier sat near the back step
and an insulated paper bag from another restaurant was caught beneath the porch.
I understood that other drivers had been directed to the same spot. I reached for the gear selector
to reverse out. Headlights appeared at the far end of the service lane. A dark minivan came in
from Grant Avenue and moved toward me. It stopped straight in the lane about 40 yards behind my car
fence. Fences bordered both sides at that point, leaving no room to drive around it.
Three men got out. I locked the doors even though they were already locked.
The men separated as they walked toward me. One stayed in the middle of the lane. Another moved
toward my driver's side and the third went along the fence on the passenger side. They weren't
carrying food and none of them called out a customer name. The delivery app made a sound
from the phone mounted near my dashboard.
The customer had sent another message. Bring it out. The man approaching my side of the car
was the same one who had pulled the handle during the second delivery.
I recognized his narrow face and the white lettering across the front of his sweatshirt.
He was holding a short hammer against his leg. He told me to turn off the engine and get out.
The man in the middle said they only wanted the car and my phone. If I cooperated, he said,
I could walk away.
I kept my foot on the brake. There was a tall metal fence in front of me.
The minivan blocked the lane behind me and three men were close enough to reach the car within
seconds. I looked to each side for another route. The vacant house's backyard was to my left.
An old wooden fence separated it from the service lane, but several boards were missing and one
post leaned toward the ground. Beyond it, the yard continued along the side of the house to Benton
Street.
It was filled with high weeds, small trees, discarded tires, and pieces of broken concrete.
It was not a road. I didn't know whether the ground was level or whether a foundation hole
was hidden beneath the growth. But it was the only space the minivan didn't block.
The man with the hammer reached my window and tried the handle. When it didn't open,
he struck the glass once. The window held, but the sound was hard enough to hurt my ear.
He shifted into reverse. He raised the hammer again. I turned the wheel toward the overgrown
yard and pressed the accelerator. The rear of the Forester moved off the gravel lane
and struck the weak section of wooden fence. Two boards broke, but the leaning post caught
beneath the bumper and stopped me. The tires spun in loose dirt. The man hit my window again.
A white line spread across the lower corner of the glass. The second man reached the passenger door,
and pulled that handle. The third ran behind the car, either trying to block me or reach the rear
hatch. I couldn't see him once he moved below the back window. I shifted into drive and moved
forward about three feet. The man at my window had to jump away. Before he regained his balance,
I put the car in reverse again and pressed the accelerator harder. The bumper pushed the post
flat. The rear wheels climbed over the boards, and the Forester moved into the back of the car.
I moved into the yard. Branches dragged across both sides of the car. I kept looking over my
right shoulder, trying to stay parallel with the house. All three men ran after me. The man with
the hammer stayed on the driver's side and ran alongside the car. As the Forester turned through
the broken fence, the rear driver's side door swung closer to him. He struck that window,
and this time it broke. Glass scattered across the back seat. He reached through the opening,
but there was nothing inside for him to grab. When the car moved over a buried piece of concrete,
the body jumped hard enough to knock his arm away. I continued backward. The weeds were too
high to see the ground. I felt the tires roll over several small objects and heard metal scrape
beneath the car. The gray house was on my right, close enough that branches from the side yard hit
the mirror. The hammer wielder remained along the driver's side and struck the rear quarter
panel as he ran. Another man moved toward the front of the house, trying to reach Benton Street
before I did. I nearly hit a large tree that stood beside the porch. I turned sharply, and the rear of
the Forester passed within a few feet of the trunk. The front end swung toward the vacant house.
For a moment, I thought I had trapped myself between the tree and the building.
I moved forward, straightened the car, and reversed again. The front yard dropped into a
shallow drainage area along Benton Street. The rear wheels went down first, and the bumper struck
the ground. I pressed the accelerator. The tires slipped in wet leaves and mud. The man with the
hammer was still running along the driver's side, coming toward my door as the tires slipped.
The second man was near the tree. The third had reached the sidewalk and was moving behind the
car. I kept my foot down. The rear wheels found solid ground and climbed the other side of the
drainage area. I kept my foot down. The Forester came out backward onto Benton Street. A car traveling along
the road braked and held its horn. I stopped before crossing the center line, shifted into drive,
and accelerated away. The man on the sidewalk ran after me for half a block.
The other two stopped near the vacant house. I expected to see the minivan come out from Grant
Avenue, but it couldn't reach Benton without returning to the main road and driving around
several blocks.
I drove to the same gas station I had used after the second delivery. It was well lit and had
several customers inside. I parked close to the entrance and called 911. Only then did I notice
the cuts on my left arm. Small pieces of glass had flown from the shattered rear driver's side
window and landed across the front seats. None of the cuts were deep, but there was blood on
my sleeve and steering wheel. Two officers arrived within minutes. I gave them a call.
I gave them my phone so they could see the active order and the messages directing me into the
service lane. I described the minivan and all three men. I couldn't provide a license plate
because the vehicle had faced me and stopped too far away for me to see the rear. Officers went to
both entrances of the service lane. The minivan and the men were gone. The back door of the vacant
house stood open, but nobody was inside. Police found several empty food bags, drink cups, and
water bottles in one room. Some were recent. Others had been there long enough for the food inside to
spoil. The tire marks through the yard showed exactly how I had escaped. The broken fence was
still beneath weeds near the lane, and pieces of my shattered side window were scattered from that
point to the front of the property. An officer told me that if my car had been lower or only
front-wheel drive, it probably would have stopped in the mud near Benton Street. My forester had
told me that if my car had been lower or only front-wheel drive, it probably would have stopped in the
mud near Benton Street. I called Marissa from the gas station. She had already gone to sleep and
didn't answer the first time. When she finally picked up, I had trouble explaining what happened
in the right order. I kept saying that I was safe before telling her anything else. She drove
over with her brother because she didn't want me sitting there alone. While we waited for a tow
truck, she looked into the back seat and saw the broken glass. The hammer had shattered the rear
driver's side window directly above the place where our son's car seat normally stood. I stopped
delivering food that night. The police investigation explained why I had been sent to the same area
three times. The group had placed dozens of orders during the previous two months, mostly late at
night.
They used several customer accounts and payment cards that didn't belong to them. Since I worked
the same delivery zone during the same hours each week, I happened to accept three of those orders.
Other drivers had received one or two. The first orders were used to study how drivers behaved.
If someone followed the instructions, walked behind the vacant building, or left the car
running, the men would move in. If a driver remained at the curb or another vehicle came along,
They collected the food and tried again later.
That was apparently what happened during my first visit.
By the second visit, they had parked a car nearby and were prepared to take my phone
and vehicle.
They abandoned the attempt when I drove away before both men reached me.
After I filed the safety report, the Benton Street address was marked as unsafe.
The group avoided that restriction by placing the third order under the tire shop's Grant
Avenue address.
the delivery instructions, which weren't screened the same way, sent me down the
to the back of the vacant house. I learned that the crew didn't only steal cars. They forced
drivers to unlock their phones, then accessed whatever earnings were available through the
delivery apps and payment services. They also took insulated bags and account information
so other people could complete orders under the victims' names. The stolen cars were used for
additional robberies and then abandoned. At least four drivers had been robbed before my third
delivery. One man had been pulled from his car behind an empty duplex and beaten badly enough
to spend several days in the hospital. Another driver's car was found in a different county with
its plates removed. Several suspicious deliveries had never been reported because the drivers
believed the customers were only stealing food. The three men who approached me were arrested
about two weeks later. Investigators were monitoring another vacant address connected to recent orders
when the same man had been robbed of his car. I learned that the driver had been robbed of his
car and the driver had been robbed of his car. I learned that the driver had been robbed of his car. I
arrived. Two of the men were taken into custody there. The third was identified and arrested the
following day. The minivan had been stolen. Inside it, officers found two delivery bags,
several phones, tools for breaking vehicle windows, and property belonging to earlier victims.
The man with the hammer was connected to all three of my orders. He was the person who collected the
chicken from the first delivery and tried my door during the second. I didn't follow every part of
the legal case. I gave another statement and later learned that all three men pleaded guilty to
charges connected to several robberies. I was never required to testify. Insurance repaired
the Forester, although it took almost two months to get all the parts. Even after it was fixed,
deep scratches remained around the lower panels where the branches and fence had dragged across
the paint.
We kept the car for another year and then traded it in. It took us longer to pay off the furnace
than we had planned. I picked up occasional weekend shifts at the hospital instead,
and we cut expenses where we could. Marissa never suggested that I begin delivering again,
and I never considered it. The thing I think about most is how ordinary those orders looked.
They were prepaid. The restaurants prepared real food. The customer accounts sent
clear-cut messages. I didn't know what to do. instructions and offered good tips. Nothing in the app said the people ordering had any
interest in eating what I brought. They only needed drivers to arrive alone,
carrying their phones and car keys. The vacant house gave them a place with no resident,
no reason for neighbors to pay attention, and more than one way to hide nearby.
The food was the least important part of the order.
What are you waiting?
Go for it. Hop on.
This is the way.
I like this kid.
Rated PG-13.
Cozy season is ahead, and you'll be spending way more time inside.
Is your home ready? Don't worry.
With Wayfair, you can upgrade your space without breaking the bank.
Score up to 70% off during their Labor Day clearance on furniture, area rugs,
mattresses, and more. Plus, surprise flash deals you can't miss.
Whether it's one room or the whole house, Wayfair has pieces for every style and budget.
Shop Wayfair's Labor Day clearance now through September 7th at Wayfair.com.
Wayfair, every style, every home.
This happened during the drive home from our honeymoon in September of 2023.
I was 28, and my husband, Evan, was 30.
We had been married for nine days.
We lived in Oklahoma City, but we had flown to Las Vegas after the wedding and planned to drive home in a rental car.
We wanted to see the Grand Canyon, spend a night in Sedona, and stop wherever we felt like stopping along the way.
Neither of us had taken a real car.
We hadn't taken a real vacation in several years.
Turning the trip home into part of the honeymoon seemed worth the extra time.
The rental company had given us a dark gray mid-sized sedan.
It wasn't the vehicle listed on our original reservation.
The employee at the counter said the car assigned to us had been returned with a damaged windshield,
so he moved us into another one at no extra charge.
He crossed out the original space number on our paperwork,
wrote a different one beneath it, and handed Evan a key fob with a small,
plastic tag.
When we reached the new space, the key opened the sedan, and the plate matched the revised agreement.
We assumed the switch had been entered correctly.
Nobody stopped us at the exit booth, and the employee there scanned the agreement before raising the gate.
There was nothing about the process that suggested we had received a vehicle meant for someone else.
The sedan looked clean.
We checked the body for dents, placed our suitcases in the trunk, and left the rental garage without
giving the change any thought.
The only strange thing I noticed was a strong lemon smell inside,
but rental cars are cleaned with strong chemicals all the time.
The first five days were uneventful.
We drove through Arizona, spent more money than we intended,
and took turns choosing restaurants and hotels.
We were exhausted by the end of it, but happy.
I remember telling Evan that our biggest problem as a married couple had been deciding whether
to buy another bag of snacks.
The sedan gave us a few minutes to think about it.
It gave us no trouble.
We opened the trunk several times each day, but our luggage covered the carpeted floor.
We never had a reason to remove the tool tray or inspect the spare.
If the tire had held for one more day, we would have returned the car in Oklahoma City
without ever learning what we had carried across three states.
On our last full day of driving, we left Flagstaff later than planned.
We were supposed to reach Albuquerque that evening, and Oklahoma City the next day.
Traffic, and a long way to go.
The long lunch put us behind schedule, and it was dark by the time we crossed into New Mexico.
We had been on the interstate for about an hour when the low-pressure warning appeared on the dashboard.
Evan said the car still felt normal, so we watched it for several miles.
Then the steering began pulling slightly to the right.
He slowed down and took the next exit.
There was no open gas station, only a closed visitor center and a gravel parking area.
We stopped beneath one of the cars.
The front passenger tire was nearly flat, with a short tear along the sidewall.
Evan called the rental company's roadside number.
The woman who answered asked for our reservation, the vehicle plate, and the exit number.
She said the nearest available tow truck was responding to another call and might take more than two hours.
Evan told her he could install the spare if the car had one.
She asked us to remain on the line while she checked.
After several minutes,
she said the sedan should have a compact spare beneath the trunk floor.
She also entered a service request for the next morning at a tire shop near Grants.
When she asked where we planned to wait,
we told her about a motel we had passed near the previous exit.
She added the motel name to the roadside case,
so a contractor could meet us there if necessary.
I held a flashlight while Evan emptied the trunk.
We placed both suitcases and several shopping bags on the pavement.
He lifted the carpeted floor panel and removed
the foam tray containing the jack and tire wrench.
The compact spare was secured beneath it with a plastic retaining bolt.
When he lifted the spare out,
we found two black plastic bags pressed into the bottom of the wheel well.
They were thick, sealed bags,
each about the size of a folded bath towel.
No labels, no markings.
They had been positioned flat beneath the tire,
where nobody would see them during normal cleaning.
Evan thought they might continue to work,
but they would not be able to contain emergency equipment.
He picked up the first bag and felt several solid rectangular shapes inside.
A seam along one side had opened enough for a corner of green paper to show.
He widened the split with his fingers.
The bag was full of cash.
The bills were arranged in tight bundles held by paper bands.
I couldn't tell how much was there.
It was more money than either of us had ever seen outside a bank.
The second bag contained seven mobile phones,
they were inexpensive models,
still wrapped in thin plastic with charging cables secured around them.
None appeared to be turned on.
For about a minute, Evan and I argued quietly beside the trunk.
He wanted to call the police immediately.
I wanted to leave everything where we found it and drive to somewhere with other people.
We were alone beside a closed building and anyone traveling along the interstate could see our open trunk.
We compromised by calling the rental rental.
We had to call the roadside number again.
Evan told a different representative exactly what we had found.
She put us on hold, returned several minutes later,
and said the items did not belong to the rental company.
She advised us not to activate the phones or handle the cash further.
She also told us to contact local law enforcement from a safe location.
The roadside representative asked whether we still intended to stay at the same motel.
Evan said yes.
She updated the case and told us that the items were not in the same motel.
She told us the service request would remain open.
We considered leaving the bags beneath the trunk floor.
and waiting for a trooper at the visitor center.
The problem was that we had no idea how long anyone would take to reach us,
and the building had been closed for hours.
Cars passed the exit without entering.
We chose the motel because it had an office,
occupied rooms, and a truck stop nearby.
At that point, we were worried about being responsible for someone else's property.
We did not yet understand that somebody already knew where the property was.
We couldn't put the black bags beneath the spare,
because we needed the tire.
I placed them inside one of our suitcases, under our dirty clothes.
Evan installed the compact spare, returned the jack to the trunk,
and drove slowly back toward the motel.
The place was called the Desert View Motor Lodge.
It was an old single-story motel beside a frontage road.
The rooms faced the parking lot, and each door had a number painted near the top.
A 24-hour truck stop stood several hundred yards
away on the other side of an empty gravel area.
Only a few cars were parked outside.
The clerk gave us room 14 at the far end of the building.
We left the sedan directly in front of the room,
and carried both suitcases inside.
The room was basic, but clean enough.
There was a bed, a low dresser under the television,
a small table, and a bathroom at the rear.
The bathroom had a frosted sliding window above the end of the bathtub.
I opened it.
Because the room smelled of cleaning chemicals.
The screen was already bent near one corner,
and the window opened wide enough that I could see the gravel strip behind the motel.
Evan called the county sheriff's office.
He explained the flat tire, the rental car, and what we had found beneath the spare.
The dispatcher said a deputy would come speak with us,
but the closest unit was handling an accident on the interstate.
She told us to keep the door locked, leave the bags untouched,
and call 911 if anything happens.
If anyone approached us about them.
We checked the parking lot several times after that call.
Nothing moved except a couple carrying ice back to their room.
The motel clerk remained behind the office counter,
and lights were on in four or five rooms.
I began to feel embarrassed by how frightened I had become.
I thought the deputy would arrive, collect the bags,
and leave us with a strange honeymoon story.
We placed the suitcase containing the cash and phones in the bathroom.
Evan moved it twice, because he couldn't decide whether it was safe or near us, or out of sight.
Eventually, he set it beside the tub.
About 15 minutes later, Evan's phone rang from an unfamiliar number.
He answered and placed the call on speaker.
The man who called said he was a regional supervisor with the rental company.
He knew Evan's full name, the make and color of the sedan, and the number on our reservation.
He said the roadside report had been estimated to have been issued by the city police.
He said we had not been escalated because we had received the wrong vehicle in Las Vegas.
For a moment, hearing him put me at ease.
Then he asked whether we had removed anything from the spare tire compartment.
Evan looked at me.
I said we had changed the tire and found only the jack.
The man was quiet for a few seconds.
Then he asked which room we were staying in.
Evan ended the call.
Evan called the rental company's official number from our agreement.
The representative who answered could see the roadside sign.
The man said he had received a roadside service request, but found no record of a regional supervisor contacting us.
She said nobody from the company should be asking about property beneath the spare tire.
She told us to remain where we were and cooperate with law enforcement.
Before that call ended, a white sport utility vehicle entered the motel parking lot.
It drove past our room slowly, continued to the end of the building, then turned around and stopped across two parking spaces.
Three people were inside.
A woman was driving.
Two men got out.
One wore jeans and a gray work jacket.
The other had a black sweatshirt and carried something narrow along his right leg.
They looked at the rental sedan first.
The man in the work jacket checked the rear plate, then pointed toward our room.
Evan shut off the lights and closed the curtains.
The first knock came a few seconds later.
The man outside said he was with the rental company.
He used Evan's full name and told us there had been a mistake with the vehicle.
He said they needed the two bags from the trunk compartment, and then they would leave.
Evan didn't answer.
He called 911 from his phone while I stayed near the curtain.
The dispatcher confirmed that deputies were already coming.
She told us not to open the door and asked whether there was another exit.
I looked toward the bathroom window.
The man knocked again.
His voice remained calm, but the second man walked along the front of the room and tried to look through the narrow gap beside the door.
He said that the door was locked, and that there was a door beside the curtains.
The white vehicle stayed in the lot with its engine running.
The man at the door said there had been an error between two rental branches.
He claimed the bags contained company equipment and that keeping them could lead to criminal charges.
Evan asked him to show identification through the window.
The man refused.
He said we had one chance to hand the property over quietly.
The second man moved to the rental sedan and opened the passenger door.
The man decided to lock the car after carrying in our luggage.
He searched the glove compartment and leaned across both front seats before returning to the room.
That was when I knew they weren't employees following any normal procedure.
The man at the door said they knew the bags were inside.
He said the money didn't belong to us and that nobody needed to get hurt over it.
Evan told him the police were coming.
The man stopped pretending to work for the rental company.
He struck the door hard enough to move it in the frame.
The dispatcher heard it.
She told Evan that deputies were less than 15 minutes away and asked us to move into the bathroom if we could do so safely.
The door opened inward.
Evan and I pushed the low dresser across the carpet until it pressed against the bottom half.
It wasn't heavy enough to stop two men, but it kept the door from opening more than a few inches if the lock failed.
We placed the small table behind it and turned it sideways.
The second impact cracked part of the frame near the dead end.
I ran into the bathroom and opened the window the rest of the way.
The sliding section was a little wider than my shoulders.
I pulled at the damaged screen, but it remained attached along the top.
Evan brought me the metal towel rack from beside the sink.
One of its screws had already pulled out of the wall when he yanked it.
I used the end to bend the screen frame.
The metal folded near the damaged corner, and I pushed it out into the gravel.
The men hit the room door again.
The dresser moved several inches across the carpet.
Evan carried the suitcase containing the bags into the bathroom and placed it in the tub.
He still had the dispatcher on speaker.
She could hear the men outside and told us to leave through the window if we believed they were about to enter.
The man with the narrow object drove it between the door and the frame.
I heard wood break.
The upper part of the door moved inward, but the dresser kept the bottom from opening.
I climbed into the door.
I climbed into the bathtub, pushed the suitcase through the window, and let it fall onto the gravel.
Then I sat on the sill, turned onto my stomach, and lowered my legs outside.
The ground was about four feet below me.
Evan held my wrists until my feet were close to the gravel, then released me.
I landed awkwardly but stayed upright.
I moved beneath the window and told him to come through.
Before leaving the tub, Evan passed his phone down to me.
With the dispatcher on speaker, I said,
Evan pulled the bathroom door shut, and turned the lock from inside.
The dresser scraped across the carpet in the other room.
I slid it into my jacket pocket so both of his hands would be free.
Evan pulled the bathroom door shut, and turned the lock from inside.
A second later, the motel room door struck the wall.
The men were inside.
Evan climbed onto the edge of the tub and pushed his upper body through the window.
He was broader than I was, and his shoulders caught against the frame.
He exhaled.
He turned sideways, and forced one shoulder through before the other.
The metal edge scraped both shoulders and tore the sleeve of his shirt.
Someone hit the bathroom door.
Evan forced himself forward until his waist cleared the sill.
I grabbed his forearms and pulled while he kicked against the tub.
The bathroom lock broke just as his legs came through.
A hand came through the opening, caught the heel of his right shoe, and pulled it back
toward the bathroom.
Evan kicked backward.
The shoe slipped off, but the attacker kept hold of it and yanked it inside.
Evan fell on top of me, and we both hit the gravel hard.
The man in the bathroom tried to push his head and one shoulder through the window,
but it was too narrow for him to move quickly.
I picked up the suitcase.
Evan grabbed my free hand, and we ran behind the motel.
The gravel strip continued along the rear wall to an open service drive; we moved away
from the parking lot and the hotel.
At the parking lot entrance, passing the bathroom windows of several other rooms, a guest opened
one curtain and watched us run by.
I shouted for him to call the police.
Behind us, the man pulled back inside room 14.
I knew he would go around the building rather than waste time on the window.
The truck stop was across a wide, dirt lot beyond the service drive.
Its fuel canopy and store were brightly lit.
Several tractor trailers were parked along the edge.
We ran toward the entrance.
Evan ran toward them, with Evan limping because he had one bare foot; the white sport utility
vehicle came around the far end of the motel. Its headlights crossed the ground behind us.
The woman drove onto the service road and accelerated toward the dirt lot.
Evan and I went between two parked trailers where the vehicle couldn't follow.
We stayed in the narrow space until it passed, then continued toward the store.
The suitcase wheels caught in the dirt, so I lifted it by the side handle and carried it.
We entered through the truck stop's side door. Evan pulled it closed behind us and told the
cashier that people were chasing us from the motel. Two drivers near the counter moved to
the windows. One of them called 911 while I stayed on the line with the original dispatcher.
The white vehicle stopped near the edge of the paved lot. It remained there for several seconds,
then reversed and returned toward the frontage road. It was gone before the first deputy arrived.
Officers were called.
Officers met us inside the truck stop. Evan had cuts on his hands and one knee.
I had bruises along my hip and forearms from climbing through the window,
but neither of us needed to go to the hospital.
The deputies opened the suitcase in a back office while we watched.
They removed both black bags, counted seven phones,
and confirmed that the other bag contained a large amount of cash.
Everything was taken as evidence.
At the motel, the door to room 14 had been
forced open with a flat pry bar. The frame was destroyed, and the dresser had been pushed
several feet into the room. Our other suitcase had been emptied onto the bed. The men searched
the trunk of the rental sedan before they left, but they didn't damage the car.
The motel clerk had seen the white vehicle enter and remembered most of its New Mexico license
plate. A truck driver who had been pulling out at the time provided the missing number.
The description was sent to officers along the way.
The vehicle was stopped less than an hour later east of Grants.
The same woman was driving, and both men were still inside.
Officers found a pry bar, work gloves, and a list containing our rental reservation number and
Evan's name. All three were taken into custody. The investigation lasted several months,
but the basic explanation was simple. The rental sedan was supposed to move the cash and phones
from Las Vegas to a criminal group in Albuquerque.
An employee working in the rental garage had placed the bags beneath the spare tire after
the car was cleaned. The vehicle was then supposed to be marked unavailable until a
courier arrived under a separate reservation. During a shift change, the car was mistakenly
returned to the available inventory. When the sedan originally assigned to us was found with
a damaged windshield, the counter employee selected the nearest clean vehicle in the same class.
That was the gray sedan containing the bags.
The courier arrived later and learned that the vehicle had already left with us.
The employee involved in the plan could see our reservation and knew we were returning the car
in Oklahoma City, but he had no exact location until the tire failed. Our first roadside call
created a service case containing the exit number and the motel where we planned to wait.
Our second call added the fact that we had found cash and phones beneath the spare.
The rental employee accessed that case,
even though his job didn't involve roadside assistance. He contacted the group in Albuquerque
and gave them our information. The man who called me wasn't a regional supervisor. He was one of the
people later arrested in the white vehicle. He already knew our reservation details from the
rental employee. His only purpose was to confirm that we had the bags and find out which room we
were in. When I refused to give the room number, the group drove through the motel lot until the
gray sedan was found. Since the motel had exterior doors, our room was easy to identify from where
the car was parked. The cash totaled a little over $90,000. Investigators said the phones were
being used to move money through accounts opened with stolen personal information.
The group transported both the phones and cash between cities using rental vehicles
because the drivers could change and the cars didn't remain connected to one person for long.
The flat tire had no connection to the motel. The motel was located in the middle of the
motel. The motel had no connection to the criminals. Road debris had cut the sidewall.
If that tire hadn't failed, Evan and I would have carried the bags all the way to Oklahoma
without knowing they were there. I don't know whether the group would have confronted us at
another hotel, waited at the Oklahoma City return location, or simply lost track of the car.
The rental employee was arrested after investigators reviewed who had accessed our roadside case.
He and the three people from the motel,
eventually pleaded guilty to charges related to fraud, conspiracy, attempted robbery,
and the motel break-in. We weren't required to travel back to New Mexico for a trial.
The rental company paid for the damaged motel room and refunded our reservation. They also arranged
another vehicle so we could drive home, but we waited until daylight and stopped at the first
place that sold shoes because Evan's right one was still somewhere inside room 14. Our families
joked that we had received enough money to pay for the motel, but we didn't. We didn't have enough
excitement for an entire marriage during the first two weeks. We could laugh about parts of it later,
but it took me a long time to feel comfortable in roadside motels. For months, I checked every
bathroom window as soon as we entered a room. We still rent cars when we travel. Before leaving
the rental lot, Evan checks the tire pressure and records the existing body damage on the
inspection form. I lift the trunk floor, remove the tool tray, and look beneath the spare tire.
The car is still in the car, but the car is still in the car. Plan term only greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy.
See terms.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
A homeowner discovered a man hiding in a cargo trailer during a yard sale, initially mistaking it for a storage issue, only to realize he was holding his estranged wife captive.
The man, Brent Nolan, had planned to abduct his wife, Kara, and transport her in a trailer after threatening her and binding her hands and ankles.
The discovery was made when the homeowner noticed a woman’s shoe moving behind a divider in the trailer and heard breathing, prompting a 911 call that led to the arrest of Nolan, who later pleaded guilty to kidnapping, burglary, and assault.
Summary:
A homeowner, during a yard sale in Kentucky, sold a large oak cabinet to a man who later returned to collect it. The man arrived late, appeared normal at first, but during the load process, the homeowner noticed unusual sounds and movements inside a sealed trailer. He observed a woman’s shoe beneath a blanket and heard breathing, which led him to believe someone was trapped.
After the man attempted to enter the house with a pry bar and threatened the family, the homeowner called 911 and locked himself and his wife inside. The man broke through the door and attacked, but was eventually stopped by the homeowner and the police. It was later revealed that the man, Brent Nolan, had kidnapped his estranged wife, Kara, who had been imprisoned in the trailer.
She had been bound and hidden behind the cabinet, and the trailer had been used as a covert confinement. The homeowner’s actions—particularly noticing the shoe and alerting authorities—were critical in preventing further harm. The case resulted in Nolan pleading guilty to multiple charges, including kidnapping and assault.
The woman survived with injuries, and the homeowner credited her proactive behavior for breaking the facade of the crime. The incident highlights how ordinary events can mask violent crimes and underscores the importance of vigilance, especially in isolated or unmonitored settings. The story also reflects on trauma, trust, and the hidden dangers of domestic abuse.
Despite the emotional toll, the family was relieved that the danger ended, and the perpetrator was brought to justice. The narrative serves as a cautionary tale about the potential for abuse to go unnoticed until it escalates.
FAQs
Star Wars: The Mandalorian and Grogu is now streaming on Disney+.
Yes, the show is rated PG-13.
A man bought a large cabinet at a yard sale, promised to return later, and later arrived with a trailer. When he failed to return, the homeowner discovered he had hidden a woman inside the trailer and was planning to abduct her.
The homeowner discovered a woman's shoe moving behind a divider and heard breathing, which led them to believe someone was trapped inside the trailer.
The man was charged with kidnapping, burglary, assault, and related crimes after being caught hiding a wife inside a cargo trailer.
The driver locked doors, refused to enter enclosed spaces, required customers to meet outside, and stopped working in high-risk areas after identifying a pattern of robberies.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.